Latest / Bloomberg Law / Trump's Business Empire at Risk
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 1: It's a stunning, perhaps unprecedented decision that puts Donald Trump's
- 0:15Speaker 1: business empire at risk of dissolution and strips control of
- 0:19Speaker 1: key properties from the former president. Judge Arthur and Goren
- 0:23Speaker 1: ruled that Trump repeatedly committed fraud by inflating the value
- 0:27Speaker 1: of his assets by billions of dollars on financial records
- 0:30Speaker 1: submitted to banks and insurers. He wrote scathingly about Trump's defenses,
- 0:35Speaker 1: saying they were a fantasy, not reality. The documents do
- 0:39Speaker 1: not say what they say. There is no such thing
- 0:42Speaker 1: as objective value. Essentially, the court should not believe its
- 0:46Speaker 1: own eyes, even quoting a famous line from the Marx
- 0:50Speaker 1: Brothers Movieyes. The judge concluded by saying that New York
- 0:58Speaker 1: Attorney General Letitia James is now entitled to a court
- 1:02Speaker 1: order dissolving any certificates issue to Trump's LLC's, putting his
- 1:07Speaker 1: ability to continue operating his sprawling Manhattan based company at risk.
- 1:12Speaker 1: Joining me is former federal prosecutor Robert Mintz, a partner
- 1:15Speaker 1: Maccarter and English. Would you say this decision is unprecedented, rare, uncommon,
- 1:23Speaker 1: how would you describe it?
- 1:25Speaker 2: It certainly is a rare decision. There is not a
- 1:28Speaker 2: lot of history in the New York State of a
- 1:30Speaker 2: judge actually dissolving a company under these circumstances. Usually companies
- 1:36Speaker 2: tivily die in bankruptcy cases. So this is something where
- 1:40Speaker 2: there is not a lot of precedent, and it has
- 1:42Speaker 2: spawned a lot of confusion, not only by people who
- 1:45Speaker 2: are looking at this case from the outside, but even
- 1:48Speaker 2: by the lawyers who are involved in the case. There
- 1:51Speaker 2: are a lot of questions as to exactly how the
- 1:53Speaker 2: court is going to try to implement this decision.
- 1:56Speaker 1: Let's talk about the substance of the decision. Tell us
- 1:59Speaker 1: why the judge decided that Trump had committed fraud.
- 2:03Speaker 2: The essence of the judge's decision is that Donald Trump
- 2:07Speaker 2: and his two oldest sons and his businesses orchestrated what
- 2:11Speaker 2: the judge called a persistent and repeated fraud in which
- 2:15Speaker 2: they vastly exaggerated the extent of the former president's wealth
- 2:20Speaker 2: to procure favorable loans. And they did that in order
- 2:24Speaker 2: to try to benefit the financially these companies and get
- 2:28Speaker 2: these very favorable loans based upon collateral ements that the
- 2:32Speaker 2: judge found was highly inflated.
- 2:35Speaker 1: Trump's penthouse in Manhattan that's been used as an example
- 2:40Speaker 1: of the exaggeration or inflation.
- 2:43Speaker 2: In that case, the judge found that former President Trump
- 2:47Speaker 2: had engaged in fraud by repeatedly claiming that his penthouse
- 2:52Speaker 2: at Trump Power, which according to most records, is slightly
- 2:57Speaker 2: under eleven thousand square feet. According to the judge, former
- 3:00Speaker 2: President Trump and his businesses would assert that the apartment
- 3:04Speaker 2: is nearly three times bigger than it was in reality.
- 3:08Speaker 2: The judge said that Trump's annual statements of financial condition
- 3:11Speaker 2: used this false square footage to inflate its network by
- 3:16Speaker 2: as much as two hundred and seven million dollars in
- 3:19Speaker 2: twenty twelve, when Trump valued the penous that is staggering
- 3:22Speaker 2: one hundred and eighty million dollars. According to the judge,
- 3:25Speaker 2: no apartment sold in New York City had ever approached
- 3:28Speaker 2: that price, and the judge essentially said that while there
- 3:31Speaker 2: may be some subjectivity in terms of evaluating the square
- 3:35Speaker 2: footage and the value of an apartment, this was on
- 3:39Speaker 2: an order of magnitude that, in his mind, showed a
- 3:41Speaker 2: clear attempt to simply inflate numbers and a knowing violation
- 3:46Speaker 2: of the law, and the judge found that former President
- 3:49Speaker 2: Trump had fraudulently inflated the value of this department to
- 3:53Speaker 2: a staggering degree.
- 3:55Speaker 1: The judge's tone was scathing. He wrote, at one point
- 3:59Speaker 1: in defense tenants world rent, regulated apartments are worth the
- 4:03Speaker 1: same as unregulated apartments. Restricted land is worth the same
- 4:07Speaker 1: as unrestricted land. Restrictions can evaporate into thin air. And
- 4:11Speaker 1: then he said that is a fantasy world, not the
- 4:15Speaker 1: real world.
- 4:16Speaker 2: Well, the judge was clearly incensed by the conduct here
- 4:19Speaker 2: and did go through numerous examples of where he thought
- 4:23Speaker 2: that the conduct was simply not tethered to reality. He
- 4:27Speaker 2: even went so far as to sanction the lawyers for
- 4:31Speaker 2: making some arguments on behalf of former President Trump on
- 4:34Speaker 2: the Trump organization, arguments that he said had already been
- 4:38Speaker 2: discredited and were simply frivolous. That the judge clearly was
- 4:43Speaker 2: not at all accepting of the defenses that were being
- 4:45Speaker 2: put forward by the Trump organization, and wrote a very
- 4:49Speaker 2: very aggressive decision here, going through in great detail examples
- 4:53Speaker 2: of what he felt was conduct that was clearly fraudulent.
- 4:57Speaker 1: Bob that seventy five hundred dollars sanctioned for Trump's lawyers
- 5:03Speaker 1: for making arguments he'd previously rejected. I mean, don't lawyers
- 5:07Speaker 1: repeat arguments that have lost in court all the time?
- 5:11Speaker 2: Yeah, that is a bit of an unusual ruling. Usually
- 5:14Speaker 2: judges do give defense lawyers latitude to make arguments, which
- 5:18Speaker 2: they do repeatedly. Sometimes, if a lawyer finds that they
- 5:21Speaker 2: make an argument that's unsuccessful, they try to make it
- 5:24Speaker 2: in a slightly different way to give the judge another
- 5:27Speaker 2: opportunity to perhaps rule differently, so to thanks to them
- 5:30Speaker 2: for making an argument simply on the basis that they
- 5:33Speaker 2: had previously made it to something that you do not
- 5:35Speaker 2: see very often.
- 5:36Speaker 1: What was the defense.
- 5:38Speaker 2: The heart of the defense by the Trump organization and
- 5:41Speaker 2: by former President Trump's lawyers was that the banks in question,
- 5:45Speaker 2: including Deutsche Bank in this case, these are the banks
- 5:48Speaker 2: that made the loans allegedly based upon these inflated valuations
- 5:53Speaker 2: of the collateral. The defense argued that these banks were
- 5:55Speaker 2: not defrauded at all, because all of the loans were
- 5:59Speaker 2: ultimately repaid and the banks in fact made quite a
- 6:01Speaker 2: bit of money on those loans. The judge did not
- 6:04Speaker 2: buy that argument, saying that it's not fair to suggest
- 6:07Speaker 2: that no harm had been done to these banks when
- 6:10Speaker 2: they loan money to the Trump organization. The judge pointed
- 6:13Speaker 2: out that the first principle of loan accounting is that
- 6:18Speaker 2: as the risk rises, so to the interest rates. So essentially,
- 6:22Speaker 2: what the judge was saying is that while in this
- 6:24Speaker 2: case the loans were repaid and the banks in fact
- 6:27Speaker 2: did make money on loaning money to the Trump organization,
- 6:30Speaker 2: had they known what the real value of the collateral was,
- 6:33Speaker 2: they would have raised the interest rates and the banks
- 6:35Speaker 2: would have made even more money. So that's where they
- 6:38Speaker 2: were victimized here, and the judge's eyes, the banks were
- 6:41Speaker 2: misled in order to make a loan at a lower
- 6:44Speaker 2: rate than they should have made it if the true
- 6:47Speaker 2: value of the collateral were known to them at the
- 6:49Speaker 2: time that the loan was extended to the Trump organization.
- 6:51Speaker 1: A lawyer for Trump, Christopher Keyes, said that he would
- 6:55Speaker 1: likely appeal the decision that's expected, which he called out
- 6:59Speaker 1: rageous and completely disconnected from the facts and governing law.
- 7:03Speaker 1: He said the judge ignored an early appeals court ruling
- 7:06Speaker 1: and also ignored basic legal accounting and business principles. Do
- 7:10Speaker 1: you think they have a good chance on appeal?
- 7:13Speaker 2: Well, this is an aggressive decision, so it's going to
- 7:15Speaker 2: be interesting to see what the appeals court does. One
- 7:18Speaker 2: thing we can know for sure that once they file
- 7:20Speaker 2: us appeal, it will likely stay the judges ruling, which
- 7:23Speaker 2: means that nothing will really be done for quite a while,
- 7:26Speaker 2: could be even years, while the appeals court takes this
- 7:29Speaker 2: decision up. In the meantime, the judges' decision does require
- 7:32Speaker 2: the appointment of a receiver, so we'll see whether that
- 7:35Speaker 2: proceeds even while the appeal is pending.
- 7:38Speaker 1: So describe the remedy that the judge has ordered or
- 7:42Speaker 1: the punishment. I'm not sure what we call it.
- 7:44Speaker 2: Well, the judges sweeping decision ordered that several of Trump's
- 7:48Speaker 2: businesses be dissolved, and he ordered that a receiver be
- 7:52Speaker 2: appointed to help in the dissolution of these entities. A
- 7:56Speaker 2: lot of the decision is not entirely clear because the
- 8:00Speaker 2: Trump organization itself is really just a shell organization, and
- 8:04Speaker 2: it's composed of about five hundred various LLC's, all holding
- 8:09Speaker 2: different properties and serving different purposes, and so exactly what
- 8:13Speaker 2: the impact of the judge is ruling on these various
- 8:15Speaker 2: LLC's is unclear. The Trump organization's lawyers, for example, raised
- 8:20Speaker 2: the fact that former President Trump's two sons, Donald Junior
- 8:24Speaker 2: and Eric live in homes which are in fact owned
- 8:28Speaker 2: by these LLC's, and so the question was do they
- 8:31Speaker 2: have to be removed from the homes? Do those homes
- 8:34Speaker 2: have to be liquidated? They also asked whether mister Trump
- 8:37Speaker 2: would have to sell assets including Trump Tower and forty
- 8:41Speaker 2: Wall Street, which is a downtown commercial property, or whether
- 8:45Speaker 2: those properties could be managed by an independent receiver rather
- 8:48Speaker 2: than being dissolved and have to be sold. So there's
- 8:51Speaker 2: lots of unanswered questions here as to how this order
- 8:54Speaker 2: will be implemented, and even the judge acknowledged that he
- 8:58Speaker 2: was not entirely certain as to how his order would
- 9:00Speaker 2: be implemented and wanted to take more time in order
- 9:03Speaker 2: to evaluate the implementation of its own order.
- 9:06Speaker 1: Doesn't that point to a successful issue on appeal for Trump?
- 9:10Speaker 1: If the judge himself, if this order is so novel
- 9:15Speaker 1: that the judge himself doesn't know how it's going to
- 9:17Speaker 1: be implemented, that the lawyers are confused. There are more
- 9:21Speaker 1: questions here than answers.
- 9:22Speaker 2: Yeah, there are a lot of unanswered questions. I mean,
- 9:24Speaker 2: I think it's clear from the judges ruling that he
- 9:28Speaker 2: is not intending or ordering that mister Trump's company be
- 9:32Speaker 2: dissolved completely. But what it does do is it affects
- 9:35Speaker 2: these LLC's, and by taking away the business certificates, it
- 9:39Speaker 2: will make it impossible for those various LLC's to operate,
- 9:43Speaker 2: which ultimately can have a crippling effect on the Trump organization.
- 9:47Speaker 2: So this is a very significant decision. It's highly controversial.
- 9:51Speaker 2: It's going up on appeal, and we'll have to see
- 9:53Speaker 2: what the appeals court does here. I think there is
- 9:55Speaker 2: certainly a possibility that the appeals court may overturn this decision,
- 9:59Speaker 2: just because it's so unprecedented and because the effects of
- 10:02Speaker 2: this decision are so sweeping on a major organization like
- 10:06Speaker 2: the Trump organization, which employs hundreds of people on holds
- 10:09Speaker 2: millions and millions of dollars in real estate, not only
- 10:12Speaker 2: in New York State but also around the world.
- 10:14Speaker 1: Apparently trial is starting next week. What's left to try.
- 10:19Speaker 2: The essence of the judge's decision was that no trial
- 10:22Speaker 2: was needed to determine that the Trump organization had fraudulently
- 10:26Speaker 2: secured favorable terms on loans and insurance deals. But what
- 10:30Speaker 2: exactly is left for the trial is not entirely clear.
- 10:34Speaker 2: Even the state's lawyers had not worked out what was
- 10:37Speaker 2: needed to go to trial at this point. But what
- 10:39Speaker 2: we do know is that the judge will have to
- 10:41Speaker 2: determine the extent of the fine he's going to order.
- 10:45Speaker 2: The Attorney General has asked for as much as two
- 10:47Speaker 2: hundred and fifty million dollars. The judge could also decide
- 10:50Speaker 2: a trial whether to borrow the former president and his
- 10:53Speaker 2: sons from running a business in the state. Ever again,
- 10:56Speaker 2: those seem to be the issues that are remaining, but
- 10:59Speaker 2: that will have to be worth out by the state lawyers,
- 11:01Speaker 2: the defense, and the judge.
- 11:03Speaker 1: Putting aside the financial consequences of this decision. For Trump,
- 11:07Speaker 1: this attacks his persona, his brand, you know, being the
- 11:12Speaker 1: billionaire real estate magnet. It's what he's all about.
- 11:16Speaker 2: In pre trial hearings before this ruling, one of former
- 11:20Speaker 2: president trump lawyers told the judge that former President Trump
- 11:24Speaker 2: is an investment genius and probably one of the most
- 11:26Speaker 2: successful real estate developers in the country. Clearly, this judge
- 11:31Speaker 2: disagreed and actually said that he's a genius only in
- 11:36Speaker 2: a fantasy world. So one of the things that's really
- 11:38Speaker 2: an issue here is the Trump brand, is the perception
- 11:42Speaker 2: of the Trump organization and the question of whether it
- 11:45Speaker 2: is really one of the great successful real estate empires
- 11:49Speaker 2: in Manhattan and even in the United States and around
- 11:52Speaker 2: the world, or whether it was built on a basis
- 11:55Speaker 2: of fraud and fraudulent statements, and in fact, as the
- 11:59Speaker 2: judge said, the empire is really simply a fantasy based
- 12:03Speaker 2: upon false information that was provided to give favorable loans
- 12:08Speaker 2: to which the Trump organization was ultimately not entitled.
- 12:11Speaker 1: It's also interesting that everyone's been paying attention to the
- 12:14Speaker 1: criminal cases against Trump, but significant punishment was meted out
- 12:19Speaker 1: here in a civil case.
- 12:21Speaker 2: In the array of criminal and civil charges that former
- 12:24Speaker 2: President Trump is facing, this is the first actual penalty
- 12:28Speaker 2: that's been imposed upon him, and now we'll have to
- 12:30Speaker 2: see whether it actually stands up on appeal, and we'll.
- 12:33Speaker 1: See what happens at the trial next week. Thanks so much, Bob.
- 12:37Speaker 1: That's former federal prosecutor Robert Mintz, a partner Maccarter and English.
- 12:41Speaker 1: Coming up next, elon Musk's many lawsuits. I'm Jrean Grosso
- 12:45Speaker 1: and you're listening to Bloomberg. Elon Musk's leadership at Twitter
- 12:50Speaker 1: and Tesla is the subject of three major face offs
- 12:54Speaker 1: coming up in the Delaware Chancery Court next month. It's
- 12:57Speaker 1: been a year since Musk, after months of court room
- 13:00Speaker 1: and social media drama, purchase Twitter now renamed as X
- 13:05Speaker 1: for forty four billion dollars. That deal allowed him to
- 13:08Speaker 1: avoid a trial in the country's premiere venue for corporate litigation.
- 13:12Speaker 1: But October will be a busy month for Musk. In
- 13:15Speaker 1: that Delaware court. He'll face suits from a stockholder and
- 13:18Speaker 1: pension funds questioning his lavish Tesla pay package, and further
- 13:23Speaker 1: legal fallout from his Twitter By joining me to sort
- 13:27Speaker 1: it all out? Is business law expert Eric Talley, a
- 13:30Speaker 1: professor Columbia Law School. Let's talk first about his record
- 13:34Speaker 1: breaking pay package of fifty five billion dollars.
- 13:38Speaker 3: Yeah, that's good work if you can get it, isn't it.
- 13:41Speaker 3: I'm going to conjecture June that if either you or
- 13:43Speaker 3: I had a fifty five billion dollar pay package, this
- 13:46Speaker 3: call wouldn't be happening right now.
- 13:48Speaker 1: You are definitely right on that one.
- 13:50Speaker 3: So, yeah, this is an interesting case. It's a case
- 13:52Speaker 3: that was brought years and years ago and was you know,
- 13:55Speaker 3: essentially taken over by Chancellor McCormick. It ended up in
- 13:59Speaker 3: a hearing some months ago. There definitely is a doctrine
- 14:03Speaker 3: out there about, you know, fiduciary duties and whether exorbitant
- 14:08Speaker 3: pay packages have the effect of breaching fiduciary duties, and
- 14:13Speaker 3: this is sort of within that cluster of cases. The
- 14:16Speaker 3: hard part about this is that, you know, in many respects,
- 14:20Speaker 3: Elon Musk's compensation package, as it was fashioned back in
- 14:25Speaker 3: you know, twenty seventeen or whatever, it was a lottery ticket,
- 14:29Speaker 3: and who knew whether that lottery ticket was going to
- 14:32Speaker 3: pay off and by how much it paid off? And
- 14:35Speaker 3: you know, he essentially did the billionaire's version of hitting
- 14:38Speaker 3: the powerball on this lottery ticket. It paid off almost
- 14:41Speaker 3: to its maximal amount. And you know, I think part
- 14:44Speaker 3: of the issue in the case, and probably what's going
- 14:47Speaker 3: to feed into the opinion is, you know, to what
- 14:50Speaker 3: extent should we or should we not use that sort
- 14:55Speaker 3: of you know, twenty twenty hindsight to try to get
- 14:59Speaker 3: a sense of whether everyone knew that this was going
- 15:01Speaker 3: to be a a powerball ticket that paid off, or
- 15:05Speaker 3: it really just turned out that, you know, the fortunes
- 15:07Speaker 3: of Tesla outshine just about any conceivable picture that anyone
- 15:11Speaker 3: would have painted at the time. Musk agreed to a
- 15:14Speaker 3: lower fixed component of his salary for this lottery ticket
- 15:18Speaker 3: version and it paid off. That's clearly the argument that
- 15:21Speaker 3: Musk is going to make that in fact, incentive contracts
- 15:24Speaker 3: are there for a reason this happened to hit the
- 15:27Speaker 3: powerball lottery, but at the time there was no reason
- 15:30Speaker 3: to expect that it would.
- 15:32Speaker 1: Does it even factor in that they claim he's essentially
- 15:36Speaker 1: a part time leader with other companies to run, strengthened
- 15:40Speaker 1: by the fact that he seems to be spending a
- 15:42Speaker 1: lot of time at X.
- 15:44Speaker 3: He kind of has to now, right, because that's a
- 15:46Speaker 3: particularly thorny situation he's in having closed that deal. Here's
- 15:50Speaker 3: the interesting thing about this compensation litigation or dispute is
- 15:54Speaker 3: that there have effectively been two defenses that Tesla has
- 15:59Speaker 3: made to try to justify this package. One is the
- 16:03Speaker 3: lottery ticket version. Right that we didn't know at the
- 16:05Speaker 3: time whether this is going to pay off big or
- 16:07Speaker 3: not pay off at all, and if it went the
- 16:08Speaker 3: other direction, then Musk ends up walking away with a
- 16:12Speaker 3: pretty minuscule salary. So that's one part of it. The
- 16:14Speaker 3: other part of it, though, Tesla's argument is that they
- 16:18Speaker 3: kind of the board had to give him a high
- 16:20Speaker 3: powered incentive contract to keep his attention because he's sort
- 16:25Speaker 3: of as distractable as a six month old labrador puppy,
- 16:28Speaker 3: and if you don't keep his attention on a really
- 16:31Speaker 3: shiny bouncing ball, then he's going to run off and
- 16:33Speaker 3: do other things. Well, they gave him that compensation contract.
- 16:37Speaker 3: It was a big one. He ended up running off
- 16:39Speaker 3: and getting distracted by SpaceX and Twitter and the boring
- 16:43Speaker 3: company and so forth. I guess I'm trying to figure
- 16:46Speaker 3: out which way that cuts. Does that mean that they
- 16:48Speaker 3: really should have given a bigger package to keep his
- 16:51Speaker 3: attention on things or not? So it's hard to tell
- 16:54Speaker 3: exactly which way that cuts. The fact that he is
- 16:56Speaker 3: so distractable almost feeds into the argument that it would
- 17:01Speaker 3: make sense to have a high powered incentive contract to
- 17:04Speaker 3: keep his eyes focused on the fortunes of Tesla and
- 17:08Speaker 3: not to get too waylaid by other shiny lights and
- 17:12Speaker 3: bouncing balls.
- 17:13Speaker 1: How much does Musk's testimony during that November twenty twenty
- 17:19Speaker 1: two trial that he played no part in the board's decision,
- 17:23Speaker 1: So is the independence of the boarding coming to this
- 17:25Speaker 1: decision important.
- 17:27Speaker 3: Yeah, it's a big deal. It's it's kind of an
- 17:29Speaker 3: interesting situation right now with Twitter because just last year,
- 17:34Speaker 3: a totally different case involved Tesla and its decision to
- 17:37Speaker 3: purchase a very struggling solar energy company called Solar City.
- 17:42Speaker 3: That case ended up resulting in an Elon Musk win,
- 17:48Speaker 3: but it did so in an odd way. The judge
- 17:50Speaker 3: in that case, you know, everyone sort of expected the
- 17:53Speaker 3: judge in that case was going to have to decide
- 17:56Speaker 3: whether he was going to declare that Elon Musk was
- 17:59Speaker 3: a controlling shareholder of Tesla, and if that was true
- 18:04Speaker 3: and the only one owns about twenty one twenty two
- 18:06Speaker 3: percent of the stock or did at the time, if
- 18:09Speaker 3: that is true, that he's deemed to be a sufficiently
- 18:12Speaker 3: large stockholder, that he's a controller, that puts a larger
- 18:16Speaker 3: onus of fiduciary obligation on him. And it also calls
- 18:20Speaker 3: into question whether he might sort of just dominate and
- 18:23Speaker 3: control everyone on the board, and therefore you can't just
- 18:26Speaker 3: trust the board to be making independent judgments. So a
- 18:30Speaker 3: lot of people thought that in that Solar City case,
- 18:32Speaker 3: we would learn answers to whether Elon Musk was a
- 18:36Speaker 3: controller or not. But the judge in that case, Vice
- 18:40Speaker 3: Chancellor Slights, who has tens left the bench. He crafted
- 18:43Speaker 3: kind of an interesting opinion that essentially was able to
- 18:46Speaker 3: dodge that. He said, I'm just going to pretend like
- 18:49Speaker 3: Elon Musk is a controller, but I'm still now going
- 18:52Speaker 3: to conclude that the way that they did this solar
- 18:55Speaker 3: city deal satisfied even the heightened requirements that I would
- 19:00Speaker 3: otherwise impose on a controller. And by doing that, he
- 19:03Speaker 3: basically said, look, I'm subjecting Elon Musk, at least for
- 19:06Speaker 3: argument's sake, to the most rigorous test that we have
- 19:09Speaker 3: in Delaware, and he passes, and therefore I don't have
- 19:12Speaker 3: to decide whether he's a controller or not, because he
- 19:15Speaker 3: would win even if he were a controller. Now that
- 19:18Speaker 3: left open this question that survives to this case about well,
- 19:23Speaker 3: what is his status? Does he own enough stock that
- 19:25Speaker 3: he can pretty much, you know, influence or has a
- 19:28Speaker 3: good chance of influencing the entirety of the board, And therefore,
- 19:32Speaker 3: in this case is going to have to be put
- 19:34Speaker 3: under much more of a microscope, and maybe the board's
- 19:36Speaker 3: judgment about this compensation package shouldn't be trusted as much,
- 19:40Speaker 3: and so there will be kind of an interesting question
- 19:43Speaker 3: about whether Chancellor McCormick in this case, you know, pursues
- 19:46Speaker 3: the same strategy as Vice Chancellor's light, deciding not to
- 19:51Speaker 3: decide whether he's a controlling stockholder and saying, assuming that
- 19:55Speaker 3: he is, this still is okay under Delaware law. Now
- 20:01Speaker 3: if in her opinion, ah boy, whether he's a controller
- 20:05Speaker 3: or not really matters for the outcome of this case,
- 20:07Speaker 3: because if he is a controlling stockholder, then he hasn't
- 20:11Speaker 3: met his burden to defend this thing. But if he's
- 20:14Speaker 3: not a controlling stockholder, he gets a lot more different.
- 20:16Speaker 3: If she decides that that's the case, she's going to
- 20:18Speaker 3: have to make a call on whether having twenty one
- 20:21Speaker 3: twenty two percent of the stock of Tesla is enough
- 20:24Speaker 3: to make him a controlling shareholder. I think a lot
- 20:27Speaker 3: of us that teach in this area are sort of
- 20:29Speaker 3: hoping that we'll hear something along those lines, but it's
- 20:32Speaker 3: not clear to me which way it goes. Because Tesla
- 20:35Speaker 3: did put up, you know, I think some pretty flashy
- 20:39Speaker 3: testimony about, you know, the idea that this was the
- 20:42Speaker 3: type of compensation package that's like a lottery ticket, and
- 20:44Speaker 3: this lottery ticket just happened to pay off, but there
- 20:47Speaker 3: are all kinds of scenarios in which it might not.
- 20:50Speaker 1: If it's just a regular CEO, there's no question about
- 20:53Speaker 1: controlling stock. Are there parameters that the judges used to
- 20:58Speaker 1: determine whether a CEO's pay is fair or not?
- 21:02Speaker 3: Yeah, there are. There are a couple things that are
- 21:04Speaker 3: an issue here. So one is, even if it's just
- 21:06Speaker 3: the CEO, the CEO still on a director by director
- 21:09Speaker 3: basis may have extra pull and extra influence, and that's
- 21:14Speaker 3: something that you have to be mindful of when setting compensation.
- 21:17Speaker 3: But to the extent that there are directors who are
- 21:20Speaker 3: sufficiently independent of mister Musk that they can exercise their
- 21:25Speaker 3: own judgment, and if he's just an ordinary CEO, then
- 21:27Speaker 3: they're kind of the presumption goes in that direction, then
- 21:30Speaker 3: their disinterested assessment of the propriety of this compensation package,
- 21:37Speaker 3: and then their vote amongst the disinterested directors to permit it.
- 21:41Speaker 3: Gets a lot of deference under Delaware law that in
- 21:44Speaker 3: order to challenge that, it basically is protected by something
- 21:48Speaker 3: known as the business judgment rule. Which isn't quite a
- 21:51Speaker 3: conclusion that Tesla's going to win this case, but it's
- 21:54Speaker 3: pretty close to that. It's basically saying, boy, you better
- 21:57Speaker 3: be able to provide us evidence that these directors, even
- 22:00Speaker 3: though they weren't influenced or dominated or controlled by mister Musk,
- 22:04Speaker 3: they basically were just phoning it in and they didn't
- 22:07Speaker 3: really care about the welfare of Tesla or Tesla's stockholders.
- 22:11Speaker 3: And you know, that's a hard boundary to get over.
- 22:14Speaker 3: It was famously tested almost a quarter century ago involving
- 22:18Speaker 3: the then CEO of Disney, Michael Ovitz, who was let
- 22:21Speaker 3: go and handed one hundred and sixty million dollars on
- 22:23Speaker 3: his way out the door, and stockholders challenged it. But
- 22:27Speaker 3: because the board of directors and the compensation committee was
- 22:30Speaker 3: deemed to be sufficiently independent of him, the court basically said, yeah,
- 22:35Speaker 3: this doesn't rise to that level of them just basically
- 22:37Speaker 3: being indifferent about the value to Disney, and there was
- 22:40Speaker 3: a rationale for what they did. And so the stockholders
- 22:43Speaker 3: lost in that case. And so that Disney case almost
- 22:46Speaker 3: certainly will rear its head if that's the nature of
- 22:49Speaker 3: the bottom line here, and that Musk is found to
- 22:52Speaker 3: be by Chancellor McCormick just an ordinary CEO and not
- 22:55Speaker 3: a controlling stockholder.
- 22:57Speaker 1: Coming up Next, the legal fallout from must purchase of Twitter.
- 23:01Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg. I've been talking to Professor Eric Talley
- 23:04Speaker 1: of Columbia Law School about how Elon Musk's leadership at
- 23:08Speaker 1: Twitter and Tesla is the subject of three major face
- 23:11Speaker 1: offs coming up in the Delaware Court of Chancery in October. Now,
- 23:15Speaker 1: let's talk about there's legal fallout from Musk buying Twitter,
- 23:20Speaker 1: which he's for some reason renamed x which everyone now
- 23:23Speaker 1: describes as formerly Twitter. There are numerous lawsuits over whether
- 23:29Speaker 1: xo's millions to former employees, vendors, and landlords, including whether
- 23:34Speaker 1: more than one point six million dollars in legal fees
- 23:37Speaker 1: are owed to Twitter's ex CEO.
- 23:41Speaker 3: Well, you know, when Musk took over Twitter, but before
- 23:45Speaker 3: we renamed it acts, there was a big house cleaning
- 23:48Speaker 3: and then sitting CEO and pretty much most of the
- 23:51Speaker 3: senior management and a lot of mid level management was
- 23:54Speaker 3: just shown the door. And there are allegations out there
- 23:57Speaker 3: that they were shown the door in a way it
- 24:00Speaker 3: was violative of their contract rights to have you know,
- 24:04Speaker 3: effectively golden parachute. No, if there's a you know, change
- 24:07Speaker 3: of ownership, that all there's options would vest and so
- 24:10Speaker 3: forth and Twitter basically stiffed them on those payments. That
- 24:14Speaker 3: has given rise to a lot of different lawsuits. Each
- 24:17Speaker 3: of them is probably going to be a little bit
- 24:19Speaker 3: different in nature, and typically you actually don't see this
- 24:23Speaker 3: after an acquisition then, you know, usually that's part of
- 24:27Speaker 3: the assumption is you know, there are these contract rights
- 24:29Speaker 3: that I'm not going to be able to avoid paying.
- 24:31Speaker 3: Twitter seems to have been a little bit more or
- 24:34Speaker 3: the new Twitter seems to have been a little bit
- 24:36Speaker 3: more litigious about about this and trying to fight the
- 24:39Speaker 3: contractual rights, you know, many of which are available on
- 24:43Speaker 3: the SEC's website. They look pretty typical and at least
- 24:47Speaker 3: on first blush, just based on the terms of those deals,
- 24:50Speaker 3: there's nothing like kind of weird or exotic or sketchy
- 24:53Speaker 3: about them. So, you know, my guess is Twitter is
- 24:56Speaker 3: going to try to make an argument that for some reason,
- 24:59Speaker 3: there was conduct by these employees before they were they
- 25:03Speaker 3: were released, and therefore when Twitter and mister Musk basically
- 25:07Speaker 3: showed them the door, he did so because he had
- 25:09Speaker 3: cause to fire them. Unclear whether that is true or not,
- 25:13Speaker 3: but that the defense that Twitter is going to be
- 25:15Speaker 3: putting forward, because usually these these contracts say look, I'm
- 25:18Speaker 3: going to get this payment unless I am terminated for
- 25:21Speaker 3: cause or something along those lines or some other type
- 25:25Speaker 3: of misbehavior. So that's almost certainly going to be the
- 25:28Speaker 3: legal strategy that Twitter takes on. But you know, in
- 25:31Speaker 3: some ways, that's not a single argument that you can
- 25:34Speaker 3: make for every one of these folks, every single one
- 25:35Speaker 3: of them. You kind of have to say, oh, and
- 25:37Speaker 3: then here's why this person was fired for cause, and
- 25:40Speaker 3: here's why this other person was fired for cause. So
- 25:42Speaker 3: it is a big and somewhat of an uphill legal
- 25:45Speaker 3: battle to do that. You know, It's it's kind of
- 25:48Speaker 3: an interesting question about whether that uphill battle is in
- 25:53Speaker 3: part kind of predicated against a ticking clock of trying
- 25:56Speaker 3: to understand just how much money Twitter or X or
- 26:00Speaker 3: whatever you want to call it has it in the
- 26:02Speaker 3: bank to operate right now, given that it is now
- 26:04Speaker 3: a heavily indebted company and is having to pay significant
- 26:07Speaker 3: interest rate payments. And so maybe if it's kind of thinking, gosh,
- 26:11Speaker 3: we may be entering a zone of insolvement sometime soon,
- 26:14Speaker 3: this possibly could just a strategy to put off having
- 26:17Speaker 3: to pay these former employees until the whole company is
- 26:20Speaker 3: in Chapter eleven and they're restructuring every creditors sorts of claim.
- 26:24Speaker 1: So there's also a settlement over a lawsuit brought by
- 26:27Speaker 1: a pension fund over executive compensation packages at Tesla. There's
- 26:33Speaker 1: going to be an October thirteenth hearing on that settlement.
- 26:36Speaker 3: That one is a little bit different because that one,
- 26:38Speaker 3: I think has to do with director compensation at Tesla
- 26:42Speaker 3: and not Musk's compensation, if I am not mistaken, And
- 26:46Speaker 3: so it's kind of based on different facts. Because it's settled,
- 26:49Speaker 3: we don't exactly know how things are going to come out.
- 26:52Speaker 3: Usually with these settlements that both sides sort of say,
- 26:54Speaker 3: we think we had a strong case, but there are
- 26:56Speaker 3: of course risks that we might lose, and therefore we
- 26:58Speaker 3: think this is a reasonable settlement amount. And so my
- 27:02Speaker 3: guess is those things typically are going to end up
- 27:07Speaker 3: getting signed off on. But you know, in recent months famously,
- 27:10Speaker 3: the Delaware chance Re Court has become an entertaining, if
- 27:13Speaker 3: somewhat frenetic landscape on which people suddenly show up and
- 27:17Speaker 3: object to settlement, such as in the AMC settlement last
- 27:21Speaker 3: month in front of Vice Chancellor's earned So my guess
- 27:23Speaker 3: is this ends up sort of failing through. A successful
- 27:26Speaker 3: settlement of a case is usually seen by all sides
- 27:29Speaker 3: as you know, kind of a victory, including the judges
- 27:31Speaker 3: who now don't have to adjudicate the case. But you know,
- 27:33Speaker 3: you never know whether an objector is going to have
- 27:37Speaker 3: some traction. There are always a few people who are
- 27:39Speaker 3: kind of thinking that this should have been a more
- 27:41Speaker 3: lucrative settlement or less lucrative settlement, But my guess is
- 27:44Speaker 3: it ends up being signed off.
- 27:46Speaker 1: What caught my eye is that attorneys for the pension
- 27:49Speaker 1: fund are looking for two hundred and thirty million dollars
- 27:52Speaker 1: in legal fees, which adds up to more than ten
- 27:56Speaker 1: thousand dollars an hour.
- 27:58Speaker 2: Yes, seriously, that's another job that we missed out.
- 28:02Speaker 3: Actually, so this is an often controversial but also a
- 28:05Speaker 3: little bit complicated thing about how our plaintiff attorneys compensated.
- 28:10Speaker 3: There definitely is a fairly large cottage industry of plant
- 28:13Speaker 3: off attorneys who say, okay, let's go after this particular violation.
- 28:16Speaker 3: We'll find a stockholder who can be our representative stockholder,
- 28:19Speaker 3: and then we're going to move forward with a class
- 28:21Speaker 3: action or a derivative action and try to get a settlement.
- 28:24Speaker 3: But there's kind of a parallel to the venture capital
- 28:28Speaker 3: industry where I think you know the famous adage that
- 28:31Speaker 3: nine out of ten VC backed companies basically just go
- 28:35Speaker 3: sideways or fail, right, you'll make any money off of them.
- 28:38Speaker 3: You'll only make money off of the one in ten
- 28:40Speaker 3: that succeeds. And there's something that's kind of similar about
- 28:44Speaker 3: these lawsuits that when you take on any one of
- 28:47Speaker 3: these lawsuits, you are effectively bearing risk to take it
- 28:51Speaker 3: on the overwhelming majority at the time, you're not going
- 28:54Speaker 3: to get that much out of it. If anything, if
- 28:56Speaker 3: the case gets dismissed, you have spent however much you
- 28:59Speaker 3: spent as a plane is firm, getting absolutely nothing. And
- 29:03Speaker 3: so the theory in a lot of these cases that
- 29:06Speaker 3: you know there will be some sort of percentage of
- 29:08Speaker 3: the overall settlement that the plaintiffs attorneys are going to
- 29:11Speaker 3: get that can't be exorbitant, but the judges generally do
- 29:16Speaker 3: try to take account of the fact that there are
- 29:19Speaker 3: significant costs in bringing these cases and there are a
- 29:21Speaker 3: lot of risks associated with them. And so you know,
- 29:24Speaker 3: if you just look x post and in hindsight that
- 29:27Speaker 3: this one settlement, it's like, oh, what attorney makes ten
- 29:30Speaker 3: thousand dollars an hour. Well, the fact of the matter
- 29:33Speaker 3: is if there were nine other cases that had just
- 29:36Speaker 3: as much effort going into them and they all ended
- 29:38Speaker 3: up with nothing, then that looks more like one thousand
- 29:41Speaker 3: dollars an hour. Right, that the fence side attorney might
- 29:44Speaker 3: easily be billing regardless of whether the case wins or loses,
- 29:47Speaker 3: and therefore doesn't even actually have any risk there. So
- 29:50Speaker 3: when you sort of look at the numbers in isolation there,
- 29:53Speaker 3: they're eye popping. They're definitely eye popping when you back
- 29:56Speaker 3: it out and sort of say, well, you know, on
- 29:58Speaker 3: some level, while we're on the topic of lottery tickets,
- 30:01Speaker 3: taking these cases from the plaintiffs side is a little
- 30:03Speaker 3: bit of a lottery ticket as well. That may give
- 30:06Speaker 3: a little bit more explanation to it. Do the courts
- 30:09Speaker 3: and the parties always get it right, It's not clear, right.
- 30:12Speaker 3: The fact of the matter is that you know the
- 30:14Speaker 3: attorneys that they are not doing this because they are
- 30:17Speaker 3: essentially the newest incarnation of Mother Teresa running around, right.
- 30:20Speaker 3: They are trying to make a living too. You know,
- 30:22Speaker 3: Plaintiff attorneys are people too, and they've got to make
- 30:24Speaker 3: a living, and so they're going to try to claim
- 30:27Speaker 3: as much as they think they can they can feasibly
- 30:30Speaker 3: claim from the transaction. One of the things that's a
- 30:32Speaker 3: little bit dangerous about these stockholder litigation cases is that
- 30:36Speaker 3: you got the defendants that would like to settle, You
- 30:38Speaker 3: got the plaintiff's attorney that would like to settle. You
- 30:42Speaker 3: got one plaintiff that's kind of phenomenally being represented by
- 30:45Speaker 3: the plaintiff, maybe backed by an entire class of plaintiffs,
- 30:49Speaker 3: but they're usually usually silent in the background. So are
- 30:54Speaker 3: the defense attorneys and Planet's attorneys basically sort of ushering
- 30:57Speaker 3: through a settlement that doesn't give a lot of value
- 31:00Speaker 3: to the real harmed parties in the case. That's a
- 31:02Speaker 3: big danger and we see how fairly significant attorney compensation
- 31:07Speaker 3: amount that better be matched by, you know, a significant
- 31:11Speaker 3: benefit that is given to the company and to the
- 31:14Speaker 3: stockholders here that there is an agreement that you know,
- 31:17Speaker 3: some of this conversation is going to be given back.
- 31:20Speaker 3: I guess there's another question that sits in the background, though,
- 31:23Speaker 3: is that is that actually going to be paid by
- 31:25Speaker 3: an insurance company or you know, are there some hidden
- 31:29Speaker 3: indemnification rights? And I think in some cases that's been
- 31:33Speaker 3: ruled out, but I'm not sure it's been completely ruled
- 31:36Speaker 3: out across all corners here, so we'll have.
- 31:39Speaker 1: To keep our eye on the Delaware Chancery Court next month.
- 31:43Speaker 1: Thanks so much, Eric. That's Professor Eric Tally of Columbia
- 31:46Speaker 1: Law School, and that's it for this edition of The
- 31:48Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get the latest
- 31:51Speaker 1: legal news on our Bloomberg Law podcast. You can find
- 31:54Speaker 1: them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www dot bloomberg
- 31:59Speaker 1: dot com podcast slash Law, And remember to tune into
- 32:03Speaker 1: The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at ten pm Wall
- 32:06Speaker 1: Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg