Latest / Love Letters to Troublemakers / E6. Workplaces are Health Hazards
Transcript
- 0:00We don't want to think that we're part of this unfair system
- 0:04that is perpetuating harm on a global scale.
- 0:09At psychosocial conferences, one of the keynote sneakers got on
- 0:12stage and said, hey, look at the US and do the opposite.
- 0:15I don't think people in the US realize that this is how we're
- 0:18viewed. Europe is putting laws into
- 0:20place to prevent American practices like the vitality
- 0:24curve because they've watched us and it's extraordinarily
- 0:28damaging to culture. All right, hi, everybody.
- 0:39Welcome to another episode of the Circle Back Club, a podcast
- 0:42for workers who are done pretending that everything is
- 0:45fine. I'm a partner, Ray, and I'm
- 0:47joined, as always, by Lars Galleon.
- 0:50And today, we're going somewhere most workplace conversations are
- 0:54scared to go, at least the ones that are being had in the US.
- 0:58Yeah, so there's there's a term by researchers and governments
- 1:03around the world called psychosocial hazards.
- 1:06It describes the conditions at work, the overload, the lack of
- 1:11control, the job insecurity, the constant surveillance, the
- 1:16'cause that is measurable and documented psychological harm.
- 1:22And today we're asking why the US, one of the wealthiest
- 1:26nations on Earth, does almost nothing about it legally.
- 1:30And to have that conversation with us, I've invited one of the
- 1:33smartest people I know working on this, doctor Nicole Decay.
- 1:36She's an organizational psychologist and founder of
- 1:38Human Analyst, a platform she built to democratize the
- 1:41employee experience and reduce harm in the workplace using
- 1:44data. Nicole, welcome to the club.
- 1:48Why? Thank you for having me.
- 1:49OK you all so I want to start with something a mentee shared
- 1:52with me last week. She's pretty early career in her
- 1:55late 20s and a few months ago she noticed that her manager was
- 1:59canceling her one-on-one calls pretty regularly.
- 2:03And last week she calls me sobbing in the middle of a panic
- 2:06attack because her manager put her on a pit and she didn't know
- 2:10what to do or if she should chat with HR.
- 2:14And I guess I'm curious to hear from you both, Nicole, as a
- 2:17researcher and practitioner, what happens in our body and
- 2:21mind when we're caught off guard in this manner?
- 2:24The signs that I would point at for what's happening in our body
- 2:27and mind, panic attack and sobbing.
- 2:30So those are two severe responses that a person is
- 2:32having to work situation. A panic attack is a, that's a,
- 2:36that's a, those are overwhelming.
- 2:38People go to the hospital for those because often they don't
- 2:39understand what's happening to them when they happen.
- 2:42So I want to name first, like there's a severe stress response
- 2:45happening. And so you want to look at that.
- 2:48And if you're into somatics and body, well, you know your
- 2:51background, so you're into somatics and body work stuff,
- 2:54right? You get them into their body so
- 2:56that they, you can stop and calm down the immediate response that
- 3:00is happening inside of them. But more specifically, what's
- 3:05happening is that person is facing uncertainty and
- 3:08uncertainty is stressful. One of the psychosocial hazards
- 3:12that I don't, I don't know if you named, but it's poor change
- 3:16management and New Zealand, they regulate this is one of the
- 3:19psychosocial hazards, not looking out change and planning
- 3:24for IT. People are the biggest predictor
- 3:26of change failing. And so you should have a plan in
- 3:28place for your people. There's a lot of tools to plan
- 3:31for change for people. There's a lot of models like for
- 3:34this as well because it's such an important aspect.
- 3:38And so when you're giving people uncertainty all the time, you're
- 3:41creating stress responses like in the body specifically you're
- 3:44triggering a threat response. So that makes me think that like
- 3:48your amygdala is getting triggered.
- 3:50You might be having stress hormones like cortisol or
- 3:52adrenaline coursing through your body because that's what happens
- 3:55when you're faced with uncertainty.
- 3:58And I also I wanted you've hit on something when it comes to
- 4:02pips that I think are becoming too common in workplaces as
- 4:07well. That I also, besides answering
- 4:09the questions I kind of want to address because this reaction to
- 4:12pips, people just getting put on pips out of nowhere is happening
- 4:16due to harmful corporate practices that don't have
- 4:20efficacy that they work. So a lot of people are being
- 4:26exposed to this thing called the vitality curve, which Aparna,
- 4:29you know, I, I am against the vitality curve.
- 4:32There is no evidence, no peer reviewed evidence that this
- 4:35works in any setting anywhere. And there is a lot of evidence
- 4:38that it works poorly. Result.
- 4:41It harms people. It harms people.
- 4:43The only thing you can find is that it increases short term
- 4:46profit because our financial systems are set up to have
- 4:49people on the liability side. And we don't have another thing
- 4:52that incorporates our IP and our brain and our knowledge that is
- 4:55extremely valuable to the company that's not on our
- 4:58assets. And so when they're trying to
- 5:00get short term profit up, they fire us, bring down their
- 5:03liabilities. And so it's good for short term
- 5:06profit, it's bad for long term things.
- 5:08There's a researcher of the University of Lucene who
- 5:10identified this as a people practice that was used in every
- 5:13major scandal and loss of life that he investigated over the
- 5:16last several decades. This is a people practice like
- 5:21where people are getting put on pips and gas lit just rampantly
- 5:25because someone has decided one in 10 people should be fired
- 5:29every year. And this just started in the
- 5:301980s. This is not something that like
- 5:32we used to have job security. This is not something that's
- 5:34common in other places they're talking about.
- 5:38There's a law that would like up.
- 5:40I don't know if it got passed, but the EU is looking at a law
- 5:43against the vitality curve specifically because of how
- 5:47harmful it is. So there's also this thing where
- 5:49it's like, I mean, what part of the year is it?
- 5:53Is it time for people to start firing for that that one in 10
- 5:56that they need to get to? It is the time of the year.
- 6:01And managers have to make up pips when they do this.
- 6:04I've talked to managers who talk about that's why they quit being
- 6:06a manager because they had to gaslight people into saying that
- 6:09they weren't performing because they were required to.
- 6:13So I was like, that's, that's a long answer.
- 6:15But like there are these pieces of just it's a stress response.
- 6:21It's AI would say it's a reasonable stress response,
- 6:24especially since the last I sellers like 60% of above 60% of
- 6:28the American workforce doesn't have any savings that are living
- 6:33paycheck to paycheck. So when you're talking about
- 6:36losing your job, it's not just loss of a job, It's not just
- 6:39loss of an occupation. That might be loss of field,
- 6:41loss of housing, loss of care, less of medical care if you have
- 6:45serious medical conditions, since we don't get guaranteed
- 6:48insurance here either. And we're in Washington state
- 6:51where you can get unemployment. Sometimes you can't.
- 6:53If you quit, you need to get fired.
- 6:55Like, right, you have to get out somehow without quitting to keep
- 7:00your dignity when you're being harmed at work or being put on a
- 7:03PIP, something that is clearly setting you up for failure and
- 7:06all you're going to do is stress about trying to meet it.
- 7:08When the goal of Pips have been in rooms where they talk about
- 7:11like, we only want 10% of Pips to pass once they get on the
- 7:14PIP, it's time to go. And like the point of Pips is to
- 7:17get people out. It's to document layoffs and
- 7:21caught in without having to go through the process of actually
- 7:24doing layoffs. It's cheaper.
- 7:28It's so normalized that you're like, well, we everyone's just
- 7:30like, well, we can do it. Everyone else is doing it like
- 7:32we need to produce our workforce.
- 7:34So let's not do it with a riff. Let's avoid the Warren Act.
- 7:36Who cares? Like everyone does this.
- 7:38So let's just keep keep it out. Thanks, Jack Welch.
- 7:41We've done great things for this nation's businesses.
- 7:44Oh, not. Jack Welch Lars, I'm curious,
- 7:48you know, what you think of situations like this.
- 7:50And one thing that we didn't actually do is like really frame
- 7:53psychosocial hazards. So yeah, we'll have Lars go and
- 7:56then let's actually frame what we're talking about.
- 8:00There's the psychosocial side and then there's the hazard
- 8:02side. And what you're talking about,
- 8:04Nicole, and what I think about in answering this question and
- 8:07thinking about this person's experiences, when you are
- 8:10treated as a liability, your body is going to respond as
- 8:14such. And that the other part of what
- 8:17she was talking to you about a part of.
- 8:18Should I talk to HR and trying to figure out if that is the
- 8:22best way to keep you safe? And the first thing that I think
- 8:26about and Nicole just touched on it is the documentation.
- 8:31And documentation is one of the primary ways to maintain control
- 8:39and a sense of safety in a large corporation because everything
- 8:42is a liability. And my initial thought in
- 8:45thinking about this person and the situation was, was she
- 8:48documenting the managers cancel cancellations?
- 8:52Is she documenting the lack of dissemination of knowledge that
- 8:55she is getting? How can she protect herself when
- 8:59more likely than not, if you are, if you are starting a PIP,
- 9:02you are responsible for hyper documentation.
- 9:05And so there's this, it's a really reasonable response to
- 9:10libel driven top down surveillance that you're being
- 9:15surprised by. And yeah, like what do we do in
- 9:18those working conditions? It's it's not, it's not a
- 9:23mediated conversation with HR. To Nicole's point, you're
- 9:26already on a pit, so it's documentation land.
- 9:29So, OK, let's frame psychosocial hazards.
- 9:31When we talk about them, we're not talking just about having a
- 9:33bad day at work, right? Like we're talking about
- 9:37conditions at work that are by design.
- 9:40It's the management, it's the culture of work that causes both
- 9:44psychological and often physical harm.
- 9:46And Nicole, you've been writing about and speaking about and
- 9:51doing work on their workplace trauma, bullying, chronic
- 9:54stress, harassment. What do people need to know
- 9:59about psychosocial hazards? And is it something like OSHA
- 10:03for which we have some regulations in the US?
- 10:09Yeah, so we've covered that, you know, psychosocial harms,
- 10:12they're health harming behaviors.
- 10:13They're usually interpersonal in nature.
- 10:15That's why people call them psychological.
- 10:18But what that means is that they're they're the way that we
- 10:21interact with each other is what causes the harm.
- 10:23And they're tied to things that we know are health harming.
- 10:26So anxiety, depression, PTSD, heart, heart attacks, but gut
- 10:33and health like stomach problems that come with a lot of the
- 10:37chronic stress symptoms in general are some these are some
- 10:40of the things that I just named. And so when you have a whole
- 10:45host of in the the US, when I tell when I describe these to
- 10:49people, people are like, oh, those are social determinants of
- 10:51health. And that's not a term used in in
- 10:54my area. I think that's more from the
- 10:57health research. And it's also not a term used
- 10:59internationally to describe this.
- 11:00They're, they're specific to the workplace.
- 11:02The psychosocial hazards are also, they're usually talked
- 11:05about in the context of work. So that's the big piece.
- 11:10So what are they? And I think that, like I
- 11:13mentioned, one that people wouldn't usually look at and
- 11:16that's poor change management, right?
- 11:17There's a lot of companies say the only thing constant has
- 11:20changed that that's what you should be prepared for.
- 11:23But there's a change cycle that gets you out of that uncertainty
- 11:25piece that stops stress. If we don't, we're constantly
- 11:28and uncertainty and constantly getting stress hormones
- 11:31released, we're not doing well. You need to plan for change.
- 11:34You need to plan and they need to go through the whole project,
- 11:37give people a chance to rest and then start again.
- 11:39Can't just constantly be expecting people to burn, burn,
- 11:41burn, burn, burn. And that's another one like
- 11:43extended work hours. A lot of salaried employees are
- 11:46expected to work 60 to 80 hour weeks and forced overtime for
- 11:51manufacturing employees. I don't know how many companies
- 11:53I've worked out where they did that, where they did mandatory
- 11:56overtime required 10 hours a week for employees like work on
- 12:00your weekends, figure out how to fit in your 10 hours.
- 12:02We need you to do this work instead of hiring people, which
- 12:04would be a lot cheaper, both in terms of the turnover that
- 12:08you're getting because you're burning people out and just the
- 12:10cost because you're paying people 10 1/2 inadequate rewards
- 12:14and recognition. And this is one that I'm like
- 12:17when we talk about the pay in the United States and that's
- 12:22part of your rewards and recognition.
- 12:24And when no, no one on minimum wage can afford to live in the
- 12:31US anymore, we have that here. Right.
- 12:34Like there isn't a single, there isn't a single census tract
- 12:37where you can live on a minimum wage.
- 12:39And even living right now with the, the expectations, you know,
- 12:43your housing isn't more than 30% of your income.
- 12:46I don't know anybody that's got that situation right now unless
- 12:49they bought in the early 2000s or earlier, right?
- 12:53Well, I guess mid like up to like 2015 you had.
- 12:55But there there's just these things that are against us that
- 12:58create this as a psychosocial hazard that's systemically
- 13:01happening to all of us. Like when I worked at Boeing, we
- 13:04had these raise pools and that's, so your manager got a
- 13:07percentage of like a pool that he got to give and it was 2
- 13:10point like 7% of his staff's salaries.
- 13:14And so he had to figure out how to.
- 13:16And we, this was in years when Boeing was making record
- 13:18profits. It was after the recession was
- 13:21over. And we are getting the lowest
- 13:23bonuses that we got in years too.
- 13:25So we're not like they're making record profits, billions and
- 13:28billions of dollars. We can see this on their
- 13:30financials. And our race pools don't go up.
- 13:32They don't match inflation. They're not doing anything.
- 13:34And then my manager tells me that he has to do this force
- 13:36distribution where he has to agree with the older person on
- 13:40my team that doesn't need the money, that in order for me to
- 13:43get above average, they have to get below average and a 1% raise
- 13:49so that I can get 5. Like, these are the sorts of
- 13:52things that we're giving people at work that's been so, so, so,
- 13:56so normalized. And then we're told to, like, be
- 13:58grateful that same year when we had record profits and got the
- 14:02lowest bonuses in years as employees.
- 14:05When I said that out loud, this guy next to me maybe 10 to 15
- 14:08years older than me, immediately his response is, well, you
- 14:12should just be grateful that you're getting a bonus.
- 14:14I didn't get that when I was your age.
- 14:15Yeah. Well, and I think something that
- 14:17gets me about this topic, right, because, well, this topic,
- 14:21nobody's talking about psychosocial hazards.
- 14:23People are talking though, about bullying.
- 14:24They're talking about chronic stress and burnout.
- 14:27What gets me is that it's always a personal feeling, You know,
- 14:32that you're stressed, that you're having gastro issues.
- 14:35You need therapy, you need boundaries, you need a gratitude
- 14:39practice. I had a coach once tell me,
- 14:41well, have you thought of journaling?
- 14:44And besides the fact that I actually can't read my own
- 14:47handwriting. And sure, there's also a world
- 14:52in which, like, all of these things are helpful and useful
- 14:56for us to consider, but the structure of the job is causing
- 15:01harm at a rate that a breathing exercise isn't going to fix.
- 15:04And Lars, you've jumped from, you know, 15 years as a
- 15:09corporate leader and now you've transitioned to being a somatic
- 15:13practitioner. Like what's coming up for you?
- 15:15And, and I guess, you know, I'm also curious, like, when did you
- 15:18become acquainted with this term psychosocial hazards?
- 15:21Well, it's because of you, Aparna.
- 15:23You brought this. Language into my life.
- 15:25And Nicole brought into my life. Here and here we are.
- 15:31Yeah, I think, you know, for me it was personal before I found
- 15:37it in the data or found it as you know.
- 15:39I didn't know that this was something that was documented,
- 15:42you know, like the CDC is reporting psychosocial hazards
- 15:46kind of, but it's not something that our HR teams ever talked
- 15:49about. We didn't sit down in our org
- 15:51design meetings and look at our sentiment data or in our
- 15:55engagement strategy and talk about how can we actually
- 15:57measure the health of our employees, How can we share that
- 16:00responsibility. And what I saw especially in the
- 16:06larger corporations that I was in, the higher up you got the
- 16:09sicker you became. And it was shocking to me to
- 16:17experience leaders getting sick, going on sabbatical, coming back
- 16:23and getting promoted and taking on even more pressure and not,
- 16:27and these are a lot of HR leaders, right.
- 16:29So they're not actually change. I mean, we were leading a
- 16:32strategic refresh every quarter and massive org design projects,
- 16:39but not talking about the way that we are treating each other
- 16:44and the way that work was treating us.
- 16:47And I think what was really supportive about learning about
- 16:51the psychosocial hazards was, of course, this is not just white
- 16:55collar work that these measure. I mean, it's really, really
- 16:58important for blue collar labor. And I was interested in
- 17:01understanding what are the differences of if you're in a
- 17:04white collar position, what are those big stressors of the high
- 17:08time pressure, high emotional labor, low job control, things
- 17:13that in HR teams are for me in DEI positions we never talked
- 17:17about, we never were getting interested in.
- 17:19How do we measure that and understand the way that with
- 17:23this data is really what's causing the burnout, the
- 17:26depression, the absent absenteeism, the cardiovascular
- 17:30diseases. So yeah, my journey in this was
- 17:36seeing it first hand and the way that we avoided harm through
- 17:44moving people across the company.
- 17:47You know, if someone did something bad, we just move them
- 17:50somewhere else because that was cheaper or something.
- 17:53I never understand that strategy.
- 17:56It's called passing the lemons. Very.
- 17:59That's very common in education, like churches.
- 18:02You move the bad priest to a different parish.
- 18:05Yeah. Yeah, across the lemons.
- 18:08Yeah. And then if you're sick, you
- 18:10know, we just, we don't talk about it.
- 18:14The person leaves and then they come back.
- 18:17And so, yeah, this got me to a point of, of it was literally
- 18:21untenable for me to feel the somatic impact of it.
- 18:27And now I'm just trying to help people to feel more and make
- 18:29more choices. Speaking of harm, OK, I want to
- 18:32play before we get too deep into our conversation, I want to play
- 18:36this video that Nicole made titled Workplace Abuse is
- 18:40Complex Trauma. And Lars, I don't think you've
- 18:41listened to it yet. Workplace trauma and complex
- 18:45trauma go hand in hand. Complex trauma is different than
- 18:51what we think of as the big T traumatic experiences that we
- 18:54associate with the word. Complex traumatic experiences
- 18:58are situations that you can't escape that result in stress,
- 19:04and they can be things that make you fear for your life here in
- 19:07the States. That's something for your PTSD
- 19:10diagnosis. If you want a diagnosis, they're
- 19:13like you got a fear for your life.
- 19:15And I think that you can easily say that for a lot of people
- 19:18here in America, if you lose your job, there is a fear for
- 19:21your life. Over 60% of Americans are living
- 19:23paycheck to paycheck. If you can't access food because
- 19:27you lost your job, I don't know how that's not a threat to your
- 19:30personhood and your life. And there are so many people,
- 19:33the majority of people actually are living in that reality with
- 19:37very little social backing. If you leave your job, there's
- 19:40very little net to fall on. And there's clinicians who do
- 19:44this work who point out that when they see people who are
- 19:48experiencing workplace abuse, their symptoms are the same as
- 19:51people who have complex PTSD because it is a situation that's
- 19:54chronically stressful that you can't escape, that we're stuck
- 19:57in. When you have complex trauma
- 19:59symptoms, they're harder to get over, they're harder to treat.
- 20:03If you expose someone to chronic levels of stress, it impacts
- 20:06their sense of self, their body, their personhood, their
- 20:08Physiology, and. We don't talk about that being
- 20:12something that an office job can do enough.
- 20:14Because it is. It is a chronically stressful
- 20:16situation. If you have someone trying to
- 20:18set you up for failure and manipulating things so that they
- 20:20can get rid of you, you are extremely fearful of losing that
- 20:25job. OK, I'm going to pause it there.
- 20:27It's such a hard video to hear. And I think so many of these
- 20:31little clips, like educational clips, Nicole, that you've been
- 20:34making over the past year, they're hard because we don't
- 20:39think about work giving us PTSD. We think about going to war and
- 20:44coming back and getting PTSD right, or losing somebody in a
- 20:48really traumatic way and then getting PTSD from that.
- 20:52Do you remember last year you shared this like 30 page
- 20:54document with me that had? Do you remember this?
- 20:58I was gonna ask you to send it to me because I think that I
- 21:00lost it. I'm like, yeah, I remember that
- 21:02I've had. I can resend.
- 21:03It to you. OK, send it back to me because
- 21:05I'm like, I don't remember where that went.
- 21:06Yes, when he pulled all the facts, I was like, God, that was
- 21:08good of me. Put those all in one place.
- 21:10Yeah. So Lars, she put all of this
- 21:12information in this like massive document and I pulled out a
- 21:16couple of stats from that, you know, So one that's really stood
- 21:20out to me over the past year as I've gone back to that document
- 21:22is that workplace stress is the cause of 120,000 deaths in the
- 21:29US each year and 83% of US workers suffer from work related
- 21:33stress. And I am assuming that these are
- 21:35preventable deaths, right? We also know that nearly half of
- 21:39American Canadian workers report experiencing work related stress
- 21:43daily and for people under 35 S younger millennials and Gen.
- 21:48Z that jumps to almost 60%. People working 40 hours or more
- 21:54show significantly higher psychological risk and burnout
- 21:58people in and Lars you said this right.
- 22:00Jobs with high demands or high pressure and low control
- 22:03associated with a 23% increase in coronary heart disease and a
- 22:0830% increase in stroke risk. And when I hear data like this,
- 22:13I guess, Nicole, when you see what's happening in the US,
- 22:18what's a trend that actually still shocks you even with
- 22:22everything that you know about psychosocial hazards and how
- 22:27workplaces are designed? There's two, I want to say
- 22:29really quick one I already mentioned, and it's the like
- 22:33older generations and people who have been through this
- 22:36reinforcing the system. I think of those, the experiment
- 22:39that they talk about with the monkeys that like go up the
- 22:40ladder and they would try to grab something and the
- 22:42experimenters taught them like it was dangerous and they would
- 22:45punish them. And so the monkeys started, they
- 22:46would pull each other down to protect each other and to stop
- 22:48them from like going forward. And they get passed down through
- 22:50generation and generation and they don't know why they keep
- 22:53pulling people down, but they're not going to let them get them
- 22:54to the prize at the top. And that's kind of how it feels
- 22:57when you've got these older generations that are like, just
- 23:00be like us. Do what we did.
- 23:02Shut up like that. We are not, we are not faced
- 23:07with the same economic reality that you were.
- 23:10Even people who are like 2009, that's when I graduated from
- 23:14college. That is the last time the
- 23:15minimum minimum wage has been raised in this country.
- 23:18That's 17 years, and in that time we've experienced so much
- 23:24inflation and so much wealth inequality and redistribution to
- 23:28the top and this vitality curve that's only rewarding the 20%
- 23:31and then giving everyone else below.
- 23:36Yeah. Below at like raises that don't
- 23:39even keep up with the cost of living.
- 23:40So it's there's that piece of like the the older generations
- 23:44that just keep saying when people are bringing this up, the
- 23:46gas lighting, they're like, just be like us and be quiet, you
- 23:49lazy little those are not that's not that's not this, that's not
- 23:54what's happening. We are not lazy.
- 23:55We are not entitled. This is a completely different
- 23:57economic reality where right now in my house, 75% of our income
- 24:03goes towards housing because that's how much it costs to live
- 24:05in the city of Seattle. Like this is not, this is not
- 24:10attendable anyway. So that's like one of them.
- 24:12The other one is, and I'm going to say this really quickly, just
- 24:14like CEO pay disparity that people are so OK with this.
- 24:18I do not understand why people are like, yeah, we should
- 24:20absolutely let CEO pay go up over 1000%.
- 24:24And the time period where worker pay goes up 27 or 28.
- 24:30No, like I don't understand why more people are so mad about
- 24:33this. The Economic Policy Institute
- 24:36put out a report that showed that CEO pay in the last five
- 24:39years is between 280 to 408 times more than average
- 24:43employee. And when you look up what an
- 24:45average employee makes, that's $64,000 a year.
- 24:48Do you think that ACEO is worth between 300 and 400 times like
- 24:53of people making 65 grand a year?
- 24:55But that seems not rational to me at all because they're not,
- 25:00no one is. No one is that bringing in that
- 25:03much productivity. And just because they own it
- 25:05doesn't mean that they should get 90% of the spoils when
- 25:09people are what's making it happen.
- 25:11So those two are like the quick ones.
- 25:13But I I think like labor, labor rights in general, the fact that
- 25:18we are regressing as a nation while our peers are moving it
- 25:21forward. There's a whole plan to
- 25:23dismantle labor that is not moving forward because labor is
- 25:28bipartisan. Everyone across the board has to
- 25:32work and we all need labor rights.
- 25:34But we've got companies trying to.
- 25:36We've got company owned to two companies that are owned by two
- 25:40of the most anti labor billionaires in the world that
- 25:42are going after the National Labor Review Board, which for
- 25:45people outside of the US, that is what makes our that's the
- 25:48government agency that gives our unions the power that they have
- 25:52to actually stand up for workers.
- 25:53And say what you want about unions, but as a group, people
- 25:57in unions are better off than people outside of unions.
- 26:00So like there might be individuals that do not match
- 26:02that trend, but as a group they bring up the Wellness of
- 26:06workforces. And communities and communities
- 26:08where there's more, we're going to talk about labor rights and
- 26:12the labor rights IT labor rights index in a second.
- 26:15But Nicole, do you remember we worked, We had this one client
- 26:19that we worked on together who got so upset with us because the
- 26:23way in which we had written the goals, we're going to jeopardize
- 26:26the bonuses of the executive suite.
- 26:30And this senior leader was livid, was livid with us.
- 26:37And yeah, it's it's a the thing about the CEO and I think
- 26:41executive compensation at large across all sectors, not just the
- 26:45private sector. We see a lot of this happening
- 26:47in philanthropy and in nonprofits as well.
- 26:50It it is also really wild to me that you have half of your
- 26:55workforce living in poverty, but you're paying yourselves $30
- 26:59million a year. I got a screenshot from somebody
- 27:03who was a warehouse employee and on their onboarding documents
- 27:07was don't forget to sign up for SNAP.
- 27:10And so SNAP is Washington state, right?
- 27:13So this is Washington state food stamps on their onboarding.
- 27:17Some HR person was like, hey, we got to reduce harm.
- 27:19Let's make sure that they know they're being paid so little
- 27:21that they qualify for SNAP. They can't lose out on those
- 27:24benefits. That is wild.
- 27:27Like we are and we are normalizing so much horror.
- 27:31It's wild, right? But I can see someone in in high
- 27:34level HR being like, hey, hey, we got to let them know that
- 27:36they qualify for food stamps. Like make sure they know that
- 27:40they got to eat because we're not paying them enough to do
- 27:42that. It's unbelievable and I think
- 27:46that the lack of Labor rights policy means that this is these
- 27:52are the decisions that HR leaders are making, you know,
- 27:55doing the bidding of this unbelievable pay and equity.
- 27:59So let's talk about it. The US scores near the bottom of
- 28:03developed nations on the wage indicator Labor Rights Index.
- 28:07And just for context for listeners, this index evaluates
- 28:11145 countries on the legal protections for workers on 10
- 28:16different dimensions. So some of them are fair wages,
- 28:19employment security, working hours, family responsibilities,
- 28:23freedom of association, which is what we're talking about, of the
- 28:26right to form groups, organizations, unions.
- 28:29And the point of it is to make this information accessible and
- 28:33ultimately improve workers rights and the conditions
- 28:36globally. For the context of where the US
- 28:39sits, we're ranked worse than our neighbor country, Mexico, in
- 28:43labor rights protections. We're closer to India, Niger,
- 28:47Egypt, China ranks higher. Countries like Canada, Angolia,
- 28:51Australia are much higher. And of course, the EU with all
- 28:55of their protections are at the top.
- 28:57So Nicole, what's going on? What's going on in the US?
- 29:02What are we up to? I think that it is a combination
- 29:06of almost like institutional gaslighting.
- 29:12We like to think that we have a lot of rights here in America
- 29:15and that trickle down economics is going to work and that people
- 29:19are going to take care of us and right.
- 29:22It's this freedom thing. We think we're free, The land of
- 29:24the free, home of the brave. I don't think that people know
- 29:30this. First of all, the labor, right,
- 29:33the labor rights index is the only one of its kind that I've
- 29:36been able to find, and it came out in the last four to five
- 29:39years. So I knew a lot of this stuff.
- 29:43I did it early in my career. I was a market researcher for
- 29:48the supply chain and the research and development
- 29:50organization, and one of the things that we did was we looked
- 29:52at economic indicators regularly.
- 29:54I built an index myself on R&D, aerospace capability in the
- 29:58world so that we could figure out where to place things for
- 30:01our supply chain. That was my job.
- 30:03And so I've been aware of the US lagging behind in a lot of these
- 30:06indicators. I remember part of this was cost
- 30:09of placement of work. And I did, I did this, I did
- 30:14this whole index had all the countries had a ton of
- 30:16indicators to figure out wage. Wage was really hard to find,
- 30:19but the US scored has the cheapest place to place labor
- 30:23every time. And my executives were like, we
- 30:25hire engineers. That's not true.
- 30:27That's going to look wrong and it's going to make everyone
- 30:29think that this whole analysis is wrong.
- 30:31You have to fix this. Nothing I did could fix it
- 30:34because on paper as our basic like minimum wage, things like
- 30:39that, we are not scoring well on the global stage.
- 30:43There's this thing called the Big Mac index too.
- 30:44That's a way to like look at like cost of living.
- 30:49Everything looks low in the US in terms of what people are
- 30:52paid. And we don't want to look at
- 30:59this. We don't want to think that
- 31:03we're part of this unfair system that is perpetuating harm on a
- 31:08global scale. At psychosocial conferences,
- 31:11there was one of the keynote speakers got on stage and said,
- 31:14hey, look at the US and do the opposite.
- 31:16Like, and I don't think, I don't think the US realizes.
- 31:20I don't think people in the US realize that this is how we're
- 31:23viewed. Europe is putting laws into
- 31:24place to prevent American practices like the vitality
- 31:29curve because they've watched us and it's extraordinarily
- 31:32damaging to culture. And I, I mean, I, I also think
- 31:36about I, one of the, I went to Catholic High schools and one of
- 31:41the priests at my high school, after he left my school, ended
- 31:44up going to become the house chaplain for the, the House of
- 31:50the United States. The speakers of the like he, he
- 31:53ended up making the news because Speaker Ryan asked him to leave
- 31:56at the time when he gave a sermon that they didn't like.
- 32:01But he did a podcast where he talked about the inhumanity of
- 32:05our highest, the jobs of our highest levels of leadership.
- 32:10And I listened to it and I, it really resonated with me in
- 32:13terms of how we trickle down dysfunction into the corporate
- 32:16when we've got our, our government employees who are
- 32:19supposed to be protecting us. They're supposed to be the ones
- 32:22that are putting things in place like psychosocial hazards.
- 32:25But look at their work conditions.
- 32:27They are required to come into DC where they live with three or
- 32:31four of their constituents in an apartment that they have to keep
- 32:35for themselves, where they're living during the week without
- 32:38their families because their constituents have demanded that
- 32:42their families stay in their state instead of move to DC
- 32:45where they have to work every week.
- 32:47Then they go home on the weekends where they don't get to
- 32:49spend time with their families and experience love and care.
- 32:52They go and get yelled at by the American populace and then they
- 32:55go back to DC where they had to do this all over again, where
- 32:58they sit in rooms, argue with people that they don't like
- 33:00trying to get things passed for us in ways that we know aren't
- 33:04effective. I don't know if you've ever seen
- 33:06that video that like Jennifer Lawrence has that that came out
- 33:08in 20. I wouldn't say 2016 at this
- 33:11point where she talks about like every law regardless of public
- 33:13opinion has a 30% chance of passing.
- 33:16It doesn't matter what public opinion is.
- 33:17If it's 0% has 30% chance of passing.
- 33:20If it's 100 percent, 30% chance of passing.
- 33:23So they're in the system where they can't really affect change
- 33:26even when their constituents want them to.
- 33:29And we're demanding this of them as the American populace.
- 33:31We're demanding you, you live this lifestyle, and we're not
- 33:34going to change it for you. And we're giving them these
- 33:36horrible working conditions, and then we're expecting them to
- 33:39change work for us. Yeah.
- 33:42And so. We've got no one has ever made
- 33:44Congress feel like the victim, the way that you you're just
- 33:49like, have you thought about them?
- 33:51It's real though. It's really, it's reasonable,
- 33:54yeah. When you're talking, when you
- 33:56said people at the top are the worst, Yeah, that's what the
- 33:59research shows too. Burnout is bad for everybody,
- 34:01but the higher up you go in an organization, the higher the
- 34:04burnout. And when our leaders are extra
- 34:06burned out and burnout is just workplace depression, we've just
- 34:09rebranded it as something that's acceptable.
- 34:11Like you want to use brand out burnout as a people strategy, Go
- 34:14for it. It's just burnout.
- 34:15But what like what you're doing is rampantly giving your
- 34:17workforce depression, which is a like a horrifying people
- 34:21strategy because of the trust workforce is not productive.
- 34:24And it takes a really long time to get over that.
- 34:26And so like it's going higher and higher.
- 34:29And then we're expecting the people at the top to take care
- 34:31of us when they're burnt out and it goes to our highest levels of
- 34:36leadership. And when we have those sorts of
- 34:39situations, like, of course, they can't regulate this.
- 34:42They're barely they're. They're barely regulated
- 34:46themselves. There's so much chaos in in our
- 34:49in our top levels of leadership that can help us with this.
- 34:51So there's. A lot of.
- 34:53There's not one right. There's not one answer to this
- 34:54question. There's a lot of different
- 34:55answers for why, but what I think is important to spread is
- 35:01that we are this far behind. And so it is important.
- 35:04Like Canada and Australia are passing legislation to improve
- 35:07workers rights, while we have people in some states trying to
- 35:10roll back child labor laws. Like these things that we accept
- 35:15as this is a harmful workplace practice are being questioned in
- 35:19ways that are so regressive. And I it goes back to like, why
- 35:26are more people not saying like we should not be doing this.
- 35:29We should be raising the minimum wage, we should be capping CEO
- 35:31pay. We should be going against the
- 35:33vitality curve. So we stopped this unfair
- 35:34redistribution of wealth. And it's, it's hard to also
- 35:38organize around this because like you got to do it state by
- 35:41state by state by state. And so having a national
- 35:43movement that goes along state by state by state by state
- 35:46that's effective and can get past is also a part of the
- 35:48problem. Well, I think there's like
- 35:50there's a couple of things that and this might be ungrounded,
- 35:54these are just feelings I'm having.
- 35:56We are a culture of hyper avoidance and hyper isolation.
- 36:00And I think we should talk about Australia today because, you
- 36:04know, one of the things that we don't learn in the US as workers
- 36:08is that there's other ways to do this, that countries are
- 36:11actually, you know, like the labor rights index, like there
- 36:15are countries who are doing this.
- 36:16So let's talk about Australia for a second.
- 36:18So in 2022, they did something that we have never done.
- 36:23They introduced a specific, a couple of specific amendments to
- 36:27their work health and safety regulations requiring employees
- 36:30to proactively identify and manage the psychosocial risk,
- 36:36not just responding to incidents, but systematically
- 36:39assessing and eliminating the hazards.
- 36:41Like if the floor is wet or there's a chemical spill, we're
- 36:45going to clean it up, right? And then in 2024, Australia's
- 36:49Commonwealth Code of Practice identified 17 specific
- 36:53psychosocial hazards that I think the cold these are global
- 36:58psychosocial hazards. Like we're all ish like close.
- 37:00OK, not quite. There's definition problems, I
- 37:04think in a lot of social science realms, right?
- 37:07I usually go to New Zealand and Australia for their definitions
- 37:12and if you look at their websites, they don't actually
- 37:14have definitions. They just have words.
- 37:15So they say low or high job demands, but it's not defined.
- 37:19And so there there's established frameworks for psychosocial
- 37:24hazards. But I think that, like, the list
- 37:26of what makes a psychosocial hazard is still up for debate.
- 37:30Yeah, OK, fair. But when what?
- 37:31What they're talking about and what they're measuring is job
- 37:34insecurity, fatigue, intrusive surveillance, low job control,
- 37:40high job demands, poor organizational justice.
- 37:44So these are actual what we care about listeners knowing is these
- 37:48are actual legal obligations. Employers who fail to identify
- 37:53and control psychosocial risk and face criminal liability,
- 37:57including penalties for industrial manslaughter, which I
- 38:01had never heard of before, I didn't know that existed,
- 38:04Industrial manslaughter if a worker dies as a result.
- 38:07So, you know, compared to the US and Occupational Safety and
- 38:13Health Administration here, we have no specific psychosocial
- 38:18hazard regulation whatsoever. The Max penalty for willful
- 38:24safety violation is just over $150,000.
- 38:28So that's not covering anything. So from your vantage point,
- 38:33Nicole, what would U.S. business culture have to believe
- 38:38differently to actually implement something like this?
- 38:42Like where, where fundamentally, I mean, I think you're getting
- 38:45to this, but what would it take to shift this resistance?
- 38:50The laws are not going to help us.
- 38:51It takes people, it takes individuals, it takes small
- 38:55businesses deciding that they're not going to copy these harmful
- 38:59practices like this. People have to make decisions to
- 39:05do things differently. I've been interviewing in jobs.
- 39:09I did employee survey work as well.
- 39:12And one of the things that is really hard about employee
- 39:15survey work is that you're not asking things that are important
- 39:18to employee health often because it's a legal liability, right?
- 39:22If, and most people don't know that your employee survey
- 39:24questions go through a legal review and that they'll get
- 39:27removed if it opens the company up to liability, you're not
- 39:30allowed to check it. You're not allowed to do
- 39:32intersectional analysis without written permission because if
- 39:35you find some sort of discrimination in your data,
- 39:39your company can sue you for doing the analysis.
- 39:44Yeah, and we've, and we've been in that fire pit together so
- 39:47many times with the client saying, Nope, I we're not going
- 39:52to ask the question. And I'm like, oh, but this is a
- 39:54really good question for you to ask.
- 39:57Yeah, yeah. OK.
- 40:03So you said, OK, you said we're not going to get get to it by
- 40:06passing different laws like people have to, you know, show
- 40:10up differently. I also think like for me
- 40:13personally, that was what I was going to say.
- 40:16I think you have for if we want to change things, we have to do
- 40:21something differently. And to me that means giving
- 40:23people the tools that they need to do the right thing if they
- 40:27care. So trauma informed is the way
- 40:30that I go. I look at trauma in a Trauma is
- 40:34a big word for a lot of people. You cover this apartment.
- 40:36Often people think of it as like PTSD.
- 40:38Complex trauma is not PTSD. And so many people are walking
- 40:42around with complex trauma, trauma, these chronic stressors
- 40:46that you cannot escape. You want people to do these
- 40:50sorts of things. I think you give it to them.
- 40:52There's this patronizing belief in the employee survey world
- 40:55that we should control what managers get on the survey.
- 41:00And I don't think that that is true.
- 41:03But there's so few people like me in the world.
- 41:05There's so few IO psychologists. I don't think people realize how
- 41:07few of us there are. Usually it's a PhD level IO
- 41:10psych running your employee surveys.
- 41:12And there's only 2000 of us in the United States.
- 41:14Less than 2000 is the highest estimate I've ever seen.
- 41:17And when you've got 75,000 clinical psychologists, like we
- 41:20are a tiny, tiny Guild of people that most people have never
- 41:23heard of. And so the model is to go in
- 41:27like executives picked out the survey questions.
- 41:30They decide what the questions are that align to the strategy
- 41:33of the company and that, you know, what's the latest that
- 41:36should be measured. Look at belonging.
- 41:38Let's look at engagement. Let's look at a turnover
- 41:39intention. But asking things about employee
- 41:42health when you don't have the resources, tools, or ability to
- 41:46do anything? About them?
- 41:48It might. That's not helpful inside of an
- 41:50organization, but if you have a manager that's committed to
- 41:52that, give them the tools that they need to do that.
- 41:53Give them the platform and the resources and the surveys that
- 41:56they need to measure employee health so that they can identify
- 41:59pockets within their realm of control that they can stop even
- 42:04little things like on a survey that I have put out that I'll
- 42:08be, I'm building an app in the background with a developer
- 42:11right now to codify this research into something that
- 42:13people can take and take with their teams.
- 42:17But what you'll see is that people themselves want to make
- 42:21these changes. And when you give them the tools
- 42:23to measure it, to name it, then they can stop harm from
- 42:27happening. When you measure harm directly,
- 42:29you're going to take different actions, like as a team, you're
- 42:32going to do things that make people feel more like they
- 42:34belong, that make people feel like they're not being
- 42:37ostracized or isolated. And if you give them also the
- 42:40comment boxes, this is something I learned that was really
- 42:43interesting. We're taught to survey people to
- 42:45not use a lot of comments, one or two, one or two, maybe 3 at
- 42:48the most, right? But what I found in practice,
- 42:52what's actually most helpful is just a shorter survey, no more
- 42:55than 20 questions, with a survey box at the like, a open text box
- 42:59at the end of every question so that managers can get direct
- 43:02feedback about what's actually happening on the team so they
- 43:04can change it. And so it's changing these.
- 43:06Tools and giving people the actual tools that they need to
- 43:09identify this proactively and removing the control from the
- 43:12companies, because I just don't think we're ever going to get to
- 43:15a place where companies, we're going with all of the
- 43:20complicated systems that are involved.
- 43:22Legal's not going to let us do this.
- 43:23Legal's not going to let an IO psych like me that's like, hey,
- 43:25hey, hey, let's measure abuse and trauma in the workplace and
- 43:28like, so we can change it. They're going to be like,
- 43:29absolutely not. Absolutely not.
- 43:33Yeah. Full stop.
- 43:35Full stop. OK Nicole, we end every episode
- 43:39with doing a short rapid fire round.
- 43:44It's like whatever comes up for you first, we have 5 questions.
- 43:47Lars will play as well. So here we go.
- 43:51OK, one law you'd pass tomorrow if you could for psych safety in
- 43:56the US. Easy, make the vitality curve
- 44:00illegal. Lars, what do you got?
- 44:04Australia style accountability for chronic workplace stress.
- 44:09OK, what's a psychosocial hazard hiding in plain sight that most
- 44:12white collar workers don't recognize as harm?
- 44:18Besides constant change. It can be constant change.
- 44:24Moving people who have harmed other people to other
- 44:27departments. OK, so Japan has a word for
- 44:32death by overwork. Give us a word for the US
- 44:37version of that. Salaried like, Oh no.
- 44:50Not exempt that I'm dead. That just ended me.
- 44:59Mine I couldn't like it past. Like burnout.
- 45:02And I said charred, but it feels too.
- 45:05Yeah. So.
- 45:07OK, vegan. Listeners, we apologize, but
- 45:11charred it is. You can have charred vegetables.
- 45:15Yeah, yeah, yeah. OK, finish this sentence.
- 45:19The Wellness industry exists to blank.
- 45:24Make you feel better about the extractive systems that you're
- 45:27living in. Give you the false hope of
- 45:33individual control. Oh.
- 45:35Ouch. OK, last question.
- 45:38What's something you've learned from data that you can't
- 45:41unlearn? Something about how harm at work
- 45:45really works? What can't you Unsee?
- 45:51That there's so many sides to every story that anyone can be a
- 45:55person that does harm. Mine's on the other side of the
- 46:01fence, which is that social emotional intelligence always
- 46:06comes up as a top need in corporations, but it is the
- 46:10least funded. And I believe if we actually
- 46:13invested in building these skills, to Nicole's point, we'll
- 46:16have skills to talk about what really matters and protect each
- 46:19other. OK, I feel like I could have
- 46:23this conversation for three more hours, but unfortunately we have
- 46:28to wrap up. So we ask, we always ask our
- 46:31guests to share one take away and one action item for
- 46:35listeners. You've given people a lot of
- 46:38action items already, but is there anything else, Anything
- 46:43that gives you hope? Any bright spots?
- 46:46I have hope that we can collectively start working
- 46:50together outside of corporate systems to try to tackle these
- 46:56in the near future, because I don't think we can tackle them
- 47:02within the systems under which are heartliness.
- 47:08And that's one of the big things that I hope, I hope I can get
- 47:13off the ground this year because I think that's the only way, the
- 47:18only way that we stop this. Like we have to have hope that
- 47:23we can do this together. Yeah, I've I, yeah, I think one
- 47:27of the things that I just am always saying at the end of our
- 47:29episodes is talk to each other. So in this from this vantage
- 47:33point, if you heard a psychosocial hazard that you're
- 47:36like, huh, that's actually something I experienced.
- 47:38Talk to your Co worker about it. Talk to each other about it.
- 47:42And for us, you know, acknowledging the class
- 47:46privilege that we have and what we're afraid of talking about
- 47:51for the sake of these golden handcuffs, we need to be honest
- 47:54about the cost. We need to be honest about what
- 47:58we put up with structurally to avoid the accountability and
- 48:03start talking to each other about it so we can break it.
- 48:06Let's do it. OK.
- 48:08My take away is the comment boxes add more comment boxes,
- 48:12give people more space to share there.
- 48:16Yeah, I mean, and look, every tool allows you to do that now.
- 48:19So there's no reason to not my, you know, honestly my action
- 48:22item. I would direct this to folks
- 48:25that work in HR, especially in larger companies where HR really
- 48:30plays a strategic role in the business.
- 48:33Ask yourself why, why you're not capping executive compensation
- 48:38with your lowest, you know, tethered to your lowest paid
- 48:41employee? What is the reason that it is
- 48:44300 X? Like why is it not 20X?
- 48:47Because that actually would give you incentive to redistribute
- 48:51your profits downwards rather than, you know, like hiding them
- 48:55upwards. So yeah, if you're listening and
- 48:57you work in HR like a different world as possible.
- 49:01And what would it take to get there?
- 49:05All right, Nicole, thank you for thank you for coming today.
- 49:11On this episode, we got to name some of the things that
- 49:16companies are still pretending. Is it a legal or economic or
- 49:22human rights issue, Right. These psychosocial hazards are
- 49:24built into how work is organized in this country and actually
- 49:28many others. We're going to put the the labor
- 49:32rights index in the show notes the so that folks can actually
- 49:35see that there is a big chunk of the world is getting it right.
- 49:39And then the other half that's getting it very wrong.
- 49:43And you can explore like all the things that you want to explore,
- 49:47you can also find, well, actually, Nicole, tell us where
- 49:50we people can find you. Yeah, I've been most active on
- 49:54LinkedIn in the last few weeks as I've started putting out
- 49:58actual videos. You can also find me now on
- 50:01Instagram and TikTok. You're on TikTok.
- 50:05I got on TikTok. It was really funny.
- 50:08I got like a notification. I have like 75 followers on
- 50:11TikTok 'cause I just started posting on there a few weeks ago
- 50:14and or yeah, 2 and I what am I posted better than 90% of people
- 50:19with the amount of followers that I have is like, all right,
- 50:22like cool, great. I'm on TikTok.
- 50:25We have 75 followers. Well, everything is relative,
- 50:28including data and how we present presented.
- 50:32But you know, for I think for our listeners, I will say that
- 50:35you were the advice that you offer on LinkedIn is, is
- 50:38actually really incredible. And even though we've known each
- 50:42other for seven years now, I learned something new all of the
- 50:47time from you. So thank you so much.
- 50:50Thank you. Thank you for being with us.
- 50:53And the next episode we are going to continue this topic in
- 50:57a way and focus in the realm that's very important to me,
- 51:01which is semantics at work. So we are going to talk about
- 51:05what are the skills that you can build to be connected to your
- 51:09body, be responsive to your body at work, lead through your body
- 51:12at work. And if that sounds weird and woo
- 51:15woo, come on and and listen because it's right here and
- 51:19waiting for you and can really help.
- 51:21So if this episode made you think, share it with one another
- 51:26person. Share it with someone at work,
- 51:29probably someone that you trust, right?
- 51:32And follow us. Leave a review and remember the
- 51:35person next to you is not your competition.
- 51:40They are your comrade. They are your friend.
- 51:42And our liberation is indeed collective.
- 51:46I'm Lars. And I'm a Parna.
- 51:48We'll circle back.