Latest / Australian Hunting Backcountry / Ep. 20 "What role should monolithic projectiles have in hunting?"
Transcript
- 0:09It's been said that luck is the intersection of preparation and
- 0:12opportunity. Welcome to the Australian
- 0:15Hunting Backcountry Podcast, where we will focus on all
- 0:18things hunting in the Backcountry, not just in
- 0:21Australia, but everywhere that Backcountry hunting is possible.
- 0:24My name is Tobias and if you're a hunter with no backpacking
- 0:28experience or even an expert, I would like you to join me as we
- 0:32explore gear, places and technologies here, lived
- 0:36experiences, different perspectives and share the
- 0:39passion that people have for a hard earned back back hunt.
- 0:43I appreciate you being here with me as I try to increase the
- 0:46knowledge that will bring us better luck in the back country.
- 0:53The Australian Hunting Back Country Podcast is proud to
- 0:56welcome 2 new partnerships for 2024.
- 0:59Skeleton Optics Australia and On Track Meals are now both
- 1:03sponsors of the show. Skeleton Optics Australia is a
- 1:06family run Australian based business offering premium, high
- 1:09performance and durable sunglasses for active outdoor
- 1:12users. Skeleton Optics sunglasses use
- 1:15polarised Zeiss lenses and feature frames designed with
- 1:19lightweight and impact resistant materials that provide a secure
- 1:23and comfortable fit. I personally now use Skeleton
- 1:26Optic Sunglasses and would encourage you to reach out to
- 1:29Chris and Daniela if you would like further information on what
- 1:32glasses might suit you best. On Track Meals are made in
- 1:36Brisbane and is a 100% Australian and veteran owned
- 1:40business. On Track Meals pride themselves
- 1:42on producing high quality, shelf stable, healthy, real food
- 1:46designed to be taken with you on your next adventure.
- 1:49Because the meals are not dehydrated or freeze dried they
- 1:52have retained all the flavour, don't require any water to be
- 1:56added, simply heat and eat or they can even be eaten cold.
- 2:00They have a broad selection of meals with many more being
- 2:02planned and cater for some allergies and diet options.
- 2:06The Coconut ginger chicken is now my new favourite and on
- 2:10track meals will be accompanying me on many future adventures.
- 2:15Welcome to this episode of Australian Hunting Backcountry
- 2:19and today I'm going to talk to somebody who studies Ballistics
- 2:26to get more perspective around the issue that's currently
- 2:30happening in in Victoria at the moment with the proposed ban on
- 2:34leadcore projectiles so I would like to welcome Nathan and Steph
- 2:40to the show guys thanks for agreeing to do this and and
- 2:45Steph thanks for for twisting Nathan's arm to come on board
- 2:47you're. Most welcome.
- 2:49No worries. So you guys are over in Taranaki
- 2:54on the the North Island of New Zealand.
- 2:56The the South Island is is my new favourite place in the world
- 2:59and I fully intend to to move over there one day, or at least
- 3:03live there for six months of the year so I can go hunting for six
- 3:06out of 12 months. Yeah, fair enough to.
- 3:09It's a beautiful, beautiful place, Yeah.
- 3:13All right. So we've, we've had a few
- 3:15conversations previously to sort of lead us up to here, but we
- 3:21want to, we want to sort of cover this topic around
- 3:26monolithic projectiles and why or why not we want those or, or
- 3:34the not necessary why or why not, but, but perhaps maybe
- 3:39where they fit into deer hunting in Australia.
- 3:44So the topic that I've sort of suggested for you, Nathan, is
- 3:49what role should monolithic projectiles have in hunting?
- 3:54When this came about, there was a lot of a lot of reaction on
- 3:58social media. People posted some, some videos
- 4:02on YouTube and, and I read through the comments and
- 4:04commented on a few. And I had a bit of back and
- 4:06forth banter with some people and, and tried to have some,
- 4:09some sort of discussions and tried to source some, some
- 4:12sources from where these people were making these claims.
- 4:16And I'm not saying that they that anyone was wrong or anyone
- 4:19was right, but I was trying to find out where the where this
- 4:23information was coming from. So in the research that I did
- 4:26subsequent, I came across your website, ballisticstudies.com
- 4:33and your business terminal Ballistics research.
- 4:38And we'll, we'll talk a bit more about that sort of towards the
- 4:42end. But I it, I had actually
- 4:44referenced and, and spoken to you several years ago, Nathan,
- 4:48in, in regards to a rifle I was thinking about building.
- 4:53But I've also been over the years have found my way to your
- 4:56website to look at some of the research that you've done.
- 4:58And there's, there's pages and pages of research.
- 5:03You go into great depth about a lot of different calibres.
- 5:09Yeah, there's a, there's a whole section there on knowledge base.
- 5:11So essentially then where I landed was a article that you
- 5:17wrote titled Homogeneous copper bullets can be Inhumane.
- 5:23So that's, that's kind of the, the direction that that the, the
- 5:28podcast is going to take. And I just, I guess I sort of
- 5:34want to make it clear that I don't have a particular stance
- 5:37either. I don't think that we should or
- 5:39shouldn't be using. I actually think there's a place
- 5:41for both. But again, it has to be the use
- 5:46of them has to be scaled appropriately to the situation
- 5:51because there is no perfect projectile, there's no perfect
- 5:53calibre. And we just need to, I guess,
- 5:57find our own path in this, in this topic.
- 6:02Unfortunately, the the Victorian government is more than likely
- 6:05going to be forcing a hand and we're we're all going to end up
- 6:08having to use monolithic projectiles.
- 6:13So coming back to to you guys, Nathan and Steph, give us a bit
- 6:19of a, an intro into yourselves and a background of how and why
- 6:25terminal Ballistics research came about.
- 6:29OK, well, my interest in in Ballistics started when I was
- 6:35very young, the usual way going and hunting with with my father,
- 6:42but also I had an uncle who who his his father was a sniper
- 6:48during the Second World War and the New Zealand Army were
- 6:52interested in having him as a sniper and he was watching his
- 6:58skills out. Hunting was just absolutely
- 7:01incredible. But so that side of it, besides
- 7:06the fascination for hunting, I also developed an interest in in
- 7:09more the technical side of it right from the get go.
- 7:13And so from a young age, I, I found myself playing with shells
- 7:17and projectiles and studying what they do and so forth.
- 7:20And, and that, that absolutely stuck with me.
- 7:23So by the time I left home and I went farming and, and that gave
- 7:29me that access to the, to the countryside and, and to be able
- 7:33to get out hunting at every single opportunity.
- 7:36But again, even in those early stages, I was always interested
- 7:39in accuracy and, and cartridge performance.
- 7:44And then I began dating Steph. We were only 1617 years old at
- 7:50that stage. And Steph would come out with
- 7:53me. And Steph, she, she found that
- 7:58she couldn't handle anything like a slow kill whatsoever.
- 8:02Of course it was, she found it to be quite cruel.
- 8:04And that caused me to actually put even more emphasis on, well,
- 8:11you know, what is it that creates a fast kill and, and
- 8:14what, what are we looking for here?
- 8:16So, and so that was kind of the, the shape of things from the
- 8:20beginning. And then later on in life, when,
- 8:24when we were able to, I decided that this would be what I, I put
- 8:29it to Steph, I'd like to actually formalise this and, and
- 8:33do this as a career. And so with Steph's blessing,
- 8:39then we, we had took our savings and we put out savings into
- 8:45producing, I'm sorry, purchasing rifles and cartridges of of
- 8:49every configuration and we said about testing them.
- 8:54So yeah, that's that's kind of how it all started.
- 8:59Even even before you decided that that was what you wanted to
- 9:03do. I mean, when we were out hunting
- 9:05from from the get go when we were kids, you know, Nath was
- 9:09always wanting to, if he could retrieve a, a spent projectile,
- 9:13then he would. And it was just there was
- 9:17always, you know, like it was always this interest of what
- 9:20happened, what happened? Why did that work?
- 9:22Where did that shot go? So I mean, all the way from the
- 9:26very beginning of our our hunting together, you were dead
- 9:31set on trying to unwind what was actually going on.
- 9:36So you were researching from all the way through and, and I
- 9:40think, and I remember, you know, talking to his mother and when
- 9:45he was a little boy, he was, or he was devising, like trying to
- 9:50trying to basically reinvent the the wheel with mouse traps and,
- 9:54and you know what I mean? Like it was this, this, this,
- 9:57this imperative, this, this, yeah, this idea that he's
- 9:59always, always been hunting. So it was kind of natural that
- 10:03we'd end up in a business related around hunting.
- 10:06Yeah, yeah. Yeah.
- 10:08So, so the, the long term result of that was where we were, I was
- 10:13going to write a book and it was basically going to be called
- 10:16something like hunting cartridges of the world or
- 10:19something to that effect. But we ended up going around in
- 10:23circles because I, I would after the first draught, it was a
- 10:27huge, huge body of work. And it involved hours and just
- 10:33years in the field working, you know, trying to get all, get all
- 10:36this data compiled. And I've written the first
- 10:40draught. And by the time I got to the end
- 10:41of the draught, my style of writing had changed because I
- 10:44wasn't formally educated in literature.
- 10:50And it also, excuse me, some of my, my beliefs had changed
- 10:56around what I was seeing because I, I was questioning myself a
- 11:00lot as as I went along. So then I went back and I wrote
- 11:03another draught. And, and as I got so far through
- 11:06that, I started to, to realise, no, there's still holes in, in
- 11:10what you're looking at you, what you think you're seeing and what
- 11:13you're seeing are two different things.
- 11:14And the style of writing keep changing.
- 11:16So then I went for a third draught of us.
- 11:18And by this stage, man who owned an IT company came along and
- 11:24this was kind of around what 2008 Internet was really taking
- 11:30off. And he said, well, how about we
- 11:32put it all up for free? You're going nowhere, we'll put
- 11:34it up for free and you can make money off advertising or
- 11:38something like that. So we did that and the
- 11:41advertising was a complete failure.
- 11:43And so that's how we ended up with the knowledge base online
- 11:46for free for everyone without any adverts on it.
- 11:50And so then after that, I wrote a smaller series of books and
- 11:55yeah, so we so. Basically, the original
- 11:58encyclopaedia that you intended to write is.
- 12:01The is just the knowledge base. Yeah.
- 12:04So yeah. And then even after all of that,
- 12:09I'm, I'm, I still find that I'm learning because the knowledge
- 12:12base then that once we had that wider audience, and then I
- 12:17started to make contact with people within the industry and
- 12:21yeah, I was able to learn a lot from those people.
- 12:24So it, it never stops, you know? Yeah.
- 12:27Yeah, I, I definitely resonate with you there, Nathan, that
- 12:31the, the learning never stops. Every time you you think you
- 12:34know something or or think you found the answer to something,
- 12:37it it something changes and then you're you're almost back to to
- 12:42Ground Zero again. Yeah, exactly.
- 12:44Yeah, yeah. From here to 0 it's.
- 12:47Basically how it goes, isn't it? Yeah, yeah.
- 12:51So I'm and I'm just reading this off your website here.
- 12:57I'm now considered a world leading expert in the field of
- 13:00terminal Ballistics and consult with companies and government
- 13:03organisations worldwide. This knowledge base and all of
- 13:08these, this research and so forth that you've done has
- 13:11gotten you to be able to get to that point where you are being
- 13:15consulted regularly by not only hunters, but by policy makers
- 13:20and NGOs and and that sort of thing around firearm projectile
- 13:28hunting. Related topics yeah, that's
- 13:31right. I've worked for Auk organisation
- 13:38on behalf of the UN and a counter terrorist
- 13:40counterterrorism research project that was to So my job
- 13:44was to supply Ballistics data just to to show you what small
- 13:50arms wounding actually looks like and to teach that to to
- 13:53the, you know, the interested parties.
- 13:56I've also helped with weapons and ammunition selection for for
- 14:02European government. I've also consulted with police
- 14:07with various cases around the world.
- 14:11But funnily enough, so, I mean, I have done quite a bit of that
- 14:14type of work, but funnily enough, I've never been
- 14:16consulted by any government body surrounding the topic of copper,
- 14:23homogeneous copper, yeah. Right.
- 14:25Yeah. So going back to what you're
- 14:30saying and Steph was saying about this natural curiosity
- 14:34that you had and, and analysing the, the bullet performance and
- 14:40so forth. Just take us through some of
- 14:43the, I guess the boundaries of the, of the testing that you've
- 14:47done. What sort of ranges have you
- 14:50shot at and how do you do your testing?
- 14:53How do you how do you record your results?
- 14:56That sort of thing? So for as far as ranges go, or
- 15:04initially in the old days, we used to test out to about 400
- 15:07yards or so. That's that seemed to be enough.
- 15:10But as time went by, I would push ranges further and further
- 15:16until I was testing out past 1000 yards.
- 15:19But that that does depend on the bullet design too.
- 15:22So as I got to understand those projectiles more and what they
- 15:27were capable of, then I would push them further.
- 15:29But as you become aware of their limitations, then of course you,
- 15:34you know that there's only so far you can push them.
- 15:37And it is for, but we're also testing close as well.
- 15:40So you, you want to test the projector, how it's going to
- 15:42perform in, in Bush situations such as, you know, hunting a
- 15:46big, tough boar, wild boar with a, a cartilage shield an inch
- 15:51and a half thick at very close ranges.
- 15:54You want to know how the bullet is going to perform there.
- 15:55But you, but it's good to know also how it's going to perform
- 15:58once that, all that velocity, the energy's fallen away.
- 16:02And that's all on both lean and, and large body game because
- 16:06they, they're going to produce different results.
- 16:09And as yeah, as far as the, the different types of game, well,
- 16:13we have a, we have a wide range of game in New Zealand from
- 16:18goats to, as I said, really tough ball.
- 16:20They're they're excellent for testing penetration.
- 16:24But also we've got lots of different DS species over here.
- 16:28We've got TA down on the South Island as well and they they're
- 16:32a really hard target as well. Big, big boned animal.
- 16:34Not not a huge body weight, but very large bones and a very,
- 16:38very tough eyed. Yeah, actually also there's also
- 16:43the feedback that comes from other people too over the years
- 16:47that's just been valuable. And even before we had the
- 16:49website we had when we first went in earnest to test in the
- 16:54South Island, there was a, a home killed butcher in one area.
- 17:00And he offered to take us, He was going to guide us and
- 17:05actually show us the ropes of hunting in the South Island,
- 17:07Qatar. But he was such a, a wonderful
- 17:10person. He knew that, you know, you can
- 17:13only collect so much data from 1 hunt at one time.
- 17:16So what he did was he, he arranged for the, the hunters in
- 17:20the area to, to, for us to go and visit these people.
- 17:24And he, he drove us from house, from farmhouse or house to house
- 17:30to meet these people and discuss their findings.
- 17:34So just there's an amazing opportunity that was, and for
- 17:39example, there was one house we visited and there was a, he did
- 17:43the tar, big tar mounted on the wall there.
- 17:46And it had three shots, three chest shots with a bullet, which
- 17:51with actually it was a couple of hunters and the bullets didn't
- 17:54perform that well. And it was the the final shot
- 17:58from the heaviest cartridge that that put it down.
- 18:02So, yeah, as much as you can learn from hunting.
- 18:05So we we do have access to a lot of hunting.
- 18:09So it's not just taking an animal.
- 18:10You've got to take multiple shots before you can actually
- 18:13develop an idea of how that's going to go.
- 18:15But also the the feedback from other people around the world
- 18:21just in a in an everyday manner has just been amazing.
- 18:24So we probably wouldn't really be able to to accurately report
- 18:30without that ongoing feedback, you know?
- 18:32Yeah. Yeah, yeah, New Zealand is a
- 18:36very game rich country. You guys are very lucky.
- 18:40And you know, Australia is not that far behind either in terms
- 18:46of other animals from around the world.
- 18:49What sort of research or data have you been able to collect
- 18:55from those? Again, yeah, again, mostly the
- 19:00the key there is just collecting data from hunters on a, on a
- 19:03week to week basis. Like even if we were to go and
- 19:06hunt to Africa and I shot 5 animals, well, big deal.
- 19:10You know, you, you want that. I mean, there's nothing because
- 19:15you really need to have people, yeah, collecting their data and
- 19:22with different types of bullets and different shop placement at
- 19:24different ranges. And then then I can compare that
- 19:28to my data. And I mean, we've got a lot of
- 19:32large game here, such as sorry, we've got kettle, wild kettle
- 19:37here, which can compare quite well to to larger body weights.
- 19:42But it's, it's only through the situations that that people are
- 19:45actually reporting that that you can learn from as well.
- 19:47So yeah, it's all, it's all quite relative and it's all very
- 19:52useful. Yeah.
- 19:54All right. So if we then look at the the
- 20:00performance of a of a, a projectile, the performance of
- 20:03a, When I say a projectile, I mean a rifle calibre bullet.
- 20:09As I've outlined to you, the, the in Victoria they have a
- 20:12legislated minimum calibre and bullet weight for hunting Samba
- 20:17deer. And that's, that's essentially
- 20:19the majority of people who are going to be affected by this is,
- 20:22is Samba hunters. So 270 calibre, 130 grain is
- 20:28the, the minimum. If they do move to, to banning
- 20:31the lead core. I, I don't know whether that's
- 20:33going to change or not. There hasn't been any sort of, I
- 20:36haven't found any information around that possibly being
- 20:40reviewed. So that might be another hurdle
- 20:44that we, you know, hunters have to overcome later on.
- 20:48But in terms of, of those sort of projectiles 270 and up from a
- 20:52rifle calibre, how do they kill an animal?
- 20:58What what's the the process and the cause and effect that causes
- 21:02an animal to die? Yeah, it's an important thing to
- 21:05cover because even though I think most hunters have a
- 21:11general understanding of what goes on, there's still some
- 21:14areas where people do get confused, which I can get into
- 21:19in a moment. But primarily bullets kill
- 21:24through blood loss or damage to the central nervous system,
- 21:29destruction of vital tissues and organs or septicemia or
- 21:34asphyxiation. So with, with blood loss,
- 21:37that's, that's your fastest way to produce a kill.
- 21:41As far as having a, a, a target that's easily that you can
- 21:46easily aim for. So that's when we're aiming for
- 21:49the chest, we're going for blood loss.
- 21:51That's the key. And the lungs tend to be the
- 21:53fastest bleeding organ, the heart, believe it or not, it's a
- 21:56slightly slower bleeding organ. And then so second to that, you
- 22:01have the damage to the central nervous system.
- 22:04That would be like a headshot or a neck shot, something like
- 22:07that. They can of course, 'cause a
- 22:11quick death, but those targets are a little bit harder to go
- 22:15for. And then destruction of vital
- 22:17tissues and organs will that that speaks for itself.
- 22:20That would be, you know, so that the organs are no longer working
- 22:24again. So that's your heart, your
- 22:25lungs, liver. I love.
- 22:27It's quite a actually also relatively fast bleeding organ.
- 22:31But death sort of take tends to take around about a minute or so
- 22:34depending on the type of bullet that's used.
- 22:37And then you've got your septicemia that would be from
- 22:40gut shots and asphyxiation as well from from drowning, from a
- 22:46very slow bleeding lung wound. Well, of course, septicemia can
- 22:50take, you know, two or three days to to cause death.
- 22:56Yeah. So with a modern, you were
- 23:00talking about a modern high powered cartridge, it relies on
- 23:04high velocity to begin with. That's the key.
- 23:07And so lots of velocity and then combined with an expanding or
- 23:10generally with an expanding type projectile and yeah, we used
- 23:16that velocity. So velocity times bullet weight
- 23:19equals kinetic energy. So, so we use that energy the
- 23:24the projector actually transfers its kinetic energy to the tissue
- 23:28and it causes an an acceleration of fluid particles around the
- 23:32bullet path. And then this creates an an
- 23:36explosive temporary wound and that subsides to a permanent
- 23:39wound channel. And that permanent wound channel
- 23:43is generally far greater than the diameter of the projectile.
- 23:48It's that's provided velocity is still relatively high.
- 23:51So yeah. But the goal of course is, is
- 23:56always towards fast killing. And the reason for we want fast
- 24:00killing is for both compassion for the animal, but also for
- 24:04meat retrieval. So those are the keys you're
- 24:06always going for, for that fast kill.
- 24:10And so, yeah, So what at high speeds with yeah, if, if, if
- 24:15this also took two sides to the central nervous system as well.
- 24:20If you directly strike the central nervous system, that
- 24:23will cause the animal to go down, but you can also
- 24:25indirectly strike the central nervous system.
- 24:28And that's. If you've got a a bullet which
- 24:31is travelling really fast and it contains lots of energy, then
- 24:35you can create what's called hydrostatic shock.
- 24:40And that's where the, the, the shockwave actually travels along
- 24:47the electrical path. So it can travel up the ribs
- 24:50into the spine and then shut down the, the animal.
- 24:52But in that case, it's not actually killing the animal,
- 24:55it's just knocking it out. And then while the animal is
- 24:58unconscious, it bleeds out. So there's actually a term that
- 25:02a lot of people get mixed up on. They, they mix up hydraulic
- 25:06shock with hydrostatic shock. So hydraulic shock by comparison
- 25:16that that of course is just the the term for hydraulic force.
- 25:22And yeah, so that's really where the the projectile is changing
- 25:26its form after impact and it's sending out those fluid
- 25:32particles ahead of it and that's creating a disproportionate
- 25:36calibre wound. Yeah.
- 25:39So in order to achieve hydraulic shock, you need plenty of
- 25:44velocity, but you also need that bullet changing a lot of its
- 25:47form and and that. So let's say that the projector
- 25:52expands to you, you mentioned 270, so let's that would expand
- 25:56to around about 1/2 inch. So but the wound channel will be
- 26:03two to three inches in diameter. So that's a disproportionate
- 26:06calibre wound and at high speeds the that's created solely
- 26:12through that hydraulic force through the the bullet hitting
- 26:15at very high speeds, but then changing form so that it can
- 26:19actually transfer the energy. So that's the key kinetic
- 26:22energy. It only exists as a potential.
- 26:25And if it's full metal jacket, it'll zip through the animal and
- 26:27it will create a a calibre size wound.
- 26:31But if you can get that projectile to really change its
- 26:33form, then it's it produces this hydraulic force.
- 26:37Yeah. So just going back to
- 26:39hydrostatic shock, so hydro, the hydrostatic effect, that's
- 26:45that's something that you can you can encourage by having a a
- 26:49very powerful cartridge, but it's not a reliable mechanism of
- 26:52killing. It's not, you can't kill an
- 26:55animal with that. It, it's nice in that it does
- 26:57put the animal down and, and it's causes less suffering, but
- 27:01as, as the range goes out, the, the, the ability for, for a car
- 27:06just to produce hydrostatic shock falls away.
- 27:08And also when you've got large game like Samba, the amount of
- 27:11energy that you would need to, to generate hydrostatic shock is
- 27:15so high that it's getting up towards the, you know,
- 27:18intolerable levels of recoil. So the only reason why I
- 27:21mentioned hydrostatic shock is just to explain that effect that
- 27:25that some if you hit the chest with enough power and the animal
- 27:28drops instantly, it's not an instant kill unless it's
- 27:32actually hit the central nervous system.
- 27:34But it can't look like an instant kill if the bullet has
- 27:38struck the ribs send a shockwave up to the spine and through to
- 27:43the brain that interrupts those electrical signals.
- 27:45The animal drops unconscious like a a boxer that's been
- 27:49Kayode in a fight. And then while it's down, it
- 27:51bleeds out. But that's that's something that
- 27:55it's good to encourage, but it's not a mechanism that you can
- 27:59focus all, all of your attentions on or build a
- 28:02cartridge around or a rifle around or something like that.
- 28:05Hydra hydraulic shock, on the other hand, is something that
- 28:07that we do need to to be aware of that that is that is the
- 28:12mechanism for producing a very wide and fast breathing wound.
- 28:17Yeah. But that also does begin to
- 28:21diminish as range falls away. And so you start to see that as
- 28:25you're getting down towards 2200 feet per second, the ability for
- 28:29a cartridge to produce hydraulic force, it is greatly diminished.
- 28:37So down at 2200 figures a second.
- 28:39In order for that to to continue, you need to have two
- 28:43things. One is some kind of weight
- 28:46sheeting action. And then that weight sheeting
- 28:49action, it helps to to promote hydraulic force, but it also has
- 28:57what I call mechanical force. And that is just the the
- 29:00shearing action of those particles striking flesh.
- 29:03So you end up with a cluster of fragments that reaches out and
- 29:07that cluster itself ensures that that that wound remains
- 29:12disproportionate to calibre. If on the other hand, the
- 29:16projectile just mushrooms only, then as you approach 2200 feet
- 29:21per second, the wound becomes proportionate to calibre or
- 29:24proportionate to expanded calibre to be more correct.
- 29:28And then as you start going down below 2200 feet per second.
- 29:31Well, if the if the bullet is producing quite a narrow wound
- 29:36and should the hunter not be a really good shot or that's
- 29:41actually not not the right way to say that under field
- 29:45conditions, of course there's always going to be errors.
- 29:46So let's say the hunter, you know, has some error because of
- 29:50his position in the field or let's so that the rifle itself
- 29:55is only capable of, you know, 3 minutes of angle, Yeah.
- 30:00Then then if he misses or she misses the vitals, if the if the
- 30:06bullet is only able to produce a proportionate calibre wound,
- 30:10then that is going to be a very slow kill.
- 30:13And that could be two to three days before the animal dies.
- 30:17So This is why it is important to have some kind of weight
- 30:21shooting action. And the problem is that for the
- 30:24last so many years, people have been complaining about bullets
- 30:29when they lose weight, they they complain the bullet has failed.
- 30:33And the 270, that's a good example of that because the 130
- 30:38grain weight that does fly to pieces and it's not really that
- 30:42suitable for for Sambedia. On the other hand, 150 grain,
- 30:48let's say a partition bullet that's, you know, it's a bit
- 30:52longer, it's got a little bit more weight behind it that
- 30:57that's able to penetrate. But the two, the two safety is
- 31:00still quite a diminutive calibre relative to large, you know,
- 31:05standardeer. So that mechanical action of of
- 31:09weight sheeting of that frontal core of the partition that
- 31:12actually does help it to produce a relatively large wound or
- 31:18otherwise it wouldn't, you know, So, yeah.
- 31:22You're making me start to regret not paying attention in in my
- 31:25high school physics class. Yeah, well, it's also a lot to
- 31:30go over on a podcast. It's a lot easier to do it and
- 31:33writing because you can actually sit down and and explain these
- 31:36things step by step. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 31:39So coming back to hydraulic and hydrostatic shock, I mean,
- 31:43we've, we've probably all seen the, the marketing videos out
- 31:47there of ammunition bullet manufacturers shooting into a
- 31:52big lump of ballistic gel and the slow MO, you know, expansion
- 31:56and, and then that Channel that it, it's sort of Burrows through
- 32:03the, the block and, and then it all comes down into place.
- 32:08So is that a? Is that a visualisation of
- 32:13hydraulic shock? Yes, it is.
- 32:14Yeah, yeah. And of course I mentioned the
- 32:19temporary wound channel. That's kind of irrelevant.
- 32:22That's it's possibly useful to scientists who want to study
- 32:27things like what actually happened.
- 32:30But as far as the resulting effect, that's not as relevant
- 32:35as the the permanent wing channel thereafter.
- 32:39But here you, you when you see the especially when you see the
- 32:42whole block, sort of the gel block jumping around off the
- 32:46bench and then you're falling down again.
- 32:48Yeah, that's that's definitely what you're saying.
- 32:51OK. Yeah, because water is is very
- 32:56difficult to compress and bodies are are made up of a significant
- 33:05percentage of water so that. Yeah, that's the key when we,
- 33:08when we start talking about copper shortly, I mean, we'd
- 33:11like to get, get these, these basics out of the way first.
- 33:14But and that point, water is one of the hardest substances on
- 33:18earth. It's it's for all intents and
- 33:20purposes non compressible. So if you you hit it hard and
- 33:25fast, it wants to, it can't be compressed.
- 33:27It just wants to move out of the way.
- 33:29Yeah, or it moves the item itself, you know, And of course,
- 33:32that's what causes that destruction of the projectile.
- 33:36Yeah. Yeah, those videos that that the
- 33:40and I've got I've got in my notes here Marketing Monster.
- 33:46Have you seen the the newest Deadpool movie?
- 33:50No, no, they're too violent for me.
- 33:52Sorry. It's OK, I took my son to see it
- 33:55on the on the weekend. Just go on.
- 33:57And there's a, a villain in it. They have psychic powers
- 34:02basically so they can read minds and manipulate people and blah,
- 34:06blah, blah. And there's one of her things is
- 34:10she puts her hand inside people's heads and sort of her,
- 34:16you know, they've, they've done the CGI very well that it looks
- 34:20like her fingers are sort of poking out through their
- 34:22nostrils and you know, the hand turns and so forth.
- 34:25And that's her manipulating their mind.
- 34:28And I thought what a great visualisation of the marketing
- 34:32monsters in ammunition and, and you know, rifle bullet
- 34:39manufacturing companies and so forth.
- 34:42Those sort of tests that they do that that ballistic gel slow MO
- 34:48stuff seems to be. And I know that they're doing it
- 34:51to provide a, a gauge by providing a constant media in
- 34:57which they fire a projectile into to show the, the
- 35:01differences. But you know, obviously that a
- 35:05block of, of gel is not a, a real representation of an
- 35:11animal. And under hunting conditions,
- 35:15you know in different angles and whether it's up or down or the
- 35:18animals turn slightly or you know all of the the variables
- 35:23that go into a hunting scenario. Yeah, exactly with yeah.
- 35:28So ballistic gelatin is only useful as a like a control
- 35:33medium. So if you've got a projectile
- 35:36that, that you know how it performs in the field on game
- 35:42and then you take that non performance and then you put
- 35:46that projectile through a, a gel block, then you can compare
- 35:51other projectiles to that projectile and maybe gauge how
- 35:56that performs in that medium. But you, you're never going to
- 36:00tell how that's going to perform on gaming until you've tested
- 36:02that. But I, I remember during the, OR
- 36:05was it the 80s or 70s when Norma brought out the Vulcan, they
- 36:13tested that on 300 most, I think it was.
- 36:17And, and they also did the Ballistics gelatin as well.
- 36:21So they when they did that, it was, it was all side by side.
- 36:24Yeah. And yeah, I think things have
- 36:26changed. Now you talk about marketing
- 36:30before we had these pioneers like John Nosler and so forth.
- 36:34And, and there was Hornady and Sierra coming along and they
- 36:37all, they use lead because a lead Corp bullet, because lead
- 36:42it's a it's a dense material. So it's the only way you're
- 36:45going to get energy down range is is through, through having
- 36:48the identity. But it was also a malleable
- 36:51material. It swayed to the bore easily
- 36:53inside of its little gilding jacket.
- 36:56But and then when it it hits it, it transferred the energy
- 36:59because it changed its its shape.
- 37:00So these are all known things. And and there was a real a real
- 37:06pioneering spirit. Yeah.
- 37:09And then companies like Sierra, they got a lot of Flack for the
- 37:14game king because it, it, this is more in recent years because
- 37:20the game king would shed so much weight when it impacted.
- 37:24And they were quite unapologetic about that.
- 37:26They said, well, you know, this is how the, the bullet actually
- 37:30transfers its energy. So if we don't do this, then
- 37:34your bullet won't actually produce a clean kill.
- 37:37And I think it's pretty hard on them because they, they were
- 37:42making the bullet. They knew the way it had to be
- 37:44made. And even if people didn't like
- 37:48that, they would continue to do that.
- 37:50They didn't make what the market wanted because they knew that if
- 37:52they did that, then, you know, the results were foreign product
- 37:56will find even more. Yeah.
- 37:58But what they could do is suggest like, you know, you
- 38:02could use a larger bullet. If the person was having
- 38:04problems with a certain cartridge on a certain animal,
- 38:07you'd say, well, then maybe it's time you stepped up your
- 38:09cartridge size. But in recent years, it's it's
- 38:14been a lot harder on companies because because of these law
- 38:16changes. And they want to, they want to,
- 38:20you know, keep, you know, keep in the game.
- 38:22Well, they've got to produce the projectiles whether they like it
- 38:26or not, if they want to, you know, stay in business.
- 38:28So yeah. So in terms of the anatomy of a
- 38:33projectile, then what have you seen of the, the differences?
- 38:38And I know that you'd, yeah, hesitant sort of mention brands,
- 38:43but in general terms, what are the, what's the anatomy of a
- 38:46projectile look like from your experience for lead versus
- 38:50monolithic? Well, yeah, as discussed with
- 38:55with the lead core bullet, you know, it's just got a very thin
- 39:01gilding jacket and they can, the manufacturer can control the
- 39:04rate of expansion by thickening or thinning that jacket.
- 39:08So, you know, not all lead Corp projectiles are the same in that
- 39:11regard. And they can also change the
- 39:14antimony content so that the the lead is, you know, less or more
- 39:19or more malleable as well. And then you've got your
- 39:23interlocking mechanisms, whether it's a mechanical lock like the
- 39:25horny interlock or you've got your salted bonded bullets.
- 39:31Vernon Speer, he was the first to create that and then others
- 39:35came thereafter. But with a conventional
- 39:39projectile, the, you know, lead core projectile, the goal was
- 39:43always to just retain around about 50% weight.
- 39:46That was kind of the balance. And that way you knew that
- 39:49you're going to get a, a good balance of wounding versus
- 39:52penetration. And yes, I went then when the
- 39:58the copper projectile monolithics came along.
- 40:03They were promoted and I will mention a brand here that was
- 40:06Barnes. He he was promoting the fact
- 40:09that these retained 100% weight. And so he was really using that
- 40:15to to push the penetration card at a time when, you know, people
- 40:19were complaining about, well, complaining about things they
- 40:24didn't fully understand. And yeah, so he really made big
- 40:31inroads there. And it's true that, you know,
- 40:32the, the, the homogeneous copper projectiles can produce
- 40:35excellent penetration, but he was also talking about less meat
- 40:39damage, which is a bit of an oxymoron because bullets kill
- 40:43through kill through, you know, tissue damage.
- 40:47So yeah, there was there, but and then he was using the
- 40:51pushing the eco card as well. And so that's how how they got
- 40:55started. But with as far as the
- 40:59construction goes, there's so those the first construction
- 41:02methods in that regard were for barns was impacting extrusion.
- 41:07So the trouble with that method is that you you're work
- 41:11hardening the projectile as it's going through each step.
- 41:14And depending on the quality of the alloy as well as the quality
- 41:19of the copper that you're purchasing it and as well as the
- 41:23steps taken, you can end up with a projectile that is quite,
- 41:26quite hard. It's not, it's nowhere near as
- 41:28malleable as lead, of course, but you can also work hard and
- 41:32that further. And so you can run into real,
- 41:35real problems with that. And then after that we hit the,
- 41:39well, it must have been a roundabout at the same time, I
- 41:42guess, but there are also smaller manufacturers starting
- 41:47to play around with lathe turned CNC, you know, projectiles and
- 41:53they're really sort of just coming into wider circulation or
- 41:57in the last decade or so, I suppose.
- 41:59But the, the C&C term projectiles, they do tend to be
- 42:06a little bit softer, a little bit more malleable on impact.
- 42:11Yeah. But there's another way to
- 42:14design them is to design, design the projectiles so that it does
- 42:17actually shed some weight. And so we have some or going
- 42:23back in a number of years now there were there were some C&C
- 42:26layer temp projectiles that were designed to shear their petals.
- 42:29But the problems with with petal sheeting is it's still a
- 42:32relatively low amount of weight lost.
- 42:35So and was the reason why I'm talking about this is that
- 42:37again, if you once you get down to about 2200 feet per second a
- 42:42homogeneous projectile, if it retains 100% weight, it produces
- 42:47a calibre sized wound. So if you miss the, if you hit
- 42:52say in, in the no man's end on the animal, you know, up above
- 42:55the, the lungs between the lungs and, and the spine, the animal
- 42:58can run off and you might never recover it.
- 43:02But they can happen too, if you hit behind the lungs or hit just
- 43:06behind the liver as well, which would of course be a gut shot.
- 43:10With an equal bullet, they could have actually been an effective
- 43:13clean kill. With a homogeneous copper
- 43:15bullet, they could be a kill, which takes two or three days,
- 43:18you know, to occur. So with the, the, the, these
- 43:23pedal sheeting designs came along, yeah, after the, the
- 43:28barns type bullet, the, the, you know, 100% weight retaining
- 43:31bullet. But those, those early designs,
- 43:34they, they had a tendency on, there's still somewhere around
- 43:37now they only shed a small amount of weight.
- 43:40So they they don't really still don't transfer a lot of energy
- 43:45inside the target. And then just more recently
- 43:50we've had homogeneous copper C&C lathe to designs which can shed
- 43:57up to about 40 to 45% weight. So they are, I wouldn't say
- 44:03available because I mean they're in circulation, but in Australia
- 44:07and New Zealand in particular, they're not readily available.
- 44:11They are extremely expensive due to the production costs and the
- 44:15costs of the copper itself, but also freight with fuel costs,
- 44:20you know, going up and getting this stuff over here has been
- 44:24very expensive. So yeah, it's not without
- 44:27problems. There's there's no, no real easy
- 44:29answers. Yeah, yeah.
- 44:30Yeah. I guess the other thing to to
- 44:34consider is that we are in the infancy stages of monolithic
- 44:39projectiles compared to lead core projectiles.
- 44:42So there's still potentially quite a lot of room for growth
- 44:48and a, a legislative change like this and, and ones that we've
- 44:53seen in in America as well, where California has gone to to
- 44:57banning lead and some other states potentially following.
- 45:02And there's, there's now programmes in other states where
- 45:06they incentivize hunters. They haven't changed
- 45:08legislation, but they're incentivizing hunters to change
- 45:11over to copper projectiles, Monolithic projectiles with that
- 45:20is going to drive more R&D by these companies.
- 45:24There's going to be more, you know, development in the
- 45:27industry. There's potential there for for
- 45:29a lot more growth. So we're yeah, the, the
- 45:35monolithic projectiles, like I said, we're, we're still very,
- 45:38very early days with them compared to how long we've had
- 45:42lead Corp projectiles. Yeah, for sure.
- 45:47And you're right on the money. As far as R and DI think though,
- 45:51you know before I talked about people like John Nosler, there
- 45:53was a real passion for hunting. That's where the focus was.
- 45:58And so that there is spending a lot of time hunting and and
- 46:03observing and so forth. I'm, I'm not sure if the, the
- 46:07emphasis is the same now with newer companies.
- 46:12I wonder if the emphasis is more on making money and, and then
- 46:18the science sort of comes after that, you know, the idea.
- 46:22I mean, I can't state that as a fact.
- 46:24I, I don't know each person's motivations, but I, I do wonder
- 46:27looking at and, and listening and, and reading some of the
- 46:32things that the, these newer companies, they write about the
- 46:35projectiles and it just leaves me shaking my head.
- 46:38But yeah, yeah. I mean.
- 46:43Sorry, isn't there always going to be some limitation though,
- 46:46because just I was just thinking about weight wise.
- 46:51I mean, copper is always going to be so much lighter.
- 46:53So you know is. Well, that is the problem.
- 46:58Because you. You I.
- 47:00Mean it's only so long that you can make a projectile.
- 47:02Yeah. And copper is only as dense as
- 47:05it as it is. Yeah.
- 47:06And that's, that is the other side of it is that these these
- 47:09all these changes are occurring and the rifles they require
- 47:13faster twist rates to to run copper, but and the magazine
- 47:18lengths are also there, there can be a limitation.
- 47:20So yeah. Just wondering like what in
- 47:22which direction R&D could go? Is it, is it sending them out
- 47:26even, is it trying to get them out faster or because I mean,
- 47:28you can't make them heavier, you can't keep making them longer?
- 47:32So you didn't? Have to try and keep making them
- 47:34faster or. Well, I think that's the
- 47:37direction it's already gone and where the where the
- 47:39manufacturers have decided to, you know, you can run a lighter
- 47:45reject. I'll drive it as fast as you
- 47:46possibly can. And then, you know, it's the
- 47:49only way you go versus your twist rate, magazine length and
- 47:53powder powder space as well. But it's kind of it's, it's run
- 47:57its course because, you know, there's a lot of people who who
- 48:01want to be able to use a cartridge, you know, across a
- 48:05good range Ridge to Ridge and light and fast is all very well
- 48:09and close, but in order to have energy at at a distance, you
- 48:13need weight. And so to get that weight then,
- 48:18yeah, the only way people we ought to do that is through
- 48:21faster twist rates, longer and longer magazines and yeah, so.
- 48:26Then if you're talking R&D then you're better off going towards
- 48:31compressed powder like different OK, we can't use lead, so OK, so
- 48:36there must be other non toxic. Or powder metal.
- 48:41Yeah, that's, yeah. So powder metal is a, is another
- 48:45technology which is, yeah, slowly coming along.
- 48:49But it, it also has its limitations in there.
- 48:52Again, you're using a lighter material unless you're actually
- 48:55using tungsten powder, but no one can afford that at the
- 48:58moment. But the core is made up from
- 49:02either tin or or copper. And what you can do is you can
- 49:06make the the rear core tougher than the front core.
- 49:09So you can use two different types of powder.
- 49:11You can press that heavily and you've got what is essentially a
- 49:17fragmenting projectile. You know, for for a larger
- 49:21bodied deer, you would need to use again, quite a large bullet.
- 49:25So you're still, you're still running into your length
- 49:27problems. But the other, there are other
- 49:29things you can do such as, you know, using it like an
- 49:33interlocking mechanism or, or a breakaway in the projectile so
- 49:37that you can retain that rear core.
- 49:40But yeah, so the makers of a compressed powdered metal RWS,
- 49:47they make one and also, or they make quite a variety of them and
- 49:52Nosler, they make them for the the varmint loads as well.
- 49:56But it's again, it's a it's an infant technology and generally
- 50:00the projectile weights are quite light and there's there's just
- 50:04been no research around large game stuff.
- 50:07Yeah. So one brand I will mention is
- 50:10cutting edge this as far as homogeneous copper.
- 50:14They make projectiles which shed weight and that the projectile
- 50:19itself is is of a good weight and has a relatively high BC.
- 50:23But again, you've got this problem of, of length, twist
- 50:27rate and then powder compression as well.
- 50:30So you need a suitable rifle, a suitable cartridge, and you
- 50:34know, ideally it'd be good to have some magazine length unless
- 50:36you want to single feed them. And then on top of all that,
- 50:39you've still got your cost and freight.
- 50:42And then I, I don't know, you know, in five or ten years what
- 50:46the cost of copper is, is going to, you know, to be like.
- 50:50But but at this point in time, you know that would be one of
- 50:54the projectiles that you know one might recommend.
- 51:04Welcome to Australian Hunting Backcountry Friends of the
- 51:07Podcast segment. Just a quick interruption to
- 51:10this episode for everyone. One of our previous Friends of
- 51:15the Podcast, Deer School Melbourne, has reached out and
- 51:18offered a special discount for the upcoming September course,
- 51:23which is closing very soon. So if you're listening to this
- 51:27later on in August or in September, you might have missed
- 51:30the opportunity. Reach out to the Deer School as
- 51:34soon as you can to get onto the course.
- 51:37The offer for Australian Hunting Backcountry listeners is a
- 51:42special discount of $150.00 off for people who mentioned that
- 51:48they heard this on the Australian Hunting Backcountry
- 51:50Podcast or saw it on the IHB page.
- 51:54So for anyone interested again, Dear School Melbourne, they're
- 51:59on Facebook and Instagram. Their Instagram profile is Dear
- 52:04School Underscore Melbourne and their Facebook profile is Dear
- 52:10School All One Word. They could also be contacted on
- 52:140405181522. If you want more information
- 52:21about the curriculum on the courses, go back to episode 12
- 52:26of the Australian Hunting Backcountry podcasts and have a
- 52:30listen to the conversation I have with Nick.
- 52:39Yeah, coming back to to Nosler, you mentioned before the story
- 52:43behind the Nosler petition, which you know arguably is
- 52:47probably one of the better hunting projectiles that's
- 52:51that's ever been created was because John Nosler was out
- 52:55hunting moose and lost an animal.
- 52:57I had to shoot it multiple times because of poor bullet
- 53:00performance. So that mistake then drove R&D
- 53:06and and change and you know, then we we ended up with that.
- 53:10So I guess that's, that's kind of the hope that if we are
- 53:14pushed in this direction that yeah, we are going to see
- 53:19particularly the the bigger companies that do have the money
- 53:22to to do this to really take a deep dive into, into the
- 53:29performance of monolithic projectiles.
- 53:31And you know, whether that's other materials or or
- 53:34construction types or like you say, you know, lathe turning
- 53:38versus drawing. Yeah.
- 53:42Yeah, yet to be seen, I guess. Yeah, that's right.
- 53:45Yeah, mostly. There are some smaller companies
- 53:48as still coming out. I was talking to the owner of of
- 53:53one company and and they get it. They so I mean the likes of
- 53:59barns. I don't think they they really
- 54:01understood terminal Ballistics in great depth.
- 54:07There was a lot of bullshit in bravado, you know, when when
- 54:11that company came about. And I mean, again, but as I said
- 54:17before, the yeah, there are times when you need good hard,
- 54:20deep penetration. You want a projectile that
- 54:24maintains a lot of weight and you want it to punch through.
- 54:26You know, on heavy animals you need that.
- 54:29But a lot of the time that can be unless you're really hunting
- 54:33heavy game, that it can actually, especially once
- 54:35velocity falls away, that initial velocity, they can be
- 54:40quite detrimental. So, yeah.
- 54:43But anyway, there's now there are some people who who get it
- 54:46and they, they're trying to design these projectiles that
- 54:51will homogeneous couple projectiles that will behave in
- 54:54a similar manner. But it's, it's really hard to
- 54:56do, you know, and, and it's the technology as you see this in
- 55:00it's infancy, it's not really widespread and it's quite
- 55:03costly. So if we, if we are pushed in
- 55:09this direction, let's say in the in the future, we're, we're all
- 55:14forced to use copper projectiles.
- 55:19What are with the, the current options that are out there?
- 55:27What are the sort of limitations that people need to be aware of
- 55:32if they're going to be using those projectiles?
- 55:34And you, you sort of already touched on some of them now in
- 55:37that, you know, existing rifles may not have the right twist
- 55:41rate in the barrels, they may not have the right magazine
- 55:43length. The projectiles are are longer
- 55:48generally or, or the same length projectile is lighter, which
- 55:55then obviously changes your Ballistics.
- 55:58There's when in terms of reloading, there can be more
- 56:04tendency towards pressure spikes.
- 56:06So your your seating has to be monitored and so forth.
- 56:11Yeah, so in terms of the rifle and the ammunition, we'll get to
- 56:17the the animal side of things in a minute.
- 56:19What are some of the things that that people need to be aware of
- 56:22for Monolithics? Well, yeah, when you come to
- 56:25monolithic, it pays to up your power level if you can.
- 56:30Also, and this depends on the brand of monolithic, because the
- 56:35hollow point has to be drilled into it, the smaller the
- 56:39calibre, the in some cases the smaller the hollow point is
- 56:44going to end up. Otherwise you know it's going to
- 56:46actually interfere with the BC of the projectile.
- 56:49So yes, you can use a smaller calibre.
- 56:54There's a, there's a point you'll reach where the hollow
- 56:56point is so small that once the energy falls away, that
- 56:59projector may not open up on game.
- 57:01So it pays to go not go too small in calibre.
- 57:04And again, this is just depending on the individual mono
- 57:09brand or bullet type. Yeah, and it pays to have plenty
- 57:15of power behind it so that you can keep the velocity as high as
- 57:19you can for as long as you can. Of course, the downside of that
- 57:21is throat where you start bringing your barrels out
- 57:24faster. But yeah, that's that's the way
- 57:28it's going to have to be, I'm afraid, if if a person wants to
- 57:31run all types of monos. Yeah.
- 57:34But even then, after that initial velocities fall in a
- 57:38way, people are going to have to be very mindful of what those
- 57:43maximum parameters are. So my advice would be to just
- 57:46monitor what's going on inside the carcass.
- 57:51You know, the each time you just shoot a little bit further, a
- 57:53little bit further and just keep a good, a good look at what's
- 57:57going on. And we're that disproportionate
- 58:00to wounding, You know, I mean, you got to be able to see the
- 58:03difference between bruising and wounding and bruising is just a
- 58:06darker coloured area, say on the lungs.
- 58:09But the actual wound, the actual damaged tissue, you want to keep
- 58:13a good close eye on there and, and observe it.
- 58:17So, you know, if you, if you hit an animal at 2400 feet per
- 58:20second, you, you cut that animal, stop and actually look
- 58:23at the lungs, look at the whole lot and just look, think about
- 58:27it relative to what size mushroom that projector would
- 58:31have had to what size wound you've got.
- 58:34Do you do you think that if a hunter spends 3 hours looking
- 58:37for his animal, that might be a clue?
- 58:39Yeah. That's a part of it as.
- 58:43Well, yeah, yeah. And that's what happened in
- 58:46Europe after the, I can't remember which country it was
- 58:49now, but as soon as the bans came into effect, they, the the
- 58:54use of tracking dogs went up because of the amount of worthy
- 58:56animals. Yeah.
- 58:59One of the other things that they're doing or proposing, I
- 59:02should say, in Victoria is permitting the use of handheld
- 59:07thermal devices. And you can't help but think
- 59:12that that's a cause and effect situation, that perhaps they've
- 59:15been advised that there may be a higher risk of, of wounding and
- 59:20therefore we need to have access to this technology so that we
- 59:24can track animals easier. Yeah.
- 59:28I'm just conspiracy theorising here, but.
- 59:32Yeah, it's, yeah, Who knows? It's unfortunately with the
- 59:39these scientific papers, when they want to prove something,
- 59:43people will prove it one or another and and they will, you
- 59:47know, make the evidence. But unfortunately without
- 59:50actually, yeah, sadly, scientific evidence these days
- 59:57is is not always or science. You know what science consists
- 1:00:01as facts. It's not always based on hard
- 1:00:02evidence. So it yeah, it can be quite
- 1:00:05demoralising. But as you say, we've got to
- 1:00:08find solutions, ways to move forward.
- 1:00:10Yeah, I'll come back to the to the the scientists and and their
- 1:00:14evidence and so forth in a minute.
- 1:00:15But so in terms of the monolithic projectiles
- 1:00:20performance on animals. So if I can put a couple of
- 1:00:23parameters in in place. So if we say that, I'm happy to
- 1:00:27state that a significant majority of samba deer in
- 1:00:31Victoria are shot at 400 metres or less.
- 1:00:36And there are, there are definitely hunters out there who
- 1:00:41are shooting deer at longer ranges.
- 1:00:45But I'm going to suggest also that the percentage of hunters
- 1:00:49that are capable and should be shooting deer at ranges 506
- 1:00:57hundred 800 metres is probably in the single digits in terms of
- 1:01:02percentage wise. So that's that's hunters who
- 1:01:06have the equipment, the knowledge, the skill set and
- 1:01:10have practised that art form to be able to confidently and
- 1:01:16ethically do that. You know the old saying it's
- 1:01:19it's often the nut behind the bolt that causes the mistakes.
- 1:01:23So if we're looking at current rifle platforms 400 metres and
- 1:01:31less, is there a place for monolithic projectiles?
- 1:01:36Well, I'll give you a good example that there's a lady
- 1:01:41hunter in Victoria. She's a excellent hunter,
- 1:01:44probably better than most guys I would think.
- 1:01:47And so she she's running a three O 8.
- 1:01:50And the reason why I say Beta is because she, she knows that
- 1:01:56she's had the odds against her. She's a female, she wants to
- 1:01:58make it on her own and she's got a, a relatively mild cartridge
- 1:02:05versus a, a large animal. And she wants to make it work,
- 1:02:10make it all work. So what she's done is she's set
- 1:02:14about making sure her rifle's really, really accurate.
- 1:02:18She's got her trigger nice. She's put a lot of attention
- 1:02:21into that and she's been working on her shooting technique, a lot
- 1:02:25of practise and she's got all that going really, really well.
- 1:02:29So here we've got this person who's put huge amounts of effort
- 1:02:34into getting her gear as best as she can get her, and that's
- 1:02:38within her limitation. She's lightly framed, she's
- 1:02:40strong, but she's she's lean and, and lightly framed.
- 1:02:45Heck, she's doing pull ups on a pull up bar.
- 1:02:47You know, that's actually hard for women with a lateral
- 1:02:49development anyway. So she's got that set up and
- 1:02:53she's worked out that for ethical killing she can use a
- 1:02:57mono and close. But for Ridge to Ridge shooting,
- 1:03:02she she does have to use a softer bullet.
- 1:03:04So she's got that all figured out.
- 1:03:07But if she was to use her mono bullet for Ridge to Ridge
- 1:03:09shooting, that would produce a pinhole wound.
- 1:03:13Yeah. And so, so that's, I'm talking
- 1:03:16inside, inside 400 metres. So, yeah, right.
- 1:03:23So the three O 8, I mean it loses velocity, it doesn't have
- 1:03:26a lot of velocity to begin with and then it loses, you know,
- 1:03:30velocity quickly thereafter. So by the time she's out at 400
- 1:03:36yards, that's not even metres, most of her loads will be doing
- 1:03:40about 1800 feet per second, right.
- 1:03:42Yeah. So they well, well below that.
- 1:03:46And and you know, with monos, they're working really starts to
- 1:03:48diminish at 2400, but somebody get to 2200.
- 1:03:51You're really this is for a a high weight retaining mono,
- 1:03:55which is the one that the scientists use in their papers
- 1:03:57to prove that monos are effective.
- 1:04:01Yeah, by the somebody's 2400, it's really starting to lose
- 1:04:05ability to produce a widely disproportionate killer wound.
- 1:04:09And then at 2200, it's it's really quite narrow.
- 1:04:12And if they'd, if they'd paid attention to their, I think in
- 1:04:15those papers I saw a lot about how far the animals run.
- 1:04:20What I didn't see in the, in the Australian paper was much about
- 1:04:24what the ranges were. And I, I did notice they were
- 1:04:27shot using night vision, shot at night.
- 1:04:30So I don't think they were, you know, that's a, an advantage
- 1:04:34that they had that this average chance to lose.
- 1:04:36Talk about this young lady here. She, she doesn't have that
- 1:04:40advantage. So.
- 1:04:42I I think that with hunters using these mono projectiles, I
- 1:04:49think that what they have to understand is that they are so
- 1:04:52incredibly unforgiving. And so, you know, like that they
- 1:04:56could be good, good, good. And then there's that very, very
- 1:04:59fine line and then they're bad. And I think that really a lot of
- 1:05:05the limitations are going to be with the hunter himself, you
- 1:05:08know, because there's so much less forgiving of shot placement
- 1:05:12of that little bit of extra range.
- 1:05:15You know, you might be feeling good on a day and go, you know,
- 1:05:17I don't normally shoot beyond 300 yards, but, you know, it's a
- 1:05:21beautiful day that animals standing clear, as clear as a
- 1:05:24bell. I'll take that shot.
- 1:05:26You know, that little bit of extra yardage and, you know,
- 1:05:30with monos, they they don't, they, they don't allow that
- 1:05:33level that that little bit of extra.
- 1:05:35Do you know what I mean? Yeah.
- 1:05:36We and we have been testing monos a lot lately because of
- 1:05:40this concern with the Australia, but also for me writing, we're
- 1:05:46we're sitting about writing more books.
- 1:05:50And so there were two things I want to do.
- 1:05:51One, I wanted to make sure there wasn't me biassed because that's
- 1:05:54so easy to do. And you're writing, you form an
- 1:05:56idea about something and you then you're stubbornly stick to
- 1:05:59it and defend it. So I wanted to make sure that I
- 1:06:01wasn't being biassed. And and then secondly, I wanted
- 1:06:06to see what the latest options are doing.
- 1:06:09You know what, what has changed recently?
- 1:06:11So we've been out there every week testing.
- 1:06:14Yeah. And, and it's funny because we
- 1:06:16came across this. So I had the rifle side and
- 1:06:20everything's going really well as far as that side of it goes.
- 1:06:23The loads were all worked out. And then we saw a mob of pigs
- 1:06:26out long, and we had to cast those aside because we did just.
- 1:06:30And it was a cow, you know, we had to actually get these
- 1:06:33animals off this bloody paddock because they're ripping the crap
- 1:06:36out of it. And if we'd gotten closer, the
- 1:06:38wind would have eddied on us. And it was a it was a demanding
- 1:06:43situation and we had to preserve that land And those minor
- 1:06:47bullets, just like no, can't use those.
- 1:06:49Go back to your your stand alone and where we went.
- 1:06:52Maybe that the key is I, I think hunters have to realise how
- 1:06:58fortunate they've, they've been with, with the traditional
- 1:07:02projectiles, traditional bullets that we've used.
- 1:07:05They are so forgiving. They, they really are.
- 1:07:08And, and that is, and I think that that's the one thing that
- 1:07:11people are not quite getting with the whole copper bullet
- 1:07:14debate is they are so unforgiving if you don't put the
- 1:07:19practise in, if you're not on, if you're not a.
- 1:07:22Yeah, it's checking failing the whole lot, Yeah.
- 1:07:24Yeah, if you don't keep an eye on on the, the quality of your
- 1:07:27gear, the quality of your own shooting, you know, how do you,
- 1:07:30how do you read your ranges, etcetera.
- 1:07:33They they can be just they're just so unforgiving.
- 1:07:37Yeah. Yeah, I, I think that's, that's
- 1:07:40probably a common thing that I've heard in other podcasts
- 1:07:43that I've listened to about this topic as well, is that the lead
- 1:07:46projectile really has a the advantage where if you have a
- 1:07:50peripheral hit, so something that's on the the outside border
- 1:07:55of your target area, you're still a lot more likely to
- 1:08:01achieve a successful, a humane kill then you would be with a
- 1:08:06monolithic. Well, you'll at least get a
- 1:08:08blood trail, you know, I mean the number of times.
- 1:08:12You're with copper, you'll get the penetration, but yeah, the
- 1:08:15someone's blood trails actually. Yeah, some.
- 1:08:17Yeah. I mean, there's been a few
- 1:08:18animals that I've shot with a copper bullet and, and there's
- 1:08:22just no trace, you know, and you know that it was a good shot,
- 1:08:26but, you know, trying to find that blood trail is very
- 1:08:29difficult. I think the problem is, so you
- 1:08:31could say, well, the hunters need to be a bit of shot, but
- 1:08:35it's just it doesn't sort of allow for the realities of
- 1:08:38hunting where the wind can cause errors or the rifle, rifle
- 1:08:45accuracy limitations of a factory rifle or just the
- 1:08:48average guy just trying to do their best.
- 1:08:50There's so many clients I've heard they want to improve when
- 1:08:53they've come in and they've just been sort of fumbling along
- 1:08:56trying to, you know, do the best that they can and they've even
- 1:08:59sought advice here, there and it but it's, you know, it's
- 1:09:03actually good. It's it's hard to, to work it
- 1:09:06out takes time. I mean, that's why we do these
- 1:09:08things. They, they, they're a challenge.
- 1:09:10We and we said about doing we want to improve animal steps
- 1:09:15forward during the shot. That's another one that can muck
- 1:09:17up the shots. So yes, a lot of mistakes happen
- 1:09:20and you've got to be, you've got to have some allowances for
- 1:09:23that. Yeah, they are definitely more
- 1:09:26forgiving. Yeah, but you, you certainly
- 1:09:29raised an interesting perspective there as well about
- 1:09:33how, you know, a lead band might affect the other hunters, the,
- 1:09:41the females and juniors, because obviously they're, you know,
- 1:09:47they're, they're more recoil sensitive than generally than,
- 1:09:51than, you know, larger bodied beings like men.
- 1:09:57And you know, I, I, I like big calibres.
- 1:10:01I've, I've shot a lot of big calibres.
- 1:10:04But it's also nice to, you know, to shoot my 6.5 or MY257 rabbits
- 1:10:10every now and then because you don't get smacked around and,
- 1:10:14and that recoil blast and all the rest of it.
- 1:10:18So yeah, is this, is this ban potentially going to be
- 1:10:21discriminating against those people, that sector of the
- 1:10:25hunting community? Yeah, well, it can do in a way
- 1:10:29with the if you drive lead slowly it yeah, it it can still
- 1:10:36deliver a great deal of energy and produce a very large won't
- 1:10:39at low speeds. So which makes it ideal for
- 1:10:43running youth loads or for anyone, anyone that's recall
- 1:10:46sensitive. That's yeah, I mean, and then of
- 1:10:49course on on the other side of this too, we've got to look at
- 1:10:51it. Well, where's the poisoning as
- 1:10:55well? Like did they test Australian
- 1:10:58hunters versus, you know, non hunters to see what, what their
- 1:11:03blood levels were and or urine, whatever.
- 1:11:07Where's the the evidence, the data for that?
- 1:11:11Yeah. So that's that's the next
- 1:11:14question. I guess that that I've got is
- 1:11:16that if there is this evidence that suggests that lead is toxic
- 1:11:23to us, to hunting dogs and to the peripheral animals, the the
- 1:11:30Raptors and the the scavengers and predators.
- 1:11:34Do we not as as hunters, as conservationists, as part of our
- 1:11:40our ethos, do we not have a a duty to change over to non lead
- 1:11:45projectiles? Yeah.
- 1:11:48Well, again, we, I mean, we know that lead is toxic.
- 1:11:55Lead poisoning is a thing. But also, I mean, with the,
- 1:12:01there's an American CDC paper from a long, long time back
- 1:12:06where they tested the lead of hunters versus the lead of other
- 1:12:13citizens, non hunting citizens and found that there was no
- 1:12:18difference whatsoever because there's so much legacy lead and
- 1:12:24background lead from other sources.
- 1:12:25So it can be actually hard. And it's the same with the
- 1:12:28American Condor as well in California.
- 1:12:30They, they blame the hunters for that, but then they found the,
- 1:12:33the towers where the lead paint was used on those towers.
- 1:12:36It's a legacy, you know, legacy contamination.
- 1:12:41The the condors were were picking it up from those towers.
- 1:12:44And so since they've had the lead bands in California, as far
- 1:12:49as I'm aware hasn't significantly changed the the
- 1:12:52lead levels in those condors. So you can say, well, yeah.
- 1:12:56Sorry, I was just going to say, I think you actually said that
- 1:12:58there were photographs or videos of the condors actually picking
- 1:13:01the the lead ships off those, right?
- 1:13:04Yeah, yeah. So some of that was covered by a
- 1:13:08doctor. Ron Seba, his name is.
- 1:13:11And yeah, he was trying to, you know, create some kind of a push
- 1:13:15back against these bans because he felt that they were entirely
- 1:13:18political, you know, that in order to start strangling
- 1:13:21ammunition supply, which with the rising price of copper and
- 1:13:26so forth, with the electronic industry moving forward, you
- 1:13:28know, that that it could be a thing.
- 1:13:31But yeah, as far as poisoning goes, well, The funny thing is,
- 1:13:36you know, there's, there are so many contaminants in in our
- 1:13:38environment now. And it's funny how the
- 1:13:44government decides which, yeah, which one we worry about.
- 1:13:49For instance, we know that aluminium, it can cause immune
- 1:13:57disorders, it can cause Alzheimer's and the elderly, you
- 1:14:03know, it causes all sorts of damage and destruction to the
- 1:14:05body. And yet that one is considered,
- 1:14:08you know, that's OK. It's OK to be in your, in your
- 1:14:11food additives and deodorants and vaccines and so forth.
- 1:14:14Yet it can cause horrendous life changing consequences.
- 1:14:19But we're, we're supposed to, you know, just be OK with it.
- 1:14:23And versus lead, well, we know that lead is toxic, but now, you
- 1:14:28know, it's being vilified out of all proportions.
- 1:14:31And it's amazing how some hunters have been contacting me
- 1:14:34absolutely terrified of using lead that really there's this
- 1:14:37fear. And what's interesting is that
- 1:14:40if you were to, to try and detox the body, well, interestingly
- 1:14:44enough, lead leaves the body very quickly.
- 1:14:47If you're using a, a collating agent such as EDTAI mean these,
- 1:14:52they can get EDTA in pill form. There's other things like
- 1:14:56pectosole as well. If you're using some kind of
- 1:14:58collating agent will lead buoyance to clothing agents very
- 1:15:03readily and it flashes from the system.
- 1:15:05And that's why when you're doing a urine test for heavy metals,
- 1:15:09when I do that urine test, they'll push for the chemical
- 1:15:12with a collating chemical to actually get to move from the
- 1:15:14body. So when you're reading the, the
- 1:15:16results for that, it will show that, that you'll see high
- 1:15:20levels of lead, whereas you'll, you'll see low levels of
- 1:15:24aluminium. Now they might still be above
- 1:15:26the reference range, what beyond what's considered acceptable,
- 1:15:31but it, it won't look as high as lead.
- 1:15:33And the reason why it doesn't look as high as lead is because
- 1:15:35the lead actually moves the transports out of the body quite
- 1:15:40quickly and readily. It, it's higher up, it's atomic,
- 1:15:45you know, a number on the, on the periodic table, it's, it
- 1:15:47will actually have that affinity, whereas aluminium that
- 1:15:52that's actually a lot harder to shift from the body.
- 1:15:55So you know, there's these, you know, these contradictions here
- 1:15:59because yes, lead is toxic, but if you, if we take well, first,
- 1:16:04lead from bullets is not easily metabolised by the body.
- 1:16:07So if you, if you do, you know, if it does go into your system,
- 1:16:11you'll, you'll move it out of your system pretty quickly.
- 1:16:14It's not the same as constant exposure to some other body
- 1:16:18sulphate or something you'll lead, but if you do have it in
- 1:16:22your system, you can, if you need to remove it from your
- 1:16:24system quickly. Yet on the other hand, these so
- 1:16:29called approved metal such as you know, these approved levels
- 1:16:34such as aluminium, they don't shift from your system and, and
- 1:16:38they even they're hard to detect.
- 1:16:40And when you do get a, you know, a urine reading, they it may be
- 1:16:43a false reading. It may, even though it's just
- 1:16:46like slightly elevated, it might be because it's not shifting
- 1:16:49from your system. And so there's a, there's a lot
- 1:16:52there to unravel. And I, and I, so I really don't
- 1:16:55like the way scientists or, or government will pick on this one
- 1:17:00small group of people, these hunters when there's these, you
- 1:17:04know, huge elephants and they're really like glyphosate and so
- 1:17:08forth. There's just so much out there.
- 1:17:10Uranium and imported fertilisers is a big one.
- 1:17:12Cadmium and this is in the phosphate fertilisers.
- 1:17:15All these things now we won't address there, just address the
- 1:17:19hunters over here. So so who knows?
- 1:17:21I. Also think that lead is
- 1:17:23something that humanity's lived with for a long, long time and
- 1:17:29you know, we, our population seem to keep growing regardless
- 1:17:33of this lead that we've been that we've all been around our,
- 1:17:37our whole lives. And, you know, I, I tend to
- 1:17:41think about areas in the, well, I, I look at Europe, you know,
- 1:17:44there's this idea that lead gets in the environment and it
- 1:17:47becomes highly toxic and it destroys the ecosystem.
- 1:17:50Well, then, you know, after the Second World War, given the
- 1:17:54amount of ordnance that were dumped on the countryside,
- 1:17:57Europe should be dead. You know what I mean?
- 1:17:59Like it should just, I mean, how, how many tonnes of lead
- 1:18:02were, were dropped during the this World War?
- 1:18:05So how did anything survive that?
- 1:18:07I mean, that must all still be in that land, in that farmland.
- 1:18:11And that's do you know what I mean?
- 1:18:13Like, I just yeah, it's it's become so vilified and and
- 1:18:19people just buy into this vilification of something and
- 1:18:22they seem to just stop, look, stop thinking rationally going
- 1:18:27well, hang on. Haven't we always been around
- 1:18:29lead? I mean, lead pipes were the
- 1:18:30absolute norm. And I'm not suggesting that we
- 1:18:32should have lead pipes, but. Well then, so then it's really
- 1:18:36the Flint, MI crisis too. I mean, there's a lot of people
- 1:18:38that were affected by lead poisoning there, and that's from
- 1:18:40constant everyday exposure, yes. And that's a, a really bad idea.
- 1:18:46But I mean, what I'm trying to say is that you, you over the
- 1:18:49years as industrialization has happened, lead has been a very
- 1:18:53normal part of of our environment.
- 1:18:56Yeah, well, you still use it on wheel weights and and so forth.
- 1:18:59It's still still same. Yeah, I'm just not quite sure if
- 1:19:01the level of vilification that it's getting for environmental
- 1:19:06reasons problems is, is quite accurate.
- 1:19:10I think that's that's sort of yeah, yeah.
- 1:19:13I think that when I've looked at this evidence and initially, you
- 1:19:18know, you read the the studies of the the Raptors in America,
- 1:19:22the bald eagles and the the vultures and so forth, and even
- 1:19:26the Australian studies with wedge tail eagles.
- 1:19:32When you look at that on its face, you know, you could, you
- 1:19:38could be you, you couldn't be blamed for thinking, oh shit,
- 1:19:42lead is lead is bad. We, you know, we probably should
- 1:19:45be doing something about this, but we're looking at a literally
- 1:19:49a snapshot in history. So you're right there, Steph.
- 1:19:53When where's the baseline here? Where's the testing that was
- 1:19:59done years ago to say this Hunter now has elevated lead
- 1:20:05levels and we can directly trace that back to him eating shop
- 1:20:11meat using lead based projectiles?
- 1:20:14Yeah, or you can do that through Linotype operators as well.
- 1:20:17Yeah. And and where's the analysis of
- 1:20:20this Wedge Tower legal that we've measured this the LED in
- 1:20:24their system and we can directly attribute that to them
- 1:20:26scavenging on deer carcasses in the Alpine National Park that
- 1:20:30have lead core projectiles and so forth.
- 1:20:33So there is no, there's no perspective, there's no
- 1:20:37background, doesn't seem to be in from the reading that I've
- 1:20:40done. And, and please correct me if
- 1:20:42I'm wrong here, but you know, evidence can kind of be skewed
- 1:20:47here a little bit to serve a purpose.
- 1:20:51And, you know, scientists work by forming a hypothesis and then
- 1:20:56going out to try and prove that hypothesis.
- 1:20:58And a lot of time that that theory is based in their own
- 1:21:02belief systems and their own opinion or, you know, led by a
- 1:21:06particular subject that may be at the forefront of the media or
- 1:21:09or a political issue at the time.
- 1:21:12Yeah, that's right. That's and that's how it's been.
- 1:21:15And if you want to make an impact, you do have something to
- 1:21:18do with the environment and you certainly get funding for that
- 1:21:20these days. It's, yeah, it's the way things
- 1:21:23have gone. Yeah, I mean, research
- 1:21:26scientists all want to. Well, not all, but you know, I
- 1:21:31guess their, their objective is to go out and do some research
- 1:21:34so that they can then publish a paper, have it peer reviewed and
- 1:21:37then be a published scientist. And then that generates more
- 1:21:41research grant money for them, government contracts, you know,
- 1:21:45all of that sort of thing. And I'm, I'm not saying people
- 1:21:48shouldn't be out there trying to make money or make a living, but
- 1:21:52you can't help but feel that maybe there's a bias slung in
- 1:21:57One Direction because of a potential political issue.
- 1:22:03Yeah, yeah. I think for hunters, I think
- 1:22:09it's good if they, if they can try and Get the facts straight
- 1:22:13in their own heads to begin with and that the facts around how
- 1:22:18bullets kill, that, that's a big one.
- 1:22:19And actually understanding, I know you see, just like we're
- 1:22:23talking about physics here and you forget your high school
- 1:22:25physics, It would don't worry about that too much.
- 1:22:29That's what I would say to guys just but there are some basic
- 1:22:32things like weight times, speed equals kinetic energy, but
- 1:22:38kinetic energy only exists as a potential and that energy has to
- 1:22:42be transferred. And so, so we know that OK, so
- 1:22:46that just transferred through a change in form.
- 1:22:49But then if you start losing that speed, then you start
- 1:22:52losing that kinetic energy. So you need either more of a
- 1:22:55change of form or you need to trans, you know, completely
- 1:22:58transfer the energy into the target via having that break up
- 1:23:03and cause what I call mechanical wounding or a mechanical action.
- 1:23:08And then so from that you, you go into the field and start
- 1:23:11looking for this and, and instead of so then you must
- 1:23:14change your expectations as well.
- 1:23:16So if you go into it and this is like you to meet with scientists
- 1:23:19with their, they've got a preconceived idea of the outcome
- 1:23:23that they want and that they can create false bias.
- 1:23:26What's the same with themselves? So instead of complaining about
- 1:23:30a bullet shedding weight, I know it can be frustrating if you,
- 1:23:34you know, hit a big animal and it runs off and, and you think
- 1:23:37that bullets, it's because the bullet blew up.
- 1:23:40You know, that's the old saying. Well, if you can just study to
- 1:23:46to see, well, is it, could I have used more bullet weight?
- 1:23:50Or, you know, it's just really have a look at what's going on.
- 1:23:54Like we're we're some where they change in form and white
- 1:23:57shielding can does actually help with wounding.
- 1:24:00Don't just create blanket statements that if a bullet
- 1:24:03sheds white, that's bad, because then you're, you're, you're
- 1:24:09missing a whole, whole piece of the picture as you start
- 1:24:13thinking about, you know, how much bullet weight might be
- 1:24:16needed to actually get the job done because bullet weight,
- 1:24:18bullet weight and bullet construction are two significant
- 1:24:21factors, though the the neither are mutually exclusive.
- 1:24:26And, and then yes, there are times when it's good to have
- 1:24:29really, really high weight retention in the bullet, but be
- 1:24:32aware that that does also have its limitations once velocity
- 1:24:36starts to fall away. And a good example of that would
- 1:24:38be Woodley. Woodley have had great success
- 1:24:41in in with the African cartridges because the bullet
- 1:24:45does shed a little bit of weight.
- 1:24:46And you know, the African cartridges are usually only
- 1:24:48going about 22 to 2400 feet per second.
- 1:24:52Think about 2400 feet per second would be the average.
- 1:24:54And some African hundreds would consider it the magic number
- 1:24:57because it's the bullet's not going too fast.
- 1:25:00So it's not stressing the bullet on impact, but it's not going to
- 1:25:03be slow. So you're still generating a
- 1:25:04fairly good sized wound. Actually, in my experience, it
- 1:25:08is actually quite by the time the bullet reaches the target,
- 1:25:11on average, it's going to be doing about 2200 feet per
- 1:25:13second, which is slow. You're talking 3030 speeds.
- 1:25:17And the reason why these bullets work well is because they do
- 1:25:20shed some weight. So even on that real the, you
- 1:25:24know, the big African game, those Woodley bullets are
- 1:25:27shedding about 25% weight. So that's how they're working.
- 1:25:30So, so try to keep that in mind as you're going forward because
- 1:25:36and, and shift if you can, or even just let go of those
- 1:25:39expectations of how bullet should perform and actually just
- 1:25:42see how it is performing. And then you start adjusting,
- 1:25:47you know what, what you need to actually make things work from
- 1:25:50there. And then can just open up, you
- 1:25:53open yourself up to, to learning, you know.
- 1:25:57And it's, it's always the case when you have a, when you have
- 1:26:04a, a failure, when you lose an animal, like Steph said, you
- 1:26:08know, you're on your hands and knees for three hours trying to
- 1:26:11look for spots of blood to track an animal and, and end up having
- 1:26:14to give up. We then fill that, that
- 1:26:18information void with assumptions.
- 1:26:22And we always look to, to point the finger of blame at
- 1:26:26something. And usually it's, you know,
- 1:26:28it's, it's never our fault, is it, you know, where it was.
- 1:26:31It wasn't anything to do with me as a hunter or my accuracy or,
- 1:26:34you know, ability. It's always something else.
- 1:26:38And so, yeah, then be, and I'm saying this because some of the
- 1:26:42comments that I read on, on some of the social media posts were
- 1:26:45people saying that they had used a certain type of projectile and
- 1:26:49had lost that animal. And so therefore they blame the
- 1:26:53the projectile, but without that, that dead animal there in
- 1:26:59front of you to be able to perform the necropsy on it then
- 1:27:04becomes impossible to actually know what the where the fault
- 1:27:09lies. And it might have been a cluster
- 1:27:10of, yeah, that's right, factors. Yeah, a good example would be a
- 1:27:14comment I heard from Hunter and it was he, he thought that the
- 1:27:18black 300 blackout would be better than the three O 8
- 1:27:22because when the bullet hits, it's going slower so it can do
- 1:27:25more damage while it's inside the animal.
- 1:27:29So this is the kind of myths and so forth that that we
- 1:27:34perpetuate. And then, but on the other side
- 1:27:36of it, and we briefly touched on this before, and that is you
- 1:27:41get, there's been a few people in the States and they've shot
- 1:27:47stumps of wood with bands type bullets or, you know,
- 1:27:51homogeneous couple of bullets and the bullets haven't opened
- 1:27:55up. And then they've gone online and
- 1:27:57they've made a comment. I can't get this bullet to open
- 1:27:59up. And people have really jumped on
- 1:28:03the on the poster and see, you know how stupid they are because
- 1:28:07they because the homogeneous couple of bullet needs water to
- 1:28:12cause it to open up. Well, then you got to ask, well,
- 1:28:14who's stupid? Because and saying that all
- 1:28:17they're saying is that it needs a super hard, non compressible
- 1:28:23substance, which is, you know, one step away from a diamond in
- 1:28:28order to get that projectile to expand.
- 1:28:30So really is the guy who was just shooting it, I don't know,
- 1:28:32a tree stump really not a good test medium.
- 1:28:35But do you really have to run that guy into the ground for
- 1:28:37actually making that observation when, you know, there might be
- 1:28:40something to it? Yeah.
- 1:28:44So. But as you say, observation is
- 1:28:45the key because often people will blame something on bullet
- 1:28:50blow up or so forth or or that the bullets just passed through
- 1:28:53and done nothing. Well.
- 1:28:54So you've got on the ground and you can, it's hard to, if it's
- 1:28:59dark and it's wet and cold or something, you want to just get
- 1:29:01the butchering over and done with.
- 1:29:03You just want to get on with things.
- 1:29:04But it does pay to just get the carcass, get the animal 1st and
- 1:29:08then, you know, look where the entrance was, where the exit
- 1:29:11was, and then then set about gutting it and then lay the
- 1:29:16lungs and liver. It will end up beside it.
- 1:29:18Just stop for a minute and if you can, take a few photos and
- 1:29:22so that you can remember all of that and then later on you can
- 1:29:25start sort of piercing all that together.
- 1:29:30So coming back to the, the evidence in air quotes we see
- 1:29:37on, on the, the government, when I say the government, I'm
- 1:29:40referring, I'm not necessarily referring to a particular
- 1:29:43politician or whatever, but the, you know, the, the people that,
- 1:29:46that are responsible for making legislation changes and so
- 1:29:51forth. So we'll see on, on certain
- 1:29:54government websites, X rays, for example, of animals that have
- 1:30:01been shot with a lead core and a, a monolithic projectile.
- 1:30:05And we, you know, have these very pretty pictures that that
- 1:30:08illustrate the point about fragmentation and, and, you
- 1:30:13know, again, trying, trying to sort of push you in the
- 1:30:17direction of the advantage of monolithic as opposed to lead
- 1:30:23core. And then we read studies about,
- 1:30:28you know, bone scanning of dead Raptors and, and the the content
- 1:30:34there. What did you see are the, I
- 1:30:40guess the advantages or disadvantages?
- 1:30:43I'm not not trying to to get you to say something here, but what
- 1:30:47do you see perhaps as being problematic with that evidence
- 1:30:51being presented in that format? Well, with an X ray, of course
- 1:30:56the that is, you know, quite an emotive means of, of delivering
- 1:31:01information because they, they don't skin or gut the animal.
- 1:31:07They would generally use like a varmint style projectile
- 1:31:12travelling really, really fast with a really light bullet.
- 1:31:15So it meets a huge amount of resistance on impact because
- 1:31:19it's such a light fast bullet. It breaks up completely and and
- 1:31:25then they make no effort to to skin or gut the animal.
- 1:31:28So yeah, it's going, it's going to look like a mess.
- 1:31:30But further to that, it also a lot of the fragments that are
- 1:31:34seen in the X ray are actually copper jacket fragments.
- 1:31:39A more realistic Yeah X ray would be if the animal had been
- 1:31:44cleaned up the way a hunter would clean it up before he's
- 1:31:47going to, you know, take it, take it over, Tucker.
- 1:31:52Yeah, that that's a good point because obviously an X ray is A1
- 1:31:56dimensional image, so it doesn't show the depth of those
- 1:31:59fragments. So, yeah, are they, are they
- 1:32:02actually in parts of the meat that we would consume normally
- 1:32:06or are they in, you know, other areas where we're we're not
- 1:32:10likely to touch or or feed to the dogs or that sort of thing?
- 1:32:14Yeah, that's right. And I mean, also they they could
- 1:32:18have one approach could have been if they were that
- 1:32:21concerned, would have been to actually have some kind of
- 1:32:25social pressure on hunters to please bury bloodshot meat.
- 1:32:31It's a really simple way to get people on board.
- 1:32:33It still allows people their freedom of choice.
- 1:32:36It, you know, they could have worked all around it.
- 1:32:39It would might have required a bit of time, but I think
- 1:32:43everyone would have really gotten on on board with it.
- 1:32:45But these days it just seems to be, you know, blanket bans,
- 1:32:52control, control and that sort of carry on.
- 1:32:54And, and I guess I understand why governments do it because
- 1:32:57they were concerned that that there's always an element that
- 1:33:03will, you know, never, you know, they won't actually do the right
- 1:33:06thing. So then it's best to just ban
- 1:33:09things. But it's a shame that yeah,
- 1:33:13well, that's true too. You know what?
- 1:33:15What was that? Sorry, Steve.
- 1:33:16Yeah, it's like, it's like asking gang members to hand over
- 1:33:19their guns. It's never going to happen.
- 1:33:20Yeah, yeah, yeah. Can you hand over those illegal
- 1:33:23guns? Because we're going to make them
- 1:33:24really illegal. Yeah, that's right.
- 1:33:27Yeah, Well, that's quite true too.
- 1:33:30You. Oh goodness.
- 1:33:34And, you know, in, in Australia, the difference between Australia
- 1:33:37and the US is that a lot of states in the US have full meat
- 1:33:42recovery, if not full carcass recovery.
- 1:33:45So some, some places it's a requirement that you have to
- 1:33:52carry the whole animal out that you've, you've just tagged.
- 1:33:58So in Australia, obviously we, we don't have that, you know,
- 1:34:01hunters, hunters take the meat, the cuts they want and then the
- 1:34:05rest is left there. And that's, I guess that's where
- 1:34:08they're sort of deriving this evidence that the wedge towel
- 1:34:12eagles are then feeding on these carcasses and, and obtaining the
- 1:34:16lead poisoning from. But I guess the, the real punch
- 1:34:23below the belt is that there is a lot of aerial culling going on
- 1:34:28in, in Victoria on public land that hunters have access to.
- 1:34:34And those carcasses are not being recovered.
- 1:34:36They're being left there to rot. Yeah.
- 1:34:40And they are using lead Corp projectiles.
- 1:34:43And the proposal is, I believe that they will be given an
- 1:34:46exemption to continue their culling operations using Lead
- 1:34:50Corp projectiles. Oh, wow.
- 1:34:52OK, that's yeah. So not really worried about the
- 1:34:55animals then? Kind of kind of, yeah.
- 1:34:59Kind of contradicts their argument, doesn't?
- 1:35:01It it does. Yeah, it really does.
- 1:35:03Perhaps it's a shame. It's yeah, it's bad, bad
- 1:35:07business. You know, I remember reading
- 1:35:11articles about the deer colours in New Zealand and they would
- 1:35:17come in and and carry out the whole animal underneath.
- 1:35:20You know, you'd see a string of them underneath the helicopter
- 1:35:24getting carried out so that I could, you know, recover and
- 1:35:26utilise the meat. Yeah.
- 1:35:30So maybe they. Were shot, Most of them were
- 1:35:32shot was the 222. Headshot.
- 1:35:34Yeah. 222 or 22 to 50? Headshot.
- 1:35:36Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So, you know, maybe if the
- 1:35:43government had done said something like that, or maybe
- 1:35:45this is something that we should be pushing for as as a hunting
- 1:35:48community in Australia to say, well, you know, you, you're kind
- 1:35:52of contradicting yourself here and the the hypocrisy is a
- 1:35:55little bit hard to swallow. I don't know.
- 1:35:59That's that's just just a thought from from my side of it.
- 1:36:06Yeah, yeah. And I, I guess that's, that also
- 1:36:12contributes to the, the emotion that everybody has expressed
- 1:36:17around this, this topic in that, yeah, they're, they're being,
- 1:36:22we're being forced to, to do something.
- 1:36:25But the the rules are different for somebody who's contracting
- 1:36:29for the government. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:36:34Yeah. It's hard times around.
- 1:36:35I think that's across the board though, isn't it?
- 1:36:38That double standard that seems to exist at the moment.
- 1:36:41You know, absolutely do as I do as I say, and not as I do.
- 1:36:45Yeah, yeah, that's right. You got, you guys have got to
- 1:36:47sacrifice. Well, you know, we don't, Yeah.
- 1:36:51I mean, they're still dropping 1080 bites through the to the
- 1:36:54National Park as well. You know, if they're really
- 1:36:57worried about environment and animals being affected by by
- 1:37:05potential poisoning, why are we still dropping such a harmful
- 1:37:10poison in poisoning? Yeah.
- 1:37:13And New Zealand is no different as well.
- 1:37:15You know, I know they're, they're doing that over there
- 1:37:16for, for interesting. We actually hit we're friends
- 1:37:20with the entomologist. This is going back God nearly 20
- 1:37:25years now, and he was contracted by DOC, which is the Department
- 1:37:32of Conservation over here. And his job was to do an
- 1:37:37entomological study to see the effects of 1080 on the insect
- 1:37:42life after it had been dropped. And what he discovered was that
- 1:37:47it gets, because of course, the big argument with 1080 is that
- 1:37:51it only gets eaten by specific target species and it everything
- 1:37:56else is perfectly safe. And this guy found that actually
- 1:38:01that was not true. It got right through brought
- 1:38:04down into the soil and, and it was affecting and it did kill
- 1:38:07the insect populations. And anyway, he, his study was
- 1:38:13never released. He was then basically told to
- 1:38:16shut up. And that was the end of that.
- 1:38:18Yeah, yeah, he was. He was abstained.
- 1:38:20Yeah, yes. Yeah, exactly.
- 1:38:24Yeah. That's about it.
- 1:38:26Yeah, yeah. And look again, I, I might be
- 1:38:31conspiracy theorising here, but if the government controls the
- 1:38:37ammunition, then effectively they control firearms to a
- 1:38:42degree as well. And if all of a sudden certain
- 1:38:48calibres become irrelevant, unusable, you know, because in
- 1:38:59in Victoria, if you have cited that hunting is a reason for you
- 1:39:03to hold a licence, firearm licence, and all of a sudden you
- 1:39:08have firearms that you can't use because you can't get copper
- 1:39:15projectiles or copper ammunition for them.
- 1:39:20You know, you know where this is going.
- 1:39:21Like it's it's. Yeah, well, that was a concern
- 1:39:24in California that that a governor had said this right
- 1:39:28from the beginning. If we can't control the guns, at
- 1:39:30least we can control the ammunition.
- 1:39:33And it was after that that the lead bands came into effect.
- 1:39:35But if he if he Fast forward that to another, let's say 5 to
- 1:39:3910 years from here, let's think about some sort of 16 to 18 year
- 1:39:44old. He wants to, you know, maybe get
- 1:39:45into hunting and and get his licence.
- 1:39:49Well, a box of ammo at 200 bucks a pop is, you know, we're
- 1:39:53usually going to find the money for that.
- 1:39:55So 20 rounds at 200 bucks, I mean, we're already getting up
- 1:40:00to over a hundred 100 bucks over here now.
- 1:40:02So. Yeah.
- 1:40:04Yeah. Not to mention the fact that
- 1:40:06copper is so important to the, you know, the electronics
- 1:40:10industry and, and of course it's becoming, I mean mineral rights
- 1:40:17for the mining. Consents are.
- 1:40:21Also being shut down for for you know, for environmental reasons.
- 1:40:25And I mean, at the end of the day, if it comes down to who
- 1:40:28gets the cop or is it going to be government?
- 1:40:33Or the electronics and industry. But also the the armies, you
- 1:40:38know, or, or is it going to be civilian hunters?
- 1:40:41Well, it's going to be the army, isn't it?
- 1:40:43And it's going to be the electronics industry.
- 1:40:46So if there's only a finite amount of copper available, then
- 1:40:51yeah, you know, hunters aren't going to get it.
- 1:40:54So yeah. And this.
- 1:40:56You know, I mean, it's quite short.
- 1:40:57It's it's very this whole defending of of solid copper
- 1:41:01bullets is actually very short, short sighted I think as well.
- 1:41:06This Ukraine, Russia conflict is a is a great example of that for
- 1:41:11the, the powder shortage, yes, because it's all being, it's all
- 1:41:15being produced and and shipped straight over there.
- 1:41:17It's it's not coming out into the domestic market anymore.
- 1:41:20That's right. Yeah, I hear ADI has got huge
- 1:41:24contracts to supply to the US, which of course then goes on to
- 1:41:27the Ukraine and yeah, and again under the liquid bugger all.
- 1:41:35I guess ideally, you know, again, I'll, I'll say that I'm
- 1:41:40not, I don't have a a for or against personally here.
- 1:41:45I, I do use monolithic projectiles and I do also use
- 1:41:50lead Corp projectiles and, and both with the intention of using
- 1:41:54both to hunt, to hunt deer and, and also in Victoria.
- 1:41:59You know, I don't live in Victoria, but I do hunt there as
- 1:42:02often as I can. So in my mind, I guess I would
- 1:42:09have probably preferred and, and supported the government coming
- 1:42:12on board and saying, hey, look, this is what we're really
- 1:42:15concerned about and these are the reasons why.
- 1:42:18Here's the evidence. We're going to put it out there,
- 1:42:21make it accessible for you guys, even if they'd said, here's a, a
- 1:42:24training module that you're going to have to do to maintain
- 1:42:26your, your hunting licence for Victoria about educating you
- 1:42:32around lead poisoning and so forth.
- 1:42:35And then we're going to leave it up to you to make up your own
- 1:42:37mind as to what you're going to do.
- 1:42:39And if you want to switch over to monolithic, obviously we'll
- 1:42:44support you. If you don't, then that's your
- 1:42:46choice. And then maintain, you know,
- 1:42:49some sort of research and study going on and so forth in the
- 1:42:53background so that we could in years to come, come to a point
- 1:42:57where they can actually provide us with a, a good body of
- 1:43:00evidence to say this is, this is the data that we've accumulated.
- 1:43:06And these are these are our findings.
- 1:43:08And then as a result of that, we're going to, you know, make
- 1:43:11these, these changes or recommend these changes.
- 1:43:15But again, it's sort of like I said before, you know, they've
- 1:43:19kind of got this snapshot and gone, oh, this looks really bad.
- 1:43:23So we're going to now make a change because whatever the
- 1:43:29reasons are behind it, like we've said, you know, there,
- 1:43:32there may be ulterior motives behind it, but on the face of
- 1:43:36it, it looks like this is what we're basing it on because of
- 1:43:38this, this lead poisoning and so forth.
- 1:43:40So we're now going to make this change.
- 1:43:43And there's been no no build up to that and and no actual real
- 1:43:48study into to providing evidence to convince people that this is
- 1:43:54this is justified. Yeah, well, I mean, think about
- 1:44:01how many, how many animals were shot after the Second World War,
- 1:44:06when the guys came after both the First World War and the
- 1:44:09Second World War and the men came home, they had rifles gamer
- 1:44:14abundant. And the, the, the tallies, the
- 1:44:18levels of animals shot in New Zealand and Australia in those
- 1:44:21years was just so, so high. Pigs, Kangaroos over here, deer.
- 1:44:30And yet these you wedge tail eagle still there, you know, And
- 1:44:35now all of a sudden he's in danger.
- 1:44:37Well, OK, yeah. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:44:42I think historically, my memory of government is that they, they
- 1:44:50make up their mind that they're going to do something and make a
- 1:44:52change and legislate and they're going to legislate for it.
- 1:44:57And then they throw out a, you know, a public forum.
- 1:45:02And this is what's happened in Victoria.
- 1:45:04They've, you know, open this subject up for public comment.
- 1:45:09But at the end of the day, they've already made up their
- 1:45:11mind. They know what they're going to
- 1:45:13do and they, they're just going to force it through and, and get
- 1:45:16what they want. But they kind of do this public
- 1:45:19consultation process to give us the impression that we've had an
- 1:45:23opportunity to have a say and have an argument and, and that
- 1:45:26sort of thing. And, and then when the change
- 1:45:28comes in, we go, Oh, well, you know, at least they gave us a
- 1:45:31chance. You know, So I can't help but
- 1:45:34feel that regardless of what we say and the evidence that we put
- 1:45:38forward, you know, for or against this, the government is
- 1:45:41still going to move in the direction that they want to
- 1:45:43move. So yeah, when that happens, I
- 1:45:50guess maybe maybe I'll, I'll have to reach out to you again
- 1:45:53and have a different conversation about what what
- 1:45:56changes people need to look at making in terms of their their
- 1:46:02hunting style or, you know, rifle.
- 1:46:08Yeah, well, it is tough because at the moment, you know, people
- 1:46:11are looking towards efficiency as well as you see with the
- 1:46:13powder shortages. And then here's me talking
- 1:46:16about, you know, using more speed, more power to try and
- 1:46:21make the most of this stuff. And those two don't go together
- 1:46:25that well. But yeah, maybe we can have that
- 1:46:27conversation again one day. And and then hopefully we're
- 1:46:31talking about the the technology being in its infancy still.
- 1:46:34I, I know that a lot of copper manufacturers wouldn't agree
- 1:46:37with that, but I don't think they should presume that they
- 1:46:42could do in just a few years. What other manufacturers took,
- 1:46:46you know, 50-60 years to do? Yeah.
- 1:46:51But anyway, yeah, yeah. I mean that the technology and
- 1:46:55machinery and and even knowledge base now is far, far further
- 1:47:01ahead than than what it was 40 or 50 years ago.
- 1:47:06So there's, yeah, there's definitely room for, for growth.
- 1:47:09There's still. Yeah, I think that the one of
- 1:47:12the trouble with the in the old days, people were good at
- 1:47:17observing and but what they didn't have was the words to
- 1:47:22articulate what they were saying.
- 1:47:23And I was no different either. A lot of gun writers of the day
- 1:47:30and, and people who were working in that those companies, they,
- 1:47:35they just came from, you know, grass roots, you know, types,
- 1:47:41types of upbringings and lives. And so they could, they could
- 1:47:45witness and observe something and they, they could develop a
- 1:47:48good understanding of it, but they couldn't really articulate
- 1:47:54that. And so that's why we ended up
- 1:47:55with words like hydrostatic shock, which is a bit of a
- 1:47:59concoction of words. It was Roy Wetherby, he coined
- 1:48:02it and, and then people already attacked him for that.
- 1:48:06But actually, you know, you think it, it's good enough, like
- 1:48:09if you pull the word apart and study it and you think, OK, that
- 1:48:12that's good enough. It, it'll do.
- 1:48:14But now we have the, the technology that's that's true.
- 1:48:20And we have all these advantages, but what we seem to
- 1:48:25be lacking is the, the ability to actually observe and
- 1:48:30understand things for ourselves. And that that's kind of gone
- 1:48:33away. Critical thinking.
- 1:48:36Critical thinking. Yeah, it's gone.
- 1:48:40And I think a lot of that is because there is so much
- 1:48:42pressure on the Internet. A gentleman can can hunt an
- 1:48:47animal, see a result and go, OK, I think this happened.
- 1:48:51And he only has to be on the Internet for half an hour to
- 1:48:53feel like he has no idea what actually happened, regardless of
- 1:48:57what he saw, because there's so, so many people going, oh, what
- 1:49:01actually happened was this. Yeah, but the other problem is
- 1:49:04too, is that you you can go onto the Internet with the most
- 1:49:10ridiculous, stupid idea and you'll find a million people who
- 1:49:14agree with you and validate it immediately.
- 1:49:17And then, OK, I'm going to start up a bullet company just like
- 1:49:20that. Well, you know, I was thinking
- 1:49:22about these, these big copper bullet manufacturers and it's,
- 1:49:28it's really interesting how they've, they've kind of turned
- 1:49:30things on on its head because it used to be a, a businessman
- 1:49:36would see a, see a, a market for something, right?
- 1:49:41Like a need. Like you see a need.
- 1:49:43And so you create, you create and you fill that.
- 1:49:46But what's actually happened in this case is that the company
- 1:49:50has created the need and now the market is filling it.
- 1:49:55You know, like it's a wrong reversal.
- 1:49:58You know, rather than creating something that that people
- 1:50:00needed, instead they've created something and then told, told
- 1:50:05the people that they need what they've created.
- 1:50:07Yeah, it's the modern line, yeah.
- 1:50:08Which is so. Different, yeah, Yeah.
- 1:50:10And I think that sort of ties in with what you said before,
- 1:50:13Nathan, about things have been financially motivated where
- 1:50:17companies may find a way to produce something that's very
- 1:50:22cheap to produce. But then they can market it as
- 1:50:27though, like you say, Steph, everybody needs this because of
- 1:50:30these reasons here. Yeah.
- 1:50:33And, you know, huge amount of markup and so forth.
- 1:50:35And then there's a, there's a, you know, there's an explosion
- 1:50:40and so forth. And again, I take nothing away
- 1:50:42from people trying to make money.
- 1:50:45But you know that, yeah, like I said, the marketing monster that
- 1:50:47that puts their hand inside your head and manipulates the, the,
- 1:50:52the thought process and, and maybe, maybe overpowers the, the
- 1:50:57rational side of the brain. Yeah, yeah, yeah, so true.
- 1:51:05Look, like I said this, this is a very emotive topic and, and
- 1:51:10I've, I've certainly tried to have some, you know, some
- 1:51:14conversations with people to, to find out, you know, where, what
- 1:51:20they're basing their things on. And because what I, I guess I
- 1:51:24saw a lot of was people just basically slamming their fist on
- 1:51:28the desk and saying, you know, this is unfair and, and
- 1:51:30therefore we shouldn't do it. When in actual fact, they
- 1:51:34haven't sort of had an opportunity to, to step away
- 1:51:39from that emotion and analyse it and see whether this is actually
- 1:51:42a good thing or not, you know, and, and weigh up what's been
- 1:51:45told to us and, and going out and doing their own research.
- 1:51:48So my concern is that this is really going to kind of split
- 1:51:56the hunting community. And, you know, Davidivism is, is
- 1:52:01not what we want and what not what we need as a hunting
- 1:52:04community. So that that's my that's my
- 1:52:09concern is that, yeah, we're going to be pitted against each
- 1:52:12other with the, you know, the civil war of the the lead corps
- 1:52:15versus the the monolithic over here.
- 1:52:17And and that's what that's what governments want.
- 1:52:21They want to, you know, they want to divide and conquer
- 1:52:25basically. So I think what I'm coming back
- 1:52:31to is that there is a place, I think we can, we can agree that
- 1:52:36there is a place for monolithics in, in deer hunting in Victoria.
- 1:52:44But it's because, and I say this because I think it's an
- 1:52:48inevitability that we're going to be pushed into, to doing this
- 1:52:53and that hunters are going to have to learn where the, where
- 1:52:58this new projectile fits into the, the scheme of their hunting
- 1:53:04and how, how that looks for them in terms of perhaps changing the
- 1:53:08style of hunting that they do or, or, you know, other
- 1:53:11modifications and so forth. And again, how, how this is
- 1:53:15going to be policed. We, we don't know the, the, you
- 1:53:19know, I mean, spotlighting in the, in the Alpine National Park
- 1:53:22is illegal. Yet you can go down there, you
- 1:53:24know, almost any day of the week and, and certainly over the
- 1:53:27weekends and you'll see the electric dog getting flashed
- 1:53:30around. So, yeah, and I'm not saying
- 1:53:34that because I want to, I want to encourage people to break the
- 1:53:36law. I'm just saying that, you know.
- 1:53:42How this is going to be done? How's it going to be achieved?
- 1:53:44Yeah, yeah. Does this mean that the
- 1:53:47government is then going to pour more money into staffing this
- 1:53:53this problem to be policed and and, you know, officers hiding,
- 1:54:00hiding behind trees and jumping out and doing random inspections
- 1:54:03on on hunters walking through the the National Park and that
- 1:54:08sort of thing. Like, yeah, we're, we're sort
- 1:54:09of, I know I'm going down a rabbit hole here, but I'm, I'm
- 1:54:13just, I guess what I'm, I'll come back to that point that I,
- 1:54:16I don't want this to divide us. That I if, if we are going to
- 1:54:21have our arm twisted here, that we're going to have to still
- 1:54:26remain as a a solid unit and. Yeah.
- 1:54:32Well, on that note, you know, when, when copper bullets first
- 1:54:37hit the scene, I was really, really keen for them.
- 1:54:40And the reason was, was because I, I was hunting large deer in
- 1:54:46the Bush and I really wanted to have a bullet that would take an
- 1:54:52animal from any, any angle sort of thing.
- 1:54:54I, I developed these ideas around, you know, the need for
- 1:55:00cartridge power and penetration, all that.
- 1:55:01And I, I actually, so this is when I was researching, but I
- 1:55:06was still very young and I thought that when I, you know, I
- 1:55:11just thought that the, the projectiles needed to be better
- 1:55:14and that, you know, why, why are they losing so much weight and
- 1:55:16all this sort of care on. Anyway, when copper finally hit
- 1:55:19the market, I was really, really excited about it.
- 1:55:23I thought this was going to fix all sorts of problems and, and
- 1:55:26I'd have this bullet that could, you know, punch through from any
- 1:55:30angle and take animals of all different sizes.
- 1:55:32Well, after I got going with it, well, the first problem was
- 1:55:36failing and poor accuracy. So that was a major issue.
- 1:55:42And then sort of managed to work around that and we had the
- 1:55:46coated bullets, they came out for a while and then we had the
- 1:55:48banded bullets. But as I went along and I
- 1:55:51started noticing that that diminished wounding performance
- 1:55:54at lower velocities in, in some cases, just poor performance
- 1:56:00because of the, the particular method or, or the, the copper
- 1:56:04that was used. I then I realised these things
- 1:56:07had serious limitations. So the reason why I mention that
- 1:56:12is because I, I, I was all for copper myself and I thought it
- 1:56:17was going to be great. So I don't think it's a case of
- 1:56:19being on one side of the fence or other either.
- 1:56:22I think as you say, people can actually work together and say,
- 1:56:25well, this, this type of bullet has strength here, but you know,
- 1:56:31it's not going to do everything. Well, that's fair enough.
- 1:56:34You know, that's that's fine. What's wrong with it?
- 1:56:37It's like knives. If you have a big heavy knife,
- 1:56:41you know you can't do you try chopping carrots with it.
- 1:56:43It just blows chunks. But you can't even cut bread
- 1:56:45with it. So you have different tools
- 1:56:49through different jobs in the middle.
- 1:56:50You know what what we're doing, it's the same.
- 1:56:53Same goes here. So yeah, copper bullets.
- 1:56:56I still still like using them for heavy animals, they can be
- 1:57:00great, but I I'm infinitely aware that they're the problems
- 1:57:05that can occur at low velocities.
- 1:57:07You know it, It can be. Yeah, yeah, I years ago I, I
- 1:57:14same thing. I was excited about using barns
- 1:57:17in my 270 and hand loaded some 140 grain.
- 1:57:23And back then they didn't have the, the tipped.
- 1:57:25So it was just the, the TSX, it was one above the X, the first
- 1:57:29model that they came out because that obviously had a lot of a
- 1:57:32lot of the issues with it. So they'd, yeah, they'd come out
- 1:57:35with the, the TSX and, and yeah, same thing.
- 1:57:39Very excited to use it. This was going to, this was
- 1:57:41going to be a game changer for me.
- 1:57:42Got good accuracy out of them. And then one of the first deer I
- 1:57:48ever shot almost, almost lost it.
- 1:57:51And it wasn't for the fact that I was hunting with a maid at the
- 1:57:54time who, who was using core locks, probably would have lost
- 1:57:59it. And what had happened was I'd,
- 1:58:04I'd hit him in that no man's zone that you're talking about
- 1:58:06right through the, the muscle between the, under the, the
- 1:58:10spinal cord and that the, you know, you could have pushed the
- 1:58:13knitting needle through the bullet hole.
- 1:58:16But you know, so then for me, I was like, OK, well, I'm never
- 1:58:21using monolithics again. They're a complete, another
- 1:58:24failure. I'm done with them.
- 1:58:27Eventually a sort of comeback. It's comeback full circle for me
- 1:58:30where I'm experimenting with another brand of, of monolithics
- 1:58:34at the moment. And I've, I've struggled to, to
- 1:58:38get an accuracy that I, I wanted from them.
- 1:58:43So I was literally at the point of going back to, to Leadcorp
- 1:58:48projectiles, but I've been able to sort of, I, I found now I
- 1:58:53found what I think is a good acceptable sweet spot with them.
- 1:58:57So, you know, I'm, I'm happy to experiment and so forth.
- 1:59:00And so far the the animals that I've shot with them have have
- 1:59:03all been good results. And that's if you that's the
- 1:59:07other side of if you're hand loading, you can muck around
- 1:59:09with it. But if you're a factory ammo
- 1:59:11user, you know, and if the handwriting was to get banned in
- 1:59:14the future, well, that really starts to muck things up, you
- 1:59:16know. But if you're you're a factory
- 1:59:19MO user, you've got to just stick with whatever you've got.
- 1:59:24You know it's not so good. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:59:27And unfortunately in Australia, we we don't see a lot of the
- 1:59:32products that are actually available, you know, because we
- 1:59:35are such a small market share over here.
- 1:59:39I think I, I spoke to somebody once who was, this was when I
- 1:59:44was in America years ago and I forget which company they were,
- 1:59:48they were working with, but it was one of the, one of the sort
- 1:59:52of distribution, distribution type companies that, you know,
- 1:59:56handled a lot of different brands and so forth.
- 1:59:58And I, I said to him, you know, why, why do you not, you know,
- 2:00:02send these over to Australia? And he said.
- 2:00:05I'll be honest, he said. Because you guys are less than
- 2:00:072% of our market share and if if I tried to convince my bosses
- 2:00:13that I could increase their their profit rate by 1.8% by
- 2:00:17doing all this work, they told me not to worry about it.
- 2:00:20Yeah. So having said that, however, I
- 2:00:25do want to highlight that it is not impossible to get things
- 2:00:27into Australia to import them. I've been successful in
- 2:00:32importing these projectiles. They, they are produced in the,
- 2:00:35in the US, I've also had some cases imported as well.
- 2:00:38So with the right paperwork and, and a bit of patience, you can
- 2:00:42do it. So if anybody out there
- 2:00:44listening is interested to know more, please reach out to me
- 2:00:47because I'll I'll quite happily walk you through it.
- 2:00:51Very good. All right, so I'm mindful of the
- 2:00:56time guys and, and I really appreciate it.
- 2:00:58And I'm sure that we could sit here talking, talking gums and
- 2:01:01Ballistics and so forth all day, but I want to talk about
- 2:01:04something a little bit more enjoyable.
- 2:01:06So one of the things that that I several years ago, Nathan, that
- 2:01:12we we connected with that was your 7 millimetre practical.
- 2:01:17So this is this is a bit of a baby of yours.
- 2:01:20So tell us, tell us about that and, and what's on offer there
- 2:01:24or potentially on offer there for people who are interested.
- 2:01:26Well, I designed the seven mill practical around 2011 and with a
- 2:01:32few modifications going on from there and it's based on the 300
- 2:01:38Winchester Magnum Nick down to 7 mill.
- 2:01:42So the case is a bit longer than the Sigmal Remington Magnum.
- 2:01:46And the reason that came about was because I had been using the
- 2:01:50Sigmal rum for a while and I was really enjoying its long range
- 2:01:53performance, but I was burning through barrels too quickly and
- 2:01:59so I had to sort of try and work out well, where's the maximum
- 2:02:03power level for the Sigmal bore? You know, how much powder can
- 2:02:08you actually put through it before you start getting into,
- 2:02:10you know, massive over ball problems?
- 2:02:13So yeah, the 301 Chester made in case seem to be about right.
- 2:02:21So yeah, we got that going and it's been a huge success.
- 2:02:28Manson Remus, they produce the the Remus for it these days and
- 2:02:32it's actually been so popular that they've been producing it
- 2:02:35in batch runs. I don't know if that's still the
- 2:02:37case now with the seven mile PRC on the market.
- 2:02:41But yeah, interestingly, the I was expecting the PRC would,
- 2:02:46would kill its popularity, but PRC is a little less powerful,
- 2:02:51although that does it does make it a bit easier for certain
- 2:02:54types of match work and things like that, you know, a bit
- 2:02:58longer barrel life. But yeah, the PRC wasn't as
- 2:03:01powerful. And also the twist rate Hornady
- 2:03:06suggests it's, they can make it quite finicky regarding
- 2:03:09accuracy. So yeah, the, the practical
- 2:03:13seems to be going really, really well.
- 2:03:15Of course, it does have its limitations.
- 2:03:17It's it's a good medium game cartridge, but you wouldn't want
- 2:03:21to, you know, put it on onto, you know, really large animals.
- 2:03:26You start, you know, asking too much of it.
- 2:03:29But yeah, we've had a lot of fun with it over the years.
- 2:03:31That's for real. Yeah.
- 2:03:34Are you, do you build your own rifles?
- 2:03:37Do you do your own gunsmithing and so forth.
- 2:03:39Because you you experiment. With a lot of so we, we over the
- 2:03:43years we've done a lot of gun work and also tutorial work.
- 2:03:49So I was guiding for a number of years and then and that was
- 2:03:54advertised on the website and then that that changed to
- 2:03:58tutorials when I found that, you know, people really as I got
- 2:04:02more into the the research of cartridges, I also found that I
- 2:04:06really wanted to educate the guys that were coming rather
- 2:04:10than just take them at hunting because, you know, I was seeing
- 2:04:13so many problems with the cat guys were bringing along.
- 2:04:17So rather than just Pooh poohing my clients and going, oh, why
- 2:04:20did the guy bring this rubbish? I actually turned it into a
- 2:04:23tutorial type hunts. And then as time went by, they
- 2:04:27became, you know, the tutorials went more towards long range as
- 2:04:32well. So yeah.
- 2:04:34And then this course is the book sets that that people read to go
- 2:04:37with it. But then and more in recent
- 2:04:39years, especially since the lockdowns have have backed off a
- 2:04:42lot of that and educate people through the through the books so
- 2:04:49they can they can find that out there.
- 2:04:50And I really do encourage people to just work through the books
- 2:04:53and do that themselves. But for us at the moment, I
- 2:04:56mean, we're still running the occasional tutorial and still
- 2:04:59doing a little bit of gun work. But the biggest thing at the
- 2:05:02moment is just to try and keep the keep up the research and,
- 2:05:06and writing. And that's so time consumer.
- 2:05:09I can't be everywhere at once, so we're just doing the best
- 2:05:13that we can and and trying to trying to make it all work out,
- 2:05:17you know? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 2:05:21Well look like I said the the seven mil practical certainly
- 2:05:24piqued my interest years ago and and I think I was even able to
- 2:05:29track down a gunsmith in Australia that had a reamer for
- 2:05:32it at the time. So I did did come close to to
- 2:05:37building 1, but in the end, I kind of the only reason I shield
- 2:05:41away from it or or didn't go with one was I, I kind of wanted
- 2:05:45A1 gun to do as much as I could. And that was mainly due to
- 2:05:51financial restrictions at the time.
- 2:05:52I I'd love to have a, you know, a gun safe full of different
- 2:05:55calibres for one for each each animal that I want to hunt.
- 2:05:58But and because the the biggest animal that I was hunting was
- 2:06:04Buffalo, water Buffalo in Australia and and North American
- 2:06:09game like elk, I decided that I needed something a bit bigger of
- 2:06:13a so. Yeah, that's right.
- 2:06:14It's not. It's just not suitable for that
- 2:06:16kind of carry on. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:06:18But no, certainly, certainly sort of like I said, I took a
- 2:06:22took a shine to it and I think we, we emailed back and forth a
- 2:06:26few times and did a lot of reading on it and I mean just in
- 2:06:30general as well. I've also found myself coming
- 2:06:32back to your website over the years, you know, multiple times
- 2:06:37because you do have that knowledge base there.
- 2:06:40So anytime you know, I had a curiosity about a particular
- 2:06:43calibre or, or you'd Google something and you know you'd
- 2:06:46come up in the search results, yeah, I'd find myself back on
- 2:06:50your website again anyway, so. Oh good.
- 2:06:53I'm glad it's been useful. The main thing is, and other
- 2:06:57people won't click here and subscribe to this and that's the
- 2:07:00Karen, but purpose of it is it's got to be practical and useful.
- 2:07:04That's it's your main concern. We we make our money from some
- 2:07:07book sales. That's great.
- 2:07:09But otherwise it's just about doing the right thing and in
- 2:07:12helping each other along. It's it's got to count for
- 2:07:15something. You know, you no point just
- 2:07:17having a bunch of waffle up there.
- 2:07:19So I'm glad you know, it's it does seem to have helped a lot
- 2:07:22of people out over the years. It's been wonderful.
- 2:07:27Well, look, I, I'm going to, I'm going to wrap this up like I
- 2:07:30said, otherwise we would, we would be talking guns and, and
- 2:07:33hunting all day. And it's now you guys are what,
- 2:07:38two hours? So it's now getting close to
- 2:07:40lunchtime for you 2 as well. Yeah, it certainly.
- 2:07:44Is so ballisticstudies.com is the website.
- 2:07:49There's like I said, there's, there's a whole knowledge base
- 2:07:52there. There's articles, there's a
- 2:07:53particularly entertaining article you just put out
- 2:07:55recently about tactical tomfoolery.
- 2:08:00I'd, I'd encourage people to go and have a look.
- 2:08:02I won't, I won't spoil it for people, but let's just say it
- 2:08:06would it relates to a recent firearm related event in the US.
- 2:08:11So that was, that was entertaining and it's in itself.
- 2:08:15I, I can't thank you enough again for, for making this
- 2:08:18happen and, and giving me your, your time.
- 2:08:22And Steph, again, thank you for for twisting his arm or, or
- 2:08:26twisting his ear for whatever you have to do to get him to
- 2:08:29come on board. You're most welcome.
- 2:08:32It's it's been great talking to you, Tobias.
- 2:08:34I really enjoyed it. Yeah, yeah, I have two mate.
- 2:08:37And like I said, no doubt we'll probably touch base again in the
- 2:08:40future and, and stay in contact. And I, I definitely plan on
- 2:08:45getting back over to New Zealand again.
- 2:08:46So either I'll make the effort to come up on the North Island
- 2:08:51and come and see, or, or maybe you're down the South Island at
- 2:08:54the same time I am and we can cross paths.
- 2:08:57It sounds wonderful to buy us. Sounds good.
- 2:08:59Yeah, we are in a pretty attractive area of Taranaki,
- 2:09:05aren't we? Yeah, yeah, we're really lucky
- 2:09:07here. Hey, thank you for listening in.
- 2:09:16If you'd like to contact me for a chat, pass on any feedback or
- 2:09:20have some ideas for future podcasts, please reach out to me
- 2:09:23on Instagram at australian_hunting_backcountryoremail.australian.hunting.backcountry@outlook.com
- 2:09:35dot AU and now. Though please look after
- 2:09:38yourselves and your mind.