Latest / Film And Whiskey / The Holdovers / Stranahan's Snowflake
Transcript
- 0:00In 2023, director Alexander Payne and star Paul Giamatti
- 0:05gave the world a warm and Invitational film about the
- 0:08power of honest conversations. In 2024, we tried perhaps the
- 0:13perfect Christmas whiskey. The film is The Holdovers.
- 0:18The whiskey is Stranahan's snowflake.
- 0:21And we'll review them both. This is the.
- 0:24Film and whiskey. Podcast.
- 0:45Welcome to the Film and Whiskey podcast, where each week we
- 0:47review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:50I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 0:52And Brad, it is officially the Christmas season here at Film
- 0:56and Whiskey. It's the weather.
- 0:58Outside is frightful, Bob. Yeah, well, that's because we
- 1:00live in Ohio. But sure, we'll, we'll tie it
- 1:03into Christmas. It's December 17th.
- 1:06So we, we, we're theming this around Christmas because next
- 1:10Tuesday we're taking a break from our regularly scheduled
- 1:13programming to bring you our latest episode of our Cruise
- 1:16Miss series. Cruise Miss.
- 1:19We'll be looking once again at a Tom Cruise film.
- 1:22We're going to try to tie it to this season's theme.
- 1:25And folks, welcome into the show.
- 1:26If this is your first time listening to us, you're probably
- 1:29wondering what is Cruise miss? What is this season's theme?
- 1:32There are a lot of unanswered questions here.
- 1:34Keep up. There's a lot to keep up with
- 1:36here. And if you are not a new
- 1:38listener, if you've been here for a while, I would encourage
- 1:40you that in this Christmas season you would give us a like
- 1:45subscribe, 5 star review. All of those things help out the
- 1:49podcast greatly and you guys warm our hearts.
- 1:53Yeah, listenership definitely goes up over the holiday season.
- 1:56People are traveling and we want to get people's eyes on the
- 1:59podcast. So if you're able to share on
- 2:00your social medias or like and subscribe, especially subscribe
- 2:04whichever platform you're listening on, it would do us a
- 2:07great Christmas service. Now, what is film and whiskey?
- 2:10Film and Whiskey is a podcast where we review classic movies
- 2:14and we drink a new glass of whiskey each week.
- 2:16This season we're looking at films released in the last 20
- 2:19years and we're asking the question, does this film deserve
- 2:23to be considered a modern classic?
- 2:25And Brad, I don't think we need to bury the lead on the
- 2:29holdovers. This is a film that came out
- 2:31last year. It was, you know, always kind of
- 2:34in second or third place in the awards season run behind the
- 2:38juggernaut that was Oppenheimer. But I think the consensus both
- 2:41among critics and audiences at the time was like, man, if this
- 2:45movie had come out in any other year, this is like a lock for a
- 2:48best picture win because it is such a crowd pleaser and was
- 2:52immediately hailed as a new Christmas classic.
- 2:55And I dare say Brad, it can easily be considered a modern
- 2:59classic. I am 100% with you, Bob.
- 3:02This was one that you very ardently strove to get me to
- 3:08see, not necessarily in theaters.
- 3:10You just wanted me to watch it. And it feels like it was around
- 3:13that time that you were really pushing the holdovers past
- 3:17lives. You had already tried to get me
- 3:20to see Oppenheimer unsuccessfully, but it felt like
- 3:23this year there was like a lot of movies that really, I don't
- 3:29know, tickled your fancy. Yeah, I think as we get farther
- 3:32and farther from it, it's going to be clear that 2023 is one of
- 3:35the best movie years ever, especially at the top of the
- 3:37heap. I can't remember the last time
- 3:40that I've made like my 10 best list, and I've looked through
- 3:43and said I'm going to go out and spend money on buying at least
- 3:47the top six of these. You know, there's a lot of times
- 3:49where I think a movie is like an 8 out of 10, and I still don't
- 3:52feel compelled to own that movie.
- 3:54But between the Holdovers, Oppenheimer, Past Lives, Anatomy
- 3:59of a Fall, Godzilla -1 even on the family side, the movie Wonka
- 4:04is a movie I really, really loved.
- 4:05I think it was just an absolute banger of a year last year, man.
- 4:09Yeah, and I'm super excited to talk about The Holdovers because
- 4:13this is a film that feels like one of the most honest and
- 4:18charming films that has come out in quite some time.
- 4:22It really is kind of a warm sweater of a movie, even though
- 4:25the characters are cold and prickly at times.
- 4:28It feels very familiar, and I think that's by design.
- 4:31You know, the director Alexander Payne is great at making movies
- 4:35like this where two prickly characters come together and
- 4:37have some sort of odyssey or journey together.
- 4:40I think for a long time I've told you about this movie I love
- 4:43from him called Nebraska. I'm sure we'll watch it someday
- 4:46on the podcast. But this is probably the
- 4:49Alexander Payne movie that has clicked the most with the
- 4:51general public, at least since his movie Sideways, which came
- 4:54out in 2004. And I think that what he's
- 4:57trying to do here is he's trying to harken back to, there's a
- 5:00director from the 70s named Hal Ashby, who is it kind of had a
- 5:04resurgence in the last 10 years. People are looking at his movies
- 5:07a lot more now. And he had very sincere movies
- 5:10that are in the same vein as The Holdovers.
- 5:12So this movie is set in the 1970s.
- 5:14They do a lot of kind of gimmicky things with the credits
- 5:16and stuff to make it mimic 1970s films.
- 5:21But more than that, it's just you don't get movies like this
- 5:24anymore where none of it feels new.
- 5:27All of it feels like pieces of other movies that you've seen.
- 5:31But it's the the alchemy, it's the recipe of adding all these
- 5:35ingredients together that add up to something that at once feels
- 5:39brand new and like it's been a part of your life for years and
- 5:43years already. Yeah, that.
- 5:45That's the magic of this movie. Like, I never found myself
- 5:50completely thrown by anything in the film, and yet I was able to
- 5:55move emotionally to the places that Paine wanted to take me.
- 6:00That felt so impactful and meaningful.
- 6:05And yeah, I I just think he knocked out of the park.
- 6:09I, I can't wait to like, really get into it, Bob.
- 6:11All right. Well, in order to get into it, I
- 6:13think it's time to throw to our first segment of the day, which
- 6:15we call, Brad explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 6:18movie plots with only 60 seconds taken on the clock, so let's go
- 6:22ahead and do your take with this little segment that we call,
- 6:26Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 6:28show where Brad breaks down the plot of the film that he has
- 6:32just seen, often for the first time.
- 6:34I'm assuming this is watch #2 for you, Brad.
- 6:38It is, yes. All right, well, you're it's old
- 6:41hat to you at this point, I think is what we're.
- 6:42Saying, I mean, for the amount of time it's been out to the
- 6:46amount of times I've seen it that like that, whatever that
- 6:49ratio is, it might be one of my higher ratios for a film.
- 6:53That's true. All right, so the way Brad
- 6:55explains works is you get 60 seconds on the clock to break
- 6:58down the plot of the film in full spoiler territory.
- 7:01So we know this movie is only a year old.
- 7:02If you have not yet seen The Holdovers, you got to press
- 7:05pause. Now you have to go watch this
- 7:07movie. If you can't tell from the
- 7:09effusive praise we've given it, it's going to be very highly
- 7:12scored by us and I would hate to ruin the movie for you right
- 7:15now. Go watch The Holdovers.
- 7:17Come back and listen to Brad explain the plot of it.
- 7:19You have one minute on the clock and go.
- 7:22The Holdovers is a film about a group of students who are left
- 7:28at their all boys preparatory school, high school, and they
- 7:34are being left with a curmudgeonly old history teacher
- 7:38named Mr. Hunsley Hunson Hunnam. Hunnam.
- 7:44Mr. Hunnam, played by Paul Giamatti.
- 7:47Within a week or so of them being there, most of the
- 7:50children go away with one of the kids dads on vacation and the
- 7:54rest of the film you follow Giamatti and the student that is
- 7:58left, Angus Tully and one of the staff members who stays behind
- 8:04to cook everybody meals. And I can't think of her name
- 8:08right now. Mary.
- 8:09Yep, Yep, Mary. So the three of them hang out
- 8:13together, learn about each other's lives, and descend into
- 8:17each other's madness, and yet come out all the more sane.
- 8:22Yeah, that's a good description of the movie, and I think it
- 8:25does enough of teasing what's to come in the movie without giving
- 8:29it away, because in a lot of ways this feels like a classic
- 8:33hangout movie, you know what I mean?
- 8:35Like there's definitely character progressions and arcs,
- 8:39but one of the things that I really loved watching it this
- 8:41time through, and if I can just give 30 seconds of background,
- 8:44I've been trying to also get my wife to watch this movie for a
- 8:47solid year. And we sat down to watch it one
- 8:50night last year and it was really late and we hit almost
- 8:53the midway point of the movie. It's when right after Angus has
- 8:57dislocated his shoulder and they go to the bar as kind of a
- 8:59reward for Angus lying and keeping Hunnam's job.
- 9:03My wife looked at me and she's never done this before.
- 9:05She's like, I'm kind of bored. I was like, no, this movie is so
- 9:10good. And and.
- 9:12All of the good stuff is still to come, please.
- 9:15But we turned it off 'cause I, you know, at that point it was a
- 9:17lost cause. Flash forward to last week.
- 9:22They're doing a free screening of this movie at my former
- 9:25employer, Case Western Reserve University.
- 9:28They have a film society on campus.
- 9:29They showed this movie on a massive screen.
- 9:32And so we went up there as part of a date night.
- 9:34And I was like, you got to commit to doing this with me.
- 9:36She's like, of course, we walked out of the movie.
- 9:39And she was like, OK, I get, I get it now.
- 9:40That was a really, really good movie.
- 9:42But on the way back to the car, I asked her, you know, what was
- 9:46it about the first half of the movie that didn't click as
- 9:48opposed to the second-half? And she just kept saying like,
- 9:52it's such an interesting movie. And she said, I don't want to
- 9:55call it disjointed, but and then she kind of trailed off and I
- 9:59understood where she was going because we've referenced this
- 10:03thing by the creators of South Park a number of times.
- 10:06This video where Trey Parker is explaining how you can't just
- 10:10have a plot where it's this happens and then this happens
- 10:13and then this happens. There has to be some causality.
- 10:16This happens. So this happens, but this
- 10:19happens. So this happens and this movie
- 10:22kind of breaks that convention. Like they're they're kind of
- 10:26moving forward as a logical progression of things that
- 10:29happened before. But I do feel like you could
- 10:31take a number of scenes in this movie and reshuffle them and the
- 10:34characters still end up in the same place at the end of the
- 10:37movie. This is more a movie about kind
- 10:40of a totality or a volume of things that happened to the
- 10:43characters in the 1st 3/4 of it to get you on their side
- 10:48sympathetically so that the whole last quarter of the movie
- 10:51can be emotional payoff. And it really works.
- 10:53And I'm, I guess I wasn't expecting a movie that felt so
- 10:57familiar to be such a convention breaking movie, but that's how
- 11:01it feels. That's interesting, Bob.
- 11:04I I don't know if I would say it feels quite that convention
- 11:08breaking. Like I, I think within scenes
- 11:12or, you know, within a small collection of scenes, you have
- 11:16the this happens so that this can happen.
- 11:19I guess I would say it feels to me like this movie kind of has
- 11:23distinct thirds. Yes, like the first third of the
- 11:26movie is them, you know, getting to know Hun Hunnam, Paul
- 11:31Giamatti Hunnam. I just keep on to say in Hunley,
- 11:36getting to know Paul Giamatti's character, getting to know
- 11:41Dominique Sera, Is that Sessa? Bro you are like 8.
- 11:45For eight on not knowing names today.
- 11:47I'm nailing it, dude. Absolutely incredible.
- 11:50It's what everybody signs up for Bob, getting to know the
- 11:54characters and seeing how they interact with other people,
- 11:58which I think is really valuable.
- 12:00Like if this entire film was just the three characters, I
- 12:03think it would suffer. So you get to see them bounce
- 12:06off of other people, which helps you then feel the claustrophobia
- 12:10of the second act when it's just the three of them and
- 12:14occasionally the janitor. And then I, I don't know.
- 12:17Would you say that the third act starts after they leave the
- 12:21Christmas? Party.
- 12:22Yeah, I was. I was thinking and I have it in
- 12:23my notes here. First act is all of the kids and
- 12:27Giamatti. Second act is these three people
- 12:30are trapped together ending in Christmas and him saying like, I
- 12:34want to go to Boston. And then the third act is
- 12:36everything that happens after they leave the campus.
- 12:38And what's what's really great about this movie, Brad, And it
- 12:41is a long movie. It's like 2 hours and 15
- 12:43minutes. And I will say for a movie that
- 12:46I'm going to give perhaps my highest possible score to, it
- 12:50does feel shaggy at parts like it, but it's shaggy in a way
- 12:53that I keep going back to this phrase hangout movie.
- 12:56It doesn't really feel boring. It just sometimes feels like
- 12:59this is how life works and you just kind of watch pauses and
- 13:02sometimes days are boring. And they do a good job of
- 13:04reflecting how boring it can be in the middle of nowhere in the
- 13:08winter time. But if the movie had ended at
- 13:12the end of Christmas, where you've these three people have
- 13:17forged a truce together, you've watched them go through
- 13:19emotional ups and downs, you have that great scene at the
- 13:21Christmas party and then kind of just fast forwarded to everybody
- 13:26comes back from winter break. It would have been a passable
- 13:29movie. Like it tells a complete arc.
- 13:32And yet Pain and the screenwriter do such a good job
- 13:36in that third act of continuing to give you character reveals to
- 13:41deepen the relationships. You watch each character bounce
- 13:44off each other in ways that are unique to them.
- 13:47I just what I love about the movie is you could end it in
- 13:50five different spots and it's a super satisfying movie.
- 13:53And ending it where they did somehow maximized the
- 13:57effectiveness. And if we had not ended it where
- 14:01we did, we would have never gotten one of the greatest
- 14:04insults in film history. When Paul Giamatti looks at the
- 14:09principal of the school and says, I've known you since you
- 14:13were a child, so I feel like I'm an expert and can say that you
- 14:17are absolute penis cancer in human form.
- 14:22What a great insult. Man.
- 14:25All right, let's dive into not the plot of the movie.
- 14:28Let's start with performances, because to this day, Paul
- 14:33Giamatti should have won Best Actor over Killian Murphy in in.
- 14:38Oh, that is strong, Bob. Killian's great dude, but, and
- 14:43perhaps it's just because this movie is a much bigger warm hug
- 14:47and because he gets his oscari moments more than Killian does.
- 14:50When he walks out of that office and starts choking up and points
- 14:54to his his lazy eye and says like this is the one.
- 14:58And then he has the moment at the very end of the movie where
- 15:01he just says see ya. And that's that's it.
- 15:05Tear 100% tears in both of those moments.
- 15:08It's so good dude. Also, his eyes, if we didn't
- 15:11mention this before, he is walleyed and it kind of feels
- 15:15like the hunchback in Young Frankenstein.
- 15:18We're like, it's like, it's like his right eye is the walleyed
- 15:21eye for a little while and then his left one and you're never
- 15:24quite sure which one is walleyed.
- 15:27It's perfect. I also think my favorite Oscar
- 15:31moment for Giamatti in this film isn't when he makes you cry at
- 15:35the end of the movie. I don't know if I've ever seen
- 15:38somebody capture the human desire to do random things and
- 15:45random moments for no real reason.
- 15:47Better than when he's walking past the football.
- 15:53It might be my favorite scene of the movie, Bob, because he's
- 15:55just walking along in the snow, there's nobody on the campus.
- 15:59He sees a football laying there and throws it with the absolute
- 16:04worst throw I've ever seen in my life.
- 16:06And then and then it just cuts to the next scene.
- 16:09Like, and then he walks away kind of self satisfied too.
- 16:12Yeah. Like I did it, like I I did it.
- 16:16That ball went like 9 feet. Here's how I know this movie
- 16:21works. So I will admit on my wife's
- 16:25behalf, that first hour, there are moments where you're still
- 16:28trying to get into the rhythm of the movie and it really does
- 16:31replicate older Hal Ashby style 70s movies.
- 16:35And you got to get on its wavelength or you're going to
- 16:38think it's boring. And the really good meat of the
- 16:41movie doesn't come until after that scene in the bar.
- 16:44So that was literally the worst place for us to stop watching
- 16:46it. We were watching last year.
- 16:48But here's how I know that everyone was bought in.
- 16:51I'm in this theater full of people, and it gets to the scene
- 16:55where they're at the holiday party.
- 16:57So the three of them have been holed up in this boarding
- 17:01school. And the, I believe the secretary
- 17:03for the headmaster is having a party, a holiday party at her
- 17:07house full of townies. And they had run into her at the
- 17:10bar. And then she invites Giamatti
- 17:12and the boy and Mary. And at this holiday party, it is
- 17:15like an extended, probably 15 minute sequence where
- 17:18everybody's character arcs to that point come to a head.
- 17:22Giamatti is finally hoping to break out of his shell because
- 17:26he is, you know, a lonely man. He has his condition that makes
- 17:30him smell really bad. He's socially inept and he's
- 17:33taking a big swing and he's taking a risk because he has a
- 17:35crush on this lady, Dominic Sessa.
- 17:38We don't know what's going on with his character aside from
- 17:41he's just been left at school. He said that made it sound like
- 17:44Dominic Sessa was the Lady. He had a crush on.
- 17:48He's chasing after her. Super problematic movie.
- 17:54Dominic says his character Angus.
- 17:55We don't really know what's going on with him other than
- 17:57that his parents kind of suck and have left him at school.
- 17:59But he's lonely and he finds a girl that he starts flirting
- 18:03with in the basement of this house.
- 18:05Mary, her son has been killed in Vietnam.
- 18:08She's living at this boarding school watching all these rich
- 18:11ash asshole ish kids have the life that her son deserved.
- 18:16And all these things come to a head.
- 18:18And the moment where it really, really clicks is when that woman
- 18:23comes over and starts talking to Paul Giamatti, reaches over,
- 18:26touches his leg, tells him, like, these kids need you now
- 18:29more than ever. And it really hits him.
- 18:32And he's like, oh, my gosh. And then she looks up off screen
- 18:35and says, oh, excuse me a second.
- 18:37And the camera cuts over to Giamatti as you watch her walk
- 18:40behind him and kind of in, you know, out of focus.
- 18:43And you don't see the top of her head or anything.
- 18:45And he's sitting there, like, really happy.
- 18:49And then he kind of turns around to see who she's greeting at the
- 18:51door, and it pans up and she's kissing a guy.
- 18:54That's her bow. The look on Paul Giamatti's face
- 18:59is bro, it's. That's the Oscar right there,
- 19:02dude. That's the Oscar right there.
- 19:04It is such an incredible scene. Like, we have been watching Paul
- 19:09freaking Giamatti for decades now.
- 19:12Be one of the best supporting actors ever to do it.
- 19:17Like, I mean, he's got to be on the Mount Rushmore of best
- 19:20supporting actors. And here he is with his chance.
- 19:24He's taken everything he's ever learned about acting and he
- 19:27throws it into that moment. And it is perfect.
- 19:31It it is the most crushing thing.
- 19:33And here's why I said this is how I know the movies working in
- 19:37the theater. You heard voices, male and
- 19:40female. At 1 moment, I'll just go, oh,
- 19:47like our sympathies are totally with this guy at this point.
- 19:50And then you get the even more crushing moment that follows it
- 19:52of Mary breaking down in the kitchen after she's gotten drunk
- 19:56and she's listening to music that she loved with her son.
- 19:59And just like, the anger of her just admitting like, he's gone.
- 20:03He's gone. It is such a necessary moment
- 20:07because from that point on, you're like, I don't know where
- 20:10this movie is going to go. Like, this needed to happen to
- 20:12give the movie direction, but what's going to happen to these
- 20:16characters now? And I'm fully bought in to all
- 20:19of them now in a way I wasn't 10 minutes ago.
- 20:22And that's the beauty of a good script Like this film gives you
- 20:28all of these terrible human beings that kind of suck.
- 20:32Like, like they're all lovable in their own way, but they're
- 20:35not especially great. And you have just enough moments
- 20:39of kindness and seeing that they care.
- 20:42Like, you get it with Angus when one of the young students has
- 20:47wet his bed because he was crying at night and and misses
- 20:51his family deeply. And you know, Angus offers, says
- 20:55hey, like, like find a dry spot to sleep.
- 20:56I'll help you clean up in the morning, but don't tell anyone
- 20:59else otherwise they'll never not give you hell.
- 21:02And the way he says it is in that way of because they gave me
- 21:06hell right And all like despite all of the, and I think the best
- 21:12word is prickliness of these characters, you can't help but
- 21:16fall in love with them. And so that when you get those
- 21:20emotional payouts of them breaking down and being honest
- 21:23about their failures and fears and sadness, it, it's the most
- 21:28honest movie I've seen in a long time.
- 21:32I think one of the most direct comparisons you can make between
- 21:35this movie and another is Dead Poet Society.
- 21:37It got a lot of that, and if you read up a little bit like I
- 21:41again, I skimmed to the Wikipedia for this movie, but it
- 21:43says that the screenwriter said it purposely in 1970 instead of
- 21:48in the 1950s or 60s because he didn't want it to be
- 21:51chronologically too close to Dead Poets Society.
- 21:54First of all, this is a better movie than Dead Poets Society,
- 21:57and I don't I don't mind saying that.
- 22:00Every time I tell people about it, they're like, oh, what's
- 22:02that about? And I'm like, it's a dead.
- 22:03It's a better Dead Poets Society.
- 22:06I think that the connective tissue though, is that I could
- 22:11see Robin Williams playing this role.
- 22:14I actually don't think it would be as good with a Robin Williams
- 22:17type. You know, Robin Williams has
- 22:19this sort of nakedness to his emotions where you can see into
- 22:24the vulnerability. And I think the closest thing we
- 22:28have to that today is maybe like Steve Carell can do that really
- 22:30well in some of his films. I don't think either one of
- 22:33those characters does a better job than what Giamatti goes for
- 22:36here. It is really the perfect balance
- 22:38of even after you're on his side, he never sheds the like,
- 22:44Checadillos or the little idiosyncrasies of that
- 22:47character. He still is who he is, but it's
- 22:49you as an audience member who's changed in how you receive those
- 22:53things or perceive those things. And that's where I think like,
- 22:57Williams probably would have gone a little bit too schmaltzy
- 23:00with this role. And I love Robin Williams, but I
- 23:02think Giamatti's doing something here that's a little bit more
- 23:05nuanced. Yeah, the the beauty of his
- 23:07performance is that he does stay the same.
- 23:12And yet those slight bits of warmth stick around and and and
- 23:17you recognize that this feels way more true to how human
- 23:22beings really are. And like, as as somebody who has
- 23:25worked as a chaplain and interacted with lots of human
- 23:28beings in their homes, in the hospital, this just felt way
- 23:34more real to who we are as a human race that we don't just
- 23:38live for, you know, 60 odd years as Giamatti's character does in
- 23:43this movie. And just suddenly, it's like 01
- 23:46Christmas break. All of a sudden we're all happy,
- 23:48go lucky and good. Like this isn't The Breakfast
- 23:51Club. We're we're not all like perfect
- 23:53friends at the end of it. And yet it's that moment when
- 23:57he's teaching his class at the start of the new semester, and
- 24:00he looks at Angus and just gives him a tiny smile, like he's
- 24:04exact, the exact same teacher that he's always been.
- 24:07But there's a warmth there now. There's a relationship that you
- 24:11can tell makes him feel like life might, just maybe, be worth
- 24:16living. Let's talk a little bit about
- 24:19Dominic Sessa. This is his first movie.
- 24:22This is like a true, honest to goodness introducing Dominic
- 24:25Sessa. They had an open casting call
- 24:28at, I believe the boarding school that they shot at, and
- 24:30Sessa showed up and they're like, that's our guy now.
- 24:33He he is a little bit older. I think he's 20 when this movie
- 24:36comes out. But they work it into the script
- 24:38a little bit where he says something like, I've been kicked
- 24:40out of three schools. That's why I'm still a junior,
- 24:42give or take a semester. So you can tell that he's an
- 24:45older character that's being forced into being a junior.
- 24:48And I think just that one little addition, if it even was an
- 24:51addition, perfectly explains why this guy looks like he's 20 and
- 24:55not 15. I think he pulls off like 1718
- 24:59year old kid. I think so too.
- 25:01I think so, too. Yeah.
- 25:02He's really, really good, man. And I think part of what makes
- 25:05his performance so good. There's a shot near the end of
- 25:08the movie, and again, we're in full spoiler territory.
- 25:12He goes to Boston because he secretly wants to see his dad,
- 25:16and he doesn't tell Giamatti. And so he tries to sneak away to
- 25:19go see his dad. Giamatti finds out and tags
- 25:22along. And the whole movie, he's been
- 25:24telling people my dad is dead. And it turns out his dad has
- 25:26actually been committed. He's in a sanitarium and he we
- 25:30have a moment where he actually goes and sees his dad on
- 25:33Christmas. And he does this thing where
- 25:35like he turns into a little boy in front of his dad.
- 25:38And he's talking about how good he's doing in school and what
- 25:40sports he's playing and how, how, how much fun he's having.
- 25:43And his dad reaches over and grabs his hands and you think
- 25:46you're going to get this great moment.
- 25:47And it's another rug pull where you can tell the dad is like
- 25:51truly lost his mind because he says something like, I think
- 25:53they're putting something in my food.
- 25:55And that's it. That's all you get.
- 25:56And then you get the reaction shot of Cessa immediate cut to
- 26:01they're all at dinner together afterwards and Cessa's talking
- 26:05about how his dad got committed. And it is done in one unbroken
- 26:10shot that just kind of pulls back slowly for about two
- 26:13minutes. The first couple times I saw
- 26:16this movie, I was like, man, I wish Alexander Payne hadn't done
- 26:19that because it takes a lot of command on screen to be able to
- 26:24hold a shot for two minutes. And I could tell at times that
- 26:27Cessa was a little bit raw and a little bit new to this.
- 26:30You're watching his Adam's apple bounce up and down when he's
- 26:32trying to play suppressing emotion.
- 26:37But I actually think the rawness of his acting chops is what
- 26:40makes this character so good. And it keeps everybody else's
- 26:44performance kind of grounded, too.
- 26:45Nobody feels like they're in a different movie here.
- 26:48And I think kind of quietly, Cessa bringing this untrained
- 26:53energy to the movie helps everybody else around him.
- 26:57I think one of the other things that really helped that scene is
- 27:01the sound design. Like if you want a master class
- 27:05in how you can help a scene feel like you're underwater a little
- 27:10bit and like this is a highly emotional moment, just watch the
- 27:15scene Bob just referenced when he's giving his little monologue
- 27:18about how his dad got committed. Because they they build it so
- 27:22that the camera is shoved up into his face.
- 27:25You can see like vaguely in the background that he's at a
- 27:28restaurant, but there's no noise other than his voice.
- 27:32And then they slowly fade in the crowd noise of the restaurant as
- 27:38the camera pulls away and you realize Giamatti is sitting
- 27:41there. And it like it is such a well
- 27:45imagined scene to help focus the attention on what needs to be
- 27:50happening, which is the emotional performance of Cessa.
- 27:55Now, I I think that Dominic Cessa as an actor, the two
- 28:00things he does well in this movie are sullen and sad.
- 28:05Like he nails those like when he's, I don't remember when it
- 28:09is at some point he is sitting in the back seat of a car, like
- 28:13looking angrily out the window and he just looks like a sullen
- 28:17teenager. And it's absolutely perfect.
- 28:21And the moments where he portrays sadness, he's
- 28:23incredible as well. I, I think my, MY1 struggle with
- 28:26the acting throughout this movie and the first time I saw it, I
- 28:31pinned it all on Cessa. And actually this time through I
- 28:34noticed it with all of the actor.
- 28:36Well, the main 3 actors, Giamatti, we haven't talked
- 28:39about it yet, Divine Joy, Randolph and Dominic Cessa.
- 28:43I think all three of them do this.
- 28:45They all kind of have run on sentences at some points.
- 28:49Like, they all have moments where it's like, man, they, they
- 28:53needed a little pause in the way they were speaking.
- 28:57They, they needed to not just get this whole line out as fast
- 29:01as possible. I think that Cessa does it and I
- 29:04don't mind it as much because he is such a raw actor.
- 29:07It's the one or two times that Giamatti and Randolph do it that
- 29:11it frustrates me because I'm like, like, like all you needed
- 29:17was a tiny little pause and this would have been perfect.
- 29:21We we are about to review Dune 2 next week, but we had to get our
- 29:26scheduling out of order, so I'll reference Dune 2 here.
- 29:30You'll you might hear me talk about it next week as well. 2-2
- 29:33weeks but like next week is cruise miss man.
- 29:35Oh, next week is cruise miss two weeks from now.
- 29:37Man, we're like really getting ahead on our.
- 29:39Recordings, Bob. First it's cruise miss and then
- 29:41it's happy Doon year. Happy Doon year dude.
- 29:45I like that Christopher Walken, famous actor, great actor, has
- 29:52the exact same problem. He has like a few like run on
- 29:55sentences where he just keeps talking and should have just had
- 29:59a nice little pause. Interesting.
- 30:01I wonder if that's more of an issue with the performances or
- 30:03with the take that was chosen by the director.
- 30:06You know what I mean? Yeah.
- 30:07And that's and that's why this time through I think I'm
- 30:11penalizing Cecil Les because I noticed it in other characters,
- 30:15which makes me think it's more of a director thing than a
- 30:19individual actor. For sure, and I'm kind of with
- 30:22you too, on he does sullen and sad really well.
- 30:24The moments of his performance that don't work for me are the
- 30:27moments in the movie that don't work as well for me.
- 30:29And it's when they're going for intentionally really broad
- 30:32comedy. Like the scene where he's making
- 30:34Giamatti chase him through the halls and just haunting him like
- 30:37a Looney Tunes character. It's funny and even like the cut
- 30:41to Giamatti's reaction after he falls and starts screaming.
- 30:45Like it's a great little moment. But it's not even that it feels
- 30:48out of place in this movie. It just feels a little too broad
- 30:51at times. And I think what Sessa's really
- 30:54good at is playing childlike at moments, and he's not as good at
- 31:00playing childish. Like when he's being
- 31:02antagonistic to Giamatti, it's a little much.
- 31:05He's a little too snarky, but there's a great moment late in
- 31:09the movie when they go into Boston and he is like ice
- 31:11skating and Giamatti is just watching him skate and he he
- 31:15just waves at him like a kid waving to his dad.
- 31:18And it's really clear at that moment.
- 31:20Like this is his surrogate father in this moment.
- 31:22And Cessa absolutely nails the really hard to do child likeness
- 31:28of a kid who is still not grown up and really needs a parental
- 31:32figure. And I think that it it's
- 31:34actually harder to pull that off.
- 31:36But the childish moments are the ones that I didn't think were as
- 31:40good. And I think that's why this
- 31:42movie is successful. Like the the need of Cessa to
- 31:48have a dad who cares about him when he's being a little shit
- 31:53like that. Like, those are the moments that
- 31:56make this movie so beautiful. Because I think what this movie
- 32:00captures on the whole is the desperate need for every single
- 32:06teenager to have an adult who's willing to have honest
- 32:09conversations with them. You know what, when they're in
- 32:12the when they're in the liquor store after they run into his
- 32:16old Harvard acquaintance and, you know, Giamatti lies to him
- 32:20about what he's doing. And, and Angus is calling him
- 32:23out on it. Like that conversation, the
- 32:27rawness of saying, like, yeah, this is what happened in my
- 32:30life, and this has been the result of it.
- 32:32Like, those are the things that teenagers desperately need in
- 32:36life. And this movie highlights the
- 32:39beauty of what can happen when those conversations take place.
- 32:43Well, and I think that's a great segue to quickly talk about
- 32:45Divine Joy Randolph. In this movie, she wins the
- 32:47Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress.
- 32:49I think it's really well deserved.
- 32:51She does. She is the epitome of a
- 32:52supporting character in this movie and I think that's what
- 32:55makes the character great. If she was in the movie more
- 32:58honestly it would become her movie because she has the most
- 33:01kind of immediately compelling character arc.
- 33:05Or not even character arc but character story.
- 33:07Like you know 5 minutes into the movie what her character is all
- 33:11about where the other two it takes some slow reveals to show
- 33:15what their characters are. So I think they use her
- 33:18perfectly in the film. And to your point about Dominic
- 33:22Sassa's character needing that parental figure, that's why her
- 33:26character playing in that that interplay between her character
- 33:29and the other two is so well done.
- 33:31It's not just that she's a third wheel thrown into this dynamic,
- 33:35it's that she's the only one that actually understands how to
- 33:39care for and talk to a young man.
- 33:41And she has no outlet for that because her son has been taken
- 33:44from her. And and so much of the movie,
- 33:47you can tell that it's her grief that's keeping her at distance
- 33:52from Tully. But after the Christmas party,
- 33:55she kind of starts to really let him in.
- 33:58And it's the moment where Tully is sitting outside the
- 34:01headmaster's office while Giamatti is covering for him and
- 34:05getting fired because of it, that she sits down and takes his
- 34:11hand. And it's just the way she puts
- 34:13her hand out and totally looks at it.
- 34:16And it's a great moment from Dominic Sessa, too, where he
- 34:18kind of looks at it and is like, oh, I guess I take her hand now.
- 34:22Like, like, I have to. And as he takes it, there's that
- 34:26like, relief in his body. Like, an adult cares about me.
- 34:30And they're not going to make me talk about anything.
- 34:32They're not going to force me into something I don't want to
- 34:34do. They just want to love me.
- 34:39Yeah, man, it's, it's just a great performance.
- 34:41I'm thinking about the moment when they're leaving the
- 34:43Christmas party after she's even had her meltdown and Giamatti
- 34:46kind of snaps at Dominic Sessa and says like, nobody wants you
- 34:50around anyway, you know? And he walks away and she's
- 34:54like, what the hell is wrong with you, man?
- 34:56Like, you don't tell a kid who's been abandoned on Christmas that
- 35:00nobody wants him around. And it's just those little
- 35:02moments where she's the voice of reason for Giamatti that
- 35:05ultimately strengthen that core relationship.
- 35:08I Brad. It's a perfectly structured
- 35:11script. They're perfectly written
- 35:12characters. Let's hope that our whiskey for
- 35:15the Day holds up to the effusive praise we've been giving this
- 35:18movie. Let's go check out some
- 35:20snowflakes. All right, everybody, today we
- 35:29are checking out Stranahan's Snowflake.
- 35:32Now, this is a whiskey that comes out of the Stranahan
- 35:36distillery in Colorado. They have released 26 iterations
- 35:42of this whiskey. They used to do it twice a year,
- 35:45once on Father's Day, once for, you know, the Christmas season.
- 35:49It got to be too big of a production schedule, so they've
- 35:52chopped it down to just once a year at Christmas time.
- 35:55And you know, the way they talk about it is this.
- 35:59There's a specific blend that they build every single year
- 36:03that's different and varied and nuanced, and it makes it a
- 36:06snowflake. I like it.
- 36:10And they name it after every iteration.
- 36:13They name it after one of the 14,000 foot mountains peaks in
- 36:18Colorado. Oh, I like that.
- 36:20What's this one named after? I don't remember Boo.
- 36:24All right. Hey, I remembered all of that
- 36:26other. Stuff that was pretty good, man,
- 36:28that was pretty. Good Yukon, Yukon gold, maybe
- 36:31all. Right.
- 36:31We'll go with that. So we are drinking the 2023
- 36:34release now. 2024 has just been released.
- 36:37We haven't got our hands on that one yet.
- 36:38We had 2023 waiting for review. So we're going to go ahead and
- 36:41give a review of last year's version because I think that it
- 36:45will give you a good indication of what we think of the label
- 36:48overall. Again, because these are
- 36:51precious and delicate snowflakes, they are very unique
- 36:54from year to year. So this is.
- 36:55One go ahead. And this one is called Pyramids
- 36:58Peak. There it is, not Yukon Gold.
- 37:01Close though I must. Have been thinking about the
- 37:03potatoes. So this 2023 release is an 8
- 37:09year old single malt and it has been finished in all of the
- 37:12following kinds of casks, Carca, Velos, Soterne, Brandy, peated
- 37:18Scotch, rum, and Applejack. So we have a crazy blend of
- 37:24different finished single malts here.
- 37:26Brad, I am super excited to try this.
- 37:27I've never had this label before.
- 37:29I'm pouring it out right now. Why don't you give us your
- 37:31nosing notes? This is a really fascinating
- 37:35nose Bob. There are baking spices, there's
- 37:39really strong cherry notes, it's floral, there's dusty leather
- 37:44and it has a little bit of a note I don't normally like, but
- 37:47I don't mind it here. It has some anise, really strong
- 37:51here on the nose. I'm going to give it an 8 out of
- 37:5410. I like this a lot, man.
- 37:56The very first note that hit me even before the malt was like a
- 38:01hard cider, like it's really bright, kind of tart apple.
- 38:04And then I get a little bit of the underlying malt and then I
- 38:07start getting pretty much in order.
- 38:09What you mentioned, Brad, the leather note is really, really
- 38:11strong on this. There is a bit of cherry.
- 38:13I think that apple note overrides the rest of the fruit
- 38:16notes a little bit. Yeah, I get a little bit of
- 38:19anise on this, but I think for me it's more just malt with
- 38:23leather, and that's kind of replicating that licorice smell.
- 38:26I think I'd like this a little bit better than you.
- 38:28I'm going to give it an 8 1/2 on the nose.
- 38:31Yeah, and the palate is it dives into cinnamon.
- 38:36There is cinnamon. It's leathery.
- 38:38It turns into like a dried cherry.
- 38:40I got like a little bit of like a pumpernickel bread kind of
- 38:43vibe off of it. Really, really tasty palette.
- 38:48I, I am so impressed with what Stranahan's has done here.
- 38:51I'm going to come up a little bit.
- 38:53I'm at an 8 1/2 out of 10 on the palette.
- 38:56This does have that note that I only ever describe on Kraft
- 39:01American Whiskey on the back where it's like that really
- 39:06strong, woody, vegetal note. And again, it's just a me thing,
- 39:12right? But this has the craft whiskey
- 39:14taste to it on the back. So I'm going to factor that into
- 39:17my palate score here because I don't like that note.
- 39:21But apart from that, it's really well done, man.
- 39:24There's tons of leather. You're right that cinnamon is
- 39:26predominant here. I do get a little bit of clove
- 39:29on this as well. It's less sweet than I would
- 39:32like it to be, but I think I was a little bit teased by the
- 39:35finishes on the nose and kind of forgot like do this as a single
- 39:38malt. Like, it's not going to be
- 39:39syrupy sweet. So what I'm essentially
- 39:43confessing to here, Brad, is my expectations for this.
- 39:46We're not what it is. And I don't think it's the fault
- 39:49of the whiskey so much as it's the fault of me.
- 39:52I'm going to come down to it. Usually is your fault.
- 39:54Bob, this is true. I've been told this by many
- 39:56people. So I'm going to come down to
- 39:59just a 7 1/2 on the pallet. But as I sip a couple more times
- 40:03I it might rebound a little bit in the later categories.
- 40:07I think that the finish is beautiful and nice and like,
- 40:12there's nothing specific about it that makes it incredible.
- 40:15It is okie. There's cherries, the cinnamon
- 40:18sticks around, there's some black pepper for being finished
- 40:23partially in a peated Scotch. I was hoping to eventually get a
- 40:26little bit of that smokiness. I don't think I did.
- 40:29I'll give it an 8 out of 10 here though.
- 40:31I like There is a lot to like here on the finish.
- 40:36I do wish that this tasted a little bit more well, aged 8
- 40:39years. I mean, eight years is a long
- 40:42time, but you know, we've had scotches from from Scotland
- 40:45obviously that are like 20-30 years old now.
- 40:49And there's just such a maturity when you let it go a little bit
- 40:53longer. This still tastes just a tad
- 40:55young to me and it because it has that craft American finish
- 40:58on it. However, second sip of this
- 41:02cinnamon bomb and kind of like standard child's apple juice,
- 41:08there's a lot of that on here. It is a little bit sweeter than
- 41:10I gave it credit for last time, and that apple juice flavor
- 41:13really carried over into the finish, which bumped that score
- 41:16up for me. I'm going to be at an 8 out of
- 41:1810 on the finish. I think balance wise we're at an
- 41:218 1/2 here like that. There is a little bit of
- 41:24complexity that helps it bump the score up and everything
- 41:28works together, like the nose leads you into the palate.
- 41:33There's a little bit of a surprise with how prominent the
- 41:36cinnamon is, but not in a way that takes away it's, it's more
- 41:41of just like a wow, I, I knew there's some baking spices, but
- 41:44boy, that's some cinnamon. Incredible balance on this
- 41:48whiskey, Bob. I'm going to give it an 8 out of
- 41:5010. Again, I think that this is a
- 41:52whiskey that I respect more than I actually enjoy, but they've
- 41:55done so much here with the finishing and especially like an
- 41:598 year single malt. There were not a lot of places
- 42:03doing American single malt 8 years ago.
- 42:04So I can complain about how it's not old enough, but like there
- 42:08really isn't a lot of, you know, double digit aged American
- 42:11single malt laying around out there.
- 42:13So I'm going to give it an 8 out of 10 on balance, on value.
- 42:17This is where I'm really curious, Brad, because I'm
- 42:19seeing it priced all over the place.
- 42:22I believe MSRP is around $120 on this.
- 42:26What are you seeing? Yes, OK.
- 42:27Yeah, they sell it at the distillery for $120.00.
- 42:31There are only 2000 bottles of this release.
- 42:35So it's, it's not like a tiny, you know, 200 bottle release,
- 42:39but also like it's a snowflake. There's 2000 bottles and then
- 42:43it's never around again so. I think I'm going to give it a 7
- 42:48out of 10 on value. I personally do not like this
- 42:52enough to spend $120 on it. However, if we're following the
- 42:56like $10 per year rule, that would put you at like 80 and
- 43:00then all of the different things they're finishing this in.
- 43:03There's a ton of Labor and craft going into this whiskey.
- 43:07I don't think it is overpriced at 120.
- 43:10Given the amount of Labor that they're putting into it now, I
- 43:13don't personally think I would pay 120 for it.
- 43:15That doesn't mean it's unfairly priced, so I'll give it a 7.
- 43:19I'm at a 7 out of 10 too. Like I think this is really
- 43:22tasty. There's a lot going on.
- 43:25I, I, I think at 120 bucks, if this was like $90.00, it'd be
- 43:28like a nine and a half on value. I like, I, I think this is
- 43:32really great under triple digits.
- 43:35I think it's pretty solid at 120 Bob.
- 43:38I am coming out to a 40 out of 50.
- 43:42Yeah, I feel like my comments sounded more negative than
- 43:45yours, but I'm literally one point below you.
- 43:47I'm at a 39 out of 50, so we're coming out to an average of a
- 43:5039.5 or a 79 out of 100, which is actually a pretty high score
- 43:56here on film and whiskey. If you get over a 35 out of 50,
- 44:00we typically start recommending that you try or buy a bottle.
- 44:03If you reach 40 out of 50, it's kind of a no brainer
- 44:05recommendation. So I think this is a definite
- 44:08thumbs up for me as try it at the bar and if you like it, I
- 44:13certainly would never say that it's overpriced.
- 44:15So it's a good value as well. Yeah, I, I think it's worth
- 44:19getting a bottle if you can get one.
- 44:21I know that you have to be in Denver and around the time of
- 44:27their yearly release and you have to go to the distillery and
- 44:30it's a whole big party and an incredible event.
- 44:33Bob, it looks like they do all sorts of really fun events
- 44:36around Christmas time at the distillery.
- 44:39They have concerts and, you know, tastings and all sorts of
- 44:43things set up. So if you are ever in the Denver
- 44:46area around the holidays, I have to recommend go check out
- 44:51Stranahan's. All right, man.
- 44:54Pretty positive review for a movie that we also have a very
- 44:57positive review of. What do you say we get back into
- 44:59talking about the holdovers? Let's get to it.
- 45:07All right, everybody. That was Stranahan's Snowflake
- 45:102023 edition. A whiskey that is unique, it is
- 45:16individualized, and it is awesome.
- 45:18All of which could be said about our game. 2 facts and a
- 45:22falsehood, Brad. Is going to try to stump your
- 45:25ball to our right and what is wrong?
- 45:312 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of
- 45:34the show where Brad presents me with three items as fact about
- 45:38the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie, and I
- 45:42have to determine which one that is Brad.
- 45:44I'm currently sitting at 7:00 and 3:00 on the season with a
- 45:48chance to redeem myself here a little bit.
- 45:50I've let it, I've, I've just kind of let it slip a little bit
- 45:52lately and that's on me, man. Yeah, it it is on you, as are
- 45:57most things. That's the second time you've
- 45:59said that in like 5 minutes dude.
- 46:01What? What?
- 46:02What secrets are you hiding about me right now have?
- 46:04You ever heard of the Jihari window?
- 46:07Bob all. Right.
- 46:10Let's, let's pivot, Brad. Let's get into.
- 46:13Let's get into two facts and a falsehood.
- 46:16Fact #1 Many of the scenes were filmed at Fair Haven High School
- 46:19in Fair Haven, Massachusetts in February of 2022 during the
- 46:24school's February break. At this time, the area received
- 46:27a snowstorm, much to the delight of the film crew.
- 46:31Since many of the scenes took place during a snowstorm, they
- 46:34took full advantage of the weather and the snow you see in
- 46:36the film was from an actual live snowstorm.
- 46:40Fact #2 All the costumes for the film were carefully sourced from
- 46:44local thrift shops and vintage stores, ensuring the
- 46:47authenticity and period appropriate detail.
- 46:50One standout piece was a tie that Giamatti wore that was
- 46:53dated back to the 1940s, discovered in a small antique
- 46:57shop in the New England region. The costume department spent
- 47:00weeks meticulously curating the wardrobe to reflect the era's
- 47:03style. Fact #3 Paul Giamatti took
- 47:08credit for getting Dominic Sessa cast as Angus, advocating
- 47:12strongly for the newcomer. After director Alexander Payne
- 47:15expressed reluctance due to Sessa's lack of acting
- 47:18experience, Giamatti insisted he be given another audition, and
- 47:22his persistence paid off as Sessa's raw talent won over the
- 47:25entire production crew. These are very good.
- 47:30I have no idea man #1 sounds very plausible.
- 47:33Snowstorm snow is a huge factor in this film.
- 47:36I'm going to say that I'm pretty immediately drawn to three as a
- 47:40potential falsehood. Not because that may not have
- 47:44happened, but because you started it with the phrase.
- 47:46Paul Giamatti took credit for Dominic Sessa getting cast and
- 47:50Giamatti for being a a very seasoned actor.
- 47:52And I'm sure having a lot of power on set doesn't strike me
- 47:56as the kind of guy who would publicly take credit for
- 47:58something like that, even if he is responsible.
- 48:02So because I have no idea about the other two being potentially
- 48:07true or false, I'm just going to make this a very short 2 facts
- 48:10and a falsehood here. I'm going to say 3 is the
- 48:12falsehood, Brad. Bob, I I've not been able to say
- 48:16this many times this season, but you are 100% wrong.
- 48:22That is a. Fact.
- 48:24Wow. Wow, what a jerk.
- 48:26Paul Giamatti taking credit. I don't, I don't know if taking
- 48:31credit is actually a jerk move. I mean, you know, I did credit
- 48:35where credit's due. I did it all right.
- 48:39What was the falsehood, Brad? The falsehood was #2 ties and
- 48:45costumes. It was way too vague.
- 48:49I had about 5 minutes to write the falsehood, and yeah, it was
- 48:54very vague. You know, there's a tie.
- 48:58A tie from the 1940s. Who knows?
- 49:00I'm on A2 game losing streak man.
- 49:03Yeah, life. Life's tough.
- 49:04Life comes at you fast, Brad. I'm going to be honest too.
- 49:08Part of the reason that I only mentioned number one and #3 in
- 49:11my deliberation is that I completely forgot what number 2
- 49:14was. So not only did you succeed in
- 49:17tricking me, you made it such a boring falsehood that I didn't
- 49:21even consider it. Yeah, I that's the goal, man.
- 49:24All. All I want to do is win.
- 49:26Yeah, at any cost, even being boring.
- 49:30All right, man, boring. Let's continue talking about the
- 49:32holdovers here. Brett, is there anything you
- 49:35want to mention about the film? Because I have a couple
- 49:37directions, we might go with the last few minutes of our episode,
- 49:39but anything you want to get out there in the open about the
- 49:43movie that you don't want to get lost in the shuffle.
- 49:45I want more of the janitor. Like why don't we get more of
- 49:49the janitor? Because every single time he is
- 49:52on screen, he is charming and funny and down to earth and I
- 49:57want more of him in this movie. Good, good.
- 50:02Keep going. Give me more.
- 50:05That's it, that's all. I just want more of him.
- 50:08Yeah, I liked him a lot. He was really good.
- 50:10I, I wish that we got even like 1 little reaction shot of him
- 50:13being rejected by Divine Joy Randolph and just having like
- 50:18one more character that we feel sympathy for at Sad Christmas,
- 50:23You know what I mean? Like, just as a way of showing,
- 50:25like everybody's trying to get through, Everybody's worthy of
- 50:28sympathy. And I felt like they had an
- 50:30opportunity a couple times. Just give him one close up.
- 50:33Yeah, come on. Don't let him get away
- 50:36unscathed. You can't just be happy.
- 50:40Brad, I think that there are a ton of movies that you could
- 50:45kind of pair this up with for Let's Make it a Double.
- 50:48And this is not an official segue into Let's Make It a
- 50:50Double, but I'm curious if you saw some of the same influences
- 50:55I did. Alexander Payne obviously has
- 50:57his own kind of style at this point, but I thought that there
- 51:02was a touch more kind of like whimsy at the beginning of the
- 51:05film in those opening scenes, especially with the boys choir,
- 51:09like soundtracking a lot of it. And the particular style of
- 51:13cinematography where they were showing like the different
- 51:15houses on campus and they were always filmed straight on with
- 51:21no angle, Like there was no depth to them.
- 51:23It was almost like a 2D kind of thing.
- 51:25And there was a ton of, at least I thought Grand Budapest Hotel
- 51:29in the first few minutes of the movie there with that sort of
- 51:31like whimsical boys choir and almost kind of dollhouse look to
- 51:37some of the buildings. I'm wondering if you saw that or
- 51:40what other movies you saw that might have influenced this one.
- 51:45Oh man, I don't know if I want to be.
- 51:51I don't know if I want to pair this movie with this.
- 51:55What? What was Wes Anderson's first
- 51:58movie? Is it Rushmore?
- 52:00Yeah. It wasn't his first one, but
- 52:01that was the earliest one that we've done on the on the OK.
- 52:04I kind of got some weird Rushmore vibes from this, you
- 52:08know what I mean? Like, obviously it's a much
- 52:11warmer movie than Rushmore. Like Wes.
- 52:14Wes is Wes. Like, he he does what he's going
- 52:16to do. I think that the the boys choir
- 52:19at the start, the shots of the overall facility just kind of
- 52:25reminded me of that. But I'm not going to lie, man,
- 52:28it's hard to get away from the Dead Poets Society vibes.
- 52:31Yeah, for sure. Like a lot of this, the shots of
- 52:34them running around, like in uniform and exercising and I, I
- 52:39don't know, there's just a lot of Dead Poets Society in this
- 52:43movie. And I think that I say whimsy
- 52:46because the shots of like the boys running around and stuff,
- 52:50it could tip into like quirky and not Wes Anderson quirky.
- 52:53But like when they were trying to make all those quirky
- 52:55comedies in like the mid 2000s, like Juno.
- 52:58I think that if if they tipped a little farther, it would be more
- 53:01like Juno than like a Wes Anderson movie.
- 53:04And so I definitely see Rushmore.
- 53:05I definitely see some Royal Tenenbaums here.
- 53:08I see some Grand Budapest Hotel. But you're right, the kind of
- 53:12classic dead poet Society of it all is obviously an influence
- 53:16here. I think we should just go ahead
- 53:18and get into Let's Make It a Double Brad presented by
- 53:21Blackwood Distilling Company. We're near the end of the
- 53:24episode, so thanks listening to the film and Whiskey show.
- 53:28Let's have another film with this one, even if it's
- 53:30struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 53:32day. Now let's make it a double.
- 53:33Let's Make It a Double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 53:36movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 53:39feature. Brad, I'm just going to take any
- 53:43opportunity I can to plug the movie Nebraska again, but that's
- 53:48not going to be my Let's Make it a double.
- 53:49That would be too easy. I'm going to plug another movie
- 53:52that we're going to get to at some point on this podcast
- 53:54because it's a hangout Shaggy movie that I love about young
- 53:58people just doing stuff. And it's a movie called Licorice
- 54:01Pizza. I would love to watch Licorice
- 54:04Pizza and the holdovers back-to-back.
- 54:06That would make just a fantastic Night of Bob book movie viewing.
- 54:10That that is a great pick, Bob. I, I think that all of Carrie's
- 54:15complaints about the first half of this movie are like the
- 54:18entirety of Licorice Pizza. Like it's just all sorts of
- 54:24random scenes put together. And I don't know if there's
- 54:28character arcs for anyone, but you're intrigued by who they are
- 54:31by the end of the film. That that's a great pick, man.
- 54:34Thanks dude. I am going to pair this up with
- 54:39what I consider to be one of the absolute best coming of age
- 54:44hangout films where you have a kid hanging out with his two
- 54:49uncles and learning how to become a man.
- 54:52Bob, This is going with second hand Lions.
- 54:55Dude how good are coming of age movies?
- 54:58They're incredible. It's just a formula that never
- 55:00gets old. Just just also Robert Duvall,
- 55:05Michael Caine, Hailey, Joel Osmond.
- 55:08Yep. Like you just, you can't go
- 55:13wrong. Well, and that's why this movie
- 55:14works so well. You know, I remember on Twitter
- 55:17last year, and Twitter is a true cesspool of negativity and
- 55:22cynicism and nihilism, which drains the life out of me with
- 55:26every interaction. But even on Twitter last year,
- 55:29this movie was a freaking hit. And part of it was because I saw
- 55:33this mentioned many times, like we needed a good sad Christmas
- 55:37movie where people are sad at Christmas.
- 55:39And of course that's going to appeal to film Twitter.
- 55:41Those people are miserable. But there's something about it
- 55:45being a movie about sad people. But placing it at Christmas,
- 55:49which is an inherently warm, comforting time of year even
- 55:54though it's cold outside, and making it a coming of age story
- 56:00means that despite the people being sad, it is not a cynical
- 56:04film. That is a deeply hopeful movie
- 56:07where even if you don't know where you're going from here,
- 56:10you feel like things are going to be OK.
- 56:12And honestly, like, that is that is such a great Christmas
- 56:15message. Like, I don't want to get too
- 56:17into the actual, you know, religious story of Christmas,
- 56:22but like, the idea of Christmas being a time where hope was born
- 56:27into a world that didn't have any hope.
- 56:29And we don't know necessarily what that means, but things are
- 56:32just going to be OK. This is like a perfect
- 56:35demonstration of that Brad in a movie that is trying very hard
- 56:39not to be a religious movie given Giamatti's bent.
- 56:42You know what I mean? Yep, Yeah.
- 56:44And the the impetus towards hope bringing movement is so strong
- 56:52in this movie that like the closer the relationships we
- 56:55have, the more well known we are by others on an emotional level,
- 57:02the more likely it is we are to do the right thing, to do good
- 57:06things in this world. And when Giamatti does the, I
- 57:11mean technically the wrong thing, he lies.
- 57:15But when he does the right thing in caring for and protecting
- 57:20Angus Tulley, it gets him fired, which is what he needed all
- 57:25along. Like it, it gives him the final
- 57:28impetus to finally go forth into the world, to leave his
- 57:31childhood behind and like stake a claim on the world at large.
- 57:36And I like what a great story to tell at the Christmas time.
- 57:43Well, we need to get into final scores, so let me say this,
- 57:45Let's Make It a Double was brought to you by Blackwood
- 57:48Distilling Company. Whatever you choose to pair this
- 57:50movie up with, you can always make it a double with Blackwood.
- 57:53And if you go to bourbonoutfitter.com/film
- 57:57Whiskey and use our code film Whiskey at checkout, you'll get
- 58:005% off your own bottle of Blackwood.
- 58:03I cannot imagine a better Christmas gift this time of year
- 58:06than Blackwood. It is like the perfect gifting
- 58:09whiskey Brad. 100% It is delicious and sweet and has all
- 58:14sorts of complex flavors. It will warm the cockles of your
- 58:18heart even if you don't drink it on Christmas Day.
- 58:21Bob. Yeah, 100%, dude.
- 58:23All right, let's get into final scores.
- 58:25I'll make this quick and easy. This is a 10 out of 10 movie,
- 58:27Brad. I've seen it 3 or 4 Times Now.
- 58:31It is Shaggy. And it is.
- 58:33It isn't as tightly constructed as some movies are, but you need
- 58:37to get on this movie's wavelength.
- 58:38It has its own rhythm to it. And once you enter that stream,
- 58:43you're just along for the ride. And I think that the best movies
- 58:46do that. We're going to talk about Past
- 58:49Lives, another movie from 2023, later this season, which has
- 58:52become one of the best movies I've ever seen in my life.
- 58:55And from day-to-day, I go back and forth on my what's the best
- 58:58movie of 2023? Is it Oppenheimer?
- 59:01Is it The Holdovers? Is it Past Lives?
- 59:04How lucky we are to have 3 movies as perfect as those three
- 59:09to debate, and The Holdovers is definitely one of them.
- 59:11Brad. I think this is this is going to
- 59:16make you angry, Bob. I think this is a nine out of
- 59:1910. That does make me angry.
- 59:21You're correct. I knew it would I like the
- 59:25second time around, that this movie had more of an emotional
- 59:29impact on me the first time around.
- 59:31It wasn't. The depth wasn't quite there as
- 59:35much the second time around. Like this is an incredible film
- 59:39that has so many beautiful moments.
- 59:42Some really great acting from Giamatti, especially.
- 59:45I I think that one of the reasons I want to rate this
- 59:50highly or even more highly than a nine out of 10, which I I
- 59:53understand, Bob, I'm not blaming you or putting you down for a 10
- 59:56out of 10 pick, which I I often and want to do.
- 1:00:00I, I enjoy ridiculing your 10 out of 10s.
- 1:00:03This is I get it. I totally understand how this
- 1:00:06works for you. I think one of the reasons why
- 1:00:09we both rate this so highly. Is because it is such a rare
- 1:00:13film like I, I think we used to get more movies like this.
- 1:00:19And so, you know, maybe it's an 8 or an 8 1/2 normally, but
- 1:00:22because of the dearth of heartwarming, coming of age,
- 1:00:28honest hangout films, I I do think it deserves a higher score
- 1:00:34because we don't get those anymore.
- 1:00:35So it's a nine out of 10 for me. There's definitely some stuff
- 1:00:40that it could have been cut from this film.
- 1:00:41It could have been like a sharp hour and 55 minutes instead of
- 1:00:46two hours and 15 minutes. But overall, The Holdovers is an
- 1:00:51incredible film that I'm probably going to end up
- 1:00:53watching more than other 10 out of 10 films I I've rated because
- 1:00:59I'm going to watch this at Christmas time now, Bob.
- 1:01:02It's a great like it has entered the rotation for me.
- 1:01:05I'm not saying like you gather the family and watch this on
- 1:01:07Christmas Eve every year. I.
- 1:01:09Was going to say that the one thing, the one thing that keeps
- 1:01:15us from being like a family watch is that there is a lot of
- 1:01:18drinking and a lot of swearing in this movie, Bob.
- 1:01:22And it is not devoid of boobs either.
- 1:01:24There are, there is a picture. There's printed boobs.
- 1:01:28Yeah. There's.
- 1:01:29What is that boob section? Boobs.
- 1:01:32An image. An image of a boobs within an
- 1:01:34image. Yeah, sure.
- 1:01:36Anyways, there are enough things that make this movie real and
- 1:01:40honest that would also keep me from showing it to my kids until
- 1:01:44they're like, I don't know, 14-16?
- 1:01:48I I do think it's a perfect December 17th movie, like you're
- 1:01:51in the Christmas season, but it's like, let's watch this the
- 1:01:53week before Christmas. Honestly, what's?
- 1:01:56Your Christmas Eve movie, Bob. I mean, I want to say Maverick,
- 1:01:59I want to say It's a Wonderful Life, but my family won't watch
- 1:02:01that with me 'cause they're small children and it's a two
- 1:02:04hour and 20 minute movie. Dude I remember watching that
- 1:02:07movie when I was a kid. I know I'm trying.
- 1:02:09I'm like, dude, I'm doing the Lord's work out here.
- 1:02:11I'm I'm doing yeoman's work. I'm trying to get it done.
- 1:02:13But all right, so it's a 9.5 out of 10 from us, but we want to
- 1:02:17know what you think of the holdovers.
- 1:02:19You can find us on any of our social media platforms,
- 1:02:22Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, TikTok, YouTube at Film Whiskey.
- 1:02:28Or if you want to talk about the movies, we are on our Discord
- 1:02:32server every single day talking to you guys, fans of the Film
- 1:02:35and Whiskey podcast. So if you want to join the
- 1:02:37conversation, you can find a link to our server at the end of
- 1:02:40every single one of our show notes.
- 1:02:42As we said, we're taking the week off next week from our
- 1:02:44regularly scheduled programming, but we will be back with Cruise
- 1:02:48Miss and I think it's time to reveal the film for the 2024
- 1:02:52Cruise Miss. Brad, you want to do the honors?
- 1:02:55Bob, we are going to be reviewing Mission Impossible
- 1:03:00Fallout. Yeah, we are.
- 1:03:01A perfect action movie question mark.
- 1:03:04It's damn close if it's not perfect dude.
- 1:03:06All I know is Henry Cavill reloads his arms.
- 1:03:10He sure does. It's incredible.
- 1:03:12The fact that they didn't add like a like a rat click when he
- 1:03:16does that is the the unacceptable.
- 1:03:18The biggest blown opportunity of all time, dude.
- 1:03:23All right, join us next week for Mission Impossible Fallout.
- 1:03:26And folks, we won't see you until after Christmas.
- 1:03:28Have a Merry Christmas, have happy holidays.
- 1:03:30We will see you on December 31st for do New Year's Eve baby.
- 1:03:37Oh, that. What a great man.
- 1:03:40What a great title, Bob. Until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:03:43I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.