Latest / Deep Dive / Australia’s 4.5% Unemployment Myth: The 1.6 Million Workers Hidden Behind the Headlines
Transcript
- 0:00So if you're, you know, listening to this on your
- 0:03commute right now, or maybe you're, I don't know, folding
- 0:06laundry after a long shift, I really want to ask you a
- 0:09question. Yeah, it's a good one to think
- 0:10about. Right.
- 0:11So have you ever looked at your phone, seen a positive economic
- 0:15headline flash across the screen?
- 0:18Like maybe a politician touting low unemployment numbers?
- 0:22Yeah. And just thought to yourself,
- 0:24that doesn't match my life at all.
- 0:26I. Hear that all the time.
- 0:27Exactly. You look at your bank account,
- 0:29you look at your friends who are, you know, struggling to get
- 0:31full time hours, and you just think these people on the news
- 0:34must be living in a completely different reality.
- 0:36It's jarring, honestly. It really is, and if you have
- 0:39ever felt that way, you are definitely not alone.
- 0:42But more importantly, you are not crazy.
- 0:45No, not at all. I mean, it is an incredibly
- 0:47common feeling right now, and it stems from this very real, very
- 0:51profound disconnect between the, well, the high level
- 0:55macroeconomic summaries we're constantly fed and the actual
- 0:59ground level reality of the modern workplace.
- 1:02Right the reality on the ground. And that brings us to the core
- 1:05mission of our deep dive. Today we are going to completely
- 1:08unravel this frustrating mystery of the Australian labor market
- 1:12as it stands right now in mid 2026.
- 1:15It's quite a puzzle. It is because if you just read
- 1:18the papers, you see a headline unemployment rate hovering
- 1:20around what, 4.4% to 4.5? Percent right in that band.
- 1:24Yeah. And on paper, that makes the
- 1:26economy look like a fortress, like it's remarkably resilient.
- 1:30But for actual workers who are just, you know, trying to pay
- 1:32rent, it feels incredibly fragile.
- 1:35It feels really tough. It does.
- 1:37O. To bridge that gap, we are using
- 1:39two really fascinating pieces of source material today.
- 1:42The first is this highly analytical article, and it's
- 1:44titled Australia as Quietly Weakening Labor Market.
- 1:48Which is a great read by the way.
- 1:49Super insightful. And the second is the official
- 1:52raw data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics, the ABS
- 1:55specifically we're looking at their June 2020 sixth data
- 1:58release detailing their new U series, which tracks
- 2:02underemployment and under utilization.
- 2:04Right. And this data is vital.
- 2:06I mean, it basically proves what you, the listener, might be
- 2:09feeling right now. The traditional metrics we've
- 2:12used for decades to measure economic pain, they are
- 2:15completely failing to capture what is actually happening in
- 2:18businesses across the country. OK, let's unpack this.
- 2:21Start with the headline numbers, because I feel like we have to
- 2:23understand the illusion before we can shatter it.
- 2:26Makes sense? So in July 2026, the official
- 2:30headline unemployment rate was 4.5%.
- 2:33Now, my understanding is that historically speaking, that's
- 2:36really not that bad, right? No, it's actually quite low by
- 2:40historical standards. Right.
- 2:41It's only modestly higher than it was a year earlier.
- 2:44And the data says total employment was actually up like
- 2:471.3% year over year, right? So if I'm just a casual
- 2:50observer, I see that and I think great, you know, the engine is
- 2:53humming. Yeah, you would be completely
- 2:54friven for thinking that. And to add to that rosy picture,
- 2:58the employment to population ratio is sitting at 63.9%.
- 3:01OK. So that means nearly 64% of the
- 3:04working age population is employed in some capacity.
- 3:07Although wait, looking at the notes we have here from the
- 3:10data, that 63.9% is actually a slight slip, isn't it?
- 3:15Like it is down .3 percentage points from a year ago.
- 3:18It is a slip, Yeah. And that tiny .3% drop is, well,
- 3:22it's the very first thread we need to pull here, OK?
- 3:24Because employment hasn't collapsed, which is why the
- 3:28headline rate hasn't spiked into the sevens or eights like it
- 3:31does in a classic painful recession.
- 3:34But employment relative to the population that has lost its
- 3:38forward momentum, it's stalling out.
- 3:40Right, because usually when we talk about a weakening economy,
- 3:44we expect explosions. Exactly.
- 3:45We expect to turn on the news and see, I don't know, a factory
- 3:48closing its doors, 1000 people walking out with cardboard
- 3:52boxes, massive redundancies. Right, the dramatic stuff.
- 3:55Yeah, but that isn't happening, which makes the market look, as
- 3:58our source article explicitly calls it, healthy by recession
- 4:01standards. Healthy by recession standards,
- 4:03but just because there are no explosions doesn't mean there
- 4:06isn't structural damage happening quietly in the
- 4:08background. Oh for sure.
- 4:10And that brings us to how companies are actually behaving
- 4:13right now to protect their profit margins without
- 4:16generating those terrible PR headlines.
- 4:21Our source material identifies this specific corporate behavior
- 4:25as quiet cutting. Quiet cutting.
- 4:28Wow, it sounds incredibly insidious.
- 4:31It kind of is. If I'm a business owner and my
- 4:34margins are getting squeezed by, say, inflation or supply chain
- 4:37costs, what does quiet cutting actually look like in my office?
- 4:40Well, let's say you manage a mid size logistics firm.
- 4:43OK, your revenue is dipping. Now in the past you might have
- 4:46laid off 10% of your staff, right?
- 4:48But layoffs are expensive. You have to payout severance
- 4:51packages, you basically destroy the morale of the remaining
- 4:54staff, and you lose institutional knowledge that is
- 4:56very expensive to rehire when the economy bounces back.
- 5:00That makes sense, yeah. So instead you implement quiet
- 5:02cutting, the most common tactic, you just freeze recruitment.
- 5:06A hiring freeze. OK, yeah, we've all heard of.
- 5:07Those right? But let's take a step further.
- 5:10It's not just freezing new roles.
- 5:11Let's say Sarah, your senior accountant, gets a better offer
- 5:15and leaves voluntarily. Good for Sarah.
- 5:17Good for Sarah, but you don't lay her off.
- 5:19She quits now in a booming economy, you to replace Sarah in
- 5:24two weeks. Under quiet cutting, you simply
- 5:27leave her vacancy unfilled. You just let her desk sit empty.
- 5:31OK, wait. I want to pause on that because
- 5:33I've actually seen this happen. The desk sits empty, but Sarah's
- 5:37workload doesn't magically disappear.
- 5:39Exactly. The clients still need their
- 5:41accounts done. So what happens?
- 5:44The employer just turns to the rest of the team and says hey
- 5:46guys, you're going to have to absorb Sarah's work.
- 5:49They are essentially consolidating roles. 2 people
- 5:52leave, they hire nobody, and the remaining staff are suddenly
- 5:55doing the work of three people for the exact same salary.
- 5:58That is a fundamental pillar of quiet cutting.
- 6:00It's making existing staff absorb more work.
- 6:03But there are, you know, other levers they pull too.
- 6:06Like what? They delay major projects that
- 6:08would have required hiring. They quietly let contractor
- 6:11agreements expire and just choose not to renew them
- 6:14further. Hourly wage workers?
- 6:16They slice casual shifts. They completely ban overtime.
- 6:20It is really a death of 1000 cuts for the workforce earning
- 6:24potential. But, and this is key, it never
- 6:27triggers a mass layoff headline. Now I need to jump in with an
- 6:32analogy here because this is honestly blowing my mind.
- 6:35This sounds exactly like shrink flation, but applied to human
- 6:39beings. Shrink.
- 6:40Flation. I like that.
- 6:41Elaborate on that. OK, so you know when you go to
- 6:44the supermarket to buy your favorite brand of chocolate bar,
- 6:46you've been buying it for years for $2.00.
- 6:48You go in today and it still cost $2.00.
- 6:51The bright red wrapper looks exactly the same size.
- 6:53The price tag on the shelf hasn't changed, right?
- 6:55But you get to your car, you open the wrapper, and you
- 6:58realize the company has quietly shaved 10% off the actual block
- 7:02of chocolate. Yep, they didn't pick the
- 7:04chocolate bar off the shelf, which would be a layoff.
- 7:06They just made the amount of product you'd get smaller.
- 7:08Yeah, employers are doing that to jobs.
- 7:11They're shrink flating the workforce.
- 7:13That is a phenomenal way to look at it actually.
- 7:15They are shrinking the volume of Labor without removing the label
- 7:19of employment. Exactly.
- 7:21Now, I do need to inject a crucial caveat here to ensure we
- 7:24stay grounded in the facts. OK, hit me.
- 7:27Our source text is very careful to point out that quiet cutting
- 7:31is an anecdotal description of employer behavior.
- 7:34It is an observation of a trend, not an official ABS statistic.
- 7:39The Bureau of Statistics doesn't have a spreadsheet titled Quiet
- 7:42Cutting right? Right.
- 7:44We have to rely on hard empirical evidence to prove this
- 7:47is a national trend, which you know we will do in a moment when
- 7:50we get to the hours data. That's a fair distinction to
- 7:52make, but let me challenge you on the premise of the headline
- 7:55rate. Then go for it.
- 7:56If I run a company of 100 people and over the course of 12 months
- 8:0010 people quit and I just don't replace them, I've shrunk my
- 8:04workforce down to 90 people through natural nutrition.
- 8:07I've shrink flated my company. Doesn't that fundamentally warp
- 8:11our understanding of what the unemployment rate is even
- 8:13telling us? Because technically I didn't
- 8:16fire anyone. It completely warps it because
- 8:18the scenario you just described creates what economists call the
- 8:21fortress effect, and understanding this effect is,
- 8:25well, it's the only way to make sense of the current Australian
- 8:28economy. The fortress effect.
- 8:30So who is inside the fortress and who is outside?
- 8:33The people who already have jobs are inside the fortress because
- 8:36companies are using quiet cutting instead of mass firings.
- 8:40If you are a salaried employee with a permanent contract, you
- 8:43are relatively safe. OK, the walls are high, the
- 8:46gates are locked, and you are sitting inside thinking, well,
- 8:50my job is secure, the economy seems pretty resilient.
- 8:53Your biggest problem is that you are doing Sarah the accountant's
- 8:56work on top of your own. So inside the fortress, people
- 9:00are stressed and overworked, but they have paychecks.
- 9:03What about the people outside? The people outside are facing a
- 9:06labor market that is utterly impenetrable because all those
- 9:09companies have instituted hiring freezes and are leaving
- 9:12vacancies unfilled. The drawbridge to the fortress
- 9:14has been pulled up. Yeah, if you are a new graduate
- 9:17trying to enter the workforce or you know someone who took time
- 9:20off to care for a child and is trying to get back in, you are
- 9:23slamming into a brick wall. This explains so much.
- 9:26I mean, I have friends who are senior in their careers telling
- 9:29me things are fine at my firm, we're just running lean.
- 9:32Exactly. And in the exact same group
- 9:34chat, I have younger friends who are applying for 50 entry level
- 9:38roles, tailoring every cover letter and they're getting
- 9:41Absolute Radio silence. Not even a rejection e-mail,
- 9:45just the void. Yeah, it's the void.
- 9:47They're looking at me saying there are absolutely zero jobs
- 9:50out there. And here is the paradox we
- 9:52promised to validate at the start of this deep dive.
- 9:55Both of those friends are describing reality accurately.
- 9:58I mean really both of them. Yes, they just exist on opposite
- 10:01sides of the portress wall. The 4.5% headline unemployment
- 10:05rate only tells you how many people are officially standing
- 10:08outside the Moat, waving a flag, actively shouting for a job.
- 10:12It tells you absolutely nothing about the shrinking size of the
- 10:15chocolate bar or the fact that the drawbridge is permanently
- 10:18raised. Which perfectly leads us to the
- 10:21next massive piece of evidence in our sources.
- 10:24Because if companies are avoiding changing their actual
- 10:27headcount, if they're stubbornly keeping the same number of
- 10:29bodies in the building to avoid bad headlines and severance
- 10:32payouts, the next logical place we have to look for economic
- 10:36weakness is in the hours those people are working.
- 10:39Yes, the transition from measuring bodies to measuring
- 10:42time. This is where the real story of
- 10:45the 2026 labor market is written.
- 10:47If you want to find the pain, you don't count the workers, you
- 10:50count the hours. Our source text provides this
- 10:54vital mathematical example to explain this shift, and I really
- 10:57want to walk the listener through it slowly because it
- 10:59fundamentally changes how you view employment.
- 11:02Data. It's a great example.
- 11:03So let's go back to that hypothetical business.
- 11:06Imagine a company with 100 employees and they are all on
- 11:08standard 38 hour a week contracts.
- 11:11OK. If you multiply that out, 100
- 11:13employees working 38 hours equals 3800 labor hours per week
- 11:17for that business. A perfectly healthy full time
- 11:20workforce, right? Now the economy gets a bit
- 11:23rough. Demand drops.
- 11:24The business needs to cut their operating costs by about 10%,
- 11:28but they really don't want to deal with the fallout of firing
- 11:3010 people. Right, they want to avoid the
- 11:32bad PR. Exactly.
- 11:34So instead management calls a meeting and says times are
- 11:38tough, we're going to reduce everyone's schedule down to 34
- 11:42hours a week. Just a four hour haircut.
- 11:45They trim an hour off a few shifts, maybe close early on.
- 11:47Fridays, a seemingly small adjustment on a per person
- 11:50basis. Exactly.
- 11:52But let's run the math again. 100 employees now multiplied by
- 11:5534 hours. The new total is 3400 hours.
- 11:59The reveal here is absolutely staggering when you think about.
- 12:02It. Yeah, it really is.
- 12:03Zero jobs were lost. Not a single person was fired,
- 12:06so the headline unemployment rate for the country remains
- 12:08completely unchanged. The local politician still gets
- 12:11to go on television and brag about the strong, resilient
- 12:14labor market, but 400 hours of paid labor just vanished into
- 12:18thin air. And this isn't just a clever
- 12:19thought experiment. We can validate that exact
- 12:22mathematical hypothetical with the real world July 2026 data.
- 12:26OK, what does the data say? The official data showed that
- 12:29monthly hours worked actually fell by .6%, even though total
- 12:34employment remained very high. Wow, the hours are evaporating
- 12:37while the headcount stays static.
- 12:39The chocolate got .6% smaller across the entire national
- 12:43economy. Precisely, And This is why the
- 12:45Australian Bureau of Statistics realized they had a massive
- 12:48blind spot. The traditional X-ray wasn't
- 12:51picking up this kind of structural weakness.
- 12:53So what do they do? That is why they introduced EU
- 12:56series, which stands for underutilization.
- 12:59It is a much more contemporary, nuanced framework for measuring
- 13:02how much of our workforce is actually being utilized, rather
- 13:06than just counting who has a pulse and a paycheck.
- 13:08Let's dig into that U series data from June 2026, because
- 13:12this puts real human faces to the math problem we just
- 13:14discussed. I'm looking at the level
- 13:16estimates here. Look at the metric called
- 13:18reduced employment or what the ABS codes as RE one.
- 13:21OK. In June 2026 there were 363,000
- 13:25employed people who worked reduced hours specifically for
- 13:28economic reasons. With 363,000 people, that is the
- 13:31population of a small city. Yes, that is a rate of 2.4%.
- 13:36And to be clear, economic reasons means this wasn't
- 13:39voluntary, right? These aren't people who asked to
- 13:42go part time so they could spend more time surfing or taking up
- 13:44pottery. These are people whose employers
- 13:47literally cut their shifts because the business was slow or
- 13:49there was a lack of materials or demand dried up.
- 13:52They were the victims of the four hour haircut we just talked
- 13:54about. Exactly, but it gets worse.
- 13:57That is just the RE one group. EU series also measures a group
- 14:01called UD1 which is broader. Underemployment.
- 14:04OK. In June there were 623,000 1000
- 14:07people classified as underemployed.
- 14:08OK, wait, I need to make sure I understand the distinction here.
- 14:11How is AUD one underemployed person different from an RE one
- 14:16person who just had their hours reduced?
- 14:18It's a matter of categorization. The 623,000 underemployed
- 14:22people, the UD1 group, are workers who already have a job.
- 14:26Maybe it's a part time job of 15 hours a week, but they want more
- 14:29hours. They are available to work more
- 14:31hours, and they are actively looking for them now.
- 14:33There is a slight overlap in the Venn diagram of these two
- 14:37groups. The ABS data notes that 88,000
- 14:40people were actually in both categories simultaneously.
- 14:43So those 88,000 people are the ones who are historically
- 14:46working say 30 hours, had their employer chop them down to 20
- 14:51hours because of the economy, and are now desperately
- 14:53searching to get those 10 hours back.
- 14:54Correct. They are working less than usual
- 14:57for economic reasons and they want more.
- 14:59This brings up such a massive point about the lived experience
- 15:02of the worker. What does this actually mean for
- 15:04the person listening to us right now who might fall into one of
- 15:07these categories? It means that you can be
- 15:09technically, officially employed, satisfying all the
- 15:13criteria to make the 4.5% headline rate look good, while
- 15:17your actual economic situation, your income, and your financial
- 15:20security have deteriorated substantially.
- 15:23Yeah, you are technically the success story in the
- 15:25government's eyes. But you can't pay your grocery
- 15:28bill because you lost those 4 hours a week, every week for a
- 15:31month. It's like a liminal space.
- 15:33You are trapped in this economic purgatory.
- 15:36You aren't jobless enough to claim certain government
- 15:38unemployment benefits or get sympathy, but you weren't
- 15:41working enough to actually survive the cost of living.
- 15:43That is the exact psychological and financial toll of EU series
- 15:46data. It quantifies purgatory.
- 15:49Here's where it gets really interesting.
- 15:51Because 363,000 people with reduced hours and 623,000 people
- 15:57actively wanting more hours. Those are enormous numbers.
- 16:00They are, but they are still just head counts.
- 16:03We have firmly established that hours are being quietly cut.
- 16:07Now I want to zoom out. I want to look at the total
- 16:10volume of unused labor in the entire Australian economy.
- 16:13Right zooming out is crucial here.
- 16:15Because our source material does this, and it reveals the true
- 16:18terrifying scale of this issue. When you combine all these
- 16:22factors, the strict unemployment and the underemployment, the
- 16:24true slack in the labor market reveals itself.
- 16:27In July 2026, the official underemployment rate hit 6.4%,
- 16:31which was up half a percentage point from the previous year.
- 16:34Now I know half a percent sounds small to someone outside of
- 16:37economics, but in labor data a .5% jump in a year is like, I
- 16:43don't know, a tectonic plate shifting under our feet.
- 16:45It is a significant deterioration.
- 16:47Now let's stack the blocks together from the June ABS data
- 16:50to see the total mass of the problem.
- 16:52First you have your strictly unemployed people, the people
- 16:55with 0 hours. That is 690,000 individuals.
- 16:59OK, 690,000. Next you add the total
- 17:02underutilized employed population, the people with jobs
- 17:05who need more hours. That is 898, 1000 individuals.
- 17:08OK, I'm doing the math in my head 690,000 + 898,000.
- 17:13When you put them together, the total Labor underutilization in
- 17:16Australia sits at a massive 1.59 million people.
- 17:19Almost 1.6 million people who are either completely out of
- 17:22work or actively being starved of the hours they need to
- 17:25survive. That is wow.
- 17:27Yes, and that gives us a total labor force underutilization
- 17:30rate, what the ABS designates as the UU one rate of 10.2%.
- 17:34Ten, 2%. I want you to compare those two
- 17:35numbers, 4.5% headline unemployment versus 10.2% under
- 17:39utilization. That paints a very, very
- 17:41different picture of the countries economic health.
- 17:43It's more than double the headline rate is hiding half the
- 17:46pain. But the source material doesn't
- 17:48just stop at counting hands, does it?
- 17:50There's a volume metric here that absolutely stopped me in my
- 17:54tracks when I read it. You're referring to the hours
- 17:56not worked metric. The ABS doesn't just count the
- 17:591.6 million people, they actually calculate the gap
- 18:02between the hours those people are currently working and the
- 18:04hours they are available and wanting to work.
- 18:06OK, so they measure the gap. Yeah.
- 18:08And when you calculate the total available but unused labor
- 18:11supply in June 2026 alone, it equates to just under 32,000,000
- 18:17hours. I just, I need to stop you
- 18:19there, 32,000,000 hours. I want you, the listener,
- 18:23whether you are driving or cooking dinner, to actually try
- 18:25and visualize that #32 million hours of human potential.
- 18:29It's almost unfathomable. It really is of human
- 18:32productivity, of innovation, of wages, of tax revenue just
- 18:35sitting on the sidelines benched every single month.
- 18:39If you divide that by a standard 150 hour working month, that is
- 18:41the equivalent of over 213,000 full time jobs just evaporating
- 18:46into the ether because the economy can't absorb them.
- 18:48Yeah, you could build infrastructure with 32,000,000
- 18:51hours of Labor. You could advance medical
- 18:53research instead. It is a staggering waste of
- 18:56potential. It is an ocean of unused
- 18:58potential and it is a drag on the entire macroeconomic system.
- 19:02If we break down those 32,000,000 lost hours into
- 19:05volume rates, the ABS categorizes them like this.
- 19:09The reduced employment volume rate is .8%, the underemployment
- 19:12volume rate is 1.4%, and the strict unemployment volume rate
- 19:16is 3.7%. When you add those up, the total
- 19:20labor force underutilization volume rate is 5.8%.
- 19:24So we have this massive gloated supply of Labor, all this desire
- 19:27and availability to work, translating to 32,000,000 unused
- 19:31hours. If we connect this to the bigger
- 19:32picture, we have to flip the coin over and look at the demand
- 19:35side of the equation. Right demand.
- 19:37Because an ocean of supply only matters if we know what the
- 19:40demand is doing, and the ABS data is very clear on this.
- 19:43In May 2026, there were 329,500 job vacancies across the
- 19:48country. Vacancies being the actual
- 19:49demand the open rolls employers are actively trying to fill,
- 19:52correct. And that 329,500 figure was down
- 19:562.1% from the previous quarter. It was also down 2.1% from a
- 20:00year earlier. Vacancies represent the appetite
- 20:04of employers, and that appetite is shrinking month by month.
- 20:07So we have a converging crisis. We have an increasing supply of
- 20:10unused hours, 1.59 million people desperate for more work,
- 20:15colliding with a decreasing demand for workers with
- 20:18vacancies dropping. This brings us to a fundamental,
- 20:21unbreakable economic law of the negotiation table.
- 20:24When underemployment is rising, meaning supply is high, and
- 20:28vacancies are falling, meaning demand is low, workers
- 20:31universally lose their bargaining power.
- 20:33Right, because the employer holds all the cards.
- 20:36If I go to my boss and say I really need to get my hours
- 20:38bumped back up to 40 or I need a raise to cover inflation, the
- 20:41employer can just look out the window and say I'm sorry.
- 20:43But if you don't want these 20 hours a week at this pay rate,
- 20:46there's a line of 50 people outside the fortress who will
- 20:49happily take it. Precisely.
- 20:50And that's where the quiet cutting phenomenon becomes
- 20:52particularly insidious for the people inside the fortress.
- 20:55How so? Employers don't actually need to
- 20:57fire you to exert leverage over you.
- 21:00They just need you to know that the market outside is freezing
- 21:02cold. Wow.
- 21:03It creates a culture of compliance.
- 21:06It makes existing employees willing to absorb that
- 21:08additional work of their former colleagues without asking for a
- 21:11raise. They put up with deteriorating
- 21:13conditions, unpaid overtime and intense stress because they know
- 21:17the drawbridge is pulled up. They are too scared to test the
- 21:20waters of a 10.2% underutilized market.
- 21:23Wow, that completely reframes how I look at corporate culture
- 21:27right now. OK, so 32,000,000 lost hours is
- 21:30a massive, abstract, almost incomprehensible number.
- 21:34We need to ground this in reality.
- 21:36We do. We need to look at exactly who
- 21:39in the population is actually absorbing this economic blow.
- 21:43If the economy is a ship taking on water, who is sleeping in the
- 21:46lower decks? Who is taking the hit for the
- 21:48team so that the headline unemployment rate can look so
- 21:51pretty? When we dive into the
- 21:53demographics of the Squeeze, it is incredibly revealing and
- 21:55frankly, a bit sobering. Let's look at age first.
- 21:58OK, age. The ABS data on a reduced
- 22:00employment, again that's the RE1 series.
- 22:03People having their hours cut involuntarily for economic
- 22:06reasons shows that the pain is not evenly distributed across
- 22:09the lifespan. It heavily, heavily targets the
- 22:13young, specifically the 15 to 24 year old age bracket and the
- 22:17older workforce, those aged 55 and over.
- 22:20The youngest and the oldest? Why them?
- 22:23It feels almost predatory. Are they just easier targets for
- 22:25management to cut? It's not necessarily predatory,
- 22:29it's deeply structural. Think about where the 15 to 24
- 22:33age bracket primarily works. They rely heavily on casual
- 22:37hourly rolls. Like retail?
- 22:38Right. Exactly.
- 22:39They are the backbone of hospitality, retail, food
- 22:42service and events. These are industries that
- 22:44inherently rely on variable hours to manage their tight
- 22:47margins. This makes young workers the
- 22:49ultimate shock absorbers for the Australian economy.
- 22:52So when a restaurant owner sees a dip in Friday night bookings
- 22:55because I'm a middle class, families are cutting back on
- 22:57dining out. They don't fire their full time
- 22:59salaried floor manager. No because they still need
- 23:02someone to open the doors and manage the till.
- 23:04Instead they look at the roster and they just delete the shifts
- 23:07of 319 year old casual wait staff.
- 23:10The business instantly saves money, the manager keeps their
- 23:13job and those 19 year olds suddenly have 0 income for the
- 23:16week. The ultimate shock absorbers.
- 23:18Yes, that is such a potent phrase, but a terrible reality
- 23:22for young people trying to get a foothold in adult life, trying
- 23:26to pay for university or save for a car.
- 23:29It is brutal, and we've seen this exact demographic pattern
- 23:32play out recently, giving us a historical precedent.
- 23:35The data explicitly points to the structural lessons we
- 23:38learned from the lasting impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic,
- 23:40lockdowns, and regional macroeconomic shocks like
- 23:43Cyclone Alfred in early 2025. Oh right, Cyclone Alfred
- 23:47devastated the northern supply chains in tourism for months.
- 23:50Exactly. During both of those events, 1A
- 23:53global health crisis, the other a localized natural disaster,
- 23:56the reduced employment rate for the 1524 demographic absolutely
- 24:00skyrocketed compared to prime age workers.
- 24:02Makes sense? Because of their propensity to
- 24:05work casual roles with highly variable hours, any shine of the
- 24:09economic system disproportionately impacts their
- 24:11ability to secure consistent hours.
- 24:13They are the first ones thrown overboard to keep the ship
- 24:16afloat and. What about the older
- 24:18demographic, the 55 plus group? They often face a different
- 24:22structural challenge. They might be in roles that are
- 24:24being phased out, or they are facing subtle ageism where
- 24:27companies reduce their hours as a form of quiet attrition,
- 24:30hoping they will just naturally transition into early retirement
- 24:33rather than having to pay out long service leave or severance.
- 24:36OK, so that's the age breakdown. The young and the old take the
- 24:39hit. What happens when we look at
- 24:41this through the lens of sex? Does the data show men and women
- 24:45experiencing this labor squeeze differently?
- 24:48It does, and the data paints a very complex picture of gender
- 24:51in the workforce. According to the June 2026 data,
- 24:55men actually have a higher rate of reduced employment that re
- 24:59one metric. Wait, men are having their hours
- 25:00cut more often than women? Yes, the data shows men have a
- 25:04greater propensity to have their working hours reduced for
- 25:07economic reasons. Furthermore, if you look at the
- 25:10strict traditional headline unemployment rate, the UN One
- 25:14rate, men also have a higher rate there compared to women.
- 25:17OK wait, I'm going to push back on this because I was reading
- 25:19ahead in the ABS tables you provided before we started
- 25:22recording and I found a massive contradiction here that I really
- 25:25need you to explain. OK, go ahead.
- 25:27If men are experiencing higher rates of reduced hours, so the
- 25:30RE1, and they are experiencing higher rates of strict
- 25:32unemployment, the UN1, why does the source material explicitly
- 25:38state that women are actually suffering more?
- 25:41When we broaden the definition of joblessness, how is it
- 25:44mathematically possible for men to be more unemployed in the
- 25:47strict sense but women to be more jobless in the broader
- 25:50sense? That is the perfect question to
- 25:52ask, and it is the crux of why labor economics can be so
- 25:55counterintuitive. To answer it, we have to start
- 25:58peeling the joblessness onion. Peeling the onion.
- 26:01I like it. We have to examine exactly how
- 26:03the Australian Bureau of Statistics defines the word
- 26:05joblessness through their expanding UN series, because as
- 26:09you're about to see, incredibly strict definitions can
- 26:13completely mask the reality of the labor market for different
- 26:16demographic groups. OK, layout this UN series for
- 26:19me. Let's peel the onion.
- 26:20How do they define who is actually unemployed?
- 26:23The ABS breaks down unemployment into 4 expanding definitions.
- 26:27I want you to visualize them as concentric circles, like a
- 26:30ripple in a pond getting wider and wider.
- 26:33OK, got the visual. The tightest innermost circle is
- 26:35called UN One. This is the standard strict
- 26:39unemployment rate. It's at a 4.4% in June 2026.
- 26:43OK, so who gets to be in this inner circle?
- 26:46To be classified as UN1, you must meet three incredibly rigid
- 26:49criteria. First, you must not have a job.
- 26:52Second, you must be available to start work immediately.
- 26:55And 3rd, and this is the absolute kicker, you must have
- 26:58actively looked for work in the last four weeks.
- 27:00By actively looked, you mean the physical labor of job hunting,
- 27:04submitting tailored resumes, going to interviews, registering
- 27:07with recruitment agencies, that sort of thing.
- 27:09Yes, if you did not perform those specific trackable actions
- 27:14in the last 28 days, the ABS decides you are statistically
- 27:18not unemployed. You wait.
- 27:19What? Yeah, you are classified as not
- 27:22in the labor force. You simply do not exist in the
- 27:254.4% headline rate. That is incredibly rigid.
- 27:29If I've been applying for six months, get depressed by the
- 27:31radio silence, and take a three-week break from sending
- 27:34resumes just to save my mental health, poof, I'm cured.
- 27:37I'm no longer unemployed, according to the government.
- 27:39Exactly, you're is a race from the X-ray.
- 27:42Now let's widen the circle to the next ripple UN2.
- 27:45OK, UN2, This group includes everyone looking for work, but
- 27:49relaxes the availability rule. They're available to start
- 27:52within the next 4 weeks rather than immediately.
- 27:54Today, when you brought in it just that tiny bit, the rate
- 27:57jumps to 5.6%. Wait, why wouldn't someone be
- 28:00available immediately if they don't have a job?
- 28:02Life happens. Maybe they are finishing up a
- 28:04short term study course. Maybe they are moving cities.
- 28:07Maybe they are recovering from a minor surgery.
- 28:10By just allowing a human being to say I can start in a month
- 28:12instead of tomorrow morning, the rate jumps over a full
- 28:16percentage point. OK, that makes sense.
- 28:18Yeah. What is the 3rd circle?
- 28:19This is where it gets really telling.
- 28:21UM 3. This definition includes people
- 28:24who were available to work last week, but they didn't
- 28:26necessarily look for work in the last four weeks.
- 28:29When you drop the active search requirement, the rate leaps to
- 28:327.1%. I do play devil's advocate here
- 28:35for a second. Yeah, if you want to work and
- 28:38you are available to work, why wouldn't you be actively sending
- 28:41out resumes? Let's build a persona for this
- 28:43group. Imagine a worker who lives in a
- 28:45regional manufacturing town. OK, the only major factory in a
- 28:49100 kilometer radius just closed its doors.
- 28:53This worker knows for a certified absolute fact that
- 28:56there are 0 jobs available in their skill set in that town.
- 29:00Are they going to sit at their computer and send out 20 useless
- 29:03resumes every month to businesses that don't exist?
- 29:06No, that would be a complete waste of time.
- 29:08Right, so they stop looking. Economists call them discouraged
- 29:11workers or consider someone dealing with a short term family
- 29:14crisis like a sick parent. They are completely available
- 29:18and desperately want an income, but they simply didn't have the
- 29:20bandwidth to meet the rigid 28 day active search criteria.
- 29:25The UN3 category captures their reality.
- 29:28OK, so we're up to 7.1%. What is the final widest circle
- 29:33of the onion? UN4.
- 29:34This is the broadest definition of joblessness the ABS tracks.
- 29:37It includes people who are available to work in the next 4
- 29:40weeks, but again, didn't necessarily actively look in the
- 29:42last four weeks. That rate sits at a massive
- 29:448.5%. So by simply relaxing the
- 29:47bureaucratic rule that a person must have actively searched for
- 29:50a job in the last 28 days, the joblessness rate effectively
- 29:53double s from the headline, 4.4% to 8.5%.
- 29:56That is wild. But bring this back to my
- 29:58original challenge. How does this UN series answer
- 30:01my question about the gender divide?
- 30:03Why does UN4 impact women more? Because it reveals the hidden
- 30:06structural realities of our society.
- 30:09What's fascinating here is that as the job search activity and
- 30:13availability criteria are relaxed as we move from the
- 30:16strict UN One out to the broad UN4, the demographic makeup of
- 30:20the group flips. Really.
- 30:22Yes, the rates become significantly higher for women.
- 30:26Because of the barriers they face.
- 30:27Precisely. Women might have a deep,
- 30:29pressing financial desire to work, and they might have the
- 30:32availability to work, but they face very different, deeply
- 30:36entrenched structural barriers to active job searching within a
- 30:40rigid 4 week window. You're talking about caregiving.
- 30:43I am talking about the disproportionate burden of
- 30:45unpaid care work. Child care, elder care and
- 30:48household management still fall overwhelmingly on women in
- 30:51Australia. Let's build a persona for a UN4
- 30:53worker. All right, let's hear it.
- 30:55Imagine a mother who desperately wants to reenter the workforce.
- 30:58She needs the money, but she is waiting for a spot to open up at
- 31:02a local daycare center. Or perhaps the school holidays
- 31:05just started and she has no family nearby to watch her kids.
- 31:09She can't commit to actively interviewing this specific month
- 31:12because her schedule is highly disrupted by caregiving.
- 31:15So under the strict UN1 definition, the ABS surveyor
- 31:19basically looks at her and says, well you didn't send a resume
- 31:22this month, so you aren't unemployed, you're just out of
- 31:24the labor force, you don't count.
- 31:26Exactly. The strict definition actively
- 31:28masks her desire to work by punishing her for structural
- 31:32barriers out of her control. That's rough.
- 31:34It is when you relax the definition to simply ask the
- 31:38core question, do you want to work and are you available to
- 31:41start soon? Suddenly the data captures her
- 31:43reality. The strict UN One rate makes it
- 31:46look like men are suffering more unemployment because men are
- 31:49generally more able to engage and continuous, uninterrupted
- 31:52active job searching. But the UN for Rate reveals that
- 31:55women are sitting on the sidelines in massive numbers,
- 31:58trapped by structural barriers that prevent them from playing
- 32:01the rigid game of active job searching.
- 32:04It is such a vital nuance. It shows how metrics can lie by
- 32:08a mission. If you only look at the inner
- 32:10circle, you think you understand the pond, but you're missing all
- 32:14the ripples. And we see the structural
- 32:16variance play out geographically too, which the data briefly
- 32:19notes. As these criteria relax, the
- 32:22impacts differ significantly across various States and
- 32:25territories in Australia. Because different states have
- 32:27different industries and demographics.
- 32:29Exactly. Think about the discouraged
- 32:31worker persona we built earlier. A discouraged male worker in a
- 32:35remote mining town in WA whose site just shut down faces a very
- 32:40different reality than a mother looking for flexible part time
- 32:43administrative work in metropolitan Sydney.
- 32:45Right, totally different situations.
- 32:47Local markets experience joblessness in very, very
- 32:50different ways based on the dominant industries and the
- 32:53availability of local social infrastructure like childcare.
- 32:56A single blended national headline number like 4.5%
- 33:01completely erases all of that local lived geographic
- 33:05experience. It flattens the entire country
- 33:07into one misleading data. Point it does.
- 33:09So what does this all mean? We need to zoom all the way back
- 33:13out to where we started this deep dive.
- 33:15We set out to validate the listeners feelings.
- 33:18We wanted to understand why a 4.5% unemployment rate, a number
- 33:22that politicians celebrate, feels so incredibly painful and
- 33:26fragile for the average worker on the ground right now.
- 33:29I think the most accurate summary comes straight from our
- 33:31source article. It states that the Australian
- 33:33labor market is, quote, resilient but deteriorating at
- 33:36the margin. Resilient but deteriorating at
- 33:39the margin. I love that phrase deteriorating
- 33:41at the margin. It means we aren't seeing a
- 33:43dramatic, catastrophic collapse of the fortress.
- 33:46We are seeing a gradual grinding loss of momentum.
- 33:49It is a slow leak. The chocolate bar is getting
- 33:51smaller, hour by hour. Yes, the weakness is showing up
- 33:55in reduced hours. The RE one.
- 33:57It's showing up in falling job vacancies, and it's showing up
- 34:01in the quiet cutting of shifts, delayed projects and unfilled
- 34:05desks rather than spectacular headline grabbing mass
- 34:09redundancies. And the most important take away
- 34:11for you the listening right now. If you are feeling the pinch.
- 34:15If you are that 19 year old who can't get more than 12 hours a
- 34:18week at the cafe. No matter how many times you ask
- 34:20the manager. If you are a parent trying to
- 34:23reenter the workforce, but you are trapped in UN4 because you
- 34:27can't find a role that accommodates your caring
- 34:29responsibilities. If you are sending out 50
- 34:32tailored resumes into an absolute void, hitting the
- 34:35raised drawbridge of the fortress, and then turning on
- 34:37the Evening News to hear someone say that unemployment is
- 34:39incredibly low, you aren't crazy.
- 34:42You are experiencing the reality of a labor market that is
- 34:45rationing hours and pulling up the drawbridge to protect
- 34:47corporate margins. The data proves it.
- 34:50The 4.5% figure simply doesn't tell the whole story of the
- 34:53workers perspective. It only tells the story of the
- 34:55completely severed worker who is lucky enough to have the time
- 34:59and resources to actively search for a job every 28 days.
- 35:02It completely ignores the 1.59 million people who are dying.
- 35:06A death of 1000 cuts through lost hours, underutilization and
- 35:11quiet attrition. And this raises an incredibly
- 35:14important question, and it's a provocative thought I want to
- 35:16leave our listeners to Mull over long after are this deep dive
- 35:20ends. Let's hear it.
- 35:21If strict headline unemployment rates like the UN ones 4.4% are
- 35:26actively masking 32,000,000 lost hours of human labor and hiding
- 35:30nearly 1.6 million underutilized people, does the modern world
- 35:34need to completely abandoned unemployment as our gold
- 35:37standard economic metric? Wow, abandoned entirely?
- 35:40Just throw it out. Think about the history of it.
- 35:42That rigid metric was designed for a post war 1950s industrial
- 35:46economy. Worked 40 hours at the factory
- 35:49and the factory closed and you were fired.
- 35:50It was binary. You had a job or you didn't.
- 35:52But if the nature of work has changed in 2026 to be this
- 35:56incredibly flexible, this casualized and this fragmented,
- 36:00where your hours can be dialed up and down by an algorithm,
- 36:03where quiet cutting is the norm, perhaps our definition of a
- 36:07healthy economy needs a fundamental ground up rewrite.
- 36:10That makes a lot of sense. Because right now, diagnosing
- 36:13the health of the economy using only the UN1 unemployment rate
- 36:16is like trying to measure the volume of an ocean.
- 36:19By only counting the waves that crash on the shore, you are
- 36:22missing all the deep powerful currents moving underneath the
- 36:25surface. Measuring the ocean by counting
- 36:27the waves. That is a brilliant and
- 36:29provocative note to end on. Thank you so much for joining us
- 36:32on this deep dive into the hidden realities of the mid 2026
- 36:36Australian labor market. We hope this exploration of EU
- 36:39series and the UN series gave you not just some incredible
- 36:42data to chew on, but also some real empirical validation for
- 36:46what you might be seeing in your own life, your own bank account,
- 36:48and your own community. Until next time, keep looking
- 36:51past the headlines.