Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Alexander's Ragtime Band (1938)
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. You remember when every 10
- 0:23minutes I would be like, in the Broadway melody.
- 0:28Did you miss that? Uh, sure. Oh, okay. No, I
- 0:33did miss it, but I have a feeling it's back.
- 0:36Yeah. Because now we're talking about Alexander's.
- 0:41Ragtime band. Okay. This is my question was whether
- 0:45or not you were going to do the actual version
- 0:47or just take the Broadway melody and put Alexander's
- 0:51Ragtime Band in there. Yeah, that's what I did.
- 0:52It's not very different. It's not. But then it
- 0:55is completely different. No, no. I mean in the
- 0:57song. Oh. Because when they first say it, it
- 1:00does sound a lot like Broadway melody. Does it?
- 1:02Yeah. Yeah, I forgot immediately. Because she
- 1:04kind of does like the jazz hands when she says
- 1:06it too. She does, yeah. We're getting so ahead
- 1:09of ourselves. How do you feel about Irving Berlin?
- 1:12You know. Nope. That's why I asked. Oh. Well,
- 1:15I don't know. I don't know. Like, meh. Meh. Meh.
- 1:20You're kind of doing, like, the stanky shoulder.
- 1:23Yeah. Like, you're kind of, like, doing that
- 1:25a little bit. So, I don't think I know enough
- 1:27to really form an opinion. That's what it is.
- 1:30Yeah. So, I'm kind of basing it off of the couple
- 1:32of things that I have seen that he's been involved
- 1:34with. Okay. Which is Top Hat. Which I like a
- 1:37lot. Like a lot. And Alexander's Ragtime Band,
- 1:40which I will reserve opinions till the end of
- 1:42the show. Have you not seen the other very big
- 1:45Irving Berlin? Is that White Christmas? Yeah.
- 1:47I've never seen it. Really? Yeah. I saw it for
- 1:50the first time like three or four years ago.
- 1:52And then I was like, well, I'm just watching
- 1:54this every Christmas season now. You liked it
- 1:56though. It's great. Okay. Big fan. That's really
- 1:59my go -to Irving Berlin for me when I want to
- 2:01watch anything of his. You know what? I'm going
- 2:05to be so honest with you. Anything of theirs.
- 2:06I have no idea. 100%. Anything of theirs. Yeah.
- 2:09Oh, I see. I don't know. I assume. Right. But
- 2:13who knows? So I was really excited when I saw
- 2:16that Irving Berlin had a very large part to do
- 2:20with Alexander's Ragtime Band, which is one that
- 2:23I feel like I've heard the name of for a while.
- 2:26And I may have even seen the poster, but I had
- 2:29no idea what it was. Yeah. I don't think that
- 2:32I had any kind of... knowledge of this at all
- 2:35i i wasn't even like oh i've heard of this this
- 2:37is just one of those that shows up in the list
- 2:40of 10 movies we cover in a month and i'm like
- 2:41yeah i don't know that one well i think it also
- 2:43just has a really cheery name so i was like this
- 2:45is gonna be a really fun watch among like you
- 2:48know the devastation of some other movies that
- 2:51yeah so i was like there's a good chance this
- 2:53one's not gonna rip my heart out so it should
- 2:55be okay um but also a very interesting reunion
- 2:59in this in when we watched on in old chicago
- 3:03I don't think that I would have thought that
- 3:05the reunion of some of the cast members here
- 3:08would have been in a Irving Thalberg musical.
- 3:12Yeah. But lo and behold, here they are. Irving
- 3:14Thalberg. Yeah. Is that not what I said? Irving
- 3:17Berlin. Oh, my God. I was like, what am I doing?
- 3:20Sorry. Wait a minute. Irving. That's a real name.
- 3:23I just don't know from what. The producer. That's
- 3:26totally what it was. Thank you so much. So, no.
- 3:29I wouldn't have thought of an Irving Berlin.
- 3:32Musical as the way that they come back into this.
- 3:34Yeah. So we are talking about Alexander's Ragtime
- 3:38Band, the movie of 1938. Not the song that I
- 3:43think is from 1911. Okay. We don't have to get
- 3:46into specifics right now. It had six nominations.
- 3:50And let's get into those nominations. Film editing.
- 3:52This was for Barbara McLean. Art direction for
- 3:56Bernard Hertzbrun and Boris Levin. Original song
- 4:00was for Now It Can Be Told by Irving Berlin.
- 4:03Original story was by Irving Berlin. Not just
- 4:07the music. He writes, too. They write. He writes.
- 4:10Music scoring was for Alfred Newman. And outstanding
- 4:14production was on behalf of 20th Century Fox.
- 4:17This was directed by Henry King, who we've spoken
- 4:22about quite a number of times in Old Chicago,
- 4:25you've already mentioned, but also State Fair.
- 4:28He is back with a vengeance in Alexander's Ragtime
- 4:31Band. And then the returning cast that you talked
- 4:34about, the reunion, is Tyrone Power as Alexander,
- 4:38the head of the band. His real name is Roger
- 4:40Grant in the movie. Alice Fay, who is the biggest
- 4:44part of this musical, the musical component of
- 4:47this musical. She plays Stella Kirby. And Donamiche,
- 4:51one of my favorite names to say in Hollywood,
- 4:53the friend of Roger Grant and eventual... Part
- 4:57-time lover of Stella Kirby. He plays Charlie
- 5:01Dwyer. A few other returning cast members here.
- 5:06We have Ethel Merman, Jack Haley, and John Carradine.
- 5:09But this is... How do I talk about this without
- 5:13immediately just like brushing it off to the
- 5:16side? I got you. There's classical musicians
- 5:20in Alexander. And his family has... Always been
- 5:25very excited whenever he's a part of a large
- 5:27orchestra and conducting. But he also has a side
- 5:32band with his friends. They end up playing a
- 5:35bar, but they don't have any music. They find
- 5:38sheet music at the bar for Alexander's Ragtime
- 5:40Band, and they start performing. They all of
- 5:43a sudden find Stella Kirby, who had brought the
- 5:45sheet music in, getting on stage with them to
- 5:47sing. And the pair of five musicians... Goes
- 5:53over like gangbusters and they're hired full
- 5:55time and eventually start an orchestra together
- 5:58called Alexander's Ragtime Band. And Roger takes
- 6:01on the titular role of Alexander and they tour
- 6:06the country. I think the world, really. Yeah.
- 6:09So that's the best way to put it. And also just
- 6:11the interpersonal relationship between Roger,
- 6:14Alexander, Stella and Charlie. Do you know the
- 6:18lore of Paramore? The band? Yes. A bit. I wouldn't
- 6:23know if I would call it lore, but sure. I feel
- 6:25like this is the story of Paramore. Kinda. A
- 6:28little bit. Except that Stella definitely does
- 6:31not become the face of Alexander's Ragtime Band
- 6:35like Hayley Williams did of Paramore. I think
- 6:38this is like the Inglourious Bastards version
- 6:40of Paramore. Oh my God. Yeah? Oh my God, I love
- 6:45that actually. Yeah? Yeah. Boom. They're like,
- 6:48what if we shot Hitler? Exactly. Of Paramore.
- 6:53Perfect. I'm proud of that one. I can't believe
- 6:56that I'm going to actually, with earnestness,
- 6:59be able to walk up to people and be like, I watched
- 7:01Alexander's Ragtime Band. They're like, how was
- 7:04it? And I'd be like, it was like Paramore, but
- 7:07if they killed Hitler. Yeah. And they'll be like,
- 7:10yeah, you nailed it. Wow, dude. Good job. Thanks,
- 7:13man. You wrap it up. Yeah, that's it. Hey, thanks
- 7:16for listening. Yeah, no, that sounds right. But
- 7:21the other aspect of this that's really interesting
- 7:24is that it's kind of like it's almost a biopic
- 7:27kind of. Yeah, a little bit. So Irving Berlin,
- 7:31not Thalberg, wanted to avoid making a biopic.
- 7:35He was like, I just I hate the idea of a biopic.
- 7:38I'm not going to do it. But they're like, we
- 7:40really want a movie like all of your music, though.
- 7:42He was like, well, then let's just do this. So
- 7:46this isn't a biopic, but it is the stand in for
- 7:49an Irving Berlin biopic because it features so
- 7:52many of his songs. So whereas like, you know,
- 7:55Bohemian Rhapsody, Michael, these movies are
- 7:58all kind of like about the person, but also feature
- 8:01all of the greatest hits of their music. That's
- 8:03what Alexander's Ragtime Band is the stand in
- 8:06for is the Irving musical. This is. That movie
- 8:11with the monkey. Better Man? Yes. Yeah. That
- 8:15is that. This is a jukebox musical. Robbie Williams.
- 8:18Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But a jukebox musical. Jukebox
- 8:21musical. I can't say that. That's hard. No, you
- 8:24got it. Jukebox. That's the one, though. Yeah.
- 8:26This is taking this Irvin Berlin's music and
- 8:30putting it into a story, a narrative, which at
- 8:33the end of this episode reminded me to tell you
- 8:35about my jukebox musical. Okay. I'm looking forward
- 8:38to it. Perfect. Alexander's Ragtime Band would
- 8:42have been more enjoyable for you if Alexander
- 8:46was a monkey. I think it would have been more
- 8:48enjoyable if Alexander was Hayley Williams. Who
- 8:51would be the monkey then? John Carradine, I think.
- 8:56Yeah, probably. Yeah, that sounds good. Yeah,
- 8:59I think so. I think their agent should have been
- 9:02a monkey. Agent? Oh, their agent. Yeah, like
- 9:05when he walks in with a cigar. He's like two
- 9:08feet tall, walks in with a cigar. But he still
- 9:11talks and just like, sales are through the roof,
- 9:13kid. Yeah, yeah. But you gotta ditch the dame.
- 9:17Yeah. Okay, but the cigar's a banana. I don't
- 9:19know why I didn't think about that before. Of
- 9:20course it is. I just assumed. So, Alexander's
- 9:25Ragtime Band. Here we have the three returning
- 9:29from in old Chicago, right? Mm -hmm. No acting
- 9:32nominations here. Not a single one, no. Film
- 9:35editing, art direction, original song, original
- 9:37story, music scoring, outstanding production,
- 9:39not a single acting. Not a single acting. Not
- 9:41even direction. Nope. Well, art direction. We've
- 9:44watched so many of these types of musicals at
- 9:47this point. And I think that it's a genre that
- 9:50maybe isn't my favorite, you know, because a
- 9:53lot of them do feel so incredibly similar. And
- 9:56some of them feel like... Other types of movies
- 9:59that have music kind of shoehorned into them.
- 10:01In Old Chicago, San Francisco are great examples
- 10:04of that. This one obviously has music surrounding
- 10:07the story and the plot a little bit more heavily
- 10:09than those films. But I don't know that this
- 10:13is the most interesting version of this film
- 10:16that we've seen. Tyrone Power, Alice Faye, and
- 10:20Donna Miche. How do you feel about this triangle
- 10:24of actors? uh i feel good about the three of
- 10:28them and i think they do a good enough job in
- 10:30this it just maybe it's because of my introduction
- 10:33to all three of them being in old chicago but
- 10:36there's just something about this movie that
- 10:39just it feels kind of like out of place like
- 10:42i don't know if the acting is great but the music
- 10:44is out of place or if the music is great but
- 10:46the acting is out of place i want to say that
- 10:49it's the latter because i mean obviously irving
- 10:52berlin being a big deal and like great songs
- 10:54the songs in this are fantastic too yeah they're
- 10:57fun but it just feels like they're kind of shoehorning
- 10:59like a story into the music and it doesn't really
- 11:03feel that inspired um so while this the music
- 11:07is great and i really appreciate some of the
- 11:09like you know performances given not even just
- 11:11the singing but like when they become a bigger
- 11:14band they have bigger performances like you know
- 11:17some names playing with them and i think these
- 11:19pieces are great But then the story kicks back
- 11:23in and you're like, okay. You know what it is?
- 11:25We just talked about The Adventures of Robin
- 11:27Hood. Yeah. And how there's incredible set pieces
- 11:30in that. And then the pacing of the drama scenes
- 11:34in between them loses you just a little bit.
- 11:37That's here, but it's more often. Because there's
- 11:40way more scenes in between the music than there
- 11:44is the music. Yeah. And I think that the music
- 11:47itself, you really only have one performer throughout.
- 11:51a majority of this movie. I think there's a gentleman
- 11:53that sings a song at one point, but it's really
- 11:57nothing special. There might be someone singing
- 11:59with Stella too. Yeah, but it's all presented
- 12:02in kind of a format that I thought we had left
- 12:06behind, which is set the camera up in the audience
- 12:09and just hit record. A lot of that feels like
- 12:12it. And there's not like a big dance number or
- 12:16anything. Alice Faye isn't... a dancer, or if
- 12:19she is, she hasn't showcased it at all in movies
- 12:21that we've seen. Yeah. She's kind of a, oh, who
- 12:26was she taking over for in Old Chicago? Like
- 12:31the actress? Mm -hmm. Oh, I'm not sure. It's,
- 12:34she done him wrong. Oh, oh my God. Shoot. I know
- 12:39who you're talking about. Why can't I think of
- 12:40her name? Mae West. Thank you. Yes. She's very
- 12:44much like a Mae West character to me. And I don't
- 12:47know if I, buy it from her the same way I did
- 12:49with Mae West. So, I don't know. The highlight
- 12:53here, I think, is supposed to be the musical
- 12:55performances, and they're never really exciting
- 12:57because it does feel kind of like a cookie -cutter,
- 12:59safe version of a Mae West performance. That
- 13:02feels right. Because while it's not necessarily
- 13:05burlesque, or any part of this is burlesque,
- 13:07it does come across as like the character herself.
- 13:12Yeah. She's the starlet, she's all eyes on me,
- 13:16you know. that element i see what you're saying
- 13:19with may west yeah even the way she speaks is
- 13:21very similar to may west totally she's got she's
- 13:24got a lot of uh spunk well i wonder if her actor
- 13:30or the character that she played in in old chicago
- 13:33carried over to this at all yeah they feel similar
- 13:36they do they feel very similar actually but that's
- 13:39the similarity in where it stops with in old
- 13:40chicago I would say. Yeah. Well, I think all
- 13:43of their characters kind of feel similar to me.
- 13:46Oh, really? Tyrone Power is definitely like a
- 13:48villain in Old Chicago. Right. Which he's not
- 13:52here. But I think that he still has the same
- 13:54type of charisma and charm. And unfortunately,
- 13:58he shares a little bit of the gross vulgarity
- 14:02in the way that he flirts with Alice Faye. Okay.
- 14:06It's not to the degree of... of like the non
- 14:09-consensual stuff that happens in an old Chicago.
- 14:12But I don't, their way of flirting is very like,
- 14:15boy, I want to take a swing at you. Yeah, me
- 14:19too. The ones that have such strong hatred for
- 14:22each other that it can only be love. Fight, fight,
- 14:25fight, kiss, kiss, that kind of thing. And it
- 14:28doesn't really do anything for me. So I think
- 14:30that like Tyrone Power is one of the most handsome
- 14:33actors that we've encountered in these old movies.
- 14:36I really think he's a good looking, I don't like
- 14:39the characters he plays. And I think that Alice
- 14:42Faye is a very beautiful woman. And I think that
- 14:44her voice is phenomenal when she's singing. But
- 14:48I'm not in love with her characters either. And
- 14:50I think it's because she feels like an imitation
- 14:53of somebody that we've seen before. Yeah, I was
- 14:57trying to determine if my prejudice on my feelings
- 15:02for, or rather, my feelings towards In Old Chicago
- 15:05was a prejudice for this movie. I was concerned
- 15:10that maybe I was carrying some of my disinterest
- 15:12in those characters and the acting and the story
- 15:16itself into Alexander's Ragtime Band. And I found
- 15:19myself feeling that way until the music started.
- 15:21And then when the music played, I was so into
- 15:23it. And it's because I enjoy the music of Irving
- 15:26Berlin. I almost did it again. So I found myself
- 15:30kind of in a mixed bag of like, I would be transported.
- 15:35Whenever the songs play. And I'm really into
- 15:37it. But then as soon as the songs end, I'm like,
- 15:40okay, we're doing this again. And maybe it's
- 15:42just so reminiscent of something in Old Chicago.
- 15:46And also just the musicals in general that we've
- 15:48gotten. Where it's like, hey, these two should
- 15:50be together. But they're not. Yeah. And here's
- 15:53the person that's stopping that. And he's not
- 15:54really a villain. But here's the complications
- 15:57of that, too. It's also like 90 minutes. But
- 16:00it feels like it's two hours. Yes, it does feel
- 16:03long, yeah. Because there's a whole subplot here
- 16:05where, like, Roger, Alexander, and some other
- 16:10characters go to war. Oh, God, I completely forgot
- 16:14about that. But I'm correct, right? Yes. I'm
- 16:16just making sure, because there's a real chance
- 16:18that I... I watched this over a week ago, so
- 16:20there's a real chance that this... I'll tell
- 16:23you that on the side. But there's a real chance
- 16:24that I've forgotten the subplot of that. Yeah.
- 16:27But I remember that they actually go to war and
- 16:29then come back. Yes. Because Stella leaves the
- 16:32band and they're like, well, what are we going
- 16:33to do now? And then they just join the war, which
- 16:36is what you do when your band doesn't work out.
- 16:39It's so funny how many of the movies we talk
- 16:41about that cover war are also musicals. And it's
- 16:45just like, we've got to go off and serve our
- 16:47country. And then there's like a sergeant that's
- 16:50really like barking orders at everyone. And you're
- 16:53like, oh, they're going to have to go do something
- 16:55serious. And he's like, rehearsals at eight.
- 16:57And you're like, oh, okay. Yes, Colonel Bob Fosse.
- 17:01Yeah. It's just so weird. Man, I forgot about
- 17:05the war stuff completely. Well, and that's the
- 17:07thing. There's no point to it. Exactly. Like,
- 17:08there's so much in this movie that just doesn't
- 17:10need to be there. Yeah. And it's one of those,
- 17:13like, we're kind of not splitting hairs, but
- 17:16we're talking badly about it. And it's not like
- 17:19this is a, you know, star and a half movie. Like,
- 17:21this isn't bad. It's just kind of uninteresting.
- 17:24And that sucks because, like, with Irving Berlin.
- 17:28one of the most notable names in like musical
- 17:30history, especially with songs. And again, the
- 17:33songs are great. Um, especially this first song
- 17:35of like Alexander's ragtime band is great. I
- 17:38mean, that's the whole reason that they call
- 17:39Roger Alexander. There's a fun setup to it. And
- 17:42like, I was really invested in that beginning
- 17:44where they're like, Hey, give it up for Alexander
- 17:46and his ragtime band. And like, well, my name's
- 17:48Roger. No, it's not. You're such a big hit. You're
- 17:51definitely Alexander. And that continues. There's
- 17:54such a fun setup to this that I think it just
- 17:56kind of like gets into, well, hey, where do we
- 17:58go from here? I don't know. What have we done
- 18:00before? Yeah. And Irving Berlin, like his music
- 18:04obviously does, you can't even say that his music
- 18:08kind of transcends like, you know, any idea of
- 18:10going to war or like, you know, that feels out
- 18:13of place. That's a huge part of White Christmas
- 18:15is like war and how it lends to the entertainment
- 18:18purpose here. You can hear some of the songs
- 18:21that are later represented in White Christmas,
- 18:24you know, one of my favorites. You can hear that
- 18:27here, like as a template or a starting note.
- 18:30But it definitely just feels like a warm up for
- 18:32something like that. I think also maybe this
- 18:34was my own fault, where I heard Irving Berlin.
- 18:38I was like, oh, I love White Christmas. Let's
- 18:40see how I feel about this one. Yeah. You know?
- 18:43But Irving Berlin's name isn't as attached to
- 18:46Alexander's Ragtime Man as it is White Christmas.
- 18:48Sure. So I'm sure that's a little intentional.
- 18:50I was looking back over the movies that we've
- 18:53watched for the podcast that kind of fall into
- 18:55the same sentiment, I think. So Flirtation Walk.
- 18:59Excellent. Yeah, Flirtation Walk. I think like
- 19:01One Night of Love is kind of similar. I would
- 19:04say so. That was the... It's opera. Opera, yeah.
- 19:07Yeah. I'm trying to find more now. I know there
- 19:10are more. Even, like, the Broadway melody of
- 19:121936. I would say Broadway melody, yeah. But
- 19:13I think that each one of these movies, in order
- 19:17for them to stand out, like, there has to be
- 19:20something in there. One unique element that really
- 19:23allows them to stand out. And, like, you could
- 19:25argue that the opera in One Night of Love is
- 19:28a little bit different. And then it kind of boils
- 19:30down to, like, you know, are you into opera or
- 19:32are you not? You're going to like it depending
- 19:34on that. Right. Something like Flirtation Walk,
- 19:37like... I don't remember either one of us being
- 19:39particularly into that. And you were, we were
- 19:44both kind of looking for something similar, like
- 19:46something that stands out. And we never found
- 19:48it. With Broadway Melody of 1936, there are some
- 19:51great set pieces in that. Those don't exist here
- 19:55in this one. Well, in multiple characters that
- 19:57are brought in, you know, it becomes like an
- 19:59ensemble piece. And with these, it's really just
- 20:01more the trio. Right. And at some point you get
- 20:04after, Are you talking about Jerry Allen? Yes.
- 20:09Yeah. She enters the picture as Alexander's wife
- 20:12when he finds out he can't be with Stella. But
- 20:16she's kind of not really an integral character.
- 20:19She's kind of just a plot device. So there's
- 20:23nothing in here that stands out. And Charlie
- 20:25feels a bit like a plot device at times, too.
- 20:28Like the only people who feel like they are like
- 20:30integral to the story are Alexander and Stella.
- 20:34Yeah, which is crazy because Charlie, Don Amiche's
- 20:37character, feels like the character I enjoy the
- 20:40most, I think. But he is. He's like a plot device.
- 20:43He's either the one kind of pushing Alexander
- 20:46to do right by Stella and his band, or he's the
- 20:50one that ends up with Stella. And the only reason
- 20:53that she leaves him is because he's like, hey,
- 20:56you should leave. You should go be with Alexander.
- 20:58He's the driving force behind it, but he's not
- 21:00written in a super interesting way. No. I don't
- 21:03know how to talk about this without just sounding
- 21:05like put, put all of these musicals that we've
- 21:08watched so far. Not all of them. You're Rogers
- 21:11in a stair. Like that's different, but put them
- 21:14all into a bowl and pull them out one by one.
- 21:17And like, you won't really be able to tell the
- 21:19difference. Well, I mean, even if you asked me
- 21:20about like specific musical sequences in this,
- 21:23I would kind of be hard pressed to tell you that.
- 21:25Yeah. Like if you, if you showed me specific
- 21:28sequences, With performances on stage, I might
- 21:31be able to differentiate if that's Broadway Melody
- 21:34of 1936 versus Broadway Melody versus this, and
- 21:38Flirtation Walk, certainly. But there's nothing
- 21:40that really stands out. Even looking at the original
- 21:42song nomination for Now It Can Be Told, I remember
- 21:45when I watched it, I was like, oh, that song's
- 21:47pretty good, and I like that performance. But
- 21:49I couldn't tell you anything about the performance
- 21:51now or how the song goes. I don't remember it
- 21:53at all. It's not extremely memorable. No. So
- 21:56it feels like one of those where it's a biopic
- 21:58that's made for someone whose legacy has not
- 22:01transcended beyond that time, right? Yeah. With
- 22:05Queen, Bohemian Rhapsody, Michael Jackson, with
- 22:08Michael. These are movies that, you know, even
- 22:11if you want to say the movies aren't very good,
- 22:12I think you can say that about Bohemian Rhapsody.
- 22:15I think I say that about Michael. You can't deny
- 22:19the power of those songs. And that's kind of
- 22:23what brings you back to that movie. It's like,
- 22:24yeah, but these songs have such a lasting legacy.
- 22:27To me, and maybe my great -grandparents feel
- 22:31differently about this, but these songs don't
- 22:34have a lasting impact to me. No. That carry the
- 22:37same kind of weight. And I think that's where
- 22:40this movie thrives, is the music. And I'm sure
- 22:43this hits even more so for people who loved these
- 22:45songs. Right? Yeah. But that doesn't do anything
- 22:48for us now. So this is like a time capsule movie
- 22:51that just doesn't do anything for us. And again,
- 22:54it's not terrible. It's just, it's there, and
- 22:57then it's over, and then you forget all about
- 22:59it. I think that's very accurate. But I'm trying
- 23:01to find the, like, I hope that's the right, succinct
- 23:04way to say it, rather than just like, it's forgettable.
- 23:06But it is. Yeah. And it's very small. It is.
- 23:09It's very small. The plot even feels insignificant.
- 23:13And I don't, man, I'm thinking about the ending
- 23:16of the movie, and I don't think that it even
- 23:17leaves a lasting impression that way. Like, you
- 23:19don't have a romantic moment. I mean, the romance
- 23:23for me was Charlie and Stella. They're better
- 23:25together, right? They're way better together.
- 23:27Yeah. And then when the movie tells you that
- 23:30it should be Alexander and Stella, you're like,
- 23:31I mean, not really. Should it? They're kind of
- 23:35like Joker and Harley Quinn a little bit. Like,
- 23:38I don't think. I think it's a little problematic,
- 23:40personally. That's a great way to put it. It's
- 23:43kind of like they bring out the worst in each
- 23:45other. Yeah. But one aspect that I thought was
- 23:47interesting was at least how Alexander wasn't
- 23:50like a musician in the band. He was more the
- 23:52composer. Yeah. So I think that harkens back
- 23:55to a one night with love kind of thing. Although
- 23:57I think that relationship was a bit more problematic
- 23:59in One Night of Love than in this. I'm not going
- 24:03to say either of them are relationship goals,
- 24:05but I'm just saying that I think One Night of
- 24:07Love... was a little more like, hey, call the
- 24:10cops. Yes. Like, call the police instead of,
- 24:13like, falling for this man, but okay. But yeah,
- 24:15there's really nothing that stands out too much
- 24:17in this. I will tell you, I forgot to mention
- 24:19this earlier, the screenplay is by Catherine
- 24:22Scola and Lamar Trotty. However, I did write
- 24:26down screenplay as Catherine Scola and not screenplay
- 24:30by. I think I just got caught up in the Tyrone
- 24:33Power as Alexander. So Catherine Scola is fitting
- 24:37in as the screenplay here, which is very strange.
- 24:40Let me ask you a question. Ethel Merman. Yeah.
- 24:43That's staying out to you, that name? Honestly,
- 24:47when I hear it, I think about Barnacle Boy. It's
- 24:49Merman. Yeah. Merman and Barnacle Boy. Mermaid
- 24:53Man. No, you're right. Is that what I'm doing?
- 24:57Yep. Yep, that's it. I thought that she played
- 25:00Ethel in I Love Lucy. Oh. which is interesting
- 25:04because I couldn't find that credit anywhere
- 25:06on her IMDb, but she plays herself in two episodes
- 25:10of The Lucy Show. Not I Love Lucy, but The Lucy
- 25:14Show. So I might be confusing those two things,
- 25:17but the name Ethel Merman does stand out to me.
- 25:20I just couldn't find any reason for why that
- 25:22should be the case. So maybe I should talk to
- 25:25some of my older peers about that. Uh, yeah,
- 25:28I don't know. She's in Airplane. She's in It's
- 25:30a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World. I mean, I've definitely
- 25:32seen her in Airplane. I love that movie. There's
- 25:34no business like show business. Who's she in
- 25:36Airplane? She is not listed on the first page.
- 25:41Oh, I remember her. She is Lieutenant Hurwitz.
- 25:45I don't know who that is. Neither do I. I need
- 25:47to rewatch that. Yeah. Love that movie, though.
- 25:50That was a classic when I was growing up. Rudolph
- 25:52and Frosty's Christmas in July. She Rudolph or
- 25:54Frosty? She's Lily Lorraine. I couldn't tell
- 25:57you. Is Frosty in this movie? Oh, there it is.
- 25:59Okay. Why is Rudolph like eighth build? Rudolph's
- 26:03got to talk to his agent. Is it by order of appearance?
- 26:06No, I don't think Letterboxd does that. That'd
- 26:08be crazy. Even if that is the case, why is Rudolph
- 26:10showing up so late in that movie? It's like 20
- 26:12minutes. Sounds like it's more Frosty and Rudolph.
- 26:15Yeah, you're right. Frosty, Lilith, and Rudolph,
- 26:18maybe? Maybe. Lily, Lily, Lily. Whoa. Lily, Lily.
- 26:23Lily, Lily. So. Let's stop beating around the
- 26:30bush here. We didn't care for this. No, and I
- 26:32didn't hate it. It's just we've done this. We've
- 26:35seen this. It's so middle of the road. It really
- 26:37is. And it was nominated for six different awards.
- 26:40And it did win scoring for Alfred Newman. And
- 26:43I think Alfred Newman is a name that is pretty
- 26:46massive with the Academy. Just the name Newman
- 26:50is huge. Randy, Paul. Exactly. Well, I don't
- 26:54think... They're all related, but Randy Newman
- 26:56is definitely related. Oh, I wasn't even going
- 26:58related. I was going off of the Newman name,
- 27:00but yeah. So at a time during the first iteration
- 27:02of the show, this may have changed, so forgive
- 27:04me if this fact does not still remain true, but
- 27:07the Newman family was the most nominated family
- 27:10in the history of the Academy Awards. Alfred
- 27:13Newman and Randy Newman are related. Interesting.
- 27:16Randy Newman's still out here getting nominated,
- 27:19and he might still be nominated this year. He
- 27:21will. So that's kind of a bummer because I don't
- 27:23really care for the scoring of Toy Story 3. Five.
- 27:29Sure. I think that he is going to be nominated.
- 27:33It doesn't really matter if it's good anymore.
- 27:34It's just more Randy Newman did something. Yeah.
- 27:36He's kind of entering. Well, I'll take that back.
- 27:40He's not entering the Diane Warren pantheon like
- 27:43that. Yes. But in terms of like, what's he doing?
- 27:46Get him nominated. That's that's real. That's
- 27:49fair. Alfred Newman, though, he's done the music
- 27:52for All About Eve, The Grapes of Wrath, How Green
- 27:55Was My Valley, Foreign Correspondent, Airport,
- 27:58and the movies we have seen, Dodsworth and Dead
- 28:01End. Oh, wow. These are all movies that we have
- 28:05either talked about or we will be talking about.
- 28:07Wuthering Heights, next year. Kind of an out
- 28:10-of -place movie for him in terms of scoring,
- 28:12too, Alexander's Ragtime Band. This one here.
- 28:14A little bit, yeah. Because if you're talking
- 28:15about Dodsworth, Dead End, Airport, Foreign Correspondent,
- 28:20like a lot of those, I wouldn't say they have
- 28:22the comedy of Alexander's Ragtime Band. No. Or
- 28:26levity. Or even the music style. Yes. So I think
- 28:28that this is a good little branch for Alfred
- 28:31Newman to showcase the range that he has. And
- 28:36while I don't necessarily think that this score
- 28:38was very memorable or anything to write home
- 28:41about, we just talked about Robin Hood. which
- 28:43has one of the most tremendous scores we've talked
- 28:46about on the podcast so far, this winning is
- 28:49very surprising for me. But because that is the
- 28:52only win of its six nominations, it's like, okay.
- 28:55I'll tell you the one that stood out to me was
- 28:57Original Story. Because it doesn't feel original
- 29:00anymore? We've been there? That and also it's
- 29:03just not that interesting. I think it's interesting
- 29:06for the first 15 minutes, and then you're like,
- 29:08what are we doing with this? It's a great logline.
- 29:10I think the log line of this is very interesting.
- 29:13But then as soon as you get to like the 15, 20
- 29:15minute mark, and they're like, yeah, so they're
- 29:18in love, but not really. But they are, but they
- 29:21can't be together. So he's going to war, but
- 29:23he's back. And I think they're together. It's
- 29:24like, okay. It's like the divorcee, how there's
- 29:28just back and forth. And then there's two other
- 29:30romantic interests. interests, one for each of
- 29:34the leads. And it really is. It's like, yeah,
- 29:37we've done this. We've seen this. We get it.
- 29:39We're good. Also, Jerry Allen deserves better.
- 29:41She does. She absolutely does. When she's like
- 29:44the second option for Alexander, I was like,
- 29:46come on, dude. Yeah. She deserves way better.
- 29:48She does. Boy, this is tough. It is tough. Film
- 29:52editing. So Barbara McLean, right? Like we've
- 29:55talked about her before as well. And I've...
- 30:00I remember praising her quite a bit. She did
- 30:02Les Mis. She did The House of Rothschild. But
- 30:06eventually we'll talk about her with All About
- 30:08Eve. There's some great stuff in all of those
- 30:11movies, I think. And this is an example of, do
- 30:14you remember the editing standing out at all?
- 30:16Do you remember being like, oh, she did great
- 30:19work. This movie is just so middle of the road.
- 30:24I'd really love to hear, I was looking at the
- 30:27Letterboxd reviews for this, right? And there's
- 30:29a lot of three stars, a lot of two and a half
- 30:32stars. And some of the words that are used to
- 30:35describe this in just like the main page are
- 30:38a lackluster showbiz tale. This uninspiring jukebox
- 30:43musical. It's, this just seems to be kind of
- 30:46like the general consensus. I mean, I think there
- 30:49was also just like, it was plagued with plagiarism
- 30:53claims as well. Like this, I noticed that there
- 30:57was a, in 1944, there was like plagiarism about
- 31:01a manuscript from like 1937 by an author named
- 31:07Marie Dyckhaus. Okay. I believe I'm saying that
- 31:11right. And she had put together the claim against
- 31:17Irving Berlin. It was eventually just reversed.
- 31:20The appeal was reversed, and nothing came out
- 31:23of it. But I think that that just also, when
- 31:25you talk about an original story, and then you
- 31:27get a claim like that, it's a tough beat. So
- 31:32I don't know. This wasn't really well -received
- 31:34by me. I'm not going to say that the lawsuit
- 31:37had anything to do with that. That was something
- 31:39that I found out in reading about it. But there's
- 31:41just something in the movie that just is not
- 31:43as engaging. I totally agree. Do you remember
- 31:47any particular scene like standing out and being
- 31:49worth talking about? I think that some of the,
- 31:56you know, I look at art direction on this and
- 31:58I had some questions too, but the only time that
- 32:00art direction makes some sense to me is whenever
- 32:02the band is performing, the venues look amazing.
- 32:05Yeah. Like I think that you're right that the
- 32:08camera just kind of like parks in films, but.
- 32:11as the band continues its success, it grows and
- 32:13grows in size. So it really does become like
- 32:16an orchestra that he is like, you know, conducting.
- 32:19And I think there's even like, it's not necessarily
- 32:22a scene, but the idea that like Alexander comes
- 32:25to defend ragtime is interesting. Cause this
- 32:28is a movie where like the most interesting thing
- 32:30about it is a C plot story in it where like his
- 32:33parents have always like praised. classical music.
- 32:39Right. And then when he plays Ragtime, they're
- 32:40like, what are you doing playing that crap? Right.
- 32:43You need to get back to classical music. You're
- 32:44wasting your time. So whenever there's any kind
- 32:47of claim in the movie where they're like, well,
- 32:48yeah, for a Ragtime band, pretty good. He's like,
- 32:50hey, there's way more to it than that. That is
- 32:52interesting. Yeah. And if they had kind of leaned
- 32:54into that as like a major storyline of it, I
- 32:57think I'd be, you know, much more engaged. So
- 32:59it's not a specific scene, but that to me stood
- 33:03out as like something that I really enjoyed.
- 33:05Unfortunately, it has nothing to do with editing.
- 33:07Sure, yeah. So that doesn't really answer your
- 33:09question. And I wasn't asking specifically about
- 33:11editing, just in the movie in general. I like
- 33:14that idea. I like the idea of having to defend
- 33:17something like Ragtime. I don't think it was
- 33:19set in 1938. I don't know the exact time. I don't
- 33:23even know. But I don't think it was trying to
- 33:26say for the general public, hey, Ragtime's really
- 33:28good. I think it was just more this was a difficult
- 33:31musical style to get embraced by the classical
- 33:35crowd. Yeah, I don't know when it would have
- 33:38taken place because they are sent off to war,
- 33:40like you said. And I assume they're talking about
- 33:42the First World War and not the coming war. That
- 33:46seems very dark to be like, we're going, you
- 33:50know, like predicting World War II. So I guess,
- 33:54yeah, like the late 1910s. Is that how you describe
- 33:57that? Movie towards the beginning after Stella
- 34:00and Alexander join up. where they are about to
- 34:05go on and Alexander enters her dressing room.
- 34:08And she's done up kind of very Mae West. She's
- 34:13got a very sparkly dress and she has a headpiece
- 34:15and all of this and lots of jewelry. And I thought
- 34:19it was interesting at first because he comes
- 34:21in and he's like, what are you doing? Why are
- 34:23you dressed like that? This is not what this
- 34:24show is about. And she's really defending herself
- 34:27and she's coming at him strong. And I liked that.
- 34:31Until he just kept going. And eventually he's
- 34:34like taking these pieces of clothing off of her.
- 34:37He's taking off her headpiece and ripping off
- 34:39the shawl or something. All of that. And I think
- 34:43that that is when I was like, oh, Tyrone Power
- 34:45is back playing this type of character where
- 34:47he's just like, whatever I say goes. And it left,
- 34:50again, such a bad taste in my mouth that I was
- 34:53just disappointed in what I, that's like at the
- 34:56beginning of the movie. And it was like, oh,
- 34:57this is what I'm going to have to deal with the
- 34:58next hour. Well, and it's important to note that
- 35:02when Stella Kirby brings that sheet music, she
- 35:05is the performance, right? There's not a band
- 35:07behind her. It's just someone else's, like, I
- 35:09think the piano maybe is playing. But she is
- 35:12the entertainer. So she's bringing this burlesque
- 35:14nature to the role. So that's what she continues
- 35:17to do as Alexander's ragtime band continues its
- 35:20success. And he kind of stops her. And it almost
- 35:23sounds like he's doing it from a way that's defending
- 35:26ragtime. Right. But it almost comes across as
- 35:29like, don't demean me this way yeah it's it's
- 35:32very controlling yes for the almost like the
- 35:37sake of his honor and and the respect of him
- 35:40like hey if my family's gonna see me perform
- 35:42they already don't like this music you're gonna
- 35:43make a mockery of that yeah so it's not like
- 35:46hey have some like honor in yourself like have
- 35:49some dignity right doesn't come across that way
- 35:52it comes across as like i'm not gonna be seen
- 35:53on stage with that right and then he he proceeds
- 35:56to use her Because some big producer comes in
- 35:59or some big theatrical director or something
- 36:03comes into a restaurant and he uses her as a
- 36:07pawn to like sweet talk him and get the band
- 36:09a show in New York. Stella just gets offered
- 36:12the chance to go to New York by herself. And
- 36:15instead of being supportive, Alexander criticizes
- 36:18her and like kind of blows off their relationship.
- 36:21Yeah. So it's constantly Tyrone Power just. using
- 36:26and abusing Stella. But because of the way that
- 36:28their romance is built, it's very much like,
- 36:31hey, I can't stand you. I want to take a swing
- 36:36at you. Smooch, smooch. And it's really kind
- 36:39of hard to watch a lot of the time. Yeah, it's
- 36:41not a romantic movie. No, not at all. So it's
- 36:46something that I enjoyed fine. But just once
- 36:51it was over, I was like, okay, it's over. There
- 36:53wasn't much keeping me engaged throughout or
- 36:56that I was hoping the best for these people.
- 36:58Right. And I feel like we should have gotten
- 37:00to know the band a bit more. Yeah, yeah. In the
- 37:02beginning, you see Roger with his bandmates.
- 37:07But then as it grows more and more, you don't
- 37:11see that. As much as I didn't love 100 Men and
- 37:15a Girl, at least those band members felt like
- 37:18they were part of it. And it wasn't just Deanna
- 37:20Durbin and Adolph Menjoo. It was like, oh, well,
- 37:23there are other people in this band. In this,
- 37:25it does just kind of feel like... I think the
- 37:28drummer is someone who hangs out with Roger a
- 37:30good bit and goes to war with him. But that's
- 37:33about it. That sounds right. Because he's almost
- 37:36like a comical person when they go to war. Yeah.
- 37:39And the war is so, like, not serious at all.
- 37:43Well, it's like you said, where it's Cadet Kelly,
- 37:45where they're like... Drop and give me five harmonies.
- 37:49Right. Yeah. The end of this movie has Alexander's
- 37:55band, ragtime band, performing and Stella is
- 37:59in the audience. And at this point, they've both
- 38:03kind of come to the realization that they love
- 38:05each other. Stella has left her relationship
- 38:08with Charlie and Alexander, I believe, has separated
- 38:12from Jerry. I believe so. I believe so. And so
- 38:17he gets wind that she's in the audience and he
- 38:20invites her on stage. Like he announces her.
- 38:23There's like a whole sequence with her in the
- 38:25cab too earlier in the movie. Do you remember
- 38:27that? Where she's kind of like forced to listen
- 38:30to the radio. Yes. She's like, turn it off, turn
- 38:32it off. And he's like, no. I don't listen to
- 38:33that anymore. Yeah. He was like, this is my car.
- 38:36We listen to what I want to listen to. Which,
- 38:38you know, three stars for this Uber. Am I right?
- 38:41I would give five stars for that Uber. Would
- 38:43you? Well, because he's right. Yeah, he is right.
- 38:46But I... Yeah. I'll say four. He probably could
- 38:49have been like, I'll turn it down. I'll give
- 38:51him four and a half stars so they have something
- 38:53to work towards. It's one of my favorites. Anyway,
- 38:57at the final show, Alexander invites her on stage
- 39:00and they perform together. They sing together,
- 39:03which really is just her performing and Tyrone
- 39:06Powers waving his arms in front of his band.
- 39:08Yeah. Well... Some respect for conducting. I
- 39:11have respect for conducting, but what we're watching
- 39:13in the movie, like Tyrone Powers is not, you
- 39:16know, he's acting. Heard. There's no performance
- 39:18element to him the way somebody like Fred Astaire
- 39:22would do with Ginger Rogers if they were both
- 39:24doing this movie. And they sing together, and
- 39:27it kind of just ends with them performing. There's
- 39:30no embrace. There's no romantic moment. You just
- 39:34kind of assume that, okay, they let bygones be
- 39:37bygones. They perform together, and that's really
- 39:40what's important in their relationship. They're
- 39:42probably not going to get along for the rest
- 39:43of their life. So you're left feeling kind of
- 39:46nothing. So the reason that whenever we talk
- 39:49about something like Top Hat or The Gate of Orsay,
- 39:53and you mentioned that it comes across as very
- 39:57problematic in how Fred Astaire is chasing after
- 40:01Ginger Rogers or kind of bothering her when she
- 40:04says she doesn't want to be bothered. That never
- 40:06strikes me as problematic in those movies because
- 40:09we get to see who he is. And we see like how
- 40:12much fun he has dancing, how whimsical he is
- 40:15when he actually falls for someone. You see that
- 40:17in his like character. Yeah. With Tyrone Power,
- 40:21he really does just seem like, hey, I'm good
- 40:23at this conducting thing. And I guess I landed
- 40:25into ragtime. So I guess we're just going to
- 40:27do this. And you don't get to see him in his
- 40:30whimsy. You don't get to see him in his joy.
- 40:32This is just kind of who he is. So when he does
- 40:34those things to Stella Kirby, it feels kind of
- 40:38like, well, that's who he is. This isn't just
- 40:40him being frustrated with her. That is who he
- 40:44is in a relationship. That, to me, comes across
- 40:46as more, I don't know if problematic is the word,
- 40:48but unenjoyable. in a relationship of like hey
- 40:51why would you even want to do this yeah he's
- 40:53a good conductor and i guess like the three of
- 40:55you are good friends but we're not seeing enough
- 40:57of you individually for me to understand why
- 41:00you'd want to be in a relationship so that's
- 41:03why i think in in the past i've been like oh
- 41:05i didn't even think of that as you know a problem
- 41:07in a relationship because we saw the character
- 41:10in uh separately yeah In this, we don't really
- 41:14see him too much as a separate character. You
- 41:16don't. At least enough. And anytime you do see
- 41:18him, it's not a representation of how he would
- 41:21behave with Stella if he ended up with her. So
- 41:25yeah, I know this will end up being a shorter
- 41:29episode because I don't want to just keep kind
- 41:31of criticizing the movie. I think that's okay.
- 41:33Yeah, I think so too. When it comes to ratings,
- 41:37what would you give this? I'll tell you what
- 41:39I did give it. I gave it three and a half. Really?
- 41:45And I don't know why. Okay. Oh, no, no, no. I
- 41:49changed it to three. Oh, okay. Okay. Even that
- 41:52seems a little high for this. Again, I like Irving
- 41:56Berlin, and I did rate this as soon as I was
- 41:58done watching the movie. Right. So this might
- 42:00be like the music had me a little on cloud nine,
- 42:03like I was into it. But now, a week out, I can't
- 42:07tell you what I really enjoyed about it that
- 42:09much outside of the music. So it's probably closer
- 42:11to a two and a half for me. But I did initially
- 42:14rate it three and a half. And I think a day later,
- 42:17I was like, that's not right. And I moved it
- 42:19back down. Yeah, three and a half would have
- 42:20been wild. I did give this two and a half stars.
- 42:24You know who gave it four stars? What happened,
- 42:28Bryce? You know. Bryce says his first sentence
- 42:31of his review, don't get the hate at all. Oh,
- 42:34okay. Well, you know, we were going to have him
- 42:36on an episode eventually. I don't know that we
- 42:38can. I think it would be too controversial at
- 42:40this point. I also feel like the way that Tyrone
- 42:44Power and Alice Faye butt heads, that's us, you
- 42:48know? That's you and me? That's me and Bryce.
- 42:50Oh, yeah. And you too. You and me are both Tyrone
- 42:53Power. Well, I don't want to be Tyrone Power.
- 42:55Can I be Ethel Merman? You can be whoever you
- 42:57want, baby. Thank you. Yeah, I don't know. This
- 43:00is so middle of the road. Again, it's not terrible.
- 43:04It's just like, man, I wish this was better.
- 43:06Yes. It's almost more interesting if it's just
- 43:09not good. Yeah. Yeah, I think so too. But this
- 43:13really is like throw it in a fishbowl and let's
- 43:16draw out which one of these mediocre musicals
- 43:19we want to watch today. But if you have any kind
- 43:22of concern about Irving Berlin, don't. He's A
- 43:25-okay. He goes on to do incredible things. White
- 43:28Christmas is on the horizon. Don't even worry
- 43:30about him. Yeah. Or them. I won't. Double feature.
- 43:35Yeah, double feature. I went with a film that
- 43:39also was about the forming of a band and the
- 43:42interpersonal relationships between them. Kind
- 43:45of doing a double feature thing here with our
- 43:47last episode of Adventures of Robin Hood, where
- 43:50I'm looking at like family children's films and
- 43:54kind of finding the corresponding relationship
- 43:56in them. I went with the 2011 film by Patricia
- 44:00Riggin called Lemonade Mouth. You ever heard
- 44:03about this? No. This is a Disney Channel original
- 44:05movie. Oh. And it's Bridget Mendler, I think,
- 44:09is the lead. And she starts a ska band in her
- 44:14high school. And this is just about their rise
- 44:17into popularity and their personal relationships.
- 44:21And because she's the lead and the guitarist,
- 44:23I think, he kind of stands in for the Tyrone
- 44:25Power character in this. I'm pairing these two
- 44:28together. 2011? Yeah. A ska band. Yep. Less Than
- 44:33Jake was well into its discography at this time.
- 44:37Right. They were well into it. Yeah. And then
- 44:39nobody else was into ska. Until Lemonade Mouth.
- 44:42That brought it back. You're right. Maybe that's
- 44:46what it is. I missed Lemonade Mouth. There's
- 44:47a lot of local ska bands that I could throw out
- 44:49right now, and I would say words, and you'd be
- 44:52like, yep, those are words. This is true. So
- 44:55I'll refrain. I... Taj Motel Cheerio. Are you
- 44:59familiar with the Super Villains? Yeah. Yeah,
- 45:01one time when I was a kid, I went and I saw the
- 45:04Red Hot Chili Peppers with my cousin David and
- 45:07my dad. And we were sitting there and it was
- 45:09the first time I'd ever seen the Chili Peppers.
- 45:11And that was like my favorite band growing up.
- 45:13And my dad, I remember him being like, hey boy,
- 45:17there's a girl sitting behind us. You should
- 45:20talk to her. And it was a girl our age at the
- 45:23time. We were in middle school. And I was like,
- 45:25no, I'm not going to do that. Absolutely not.
- 45:27No, no way. I'm shy. And my cousin turned around
- 45:30and was like, hey, what up? Immediately. And
- 45:33they ended up talking for like a long time. She
- 45:36ended up being like the cousin, I think, of the
- 45:39bass player of the supervillains. Oh, wow. Yeah.
- 45:41And I was like, oh, that's so wild. How close
- 45:45I was to having a connection to a ska band. Wow.
- 45:48So maybe Lemonade Mouth, Lemonade Mouth, Lemonade
- 45:54Mouth. There it is. You know, really is for me.
- 45:56And I should check it out. You're going to lose
- 45:58your mind when you find out it was written by
- 46:00that girl who went to the Red Hot Chili Peppers
- 46:02show. I wonder how she's doing. Well, you know
- 46:06what she did with the money that she earned from
- 46:07this? What'd she do? She gave it away. Gave it
- 46:10away, give it away now? There you go. I got it,
- 46:12I got it. Lemonade Mouth. Okay, I'll have to
- 46:15look into that. You don't need to. I'm not saying
- 46:20it's a better movie than Alexander's Ragtime
- 46:22Band. I'm just saying it's a memorable one about
- 46:25when Disney was like, hey, what are kids doing
- 46:27now? Listening to Scott. They're like, well,
- 46:30look, we've had them figure skating. We've had
- 46:32them rollerblading. We've done bowling. What
- 46:36have we not done? And someone's like, music.
- 46:38And they're like, great, we haven't done music.
- 46:39So I guess they're going to start, and they're
- 46:41about to say, rock, pop, hip hop. And someone
- 46:44in the back's like, the Scott Band. Sure. It's
- 46:47the one guy from Real Big Fish that is like hanging
- 46:49on. And you know how he even got into that building
- 46:53with all the executives. How's that? He sold
- 46:55out. Damn. Damn. Man, if someone doesn't know
- 46:58Red Hot Chili Peppers or ska music in this, these
- 47:02jokes are just... Trust me. These jokes are just...
- 47:06Guaranteed. Guaranteed. What's your double feature?
- 47:10So my double feature, hang on with me. I did
- 47:13Lemonade Mouth. How crazy are you going to get?
- 47:16I went with a movie that has a very sassy female
- 47:21lead, right? Lemonade. Very similar to Stella,
- 47:24played by Alice Faye. Lemonade. And I went with
- 47:27a movie that involves kind of a spunky leading
- 47:31man who I would say has almost like an abrasive
- 47:36personality, but it's still kind of fun. You
- 47:38know, he's into ragtime. He's into something
- 47:40exciting and fun. He doesn't like boring classical
- 47:44music. which you could compare to something like
- 47:47broccoli, maybe. And I went with a movie that
- 47:50also stars kind of a wise third character who
- 47:55does his best to help push along everybody on
- 47:59this incredible journey together, who also happened
- 48:03to be voiced by Don Amice. I went with Homeward
- 48:07Bound. Who was Don Amice? Shadow. Don Amice is
- 48:12Shadow in Homeward Bound. Like... The one with...
- 48:15Is Matthew Broderick Chance? Michael J. Fox.
- 48:19Michael J. Fox. Thank you so much. And then Sally
- 48:21Field is Sassy. Correct. Why on earth did I think
- 48:25Liam Neeson was Shadow? Peter. Peter. I don't
- 48:32know where you are. I will find... He might say
- 48:35that. He might. I'll find you. That's Don Amidje.
- 48:40I always thought that it was... Oh, he's in Tombstone.
- 48:45It was his last role in Tombstone. Charlton Heston.
- 48:49He was in Tombstone after Homeward Bound? No,
- 48:51no, no. Don Amiche is not in Homeward Bound.
- 48:52I always think that Charlton Heston, who is in
- 48:56Tombstone, voiced Shadow. Didn't you just say
- 48:59Don Amiche was Shadow? Don Amiche is Shadow.
- 49:02But you just said Don Amiche wasn't in Homeward
- 49:04Bound. He's not in Tombstone. Charlton Heston
- 49:06is not in Homeward Bound. Anyway, I went with
- 49:09Homeward Bound because Don Amice is in it, and
- 49:11I really like Homeward Bound and Don Amice's
- 49:14Shadow. I love that watching Don Amice in these
- 49:16movies has resulted in, I've always heard him
- 49:20say the word sassy. Sassy. Yeah. Sassy. That
- 49:24movie makes me cry. Oh my God, it's incredible.
- 49:27Yeah, The Incredible Journey. I love at the end
- 49:30when they're like, I guess he was just too old.
- 49:33And you're like, my God. And then you just hear,
- 49:37Peter. Peter, my boy. Well, it becomes. I don't
- 49:43know why, but I think that scene is roughly three
- 49:45minutes long of Shadow on the Hill. Yeah. And
- 49:48Peter. Shadow. Peter. Peter. Shadow. My boy.
- 49:53Oh, my God. So completely different movie. Is
- 50:00it? I tried to tie in, you know, the sassy and
- 50:02the. No, you got it. You know, it's nothing like
- 50:06it. You think Shadow doesn't like ragtime? I
- 50:08think he's too busy. He's too busy protecting
- 50:10Peter. You know? Shadow's right on, man. You
- 50:14know what always bugs me? When they're like,
- 50:16oh, we're going to go pick up, they found him
- 50:17at this ranch or whatever. Yeah. We're going
- 50:19to go pick him up. And the car drives by like
- 50:22just as they walk into the woods to try and get
- 50:24home and they cross paths. Yeah. And the family
- 50:27is all singing, I told the witch doctor I was
- 50:31in love with you. And you're like, that always,
- 50:34even as a kid, I was like, look out the window.
- 50:38It's not even that that bothers me. It's more
- 50:40like your dogs are missing. Like your whole pets.
- 50:43All three of them are missing. All three of them.
- 50:45And you're just being like, hey, we're on the
- 50:46way. You know, we should blast. Ting, tang, walla,
- 50:49walla, bang, bang. It drives me nuts. Hey, maybe
- 50:52we don't have the radio on. I just know that
- 50:54as a kid, I'd be sitting in the back seat like,
- 50:57I miss Shadow. You'd be like, is that Shadow?
- 51:01Right, like I'd be looking out the window. I'd
- 51:03be doing that thing where my fingers are running
- 51:05out the window. It's just, it's absurd. I can't
- 51:07stand it. Anyway. This is how I learn of the
- 51:10connection between In Old Chicago and Homeward
- 51:13Bound. Yeah, which is wild because In Old Chicago
- 51:16takes place in, oh, Chicago, never mind. San
- 51:20Francisco takes place in San Francisco and Homeward
- 51:22Bound 2 is lost in San Francisco. Were you about
- 51:25to say that In Old Chicago took place in San
- 51:28Francisco? Alexander's Ragtime Band takes place
- 51:31in San Francisco, and Homeward Bound 2 takes
- 51:33place in San Francisco. Boom! Nailed it. Isn't
- 51:36it called Lost in San Francisco? I think so.
- 51:38Anyway. Is Don Amiche in that? Because that should
- 51:41have been your WP. There's definitely a line.
- 51:44If he's in it, there's definitely a line where
- 51:46he's like, I haven't been to San Francisco since
- 51:481936. Do you want to do the closing while I look
- 51:53up? If he was in that? Yeah. All right. So if
- 51:56you listen to this episode and you said, man,
- 51:57I need to get more of that, you can always check
- 52:00us out on Spotify or anywhere else that you get
- 52:03your podcasts, including Apple Podcasts. If you
- 52:08want to reach out to us and say, hey, guys, you
- 52:10got Alexander's Ragtime Band all wrong. It's
- 52:13actually this good, and here's how good it is.
- 52:15Feel free to send over that and any delusions
- 52:17that you have along with it to our email, which
- 52:20is outaopodcast at gmail .com. You can also check
- 52:25out our Patreon if you feel so inclined to financially
- 52:29support. the podcast. Thank you so much. We have
- 52:32exclusive episodes of Horror of the Overlooked,
- 52:35including any bonus episodes we release. You
- 52:38have early releases on all the episodes that
- 52:40we release. And you also get access to our Discord
- 52:44to talk through all the fun stuff that we're
- 52:46going through at the time. There's no way it's
- 52:48taking you this long to look up San Francisco
- 52:49in Homeward Bound 2. Ralph Waite was the voice
- 52:53of Shadow in Homeward Bound 2, Lost in San Francisco.
- 52:56Homeward Bound 1 came out in 1993. Dr. BJ died
- 52:59in 1994. He died in 1993. Yeah. Uh, Peter, my
- 53:06boy guys, that's going to do it for this episode
- 53:09of once upon a time at the Oscars. Thank you
- 53:12so much for listening. Uh, next episode we'll
- 53:14be covering. Are you affected by this news? Uh,
- 53:18you know, I'm fine. I'm fine. Next episode is
- 53:21four daughters. So stay tuned for that. As always,
- 53:26I'm Kyle. I'm confused, but I'm Ryan. And we'll
- 53:29see you. See you at the movies.