Latest / Politics with Paul / Why Our Ideas for Fixing Politics Aren’t as Easy and Obvious as We Think | Politics with Paul #81
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08Today, we're gonna talk about why our ideas for fixing politics aren't as easy and obvious as
- 0:15we think.
- 0:16And this topic was prompted by a Substack post written by a podcast guest of mine from a few
- 0:22weeks ago, Stephanie Houghton.
- 0:24Basically, idea was how people often think they have the answers to fixing democracy in
- 0:29America, but we often think they are far easier and more obvious solutions than they really
- 0:35are.
- 0:35We can all fall into this trap of thinking our policy or reform solution is more obvious,
- 0:41sound, and foolproof than it actually is.
- 0:43Though for some people, that's a chronic attitude.
- 0:46And to be honest, I find it kind of obnoxious when people regularly think they have an easy
- 0:52solution to politics and political problems such as, oh, we need to get money out of
- 0:57politics, or we need to get rid of the electoral college.
- 1:00Not saying that those things are wrong or anything like that, but I'm saying that those
- 1:03are just they're not really in-depth.
- 1:06It's as if other people haven't been able to come up with obvious solutions before.
- 1:12When it's something wide ranging and broad, it's never going to be an easy fix.
- 1:18And that's not to dunk on people's thoughts and opinions about reforming politics.
- 1:22We should encourage people to suggest ideas, but we also need to get people to think more
- 1:30critically about their own ideas for reform and how to make these reforms potentially happen.
- 1:37So what are the most critical things to think about when you are designing your own ideas or
- 1:43thinking about other people's ideas for making American politics function better or for
- 1:48improving policy?
- 1:49Well, that's what we're talking about today.
- 1:51So here we go.
- 1:53First of all, we need to talk about a prevalent problem in politics, this level of political
- 2:01overconfidence that we see.
- 2:03We often think our ideas for fixing politics are more sound or obvious because we all think
- 2:08we know more about politics than we actually do.
- 2:12It's what many researchers and commentators call political overconfidence.
- 2:16And all of us can exhibit this to some extent, but for some people it's a very common thing to
- 2:22do.
- 2:22Academic research has shown a propensity for political overconfidence in the public.
- 2:29It's similar to that Dunning Kruger effect where people are often poor at self assessing
- 2:33their knowledge and skills, oftentimes overestimating them.
- 2:38But how does this political overconfidence manifest?
- 2:41Well, one, it makes us more defensive of factually wrong beliefs about politics.
- 2:47We think we've already got them figured out.
- 2:49So somebody coming in to try to tell us, well, actually, no.
- 2:51That's not what it is.
- 2:52We think, oh, this person is an idiot.
- 2:54They don't know what they're talking about.
- 2:55I've got this figured out.
- 2:57Number two, we underestimate the political skill of our peers.
- 3:02Our peers being sometimes people who think similarly than us, but we still think we know
- 3:08more than them or people, especially on the other side of an argument.
- 3:13We tend to think, well, they don't know what I think.
- 3:16So they don't know what I know.
- 3:18They don't think what I think.
- 3:19So they obviously don't know what they're talking about.
- 3:22That's another example of political overconfidence.
- 3:24Number three, those who believe themselves to be political experts often dismiss the guidance
- 3:30of real experts.
- 3:31There's a lot of self professed experts in politics as a former professor of mine called
- 3:36the local political genius.
- 3:38You see them talk all the time on social media.
- 3:41And that's not to say that real experts can't also be susceptible to overconfidence, but
- 3:45there are some people who have not really worked in or studied a field in politics and
- 3:52think they know all about it.
- 3:55Another way political overconfidence manifests is that it interacts with political
- 3:59partisanship in making partisans less willing to listen to peers across the aisle.
- 4:06So if I'm a Republican, all those Democrats are stupid.
- 4:09If I'm a Democrat, all those Republicans are stupid.
- 4:11If I'm an and I'm an independent, all the Republicans and Democrats are stupid.
- 4:15And then Republicans and Democrats might think independents are stupid.
- 4:18It's not really born out of, oh, we're critiquing really what these people are
- 4:22thinking.
- 4:23We think we're critiquing what they're thinking, but, really, we're just looking at
- 4:26their labels and assuming their intelligence at that point and overestimating our intelligence.
- 4:33Another way that political overconfidence manifests is that it increases our affective
- 4:38polarization.
- 4:39That is to say our negative feelings toward opposition.
- 4:42We get angry at them.
- 4:44We are more disgusted by them.
- 4:46We think even more that they're dumb or that we should be fearful of them.
- 4:52They don't know what they're talking about, and they're going to destroy everything.
- 4:55And then lastly, political overconfidence manifests itself as a more staunch ideological
- 5:02and partisan unity or partisan unity.
- 5:05Now that's not to say that people who aren't hardcore partisans or ideologues can't also be
- 5:11politically overconfident.
- 5:12Again, it can happen to anybody, but you do see it a lot in people who are very far to either
- 5:18the right or the left because they're very set in those ways and thinking that their ideology
- 5:23explains everything in the world.
- 5:25And look, I've been guilty of some of these things too.
- 5:28I'm not gonna pretend that I am an exception to the rule because every one of us has been
- 5:32guilty of it.
- 5:33But some people are regularly guilty of it, and we need to be a lot more self introspective and
- 5:40self reflecting.
- 5:42And there's also a problem that some people have a psychological intolerance of
- 5:47uncertainty.
- 5:48They have to have a stable view of the world.
- 5:51They it all it almost makes them sick to think that's there's more nuance and uncertainty in
- 5:59the world, especially with stronger partisans.
- 6:02But you don't have to be one of those to have an aversion to uncertainty.
- 6:06Politics is with very few exceptions as black and white as it's often made out to be.
- 6:12There are just all these nooks and crannies that you have to account for.
- 6:16And when human beings are involved, there's going to be some sort of flaws in their
- 6:21reasoning no matter how logical we think we are.
- 6:24So one of the fronts, if you will, to talk about when it comes to thinking we know more
- 6:30about or that our political ideas are more sound than they actually are is we don't really
- 6:36do a good job of distinguishing between vague and specific ideas.
- 6:41You really should know this difference between whether your solution is vague or specific.
- 6:47Because a vague idea, a general, broad, this is what we need to do, that is not a solution.
- 6:54It is merely the semblance or beginning of a solution.
- 6:58But how do you know it's a vague idea?
- 7:01Well, for one, it sounds more like an ideal than an actual policy.
- 7:05So if you hear somebody say, we need to get money out of politics.
- 7:08Okay.
- 7:09Maybe we need to do that, but that's that's not an actual solution.
- 7:12That's not an actual reform.
- 7:15How are you going to get that money out of politics?
- 7:18How are you going to limit money's impact on politics?
- 7:22You have to get more specific on that.
- 7:24That's how you actually come up with a solution.
- 7:26Another way that you know it's a vague idea is that it's more of the end goal of an idea, not
- 7:31the idea itself.
- 7:34So maybe you're thinking, we need to increase voter turnout.
- 7:37That's not, again, that's that's not an actual solution.
- 7:41That is a very vague idea that could become a solution.
- 7:44How are you exactly going to achieve that increased voter turnout?
- 7:49And that could be a whole bunch of different things, both indirectly and directly impacting
- 7:54voter turnout.
- 7:56And then another way you know that an idea is vague and therefore not really an actual
- 8:01solution is it doesn't really include any specific provisions on what to do.
- 8:05So it might sound a little bit more specific like we need an age limit on government
- 8:11officials.
- 8:11Okay.
- 8:12Well, what is that age limit?
- 8:14Are there any exceptions to that rule?
- 8:16That's when you start to get to an actual solution.
- 8:19Now this does not mean I wanna make this clear.
- 8:21It does not mean that vague ideas are are bad or unwarranted or that they shouldn't be put
- 8:27out there because they can start necessary conversations.
- 8:31If we were to really agree, and I'm not saying that this is or isn't what we should be going
- 8:36for, but if we talk about let's all agree that age limits on government officials are
- 8:42necessary for more government officials because some states do have that already for their
- 8:47state level officials and even some local officials.
- 8:50Okay.
- 8:51Well, we can start from this whole okay.
- 8:54This is we need age limits and maximum age limit on government officials because of x, y,
- 8:59and z.
- 9:00Now you're getting the ball rolling.
- 9:02But the age limit itself or just saying that we need an age limit is not a solution.
- 9:08Just when you're proposing a vague idea as a way to get to a solution, just don't think that
- 9:15it is a viable solution itself.
- 9:18It could start to lead to a solution, but it's not the actual solution.
- 9:23But even if you get a more specific on your provision, so you say maximum age that an
- 9:31elected official or government official should be in office for is 80 years old, or we need to
- 9:37increase voter turnout by making election day a holiday, or we need to get money out of
- 9:43politics by putting a cap on spending on these kinds of elections.
- 9:50Even if it is specific, it's not necessarily a complete idea that is actually feasible.
- 9:56Your idea might be just getting rid of a current policy, but have you thought about what
- 10:01you are replacing it with?
- 10:03A lot of times, we don't think about that other side of the equation, even if it seems obvious
- 10:08what we do and to replace something.
- 10:11It's similar to those of us who are sports fans, and we root for a team that's had a bad
- 10:16record, and we want the coach fires.
- 10:18I get this bum out of here.
- 10:19He's so bad.
- 10:20Just fire him now.
- 10:22Okay.
- 10:22Well, we don't always think about the replacement and if there is a potential better
- 10:27replacement.
- 10:28We just know we're angry at a current policy, and we want it gone as soon as possible.
- 10:35But the replacement could potentially be worse than the current policy that we have.
- 10:41Just because you have something new doesn't mean it's good.
- 10:45So, new so then having nothing to replace it can also be particularly bad too.
- 10:53Some people think that nothing would be better than the thing that we have now.
- 10:56And you might think that, but you might also be speaking out of bias against the current policy
- 11:01and it turns out, oh, wait, it's actually not good to have nothing in place.
- 11:07So let's talk about like if you were to get rid of the electoral college, what do you replace
- 11:11it with?
- 11:12Some people might think it's obvious.
- 11:14Oh, just simple direct election.
- 11:15One person, one vote.
- 11:17Okay.
- 11:17That but you need to how are you exactly going to codify that?
- 11:22Because everything needs to be codified.
- 11:24It needs to have specific legal language that makes that happen.
- 11:28You need to actually implement it in the US constitution.
- 11:33But is there potentially a different way to go about it?
- 11:36Is there some sort of hybrid between electoral college and a direct election?
- 11:41A lot of times people think it's just one or the other in that regard, but there might be
- 11:45other ideas because back when the founding fathers were debating the or the framers of the
- 11:49constitution, excuse me, were talking about the US constitution and how to write it, there was
- 11:56a lot of different discussions about how to elect the president.
- 12:00Or what if you talk about something a little more specific policy like Obamacare?
- 12:06So, again, this is not to say that I think that the electoral college or that Obamacare is good
- 12:11or bad.
- 12:12These are just examples I'm using to illustrate my point.
- 12:16If you say, We need to get rid of Obamacare.
- 12:19Okay, well, what are you replacing it with?
- 12:21Just getting rid of Obamacare is not really a solution in itself.
- 12:26You have to have at least something in mind to replace it with.
- 12:31But whatever your idea is, it still has to go through some sort of political process, which
- 12:36we'll get to in a moment.
- 12:37But specific ideas have their own issue to contend with compared to more vague ideas, and
- 12:43that's opening themselves up to more concrete criticisms.
- 12:48When you start detailing your specific idea, there are inherently more avenues for
- 12:53opposition.
- 12:54You see it a lot of times in the legislative process when bills are being debated in
- 12:58committees, in the legislative chamber, or between chambers because if it's a bicameral
- 13:03legislature, which almost all of the legislatures in The US are, both chambers have
- 13:07to agree on the exact same wording.
- 13:10So there might be the general idea might be something that everybody agrees on, but the
- 13:16exact specifics need to be talked about.
- 13:19And then, of course, if there is large disagreement, then you have to work even harder
- 13:24to get agreement on something.
- 13:27Now some opposition is good for refining your idea because pretty much no idea is is perfect.
- 13:34No.
- 13:34No.
- 13:35Definitely no idea is perfect, but no policy idea comes completely done when it's proposed.
- 13:42It needs to be hammered out.
- 13:43It needs to be refined.
- 13:45Now, of course, with this opposition can come some political games being played, and that's
- 13:51what happens all the time in the legislative process.
- 13:53But some pushback is good.
- 13:56You should not have everything just being run rough shot.
- 14:00We have a more deliberate political process for a reason.
- 14:04Now it does does not mean that it couldn't be more efficient, but things are not supposed to
- 14:09happen like that.
- 14:10They're supposed to take at least some time.
- 14:13Speaking of these rules to follow, what are the relevant political and legal rules to follow
- 14:19when you're implementing your policy?
- 14:21Because ideas are not debated and implemented in a vacuum.
- 14:25How it becomes reality can differ a lot depending on what the policy is and where it is
- 14:30being implemented because it's all well and good to have an idea.
- 14:34And it may be a great one, might be the best one anybody could come up with, but you still
- 14:39have a process to go through to make it happen.
- 14:42You don't just get to say, Okay, this is something we need to do, and people say, Yeah,
- 14:47I like that, and then boom, it's done.
- 14:49No, it does not work like that.
- 14:51And there might be a whole bunch of avenues for implementation that may or may not be
- 14:56applicable to what you are trying to do.
- 15:00So for example, whatever this reform is, would it be a federal, state, or local political
- 15:06change?
- 15:07Because some ideas are in the purview of one level of government but not another.
- 15:11For example, we talk a lot about federalism.
- 15:14What is in the scope of federal government versus what's in the scope of state government?
- 15:18So is it something that federal government legally does not have a hand in?
- 15:24Or is it something that is ambiguous whether it's federal or state, but you think it should
- 15:29be implemented at the state level instead?
- 15:31Or is it something that actually should be a local level thing that's implemented?
- 15:36Some ideas also might need time to build at a lower level of government before it can be
- 15:41implemented at a wider level.
- 15:42So you might need a proof of concept at the city or county level before you can expand it
- 15:48even further.
- 15:49Now, whether it's federal, state, or local, does it have to be done through legislation?
- 15:56Are there legislative restraints on what the bill can do?
- 15:58For example, most states have what are called single subject rules for legislation.
- 16:04So legislators can only put forth bills, and usually there's an exception, a few exceptions
- 16:10like particularly budgets because budgets are inherently all encompassing.
- 16:16But beyond that, most legislation in a lot of these states have to focus on one specific
- 16:22policy area.
- 16:23So it can't say x y z about medical marijuana and then a b and c about guns unless somehow
- 16:33that thing about guns ties back to medical marijuana.
- 16:37You have to space those out into different bills for the most part.
- 16:43There are a few states that don't have those single subject restrictions, but the general
- 16:48idea between states is that for their state legislatures, they have to be single rules.
- 16:53Now congress notably does not have that restriction.
- 16:57That's partly why you see some really huge bills in congress because they can cover a
- 17:02whole lot of different things.
- 17:04Also, are you allowed to propose this legislation as a citizen?
- 17:08Because in some states, there are avenues through which you can do that.
- 17:12Or as an interest group, you can propose legislation, and a legislator can take it up
- 17:17and say, okay.
- 17:18You know what?
- 17:18I'm gonna put put forth what this says or maybe make minor tweaks.
- 17:22What is the partisan and ideological makeup of that legislature?
- 17:26Because, obviously, whether it's Republican or Democrat or whether it's conservative or
- 17:31liberal and depending on what your policy idea is, it may or may not be amenable to what you
- 17:37are trying to do.
- 17:38Or is there a different relevant demographic to account for?
- 17:42So if we talk about age limits again, if we wanna implement age limits, a legislature that
- 17:47skews older probably won't be amenable to it, depending on certain exceptions that you might
- 17:53make like, oh, people who are in office right now are not subject to age limits, for example.
- 18:00But if it's not the making its legislation is not as viable an option, would it be best as a
- 18:07ballot measure instead?
- 18:09So a ballot measure is basically legislation that citizens can vote on.
- 18:13And a lot of states most states allow that and a lot of local areas have their own version of
- 18:19ballot measures.
- 18:20We do not have that at the federal level, at least not yet.
- 18:23Probably won't ever have that at the federal level, but you never know.
- 18:26States most states and lots of local areas have ballot measures that you can vote on, but they
- 18:32have a process that they go through.
- 18:33And a lot of these or each of these states and local areas has different processes for which a
- 18:39measure can get on the ballot.
- 18:41They have to have a certain number of signatures on their petitions that are required
- 18:45so that it can qualify for the ballot.
- 18:47You don't just say, hey.
- 18:48I want this ballot measure on the ballot, and then poof.
- 18:51It goes there.
- 18:51No.
- 18:52You need lots and lots of signatures, especially in bigger states.
- 18:56Where do those signatures come from?
- 18:58So does it have to come from multiple areas of the state or is there no stipulation in that
- 19:04regard?
- 19:05Who can gather those signatures?
- 19:07Because in some states they might have certain restraints on who can gather those petition
- 19:13signatures.
- 19:14All sorts of other nooks and crannies to account for might also depend on what that
- 19:20ballot measure is and might have to get more than 50% of the votes in a couple of states or
- 19:29in some states, if it's a specific policy area like taxes, it might need a higher threshold of
- 19:35the vote in order to pass.
- 19:37So all sorts of different things to account for in that regard.
- 19:43But whatever the case is, whatever your reform idea is or your policy idea, you have to look
- 19:49at what the legal and political and legislative rules are for making that policy happen.
- 19:57Doesn't matter how great that policy is, whether objectively or subjectively, there are
- 20:03certain checkpoints you need to hit in order to make it a reality.
- 20:08But even if you have a super great idea, every single idea has flaws, trade offs, or blind
- 20:15spots.
- 20:16Just about every policy or reform idea can be argued against in some way.
- 20:21Sometimes those arguments are disingenuous, but you're never going to have a perfect policy.
- 20:30It's just not gonna happen.
- 20:31I hate to break it to you.
- 20:32We don't want to admit it, but every idea for reform has a weak spot and it will be exploited
- 20:38by somebody.
- 20:39Now whether they succeed in exploiting that and trying to kill whatever idea you have.
- 20:47That's a whole other can of worms.
- 20:48But there's always going to be a weak spot.
- 20:52There might be one of those weak spots that are it might be that there's an aspect of the
- 20:56policy that can't be or an aspect of policy in general that can't be accounted for because you
- 21:01can't address every single problem.
- 21:03Most policies have to be narrow in their focus in order to actually get past because if
- 21:08they're trying to cover too many things at once, you're gonna get way too many different
- 21:13viewpoints on, hey, no, we can't do we're not I don't I don't like this particular part of the
- 21:18policy, so this policy is not gonna happen.
- 21:21You need to be a lot more narrow and focused on what that policy is trying to do.
- 21:28Also, if we accept the mindset that government and policy can always be made better, then that
- 21:35inherently means there is something that a policy was not able to fix before.
- 21:39That inherently means there was some sort of weak spot.
- 21:42And if you do legitimate policy analysis, actual policy analysis, not some super biased
- 21:49interest group did a study and said, oh, see, everything about this thing is great because,
- 21:54you know, we came up with it.
- 21:56No.
- 21:57Legitimate policy analysis will show you that there's always, always a trade off between
- 22:01ideas.
- 22:03If you do x, you won't be able to do y or you won't be able to do z.
- 22:07You only have so much time and effort to expend trying to make a reform happen or multiple
- 22:13ideas you have for a problem, but you might only find supporters for one of those ideas.
- 22:18So you focus on that one idea instead.
- 22:21You can't fix everything.
- 22:23It's just there's just too many things going against you.
- 22:26It would be nice if we could fix everything, but if but we can't.
- 22:30In campaigning, there's this concept, and I brought it up on several episodes of the
- 22:35podcast before what we call a SWOT analysis, SWOT, strengths, weaknesses, opportunities,
- 22:41threats.
- 22:42And you could do something similar with your reform ideas.
- 22:44You could take one of your reform ideas and say, this is one of the strengths or these are
- 22:49a bunch of the strengths.
- 22:50These are potential weaknesses.
- 22:52This is opportunities to get people to support it, and these are threats that can kill support
- 22:57for that idea.
- 22:58Every single idea for a policy or reform is going to have a strength, a weakness, an
- 23:07opportunity, a threat.
- 23:08It's always going to be the case.
- 23:10No matter how tied we are to our idea, no matter how great we think it is, it's always
- 23:16going to have something that can be attacked.
- 23:19And also, there are almost always unintended consequences with your policy idea.
- 23:26You can deeply and genuinely analyze policies to try to root out these unintentional issues.
- 23:32But some of them are only going to crop up after you implement a policy change or reform.
- 23:38Hence, the fact that there are unintended consequences.
- 23:41So one of the ideas I want to give or an example I wanna give to demonstrate this whole
- 23:48idea about trade offs and flaws is I'm gonna go back to a class I did in grad school, public
- 23:55policy analysis.
- 23:57And one of the projects, I think it was the end of year project we had to do is we had to do a
- 24:04policy analysis proposal, we had to go through different ideas based on a certain policy
- 24:11problem.
- 24:11And my policy analysis project was on obesity in kids in Florida, something that I I have
- 24:17personal involvement in because as a kid, I struggled with weight as well.
- 24:22And so basically, we had to come up with the the background of the problem and then make
- 24:29several proposals for how to address it and then talk about all the strengths and
- 24:34weaknesses that they had and the trade offs there.
- 24:36So I can't remember the exact policy proposals I came up with, but it was something along the
- 24:42lines of these four ideas to fix or at least address the problem of obesity of kids in
- 24:48Florida.
- 24:49It was subsidizing participation on school sports teams, expansion of recess for
- 24:54elementary and middle schoolers, some way of subsidizing or expanding access to healthy food
- 24:59in low income communities because of the prevalence of what are called food deserts in
- 25:04Florida, which basically means low income, low access areas that have little access to
- 25:11affordable, healthy food.
- 25:13And then the fourth idea was a public private partnership with the YMCA and other relevant
- 25:20nonprofits and private organizations.
- 25:23And so each of these proposals has some good things about it and some drawbacks.
- 25:28I picked one in the end.
- 25:29I'm not going to say which one I picked.
- 25:32But each one of these policies had drawbacks and good things.
- 25:37So, if we subsidize sports participation for school teams, it's on the positive side, will
- 25:42give kids an opportunity to build camaraderie and give them direct access to training
- 25:47regimens because they're practicing all the time, they're working out in the off season,
- 25:52but it could be costly because you're trying to pay for all of these sports teams.
- 25:58So even ones you might not necessarily think of.
- 26:00So you got football, basketball, soccer, baseball, track, hockey, if you if you probably
- 26:06more so in the North, although in the South, there is a little bit of that.
- 26:09Lacrosse, swimming, track, field.
- 26:12It's probably it's softball, baseball, or I think I said baseball already, but softball.
- 26:16All these sports then you would have to subsidize so it can get very costly.
- 26:20And, also, kids don't necessarily want that kind of environment.
- 26:23That might be too high stakes for them.
- 26:24They might wanna do sports, but they don't wanna do it for a school sports team.
- 26:29If we talk about the expansion of recess idea, you're getting more kids out of the classroom
- 26:33for a time to recharge their brains because don't wanna just sit in the classroom all day
- 26:39and, you know, make their eyes glaze over with all the the stuff that they're doing in class.
- 26:45So you're getting them to run around a little bit.
- 26:48It's more direct impact on their exercise, so you give them more time to exercise.
- 26:53But that could also cut into time for other classes, and it doesn't address the problem of
- 26:59food insecurity.
- 27:00And diet is arguably a much more important factor for your weight than exercise is.
- 27:11So speaking of which, we talk about that subsidizing access to healthy food idea.
- 27:16It addresses food insecurity, which is arguably a bigger culprit of obesity than lack of
- 27:21exercise, and it levels the playing field in terms of socioeconomic access.
- 27:26But it could be costly and have to take government spending from other programs and
- 27:30apply it to these subsidies, and so it might also generate some difficulty in getting
- 27:36political support behind these subsidized subsidies for access to healthy food because
- 27:43you're shifting the funding from certain programs, which somebody else in government is
- 27:47not gonna be happy with because those are their projects.
- 27:49Why should they have to agree to their projects not getting money and pointing it to these
- 27:54other places?
- 27:55And then you have the public private partnership idea.
- 27:59You can coordinate with existing organizations already involved in addressing obesity in
- 28:04children and using their infrastructure, but you're also involving multiple organizations
- 28:10that have their own ways of doing things, and so that can be very clunky and not cohesive.
- 28:15And the coordination could be quite difficult because you're having both government and a
- 28:21private or nonprofit organization being involved.
- 28:25So when you have more organizations being involved, it's inherently gonna be a little bit
- 28:29more difficult to coordinate efficiently.
- 28:33So overall the overall point of illustrating that example of my policy analysis project was
- 28:39that each of these proposals had strong points.
- 28:41Each of them had weak points, things that they addressed that other policies didn't or
- 28:45couldn't.
- 28:46So it's that same concept that could be applied to basically any other reform idea you have.
- 28:53So if somebody tells you that there's nothing wrong with their policy, you should be very
- 28:57skeptical, basically.
- 28:59But there's also very little incentive to publicly admit that there are flaws in your
- 29:05policy.
- 29:06Unless all sides that are involved in a policy or a reform dispute are genuinely willing to
- 29:11admit that they don't have all the answers and that they're going to accept critiques of their
- 29:16ideas, but you don't really see that happen very often in politics.
- 29:21Politics.
- 29:21It does not behoove people running for office or even interest groups who are trying to get
- 29:27their chosen candidate elected into office.
- 29:31It does not behoove them to admit, well, you know, I guess there could be this problem with
- 29:36my policy.
- 29:36No.
- 29:37They're not they're not gonna say that.
- 29:38Politicians must appear to be steadfast to not anger their polarized supporters.
- 29:45They're very ardent supporters because then otherwise, they might pull pull for somebody in
- 29:50the primary to challenge that candidate, especially if they're an incumbent.
- 29:53People in general are reluctant to admit that they're wrong or could possibly be wrong.
- 29:59Hey.
- 29:59Look.
- 29:59We've all been there.
- 30:00I've been there.
- 30:01It's not fun to admit that you're wrong, but some people can take that lot more than other
- 30:06people can.
- 30:06And then everybody wants their policy implemented because it benefits them in some
- 30:10way, or at least they think it benefits them in some way.
- 30:12But no matter what your policy is, you have to work with other people to get it implemented.
- 30:19Whether they support your idea or not, you have to spend time trying to build a coalition.
- 30:26Because sometimes people just wonder, why can't we just do x thing?
- 30:30Just be so easy.
- 30:31It's it's so easy.
- 30:32Just do this thing.
- 30:33Problem is human beings are involved with all their own interests, and priorities and biases.
- 30:40And so it's never that simple.
- 30:42You should always be skeptical of easy ideas when it comes to political reforms because
- 30:49they're never easy.
- 30:51Whatever your idea for reform or policy changes, you have to get other people to sign
- 30:56on to this idea.
- 30:57And so you need a strategy.
- 30:59But finding out who your supporters are or your potential supporters are is not always easy.
- 31:04Some people will be pretty obvious, but you have to spend money and time finding out who
- 31:10these people are.
- 31:11You might have to do polls.
- 31:12You might have to do focus groups.
- 31:14In any case, you're gonna have to do a deep dive in the electorate and figure out prominent
- 31:20interest groups and which people are regular voters, because people who are they're
- 31:30inconsistent in their voting, they are probably they're gonna be hard to rely on to generate a
- 31:38coalition.
- 31:38Doesn't mean that you don't try to get them to support you, but it is gonna be harder for them
- 31:42to or for you to get them to come and support your idea.
- 31:47And even would be supporters may not help you out even if you are mostly on the same page.
- 31:53For example, you might find a congressperson that really likes your idea, and they might
- 31:57tell you in private, hey.
- 31:58I like your idea.
- 31:59But there's an influential block of constituents of mine who would be very pissed
- 32:05off if I supported this thing.
- 32:06So I cannot publicly support you.
- 32:09Sometimes you see politicians say things off the record, you get their quote, but you don't
- 32:15actually see who said it.
- 32:17And like minded people might not be fully on the same page because they disagree on key
- 32:21detail.
- 32:22So if we go back to that maximum age limit on government officials, again, maybe you get a
- 32:28whole bunch of people that say, Yeah, we do need that.
- 32:31But they may not agree on the exact age.
- 32:34This one person over here says it should be 70.
- 32:36And somebody says, Well, that's a little low.
- 32:37How about 75?
- 32:38And then another person says, Well, that's that's too low too.
- 32:41How about 80?
- 32:42And then somebody else comes in and says, you guys need to go all in on this.
- 32:46We need it to be 60.
- 32:47Or maybe you agree on the exact age, but our current officials exempt from it.
- 32:53So even if there is, like, a 90 year old that's in office right now, to get his support or her
- 32:59support, you might need to say, okay.
- 33:02You are exempt from this.
- 33:04It's only people who are elected after this point in time, or maybe people can be exempt
- 33:10from the age limit if they pass a cognitive test.
- 33:13But then what does the cognitive test entail?
- 33:16This is something I talked about either the first or second episode of my of this podcast
- 33:20here.
- 33:21It's about this age limit debate.
- 33:24And then some people might fully or might otherwise fully be on the same page as you, but
- 33:29have other priorities they are working on and not enough bandwidth to help you, or they don't
- 33:34care enough about politics to want to get involved.
- 33:38Sometimes we talk a big game about what we should do, but we don't really actually try to
- 33:42make a reality.
- 33:43So somebody might say, we need immigration reform, but they just say that, but don't
- 33:49actually do anything about trying to make that happen.
- 33:52Not even, like, participating in conversations about it.
- 33:55And that's not necessarily to rag on them because some people just have a lot of other
- 33:59things that they have to do.
- 34:00But there are also other people who they talk a big game and they could do something about it
- 34:05and they just choose not to.
- 34:07But again, that's not everybody.
- 34:09And so it's easy to say we need to do something, but then actually trying to make it
- 34:15happen, that's a whole other thing.
- 34:18Whatever the case may be, whatever the policy is, you're gonna have to try to get people on
- 34:23your side.
- 34:25And that might take a little bit of coaxing is not the right word, but it's the only one I can
- 34:29think of right now.
- 34:29It might take a little bit of prodding to get them to come to your side.
- 34:33But we are not as persuasive and well well reasoned as we think we are.
- 34:39Because once again, we are oftentimes overconfident in our abilities when I
- 34:44especially when it comes to politics.
- 34:46Our biases influence how much we think we have thought things through.
- 34:51But even if we do have some talent in persuasion, some people are just going to be
- 34:56set in their ways, and there is nothing you can do to convince them.
- 34:59It's just not gonna happen.
- 35:00You might be the opposite party of them.
- 35:03You might be the opposite ideology of them, and they're just not gonna hear what you have to
- 35:08say.
- 35:09Even if it's something that's not necessarily a partisan or ideological issue, they might still
- 35:17be like, no.
- 35:17I'm not helping you.
- 35:18And so they just won't listen to you.
- 35:20And even if we have hashed out a lot of the details in our plan, we don't oftentimes really
- 35:27have a strategy or think far enough ahead into the future.
- 35:32And I actually refer back to episode 49 of this podcast I did with Graham Bernstein and Jacob
- 35:39Kaplan of the Florida Student Policy Forum where they talked about, you know, working with
- 35:45legislators and trying to to get them on your side and having to work with them.
- 35:51You know, if you just yell at them and make them enemies, they're not gonna listen to you.
- 35:56We like to think we could just run roughshod over the opposition.
- 36:01But guess what?
- 36:01They'll return the favor the next time they are in power or any chance they get, and the
- 36:07pendulum inevitably swings back against you.
- 36:10Now some people might look in sub states that are very heavily Republican or heavily
- 36:15Democrats, but in Congress, at some point, the pendulum swings from Republican back to
- 36:21Democrat, from Democrat back to Republican.
- 36:24And even in these states that are one party rule, there are factions within those parties
- 36:31that will duke it out.
- 36:32And so if you are very if you're the more ideological wing of that party and you're or
- 36:38you're the more moderate wing of that party, pendulum will swing back and forth to some
- 36:43extent as well.
- 36:44And then even the people in the more extreme wing will start fighting each other or the
- 36:49moderate wing will start fighting each other.
- 36:52So it behooves you to try to work more with other people.
- 36:57There are a lot of incentives to not do that, but there are also a lot of incentives long
- 37:02term for you to work with other people.
- 37:05And even if you can't achieve all your goals, you can achieve at least some of them working
- 37:10with other people.
- 37:11Now, for some people, they think it's completely immoral to not stand on business
- 37:17and, you know, they'd rather just lose wholesale than win a little bit because they
- 37:22think it's compromising their values, which is not the way to think about things, but it's how
- 37:28a lot of people view politics.
- 37:32Some people just they just won't work with you if they don't think they can achieve everything
- 37:36that they can, or they really believe that they can achieve everything they can by just, you
- 37:41know, bulldozing everybody.
- 37:43But it comes back to bite you in the end.
- 37:46But now let's get past the actual formulation of the policy.
- 37:51Now let's talk about the results of the policy, especially this question.
- 37:56Does your idea actually achieve the benefits you think it will?
- 38:00When you get even partially invested in your idea, it is very easy to assume that it will
- 38:05have all the benefits you believe it will, that you expect it to have.
- 38:09This thing is gonna save us so much money in the future.
- 38:12Oh, this will lead to so much less in fighting.
- 38:14This will lead to more voter turnout, blah, blah, blah.
- 38:17But does that really happen?
- 38:20You might be surprised.
- 38:21I'm not even talking about unintended consequences.
- 38:23It might just be that it just doesn't quite work the way you think it will.
- 38:29You can make all projections you want.
- 38:31It's often hard to know what the effects truly will be until they actually happen, hence those
- 38:36unintended consequences.
- 38:38But the benefits you are looking for might happen, but not to the extent you want.
- 38:43So maybe you have a reform idea that you expect will increase voter turnout by 10%, but the
- 38:50results say that it's only about 5% more.
- 38:54Now you did somewhat achieve that goal, but it wasn't quite what you thought was going to
- 39:00happen.
- 39:01And even when you think a benefit will intuitively arise from a reform, it may not
- 39:06work out the way you expect it to because the way you looked at a problem was flawed.
- 39:11And to demonstrate that, I'm going to use the example of some reforms in voting that we saw
- 39:17from the 1970s through the 1990s that were aimed at making voting and registering to vote
- 39:23much less onerous.
- 39:24So we are talking about primarily early voting, absentee voting, and the National Voter
- 39:32Registration Act of 1993, which is also called the Motor Voter Act.
- 39:35Now early voting and absentee voting didn't all start at that point, but they became much more
- 39:42common and expanded throughout The United States back in those decades, what some people
- 39:48call the But here's a little bit of background for it.
- 39:51So there was an idea that a couple of political scientists had that basically people were not
- 39:55voting because The US has a compared to other democratic countries, even ones without
- 40:02mandatory voting, has a fairly low voter turnout rate comparatively.
- 40:07And the idea was that, oh, people were not voting because there were major tangible
- 40:12barriers to voting, which there were.
- 40:14There was a lot of times travel distance.
- 40:17You might have had to travel a really long way to go register to vote, or you might have had
- 40:22to register well before election day, and then you need to have access to this information
- 40:27that told you when to be registered to vote and what you needed to register to vote.
- 40:31Especially back in the nineteen seventies, we didn't have the Internet, so you couldn't just
- 40:34look this stuff up.
- 40:36And then even today, sometimes it's hard to find this information even though we do have
- 40:40the Internet.
- 40:41When early voting and absentee voting were being implemented, the assumption was made that
- 40:45it would increase voter turnout because voting became easier.
- 40:49And in 1993, that motor voter act directed states to allow voter registration at motor
- 40:54vehicle agencies and through mail in procedures.
- 40:57So voting and registering to vote became easier than ever.
- 41:01And today, it's easier than ever to do those things.
- 41:05So how much do you think that voter turnout increased with those?
- 41:10Well, results say that those reforms didn't actually impact voter turnout much.
- 41:15Now some would even argue that turnout decreased or at least it hasn't consistently
- 41:21increased since then.
- 41:22So partially depends on which states you look at.
- 41:25The results said that actually most of the people taking advantage of early and absentee
- 41:31voting were going to vote on election day anyways.
- 41:34They just saw, oh, okay.
- 41:35I could just do it without going to the polling place, or I can do it before election day.
- 41:42Okay.
- 41:42I'll just do it then.
- 41:44So well, that's weird.
- 41:45Why if we're making voting easier than ever to do, why aren't people doing it?
- 41:50What were these reforms missing?
- 41:53Well, political scientist and professor Adam Barinsky argued that we were focusing on the
- 41:59wrong types of costs.
- 42:01Now, obviously, not or when we talk about costs, don't necessarily mean like actual
- 42:05monetary costs.
- 42:06Sometimes we are talking about costs in time and effort.
- 42:11The tangible barriers, like the cost in time, money, effort to register to vote and cast a
- 42:18ballot.
- 42:19That, according to professor Barinsky, is not actually the cost that we should have been
- 42:25focusing on or not not to say that he didn't think that those were good reforms.
- 42:30I mean, they were good reforms, but the actual costs that weren't addressed are the cognitive
- 42:38effort of becoming involved with and informed about politics.
- 42:42I've said it before, but I'll say it again.
- 42:44A lot of people that are in politics like me, we find it.
- 42:48It's very hard for us to appreciate the reasons that other people have for not getting involved
- 42:53in politics.
- 42:53And it's not because, oh, they don't want to or that they're lazy or that they don't care.
- 42:58It's just that they don't have time or they don't know why they should be interested.
- 43:04They just have for some reason or another, they're unenthused about the choices they have
- 43:08or think about, man, what's the point of going to vote?
- 43:11They might really want a reason to vote.
- 43:14At least in their minds, they don't, they think they don't have a reason to vote.
- 43:17Problem is people being registered to vote doesn't inherently make them vote.
- 43:22Just because you're getting all these people registered doesn't mean Oh, okay, you know
- 43:25what, I'll go vote.
- 43:26Some of them didn't go to vote not because they found it onerous, but because they just didn't
- 43:32care.
- 43:32They weren't interested.
- 43:34Lots of registered voters don't vote in elections, especially when he gets had non
- 43:38presidential elections.
- 43:39It's about interest and engagement.
- 43:42You will not truly increase voter engagement consistently until it becomes easier to sift
- 43:48through political info, and more voters are consistently more interested in and engaged
- 43:54with politics.
- 43:56And that's a very tall task.
- 43:58And, again, that's not a solution to say, oh, we need to make voters more consistently
- 44:02engaged and interested in politics.
- 44:05That is not a solution.
- 44:07How are we gonna make them more interested and engaged?
- 44:09And that is a very long standing question.
- 44:12And no matter what you do, you're never gonna get a 100% of voter turnout.
- 44:16It's just not gonna happen.
- 44:18Even if we made mandatory voting a thing, you'd still would not get a 100%.
- 44:23Again, that does not mean that these reforms like early voting and absentee voting and
- 44:28increased access to voter registration weren't necessary because they were.
- 44:32They just didn't really do what they set out to do on their own.
- 44:36So even though you think intuitively, this is going to fix this problem that we have, this
- 44:41problem of low voter turnout in this case.
- 44:44That's not what actually happened.
- 44:45And in some cases, might have upped it a little bit.
- 44:48There might have been a little bit of an uptick, but then it went down again.
- 44:50It was never consistent.
- 44:52So think harder about whether your idea for reform or policy change will really lead to the
- 44:59benefit that you expect.
- 45:01Ultimately though, we need to recognize the importance of critiquing our own ideas.
- 45:08Intuitively, a lot of us get the importance of self assessment, and we and we think we self
- 45:14assess.
- 45:15A lot of times, we don't really do that, though, or at least we're not good at it.
- 45:20Now some people just think they have everything figured out.
- 45:22There's a lot of people like that or at least a lot of loud people like that.
- 45:25They're the ones that pop up on social media all the time and are on that are pundits.
- 45:31They they they you just need to listen to them, and you'll get all the answers from them or
- 45:36politicians.
- 45:37But there are other people who genuinely want to get better at critical thinking even if they
- 45:42think that they're better at it than they actually are, but they do wanna get better at
- 45:45critical thinking.
- 45:46They just they don't necessarily know how.
- 45:49And all of us can get better at it, myself included.
- 45:51I'm always trying to improve on that front.
- 45:54But, again, like I said before, everybody falls into that trap of thinking they know more than
- 45:59they actually do, and that happens to me sometimes.
- 46:02And I try to be as self aware as possible about that.
- 46:05But self assessment is unbelievably important.
- 46:09I'm a big advocate for self awareness and it might seem like a self evident thing, but it's
- 46:15not.
- 46:16We really need to stress the benefits of self assessment, like how it keeps us grounded.
- 46:21We get better at what we are doing naturally.
- 46:24We become more self aware, which is in short supply these days.
- 46:27We break unproductive habits and get closer to our goals, and in this case, policy goals.
- 46:33And we get healthier civic engagement and decreased polarization, which makes things
- 46:39function a lot better.
- 46:41None of us have 100% of the truth figured out.
- 46:44So if we really care about truth, like we say we do, because ostensibly, we all care about
- 46:49truth.
- 46:50We need to seek self improvement, we need to be constantly refining and critiquing our own
- 46:55beliefs.
- 46:56Doesn't mean you need to change everything wholesale, but it does mean that you need to
- 47:00look at little bits at least and think, okay, you know what, this part, I have new
- 47:06information.
- 47:07I don't necessarily think about.
- 47:09I don't think x about this anymore.
- 47:12If we don't critique our ideas or genuinely hear out different viewpoints, it's always
- 47:18going to lead to bad or heavily flawed policy.
- 47:23You don't notice your own blind spots, and therefore you miss other points for
- 47:28improvements.
- 47:29And you also just make other people mad at you, which some people enjoy, some people like to
- 47:33troll, but they're not gonna listen to you in turn.
- 47:36And then you might find, oh, wait.
- 47:39I need those people to at least help me out a little bit in some way, and they're going to
- 47:46purposely screw you over.
- 47:47And then it's just gonna lead to this culture of one upmanship that we constantly see.
- 47:53And we also just can't continue to improve things if we're going to act this way where we
- 47:57just don't listen to other viewpoints.
- 48:01This country has not improved in any point in time except for when it's been introspective
- 48:07and when it's tried to incorporate other views, when it's tried to take in new information.
- 48:14Most notably, when expanding rights like voting to more demographics with race and gender as
- 48:22the two prominent examples there, eliminating slavery and Jim Crow laws.
- 48:28Those did not come or would not have come if we weren't more introspective as a nation, and we
- 48:35didn't hear other ideas out.
- 48:38And so more improvements are necessary and those improvements are not gonna come unless we
- 48:44actually listen to other people.
- 48:46Because no matter what our background is, no matter what our demographics are, none of us
- 48:50are above listening to other people and hearing other viewpoints because everybody's got a
- 48:57perspective that even if it's flawed or maybe they have bad information, just the act of at
- 49:04least letting them speak is going to make political discourse a lot better, and we can
- 49:11come to a much greater understanding and help revitalize the civic health of this nation.
- 49:19Obviously, it's a lot easier said than done just like how this whole episode was about how
- 49:24policy ideas are much easier said than done, but it's something we should constantly strive
- 49:30for.
- 49:31So, hopefully, that gave you a lot of applicable practical information to use so that
- 49:37you can critique your own ideas.
- 49:38And there are things that I need to make sure I remind myself of whenever I come across an idea
- 49:44that I really get tied up in and think this is the thing.
- 49:48This is the one.
- 49:49We I just need other people to to hear it.
- 49:51It's so obvious.
- 49:53It's not obvious.
- 49:54It never if you think an idea is easy and obvious, almost never is.
- 49:59And if it is, it's only for a very specific particular thing.
- 50:04When you're talking about broad ideas, broad fixes, broad policy, it's never an easy or
- 50:10obvious solution.
- 50:11Bear that in mind.
- 50:13But that's gonna do it for today's episode of politics with Paul.
- 50:16Thank you all so much for listening.
- 50:17Please like, comment, share, and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple
- 50:23Podcasts, and also rate the show and review, please.
- 50:27So links to the show notes.
- 50:29I I'll also link Stephanie Houghton's substack that I mentioned at the very beginning of this
- 50:34episode so that you can see what ultimately spawned this idea that I had.
- 50:40Although it's something I kinda played around with a little bit for a while, but that that
- 50:44substack piece really got me going on this.
- 50:49So I'll link to that.
- 50:50But in my other links, my LinkedIn profile that I write on very frequently, my Facebook page,
- 50:57Paul Raider author and speaker, my email, Paul Raider writes at Gmail dot com, My five day
- 51:03educational email course about how we can all improve on depolarizing politics in America.
- 51:10My book on Amazon about political independence and why they struggle so much and how they
- 51:16could potentially make their lives easier when it comes to running for office.
- 51:22Not arguing that we should or shouldn't have more of them.
- 51:25It's just things to think about about a topic that's not very well discussed or understood.
- 51:33Is there another thing I'm missing?
- 51:35Oh, my medium.com profile that I write on from time to time.
- 51:39So that is going to wrap things up for today.
- 51:41Thank you all so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.