Latest / Statecraft / What Can We Learn from Estonia?
Transcript
- 0:04SPEAKER_01: Hi, I'm Santi Ruiz and this is Statecraft.
- 0:07SPEAKER_01: Today's big motivating question is, what can we learn from Estonia?
- 0:11SPEAKER_01: It's not a question you hear often.
- 0:13The nation of under two million residents doesn't mean much to
- 0:16many Americans.
- 0:17SPEAKER_01: There's not a big expat community here.
- 0:19SPEAKER_01: It's not a major geopolitical player.
- 0:21But for good governance advocates,
- 0:23it's long been a touch point for its e-government model.
- 0:26SPEAKER_01: As The New Yorker wrote in 2017,
- 0:29SPEAKER_01: quote,
- 0:30SPEAKER_01: apart from transfers of physical property,
- 0:31SPEAKER_01: such as buying a house,
- 0:33SPEAKER_01: all bureaucratic processes can be done online.
- 0:37Wired called Estonia,
- 0:38quote,
- 0:39the world's most digitally advanced society.
- 0:42SPEAKER_01: On its own eEstonia site,
- 0:44SPEAKER_01: the country brags,
- 0:45SPEAKER_01: we have built a digital society and we can show you how.
- 0:49Now,
- 0:49the Estonian model has a lot going for it from the perspective
- 0:52of a citizen.
- 0:53SPEAKER_01: For example, taxes take just a few minutes to file.
- 0:56SPEAKER_01: You can see every time the government looks at your data and why.
- 1:00and you never have to give the government a piece of
- 1:01information about you,
- 1:03SPEAKER_01: your address,
- 1:03SPEAKER_01: your social security number,
- 1:05SPEAKER_01: more than once.
- 1:07SPEAKER_01: It also has governance benefits.
- 1:09Bureaucracy is leaner,
- 1:10information is shared across agencies,
- 1:13and data is more secure.
- 1:14SPEAKER_01: I've been reading about Estonia for a while.
- 1:17My big question has been,
- 1:18how much of this model could we actually adopt here in the U.S.
- 1:21SPEAKER_01: or in the West generally?
- 1:24And how much of it is reliant on a cultural and a societal
- 1:26context we just don't have here?
- 1:29SPEAKER_01: To get answers,
- 1:30SPEAKER_01: I talked today to Joel Burke,
- 1:32SPEAKER_01: author of the new book,
- 1:33SPEAKER_01: Rebooting a Nation,
- 1:35SPEAKER_01: The Incredible Rise of Estonia,
- 1:36SPEAKER_01: E-Government,
- 1:37SPEAKER_01: and the Startup Revolution.
- 1:39Joel's an American who worked for the Estonian government,
- 1:41and I learned a lot from his book.
- 1:43SPEAKER_01: Before we get into it, a quick plug.
- 1:45SPEAKER_01: As you've heard me say before here,
- 1:46SPEAKER_01: you can find the transcript for this conversation and many others at
- 1:49SPEAKER_01: www.statecraft.pub.
- 1:52SPEAKER_01: If you're not subscribed to the newsletter, I highly recommend it.
- 1:55SPEAKER_01: You get the transcript in your inbox once a week.
- 1:58SPEAKER_01: We clean up the transcript quite a bit.
- 1:59SPEAKER_01: All the show notes and links are there.
- 2:02SPEAKER_01: And I think you'll enjoy some of those conversations.
- 2:04SPEAKER_01: Also consider subscribing on here,
- 2:06SPEAKER_01: whatever platform you're listening to,
- 2:08SPEAKER_01: whether it's Spotify or Apple Music.
- 2:10SPEAKER_01: And if you like this podcast,
- 2:11SPEAKER_01: if you're a fan of Statecraft,
- 2:13SPEAKER_01: we would really appreciate a five-star rating.
- 2:15SPEAKER_01: Give it a thought.
- 2:16SPEAKER_01: Okay, that's it.
- 2:17SPEAKER_01: Without further ado, Joel Burke on Estonia.
- 2:21SPEAKER_01: Joel Burke, thank you for joining Statecraft.
- 2:23SPEAKER_00: Well, thanks so much for having me.
- 2:24SPEAKER_00: I'm a big fan of the show, and I do want to give a shout out.
- 2:26SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 2:27especially the episodes that you did with your dad were both
- 2:30really informative and
- 2:31SPEAKER_00: touching.
- 2:32My parents have been hugely influential in my life,
- 2:34so I was really glad to see those episodes.
- 2:36SPEAKER_00: I thought it was awesome.
- 2:37SPEAKER_01: I'm glad you enjoyed them.
- 2:38SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 2:38SPEAKER_01: I was listening to Patrick McKenzie's podcast,
- 2:42SPEAKER_01: and he was interviewing his dad,
- 2:44SPEAKER_01: who's been in banking.
- 2:45And it was like 40 minutes into listening to that episode that
- 2:48I suddenly realized,
- 2:49SPEAKER_01: like,
- 2:49SPEAKER_01: wait,
- 2:50SPEAKER_01: I should talk to my dad.
- 2:52SPEAKER_01: It took me a moment to draw the connection.
- 2:53SPEAKER_01: I'm glad you enjoyed it.
- 2:55SPEAKER_01: I am really excited about this conversation.
- 2:57And I want to start with making sure that we get the historical
- 3:01background to what
- 3:02SPEAKER_01: you talk about in this book,
- 3:03SPEAKER_01: to why Estonia is the way it is,
- 3:05SPEAKER_01: and then what that actual model is.
- 3:07And then I think we should turn it around and talk about the
- 3:10lessons maybe for the
- 3:11SPEAKER_01: US or for the rest of the West more broadly.
- 3:13SPEAKER_01: But before we get into US application,
- 3:15SPEAKER_01: I want to make sure we just nail what is the Estonian e-government model?
- 3:19SPEAKER_01: What are we actually looking at?
- 3:20SPEAKER_01: So in 1991, Estonia becomes independent from the Soviet Union.
- 3:24give me like a two minute lay of the land where are we where is
- 3:27estonia as a
- 3:28SPEAKER_01: society at this point
- 3:30SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 3:30So if we roll back the clock to 91,
- 3:32I'd say that things are tough but hopeful.
- 3:36It's a country that has been occupied for several decades by
- 3:39the Soviet Union.
- 3:39I mean,
- 3:40it also has a very long history of occupation from various
- 3:43regional powers.
- 3:44SPEAKER_00: But basically, the country is faced with a bit of an economic conundrum.
- 3:49SPEAKER_00: As you can imagine, the Soviets were not that great at capitalism.
- 3:52SPEAKER_00: The factories and institutions that were built in the country were not
- 3:56SPEAKER_00: very efficient.
- 3:57SPEAKER_00: So the country basically had to figure out,
- 3:59as with almost every country that achieved independence from
- 4:02the Soviet Union,
- 4:03SPEAKER_00: had to deal with economic reform.
- 4:05SPEAKER_00: And Estonia decided to wholly embrace the market economy.
- 4:10SPEAKER_00: And there was a gentleman who became prime minister,
- 4:14SPEAKER_00: Mark Lahr,
- 4:14SPEAKER_00: who basically helped do economic shock therapy for the country.
- 4:18SPEAKER_00: And it was very, very aggressive here.
- 4:19But I think I'll gloss over kind of the general economic shock,
- 4:24removing subsidies,
- 4:25But there's a couple things that I want to highlight that I
- 4:27think set Stoney on a
- 4:28SPEAKER_00: very good trajectory.
- 4:30SPEAKER_00: One is that I think in many places,
- 4:32SPEAKER_00: and it sounds intuitive,
- 4:33the factories and facilities like that were given to the
- 4:37managers of those
- 4:38SPEAKER_00: facilities to run because the thought was that,
- 4:40SPEAKER_00: give it back to the people,
- 4:41SPEAKER_00: they know how to run it best.
- 4:43SPEAKER_00: But if you think about
- 4:44SPEAKER_00: running a factory during the Soviet Union.
- 4:46It was a very political job versus a job focused on managerial
- 4:49efficiency.
- 4:50So Estonia actually focused more on finding foreign partners
- 4:54who could help reform
- 4:55the practices of these factories and make them more efficient
- 4:58and do co-investment.
- 4:59SPEAKER_00: The second thing was really focusing on
- 5:02SPEAKER_00: when you found that foreign direct investment,
- 5:04trying to get them to invest in more digital and maybe not
- 5:07directly digital as we
- 5:08SPEAKER_00: think of today.
- 5:09SPEAKER_00: We're not talking about smartphones and such.
- 5:11We're talking about the early 90s,
- 5:12but really modernizing the systems that they went into.
- 5:15SPEAKER_00: This is most obvious in the banking sector, for instance.
- 5:18Many of the banks even today are from Sweden and other
- 5:21countries in the region,
- 5:22but a big part of what they ended up doing in helping to build
- 5:26the estate was
- 5:27SPEAKER_00: investing in
- 5:28SPEAKER_00: online banking,
- 5:29which then led to a whole kind of series of events that helped
- 5:32to kind of foment
- 5:33SPEAKER_00: the digitization of the country and the adoption of technology.
- 5:37SPEAKER_01: If you zoom out,
- 5:38just to kind of compare Estonia to a bunch of the other former
- 5:41Soviet bloc
- 5:43SPEAKER_01: countries,
- 5:44SPEAKER_01: from a cultural or from a national level,
- 5:46SPEAKER_01: why does Estonia
- 5:48SPEAKER_01: have this instinct towards modernization or digitization.
- 5:52SPEAKER_01: It's not that it's crazy or weird necessarily,
- 5:55SPEAKER_01: but you don't see it across the rest of the Eastern European states.
- 5:58SPEAKER_01: What's in the water that makes Estonia the edge case?
- 6:02SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 6:02SPEAKER_00: So I'd say it's what's across the water.
- 6:05SPEAKER_00: It's Finland.
- 6:05So Estonia is a short way away across a body of water from
- 6:10Finland and Helsinki on
- 6:11SPEAKER_00: the coast there.
- 6:13SPEAKER_00: when they transmitted radio and television waves,
- 6:15SPEAKER_00: they were strong enough to reach from Helsinki to much of Estonia,
- 6:19SPEAKER_00: including the capital.
- 6:20SPEAKER_00: So that meant that even during the Soviet days,
- 6:22unlike many of the other occupied nations that were really cut
- 6:25off behind the Iron
- 6:26SPEAKER_00: Curtain,
- 6:27SPEAKER_00: Estonia still got exposure to Finland.
- 6:30you would read advertisements for grocery stores that were full
- 6:32of meat at a time
- 6:33SPEAKER_00: when there were bread lines,
- 6:34SPEAKER_00: right?
- 6:35And so you both had this exposure to a capitalist society that
- 6:38was kind of a short
- 6:40SPEAKER_00: distance away from you and having that exposure repeatedly.
- 6:42SPEAKER_00: And again, there are kind of fun stories.
- 6:44I think President Elvis talks about watching reruns of Dallas
- 6:47and Dynasty and these
- 6:48SPEAKER_00: like 80s and 70s TV shows that were broadcast in English in Finland.
- 6:52SPEAKER_00: So there was like a bit more exposure to the West.
- 6:55SPEAKER_00: So I think that helped.
- 6:56SPEAKER_00: But the other reason I mentioned Finland is I think there was,
- 6:59SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 6:59SPEAKER_00: if we roll back the clock even further to just before World War II,
- 7:03SPEAKER_00: when Estonia is occupied,
- 7:04SPEAKER_00: it had about the same standard of living as Finland.
- 7:07So,
- 7:08and then you roll the clock forward,
- 7:09you know,
- 7:10five decades of Soviet occupation.
- 7:12SPEAKER_00: And as you can imagine,
- 7:13SPEAKER_00: any calculation of wealth or wellness,
- 7:15SPEAKER_00: Estonia far lags its neighbor Finland now,
- 7:18SPEAKER_00: right?
- 7:18And so I think there was this sense of collegial rivalry or
- 7:22competitiveness where
- 7:23SPEAKER_00: Estonia and Finland were always each other's measuring sticks,
- 7:25SPEAKER_00: or at least for Estonia,
- 7:26SPEAKER_00: Finland was.
- 7:28After you receive independence and you really see,
- 7:30wow,
- 7:31Finland is way far ahead of us.
- 7:32SPEAKER_00: If we just follow the traditional development methods,
- 7:35SPEAKER_00: we're never going to actually catch up to these guys.
- 7:38SPEAKER_00: We have to pursue a really radical agenda.
- 7:40SPEAKER_00: I think
- 7:41Estonians were bought into this idea of trying to jump across
- 7:46the chasm and really
- 7:46SPEAKER_00: leap to try and make a better life for themselves.
- 7:49And both the popular support and boldness of leaders allowed
- 7:52for really aggressive
- 7:53SPEAKER_00: moves for reform.
- 7:55SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 7:56SPEAKER_01: In your book, you talk about how Estonians...
- 7:59really want to think of themselves as Nordics rather than as
- 8:03Baltic countries or as
- 8:04SPEAKER_01: an Eastern European country.
- 8:05The comparison culturally really is no part of kind of the
- 8:08greater Scandinavian cultural region.
- 8:11SPEAKER_01: That's kind of what you're alluding to here.
- 8:13SPEAKER_00: Yeah, indeed.
- 8:13SPEAKER_00: And actually, I think it's...
- 8:16SPEAKER_00: It's interesting.
- 8:17SPEAKER_00: One of my former colleagues,
- 8:18SPEAKER_00: Adam Rang,
- 8:18SPEAKER_00: who is a great writer and he's a Brit who moved to Estonia,
- 8:22SPEAKER_00: was just talking about this.
- 8:23And it does seem that Estonia is also somewhat finding its
- 8:26groove and being itself.
- 8:28It's not trying to be the Silicon Valley of Europe anymore or
- 8:30trying to be a part
- 8:32SPEAKER_00: of the Nordic nations.
- 8:33SPEAKER_00: It's like, no, we're Estonia and we matter just on our own.
- 8:36SPEAKER_00: So it is cool to see that evolution over time, but certainly...
- 8:39SPEAKER_00: When I worked for the Estonian government,
- 8:41SPEAKER_00: I led a business development for the e-residency program.
- 8:43And it was certainly a key talking point that we were supposed
- 8:45to get across that
- 8:46SPEAKER_00: like,
- 8:46SPEAKER_00: no,
- 8:46SPEAKER_00: no,
- 8:47SPEAKER_00: Estonia is not Baltic,
- 8:48SPEAKER_00: it's Nordic.
- 8:49SPEAKER_01: That's very funny.
- 8:52SPEAKER_01: So 91 is independence.
- 8:53You have this big privatization push,
- 8:55export restrictions are abolished,
- 8:56no more price controls.
- 8:59SPEAKER_01: One thing you flag is even before the kind of full digitization in 1993,
- 9:04there's a national commitment not to buy any legacy equipment
- 9:08that they're going to
- 9:09SPEAKER_01: build as much as possible internally or by the cutting edge.
- 9:13SPEAKER_01: as a government.
- 9:14Give me just a little bit on that and then we can get to the
- 9:17actual digitization push.
- 9:19SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 9:19So I think this is emblematic of these principles that have
- 9:22become endemic to
- 9:23SPEAKER_00: Estonian society,
- 9:25especially around the civil service and kind of political and
- 9:27startup culture.
- 9:28SPEAKER_00: And there's a lot of mixing in between those worlds.
- 9:31idea of not purchasing or not using legacy equipment was really
- 9:35important because I
- 9:36SPEAKER_00: think the first time this really came up was,
- 9:39SPEAKER_00: I think it was either Sweden or Finland,
- 9:41SPEAKER_00: which were major,
- 9:42major supporters of Estonia after independence because the
- 9:45country just desperately
- 9:46SPEAKER_00: needed help.
- 9:46SPEAKER_00: One of them offered to revamp the phone system in Thailand.
- 9:50SPEAKER_00: And it was kind of a choice of like,
- 9:52SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 9:52we could take this free thing that's old while this other
- 9:54country upgrades to the
- 9:55SPEAKER_00: new system,
- 9:55SPEAKER_00: or we can make sacrifices.
- 9:57SPEAKER_00: We can focus on building our own solutions and leapfrogging.
- 10:00SPEAKER_00: And I think it
- 10:01fits in with this idea that the country was like we can't just
- 10:05adopt the common
- 10:06model and grow slowly and kind of work our way up the value
- 10:09chain that doesn't work
- 10:10for a country like estonia that's 1.3 million has no natural
- 10:13resource it has to do
- 10:14really bold things and so this idea also led to the conclusion
- 10:18or realization that
- 10:20maybe was quite apparent at the time after you know you go to
- 10:22microsoft or oracle
- 10:23and try and get a quote for something that like actually we
- 10:25can't really afford the
- 10:26SPEAKER_00: big western companies they're going to charge us 20 million for something
- 10:29So it also led to this culture of fomenting domestic public
- 10:32private partnerships
- 10:33SPEAKER_00: for the development of much of what would become the e-government digital
- 10:36SPEAKER_00: infrastructure.
- 10:37SPEAKER_00: So if you look at,
- 10:38SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 10:38SPEAKER_00: EIDs,
- 10:39SPEAKER_00: for instance,
- 10:40this was built with a consortium of the kind of local banks to
- 10:43help facilitate
- 10:44SPEAKER_00: access to online banking.
- 10:45Basically,
- 10:46every e-service is built in partnership with a local tech
- 10:48company.
- 10:49And this is partly a deliberate strategy to at the beginning to
- 10:53keep costs down,
- 10:54but with the added benefit of helping to build up a domestic
- 10:57tech industry that has
- 10:58SPEAKER_00: turned into an export engine and frankly,
- 11:01SPEAKER_00: a branding engine for the country.
- 11:03You have a useful typology in this book of the problems that
- 11:07e-government solves
- 11:09SPEAKER_01: for Estonia as a nation in the late 90s.
- 11:12SPEAKER_01: Three things you flag.
- 11:13SPEAKER_01: One is you just have a lack of experienced bureaucrats.
- 11:15SPEAKER_01: You're a new country.
- 11:17SPEAKER_01: All the Soviet administrators are gone.
- 11:19And so you have to build a new government without this kind of
- 11:22cadre or this
- 11:22SPEAKER_01: history of administrators and totally new regime.
- 11:25SPEAKER_01: Another one is public sector corruption.
- 11:27You want to avoid the problems that you had in the USSR of rank
- 11:31corruption and
- 11:32SPEAKER_01: digitalization can help create transparency.
- 11:35And then the last one is just the inefficiency of delivering
- 11:38the services that the
- 11:39SPEAKER_01: government needs to deliver.
- 11:40The kind of basic,
- 11:40like we'd like to make this smoother and faster and easier.
- 11:43Talk about how those three factors played into the development
- 11:47of the e-government model.
- 11:49SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so absolutely.
- 11:50SPEAKER_00: So as you can imagine,
- 11:51if you're in a situation where you've achieved re-independence
- 11:54after years and
- 11:55SPEAKER_00: years of fighting for it,
- 11:57SPEAKER_00: and you're in a situation where you're now in charge of your own destiny,
- 12:00SPEAKER_00: and you don't want to fall into this trap of corruption,
- 12:02SPEAKER_00: because at the time,
- 12:04SPEAKER_00: there was something called the Bloody Autumn.
- 12:06SPEAKER_00: I think this was 94,
- 12:07where basically gangs from across the Soviet Union were kind of
- 12:11battling for turf
- 12:12because Estonia has always been part of the reason it was
- 12:15repeatedly occupied.
- 12:16It has a privileged position from a trading standpoint and been
- 12:18part of the
- 12:19SPEAKER_00: Hanseatic League long ago.
- 12:20SPEAKER_00: And so you don't want to allow corruption to take hold in your system,
- 12:24but you also don't have the literal manpower to actually staff
- 12:28these things.
- 12:28SPEAKER_00: So what do you reach for?
- 12:30SPEAKER_00: digitization is kind of,
- 12:32SPEAKER_00: well,
- 12:32SPEAKER_00: I'd say it's obvious and it feels obvious in Estonia,
- 12:34SPEAKER_00: but obviously many countries didn't do this.
- 12:36SPEAKER_00: But for Estonia, they decided to bet on this.
- 12:38SPEAKER_00: And former President Elvis has a great quote, you can't bribe a computer.
- 12:42SPEAKER_00: And I think that's also something you're starting to see pick up in other
- 12:45SPEAKER_00: Other regions, and I want to shout out Ukraine in particular.
- 12:48So one of the first big e-government projects in Ukraine was
- 12:52this pro-Zorro open
- 12:54SPEAKER_00: contracting,
- 12:54SPEAKER_00: which has been held up as one of the gold standards.
- 12:56SPEAKER_00: And a part of the reason why you do this and make contracting open,
- 12:59SPEAKER_00: because government procurement contracts are a prime vector for potential
- 13:02SPEAKER_00: corruption.
- 13:02SPEAKER_00: And so it's just this idea of putting things out in the sunlight,
- 13:05SPEAKER_00: digitizing them so people can't mess with them.
- 13:07SPEAKER_00: So if you go and you ask for a construction contract,
- 13:10SPEAKER_00: you don't have a guy showing up at your house and saying,
- 13:12SPEAKER_00: we can expedite this for a tip,
- 13:13SPEAKER_00: right?
- 13:15SPEAKER_00: Instead, it's through a computer-based system.
- 13:16SPEAKER_00: It gets submitted.
- 13:17Everyone can see who checked it and it goes through a normal
- 13:20workflow,
- 13:21right?
- 13:21SPEAKER_00: And then at the same time,
- 13:22SPEAKER_00: I think digital and technology in general,
- 13:25SPEAKER_00: and now we're seeing this with AI and Estonia is making a big bet there,
- 13:28has just been seen as a necessary force multiplier for a
- 13:31country that just
- 13:32literally did not have the manpower to do things that other
- 13:35countries could.
- 13:35SPEAKER_00: And I think that
- 13:37SPEAKER_00: if you're Poland,
- 13:38SPEAKER_00: if you're Ukraine,
- 13:39you've got enough of a domestic mass that you're going to
- 13:41matter almost no matter
- 13:42SPEAKER_00: what,
- 13:42SPEAKER_00: just purely based on your population and your size.
- 13:45SPEAKER_00: But for Estonia, that's not the case.
- 13:47And so you need to find other ways to basically compete and
- 13:50make yourself into an
- 13:51interesting market or really do anything at the global stage if
- 13:54you want to have a
- 13:55SPEAKER_00: meaningful impact.
- 13:56And so technology was seen as that kind of dual role of
- 13:59preventing corruption and
- 14:00SPEAKER_00: serving as a force multiplier for
- 14:03a workforce that just did not exist in the country
- 14:05post-independence and also solve
- 14:07SPEAKER_00: these pressing problems.
- 14:09SPEAKER_01: That makes a lot of sense.
- 14:10There's two key technologies that I'd love you to explain for
- 14:15an American audience
- 14:16SPEAKER_01: as you describe it.
- 14:17SPEAKER_01: These are the two digitalization pieces that really matter.
- 14:21SPEAKER_01: There's the digital identity,
- 14:22SPEAKER_01: the EIDs for Estonians,
- 14:25SPEAKER_01: and there's this thing called XROAD,
- 14:27SPEAKER_01: which is your secure data exchange layer.
- 14:29SPEAKER_01: I could use a 101 on what each of those is,
- 14:32SPEAKER_01: and I think that probably should frame the rest of the conversation.
- 14:35SPEAKER_00: Cool.
- 14:35SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 14:36SPEAKER_00: So indeed,
- 14:37SPEAKER_00: I think,
- 14:38SPEAKER_00: well,
- 14:38one thing before we get into it that I want to emphasize is
- 14:40that I think these are
- 14:41SPEAKER_00: the foundations of Estonia's e-government and Estonia's digital society.
- 14:45SPEAKER_00: But I don't think,
- 14:47and nor should any other country necessarily adopt wholesale
- 14:50the exact technologies
- 14:51SPEAKER_00: or the exact techniques that Estonia did.
- 14:53SPEAKER_00: And that's something that I hope I get across in the book as well,
- 14:57SPEAKER_00: is that Estonia should be looked at for kind of the foundational lessons.
- 15:01SPEAKER_00: But
- 15:01SPEAKER_00: When I used to work for the government,
- 15:02SPEAKER_00: because I'm an American,
- 15:03SPEAKER_00: when American delegations would come to town,
- 15:06SPEAKER_00: sometimes they'd bring me out and say,
- 15:07SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 15:07SPEAKER_00: talk to them about Estonia.
- 15:08SPEAKER_00: And one of the things that would come up frequently is,
- 15:10SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 15:11SPEAKER_00: can we kind of take Estonia in a box or like just copy this?
- 15:13SPEAKER_00: And like that doesn't really work, nor should it.
- 15:16SPEAKER_00: So I hope that for someplace like America,
- 15:18SPEAKER_00: where I'm pretty skeptical that,
- 15:20SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 15:20SPEAKER_00: a digital identity at the federal level is likely.
- 15:23SPEAKER_00: I mean, we're dealing with real ID, which has taken...
- 15:27SPEAKER_00: 15 years or something to just update our driver's license.
- 15:29SPEAKER_00: Yeah, exactly.
- 15:31But I do think that you might end up in a situation where we've
- 15:35all got phones and
- 15:36SPEAKER_00: most of them have biometric information or Facebook or whatever.
- 15:40So we might end up with some interesting public-private
- 15:42partnership for proving the
- 15:44SPEAKER_00: authenticity of who we are and kind of connecting our documents to that.
- 15:47SPEAKER_00: So anyways, I just want to clarify that.
- 15:49SPEAKER_01: That's a really good caveat because I think
- 15:52You know,
- 15:52we'll get into the obvious differences between the two
- 15:55societies.
- 15:55I mean,
- 15:55as you flag,
- 15:56Estonia is like 250 times smaller on a population level in the
- 16:00US.
- 16:00So we'll put a pin in,
- 16:02you know,
- 16:02exactly how much you can adopt from the Estonian model.
- 16:05SPEAKER_01: But I just want to get what is the Estonian model?
- 16:07And then we can try and figure out which pieces are applicable
- 16:09and which are not.
- 16:10SPEAKER_00: Absolutely.
- 16:10So digital identity is basically this idea of how do you verify
- 16:14who you are as an
- 16:15SPEAKER_00: individual and authenticate it?
- 16:16SPEAKER_00: So let me give you the tax example,
- 16:18SPEAKER_00: which is kind of a classic one because,
- 16:20SPEAKER_00: well,
- 16:20it's only a month out and maybe I'm still mentally scarred from
- 16:23doing my taxes in
- 16:24SPEAKER_00: the US.
- 16:24So the idea is that you would go to the government website for
- 16:28the tax portal.
- 16:28SPEAKER_00: And actually it has many different services,
- 16:30SPEAKER_00: but you would go into the login page and then you would
- 16:34SPEAKER_00: have a little card reader on your computer,
- 16:36SPEAKER_00: you insert your digital ID,
- 16:37and then it asks you for your identity code and then an
- 16:41authentication pin,
- 16:42SPEAKER_00: right?
- 16:43SPEAKER_00: So basically,
- 16:43you can think of this as like a much more secure version of
- 16:46using your email and a
- 16:47SPEAKER_00: password that has probably been,
- 16:49SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 16:49SPEAKER_00: pwned like long ago.
- 16:50And this basically serves as the authenticator for who you are
- 16:53and whether it's
- 16:54SPEAKER_00: accessing government services or,
- 16:56SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 16:58SPEAKER_00: adding a digital signature to something.
- 16:59This is kind of the foundation that allows you to access these
- 17:02things from the individual side.
- 17:04SPEAKER_00: And then on the other side,
- 17:05SPEAKER_00: you've got the X road,
- 17:06which is the data layer that underlies all of it and allows for
- 17:09the distributed
- 17:10SPEAKER_00: data exchange.
- 17:11So we talked about one of the principles and another one is
- 17:14called the once only principle.
- 17:16And this is the idea that if you submit something like your
- 17:19home address to one
- 17:21SPEAKER_00: government agency,
- 17:22SPEAKER_00: another government agency that needs it shouldn't have to ask you.
- 17:25But you have the problem of like,
- 17:26how do you share that information in between them?
- 17:29SPEAKER_00: And so this is the X-Rod is basically what's trying to solve this.
- 17:32And I'd also mentioned for those who are more technically
- 17:35minded and interested,
- 17:36SPEAKER_00: it's actually run by an open consortium now.
- 17:38SPEAKER_00: So other countries can kind of look at it and adopt it.
- 17:40So if you want to go and like talk to engineers about how to
- 17:43build on this and play
- 17:44SPEAKER_00: with the code,
- 17:44SPEAKER_00: you can do that.
- 17:46SPEAKER_01: Will you talk a little bit more about the X-Road?
- 17:48SPEAKER_01: Because I'm your non-technical audience here.
- 17:51SPEAKER_01: Explain it to me and explain why it matters.
- 17:53SPEAKER_01: What's the upshot for me as an Estonian citizen?
- 17:56SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 17:57SPEAKER_00: So I think the once only principle is somewhat emblematic of this, right?
- 18:00SPEAKER_00: So like just imagine a scenario where you're moving homes.
- 18:03SPEAKER_00: So maybe you have to update your utility,
- 18:06SPEAKER_00: which is,
- 18:06SPEAKER_00: well,
- 18:07I won't use utility because utility is quite often some pseudo
- 18:10private entity,
- 18:11but you have to file your taxes or maybe you have a child and
- 18:15you have to update
- 18:16where they're going to school or something to make sure that
- 18:18you're in the right
- 18:19SPEAKER_00: district.
- 18:19So instead of kind of going through the slog of having to
- 18:23submit this information
- 18:24SPEAKER_00: to multiple parties and maybe
- 18:26SPEAKER_00: you forget one and a letter ends up getting sent to your old house,
- 18:29SPEAKER_00: or maybe you even move countries.
- 18:30SPEAKER_00: And there's just like,
- 18:31SPEAKER_00: it sounds small,
- 18:32but just these little things add up over and over and
- 18:36transferring this data.
- 18:37So it enables that,
- 18:38but it also just enables seamless information sharing between
- 18:41agencies.
- 18:42SPEAKER_00: And something I do want to flag here,
- 18:43because I imagine for some of the folks who are listening are
- 18:46immediately screaming
- 18:47SPEAKER_00: like,
- 18:47SPEAKER_00: oh my God,
- 18:48SPEAKER_00: what about the privacy concerns here?
- 18:49And something that it also helps to enable is that in Estonia,
- 18:53they have a
- 18:54system where you can look at all the information that
- 18:56government has about you.
- 18:57So for instance,
- 18:58they have a digital health record system that is through the
- 19:00government portal.
- 19:01So when I go to a doctor,
- 19:02maybe they add something to my health record or they upload a
- 19:05lab.
- 19:06But the interesting thing here is that I can see who has looked
- 19:09at my information.
- 19:11And if I see that someone that I didn't expect or didn't
- 19:13authorize has looked at
- 19:14SPEAKER_00: it,
- 19:15SPEAKER_00: with the exception of some national security stuff,
- 19:17SPEAKER_00: I can basically demand that the government give me that information.
- 19:20And so it also enables kind of this transparency across the
- 19:24ecosystem of the data
- 19:25SPEAKER_00: that the government holds.
- 19:26SPEAKER_00: And in a way to me is somewhat more,
- 19:29SPEAKER_00: maybe not directly privacy preserving,
- 19:31but kind of fundamentally enabling of an environment that
- 19:34facilitates my privacy.
- 19:36SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 19:36SPEAKER_00: compared to a system like the
- 19:56SPEAKER_00: check about that.
- 19:57I know I could send a FOIA,
- 19:59but I'm not even sure who I would send a FOIA to.
- 20:00SPEAKER_00: And I mean,
- 20:01that's a crazy amount of work to put on an average citizen
- 20:03where the X-Road and
- 20:05also the rule of law that comes along with these technical
- 20:08systems has enabled this
- 20:10SPEAKER_00: environment for Estonia.
- 20:12This was really interesting to me and counterintuitive at this
- 20:14point that you make,
- 20:16which is that you kind of think of this data centralization or
- 20:21the data sharing as
- 20:22SPEAKER_01: this privacy concern,
- 20:23SPEAKER_01: if you don't pay much attention to this.
- 20:26SPEAKER_01: But
- 20:27SPEAKER_01: Right,
- 20:27like I have no idea who the federal government is poking around
- 20:30in my records and
- 20:32there are really not any checks that are visible to me on who
- 20:36can look at this
- 20:36SPEAKER_01: stuff.
- 20:37SPEAKER_01: Whereas in this centralized data model,
- 20:41I can go in and see here's all the data and here's everybody in
- 20:43the federal
- 20:43government or in the Estonian government who has opened this
- 20:47file and looked at it
- 20:48SPEAKER_01: and here's the reasons that they're flagging for doing that.
- 20:51So you can make privacy arguments in both directions is
- 20:54actually the really
- 20:55SPEAKER_01: interesting part that I had not picked up before.
- 20:57SPEAKER_00: Yeah, absolutely.
- 20:58SPEAKER_00: And I mentioned it kind of at the tail end there,
- 21:00SPEAKER_00: but it's really important that Estonia has a very strong rule of law.
- 21:05SPEAKER_00: It's low corruption.
- 21:06And so you're also in a trusted environment where if you demand
- 21:10that the government
- 21:11SPEAKER_00: tell you who looked at it,
- 21:12SPEAKER_00: they're going to do it.
- 21:13SPEAKER_00: And also that...
- 21:15SPEAKER_00: they're not going to leverage the data for ill purposes.
- 21:17So I would be more concerned about collecting a ton of data and
- 21:20centralizing it in
- 21:21a country that maybe didn't have as strong a rule of law or
- 21:24didn't have the checks
- 21:25SPEAKER_00: and balances and systems in place to do that.
- 21:27SPEAKER_00: But in Estonia, it works quite well because of the rule of law.
- 21:30SPEAKER_00: And they also have a very strong press.
- 21:32And one of the perks of being a small country of 1.3 million is
- 21:36there's a lot of,
- 21:37SPEAKER_00: let's say,
- 21:38SPEAKER_00: local accountability where
- 21:39SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 21:39maybe your parents went to school with the president so they
- 21:42can message them on
- 21:43SPEAKER_00: Facebook and just be like,
- 21:44SPEAKER_00: hey,
- 21:44SPEAKER_00: don't really like that thing you do.
- 21:46SPEAKER_00: And nothing grounds someone more than like,
- 21:48SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 21:48SPEAKER_00: an old teacher or one of their favorite professors being like,
- 21:52SPEAKER_00: oh,
- 21:52SPEAKER_00: I don't really like that thing that you did.
- 21:54SPEAKER_00: And it's a much flatter hierarchy in society here.
- 21:57SPEAKER_01: Totally.
- 21:59SPEAKER_01: Talk to me about the upshot of all this digitization.
- 22:02SPEAKER_01: I'm a citizen and I'm having a kid or I'm paying my taxes.
- 22:08SPEAKER_01: What does it matter to me?
- 22:09SPEAKER_01: What does it cash out to?
- 22:11SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 22:11SPEAKER_00: Well,
- 22:12SPEAKER_00: let me just mention that at the high government level,
- 22:14SPEAKER_00: basically it's massive amounts of efficiency.
- 22:16SPEAKER_00: And so there's two sides to that coin.
- 22:18SPEAKER_00: And it's the government time savings,
- 22:20but it's also the citizen time savings so they can focus on
- 22:22things that are more
- 22:23SPEAKER_00: worthwhile and productive.
- 22:24SPEAKER_00: Not to put it in bluntly economic terms,
- 22:26SPEAKER_00: but it helps save money and create a larger economy,
- 22:30SPEAKER_00: right?
- 22:30SPEAKER_00: So there's that side.
- 22:31SPEAKER_00: But on the more human individual side, the taxes, for example.
- 22:34SPEAKER_00: So when I lived in Estonia, I filed my taxes.
- 22:36SPEAKER_00: And just to
- 22:38SPEAKER_00: Right before that,
- 22:39SPEAKER_00: I had been in Germany running a company for Rocket Internet,
- 22:41SPEAKER_00: which is a private equity venture builder place.
- 22:44SPEAKER_00: So I filed my taxes in the US, Germany, and Estonia in quick order here.
- 22:47SPEAKER_00: And so in Estonia,
- 22:48SPEAKER_00: basically the process was I go to the website,
- 22:51SPEAKER_00: I pop in my card,
- 22:52SPEAKER_00: I sign in,
- 22:53SPEAKER_00: and all the data is pre-populated because the
- 22:55SPEAKER_00: the government knows how much you owe.
- 22:57And I can kind of check it and maybe change a few fields if it
- 23:00was necessary.
- 23:01SPEAKER_00: And then I press accept.
- 23:02SPEAKER_00: And so for me, it took roughly five minutes.
- 23:04SPEAKER_00: And I mean, that's pretty incredible.
- 23:07SPEAKER_00: I was a foreigner.
- 23:07SPEAKER_00: It was my first time.
- 23:08SPEAKER_00: And I'm sure if I was just aware of the system and tried to speed run it,
- 23:12SPEAKER_00: I could get through it much,
- 23:13SPEAKER_00: much faster.
- 23:13But compare that to Germany,
- 23:15where you just don't even try to file your own taxes,
- 23:17right?
- 23:17SPEAKER_00: That's just not a thing a foreigner would do.
- 23:19SPEAKER_00: Or
- 23:20SPEAKER_00: probably even a local in some of these situations, right?
- 23:22So I paid several thousand dollars to a Steuerberater that I'm
- 23:25probably horribly
- 23:26SPEAKER_00: mispronouncing,
- 23:27SPEAKER_00: but a tax lawyer or tax accountant.
- 23:29SPEAKER_00: And then in the US,
- 23:30you have the privilege of telling the government information
- 23:32that they probably
- 23:33SPEAKER_00: already have and paying a private company at least a hundred bucks,
- 23:37SPEAKER_00: if not many,
- 23:37SPEAKER_00: much more to an accountant to do your taxes for you,
- 23:41SPEAKER_00: even though the government already has all that information.
- 23:43SPEAKER_00: So that's just like one of the many things that just happened throughout.
- 23:47SPEAKER_00: Think of every interaction with the government and
- 23:49SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 23:49SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 23:49SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 24:10To your point about government efficiency and bureaucracy
- 24:14cutting benefits,
- 24:16SPEAKER_01: you flagged that Estonia has the lowest debt to GDP ratio in Europe.
- 24:19SPEAKER_01: And obviously there are other big factors that go into that.
- 24:22SPEAKER_01: It's not just a function of the raw size of the bureaucracy,
- 24:25but it's a kind of point in the direction of the value of
- 24:29government efficiency
- 24:30SPEAKER_01: from a kind of broader economic perspective.
- 24:32SPEAKER_01: in the book,
- 24:33you compare having a newborn in the US and getting that set of
- 24:38paperwork to having
- 24:40SPEAKER_01: a newborn in Estonia.
- 24:40SPEAKER_01: Will you give that example to our listeners?
- 24:43SPEAKER_00: Yeah, absolutely.
- 24:43So with the caveat that this is research driven,
- 24:46I haven't had a kid in either place yet.
- 24:49SPEAKER_00: I don't have the personal experience to compare here.
- 24:51SPEAKER_00: But basically,
- 24:53SPEAKER_00: my understanding of the system is that in the United States,
- 24:56SPEAKER_00: you show up at the hospital.
- 24:57SPEAKER_00: You've got private insurance.
- 24:59SPEAKER_00: Maybe you're on WIC.
- 25:01SPEAKER_00: There's public programs as well for folks.
- 25:04SPEAKER_00: And probably there's many state and local programs that exist,
- 25:06SPEAKER_00: too,
- 25:06SPEAKER_00: that you may or may not know about.
- 25:08that are relevant for you maybe for your taxes or for benefits
- 25:11after so basically
- 25:12you you have your child and then maybe the hospital helps you
- 25:14with the registration
- 25:15but then they're going to send you the social security card and
- 25:18like a birth
- 25:18certificate in physical form that you're then going to stash
- 25:21like a probably a
- 25:22fireproof safe in your home or a safety deposit box in a bank
- 25:25which is just
- 25:26incredible whereas in estonian system you show up at the
- 25:28hospital the parent has
- 25:29their digital identity it's tagged to them the baby is born and
- 25:33then basically
- 25:34SPEAKER_00: they're
- 25:35It sounds a bit funny to say tagged to your profile,
- 25:38but that's essentially what it is.
- 25:40And then because they have that information and maybe they know
- 25:43that this is your
- 25:43SPEAKER_00: third or fourth child,
- 25:44in which case maybe that triggers an additional tax benefit for
- 25:48you because like
- 25:49SPEAKER_00: many countries in Europe,
- 25:50they're dealing with low birth rates and trying to incentivize
- 25:52more families to
- 25:53SPEAKER_00: have kids.
- 25:53So maybe it means that you get additional tax benefits or
- 25:55additional monthly
- 25:56SPEAKER_00: benefits and they just...
- 25:58instead of you having to figure out what programs there are and
- 26:01sign up for them or
- 26:02SPEAKER_00: apply for them,
- 26:03they just proactively either sign you up in the case of some
- 26:06taxes or they'll send
- 26:07SPEAKER_00: you a message like,
- 26:08SPEAKER_00: yes,
- 26:09SPEAKER_00: no,
- 26:09SPEAKER_00: do you want to do this?
- 26:10SPEAKER_00: Which just makes all the difference.
- 26:12I can only imagine what it's like to have a newborn and dealing
- 26:15with all the just
- 26:16natural things of having a new life at home and then having to
- 26:20think about applying
- 26:21SPEAKER_00: to a government program to get a tax rebate or something.
- 26:23SPEAKER_00: I mean, that sounds nightmarish.
- 26:25SPEAKER_00: And so
- 26:25They just try and remove part of that experience to make it
- 26:28easier for you.
- 26:29SPEAKER_01: Totally.
- 26:30SPEAKER_01: Okay.
- 26:30So why don't we see more of this kind of digitalization in the
- 26:34U S and in,
- 26:36SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 26:36SPEAKER_01: the developed world more broadly,
- 26:38SPEAKER_01: you flag,
- 26:38SPEAKER_01: obviously the U S has a lot of work to do.
- 26:40I think listeners who are American will have a sense that a lot
- 26:44of American systems
- 26:46SPEAKER_01: are way behind where they could be.
- 26:47SPEAKER_01: But as you point out,
- 26:48SPEAKER_01: Estonia is much better than most,
- 26:50SPEAKER_01: if not all the developed world on government digitization.
- 26:55SPEAKER_01: Taking it broadly, why do we not adopt some of these practices?
- 26:58And then just why don't you see them more commonly across
- 27:01Western Europe or even
- 27:02SPEAKER_01: parts of East Asia?
- 27:04SPEAKER_01: What's going on there?
- 27:05SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 27:05So with the caveat that there's no silver bullet here,
- 27:07so I don't think there's any one thing.
- 27:08SPEAKER_00: But I think there's a couple things that I touch on.
- 27:11SPEAKER_00: One is that...
- 27:12SPEAKER_00: Well, I just want to mention the timing factor as well.
- 27:15Estonia achieved its independence at a time when it was kind of
- 27:18the dawn of the
- 27:18SPEAKER_00: modern web,
- 27:19SPEAKER_00: at least in a more commercial sense.
- 27:21And that being said,
- 27:22they had the wherewithal to identify that trend and kind of
- 27:24build on it.
- 27:25SPEAKER_00: But timing was a factor.
- 27:27SPEAKER_00: If they had achieved independence 20 years earlier,
- 27:29SPEAKER_00: I don't know that they would have or could have made the same bets.
- 27:32SPEAKER_00: And they might have ended up with a very different system.
- 27:34So I just want to kind of acknowledge the timing being a factor
- 27:36here,
- 27:37but also flag that
- 27:38SPEAKER_00: If you are thinking about digitizing your country today,
- 27:41SPEAKER_00: like the US is,
- 27:42SPEAKER_00: I hope that,
- 27:42SPEAKER_00: again,
- 27:43SPEAKER_00: not copying what Estonia did based on the technology of the 90s,
- 27:46SPEAKER_00: you should be thinking about how you're using AI to reform systems,
- 27:49SPEAKER_00: yada,
- 27:49SPEAKER_00: yada,
- 27:50SPEAKER_00: et cetera.
- 27:50SPEAKER_00: So that's one caveat.
- 27:52SPEAKER_00: But on the other side, I think there's a couple things.
- 27:54SPEAKER_00: So one is just...
- 27:56I struggled with this in the book a little bit because I didn't
- 27:59want to get fuzzy with things.
- 28:00SPEAKER_00: I wanted to try and get very concrete.
- 28:02SPEAKER_00: But the idea of culture came up over and over and over again.
- 28:05And so what I mean by this in very concrete terms for Estonia
- 28:08is that they have
- 28:09SPEAKER_00: created a culture,
- 28:10SPEAKER_00: especially within the civil service,
- 28:12SPEAKER_00: that rewards innovation and innovative thinking and trying new things.
- 28:17SPEAKER_00: I think it's best exemplified by this program,
- 28:19SPEAKER_00: Accelerate Estonia,
- 28:20SPEAKER_00: which has a tagline of like,
- 28:21SPEAKER_00: let's make illegal things legal.
- 28:23And it's basically a program that is focused on taking ideas
- 28:26from private citizens
- 28:27as well as some folks in the public sector and then helping to
- 28:31change the legal
- 28:32SPEAKER_00: framework.
- 28:32SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 28:33if they make sense and they actually think it's going to be
- 28:35good for the country
- 28:36SPEAKER_00: and proactively working with these entrepreneurs to fix them.
- 28:39SPEAKER_00: And like the people who helped to build this program were...
- 28:43SPEAKER_00: Lauded for this.
- 28:44SPEAKER_00: They're well known in society.
- 28:45I think one of them is now ambassador to the UK,
- 28:48which is a pretty prestigious role.
- 28:49SPEAKER_00: The UK is a very important partner for Estonia.
- 28:52SPEAKER_00: And,
- 28:52SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 28:52SPEAKER_00: folks like Sim Sekut,
- 28:54SPEAKER_00: who is the former CIO of Estonia and now runs Digital Nation,
- 28:57SPEAKER_00: helping other nations kind of build this arc.
- 28:59SPEAKER_00: well-known and applauded in society.
- 29:01Whereas I think in the US,
- 29:02we have this idea that we want public servants to be more
- 29:06innovative.
- 29:06SPEAKER_00: But I can tell you,
- 29:07SPEAKER_00: having been on the congressional side,
- 29:09what I would expect to happen here is that as soon as there's a
- 29:12failure in one
- 29:12SPEAKER_00: department,
- 29:13so let's say someone in the DOD procurement team does the right
- 29:16thing and says,
- 29:16we're going to choose an unproven startup that has this amazing
- 29:18capability,
- 29:19and we're going to give them a $500 million contract instead of
- 29:22going with Lockheed
- 29:23SPEAKER_00: Martin or something.
- 29:24SPEAKER_00: to one of the traditional primes.
- 29:26SPEAKER_00: And then that project goes belly up.
- 29:28There's going to be congressional hearings and people screaming
- 29:30about government
- 29:31SPEAKER_00: waste and this stuff.
- 29:31SPEAKER_00: So instead of being applauded for trying to do something innovative,
- 29:35SPEAKER_00: they're going to get yelled at.
- 29:36SPEAKER_00: And so that creates this incentive problem among the bureaucracy of like,
- 29:40SPEAKER_00: well,
- 29:40SPEAKER_00: it makes sense to just keep my head down and move up the ladder in a
- 29:43SPEAKER_00: seniority-based institution.
- 29:45SPEAKER_00: So that's one.
- 29:45SPEAKER_00: And then I'd also just say that when I think about
- 29:50why Estonia took this pathway and not the US,
- 29:53I think that we are victims of our own success.
- 29:56SPEAKER_00: And ditto for Germany and Japan,
- 29:58SPEAKER_00: for instance,
- 29:58which paradoxically are very wealthy and successful nations in
- 30:02almost every other
- 30:03SPEAKER_00: metric.
- 30:03SPEAKER_00: But their bureaucracy is crazy.
- 30:05SPEAKER_00: I mean, the amount of paperwork you have to do is crazy in these places.
- 30:08And I think that's because when you're wealthy enough or
- 30:11successful enough in
- 30:12SPEAKER_00: society,
- 30:12SPEAKER_00: you can either paper over these problems,
- 30:14SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 30:15SPEAKER_00: in this case,
- 30:15SPEAKER_00: literally,
- 30:16SPEAKER_00: or you can...
- 30:18SPEAKER_00: basically get trapped in this mentality of like,
- 30:21SPEAKER_00: we were successful this way and we don't want to mess up our success,
- 30:24SPEAKER_00: right?
- 30:24I mean,
- 30:25it's kind of this,
- 30:26you don't want to be the one that disrupts your own business.
- 30:28SPEAKER_00: I use this example in the book of the Macy's dilemma, right?
- 30:31SPEAKER_00: Where you're a very successful big box retailer,
- 30:33SPEAKER_00: you're synonymous with upscale fashion and the Macy's date parade,
- 30:37SPEAKER_00: which still exists,
- 30:38SPEAKER_00: but Macy's is kind of a shell of its former self due to fast fashion,
- 30:41SPEAKER_00: Amazon,
- 30:42SPEAKER_00: all the kind of
- 30:43SPEAKER_00: converging trends there.
- 30:44SPEAKER_00: And I can only imagine,
- 30:46and I can sympathize with whatever executive team was there at
- 30:49the dawn of Amazon
- 30:50SPEAKER_00: and was like,
- 30:51SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 30:51so should we blow up our business and bet on the web at a time
- 30:54when we have no idea
- 30:56SPEAKER_00: if this thing is going to be successful?
- 30:58SPEAKER_00: And that's kind of a crazy thing to ask.
- 31:00And so take that to the nation state level where you're asking
- 31:03a politician on two,
- 31:04SPEAKER_00: four,
- 31:05SPEAKER_00: six year cycles,
- 31:06SPEAKER_00: should we blow up the system that...
- 31:08SPEAKER_00: It has faults,
- 31:09SPEAKER_00: but for the United States,
- 31:10we're the wealthiest country in the world and have very high
- 31:13quality of life.
- 31:14SPEAKER_00: And yeah, there are problems, but all in all, it works pretty dang well.
- 31:17SPEAKER_00: And that's a tough thing to do.
- 31:19SPEAKER_01: Totally.
- 31:20I can't remember whose idea this is,
- 31:21but I'll dig it up and link it in the written transcript.
- 31:25SPEAKER_01: But the same thing applies at American state governance,
- 31:28SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 31:28SPEAKER_01: the,
- 31:28SPEAKER_01: the prettier,
- 31:29SPEAKER_01: more lovely states,
- 31:30SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 31:31SPEAKER_01: California gets to get away with just,
- 31:33SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 31:34SPEAKER_01: ridiculous,
- 31:34SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 31:35SPEAKER_01: mistakes in governments generally,
- 31:37SPEAKER_01: because it's got this remarkable premium.
- 31:39SPEAKER_01: Whereas if you're a,
- 31:41SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 31:42SPEAKER_01: generally less pleasant state to live in,
- 31:44the demands on you to exhibit good governance are much stronger
- 31:48and you can kind of
- 31:49SPEAKER_01: skate if you're,
- 31:50SPEAKER_01: if you're otherwise lovely,
- 31:51SPEAKER_01: if you have other advantages.
- 31:53SPEAKER_01: Absolutely.
- 31:53SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 31:55SPEAKER_01: So I'm curious.
- 31:56I know you made it really clear you can't just port over a
- 31:59bunch of the parts of
- 31:59SPEAKER_01: the Estonian model to the U.S.
- 32:00SPEAKER_01: And I think there are some obvious reasons for that.
- 32:02SPEAKER_01: One is the scale.
- 32:03SPEAKER_01: We're 250 times larger.
- 32:04SPEAKER_01: One,
- 32:05they're a much newer country and they were formed right at the
- 32:09opportune moment for
- 32:10SPEAKER_01: adopting new digital technologies.
- 32:13I don't know if we've gotten into this yet,
- 32:14but federalism is another big piece of it,
- 32:16right?
- 32:17We have 50 states,
- 32:18almost all of which are larger as governing entities than
- 32:21Estonia itself.
- 32:22SPEAKER_01: And you've got,
- 32:23SPEAKER_01: I think,
- 32:23like a kind of folk libertarianism or a distrust of centralized
- 32:27power in the U.S.
- 32:27SPEAKER_01: that I think is both a strength and weakness for us.
- 32:30So given all that and probably other important differences I
- 32:33haven't flagged,
- 32:34what parts of the Estonian model would it be productive for
- 32:37American lawmakers and
- 32:39SPEAKER_01: public sector servants to think about taking?
- 32:41SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 32:42So I do have to mention one thing because I think it's a little
- 32:45bit funny and interesting.
- 32:46The Prime Minister Lar and actually many of the politicians in
- 32:48Estonia also have a
- 32:49SPEAKER_00: very,
- 32:50SPEAKER_00: very libertarian bent.
- 32:52SPEAKER_00: He was a great fan of Margaret Thatcher.
- 32:55SPEAKER_00: And occasionally you'll see these articles from like...
- 32:57the Heritage Foundation and Cato and these traditional more
- 33:00libertarian or right think tanks.
- 33:01And there's definitely been a lot of cross-pollination of ideas
- 33:04between these groups.
- 33:05SPEAKER_00: So despite or because of the e-government and push,
- 33:08there is a lot of libertarian sensibility because if you want
- 33:12to have a small but
- 33:13SPEAKER_00: effective state,
- 33:14Digital is a great way to do that and bring down the bloat of
- 33:17the actual pure
- 33:18SPEAKER_00: number of bureaucrats.
- 33:19SPEAKER_00: So there is a little bit of that mentality that exists in Estonia.
- 33:21But I think that when I think of the core lessons from Estonia
- 33:25that are applicable
- 33:25SPEAKER_00: to the US,
- 33:26SPEAKER_00: I want to talk about the broader factors.
- 33:28So the first one that I want to speak about is doing unpopular
- 33:31things when they're
- 33:32SPEAKER_00: going to be very politically difficult for you and cost you.
- 33:36So the example I'd give here is the economic shock therapy that
- 33:39Prime Minister Lar
- 33:40SPEAKER_00: put the country to.
- 33:41SPEAKER_00: I'm paraphrasing here, but
- 33:43He had this quote later in his life after his political career
- 33:46that was something
- 33:46SPEAKER_00: like,
- 33:47SPEAKER_00: if the people knew what we were going to do,
- 33:48SPEAKER_00: they never would have elected us or something along these lines.
- 33:51SPEAKER_00: And because he knew that for the country to be successful,
- 33:54SPEAKER_00: he had to put them in pretty difficult economic circumstances.
- 33:58SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 33:59there were stories of like the government buildings not being
- 34:01heated because there
- 34:02was just not enough money to pay for these things because the
- 34:05country was going
- 34:05SPEAKER_00: through such a shock.
- 34:08SPEAKER_00: The second thing is investing from a long-term perspective.
- 34:11SPEAKER_00: So the example I'd give here is the Tiger League campaign,
- 34:15SPEAKER_00: which sounds a bit basic now,
- 34:16SPEAKER_00: but if you're in the 90s in a relatively poor country,
- 34:19SPEAKER_00: is quite a step to take,
- 34:20is the idea of connecting all the schools to the web and
- 34:23basically closing the
- 34:24SPEAKER_00: digital divide,
- 34:25SPEAKER_00: as we'd say in the US,
- 34:25SPEAKER_00: which unfortunately we're still struggling with that.
- 34:28SPEAKER_00: But Estonia was able to achieve that roughly two decades ago.
- 34:32SPEAKER_00: It sounds intuitive, like, yeah, let's give kids access to the web.
- 34:35Let's help them become more familiar with technology so that
- 34:38they can enter the
- 34:39workforce in the future and be ready to take advantage of the
- 34:41internet economy.
- 34:42You can imagine if you were a teacher and you're like,
- 34:45we're barely paid anything.
- 34:46SPEAKER_00: We're barely scraping by.
- 34:48Our pensions have been decimated because maybe they were
- 34:50denominated in rubles and
- 34:51SPEAKER_00: then you had to turn away.
- 34:52SPEAKER_00: And so it was...
- 34:54SPEAKER_00: quite politically difficult,
- 34:55but Ilves and a number of other folks put their political
- 34:58careers on the line and
- 34:59SPEAKER_00: focused on this long-term thinking to get it done.
- 35:02And then the other one that I mentioned is just this idea of
- 35:06bold leadership.
- 35:07SPEAKER_00: And again, it's doing things that are unpopular, but will really matter.
- 35:11SPEAKER_00: So digital identity,
- 35:12SPEAKER_00: as we've talked about,
- 35:13one of the big differentiating factors for Estonia versus the
- 35:16rest of the world,
- 35:16SPEAKER_00: because other places have digital identity solutions.
- 35:20that they made it mandatory from the outset and this was really
- 35:22important but a
- 35:23little bit controversial because as you can imagine this is
- 35:26again not super cheap
- 35:28compared to alternatives there was a joke that used to go
- 35:30around the only thing
- 35:31this is good for is scraping the ice off the windshield because
- 35:34what are you going
- 35:34to use this card for because there were no services but because
- 35:37the government had
- 35:38made it mandatory it created even though estonia is a small
- 35:41market if you're a
- 35:41SPEAKER_00: supermarket chain here or the local you know a local
- 35:44SPEAKER_00: bank or a local transport company running public transport,
- 35:48it's a large enough market that maybe you start building things
- 35:51on top of it.
- 35:51SPEAKER_00: So today,
- 35:52SPEAKER_00: if you go to the grocery store as an Estonian,
- 35:54SPEAKER_00: your loyalty program is attached to your digital identity card.
- 35:57So you don't have to carry two things or put in your phone
- 36:00number or whatever.
- 36:01If you go to the metro,
- 36:02you've got another card that you can just tap,
- 36:05right?
- 36:05SPEAKER_00: So there's a number of things that basically
- 36:08got bundled in with a card because it became mass adopted
- 36:11across society that made
- 36:12it useful for the population that I don't think would have
- 36:15happened if it was
- 36:15SPEAKER_00: optional and you only got 20% opt-in in a country of 1.3 million,
- 36:18SPEAKER_00: right?
- 36:21SPEAKER_00: So I think because basically they were bold,
- 36:24SPEAKER_00: they did things that were unpopular,
- 36:26SPEAKER_00: and they took a long-term view of this.
- 36:27And frankly,
- 36:28they built the political will across different political
- 36:31parties.
- 36:31SPEAKER_00: So these things continued,
- 36:33SPEAKER_00: and there was kind of a consensus on digitalization for many years in
- 36:36SPEAKER_00: administrations that they were able to execute on this agenda.
- 36:39So I would mention these three things that are very difficult
- 36:42to come to a
- 36:43SPEAKER_00: political consensus on and execute on,
- 36:44SPEAKER_00: but I hope we can get to in the United States.
- 36:47sure well let me use that framing and i want to ask you about
- 36:51doge because at least
- 36:53initially you could argue doge satisfied all three of those
- 36:56criteria i mean
- 36:57certainly it's doing things that are short-term unpopular bold
- 37:01and trying to act
- 37:02very quickly and then you know i think pre-inauguration there
- 37:07was widespread
- 37:08interest in doge even on both sides of the aisle you had house
- 37:12democrats signing up
- 37:13to join the house doge caucus etc obviously the executions look
- 37:16very different but
- 37:17SPEAKER_01: How would you read the Doge push in light of the Estonian experience?
- 37:23SPEAKER_00: Yeah, it's an interesting and difficult question.
- 37:25I think in part because the actual information that at least I
- 37:30feel I have that is
- 37:31absolutely ground truth information is somewhat limited still
- 37:34on exactly what is
- 37:35SPEAKER_00: happening with Doge.
- 37:36I'm going to do a reverse shameless plug and say everyone
- 37:39should read your piece
- 37:41SPEAKER_00: about Doge to get a firmer grasp of it.
- 37:44SPEAKER_00: I think that
- 37:46because they weren't starting from scratch and kind of aligned
- 37:50at the population
- 37:51SPEAKER_00: level,
- 37:52SPEAKER_00: from the bureaucracy at least.
- 37:53SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 37:53there was a relatively small group of folks who were building
- 37:56the actual government
- 37:57SPEAKER_00: systems post-re-independence in Estonia.
- 37:59SPEAKER_00: So they were collaborating and working together.
- 38:02SPEAKER_00: And I think with Doge, there obviously wasn't a...
- 38:05working to get aligned with the existing bureaucracy and bring
- 38:08everyone into the
- 38:09SPEAKER_00: fold,
- 38:09SPEAKER_00: even though I thought it was quite interesting because,
- 38:12SPEAKER_00: like you said,
- 38:12SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 38:13there were many Democrats who also are well aware that there
- 38:15are problems in the
- 38:16SPEAKER_00: system.
- 38:16SPEAKER_00: And even like you talk to folks at any of these agencies,
- 38:20SPEAKER_00: and I think almost everyone will admit that,
- 38:22SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 38:23SPEAKER_00: things could be better.
- 38:24I think it's pretty rare to say like,
- 38:25yeah,
- 38:25yeah,
- 38:25like we're 100% efficient.
- 38:27SPEAKER_00: So I think that was a bit of a missed opportunity.
- 38:30SPEAKER_00: But I don't want to like...
- 38:32SPEAKER_00: backseat drive here.
- 38:33SPEAKER_00: It's a difficult, you know, it's a 100% difficult thing.
- 38:36SPEAKER_00: I guess if I could pitch to Doge and to,
- 38:39SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 38:39SPEAKER_00: the admin folks here,
- 38:40like I would think about the big picture things that would
- 38:43create an enabling
- 38:44SPEAKER_00: environment for government to thrive.
- 38:46SPEAKER_00: Because my experience, at least, you know, being in D.C.
- 38:48the last couple of years and getting to interact with civil
- 38:50servants as well as on
- 38:51the political side is like most people are doing this for the
- 38:53right reasons,
- 38:54SPEAKER_00: right?
- 38:54SPEAKER_00: They want to help their country.
- 38:55SPEAKER_00: They're patriotic.
- 38:57Maybe they're stuck in bad systems and like the systems
- 38:59incentivize them in bad ways.
- 39:00SPEAKER_00: But like by and large, people
- 39:02SPEAKER_00: came to the government for public service.
- 39:04SPEAKER_00: So I would think about making it,
- 39:07SPEAKER_00: and this is going to sound very paradoxical,
- 39:09SPEAKER_00: I would think about making it much easier to fire people to start with,
- 39:12SPEAKER_00: because frankly,
- 39:13SPEAKER_00: there are low performers.
- 39:14SPEAKER_00: You have an environment that incentivizes seniority,
- 39:16SPEAKER_00: keeping your head down,
- 39:17SPEAKER_00: as well as it just has been very difficult to let underperformers go.
- 39:21And I've been lucky enough to work in my career with some
- 39:23incredible people.
- 39:24SPEAKER_00: And I'll speak for myself here.
- 39:26SPEAKER_00: It is pretty demoralizing to see someone who's like,
- 39:29SPEAKER_00: rankly incompetent,
- 39:30and they're promoted on the basis of seniority just because
- 39:32they happen to get
- 39:33SPEAKER_00: there before another more competent car league.
- 39:35SPEAKER_00: I can only imagine what that does to morale.
- 39:37So instituting these sorts of reforms to make it easier to get
- 39:40rid of the low
- 39:41SPEAKER_00: performers,
- 39:42SPEAKER_00: then making it way easier to hire people.
- 39:44Because the other problem that you have is that you might try
- 39:46and get someone,
- 39:47SPEAKER_00: and it might take six or 12 months to actually...
- 39:50SPEAKER_00: You put out the job on USA Jobs,
- 39:52SPEAKER_00: and at first,
- 39:52SPEAKER_00: the person has to know and understand the
- 39:55SPEAKER_00: fascinating USA jobs website,
- 39:57SPEAKER_00: which I know they've worked to improve,
- 39:59SPEAKER_00: but like it's still,
- 40:00SPEAKER_00: it's not the same as,
- 40:01SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 40:02SPEAKER_00: LinkedIn,
- 40:02SPEAKER_00: easy apply.
- 40:03SPEAKER_00: And then you have to go through all these hurdles and whatever.
- 40:06And so it can take months and months and months and there's
- 40:08great IG reports and
- 40:09SPEAKER_00: whatever on this.
- 40:10SPEAKER_00: So,
- 40:10SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 40:11like I would then make it much easier to hire people so you can
- 40:13attract the people
- 40:14SPEAKER_00: that you want.
- 40:15And then I would give people more autonomy because once you've
- 40:17got really good
- 40:18SPEAKER_00: people and you've got people who are in it for the right reasons,
- 40:21then I think you want to give them room to actually execute and
- 40:24deliver on things.
- 40:25Because post-Chevron society,
- 40:26I still,
- 40:27you know,
- 40:28let's see how that all plays out.
- 40:29SPEAKER_00: But if I look at the world,
- 40:30SPEAKER_00: having been a former congressional staffer,
- 40:32SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 40:32SPEAKER_00: imagine trying to write a requirements doc for like make an e-tax system.
- 40:35Like I'm sure someone can write the bill that tells line by
- 40:38line someone how to do
- 40:39SPEAKER_00: that,
- 40:39SPEAKER_00: but that's a crazy way to try and execute policy versus
- 40:42SPEAKER_00: here's the end state we're trying to get to and kind of at a high level.
- 40:45SPEAKER_00: Now, you agency being the expert, go execute and do it, right?
- 40:48SPEAKER_00: And Congress can and should provide oversight throughout these processes.
- 40:52But I want the most knowledgeable people within an agency to
- 40:56execute on this.
- 40:57I wouldn't think about going to the DOD and be like,
- 41:00no,
- 41:00you guys should fight a war this way.
- 41:01SPEAKER_00: That's not my job as a congressman.
- 41:03SPEAKER_00: Of course,
- 41:03SPEAKER_00: there's oversight and whatever,
- 41:04SPEAKER_00: but I want the experts to make the day-to-day decisions.
- 41:07SPEAKER_00: So-
- 41:08SPEAKER_00: I think increasing the autonomy,
- 41:10SPEAKER_00: which I also,
- 41:11SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 41:11having worked with many great people in Congress and throughout
- 41:14the civil service,
- 41:15I think it's something that also drives out really top
- 41:18performers is they came here
- 41:19SPEAKER_00: to do something and to give back and build.
- 41:21But if you're just trapped under checkboxes and checkboxes of
- 41:25paperwork and
- 41:25SPEAKER_00: processes and whatever,
- 41:26and you can't actually do anything and you've got a job waiting
- 41:29for you back in the
- 41:29SPEAKER_00: private sector that pays your three or five times as much like.
- 41:33SPEAKER_00: That's an easy question, right?
- 41:35SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 41:35SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 41:36just to your point about the Doge missed opportunity to bring
- 41:40people in the civil
- 41:41SPEAKER_01: service and from across the political spectrum who have these good ideas.
- 41:45SPEAKER_01: I will have to anonymize this,
- 41:48SPEAKER_01: but I talked to somebody who was pretty senior in a recent Democratic
- 41:52SPEAKER_01: administration who said,
- 41:54SPEAKER_01: I'd love to lay out
- 41:55SPEAKER_01: for you,
- 41:56all of the places in my agency that I think Doge could take a
- 42:01scalpel to and all of
- 42:02SPEAKER_01: these things that they could fix.
- 42:03SPEAKER_01: But because of the political environment that Doge has created,
- 42:06SPEAKER_01: that would be seen as a total betrayal of former colleagues.
- 42:09SPEAKER_01: And I think you can apportion blame where you want.
- 42:11You can say this person should be braver about that or trust
- 42:15Doge more,
- 42:15or you can say,
- 42:16I think
- 42:17pretty reasonably,
- 42:17Doge has created a really toxic environment for sourcing this
- 42:21kind of stuff.
- 42:21And you can't trust that they won't take a hatchet to the
- 42:24entire system root and branch.
- 42:26But it was really striking because this person who was very
- 42:28senior had a bunch of
- 42:29SPEAKER_01: criticisms about the way this agency functioned.
- 42:32SPEAKER_01: And I think in another context,
- 42:34we've been happy to give those criticisms to a Republican
- 42:37administration and said,
- 42:38SPEAKER_01: you should tackle these issues.
- 42:40SPEAKER_01: I am curious, one piece of
- 42:43the doge push that we have not seen a lot of in public is this
- 42:46idea that Elon
- 42:47talked a lot about initially of integrating AI and integrating
- 42:53data across the
- 42:54SPEAKER_01: federal government.
- 42:55And this is one that I think was more tweeted about than
- 42:59publicly reported on.
- 42:59But I'm curious if you were at the helm of of that push in the
- 43:05federal government,
- 43:06SPEAKER_01: having had your deep Estonia experience,
- 43:10SPEAKER_01: what kinds of things would you be interested in tackling?
- 43:13SPEAKER_01: Like leaving whatever is actually going to kind of doge aside,
- 43:16SPEAKER_01: what would you want to see from an AI integration perspective?
- 43:21SPEAKER_00: Oh, fascinating.
- 43:22SPEAKER_00: Okay,
- 43:23SPEAKER_00: so I'll start with saying I had a colleague who always said,
- 43:26SPEAKER_00: you have to do your homework before you were able to watch TV.
- 43:29SPEAKER_00: And so the idea here,
- 43:30SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 43:31in this context is you have to kind of fix the foundations of a
- 43:34bunch of systems.
- 43:34SPEAKER_00: So,
- 43:35SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 43:35SPEAKER_00: certainly you had EID and the X road,
- 43:37but making sure that you had the fundamentals in place to
- 43:41actually build properly
- 43:42rather than just introducing more kludge and like another
- 43:44workaround to the system.
- 43:46SPEAKER_00: So with that being said, something that I would prioritize and...
- 43:51SPEAKER_00: I guess I boil this down to the American dream of like the house,
- 43:54SPEAKER_00: the yard,
- 43:55SPEAKER_00: the picket fence,
- 43:55and the 2.5 kids and having a family and having kids who will
- 43:58have a chance at a
- 43:59SPEAKER_00: much better life than you did.
- 44:00When I boil that down,
- 44:01it's like healthcare,
- 44:03education,
- 44:04and housing,
- 44:05right?
- 44:05And so I would love to use AI to effectively look at rules that
- 44:10we could eliminate
- 44:11SPEAKER_00: in the permitting process,
- 44:12SPEAKER_00: for instance.
- 44:13SPEAKER_00: I think that's probably one of the big ones.
- 44:14SPEAKER_00: And I think people are actually actively trying to do that.
- 44:17SPEAKER_00: I don't know,
- 44:17SPEAKER_00: inside government or outside government,
- 44:19SPEAKER_00: but I think kind of this is a bit of a cop-out,
- 44:21but like focusing on the biggest things that really affect
- 44:24people day to day and
- 44:25SPEAKER_00: are having the worst outcomes on society.
- 44:28SPEAKER_00: So for instance,
- 44:29the VA runs basically the largest healthcare provider in the
- 44:32United States,
- 44:33SPEAKER_00: right?
- 44:33SPEAKER_00: And so I would love to go to VA and just be like,
- 44:36SPEAKER_00: hey,
- 44:36SPEAKER_00: what are the things that we can do to use AI to make this more efficient?
- 44:40SPEAKER_00: And maybe it's...
- 44:41automating some of the scheduling,
- 44:43maybe it's freeing up times for doctors.
- 44:45SPEAKER_00: I don't know what it is,
- 44:46SPEAKER_00: frankly,
- 44:46SPEAKER_00: from the outside,
- 44:47SPEAKER_00: but I would just look at what are the biggest,
- 44:49thorniest problems that would mean the most to the most people
- 44:52and focus on solving
- 44:53SPEAKER_00: those.
- 44:53SPEAKER_00: Because I think that this is also,
- 44:56SPEAKER_00: frankly,
- 44:56part of the reason why I wrote the book is because I was
- 44:59concerned that people are
- 45:01SPEAKER_00: losing trust in government and institutions broadly.
- 45:03And I think somewhat rightly,
- 45:05because they're not delivering on what they promise.
- 45:07SPEAKER_00: And I sympathize.
- 45:08SPEAKER_00: When you pay
- 45:08SPEAKER_00: you know, 40, 50% of your tax bill.
- 45:10SPEAKER_00: And you're like, when did I actually get for this?
- 45:12I think that if you end up having these things and the
- 45:15government can fix part of
- 45:16SPEAKER_00: the problems where I think the taxes one,
- 45:18SPEAKER_00: for example,
- 45:18SPEAKER_00: again,
- 45:18SPEAKER_00: if I had a solution where every April,
- 45:21SPEAKER_00: instead of paying quick
- 45:24SPEAKER_00: QuickBooks,
- 45:24SPEAKER_00: $150 for the privilege of me spending Saturday to do my own taxes to send
- 45:28SPEAKER_00: information that the government already has.
- 45:30SPEAKER_00: And the government just had a free pre-filled form that I just click,
- 45:34SPEAKER_00: verify the information and click yes.
- 45:36SPEAKER_00: And I was done in five minutes over coffee.
- 45:38And assuming it worked well and was procured on time and on
- 45:41budget and all the
- 45:42SPEAKER_00: caveats,
- 45:43SPEAKER_00: it has to work.
- 45:44SPEAKER_00: I think that would give me more trust in the institutions broadly.
- 45:47SPEAKER_01: Totally.
- 45:47SPEAKER_01: I think it's a great place to close.
- 45:49SPEAKER_01: I'll just flag for readers again,
- 45:50SPEAKER_01: the book is Rebooting a Nation,
- 45:52SPEAKER_01: the Incredible Rise of Estonia,
- 45:54SPEAKER_01: e-government,
- 45:54SPEAKER_01: and the Startup Revolution.
- 45:56SPEAKER_01: Joel Burke, thank you for joining us.
- 45:58SPEAKER_00: Thanks so much for having me.