Latest / The Vegan Report / A Vote For The End of Animal Abuse. With Liz White | Ep. 17
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you're listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:04If you are an ethical vegan and you care to do more to end animal abuse, but you're not
- 0:11sure what to do, then this podcast is for you.
- 0:15Every week, discover passionate, thought-provoking and inspiring vegan leaders from all walks
- 0:21of life who will inspire you to take action and help you find your voice, your own special
- 0:28contribution to the animal rights movement.
- 0:31Today, we are going to talk about animal rights and political activism.
- 0:36And I have with me a very special guest whose commitment I immensely respect, Liz White,
- 0:42the leader of the Animal Protection Party of Canada.
- 0:46Liz began her career as a registered nurse.
- 0:49She has spent over 30 years as a community activist and has worked on issues, including
- 0:55advocating for the disadvantaged, animal protection and aboriginal land settlements.
- 1:02In 1987, Liz began working with the Toronto Humane Society, an experience that redefined
- 1:09her activism.
- 1:10She is a founding member of Animal Alliance of Canada and has remained with the organization
- 1:16for over 25 years.
- 1:19In 2005, Liz became the leader of the Animal Protection Party of Canada.
- 1:25Liz, welcome to the podcast.
- 1:27Thank you so much for being here.
- 1:29Thank you for having me.
- 1:31Let me start by saying this.
- 1:33I always thought that you cannot be an environmentalist who supports the animal industry.
- 1:40If you say you care for the environment, my question for you is, are you vegan?
- 1:45Well, I'm realizing more and more that this logic applies to other areas of society.
- 1:52For example, in episode 9 of the show, I had a great conversation on veganism and Catholicism,
- 1:58and that made me realize that it would be hard for me to take seriously a religious
- 2:04leader who ignores one of the most reprehensible moral and ethical abuse of our time.
- 2:11Which brings us to politics.
- 2:14If you care about our democratic institutions, then you should not be supporting an industry
- 2:20that spends millions and millions of dollars on a global operation to undermine our democratic
- 2:27process.
- 2:28And I'm thinking about the lobbying campaigns through which this industry captures our representatives
- 2:34to implement unconstitutional policies like the ag-gag laws, or to make sure the government
- 2:40keeps subsidizing them with our money, protecting them against the winds of the market.
- 2:47Or I'm thinking also about this industry and how it weaponized forces like the FBI in the
- 2:55US against vegan activists.
- 2:58William the founder of Animal Partisan told us about this in episode 5 of the show, or
- 3:05captured our public health institutions to make us believe that dairy and meat is required
- 3:11for our good health.
- 3:13In episode 4, Catherine tells us about how Vietnam has fallen to this industry's lies
- 3:20on health through international development policies.
- 3:24And the list goes on and on and on.
- 3:26So my first question for you, Liz, is, is this an accurate depiction of what is happening
- 3:33on the political front?
- 3:35Did I miss something?
- 3:36No, I don't really think you've missed anything.
- 3:39Excuse me.
- 3:42When you look at the whole situation from a moral, ethical, and political perspective,
- 3:49and know what we're facing with global warming, it is absolutely true that unless we deal
- 3:56with animal agriculture as part of the solution to global warming, we will never reach our
- 4:02targets because animal agriculture contributes to at least a quarter of the emissions into
- 4:09the air that causes all the wildfires and flooding and all that sort of stuff.
- 4:15So it's really important that we get governments to look at it, if not from the animal welfare
- 4:21point of view, which I think they should do, but certainly from an environmental point
- 4:26of view and for bringing the planet back to a livable place for people who are coming
- 4:33after us.
- 4:34And I would argue, importantly, for the animals that are going to come after us that are going
- 4:39to be equally impacted by what we're doing to the planet.
- 4:43With regard to the industry, it's got a very heavy lobby at the federal level and at the
- 4:53provincial levels all across Canada, and as a result have acquired substantial subsidies
- 5:00to allow them to market their products more widely.
- 5:05And because of the demand, we have systems that inherently are cruel to the beings that
- 5:12we ultimately, some people ultimately put on the plate.
- 5:16So it's a big Titanic to turn around.
- 5:21It's a very, very big ship because people are pretty bent in their ways to actually
- 5:27eat meat and leather and all that sort of stuff.
- 5:32So I think we have a big job, but until we actually deliver the political part of it,
- 5:40because that's where the politicians make the decision, we're not going to see the change
- 5:45that we need.
- 5:47When I hear words like subsidy, I have a feeling of boredom and I'm thinking, oh, this is something
- 5:56about economics.
- 5:57I don't really get it.
- 5:59But can you explain why it's important to understand what's happening on that front?
- 6:08The most common thing that people say to me when I talk about the political party is they
- 6:13hate politics.
- 6:14They don't like politicians.
- 6:16They don't trust them.
- 6:17They don't want to have anything to do with them.
- 6:19They're going to turn their back on democracy and walk away.
- 6:22And I say to them, that is a huge mistake because like it or not, if we really want
- 6:30things to change for animals in Canada, we have to do the politics.
- 6:37And it's the politicians.
- 6:38They're the gatekeepers of all the legislation.
- 6:40They decide who lives, who dies, when they die, in what manner, is it cruel, how they're
- 6:45sold, what's done with them.
- 6:47All of that is political.
- 6:49And until we address that, there is no way that we are going to change the landscape
- 6:55with regard to how we treat animals, particularly food animals, which of course accounts for
- 7:00the largest number.
- 7:02Well let's take maybe a few step backs before getting into the heart of this issue.
- 7:07I'm curious about your own journey.
- 7:10So when and why did you decide to become vegan?
- 7:14And most importantly, why did you decide to take the extra step by becoming an activist?
- 7:23I went, well, at the end of my nursing part, a friend of mine, Clay Ruby, he's a criminal
- 7:30lawyer, was helping the Toronto Humane Society and asked if I would go down and do some public
- 7:37relations stuff with.
- 7:38I did and was there for just a few years.
- 7:42But during that time, I was vegetarian and very proud of it.
- 7:47And Gary Francione came to the Toronto Humane Society to do some work.
- 7:51He's an activist in the United States and a lawyer.
- 7:54And he said, you should be ashamed of yourself.
- 7:57You do not know what you're talking about.
- 8:00Unless you become totally vegan, you are not accountable to the animals that you claim
- 8:04to represent.
- 8:05And so that was the turning point for me.
- 8:07So I became vegan, I think in 88, maybe 89.
- 8:13I can't remember now.
- 8:14It's a long time ago.
- 8:16But that was a turning point for me.
- 8:19And I realized that if we didn't do something about it in a greater sense than just exposing
- 8:26all of the cruelty, which is important to do, but to try and find a real solution for
- 8:32it, can we get legislation that changes certain things?
- 8:35Can we?
- 8:36But what is it that we can do to move the yardstick along to help people consider becoming
- 8:42vegetarian and vegan?
- 8:43And so that was the journey.
- 8:47So my goal with this podcast is to convince vegans to do more.
- 8:54What would you say to those vegans who want to do more but don't know where to start?
- 8:59Well, I guess I would say you start in your own neighborhood.
- 9:04You have municipal politicians, provincial politicians, or federal politicians.
- 9:13And those are people who are game changers in terms of legislation.
- 9:19So I would recommend that people set up a meeting with their MP, MPP, and their local
- 9:26person, and begin to explore the solution to some of these issues to see if the person
- 9:33is at all open to it.
- 9:36And it's hard to do.
- 9:37I understand that.
- 9:38It's really intimidating to meet a politician and to be prepared to talk to that politician
- 9:46and learn to get the type of information that that politician wants and needs.
- 9:55You know, without the cosmetic, when we won the cosmetic testing, that of course took
- 10:00a very, very long time, but we finally found a politician, Yves Duclos, who was the minister
- 10:06at the time.
- 10:08And he helped tremendously to push that legislation over the finish line.
- 10:13Now it's kind of small in many ways because not many animals are tested in Canada, but
- 10:18the import ban into Canada has much greater impact.
- 10:23And I think the second thing I would recommend is that you have to understand that this is
- 10:29an incremental change.
- 10:32You're not going to find a politician who will snap his or her fingers and there's no
- 10:36more animal agriculture.
- 10:38So my second thing is to do a bit of research.
- 10:42Find out the areas where it's most likely to change.
- 10:46For example, we have bird flu.
- 10:49Bird flu can become a pandemic virus and begin to skip from animals to people.
- 10:55I think we have very credible information on that.
- 10:59And I think approaching the politicians about the intensification of raising chickens, both
- 11:06as meat birds and as egg layers, that we can actually begin to make change there.
- 11:14Because if nothing else, we can appeal to the threat to humanity as opposed to threat
- 11:19to the birds.
- 11:20But if we can move it in a direction so that it protects the birds, that is, I think, a
- 11:26win in my regard anyway.
- 11:28Yeah.
- 11:29Let's be smart about it.
- 11:30And I want to plug an organization called, I think, Animal Justice Academy.
- 11:37And I got in contact with them this summer and they helped me prepare to talk with my
- 11:48own MP.
- 11:50And they were very helpful.
- 11:52They addressed all of my fears.
- 11:55And I had a great meeting with my MP.
- 11:59It went great.
- 12:00So yeah, maybe get in contact with Animal Justice Academy.
- 12:06What people don't realize is that most politicians are like the rest of us.
- 12:11They just hold a different type of power.
- 12:14Most of them want to please and help their constituents.
- 12:19Depends on the magnitude of what you're asking.
- 12:21But for example, in Montreal, before the horse carriages were banned, working at the local
- 12:30level to make that happen ultimately saved the lives of many horses that were used in
- 12:36that industry.
- 12:37So it's really important to fix something that you can win.
- 12:44And it may take a long time.
- 12:46I started working on the cosmetic issue in 1988.
- 12:51So it took that length of time to get it over the finish line and done.
- 12:54But we got it done.
- 12:56And we'll get other things done.
- 12:57So you have to be patient, persistent, chipper, polite, and don't ask for too much so that
- 13:08you can build up a relationship with the politicians and make things happen.
- 13:13Wow, where do you find that commitment?
- 13:16How do you find that mental fortitude of continuing to work year after year, decade after decade?
- 13:25I guess I'm not sure.
- 13:28I just am kind of driven in that regard.
- 13:32It really makes me very angry to see the kinds of activities that are done to animals, some
- 13:41of it entirely unnecessary and achievable to turn around.
- 13:47For example, in Ontario, we have train and trial compounds where they put 50 dogs or
- 13:54more onto a coyote and chase the coyote and sometimes the animals torn apart.
- 13:59We have Parks Canada going in Sydney Island in BC going to shoot all the deer on the island
- 14:06by helicopter and with dogs on the ground.
- 14:10These are issues that are imminently solvable.
- 14:15And so when you see that kind of thing, incomplete inaction on the part of the government or
- 14:19actually denial of what's actually going on, it just makes me really angry.
- 14:24And so I just have to try and work on it to solve it.
- 14:29I share that anger.
- 14:30It's just something you cannot ignore.
- 14:32You have to do something about it.
- 14:34It doesn't go away.
- 14:36So I understand that mindset.
- 14:39What I would say to people though is use your anger and your depression and your fear and
- 14:48all the things you experience when you see what happens to animals, turn it into a positive
- 14:53thing.
- 14:54You don't find something that you can do about it and take the work and do it step by step,
- 15:01regardless of how long it takes.
- 15:03And don't get discouraged.
- 15:04Ultimately, you're going to find a politician who says, yeah, this is extraordinarily awful
- 15:10and I'm going to do something about it.
- 15:13And then you can actually work with that person to make it happen.
- 15:15And so we just need to take that energy, which can be very negative and make it a positive
- 15:25energy for change.
- 15:27I love that advice.
- 15:30So you are the leader of the Animal Protection Party of Canada.
- 15:35And I want to know how did this initiative start?
- 15:39How did we understand that we need an animal protection party?
- 15:45And why is it important to have a political party devoted to the cause of animal rights?
- 15:54Well, it started because way back about 20 years in Canada, you could not start a small
- 16:02party many years ago.
- 16:04You required 50 candidates to be able to run.
- 16:09And you had to pay a thousand dollars per candidate to allow them to run.
- 16:13So the barrier was so high that most small parties couldn't make that happen.
- 16:22And then there became an issue with the Communist Party of Canada.
- 16:26They went all, they fought the issue all the way to the Supreme Court.
- 16:30The Supreme Court ruled that it was a barrier, in fact, to democracy and to electoral politics.
- 16:35And so the act was changed to allow one candidate and a number of people who said that they
- 16:42belonged to the party to become a party.
- 16:45So we went to our members and asked if they wanted to do that.
- 16:49They thankfully said yes.
- 16:52And so we were able to meet the threshold and start the party.
- 16:58But in my mind, the goal of a political party is to get into power.
- 17:05And I don't see the animal party of Canada getting into power.
- 17:12So what is its usefulness?
- 17:16But first of all, in countries where they have proportional representation, they have
- 17:24elected animal rights people, particularly in the Netherlands, with the Party for the
- 17:31Animals.
- 17:32They've elected well over 60 individuals to the European Union, to the parliament, and
- 17:40all the way down to the water boards.
- 17:42And so they have... so then I'm asked, okay, so the assembly's got 300 people and you have
- 17:49five animal rights people elected to the assembly.
- 17:52How can you possibly make change?
- 17:55And what we're seeing in the Netherlands is you can make a lot of change.
- 17:58I mean, the government is considering phasing out animal agriculture in many respects.
- 18:06And they're doing many, many different things with regard to research animals and a whole
- 18:11number of things that never happened before.
- 18:14And so you've got to ask yourself, does the presence of five people in the legislature
- 18:18make a difference?
- 18:19And the answer is quite clearly yes.
- 18:21Now in Canada, you're absolutely right.
- 18:24Under the current system, we will not probably get elected.
- 18:29There are just too many barriers to it to actually achieve that.
- 18:34It took the Green Party 30 years to get somebody elected, and they've only been able to get
- 18:39a few seats elected.
- 18:43So our fight is to get proportional representation.
- 18:46And in fact, on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, there's a superior Supreme Court challenge
- 18:55on fair voting.
- 18:56We've supported that initiative extensively and will attend it.
- 19:02So the way you make change isn't always just talking about animals.
- 19:07It's talking about process.
- 19:09It's talking about political action and political power and how you use it.
- 19:13Beyond that, we are there during elections when nobody else is talking about animal agriculture
- 19:23or any other animal issue for that matter.
- 19:27And so I think we make a difference in terms of getting people thinking.
- 19:35At the federal level, we have a number of people who are running.
- 19:41We've had up to almost 20 candidates, and those candidates are out there talking the
- 19:48line about making a country a compassionate country.
- 19:54And that's why we talk about Animal Protection Party as a compassionate political entity.
- 19:59And just out of curiosity, if we had a proportionate system of democracy, how many candidates we
- 20:09would be able to elect?
- 20:13It would depend on how many people we got running.
- 20:16It would depend on the riding and the possibility in that riding.
- 20:19Depend on a whole bunch of different things that we, hurdles that we would have to look
- 20:26at and see if we could get over.
- 20:28But I do think that the way the votes are counted, it means that if we work really hard
- 20:35and get more votes than we normally do, that we have a very great possibility of actually
- 20:42having possibly one person, possibly two people.
- 20:46And then we would be in the situation like the Animal Party for the Animals, where you
- 20:51can actually begin to mold the kind of debate that takes place in parliament.
- 20:58Okay.
- 20:59It's, you know, one of my political heartbreak is having supported the government of Justin
- 21:08Trudeau, the liberal government of Justin Trudeau.
- 21:12And one of the reasons I supported him in his first campaign to become prime minister
- 21:17was because he promised a proportionate system of election.
- 21:25And then of course, he just break his promise.
- 21:29And yeah, it's things like that that make people tired of politics, you know, their
- 21:36little betrayals of their representatives.
- 21:43Just in that point, I've been, I've been part of doing political work for a very, very long
- 21:53time.
- 21:54I was a city councillor, City of Toronto ran that campaign.
- 21:59I have to say, you know, we need to cut politicians a little slack.
- 22:05It's a very hard job.
- 22:08You can imagine the number of people coming to them saying what they want that politician
- 22:12to do.
- 22:13And most of the time, it's going to be difficult to do that.
- 22:15And so we need to set aside that kind of feeling and begin to figure out how to approach these
- 22:23people, what it is they're looking for and whether they can help.
- 22:29I do think it was a very big betrayal on the part of Prime Minister Trudeau to back down
- 22:38on the proportional representation.
- 22:40On the other hand, I would just say he's the one government, he's banned cosmetic testing
- 22:47and the import.
- 22:48He has going to amend the testing regulations for a much broader range of products.
- 22:55And he's going to end the transport of live horses to Japan if that piece of legislation
- 23:00goes through.
- 23:02So more than any other government actually in the last few years has actually brought
- 23:08in legislation that actually directly impacted animals.
- 23:13And so I find when we talk about that, most people say, ah, that was just one thing.
- 23:19That was easy.
- 23:20Yeah, not many animals.
- 23:22I think what we have to do is to give the government a lot of credit for doing something
- 23:29that clearly was not that easy to do and that we begin to build on that as opposed to dismissing
- 23:37it or as opposed to saying it wasn't good enough or it wasn't whatever.
- 23:41It isn't that we should betray our values and our morals.
- 23:48We shouldn't do that.
- 23:49But we need to understand that we have to work with these people.
- 23:53And if we can do it in a productive way, like our coalition did with Minister Yves Duclos,
- 24:00the government came away with a very positive experience.
- 24:05They were putting their toe in the water.
- 24:07Were they going to get something to bite it off or were they going to be able to flourish
- 24:12as a result?
- 24:14And it was a fantastic experience even for Minister Duclos.
- 24:18And so I think we can begin to change that dynamic with politicians by being supportive
- 24:25and helpful as opposed to angry and dismissive.
- 24:28I agree.
- 24:29I'll try to be more positive on my outlook.
- 24:34So you mentioned the Netherlands.
- 24:38Do you know how many countries out there have an animal rights party?
- 24:43And how is their fight going?
- 24:47I don't remember the exact number, but we, I think Australia, it's a lot of countries
- 24:53in Europe, Portugal, Spain, countries that you would say might be harder.
- 24:59Like Spain has a bullfight or that kind of thing.
- 25:03They think, maybe not.
- 25:05But these are people who have actually got elected in countries where there's proportional
- 25:11representation and they're doing some great work.
- 25:16I would recommend anybody go to the website, Party for the Animals.
- 25:21They run a group of all the parties, have representatives to this group of all the parties,
- 25:31animal rights parties.
- 25:35And they do some fantastic work, fantastic training.
- 25:40And I would say for anybody who's listening to this podcast, anywhere in Canada, if you
- 25:46want to become a candidate for a party that has a great platform, progressive in every
- 25:51sense of the word, call me, email me.
- 25:57And we do a little interview.
- 25:59We have a form to fill out and we evaluate people in that regard.
- 26:05So it would be great to have somebody.
- 26:07It's a hard go.
- 26:08Okay.
- 26:09I won't say otherwise.
- 26:11We don't have a lot of big support systems.
- 26:13We're not a big wealthy party.
- 26:15So you're kind of out there on your own in the riding and it's kind of intimidating,
- 26:21but I find that once people get into it, they actually enjoy it.
- 26:26I'm curious, apart from a passion for animal rights, what does it take to be a candidate
- 26:34for the Animal Protection Party of Canada?
- 26:38Well, you have to be vegan.
- 26:42There's no point in putting a candidate up who doesn't live the values of the party.
- 26:49So you have to be vegan.
- 26:50There's a number of other things.
- 26:53People who are rudely, very outspoken, we tend to shy away from because we want the
- 27:01politicians to have a good experience with the candidates that come to their meetings
- 27:07and who come to talk to them.
- 27:11But mostly the criteria is set out in Elections Canada.
- 27:16If we agree that you're a candidate, the basic thing that you have to do is you have to go
- 27:22and collect signatures of a hundred people within your riding that say, okay, I would
- 27:29like this person to run in my riding.
- 27:33And so that's really the only thing.
- 27:38Even that is really intimidating to people.
- 27:40But I would say to everybody who's considering this, it's really important not to talk,
- 27:50we talk to people who believe what we believe, but it's really important to talk to people
- 27:57who have a different opinion and to be able to exercise that in a controlled way so you
- 28:04can have a reasonable conversation.
- 28:06It's one thing to think that what you're saying is terrific and believable and all that sort
- 28:12of stuff.
- 28:13But I can tell you when you get up in front of an audience of 300 people who might not
- 28:17like what you're saying, it's really hard.
- 28:23But it's really good if you can do it in a way that is not threatening, not pointing
- 28:31fingers, but being inclusive in the discussion and having a respectful discussion.
- 28:37And I've had a number of all candidates meetings that have been really interesting because
- 28:42most of the people in the audience were hostile in one of the riders that I ran in.
- 28:47But at the end of the day, when the whole thing ended, people came up to me and thanked
- 28:53me for being there, for putting an alternative point of view across, for being able to listen
- 29:00to what people were saying and then in turn listening to what I was saying.
- 29:06It's like that saying, you make peace with your enemies, not with your friends.
- 29:11So yeah, it's very interesting.
- 29:13And I would bet that becoming a candidate would be such an educational experience in
- 29:22one's life.
- 29:23It would bring a lot of growth in your personal and maybe even professional life.
- 29:29Well, it's easy to talk to friends.
- 29:33It's much less easy to talk to people who don't agree with us.
- 29:39And I would argue that at the end of the day, we advocate for animals.
- 29:45The end of the day, it isn't going to affect the money that we bring in, the work that
- 29:49we do, the pensions that we have.
- 29:52And so if somebody disagrees, we can just go home, go to bed and get up and do the same
- 29:56thing the next day.
- 29:57What we're advocating is a shutdown of people's livelihood and people tend to fight a lot
- 30:06harder to protect their livelihoods.
- 30:09So we need to reach out to those people who are troubled by what people are saying and
- 30:18see if we can begin a dialogue about how to move from an intensive animal agriculture
- 30:26industry to a plant-based industry.
- 30:32And one that is environmentally friendly, because just because you go to plant-based
- 30:36doesn't mean you're environmentally friendly if you're running an intensive plant-based
- 30:41agricultural system.
- 30:44So we need to move in a number of different directions.
- 30:47And I think what we're looking at is figuring out how many, what are the vegan, what does
- 30:58the vegan industry look like?
- 31:01What does the agricultural part of it look like?
- 31:03What does the processing part of it look like?
- 31:07Because we need to figure out what economic contribution that makes to Canada.
- 31:16With that in mind, then we can go and talk to governments because they have an economic
- 31:22interest in moving that forward.
- 31:25And I think that we could go and talk one-on-one farmer to farmer with people who are doing
- 31:32vegan work to actually make change through the agriculture, the intensive animal agriculture.
- 31:39It's a big move.
- 31:40It's really hard to do.
- 31:42But at the end of the day, I think we need to figure out how to move that along.
- 31:48What's the division, the goal ahead?
- 31:54Have you ever thought of a future where we're successful in our cause?
- 32:00It's a question I have asked other activists.
- 32:04Would you support a law banning completely animal exploitation and eating animals?
- 32:10Or do you see a future where it's just illegal to even purchase bacon or something like that?
- 32:20Do you ever think about a future like that?
- 32:24Absolutely.
- 32:25A colleague of mine is exploring the idea about what the planet would look like if we
- 32:31let animals live.
- 32:33He hasn't finished it, but he's looking at that.
- 32:38I do think it's much better to do it slowly as opposed to having it imposed.
- 32:47Because you need to bring all the communities along and get buy-in for why it's being done.
- 32:56Otherwise, we did a campaign and ended the spring bear hunt in Ontario in 14 years.
- 33:04It was a tumultuous time.
- 33:06The hunters went crazy.
- 33:08The outfitters went crazy.
- 33:10And 14 years later, it was overturned.
- 33:14My experience is the wind was great, but if it doesn't last 14 years, the bears didn't
- 33:21get killed in the spring, but now they do again.
- 33:24It's really important to figure out how to get buy-in from the whole community.
- 33:30I think it's better to go slow and to bring people along, not to threaten them, but to
- 33:36make them inclusive in the whole situation in order to allow the changes that can be
- 33:42made to stick.
- 33:46Bear hunting is one of those things that is just barbaric.
- 33:53I was visiting my parents who live in the north.
- 33:58Here I was hiking in a national park and then I started talking with one of the employees.
- 34:08He told me about bear hunting and how there was a market of even Americans going every
- 34:13season to Canada in order to hunt bears.
- 34:18So let's get talking about the fights of your party and how to support those fights,
- 34:25even if it's not as a candidate.
- 34:28And let's start with bear hunting.
- 34:29What is that?
- 34:31Why is it happening and how can we stop it?
- 34:34Well, bears are considered trophy animals.
- 34:40And the provinces all across Canada have marketed it to Americans to come up for a trophy hunt.
- 34:51And it's also unlike any other hunt, is done in the both both in the spring and in the
- 34:58fall, mother and cubs come out of their den in March and it starts mid-May.
- 35:06The cubs are tiny.
- 35:08She usually goes to the bait site alone, puts the cubs up the tree.
- 35:12Hunters say that they know that that's a female bear and won't shoot that animal.
- 35:18But in fact, many females are killed.
- 35:22Many females with dependent cubs and rescue groups all across the country are faced with
- 35:27the notion of what do we do with these orphan bears, bear cubs?
- 35:33Most of them just die because they can't defend themselves and they don't know what to eat.
- 35:38So and in the fall, of course, that's when the bears are most active because they have
- 35:46to put on a huge amount of weight in order to go into hibernation because they lose a
- 35:51huge amount of weight when they come out in the spring when there isn't much food.
- 35:56So they bulk up in the fall.
- 35:59And that's when they're hunted for two months, two and a half months.
- 36:05So in Ontario, because we had the spring bear hunt ended, they extended the fall hunt into
- 36:12August.
- 36:13So mid-August to I think the end of November.
- 36:15It depends on where you're hunting.
- 36:18But these animals are now being hunted for a much longer period of time than they were
- 36:25previously.
- 36:27So it's very, very troubling.
- 36:30In fact, in B.C., the government there is looking at possibly lifting the ban on grizzly
- 36:35hunting, even though grizzly bears are at risk animals.
- 36:41And so at the end of the day, we won a bunch of stuff, but it didn't last.
- 36:50So that's why we need to have the parties because that's where the legislation happens.
- 36:57Unfortunately, for bear hunting, it's a provincial matter.
- 37:01So it would have to be at the provincial level.
- 37:03That's where our other organization, Animal Alliance, will run campaigns parallel to the
- 37:10election to see if we can stop some of these activities.
- 37:16And I mentioned about getting involved without being a candidate.
- 37:21What form does it take?
- 37:24You can become a donor for the party.
- 37:29The maximum you can give is $1,700 this year.
- 37:32This goes up $25 each year.
- 37:36Most people don't have that kind of money.
- 37:38So a monthly donation of $10 would be wonderful.
- 37:42And then if the person in the riding that they're looking in wants to actually engage
- 37:47in an issue, just call.
- 37:50Call me and I will actually walk you through the process and how to do it, show you how
- 37:55to do.
- 37:56You know, much of it is related to I do tons of ATIP requests and freedom of information
- 38:02requests because what politicians sometimes tell you isn't exactly what happens.
- 38:09So it's good to go armed with actual material.
- 38:13At the federal level, you can do ATIP requests and you don't have to pay for them.
- 38:18It's all free except for a $5 deposit.
- 38:22At the provincial level, that's not the case.
- 38:24So you might have to put out of pocket.
- 38:28However, some help in that regard.
- 38:31We can help you with that too.
- 38:34Amazing and giving is a simple way.
- 38:37You know, giving money is a simple way to make an impact and your party is making an
- 38:44impact.
- 38:45So let's talk about a victory of yours, which is the ban on cosmetic testing.
- 38:51You said it started in the 80s.
- 38:55How did it start and how did it come to a victory?
- 39:00And by the way, congratulations and thank you for this good work.
- 39:06It started because I knew some people in the New Democratic Party in Ontario and talked
- 39:15to one of the persons there.
- 39:17They were in opposition and he agreed to put bring forward a private members bill.
- 39:24Then in 1990, this is a long time ago, Bob Ray and the NDP actually took power in Ontario
- 39:32for the first time ever and Elmer Buchanan, who was Ray's Minister of Agriculture, we
- 39:40met with him.
- 39:41He was wonderful.
- 39:42He decided that he was going to move and ban cosmetic testing and that would have been just
- 39:47in Ontario.
- 39:48And so we worked right up to the very end.
- 39:52It was going to move forward and then Premier Ray stepped in and said, no way.
- 39:58And so that killed it immediately.
- 40:02So we decided that we would try at the national level because then it would impact all of
- 40:08Canada.
- 40:09And at the end of the day, we worked with a group of people.
- 40:13We had a coalition of people, including the industry.
- 40:17So a lot of people might not like that very much.
- 40:21But we went to various ministers at the time with this coalition of people who were all
- 40:28supporting, including the industry, who were all supporting this ban.
- 40:31So at the end of the day, it was an easy victory for the government with nobody really in opposition.
- 40:41And so that's why it became a very positive experience.
- 40:46And why the opposition?
- 40:49I feel like this is an easy, yes, let's ban cosmetic testing.
- 40:56We don't need it.
- 40:57And it's actually truly horrible in the spectrum of suffering.
- 41:03This is something very acute.
- 41:07So why?
- 41:09Why do people hesitate on supporting, hesitated on supporting this ban?
- 41:17If you're a politician and the cosmetic industry comes to you and say, look, if you ban us
- 41:25testing on animals, we cannot assure the safe delivery of the cosmetic because some of it
- 41:30needs parabens, very, very difficult products that actually do need to be tested in some
- 41:39manner or other.
- 41:41The difference, I think, today is that there has been an explosion of change in non-animal
- 41:50alternatives, NAMs.
- 41:52There's a recognition that animals are not the gold standard for most animal testing,
- 41:58not just cosmetics, but education and training and testing and even biomedical research because
- 42:05each animal, even though they all look the same because they're genetically a replica,
- 42:14they're all individuals.
- 42:16They all react to stress, housing, food, et cetera, they react differently to those changes.
- 42:24And so it makes a result from one mouse not to be predictive for another mouse or another
- 42:32rat or another dog.
- 42:34And so I just attended the World Congress on non-animal alternatives and there is an
- 42:43explosion of people looking at alternative ways of doing these kinds of tests, finding
- 42:50that it's less expensive, more accurate.
- 42:55The drug companies are the leaders in it because it's shocking, but 90 to 95% of the drugs
- 43:05that were of benefit to the animals are of no benefit to people or in fact are problematic
- 43:12for people.
- 43:13And so the industry is pouring millions of dollars into dead end kind of research.
- 43:19So they're seriously looking for change.
- 43:23The biggest numbers of animals in research is used in the biomedical field and that's
- 43:27a much harder area to actually bring about change, but there is a lot of work being done.
- 43:34So I'm very hopeful that things are going to change fairly quickly over the next five
- 43:39or six years.
- 43:41With Dr. Jens Voeld, who's running the Faux Nursing Trary here in Quebec where I am, we
- 43:50talked about experimentations on monkeys and chimps.
- 43:56What is the situation right now concerning testing on primates?
- 44:01Well, let me back up a little bit because in Canada we have very bad...
- 44:10We have really no legislation that would protect animals in research laboratories.
- 44:15The Canadian Council on Animal Care is the governing body, but it's voluntary.
- 44:22You can't atip it and not all the companies, private companies don't have to belong.
- 44:29So in fact, we have no idea how many animals are being used in Canada, what they're being
- 44:34used for, what kind of invasive procedures are happening.
- 44:39If you look at the undercover work that was done by Last Chance for Animals for ITR, which
- 44:46is a testing laboratory in Quebec near Montreal, I think, you look at how those animals were
- 44:52treated, which was shocking.
- 44:55They were abusive beyond just the testing part of it.
- 45:03That organization is part of the CCAC and continue to hold their certificate of good
- 45:09animal practice, regardless of what we saw in that undercover thing.
- 45:14So the problem is that we have very little leverage to know exactly what's going on and
- 45:21how things are being done.
- 45:22The only way...
- 45:24Ontario has an Animals for Research Act, which we can do with freedom of information, and
- 45:30that has exposed a number of really problematic things in research laboratories with regard
- 45:36to animal welfare.
- 45:38And the other big thing, so if people want to learn about the Canadian Council on Animal
- 45:43Care, they can go to the Animal Alliance website.
- 45:46It has a whole report on the deficiencies of...
- 45:51But the big, big thing that I think really exposed in a big way was our Department of
- 45:57National Defense report called Defenseless about the use of 10-week-old pigs in trauma
- 46:07training.
- 46:08So they knock the pigs out and then they eviscerate them, irradiate them, chop off their legs,
- 46:15cut their guts out, all sorts of different things, and then try and sew them back up
- 46:20and learn how to do trauma when there's absolutely alternatives to that process.
- 46:28So it just exposes the problem.
- 46:34And the reason why we got the Department of National Defense is anybody, any research
- 46:39facility that gets government funding can be a tit or a foit.
- 46:47And at the end of the day, it just shows you that there is virtually no protection for
- 46:54animals in research laboratories.
- 46:56Animal care committees are supposed to be the drivers to care for the animals, to make
- 47:00sure they're being treated properly and so on.
- 47:03The information that we got out of Ontario's Animals for Research Act is that these animals,
- 47:11most of the animals...
- 47:12Not most, animal care committees can be dysfunctional, not meet, never go into the lab to look at
- 47:19the animals, approve greater numbers that you were used rather than lesser numbers,
- 47:25all sorts of different things that run contrary to what animal care committees are supposed
- 47:30to do.
- 47:32And so it makes it really difficult to kind of get a handle on what's happening.
- 47:38That's the thing.
- 47:39There might be laws forbidding certain unethical behaviors, but are they applied?
- 47:48There are no laws that require ethical behavior.
- 47:50It is supposed to be that the core of protecting research animals is the animal care committee.
- 47:59Okay.
- 48:00So the Department of National Defense has a number of different areas in which they
- 48:05use animals for testing and research.
- 48:10And yet there's only one animal care committee to monitor that whole range of numbers of
- 48:17animals that are used by the Department of National Defense.
- 48:22And that's one that we can figure out.
- 48:25We don't have information on any of the other testing labs.
- 48:29We've done an ATIP request on the numbers of non-human primates that are being brought
- 48:35into the country.
- 48:36And there's this whole debate going on about the short-tailed macaques that are coming
- 48:43from Cambodia, whether they're from the wild, whether they're from the streets, whether
- 48:47from a breeding facility.
- 48:49And so we'll figure out whether that's happening by the ATIP request that we will have ultimately
- 48:56fulfilled.
- 48:57At the moment, I mean, any normal citizen, me included, unless you really dig around,
- 49:06cannot find anything out about what happens to these animals.
- 49:11Just briefly, there was one investigation report from Ontario, from the Ontario, and
- 49:21they had a non-human primate.
- 49:23Don't know what species, because they didn't say it.
- 49:24They redacted all that.
- 49:26This non-human primate had contacted a MRSA, which is, you know, anyway, they didn't know
- 49:37what to do with his animals.
- 49:38So he was shut in a room in a tiny little cage and left because that MRSA can be passed
- 49:48on to other non-human primates.
- 49:51And obviously the person who was doing the inspection said that that wasn't acceptable.
- 49:56But how long was that animal there like that?
- 49:58Where was the animal care committee?
- 50:00How could that possibly happen?
- 50:03And so you realize that when things like this break down, that there's just nothing there
- 50:08that really demands them to do something right for that animal.
- 50:14Well, I mean, you just have to visit the shelter and see how people who are supposed to be
- 50:21loving their animals take care of them.
- 50:26And then you think that if this is the level, then what should I expect from an industry
- 50:32that only cares about profit?
- 50:35And also that's why we should advocate for giving the legal status of a person to animals,
- 50:42because if they're not people, according to the law, then they don't have legal rights.
- 50:48Yeah, they're considered objects.
- 50:51But if listeners want to know more about the plight of non-human primates, they can listen
- 50:58to my episode one of the podcast with Dr. Jens Vold.
- 51:03She draws a good portrait of the situation.
- 51:10I want to discuss something I consider one of the greatest threat to animal rights activism.
- 51:19And I'm talking about the ag gag laws.
- 51:22Yeah, that was the reason why I approached my MP this past summer.
- 51:31So what are those?
- 51:32And why are they so dangerous for our cause?
- 51:37Well, the worst of the ag ag laws is Ontario.
- 51:43Okay, so they provide the farmer with the right to arrest somebody if the person's on
- 51:48the farm.
- 51:50People get fined for trying to document the condition of animals, even in the trucks that
- 51:55go by so they're not on the farm.
- 51:58And so animal justice is going in as the main.
- 52:03We've acted as interveners in the process.
- 52:06And that court case takes place at the end of October, beginning of November.
- 52:12And I think it's one of the most important court cases because animal at the bill 156
- 52:21actually actually, you come away from it, thinking that animal rights people are thugs
- 52:30and do illegal activities.
- 52:32So what is sorry, Liz, what is that bill?
- 52:36Who wrote that bill?
- 52:38And who introduced that bill to the Ontario government under Doug Ford?
- 52:43So Doug Ford is member of the Progressive Conservative Party.
- 52:47They're elected with a majority government.
- 52:49It was passed in his first term.
- 52:53Because there were some people who went on to the farm to document the current situation
- 52:59on whichever farm they chose, and there were a number of undercover things.
- 53:03Mercy for Animals went into Maple Lodge Farms.
- 53:07And I think it was Last Chance for Animals that went on to a goat farm.
- 53:11So all these exposés were kind of rolling out showing that farmers who say they love
- 53:18their animals, but none of us could measure that quite as love, given the condition that
- 53:23these animals were in.
- 53:25And it also they exposed a number of dairy operations and pig operations in Alberta and
- 53:30BC.
- 53:31And so there was this rising fear, I guess, amongst the farming community that would actually
- 53:38impact their industry.
- 53:39And I think it could.
- 53:42But the only way that they chose to deal with it was to shut down all observation of the
- 53:49condition of the animals as opposed to say, OK, we don't need this bill.
- 53:53We have a trespass bill.
- 53:54We'll trespass on properties.
- 53:55We can deal with that.
- 53:57But we want to be more open and transparent about the condition of these animals and but
- 54:04chose the other way.
- 54:05So I think this is the most regressive bill that I've read because it impacts every aspect
- 54:15of what animal rights people do, including documenting on the farm or just watching the
- 54:23trucks go by and documenting the animals.
- 54:26There's a couple of people that sit out in front of St. Helens Meats.
- 54:31They handle a lot of spent dairy cows.
- 54:34So these animals are in pretty bad condition.
- 54:38And so but some of them have had huge fines for doing that.
- 54:45And luckily, they've continued to go back.
- 54:47But you risk everything, your money, everything by doing it.
- 54:55And thankfully, some people do because short of doing that, you can't really show how the
- 55:01animals exist.
- 55:04And now they want to pass a similar bill, but on the federal level.
- 55:10And they say that it's for health reasons.
- 55:13We don't want you to enter the slaughterhouses and buildings because you're going to contaminate
- 55:21the place.
- 55:22So yeah, what do you think about that?
- 55:25I think it's utter nonsense.
- 55:29Most of the time, people go in there and just sit and and document what's going on.
- 55:37And if people are really worried about biosecurity, there isn't one vehicle that has gone into
- 55:45those plants where people have given the pigs water or taken pictures of the cows that have
- 55:50turned back because biosecurity was violated.
- 55:55And in fact, when you look in these trucks, they're so filthy, dirty from these poor animals
- 56:01and the stress that biosecurity is a joke.
- 56:05In fact, on the transfer of bird flu, there have been some look at that.
- 56:15And the spread of bird flu came from cross contamination from one vehicle entering a
- 56:21barn and cleaning it up, going to the next bar, entering that barn, cleaning it up, and
- 56:26so on and so forth.
- 56:27So the transmission doesn't come from animal rights people.
- 56:31We're not even we don't want to have anything to do with eating the animals.
- 56:37So it's ridiculous, really.
- 56:43It's ridiculous, but it's fascinating because it's like they take a threat, which is viruses
- 56:51coming from slaughterhouses and their industry.
- 56:56And they're making it look like it's the fault of animal rights activists.
- 57:02And we're risking public health.
- 57:07We're a threat to public health for everyone else when they're the cause for so many what
- 57:14we call zoonotic diseases.
- 57:19And this is something your position, your party takes position against.
- 57:25And I think it is essential, I think in politics, now that we have gone through COVID-19 and
- 57:33understood what is at stake with the pandemic, I think every political party should think
- 57:41about the risk of zoonotic diseases.
- 57:47So you're taking a position on that issue.
- 57:51What is that position?
- 57:53Can you expand on that?
- 57:56On the issue of transference of zoonotic diseases, you mean?
- 58:01Yes, of the public health threat that the industry represents.
- 58:06I just read an article the other day, which said we haven't learned anything from COVID-19,
- 58:10from the coronavirus.
- 58:13That we are in denial about the risk on the bird flu side.
- 58:19Sometimes talk about animal welfare issues with a barn.
- 58:25They have 40,000 chickens in it.
- 58:28And that's a small barn compared to the states.
- 58:31If there's an indication that there's bird flu there, how do you euthanize humanely 40,000
- 58:38chickens?
- 58:40So we know it's not done humanely.
- 58:41They have to shut the barn door, turn off the air supply, and heat up the barn and suffocate
- 58:50the birds, 40,000, or they bury them in foam in the barn, depending on what species of
- 59:00bird we're talking about.
- 59:02And so there is this fear, but they don't want to do anything really about it.
- 59:11And I think we're sitting on very, very tenuous circumstances.
- 59:18I went to the City of Toronto, we went to the City of Toronto a little while ago asking
- 59:23them to shut down backyard chicken operations.
- 59:27That was over a number, we started a number of years ago, a number of years ago, nobody
- 59:31thought there was a problem, you know, we're just being silly.
- 59:34This time it worked, because at least the public health person said there is a real
- 59:41risk of transference of bird flu from the animals to people and the start of a pandemic,
- 59:48we shouldn't do this.
- 59:49So the city banned backyard chickens, but that is so small in comparison to the large
- 59:54agricultural package.
- 59:56And so far, I see no indication that anybody is really doing anything real about it.
- 1:00:04Because and by the way, I talked about this with Colin, who was a worker of this industry,
- 1:00:10he's now a microbiologist, he's working in the health sector.
- 1:00:14And he was talking about it is only a question of time before this backyard chicken situation
- 1:00:22will get to, you know, disease transmission pandemic crisis.
- 1:00:30And many virologists have said, you know, it is only a question of time before the big
- 1:00:35one before a big pandemic.
- 1:00:37And by exploiting animals by doing this, by going through, you know, doing this animal
- 1:00:45exploitation thing, by supporting this industry, we're just playing the odds.
- 1:00:53So yeah, what can we do about it? Concretely? Do you have any actions?
- 1:01:02That's a real toughie.
- 1:01:03I think you, you know, you got to live your own values and, and just by virtue of not
- 1:01:09buying into the industry at all.
- 1:01:12I think if, if people have the opportunity to go and document, I mean, you know, we have
- 1:01:18these spent dairy cows that are going into St. Helens, some of them are in grim, grim,
- 1:01:25awful stuff.
- 1:01:26And some of them are downers, which should not be transported.
- 1:01:31And even complacent to the CFIA doesn't really rectify that situation.
- 1:01:35So I think the more we find that stuff, the more we expose it.
- 1:01:43And I think the industry has been smart in that they have blamed wildlife for the spread
- 1:01:52of the, of the bird flu.
- 1:01:55The latest article that I saw research done on that is that it hasn't come from wild animals
- 1:02:00at all.
- 1:02:01These birds are locked into a barn.
- 1:02:05And so it's, it's, it's clearly within the purview of the industry.
- 1:02:11And I think they're playing with our health, their health, and obviously the bird's health
- 1:02:16in a very reckless way.
- 1:02:19And what about the end of the antibiotic era?
- 1:02:23I guess there is more momentum around that.
- 1:02:27I've heard people talking about the antibiotic, the end of the anti, so the, you know, the
- 1:02:32superbugs and things like that.
- 1:02:34Right.
- 1:02:35That they can't, yeah.
- 1:02:36Because I've been hearing people talking about this since, I don't know, 10 years ago, you
- 1:02:44know.
- 1:02:45So this is not as recent as the discussion on pandemics.
- 1:02:50Have we made some progress around that or are we just as blind as we were?
- 1:02:56I think we're running pretty blind.
- 1:02:58We have the federal government set up committee to look at these anti, the antibiotic resistant
- 1:03:08bugs.
- 1:03:11But I don't think that they've really done anything about it.
- 1:03:14I mean, you can't keep animals in intensive conditions without using antibiotics, growth
- 1:03:23promotants, you know, milk enhancements, all those sort of things that A, compromise the
- 1:03:33ability of the animal to fight off whatever disease there is.
- 1:03:37And then of course, the antibiotic becomes resistant to, it becomes resistant to the
- 1:03:44antibiotic.
- 1:03:46And so I think there's, I think they continue to play a very scary role in the whole issue
- 1:03:55of pandemic.
- 1:03:56It's, you know, with COVID, it was easy to point your finger at another country and blame
- 1:04:04another different people from us for actually passing on the, but the large animal agriculture
- 1:04:14industry is going to be the feeder, I think of another pandemic.
- 1:04:20I hope that's not true, but I think that is a good possibility.
- 1:04:24And I think we're going to see, think about it with these antibiotic resistant drugs.
- 1:04:29When you go into the hospital and you have an infection, you get these antibiotics, if
- 1:04:35those are no longer active, what does that mean?
- 1:04:39What does that mean?
- 1:04:40Even from a self-interested point of view, if you can't get an antibiotic that's going
- 1:04:45to deal with you, with having a bug, what does that mean for the population?
- 1:04:52And so, I mean, even from a self-motivated point of view, I would suggest that people
- 1:04:58get busy and start doing something about it.
- 1:05:02I was told by a physician, we limit prescribing antibiotics to people because we don't want
- 1:05:09this antibiotic resistance state in society.
- 1:05:17And I thought it was just such a funny joke because here we have millions of animals being
- 1:05:24injected with antibiotics daily and you're limiting the prescription of antibiotics to
- 1:05:32humans.
- 1:05:33This is crazy.
- 1:05:34Well, the vast majority, I think, I don't know the percentage, but way up 80, 90% of
- 1:05:41antibiotics produced are for agriculture animals.
- 1:05:44It's got nothing to do with human beings and it's to allow them to raise them intensively.
- 1:05:49I think a government that would just ban the use of antibiotics as a way to allow intensive
- 1:05:58animal agriculture would begin to make that change.
- 1:06:01People have to make that change pretty quickly.
- 1:06:04So yes, it's a threat, but it's also a challenge.
- 1:06:08And I hope that people who are listening feel like maybe this is for them.
- 1:06:14This is the area where they want to make a difference.
- 1:06:17This is calling for further action.
- 1:06:21So Liz, did you want to add something before we end this conversation?
- 1:06:25Well, I would encourage anybody who has this burning desire.
- 1:06:30And that's, I think, how most of us feel to go out there and do something to or try to
- 1:06:39protect the animals that you're most interested in.
- 1:06:43I would recommend that you go for it full tilt because we need many, many, many more
- 1:06:49people who are willing to look at the political side of it and to figure out how best to do
- 1:06:57that.
- 1:06:58I would recommend people just to begin to immerse yourself in some of the politics before
- 1:07:04you even deal with the issues that you want.
- 1:07:07Go work in a campaign.
- 1:07:09Go canvas.
- 1:07:11Go try these various things.
- 1:07:14Sign up as a volunteer for your MP or your MPP to help with various things.
- 1:07:21Listen to what people are saying.
- 1:07:23Figure out how people move these issues forward.
- 1:07:26And then apply that learning to your own desire to begin to make change for animals.
- 1:07:34And so a lot of it isn't actually documenting.
- 1:07:38You have to do that.
- 1:07:40But most of it is figuring out how you get that information to the politician who might
- 1:07:46actually move the thing forward.
- 1:07:49And that's a skill in itself.
- 1:07:51But I would argue it is the primary skill that you need to actually make change.
- 1:07:59So I would recommend that people become political.
- 1:08:02Great.
- 1:08:03That's an invitation.
- 1:08:04So Liz, thank you so much for having been a guest and for having answered my questions.
- 1:08:11This was a pleasure.
- 1:08:13Thank you very much.
- 1:08:14It was a pleasure talking to you.
- 1:08:16Thank you everyone for listening.
- 1:08:18I hope you feel inspired by this conversation.
- 1:08:22Liz has truly challenged my cynicism toward politics, whether you are Canadian or not.
- 1:08:29If you want to follow her footsteps and make a difference, make sure to visit the description
- 1:08:34below where I left some relevant links.
- 1:08:39Subscribe to the podcast now and don't miss out on next week's episode covering anonymous
- 1:08:45for the voiceless.
- 1:08:46You know those activists wearing that mysterious mask.
- 1:08:50What is it all about?
- 1:08:51Tune in to find out.
- 1:08:54And as always, please tell your family and friends about the show and why you love it
- 1:08:58so much.
- 1:09:00Finally, you can always follow me on Instagram at vegan report podcast.
- 1:09:06Thank you again for listening.
- 1:09:08Take care and see you soon.