Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Nuts and Bolts of Design Defect Cases
Transcript
- 0:03The nuts and bolts of design, design defect cases.
- 0:07I'm Lori Krip -Martin, a certified family law
- 0:10specialist and the immediate past vice chair
- 0:13of BHBA's litigation section. I'm delighted to
- 0:17introduce our speaker today, Nicholas Yoka, who
- 0:21also goes by Nick. Nicholas W. Yoka is a trial
- 0:25attorney at Panache Revaputi LLP focusing on
- 0:29civil rights. and complex personal injury cases
- 0:33and he has been recognized as a rising star by
- 0:37super lawyers and named to the best lawyers in
- 0:40America. Ones to watch. Since Nicholas joined
- 0:44the firm he has helped recover over 100 million
- 0:47for clients and currently serves his second term
- 0:50as a trustee for the University of California
- 0:54Hastings College of the Law where he also holds
- 0:58leadership roles on several committees. And now
- 1:02let's get started. Off to you, Nick. Thanks,
- 1:07Lori. Thanks for the introduction. Appreciate
- 1:09it. So yeah, we're here to talk about specifically
- 1:12design defect cases and trying to go to the next
- 1:19screen. There we go. Specifically within design
- 1:24defect cases, we're going to be discussing certain
- 1:27types of evidence which comes into play quite
- 1:31frequently, oftentimes plaintiff or even defense
- 1:36using this evidence, which is compliance or non
- 1:39-compliance with industry customs or standards
- 1:41and government standards. In design defect cases,
- 1:45defendant manufacturers and plaintiffs frequently
- 1:48are confronted with this issue of whether a certain
- 1:52product's design complied with any of these types
- 1:55of standards, and further, whether that compliance
- 2:01or noncompliance is admissible evidence at trial.
- 2:07Just to give kind of a roadmap of where exactly
- 2:12we're going to go, And this is, I think I could
- 2:15probably break it down into five parts. The first
- 2:19is just simply, we're going to look at what are
- 2:20industry customs and standards. Where do they
- 2:25come from? What organizations provide them? And
- 2:30the most common ones. And I think that actually
- 2:34would be of the five points, one and two. So
- 2:36first, what are the industry custom standards?
- 2:38And two, where do they come from? And then three,
- 2:41we're going to look at what circumstances the
- 2:43evidence is admissible or inadmissible, and what
- 2:48claims are brought forth to assist in making
- 2:53this evidence. admissible or inadmissible. Specifically
- 2:56within design defect cases, we obviously have
- 2:58a negligence claim and then we have our strict
- 3:01liability claims and that comes under two tests.
- 3:05The consumer expectations test and the risk utility
- 3:08test are also known as risk benefit test. So
- 3:11we're going to be looking at those and that's
- 3:12going to be really the meat of this talk is assessing.
- 3:16what are advantageous claims to bring forth,
- 3:19which claims you should drop and which tests
- 3:22under strict liability would benefit or hurt
- 3:26your claim at trial and kind of analyzing that
- 3:30strategy that I don't think is really looked
- 3:32into detail by a lot of lawyers until it's time
- 3:37to start thinking about trial. And it's really
- 3:39important I found in our experience of handling
- 3:41many product liability cases to understand this
- 3:45well before you're taking depositions and even
- 3:49into written discovery of how this evidence is
- 3:53ultimately going to play out at the end of the
- 3:55day. And so the fourth thing we're going to look
- 3:57at is also expert testimony, when this evidence
- 4:00can be used through an expert, when it's helpful,
- 4:03and when an expert can't testify as to certain
- 4:07industry customs compliance evidence. And the
- 4:10last thing we're going to look at is just specifically
- 4:12then government standards and looking at specifically
- 4:17government standards, different types of government
- 4:19standards, and how that comes into play. That's
- 4:22a little bit more complex because you have obviously
- 4:25federal preemption and certain issues, which
- 4:27could be a whole other multi -lecture class,
- 4:32law school class, but we're going to touch on
- 4:34it briefly and give what I found to be the easy
- 4:37cliff notes to understanding those situations.
- 4:43So I actually wrote an article recently called
- 4:46the devil is in the details involving this issue
- 4:49because I found that when I was researching a
- 4:52lot of these issues as it came time to prepare
- 4:54for trial is there wasn't much literature on
- 4:59industry customs and compliance and assessment.
- 5:02And I think it's because as one concurring opinion
- 5:06in a prominent case in California, it's called
- 5:11Kim. versus Toyota Motor Company, a concurring
- 5:16opinion actually stated, basically kind of dissed
- 5:20the majority opinion in stating that it's so
- 5:23complex, the devil really is in the details.
- 5:25And it really does matter on the specific evidence,
- 5:31the situation that it's being used for, what
- 5:33purposes is such evidence admissible? And what
- 5:36purpose is it not admissible? And this comes
- 5:41into a multi -factor assessment, but I'm trying
- 5:46to make this as simple as possible from just
- 5:49a bird's eye view lots of times because I felt
- 5:51like that that wasn't being provided and it can
- 5:53be very confusing in assessing the positives
- 5:58and negatives. So we're ultimately really looking
- 6:02when filing a complaint, if you're the plaintiff
- 6:05or if you're the defense, is looking at how a
- 6:09jury is going to be such evidence. And specifically,
- 6:12what evidence will they ultimately even be able
- 6:14to hear under certain causes of action or claims?
- 6:23So I just want to start out by saying because
- 6:25there's, I think, sometimes a little bit of disconnect
- 6:30on understand the difference between what industry
- 6:33standards are for state of the art evidence.
- 6:36Those are both terms of art and product liability
- 6:39cases, but they're very, very different here.
- 6:43And I found that sometimes in case law and in
- 6:47briefing, I've seen that it sometimes gets a
- 6:50little confused. So I think it's worth just pointing
- 6:52out at the start what defining these two terms
- 6:56and why they are different. Industry custom and
- 6:59practice evidence. often refers to design evidence
- 7:03within the relevant industry. Relevant industry
- 7:07meaning any type of specific case that you have
- 7:11in whatever defect it is, whether it's an engineering
- 7:15as to a certain type of metal used in construction
- 7:20project or a children's toy is common in product
- 7:26liability cases, whatever the relevant industry
- 7:28is. is the industry customer practice. And we're
- 7:31going to go a little bit further into detail
- 7:33on that industry customer practice. But I think
- 7:37this can be also considered, and I've seen cases
- 7:40referring to it as industry standards evidence,
- 7:44as basically the what is done evidence, the use
- 7:48of the challenge design within that relevant
- 7:51industry that other people may be using or considering
- 7:54using, as opposed to state of the art evidence
- 7:59which addresses what can be done under the current
- 8:03state of technology. And so another way of saying
- 8:09this is that state -of -the -art evidence concerns
- 8:12what can be done under present technological
- 8:18capacity. It's kind of the best evidence. In
- 8:24other words, just put this in other words, industry
- 8:27customer is the prevailing use of technology,
- 8:30and state -of -the -art evidence is the best
- 8:33technology reasonably available at any given
- 8:35point in time. So now we're going to look at
- 8:44that second part of what I said is the five areas
- 8:48that we're going to be covering. And that just
- 8:51generally where do industry custom standards
- 8:54come from? And they come from a lot of different
- 8:58areas. And I think it sometimes surprises people
- 9:01how many different areas and how often this evidence
- 9:05is confronted in cases. And so we first have
- 9:11trade organizations and associations. Organizations
- 9:15involved in a number of things, including, for
- 9:18example, research and development. and creating
- 9:21codes and standards within certain industries.
- 9:27Here are two examples. The Associated Society
- 9:31of Mechanical Engineers, also known as ASME,
- 9:36or what is I think very common, particularly
- 9:38in personal injury cases and product liability
- 9:41cases, is the Associated Society of Testing and
- 9:45Materials, or ASTM. Generally, trade organization
- 9:49associations standards are voluntary standards
- 9:53as opposed to mandatory standards. But they can
- 9:58become mandatory standards if adopted by the
- 10:02government. For example, I believe that the government
- 10:06through, which we're going to discuss later,
- 10:09what's known as the Consumer Product Safety Commission,
- 10:11which is a government agency, has adopted certain
- 10:13requirements, for instance, children's toys.
- 10:17And so although these are voluntary standards,
- 10:24sometimes they have become adopted as mandatory
- 10:27standards. And for these trade organizations,
- 10:33they're generally made up of many, many thousands
- 10:35of members. Generally, anyone can be a member
- 10:38that's involved in those specific activities
- 10:42that they're covering. But as many people who
- 10:47are listening may know, ASTM, for instance, covers
- 10:51many fields. I've looked at these standards.
- 10:57In, for example, premise liability cases for
- 11:02sidewalks. Premise liabilities for when my client
- 11:06was struck by a baseball many years ago during
- 11:12a baseball game and what the requirement for
- 11:14fencing is at high schools. Recently in a product
- 11:20liability situation, in a case that's been resolved,
- 11:27the power of magnets and children's toys, and
- 11:31basically assessing what types of magnets are
- 11:37allowed to be used in toys and how powerful they
- 11:40can be. Just to give a few examples before we
- 11:44actually go into the law of applying these standards,
- 11:49and maybe we can then apply it, is a couple cases
- 11:52that I've looked at where ASTM standards have
- 11:54been critical. and showing liability, even at
- 12:01mediation, is I've had cases where a child has
- 12:07ingested magnetic toys, small pieces, and it
- 12:13actually gets caught in the digestive tract.
- 12:16So basically throughout the intestines, the child's
- 12:18intestines are being magnetized towards each
- 12:21other, which then you have to go in and surgically
- 12:24remove the magnets. And so having an expert break
- 12:29down the magnets, test the power of those magnets,
- 12:33and according to the calculations provided in
- 12:35certain ASTM standard sections, how much above
- 12:41that? How much above the threshold? were those
- 12:45magnets in power. And it can be critical evidence
- 12:48and convincing evidence on the plaintiff's side
- 12:51or as opposed to the defense side, if it's shown.
- 12:54Well, actually these magnets were well below
- 12:56what the industry shows to be powerful. That
- 12:59wasn't the case here, but that is oftentimes
- 13:02that plaintiffs are also equally confronted with
- 13:06evidence of complying with the ASTM standards.
- 13:12Oh, I don't think I really discussed actually
- 13:14specifically. The Associated Society of Mechanical
- 13:17Engineers is just another example. This covers
- 13:20anything from elevators to plumbing fixtures.
- 13:24It's just another society. On a side interesting
- 13:30note, I actually discovered that ASTM was actually
- 13:34formed in the late 1800s. to address frequent
- 13:38rail breaks because it was so common as rail
- 13:40works were expanding throughout America. The
- 13:43rail breaks were happening and a group was actually
- 13:45developed for a standard for the steel used to
- 13:51create these rails, which I thought was kind
- 13:53of an interesting thing. Having dealt with ASTM
- 13:55for so many years in my practice, I sometimes
- 13:59like knowing how it kind of started. There's
- 14:02also lesser known trade organizations. One example
- 14:06that I've recently encountered in cases that
- 14:11I've resolved is portable generator manufacturer
- 14:15association, right? It's very random. And I know
- 14:17you're probably, I'm never gonna run into these
- 14:19kinds of trade organizations, but I would say
- 14:21that in product liability cases, you'd be wrong.
- 14:24It's very common for different manufacturers
- 14:28to be part of these. lesser known or specific
- 14:32nuanced trade organizations, which they can come
- 14:36together and discuss many issues that all these
- 14:40companies throughout the country are confronting.
- 14:42And a lot of this information is actually publicly
- 14:44available. It's very useful to plaintiffs because
- 14:48it allows certain evidence to be known on these
- 14:53complicated cases before discovery even happens.
- 14:56And oftentimes defense is aware that the plaintiffs
- 15:00have this information before. So it does become
- 15:05popular. And in this case, it's actually so these
- 15:10portable generators are used mostly in the south
- 15:13during hurricanes or when electricity goes down.
- 15:17And families that lose electricity have to power
- 15:20their house by attaching a portable generator,
- 15:24which many houses have in the south. And These
- 15:29generators are actually very powerful and often
- 15:32produce carbon monoxide levels that are 450 to
- 15:371 ,000 times the rate of production of idling
- 15:41vehicles, for example. And what happens is that
- 15:45sometimes families accidentally put the portable
- 15:48generator too close to an open window or even
- 15:52partly inside of a home or inside of a home.
- 15:57And it creates poison for the family. And unfortunately,
- 16:01in these cases, lots of times, a family's gone
- 16:04to sleep and not waking up. And it's very tragic
- 16:08cases that we've had. And through the information
- 16:13that's publicly available from this association,
- 16:17we were able to scale along before the case that
- 16:19it was well known that at least over 600 deaths
- 16:26had occurred over, I believe, less than a 10
- 16:28-year period involving carbon monoxide poisoning
- 16:32from these portable generators, oftentimes during
- 16:35hurricane seasons when there's no other choice
- 16:37but to use these portable generators. In many
- 16:44of those deaths, a large majority occurred within
- 16:47a fixed structure, a home. What we also did find
- 16:53out is that there is commonly a shutoff valve
- 16:58that these organizations and associations had
- 17:00been discussing, which would automatically, if
- 17:03the carbon dioxide reaches a certain level, it
- 17:05would shut off the portable generator, preventing
- 17:08harm or death to people in the home. I mean,
- 17:12this technology has actually been commonly known.
- 17:15For example, now for those of us in California,
- 17:19we have carbon oxide detectors in our homes.
- 17:23And that technology is actually very similar.
- 17:25And we were able to show in this design defect
- 17:28case that this wasn't complex technology and
- 17:31that these associations knew that it was going.
- 17:36Defense, in this case, argued, which I think
- 17:40is very common, that This isn't a cognizable
- 17:45claim because the option for such technology
- 17:51advancements or alternatives is not an industry
- 17:54standard and nor is it required under the law.
- 18:00But from the plaintiff's perspective, we just
- 18:05need to show that the evidence that other companies
- 18:07in industry for years had been testing this and
- 18:13had confirmed the effectiveness of this technology
- 18:16and discussed it. And I think that the prevalence
- 18:19of how many other companies throughout the country
- 18:22had this technology and were actually selling
- 18:24it at the time was convincing evidence. Something
- 18:30that we're going to discuss a little bit more
- 18:33is that California courts basically have held
- 18:40that evidence of industry customs and practices
- 18:43such as that example I was just discussing is
- 18:47not dispositive, even if it was a mandatory rule
- 18:51though, because everyone in industry could have
- 18:56lagged behind in adopting feasible safety technologies.
- 18:59So even if something wasn't mandatory and something
- 19:04wasn't required, that's not convincing necessarily
- 19:10evidence by the law, because then by that logic,
- 19:14you could say that there would be really no advancements.
- 19:18I mean, think of Ford crash cases, rollover cases,
- 19:22that there's times where maybe a roof was the
- 19:27same type of roof structure as all the cars that
- 19:30were used out there. But then the first lawsuit
- 19:33had to come and say, hey, you guys knew of a
- 19:36better way to do this, even though the whole
- 19:38industry maybe has these types of rules that
- 19:42the entire industry is behind and is aware that
- 19:47they can make this better. OK, now just to go
- 19:52quickly through the next, because I don't think
- 19:53they're very common, but I don't think they're
- 19:56as common, is the Underwriter Laboratories, which
- 19:59is an organization that performs testing on products
- 20:03and makes determinations. for the safe operations
- 20:07of those products. I discussed this previously.
- 20:10This is the Consumer Product Safety Commission.
- 20:12I find product liability cases, there's not much
- 20:15more important than the Consumer Product Safety
- 20:18Commission. It's immediately where I think when
- 20:20you're assessing a case, you look to first, there
- 20:24are recalls made by the Consumer Product Safety
- 20:26Commission on anything from example, the children's
- 20:33toys to scooters to cars, any type of product
- 20:41you can really think of that the Consumer Product
- 20:43Safety Commission is also involved in that. It's
- 20:46an agency of the United States government, and
- 20:49its real purpose is, its mission is to protect
- 20:52the public against unreasonable injuries or unreasonable
- 20:58risks of injuries associated with products. And
- 21:03as I was discussing before, these can be mandatory
- 21:08safety standards, but sometimes actually the
- 21:11Consumer Product Safety Commission develops voluntary
- 21:14safety standards. The last one is experts or
- 21:17manufacturer. This evidence of industry custom
- 21:21standards can actually just come sometimes from
- 21:24the experts or the manufacturer itself. Basically,
- 21:30an expert can say and show evidence that this
- 21:32technology is done by everyone in the industry
- 21:35or not done by everyone in the industry. And
- 21:39sometimes it can be as simple as that to show
- 21:41it. And same with the manufacturer evidence.
- 21:46Just briefly, I was discussing the devil and
- 21:50the details point here. Although it's not going
- 21:54to be addressed here, it's always important to
- 21:57keep in mind a few things that most lawyers already
- 22:01are aware of, but it's worth mentioning is that
- 22:05you need to lay a foundation for such evidence.
- 22:07For example, if there's testing being done by
- 22:10a manufacturer or testing done by an organization,
- 22:15there needs to be foundation for that evidence.
- 22:18You may run into issues with that and knowing
- 22:21the methodology or testing could amount to an
- 22:28invisible hearsay at trial, so it's important
- 22:30to make sure that you take the right depositions
- 22:33and are prepared. Also, beyond what we're going
- 22:37to discuss in one second regarding the different
- 22:40cause of action that this evidence can sometimes
- 22:43not come into evidence under, it's important
- 22:46to just obviously be ready to address the probative
- 22:51value of that evidence. or if you're the defense,
- 22:55obviously, looking at the undue prejudice and
- 22:56weighing those. So now we're going to get in
- 23:05and meet that third part of this talk, which
- 23:11I think is the most important, which is how this
- 23:15evidence can come in and what cause of action
- 23:17should not be brought under circumstances and
- 23:20what Shouldn't a lot of times plaintiff lawyers
- 23:23think I should bring every cause of action I
- 23:25should you know, it's it's important to have
- 23:28all the cause of action of the jury have the
- 23:30ability to To make the determination as to all
- 23:35of them and that is I would say very incorrect
- 23:38and and it I'm about to explain why the two questions
- 23:43here is Obviously, what purpose is the evidence
- 23:48being offered in the industry, customs, and practice?
- 23:50What sections of these, for example, the ASTM
- 23:53standards, what is that evidence being offered
- 23:56to show? And what type of liability theory for
- 23:59the product defect is being sought? I've been
- 24:10discussing this briefly, but I think it's really
- 24:13important. to talk about is when I was actually,
- 24:16I have a lot of defense lawyer friends. I'm a
- 24:19plaintiff lawyer. But I think sometimes when
- 24:23I was talking about presenting evidence of industry
- 24:26customer standards, that my defense attorney
- 24:30friends had trouble understanding that I liked
- 24:33this evidence lots of times because they always
- 24:36associate the industry customer practice evidence
- 24:38as favorable to them. And so for example, let's
- 24:42say A defendant manufacturer wants to present
- 24:44evidence that they complied with certain industry
- 24:47and customs. As a general principle, which I
- 24:54had mentioned earlier, is that it's not dispositive
- 24:58because it can show that all of them lacked in
- 25:03making that evidence feasible and prevalent throughout
- 25:08the industry. But if the plaintiff brings this
- 25:13evidence, I actually think it's a little bit
- 25:14of a trickier assessment for the plaintiff, because
- 25:17the defense has to just make do with what claims
- 25:20and cause of action are brought by the plaintiff.
- 25:24But the plaintiff has to really make an assessment
- 25:26early on in a calculation of what claims to bring.
- 25:32Because if they bring certain cause of action
- 25:35or certain consumer product, the consumer expectation
- 25:39test under strict liability versus the risk utility
- 25:42test, they could open the door lots of times
- 25:44to harm the evidence to their case that otherwise
- 25:47the jury probably wouldn't be able to hear. And
- 25:50so for example, it's very common for plaintiffs
- 25:56to include a negligence cause of action in their
- 25:59complaint, but then drop that claim before the
- 26:03start of trial and The reason is for this is
- 26:07to give the opportunity To exclude certain piece
- 26:12of evidence because in a negligence cause of
- 26:14action for product liability I think a lot of
- 26:16this evidence that may be harmful may come in
- 26:19if they find out that there is such evidence
- 26:21of compliance that the defendant wants to show.
- 26:25I'll go over this in just another second. So
- 26:28let's really look at this, the difference between
- 26:30negligence for strict liability and looking at
- 26:34industry customs and practice evidence. So let's
- 26:36start first with negligence. So. Under the Casey
- 26:44Jerry instruction 1221, we have the negligent
- 26:47basic standard of care for a product liability
- 26:50case. And it's, so I want to look particularly,
- 26:55stress one part of this. And so I'm not going
- 26:59to go through and read all the Casey instructions
- 27:01to you all, but let's say just choose the manufacturer
- 27:04here in that first sentence. A manufacturer is
- 27:07negligent if he or she fails to use the amount
- 27:12of care. So fails to use the amount of care.
- 27:19Industry customs or standards may be under admissible
- 27:24or more likely admissible under a negligence
- 27:28theory because it's showing whether a manufacturer
- 27:32exercise do care. The issue in negligence cases
- 27:38is whether I apologize. Let me make it a little
- 27:43bit more clear. The issue is whether the manufacturer
- 27:46exercise due care. And so a jury should be able
- 27:49to take into account what a manufacturer may
- 27:52or may not have considered in a design approach
- 27:57as shown under the industry customs and standards.
- 28:04Let's see here. Let's go to the next. So again,
- 28:11industry customs or standards may be admissible
- 28:13under negligence theory to show whether manufacturer
- 28:16exercise do care. And a jury should have, I just
- 28:19repeat what I already, I didn't realize I had
- 28:21a slide for that, so I apologize. But again,
- 28:23a jury should take into account what a manufacturer
- 28:26may or may not have considered in sign approach.
- 28:30So that's briefly why I was saying that. as a
- 28:37practical matter, a plaintiff will sometimes
- 28:39bring a complaint with a negligence cost of action
- 28:41and drop it, because you really want to see in
- 28:45a negligence claim what that manufacturer knew
- 28:50about and what they took into account. And if
- 28:53they knew that industry standards and they were
- 28:55part of these organizations associations, then
- 28:57that's important. And so that's what I was saying
- 29:01that a defense counsel may find that favorable
- 29:05because in a lot of companies, they have, it
- 29:09can show that they complied with certain bare
- 29:12minimum standards. And a jury might find that
- 29:15convincing. Industry standards under strict liability.
- 29:20So we're gonna first... Okay, so we're looking
- 29:30at the design defect and in a second, then we'll
- 29:33look at under... each standard, but just as a
- 29:39basic principle, I just want to raise the difference
- 29:41between strict liability and negligence. In strict
- 29:46product liabilities, the defect cases, the product
- 29:52is at issue, not the manufacturer. And whether
- 29:57the manufacturer... exercise due care is not
- 30:01relevant. It's irrelevant because strict liability,
- 30:03the product is what we're looking at, the product
- 30:06itself. Many have argued that actually the admission
- 30:15of industry standard, customer standards, would
- 30:18eliminate the very difference or policy purpose
- 30:21between having a negligence in strict liability
- 30:25and product liability cases. This is because,
- 30:32again, we're looking at the manufacturer's conduct
- 30:34versus the product itself. So we focus not on
- 30:42the conduct and strict liability of the manufacturer
- 30:44but on the product itself. The American Association
- 30:47of Justice has stated that the conduct of the
- 30:50manufacturer should not be judged by reference
- 30:53to other manufacturers. It is the product which
- 30:55was based be judged as either sufficient or deficient.
- 31:05But really, and this is what I really want to
- 31:09get down into, is this consumer expectations
- 31:12test and the risk utility risk benefit test.
- 31:18Because the admissibility will in large part
- 31:21turn on which of these tests are utilized. and
- 31:25which tests should be dropped or kept by plaintiff,
- 31:29and how to avoid bad evidence or use good evidence.
- 31:39So again, we have these two tests. So let's first
- 31:42look at the consumer expectations test. And this
- 31:51is under Casey jury instruction 1203. And I'm
- 31:57going to read it, but I just want to focus in.
- 31:59What I really think is important here is, sorry,
- 32:05I thought I had a mouse that I could point to,
- 32:07but apparently I don't. This quote is, as safely
- 32:16as an ordinary consumer would have expected.
- 32:20That's really the important part for what we're
- 32:22looking at here. plaintiff claims the product's
- 32:26design was defective because the product did
- 32:28not perform as safely as an ordinary consumer
- 32:32would have expected. It's intuitive, but it's
- 32:35really important for the purposes here. Under
- 32:45the consumer expectation test, evidence of industry
- 32:48customs or standards is irrelevant because the
- 32:51only issue is whether the product fails to perform
- 32:53as an ordinary consumer would have expected.
- 32:58So this consumer expectation test, unlike what
- 33:02we're going to look at the risk utility test,
- 33:05the consumer expectation test is really narrowed
- 33:08in and focused. It's just looking at what an
- 33:12ordinary person would have expected. So under
- 33:15that theory, it's irrelevant what these associations
- 33:18or industry standards generally are saying. Throughout
- 33:24the country, in fact, there was a recent case
- 33:27in Pennsylvania which really kind of brought
- 33:30this to light and to the forefront where reading
- 33:35what The different sides had to say some argued
- 33:38that under the consumer expectation test, the
- 33:40jury should still be able to consider this evidence
- 33:42because a consumer expects their products to
- 33:46meet regulations. And by not allowing the jury
- 33:50to hear some of this industry standards evidence,
- 33:54you're really asking the jury to decide in a
- 33:56vacuum whether a product is defective or not.
- 34:08And actually, I'll just briefly discuss, because
- 34:10this is an important case, and it is the Howard
- 34:13versus Omni Hotels Management Corporation case.
- 34:17There, the plaintiff was a guest of the Omni
- 34:19Hotel and slipped and fell in a bathtub. And
- 34:23the plaintiff filed suit alleging that the bathtub
- 34:26was defective because it did not apply with,
- 34:28I believe, certain ASTM standards. The defendant
- 34:33filed summary judgment providing a declaration
- 34:37from their expert engineers, showing that the
- 34:41bathtub, in fact, did comply with ASTM standards.
- 34:51The court of appeal, if I recall correctly, held
- 34:56that applying the consumer expectations test,
- 35:01the safety expectations of the general public
- 35:06was at issue here. And so by using that consumer
- 35:10expectations test in this case and having the
- 35:13plaintiff bring forth the safety expectations
- 35:16of the general public were at issue and not the
- 35:20safety regulations of a government agency. So
- 35:24under that test, this court held that the plaintiff
- 35:28is limited in the amount of expert testimony
- 35:30that can actually be brought forth. And so having
- 35:33a plaintiff provide expert testimony that it
- 35:37did or did not comply can't be done under this
- 35:41test because that's reserved for the jury. And
- 35:45it's invading the providence of the jury to allow
- 35:49them the ability to assess their everyday experiences.
- 35:54So essentially, when the safety of a product
- 35:57is within the common knowledge, of people, expert
- 36:01witness can't be used to demonstrate what an
- 36:05ordinary consumer should anyway expect on their
- 36:07own. And so I got ahead of myself. So what about
- 36:17expert testimony? Well, as we just assessed under
- 36:19consumer expertise, the expert can't look at
- 36:21this. And it's actually, which I didn't mention
- 36:25before, it's reversible error. in fact, under
- 36:30this Buell Wilson or Spode Motor Company to admit
- 36:34such evidence under the consumer expectations
- 36:36test. And that works both ways, obviously, again,
- 36:40for the plaintiff or the defense. So knowing
- 36:42whether this industry customs standards favors
- 36:45you as a plaintiff or disfavors you is very important
- 36:48to determine whether you should, in fact, bring
- 36:50a consumer expectations test. So in that same
- 37:05vein, when would a plaintiff actually, for example,
- 37:10want to even bring the consumer expectations
- 37:12test in certain circumstances? Well, in situations
- 37:17maybe where the plaintiff knows that defense
- 37:19will try to admit into evidence that the manufacturer
- 37:23met or complied with certain safety standards,
- 37:28the plaintiff may consider only using the consumer
- 37:32expectations as their basis for liability. Because
- 37:36then it takes the wind out of the defense sales
- 37:39in terms of using that evidence. And it could
- 37:43be useful. It's obviously, I think that freaks
- 37:46a lot of plaintiff lawyers out the idea like,
- 37:48oh, I'm just going to hang my hat on this one,
- 37:50you know. theory, but if the most damaging evidence
- 37:53to your case and what the defense is putting
- 37:56forth mostly in their depositions or throughout
- 37:59discovery appears to be that evidence, it's worth
- 38:02considering going down that route. Before I actually
- 38:16move on, just the... It's important to stress,
- 38:19though, conversely, if the plant doesn't do this
- 38:23and chooses to go down the negligence route or
- 38:29what we'll discuss, the risk benefit test, and
- 38:33bring forth evidence of certain noncompliance,
- 38:38There's that maximum jurisprudence that says
- 38:40who takes the benefit must also bear the burden.
- 38:43So then you have competing, conflicting arguments
- 38:46basically on the compliance versus non -compliance
- 38:49and what standards are being applied. And then
- 38:54a duel of experts, I guess you could say. So
- 38:58now let's look at the risk utility, which obviously
- 39:00I already gave away, is going to be more. lenient
- 39:05as opposed to the consumer expectations test
- 39:07and allowing this evidence in. And first, we'll
- 39:12look at, as we did before, Casey instruction
- 39:171204, which is the risk benefit test. But this
- 39:21is just the first part before we get to the Barker
- 39:25factors. And so here, the plaintiff claims that
- 39:30the design caused harm to the plaintiff. To establish
- 39:35this claim must prove the manufacturer, distributes,
- 39:38sold the product, that the plaintiff was harmed,
- 39:41and that the design was a substantial factor
- 39:42in causing harm. But as I'm sure most people
- 39:46here know, the real crux of the risk benefit
- 39:49test, as I said, is the Barker factors, which
- 39:55is also found in KC 1204 and based on the seminal
- 39:59case of Barker. versus low engineering. And under
- 40:07the risk benefit or risk utility test, whatever
- 40:12you prefer, it really goes to reasonableness.
- 40:17And here we have the different factors laid out.
- 40:22So the gravity of the potential harm resulting
- 40:24from the use of the product to the likelihood
- 40:27that this harm would occur. Three, the feasibility
- 40:32of an alternative, safer design at the time of
- 40:35the manufacturing. The cost of the alternative
- 40:39design and the disadvantages of an alternative
- 40:42design. And so it really is coming down to reasonableness
- 40:56and weighing the benefits and risks of changes
- 41:02to a specific product. And this actually kind
- 41:05of, as one court essentially stated, was that
- 41:10this kind of sounds in traditional negligence
- 41:12principles, similar to reasonable foreseeability
- 41:16of harm, for example. So, you know, sometimes
- 41:19I actually have a little bit of time different,
- 41:21hard time differentiating how this risk utility
- 41:24test is actually different than negligence because
- 41:27it kind of has a little bit of crossover in how
- 41:32you really assess, for example, the manufacturers
- 41:36do care. And obviously, in strict liability,
- 41:41as we discussed, we're looking at the product
- 41:43self. But I have a hard time differentiating
- 41:46sometimes the advantages or disadvantages of
- 41:50the risk utility as opposed to just a negligence
- 41:53when it ultimately is said and done. beyond just
- 41:57basically an academic perspective of the differences.
- 42:10So unlike under the consumer expectation test,
- 42:13the issue of design defect cannot fairly be resolved
- 42:15by standard list reference to the expectations
- 42:18of an ordinary consumer. We basically just discussed
- 42:22that. So here, in this analysis, the jurors are
- 42:40forced to assess technical issues, as we discussed
- 42:44all those barker factors, such as the gravity
- 42:47of the potential harm, the likelihood of harm,
- 42:50the feasibility and cost of alternative designs.
- 42:54In these cases, expert testimonies actually,
- 42:57unlike under the consumer expectation test, courts
- 43:00have said essential sometimes to help the jury
- 43:02in looking at these industry customer standards.
- 43:05Because you obviously, this is beyond the consumer.
- 43:08It's reasonable. What is beyond common knowledge,
- 43:13engineering expertise, and all these associations
- 43:17and specialized associations that make up industry
- 43:20standards to actually break this down for the
- 43:26jury. And it's why expert testimony is particularly
- 43:30important under the risk utility test as opposed
- 43:34to the consumer expectations test. I apologize,
- 43:37talking for almost 45 minutes, a little bit of
- 43:40water. So we briefly touched on this in the beginning,
- 43:58but this is a very important case at Kim versus
- 44:00Toyota Motor Company. It illuminates the relative
- 44:04complexity of design decisions and the trade
- 44:07-offs that are frequently required in the adaption
- 44:09of alternative designs. Again, what we're saying
- 44:11about the expert here, just as a brief background.
- 44:15In Kim, the plaintiffs were injured after losing
- 44:19control of a Toyota Tundra. The plaintiffs had
- 44:25alleged that the truck was defective because
- 44:29its configuration did not have stability control
- 44:36on the vehicle, they alleged. And during trial,
- 44:40the defendant manufacturer presented evidence
- 44:41that no vehicle manufacturer actually at that
- 44:45time had this vehicle stability control. And
- 44:51it wasn't just standard equipment in a pickup
- 44:53truck. And so the verdict was returned for the
- 44:57defense based on that testimony. And the plaintiff
- 45:01appealed because the court had denied or they
- 45:06believed erred in denying in their motion limiting
- 45:10to exclude those customers of practice evidence.
- 45:14So the real issue in Kim became for the appellate
- 45:17court was the admissibility of the evidence of
- 45:21custom and practice evidence and claims under
- 45:26the risk utility test. And the court, as laid
- 45:31out on this slide, came down and said, no, this
- 45:36evidence is necessary under the risk utility
- 45:38test because it actually illuminates the complexity
- 45:41of design decisions and trade -offs. that are
- 45:45frequently used in the adaption of alternative
- 45:48designs. And so you need to have that evidence,
- 45:51even though it wasn't necessarily this vehicle
- 45:53stability control technology wasn't on every
- 45:57vehicle at that time, using your expert and using
- 46:04what the knowledge was at that time of this technology
- 46:08was important. Under Kim, a defendant can present
- 46:22evidence that a particular safety design feature
- 46:24is not standard in the industry. Similarly, though,
- 46:27a plaintiff can also legitimately seek to present
- 46:29evidence that a manufacturer has not utilized
- 46:32a safety device that is in the industry. So now
- 46:44turning to the last portion, of this discussion
- 46:51is looking at governmental safety standards and
- 46:55how they're different than just generally industry
- 46:58standards. Government safety standards such as
- 47:02we're discussing the Consumer Product Safety
- 47:03Commission can be voluntary or mandatory depending
- 47:09on the circumstance. So what are government safety
- 47:19standards? Well, so we have, we discussed the
- 47:25Consumer Product Safety Commission, which again
- 47:28is a government agency that is actually, I don't
- 47:31know if I stated earlier, but it actually is
- 47:33codified and found in 15 USC section 2051. But
- 47:41we also have many other types of government standards,
- 47:45which we are. all aware of, such as the United
- 47:49States National Highway Traffic Safety Administration,
- 47:52which issues safety standards to implement laws
- 48:02for Congress. and are lots of times used by governments
- 48:07to have an understanding of what the laws really
- 48:10should be after studies are done and evidence
- 48:15is provided. Just as a way of background, actually
- 48:21the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
- 48:24began developing for motor vehicles safety standards
- 48:31and The purpose of these standards was to ensure
- 48:36that vehicles are manufactured and sold reasonably
- 48:39safe, particularly as the 60s, many different
- 48:44vehicles were becoming prevalent. If I'm not
- 48:46correct, I believe that that's like the Peugeot
- 48:48era, but I could be wrong about that. I believe
- 48:52that was my brother's first car, and it was from
- 48:54the 60s. And I remember it lit on fire while
- 48:56going to a Dodger game. By the way, go Dodgers.
- 49:01The standards are broken down and relate in different
- 49:04parts for different parts of the motor vehicle.
- 49:07For instance, there are standards dealing with
- 49:09seat belts. There are standards involving the
- 49:14crash worthiness of a vehicle. And for example,
- 49:18if it rolls off the roof, how much basically
- 49:22should the roof force be able to hold? in terms
- 49:28of the seatbelt, webbing characteristics, the
- 49:32buckle, the strength of the buckle, and all sorts
- 49:35of specific standards within then HTSA. And then
- 49:44we have the Federal Aviation Administration,
- 49:47which obviously I think recent events have made.
- 49:51the Federal Aviation Administration much more
- 49:55common on any new source you're turning on right
- 49:57now. It's just another example of a government
- 50:03agency that sets wide range of standards and
- 50:06regulations. Again, like we discussed in the
- 50:22industry standards, presenting government safety
- 50:25standards can come in different ways when used
- 50:28by the plaintiff or by the defendant. A plaintiff,
- 50:32for instance, may generally raise the issue of
- 50:36failure of a defendant manufacturer to comply
- 50:38with a government statute. And in doing so, A
- 50:47plaintiff may even raise a theory of negligence
- 50:50per se by doing that. And despite a government
- 50:55agency certifying that a manufacturer met the
- 51:00applicable standard, there's might be actually
- 51:06going to it in a second, but there's a case Ellsworth.
- 51:10beachcraft, beach aircraft company case, where
- 51:14the appellate court actually upheld the trial
- 51:17court's decision to award a negligence per se
- 51:20jury instruction. Yet, even if the plaintiff
- 51:25fails to prove that the defendant manufactured
- 51:28by the statute, the plaintiff can still bring
- 51:30other product liability actions to show the product
- 51:34was defective. So in other words, even if It's
- 51:39shown that compliance with the government standard
- 51:43took place. Sometimes the plaintiff can still
- 51:47bring a cause of action, even if they lose maybe
- 51:50the negligence per se or cause of action. OK,
- 52:09so I just mentioned this case, actually, which
- 52:12I'm sorry I did not realize I had on the next
- 52:14slide. But I know I listed a few cases here.
- 52:17So again, Ellsworth, the plane manufacturer's
- 52:20compliance with Federal Aviation Administration
- 52:23regulations did not preclude a jury from finding
- 52:26a manufacturer liable for a design defect. And
- 52:32then in Boucherie v. General Motors, This case,
- 52:36actually, the plaintiff alleged that the motor
- 52:38vehicle was defected because it didn't have a
- 52:41padded head restraint on the back. And the plaintiff
- 52:44expert on cross -examination testified that the
- 52:48federal safety standard requiring head restraints
- 52:51did not apply to the subject vehicle. The trial
- 52:55court granted a non -suit holding that that General
- 53:01Motors here had complied based on the testimony
- 53:04with the safety standards. And the court appeal,
- 53:09though, reversed holding that compliance with
- 53:11the Federal Motor Safety Standards, did not preclude
- 53:14liability based on the product defect. So once
- 53:16again, even though there was an expert that said
- 53:20it complied with the standards for the head restraint,
- 53:25it still did not preclude the product liability
- 53:30action moving forward. And then here we have
- 53:39one more Ramirez versus Plow. And while a defendant's,
- 53:47under this case, while a defendant's compliance
- 53:49with statutory requirements is usually not a
- 53:53defense, the minimum standard prescribed by legislation
- 53:57regulation may be accepted by the court or by
- 54:01the jury as sufficient. And this is where this
- 54:06case is really important. It's where really the
- 54:09evidence shows no unusual circumstances beyond
- 54:12that, specifically intended by the administrative
- 54:15rule. This is often used, I find, in my plaintiff
- 54:18setting by defense. to show that it applies to
- 54:23strict liability. In Naglin's case, I just want
- 54:24to warn that this was specifically involved in
- 54:27a failure to warn case. But the way that the
- 54:30court wrote it up, it sometimes is a little bit
- 54:33unclear. And maybe it's necessary for another
- 54:37court now to interpret this a little bit more
- 54:39clear. But basically, where the evidence shows
- 54:43no unusual circumstances, but only the ordinary
- 54:47situation that was intended by the statute. It
- 54:52can be accepted by the Trier fact or as a matter
- 54:56of law. And just a couple more slides left here
- 55:04is the importance of limiting instructions here.
- 55:07And this is from a case called Hanson versus
- 55:11Sunnyside. And so sometimes, and this applies.
- 55:17to everything that we've discussed, but limiting
- 55:19instructions should be very important. Here specifically,
- 55:23I took this limiting instruction from that court
- 55:25opinion and says, you have heard certain evidence
- 55:28that the defendant has complied with government
- 55:31standards or guidelines regarding labeling its
- 55:34product. Compliance with governmental standards
- 55:36or regulations does not preclude imposition of
- 55:40liability for a defective product. It merely
- 55:44It is merely to be considered by you as some
- 55:47evidence on the issue of adequacy of warnings
- 55:51as I will otherwise instruct you. So it's very
- 55:53important that you have the right jury instructions,
- 55:57obviously, and including them to make sure that
- 56:02in closing argument or an opening that the jury
- 56:06is aware of how certain evidence of compliance
- 56:10or non -compliance may be considered by them
- 56:13when rendering a verdict. I mentioned this early
- 56:18on, but it's one of those things that I honestly,
- 56:21when I was even writing the article that I was
- 56:23discussing, I started writing this article and
- 56:27all of a sudden before I knew it, it was becoming
- 56:29a thesis project when I got into federal preemption.
- 56:33Nevertheless, when we're discussing these issues
- 56:36and especially the applicability of government
- 56:39safety standards, it seems wise to at least mention
- 56:44it and as most of us may remember, because I
- 56:49feel like most people don't run into federal
- 56:51preemption that often on a day -to -day basis
- 56:53in actually the practice of the law. But the
- 56:58basis of federal preemption obviously is found
- 57:00in Article 4 of the U .S. Constitution. It provides
- 57:02that federal law shall be the supreme law of
- 57:05the land, and the judges in every state shall
- 57:08be bound there by anything in the constitution
- 57:12or laws of any state of the contrary or notwithstanding.
- 57:15So when a federal agency has created safety standards
- 57:17for a product, it's important to become familiar
- 57:19with these federal regulations or standards and
- 57:22addressing the application of federal preemption
- 57:27as a potential defense, because that will sometimes
- 57:30be raised. I've also found that in, for example,
- 57:33opposing motions for summary judgment and design
- 57:36defect cases, The defense has utilized oftentimes
- 57:40many cases throughout the country that assess
- 57:44product liability and maybe granted summary judgment.
- 57:50when the main basis of the summary judgment was
- 57:53federal preemption, which sometimes will not
- 57:55apply, actually quite frequently will not apply
- 57:58in your product liability case. So reading those
- 58:01specific cases that are provided in the defense's
- 58:05summary judgment motion and actually seeing the
- 58:08real basis for the argument as opposed to just
- 58:10the one line quote that I think many lawyers,
- 58:13regardless plaintiff of defense, utilize in assessing
- 58:17actually where that came into play. And so that's
- 58:24the conclusion. I know we probably don't have
- 58:26too much time for question and answer, but I
- 58:28did include my email. I'm sorry that this topic
- 58:31is not as... exciting, I think, as many topics,
- 58:35but I think it's hugely important with anyone
- 58:38dealing with product liability cases and hasn't
- 58:41had the opportunity to really go through the,
- 58:44especially the pretrial necessity of working
- 58:47up a case. But here's my email, and I'm also
- 58:51happy to meet and talk and always happy to exchange
- 58:56briefing or whatever anyone needs. So thank you
- 59:01very much. Nick, thank you so much for your presentation
- 59:06today. I don't see any questions in the Q &A,
- 59:10so I want to take a moment to thank our attendees
- 59:11for joining us this morning. Thank you so much.