Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Buckeyes Suffer Surprising Loss To Transfer Portal
Transcript
- 0:01Hello, everybody, Welcome to the buck Eye Weekly Podcast. I'm Tony Gerdiman
- 0:05here as always with Tom or Tom, how's it going, Tony? Once
- 0:10again, it is a breaking news edition of the podcast. But I'm like
- 0:14past breaking news episodes, we did not record this one in advance, so
- 0:17this actually is a breaking news episode in the true sense of the word,
- 0:21and a surprising one because this is something that we didn't have prerecorded, pre
- 0:26written, you know, anything, anything like that. And it's Caleb Brown,
- 0:29retchyear freshman wide receiver hitting the transfer portal kind of late Sunday night as
- 0:35the portal door was closing, he slid under it like Indiana Jones, reached
- 0:40back for his hat and grabbed it and then when it was out the door
- 0:45and the yea and uh so that's it was a surprise for me that I've
- 0:51I've been the guy on the the Caleb Brown hype train since since he arrived,
- 0:57probably before that. So this is a a personal attack on me,
- 1:00basically unfortunate, And as I said, that's surprised. But if you look
- 1:07at it time, I don't know how how much of I don't want to
- 1:12say surprise, but if you look at a decision why it was made,
- 1:17and we're just assuming why it was made. This is a guy that's playing
- 1:19in the slot, and right now, how do you get on the field
- 1:23as the third or fourth slot this season knowing that Marvin Harrison is also going
- 1:29to be moving around? Right This feels like when we go, you know,
- 1:34post spring, you sort of have a list of here are the guys
- 1:38who I think might kind of transfer, who fit the typical transfer kind of
- 1:41model, and generally that's guys who are third, fourth year guys who've been
- 1:48passed up on the depth drug by younger guys and where there's not a clear
- 1:51path at the playing field really at any point, and so then they transfer
- 1:55and they go to a lower level school and then they have a clear path
- 1:57of the playing field. Caleb Brown really doesn't fit that because Caleb Brown was
- 2:01someone who felt like he was improving this spring, felt like he was maybe
- 2:07taking on a little bit of a bigger role this spring, but he didn't
- 2:12necessarily have a clear path of the playing field this year. And you know,
- 2:15as you pointed out, not only is that you're not going to play
- 2:21this year, but also that delays potentially some of your nil opportunities, you
- 2:25know, pushes that back a year and all that. And there are a
- 2:29lot of guys who have left Ohio State over the years where you kind of
- 2:30go, well, that's someone you're not necessarily going to see, you know,
- 2:35Ohio State is not going to see them on the field, and they
- 2:37point in the future. And then you do have the occasional Joe Burrow,
- 2:40the occasional Jamison Williams. And I'm not necessarily saying Caleb Brown is one of
- 2:46those, but he feels like he's more on that end of that spectrum than
- 2:52probably anyone else they've lost this spring. Yeah, I would agree with that.
- 2:58I do think he can play it. I think will plan and I
- 3:00think he'll go somewhere and probably start and be an impact player. It's just
- 3:07at Ohio State, you've got a Mecca Buca as the number one slot.
- 3:10You've got Xavier Johnson in there as well. I feel like Xavier Johnson coming
- 3:15back may have expedited this decision. We also saw Bryson Rogers in the slot
- 3:21and then oh yeah, in the summer, here comes five star slot receiver
- 3:25Brandon Nis as well. So I'm sure and I'm not going to accuse anybody
- 3:31of tampering, but there's easy math to do and that other schools can do
- 3:37it as well. And if you are going to be another school looking for
- 3:39a wide receiver, there are a few places you're going to look harder at
- 3:43than Ohio State. And there are many ears that you can get into to
- 3:46make some stuff like this happen. But also I'm sure you, as you
- 3:52said, the nil stuff you see your teammates with that, you see the
- 3:57opportunities that you're not able yet to realize that you could somewhere else. The
- 4:01decision making that goes into transferring or staying these days is so much different than
- 4:06anything before because we also see guys that get found everywhere, and the NFL
- 4:14will find you, as they say, wherever you go. So you don't
- 4:15necessarily need to be in an Alabama or Ohio State or Georgia helps if you
- 4:20want to be a first rounder, but you know you can go elsewhere and
- 4:26make a good living as a college player and then also be put in the
- 4:30eyes of the NFL. But I am disappointed about this. When he was
- 4:34the highest ranked player highest rank receiver in the twenty twenty two class among the
- 4:40receivers. He was the number seventy nine player in the twenty four seven composite,
- 4:46a couple of spots, nine spots ahead of Keyan Grace, who is
- 4:48still at Ohio State. Caleb Burton, who has already left, was a
- 4:54number one thirty two player. Cojoyn tweet the number one fifty one player still
- 4:59here. So they're dow two guys they kept too. When Ohio State and
- 5:02Brian Hartline signed their twenty twenty three receiver class, I think there were there.
- 5:10There's plenty of speculation that this twenty twenty two class had been recruited over.
- 5:15Ryan Day even said it on signing day or before spring, like they're
- 5:19going to have to step up. They're already being pushed by the early enrollies.
- 5:23And three of those guys enrolled early Cardinal Tate Pryce and Rodgers and Noah
- 5:26Rodgers. And you've seen since since spring two guys Caleb Burton and now Caleb
- 5:32Brown both out. How much of an impact do you think the twenty twenty
- 5:35three guys had on these decisions. I think it has to You have to
- 5:40assume it had a decent, decent size impact there, because you've got guys
- 5:44like Cardinal Tate losing his black stripe already, and the guy who was the
- 5:48highest ranked of those guys, those twenty three recruits isn't even here yet in
- 5:54Brandon innis so the path to the playing field. You know, they did
- 5:58not lose a bunch of wide receivers from last year's team. You've got a
- 6:01Mecho Bucha back, he got Julian Fleming back, he got Marvin Harrison back,
- 6:04so already it was going to be hard to get time this year.
- 6:08Jaden Ballard feels like he stepped up. He kind of took that next step
- 6:12towards the field. Cardinal Tate took a big tep step towards the field.
- 6:15He looked at these starting wide receivers for the spring game. It was Marvin
- 6:19Harrison and Jaden Ballard and Cardinal Tate, and it was none of the twenty
- 6:25twenty two guys, and it felt like they were trying to find a role
- 6:29for someone like Caleb Burton. We saw him returning kicks at one point,
- 6:32I think we saw him returning punts as well, so they were it felt
- 6:35like they were trying to find a role for him to you know that that's
- 6:40sometimes what they do to you know, give give guys an opportunity to get
- 6:44touches, have a role, you know, be able to be able to
- 6:47feel like an active part of the team even if you're not. And you
- 6:49know, starting at the wide receiver position, that was something that happened with
- 6:53Julian Fleming a couple of years earlier. Buco, you saw him before he
- 6:57was a starter on at wide receiver, he was a starter kick returner.
- 7:00It felt like that was sort of the path that Caleb Brown was on.
- 7:03But you know, when you have carnal Tate, when you have Noah Rodgers
- 7:08and Bryson Rodgers, you know, starting to look like, okay, there's
- 7:12there's definitely something here that you know that that's tough, that that's that's the
- 7:15kind of thing where you can feel like, oh, you know, there's
- 7:20there's the road ahead of me is crowded. Now there's a bunch of guys
- 7:24coming up behind me. There's not a whole lot of you know that that
- 7:28that's a tricky, tricky spot to go and you know these are these are
- 7:30guys. Caleb Brown as someone who had offers from just about everyone in the
- 7:34Big Ten. He had offers from he had an offer from Alabama. Uh,
- 7:39he was at one point considered someone who who might be headed to Michigan,
- 7:42but it offers of Michigan, Penn State, Notre Dame, Wisconsin,
- 7:45Nebraska, Minnesota, Michigan State, I mean, Kentucky, Louisville. This
- 7:49is someone who has options. And when you are you know, you're talented,
- 7:56but you're gonna have a tough time finding finding a spot in that rotation
- 8:00this year. You know, some guys will choose to be patient and try
- 8:03and wait it out and try and you know, get you know, get
- 8:05those kick return reps or whatever. And sometimes it's you know, they feel
- 8:09like it's in their best interest to go somewhere else and try and get on
- 8:11the field earlier. And you gotta remember, this is someone who has had
- 8:15the benefit of working with Brian Hartline now for a year. So you've gotten
- 8:18the teaching on route running and teaching on all the little stuff and hand physician
- 8:22and all the all the stuff that Brian Hartline is so good at teaching.
- 8:24Okay, you've had a year at Brian Hartline's finishing school, so now you
- 8:28know, now he's going to go somewhere else and try and make it more
- 8:31of an immediate impact. You mentioned Michigan. I don't want to throw this
- 8:39out there, but Michigan loses Ronnie Bell to the NFL slot receiver aj Henning
- 8:46transfers out that that's a guy that could go in there and really make some
- 8:52noise. M from Chicago area. Does he end up somewhere in the midwest.
- 8:58USC loves to bring and transfers, They love to throw the ball.
- 9:03That could maybe be an option. Deon Sanders, Colorado. I know they're
- 9:07already after other Ohio State transfers, so like, why wouldn't you be after
- 9:11Kylen Browns. I think he's going to have his options and it will be
- 9:16interesting to see what wins out like opportunity and I l what is it that
- 9:22you're missing right now? And you know, I still think he's gonna be
- 9:26one of these guys that I follow on because I do think he is.
- 9:30He's I think he's an explosive player who can play. It's just interesting to
- 9:35me how Ohio State just can't get these types of receivers to work, whether
- 9:41it's Kylen brown whether it's Mookie Cooper trying to get Jaylen Gill trying to get
- 9:48Ron Dale Moore, trying to get wan Dale Robinson where you know, I
- 9:52think the only one that they've gotten in this vein might be Donentrey Wilson.
- 9:56And really that's that's almost a different world now. But they just can't get
- 10:03these five ten crazy slot receiver type of guys to work out. And at
- 10:07some point do they do? They keep trying, I don't know. And
- 10:13now with this twenty four class, which I think has two outside receivers right
- 10:16now, and Jeremiah Smith and Mylon Graham, I consider, you know,
- 10:20an excellent z basically, now they'll go you got to go find somebody to
- 10:24replace this loss of Caleb Brown. And I know Brandon Innis is already in
- 10:31twenty twenty three, but this is a spot that you now have to replace.
- 10:35And I guess who do you go to go replace that? Hey,
- 10:39Brian Hardland, go find us another slot receiver. Okay, don't worry,
- 10:43I've got you. And so, I mean, it will be interesting to
- 10:46see how they replace them with. But now it's instead of maybe a three
- 10:50receiver class, it's probably gonna be a four receiver class in twenty twenty four.
- 10:54Well, let me throw this out. There is Sam Williams Dixon already
- 10:58in the class potentially the replacement. He's someone. I mean, they had
- 11:01James Peoples and Sam Williams Dickson as running backs committed for twenty twenty four already,
- 11:07and then over the weekend they got a commitment from Jordan Lyle. So
- 11:09now you've got three running backs in the class. You're not probably gonna have
- 11:13three true running backs in the class, and you can either sort of space
- 11:16them out and maybe one of those guys takes a redshirt, you're and you
- 11:18space him out, you know, chronologically, or you space him out on
- 11:22the field. And you know, Sam Williams Dickson feels like he the word
- 11:26from our guys is that he is maybe being looked at as a little bit
- 11:31more of an athlete and maybe he takes on that Xavier Johnson kind of role
- 11:35rather than a true running back. So you know, maybe the answer is
- 11:39already in the recruiting class and just is not labeled as such on the recruiting
- 11:43services. That's a great point. I completely whipped on that one. Yeah,
- 11:48I listened at five eleven, two oh three. I can't wait to
- 11:50watch him this year. He's moved to Pickerington, North and see how they
- 11:54use and I assume they'll use him as a running back, but you see
- 11:56the projections and the jail and Gill was used as a running back but then
- 12:01also in the run sweeps, and Paris Campbell was another. Kaitlyn Brown was
- 12:07a running back in Chicago and became this So I think that's an interesting point.
- 12:13I feel like this Xavier Johnson role and usage needs to be expanded.
- 12:20And I think I've said this before. It feels like we're going back to
- 12:22the future with the Urban Meyer h back. But it was a valuable weapon
- 12:28and a useful weapon, and one that was effective when they would use Xavier
- 12:33Johnson however they needed to use them, and I think there's tremendous value in
- 12:37having a skill guy like that, and it's makes it harder for the defense,
- 12:43but it will be if that's like a new thing or a new old
- 12:48thing that they go back to looking for. And clearly they are telling everybody
- 12:54athlete because when it was the last time Ohio State had three true running backs
- 13:00in the class, um, I'm immediately going back to like the early nineties
- 13:05and it was yeah, like Butler and yeah, I mean that's about the
- 13:13last time you can think of it, because it's just, you know,
- 13:16they need a big running back class this year because they're potentially you know,
- 13:20you're losing Mine Williams to figure after the year, you're losing chip training after
- 13:22the year. Is Trevian Henderson going to be off to the NFL? I
- 13:26think that's a real possibility. So at that point, you've got just Evan
- 13:31Pryor and Dalen Hayden left of the scholarship backs from this year. And you
- 13:35know, if someone goes to the portal, if someone gets hurt, I
- 13:37mean, you're really you're really quite thin. There They famous you know the
- 13:41old famous saying you need a pair in a spare. Well you could be
- 13:45even with two running backs in this class, you could be down to just
- 13:46a pair in a spare at that point. So yeah, that's a that's
- 13:50an area where they they certainly are going to have a you know, it's
- 13:54not a coincidence that they have two guys, you know, two guys plus
- 13:58maybe one more depending on how you want to categorize people. But yeah,
- 14:01this is a big this is a big recruiting year at running back for a
- 14:05house date, and they have definitely, definitely I think Tony Alfred. You
- 14:07know, all the all the concerns about Tony Alford magically forgetting how to recruit
- 14:11seem to seem to no longer be valid. Turns out he can still still
- 14:16identify and recruit talent at running back. Good news for everyone, I guess,
- 14:20unless you just want to give the credit too. Offensive coordinator Brian Hartline,
- 14:26I there are folks who will definitely want to do that, So yes,
- 14:28I think, yes you can, you can. Yeah, it was
- 14:31all it's all someone's fault what it doesn't happen, and it's all someone else's
- 14:35credit when it does happen. Yes, that's we've seen that. We've seen
- 14:37that happen before too. Yes, I who give anybody credit? You one,
- 14:41but I blame ran Day. The final thing I think I would just
- 14:46say is Caleb Brown departing. This is a receiver room that will be losing
- 14:50Margaret Harrison's, Avid Johnson, Julian Fleming likely possibly I Meca book like there
- 14:56are going to be spots available for next year, but clearly Caleb Brown wants
- 15:03to play this year and has taken a move of making a move to to
- 15:07get that done. Anything else before we get out of here. No,
- 15:11just this is he's someone. This is someone who I think Ohio State fans
- 15:13at some point this fall will watch him on highlights wherever he is, you
- 15:18know, is he playing for Alabama or Michigan or Colorado or wherever, and
- 15:22they will look at him and go, oh, why did we let that
- 15:24guy go? And you know, I mean, there's there's plenty of other
- 15:26talent in that wide receiver room. And that's just that is kind of the
- 15:30way college football works right now. So you know, that's the best of
- 15:33luck to Caleb Brown and I think he's probably going to have a very successful
- 15:37career wherever halc ends up. And just try to try to be happy for
- 15:41him. Try to be uh you know, like the Ohio State players.
- 15:43Uh remember watching the Jailhigh State players on the field that Jerry World cheering for
- 15:46Joe Burrow is there had the LSU game on the JumboTron during Joe burrows first
- 15:52year at LSU. You know, try try and be happy for him and
- 15:56you know, enjoy enjoy his success wherever that ends up happening. You know
- 16:02that that offer maybe not be valid if he ends up at Michigan for most
- 16:04of the Ohio State fan base. But you know, wherever it is,
- 16:07you know, it's uh, you know, good good luck to him.
- 16:11I was going to say, I remember watching the Michigan fans being so happy
- 16:15for Justin Born when they get his victories over Michigan. So yes, be
- 16:21classy like those Michigan fans if it happens Ohio State fans. So thank you
- 16:25all for tuning in. Find us in bucket huddle dot com, become a
- 16:29member, say hello to us. We're there, we're hanging out. Also,
- 16:33thank you for continuing to watch us on YouTube at YouTube dot com slash
- 16:36bucket Huddle. Go ahead and liked this video If you want subscribe if you
- 16:40haven't, hit the bell to be notified when we drop videos like this.
- 16:41Kind of emergency is happening all all of the time, so plenty of videos
- 16:47like this one. So thank you all for tuning in and we will talk
- 16:48to you guys later