Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Bible, Chicken, or Dog? The Bizarre World of Courtroom Oaths
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment, joined as always by Barrister and Solicitor with Mulligan Defence Lawyers.
- 0:04Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, it's Legally Speaking on CFAX 1070.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Afternoon, michael, how are we doing?
- 0:09Michael Mulligan: Hey, good afternoon.
- 0:10Michael Mulligan: I'm doing great.
- 0:11Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here.
- 0:12Adam Stirling: Some interesting items on the agenda this week.
- 0:14Adam Stirling: I'm reading number one.
- 0:15Adam Stirling: It says the Supreme Court of Canada overturns a BC sexual assault conviction.
- 0:26Michael Mulligan: It says, due to the Crown leading evidence that the complainants does, that say virginity.
- 0:28Michael Mulligan: That's exactly right.
- 0:28Michael Mulligan: That's exactly what it says and it's the language that the Supreme Court of Canada used was sexual inactivity evidence.
- 0:32Michael Mulligan: Now there's some interesting background to all of this.
- 0:36Michael Mulligan: For some time in Canada we've had some provisions that limit the evidence that can be led in sexual assault cases, and those rules were designed.
- 0:48Michael Mulligan: They've changed a bit over the years, but they've been designed to prevent what's been referred to as twin myth reasoning, and the rules are generally applied to the defense.
- 1:03Michael Mulligan: No-transcript.
- 1:25Michael Mulligan: Somebody might have consented to other activity doesn't mean you've consented to the particular activity that's being dealt with, so that's viewed as a myth and prohibited.
- 1:32Michael Mulligan: And then the other myth that the rules intended to deal with is a myth that if somebody is promiscuous they are less worthy of belief.
- 1:42Michael Mulligan: Now, I'm not sure where that's getting with anyone at 2025, but that's the other part of the twin myth reasoning those rules are intended to prevent and what they mean is that if the defense wants to lead evidence about some past activity that the complainant has engaged in, there has to be what's called a voir dire, like a hearing before the judge hearing the case to decide whether that's going to be permitted or not.
- 2:06Michael Mulligan: There are some circumstances where it might be relevant and permitted, but not to make those arguments that you're more likely to have consented to this because you consented to something else to the extent that makes any sense to anyone anyways or the argument that you're promiscuous, therefore you shouldn't be believed.
- 2:23Michael Mulligan: Well, that's been around for some time and, interestingly, it's caused some challenges in terms of the time it's taken for trials to complete because it requires this two-stage hearing or voir dire, prior to that kind of evidence being allowed or not allowed.
- 2:41Michael Mulligan: And sometimes even those kind of things occur unexpectedly during a trial, which causes trials to be adjourned and take longer.
- 2:48Michael Mulligan: And that's been a challenge.
- 2:51Michael Mulligan: And that was the context in which the Supreme Court of Canada was dealing with this decision that they just came out with, which was the opposite of that and it's a BC case and it was a sexual assault allegation.
- 3:04Michael Mulligan: It was two people who met, I think, at a motorcycle dealership and then had a series of social media exchanges for months and then eventually got together at the apartment of the accused.
- 3:15Michael Mulligan: The complainant alleged that she was sexually assaulted and the accused said no, it was consensual, was consensual.
- 3:27Michael Mulligan: And in that context the Crown not the defense led a whole bunch of evidence from these social media posts or messages back and forth between these two people, and those messages included messages from the complainant saying that she was a virgin, that she was not interested in any sexual activity and not interested in sexual activity at least at some point with the accused.
- 3:46Michael Mulligan: And the judge allowed all of that evidence to go in without having one of those board years to decide if it was allowed or not.
- 3:53Michael Mulligan: Both people testified, the judge relied upon those messages in finding that the accused was guilty, and so that's the fact pattern.
- 4:04Michael Mulligan: They got appealed first to the BC Court of Appeal and then just recently to the Supreme Court of Canada, and the Supreme Court of Canada concluded that what the Crown did in that case was prohibited, and they referred to that twin myth reasoning we just talked about and it found that the same applies in the reverse for the Crown.
- 4:27Michael Mulligan: And here the Crown was trying to lead this evidence about the complainant saying she had not previously engaged in sexual activity, to argue that it's less likely she consented to the sexual activity in question, and the Supreme Court of Canada said well, that's not permitted, that's presumptively inadmissible, on the same reasoning that just because somebody might have consented to other sexual activity in the past doesn't mean they consented to the subject matter that's being dealt with.
- 4:55Michael Mulligan: The flip side of that is true Just because somebody hadn't consented to activity in the past with other people or in other circumstances does not mean they didn't consent to the activity in question in the case being tried.
- 5:08Michael Mulligan: And so the Supreme Court of Canada found that was not permissible and that where the Crown wants to try to lead evidence of sexual inactivity, a judge would need to have one of these two-stage hearings.
- 5:22Michael Mulligan: First of all to ask in the first part of this first stage of it is it even possible this evidence could be admitted?
- 5:28Michael Mulligan: Because it can never be admitted for one of those myths Like the Crown could never get away with saying we want to lead evidence of the person's lack of interest in sexual activities to suggest either they're less likely to have consented or that they're more worthy of belief.
- 5:43Michael Mulligan: Those don't fly.
- 5:45Michael Mulligan: And if there's to be some other argument by the Crown about how the inactivity or professed sexual inactivity is relevant to the particular case, the judge needs to conduct one of those voir dire or hearings, just like they would need to conduct if the defense was trying to lead the opposite, saying the person is unbelievable or more likely to have consented, and so that's now clear in the law from the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 6:10Michael Mulligan: The Supreme Court of Canada overturned the conviction of this case because the judge did in fact rely upon those things in finding that the in disbelieving the accused and convicting him, and so there'll be a new trial, and so it's an interesting case, I thought, both because it deals with that concept of that twin myth reasoning that those need for those other hearings and the fact that they're now going to be applied in cases where the Crown wants to leave some kind of evidence like that.
- 6:39Michael Mulligan: And one of the worries here and the Supreme Court of Canada referred to it because it was part of the argument here, but whether this should be necessary or not is that this will lead to further delays in trials of this kind where, for example, the Crown decides they want to do that sort of thing at the last minute.
- 6:59Michael Mulligan: It may mean that trials get adjourned and in some cases, cases we've seen have been stayed as a result of taking too long, and so that's one of the worries.
- 7:09Michael Mulligan: One of the other interesting things is that in a case where the defense wants to lead that kind of evidence right about previous activity, the complainant is entitled to have their own lawyer show up in court and argue about it, because sometimes they have a different position on the Crown right?
- 7:28Michael Mulligan: The Crown might say in some case, yeah, this evidence is perfectly reasonable and it should be admitted, but maybe the complainant wants to take a different position.
- 7:35Michael Mulligan: That leads to even further delay because then you've got to get, you've got to inject a third lawyer into the process in order to have one of the hearings.
- 7:43Michael Mulligan: Interestingly, the Supreme Court of Canada said usually that's not going to be an element of this.
- 7:48Michael Mulligan: Where the Crown's trying to evidence of sexual inactivity, a judge will have some discretion, but generally they aren't going to inject a third lawyer into it on behalf of the complainant.
- 7:58Michael Mulligan: The submissions about trying to get that kind of evidence in would be made by the Crown.
- 8:04Michael Mulligan: So I guess you could have a really bizarre circumstance where you might have the Crown trying to get sexual inactivity evidence admitted where the complainant doesn't want it but doesn't have counsel to oppose it.
- 8:14Michael Mulligan: So anyways, that's the latest from the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 8:18Michael Mulligan: Plainly, everyone's very sensitive about these things.
- 8:20Michael Mulligan: They're really sensitive and important cases.
- 8:22Michael Mulligan: But it's going to mean there's going to be screening on both sides if anyone wants to try to get into past sexual activity or the absence of sexual activity.
- 8:32Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the Supreme Court of Canada on more deers in sexual assault cases.
- 8:38Adam Stirling: All right, we'll take a quick break.
- 8:39Adam Stirling: Legally speaking, we'll continue right after this.
- 8:41Adam Stirling: Legally speaking continues on CFAX 1070.
- 8:44Adam Stirling: Whoops, I hit the wrong button because I fell short of the phone.
- 8:48Adam Stirling: I think Michael Mulligan from Mulligan and Defense Lawyers is on this slide.
- 8:52Adam Stirling: Sorry about that, michael.
- 8:53Adam Stirling: I hit a different phone line today and good news, it still worked.
- 8:57Adam Stirling: Where were we?
- 8:58Adam Stirling: It says up next year.
- 8:59Adam Stirling: It says a new BC Supreme Court practice direction.
- 9:02Adam Stirling: What's a practice direction?
- 9:04Michael Mulligan: That's a great question.
- 9:05Michael Mulligan: So the way it works is for a set of administrative decisions about how the court is to run.
- 9:10Michael Mulligan: Each of the courts in the province like the provincial courts, supreme Court, court of Appeal, the chief judge or justice as the case might be can issue these things that are practice directions, that are sort of rules about how the sort of procedure of court should operate, rather than a particular decision in a particular case, and so we just had one of those it's an interesting one out of the BC Supreme Court and the practice directions title is Witness, oaths and Affirmations.
- 9:41Michael Mulligan: Now the first part about that.
- 9:44Michael Mulligan: It has three rules that are set out here.
- 9:46Michael Mulligan: One before a witness is called to testify, the party or council must advise the clerk whether the witness wishes to swear an oath or affirm.
- 9:55Michael Mulligan: Now, that's interesting.
- 9:56Michael Mulligan: That used to be the case For a period of time over COVID.
- 10:00Michael Mulligan: We stopped asking witnesses if they wanted to swear an oath or affirm for fear they would get COVID from the Bible.
- 10:05Michael Mulligan: That's what.
- 10:06Michael Mulligan: Back in the early days we were wiping down our groceries with alcohol and so they stopped that.
- 10:11Michael Mulligan: They just said everyone's going to affirm.
- 10:12Michael Mulligan: Because we don't know how this is getting transmitted.
- 10:14Michael Mulligan: We don't want people picking up Bibles, so they actually took the Bibles out of the courtrooms.
- 10:17Michael Mulligan: Now we're back, I should say.
- 10:20Michael Mulligan: In that regard, if it were for me to decide, I would just have everyone affirm Frankly, why do we need a religious declaration?
- 10:26Michael Mulligan: Is that really getting a grip on somebody's?
- 10:28Michael Mulligan: You know, are people going to be telling me the truth more frequently for fear that their soul is going to be damned if they don't?
- 10:35Michael Mulligan: I don't know if that's getting us too far in 2025, but we're back Now.
- 10:41Michael Mulligan: Another interesting thing rule two.
- 10:42Michael Mulligan: Now another interesting thing.
- 10:43Michael Mulligan: Rule two if the witness wishes to swear an oath using a religious or cultural item other than the Bible, it is the responsibility of the party calling the witness or their counsel to make arrangements for the appropriate item to be available, so they're not going to have a selection of religious books or objects for people to swear on.
- 11:03Michael Mulligan: You've got to bring your own if it's anything other than the Bible.
- 11:07Michael Mulligan: That's an interesting one to think about.
- 11:08Michael Mulligan: Should we have that right, or should we have this at all?
- 11:10Michael Mulligan: And if we are having it, should there be one option there?
- 11:13Michael Mulligan: That's interesting.
- 11:15Michael Mulligan: That's rule two.
- 11:16Michael Mulligan: Now, there's a long history to these things, and there's a long history and this will come to rule three in a moment.
- 11:22Michael Mulligan: Here there's a long history of different oaths being taken by different groups for different reasons.
- 11:28Michael Mulligan: One of the ones there are a whole series of them.
- 11:31Michael Mulligan: They actually were set out until very recently in a desk book that all the clerk said.
- 11:35Michael Mulligan: They were all listed.
- 11:36Michael Mulligan: You look them up.
- 11:37Michael Mulligan: They gave them instructions on how to do it.
- 11:40Michael Mulligan: One of those oaths which was apparently used with some frequency was what's called the chicken oath the chicken oath and the chicken oath, and the desk book provided instructions about how that was to work if somebody chose to take the chicken oath.
- 11:55Michael Mulligan: When they asked to take the chicken oath, it specified that the court clerk was required to procure a cock like a male chicken, required to procure a cock like a male chicken.
- 12:07Michael Mulligan: The court proceedings were to be adjourned to outside the courthouse and there would also be a knife and a block of wood and the witness would cut the head off the chicken and say some things about how they were going to tell the truth or they'd be killed like the chicken and one of the backgrounders for this rule.
- 12:22Michael Mulligan: There's a picture up in Nanaimo from 1914 of the whole court standing outside while somebody cuts the head off a chicken.
- 12:28Michael Mulligan: Now that comes to the issue of providing the item.
- 12:33Michael Mulligan: There's actually a Vancouver Island case indeed from 1895, where there was a bill submitted to the government for several chickens and a knife as a result of witnesses wanting to testify with they're testifying with the chicken oath.
- 12:48Michael Mulligan: They thought government should pay for the chickens, in that case the BC government.
- 12:52Michael Mulligan: They refused to pay for the chickens and the rationale was because they were being used by the plaintiffs in a case rather than the defense.
- 12:59Michael Mulligan: So the fact that you've got to bring your own is actually to the subject of some litigation, at least in that context.
- 13:07Michael Mulligan: There are a whole series of other types of oaths that were in the book and were used, and they include things like there's one called the candle oath, where a witness would hold their hand over a lit candle while swearing the oath and then extinguish the flame, I guess, with their hands.
- 13:22Michael Mulligan: There's a saucer oath where you'd smash the saucer and say that your soul shall be broken like the saucer if you lie.
- 13:28Michael Mulligan: There's a paper oath where you'd swear to write your name on a piece of paper and light it on fire.
- 13:34Michael Mulligan: The most bizarre list is here, although this was used in some of the colonies.
- 13:39Michael Mulligan: I don't know if we had a BC history of it where there was one group, cultural group, who would bite the skin from a live dog and then say I bite this dog so I may be eaten if I lie, just imagine that.
- 13:51Michael Mulligan: So there's a long history to it.
- 13:54Michael Mulligan: That may explain rule three in the practice directive.
- 13:57Michael Mulligan: Rule three in the event of any concern that a religious or cultural item, be it a plate, dog or chicken, I guess a witness intends to use, is not compatible with the dignity, decorum and or safety of the court proceedings, the court clerk or sheriff will notify the presiding judge, associate judge or registrar and seek directions.
- 14:23Michael Mulligan: Signed Chief Justice Ron Scowrod.
- 14:27Michael Mulligan: So that's the third rule, and I don't know what prompted that right now, because this is a brand new practice directive, but something did.
- 14:38Michael Mulligan: And so if somebody purports to use a chicken or a candle or a saucer or a live dog, for heaven's sakes, they've specified in this practice direction that the court clerk, rather than just going out and procuring the caulk and the knife, is now going to have to notify the judge, associate judge or registrar and get direction.
- 14:59Michael Mulligan: It doesn't say what direction they shall give or what criteria they ought to apply, but it does specify that they're going to have to get direction.
- 15:07Michael Mulligan: It also specifies that the party wanting to do one of these various things is going to have to go get the object or the book.
- 15:14Michael Mulligan: And so I guess, again in this whole context, perhaps the solution would be to just have everyone affirm to tell the truth, and that way we can start with witnesses not having to make some, you know, religious declaration.
- 15:27Michael Mulligan: And really, is it appropriate?
- 15:28Michael Mulligan: If there's some greater weight given to somebody who's making a religious declaration as opposed to an affirmation, why is that appropriate, you know?
- 15:36Michael Mulligan: Should there be some kind of judgment call made or some greater or less degree of reliability placed on a witness because they've chosen to use a Bible or a different book?
- 15:46Michael Mulligan: Why are we doing this?
- 15:47Michael Mulligan: But anyways, there we are.
- 15:49Michael Mulligan: It seems to me we could have, perhaps quite conveniently, just stuck with the state of affairs that we had as a result of the you know misguided conclusions about how COVID spread to get rid of the Bible, and just stuck with every single person getting up there and affirming, rather than worrying about chickens and candles and live dogs and who's got to get the book and whether we should only have the Bible or not.
- 16:12Michael Mulligan: But there it is.
- 16:15Michael Mulligan: And I should say as well you know, some of this may come as recently as 93, the Supreme Court of Canada spoke about well, it still thinks they still view it as a compelling reasons to prefer statements made with these sort of with oaths.
- 16:29Michael Mulligan: I don't know right.
- 16:31Michael Mulligan: I mean, I guess you ask yourself if you're listening, you're on a jury and you're listening to a witness, you know, are you going to feel more confident that the person's telling the truth because they swore an oath on a religious book?
- 16:44Michael Mulligan: What do you think of it if you don't agree with the religion, should a juror be giving less weight to it?
- 16:50Michael Mulligan: What if you think the ceremony the person's performing is somehow distasteful?
- 16:54Michael Mulligan: Should that affect it?
- 16:56Michael Mulligan: You know, really, that's kind of where the rubber hits the road.
- 16:59Michael Mulligan: You're going to have serious cases.
- 17:00Michael Mulligan: You're going to have potential juries or jurors or judges listening to these things.
- 17:04Michael Mulligan: How should this have any bearing on it really at all?
- 17:07Michael Mulligan: And so well, I guess, in my view, it's perhaps unfortunate that we just missed out on the opportunity to fix upon what we've been doing, perhaps for some mistaken reason, in terms of why we got rid of all these oaths.
- 17:21Michael Mulligan: But anyways, as of the 6th of this month, we've got a new practice directive and if people want to be using some other cultural object or some other book other than the Bible, they're going to have to bring it along and we're going to get back to asking every witness which they prefer, and then somehow some judicial official has to figure out what to do if they view the practice as somehow incompatible with dignity or decorum.
- 17:45Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest in terms of what a practice directive is and what's required in terms of oaths and affirmations.
- 17:53Adam Stirling: We have three and a half minutes left and it's the case of the push and the accidental fall off the cliff, and I've seen this going around in headlines.
- 18:01Adam Stirling: Your thoughts on this one.
- 18:03Michael Mulligan: Well, the actual decision from the BC Court of Appeal and it's a tragic case.
- 18:07Michael Mulligan: It's a case involving a man who pushed his girlfriend.
- 18:11Michael Mulligan: She fell off a cliff.
- 18:12Michael Mulligan: It was accepted that that was accidental, but it was still an assault, so he pled guilty to manslaughter and he was assault, or whether the sentence generally was appropriate or not.
- 18:34Michael Mulligan: And it has to do first of all with what a joint submission is.
- 18:39Michael Mulligan: And a joint submission in a case is where the Crown and the defense agree in terms of what the sentence is going to be and it's the basis upon which people wind up pleading guilty, right.
- 18:54Michael Mulligan: And you can imagine, in this case there could well have been real challenges of proof about sort of what happened or how she wound up over the cliff or whatnot.
- 19:01Michael Mulligan: But in any case, the man wound up pleading guilty to manslaughter on the basis of this push that caused the woman to, on the basis of a manslaughter plea, unintentionally fall off and die.
- 19:12Michael Mulligan: Right.
- 19:13Michael Mulligan: If you intentionally did that, that's murder, right.
- 19:16Michael Mulligan: But there was a joint submission.
- 19:17Michael Mulligan: Both Crown and Defense agreed on the fact pattern and also agreed on exactly what sentence should be imposed, right down to the calculation of time spent, and had already spent in jail.
- 19:29Michael Mulligan: He'd spent in jail 440 days waiting for his eventual trial or guilty plea right, and so that's taken into account.
- 19:39Michael Mulligan: Right.
- 19:39Michael Mulligan: It would be unreasonable to say sorry, we're not taking into account, you spent a year and a half in prison.
- 19:43Michael Mulligan: But there then has to be a decision about how do you calculate that, and usually there's some additional credit given for the time in custody beforehand.
- 19:52Michael Mulligan: Because there's no parole, you're sitting in a cell without any programming.
- 19:55Michael Mulligan: It can be miserable.
- 19:56Michael Mulligan: And so there was the joint submission of this case went right down to calculation of like how many days credit should be given for the 440 days spent in custody and what should the results of that be in terms of how long this person's sentence should be.
- 20:11Michael Mulligan: The sentencing judge had some problem with that said.
- 20:14Michael Mulligan: Well, I want further information, I want to get a pre-sentence report ordered and kind of delayed the sentencing proceeding.
- 20:20Michael Mulligan: All of that is interesting because the Supreme Court of Canada has said clearly that where there's a joint submission, a judge doing the sentencing does not have the authority to depart from what the Crown and the defence have agreed to, unless what's being agreed to is so inappropriate that it would bring the administration of justice into disrepute.
- 20:41Michael Mulligan: It's sort of got to be completely outlandish or the judge is required to accept it.
- 20:46Michael Mulligan: In the Supreme Court of Canada and the Court of Appeal has said, as is, they can't tinker with it, the theory being that if the judges could depart from what's being agreed to routinely, nobody would plead guilty and the justice system would basically come to his knees.
- 20:59Michael Mulligan: Here the judge did tinker with it and rather than ultimately imposing a provincial sentence, which is one of two years or less, she imposed one which was a federal sentence of just over two years, by giving him slightly less credit in the calculation for dead time.
- 21:15Michael Mulligan: That was the basis of the appeal, and the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and they said look, that's just an error of law.
- 21:21Michael Mulligan: The judge does not have authority to do that.
- 21:23Michael Mulligan: They can't tinker with it.
- 21:24Michael Mulligan: The judge can assess whether it's so unhinged from the circumstances that it would bring the administration of justice into disrepute.
- 21:31Michael Mulligan: But if it doesn't fail on that very high bar, a judge can't then just meddle with the sentence and change it, even in small ways.
- 21:39Michael Mulligan: And here this was a true joint submission.
- 21:41Michael Mulligan: They agreed right down to the calculation of time and so, on that basis, allowed the appeal and imposed the sentence that was agreed to, meaning the person will serve it in a provincial jail rather than a penitentiary.
- 21:53Adam Stirling: that's what's going on in that case michael mulligan, from mulligan defense lawyers, legally speaking during the second half of our second hour every thursday.
- 21:59Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 22:00Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always thanks much.
- 22:02Michael Mulligan: It's always great to be here.
- 22:03Michael Mulligan: Have a great day.
- 22:03Michael Mulligan: All right, you too, we'll take quick break.
- 22:05Adam Stirling: News is next.