Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Give Constructive Feedback to a Peer
Transcript
- Lucas: You're a manager. You've got a peer — same level, different team — and they're doing something that's making your life harder. Maybe their presentations are rambling and your team has to clean up the confusion. Maybe they keep changing scope last minute. Classic stuff. But here's the thing: you don't manage them. So how do you say something without causing a rift? Luna: Right, because the second you give feedback to a peer, the dynamic shifts. They don't have to listen. And they might wonder, 'Who died and made you my boss?' Lucas: Exactly. And it's not just awkward — the data says most managers avoid it entirely. The Center for Creative Leadership published a study in 2023 that found 82 percent of managers said they'd held back constructive feedback to a peer at least once in the previous year. Eight-two percent. That's not a skill gap — that's a culture gap. Luna: And when we avoid it, the problem compounds. The peer keeps doing the thing, resentment builds, and eventually you escalate to your boss — which is way more toxic than just having the conversation early. Lucas: Exactly. So let's talk about how to do this well. I think the first step is checking your own intent. If you're giving feedback because you're annoyed, or because you want to show you're smarter, it's going to land badly. The peer will feel attacked and they'll get defensive. Luna: So lead with genuine curiosity. 'Hey, I noticed something in the meeting today — can I share an observation?' Not 'Your presentation was a mess.' Lucas: Right. And the best framing I've found is to tie it to a shared goal. If you both care about the project's success, start there. I worked with a product lead at a mid-sized fintech — let's call her Sarah — who had a peer in engineering who kept presenting half-baked timelines. Every sprint review was painful. Sarah's team was losing confidence. Luna: So what did she do? Did she go to his manager? Lucas: She almost did. But instead, she sat down with him and said, 'I want our sprint reviews to be more useful for the stakeholders so we can get faster approvals. I've noticed sometimes the timeline slides feel a bit vague. Would it help if I shared a template I use?' Luna: That's smart — she made it about the outcome, not about his skill. And she offered help instead of criticism. Lucas: Exactly. He actually said yes. And over time, his presentations got tighter. But the key was she didn't say 'You're bad at timelines.' She said 'Here's a way we can both win.' Luna: I think that's the golden rule of peer feedback: frame it as 'us against the problem,' not 'me against you.' Lucas: Exactly. And that's a lot easier to do when you've built some relationship capital before the feedback moment. If you've never had coffee with this person, and suddenly you're critiquing their work, it's going to feel like an ambush. Luna: So invest in the relationship early. Grab a virtual coffee, talk about non-work stuff, find common ground. Then when you need to give feedback, it lands in a context of trust. Lucas: And if the feedback is more urgent — say they keep interrupting you in meetings — then you need a different approach. I'd suggest a very specific, low-emotion observation. 'In yesterday's review, I noticed I was three sentences into an update and you jumped in. I'd like to finish my points before we discuss — can we try that in the next meeting?' Luna: That's direct but not accusatory. You're stating the behavior, your preference, and a forward-looking request. No blame. Lucas: Right. And then you wait. You don't need a long apology or an explanation. Just a 'Sure, got it.' And then you follow up. If they do it again, you can say 'Hey, remember that thing we talked about?' and they'll usually correct. Luna: One thing I've found useful is to use the phrase 'I'm sharing this because I think we can be more effective together.' That signals partnership, not hierarchy. Lucas: That's a great line. And it also gives the peer a dignified way to respond. They can say 'Thanks, I appreciate that,' and you've both moved forward. Luna: Let me ask you this: what if the peer is defensive no matter what? You frame it perfectly, you're kind, you use 'we' language, and they still bristle and say 'I disagree' or 'That's not a problem.' Lucas: Then you have a different problem. If you've done the prep — checked your intent, built the relationship, used shared goals — and they still reject it, I think you have to decide whether this is a pattern that needs to be escalated. Not to punish them, but because the team's performance is suffering. You can go to your manager and say 'I've tried talking to Jen about the deadline slips. It hasn't landed. I'm concerned about the project timeline — can you help me think about next steps?' Luna: That's a much better conversation than 'Jen is impossible to work with.' You're framing it as a business risk, not a personality conflict. Lucas: Exactly. And that's actually the manager's job — to help you navigate difficult peer relationships. A good boss will either coach you on a different approach or step in themselves. Luna: Alright, I want to zoom out a bit. We've talked about specific techniques, but I think there's a bigger principle here: peer feedback is one of the highest-leverage skills for a manager. Because if you can influence sideways, you don't need to wait for authority — you can get things done faster. Lucas: Absolutely. And it builds your reputation as someone who's candid but kind. People will trust you more, not less, after a good feedback conversation. Luna: Yeah. I've seen managers who avoid peer feedback get sidelined, because they're seen as indirect or passive. And I've seen managers who do it well become the go-to collaborators. Lucas: Right. And before we wrap, I want to say: if you found today's episode useful, the reason we can keep doing these deep dives without ads is listener support. If you'd like to help us keep it that way, you can buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo — that's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: And honestly, even a small contribution makes a difference. It lets us spend time on the research and real-world examples rather than chasing sponsorship deals. Lucas: Exactly. So if today's episode gave you a phrase or a framework you'll actually use, consider throwing a couple bucks in the virtual tip jar. We appreciate it. Luna: Alright, back to the topic. One last thing I think is worth mentioning: sometimes peer feedback doesn't need to be a big formal conversation. You can give it in a casual moment — walking back from a meeting, or over Slack if it's a quick observation. Lucas: Yeah, I'm a fan of the 'micro-feedback' approach. A quick message: 'Loved your point in the meeting. One small suggestion — could you send the deck a day earlier next time? Gives us more time to prep.' That's low stakes, easy to absorb. Luna: And it's specific. The best feedback is specific and timely. Not 'you need to communicate better' but 'sending the deck earlier helps us prepare.' Lucas: Alright, let's recap the three steps for peer feedback. One: check your intent — are you helping or venting? Two: frame it around a shared goal — we both want this project to succeed. Three: use a specific observation and a forward-looking request, not a judgment. Luna: And if it doesn't land, escalate gracefully — as a business issue, not a personal complaint. Lucas: Perfect. I'd love to hear from listeners — have you had a peer feedback conversation that went surprisingly well? Or one that blew up? Drop us a note. We might cover it in a future episode. Luna: Until next Monday, keep leading sideways. Lucas: Take care, everyone.