Latest / Shiny New Object - a Marketing Podcast / Getting in a scrum with Golfbreaks' Bee Craft
Transcript
- 0:00Bee Craft: Data driven marketing isn't new. We just have loads
- 0:03more data available to us, but I guess it's just remembering that
- 0:07it's not just about the data, like data is really important,
- 0:11but it's, I guess it's remembering that there is a
- 0:13human at the other end of everything that we're trying to
- 0:16do as marketers.
- 0:23Speaker: Are you a fitness loving foodie? Then defy snacks
- 0:26is for you. Defy offers real high quality chocolate you love,
- 0:29combined with functional ingredients, giving you as much
- 0:31as 26 grammes of protein per bag. So you can be both a little
- 0:35bit bad and a little bit good at the same time as a female owned
- 0:38brand, defy dedicates a portion of its profits to other women
- 0:42owned businesses currently sold in the US. You can find us on
- 0:45defy with an i snacks.com and follow us on social at
- 0:49defisnacks.
- 0:56Tom Ollerton: Hello and welcome to the shiny new object podcast.
- 0:59My name is Tom Ollerton. I'm the founder of Automated Creative,
- 1:03the creative effectiveness ad tech platform, and this is a
- 1:06weekly podcast about the future of data driven marketing. And
- 1:09I'm the lucky guy that gets to interview all these clever
- 1:11people from around the industry about what they think is going
- 1:14to happen in the future of data driven marketing. And this week
- 1:17is no different at all. I'm on a call with Bee Craft, who is head
- 1:22of performance marketing at Golfbreaks. So Bee, for anyone
- 1:26who doesn't know who you are and what you do, could you give the
- 1:29audience a bit of background?
- 1:30Bee Craft: Yes, absolutely. So I have been in digital marketing
- 1:35for 15 years, always been in the travel space, so a long time now
- 1:40seen lots of changes. And during that time, I've basically looked
- 1:46after most marketing channels, actually, whether that be SEO,
- 1:51PPC, you know, performance, marketing channels, content and
- 1:57you know brand as well. So seeing quite a lot over my time.
- 2:01And, I mean, I think one of the biggest pieces is just like, how
- 2:06much it's changed in that time. And I'm sure that we'll explore
- 2:09that a bit more in the podcast.
- 2:11Tom Ollerton: Which channel have you got, like, love eyes for
- 2:14like, if you could go back or do it, were you like, oh, SEO is
- 2:18where it's up for me, you know, which one's got, like, you know,
- 2:21if they cut you open on your heart, what's it gonna say?
- 2:23Bee Craft: Well, I did start in SEO, so, like, right back 15...
- 2:2615 years ago, when it was very new, and more like, I guess, a
- 2:30bit black hat, where there were lots of, like, keyword stuffing
- 2:34and everything, and sort of like, that's obviously changed a
- 2:37lot since then. I, I would probably it's, it's definitely
- 2:43within search. I would say it's, it's organic, but so over my
- 2:47time, it's just understanding that whole search space. So it's
- 2:50definitely between organic and PPC and that search. But yeah,
- 2:54it's changed so much with the likes of social search coming
- 2:58in. So actually, that's probably just me saying all the channels,
- 3:01because it's as touched on social as well, really.
- 3:04Tom Ollerton: So if you were going to give a smart, driven
- 3:08student some advice to follow in your footsteps, what advice
- 3:12would you give them?
- 3:13Bee Craft: I would say that it's really hard to get experience
- 3:19somewhere without experience, and being a student, it's
- 3:25particularly challenging to get that experience in the first
- 3:28place, so you need to think about what's going to make you
- 3:31stand out. I've had a lot of experience recruiting students,
- 3:35so we have student placement programmes, and so I'm quite
- 3:41used to seeing students come through our doors and seeing
- 3:44what makes them stand out, and it can be difficult because it's
- 3:47so competitive out there. There aren't that many jobs for
- 3:51juniors, especially, and for people to be given a chance. And
- 3:54I think some of the things that have really stood out to me are
- 3:58students just taking or juniors, doesn't necessarily have to be
- 4:01students, obviously, people applying for grad roles, just
- 4:05taking a bit of initiative, reaching out to people on
- 4:08LinkedIn, and understanding that not everyone's going to get a
- 4:13response, and sometimes that rejection is a bit hard hitting.
- 4:16But for example, one of our one of our current students. How she
- 4:22first came to my attention was she reached out to me on
- 4:25LinkedIn and just said, Have you got anything going where I can
- 4:28just come and shadow your team? I live locally. I would love to
- 4:32just shadow your team and find out about marketing. I'd love to
- 4:36go into it. And she did. She came and for a week's work
- 4:40experience. We really used her for like work experience as
- 4:43well, and then she ended up getting a placement here with
- 4:48us, for example. So it's thinking about those different
- 4:52things that will make you stand out from the crowd. And it's not
- 4:55necessarily about skills. It's more about attributes. So like
- 4:59someone. Who just is really inquisitive, wants to learn
- 5:03more, is, like, quite passionate, especially about AI
- 5:06and this AI world and everything and, yeah, in inquisitive
- 5:10nature, I would say, like, think about the the attributes you
- 5:13possess that you can really own and really sell yourself
- 5:16essentially, because you it's not necessarily going to be the
- 5:18skills that you can do at that stage.
- 5:27Tom Ollerton: Funny story. I was, I was a chef many years
- 5:30ago. I was about 30, and I don't why I decided I wanted to work
- 5:35in digital advertising. I did someone I was going out with.
- 5:37That's the truth. And so I was on Gumtree. You know, the
- 5:41Gumtree I don't know if Gumtree is still a thing anymore, but it
- 5:42was it. And there was, like, what I was searching for. But
- 5:44anyway, it said digital internship available. And I saw
- 5:48it. I saw it like, drop in. And it was like, 20 minutes walk
- 5:52from my house. I just walked straight down there, knocked on
- 5:54the door, and I'm like, I'm here about the internship. And they
- 5:57were like, what we just, we just posted it in this like, Ginger.
- 6:00Ginger guy appeared, so thanks Damian for that, for me break.
- 6:03But yeah, it's true.
- 6:04Bee Craft: You did it?
- 6:05Tom Ollerton: Show up. Yeah.
- 6:06Bee Craft: Amazing.
- 6:08Tom Ollerton: That's yeah. And then about a month later I was
- 6:10head of new business. There you go. Yeah. Gosh, I was an odd
- 6:16anyway, you know, I mean, you take you take your breaks don't
- 6:19you. But yes, I think that's true. Anyone could send a CV.
- 6:22Bee Craft: Yeah, exactly.
- 6:24Tom Ollerton: It's like, what is, what is the, what is the
- 6:26extra thing you're going to do? Everyone else isn't prepared to
- 6:27do? Yeah, so that's how to get a job. But once you've got a job
- 6:31and they're working on your team or adjacent to you, what is the
- 6:35best bit of advice you have to become a better data driven
- 6:39marketer?
- 6:40Bee Craft: I think this is, like, quite a common one. And,
- 6:45you know, I've already mentioned AI probably about three times
- 6:47already, but, you know, data driven marketing isn't new, like
- 6:52it's always been there. We just have loads more data available
- 6:56to us, and although Google and Apple make it really quite
- 6:59challenging to unlock a lot of that. But I guess it's just
- 7:05remembering that it's not just about the data, like data is
- 7:10really important, but it's, I guess it's remembering that
- 7:12there is a human at the other end of everything that we're
- 7:15trying to do as marketers. And it's understanding that, you
- 7:20know, there is that human connection, and we can get so
- 7:22lost in being like, well, the data says this, and they're just
- 7:27saying this, but then actually, it's not as clean cut as that,
- 7:30and it's trying to understand, maybe more of what the intent is
- 7:33behind it. So that's definitely something that I've been trying
- 7:36to explore more. It's like, see beyond just the conversion, see
- 7:39beyond those metrics, which is all about ROAs and return and
- 7:44what is my money getting me and actually looking at okay, so
- 7:48those that didn't convert, there are people there who actually
- 7:52probably have a lot of intent and had built up a lot of
- 7:55engagement with your brand, but there was something that just
- 7:58didn't tip them over the edge. So it's actually understanding
- 8:01more about why someone didn't do something and how you can get
- 8:05them to act upon it. So I think AI, you know, it's it can be a
- 8:13dangerous tool for lazy people, like if you're just using data
- 8:19and looking at that and not understanding the human element
- 8:22behind it. So and it's also about the interpretation of the
- 8:27data as well, and the taking insights and how you communicate
- 8:30that as well. I think it's, you know, AI at the moment. I mean,
- 8:36at the moment, I don't know if it will, or if it does, then
- 8:39we're all in trouble. But like, you know, it doesn't know how to
- 8:42connect with a human. It doesn't know how to love someone. And I
- 8:46think that's the element that in marketing that you will always
- 8:50need. You need, like, that creative layer above data. So
- 8:54having those two working hand in hand is really important. But I
- 8:57mean, even with me, like, it's really, sometimes really easy to
- 9:01forget that, because it's all changing so quickly, and it's
- 9:05just remembering, what are those basics and why are we doing it?
- 9:11Who's it for?
- 9:12Tom Ollerton: Yeah, we talked about this quite a lot recently.
- 9:14It's like, abundant data doesn't equal important data. So from
- 9:18early platforms, you've got this abundance of, like, as much of
- 9:21it as you want. You know, you can slice it and dice it. It's a
- 9:24deluge of stuff, but it's not necessarily the most important
- 9:27data, right? You've got data come from GA4 or whatever,
- 9:30right? You know, add to basket conversion rate. But as you say,
- 9:33there's a human being, and the not abundant data is what that
- 9:37person thinks, and the only way to get it out of them is email
- 9:40them, speak to them, go and see them, and that takes time. It's
- 9:44a big investment, and even the data you get back from them
- 9:46isn't necessarily that trustworthy, because often
- 9:49people lie about what they think versus what they do. But just
- 9:52because data is hard to get doesn't mean you shouldn't go
- 9:55for it. It doesn't mean it's less important than the
- 9:57abundance stuff. So I massively agree with that, and. We just
- 10:00published a book called using data and creativity and
- 10:03marketing, and I interviewed 40 very senior people about it. And
- 10:06that refrain was the most common is that, like, don't just look
- 10:09at what the data is telling you, look at what it's hiding from
- 10:13you as well. And that that takes, takes a bit more work.
- 10:14Bee Craft: Yeah, absolutely. I think just being in that quite
- 10:17especially like the performance marketing space, you know, when
- 10:20you are getting questioned of like, well, what's the return?
- 10:24What? You know, these are our budgets. We need to make sure
- 10:27it's got this return. It's very easy to get focused so much on
- 10:31that one, those core metrics of conversions and everything that
- 10:37actually, what are, what is the rest of it, telling us, like,
- 10:40what are we missing in this? And how can we, I guess, improve
- 10:44that experience to ultimately help that end, that end goal.
- 10:49But it's just shifting, yeah, shifting that focus, I guess,
- 10:52which is hard as well to sell in, I guess, to a business as
- 10:56well, yeah?
- 10:56Tom Ollerton: And it's like, I don't know, you should show 100
- 10:59impressions and one person buys like, great. Yeah, that's we got
- 11:02a 1% conversion rate. Now, why did 99% of people not? Yeah,
- 11:07that's huge. That's a ginormous bit of data that isn't captured
- 11:10by your spreadsheet or your data set, right? So, yeah...
- 11:14Bee Craft: Absolutely it's hard, it's hard to find that. How do
- 11:19you find that data, and we've actually just started looking,
- 11:24there's a platform called made with intent. I don't know
- 11:26whether you've heard with it, but it's basically that whole
- 11:28concept, that whole premise, which is the code behind the
- 11:33scenes, is amazing. And going from talking about loads of
- 11:36data, I'm aware that I'm about to contradict myself, but it
- 11:39actually shows you that intent data of people that are on your
- 11:43site, and looking at, you know, where's the intent built? Are
- 11:47people in a building intent phase? You know? Are they? Do
- 11:52they have low intent? And is actually customising those
- 11:56journeys for those people at different stages. So, for
- 11:58example, if someone's got low intent about to abandon like
- 12:02they haven't really engaged with your brand. You don't
- 12:05necessarily want to be showing discount codes all the time to
- 12:10absolutely everyone. It's maybe those people that need that
- 12:13nudge over the line. So it's just taught thinking about how
- 12:16you use the messaging differently for different
- 12:18people. So it is like personalization, for example,
- 12:22but it's just looking at different metrics to help
- 12:26personalise those experiences really. So it's really
- 12:29interesting way to be looking at data differently and visitors
- 12:32essentially on the website.
- 12:33Why is it your shiny new it?
- 12:39Tom Ollerton: This episode of the shiny new object podcast is
- 12:43brought to you in partnership with Madfest, whether it's live
- 12:46in London or streamed online to the global marketing community,
- 12:49you can always expect a distinctive and daring blend of
- 12:52fast paced content, startup innovation pitches and
- 12:55unconventional entertainment from Madfest events. You'll find
- 12:58me causing trouble on stage, recording live versions of this
- 13:01podcast and sharing a beer with the nicest and most influential
- 13:05people in marketing. Check it out at www.madfestlondon.com.
- 13:16Right. Okay, so we're gonna move on now to your shiny new object,
- 13:20which is scrum for marketing. What's that? What does that? I
- 13:27think I know what that but I'm not sure. Explain scrum
- 13:29Bee Craft: Yeah, so it's my shiny new object, because, as
- 13:35we've alluded to already, like the world of data and marketing,
- 13:40data driven marketing is has changed so much, but it's just
- 13:44AI has sped up that change. And just when you think you've got
- 13:48something nailed, you're like, actually think I know what I'm
- 13:52doing here, all of a sudden something else is coming in.
- 13:55Like, there's a new Google algorithm update. You know,
- 13:58actually we need to be jumping on p max or demand gen or AI
- 14:03Max, and it's overwhelming. And so actually, how do you find...
- 14:10how can you be reactive, and how can you create a work
- 14:13environment that isn't just creating burnout and everyone
- 14:18just losing their heads and running around like headless
- 14:21chickens, like, how do you keep that consistency? And so for me,
- 14:25one of the things that I have implemented, and I don't know if
- 14:28I could ever not do this now, but is scrum for marketing. And
- 14:32essentially it's like it's a software development
- 14:35methodology. So you know, our software, our dev team like this
- 14:40is implemented in them, and basically stole it from them,
- 14:44and it's a framework that essentially allows you to break
- 14:48down larger projects into smaller, manageable tasks, and
- 14:52you work in sprints. So we work, for example, in two week
- 14:57sprints, and then essentially just everyone. One has tasks to
- 15:03action based on, you know, what your company goals are, or what
- 15:06project you need to get over the line by when. And it just means
- 15:10that everyone comes in and knows exactly what they're working on
- 15:13every single day. And we, you know, you can use, there's
- 15:17different platforms that you can use, project management
- 15:21platforms that you can use. I use Asana, but there's also JIRA
- 15:25that you know, that's more of a dev focus platform, but it's
- 15:30just really helps fight through the noise and just manage time.
- 15:35Essentially, it's, it can be really difficult to one, manage
- 15:42stakeholders. You know, getting multiple requests in marketing.
- 15:46Get so many requests, like, where I oversee website,
- 15:52content, SEO, PPC, like we there's just requests coming
- 15:56from everywhere, like, I want something on the website. I you
- 15:59know, we need to make sure that we were putting 10k more into
- 16:02this campaign, or whatever it is. And I like, but way back
- 16:08when, before this was implemented, I got to a point
- 16:10where I was like, No, we can't do that. We can't do that. We
- 16:12can't do that because it was difficult to see the wood
- 16:16through the trees. Like everyone was just like, well, we know we
- 16:19need to do this, but I also need to do this. Essentially, what it
- 16:21does is mean that you can make sure that you meet deadlines and
- 16:27projects, because you've broken down everything based on, you
- 16:32know, deadlines, and then if things come in, you can either
- 16:36move items that are already in that sprint, or you say no,
- 16:41like, I can't do this because we're trying. We're delivering
- 16:45this, this, this. If you want this to be done, then this is
- 16:48going to be sacrificed. It just makes conversations a lot
- 16:51easier. And then, from a team perspective as well, like
- 16:55everyone coming in, they know exactly what they are doing
- 16:59every day. It allows us to be really agile. And I know that
- 17:04that is a bit of a wanky word, I guess that people throw around a
- 17:08lot, but you really need to be. You need to be because it's
- 17:12changing so much.
- 17:13Tom Ollerton: So Bee, I get it from a theoretical perspective.
- 17:17So yeah, so we, we also use a an agile methodology in optimising
- 17:19our ads, right? So for our clients, we go, right, what's
- 17:19the first sprint? It's going to be, we'll test visuals, and then
- 17:20we'll be in, test messaging, then test format, and then test
- 17:29something else. And it's, you know, it's hypothesis,
- 17:33variation, live media data, and then that, that process repeats
- 17:37itself. So I'm familiar with it, as many of the people will be
- 17:40here. But could you sort of practically not giving anything
- 17:43away, tell me how that might work. So say the sprint starts
- 17:47tomorrow. What are you going right? So the goal of this two
- 17:50week sprint is to increase conversion rate. Could just,
- 17:53could you help us understand practically what that might look
- 17:56like?
- 17:56Bee Craft: Yeah, so we would have so every so we have two
- 18:00week sprints. So we work in two weeks worth of time, and what we
- 18:05do is we have a board, and everyone in the team will have
- 18:10their tasks that are for that two weeks. And how we get to
- 18:13that point is we will have a sprint planning session. So our
- 18:18sprints start on a Wednesday. We'll have a sprint planning on
- 18:21a Tuesday, and everyone will say, right, these are all my
- 18:25available hours because I've got X number of meetings. And, you
- 18:30know, nobody works at, say, 100% velocity, because people need
- 18:34comfort breaks. They need to go and have a coffee, they need to
- 18:37go and have a rant at the water cooler. And so it just takes
- 18:40into account everyone's available time, and then we can
- 18:44plan the work accordingly, so everyone will have say tickets
- 18:48within it. So that might be that, okay, I need to build this
- 18:51campaign. I need to allow for reporting during this time. I
- 18:55need to research this area, because AI Max, I'm hearing
- 19:01loads about that, and actually I need to explore is this right
- 19:04for my brand, etc, and it just breaks down everything that you
- 19:09need to do, which may seem a bit restrictive to some, but it's no
- 19:15different to having a to do list. But what it's doing is
- 19:19it's just actually making sure that it's a realistic to do list
- 19:25within that time that you have got, and it prevents burnout,
- 19:29essentially, because we don't want, well, I don't want a team
- 19:33of people who are so frantic and actually being unproductive
- 19:39because they don't know actually if they're coming or going. So
- 19:43it just actually allows people to step back and breathe and see
- 19:46what they need to do. And then also we and then as part of
- 19:49that, we have daily stand ups. So that is 15 minutes only ever,
- 19:5415 minutes every morning, and the team just share, right, this
- 19:58is what I'm working on. This is what I did yesterday. Actually,
- 20:02I've got a blocker here. Can anyone help me with this? Like,
- 20:05oh, I'm not going to get this done because I need to speak to
- 20:07this person. Or actually, I'm going to really struggle. Can
- 20:11anyone help me with this? And it just really helps that
- 20:14communication as well with the team. So just having that face
- 20:17to face, face to face or screen to screen, if we're working from
- 20:22home, time just really helps manage that and also share, I
- 20:28guess, ideas like so from a communication perspective across
- 20:32the team, like the whole marketing team, everyone knows
- 20:35what's going on. And so, for example, if we need something
- 20:38from a partner because something's going live on the
- 20:41website, we need to build a campaign around that, or,
- 20:43actually, we need to put some spend behind that to launch a
- 20:46partnership. Then everyone's aware. And it just makes it's
- 20:50just a really efficient way of working. But it does also allow,
- 20:56it allows you, I guess, to focus on the creativity and the
- 21:00strategy that often would maybe get left behind because you're
- 21:06so busy trying to manage your time and be reactive.
- 21:15Tom Ollerton: It sounds horrendous to me, but also music
- 21:18to my ears at the same time, because I'm terrible at going,
- 21:21this is the end goal. What are the milestones and working back.
- 21:25And, you know, because if I arrive and I'm like, Well,
- 21:27you've got to do this. I'm like, Oh, what's the fun in that, I
- 21:29quite, quite like the chaos of it, but, but however, the logic
- 21:33is brilliant. So how much resource do we have? What are we
- 21:37all trying to do? Right? We're going to go there. You're going
- 21:40to do that. I'm going to do that. I'm gonna do that. And if
- 21:54someone comes down from upstairs and says, I want this thing, you
- 21:54go, well, right, fine, I'm not going to do this. Which, what,
- 21:54what things you want me to stop doing? And that's really
- 21:54powerful is that, like, Sure, Yep, I'll, I'll put a green
- 21:54banana on the homepage, sure. But like, is that more important
- 21:54than crushing Black Friday or something, exactly?
- 21:57Bee Craft: And don't get me wrong, there was resistance,
- 22:00like being marketeers at first, because, you know, we do see
- 22:04ourselves as as creatives as well, as data led as well. And
- 22:09you have, you have different levels of that. So you have some
- 22:12people who are very much in the creative camp. And it was seen
- 22:17as like, actually, this could be quite rigid and restrictive, but
- 22:21now, actually the whole team are on board, and that they're like
- 22:24me. I don't know how we work without it. And I think actually
- 22:28I was having this conversation at a networking event, I don't
- 22:32know if you've heard of it, little grey cells, which is
- 22:34where senior marketers... yeah. Well, I was, I've only just
- 22:38recently been introduced to it by Becky Simms, who does a lot
- 22:43with it as well. She's from Reflect Digital. She she's an
- 22:48owner of that agency, actually. And I don't work with her,
- 22:51actually. I just think that she's a lovely person. And she
- 22:56introduced me to it, and she was like, I actually think that this
- 22:59would be really great for you. And I went to my first one, and
- 23:01it was all about, is there a formula for marketing? And we
- 23:05were having this discussion on our round table about, there is
- 23:10no formula, but actually, sometimes a bit of process
- 23:13really does help, like having that a bit of structure and
- 23:18getting the basics right, really does help to allow you to
- 23:22actually get momentum and elevate and be agile and and
- 23:26everything.
- 23:27Tom Ollerton: I'm in. I'm sold. I want to work on your team, but
- 23:32we're at the end of the podcast, unfortunately. So if someone
- 23:37wants to get in touch to talk about scrum for marketing, or
- 23:42any of the other things we've talked about, where's a good
- 23:44place and what makes a message that you'll actually respond to?
- 23:47Bee Craft: Yeah, so I would say for me, it's LinkedIn, and I do
- 23:50sometimes struggle, because I do get a lot of people trying to
- 23:55sell me stuff on that. So if someone just introduced and said
- 23:59I heard the podcast. I'd love to find out more about this. That
- 24:03would be a great way of me to respond, because sometimes I the
- 24:07amount of times that I have to respond to sales things, and
- 24:11it's like, actually, this isn't for me. But yeah, I would love,
- 24:14I love talking about it, and the fact that the podcast is over
- 24:17already, actually, I have so much more to say. So yeah, very
- 24:21I am very open to speaking about that for anyone who does want to
- 24:25know more.
- 24:26Tom Ollerton: Thank you so much.
- 24:27Bee Craft: Amazing. Thank you, Tom.
- 24:35Tom Ollerton: hi just before you go, I'd really appreciate it if
- 24:40you could take the time to write a review of the shiny new object
- 24:43podcast on Apple podcasts or iTunes, whatever it's called
- 24:46these days, or whichever podcast provider you use. We're at any
- 24:51podcast. So it would go a long way for us if you could just
- 24:54share the Word and give us a bit of a support on those channels.
- 24:57That would just be fantastic. If you haven't got time. That's
- 24:59also. Cool, and yeah, if you could tell your colleagues about
- 25:02the podcast, and also, if possible, don't forget to
- 25:06subscribe. And I'd love to hear your feedback. If you'd like to
- 25:09speak on the podcast or be a guest, or you think I'm asking
- 25:12the wrong questions, anything I'd be super interested to hear
- 25:15what you think. So please email me. Tom at automated
- 25:20creative.net that's Tom at I'm not going to bother spelling it
- 25:25anyway. You'll work it out. Thanks so much.