Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) (2018 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00So, Bob, you work in dialectical behavioral therapy. Dialectic dialectical dialectical behavioral
- 0:08behavior. That's really cool behavior dialect DBT. Yeah, DBT, but is
- 0:14it behavior or behavioral? I should know that, shouldn't I let me look
- 0:18it up real quick, so I thought we would do an episode about it
- 0:22so we could find out exactly whether it's behavioral or behavior This might be a
- 0:29short episode behavior dialectical behavior therapy that makes sense, behavior therapy, right,
- 0:36Yeah, I didn't tell you that that's what we're going to talk about today,
- 0:39but would you enjoy talking about it with me? Wohilch sure? Okay,
- 0:44Yeah, this is the Psychology in Seattle podcast. I'm your host,
- 0:48doctor Kirkhanda. I'm a therapist and a professor. Who you, Bob?
- 0:52I am Bob Gettle. I'm your old friend from graduate school from way back
- 0:54when, and a counselor here in Seattle as well. And if you're looking
- 0:59for one of the best therapists around, you can hire Bob, but you
- 1:03have to be in the Washington state, but you would go to Bob Gettle
- 1:07dot com. Thank you. So DBT, what is it? Yeah?
- 1:12Right? A treatment that was originally developed to help people with suicidal and self
- 1:19harm impulses not kill themselves. Okay, And you've been doing that DBT for
- 1:26a long time, like, yeah, fifteen years or something almost twenty twenty
- 1:32years. Yeah, And it was developed by Marshall Nahan. Was she working
- 1:36at the University of Washington at the time. Originally she was in Stonybrook because
- 1:42she's New York, and then she was at the American University is DC in
- 1:46DC, and then she moved here. I think you needed the late eighties
- 1:49or the very early nineties. Okay. And she has self disclosed that she
- 1:55suffers from borderline herself, right, I don't recall her saying that exactly.
- 2:00Oh, she has a history of self harm, okay. Yeah. And
- 2:06she developed a integrative therapy that was evidence based, that had elements of cognitive
- 2:14therapy, behavioral therapy, mindfulness and is that the main integrations. Yeah,
- 2:22and developed a very prescriptive therapy, manualized approach that isn't open ended, you
- 2:35know, it's there are tasks and worksheets and it's primarily a group therapy model.
- 2:42Correct. Well. It has two components. One is individual counseling and
- 2:46the other is skills training, which tends to take place in a group format,
- 2:51okay, and it was so it was originally developed to help people who
- 2:57were doing non suicidal self injury and having suicidal ideation. Yeah. Her original
- 3:02goal was to help people not kill themselves. That's the population she wanted to
- 3:07work with, and because it's linked to borderline personality disorder. What I heard
- 3:10her say once is when she started, she didn't know anything about borderline personally
- 3:15disorder. She just wanted to help people not die. Okay, she wanted
- 3:20to That's interesting. I didn't know that. So it wasn't about non suicidal
- 3:23self injury. It was mainly about suicidal I think both, oh, both
- 3:28of yeah, and then I'm guessing over time she started realizing that many of
- 3:34her patients were borderlined, yeah, and decided to learn more about that and
- 3:40how this model might work with borderline in general, not just with suicide and
- 3:47preventing death, but also with emotional regulation and bettering your relationships and coping skills
- 3:55and all this kind of stuff. Right. Well, it's true. Originally,
- 3:59you know, she came out of the eighties, and in the eighties,
- 4:01assertive as training was all the thing. You know, we work in
- 4:05a fetish kind of field, and that was the fad back then. And
- 4:09her original plan was to teach people to speak for themselves because she figured if
- 4:13they could speak for themselves properly, that would have an impact on you know,
- 4:17these behaviors that she was trying to help people with interesting and so she
- 4:21did. She started out teaching assertiveness, and indeed that's still part of the
- 4:25skills curriculum. But what happened is her clients would be like, yeah,
- 4:30all well and good, but they call her in the middle of the week
- 4:31and they'd be like, I'm in crisis now, so what do I do?
- 4:34And so from that she developed another part of her skills training, which
- 4:40is called distress tolerance, which is about how to survive without making life worse.
- 4:45Okay, tell us about that, Oh okay. It comes in two
- 4:48flavors. The first part is crisis survival skills, which are nuts and bold
- 4:54skills. I really like them. I like them in part because everybody already
- 4:59knows them. But most of the people that show up in DBT have a
- 5:01habit of mind that's self critical, as do I think most people anyways,
- 5:08and fail to recognize the worst at that Kirk's being ironic Anyways, how was
- 5:20I saying I've lost my Well, people already know these skills, but in
- 5:25DBT they have all this jargon, and the jargon is only useful in my
- 5:28opinion, because what it does is it gives a person a frame to recognize
- 5:31the things that they're doing that are skillful. So I say to my students,
- 5:38half of what we're going to do here is reinforce what you already know
- 5:42and do, and half what we're going to do is teach us something new.
- 5:46So is DBT typically done in the way that you do it in terms
- 5:54of the the groups and the individual and the particular modules that you walk people
- 6:01through. Is that the typical format. Yeah, Standard DBT has two components.
- 6:06One is individual counseling, which is very similar to sort of standard Western
- 6:13CBT kind of behavioral therapy once a week, usually about once a week,
- 6:16it could be more or less depending on someone's acuity. And then it has
- 6:21this other component which is skills training, which tends to take place in a
- 6:26group. And then the other bit of DBT is that therapists work on a
- 6:31team so that nobody is carrying the load alone. So therapists who have clients
- 6:38in the skills class attend the weekly meeting in the skills trainers that's me attend
- 6:44the weekly meeting too. And there's a coordination of care. So you're the
- 6:50group counselor person and other people are the individual counselor. Yeah, are do
- 6:58Sometimes people do both roles. Okay. Occasionally I'll have somebody in my class
- 7:02who is my also my individual client. And group is once a week.
- 7:08Yeah, once a week, two and a half hours, and like ten
- 7:10people, eight students, and then me and my co teacher, Terry Georski.
- 7:15Okay, and I didn't know Terry was doing it, yeah, about
- 7:19seven years now, believe it or not, well, because he used to
- 7:23do it with another friend of yours. Well, And so how many groups
- 7:30do you have? I run two each week, both on Wednesdays, with
- 7:33eight people, eight students each year long class two and a half hours is
- 7:38one class. You're saying students, because why you've told me this before,
- 7:43But yeah, I have this thing. I have really because of insurance.
- 7:49If I'm in panels on an insurance, if I'm hooked up with an insurance,
- 7:54right, and I call it group therapy, I'm bound to accept the
- 7:57rate that the group therapists that the insurance company will pay for group therapy,
- 8:01which tends to be very very low and not nearly what I need to make
- 8:05in order to actually make the thing work, because I got to pay TOO
- 8:07therapists like twenty bucks per client or something, Yeah, for what they call
- 8:13a ninety minute session, And we do two and a half hour session with
- 8:15TOO therapists, and they don't pay for that extra time. So you're getting
- 8:20one hundred and sixty maybe two hundred bucks from the including the cope and everything.
- 8:26Yeah, Yeah, like two hundred bucks ish for two people working two
- 8:31and a half hours plus prep time and set up. Yeah, and you
- 8:35have to rent like a pretty big office to you know, have that many
- 8:39seats, and sometimes you don't have eight people, and so that's not a
- 8:43sustainable model. So then so you call them students instead. So what I
- 8:48did is I changed the way I think about it, and I call it
- 8:52a class, which is not group therapy. And if you if I'm honest,
- 8:56I actually believe that it is not group therapy. It's not group therapy
- 8:58as I understand it. But I don't get so bent out of shape about
- 9:03that anymore because I'm not on any insurance panels, so I don't have to
- 9:05kind of play a game. So people pay, people pay out of pocket.
- 9:09Yeah, how much do they pay percession per group? Yeah, we
- 9:13don't charge percession. We charge but that's okay because it breaks down to ninety
- 9:18bucks a class each, you know, for each of eight students, and
- 9:22we charge it like a college class, which is a pretty weird way to
- 9:26do anything in the counseling field is to pay upfront for service you haven't gotten,
- 9:31like tuition. Yeah, like tuition. We truly treat it like a
- 9:33college class and I yeah, yeah, And it's not group therapy to you
- 9:37because why because it's curriculum based as opposed to person based. Okay, what
- 9:43does that mean. It means that we teach a very specific curriculum. It
- 9:48really is a class. We spend an hour on homework review, we take
- 9:50a little break, then we spend an hour on material which comes out of
- 9:52that manual and the official Marshal in Hand DBT manual. Yeah, yeah,
- 10:00which just got republished updated when accomplished. It's called Skills Training Manual for a
- 10:05borderline personally disorder. It might be called DBT Skills Training Manual now something like
- 10:09that for borderline specifically. Its original title was Yeah, Skills Training Manual for
- 10:16a borderline person I disorder? Yeah? Interesting? Yeah, okay, So
- 10:22is it a good way to make a living? Yeah? Is it sounds
- 10:26stressful? Kind of? It has been. Yeah, I've been doing it
- 10:28a long time now, and I can honestly say that when I started,
- 10:33I sucked. But the thing about how did you suck? I was not
- 10:39flexible enough. I was too pushy and too hell bent on what it is
- 10:46that I thought people should be doing my students should be doing, and not
- 10:48flexing enough and not actually reinforcing their practice in a way that made them feel
- 10:54good. And I didn't run the class in a way that made people feel
- 10:58good about being there and feeling sack. And I'd say that right now,
- 11:01the thing that we do best is that that we make it a place people
- 11:05like to come where they really genuinely feel supportive by one another and by us.
- 11:11And I am far less pushy. Was it based on your understanding of
- 11:20DBT at the time, Yeah, you just or too. That's what you
- 11:26thought DBT was was to be fairly prescriptive and not attend too much to the
- 11:33experience of them in the in the in the group, yeah, which saying
- 11:37when you say it like that, it sounds ludicrous. But indeed, I
- 11:41think the problem for me is that I read that treatment manual and I was
- 11:43sort of on my own to kind of learn how to do it, and
- 11:48I have a bias, and so I have this overlay about what it is
- 11:52to be a student and the kind of student I used to be when I
- 11:54was in school, compliant and yeah and loyal, yeah, which basically describes
- 12:01my upbringing. And when your students or clients weren't like that, you were
- 12:09didn't care so much in the beginning, but now you do. I would
- 12:11get irritated. You get irritated, but now you really do spend a lot
- 12:16of emotional energy on making people feel heard and go at their pace and more
- 12:22collaborative. And I quite frankly, I admire my students. I think they
- 12:26work very hard, and they often do not do what I would like,
- 12:31but that's life, right, That's everybody's life. But they do amazing and
- 12:35extraordinary things. And I find you get more out of paying attention to what
- 12:41people do than paying attention to what they don't do. So this is a
- 12:45year long thing. So people pay for a year of this individual slash class
- 12:52that they will probably spend so two and a half hours a week in class
- 12:58and one hour a week in therapy. Yeah, and do they ever go
- 13:01longer than a year? Occasionally people will. The way we have it set
- 13:05up is a person can do a six month followup. The curriculum takes six
- 13:09months to work through, and everybody goes through twice. That's the research model,
- 13:13and so I'm not messing with that. So meaning that you go through
- 13:18it through six months and then you start over again and do the exact same
- 13:24thing, even as if you had never done it the first time, and
- 13:28there might be new people in the group that second time. That's true.
- 13:31People can phase in at the six month mark. Well, they phase in
- 13:33and out all the time. Like if I start in April, I'll graduate
- 13:37in April. But if I started in June, I'll graduate the next June.
- 13:39And so you can start always changing. You can start anywhere in the
- 13:45sixth month. But to you, you know where it starts. But to
- 13:50other people, they might start on chapter ten, go to chapter twenty,
- 13:54go to chapter one, and then end on chapter nine exactly, and it
- 13:58doesn't matter because each chapter is a standalone thing that doesn't require you to have
- 14:05the previous chapters. That's correct. Interesting, Well, that's a fairly convenient
- 14:11model to follow, so the and do people generally stick with it for twelve
- 14:18months? Yeah, I'd say our graduation rates about ninety eight percent. Wow,
- 14:24I'm surprised because my experience of DBT and referring people to DBT was back
- 14:31when I worked with a lot of teenagers and there were it was trendy,
- 14:37and I don't know if it still is. I'm guessing it still is.
- 14:39For a fifteen year old girl who is having a lot of emotional problems and
- 14:46acting out and you know, fighting with her parents every day and very distressed
- 14:54and has suicidal thoughts to be assumed that she's a a budding borderline as they
- 15:01call it, and that DBT is really the only answer and probably a good
- 15:07answer. And then but the fifteen year old didn't want any kind of counseling,
- 15:15and so so then you know, the system or me involved in the
- 15:20system, or the family would end up referring, and then I would always
- 15:24have a pretty pessimistic thought about them completing it because they were pretty erratic and
- 15:35chaotic just on an hour to hour basis, let alone like sticking with something
- 15:39for twelve months, especially when I imagined the class would require meaningful participation,
- 15:48right, you'd have to do the homework and at least talk, and you
- 15:52know, some of these kids were not about that, yeah, at that
- 15:56stage. So so I'm guessing you don't get those kinds of clients. I'm
- 16:02my classes for adults, so I don't work with teens. You know,
- 16:04eighteen and above, So we have a pretty broad age range of ages in
- 16:10my class, but we don't work with teens per se. There are DBT
- 16:15programs that actually incorporate family as opposed to just the identified teen client, and
- 16:22the parents go through the program. Yeah, parents and everybody attends skills training
- 16:26together. Wow. And I don't know about the research on that, though
- 16:30I suspect a person could feel confident that it would be helpful. Yeah,
- 16:36yeah, absolutely, I mean DBT that so give us an idea of what
- 16:41DBT well before I go to there. So the people who come to you,
- 16:47are they self referred? Are they are they wanting DBT? They're wanting
- 16:52skills training. That's who I get so I don't actually run a standard program
- 16:56which has those three components I mentioned earlier. I run a d skills class,
- 17:00and I don't require that my students engage in one on one DBT therapy.
- 17:06I do require them they'd be in some kind of therapy, but it
- 17:10doesn't have to be DBT. And the reason for that is because the research
- 17:14study that I worked on at the University of Washington was a dismantling study where
- 17:18they wanted to see what's the active ingredient in this therapy. So they have
- 17:22three conditions thirty three subjects per condition. First condition was standard DBT, which
- 17:27is the individual component plus the skills training, and the second condition was just
- 17:33individual counseling with no skills training component. Those folks, though, to control
- 17:37for time in a group met once a week in what they called an insiders
- 17:41group, which was the social group essentially where they did interesting fun stuff,
- 17:45you know, bowling or movie or whatever. And then the third condition was
- 17:48people just getting skills training who did not have an individual counselor, who had
- 17:53a case manager who would link them to resources and provide support in limited support
- 18:00though anyways, And the reason for that third condition was because that's what most
- 18:08people in the country, and community meal health clinics were getting they weren't getting.
- 18:12The thing about individual DBT that makes it a little bit different from other
- 18:15kinds of therapy is that the therapist tends to be much much more available for
- 18:22coaching calls between sessions, right. That's the model that Marshall and Hand found
- 18:26to be helpful was that they're basically on call. Yeah, when the person
- 18:33is having a crisis of suicidal thoughts and they're available. Yeah, And that's
- 18:41hard to facilitate for if you're at a clinic. I guess is that the
- 18:47idea, well, community is copensive. I guess, yeah it is.
- 18:49But community metal health clinics are not generally set up for a therapists to be
- 18:53on call like that. They rely on the crisis clinic at least in the
- 18:57King County area where or they're our own crisis line that doesn't involve the actual
- 19:03therapist. Price models like the actual individual therapist is available in between sessions.
- 19:07Yeah. Yeah, and there's some flexibility of limits within that, you know,
- 19:11open to interpretation. I have a friend I think is a very good
- 19:14DBT person who does not take calls after ten PM. Well, so by
- 19:22omission, you're saying that the standard for DBT is to take calls after ten
- 19:29pm. A person could take a call at any time. What's the typical
- 19:33I mean, so interesting? And do you get paid for that as a
- 19:40DBT person. Well, I don't know how therapists work it. I could
- 19:45imagine somebody asking to be paid for the phone console time, especially if it's
- 19:52waking them up in the middle night. I mean, you know, that's
- 19:52disruptive. I heard a friend of mine who is very good DBT therapist said
- 19:59at one point he he was getting calls in the middle of the night from
- 20:02this one client and it was really disrupting his life in his sleep, and
- 20:04so he just made that part of therapy is to target they call it targeting.
- 20:10It's kind of it's kind of a interesting word. Yeah. Anyways,
- 20:14what he did is he just made that a topic of therapy, which is
- 20:18to get this client such that she didn't need to call him in the middle
- 20:21of the night. Yeah, so he could sleep. Yeah. So Lenahan
- 20:25and I agree found that when a person who has warline or something related,
- 20:33a therapist or a counselor who's there all the time, it's a huge relief
- 20:38to them and something that is very curative. I would call it a corrective
- 20:45experience. I think Lena Ahnann would call it some kind of emotional regulation.
- 20:48She might call it a corrective experience. Nowadays she might okay, And that
- 20:55is one of the struggles actually of when I work with people with personality disorders.
- 20:59They often will will increase their dependence on me, which is fine and
- 21:04good and corrective. And I have other things I have to do with my
- 21:11with my week, and I have a model of you know, pretty much
- 21:15maximum one hour a week, and and so there's sometimes some negotiation of boundaries
- 21:22around that. And uh, but if I had a different mindset or a
- 21:29different lifestyle that allowed for such a thing, I might allow that. It's
- 21:33a it's a compassionate thing that these DBT people do. But anyway, so
- 21:37getting back to your the study, Oh yeah, they found I'm guessing that
- 21:41the class was quite successful. In relation to the other elements of the DBT
- 21:48model. Is that what you're saying, I am so standard DBT helps And
- 21:53what do you mean by STANDARDBT? So that's individual counseling plus skills training of
- 21:56that standard that's a standard model. And the therapist is there twenty four to
- 22:02seven kind of yeah, yeah, available though it's I like what you're saying.
- 22:07I think therapists DBT therapists still do have boundaries that they want to observe,
- 22:11limits that they want to observe. So it's not like you can call
- 22:14me any old time. It's like, if you're calling me and it's disrupting
- 22:15my life, then we're going to have to deal with it because if I
- 22:19burn out, I'm no good to you. Right, So that's on the
- 22:22table therapists are. Self care for therapists is really important, which is a
- 22:29lot of why there's a team, because there's a team at therapists supporting somebody
- 22:32who's very right. That's another great part of the model that I think it
- 22:37is hard to facilitate sometimes and to have it formalized in the model I think
- 22:42helps to make sure that we do that essentially self care. You know.
- 22:48Yeah, So okay, So in the study, if you had asked me
- 22:53at the beginning, who's going to be helped here, I would have said
- 22:55the standard, the standard B it's going to help and individual counseling without skills
- 22:59training is going to be helpful and just skills training alone isn't going to do
- 23:02anything for anybody interesting. And it actually turns out that individual counseling without skills
- 23:07training, they had a far weaker treatment response and greater dropout, and skills
- 23:15training without individual counseling was nearly as effective as standard DBT. Wow, I
- 23:21was the skills trainer on that research study, so you can imagine I feel
- 23:22pretty good about that. And so as a result, I changed the way.
- 23:27Did you just throw the data into the individual therapist's face and say I'm
- 23:34better than you? Well, of course the data has proven I am effective
- 23:38and you are not. Of course I did that. I still do that.
- 23:45So what I did is though I changed the way I ran my DBT,
- 23:48the part of that DBT part of my private practice, and I no
- 23:52longer required that my clients being individual DBT, and I no longer required that
- 23:59their individual therapy is to tend a consult meeting that I ran. Do Other
- 24:03DBT people frown at this because it's still the standard models to have individual DBT.
- 24:08Yeah, certified DBT, right, you have to be a certified that's
- 24:12the other thing. You have to be certified as a DBT person to do
- 24:15this. Sort of thing. Right, you don't have to be certified,
- 24:18but that certification has come and it's available and it's probably a good thing.
- 24:22Are you certified? No, they don't certify skills trainers. They only certified
- 24:26individual counselors. Okay, but you don't have to. Just like you could
- 24:30be a CBT therapist, you could be a DBT therapist. Okay. Well,
- 24:36let's take a break, and after that, I want to hear about
- 24:37the specific skills that you teach. I think that's a part that might be
- 24:41interesting to people. The second half of this episode, in which we talk
- 24:45about dialectical behavior therapy, is just for patrons of the podcast, So if
- 24:49you're not a patron, the content will end now. But if you're a
- 24:52patron, then you get to hear the rest of the episode, which is
- 24:56me and Bob talking about dialectical behavior therapy. So if you're not a patron
- 25:00yet, go to patreon dot com and become a patron, and then you'll
- 25:03get instructions on how to access the rest of this episode, along with hundreds
- 25:07of other Patreon exclusive episodes in which I do deep dives into various things like
- 25:12narcissistic personality disorder, histrionic personality, disorder, borderline, and so on.
- 25:18So go to Patreon dot com become a patron of the podcast.