Latest / Pensions Perspectives / The future of income investing: Taking a Total Portfolio Approach
Transcript
- 0:04Hello and welcome to this episode of the Pensions Perspective podcast, brought to you by WW. I'm your
- 0:11host, Sophie Tennison, and I'm an investment consultant here. And today I'm joined by two
- 0:16colleagues from our Leeds office. And it's very exciting for those who are watching on YouTube,
- 0:20you'll notice that we are in a different studio. And just like Andy Burnham's Number ten, the
- 0:25Pensions Perspective podcast has been on the road and we've come up north, which is very exciting.
- 0:31Yeah, hopefully you'll have some subtitles for the video. Yeah. In this episode we're going to talk
- 0:37about income. So a topic that many investors will feel comfortable with. But the questions that
- 0:42we're guessing for investors are changing. So obviously we've got defined benefit pension
- 0:47schemes. They're looking to meet their pension payroll defined contribution members are looking
- 0:52to transform their savings pots at retirement into an income for life. And then we've got wealth
- 0:58investors that are looking to develop a stable income that's going to help, uh, hedge against
- 1:04inflation and, um, other market conditions. Ben Johnson and Chris Thompson recently
- 1:11published a article called a Rethinking Income Investing A Total Portfolio Approach. And I've
- 1:18included the article in the show notes of this episode. So really glad you could join to to
- 1:23discuss that in more detail and really explore some of the themes there. Ben is a strategic
- 1:28advisor, and he's one of the architects of our Think act Invest framework, which hopefully some
- 1:33of our listeners saw a previous podcast on. And Chris is one of our DB portfolio specialists.
- 1:40So he's working on portfolio construction for some of our largest DB run on portfolios. Would
- 1:46you both like to introduce yourself to our listeners, and maybe give an outline of the role
- 1:50that you have at WDW? Well, thank you very much for having me. I'm looking forward to this. Um, so I'm a
- 1:56managing director at WDW. I've been here for coming to 17 years now, I think. Or over 17 years
- 2:02actually. And I spend a lot of my time advising DB and DC investors. So helping them think
- 2:08about ultimately what they're trying to achieve. Think about what risk means. Think about what
- 2:14opportunity means for them, and then building a framework and portfolio approach that gets them
- 2:18to deliver it ultimately. Yeah. And thanks again for having having me. It's great to be on
- 2:25the pod, to be honest. Um, yeah. So I'm a portfolio manager within our delegated investment
- 2:32business, and I think you did a great job introducing me in my role. Um, I do spend a lot of
- 2:39my time thinking and constructing portfolios for some of our biggest clients that are focusing
- 2:45more on, run on and, and income focussed portfolios. Brilliant. Well, maybe I'll start with you then.
- 2:50Chris, obviously you're having a lot of conversations with investors about income, but
- 2:54what's changed in terms of the questions that you're getting and the conversations you're
- 2:57having. Yeah, I mean, it's I think it's fair to say quite a bit. It's changed in the, in the, in the
- 3:03last few years hasn't. Gotten an easy question. Yeah, absolutely. Um, no. We've seen, um, markets
- 3:10change. We've seen material increase in, in in yields. We've seen strong equity market
- 3:15performance. So what that has meant for most schemes is that their funding levels, their
- 3:22position has, has, has accelerated. And they are now ahead of where they expected to be at this point
- 3:28in time. And then when you combine that with, um, other changes that we're seeing, sort of
- 3:34legislation changes around, um, extraction of surplus and um, the sort of DB funding code. I
- 3:40think the, the discussion about the, the strategic objectives are just becoming more and more
- 3:46important. And it's important to get those those clearer outset before you even start thinking
- 3:51about making those portfolio decisions. Um, obviously sat next to Ben here, so it'd be remiss
- 3:56of me not to mention, I think, acting best, but I think one of the key principles there is that
- 4:01making sure that any decisions you are making from a portfolio perspective are sort of anchored
- 4:06to that, that strategy and those objectives. So, um, yeah, once you've got that, that clarity of that
- 4:13strategy, um, and how trying to achieve that with confidence, it's sort of
- 4:20it's clear why schemes are focusing more on income, more unpredictable income streams,
- 4:27um, to give you that confidence to achieve those, those outcomes. I guess you build on that a bit
- 4:32because the, the DB context, if we think about DC investors, you've effectively
- 4:38got the first wave of members who are going to have exclusively DC benefit and state pension as
- 4:44well, but those members are retiring now or retiring retiring soon. And if you just think
- 4:49about those individuals, they've spent their whole lives, I guess, turning up doing the day job,
- 4:53getting a paycheque, probably thinking they have to turn off to turn up to the day job to get the
- 4:57paycheque, but they haven't had to think that hard about it. And they're getting to the point now.
- 5:01They're retiring, got this big pot of money. They've got to turn that big pot of money into
- 5:05that reliable, resilient income that will last them for the rest of their lives. And I think
- 5:10that's a really difficult challenge because that's an investment question, and it's an
- 5:14actuarial question. And you spent your whole life specialising in one thing, and you're now being
- 5:19asked to be an investment in actuarial expert. And I think that's really difficult. And so when I
- 5:24think through the the kind of considerations that the having to battle with of sequencing risk,
- 5:30longevity, thinking about investment risk, thinking about cash flows, liquidity, all these kind of
- 5:37things. It starts to sound to me a lot more like a, a DB problem. Um, and I often think, yeah, if you
- 5:43kind of wait a long wait long enough, everything comes back into fashion. And my life often says
- 5:47that's probably true about my wardrobe as well. Maybe we'll get more viewers flipping over to
- 5:52YouTube now to check out your wardrobe. Yeah, I should. Have made that song really lean into it.
- 5:59Yeah. Subtitles. Flat caps and whippets. I'm mindful that some of our listeners, when they will have
- 6:06seen the title of the podcast and might be thinking more around cash flow driven investment
- 6:11and expecting us to be talking about that. And I guess I'll be interested to know, under that kind
- 6:17of regime, how a well funded DBS scheme would have invested and how what you're talking about today
- 6:22is differs from that. Yeah, sure. So I think where we've been historically is that schemes have been
- 6:29targeting this self-sufficiency funding level. And when they've been getting close to that or past
- 6:34it, um, we've seen schemes taking risk off or more like actually just taking return off and
- 6:41reducing return quite, quite materially. Um, so what that's meant is that they've been focusing on
- 6:46assets, gilts and credit to more precisely match what their expected
- 6:53liability outflows are. Um, and whilst as consultants, we we like the illusion of precision.
- 6:59I think it's fair to say that, um, liabilities are far from that. They the sort of
- 7:06the, the actual expected the actual experience will be different to, um, what
- 7:13we expect. So you sort of don't want to construct your portfolio around something that's just sort
- 7:18of relatively imprecise. So we think whilst there are a lot of good things and foundations from the
- 7:24CDI framework, I think the question just needs to become more broader. Um, and it comes back to Ben
- 7:30mentioned it earlier. It's just that sort of resiliency point. And how do you make sure that
- 7:34the portfolio is resilient enough to achieve those those outcomes with confidence. So
- 7:40you start asking yourself more broader questions of it's a portfolio. Um, sufficiently diversified
- 7:46is the income, is the income stream a truly diversified source. You have you got sufficient
- 7:52flexibility, one within the portfolio to take advantage of opportunities. But do you have the
- 7:56governance framework in place in place to do that? So once you once you combine all of that, that
- 8:02puts you in a, in a better, better place from where you were. And it's just an evolution of those,
- 8:09those concepts that we had from a sort of portfolio construction standpoint. I guess that
- 8:13makes sense in terms of not wedding yourself to precision. I know we've all had conversations with
- 8:18schemes around all those risks that can take you off, that we can't model, no matter how good we are.
- 8:23Yeah. No, it's it's not investment risk. That longevity risk expense is changing all that thing
- 8:29kind of really data cleansing all that can kind of change the ballpark. So ballpark. So if you are
- 8:33trying to wedge yourself to one specific out, you know, number then then these things just are. Going
- 8:40to be wrong. Yeah. Exactly. Exactly. Yeah. You mentioned resilience there Chris. And obviously
- 8:45the regulator is really keen on schemes, thinking about strategy in a resilient way, making sure
- 8:51that it can cope with different market outcomes. I guess maybe I'll come to you now in terms of
- 8:58thinking about resilience from an income perspective, what do we mean by that? Is it just a
- 9:03case of just maximising the amount of income you can get from assets? Yeah, I think I don't
- 9:10put words in the the sweeping generalisation, but maybe I will actually. I think when people think
- 9:14about income stability of income, I think what they're really getting at is an
- 9:21income that can adapt, that can support me through time throughout the whole journey, throughout my
- 9:27retirement. And so I tend to think of it as, yeah, kind of if maximising income is out of
- 9:34the snapshot. Resilience is such easy, but resilience is sort of the journey. It's making
- 9:39sure that that income stream will continue to support the objectives, will continue to do what
- 9:44you need it to do all the way through. It'll protect against inflation, whatever it might be.
- 9:49That's why that's where I come from. I think it's the distinction between the snapshot, which might
- 9:52be stability objective and the journey, which is the the resilience angle. So what would a
- 9:59scheme need to do to to kind of be ready from an income perspective. I think yeah.
- 10:06So Chris has mentioned the you've both mentioned it's the think act inverse frame, which I'm sure
- 10:11listeners can pick up on on the other podcast. But the kind of one of the key principles
- 10:16underpinning all of that is you need to start first with what are we looking to achieve? Because
- 10:22you can only build something that's really resilient to manage the risks. If you first know
- 10:25what it is you want to do, and then only then can you quantify what risk is, because risk in its
- 10:29most simplest term, we've got all these tracking errors of value at risk. All these measures,
- 10:33they're useful. But the true measure of risk is I can't do what I wanted to do and what I set out
- 10:38to do. So we want to start by asking that fundamental question of what we here to do. What
- 10:43then does the rest look like in that context? Then we can start thinking through some of those
- 10:47things. And I think when I look across from I'm talking from the strategic perspective, I'm sure
- 10:51Crystal touched on some sort of more, more portfolio aspects. But when we think from a DB
- 10:56client perspective, we want to build resilience. The natural tendency is to think, well, that's a
- 11:03stability point. I'll reduce investment risk because I can make it more, more stable. But you
- 11:08mentioned, Sophie, that investment risk is but one of many. There are a whole lot of other non
- 11:12investment factors. Um, we just don't everyone doesn't know individually and collectively how
- 11:17long people are going to live. There's a longevity risk. We talk about the risk of people living
- 11:21longer, which sounds perverse in the real world, but in pensions world, that's the way we kind of
- 11:24think about it. And so you don't reduce that risk by selling some equities. You reduce that risk
- 11:31by hedging it, or you manage that risk by building a buffer so that if a bad event happens, you can
- 11:36absorb it. So where we get to in that is from an overall resilience perspective for the strategy.
- 11:42low risk is not low return. A moderate return is higher resilience. So that's kind of a headline DB
- 11:48strategy, a thing I guess from a DC perspective. And the individual kind of wealth
- 11:55perspective from the DC angle primarily, is that you can think about some of these things in
- 12:02the design. So I think you've touched on you've done sessions on podcasts, on collective, DC, on
- 12:09flex, then fix things like annuities can help provide that stability. Things like pooling and
- 12:15investment and longevity risk can certainly help. Um, but I think, yeah, there are a number of things
- 12:21there to think about. In the final thing I would just say is that that having that clarity on what
- 12:25you want to achieve, understanding what risk means in that context, and then putting the governance
- 12:29framework into deliver, it is really key. And that makes sense. I guess one of the other key themes
- 12:36that's in the article that you published was around the total portfolio approach, and
- 12:40appreciate this has got more traction. It's got more, um, traction in the press in terms of what it
- 12:46is, but it might be worth just for all our listeners just to cover off again what we mean by
- 12:51a total portfolio approach. Um, but also, I'd be interested to hear how that framework can support
- 12:57trustees and how they're thinking about strategy specifically. So I think when I think about it, I
- 13:03kind of come up with sort of three, three points that I think are really important for how how we
- 13:09build a sensible and resilient portfolio. And the first of those we've kind of touched on a few
- 13:13times already, but it's objective led portfolio construction. So it's again being clear on what
- 13:19the objective is and then making sure that everything in the portfolio is there specifically
- 13:24to deliver that ultimate objective. And that sounds really obvious, but we often start from the
- 13:29answer appears to the portfolio and kind of work back and anchor and adjust it. You're going to
- 13:33arrive at very different outcomes for how you build a portfolio. Obviously, you can do it between
- 13:38CBDC individual investors. can derive a DIF outcomes, but different DB investors, different DC
- 13:42investor will end up at different positions depending on what the ultimate Jet2 is. So that
- 13:44means a really key thing. The second thing is, is this kind of competition for capital.
- 13:52It's like a weird way of putting it, but maybe it's the it's almost one in, one out or every
- 13:56investment have to earn its place. And that you think about the portfolio as a number of ideas,
- 14:02income generating ideas that are trying to are vying for that position in your portfolio. So if
- 14:07something else comes in, it's better than what you've got. It can bump it out of the portfolio. So
- 14:13that kind of competition for capital mindset thinks important. And the final thing I'd say is
- 14:16just adaptability. And we've mentioned a couple of times. Yeah you've got these. Someone in a DB sense,
- 14:21someone will draw you this perfect cash flow chart. You know, that's just a reflection of that's
- 14:25just an illustration of some abstract. Yeah. Reality is a whole lot of assumptions going into
- 14:30it. So we need to be prepared to adapt and refine that that portfolio over time. And I think the
- 14:34final thing I'd just say is that it's almost income isn't a it's not an asset class. I think we
- 14:40need to move away from that. We need to think of that as income is kind of an objective. And then
- 14:45once we've got that, we can be much, much clearer in how we build the portfolio. But those are those
- 14:48will be the three things. So I've rambled on a bit there, Sophie a bit. Yeah. And I think how sometimes
- 14:53I'd like to think of it, I like to do, like to try things in the spark context. And we've fresh off
- 14:58the back of the World Cup, um, start of the football season. So apologies to any, uh,
- 15:03non-football fans here, but here comes a football analogy. But, um, when you think of,
- 15:10um, the sort of total portfolio approach, if it's if you think of a total, total
- 15:17football, um, what you're looking for is a team that's, that's flexible. You're looking for a team
- 15:23that can adapt to changing conditions. You're looking for players that can can move around that
- 15:28aren't necessarily rigid to a particular position in the portfolio and portfolio in the team. Um,
- 15:35whereas the more traditional way may have been more of late. Or to have your big striker at the
- 15:39top who can, um, has has only a single role to play. So I think that when you put that into context of
- 15:46what Total Portfolio is looking for, it's you wanting just that, that ability to yet compete for
- 15:53the right places. And, um, make sure you have that flexibility to, to adapt. And change tactics
- 15:59mid-game. Yeah, absolutely. Bring on subs. It's competitive. Yeah, I think it works. I'm
- 16:06glad you both think so. I'll be googling FourFourTwo after this. Yeah, but could you give me
- 16:12a practical example of how it actually works in practice in the portfolio construction space? Yeah,
- 16:18sure. So on the I suppose on the DB theme. So a more sort of
- 16:24traditional thinking, um, from a liability hedging standpoint, um, the traditional question might have
- 16:30been what assets can I buy to match the benchmark that I'm measuring, um, my
- 16:37liabilities against. And for most pension schemes that it would likely have been buying a large
- 16:43proportion of UK government bonds. Whereas with a more total
- 16:50portfolio mindset, you're you're starting with, well, actually, what are we trying to achieve
- 16:55overall and what are the total risks that we're managing. As Ben's already alluded to. So once
- 17:02you start thinking from that perspective, um, you could end up with a portfolio that is in a
- 17:09totally different place to where you where you would naturally start. You might end up in the
- 17:13same place, but you've at least gone through the right challenges to to get there. So you you
- 17:20again, one thing that you've discussed on the podcast previously is just, um, UK government bonds
- 17:26aren't necessarily no risk or low risk. So it's something to that's once you bring that into
- 17:32consideration alongside the value of assets and that that can offer to achieve what you're
- 17:38looking for from your liability matching assets. Pulling that together, you you do likely end up in
- 17:44a different place versus where you would where you would be. And it's it's not about sorry. It's
- 17:50not about, um, sort of maximising the or the minimising the tracking
- 17:57error versus a benchmark and your actuarial basis. It's maximising the probability of achieving that,
- 18:03that outcome that you're looking for in the, in the longer term. Um. That's a good point. I think
- 18:08just thinking from a another example, maybe from a growth portfolio or a return seeking
- 18:14perspective, albeit given with gilt yields where they are, you could question whether that's a
- 18:18return seeking asset, but that's a topic for another, another time maybe, or not entirely. Um, but
- 18:24if we think about yeah, think about another asset. Let's, let's we talked about TPA not total
- 18:29portfolio approach not being a rigid framework. If people are following a very rigid strategic
- 18:33allocation framework that they've set a couple of years ago, and you get something like an idea,
- 18:38let's think of insurance linked securities. What I'm talking about here are effectively bonds like
- 18:44like corporate bonds where you get paid a premium like you would do with a bond, you get paid an
- 18:50interest payment, and then you get your money back at the end in a bond, if the company doesn't
- 18:54default, you get your money back in an insurance contract. If negative insurance event doesn't
- 18:59happen, perhaps an earthquake or a hurricane or whatever it might be. So from an income
- 19:04perspective, to me that looks very like corporate bond. It's something that's paying a regular
- 19:08income, and I get my principal back at the end. As long as the bad event doesn't happen, it's very
- 19:14diversifying because stock market crashes don't cause earthquakes, aside from, I guess, metaphorical
- 19:21ones. But if you've got a very rigid framework that you've set that puts things into certain
- 19:25buckets and something like this doesn't neatly fit into those buckets, then it gets excluded,
- 19:29Potentially. Whereas if you start from the perspective of what is my objective, I need to
- 19:34generate some income to achieve this mission. I've got assets that are competing for capital, so this
- 19:39is better than something else that's already in there. It can boot it out. And equally I can adapt
- 19:43to the portfolio over time, whether that's changing returns, whatever that might be. You maybe
- 19:48arrive at a different answer. I guess there's some. For some investors, a strategic asset allocation
- 19:53will be familiar and probably feel quite simple to an extent. And I guess one of the challenges I
- 20:00can see posed a total portfolio approach type mindset is this is more complicated. This is going
- 20:07to increase the complexity within the portfolio. I guess, could you speak to that? Is that is that
- 20:12true? Is that the case? I mean, I can certainly see that as a, as a viewpoint. Um, I mean, I think
- 20:19one of the things that the total portfolio approach at least starts with is making sure that
- 20:24when you're thinking of investments, you're looking for the best assets and you're making
- 20:27sure you're at least looking at a starting point across the full opportunity set. Um, and I think
- 20:34that's, that's a positive and something that could be a value additive to, to schemes, but that could
- 20:40then be seen. Yes, that could be more complex because you've got different ideas in. But I think
- 20:44that complexity shouldn't be assumed to, to add value. I think any new idea that comes into the
- 20:50portfolio needs to pass a burden of proof. And I think that that level of proof will be different
- 20:56for different schemes just because of their beliefs, the governance frameworks that they have
- 21:01in place. But I think the steps are important, and it's making sure that then
- 21:07any investment that you are making and wanting to make, it's able to prove is it improving the
- 21:14portfolio versus the objective that we're looking for, given all of that, that that context?
- 21:21I mean, equally on the other side of things, I think if you have a more of a static portfolio,
- 21:27it's unlikely that one manager, one asset class, one strategy over the longer term is going to
- 21:34always be the right place to be. And they're not going to be the sort of monopoly of good ideas as
- 21:39such. So, um, it just places that importance of actually being able to source
- 21:47good ideas, um, and find those attractive opportunities that fit within,
- 21:53within, um, client portfolios. Um, and I think that's one of the important things alongside then
- 22:00actually allocating to them and the sizing of positions. Um, so the sort of portfolio approach
- 22:05isn't necessarily it's not about being the most complex, it's about finding those best
- 22:10opportunities and combining them together to help give that confidence of achieving those outcomes.
- 22:17Um, given the the constraints and the context that we're working with for, for clients. And I
- 22:24mean, you can't end up, uh, You, kind of you kind of end up at an extremely simple portfolio.
- 22:31If credit spreads were higher than they were right now, you could load up and that would be
- 22:37that'd be great. I think it's just it's just being clear on. So I think one of the things that I mean
- 22:41is someone we used to work with, um, used to have a phrase which I've kind of probably both adopted
- 22:46as a mantra, which is as simple as possible but as complex as necessary. And I really like the way
- 22:53the kind of burden of proof point, I think. Yeah, it can't be complex for complexity sake. It has to
- 22:58really, if you're going to do something more complicated than a simple alternative, it has to
- 23:01be justified. But that doesn't mean you shouldn't do it clearly, because if you can achieve do
- 23:07something that is more aligned with achieving that ultimate objective minimises the risk of
- 23:12mission impairment, and you've got the governance capabilities set up to do it, then that's
- 23:17something we should challenge ourselves to think about whether we can. Yeah, that's really
- 23:21interesting because I think Like what you're saying, but it doesn't necessarily mean you're
- 23:26going to end up with a completely different portfolio. This could just be a tweaking around
- 23:30the edges or thinking about something new and fundamentally twisty. Beliefs and preferences
- 23:34would be driving all those discussions anyway. Yeah. So. So if trustees did want to adopt this way
- 23:41of thinking, what are the types of questions they should be asking themselves or their advisors
- 23:45when they're reviewing the portfolio? Yeah, I'm starting at risk of being the broken record, but I
- 23:52might as well be is that I do come back to that first. First question is just trying, and it can be
- 23:58difficult to answer it because there is a desire to keep be flexible, but having clarity on what
- 24:04you are looking to ultimately achieve, what is the purpose, and then be able to think about what risk
- 24:09is in that context. Very practically, I think is is really helpful. And then trying to be practical
- 24:14about risk. So one of the things when we've done it with a few few clients but is think about
- 24:18reverse stress testing. So in the old world we used to sort of get a starting point project
- 24:24forward and arrive at a future outcome, which you mentioned at the beginning. Many kind of DB
- 24:28schemes are kind of at that sort of future outcome. And so the big question trustee boards
- 24:32need to ask themselves or one of the big questions is what what's painful, what what's what
- 24:37could hurt us from here. Think about what that could be. Maybe if you're a well-funded DB scheme
- 24:43that could be a 10% funding that'll drop that tips you into deficit, ruins your surplus. Sharing
- 24:48plans requires company contributions. Think about what are the events that could cause that fall?
- 24:54Are they plausible? Get the history books open and then have a practical conversation about do I
- 24:59need to do anything differently result. And that's kind of to my mind, that's a really pure
- 25:02expression of that, that mission impairment point. There's a whole lot of I mean, you've probably
- 25:08again rambled on, but you've probably thought of the killer question in that in that time. Chris, I
- 25:12don't know. Yeah. I mean, I wouldn't necessarily call it a killer one. Um, the one might be it might
- 25:17be lucky if it's a knockout one, to be honest. Um, no, I think it comes to.
- 25:24The assets that you're holding and what role are they playing in the portfolio and are they
- 25:29pulling their weight? Um, and in the context of thinking of the, the sort
- 25:36of the income that it's offering, is that sufficiently then diversified across the sources
- 25:41of, um, of income and, and the borrowers that you're sort of dealing with? That's really helpful. Um, I
- 25:48think there's a lot of things that trustees do need to kind of work through here. But actually,
- 25:52when you think of it on that level, it's relatively simple questions and probably easy
- 25:57ones that you can revisit. One of the, I guess, one of the other key themes that comes out in the
- 26:02article is the framework that you've established. Um, Snapple named, uh, tilt rotator increase. We
- 26:09always love a three word framework in WDW and. Give them the name. Yeah. Exactly.
- 26:15Um, but that framework you go on to describe in the article how it can help trustees constantly
- 26:22kind of evolve and review the strategy over time. So just wondering if you could just outline that
- 26:28in more detail of how in practice, trustees can use a framework like that to review strategy in
- 26:34different market conditions? Yeah, sure. So, um, the tiltrotor increase or the, uh, the
- 26:40trifecta? Um, yeah, I think. Ride it all the time. Yeah, yeah it does. Communities in
- 26:47transfer market, etc. to to change and add players to the, to the system. So bringing that into the
- 26:53context of what that might mean from a, from an investment perspective, if you think of well from
- 26:57a, if I'm looking to sort of tilt it, that might be within asset class and change the sort of tactic
- 27:02rotate maybe meaning actually I want to change from one area of the market to another. It's
- 27:08something that we've seen done quite a bit across our client base recently, just linking to what Ben
- 27:14said earlier about, um, insurance linked securities. It's an area of fund. attractive particular time
- 27:19when traditional credit spreads have narrowed materially. And the final one on this
- 27:26of the increase side of things, it's making that one it's been able to and being ready to
- 27:33and having the flexibility. But it's been having the the framework in place to be able to to take
- 27:38advantage of opportunities in the market to, to increase positions if necessary. And that links to
- 27:45investment grade credit. Again, it's an area we've seen and taken advantage of over the last 5 or 6
- 27:51years when there has there have been spikes in credit spreads, whether that be, um, for example,
- 27:55during Covid or more more recently, um, and it's just being able to take advantage of that quickly
- 28:02to and and increase those positions. And you mentioned there about kind of taken advantage of,
- 28:07of market conditions or things happening, which obviously we know doesn't always neatly fall into
- 28:12a quarterly cycle of meetings. Um, so just thinking more practically, how can trustees be ready
- 28:19to take advantage of these market changes when they aren't happening at perfect time points? Yeah,
- 28:26I won't. I'll make a point of not repeating my kind of yeah, I haven't gone on doing a mission
- 28:31risk thing, but I think you it's very difficult to capture opportunities if you're starting from a
- 28:37blank sheet of paper all the time. So I think you've got to be very clear on what you're
- 28:40looking, what you're looking to do. And then you can set out the framework for how those decisions
- 28:45can be made and whether that is subgroups of trustees, whether that's delegation to certain
- 28:51entities or whatever that might be. But I think it's first of all, it's thinking about those
- 28:55objectives, thinking about that governance framework and not not starting from a blank sheet
- 28:59of paper every time. Because frankly, it's just, yeah, the world doesn't work to quarterly meeting
- 29:04cycles, does it? And I think that governance, that strength of governance is always an important
- 29:09thing that we come back to with any kind of conversation around strategy is that, um, well,
- 29:13we've had a really good conversation. So thank you both very much. But I just wanted to finish with
- 29:17one final question and maybe challenge you to stick to one sentence. But what
- 29:24mistake do you see investors most likely making when it comes when it comes to income investing?
- 29:30That was definitely a dig, wasn't it? I think it kind of just a lot. I think it was nothing at all.
- 29:38In two sentences and three I come back to, I stop thinking of the income as an asset class.
- 29:45Think of it as a requirement. And if you kind of take that mindset, you have a much broader
- 29:50perspective on how you can build that portfolio. And I think the portfolio would be built more
- 29:54effectively. Five sentences, maybe six. Um, I'll go for
- 30:01two. Uh, so mistaking a predictable income stream for a resilient one,
- 30:07um, I think you can have a highly predictable income stream that can fall still short of what
- 30:14you're trying to achieve. Definitely wasn't too. Well. Our listeners decided to comply with
- 30:21that question, but it comes back to, I guess, the objective, every asset having having a role and
- 30:26being able to adapt to market environment. So thank you both so much for the conversation. It's
- 30:32been really nice to have an excuse to do it in our hometown. So that's been really good. Awesome
- 30:37city I should say. Um, and thank you to our listeners for joining us today, and hopefully you
- 30:42can join us for another episode of Pensions Perspective Podcast, brought to you by WW. Thank
- 30:48you very much.
- 30:55Thanks for listening. This podcast is for informational purposes only and does not
- 31:00constitute financial advice. The views expressed by any hosts and guests are their own and may not
- 31:06reflect those of their employers or affiliated organisations. All content is protected by
- 31:12copyright.