Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / #Channel-Have games become too conservative
Transcript
- 0:00We're going to get the show started or what Well, I'm trying to get
- 0:02the bloody show started. Will you wait, I'm going to get myself.
- 0:06I don't believe it lays the issue, right? Are you going to shut
- 0:08up? Yeah? Go do it? Do it? Do the intro?
- 0:10Are you? Are you going to shut out? Just shut up part of
- 0:13the show. This isn't going to go No, of course it's not.
- 0:15I'm going to edit this out. I'm just going to start. I'm going
- 0:17to introduce the show now, all right, you're not going to interrupt me?
- 0:19Yeah? No, all right. So well, ladies and gentlemen,
- 0:24welcome to keep telling you you're such a twat. This is Hashtag Channel,
- 0:33a podcast about Discord with Ben and Steve. Well, actually, a hashtag
- 0:40means it's a channel. So here we are hashtag channel, and this is
- 0:50a special hashtag channel. Stephen, isn't it Tell the listeners why this is
- 0:55a special hashtag channel. Well, I'm in the blow of Kingdom in that.
- 0:59In it, I'm gonna go down, down down the chippy. You
- 1:03beat you all, go down the chippy, the chippy. You got the
- 1:06chippy? We do call it the chippy. Yeah, we're gonna go down
- 1:08the pub, have a couple of points, talk to a couple of birds,
- 1:12and then go to the chippy. Are you Are you in Australia?
- 1:17And then why if you have a take away and the Yeah we have ake
- 1:19away? Lock to go down to the Indian never takeaway, get me some
- 1:23chicken chicken massole. And it's accurate, isn't it. This is how not
- 1:27only unnecessary rhymes and puns in their beds. Yeah, but not only that,
- 1:36Steve. Look, look, you're gonna let me bloody speaks. It's
- 1:38a two person podcast. This not only that, Steve is you are in
- 1:44the country of my birth and I, Stephen, Are you in New York
- 1:49City? No, I'm not in New York City, the country, Stephen.
- 1:52I'm not from London. I'm not an insufferable asshole. I'm from real
- 1:56Britain and I'm currently sat in real America, Reno, Nevada. This is
- 2:02a five G for d First, exactly, I'm in the United ross the
- 2:08Atlantic. Yeah, you're in Britain. I'm probably within a mile of your
- 2:15king right now. Probably. So this is great, right because you're in
- 2:20Britain. Two days as we record before the election, the general election in
- 2:24the UK, and they changed the law last year, so I was able
- 2:29to vote. I hadn't been able to vote for years, right, So
- 2:30I registered to vote and I was going to vote by post. Guess what
- 2:35happens, Steve, m hm, how did you fuck it up this time?
- 2:39You got the ballot the ballot No, no, because they sent the
- 2:45ballot too later. I was already in the States when the ballot arrived through
- 2:47my postbox. So I don't get to vote again. So Rishie Sunak is
- 2:53going to lose by even that much more exactly, he's going to lose by
- 2:57one more so anyway, So and you're you're like a drink Independence Day by
- 3:01the way, exactly. This is my second year being in America on July
- 3:06the fourth. It's very exciting stuff. Yeah, you were there for the
- 3:07big debate. I was there for the big debate, though I didn't watch
- 3:12it. I was I was at a gaming convention, so I didn't watch
- 3:14it, but I heard it was a complete disaster, which was nice.
- 3:16Anyway. So you're in it. You're in Britain, Steve, what have
- 3:20you noticed. I've noticed there's like a lot of a lot of the neighborhoods
- 3:23have very colorful names. Right, So, okay, my office is in
- 3:29Soho, which I guess they ripped off from New York City. I had,
- 3:34Yeah, yeah, yeah, I had. I had drinks with a
- 3:37friend after work a former colleague in a neighborhood called Shoreditch. That that yeah,
- 3:42that's right, the most hipster part of London. Is it actually utterly
- 3:46insufferable? Yeah? Yeah, that's why I liked it so much. Okay,
- 3:51it makes sense. And I also noticed on on the on the map
- 3:55the famous Billingsgate market, and and I recalled that that the term billings Gate
- 4:03is actually a kind of term of art that has its origins in the vulgarities
- 4:09of the fish market. I looked it up. So the market is famous
- 4:14for its fishmongers, who are known for their rough and colorful speech. Right,
- 4:18billings Gate itself refers to course or vulgar language, and over time it's
- 4:26it's come to be associated with abusive or scurless language in general. I then
- 4:30looked up the word scurless just to make sure I have the right definition.
- 4:35Scurreless refers to something that is coarsely abusive, vulgar, or indecent. In
- 4:42language or expression. It often describes speech or writing that is intended to offend,
- 4:47slander, or insult someone. Then English, then it's not what I'm
- 4:53getting at. It's not what I'm getting at. What are you getting at?
- 4:55You're fucking You're fucking mister billings Gate from morning to the night. And
- 5:05this is not even in the news show. I can I can live with
- 5:09it. I can live with it. So anyway, I'm in I'm in
- 5:11Reno, Nevada, and it's really interesting because in the convention there were loads
- 5:15of people from California came up and we were just talking about the West and
- 5:17how the West is different and just just how so you you're a West Coast
- 5:24elite, East Coast elitist, and you basically don't have any space or anything,
- 5:29whereas the West it's just massively open. So as I stand, I'm
- 5:32looking out of the window towards the Sierra Mountains on the right and on the
- 5:36left just desert just extending to the horizon, and it's it's really interesting.
- 5:43Everyone here seems so firstly, very very chill and also very unspiky, and
- 5:50I realize my demeanor is very is very at odds with the sort of chilled
- 5:59demeanor of the peace people in the west. Right, the people in the
- 6:00West are just completely relaxed the whole time, whereas I I am spiky and
- 6:08annoyed, and when I when I do my usual thing about moaning about everything,
- 6:12people on the West Coast just just don't know how to deal with it,
- 6:15whereas people from the East Coast will go, yeah, absolutely, and
- 6:18then we can have a three hour conversation about moaning. You know what I
- 6:21mean? Yeah, I mean you and I probably have more in common than
- 6:25I do with anyone from the West Coast. I mean, the chillness of
- 6:29the of the West Coast people fucking infuriates me. Like I'm not even trying
- 6:33to be that hill. Like I feel like when I go there, it's
- 6:38it's a competition to see who can care the least about anything, and I
- 6:42don't. I don't have a chance. The beautiful place like nice enough people
- 6:46totally different like you. You know, by the way, you you can
- 6:50go out into that desert and like I don't know, the US Constitution says
- 6:55you can claim as much of that land as you want, as long as
- 6:57no one lives on it. You can start You're on a stage. Yeah,
- 7:00probably, Yeah, I think it's true. I mean, you can
- 7:02look it up, but no, you're you're you're absolutely right about this,
- 7:05and you haven't actually experienced firsthand the East Coaster yourself. You've had your entire
- 7:11experienced channels. I'm slowly becoming a West Coast American and I'm happy with it.
- 7:18I set up a being negative and cynical and you know, just moaning
- 7:23about everything. I wish I could have a bit of sang foir about the
- 7:26world, you know what I mean? Well, counterpoint, So what I
- 7:30enjoy about being in London versus Germany. Right, So we're all familiar with
- 7:35the famed sense of humor of the Germans, right, Right. So I
- 7:44come into the office this morning in London and there's a guy there who I
- 7:48recognized from some company event. He's like a high level of sales executive and
- 7:55his name's Simon. And there's another sales guy that I've been kind of chatting
- 8:00with recently and his name is also a Simon, and he came in later.
- 8:05I didn't realize that they're both. I didn't realize they're both based in
- 8:07London, and I definitely didn't know that one of the simon's reports to the
- 8:13other one. So I had already met the boss Simon when I came in.
- 8:18He came in first, and we had a bit of banter, a
- 8:22little bit of a chat, and then the other Simon comes in, and
- 8:26I think second Simon is like, is like French. First Simon is very
- 8:30British. He's like, yeah, I don't know, like my idea of
- 8:33some stereotypical middle aged English bloke, and so like, the second Simon comes
- 8:39in, Yeah, totally, totally. When the second Simon comes in,
- 8:41I say to the first Simon, so do you just require that everyone who
- 8:45reports to you have your name so you don't have to bother memorizing them?
- 8:50And he's like, some people say it's about ego. I think it's just
- 8:52efficient and that's what I'm looking for at work. Wait, this is the
- 8:58thing. You say that to a German and that will be no offense to
- 9:00the Germans who are listening to this. But they'll say, what do you
- 9:03mean there is only one person who reports to me whose name is Simon,
- 9:05as you've just met that. Just because one person is called Simon, that
- 9:09does not mean all of them are called Simon. Why would you say something
- 9:11sore patently absurd. It's the likelihood of everyone being called Simon in a group.
- 9:16It's very, very low. It's almost impossible that would be the case.
- 9:20I don't understand what you're saying to me, you know what I mean,
- 9:22fair to see as a humor in this situation or any situation. And
- 9:28by the way, the explanation would go on for that long and you would
- 9:31have to sit there and listen to it. What's really interesting is I expected
- 9:35more people to be wowed by the fact that I'm English and be impressed by
- 9:41it. Really, it is a real indication at how unimportant my country is.
- 9:46That no one really gave a shit that I was English. You know
- 9:50what I mean, No one cared one iota. I'm not sure it really
- 9:54computes for them, you don't think. I don't think so. I would
- 9:58guess that if you've got in your city, you're more likely to meet people
- 10:01who are interested, because like they're they're sort of maybe more worldly. I
- 10:05know that sounds very judgmental, more likely to Yeah, I know, they're
- 10:11more likely to have been to the UK, and they would let you know
- 10:13about it immediately. You tell people that you're British like I went to London
- 10:18once I saw a big bent or even worse. Like like me, I
- 10:22did a study abroad in London, UCL nineteen ninety nine. Loved it.
- 10:26I love the West End, I love it Covent Garden. It's really interesting
- 10:31though, because you know, everyone was so nice and what was really great.
- 10:35And I was speaking to Kathleen Mercury, So there's all this there's always
- 10:39this thing, right that there's all this thing that Americans don't leave America.
- 10:43But Kathleen made a very good point. She's driving, she's driving to gen
- 10:48Con from Reno, So she's driving from Reno to Indianapolis, and she's making
- 10:52a couple of stops along the way, and she said, the thing is,
- 10:54she said, the thing is, though, I mean, America don't
- 10:58leave the country. But the point is, if you drive across the country,
- 11:01you could well have traveled through five different planets, let alone countries,
- 11:07you know what I mean. So I guess there's that feeling that in America
- 11:09there's so much to explore, there's so much opportunity to disappear, and there's
- 11:15so much opportunity to see different things that people in Europe you have to cross
- 11:20into different countries to do it right. Yeah, and I have also made
- 11:24this argument before when people criticize Americans for not having seen more of the world.
- 11:28I mean, first of all, yes, huge country. This might
- 11:31explain why whatever nine percent of us have passports or whatever it is. But
- 11:37also we have no vacation time. I mean, I'm German, I'm German
- 11:41by choice, right, I've got thirty days holiday and you know national holidays,
- 11:46generous allowance for sickly other forms of leave I can take advantage of.
- 11:50It's great. Most Americans don't have that, and in fact, many have
- 11:56to work multiple jobs just to be able to survive in that fucking hell whole
- 12:00the country. No disrespect to my fellow Americans and the idea that they're going
- 12:05to go on like a European vacation for like multiple weeks at a time.
- 12:09I mean, it's far away, You've got to leave your family, it's
- 12:11expensive, it's like unfamiliar, especially for people who aren't used to crossing national
- 12:18borders on a regular basis. I can see it on both sides. I
- 12:22understand why people criticize Americans for not being worldlier than they are, especially given
- 12:28the importance of America in the world. At the same time, one has
- 12:33to have like empathy for the average American because not everyone can be a globe
- 12:37trotting dickhead like me, right, And it's fascinating that. What's really interesting
- 12:43is I was speaking to a lot of people who are in the game industry
- 12:46over the weekend, and the gaming industry is essentially a freelance industry, even
- 12:50if you own a publishing company, right, And so these people don't have
- 12:56those constraints in the same way, so they can and also they can couple
- 13:03business trips with going to Europe because gaming is such an international industry, and
- 13:09so a lot of gaming people I met are very much sort of worldly and
- 13:16traveled, and they go to Germany and they go to the UK Games Expo
- 13:18and all of that sort of stuff, and that seems you know, I'm
- 13:22sure there are certain protections that you don't get being a freelancer in America,
- 13:26but also you get out of that. I mean, as far as I
- 13:31can see it, in Germany, you don't want to be a freelancer.
- 13:33Really being having a proper contract is just much more advantageous in so many ways,
- 13:39especially because you get loads of holiday time right, Whereas in America maybe
- 13:46you'd think about being a freelancer just so you're not confined having five days a
- 13:50year where you can you know, do something you know. I don't think
- 13:56the German system is really well designed or like up for like marching to the
- 14:01beat of your own drummer. You know, no, if you do what
- 14:07everybody else is doing, you are well taken care of freelancing in Germany as
- 14:13possible. But the people I know who do it make it sound like it's
- 14:16a real pain in the ass, Like this system just doesn't understand it.
- 14:20It doesn't know how to account for it. You're constantly having to like start
- 14:22and stop your health insurance. I believe it should be accommodated better than it
- 14:26is. It just isn't. Well. The point is as well, So
- 14:30what happened in the two thousands is that you had a center left government,
- 14:35and often the center left in the last twenty years have been the ones to
- 14:39liberalize the economy and take away workers right, and so what happened was is
- 14:43they made employing freelancers for companies much much easier and much and it is much
- 14:50much cheaper. But they didn't change the conditions for the freelancers themselves. So
- 14:56the freelancers themselves who are working are still bound to the weird sort of German
- 15:01system, not understanding what they do. And yet the companies and so teaching
- 15:09language teaching is what I'm experienced in. It's almost impossible to get a contract
- 15:13now as a language teacher. You have to be a freelancer. But and
- 15:18this is the fucking terrible thing. If you work for a company like Burlitz,
- 15:22you get minimum wage as a language teacher, and the costs of health
- 15:28insurance, pension insurance and all of this come directly out of your minimum wage
- 15:33job. And by the way, it's zero contracts. They can tell you
- 15:37at the beginning of the week, oh, we've got no work for you,
- 15:39right, and so and so the system has become very liberalized in one
- 15:43way and completely unreformed in the other. And all that happens is it benefits
- 15:48the company owners and doesn't benefit the workers. And so, if you right,
- 15:54it's total exploitation. Anyway, on that stave, you've been talking too
- 15:58long, and we'll move on to the meat of the podcast. After altogether
- 16:03too much consultation with the greatest minds in the world of topics we present.
- 16:10This is all right. So the question this week this month, Stevie,
- 16:18is are we doing this every week? Now? Yeah, we're doing it.
- 16:22We're doing one every week. It's des really gonna happen, fucking cracking
- 16:25the whip on me. I go to the States, I go to no
- 16:30matter where I am, you find me and make me record shit. So
- 16:33I've written with the pearl clutching over the stripper game and the default theme of
- 16:36most games being stultifyingly cute is the conservative mindset of the gaming public holding games
- 16:41back from exploring ideas that extend beyond cats? Is gaming two conformists? Do
- 16:45we shun those of divergent views? Am I making all this shit up?
- 16:49So? I guess it's essentially a thematic question rather than mechanical question. And
- 16:56I think I'll get to mechanics at some point because someone has made a comment.
- 16:59But what what do you think by and large? Is gaming respectable in
- 17:04a sort of Victorian manner? Good question, if I may say, good
- 17:11question. There are a couple of different questions in there, all at the
- 17:15same time. I'm not sure which one to address first. I think that
- 17:22there is a tendency in the gaming world as a sort of like function of
- 17:30the increasing capitalist takeover of the gaming world to veer toward safe themes, safe
- 17:38subjects, doing what already works, copying prior art, continuing like series of
- 17:48things that have proven themselves in the marketplace. I guess one shouldn't be surprised
- 17:52by that. You and I especially you. I mean, you're the first
- 17:56person I've ever met who referred to board games art. I don't know if
- 18:00you're the first person to do it, but you you you really like you
- 18:03really lean, you really lean into this idea. It had never occurred to
- 18:07me before talking to you about it. I mean, it had never occurred
- 18:10to me to like think this much about board games in general. Anyway,
- 18:14if we if if it's a form of art worthy of the name, then
- 18:18they we should expect them to take on less conservative, uh more, more
- 18:26controversial subjects, explore areas not yet explored. I mean, there are there
- 18:30are games that do this. Maybe you could review briefly what's going on with
- 18:36the Stripper game. Though this is like an attempt at a riskae theme that
- 18:40was then canceled. Well, so it's very fast, it's interesting something it's
- 18:45called night shift and it's a game about strippers on Kickstarter, and it's designed
- 18:48by a stripper. Because we live in an age where the art doesn't matter.
- 18:52The person who creates the art is the fundamental thing. So actually,
- 18:56just because a lot of people's arguments on this, well it's designed by a
- 19:00stripper, so it's fine, which is the most moronic argument I've ever heard.
- 19:03But you had basically, and this is the kind of thing which is
- 19:08interesting. I think you had people both on the left and the right condemning
- 19:11it kind of for different reasons. One said it was exploitative of women.
- 19:15The other said that, you know, it's sinful and it's Unchristian and all
- 19:19of this sort of stuff, and also it's non board gaming. But I
- 19:22was I'm staying with Johnny Pack at the moment, so we were talking about
- 19:25this, and he I think, I think there are three sort of strands
- 19:30to this sort of board game conservatism, which I think definitely exists. I
- 19:34think, firstly Johnny came up with this, and I think it's right,
- 19:38is that games are things you learn as a child, and so the act
- 19:45of playing is often an escape into childhood to a place where taxes and rent
- 19:53and mortality don't exist. And so there's this the feeling that if you bring
- 20:00this sort of adult nature into gaming, so somehow sullying something that was perfect.
- 20:07There is and I think what it is is a resistance against the real
- 20:11world intruding into something that is a place of sort of pure escapism, and
- 20:15escapism not in any theme in board games, but escapism into your childhood where
- 20:21life was easier. So I think that's one thing. And then and then
- 20:26what you were talking about, they are commercial art forms and so and they
- 20:33are blindingly commercial art forms, and so there is a sense that if you
- 20:40rock the boat, you're taking a gamble on your game making any money.
- 20:45And board game companies have no margins, and you know, there are very
- 20:51few board game companies out there. I think that can last a big failure
- 20:56in publishing a game and survive or at least not be incredibly constrained. And
- 21:03then I think that there is also there is also this political dimension which people
- 21:10on both sides of the spectrum are sort of crouching against adult themes for different
- 21:15reasons. And I think I think it's because and this is this is very
- 21:22internet based. I don't think it's political. I think it's more social media,
- 21:26which is sort of even though people on the left and there are people
- 21:30on the left of the right the act in exactly the same way. It's
- 21:32essentially a symptom of social media. And this is there is a glee in
- 21:37accusing people of being something terrible because there is a reflected social Q doss that
- 21:45bounces back onto you if you can point out that someone's a bad person,
- 21:48and so all of the bigger problem than just no, no, sure,
- 21:53but if you if you look at these things, if you put all these
- 21:56three, these three things together, when you're when you're making a game,
- 22:02you think, and it comes back to money, right, If you're making
- 22:07a game, you're thinking, am I prepared at all to have any of
- 22:11this fucking hassle? M? And am I prepared to have any of this
- 22:17fucking hassle because it might sink my company? And so and so the nature
- 22:21of this makes gaming inherently thematically conservative, I think, and you've seen.
- 22:27And the thing is what's so funny, it's both the left and the right
- 22:32are attacking night shift, and both the left and the right are being censorious,
- 22:37and both the left and the right think that they're on the side of
- 22:41justice. And I mean it's you know, the right talking a lot about
- 22:47how the left cultail free speech. And I don't think that's wrong, but
- 22:51the idea that the people who ban books are complaining about free speech is highly
- 22:56ironic, right. I mean, on the on the topic of games representing
- 23:03some kind of escape into childhood, I mean, how does this explain like
- 23:07all war games? How does it explain world in flames? My only counter
- 23:12argument to myself would be, like middle aged men simulating World War two is
- 23:18essentially regression to little boys playing with army soldiers. So you listen to history
- 23:26podcasts. I listened to history podcasts, right. There is an element of
- 23:33huge escapism in being into history because you're dealing with an age in which you
- 23:37didn't live, right, and often they're talking about things that are exciting but
- 23:42terrible, a lot of wars, a lot of battles, and so and
- 23:45so you're The anxiety you will feel listening to a podcast about Joe Biden in
- 23:52the debate is completely removed if you're listening to history, right, because that's
- 23:59gone, that's somewhere else, that is, that is another place where you
- 24:03can live, that you can for an hour be transported away from your current
- 24:07life and its current stresses. And so wargames history being a history buff is
- 24:11that to a large degree, I think, and and wargames are an extension
- 24:15of that. No, I mean it's a it's a pretty good argument.
- 24:19So and yet we're left with like some contradiction in which either they don't count
- 24:26or it's okay to play as the Germans in World War two but not as
- 24:33a prostitute or or whatever, or or or someone or for me to point
- 24:38out hypocrisy, right, So no, I think. And Johnny was saying
- 24:44to this this to me, asked me the other night, he said,
- 24:47how do wargames get away with it? How come if someone does something in
- 24:52a board game that's not a war game, it gets loads of grief,
- 24:55And yet you're allowed, you're allowed to murder loads of people in wargames.
- 24:59How do they get away? And I think it's just basically the narrowness of
- 25:04well do they do they get away with it? Do they get away with
- 25:08it? I mean sometimes war games here here, here's where CD hunter is
- 25:15gonna is gonna correct me. What what is the size of the war games
- 25:18industries specifically? Is it not dominated by like a few niche publishers who have
- 25:25painstakingly built up an audience of devoted followers over the years. I mean,
- 25:30I think the P five hundred system, for example, that GMT does is
- 25:33brilliant. They don't need to cater to the larger market. They don't need
- 25:37to do like games about uh, you know, kittens and robots. Yeah,
- 25:44they can. They can pitch. I mean, I mean mostly I
- 25:48guess what they do is war games. But they can pitch like these very
- 25:51interesting, historically controversial counterinsurgency games. I think they they really do like engage
- 25:56with interesting uh subject matter and because people want them. Yeah yeah, And
- 26:03if people people want them, they support them. And I think this is
- 26:06where the art is happening. Perhaps here and maybe like some independent game designers
- 26:11who also like Splatter we're always talking about, who also have a following,
- 26:15they don't need to to respond to the demands of the market. But like
- 26:18the larger commercial space, maybe is what's that issue here? Not these like
- 26:22sort of edges of creativity. But you know, you always have these edges
- 26:26of creativity, even like the art world itself is like enormously commercial. And
- 26:32then there are and then there are people doing actually interesting art, actually pushing
- 26:36forward the discourse, actually who have something to say, you know, on
- 26:41the edges, on the margins. Eventually they may get co opted and sell
- 26:45out as the expression goes, but you know, the cycle continues to renew
- 26:49itself, we hope. So Knits amidst Trees says to the idea that our
- 26:56game is two conservative likely. But but personally, mechanics are greater than themes.
- 27:02So I'm not bothered by generic or cute themes. I'm not clutching my
- 27:06pearls over the strip of game. But equally it doesn't appeal and I wouldn't
- 27:07spend money of it. So safe themes equal more profit. And I think
- 27:11when people talk about this in me Too, I'm guilty of this, they
- 27:18fail to understand the central truth about games. Right now, that would be
- 27:22a good game, me too, the board game. Right So, the
- 27:27central truth about games is that they are a mechanical art form. And the
- 27:33art and the way they affect the brain and the way they affect the body
- 27:37with release of you know, adrenaline or cortisol or all that sort of stuff,
- 27:42is about the way mechanics interact with each other. Theme is almost inconsequential
- 27:51in many ways, and so especially a lot of the games people say are
- 27:56super thematic are just you know, you rolled dice. That doesn't strike me
- 28:00as particularly thematic. I think if you get the theme and the mechanisms together,
- 28:03then that is obviously better. But mechanics are so vital, and mechanics
- 28:08in and of themselves are a political Are a controversial right or no? A
- 28:21controversial? Yes? Is that a word I've just If it isn't, I've
- 28:29just made it up. You're you're, you're just down the road currently from
- 28:32the globe. I can theologize if Shakespeare can theologize. So yeah, it
- 28:40is a controversial words. Me me, me, I'm the world's biggest toy.
- 28:45Me me, me, don't say words that make I don't understand me,
- 28:49me me, carry on, You're an a? You're you're an a?
- 28:57What the hell are we talking about? I want to have it both
- 29:02ways. I mean, I'm really on board with the idea that the artistry
- 29:07is in the mechanics, But I think it's wrong to say that theme doesn't
- 29:11matter. Like all of the Lord of the Rings games that we play,
- 29:15theme does matter, right, We would enjoy them much less if it were
- 29:18a different theme. I don't know that it would like change the nature of
- 29:23the game, but like our experience of the work of art has to have
- 29:27something to do with our appreciation of it or our interaction with it, right,
- 29:34I guess when we say theme doesn't matter, we're talking about these like
- 29:40euro games that are all named after some German village, where it's like completely
- 29:45arbitrary. I still find them incredibly charming, And I don't know what do
- 29:51we say about it. Is it simply a patina that's meant to attract a
- 29:55certain type of audience. Like if you took one of these typical like midweight
- 30:00euro games, uh, you know, designed by Uve Rosenberg, named after
- 30:06the town he grew up in, and you've replaced it with like kittens and
- 30:08unicorns and shit like, I'm probably not gonna be immediately drawn to it on
- 30:15the shelf. I've been programmed by the industry to go for like the fucking
- 30:19you know, I don't want I was gonna say, boring looking box to
- 30:22me is not a boring looking box, but uh, there there is an
- 30:26esthetic, and the aesthetic somehow determines the category of game buyer. We end
- 30:32up becoming and they they clearly know who they're targeting, when, when they
- 30:37when they do this stuff. So we can strip it all away and we
- 30:40can play completely abstract games with no theme. I think it's much less fun.
- 30:45Do we want to say that the the art has nothing to do with
- 30:52the like sorry, the art the art as in like the assets, like
- 30:55the the illustrations or whatever like, has nothing to do with the artistry of
- 30:57the game. I think it's a topic we're digging into. I mean,
- 31:02with like, you know, the average large box. If you tell aserta
- 31:04game illustrated by eno toool be the same game if it wasn't illustrated by eenotool,
- 31:11there must be some value there. At the same time, I can't
- 31:15quite I can't quite explain what it is and how these two things interact.
- 31:21I do agree that we're like theme and mechanics connect or engage. That's really
- 31:29special, that's magical, maybe it's almost a bonus, But like we're games
- 31:33where it doesn't really do that. I mean, are they flawed in some
- 31:37way? Does it just really not matter? I'm not sure. The more
- 31:41we talk about it over the years, I'm not sure where I come down,
- 31:42but I definitely would not like give up on them. And you know,
- 31:47it's very easy to criticize the theme, and we do all the time
- 31:48and say that this game is essentially themeless. For me, it's more of
- 31:52an observation. It's not necessarily like a denunciation, right, absolutely, So
- 31:57Cinisad says, profit of an artistry only takes you so far. Eventually the
- 32:01business side of things starts going against the development of the art form. Hardly
- 32:05a new thing, but game designers will keep pushing the art form forward,
- 32:07that's for sure. Will they be able to make a living with their worker,
- 32:10that's a different question entirely. And so I remember speaking to a guy
- 32:15about five or six years ago and he was talking about he did event games
- 32:20in London, and he was talking to me and it never really occurred to
- 32:23me at the time, but he was saying, you know, you have
- 32:27government grants for novelists, for theater makers, for fine artists. Why are
- 32:31there no government grants for board games. Why aren't there people who were making
- 32:38board games where they can just make a game where profit is not the motivation,
- 32:45right? And I think what would be interesting in that if you look
- 32:47at other art forms, what you see in other art forms. Is those
- 32:52who aren't propelled by profit motivations make the most exciting avante guards weird stuff that
- 33:00might actually not function particularly well, but it is then the synthesis of their
- 33:08ideas into a more familiar structure that makes incredibly valuable resonant art. I think
- 33:17of the nouvelle vague coming into the you know, the American cinema of the
- 33:23seventies for instance, right, and a lot of the experimental filmmakers Kenneth Anger
- 33:29or something from the sixties techniques that he was using being ameliorated and taken into
- 33:35more mainstream art forms. And I think I think board games. I think
- 33:38board games are art. I think board games can say something about the world.
- 33:45And I think state funding for people to create stuff is a vital way
- 33:51to generate art, right or am I just being a comie neuville varve louvelva
- 34:00glove. We said a new wave Where I come from, you knows salt
- 34:07of the earth. I think there's probably no government funding for board games other
- 34:14than the obvious reasons, because it doesn't seem like an art forum that is
- 34:19in any danger of dying. I mean, it doesn't seem like it requires
- 34:22support, Right, it's doing fine in the commercial space on its own,
- 34:27whereas well, No, not neither the novels, right, where's their government
- 34:35funding for novels? Well, you know, people get bursaries and things like
- 34:38this in the UK to go and and writers in residence and all of that
- 34:44sort of stuff from from the government. Sure, I mean, I don't
- 34:49I don't know what is available in the UK. Probably there's no comparable grant
- 34:54of any kind coming from from anywhere government or nonprofit support board game design.
- 35:05It'd be interesting to know if there was such a thing. But I'm I'm
- 35:07guessing. I'm guessing though that it seems like it's doing so well in the
- 35:10commercial space there's no need for Also, what would be what would be the
- 35:15goal to get a game published like pub pub published by whom like if if
- 35:20someone like there are there are writers and residencies. But if this ends up
- 35:24in a novel being published, I guess that novel still has to be picked
- 35:27up by an actual publisher who then I guess, like to publish it right
- 35:31and distribute it. I guess, like I guess like organs that are sort
- 35:37of like the Cambridge University Press or something like that. Right, organs that
- 35:42are there specifically to publish things that are that are if not express if if
- 35:46the if the intention is not expressly non commercial, is not commercial in the
- 35:52same way that more mainstream stuff is. Right, you're not you're you know.
- 35:59Do academic philosophers are not getting published by Penguin, you know, or
- 36:07until at least fifty years later when they've become classical books, and even then
- 36:10probably right deep academic philosophers may only have like a few hundred copies of their
- 36:16book published, and then they're purchased by university libraries and they're filed away and
- 36:23never read. So it's like you can design a see one at low cost
- 36:28and then like so the goal of funding would be would be what exactly like
- 36:31wide distribution or what No, the goal of funding would be allowed the artists
- 36:37the time and energy to create simply what they wanted, as opposed to something
- 36:43that are constrained by the needs of commerciality. Right. So, if you
- 36:46look, if you look at game designers who are pitching to publishers, Publishers
- 36:52may sign a game and they will change a game, and the reasons they
- 36:54will change a game are to make it more viable in the market. If
- 36:59your kickstar game and there are a load of cliches and hoops that you have
- 37:04to jump through to make the game viable for the market, I think I
- 37:07think RPGs, but I think I think RPG's do this. But the fundamental
- 37:14thing is, I think you have a lot of people who do this as
- 37:17amateurs. I think the gift of professionalism is vital to being truly great at
- 37:25your artful I think it's undeniable if you could spend your entire time thinking about
- 37:30it rather than having to suspend it because you have to you have to consider
- 37:36paying the rent. That kind of freedom allows you to be incredibly creative,
- 37:39to have the creative fetters taken off, right, I mean, I'm I'm
- 37:44I'm on board in principle. I wonder how it would work. So plenty
- 37:47of people seem to be perfectly successful board game designers in their spare time.
- 37:52It's always possible to do like print in plays, or to put something on
- 37:55board game arena or table topier or whatever it is. H what is it
- 38:00called table table top tabletop table top board game arena. Yeah, So the
- 38:07only thing that you don't get in these formats is like actual physical publication and
- 38:14wide distribution. But maybe there is maybe there's some kind of middle ground.
- 38:20I I don't know what it would be. There's like, there's a good
- 38:23concept here, it's probably worth workshopping it further. And in a hundred years
- 38:29maybe maybe we'll see like university presses publishing board games, or like cultural societies
- 38:36for board games supporting, you know, emerging talent. I think it's possible.
- 38:40Maybe we have to accept that this industry is really still in its infancy.
- 38:46So Marcus the Dog Shepherd says, I do think that the mainstream within
- 38:51the hobby board gaming brackets, which is a weird concept but let's run with
- 38:54it, is getting safer and overall more boring. That's why we see nature
- 38:59kitch, anthropomorphic animals, and ips everywhere. But I think the last point
- 39:04might be more of a cause than perl clutching on X. There's definitely a
- 39:07marvelization of board gaming going on. We've entered the period of blockbuster titles such
- 39:12as TTR Legacy. Luckily, off the beaten path of the hobby is very
- 39:14healthy and probably more creative and diverse than ever. In a way, this
- 39:19is just a sign of natural naturation and my fundamental criticism of that. I
- 39:24think it's broadly right. But Okay, I'm going to ask you a question,
- 39:29and I want you to answer honestly. Do you think board gaming,
- 39:37especially in the creative side, is dominated by one political side of the spectrum
- 39:43as opposed to the other board gaming as as like what as what kind of
- 39:50phenomenon publishing the Yeah, the people who make the board games. It's really
- 39:58hard to say, because it's such a there's so much diversity in board games.
- 40:02You can probably find just about any political attitude represented somewhere, like the
- 40:10larger commercial Are you talking amongst gamers or are you talking amongst games? I
- 40:19mean, I think both both. Actually, I think there are plenty of
- 40:22people who are conservative who are publishing board games, plenty of people who are
- 40:29liberal. The zeit guy certainly seems to be quite quite what is the correct
- 40:35word? I mean, I don't think like left liberal progressive necessarily is what
- 40:39we're talking about. Like, I think there's a strong element of identity politics
- 40:44that is impacting the mainstream of board gaming, like it's impacting the mainstream of
- 40:49everything else. And it is inspired a bit of a bandwagon effect to that
- 40:52extent, which may also be causing the retreat into safer topics. But this
- 40:59isn't It's not like the whole board game world. It's just maybe the most
- 41:01visible part of it. I don't know, what do you think? So
- 41:05I'm very much of the view. So I think we live in an age
- 41:10that is culturally left wing, and I think that there are people within that
- 41:17side of the debate that are censorious, and there are people within that side
- 41:22of debate that do not like to see things that they disagree with be made
- 41:30public. And so we have seen many situations. Just the recent time,
- 41:36the guy who made the board game won a competition and it was about manifest
- 41:40destiny, and people complained, and so he said, I'll change the thing.
- 41:46This is just the latest example of people losing their shit over stuff on
- 41:52the internet, probably in many ways on the basis of never having actually interacted
- 42:00with the artful themselves. And so the problem is whether this is true or
- 42:05whether this is not. There is a perception that this is true to the
- 42:09point where there are certain grifts like cultural consulting that have become prevalent that if
- 42:19you're doing a game, if you're doing a game that is set in a
- 42:22country that is not yours, and actually this is not true. If you're
- 42:27doing a game that is set in a country that is not yours, that
- 42:30is not Europe with the United States, then there is this feeling that you
- 42:34have to have a name of that person from the country in your rule book
- 42:37otherwise you'll get leapt on on Twitter whether they really did much or not right.
- 42:44And I'm very much of the view that we should be able to create
- 42:45what we wish. And I'm very much of the view also on the other
- 42:50hand, that if you are creating something that is outside of your immediate culture,
- 42:54that you should be judicious, You should do your research, you should
- 42:59respect that other culture, well the elements of that other culture that are warranting
- 43:02of respect. And I guess what respecting that other culture means is reflecting it
- 43:08realistically. So I think I think the left, I think the rights have
- 43:12a problem with stereotyping other cultures. I think the left have a problem with
- 43:17looking at other cultures through rose tinted spectacles. I think they're they're they're equally
- 43:22as pernicious. But yeah, I think what I think, I go ahead,
- 43:27So regardless of whether this is true or not, whether whether whether the
- 43:30left is being hugely censorious or not, whether this is true or not,
- 43:36publishers think it is, and so, and this is the problem of a
- 43:40commercialized art form. And so you have seen over the last ten years a
- 43:45retreat into nature cats and there are some eurogames coming out, but you know,
- 43:53and then people get up in arms about, oh, you're just making
- 43:55another game about Europe. Well at the same time, so you can't appropriate
- 43:59other it's a complete hypocrisy. But the point is you've seen a retreat intoconservatively.
- 44:05And I don't mean concern right, I don't When I say conservatism,
- 44:07I don't mean conservatism politically. I mean conservatism in a sense of, Okay,
- 44:14this is going to be unchallenged, Yeah, unchallenging, uncontroversial, and
- 44:19we have to do this otherwise otherwise dickheads on Twitter are going to complain.
- 44:24And so I think that's an issue, and I think I think it's always
- 44:30been an issue throughout society. If you look at the Victorian Times, it
- 44:35similar things would happening. It's just the rapidity with which it happens results in
- 44:42a reflex from people whose lives and livelihoods are on this a reflex that is
- 44:49very reactive, very quick, and fundamentally going to stop them thinking about doing
- 44:57things they might otherwise do. Right. First of all, censorious top recent
- 45:01nickname, Thank you for the callback. Second, I like to think that
- 45:07we're in a very like a yes and situation because the board game space is
- 45:13just like inflating every year, more and more games are coming out, and
- 45:17it's not as if some areas are being neglected, like the growth in this
- 45:27sort of like the commercialization. Maybe it's a question is it coming at the
- 45:31expense of games exploring the kinds of ideas we're interested in, Like, is
- 45:37it crowding out you know, the themes of your I'm not sure, so
- 45:44I would guess that it's not, and we can kind of ignore. I
- 45:49mean, I tend to like just ignore the shit I don't care about.
- 45:52But I would accept as a counter argument if you think that the sort of
- 46:00your narrative of the moment is creating a chilling effect, that means that like
- 46:05a lot of games that might have been published that we could have enjoyed aren't
- 46:10because they need to be made more palatable or they wouldn't be accepted, or
- 46:15they would receive the same treatment as what is it called night walker night Shift?
- 46:24I like night Walker better, actually, Christian Noodle. Christian Noodle's palla
- 46:31says, I'm not sure I understand the concepts of conservative and held back correctly
- 46:36in the original question. But I think the main problem is time. Movies
- 46:38have been studied as an art form for a long time, and as a
- 46:42result, there have been a decent number of directors and writers who could tackle
- 46:45edgy, serious themes and do a good job of it. Still, most
- 46:47of what flashes across the screen is about fast cars and boy meets girl and
- 46:52animals who do martial arts and shit, because that's where mediocrity makes money.
- 46:57Does that hold back film as an art form in your opinion? So?
- 47:00I think this is interesting. I think what we've seen in cinema is the
- 47:07destruction of the mid budget film, right because you can spend two hundred million
- 47:17on a Marvel movie with loads of special effects, and that's almost or at
- 47:21least it was almost a sure thing. You can make a film for two
- 47:27million quids and kind of if it doesn't make any money, that's not an
- 47:30issue. It's where you're spending thirty or forty million quid on an historical drama
- 47:35or a you know, a quote unquote serious movie that has serious production values
- 47:40that if it fails, that's a lot of money to lose, right,
- 47:45And I think I think what you see actually, I think board games,
- 47:49interestingly pretty much all fall within that medium budget, and so they're very conservative
- 47:55about it. RPGs tend to be the sort of super low budget staff,
- 48:00right, and so it doesn't matter if you've and it's only a PDF.
- 48:05Mostor things aren't getting published physically now, and video games tend to be the
- 48:08big triple A things. And I think all and I think part of the
- 48:12reason is is there is this sense that the potential losses, the potential losses
- 48:17of writing an RPG, a ten page indie RPG and putting it up on
- 48:25drive through and no one buying it, well, you know it's spent maybe
- 48:30you spent a week or two weeks writing it, but fundamentally it doesn't end
- 48:32your life. The thing is with board games, it's just clear that I've
- 48:37been speaking to a lot of people from small publishers over the weekend, and
- 48:42you know, they're making those mid budget films, they're making games that they
- 48:45want to sell between three thy and twenty thousand. Right, this isn't wingspan,
- 48:52this isn't to get a ride legacy, and most of these people that's
- 48:55okay, But if it fails, it's the end of the And so I
- 49:00don't and we've been to basically we've been beating about the same point. I
- 49:04think. I don't think it's political. I don't think it's the left blockbuster
- 49:10driven industry like so many others in the arts right, And so I And
- 49:16although I like to I like to bitch and moan about the culture wars and
- 49:20things, I think fundamentally the fundamental problem is is that it's essentially so bloody
- 49:25risky, especially when especially when freight costs are so expensive since the pandemic.
- 49:31And also you can't get away from the fact that board games are an industry
- 49:36that is totally dependent upon China. Without China, board games don't exist.
- 49:43I was speaking to I was speaking to a to a publisher this weekend,
- 49:46and I said, what if China went into Taiwan and we had the same
- 49:51sort of attitude with China as we currently do with Russia, what would happen
- 49:53to gaming? And he just said, it's dead, It's gone, Gaming's
- 49:57gone. You might have card games, and that would be it, because
- 50:00also we've become completely addicted to beautiful components and wonderful product design. And the
- 50:07interesting thing is Ludo fact the German manufacturer basically can't do that anymore. And
- 50:12so we've completely sort of shipped out the manufacturing of board games to China.
- 50:19And so it has to be conservative by its very nature, right, because
- 50:22otherwise people lose their jobs and fundamentally lose that you know what I mean.
- 50:27Yeah, people make the same argument about film, right, Like films can
- 50:30no longer simply appeal to American audiences. They have to appeal to global audiences,
- 50:35and that means a Chinese audience. And you can't not only can you
- 50:39not release films that are offensive to China, but you are trying to appeal
- 50:47to a sort of like I don't know, you create palatable material for a
- 50:53world market. That like this is why, like Marvel films are popular everywhere,
- 51:00right, this sort of like science fiction action comic book movies will find
- 51:06fundamentally inoffensive no matter what country. Yeah, yeah, some people. The
- 51:13thing is like they're always going to be the yeah butts in the world.
- 51:15So we might say the last great era of filmmaking was the nineteen nineties,
- 51:20like the last great era of the kind of film that you're talking about,
- 51:22right, But then someone can come along and say, like what about Alexander
- 51:27Payne, Like oh okay, so rules, yeah, yeah, yeah exactly,
- 51:32Like they're still there. They're still there, they're just not maybe capturing
- 51:37like as much mind share as they used to. Right, So, anyway,
- 51:42that was interesting, Stave, wasn't it. Do you think you said
- 51:45anything anything that would get canceled? I don't know, what do you think?
- 51:49Well, I was recording before I get the record, buttons so definitely.
- 51:55In an act of willful competition, we present our so here we ask
- 52:02Stevie poster of the week? Come on now, did did Uli ask a
- 52:08question? No? OUI didn't ask it to think so because he posted something
- 52:14in like the general channel. Yeah, but he could be poster of the
- 52:19month. But he can't be posted with a month, Steve. If he
- 52:22doesn't contribute to the current topic, can he? He can't. He doesn't
- 52:27follow instructions. Ben, I can't steer his behavior any more than you can.
- 52:32But it's Uli, this is true. He hasn't been poster of the
- 52:38month in ages because he hasn't posted. That's why. All right, I'm
- 52:45giving it to Marcus the Dog Shepherd because I like the nickname excellent. So,
- 52:50Marcus the Dog Shepherd, you're not supposed to say that, by the
- 52:52way, You're supposed to say because of your amazing, great post. I
- 52:57liked it a lot. It was all about games in that So Marcus the
- 53:00Dog Shepherd, you are our poster of the months. Who that was our
- 53:12all right, Stevie, It's it's late there in the UK, and I'm
- 53:15going to go outside of the desert. So we got to get through this
- 53:19intro. How'd you join the discord? Okay, so in order to join
- 53:22the top board game discord on the Internet, no exaggeration, you need to
- 53:30visit five G four D dot com. I haven't had to say this in
- 53:34a while. I'll just repeat it in case you know we have new listeners.
- 53:38You do not spell out the numbers five and four. It's the number
- 53:45five G, the number four D, five games for Doomsday, five G
- 53:52for D dot com, not dot ac dot UK, not dog e E.
- 54:00Yeah. Should be r G though, shouldn't it? Because we are
- 54:06such a August intellectual facade, It's not dot dot, dot biz, not
- 54:14dot family, dot email, not dot any of this shows dot com.
- 54:19It's the fucking O G dot thing five G for D dot com. You
- 54:23think Ben is fucking around? He didn't get a dot He didn't. He
- 54:29didn't get like a dot mill. I mean you're not military. Obviously you
- 54:32couldn't get a dot million if you wanted one. Did you see what I'm
- 54:37saying? You have a top level domain. Ben is a top level domain,
- 54:40and if you want to be part of a top level discord, you
- 54:44go to that top level domain. Five G for D dot com. Click
- 54:47the pinned post at the top of that page. You're gonna You're gonna be
- 54:52there immediately. It's like a fucking wormhole. Two the most engaging, scintillating
- 54:59board game conver stations on the Internet. Lots of lulls. You're all welcome.
- 55:04Just jump right in. Don't let CD hunter and famed board game designer
- 55:08Isaac shallv intimidate you. Fight back. This is your board if you're listening
- 55:14to this right now, this is your board game community, and we want
- 55:16to see you there. Me and Ben want to see you there. Posting
- 55:21responses to the hashtag channel questions of the month, getting nicknames, doing dands,
- 55:30all that. Get in there, now do it? Steve demands it
- 55:35and yeah, well so it was great. It's great, it's perfect.
- 55:39It's perfect. So go go to iTunes rate us five stars. And how
- 55:44do they support the show, Stevie. You can support the show by going
- 55:49to patreon dot com slash five G for D. We're very consistent with this
- 55:52five G for D thing. And you can become a patron for one euro
- 55:58a month, not not not pound dollar, ruble, shekel, Australian dollar,
- 56:04New Zealand dollars, Singapore dollar, no, no varieties of dollar at
- 56:07all. Euro the European currency. For one euro a month, you can
- 56:12get a nickname and access to all of the bonus material Yeah, loads of
- 56:19bonus materials, loads of battle reports. Do you get the battle reports for
- 56:22one one? Wait? For one year a month? Do you get the
- 56:25battle reports? I think no, No, that's five years a month one
- 56:30euro. You get access to AD free, AD free interviews. This is
- 56:37a new feature. You get the movie show when we record it. You
- 56:40get all kinds of other ship. Five. The five is the sweet spot.
- 56:45Five is where you're going to get the battle reports, which is where
- 56:47you get to hear more of me exactly, and and and and various board
- 56:52game celebrities who join us in the in the battle reports as they have done.
- 56:55So might if you're interested five G for D swag please go to serve
- 57:01people dot com slash Yeah, five G for D Now, just got to
- 57:08some people dot com and then you'll find the drop down menu and you can
- 57:12get it there. Yeah, you can get yourself a hashtag more Steve in
- 57:15the feed t shirt. We're really running the sub left. If there's some
- 57:20left, they might have sold out at this point. Yeah, they're probably
- 57:22they're probably none left. Check now get one while you can. If there's
- 57:27like one left, we're not printing them again. This is it. And
- 57:32anyway, just to wrap up, Just to wrap up, i'd like to
- 57:36say, yeah, I think that's about it. That's every right. Yeah,
- 57:39So I'd just like to say thank you to everyone and contributed. If
- 57:43you want to contribute, you can join the discorder, you can be featured
- 57:45in the next episode. And it just leaves me to say say goodbye Steve.
- 57:51Before I say goodbye Steve, I want everyone to understand we're not taking
- 57:55the piss when we do this end of episode plugging. Ben's in the US,
- 58:02I'm in the UK. We really love doing this. We love it
- 58:06enough that we're willing to take time out from opposite sides of the planet to
- 58:10record for all of you, and your support really matters. It really makes
- 58:15a difference. It really keeps us motivated to do this. I don't think
- 58:17we would be as motivated if we didn't know people were listening, if we
- 58:21didn't have people in the discord, commenting, chatting, giving us feedback.
- 58:24It really means a lot, So please consider doing it. If you're already
- 58:28doing it, please do more and with that goodbye. Steve would like to
- 58:40you this show wouldn't exist, so really you're to blame, so thank you
- 58:45for listening and oil up your ears for the next hashtag channels the Fundstone to
- 59:04Find, Stone to Find Stand to Finish