Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Project Management of Your NCUA Documents of Resolution (DOR)
Transcript
- 0:03Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save
- 0:24time and money, visit marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:34Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:38Today's topic of the day of the podcast is going to be document
- 0:42resolutions and project management.
- 0:45I'm excited that I've got two of my most frequent guests, Steve Farr ar
- 0:51and Todd Miller, formerly of NCUA and currently members of my team.
- 0:55How are you guys doing today?
- 0:56Good and a little bit of an introduction in case somebody is hearing with
- 1:04flying colors for the first time.
- 1:06Steve, could you give a little bit of your background at NCUA
- 1:10before you change teams and started helping credit unions more directly?
- 1:15Glad to.
- 1:17I always break my career down into two parts.
- 1:19The part is a examiner related, which was half of my career, about 15 years.
- 1:24And then the last 15 years was in the central office and various assignments,
- 1:29but my time as an examiner allowed me to become, really well versed in.
- 1:34The regulations in the Federal Credit Union Act and credit union
- 1:37operations, and I enjoyed that.
- 1:39And as an examiner, I was involved in multiple administrative actions as a PCO,
- 1:45worked with the ones facing trouble.
- 1:48And then I was able to help the agency and worked in conservatorships.
- 1:54Throughout the nation and all that helps with my background and help me
- 1:58when I went into the central office and worked in risk management there.
- 2:04And in that, we work on a lot of guidance that's issued to the industry and wrote
- 2:10a number of rules and regulations.
- 2:14And then even after I got out of in and see way and.
- 2:19was retired.
- 2:20One of my first jobs out of retirement was the CFO at a large conservatorship.
- 2:25So that was my first venture with being on the other side and having
- 2:30to be faced with NCOA giving us a significant amount of actions in the
- 2:34sense of a DOR for a conservatorship.
- 2:37So that helps with this discussion today.
- 2:40Yeah, it certainly does.
- 2:41And when we talk, you, the three of us talk about conservatorships a lot, and
- 2:45of course, conservatorship is the most harsh administrative action NCUA can take.
- 2:50That's when they remove the board and NCUA serves as both regulator.
- 2:54Three roles, regulator, insurer, and they represent the interests of the members.
- 2:58It's a draconian action.
- 3:01Saved for the most challenging cases and we have a separate
- 3:04podcast out there on that topic.
- 3:06All right, Todd, a little bit of your background.
- 3:08I spent 34 years with NCOA.
- 3:11I can break it up into three different chunks.
- 3:13One part as an examiner problem case officer for about the first
- 3:18third of my career, the middle 10 years from 2000 to 2010.
- 3:24I was a capital market specialist spent the last year at Westcore there
- 3:29as a capital market specialist after NCOA placed them in conservatorship.
- 3:33And then from 2010 to the end of my career in 2021 I was the director of
- 3:39special actions in the Western region supervising problem case officers
- 3:43and capital market specialists.
- 3:45I did have some regional lending specialists under my purview
- 3:49for a period of time as well.
- 3:51Was also involved in a lot of conservatorships.
- 3:54Probably two of my bright points at NCOA is two of the conservatorships I
- 3:57managed were returned to the members and those guardians are still there today.
- 4:01So those are always enjoyable exercises when you can continue
- 4:05service in a situation.
- 4:08Like that.
- 4:09So all in all an enjoyable 34 years where I got to see a little bit of everything.
- 4:14Yeah, it was a great journey.
- 4:15We all had, we dealt with a lot of problems at NCUA and Steve, pivoting
- 4:19back to you on, that, that experience you had, you spent 30 some odd years at NCUA.
- 4:25Now you're doing what we do now, but you had that role as a conservatorship.
- 4:28CFO, if you will, where you were getting into a giving you document resolutions
- 4:34that had a lot of tentacles to it.
- 4:35And a lot of tentacles mean that you probably need to have some sort of
- 4:39project management wrapped around it.
- 4:41So what are your thoughts as it relates to document resolutions and resolving
- 4:48them in a way that makes everybody happy?
- 4:52I'm going to start with kind of a discussion of a trend that we're seeing
- 4:55that was different from when Todd and I were working with our troubled
- 4:59credit unions and that we are seeing extremely lengthy documents of resolution
- 5:06containing upwards of 30 action items.
- 5:12Of and some of them would have parts underneath them.
- 5:15So they're extremely long.
- 5:18And, because we always had that we would prioritize and say, these are
- 5:21the things we really need to do 1st to make sure we can keep the doors open.
- 5:25And I know there's more of the I'll cover later.
- 5:27And I thought maybe I'd put the question out for Todd and that.
- 5:30Is this is the reason that these doors are containing the, everything that
- 5:36they find that needs to be fixed, is it because of the system that's being used?
- 5:40The merit system or the exam system?
- 5:42Do you think that's contributing to why the long door item, doors?
- 5:49Possibly, but it shouldn't because prior to merit, NCOA had internal tracking
- 5:54for doors, but not findings under merit.
- 5:57Now they have reporting on both doors and findings.
- 6:01So merit might contribute to a little bit of it.
- 6:05What I think is probably a bigger contributor to it is lack of experience
- 6:11and problem resolution with examiners.
- 6:14As you get more experience, you get more discerning about
- 6:17what is the most critical.
- 6:19And you.
- 6:20Over time come to understand that cartings have finite resources.
- 6:25So you can only address so many things at once.
- 6:28And I think just the younger generation of examiners that hasn't
- 6:33went through a recession before.
- 6:35They haven't learned that lesson that where cratings can only do so much.
- 6:39And I think they just experience wise, they don't know how to prioritize,
- 6:44which one of these are these really important and which ones are not.
- 6:48So they treat everything as being important, not understanding
- 6:53that's an impediment to problem resolution, not an aid to it.
- 6:58That's my take on it.
- 6:59Some of it might be merit, but I think more it's just examiners
- 7:03haven't had to write a lot of during periods of stable time periods.
- 7:07So they have just overreacted.
- 7:12The other thing we're seeing is, in the NSPM, it says indoors,
- 7:15you should use the credit union's language for corrective action and
- 7:19negotiate with that, them about that.
- 7:22And we see that not happening anymore either, where the examiners
- 7:25are just dictating and they're not having that conversation with
- 7:29management or understanding that part of their requirement is to
- 7:34negotiate this corrective action.
- 7:36But you're right, some of these doors, when you see a 30 item door and they have
- 7:42to do them all in six months and they're all things that take hundreds of hours
- 7:46and lots of dollars, the examiners are just giving a credit and lengthy door and
- 7:52they're almost guarantee and failure in the process, which doesn't help anyone
- 7:58because it's going to make their job harder and the credit is job harder.
- 8:02And it just makes both sides frustrated and it's just not.
- 8:08The way to approach things You know, I don't know.
- 8:12I think it's maybe a combination of a lot of different factors
- 8:15and merit is probably part of it.
- 8:17But you would think merit would have actually reduced it because
- 8:20they can track findings now when they couldn't in the past.
- 8:23A couple thoughts there that popped into my mind that I wrote down is,
- 8:27yeah, they should be negotiable, but with the new approach.
- 8:32It's not so new anymore.
- 8:34Four or five years old approach where all reports are reviewed by a higher
- 8:38level that has complicated things.
- 8:40And if something gets reviewed in the office, we're seeing the
- 8:43office drop something in that was a document resolution that
- 8:46surprises the credit union.
- 8:48And oh, by the way, when they drop that in there and they link it to
- 8:51the dates that they established when they might have given them the
- 8:54draft, all of a sudden, the days have passed, which can be very frustrating.
- 8:58Another thing that popped into my mind, Steve, you mentioned, 3840
- 9:02document resolutions and in 1 report.
- 9:06Two things that jumped into my head.
- 9:07I remember giving one of our clients some guidance saying, hey, why
- 9:10don't you ask into a in their mind what the priorities here are here.
- 9:14We've suggested that in many instances, but in one instance the examiner got.
- 9:20obnoxiously frustrated that they were asking for that information,
- 9:24which isn't how it should be.
- 9:25If you're going to tell me I have to do 40 things, you should tell me a little
- 9:28bit of which ones are more important.
- 9:30And then lastly, phone numbers are seven digits long for a reason.
- 9:35The optimal size of a board or a group is seven for a reason, because it
- 9:40gets too unwieldy if it gets bigger.
- 9:42And we're, there's a frustration that I'm seeing when the reports
- 9:47get so long, or if everything's a priority, nothing's a report priority.
- 9:51All right, back to you, Steve on that or anything else on this topic.
- 9:54We'll pull it back right, to the topic, of that project management and we'll
- 9:58start with kind of everything that we seem to deal with in our clients that
- 10:02are expressing some frustration and sue a, it, it's that communication,
- 10:06communication, communication, the same as real estate location, location,
- 10:11location, and we're seeing a, a variety of these communications being
- 10:18more difficult than they should be.
- 10:21And the only thing you can do is control what's within your, Stephen Covey would
- 10:26say, within your circle of influence.
- 10:29So you need to make the efforts.
- 10:32That you can make in trying to communicate with your examiner and make sure number
- 10:36one, you clearly understand what they're asking for in that document of resolution
- 10:42and, those dates are particularly useful.
- 10:47And then, even as we speak, we've looked at a report that we got
- 10:51last night and what are we here?
- 10:5222nd of August.
- 10:54And it was a really big request for turning basically the
- 10:58operation around from unprofitable for a long time to profitable.
- 11:03And they want it completed by the end of September.
- 11:05It's I don't think you could do a real quality one and get it through your
- 11:10board in that sort of a time frame.
- 11:12So that's the thing where they start to have to communicate to the examiner
- 11:16and say, this is an item that would be approved by the board of directors.
- 11:19The board, we have to prepare it.
- 11:21We have to get it to the board.
- 11:22They have to review it and all that.
- 11:24That can't be done in that time frame.
- 11:27So the communication is the most important thing that you to get through.
- 11:31Now, I'm going to open that up for you guys to talk about that communication.
- 11:38Todd, any thoughts on what Steve said there about communication as it relates
- 11:41to the door and project management?
- 11:45It keeps us busy.
- 11:48Our failures in communication keep us busy.
- 11:51It seems to be a common pattern with Folks that call us up and hire us is quite often
- 11:57there's been breakdowns in communication.
- 11:59There's a lot of other things going on too, but that seems to be involved in that
- 12:05exam process with many of our clients.
- 12:08I think you hit the nail on the head, Mark.
- 12:10In their quality assurance program is creating some of this because the examiner
- 12:15and credit unions reach some set of agreements and then the quality control
- 12:19process changes that so credit unions end up surprised that doesn't help anyone.
- 12:25I also think some of this is COVID related, you know they spent two
- 12:29years essentially working off site.
- 12:31So you had things that weren't looked at.
- 12:34So they're getting surprises during exams because examiners haven't looked
- 12:37at a specific area in detail in a couple years now that they're back on site.
- 12:42And some of it's the credit union side too because credit unions now and many of
- 12:46them, their executives are off site too.
- 12:49So there's roadblocks being put up.
- 12:52A well, I wouldn't call them roadblocks.
- 12:53Let's call them hurdles that you have to get over on both sides, so we just
- 12:58had a shift in culture During the whole pandemic and after that and that kind of
- 13:04creates some of this too where You know good communication takes effort on both
- 13:09sides and we see breakdowns sometimes on the crediting side sometimes on the
- 13:14examiner side so that contributes to some of it but doors, this is a sticky point.
- 13:21Examiners, a lot of times, and we talked about it earlier in the podcast they
- 13:24don't have the experience they used to.
- 13:27So a lot of times when examiners are writing these doors, they have
- 13:30no idea what the cost of these is.
- 13:32And the cost is real.
- 13:33Some of these doors, when they take hundreds of hours and involve
- 13:37third parties, you're looking at costs that hit 100, 000, half
- 13:41a million dollars really easy.
- 13:43And then, they're complaining about crediting's profitability,
- 13:46but then they're putting a burden on them that, okay, you just cost
- 13:49them another five basis points of expenses by what you're requiring.
- 13:54And.
- 13:54Outside of really experienced people or problem case officers, and even in
- 13:58many cases, then I don't think examiners understand the cost implications of
- 14:05what they're asking credit unions to do.
- 14:08That's a great point.
- 14:09That's a great point.
- 14:10And then
- 14:13the document resolution can become incongruent, right?
- 14:16Because we want you to improve your profitability, but we
- 14:19want you to do these 10 things.
- 14:20And five of those things might require going outside and hiring An expert, a
- 14:25consultant, and oh, by the way, we want it done by September, which gives you
- 14:29one board meeting and you still have to go out and find the consultant or even
- 14:33if they give them three, four months, sometimes, consultants, everybody
- 14:37has a how do you get fully staffed issue, credit unions, banks, schools,
- 14:42police office, police officers, the military, nobody can be fully staffed.
- 14:48And or has challenged being fully staffed.
- 14:51And then you've got new staff.
- 14:53So you have all these challenges.
- 14:54And then, out of thin air, they drop a date on 4, 10, 12, 15 requirements that
- 15:01many times are untenable and incongruent.
- 15:07Very good.
- 15:07Let's move it to the kind of next thing that we've done.
- 15:09What we see is the initial start process of now you get you've done got your exam.
- 15:14You communicated with the examiner.
- 15:17You have you understand what that door requires those action items.
- 15:22And and the timeframes for doing them, now you have to deal with it
- 15:25internally is the project management.
- 15:28And it, it's the same as you would have any other process for project management.
- 15:34And you may have people on your staff that have taken the courses and have
- 15:38project management certifications.
- 15:41I've found that doesn't necessarily make them a really good project manager.
- 15:45And there's different systems of doing it, but, now you have to deal
- 15:48with that internal communication.
- 15:50That you're going to have to deal with.
- 15:52And, it always starts with, here's the door.
- 15:54Here's the primary point person on that.
- 15:58Yeah.
- 15:58Here's the resources that we're going to need on that, in tracking the
- 16:03timeframe, I would leave it up to individuals as to how they like to
- 16:08document their project management system.
- 16:12But in that 1, another important thing needs to be that internal reporting.
- 16:15That's going to take place.
- 16:16How is that going to be?
- 16:17Or is there a community?
- 16:18Committee that's going to meet, bi weekly, monthly based on, volume and thing.
- 16:23But, the strategy needs to be put in place and thought through on those items.
- 16:27So it really is that basic project management thing, but it
- 16:31needs to be, established early on and communicated internally.
- 16:37I have thoughts on that.
- 16:39I have a couple things written down and they just reinforce
- 16:42things that Steve said.
- 16:44The first one is transparency in this reporting process.
- 16:48Whatever tools you use, where you're at in this project needs to be
- 16:54transparent across your management team and with your board of
- 16:58directors and supervisory committee.
- 17:01One, it demonstrates that, there's commitment to correcting the issues.
- 17:06Within it another thing I wrote down here.
- 17:10There needs to be staff accountability in this project management.
- 17:13Steve mentioned it right up front.
- 17:16But without that accountability assigned to specific people,
- 17:19projects have a way of falling apart.
- 17:22The thing that thinking about accountability, think about thinking
- 17:26about internal reporting, the light bulb that goes on in my head is NC ways.
- 17:34Focus on corporate governance, right?
- 17:37That reporting the progress to the board.
- 17:42So the board's aware and that will allow there to be appropriate.
- 17:48Should help improve the fact that there is appropriate accountability
- 17:51and it should make NCOA a little bit more comfortable that.
- 17:57Everybody's taking it serious if it's being tracked and watched and
- 18:01then also watched by the board.
- 18:03It's on that like I said, and then it emphasizes that commitment to
- 18:08correct most credit unions Not most but a lot of the credit unions
- 18:12that have documents of resolution.
- 18:14They're either a code three or a code four So if they're of any size
- 18:18their examiner are gathering up their financial reports and board minutes
- 18:22every month And it makes it a lot easier to With your examiner communications
- 18:28if they can see every month, here's what you're doing or once a quarter.
- 18:32Here's what you're doing to address these items in the document or resolution.
- 18:37We talked a little bit about prioritization before we started
- 18:40in the project management.
- 18:42It's good to set those priorities within your project management plan.
- 18:45If you got three or four door items or a number of findings include the
- 18:49findings to but prioritize these
- 18:54this.
- 18:54Some don't, but some and hours involved in get because sometimes it's si
- 19:04it's interesting.
- 19:05You I think we were on a call with a client where I might have brought this
- 19:09up, but when I was at NCUA and at the time Mark McWaters was the chairman, we
- 19:15would be doing a budget briefing with him, and it was like OPM did X, and
- 19:19it's going to cost us this much more, and Congress did this, and we have to
- 19:23do this, and it's going to cost us this much more, and he said, and we have a
- 19:27chart that says, here's the increases to the budget because other government
- 19:31agencies made us do something, We put it in the budget in maybe 2018, 2019,
- 19:38and every year since then it's there.
- 19:41It's something that gets purported.
- 19:42But, every action has a cost, more so now than yesterday.
- 19:47And it's something to be cognizant of.
- 19:51Steve, what else we got?
- 19:52What's next on project management?
- 19:54That was a, pretty much says it isn't difficult, but it's just has to be
- 19:58properly managed and resourced itself.
- 20:03Very good.
- 20:03Very good thing.
- 20:06And that's the cost benefit of this reporting.
- 20:09Because we do see doors that end up where you can reach a point where you're
- 20:15reporting on projects and you're not getting anything done because you're
- 20:19spending all your time reporting.
- 20:21Be careful to balance out what you put in those reports, you do need to
- 20:25be transparent and let people know.
- 20:28throughout the organization, be informed where you're at.
- 20:31But there is a point where sometimes you can spend more time reporting
- 20:34than you do fixing the problem, and you want to avoid that issue too.
- 20:39Summary reports are good, and I think disparity is when you do, especially
- 20:44if you have one of these big long items where you have 10 or 20 things that you
- 20:49have to fix in a short period of time, you have to be careful that you don't
- 20:53spend all your time reporting and End up not getting actual progress made because
- 21:00reporting has taken up all your time and we have seen situations where that has
- 21:06happened, where that reporting becomes such a burden that you're not actually
- 21:10getting any corrective action done.
- 21:12Those are great.
- 21:13Yeah.
- 21:13Thoughts on that, Steve.
- 21:18Total agreement.
- 21:19Total agreement.
- 21:20I've got two, I've got two reporting things that popped into my mind when
- 21:25you said that number one was dating ourselves here, 20 2000 Y2K, and we had
- 21:32to report to the examiner had to report to the credit union, had to report to
- 21:37the examiner had to report to the S.
- 21:39E.
- 21:39The S.
- 21:39E.
- 21:39had to report.
- 21:41To the office.
- 21:41The office had to report to the central office and the central office
- 21:44had to report to Washington, DC.
- 21:47If every system was red, yellow, or green, and we broke our back, making sure that
- 21:53we reported that two, three times a day, and thank God there weren't any problems
- 21:58because there was no time to do anything.
- 22:00Other than report that everybody was green or yellow or there weren't any reds.
- 22:07The other reporting comment is a guy near and dear to all of our hearts.
- 22:12Bob Blattner in the old region six said to me one time there was a report that
- 22:17he had to send into the office that he thought was so dumb that he changed the
- 22:21last sentence that said, if anybody ever reads this report, please give me a call.
- 22:26Nobody ever called.
- 22:32Very good.
- 22:33That has not a lot to do with project management, anytime you can think
- 22:38about Bob Blattner it's a good day.
- 22:40Thanks guys.
- 22:41I appreciate your time today.
- 22:43All right.
- 22:44Take care.
- 22:45Good luck.
- 22:47Good luck and listeners.
- 22:48I want to thank you as always for listening.
- 22:50This is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.
- 22:59Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 23:03your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 23:07of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 23:11If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 23:14out our services at marktreichel.
- 23:17com.