Latest / Gaming The System - The Feminist Gaming Podcast / Bye Bye BioWare (Episode 300!!!)
Transcript
- 0:00Jem: Tonight we're marking the end of an era.
- 0:03Jem: Last Wednesday, the 21st of October, Electronic Arts announced that it is closing BioWare.
- 0:11Jem: After 31 years, the studio is shutting its doors, and the next Mass Effect game, which was first teased back in 2020, has been canceled
- 0:26Matt he/him: It's just, it's so sad.
- 0:29Matt he/him: It's so sad just having that taken away.
- 0:33Matt he/him: And it- it's different if the studio had gone bankrupt after Mass Effect or whatever, and then it's going,"Oh, I want-- I wonder what could have been?" Whereas this, it literally, it just bled out obviously over such a long time.
- 1:05Speaker 2: Hello and welcome back to another episode of Gaming the System, the podcast where three intersectional feminists examine gaming and games through a feminist lens.
- 1:16Speaker 2: Today.
- 1:16Speaker 2: I'm your host, I'm Gem, and I'm joined by Matt.
- 1:22Speaker 2: So before we get started, if you want to support us, you can subscribe to our patron at patron.com/gaming the system for some exclusive content.
- 1:33Speaker 2: Or you can send us a one-off donation via PayPal to our email address.
- 1:38Speaker 2: We are gaming the system@gmail.com.
- 1:43Jem: Tonight we're marking the end of an era.
- 1:46Jem: Last Wednesday, the 21st of October, Electronic Arts announced that it is closing BioWare.
- 1:55Jem: the Canadian studio was behind Baldur's Gate, Knights of the Old Republic, Mass Effect, and Dragon Age.
- 2:03Jem: After 31 years, the studio is shutting its doors, and the next Mass Effect game, which was first teased back in 2020, has been canceled the Canadian studio was behind Baldur's Gate, Knights of the Old Republic, Mass Effect, and Dragon Age.
- 2:27Jem: After 31 years, the studio is shutting its doors, and the next Mass Effect game, which was first teased back in 2020, has been canceled BioWare's own goodbye was short, and quite raw.
- 2:47Jem: For more than 30 years, BioWare has been more than a studio.
- 2:52Jem: It has been a home for storytellers, developers, and the players who brought our worlds to life.
- 3:01Jem: Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic, Dragon Age, Mass Effect, Anthem.
- 3:08Jem: Now, after more than three decades of shared adventures, BioWare is closing and early development on the next Mass Effect project is ending.
- 3:19Jem: There is nothing easy about writing those words.
- 3:22Jem: Our focus right now is on our incredibly talented team, who put their hearts into these games, and supporting one another through this transition.
- 3:34Jem: what generations of BioWare built together is something to celebrate and remember.
- 3:39Jem: These games became so much more because you played them and debated your choices, fell in love with the characters, and made these worlds your own.
- 3:49Jem: From all of us at BioWare, thank you for being the most meaningful part of our story the closure is part of a wider shakeup at EA.
- 3:59Jem: there's around 400 jobs going in total.
- 4:02Jem: 50 of them are going at BioWare.
- 4:05Jem: And it, this is their first big, shift since, going private in August when the Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund, Silver Lake, and Affinity Partners completed a$55 billion buyout.
- 4:23Matt he/him: Jared Kushner.
- 4:24Matt he/him: Don't forget Jared Kushner
- 4:26Jem: Exactly, Jared Kushner.
- 4:28Jem: And about 20 billion of that was actually borrowed money, and we did talk about it at the time.
- 4:36Jem: We talked about our concerns over what that would mean for EA going forward, and I think, you know, we'll get onto it, but I'm, I suspect we're not that surprised that this is one of the earlier casualties.
- 4:51Jem: But going back to talk a little bit more about BioWare, and why it's important and why this matters.
- 4:58Jem: BioWare was founded in 1995 and it was bought in 2007 by EA.
- 5:05Jem: and was one of the stalwarts of narrative and story-driven RPGs, so it really kinda brought all of that into the gaming world.
- 5:21Jem: They created companions that we actually cared about.
- 5:24Jem: They gave us the opportunity to make choices about what our characters were doing and, that influenced the stories.
- 5:31Jem: Crucially, the romances weren't only written from the perspective or for the gaze of straight men.
- 5:40Jem: They started bringing in, same-sex relationship options and, the ability to be a female lead character in Mass Effect was huge at the time, and companions were, trans and non-binary, and this is all happening within triple A games.
- 6:01Jem: That was one of the really fantastic things that BioWare brought to the gaming world.
- 6:06Jem: However, and we will talk about this again in more detail but, it hasn't actually been that easy for them over the last 10 years.
- 6:14Jem: Mass Effect was mocked at launch in 2017 because it was really buggy.
- 6:21Jem: There was weird stuff going on with the, facial animations and, It ended up having to be basically built in 18 months, which is why it wasn't the standard that it should have been.
- 6:35Jem: Anthem in 2019 was, a live service flop.
- 6:40Jem: It was buggy and, again, without a clear vision.
- 6:44Jem: Dragon Age: The Veilguard, we have talked about that quite a lot.
- 6:49Jem: I know, Matt, you have, strong feelings about what a nightmare that game was and how disappointing it was.
- 6:57Jem: So yeah, it is fair to say that BioWare had not had a very good, final decade and, you know, that has led some to argue that, it was too woke and that's why it's failed.
- 7:11Jem: When I heard the news about BioWare, I was like,"Right, we have to talk about this," because it's a big deal.
- 7:17Jem: It matters because of what BioWare represented, because of the BioWare story and what that means for the broader industry, and it also matters because of what it says about EA is going next.
- 7:32Jem: So firstly, I just want to get your initial thoughts, your initial reaction to this news, Matt.
- 7:41Matt he/him: I was surprised that they are just shutting shop and canceling a project entirely because it's so rare that we find out about big projects that have gone away.
- 7:56Matt he/him: And they almost always end up being projects.
- 8:00Matt he/him: You're going,"That sounds awesome.
- 8:03Matt he/him: That would be incredibly popular and successful," and they just throw that away, burn it to the ground.
- 8:14Matt he/him: And I would rather, I think, a really shit game come out that they've made, and then after that happens, they can course correct or just keep on digging themselves down into a hole.
- 8:31Matt he/him: So like with the Suicide Squad Kill Justice League absolutely ruined Rocksteady.
- 8:40Matt he/him: 'Cause it was just...
- 8:42Matt he/him: It was an absolute piece of shit that they made for entirely the wrong reasons.
- 8:47Matt he/him: And then the second it came out, they went,"Oh no, we're going, we're going back to Batman now.
- 8:52Matt he/him: Don't worry about this.
- 8:52Matt he/him: This is just a little blip on the radar.
- 8:54Matt he/him: We're going back to Batman now.
- 8:56Matt he/him: We're just gonna just pretend that this didn't happen." And they might not end up surviving it as a successful studio, but, I don't think they're owned by, like, a corp...
- 9:13Matt he/him: They haven't been sold for a massive$20 billion loan, so they're in a better place than BioWare has been.
- 9:22Matt he/him: But this coming up is just going,"Oh yeah, I'm not surprised." of course this would...
- 9:28Matt he/him: This is a thing that would happen based on the acquisition by Saudi Arabia and Jared Kushner.
- 9:37Matt he/him: It's always gonna be,"Oh, what's the worst thing they could do?" they're never gonna...
- 9:42Matt he/him: never going to accidentally come up with a really good thing'cause it's always gonna be,"How do we get all the money?
- 9:49Matt he/him: We've already got all the money.
- 9:51Matt he/him: How do we get the rest of all the money?" So Dragon Age and Mass Effect have never been a massive part of my gaming identity, whereas for untold millions of people, these games are the backbone of the way that they play games.
- 10:12Matt he/him: And Austin Wintory, Alex's favorite composer, was saying that the Mass Effect trilogy was the most important, gaming experience he's ever had.
- 10:26Matt he/him: And it's, it's an, it's one of the absolute classics, especially Mass Effect.
- 10:33Matt he/him: He made an audition for the latest Mass Effect game to be composed.
- 10:38Matt he/him: He made a 30-minute love song of his journey through Mass Effect, and he just released that because it wasn't commissioned for it.
- 10:48Matt he/him: It was just a sharing of what it meant to him, which is what has been happening all over the internet
- 10:56Jem: Ja.
- 10:56Matt he/him: doesn't matter where BioWare is now or where it's been recently, it still did these things.
- 11:01Matt he/him: It still was these things.
- 11:03Matt he/him: And dragon Age: Inquisition was my first step into proper RPGs and laid the foundation for my journey into other RPGs.
- 11:19Matt he/him: So Dragon Age: Inquisition came out in 2014, 12 years ago, and I must have played it near that time, and it was awesome.
- 11:31Matt he/him: And then I either went from Inquisition into Mass Effect or Inquisition to Origins to Dragon Age II, then into Mass Effect.
- 11:42Matt he/him: Dragon Age was always my foundation of it.
- 11:45Matt he/him: I've only played through the Mass Effect trilogy once, purely because it's so massive.
- 11:50Matt he/him: It feels like a massive long story, whereas Dragon Age feels like a series of quests along its way to the main quest.
- 12:02Matt he/him: Mass Effect feels like you really do need to play the hundreds of hours in one go.
- 12:08Matt he/him: You can't dip in and out of things.
- 12:12Matt he/him: Amazingly, I was looking at the release dates for Dragon Age and Mass Effect.
- 12:19Matt he/him: The Mass Effect trilogy, those three entire games were released between 2007 and 2012.
- 12:28Matt he/him: We got an entire trilogy in five years, and that trilogy is still one of the benchmarks for sci-fi RPGs.
- 12:41Matt he/him: And this was on PS3.
- 12:44Matt he/him: And Dragon Age, the trilogy was released between 2009 and 2014, able to do another trilogy, another iconic trilogy in five years, which just proves to me that we have lost our way in terms of game development because it doesn't need to take five years to make a game.
- 13:10Matt he/him: They find a way to make it take that time.
- 13:13Matt he/him: Just the, the lessons to be taken from this is that you can pump out incredible games, incredible single-player games.
- 13:22Matt he/him: And I really enjoy Mass Effect Andromeda.
- 13:28Matt he/him: I, I really enjoy Angry Joe's review of it, which is a, a classic where he...
- 13:36Matt he/him: The woman on the bridge, he goes,"I'm sorry, my face is tired." And her eyes are sort of like that on her forehead and jiggling around a lot.
- 13:45Matt he/him: And so I enjoyed that, but that was in 2017.
- 13:49Matt he/him: And so we've not seen anything for nine years since the last Mass Effect.
- 13:56Matt he/him: And I, I just assumed based on what BioWare has been like recently, that it was gonna be rubbish anyway.
- 14:04Matt he/him: And so this development doesn't really hurt me because from my perspective, BioWare has been dead for quite some time because Mass Effect Andromeda was like the last throw of what it was and then that was the transition point, whereas Anthem was the transition point to where we are now'cause Anthem was a disaster and was discontinued in January.
- 14:40Matt he/him: I wonder if that has anything to do with this situation.
- 14:44Matt he/him: And then Dragon Age Veilguard, an absolute butchering of the Dragon Age franchise just goes,"Right, we can't do live service.
- 14:56Matt he/him: We can't do single-player RPGs anymore." And all the people that made it, those original games, amazing games, they're not there anymore, and if they are, they're not allowed to do the work that they're good at because it isn't a live service game that can make all the money So it's just another very sad story of a beloved studio with its brand and its reputation just slowly petering out in such a pathetic and pitiful just draining down into nothingness.
- 15:40Matt he/him: So it's just shit in every way really.
- 15:47Matt he/him: I'd be interested, so we...
- 15:50Matt he/him: I imagine we both have different relationships with BioWare games.
- 15:55Matt he/him: So I've just said a bit of mine.
- 15:56Matt he/him: What was your journey into BioWare like?
- 15:59Matt he/him: Did you play the original Baldur's Gates?
- 16:02Jem (2): I played the original Baldur's Gate, and I played neverwinter Nights, which I absolutely loved.
- 16:08Jem (2): I really enjoyed Baldur's Gate, but my, emotional response is more to Neverwinter, and I think it was because they had, this wintery area.
- 16:19Jem (2): I just remember feeling really cold when I was playing in there, and had a very strong emotional, connection that became a sort of physical connection as a result of that snow.
- 16:30Jem (2): So it always comes to me.
- 16:32Jem (2): I do have quite a strong connection with them, and their logo or when their name popped up on the screen, it always had a positive emotional connection for me.
- 16:42Jem (2): I feel sad about it especially because for me, coming from a modding background, the whole story-led RPGs was something that I was really craving and, that was something that games didn't have a lot of at the time.
- 17:00Jem (2): And so they kind of pioneered that.
- 17:03Jem (2): It did appeal to me a lot.
- 17:05Jem (2): I did play Mass Effect.
- 17:07Jem (2): I finished the first one, but I didn't finish the second one, but that's more just because of the adulting really.
- 17:16Jem (2): It wasn't because of the game.
- 17:17Jem: I bought Veilguard, but I haven't played it because of all the ba- all the bad reviews it got that I was just like,"Well, I only have limited time, and I'm not gonna sink it into that." yeah, I think it has a very special place in my heart.
- 17:32Jem: But I do also feel that, you know, things die, things run their course, It doesn't mean that there was anything necessarily wrong.
- 17:43Jem: It's just that, sometimes people run out of good ideas.
- 17:47Jem: Sometimes there's a, a series of bad choices that are made.
- 17:52Jem: Unlike many other stories around, EA and companies that it acquired, I do think that this isn't a case of EA just swallowing them up and spitting them out.
- 18:07Jem: I do feel like this was, an example of a company that just lost its way for whatever reasons, probably many different reasons that we can't see.
- 18:20Jem: Do you think that EA prolonged their demise by propping them up?
- 18:26Jem: Do you think that if, if EA hadn't, hadn't been there of bankroll them, that they would have gone a lot sooner?
- 18:36Jem: Would they have been better off if they'd never joined, never got snapped up?
- 18:39Matt he/him: They never should have allowed themselves to be bought by anything.
- 18:45Matt he/him: They were at some point before, I'm going to say like 2012, between 2010 and 2012, when they decided, right, we're going to try Anthem.
- 19:01Matt he/him: Our next big project is going to be this live service thing.
- 19:05Matt he/him: And 2012, there wasn't a live service like ecosystem anywhere near like there has been recently.
- 19:16Matt he/him: So the reason they chose to do that, because they're going, right, we've got our team that's working on Inquisition.
- 19:26Matt he/him: What we're going to do after Inquisition, we'll think about that now.
- 19:29Matt he/him: And their choice was Anthem.
- 19:33Matt he/him: Which was a terrible choice for them to have made.
- 19:38Matt he/him: It just feels like a terrible series of management that preceded everything that's happening now because you finish the Mass Effect trilogy on a high, even though there was lots of controversy about the ending.
- 19:56Matt he/him: People didn't like the ending, but still very successful.
- 19:59Matt he/him: Dragon Age series, Inquisition, massively successful.
- 20:04Matt he/him: It's not like you're starting off with nothing and you're trying to make something.
- 20:08Matt he/him: You started off with an incredible successful catalog that has generated a massive amount of profit for you, and what the management should be doing for that is going,"Right, we're gonna keep this so that we can keep the studio open for the next 20 years, no matter what.
- 20:27Matt he/him: We're going to have multiple plans.
- 20:30Matt he/him: We're going to split into multiple mini studios and work on different kinds of games." And it becomes a business thing then, whereas the game design side is a...
- 20:43Matt he/him: It should be a purely creative side.
- 20:45Matt he/him: The business people need to be making good business decisions.
- 20:51Matt he/him: And at some point, the people making those decisions started making bad decisions in a way that they hadn't done before, and that left them after Mass Effect Andromeda and Anthem with nothing.
- 21:09Matt he/him: Their Dragon Age was dead.
- 21:11Matt he/him: Mass Effect was petered out.
- 21:13Matt he/him: Anthem was a disaster.
- 21:16Matt he/him: That's the point where they, they had nothing.
- 21:19Matt he/him: They'd squandered everything.
- 21:21Matt he/him: They had an incredible success, and they squandered it somehow.
- 21:27Matt he/him: And then that leads to everyone losing because they're, they're not having a studio anymore.
- 21:35Matt he/him: They're not making any new games.
- 21:38Matt he/him: Gamers aren't getting the games that they know that they want, that they would pay through the nose for.
- 21:46Matt he/him: Like with the God of War series.
- 21:48Matt he/him: Originally, God of War came out in 2005, and then God of War II came out 2008, and then God of War III came out 2011.
- 22:00Matt he/him: And looking at these timeframes, it really feels like the transition to PS4 was a real make or break period in terms of where studios decided to go.
- 22:13Matt he/him: And God of War, that studio chose to pivot into the latest iteration of God of War, which is completely different to the original but has the exact same soul of it and is just that kind of evolution that everyone wants from their favorite studios'cause I don't want to have an awesome game and then be able to anticipate what the next one's gonna be, to going,"Oh, I hope it's like this, this, and this," and I'll be disappointed if it's not.
- 22:51Matt he/him: I know that I can rely on the Sony Santa Monica, the games for the God of War studio.
- 22:59Matt he/him: I know that I just don't need to worry.
- 23:01Matt he/him: Whatever they come out with next, I will be surprised and excited, which is what happened when God of War: Laufey was announced.
- 23:09Matt he/him: They come out with, out of nowhere, this 20-minute gameplay trailer of this completely impossible, impossibly awesome thing.
- 23:22Matt he/him: That's what everyone deserves from game studios that they love.
- 23:28Matt he/him: That should be the only remit of game studios that have had some success with a franchise.
- 23:35Matt he/him: Their goal should be, right, what do we need to do in order to evolve this to give the people the experience that they don't even know they want yet?
- 23:47Matt he/him: They don't even know it can exist yet.
- 23:49Jem: Mm.
- 23:53Matt he/him: It's just, it's so sad.
- 23:55Matt he/him: It's so sad just having that taken away.
- 24:00Matt he/him: And it- it's different if the studio had gone bankrupt after Mass Effect or whatever, and then it's going,"Oh, I want-- I wonder what could have been?" Whereas this, it literally, it just bled out obviously over such a long time.
- 24:17Matt he/him: It's so devastating looking at the last 10 years and you think,"We've only got so much time to have so many games come out." And the God of War games took 10 years in total to do the last two.
- 24:34Matt he/him: So the one that came out in 20- 2018, the other one came out in 2024, including the development of the first one, that was 10 years.
- 24:45Matt he/him: And that's 10 years' worth of work.
- 24:50Matt he/him: There was no shortcut to creating that product.
- 24:54Matt he/him: But you got the...
- 24:55Matt he/him: we got the product, and that has laid the foundation for wherever they're gonna go next.
- 25:01Matt he/him: And you look at a studio and you go,"Oh, they've been working their asses off for five years," and that means they're gonna create this awesome game.
- 25:13Matt he/him: But like with Rocksteady and Suicide Squad and with this, they spend five years making an utter disastrous piece of shit.
- 25:24Matt he/him: Five years.
- 25:26Matt he/him: They could have made an entire new trilogy that's, that they could just copy and rebrand what they've done already.
- 25:35Matt he/him: They could have done that, and we could have had three new games.
- 25:38Matt he/him: But they spend five years and they go,"Ah, here's Velguard." And you go,"You wasted five years making this.
- 25:45Matt he/him: It's not gonna make any money.
- 25:48Matt he/him: It's going to be a terrible failure." And then that means that's what you're gonna do for the next five years.
- 25:53Jem: Ja
- 25:54Matt he/him: find out two years later,"Oh yeah, we haven't got a studio anymore." And so that's just another, decade of waste, absolute waste when we could have had a decade of two awesome games or an entire trilogy.
- 26:15Matt he/him: It makes me so sad looking at wasted, wasted time
- 26:20Jem: Mm.
- 26:21Matt he/him: when from studios that they had it, they had everything they needed.
- 26:29Jem: Mm.
- 26:29Matt he/him: They had a franchise, they had success, they had profit.
- 26:34Matt he/him: They had everything, and they wasted it.
- 26:38Jem: Yeah.
- 26:40Jem: Absolutely.
- 26:42Jem: It's really sad that it went the way it did, and that nobody stepped in or recognized what it was doing and, helped out.
- 26:52Jem: I think we can get onto sort of conspiracy theories or ideas on why that happened.
- 27:00Jem: But before we do that, I wanted to talk a little bit about what we feel that BioWare has actually done for the gaming world, particularly with regards to, representation and equality,'cause obviously that's one of the things that we're always, banging on about.
- 27:17Jem: And, you know, I think it was really cool how BioWare sort of normalized the idea of playing as a female character, so much so that, they had, a female version of Commander Shepard on the front of the, game box I was just really wondering, how, how you feel about that.
- 27:38Jem: Do you feel that, that, that they were sort of a, a, a bastion for, that kind of, progress within gaming?
- 27:47Jem: Or is that a case of rose-tinted glasses
- 27:50Matt he/him: No, it's 100% true because it gives me that, same vibe as from...
- 28:00Matt he/him: It's the same family of inclusivity, but it's like the original of this kind of thing is Star Trek, the original series.
- 28:12Jem: Mm.
- 28:13Matt he/him: The inclusion of a Black woman on the bridge as an officer and going,"Right, in this show, this is normal.
- 28:25Matt he/him: This is, we're gonna present this as if no one ever blinked at it," which is exactly how it is now, and it became, in the decades after.
- 28:36Matt he/him: And in order for it to get to a place where it's normalized, someone needs to do it first.
- 28:43Jem: Mm.
- 28:44Matt he/him: There isn't a Black woman was in the background of one scene in one episode, and you go,"Oh, look, a Black woman on screen in Star Trek." It was, she's on the bridge, and she's an incredibly important part of the crew.
- 29:03Matt he/him: She's like, you can't, you can't just rip her out of it and have it be the same.
- 29:10Matt he/him: And the absolutely revolutionary, impact that Uhura's representation had is, so utterly profound, beyond words how profound it is.
- 29:26Matt he/him: That was the first step with that.
- 29:29Matt he/him: now we can look back and go,"Oh yeah, obviously wouldn't occur to anyone of our generation, most of our generation care about that." And I get the same feeling with the Effect and Dragon Age games of going, this is saturated with, representation in the same way that Baldur's Gate 3 is.
- 29:54Matt he/him: You can't...
- 29:54Matt he/him: Can't unwoke the Mass Effect and Dragon Age games because then they're not those games.
- 30:01Matt he/him: They are a central pillar of the games.
- 30:05Matt he/him: And to have it be not a tiny part, have it be part of the DNA of it, that's how you force progress to happen.
- 30:17Matt he/him: Because you go, right, this is this now, and it exists whether these people, like it or not.
- 30:25Matt he/him: And then it creates this massive fan base, and people who like it because of their representation, and people who like it'cause they barely notice it.
- 30:35Jem: Mm.
- 30:35Jem: I think, her was amazing and, you've heard of the Bechdel Test where you look at films and TV shows to see how often women are...
- 30:47Jem: Not just how many women are in a film, but how, how they're in the film.
- 30:52Jem: Like, how often are they talking about to another woman, not about a man?
- 30:58Jem: How often are they kind of given agency?
- 31:01Jem: And I think that was the great thing about her is that she was Black, but that she was Black was not a thing.
- 31:07Jem: And that's not in a color blind, you know, we don't see blackness kind of way.
- 31:12Jem: It's more about that it was just, it wasn't a thing that she was there in that role, and I think that was probably the strongest and most powerful thing that they did with her.
- 31:25Jem: That they didn't feel the need to kinda go into a whole kind of, like, race stories and things like that.
- 31:31Jem: And I think, you know, the same with, like, you know, FemShep or BroShep.
- 31:35Jem: You know, you've, you, you kinda have the option to play the character as female or male, and it doesn't change the way the story plays out.
- 31:48Jem: It doesn't, it's just the way that you appear and those are the ways that we normalize the idea that people are equal, no matter what their gender.
- 31:58Jem: And I think that's extremely powerful and so important.
- 32:03Jem: And they did that.
- 32:04Jem: They, you know, they did that when almost no one else was doing that.
- 32:09Jem: And I think that's really, you know, that is something that we need to, really thank them for and I know that we talked about when EA was acquired, or sold or whatever, the way you want to look at it.
- 32:24Jem: We talked about how would that impact on these kind of, you know, for want of a better word, woke policies and woke writing.
- 32:38Jem: So yeah, it makes me wonder if it, was entirely down to, non-political judgments I don't know.
- 32:49Jem: The things that I've read about it seem to imply that, really the writing had been on the wall for, as you were saying earlier, Matt, for quite a long time and just nothing was being done about it.
- 33:03Jem: But it does seem mighty convenient that one of the companies that, has really pushed that kind of, game design and story design would be one of the first out the door
- 33:22Matt he/him: I get so frustrated and angry with a lot of representation these days because representation has improved, it is consistently the safe kind of representation, the ones that going,"Oh, we've got a gay romance in here." Going,"Oh, but they are both skinny, hairless,
- 33:48Jem: Ja
- 33:49Matt he/him: because they were...
- 33:50Matt he/him: If they looked like the average man, then that would terrify straight men.
- 33:55Matt he/him: They're thinking,"Oh my God, I...
- 33:57Matt he/him: Oh my
- 33:57Jem: I might be gay.
- 33:59Matt he/him: exactly.
- 33:59Matt he/him: That's-- I could rant for days about my frustration with safe And you could see it so much when the, the censorship that is semi-censorship.
- 34:17Jem: Mhm.
- 34:19Matt he/him: a lot of times when things like where the person is wearing a Pride armband
- 34:26Jem: Mm.
- 34:27Matt he/him: and, he-- I think it was a footballer I think he'd been signed by a Saudi Arabian team, and there was a highlight reel him, and the ones where he had the armband on were in black and white.
- 34:43Matt he/him: And people on the BBC having, it's like Palestine tags or
- 34:50Jem: Mm.
- 34:50Matt he/him: the trans pride flag, and how they were being removed by the BBC, and then the BBC would say,"Oh, this is all part of our guidelines of being neutral, even though we are the British Broadcasting Company, and we somehow serve the ruling class, even though we're not a private corporation, and we don't have to."
- 35:13Jem: And they all wear poppies.
- 35:15Jem: You know, nobody argues about that, and they all wear poppies and, they're not even allowed, you know, nobody's allowed to wear white poppies instead.
- 35:23Jem: They all have to wear the red poppies.
- 35:25Matt he/him: It's about the f--
- 35:26Jem: it's double standards
- 35:27Matt he/him: it's about a framework that the ruling class sets for the society that they want us to exist in, where they can go,"It used to be, segregation.
- 35:40Matt he/him: You can have Black people, you can have white people, you can't mix them."
- 35:43Jem: Mm.
- 35:44Matt he/him: And then eventually, through an insane amount of hard work and suffering and brutality, segregation was ended in America.
- 35:55Matt he/him: And now America isn't segregated by Black and white anymore.
- 36:00Matt he/him: But is still the taboos around it.
- 36:05Matt he/him: ah, we've got representation now, and it's, integrated, no more segregation.
- 36:12Matt he/him: But it's still within that framework of going, oh, but Black
- 36:15Jem: Black men aren't completely safe
- 36:16Matt he/him: You're not completely safe.
- 36:17Matt he/him: You're, screwed with by cops the most, killed by cops the most, et cetera.
- 36:26Matt he/him: That means that even though, oh yeah, we've got a bit of this representation, you are still part of the problem
- 36:33Jem: Mm.
- 36:33Matt he/him: because you're, not pushing it where you're meant to.
- 36:41Matt he/him: if you think about back to Uhura, that was just utterly revolutionary.
- 36:49Matt he/him: That was the most unsafe form of representation, which makes it the most important.
- 36:55Matt he/him: When you're doing the things that other people are doing and not pushing it, then if you go,"Right, we're pushing it up till we feel safe and comfortable doing it," say that, and we can judge you based on that.
- 37:10Matt he/him: But when you go,"Oh, celebrate our representation and our diversity," and they are deliberately not pushing it, those people I have real disdain for.
- 37:25Jem: So Veilguard had, the first sort of non-binary companion.
- 37:32Jem: And some people were like,"Oh, yeah, so go woke, go broke." no one can argue that Star Trek went broke.
- 37:41Jem: So do you think that the problem was that it was more of a box-ticking exercise, it was more of a performative sort of wokeness, rather than an actual effort to bring in more equity in the game and that that was part of the problem, that the whole thing about Veilguard's, underlying problems was that it felt disingenuous on many levels, and that is another example of that disingenuity?
- 38:17Matt he/him: It is one of the worst attempts at representation because it is hollow.
- 38:24Matt he/him: It was a very underperforming game.
- 38:27Matt he/him: I have no idea who that character was.
- 38:31Matt he/him: no idea what role they played.
- 38:34Matt he/him: And that just means that if you're gonna tick a box somewhere, that's the kind of thing that is just throw away.
- 38:44Matt he/him: You could release it and Saudi Arabia and goes,"Oh yeah, we'll just cut that character out and it won't matter." And When technically, like in Star Trek, it's just, it's a woman, Black, she's an officer, on the bridge.
- 39:01Jem: Yeah.
- 39:02Matt he/him: That's that.
- 39:03Jem: Get over it.
- 39:04Matt he/him: Those are four boxes, and that was revolutionary.
- 39:11Matt he/him: You can tick three boxes in terms of representation and have it be revolutionary, and not every role needs to be revolutionary.
- 39:23Matt he/him: But you need to respect it.
- 39:26Matt he/him: You need to give it the importance that it deserves, to respect the richness that it can have.
- 39:36Matt he/him: Because what this kind of thing smacks of is the, just put the name on the box, non-binary, not a he or a she, and go,"Oh yeah, that's representation, isn't it?" We'll get in trouble.
- 39:54Matt he/him: We feel like, oh, we're gonna get in trouble with the wokerati for doing that, and it just, didn't matter.
- 40:05Matt he/him: If you're gonna try and do representation, you can't think of the framing of the right wing.
- 40:12Matt he/him: You just can't
- 40:13Jem: Nei.
- 40:15Matt he/him: 'cause they're never gonna...
- 40:16Matt he/him: There is-- Y- you can't negotiate the right wing down.
- 40:20Matt he/him: You can't talk
- 40:21Jem: Nei
- 40:21Matt he/him: You can't convince them.
- 40:24Matt he/him: They're not doing it because they're just misinformed.
- 40:29Matt he/him: It is rooted in them just hating things, hating people, and then the ruling class and the media convince them that they're not hateful morons.
- 40:41Matt he/him: It convinces them that they are critical thinkers.
- 40:45Matt he/him: not fucking dipshit morons who think that woke is an intelligent description of what they believe.
- 40:55Jem: I think it's a bit like anxiety.
- 40:57Jem: You know, you can't reason with it because it's unreasonable.
- 41:01Jem: It's not logical.
- 41:02Jem: It just is, you know?
- 41:04Jem: So you cannot sit and have a conversation with somebody regarding anxiety and say to them like,"Well, you know, there's nothing scary about this particular situation, and if you think of it like this and that and this." It...
- 41:17Jem: That doesn't work because it isn't logical.
- 41:20Jem: It may have some, seeming basis in logic somewhere, but it isn't actually logical.
- 41:26Jem: And I think the same applies to, the far right and it's basically, it isn't logical because it's based in, hate and, confusion and-
- 41:38Matt he/him: Cognitive
- 41:38Jem: Cognitive dissonance yeah, cognitive dissonance like you wouldn't believe.
- 41:42Matt he/him: dissonance is the fucking, the root of it all because that's how you, turn people into infinite extremists, where what they hate, they want to cause suffering to, that's how you build a, a limitless hunger for the suffering of other people.
- 42:05Matt he/him: Because look at the Reform UK and the Conservatives at the moment.
- 42:14Matt he/him: So the Reform UK, who their whole thing is they hate Black and brown people from other countries.
- 42:26Matt he/him: That's the root of it.
- 42:27Matt he/him: And they also happen to be the same group of people who are incels, and so they are hating women as well.
- 42:38Matt he/him: If you notice, every time that you see a front page or a news story that is, mentions immigration, controversy about immigration, it was always a picture of Black and brown-skinned men on small boats.
- 42:52Jem: Ja
- 42:52Matt he/him: That's every single time.
- 42:55Jem: Oh my God, sorry.
- 42:56Jem: We got a newspaper through from Reform, called The Reformer, and, one of the things they had in there was that you can download an app so you can track the small boats, so that you can go down and harangue at people who have, just survived a life-threatening journey on a dinghy across the channel.
- 43:17Matt he/him: And that's what it comes down to.
- 43:19Matt he/him: I've thought for a very long time that what they want is to be able to...
- 43:26Matt he/him: They want the Coast Guard, so when they see one of these boats, they want them to go over and tip it over
- 43:33Jem: Mm.
- 43:34Matt he/him: and then film and laugh as these desperate people drown in the channel.
- 43:39Matt he/him: That's what they want, and they are angry that they can't have that.
- 43:45Matt he/him: So you could say to them you don't care about immigration.
- 43:47Matt he/him: You don't care about Britain.
- 43:48Matt he/him: You don't care about the sanctity of the British identity.
- 43:51Matt he/him: You care about hating Black and brown people from other countries.
- 43:56Matt he/him: That's all it is.
- 43:58Matt he/him: It's as simple as that, and then you have Braverman and Kemi Badenoch being the most viciously racist against Black and brown people from other countries, just giving these right-wing racists the red meat that they want and saying just all the extreme, the extreme messages.
- 44:28Jem: Ja.
- 44:29Matt he/him: And they are and brown women parents are Black and brown people from other countries,
- 44:36Jem: Ja
- 44:37Matt he/him: And then that leads us to having hundreds of men dressed in black and balaclavas going to the fucking Port of Dover and the police just going there,"No, we can't touch them they need to be allowed to be normalized in the framework of our society." We can't have a pro-Palestinian protesters Sitting down.
- 45:01Matt he/him: Tons of these protesters sitting down, and how many clips have you seen of them being sat there like that, four policemen come
- 45:09Jem: Ja
- 45:09Matt he/him: Pick them up, calmly carry them off to the
- 45:12Jem: Yeah.
- 45:12Matt he/him: arrest them,"
- 45:13Jem: And it's always some little old lady, you know?
- 45:15Jem: It's not some bloke in a balaclava.
- 45:17Jem: It's terrifying.
- 45:19Jem: It's terrifying that we allowed that to happen, that the police allowed that to happen.
- 45:24Jem: I cannot understand that.
- 45:27Matt he/him: Another area of patheticness with it is they get the message they get is that they are right to be doing these things.
- 45:36Matt he/him: Because if you see two hundred men with balaclavas, you should see them immediately, balaclavas off, arrested, and that's what-- If, the people who want to behave like that saw that they were being treated that way, they wouldn't do it because
- 45:54Jem: Nei
- 45:54Matt he/him: cowards.
- 45:55Matt he/him: They are waiting to see what other people are getting away with, and then they'll do that.
- 46:01Matt he/him: And that's why nothing was done.
- 46:04Matt he/him: It's'cause the conservatives and Reform need that kind of action
- 46:11Jem: Mm.
- 46:12Matt he/him: to be on the table for these people to do so they can continue ratcheting up the extremism.
- 46:20Matt he/him: And the cognitive dissonance of Suella Braverman and Kemi Badenoch and they are sitting on a powder keg of right-wing extremism and they are sat there on top of it going,"Yes, add more stuff to it.
- 46:35Matt he/him: And every day they light a cigarette and go,"Is it gonna explode?
- 46:39Matt he/him: Hoping that they can get enough notoriety and wealth they step down.
- 46:45Jem: Ja
- 46:45Matt he/him: It's mind-boggling that whatever Reform wants,"Right, what, what we're going to do is get every Black and brown person in the United Kingdom and shove them off into the channel and make
- 47:00Jem: Ja.
- 47:00Matt he/him: in the channel so that there's only white people left." They would go,"Ah, thank you, Suella Braverman, Kemi Badenoch.
- 47:08Matt he/him: We couldn't have done this without you.
- 47:09Matt he/him: Thank you.
- 47:10Jem: Yeah.
- 47:11Jem: Off you go.
- 47:11Matt he/him: you go."
- 47:13Jem: Yeah.
- 47:14Matt he/him: That's it
- 47:16Jem: Yeah, absolutely.
- 47:17Jem: As you say, cognitive dissonance.
- 47:24Jem: Okay, so BioWare have gone.
- 47:27Jem: We...
- 47:27Jem: For reasons.
- 47:28Jem: Many possible reasons.
- 47:30Jem: Who's gonna pick up the mantle?
- 47:33Jem: Who can we turn to in our hour of need to champion, the woke folk?
- 47:42Matt he/him: The, thank God for, Larian
- 47:46Jem: Yes.
- 47:47Jem: Yeah.
- 47:48Matt he/him: I thought of that as the literal successor to Baldur's Gate 1 and 2 and the spiritual successor to Dragon Age.
- 47:55Jem: Ja.
- 47:55Matt he/him: where I went,"Oh, I don't care if the new Dragon Age is rubbish because, Baldur's Gate 3 is awesome."
- 48:02Jem: I love that you love Baldur's Gate 3 because I remember when you were saying to me like,"Do you think I'll like it?" And I was like,"Yes, I do, but it's gonna be a bit different from what you're used to."
- 48:15Matt he/him: Yes, I remember,'cause I bought it and then turn-based and from the overhead
- 48:23Jem: Mhm.
- 48:23Matt he/him: And then I didn't play it for a really long time.
- 48:26Jem: Nei
- 48:27Matt he/him: And then I can't remember exactly why, but I started playing it, and then here I am.
- 48:31Matt he/him: Played it a couple of times.
- 48:33Matt he/him: Playing it with you guys, playing it with my mom.
- 48:36Matt he/him: We were on session 35 of
- 48:38Jem: Oh wow
- 48:39Matt he/him: We're just in the...
- 48:41Matt he/him: reached the House of Healing in the Shadowlands.
- 48:45Jem: Oh yeah, yeah
- 48:47Matt he/him: so many things have happened I had no idea were there, and things that surprising me all the way.
- 48:57Matt he/him: now they're moving on to doing Pillars of Eternity.
- 49:00Matt he/him: Of Eternity, the new one they're doing?
- 49:02Matt he/him: So that's gonna be awesome, and I'm glad that they have the creative, drive to pivot into a different direction than continuing with, another Baldur's Gate.
- 49:19Matt he/him: The only thing that I'm missing from them is they need to have a sci-fi wing.
- 49:26Jem: Mm.
- 49:27Matt he/him: They need to do what BioWare did and what Bethesda did in you have your Elder Scrolls and your Dragon Age, that's half, and
- 49:35Jem: Ja.
- 49:36Matt he/him: your Mass Effects and your Fallouts on the other half.
- 49:40Matt he/him: Can you imagine if we had Baldur's Gate 3 in space?
- 49:45Jem: Yeah.
- 49:46Jem: You see, spacey games just don't appeal to me, but yes, I can imagine that it would be so good for so many people,'cause I know it is a massive genre.
- 49:55Jem: So yes, I think you're absolutely right.
- 49:58Jem: I mean, I would probably play Baldur's Gate 3 in space, actually.
- 50:03Jem: As long as Astarion was still there floating about.
- 50:07Jem: Are we pinning all of our hopes on Larian, or do we think there's anyone else that might be able to step up to the challenge?
- 50:16Matt he/him: In terms of, ah, it's all double-edged swords these days.
- 50:21Matt he/him: But we've got Larian, which is a single-edged sword.
- 50:24Matt he/him: That's always gonna be good.
- 50:25Matt he/him: I suppose the only other edge to it is that they don't have a sci-fi division.
- 50:28Matt he/him: But that's
- 50:29Jem: Yes, but they can change that
- 50:31Matt he/him: They've, they're on the right path, we don't have to worry about them the time being.
- 50:38Matt he/him: The indie market is the saving grace of the gaming industry because that's where the things that are showing up all the AAA games, so we're not just restricted to...
- 50:52Jem: Ja.
- 50:53Matt he/him: Imagine if it was only stuff like Dragon Age: Veilguard and Anthem and Suicide
- 50:58Jem: Ja,
- 50:58Matt he/him: So AAA studios don't have a monopoly on it.
- 51:01Matt he/him: Problem with indie games is that there are an exponentially increasing amount of them, And gonna get even more exponential with AI improving so much.
- 51:15Matt he/him: Because I have been with AI as a way to improve my Unreal Engine, knowledge and skills, and it so much easier to diagnose problems and, just analyze things.
- 51:40Jem: Ja, ja
- 51:41Matt he/him: And that's the, the actual hard technical part.
- 51:46Matt he/him: So whereas the creative stuff is the stuff that's easiest for it to, to generate on its own.
- 51:56Matt he/him: so like with these, there are thousands of these tidying games that I'm addicted to now, and you can handcraft, if there are five thousand items, you can handcraft the appearance and the, the titles and description of all of it.
- 52:15Matt he/him: You can handcraft that, which is what the people who really love it do.
- 52:21Matt he/him: you can make the gameplay, ask ChatGPT to create five thousand items, and then just stick that into it.
- 52:31Matt he/him: the months that it would take to come up with all those items are just skipped.
- 52:37Jem: Ja
- 52:37Matt he/him: And so we've got the indie market, if there's no, like, serious AI usage, are far too many games, and that's gonna continue growing.
- 52:54Matt he/him: And the indie games that are gonna be to, easier and quicker to make, it not just about them being made completely by AI, it's about
- 53:07Jem: Yeah.
- 53:07Jem: My-- Yeah, yeah
- 53:11Matt he/him: And then that makes it harder for developers releasing their games because
- 53:17Jem: Mm.
- 53:18Matt he/him: it's, unless you've got the marketing budget or you get a viral hit, you can
- 53:24Jem: Saturated.
- 53:25Jem: Yeah
- 53:25Matt he/him: could have an incredible potential audience,
- 53:28Jem: But won't ever get seen.
- 53:30Jem: What about Owlcat?
- 53:32Jem: They're Pathfinder and they're doing The Expanse.
- 53:36Matt he/him: yeah.
- 53:37Matt he/him: Yeah, that sounds good.
- 53:38Jem: Pathfinder Kingmaker, Pathfinder Wrath of the Righteous, they're sort of tabletop style fantasy RPGs.
- 53:47Jem: And then they did Warhammer 40K: Rogue Trader in 2023
- 53:55Matt he/him: tried that a few days ago and, it, looks like it's gonna be awesome.
- 53:59Matt he/him: It's almost exactly the same as...
- 54:02Matt he/him: It's turn-based combat.
- 54:03Matt he/him: It's a massive sprawling story.
- 54:08Matt he/him: And I think I was getting it confused with The Walking Dead Tales
- 54:12Jem: Okay.
- 54:13Jem: Yeah.
- 54:14Jem: Yeah
- 54:15Matt he/him: So there's every reason to suggest that it'll be really good.
- 54:19Jem: So that might be a...
- 54:21Jem: Yeah, there might be some hope there.
- 54:24Jem: I guess we just have to watch and see well, I think we've kind of covered it all.
- 54:32Jem: We went on a really long journey today, is there anything else that you wanted to add about the demise of BioWare?
- 54:44Jem: Farewell Bi- bye-bye, BioWare.
- 54:48Matt he/him: Do you have, any of your favorite most impactful NPC companions that you can call off the top of your head?
- 55:01Jem: The one that had the biggest effect on me, or really the one that had the biggest effect on me was Boo in the original Baldur's Gates.
- 55:13Jem: It's Minsc because he used to say,"Go for the eyes, Boo.
- 55:16Jem: Go for the eyes," and that used to be his thing.
- 55:19Jem: And the other thing that I really loved, about the Baldur's Gate, characters was...
- 55:25Jem: And then they do do it in Baldur's Gate 3, but it just didn't, it never quite got me in the same way.
- 55:33Jem: I think maybe it didn't happen often enough.
- 55:35Jem: But what, what was great was the way they just chatted to each other and you were wandering around in the game, and they were just having these, like, arguments and little conversations.
- 55:45Jem: And they do do it in the latest one, but I don't think they do it enough.
- 55:51Jem: It was too rare, and it just didn't...
- 55:54Jem: You never quite got that feel that it was a genuine party kinda hanging out and wandering around and doing stuff, whereas in the older versions, yeah, Baldur's Gate 1, Baldur's Gate 2, it was great'cause they just felt like they were talking.
- 56:08Jem: And the other thing that I'm gonna say other than the snow that I mentioned earlier about Neverwinter Nights was, was the sound of them, of the towns, and I c- I can't describe it right now, but if I heard it when you walk i- when you walked into a town in the game, there was a certain sound with people calling and, like, con- background conversation, and if I wa- if I heard it today, I'd be like,"What's that?" It would just take me right back there because it was really fundamental for me.
- 56:45Jem: So I think it does go all the way back there.
- 56:48Jem: I definitely had good moments with other characters in later games, but that's really where my heart lies.
- 56:56Jem: So what about you?
- 56:59Matt he/him: There are lots of characters that I really liked romancing, and there are some fabulous companion quests.
- 57:09Matt he/him: And two that really, touched an emotional part of me are, Merrill in Dragon Age II.
- 57:21Matt he/him: She was this just very strange elf mage who was an outcast from her tribe and was a completely unconventional kind of character to be in any kind of situation.
- 57:40Matt he/him: And it just felt like She was so out of place, but such an excellently made character that it really elevated it.
- 57:55Matt he/him: then, I think it's Drack from Krogan from Mass Effect: Andromeda.
- 58:08Jem: Ja.
- 58:09Matt he/him: And he, the Krogan, have a fascinating, tragic, backstory of being sterilized by the s...
- 58:23Matt he/him: begins with S One of the other races sterilized by them, desperately them trying to children is a devastating, long, journey that they've been on, where constantly being met with, failure and capturing the real trauma that that kind of process have.
- 58:55Matt he/him: And in Andromeda, that really comes through.
- 59:02Matt he/him: And there's a storyline with him where you discover that he's actually in terrible physical agony all the time of he's been alive for like eight hundred years, and he's been a warrior that entire time, and that just all those wounds and injuries and replacements just had built up and taken its toll on him, and just really That kind of pain really shapes a person,
- 59:39Jem: Ja.
- 59:40Matt he/him: to have that be represented like that had made a massive impact on me.
- 59:49Matt he/him: wonderful examples of the human condition.
- 59:53Matt he/him: Don't need to be human, it doesn't matter if you're an 800-year-old alien.
- 59:59Matt he/him: Having centuries of fighting,
- 1:00:03Jem: Ja
- 1:00:05Matt he/him: you're gonna break down physically and mentally and emotionally.
- 1:00:10Matt he/him: And of seeing generation after generation not be able to have children, feeling like you're getting close to the end of your life and your legacy isn't secured.
- 1:00:25Matt he/him: And being this outcast mage elf who has no social skills and doesn't really understand the world, and you slot that into the situation
- 1:00:39Jem: Mm.
- 1:00:41Matt he/him: They're just Ugh.
- 1:00:44Matt he/him: And those things will always be there
- 1:00:47Jem: Ja.
- 1:00:48Jem: Yeah.
- 1:00:48Jem: I mean, those stories will always be there and yeah.
- 1:00:53Jem: I think, you know, it's the storytelling, isn't it, at the end of the day?
- 1:00:57Jem: It's the storytelling.
- 1:00:58Jem: They just told good stories, and hopefully somebody else will step up, and I think they are, and they will.
- 1:01:06Jem: Well, thank you so much.
- 1:01:08Jem: It's been really interesting and, nice to reminisce about BioWare.
- 1:01:13Jem: Sad to see it go.
- 1:01:15Jem: I'm very sad for all the people who are having to find new jobs now.
- 1:01:20Jem: But I am sure that they will, because they were a creative and talented group of people.
- 1:01:27Jem: At the end of the day, there are people behind all of this whose lives, have been thrown up in the air right now.
- 1:01:35Jem: So, our sympathy's with them.
- 1:01:37Jem: So thank you so much for, joining me, Matt, to talk about this.
- 1:01:41Jem: We are, releasing things every Thursday, and, we are also streaming at sort of irregular times, depending on our schedules.
- 1:01:52Jem: So yeah, like, share, follow us, tell your friends and, feel free to comment on what your thoughts are on BioWare and what your most memorable characters are.
- 1:02:05Jem: Thank you.
- 1:02:05Jem: Goodbye.