Latest / Arroe Collins: Unplugged & Totally Uncut / PBS Presents The Librarians From Julie Miller And Kim Snyder
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Erow dot net a r r o e dot net.
- 0:03It is the home of the Daily Mess. Come on,
- 0:06we all have questions, we ask them every day. Our
- 0:09fault and our problem is is that we don't write
- 0:11them down and finish out the research project. So what
- 0:14do we do? We mop around? Oh it's so boring,
- 0:18look that up. Why are we bored with life?
- 0:21Speaker 2: See?
- 0:21Speaker 1: That's what the Daily Mess is all about. It is
- 0:23asking real people questions and getting real people answers. Only
- 0:26on ero dot net A R r oe dot net.
- 0:30Enjoy your exploration him Hell Loen, good morning you too.
- 0:34How are you doing today?
- 0:36Speaker 2: Very well?
- 0:37Speaker 1: I gotta tell you. I can't thank you enough for this.
- 0:40And the reason why is because my wife is a
- 0:42retired teacher. I lived and breathed the library. But as
- 0:46of late we all know why we're not all jumping
- 0:48in there because I don't want someone to push their
- 0:50agenda onto us. But this what this documentary does on PBS,
- 0:54it says, do not ever go in there and judge
- 0:57the librarian. It's not their fault. And that's what I love.
- 1:01That's what I picked up on this is that it's
- 1:03the community that's making the changes. It's not the librarians,
- 1:07that's correct.
- 1:09Speaker 3: I'm jumping in here to say what I learned as
- 1:11a person outside the space and starting to document this
- 1:15four years ago. These are trained professionals who provide such
- 1:20an important service to us, and are trained in age
- 1:24appropriate materials, in representation and all of these amazing things.
- 1:29And unfortunately, with the escalation of this attack on our
- 1:33freedom of expression, they have now become the firewall. They
- 1:37didn't ask to do that. In essence, they are now
- 1:41these incredible patriots in my mind and heroes of upholding
- 1:45all the tenets of American democracy and protecting our First
- 1:49Amendment rights.
- 1:50Speaker 1: One of the things. And I'm not going to lie
- 1:51to you. I cried real tears because I'm blessed with
- 1:54the opportunity to speak with all of these ya authors
- 1:57that are releasing books right now, and we do talk
- 1:59about them being banned. They've learned to laugh it off. Yeah,
- 2:03I just got another stripe on my arm and I go,
- 2:05how can you be laughing about this? Because there's always
- 2:08a bookstore? And I went, you're taking them away from
- 2:11the library. How do you feel about that?
- 2:14Speaker 4: So I think that is a it's a common mental
- 2:19mistake that people make when it comes to the idea
- 2:23that well, these aren't really being banned, they're just being
- 2:26taken out of school libraries, and so therefore they're still available.
- 2:32You know, anybody can go to Amazon or a bookstore.
- 2:36But the thing is that we forget that not everyone
- 2:40has the same access to resources. While yes, I can
- 2:45go and purchase you know, the latest dog Man book
- 2:49for my son on you know, Amazon or you know
- 2:52bookshop dot org, not every parent has the expendable funds
- 2:58to do so. And so what we're essentially doing is
- 3:02furthering the divide when it comes to access to resources
- 3:06and information, because not only are the libraries the books
- 3:11on the shelves under attack, the libraries themselves are under attack.
- 3:15And we are seeing across the country the cutting of
- 3:19library staff, the elimination of school libraries, and it's it's
- 3:25really terrible, and even classroom libraries have been under fire
- 3:30through this.
- 3:30Speaker 3: I just wanted to jump in and say, it isn't
- 3:33just the school libraries. You know, four years ago when
- 3:35I started, one of our libraries said we are the
- 3:38canaries in the coal mine. This is like a trojan horse.
- 3:41And she was so right, because here we are four
- 3:44years later. It's the public libraries, it's the museums, it's
- 3:48the it's the institutions.
- 3:50Speaker 2: Of higher learning.
- 3:51Speaker 3: I just had a conversation lest you think that you know,
- 3:54these books are safe in the bookstores with the someone
- 3:57from you know, representing the American Bookseller Association, and there's
- 4:03fear that there will be censorship in the books in
- 4:07the independent bookstores themselves. So I don't think it's I
- 4:11think that we have to question really all these places
- 4:16in the food chain, if you will, of where our
- 4:18books land.
- 4:19Speaker 1: You know, one of the things that I have to
- 4:20give you, guys, big kudos on is the fact that
- 4:22you take both sides of the fans. You show us
- 4:25these books that do have some things in there, and
- 4:28my wife and I looked at each other, going, WHOA, Well,
- 4:30I didn't know and so, but then she would say, well,
- 4:33how do you feel about that? You can't judge another
- 4:35person's a reason for reading a book. Don't take it
- 4:38away from them. It's like, no matter how much you
- 4:40unveiled to me, I believe that people deserve to have
- 4:43the right to see it.
- 4:44Speaker 3: Well, it's also built into our constitutional precedence setting legal
- 4:49cases like Peekoversus Island Treadings which established these things. And
- 4:54I think what a lot of the public doesn't understand
- 4:56is there have always been parental rights.
- 4:58Speaker 2: And I have not met one librarian.
- 5:01Speaker 3: Who has not who's either said before this there were
- 5:04almost zero challenges, but there was a process. And now
- 5:07that process, in that protocol has been brazenly broken of
- 5:11just taking the books like you know, no due process
- 5:16and dictating a minority of people are able in a town.
- 5:21Sometimes it's in Julie's case, you know, one individual who
- 5:25could dictated what a lot of kids could or couldn't read.
- 5:29So don't you know it's the parental rights should be flipped.
- 5:33Speaker 2: Don't tell me what you know. I can, my kids
- 5:37can have to read.
- 5:39Speaker 1: Please do not move. There's more with Julie Miller and
- 5:41Kim Snyder coming up next the name of the documentary
- 5:46The Librarians from PBS. We are back with Julie Miller
- 5:51and Kim Snyder. You know one of the things that
- 5:53my Wipe the school teacher, brought up and I thought,
- 5:55my god, that's exactly why you're a school teacher. She said,
- 5:58well what about the dictionary? And she goes, you're a guy.
- 6:01As a little boy, you would look up words in
- 6:03that dictionary and giggle. She's right, there's stuff in that dictionary.
- 6:07Do they get to stay?
- 6:10Speaker 4: So, actually, dictionaries have been challenged, Wow, in different districts.
- 6:16It's not new. That did happen previously. I probably in
- 6:22the eighties or nineties, I don't remember the exactly, but yeah,
- 6:27parents being upset that their child looked up definitions of
- 6:31dirty words. But yeah, it's it's the thing is that
- 6:36when we are talking about opening the door to censorship, like,
- 6:41where does that take us? Because that's that's actual information. Dictionaries,
- 6:49books that deal with comprehensive sexual education, which is often
- 6:56in school's like mine, not even taught in schools anymore.
- 7:02So we're denying students access to information that even its
- 7:07just about Books about race are under attack here. Books
- 7:12that deal with the history of racism in our country
- 7:16are being targeted. Because this is not about inappropriate content.
- 7:22There isn't pornography in school libraries. By the way, you
- 7:28can access it on phones, which most of these teens
- 7:32and preteens have in their pockets. But that's beside the point.
- 7:38But when it comes to access to materials, this isn't
- 7:43just about sexual content or what have you. It's about
- 7:47marginalized people, and it is about like shutting out diversity
- 7:53of voices, and beyond that, it takes it into freedom
- 7:58in general, freedom of it expression Because where were the
- 8:02canaries in the coal mine here? This may have started
- 8:06with school libraries, but I think anybody could see that
- 8:09this has gone far beyond libraries, public libraries, bookstores. You know,
- 8:15we're seeing the creed of infringement on our freedoms.
- 8:20Speaker 1: And you proved this is not a new millennium thing.
- 8:22This has been going on all the way back to McCarthyism.
- 8:25And that's why this documentary is so important because you
- 8:28don't just say here's what's going on today, No, you
- 8:31showcase the journey.
- 8:33Speaker 3: Absolutely, we really I tried as a documentarian to reflect
- 8:39the journey that I took and to reflect that back
- 8:43in following an odyssey, if you will, of librarians that
- 8:48traverse a number of states and even New Jersey up north.
- 8:53Because less you think this is just happening in Texas
- 8:55and Florida, we have not played this in one state,
- 8:58and there have been many where someone hasn't said this
- 9:01is happening, right, here, So we're hoping people take the
- 9:04cues from these heroic individuals like Julie and others flanking
- 9:09them to get involved locally, because censorship is actually something
- 9:14where the policies are often dictated in very hyper local ways,
- 9:18So we want people It's not a partisan message. I
- 9:21don't feel the film is that. I think most Americans
- 9:25feel that censorship is just fundamentally un American. They know
- 9:29the dangers of what it's meant in history, and people
- 9:32should show up and vote in their school board elections,
- 9:36get involved in the library boards, in local city councils,
- 9:41and understand what's happening in your community around this issue.
- 9:44Speaker 1: And it really does filter through everything from pamphlets that
- 9:47are at businesses. It is being censored as well. Even
- 9:50as a podcaster, I rely on what I call hidden
- 9:53speak to make sure that they don't come and shut
- 9:55my butt down because they well, it's coming, but it
- 9:57has to start at the library first. But it is coming.
- 10:00Speaker 2: That's why we say it's a trojan horse.
- 10:03Speaker 1: Yes, yeah, wow. Where can people go to find out
- 10:06more about what you guys are doing? Because this is
- 10:08an everyday thing. This is why PBS is so brilliant.
- 10:12In our lives because they make it about our now
- 10:15and beyond.
- 10:17Speaker 2: I couldn't agree with you more.
- 10:19Speaker 3: I couldn't support I've made three films with PBS and
- 10:22independent lens.
- 10:24Speaker 2: It's an amazing strand we're so thrilled to be.
- 10:27Speaker 3: Broadcasting on February ninth.
- 10:32Speaker 2: On independent lens and YouTube channels.
- 10:35Speaker 3: And we also have a website, the librariansfilm dot Com,
- 10:40where people could learn more about our impact campaign and
- 10:43how we're really creating a movement. I call it Librarians
- 10:46without Borders. But we have seen this support, as Julie
- 10:53mentioned earlier, across our borders in Canada and Europe. People
- 10:58are concerned that we're supporting this, and uh, we're We're
- 11:03thrilled to be having this tool to organize and get
- 11:07people involved. Wow.
- 11:10Speaker 1: Well, please come back to this show anytime in the future.
- 11:13The door is always going to be open for you.
- 11:17Speaker 2: We thank you so much for having us.
- 11:19Speaker 1: You'd be brilliant today.
- 11:20Speaker 2: Okay, you two, thank you. You did the same