Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Can Someone Hack My Brain? (with Professor Nita Farahany)
Transcript
- 0:02We understand my tree, the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's
- 0:09a symbol, an idea. The population of atheist this country is going through
- 0:14the rule, rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I
- 0:20tell the truth, it's because I tell the truth, not because I put
- 0:24my hand on a book and made a wish and working together for a more
- 0:29rational world. Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness,
- 0:33truth, future, and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing,
- 0:38question everything, and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted
- 0:48by Seth Andrews. There is video of this conversation. That YouTube link is
- 1:00in the description box of the show. I'm fascinated by neurotechnology. I'm terrified
- 1:10by neuro technology. I have a very special guest today. I've got Nita
- 1:15Fara Honey. She is an expert on this stuff, an expert on the
- 1:19impact and ethics of the emerging technology. She is Professor of Law and Philosophy
- 1:25at Duke Law School. She's done a ton of speaking and writing on neuroscience
- 1:30and bioethics. You may have seen her ted talk on YouTube back in twenty
- 1:36ten. She was appointed by President Barack Obama to the Presidential Commission for the
- 1:41Study of Bioethical Issues. She's got degrees in genetics, sell and developmental biology,
- 1:48and she's author of the book The Battle for Your Brain, Defending the
- 1:53right to think freely in the Age of neurotechnology. Nita, may I call
- 2:00you need to, I want to call your professor or because you've got this
- 2:04pedigree. Thank you for coming down from the great halls of academia to splash
- 2:09in the shallow waters with me today. I loved your book and I read
- 2:15it with tremendous wonder and awe. And then I went back to the closet
- 2:21and I shut off the light and closed the door and just rocked back and
- 2:24forth for about an hour. Right, you know, I have a lot
- 2:29of conversations with my wife Natalie about not turning into my parents. Do you
- 2:35ever have that conversation, like I don't want to turn into my parents?
- 2:38Right? Yes? Yes, Like this new fangl technology. Back in my
- 2:43day, we did it right, So I don't want to be the person
- 2:46resistant to I know the new stuff coming down, new ways of thinking,
- 2:51living our lives, etc. But we're talking about technology that can read minds.
- 3:00Would you even use those words read minds. That isn't what you think
- 3:05your mind is. But yeah, I mean it can I say, read
- 3:07brains, but certainly it can decode a lot of what's happening in the human
- 3:13brain, and depending on the technology, it can even read whatever the mind
- 3:16is. So well, I mean, I know this is a long answer
- 3:21that I'm asking you to give in a short way, but let's talk about
- 3:23brain waves. They act and react in ways that can be measured. Can
- 3:29you sort of let us play in that sandbox as civilians? Yeah, let's
- 3:32do it. So okay. You know, the average person thinks thousands of
- 3:38thoughts per day as they think. Neurons in their brain are firing with any
- 3:45particular thought or brain state. Say you're happy or sad. Hundreds and thousands
- 3:50of neurons are firing in your brain and concurrent patterns, and those patterns of
- 3:57electrical activity in the tiny discharge that they give off can be picked up by
- 4:00brain sensors. Brain sensors are just like the sensors you might have in your
- 4:04Apple watch, or in your ring that you wear that picks up your temperature
- 4:11and your sleep patterns, or your fitbit. But these sensors pick up that
- 4:15electrical activity, and then sophisticated machine learning algorithm so AI can just like it
- 4:21decodes patterns of activity and everything else and translates what those patterns being. Can
- 4:27take those patterns and say, Aha, this pattern of electrical activity means this
- 4:31person is happy or sad, or their mind is wandering or their board or
- 4:34they're engaged, or that is recognition of this particular sequence of numbers, which
- 4:41is their pin number or their home address. And so you know what's happening
- 4:45in your brain, your brain waves, the different waves correspond to this firing
- 4:51of electrical activity in your brain that AI to codes. So I've got an
- 4:57Apple watch, which I'm obsessed with the way I've taken one thousand, five
- 5:00hundred eighty three step today, I don't know, I'm obsessed with we should
- 5:04we do this while walking? Because that's not a lot of steps. Who
- 5:09was the comedian who said that, like she registered to step by drinking a
- 5:12glass of wine in the arm movement, she drank three miles that day.
- 5:16Do I need to think about a future where I'm maybe I'm already in it,
- 5:20where my smart watch is reading more than just my pulse my heart rate,
- 5:26my steps. You know. It's funny is about a week ago I
- 5:30went to my mailbox and a neuroscientist sent me an Apple Watch and asked me
- 5:36to download the application that they've developed that picks up neural activity through your Apple
- 5:43Watch by some algorithm that they've trained on the kind of in between your heartreach
- 5:48or something like that. I don't know exactly how the science works on this,
- 5:50but supposedly it picks up immersion and engagement like you can watch you know,
- 5:56commercials or video and it will, based on the algorithm that has been
- 6:00trained on your Apple Watch, help pick up what your emotional state is from
- 6:05your brain in doing so. Now, I say that, you know,
- 6:08with a grain of salt, because I haven't investigated it. I don't know
- 6:11more than that about it. But the short answer is like, yeah,
- 6:15your Apple Watch is gonna already be able to do that, and then there
- 6:19are sensors that are not yet in your Apple Watch. What your Apple watch
- 6:24has is probably ECG. Are you able to pick up your heart rate and
- 6:27your Apple Watch yes? Yeah, okay, so so then apparently you can
- 6:30measure your brain activity too. But what meta is developing that will be embedded
- 6:36in a watch is they're called EMG sensors electromiography, and electromiography picks up brain
- 6:45activities. It goes from your brain down your arm to your wrist, and
- 6:49when you type or swipe or anything else you do with your hands, those
- 6:55neurons go from your brain down the wrist, and those sensors can pick up
- 7:00your intention to type or swipe, and not just like a general intention like
- 7:06Seth wants to swipe or type, but Seth wants to type, you know,
- 7:11need a fair honey out onto his computer and decode literally the typing of
- 7:16need a fair honey out onto the computer, or any number of things that
- 7:19you might intend to do with your hands, including very private ones. And
- 7:24so the point is, the sensors don't have to be on your head to
- 7:30pick up brain activity because your brain sends signals throughout your body and you can
- 7:34pick up from what's called your peripheral nervous system the signals that are sent out
- 7:39by having sensors on those other parts of your body. All right, So
- 7:43the dystopist, which probably isn't a word, but I'm going to use it
- 7:46as a word. The dystopist in me is starting to panic. But we're
- 7:49going to come back to that. And you brought up it, ay did
- 7:51You went to the closet and rocks for all. Did? But I've now
- 7:55emerged back into the lights so that we can continue our conversation before I get
- 8:00into big tech and meta who you're just brought up and I have in my
- 8:03prep, I want to put that back down and talk about some of the
- 8:07positives. I mean, being able to read brain waves brain activity might help
- 8:13us to screen for certain probably even more than just brain related illnesses, etc.
- 8:20Yes, yeah, far more so. You know, I'm not a
- 8:26lot about this technology, right. I actually think that part of the solution
- 8:33that I propose in this book is to give people a robust right to self
- 8:37determination over their brains and mental experiences. And by that I mean a right
- 8:41to access and to enhance and to change their brains. And that's because we
- 8:46haven't until now taken brain health and wellness as seriously as we have all of
- 8:52the rest of our physical health. You're wearing an Apple watch. You know
- 8:54the number of steps that you've taken today. You can quantify a whole bunch
- 8:58of things about yourself, but you know virtually nothing about your own brain activity
- 9:01other than through your internal software of self reflection, which is probably not that
- 9:05accurate. But you know should you know, for example, when you focus
- 9:11best, or where you focus best, or what time of day is you
- 9:15know better for learning or better for running, better for sleeping, which you
- 9:20know which times you have the most RESTful sleep, and what the right kinds
- 9:24of activities are that enhance your mental performance or your flow state. These are
- 9:31possibilities with brain activity sensors. But for the people who want to go further
- 9:37still, you know epileptics. You know a dear family friend who I called
- 9:43my aunt growing up. She suffered from an epileptic seizure and died because she
- 9:48didn't have advanced warning of the seizure and she choked having you know, thrown
- 9:54up from the seizure. No one was there. If she'd had early warning
- 9:58of that seizure, she would I am sure be here with us today if
- 10:03she died far too young. And with brain sensors, they're tiny electrical changes
- 10:09that happen in the brain before you have a seizure, and already using these
- 10:13consumer wearable devices, researchers are found that minutes to up to an hour before
- 10:18an epileptic seizure, you can find out that a person is about to suffer
- 10:22from that seizure, and that could be life transforming or glioblastoma. I have
- 10:28a friend who passed away from a glioblastoma. John McCain a year from the
- 10:31time he was diagnosed until he died was diagnosed with a glioblastoma. It's a
- 10:37very aggressive form of brain cancer. Most people when they present already have electrical
- 10:43changes that can be detected by EEG, and those electrical changes apparently happen much
- 10:46earlier, and early detection is critical for it actually being something that is treatable.
- 10:54And you would see those tiny electrical changes if you were wearing brain censors
- 10:58in your earbuds and in you know, headphones or in your watch on a
- 11:03daily basis. Maybe not your watch for the for the glioblast emma, but
- 11:05at least in your earbuds and in your headphones or the tiny tattoos behind your
- 11:09ears. So there's a lot of good that can come mental illness, depression,
- 11:15Parkinson's, Alzheimer's disease. Like we could just rattle them all off,
- 11:18and it's promising in your own hands empowered to actually have access to your own
- 11:24brain, health and well being and do something about it. I think that
- 11:28could be a revolutionary The problem is the risk, right, and how we
- 11:31safeguard against the risk to make that happy, optimistic future something that you know
- 11:37is possible to enjoy without living in like the Orwellian dystopian closet that you had
- 11:43to lock yourself into, which is also a very real possibility. From all
- 11:48of this, and the skeptic slash cynic in me does where we I walk
- 11:52outside and just look up and say, hi, Google, right, I
- 11:54mean somebody's watching. I do feel like I live in a survegulance culture and
- 12:00I feel like I'm I'm part of the problem. Would you like to use
- 12:03this platform? And then there's the terms and conditions and it's fifty digital pages
- 12:09in seven point font and I just scrolled at the bottom and click I agree
- 12:13because I'm ready to get to the good stuff. I have no idea what
- 12:18I signed well to treat this ot like you don't have a choice, really,
- 12:22right? I mean you can say I have a choice and that I
- 12:24don't have to use the products, but maybe you need it to do your
- 12:28job or even just the function in society. I think the terms of service
- 12:31have become a joke, right, It's like, oh yeah, let's scroll
- 12:35to the bottom and say, okay, of course I read the seventy pages
- 12:39of the terms of service that just gave away all of my data and personal
- 12:43information in order to be able to run this simple search term. That's idiotic.
- 12:48But more than that, it doesn't have to be the way it is
- 12:50when it comes to our brain data, Like we don't have to allow for
- 12:54the same terms of service that say you have to give away your brain data
- 12:58in order to gain access. That can be a barter that is not legal.
- 13:01And I think with the right that I propose the right to cognitive liberty
- 13:07that should not be part of the terms of service. That it cannot be
- 13:11a bartered for system where you have to give access to your brain data to
- 13:13have access to services. That's an interesting term that you use in the book,
- 13:16and you just use now when I come back to a cognitive liberty.
- 13:20By the way, I'm talking with Nita Farahney. She is author of the
- 13:24book Battle for Your Brain. You mentioned social media meta or I did one
- 13:30of us did? There's some privacy problems I mean, we're talking about there's
- 13:33mismanagement of our private data. You would agree with that, well, I
- 13:41would agree that that might be the understatements of the hour. Yeah, all
- 13:46right, that's a football I'm throwing in your side. On the your side
- 13:48of the field. You just social media and the big texts and all that
- 13:52and privacy, just take that where you want. Yeah, well, I
- 13:56mean so maybe it's like, are we playing the game of which one of
- 14:01these things is not like the other, which is like social media and big
- 14:03tech and privacy. And if it is, then I would say the one
- 14:07that is not like the others is privacy. So, you know, social
- 14:11media, big tech. What they have discovered is that the most valuable thing
- 14:16that they collect about individuals is their personal data and the commodification of that data,
- 14:22selling the data or selling it to advertisers in order to be able to
- 14:24micro target products to people is where the money comes in. There are no
- 14:30such thing as free services. You pay for the service with your data.
- 14:33And we're all familiar with this by now. We understand that we are the
- 14:37product, but most people don't think they have a choice, or I often
- 14:43hear this which is like, yeah, but I got this really gay,
- 14:48great product and my feed and I bought it and I liked it, you
- 14:52know, and so like it's getting better. It giving me exactly the kinds
- 14:56of products that I want. Okay, can buy that, and maybe people
- 15:01are okay with that, or like, I don't have anything to hide,
- 15:03So what am I worried about? Nobody thinks that about their brains. Nobody.
- 15:07I mean, everybody has bad thoughts. Everybody has thoughts that they don't
- 15:11want shared with other people. Everybody you know has had the experience of having
- 15:16a friend be like, do you like this new shirts? And you think,
- 15:20no, no, I don't. I think it is hideous, right,
- 15:24But you're not gonna telegraph that You're gonna of course I like your new
- 15:28shirt. It looks, you know, fantastic on you, or you know,
- 15:31whatever it is. There is a whole private inner monologue, an inner
- 15:37space that we have of mental reprieve, where we can think whatever we want
- 15:41to think. And that is different in kind than the things that we express
- 15:46through our online searches, or through our like buttons, or through our financial
- 15:50transactions or our GPS location data, all of which is at least express behavior.
- 15:54There's still that thing happening on the inside, and that thing is something
- 16:00that social media and tech titans should not by default have access to. That
- 16:06thing. Even if we suddenly have the ability to track our brain health and
- 16:10wellness and well being should not be that we get access to our health and
- 16:14well being in exchange for our privacy of our mental you know, internal form.
- 16:21Oh Nita, I'm I'm guilty. I've got that dark place in my
- 16:25brain that I'm sure everybody has my shirt. I know you were, you
- 16:30were thinking like, okay, yeah, no need, that's a lovely shirt.
- 16:32It was darker. I was going darker. I was giving you the
- 16:36benefit of the doubt. One of my first employers was one of the worst
- 16:41human beings I've ever met, and the way treated people is terrible, And
- 16:44in the dark recesses of my brain, I've fantasized about him having an aneurisk.
- 16:49I mean, I'm not proud of it, right, which is right
- 16:52in that dark moment, you don't really want that, because you wouldn't really
- 16:56want that from anybody, but I get it. You go to these places
- 16:59where you like, you know, what, if you got hit by a
- 17:00truck. I could imagine that for a moment and for a second getting satisfaction
- 17:04of it. You cut me off in traffic, I you know, would
- 17:07I'd like to see you into a ditch? Just for a microsecond, And
- 17:11then the civilized part of my brain takes over. If I can be measured
- 17:15and surveil, would someone say that I am then a danger because I wish
- 17:21harm on another? Is that hyperbole? I mean, so it's hyperbably only
- 17:26in the sense that these devices can't quite do that yet, right, They're
- 17:30not going to pick up the literal thought of like I hope you find yourself
- 17:36in a ditch, But the rage you feel, it's going to get that
- 17:40right, So the rage that discussed, the emotional reaction, A lot of
- 17:45that kind of stuff can already be decoded right now. And frankly, you
- 17:49know, we do a pretty good job of putting on our civil hat and
- 17:56keeping those feelings in check. You know, you get home your spouse.
- 18:03Here's a good one. Yesterday, my spouse was supposed to tell our caregiver
- 18:10to pick up our child from school because she had a half day of school.
- 18:14Twelve thirty. I get a call from her school and they were like,
- 18:19hey, there, your daughter's here. You know, nobody picked her
- 18:25up. Well, of course he forgot to tell the caregiver to pick her
- 18:27up. What did I feel? I felt rage, right, And you
- 18:33know, then I went to go pick up my child because I had to,
- 18:36you know, kind of drop everything to go get her. Our caregiver
- 18:37was taking care of our other child who was asleep. And did I want
- 18:42my daughter to know that I was feeling read No, I wanted her to
- 18:48experience only like her loving, happy mother, delighted to see her, pick
- 18:52her up and take her home and then get back to work. We do
- 18:56this all the time. We have a lot going on inside that we choose
- 19:00not to express outside intentionally because it helps us to navigate the world, but
- 19:06it also allows us to decide what we're sharing in with whom. And you
- 19:11know, do I want telegraphed to my daughter rage when while I want her
- 19:15to experience is love? Absolutely not right? We get to decide with whom
- 19:18and when and under what circumstances we share that. If I could, at
- 19:22the same time have transmitted just by text message from rage to my partner,
- 19:26I would have been okay with that. That's right, But you know again,
- 19:30it's it's about the choices It's about being able to decide what's happening on
- 19:37the inside and with whom you share it and under what circumstances. That's got
- 19:41to be up to us. That's fundamental to what it means to be human.
- 19:45Well, back to big tech and the corporations and whatnot. The industry
- 19:49of outrage. If they can see my buttons, if I'm broadcasting my buttons,
- 19:55here's what they are, here's where they are. All they have to
- 19:57do is push them rand it's outrage for click. Somebody gets paid, they
- 20:02get more scroll time. I mean, people have weaponized outrage in that way.
- 20:07Yes, yeah, yeah, I worry a lot about this. Right,
- 20:10we're not talking just about reading the brain. We're talking about writing to
- 20:12the brain. And that doesn't have to be through a device that's literally hooked
- 20:15up to your brain. So you know, Meta has announced its neural interface
- 20:21Watch is going to launch in early twenty twenty five, and it's going to
- 20:25be integrated with WhatsApp and Instagram, and that means like the same company that
- 20:30can read your brain activity is also giving you the environments in which you're interacting
- 20:34with, right, and it can pick up like okay, I need to
- 20:37change the feed ever so much and the features ever so much because I'm not
- 20:41getting the right rage based reaction, which brings this person over and again back
- 20:45to the same environment. It's a closed loop system of being able to both
- 20:49read and change what you are interacting with and do that at scale, right
- 20:53understand how people are reacting much more precisely, and then being able to manipulate
- 21:00the technology and the platforms and the social media that we consume and the way
- 21:03it's structured and the algorithms that decide what's on the for you and what comes
- 21:08next. That's a frightening world because it's already something that's happening a lot in
- 21:15social media, which is it's it's designed with technology, it's designed with features
- 21:21meant to, you know, be clickbait to tap into our brain heuristics,
- 21:26our cognitive biases. Most of that's based on the assumption of how you're going
- 21:30to react quickly and not think critically and become addicted to technology. But when
- 21:34you can literally see it right, you're the company who can collect the brain
- 21:38data and much more precisely calibrate your technology to achieve those goals. That concerns
- 21:45me deeply, That left me in the closet for a while, but then
- 21:48I had to write a book, so I came out. Yes, our
- 21:52moment in the sun right here. Yes, beyond the outrage for clicks,
- 21:57what about the construction of an alternate reality? I mean that plays into conspiracystem
- 22:03the anti scientist. If the algorithms are feeding on each other, and before
- 22:07you know what, you live in a world that may not actually exist.
- 22:10Right? Have you read the Anomaly? No? Should? I is it
- 22:15terrifying? Like it's so it's so so good, it's so good. Um,
- 22:22I'll leave it there. I'll say everybody should read it. I thought
- 22:25it was fantastically okay, the anomaly, but okay, So who knows where
- 22:32we're going with VR? Right um, right now? The headsets are pretty
- 22:36heavy, they're cumbersome. The bandwidth, the computing bandwidth, isn't large enough
- 22:41to really enable enough people to be in there. The game still feel a
- 22:45little bit like you're, you know, in Disney World rather than in the
- 22:49real world when you're inside of them. But the hope in the ambition for
- 22:53the whole XR world is to really enable us to have these virtual worlds in
- 23:00which we spend much more time interacting and those virtual worlds are most of them
- 23:07the VR headsets, whether it's Galaia from you know, Microsoft, or any
- 23:11of these other technologies Oculus, it's you know, the meta one they're they're
- 23:18trying to embed both sensors that pick up everything from facial you know, changes,
- 23:22eye tracking, but also neural sensors that pick up your brain activity both
- 23:27at the head and all the wrist as the way you interesce with these other
- 23:32technologies and when you layer onto that generative AI that can construct and reconstruct,
- 23:40I worry about not only the brain's perception in those environments, but the ability
- 23:47to easily manipulate the brain because you know, as they say, perception is
- 23:49reality. You can continuously change your perception in ways that manipulate the brain.
- 23:55And here's here's one that terrifies me. So deep fakes, right, deep
- 24:00fakes are getting better and better as you know, or worse and worse,
- 24:03depending on how you want to characterize it. And it turns out that you
- 24:10know, you could take a person's face, like a politician's face, and
- 24:14with generative AI subtly change it, you know, tell the algorithm like make
- 24:18this picture of you pick your least favorite politician subtly different, so that it
- 24:26would be imperceptible by the human eye that you made any changes, even to
- 24:30the person themselves. But make it so that the changes lead a human to
- 24:36trust that person more and to trust what they're saying more. And it would
- 24:40make tiny changes to you know, the way their eyes moved, the kind
- 24:44of curl of their lips, the symmetry of their face, and you wouldn't
- 24:47be able to tell, but it would trigger greater trust in your brain.
- 24:52That's terrifying when you think about the precise ways in which you can manipulate human
- 24:59brain through changing the constructive environment that they're operating in. That's interesting. I've
- 25:04always thought about the more grand or overt deep fakes, which terrify me.
- 25:11Right, all you need is a world leader saying in a deep fake that
- 25:17they declare war on another nation. Right if somebody wants, some terrorist was
- 25:22able to weaponize that technology, but that may be even scarier. All you
- 25:26need is the tiniest little nudge one way or the other to engender or whatever
- 25:32trust. Let's talk about smart cap technologies. I didn't know this existed until
- 25:38I read about it in your book. I'll just throw it out there.
- 25:41What is smart Cap? Yeah? You know. One of the things I
- 25:45will say is that even neuroscientists who are deep in this field read the book
- 25:51and they're like, oh my god, I didn't know that that was happening,
- 25:53right, I didn't know that that existed. It's part of why I
- 25:56wrote it, right, is to like, we need somewhere where all of
- 25:59this is docunted. But smart Cap has been around for more than a decade.
- 26:02Their company out of Australia. They were I think bought by another company
- 26:06maybe out of Japan, that have been selling to companies worldwide what they call
- 26:12their lifeband technology. It's basically a headband that can be put into a baseball
- 26:18cap or a hard hat or train conductor's cap, which have these brain censors
- 26:22that I've been talking about the pick up the electrical activity in the brain.
- 26:26But they've been selling it to companies to monitor employees for fatigue levels. And
- 26:32you know, I'll say this, which is as creepy as that sounds,
- 26:34they have attempted to do this as absolutely responsibly as they possibly can, which
- 26:38is the data that they collect from the brain is on device only. It's
- 26:44not transmitted to the cloud. Or you know, the not mind for other
- 26:48data, and then it's overwritten on device, meaning that what you could do
- 26:52is mind that data to learn a whole bunch more information from the employees than
- 26:56they otherwise do. They're using an algorithm that just extracts fatigue level on a
- 27:00score of one to five and then gives that information both to the employee to
- 27:03tell them whether they need to take a break, but also to the managers
- 27:07and you know, kind of command central so that they can know whether the
- 27:11person is dangerously tired or awake. And I would say, if I had
- 27:15to design the technology in a way that would be the least intrusive, it
- 27:19would do all of those things. It would keep the data on device,
- 27:25it would not transmit it anywhere else, it would overwrite the raw brainwave data,
- 27:30and it would only use the extracted feature of fatigue levels in a score
- 27:33of one to five that you would ideally only give to the individual, not
- 27:36also give to the employer. But other companies can do exactly the same thing,
- 27:41and instead of overwriting it on device, they can send that data with
- 27:45rich what I call raw brainwave data, the kind of full spectrum of information
- 27:51from the brain, which then could be mined for much more than just are
- 27:53they tired or awake. So a long distance interstate truck driver is he's been
- 28:00at a too long, his vision is blurry, he shouldn't be behind the
- 28:03wheel. An employer would be able to know that remotely using this headband.
- 28:08Yeah, and you know, I should say there's already a lot of tracking
- 28:14features that are in trucks to do this or in cars to do this.
- 28:17Many people have driver assist technology in their cars that try to predict whether or
- 28:22not they're sleepy or awake by doing things like cameras and centers that look at
- 28:26the road and try to see whether you know, the way your car is
- 28:32shifting relative to the lines on the road suggests that you are starting to get
- 28:36tired, or the way your hands are moving the wheels suggests that you're starting
- 28:41to get tired, or more intrusively, for truck drivers, a lot of
- 28:44times there's in cab cameras that are literally trained on the person's face and can
- 28:48see inside of the entire cabin remotely can be monitored by managers to see far
- 28:55more than whether they're tired or awake. But the same idea these sensors are
- 29:00being used for truck drivers to monitor whether they're tired or awake, and they're
- 29:03being sent in real time back to command center. So it's a piece of
- 29:07information which I say, and I kind of provide as an example in the
- 29:11book, which is the right to mental privacy. Any privacy interest is not
- 29:15absolute, and we've never recognized individuals is having absolute right to privacy. And
- 29:21that's true, I think when it comes to mental privacy too, just different
- 29:25than freedom of thought that we can talk about. And so it's an example
- 29:29I've given the book to say, like maybe done right. Maybe you know,
- 29:33for a commercial driver where lives are at stake and the only thing that
- 29:36you're trying to figure out from them is if they're tired or awake, maybe
- 29:40they don't have such a strong interest and you know, whether they're falling asleep
- 29:44at the wheels they're driving a forty ton truck down the freeway. And that
- 29:48might be the kind of instance in which we think it's okay for the kind
- 29:52of surveillance of brain activity. What happens when governments decide they want to scan
- 29:59the population looking for dissent that's terrifying. We're going to talk about it next,
- 30:12don't forget my second podcast, short form five minute true stories about all
- 30:19kinds of fun, fascinating, and sometimes alarming stuff. Go to True Stories
- 30:26podcast dot com or just subscribe to True Stories with Sath Andrews on all major
- 30:30podcast apps. Talking here with Professor Nita Farah Honey. She is author of
- 30:38the book The Battle for Your Brain, Defending the right to think freely in
- 30:42the age of neurotechnology. My first thought when I hear about headbands that can
- 30:48read brain waves is this sounds like Christmas for totalitarian regimes. Governments would love
- 30:56to be able to monitor their people to age dissent, right, I mean,
- 31:03you've spoken, you've written about this kind of thing, so I mean
- 31:07I'm running an American. My first thoughts in most of this was this is
- 31:14terrifying in the hands of an authoritarian regime. And with all of my extended
- 31:19family in Iran, who are afraid to speak, who've been subject to significant
- 31:25persecution themselves over time, who every time I've ever talked with them, are
- 31:29afraid to ever say any dissident word against the government for fear of surveillance.
- 31:34I've often thought like, Okay, well, what if literally their thoughts could
- 31:38be read by the government, and it turns out that you know, it's
- 31:44not something you have to imagine. It's already happening in China, where you
- 31:48know, train conductors and factory workers and even students in classrooms or required to
- 31:53where brain censors and the brain censors are being monitored not just by you know,
- 31:59the employers, but by the state. And okay, forgive me,
- 32:01I must energet quickly. This is happening now. We're not talking about some
- 32:06theoretical future scenario. This is going on. Okay, this is literally right
- 32:10now, all right, people are wearing that China has employees wearing brain monitoring
- 32:16devices right now, right now. Okay, I mean I don't know if
- 32:21this second, because I think I got you. No, no, no,
- 32:22in the contempor in this cultural moment. It's going on, in this
- 32:28cultural moment. It's going on in this cultural moment. Workers are required to
- 32:31wear brain censers in China, and in this moment, there are even reports
- 32:37that people who are required to wear brain censors their brains are being interrogated by
- 32:44showing them, for example, images or political propaganda from the Communist Party and
- 32:49seeing how their brain reacts to that. And that's today. This isn't like
- 32:54we don't have to imagine or really in future. It's it's happening. It's
- 32:59arrived at least in China, and there are law enforcements offices across the world
- 33:04where criminal suspects are being brought into interrogation rooms and their brains are being interrogated
- 33:09by requiring that they put on neural sensors brain sensors while they're shown different images
- 33:15of crime scene details to see whether or not their brain signal recognition and response
- 33:20to memories. This is not science fiction. This is not some movie called
- 33:23Minority Report. This is today, happening across the world. And the question,
- 33:30I mean, the reason I wrote this book is both to sound the
- 33:32alarm, like hey, everybody, wake up, this is happening, but
- 33:37also it's a moment before because this is happening, but it's not happening at
- 33:40scale across the world. All the tech titans are at the table. They're
- 33:44all coming forward with products that are embedding these brain sensors into our earbuds and
- 33:49watches and headbands and tattoos and everything else. But it hasn't hit the mass
- 33:53market just yet. Right, It's coming all within the next couple of years,
- 34:00which means we could do things differently before then, we could make some
- 34:02smart choices so that we're looking at a future where you know, in the
- 34:07same way that you're comfortably wearing your Apple Watch, you're comfortably wearing your brain
- 34:12censors without worrying about living in a totalitarian or welling in nightmare and not because
- 34:17you've been normalized and lulled into, you know, believing that it's okay when
- 34:22it's not, because it actually would be okay in that world. I'm stuck
- 34:27on tattoos. I'm sorry, did you say tattoos. Tattoos? Yeah,
- 34:34wearable tattoos. Think like think like a little flexible clear bandage that you could
- 34:39just put right behind your ear that is has sensors and makes really good contact
- 34:45with your skin. Wearable tattoos that you know could be worn there and could
- 34:51be worn you know, kind of in the back of the head and places
- 34:52where you could touch your scalp directly. There are these wearable tattoos that allow
- 34:57you to have the sensors directly on your skin rather than having to wear some
- 35:00other device that the sensors are embedded into. So you think, I'm We're
- 35:06coming to a point where I could say, call my wife. I could
- 35:08just think that and and my wife would be called on some device. I
- 35:15mean I just think, think the thought without doing anything. Yeah, you
- 35:19might think, hey, Siri, call my wife. I'm not sure how
- 35:23I feel about that. Right? Can we reverse the streams in the future.
- 35:29I know this is speculation, but if brain waves can be read,
- 35:32can they be altered? Right? Can somebody reverse those streams? And not
- 35:37to be against seth we're here today is hacking the brain. It's hacking hacking,
- 35:44right, I mean so yes, they're already stimulation devices. Some of
- 35:47the sensors are already two ways. The implanted devices can already read and write
- 35:52to the brain. I give an example of a good positive use just to
- 35:55make you feel a little bit better for moments, right, which is there
- 36:00was a patient named Sarah who that's a code name, but who you know.
- 36:05She described herself as really being terminal with depression, that she no longer
- 36:12had a life worth living, that she was at the end of the line,
- 36:15and she had tried all of the conventional treatments, all of them had
- 36:17failed, and researchers and scientists and her clinicians were able to implant electrodes into
- 36:27her brain and to trace the electrical signals when she was the most symptomatic,
- 36:35and then like a pacemaker inside the brain, they could as that firing happened,
- 36:40stimulate the activity in her brains such that interrupted that pattern. She wouldn't
- 36:47continue to have those same symptoms, and it has literally cured her of addiction.
- 36:53She now has a normal range of emotions. But that's writing to the
- 36:57brain through electrical stimulation of the brain. And you know that's the positive use
- 37:01case, right, I mean, in the same I was thinking about another
- 37:06positive example that just popped into my head. Forgive the interruption, but that's
- 37:08it's because I stimulated it. Unlike a child, you know, I'm sitting
- 37:12at the edge of the table going pick me. Yeah, but being able
- 37:15to like amputees with the artificial limbs, right, they're able to think,
- 37:21I would like to move my fingers. Yeah, yeah, exactly. And
- 37:24you know, right now there's only about forty people who have this implanted neuro
- 37:29technology because it's difficult to get it into the brain, to not have it
- 37:32cause infection, to not cause brain damage on the way into embedding electrodes,
- 37:37and so there are companies like Cognition that I write about in the book,
- 37:40who are trying to develop ar headsets that are embedded with electrodes that enable,
- 37:45for example, an als patient who can no longer communicate through you ordinary speech
- 37:52or move to be able to use their brain activity to do that, to
- 37:59speak, to stimulate um, you know, movements, to move a wheelchair,
- 38:05to turn lights on and off. And writing to the brain has also
- 38:07been used for enhancement purposes, so people use transcranial direct current stimulation, which
- 38:13you know kind of speeds up the firing of the neurons and the prefrontal cortex.
- 38:17It's been used for a long time in the military by athletes when they're
- 38:22training because it can enhance and reinforce learning. It's been used in a lot
- 38:28of different contexts to write to the brain. But of course, you know,
- 38:31we can go to the scary place if you want to go to the
- 38:34scary place, which is if you know, I can choose to write to
- 38:37my own brain, or if I have implanted electrodes that you know, I
- 38:43use as a pacemaker for the brain to you know, control the symptoms of
- 38:46depression. Could you also induce depression or induce pain or induce thoughts. Yeah,
- 38:53hacker could do that, right, A hacker could hack into the technology
- 38:58and could you know, precisely stimulate the brains and ways that could be deeply
- 39:01problematic, and you know, kind of the scary I guess all of this
- 39:07is scary. The scarier side of that is, you know, the fact
- 39:12that there's this kind of declaration that the human domain is the sixth domain of
- 39:17warfare, and the countries are racing to develop weapons that are kind of purported
- 39:23brain control weapons. And that's not just influence campaigns like using TikTok. It
- 39:29is literally the development of weapons to try to disable and disorient brains. So
- 39:37you know, there's some frightening possibilities ahead given the misuse of the technology that
- 39:45is already occurring and that could occur in the future, like an EMP for
- 39:49the mind. That's fascinating. You don't have to answer this, but since
- 39:52I've got you, I mean, I got pissed off and I read about
- 39:57Elon Musk and the Narrowlink monkeys and all that kind of do you follow any
- 40:00of the you're a bioethicis do you get into the experiments they're doing on animals
- 40:05with these neurolinth things. Yes, I do. I mean, I've been
- 40:08following all of the implanted neurotechnology companies very closely, and especially Elon Musk,
- 40:14because once Elon Musk is in the misks, you know, brings a ton
- 40:16of attention both to the field but also in some ways you hope that,
- 40:22you know, his kind of approach, if you might call it, that
- 40:27might drive the field forward. But you know, you can't move fast and
- 40:34break things when you're talking about experimentation with people and with non human primates,
- 40:42and you can't rush through implanting neurotechnology and doing so without care for animals and
- 40:51you know, treating animals and you know, instrumenting them in ways that you
- 40:57know doesn't wait for one at a time to find out what's happening in order
- 41:01to safeguard both animals during the research process, but also just the responsible progress
- 41:07of scientific research at all. So I've been disturbed by the reports to say
- 41:13the least. I think it's not a good or responsible way to do science.
- 41:17And at the same time, you know, I'm like Pollyanna, like
- 41:22I still wish that the nanotainers that Elizabeth Holmes was talking about were real and
- 41:29that you know, we had that technology, and I still wish and hope
- 41:32that the ability to use robotic surgery to have tiny, you know, hair
- 41:37like threads that enable implanting neurotechnology and enable people with paralysis and neurodegenerative diseases to
- 41:46be re enabled might come true one day. So there's a part of me
- 41:51that really hopes it all works out in the end, but is deeply disconcerted
- 41:54by what we hear from reports coming out of Neuralink. It's messy. I
- 42:00mean that's probably a way to some it's just freaking messy. You've been so
- 42:04generous with your time. I'm almost done, but I got a couple more
- 42:07real fast. You mentioned Minority Report, one of my favorite films. There's
- 42:10a great scene where John Anderton walks in after he's had an eye transplant.
- 42:15He's in a mall and his retina is just scanned by some sensor on a
- 42:21wall and it says welcome. And this is certainly the case with facial recognition
- 42:27technology, and some people have taken to wearing masks. I saw an article
- 42:32that was posted by the Civil Liberties Union in Europe, and the article was
- 42:37titled anti facial recognition masks accessories of the future. Do I have the right
- 42:44to not be seen or scanned in public? Yeah? You see us walking
- 42:47around with preventatives, you know, some kind of a prophylactic against being scans
- 42:53in this world. So to do this a little tongue in cheek with you,
- 43:00which is you know the I thought maybe as something to hand out with
- 43:07my book, I might have like little nerves security caps, like tinfoil lined
- 43:12baseball caps from for people to wear. Who are really I've thought about I
- 43:16make fun of the tinfoil hat crowd, But after reading your book, I
- 43:21thought, how much foil do I have? And how often do I have
- 43:22to change it? Out? Right? Right? So I mean I think
- 43:27it'll be simpler than that, which is, I think, you know,
- 43:30for for the tinfoil community, they can just choose not to wear the sensors,
- 43:37And for me, I hope that that's what self determination includes. I
- 43:40hope that's what cognitive liberty includes. I worry, especially in the context of
- 43:45work, of people being required to wear brain sensors and having very little choice
- 43:50in that context and having to do so. So I think it I don't
- 43:55know of any technology today that enables remote monitoring of the brain. It still
- 44:02requires some contact of some sensor that is applied to the body in order for
- 44:08that detection to occur. And I think, you know, the right to
- 44:10cognitive liberty should include the right to choose not to wear any of that technology,
- 44:15or to use that technology, or to have it be necessary to interact
- 44:19with other technology. That may be difficult to achieve in a world in which
- 44:22it becomes the universal controller to all of the rest of our technology, in
- 44:25which case we will need some kinds of countermeasures, whether that's on off switches
- 44:30to be able to take a conference call without having my brain activity monitored at
- 44:34the same time, or you know, having a baseball cap with tinfoil around
- 44:39it that has lots of interference with the brain activity measurements that are happening at
- 44:44the same time. People will find a way to be able to have an
- 44:46off switch for the brain activity monitoring if it's in multifunctional devices. To bring
- 44:52us full circle, let's explore the term cognitive liberty. You see this as
- 44:58something that like a human and rights law or series of laws that should be
- 45:01enacted. Yeah, so I see it as a new right which really directs
- 45:07us to update existing international human rights, so it encompasses a bundle of existing
- 45:13human rights. Those rights are the rights of privacy, which needs to be
- 45:16explicitly updated to include mental privacy, the right to freedom of thought, which
- 45:22is already a human right, but it has primarily been interpreted to apply to
- 45:27freedom of religion and belief, and it needs to be extended to apply to
- 45:32the right not to have your thoughts read and punished and manipulated. And the
- 45:37right to self determination, which has been understood as a collective and a political
- 45:42right, but needs to be updated as a basic and fundamental individual right to
- 45:46self determination, particularly over our brains, to mental experiences. And I think
- 45:51the best way to do that is by recognizing it is an international human rights
- 45:58by like the Human Rights Committee that over sees the International and Civil the ICCPR,
- 46:04which implements the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. But even just as a
- 46:07norm right, even as a cultural, social and political norm, it has
- 46:13power and effect. And so I think we need to demand that cognitive liberty
- 46:19be the way in which we operate in the digital age to give people those
- 46:22rights over their brains and mental experiences. And I hope we can codify it
- 46:27into law, so that it has both the legal enforceability and the power of
- 46:32the norm across the globe. Read need a Farah Honey's book The Battle for
- 46:38Your Brain, which I will link in the description box. You have been
- 46:44a tremendous interview and a lot of fun to talk to. We move forward
- 46:46with caution and optimism. Would that be a fair way to say? Do
- 46:51you have caution and optimism? I have a lot of caution and well,
- 46:59I mean you seems optimism. No, I have both. I mean I
- 47:04believe I have not. Actually, I believe that this can be incredibly empowering
- 47:09if we get it right. My cynicism only comes as to whether or not
- 47:14people will mobilize to the call to action to get it right. And so
- 47:17I would say, join the call to action, join the battle for your
- 47:21brain, so that we can all be optimistic about the future together. Professor
- 47:25Nita Farahney, thanks again for talking to me. Thank you, it's been
- 47:30a pleasure. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive
- 47:35of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist
- 47:39logo, blinks to Atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free Thon
- 47:45events and conventions. Log on to our website, The Thinking Atheist dot com