Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Separate Growth CapEx From Survival Cost
Transcript
- 0:00So let's unpack A frustration that trips up pretty much every
- 0:04investor at some point, no matter how long you've been
- 0:06doing. This.
- 0:06Oh yeah, I know exactly the one you're talking.
- 0:08About you find a company and on paper the numbers just look
- 0:12great. Net profit is climbing, the PE
- 0:14ratio looks cheap. You know, and screaming value.
- 0:17And yet the stock price is just flat.
- 0:20Utterly flat. Worse, the company keeps saying
- 0:23year after year that they can't pay a dividend or buy back
- 0:26shares because they're quote, reinvesting.
- 0:29It's the classic question, isn't it?
- 0:30The company is so profitable, why is there never any cash?
- 0:33Why is the stock dead money? Exactly.
- 0:35And the source material we've been digging into for this deep
- 0:38dive really pinpoints the vanishing act that reported
- 0:41profit. It's disappearing into something
- 0:44called capital expenditure or CapEx.
- 0:47Right, The company is definitely spending the money.
- 0:49The trick is figuring out what they're spending it on.
- 0:52Are they spending it to make you more money in the future or are
- 0:54they just spending it to survive?
- 0:56And that is our mission for today's Deep Dive.
- 0:59We want to give you the analytical tool to answer that
- 1:02exact question. We have to stop looking at total
- 1:05CapEx as just one single number on a spreadsheet.
- 1:09You have to dissect it. You have to learn how to tell
- 1:12the difference between the money spent just for maintenance, you
- 1:15know, the cost of survival, and the money spent for actual real
- 1:19growth. Once you can do that, you can
- 1:21spot the true cash machines. And separate them from the ones
- 1:23whose profits are, well, kind of a mirage.
- 1:27It's a critical insight that just fundamentally changes how
- 1:30you value a business. It really does.
- 1:32Now, before we jump into the mechanics, a quick reminder.
- 1:34This analysis is all based on publicly available sources.
- 1:37It's purely for education purposes, not investment advice.
- 1:40Always, always do your own homework.
- 1:42And if you're interested in keeping an eye on the bigger
- 1:44picture, you know the overall market temperature, you can
- 1:47search for it and download our iOS App Buffett Indicator right
- 1:50from the Apple App Store. It's a great tool for tracking
- 1:53the key metrics that value investors watch.
- 1:55OK, let's start simple. Before we even open a financial
- 1:58statement, let's use an analogy to really ground this concept.
- 2:01Let's just forget spreadsheets for a second and think about a
- 2:03really simple business like a small taxi company.
- 2:06Perfect starting point, simple business model.
- 2:08The car makes the money, right? The taxi itself, that's your
- 2:11main revenue generating asset. But here's the thing, that asset
- 2:14starts degrading the second you drive it off the lot.
- 2:18Every single mile adds wear and tear.
- 2:21So if you as the owner want that car to be working just as well
- 2:24next year to bring in the same amount of money, you have to
- 2:28spend cash. You need new tires, oil changes,
- 2:31eventually, you know, maybe a new transmission and.
- 2:33That right there is the heart of maintenance CapEx.
- 2:36It is money you absolutely must spend.
- 2:38It's mandatory just to keep the business running at its current
- 2:41level. If you skip it, what happens?
- 2:43The asset falls apart and your ability to make money shrinks.
- 2:47It is a necessary cost of doing business.
- 2:48It feels like a cost, even though accounting rules let you
- 2:51capitalize it instead of expensing it all at once.
- 2:54And that's the little accounting trick, isn't it?
- 2:56That capitalization is why the reported net profit can look so
- 3:00good. The full cost of keeping the
- 3:02business alive hasn't hit the profit and loss statement
- 3:05immediately. Precisely so the profits look
- 3:08higher than the, let's say, the true economic reality.
- 3:11OK, so now contrast that mandatory spending with spending
- 3:15by choice. Your taxi business is doing
- 3:18great and you decide to take your profits and buy a second
- 3:21taxi, a brand new one. Now that's a deliberate choice
- 3:23to expand. You're spending money with the
- 3:25specific goal of making more money next year.
- 3:28That is growth CapEx. That's a real discretionary
- 3:30investment. So we've got these two
- 3:32completely different things, maintenance CapEx and growth
- 3:35CapEx. Different animals.
- 3:35And they're both just lumped together under one line item on
- 3:38the financial statements, total CapEx.
- 3:41One is the cost to survive, the other is an investment to grow.
- 3:44And the big challenge for you as an analyst is that companies
- 3:46only report the total. They don't break it down for
- 3:49you. They don't say, you know, this
- 3:50much was for oil changes, this much was for the second taxi.
- 3:53Which brings us right to the hard part.
- 3:55First, where do we find that total number?
- 3:57And 2nd, how do we even begin to split it apart?
- 4:01OK. So finding the total is the easy
- 4:02part. You go to the cash flow
- 4:04statement, look for the section called cash flows from investing
- 4:06activities. You're looking for a line.
- 4:09It's almost always a negative number because it's cash going
- 4:11out and it'll say something like cash page for the acquisition of
- 4:14fixed assets or tangible assets. That number that's your total
- 4:18CapEx for the period. So once we have that total, we
- 4:21need a way to estimate the maintenance part.
- 4:24And for a long, long time, the standard shortcut, the one
- 4:27analysts have always used, was to look at a different number,
- 4:30depreciation and amortization, or DNA.
- 4:34And this is a really crucial distinction.
- 4:36We are using an accounting expense DNA which you find on
- 4:39the income statement as a kind of proxy for a cash expense
- 4:42maintenance CapEx. OK, what's the logic there?
- 4:45The logic is simple. It's almost seductively simple.
- 4:47Depreciation is the non cash charge that represents the asset
- 4:51losing value from wear and tear each year.
- 4:53So the theory goes, if you spend an amount of cash equal to that
- 4:58depreciation. You've basically cancelled out
- 5:00the wear and tear. You've kept your assets in their
- 5:01original condition. That's the idea, yeah.
- 5:04So the simple formula that comes from this is growth CapEx equals
- 5:07your total CapEx from the cash flow statement minus
- 5:10depreciation and amortization from the income statement.
- 5:12Can you walk us through a quick example?
- 5:14Sure. Let's say a factory reports
- 5:16total CapEx of say 100 million and their DNA for the year is 80
- 5:20million. The simple logic would suggest
- 5:22that 80 million of that was just to fix the old machines.
- 5:26That's your estimated maintenance CapEx.
- 5:28Which means only 20 million was leftover for real growth for
- 5:31buying new machines. Exactly.
- 5:33And if that 20 million is tiny compared to the companies net
- 5:35profit, that's a huge red flag, right?
- 5:37Yeah. Okay, that shortcut seems really
- 5:40useful, at least as a first pass screening tool.
- 5:42Let's you see if a companies even trying to grow.
- 5:45But I feel a butt coming. A very big butt.
- 5:49As soon as we introduce the real world, specifically a little
- 5:52thing called inflation, that simple equation just starts to
- 5:54fall apart. It becomes a major liability.
- 5:57This is where the deep dive really gets interesting, isn't
- 5:59it it? Is because that simple DNA
- 6:01shortcut is built on a massive hidden flaw.
- 6:04And the flaw is that it assumes the cost to replace an old
- 6:08machine is the same as its original cost, which is what
- 6:11depreciation is based on. Exactly.
- 6:14DNA is calculated based on the historical cost, what the
- 6:17company paid for that machine 10, maybe 20 years ago.
- 6:20The real world doesn't work like that.
- 6:22Let's go back to the taxi. Perfect.
- 6:24So you bought that taxi 10 years ago for let's say $20,000.
- 6:28You're depreciating it at $2000 a year.
- 6:29That $2000 is your DNA. OK, but if you go to a
- 6:33dealership today to replace that 10 year old taxi with an
- 6:35identical new one, well due to inflation that same car might
- 6:39cost you $30,000 now. So the $2000 DNA figure on your
- 6:44books dramatically understates the real cash you actually have
- 6:47to spend. Year after year has to stay in
- 6:48the same in place. Your real required maintenance
- 6:51CapEx is way higher than what DNA is telling you.
- 6:54And for any asset heavy industry, we're talking
- 6:56railways, airlines, utilities, heavy manufacturing, this
- 7:00inflation trap is everything. It's why the reported earnings
- 7:03can look fantastic, but the actual cash flow available to
- 7:06the owners is basically 0. Because they're on a treadmill,
- 7:09they're constantly just pouring money into maintenance to fight
- 7:13the rising cost of replacing their old equipment.
- 7:15It's a battle they can't win just by spending their
- 7:17depreciation allowance. OK.
- 7:19Let's really connect this to the real world then.
- 7:21If you see a big railway company, one with massive
- 7:24physical assets that lasts for decades and they are only
- 7:28spending an amount on CapEx that's equal to their DNA,
- 7:32what's really happening? They're not maintaining their
- 7:34status. They are, in real economic
- 7:36terms, shrinking. It's a form of financial delayed
- 7:39maintenance. They are letting their assets
- 7:41slowly degrade because they aren't spending enough cash to
- 7:44replace them at today's prices. So they're either taking on debt
- 7:47to make up the difference, or they're just kicking a giant
- 7:50repair bill down the road for the next management team to deal
- 7:53with. The implication here is huge.
- 7:55It means those companies reported net profits are
- 7:58basically a work of fiction. They're inflated, inflated by
- 8:02the fact they are under reporting the true real world
- 8:05cash cost of simply staying in business.
- 8:08The true economic profit, the cash that's actually available
- 8:12to you as an investor, is much, much lower than what the income
- 8:15statement shows. Which forces us to move beyond
- 8:17that simple formula. If DNA is flawed, especially
- 8:21when there's inflation, what's a bitter tool?
- 8:23How can we estimate the true maintenance CapEx?
- 8:26Right, because we can't just call up management and force
- 8:28them to use what's called replacement cost accounting,
- 8:30even though that would be the most honest way.
- 8:32So we have to find some kind of external benchmark.
- 8:35Exactly 1 of the better methods is to look at historical
- 8:38industry data. You find similar successful
- 8:40companies in the same sector, the ones that have clearly
- 8:43maintained and even grown their assets over decades, and you
- 8:46calculate their capital intensity.
- 8:48How? Do you do that?
- 8:49You measure their historical total CapEx as a percentage of
- 8:52their total revenue and and you do it over a long period, like
- 8:5510 years to smooth things out. I see.
- 8:58So that's a great approach because you're not relying on
- 9:00the company's internal historical accounting, you're
- 9:03creating an external real world metric based on what it actually
- 9:08costs to compete in that industry.
- 9:10Precisely. So if you find that historically
- 9:14successful railway companies have to spend say 12% of the
- 9:17revenue on CapEx just to stay competitive and the company
- 9:21you're looking at is only spending 8%.
- 9:23That 4% difference is likely chronic underinvestment.
- 9:26It's delayed maintenance CapEx. It shifts the question from what
- 9:29did the accountant write down to what does it actually cost in
- 9:32cash today to run this type of business?
- 9:35You're setting a realistic floor for maintenance CapEx based on
- 9:38industry reality. So OK, let's tie this all
- 9:40together. What does this all mean for you,
- 9:42the person listening when you're trying to make better financial
- 9:44decisions? It means you have to shift your
- 9:46focus completely. The most important question is
- 9:48not how much net profit did they report.
- 9:51The question is what is the economic purpose of their
- 9:53capital deployment? You have to break down that
- 9:55CapEx number. If a company is sinking almost
- 9:58all of its cash flow into just keeping up with inflated
- 10:01maintenance costs, it's not an investment, It's a treadmill.
- 10:04And that stock is dead money until something changes.
- 10:07And this leads us directly to the only number that really
- 10:10matters to an owner, which is true free cash flow.
- 10:13We have to define that correctly, right?
- 10:15True free cash flow is the cash that's really truly available
- 10:18for things like dividends, paying down debt, or actual
- 10:21expansion. And to calculate it, you must
- 10:23subtract the real maintenance CapEx, the money that is not
- 10:27discretionary, from the company's operating cash flow.
- 10:30And if you just use the reported DNA number as your maintenance
- 10:32figure in an inflationary asset heavy business?
- 10:35You are almost guaranteed to wildly overstate that company's
- 10:38true free cash flow. This kind of deeper analysis
- 10:41pulls you out of the trap of just looking at the reported
- 10:43numbers and forces you to think about the reality of the
- 10:46business. It forces you to think
- 10:48critically, to question that core assumption that an old
- 10:52accounting number is a good enough proxy for a real world
- 10:55inflated cash expense. You now have a key tool to look
- 10:59past an attractive net profit number and to really assess if
- 11:02those earnings are just masking huge necessary maintenance cost
- 11:06that are slowly eating away at the long term health of the
- 11:08business. You have to decompose CapEx.
- 11:11And that leads us to a final provocative thought for you to
- 11:13chew on. If you see a company in one of
- 11:16these inflationary asset heavy sectors like our taxi company
- 11:19trying to replace its old fleet and their total CapEx year after
- 11:23year just happens to exactly equal their DNA.
- 11:26What does that imply? What does that really tell you
- 11:28about the quality of their assets and their competitive
- 11:30position? Five years from now?
- 11:31They are, in effect, slowly liquidating their own future.
- 11:35That is some food for thought that maintenance cost isn't just
- 11:38a number, it's the gatekeeper to a company's entire long term
- 11:41future. Absolutely.
- 11:43Now, if you found this deep dive useful and you want to explore
- 11:46even more advanced content like this, we'd welcome you to join
- 11:49the Deep Value Club membership. And please don't forget to
- 11:51subscribe to the Deep Value Investing channel on Apple or
- 11:54Spotify Podcasts. And remember our disclaimer, all
- 11:57of this content is for educational purposes only.
- 12:00It is not investment advice. Please conduct your own due
- 12:03diligence before making any decisions.
- 12:05And you can track the total market temperature by searching
- 12:08for and downloading the IO, a buffet indicator from the ALE
- 12:11App Store. Thanks for diving Dee with us
- 12:14today. We'll see you next time.