Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline for Wednesday, April 17, 2024
Transcript
- 0:20Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on the Metro News Radio Network. You
- 0:25agen radio turned off from the studio so w v RC Media and the Metro
- 0:37News Radio Network, the Voice of West Virginia comes the most powerful radio show
- 0:42in West Virginia. This this is Metro News talk Line with Happy Kerchible.
- 0:51Switch Network can from Charles Stared. Bye you, Hoppy. You're on Metro
- 0:57News. Talk Line with Hoppy Kerchible is brought to you by in COVID Insurance,
- 1:00encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visit in
- 1:04covid dot com to learn more. Morning. Welcome to talk Line on Metro
- 1:07News from the Encove Insurance Studios in the Dale Miller Building. Ethan Collins Desire
- 1:12producer Zach Carrolchick with a video stream you can watch at wv Metronews dot com
- 1:19phone number one one hundred and seven sixty five eight two five five, text
- 1:22me three oh four, talk three oh four, three oh four, talk
- 1:26three oh four. Let's get right to it. Huge decision by a federal
- 1:29appeals court in Richmond. Federal Appeals Court judges have ruled that West Virginia's law
- 1:34forbidding the participation of transgender athletes on schools sports teams violates the rights of a
- 1:44middle school track and cross country runner. The case was decided by a three
- 1:49judge panel from the Fourth Circuit, which covers West Virginia, and this is
- 1:55what the court said. The question before the court is whether the Act of
- 1:57West Virginia Act in the West virgin Law past couple of years ago, says
- 2:01that a transgender girl cannot participate, that is a biological male, but transgender
- 2:07to female, transition to female, that a transgender girl cannot participate in girls
- 2:14sports. This is what the court said. The question before us is whether
- 2:16the Act may lawfully be applied to prevent a thirteen year old transgender girl who
- 2:23takes puberty blocking medication and has publicly identified as a girl since the third grade,
- 2:30from participating in her school's cross country and track teams. We hold it
- 2:34cannot. So the effect of that is that this young student can then participate,
- 2:42that this law does not prevent her from participating on her middle school track
- 2:47team. West Virginia Turney General Patrick Morrisy strongly disagrees he will challenge this.
- 2:52He joins us on Metro News Talk on Patrick Good morning. How are you
- 2:54hey, Good morning, happy and thanks for having me on. I think
- 2:58this was a terribly wrong decision. It was a divided court two to one.
- 3:04I think that the district Court got it absolutely right when they said that
- 3:07it was constitutionally permissible and that the law complies with Title nine. And we're
- 3:12going to keep fighting to safeguard Title nine. This is a very important issue
- 3:16with a lot of precedents. It's key to protect women's sports, it's important
- 3:22to protect women's safety, and this is a case that's going to have a
- 3:25lot of influence on what happens in the future in terms of kind of the
- 3:30distinction between men and women biologically and how they're categorized. Patrick Marcy's with this
- 3:37Attorney General. Patrick, give me a legal clarification here. Does this decision
- 3:42apply only to this student or does it up end the law itself? I
- 3:50mean it's supposed to apply to the specific student. Obviously, there will be
- 3:53a lot of people that if they're similarly situated, they may cite that or
- 3:59decide to go to court. But what this court did is the court ruled
- 4:03definitively on the Title nine issues, and then they sent the equal protection issues
- 4:10back to the district Court and suggested that they weren't able to resolve that there
- 4:14were some factual disputes. But obviously the import of this is that this is
- 4:20a very significant setback for the law's status. However, I have always believed
- 4:29and Hoppy, We've been on the phone on a lot of issues over the
- 4:31years, that is, you keep going higher up in the process. So
- 4:34what do you do? What do you do? How are you going to
- 4:36challenge this? If you're going to challenge it, Look, we're analyzing now,
- 4:40but we will be challenging it. There are two options, Hoppy.
- 4:44Right now, you can go on back to the whole fourth Circuit where you
- 4:47get the whole sitting of the court, where you can go right up to
- 4:51the US Supreme Court and the questions are teed up. The Title nine question
- 4:57is teed up. And I think that if this goes up to the High
- 5:00Court, I am predicting you're going to have a very different decision because I
- 5:05think that the legislature acted reasonably based upon the distinction biologically between men and women.
- 5:14That's correct, that's permission wonder law. And I believe that the Supreme
- 5:17Court is ultimately going to agree with us. Patrick, let me go to
- 5:21some of the arguments made by the majority, and I'm reading from the opinion.
- 5:26I've been reading through this and trying to make you understand it. Here
- 5:28was one key part the majority said the defendants, that is, the local
- 5:31school board and the SSAC, et cetera, et cetera. The defendants that
- 5:38they concede neuraal argument that the government, the government has no interest in protecting
- 5:44one girl's ranking in any competition or ensuring or ensuring that sis gender girls do
- 5:50not lose, do not ever lose to transgender girls. So what the majority
- 5:55said was that the government doesn't have a specific interest in guaranteeing that girls whose
- 6:00gender identify with their biology that they are somehow protected from a transgender girl.
- 6:06What's your reaction to that, Look, I think that the decisions wrongheaded for
- 6:11a few reasons. Number One, if you look at the dynamic of what's
- 6:15going on right now, there are athletic competitions that are out there. The
- 6:19law sets forth the distinction on biology on the basis of how you were born.
- 6:26You were born a man, then you're categorized one way. You're born
- 6:29a female, you're categorized in other ways. So it doesn't mention transgender.
- 6:32It's focusing on your status at birth, because the legislature has the right to
- 6:38set those things up. But this issue of displacement is a very significant one
- 6:42as well. I bet if you asked any athlete or any person listening,
- 6:46if you ever competed in sports, and if you were to tell someone no,
- 6:49no, you didn't take third, you didn't get the bronze medal,
- 6:51you took fourth, you took fifth. You were displaced, you were excluded
- 6:56from the team. That's a very significant issue, and I don't think the
- 7:00court gave that justice. And that's something that people know about every day.
- 7:04Hoppy. I grew up, I ran cross country, I played tennis.
- 7:08If you told me, well, I didn't win the meet, I took
- 7:12second place, that's a really important thing, especially when the rules are set
- 7:15up to be so unfair. So that's why the West Virginia legislature stepped up
- 7:20and set up a very positive, very reasonable policy to protect women. The
- 7:26other point, which is critical is that this also tries to protect women from
- 7:30a safety perspective, and that's critical. A lot of those issues didn't come
- 7:34up in this particular case, but that's also one of the underlying purposes behind
- 7:39the app. Yeah, I was going to say, I think the defendants,
- 7:42school board, etc. Conceded that safety was not an issue in this
- 7:45case. I mean, the kid is running a cross country and doing shot
- 7:47put in discus, so safety really wasn't an issue anybody was arguing about.
- 7:51But you know what if you're playing soccer, what if you're playing in other
- 7:56sports where there's a lot of contact, that's where people really heroin in focus
- 8:01on it. And this is a law that's encompassing on all the sports that
- 8:05are played here in West Virginia. So obviously people look and they try to
- 8:09pick the one situation they think where we'll get the best reading. But if
- 8:13you look at the law as a whole, you see that the distinction on
- 8:16the basis of sex is absolutely correct. And that's why I think as we
- 8:20go up higher in the process, we are going to prevail. And so
- 8:24I ask everyone keep the faith. We're going to continue to argue, continue
- 8:28to fight. I've been working on these issues the last decade, pushing back
- 8:33on what's been going on. I think that this issue publicly has finally started
- 8:39to get more attention. When you look at what happened with Riley Gaines and
- 8:41the NCAA Women's Swimming Championship that Americans are beginning to see the fundamental unfairness of
- 8:50classifying these athletes in a way other than biological distinction. Let me go to
- 8:56again the reasoning by the majority. This is what the majority said. The
- 9:00undisputed evidence shows that the student, and she's publicly identified Becky Pepper Jackson,
- 9:05has never gone through puberty. As part of her treatment for gender dysphoria,
- 9:11she began receiving puberty blocking treatment at the beginning of that stage. The medication
- 9:18prevented her from progressing through puberty. As a result, she has never experienced
- 9:24elevated levels of testosterone. So, based on that, the majority is saying,
- 9:28Look, she's not she's identifying as a girl. She was born a
- 9:35male, but she does not have when it came to the part of her
- 9:37life where she was going to have testosterone, that hasn't happened. Therefore,
- 9:41there is not any any quality here that exists among those among those participants.
- 9:48What do you say to that? I think it's flat long from a factual
- 9:52perspective, and now those listening can looked as a website run by the American
- 9:56Association for the Advancement of Science, and I'm going to quoted here, Men
- 10:01on average run faster, lift more weights, throw harder, and further than
- 10:05women. Sporting events therefore usually split into male and female categories to ensure fair
- 10:11competition. All the statistics that we've looked at and we've dug in hopy that
- 10:18regardless of any particular person, if you look at this, the statistics don't
- 10:22lie. Men are different biologically than women, and regardless of when these puberty
- 10:28blockers are these transitions occur, men have an advantage in the athletic arena.
- 10:33We see it with the statistics. I don't think they lie, and that's
- 10:37going to keep coming out hoppy. The other big point I would mention is
- 10:41that in this case, the district court judge originally slapped an injunction down on
- 10:46the law. You may remember that, and then a year and a half
- 10:50later, after we submitted three thousand pages five hundred doct entries with all of
- 10:56this evidence and the background information, that's when the district court judge actually changed
- 11:01his position and he deemed the law constitutionally permissible. I am very hopeful that
- 11:07as this goes higher and higher in the courts, they're going to come to
- 11:11the same conclusion. Men are different from women and every court in the world
- 11:16is not going to be able to change that fact. The other point I
- 11:20would mention is that this was a two to one decision. We think we
- 11:24have some good information from the dissenting judge, and look, there can be
- 11:28very big differences in these courts. The Fourth Circuit has issued some of the
- 11:33more aggressive and left leaning decisions in the country, and I think that that's
- 11:37something for folks to know. Patrick. Finally, do you believe that given
- 11:43this decision, and as you said, it specifically talks about this particular student,
- 11:48but it can have broader applications. But given this ruling, do you
- 11:54think then as of today, the West Virginia law is essentially moot and that
- 12:01in West Virginia, if a transgender female wants to participate in female sports at
- 12:09high school or a collegiate level in West Virginia, they could be able to
- 12:13do that based on this court decision. Even though you want to fight and
- 12:18understand that, but I mean, here's the thing, Topy, we are
- 12:20going to fight it. Answer is no, this applies to a specific person.
- 12:26But also you will hear from our office in the upcoming days and probably
- 12:30by next week as we're analyzing the best pathway for we will be fighting,
- 12:35we will be appealing. People should keep the faith that the right thing is
- 12:37eventually going to happen. Hoppy, how many times I've ever been here your
- 12:41show before, whether it's clean power plan or other different issues where a district
- 12:46court or a court of appeals goes one way the Supreme Court goes another way.
- 12:50This is part of the process, and we will be vigilant, and
- 12:54we have a pretty darn good batting average on these issues. So Patrick,
- 12:56finally, finally, finally, on a personal level, and again you have
- 13:01the responsibility of representing the state in these matters. On a personal level,
- 13:05A do you believe that gender justice for you, which the medical community acknowledges,
- 13:09is a real thing? I mean, do you believe in gender dye
- 13:11for you? Number one? And do you have any empathy for this?
- 13:16Well, now, I think fourteen year old who simply wants to participate with
- 13:18their teammates in track, Look, no one wants to. I always have
- 13:22empathy for kids that are having problems, and I think that folks should get
- 13:26the help that they need. But I think that when people try to go
- 13:31to these extremes and set up rules based upon their gender identification instead of biological
- 13:37sex, that's wrong. And what happens and what gets lost in the equation
- 13:43is what happens to all the other people, all the little girls who are
- 13:46competing in sports and watching a hulking male compete against them. That's wrong.
- 13:52And we have to be willing to say that. And I think that overrides
- 13:56the interest these kids are being transitioned at a young age. Not right,
- 14:01And I think that we need to be willing to say that, and I
- 14:03certainly have and I will continue to do so. Patrick Morrissey, Attorney General,
- 14:09who will challenge this in a higher court. And also, of course
- 14:11he's a candidate for the republic nomination for governor. Patrick, thanks for coming
- 14:15on today. Hey, thanks so much, Shaby, you be well all
- 14:16right, We'll be all right back Tiggs at the trough. They can't stop
- 14:22eating. Kind of like Patrick Morrissey when it comes to making money from the
- 14:28woke sex change industry. Morrissey lobbied to spend Medicare dollars on a New York
- 14:33hospital that performs gender reassignment surgery, and his wife's firm lobbied for Planned Parenthood.
- 14:39They're not just an abortion provider. They're also a group that gives puberty
- 14:43blockers to kids, and they have a clinic right here in West Virginia.
- 14:48Perform's lobbyists have given thousands of dollars to Morrissey's campaigns, So let's review,
- 14:54shall we kids transitioned? Morrissey guzzled millions in trans ca dash Patrick Morrissey says
- 15:01he's a true conservative. He's just a liberal lobbyist that's pigging out on the
- 15:07woke sex change industry. Morrissey is wrong for West Virginia. Paid for by
- 15:11West Virginia Forward, not authorized by any candidate or candidate's committee. The WVU
- 15:20Cancer Institute and its integrated regional network offer hope by saving and improving lives.
- 15:26By providing high quality cancer care close to home, patients don't have to go
- 15:31far to receive comprehensive personalized care. Our vast network of WVU Cancer Institute locations
- 15:37means patients can be surrounded by loved ones during their treatment and not bear the
- 15:41burden and expensive travel to make an appointment called eight five five WVU Care.
- 15:48Right now is Peia open enrollment, But did you know you have options when
- 15:52selecting your Peia coverage. The health Plan is a West Virginia based option and
- 15:56has been the most trusted carrier for over forty years with the popular zero dollar
- 16:02cost for routine lab work at all participating lab core locations, and the use
- 16:07of telemedicine through healthiest You. There are three plans to choose from. Make
- 16:11the health Plan your choice. Remember you have a choice with Peia. Choose
- 16:15the health Plan. Log on to health plan dot org for more information.
- 16:19Picture a community where every space tells a store. Those are the communities we're
- 16:25designing at zlmlm architects and engineers with a blend of creativity and technical expertise.
- 16:30We design spaces that inspire, innovate, and ignite change, from cutting edge
- 16:34educational facility to community centric gathering spaces. We're committed to improving lives through design.
- 16:41Let us help you use shape a brighter future for generations to come.
- 16:45Because at ZML it's more than architecture, It's about building your legacy. Technology
- 16:52can be daunting. Gigs ISPs HD, this cybersecurity that all you know is
- 16:59you wanted, fact, fast, reliable, and affordable. City Net delivers
- 17:03all three. They're leading the way to connect West Virginia. Also, Cittyet
- 17:07is your neighbor. Their national headquarters is in Bridgeport, and just like you,
- 17:11their phone number begins with three zero four. Visit citynet dot net.
- 17:15When it comes to technology, city Net connects, protects, and perfects.
- 17:22This is talk Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia. Wow
- 17:27Metro News this morning, the biggest stories from around the state of West Virginia
- 17:32when you want them, Brought to you by Burdett Camping Center, home of
- 17:36the RV warranty forever. Chris Lawrence at the anchor desk, we are ready
- 17:40to get today. Who started in West Virginia with all of the information you
- 17:41nage. Harry Houda secrings you the day's headlines. At fifth tornado in West
- 17:47Virginia touchdown during last week's storm. That tornado was confirmed on Fifth Street and
- 17:51Huntington near the Cowbal Wayne County line. Three other tornadoes tour through Knawk County
- 17:55and St. Albans Cross Lanes and Quick and a fourth one in Fayette County
- 17:59which devis dated the community of La Vista. Kyle Wiggs at the sports desk
- 18:03in Caldwell has moved on to Tennessee after one year at Marshall. Both the
- 18:07school and the coach confirmed its Sunday the Women's National Championship game Sunday one by
- 18:12South Carolina over Iowa eighty seven to seventy five and Hoppy Kirchible's daily commentary.
- 18:18Metro News This Morning brought to you by Burdette Camping Center Listen, where you
- 18:22get your favorite podcasts and online at WV metro News dot com. It's two
- 18:27hours of sports conversation to wrap up your weekend. It's the City Net Sunday
- 18:32Night Sports Line. Hey, this is Travis Jones joining myself and Greg Hunter
- 18:36every Sunday night from six oh six until eight o'clock as we wrap up the
- 18:38sports weekend. We talk Mountaineers, high school, Mountain East Conference, and
- 18:42the latest in the national scene. The Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive.
- 18:47You could call or text the show at three oh four Talk three oh four.
- 18:51It's a perfect weekend sports wrap up on your favorite Metro News affilia,
- 18:55or watch the show at WV metro News dot com. Hey there, Dave
- 18:57weekly. Here at your host from me News Hotline. Get ready for an
- 19:00epic journey. Every weekday from three to six pm, We've got all the
- 19:04excitement you need from sports to tech, music, pop culture, and everything
- 19:07in between. Join Coop and I as we bring you engaging discussions, captivating
- 19:11interviews, fun games, and the latest sports and entertainment headlines that will keep
- 19:15your hook. Metronews Hotline is your go to source for sports, news,
- 19:19entertainment, and most importantly fun. Tune in weekdays from three to six on
- 19:23Metronews and WV metronews dot com. Metronews Talkline with Hopy Kerchible is brought to
- 19:41you by Encoca Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what do you care
- 19:45about most? Visit in Coca dot com to learn more. Talkline from the
- 19:49Cove Insurance studios in the Miller Building, and we're gonna spend more time on
- 19:52this. I got a ton of texts. I'll get to texts, phone
- 19:56calls if you want to participate that way. And also I'm efforting to get
- 20:00the other side on that court decision meantime. One of two fourteen year olds
- 20:08charged in connection with the January thirtieth murder of a tobacco store clerk in North
- 20:12Charleston. Again, fourteen year olds will be tried as an adult as part
- 20:18of a tentative plea agreement with prosecutor. Jeff Jenkins says the story in the
- 20:21Metro News newsroom. Jeff, what is the story? Okay, Hopy.
- 20:23We now know the name of the alleged shooter in this fourteen year old b
- 20:27Jehan Williams Hampton of Charleston. He was in court yesterday, had not been
- 20:32identified up to this point. There is a hearing in which he agreed to
- 20:37have his case transferred to adult status, and in the court document there's mention
- 20:42of a plea agreement. So basically what this does is that he attended a
- 20:47plea agreement, he's agreed to have his case transferred to adult status. He's
- 20:52waived a preliminary hearing. It'll go to a grand jury. We expect him
- 20:56to be indicted if the grand jury decides to do that, probably next month,
- 21:00and then there could be a plea hearing sometimes shortly after that. It
- 21:04appears that there have been some discussions for him. There was a crime spree
- 21:10over like a nine day period in late January. Where these two are charged
- 21:14not only with this robbery and murder of Caden Martin, the nineteen year old
- 21:18tobacco store clerk, but also shooting a woman in the face and holding a
- 21:22man at gunpoint on a robbery and three separate things. He's agreed to adult
- 21:29status on the robbery and murder. So if you kind of compiece this together
- 21:32a little bit, there may be a plea in connection with those crimes,
- 21:37and you know, in exchange for his plea right and so well, we'll
- 21:41have to see how that works out. But that's kind of that kind of
- 21:45seems how's that that's going with his case? Jeff? Did I read perhaps
- 21:48in your story that as a juvenile, even though you go to adult status,
- 21:55that you cannot be sentenced to life in prison. Not as a fourteen
- 21:59year old, you can't. That's right, that's true at state law.
- 22:00So you can be you have to have mercy onto it, right. So
- 22:04so so let's go down the road just a piece. If he does plead
- 22:08plead the first degree murder, first degree murder with mercy, then he would
- 22:11have a chance for parole in fifteen years on that particular charge. If that's
- 22:17if that's where they go with that, we'll see. I mean, there
- 22:19were there was information in the court filing that we got to see late yesterday
- 22:23about what had happened. You know, the surveillance video shows cave Martin,
- 22:29the clerk, cooperating, appearing to a cooperate with the robbery. It'samp putting
- 22:33VAP products in in in a backpack for b John Williams Hampton, but then
- 22:40getting shot right after that after he gave it back to him. And uh
- 22:45so he cooperated, he didn't try that's right, He didn't try to interfere
- 22:51with the robber. That's what the criminal complaint says. Yes. And also
- 22:55a Conaw County Shafess deputy was the first to be flagged down because a person
- 23:00went into the shop afterward and no one was there and they didn't see anybody,
- 23:03so they flagged down. The deputy deputy goes in, he finds the
- 23:07clerk and he had been shot twice, once in the head, and that's
- 23:12in the court document. So it was a short time later that they found
- 23:15Williams Hampton on Hunt Avenue and they found him and then they eventually charged a
- 23:22second fourteen year old who we don't know the name of yet he has not
- 23:25been transferred, so his case is a little behind this first one. All
- 23:29right, jeff Jenkins from the Metro News newsroom. Thank you, Jeffrey.
- 23:30Still hard to comprehend these two fourteen year olds, fourteen year olds charged with
- 23:37participating in a crimes free that led to the death of a nineteen year old
- 23:41store cork. All right, We're coming back and I'm going to open phones
- 23:45and texts on this court decision on transgender athletes. This is talk Line on
- 23:48Metro News. Metro News is the voice of West Virginia. It's ten thirty.
- 23:53Let's get a news update, checking with the Metro News Radio network.
- 23:56And finally, what's happening statewide this hour the great state of West Virginia,
- 24:03West Virginia Metro NEWSS. I'm Kerrie Huda. Saga. Fight early this morning
- 24:07in Kannak County has left a man dead and a woman hospitalized. Deputies were
- 24:11called to a home at Gatewood Court in the Shillian area a little before two
- 24:15o'clock this morning. Kennall County Chief Deputy Joe Crawford says there was a domestic
- 24:18incident in which a woman was stabbed. Discovered that there was one female victim
- 24:22that had been stabbed. They started trying to attend to her. The male
- 24:29individual involved in the domestic that was the suspect in the stabbing, retreated into
- 24:34his resident. The man then refused to come out. Crawford says it then
- 24:37became a standoff. Deputy shot him and he died at the scene. The
- 24:41woman is being treated for stab wounds at the hospital. A US appeals court
- 24:45denouncing its decision on a West Virginia case involving a Harrison County transgender student who
- 24:49wasn't allowed to run girls track. The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeal says Becky
- 24:52Pepper Jackson should have been allowed to run. Metro News statewide correspondent Brad mclhaney
- 24:57writes about it at wv metro news dot com. The Kennall County Commission is
- 25:02seeking more transparency from members of the West Virginia First Foundation who are handling one
- 25:06billion dollars in opioid settlement funds. Commissioner Kent Carper says they've sent a letter
- 25:11to their rep on the board at State Health Officer doctor Matthew Christensen. Their
- 25:14answer is going to bay. Look, we've just got started it takes time,
- 25:18but the communication to the local governments that brought this litigation needs to be
- 25:23improved. The foundation recently hired an executive director. You're listening to Metro News.
- 25:27The Voice of West Virginia takes at the trough. They can't stop eating.
- 25:37Kind of like Patrick Morrissey when it comes to making money from the Wolke
- 25:41sex change industry. Morrissey lobbied to spend Medicare dollars on a New York hospital
- 25:47that performs gender reassignment surgery, and his wife's firm lobbied for Planned Parenthood.
- 25:52They're not just an abortion provider. They're also a group that gives puberty blockers
- 25:57to kids, and they have a clinic right here in West Virginia. Her
- 26:03firm's lobbyists have given thousands of dollars to Morrissey's campaigns. So let's review,
- 26:07shall we kids transitioned? Morrissey guzzled millions in trans cash. Patrick Morrissey says
- 26:15he's a true conservative. He's just a liberal lobbyist that's pigging out on the
- 26:19Wope sex change industry. Morrissey is wrong for West Virginia. Paid for by
- 26:25West Virginia Forward not authorized by any candidate or Candidates Committee. Workers said to
- 26:32soon lose their jobs at the Cleveland Cliff's ten Mill and Weirton are getting help
- 26:34with resources and possible new jobs. Workforce West Virginia's more in person says they're
- 26:38trying to help the workers through the transition. Very difficult when the you know,
- 26:42in the loyal for forccurs, people are already kind of well, you
- 26:48know how they overwhelmed. So we try not to overwhelm them, but we
- 26:52also try to give them a push in the right direction. A job fair
- 26:56was held in Weirton Tuesday. From the Metro News anchor desk in Kerry who
- 27:00to sack talk one from me and COVID Insurance Studios text me three oh four
- 27:27talk three oh four phone number one hundred and seven sixty five A two five
- 27:32five. So back to this court decision involving this young female participant in cross
- 27:38country Bridgeports Middle School. I want to make a couple observations and I'll go
- 27:41to texts and all the phones. One is that this I do think it's
- 27:48a complicated issue, and I know that I'm gonna get a lot of texts
- 27:52and girls or girls, boys or boys. I understand that I'm not I'm
- 27:56not disputing the biology. But gender dysphoria is a real thing recognized by the
- 28:00medical community. And I'm not talking about individuals who decide, for whatever reason
- 28:07to ignore gender norms and decide to be fluid on that front. I'm talking
- 28:12about individuals who have a condition that can be diagnosed as dysphoria where your gender
- 28:18identity does not match your biology. That is a real thing that is acknowledged
- 28:22by the medical community. So that's number one. Number two is that even
- 28:33if an individual takes and these are my observations based on what I'm reading and
- 28:37what I'm trying to sort through, that even if an individual takes huberty blockers,
- 28:42and by the way, there's some questions about that too, and I'll
- 28:45get to that in a second, that even if a youngster takes puberty blockers
- 28:49and is identifying as a female, there are other characteristics that are at play
- 28:56here. There are other physiological differences, and that was noted in the descent.
- 29:00It was a two to one decision that was noted in the descent.
- 29:03There are bone density issues, there are muscle mass issues, there's lung capacity
- 29:08issues. So it's not just about it's not just about puberty. It is
- 29:17about that and these other physiological conditions that are a result of your biology at
- 29:26birth, and that generally speaking to me, gives an individual, even if
- 29:33they are transgender female and advantage. So that to me seems inherently unfair.
- 29:41And look, I have empathy for this child that wants to compete, wants
- 29:45to participate with her friends, but also there is a displacement and that was
- 29:49cited in the Descent that when she and I hate the fact we're talking about
- 29:55a thirteen or fourteen year old girl and it's all out there publicly, but
- 29:59it is. And when she participates in a meet and she's had success,
- 30:03I looked up to you. I looked up at one meet in March and
- 30:04she won the shotput. So good for her for winning the shotput. But
- 30:08that also displaces a girl who is a biological female. So there is a
- 30:17displacement issue that occurs. Whether it's this case or other cases, there are
- 30:22displacements that take place that seem inherently unfair to the other girls, which would
- 30:29seem to me to raise a Title nine issue. And I know the courts
- 30:33have said that discrimination in referencing Title nine that discrimination based on gender is the
- 30:37same as discrimination based on sex. I understand there's been a court opinion on
- 30:41that, but it seems inherently unfair when given the progress that's been made under
- 30:48Title nine, that you have an individual can participate in the girls' sports and
- 30:55therefore displace other biological girls. Here's another point, and boy, this is
- 31:02really going to get down into it. But I was flagged this the other
- 31:06day and it just obviously came up and is appropriate the leading No, this
- 31:11was not it is that it No, that's not it. Let me get
- 31:15this other piece I'm looking for, and this has to do with with puberty
- 31:19blockers. Here it is a new report commissioned by the National Health Service of
- 31:26England. The National Health Service of England advocates for further research on gender affirming
- 31:34care for transgender youth and young adults. Okay, that in of itself doesn't
- 31:38sound very productive provocative. You're always looking for more research. But following four
- 31:45years of data analysis, their research concluded this, while a considerable amount of
- 31:51research has been published in this field, systematic evidence reviews demonstrated the poor quality
- 31:57of the published studies, meaning there is not a reliable evidence based upon which
- 32:05to make clinical decisions or for children and their families to make informed decisions.
- 32:10So the essence of it, it's not saying that gender dyspory isn't real.
- 32:14It says it is. But it is raising questions, saying that with the
- 32:16research it's been done so far, that there are serious questions about the use
- 32:23of gender affirming drugs or gender or puberty blocking drugs among miners. Now I
- 32:32don't say that as I don't weaponize that to say it shouldn't be done.
- 32:37What I'm saying is that it's still relatively new. This whole process of gender
- 32:44blocking, I mean of gender transition and accept as by the medical community and
- 32:49about puberty blockers still relatively new, still relatively new. And this is by
- 32:54the National Health Service of England saying, you know, we just don't know
- 33:00all we need to know to be conclusive about this. I think that's relevant.
- 33:05Again, families and their medical doctor can make these decisions. But this
- 33:10suggests is not just a slam dunk. All right, let me get the
- 33:15comments hoppy, why have sex based categories at all? I'm pretty tolerant people
- 33:20can be transgender, but people don't have the right to compete in the opposite
- 33:22sex sports. The fact we're arguing that boys can be girls is a sign
- 33:27of the downfall of society, says the Texter Hoppy. Are any of the
- 33:36candidates going to use this opportunity on your show to discuss the real issues affecting
- 33:39West Virginia or we're going to drone on about trans people. Look in my
- 33:44defense and I'm trying not to be defensive, but in my defense and in
- 33:47the defense of Patrick Morrissey, frankly that this is a big story. This
- 33:52was a law passed by the West Virginia legislature. This is a federal court
- 33:55decision that has a significant impact on this case and and perhaps on the law
- 34:00itself of an issue that has come up across the country. So it is
- 34:06a relevant issue, and it's appropriate for the attorney general who represents the state
- 34:10of West Virginia to comment on that. And the other candidates that I've had
- 34:15on I've had on Morrisey too, we talk about other issues affecting the state.
- 34:19I had Mac Warner on the other day, talked about education for the
- 34:22most part. But this is a relevant issue for the Attorney general to speak
- 34:25to happy. Is it to coincidence? And directly after your interview with Morrissey,
- 34:30a commercial came on disrespecting Marcy. Look, I don't determine the rotation
- 34:37of the commercials. I will say this, I think it is unfortunate and
- 34:42I apologize that that commercial ran right after Marcy was on the show. I
- 34:46apologize for that. That was that was poor. That was poor on my
- 34:53part. It was not intentional, just's that's where the commercials were in the
- 34:59rotation. So I apologize to Patrick for that. I think that was in
- 35:02poor taste. It shouldn't have happened, but it just I just fired the
- 35:06commercial. I really did not look to see what the next commercial was.
- 35:12Hoppy. Imagine all Republican candidates for Senate and governor are tripping over themselves wanting
- 35:15to express outrage. Well maybe, I mean, that's up to them.
- 35:21Once again, this is a state law that has essentially been gutted by a
- 35:25federal appeals court. There will be a challenge to it by the State of
- 35:30West Virginia. The representative of the state of West Virginia is the Attorney General.
- 35:34Therefore, it is appropriate for the Attorney General to speak to it i'll
- 35:44be The conclusion shared by Patrick Marcy about male and female athletes were those that
- 35:47reflect performance after puberty and the male testosterone. Are you aware that all men
- 35:52and all women don't have the same testosterone? It varies even among genders.
- 35:57He mentioned size. There are women who are taller and bigger than men.
- 36:01Obviously, my point is gender alone does not dictate advantage. I agree.
- 36:07I agree with that there are other factors. There are multiple factors. I
- 36:10agree with that, I'll be understand. But is that a mental condition and
- 36:19transgender should not be able to participate in female sports? I don't know.
- 36:22Gender dysphoria is a condition. I think it is described as a as a
- 36:29psychological condition or maybe physiological as well, but it is a recognized condition for
- 36:36which there is recognized treatment. Yeah. Again, somebody referencing that ad.
- 36:43That was unfortunate. Again, I apologize that was really bad juxtaposition, but
- 36:51it it was just an accident. It's happened before. I remember one time
- 36:54I had warn McGraw, the late Warren McGraw, in a program UH and
- 36:59UH was interviewing him and the first commercial was one of those ads criticizing Warden
- 37:04McGraw. He was not happy about that. Happy Morrissey did not answer your
- 37:09question about gender dys for you. Apparently he disagrees with all the medical associations.
- 37:15I don't know, he didn't specifically say that. I don't call him
- 37:17specifically say that. So it's okay for a male to compete against a female
- 37:28who's two times stronger. That's not fair, says the Texter Happy. Your
- 37:35puberty blocker is a form of chemical castration. I am not a I'm not
- 37:39well versed in that. I'm just like a lot of people. I'm trying
- 37:43to research and educate myself on that. So uh and frankly, as I
- 37:50told you what the research says, even the medical community is trying to sort
- 37:54through the how to use puberty blockers when it's appropriate, when it's not appropriate,
- 38:05trying to figure it all out. So it's still medically, it's still
- 38:08relatively not relatively new territory talk like continues. We'll be right back. Larry
- 38:14Pack is a proven conservative Republican running for state Treasurer who fights for our families.
- 38:20Larry Pack is one hundred percent pro life and supports the Second Amendment.
- 38:23Larry Pack has real West Virginia values Larry Pack is a proven job creator and
- 38:29knows what it takes to grow our economy. Larry Pack helped Governor Justice deliver
- 38:32the largest tax cut in state history. Our families now keep more of their
- 38:37hard earned money. Let's all vote for Republican Larry Pack for State Treasurer.
- 38:42Paid for by Larry Pack for West Virginia Larry Pack Treasurer. Winning the lottery
- 38:46means time to work on my skydiving skills. I'm a thrill see kind love
- 38:51the rush, arm stretch wide, free falling, win on the cheeks.
- 38:57I want to join the skydiving acrobat too. Man, your turn is up.
- 39:01You have to exit the car wash driver. Oh sorry, just guideim
- 39:06training. I'll see you tomorrow. It's a car wash. I better check
- 39:08my tickets. This could be my chance West Virginia Lottery. What if it
- 39:13could happen to you? Please play responsibly. Takes at the trough they can't
- 39:20stop eating. Kind of like Patrick Morrissey when it comes to making money from
- 39:24the woke sex change industry. Morrissey lobbied to spend Medicare dollars on a New
- 39:30York hospital that performs gender reassignment surgery and his wife's firm lobbied for Planned Parenthood.
- 39:37They're not just an abortion provider. They're also a group that gives puberty
- 39:42blockers to kids, and they have a clinic right here in West Virginia.
- 39:46Perform's lobbyists have given thousands of dollars to Morrissey's campaigns. So let's review.
- 39:52Shall we Kids transitioned? Morrissey guzzled millions in trans cash. Patrick Morrissey says
- 39:59he's a true conservative. He's just a liberal lobbyist that's pigging out on the
- 40:04woke sex change industry. Morrissey is wrong for West Virginia. Paid for by
- 40:09West Virginia Forward, not authorized by any candidate or candidate's committee. You're listening
- 40:15to talk Line on Metro News. The Voice of West Virginia. West Virginia
- 40:22Outdoors is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more
- 40:28than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence
- 40:31has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years.
- 40:36I shot him. He ran over to the edge of the field. He
- 40:38made it about five ten yards out of the edge of the field. And
- 40:43fell over there. Whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about
- 40:47the enjoyment of the great outdoors. He stuck his head through the blind into
- 40:52where you were. Yeah, yeah, well he had jumped, he leaked,
- 40:55okay blind, Oh gosh, yeah he had. His whole body was
- 41:00in the air for a couple of seconds and is the only thing that landed
- 41:05in the blonde was of course at Bartley. West Virginia. Outdoors covers it
- 41:08all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for your daily fix, Outdoors
- 41:14Today brings you two and a half minutes of news and notes from the woods
- 41:16and water every weekday morning on Metro News of Voice of West Virginia. Hey
- 41:22everybody, it's Tony Coritty, I'm Greg Hunter, and I'm Brad Howe,
- 41:24and we invite you to join us. Sunday through Fridays right here on the
- 41:29Metro News radio network, it's the City Nets Statewide sports Line. We talk
- 41:34West Virginia University football, basketball, baseball, you name it. If it's
- 41:37got anything to do with the Golden Blue, we're on it. And don't
- 41:40forget the text line available every night. So we invite you to join us.
- 41:45The Senator, Coach Hunter and me Tony Coritti. It's the city net
- 41:49state wide sports line on Metro News. News in the Mountain State happens quick
- 41:52and for decades you have depended on Metro News for accurate news delivered fast.
- 41:59Now here's your chance to help keep your fellow West Virginians informed. If you
- 42:02see news happening, become a Metro News hawk by texting news to three five
- 42:07sixty five to one. If you take a picture or video of what you
- 42:09see, submit that as well. Text the word news to three five sixty
- 42:15five one to submit your tip or story. Standard texting rates applying. Please
- 42:19don't text and drive. Metro News talk Line with Hoppy Kerchible is brought to
- 42:37you by Encovia Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about
- 42:40most. Visit in Covia dot com to learn more. Talk on from the
- 42:45Cova Insurance studios. By the way, we hope to have another the other
- 42:51side of the story on this court decision coming up a little bit later on.
- 42:54We are efforting, as we say in the industry. Let me bring
- 42:57in Brett mackliney Metro nes to y Carspot, who wrote the story based on,
- 43:00not based on, but about the court decision, and Brad, you
- 43:05spent some time as well reading through this and trying to sort it out.
- 43:07And we listen listen to the Attorney General's interview, and my takeaway was,
- 43:13yes, this decision is to one decision applies only specifically, applies specifically to
- 43:20this young student a Bridgeport Middle school. However, given what this ruling is,
- 43:25it has broader implications. What's your takeaway? Same here? And I
- 43:31am not a lawyer, I am merely a cave man lawyer, and so
- 43:37I tried to read this ruling very carefully to determine what its effect might be
- 43:43on West Virginia law. And my takeaway right after reading it is that it
- 43:49fairly narrowly addressed the circumstances of this particular young athlete, Becky Pepper Jackson a
- 43:55couple of key passages I think from the ruling. The question before us is
- 44:00whether the Act West Virginia's law may lawfully be applied to prevent a thirteen year
- 44:06old transgender girl who takes puberty blocking medication and has publicly identified as a girl
- 44:13since the third grade from participating in her school's cross country and track teams.
- 44:17Then the two judges of the three judge panels said, we hold it cannot
- 44:22You know that what I get out of that is a lot of definition of
- 44:28who the plaintiff was here, transgender girl who takes puberty blocking medication. And
- 44:34so that, in concert with another passage from what the court ruled, we
- 44:39do not hold this is what they did not do. We do not hold
- 44:43the government officials are forbidden from creating separate sports teams for boys and girls,
- 44:47or that they lack the power to police the line drawn between those teams.
- 44:52They said, we do not. We also do not hold the Title nine
- 44:55requires schools to allow every transgender girl to play on girls sports teams, regardless
- 45:01of whether they have gone through puberty and experienced elevated levels of circulating testosterone.
- 45:07So that kind of definition made me conclude that it was specific to the circumstances
- 45:14of this particular young athlete, that you could not say it knocks down West
- 45:17Virginia's law. But because I am only a Cayman lawyer, it came as
- 45:22a great relief to hear that the Attorney General sized it up very similarly to
- 45:27say that it applied particularly to Becky Pepper Jacksons circumstances, but that it could
- 45:31be construed that if there were another young athlete defined in the same way,
- 45:37it still would apply. Maybe the court, boy, this is way out
- 45:42on a limb, but maybe the court did not want to be in position
- 45:45of making a ruling that had a that had a sweeping effect, and was
- 45:49just doing it, as you said, narrowly in this particular case, rather
- 45:52than just striking down the law. Again, well, and I would add
- 45:59that was the nature of the plaintiffs Becky Pepper Jackson's original complaint. It was
- 46:06that she wanted West Virginia law to not prevent her from participating on the track
- 46:14and cross country teams. Her complaint originally in the court system, was not
- 46:17to knock down the West Virginia law. It was to allow her own participation.
- 46:22Brad, Let's go to the descent though, and again it was a
- 46:24two to one decision. In the descent, the judge wrote, it is
- 46:29neither myth nor outdated stereotype that there are inherent differences between those born male and
- 46:35those born female, and those born male, including transgender women and girls,
- 46:39have physiological advantages in many sports. Indeed, the tangible performance terms. In
- 46:46tangible performance terms, studies have shown that these biological differences allow post pubescent males
- 46:52to jump twenty five percent higher than females, throw twenty five percent farther than
- 46:55females, et cetera. Ter so that they're they're talking about post pubs males.
- 47:00So, but it does get to this issue of it's not just about
- 47:07blocking your testosterone, that there are these physiological differences that that have to be
- 47:14taken into account. That's what I read there. Mm hm. You know
- 47:19the fact that this was a split decision, it was two to three,
- 47:22only a three judge panel, uh from the appeals court two to one,
- 47:27true to one. Uh. You know what the Attorney General described as potential
- 47:30next steps would be to ask the entire Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals on bunk
- 47:38to to make a judgment of its own, which would provide a greater number
- 47:45of Appeals judges weighing in here or potentially going to the US Supreme Court.
- 47:51And you know, these kinds of decisions, these kinds of of views among
- 47:58among legal authorities are not uncommon in the United States. There are twenty some
- 48:05states that have established laws similar to West Virginia other district courts that are weighing
- 48:12in on these matters, and it's not unlikely that the US Supreme Court will
- 48:17eventually take it up because this is clearly an issue that society is grappling with.
- 48:22By the way, unbank means of the bench right or on the bench,
- 48:27So it means that the entire because this is the three judge panel of
- 48:30the district. But this means that further appeal or be the Attorney General would
- 48:35want are taken up by the entire district court. I don't know how many
- 48:37members are on the entire district there in Richmond, but was twelve or four
- 48:40more than three? Thank you all right, Brad mackliny. The story's posted
- 48:45at wv metronews dot com. Thank you, Bred. We can all agree
- 48:46that hearing aids are expensive. No more. Fruit Pharmacy now offers hearing aids
- 48:52at affordable pricing. You can find the perfect over the counter Nuva met hearing
- 48:55aid and you'll have money left over to go to a concert and put that
- 48:59new aid to test. Choose from the digit earplus max pro or Life.
- 49:04Not only are you saving hundreds of dollars, but you also get a one
- 49:07year warranty and Nuba Men has a forty five day money back guarantee. Visit
- 49:10your local fruth today for your next hearing, aid your hometown family Pharmacy.
- 49:15For over seventy years, as governor, Justice always says West Virginia is a
- 49:22diamond in the rough. That diamond just got a bit shinier with the state
- 49:25being named one of the top travel destinations in the world. Our scenic beauty,
- 49:30natural wonder and unique culture are unsurpassed, and it's no surprise people are
- 49:36catching on. And for those visiting, we hope you'll decide to stay in
- 49:38West Virginia. Job opportunities abound, especially in the coal industry. Coal mining
- 49:44is a high tech, high growth industry that exists side by side with exceptional
- 49:49hiking, biking, climbing, kayaking, hunting, fishing, and so much
- 49:53more. With state of the art mining operations, West Virginia's coal industry is
- 49:58recognized as the best in the world. We produce the coal that makes the
- 50:01steel that built this great country while continuing to power America today, join one
- 50:07of America's most honorable professions. While living in one of the top travel destinations
- 50:13in the world. Join us in almost Heaven, West Virginia. A message
- 50:16from the friends of Coal, West Virginia. It's here. The all new
- 50:21Metro News TV app has arrived. Metro News Television brings you our award winning
- 50:25content to your connected devices. You can now watch on your phone, television,
- 50:30tablet, or laptop absolutely free. Sure we're still going to be on
- 50:34the radio and audio streams, but sometimes watching is just a little bit better.
- 50:38Direct links to each platform are available at WV metronewstv dot com. Metro
- 50:45News Television. Now you can watch the Voice of West Virginia. This is
- 50:50talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. Wvmetronews dot com
- 50:57the only website you need to stay in form in the Mountain State. Get
- 51:00the latest news and sports story, information on the great outdoors, and never
- 51:05miss an episode of your favorite Metro News programs and podcasts, including Talkline,
- 51:09Hotline, Sports Line, and Three Guys Before the Game. Make a bookmark
- 51:15now and visit WV metronews dot com first thing every morning to find out what's
- 51:19happening all across the state. WV metronews dot com. West Virginia Outdoors is
- 51:24the Mountain States only hook and Bullet radio show dedicated to the more than quarter
- 51:30million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been
- 51:35tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years. Stockfish for
- 51:38repatriation purposes to that's reintroduction, re establishment of brookshrout and two of those streams,
- 51:45the oldest that we have worked on, the earliest ones that we started
- 51:49putting fish into. We've noticed natural reproduction in both of those streams, whether
- 51:52it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great
- 51:58outdoors. It was a pretty good all right. It takes me about ten
- 52:00minutes to get it in. My dad actually had to run to the truck
- 52:05and grab an that because there's my way. I could list him up over
- 52:07top of the rail. West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven
- 52:13oh six am and for your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you two and
- 52:16a half minutes of news and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning
- 52:21on Metro News of Voice of West Virginia. It's two hours of sports conversation
- 52:25to wrap up your weekend. It's the City Net Sunday Night Sports Line.
- 52:29Hey, this is Travis Joes joining myself and Greg Hunter every Sunday night from
- 52:32six oh six until eight o'clock as we wrap up the sports weekend. We
- 52:36talked Mountaineers High School, Mountain East Conference, and the latest in the national
- 52:40scene. The Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive. You could call or text
- 52:44the show at three oh four Talk three oh four. It's a perfect weekend
- 52:47sports wrap up on your favorite metro news Aphilia four. Watch the show at
- 52:52wv metronews dot com, talk line from the and COVID Sure in studios.
- 53:07Text Hoppy. As a father of a daughter who required hormone therapy as a
- 53:12young child, I believe that A. G. Morrissey, anti trans groups
- 53:15and the government have no business dictating what kind of healthcare any child should be
- 53:20receiving. Stick to politics and leave medicine and healthcare up to the doctors and
- 53:24their patients. AG Morrissey has no authority to tell anyone how they can live
- 53:29their own lives. I thought Republicans were for small government and against legislative overreach,
- 53:35says the texture. All right, we're going to take a break here
- 53:37more on this next hour. A lot of texts I'll try to get to
- 53:40as many as I can. Also, coming up next hour, we'll talk
- 53:45to Kenny bast WCCHSTV about the whole situation with the former Charleston police chief.
- 53:50This is talk line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. Alrighty,
- 54:31our number two talk line on the Metro News radio network from the en
- 54:34COPD Insurance Studios. What's in a number? If you matched just six of
- 54:37twenty five correctly playing Cash twenty five for the West Virginia Lottery, you'll take
- 54:40on the top prize of twenty five thousand dollars. Drawings are held Mondays,
- 54:44Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Fridays. It only calls it doll going to play
- 54:46with four drawings each week, the odds are pretty good. You're gonna have
- 54:51fun playing Cash twenty five from the West Virginia Lottery. My commentary today.
- 54:55First of all, the fact City of Charleston recently announced that former police chief
- 55:00Tyke Hunt has been suspended and demoted from lieutenant to corporal. The action follows
- 55:05an internal investigation into allegations that Hunt ensured that a woman applying to be on
- 55:12the police force, passed a polygraph test in return for sex with Hunt.
- 55:17Chelsea McCoy has sued Hunt, and she said in an interview with WCHSTV and
- 55:22Kenny Bass that there was an understanding that sex was part of the deal.
- 55:29Who's the second time the city of discipline Hunt. Last August, Hunt resigned
- 55:31as chief but stayed on as a lieutenant after revelations that he invited a woman,
- 55:36Jenny Harless, to his city office after hours, where she says that
- 55:40Hunt disrobed and pulled her on top of him. So now Hunt is down
- 55:46to this. He's on suspension, he had been on medical leave. He's
- 55:52closed to retirement. And when reporters in Charleston have pressed the city for more
- 55:57information about this, the mayor the chief have said, well, this is
- 56:00a personnel issue, and the city attorney has said this is a personnel issue
- 56:04and we can't say anything more about it. Those are the rules. Let
- 56:07me bring in. But we raised the question yesterday on this program, what
- 56:12do you have to do to get fired off the police force? Let me
- 56:15bring in Kenny Bass WCHSTV, who's done a lot of frontline reporting on this
- 56:19story. Kenny Good morning. How are you. I'm doing well, hopey.
- 56:22How are you today? I'm well, Thank you for coming on.
- 56:24You and I talked yesterday. You have been one of the leads, if
- 56:28not the lead, on this story. You've talked to both the women who
- 56:30say they had sexual encounters with ty Hunt. What am I missing here?
- 56:35I mean, what needs to be said about this story in your opinion?
- 56:38What needs to be said is something by the administration or something by the Charleston
- 56:42Police Department. Hiding behind it's a personnel issue is just cowardly. I mean,
- 56:46this is a public official official. This was the leader of the Charleston
- 56:51Police Department. I mean, two women have come forward credible claims of some
- 56:55type of misconduct. It was consensual with Chelsea McCoy, there was obviously the
- 57:00power dynamic in play, and it wasn't contentual with Sammy Harliss. He said,
- 57:06It's made it very clear that nothing was going to happen, and yet
- 57:09Taikon allegedly continued with his advances. So for the mayor just to say it's
- 57:15a personal issue, in the city attorney, it's a personal issue. They
- 57:17hide behind that a lot. But there's a lot of things you can say
- 57:21about the investigation, the results of the investigation, what you found to be
- 57:23true, and without damaging or violating privacy. Certainly Chief Hunt has a right
- 57:30to privacy, but in his public duties on public property, that line gets
- 57:37very, very blurry. I think it's a convenient excuse for this administration,
- 57:40which has not been very forthcoming since it took office, to hide behind and
- 57:45then to try to just move past this thing. Kenny basses with his WCHSTV.
- 57:51What about the argument that, look, there are personnel rules, and
- 57:53you can't go around saying, well, we're gonna just play loosey goosey with
- 57:59the rules in this instance, but in other instances we're going to remain We're
- 58:04going to make sure we maintain confidentiality, or the thought that if you release
- 58:07public information about this investigation, then others who might be willing to come forward
- 58:12would be reluctant to come forward because it might become public. What about that
- 58:15argument, which you've probably heard as well, who's reluctant to come forward?
- 58:20Victims? Maybe, but you can protect the victim's identity and still do an
- 58:23investigation. At the end of the day, you've got to be accountable for
- 58:28what you've done, especially if you're paid with public money, you're a public
- 58:30servant, and he's saddled with the added burden of being a law enforcement officer.
- 58:37I mean, you have to be above and beyond reproach. You have
- 58:38the power to literally arrest people, to put them in jail. You have
- 58:42the power to shoot people in certain circumstances if it's justified. I mean,
- 58:46this is a very serious position. And then to be allegedly misusing it with
- 58:51these again credible claims that we've aired that he apologized for at least in the
- 58:55Harless incident. This is this is serious stuff. And then it's to say
- 59:01personnel matters. Why did he get suspended, why has he been double demoted
- 59:07to corporals? What did you find that led you to those conclusions? And
- 59:13if you reached those conclusions, what did you fail to find out or what
- 59:16threshold wasn't crossed or you would terminate him. I like Ty Hunt. I
- 59:22think Ty Hunt was a good Charleston police chief. I had a good relationship
- 59:24with Ty Hunt for years. But at some point, if you're doing these
- 59:29things and you're the Charleston police chief and you're taking advantage of women, that
- 59:36has to be addressed. What about the rights of the women who came forward.
- 59:39They were brave enough to come forward and put their names on the line
- 59:43and their faces on the line. How have they been served by this?
- 59:45Kenny? I wrote today and you and I talked to him about this yesterday,
- 59:50and I wrote today and I mentioned this yesterday. If you don't get
- 59:53fired for this, what do you get fired for? That's first? What
- 59:58can you get fired for? If you don't get fired for this, things
- 1:00:00that are on the public record that happened, that's first. Second of all,
- 1:00:06And I think you allude to this that if the circumstances were not exactly
- 1:00:10what has come out in the public and you're reporting in others, then were
- 1:00:15there mitigating circumstances that led to him just being suspended and not fired? And
- 1:00:21if there were, I think the public has a right to know what they
- 1:00:24are. Otherwise you come away going wait a minute, asking the same question
- 1:00:28I did, and you did, like, well, why wasn't he fired?
- 1:00:30So were there other circumstances that say, well, it wasn't quite what
- 1:00:36that publicly it seemed to be. Therefore he shouldn't have been fired. In
- 1:00:40the suspension works in this instance. So I think there's that that stands out
- 1:00:47to me about this, and I think that that and I know the mayor
- 1:00:51would probably say, look, I'm gonna follow the rules no matter what.
- 1:00:53I don't care what people say on the radio. Okay, I get that.
- 1:00:57But Danny Jones said on the area yes today, And you know Danny
- 1:01:00is certainly not shy. He just said he would have fired him, and
- 1:01:05he would explain, have explained why. So that's probably the right thing to
- 1:01:09do. And if you're not going to fire an explain why any Goodwin answers
- 1:01:15to the voters. She's not on some pedestal, she's not been she's not
- 1:01:19royalty. But I mean the way this office has been operating. We've done
- 1:01:22a lot of stories with the City of Charleston administration. I worked with Amy
- 1:01:27Goodwin for years, had a good relationship with Amy Goodwin. I still hope
- 1:01:30I have a good relationship with Amy Goodwin. But the fact remains that there's
- 1:01:32been there have been some things going on that the serious questions have been raised
- 1:01:37without with very very very few answers. And wouldn't that benefit tight hunt hobby
- 1:01:43when you talk about well, if it wasn't what has been put out publicly.
- 1:01:45If it wasn't what's been put out on my reporting and others that if
- 1:01:50it wasn't that case, then explain it. Well, it wasn't that bad,
- 1:01:53and you know it's a misunderstanding, and yeah, he shouldn't have had
- 1:01:57women in his office, but that's why he wasn't fired. I think that
- 1:01:59would been a tight hunt benefit the city. We have no idea what this
- 1:02:02investigation was. It was seven months and it came out with this canny break.
- 1:02:07Kenny Basses with his WHS TV. You talked with both of the women
- 1:02:15involved in this, and what was your takeaway after talking with both of them,
- 1:02:19Each of them they were credible, they were seriously injured by what happened.
- 1:02:24Chelsea McCoy has actually filed a lawsuit. Jenny Harlst I know, has
- 1:02:29been looking for an attorney, but people have been hesitant to take the case
- 1:02:31because frankly, going there against the city of Charleston, going up against the
- 1:02:35Charleston Police Department to daunting task small town. I think at the end of
- 1:02:40the day, this is not about tight hunt and whether he got fired or
- 1:02:45whether he got suspended. At the end of the day, it's about these
- 1:02:46two women and others that we've heard about but have not reported on because we
- 1:02:52haven't gotten the same type of receipts that we did with those first two women.
- 1:02:59What exactly happened to them, how were they injured and affected? Chelsea
- 1:03:02McCoy lost her job, lost her reputation. Jenny Harlst still suffers from this.
- 1:03:07I talked to her yesterday. There is no finality for her in this,
- 1:03:12but she told me was I guess it's over. Well, it appears
- 1:03:16to be over, at least from the city standpoint, but it's not over
- 1:03:20for her when you look into their eyes and you sit across the table,
- 1:03:22and I don't want to get too dramatic here, but they're human beings and
- 1:03:27what happened to them should not have happened. And what the City of Charleston
- 1:03:30has done here in this case, in the lack of any more information that
- 1:03:37could further clarify or specify why these decisions were made, falls incredibly short.
- 1:03:43I think of the responsibility of the city and of the mayor to take care
- 1:03:46of its citizens, to take care of its officers. Remember, Chelsea McCoy
- 1:03:52was a police officer applying for a police officer job, and then the intimate
- 1:03:57encounters with then lieutenant continued after she was on the force. So how are
- 1:04:03you protecting your officers, your female officers, tell me, Kenny, go
- 1:04:10back to the And I think that's a we should explain for everybody. I
- 1:04:13mean, we know what's been reported, but not everybody has heard that pick
- 1:04:15with people were not in Charleston, but there's specific case about McCoy who was
- 1:04:18trying to become an officer and the polygraph test. So based on your reporting,
- 1:04:24what happened there, Based on your reporting, she said that she'd done
- 1:04:27drugs when she was younger, when she was a teenager. She was very
- 1:04:30concerned about taking a polygraph test and lying about that. And she said that
- 1:04:33that then, Uh, Lieutenant Hunt, who was the I think it was
- 1:04:39lieutenant forgive me if the w I think it was sergeant. It might have
- 1:04:41been sergeant at the time. Nevertheless, it might have been sergeant at the
- 1:04:44time. You're right, thank you. I don't have my notes in front
- 1:04:45of me, but he was this I do know. He was the polygraph
- 1:04:48administrator. He was the guy reading the polygraph. And she takes the polygraph
- 1:04:53and she says what she says now that she didn't use drugs, et cetera.
- 1:04:57And at the end of the polygraph he says, okay, you passed.
- 1:05:00And then from what she said happened next her accounting, her accounting that
- 1:05:05there was a couch in the polygraph examination room in City Hall at Charleston Police
- 1:05:11Department that immediately after the polygraph was finished, they had sex immediately. So
- 1:05:20you can say it's not a quid quote pro but I mean, the polygraph
- 1:05:25happens, and then they allegedly had sex on a couch in the polygraph room,
- 1:05:30and then that relationship continued for some time where he would contact her sender
- 1:05:35her text. She actually said they had sex in his office and eventually though
- 1:05:41his interest waned and things tapered off. And then there were some other mitigating
- 1:05:45circumstances with her in her career, and she said that because of that she
- 1:05:50was pressured to resign by another officer who was in ty Hunt's circle. And
- 1:05:56she loved the force. And now as part of this law this lawsuit,
- 1:05:59I understand not only is she asking for damages, she wants to be reinstated.
- 1:06:01Chelsea McCoy's also, yes, you remember the Western National Guard she served
- 1:06:05not only her city, in her state and her country. Is she perfect?
- 1:06:10No, and neither am I, and neither is anybody else. She
- 1:06:13wasn't in the position of authority, and Tyke Hunt was. And that is
- 1:06:17a big problem. All right. Kenny BASTELSTV has been on the front of
- 1:06:23the story, continues to follow it. Kenny, thanks for coming on.
- 1:06:25I appreciate it. Thank you. Hopey, all right, take care talk,
- 1:06:29he continues, right back. Pigs at the trough they can't stop eating.
- 1:06:34Kind of like Patrick Morrissey when it comes to making money from the woke
- 1:06:39sex change industry. Morrissey lobbied to spend Medicare dollars on a New York hospital
- 1:06:45that performs gender reassignment surgery, and his wife's firm lobbied for Planned parenthood.
- 1:06:50They're not just an abortion provider. They're also a group that gives puberty blockers
- 1:06:56to kids, and they have a clinic right here in Virginia. Her firm's
- 1:07:00lobbyists have given thousands of dollars to Morrissey's campaigns. So let's review, shall
- 1:07:06we kids transitioned Morrissey guzzled millions in trans cash. Patrick Morrissey says he's a
- 1:07:13true conservative. He's just a liberal lobbyist that's pigging out on the woke sex
- 1:07:18change industry. Morrissey is wrong for West Virginia. Paid for by West Virginia
- 1:07:24Forward, not authorized by any candidate or candidate's committee. Winning the lottery means
- 1:07:30time to work on my skydiving skills. I'm a thrill seek I love the
- 1:07:34rush, armstretched wide, free falling, went on the cheeks. I want
- 1:07:41to join the skydiving acrobat to you man, your turn is up. You
- 1:07:46have to exit the car wash dryer. Oh sorry, just guydipe training.
- 1:07:49I'll see you tomorrow. It's a car wash. I better check my tickets.
- 1:07:54This could be my chance West Virginia Lottery. What if it could happen
- 1:07:58to you? Please play response gives almost Pontoon Voting is a great way to
- 1:08:05spend time with your family and friends. Lou Wendell Marine has just received a
- 1:08:10new shipment of boats, so now is a great time to buy. Open
- 1:08:14Tuesday through Saturday, eight thirty to five Sunday one to five, four eighteen,
- 1:08:17First Avenue in Saint Albans. Come in and pick up your new pontoon
- 1:08:21boat. Today we give almost Blue Wendel Marine Sales, wait Furnish Family Fund.
- 1:08:30You're listening to talk Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia.
- 1:08:36Metro News this morning the biggest stories from around the state of West Virginia
- 1:08:41when you want them, brought to you by Burdett Camping Center, home of
- 1:08:45the rb Warranty Forever. Chris Lawrence at the anchor desk. We are ready
- 1:08:47to get to day who started in West Virginia with all of the information you
- 1:08:50need carry Houdah secrings you the day's headlines. Fifth tornado in West Virginia touchdown
- 1:08:56during last week's storm. That tornado was confirmed on Fifth Street and Huntington here
- 1:09:00the calbal Wayne County line. Three other tornadoes tour through Kenawk County and Saint
- 1:09:03Albans Cross Lanes and Quick and a fourth one in Fayette County which devastated the
- 1:09:09community of La Vista. Kyle Wiggs at the sports desk. Kim Caldwell has
- 1:09:13moved on to Tennessee after one year at Marshall. Both the school and the
- 1:09:16coach confirmed its Sunday the women's National Championship Game Sunday one by South Carolina over
- 1:09:23Iowa eighty seven to seventy five and Hoppy Kirchible's daily commentary. Metro News This
- 1:09:28Morning brought to you by Burdette Camping Center Listen, where you get your favorite
- 1:09:31podcasts and online at WV metro News dot com. It's two hours of sports
- 1:09:36conversation to wrap up your weekend. It's the city Net Sunday Night Sports Line.
- 1:09:42Hey, this is Travis Jones, joined myself and Greg Hunter every Sunday
- 1:09:45night from six oh six until eight o'clock as we wrap up the sports weekend.
- 1:09:47We talked Mountaineers, High School, Mountain East Conference and the latest in
- 1:09:51the national scene. The Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive. You could call
- 1:09:56or text the show at three oh four Talk three oh four. It's a
- 1:10:00perfect weekend sports wrap up on your favorite Metro News a Philly or watch the
- 1:10:03show at WV Metronews dot com. Hey there, Dave Weekly, here your
- 1:10:08host from Metro News Hotline. Get ready for an epic journey. Every weekday
- 1:10:11from three to six pm, We've got all the excitement you need from sports
- 1:10:15to tech, music, pop culture and everything in between. Join Coop and
- 1:10:17I as we bring you engaging discussions, captivating interviews, fun games, and
- 1:10:21the latest sports and entertainment headlines that will keep you av Metronews Hotline is your
- 1:10:26go to source for sports, news, entertainment, and most importantly fun.
- 1:10:30Tune in weekdays from three to six on Metronews and wv metronews dot com.
- 1:10:47Metro News Talkline with Hoppykerchible is brought to you by Encovia Insurance, encircling you
- 1:10:53with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visit in Covia dot com
- 1:10:57to learn more. Dot Line from the Encode Insurance studios in the Miller Building,
- 1:11:00the US Senate set for a showdown over the articles of impeachment against Home
- 1:11:04Land Security Secretary Alejandro Majorkos. As Democrats are expected to move quickly to dismiss
- 1:11:11the articles of impeachment. Let's bring in Ryan Schmill's Fox News Radio on Capital
- 1:11:15Hill to sort all this out. Ryan, what's going to happen? A
- 1:11:18lot to be sorted out, Hoppy, And your friend Jared is just here.
- 1:11:21He just walked down there the boot here right. Yeah, but yeah,
- 1:11:26So it looks like the motion to dismiss is a lot more likely for
- 1:11:30this trial. And you have just about every Democrat on board. It looks
- 1:11:33like even Senator Joe Manchin said earlier today he's going to vote to dismiss if
- 1:11:40Leader Schumer goes that direction. And while Republicans are probably going to make the
- 1:11:45best effort possible to keep this going and try to push for some type of
- 1:11:48trial, it just looks like if Leader Schumer decides to go this route,
- 1:11:54then he'll have the votes and be able to move on. So it'll be
- 1:11:56fifty nine something like that, or expecting unless a couple of Republicans will a
- 1:12:00couple of Republicans jump in there. I think there's a possibility it happens.
- 1:12:05We do not know for sure if any will. I think even the Republicans
- 1:12:09who probably wouldn't vote to condemn or vote vote guilty on Secretary Americas may still,
- 1:12:16you know, want the process to be carried out, which is have
- 1:12:18a trial. I think there's a big problem with precedent that's being made,
- 1:12:23and it's being made on both sides of this, whether they're supporters of my
- 1:12:26Orkus or not. They don't want to set the president of you know,
- 1:12:29tabling or dismissing impeachment trials without actually having the trial. But they also on
- 1:12:34the dem side. They don't want to set the president of you know,
- 1:12:38impeaching somebody over what they believe is policy differences. By the way, West
- 1:12:43Virginia's delegation would be split on this, as you said, Sadra Manchin,
- 1:12:46he's against trial. Senatra Capito has been a frequent critic of Majorca. So
- 1:12:51we have a split in West Virginia on net. Hey, meantime, what's
- 1:12:56up with Mike Johnson? I mean, is he still hanging by a thread?
- 1:13:00Well, we'll have to wait and see. Very curious to the how
- 1:13:02the reaction is going to go down to what it's transpired over the last fifteen
- 1:13:06minutes or so. So what happened is is that Speaker Johnson put out this
- 1:13:10message to lawmakers across the caucus and he said that he has received significant feedback
- 1:13:18that he's going to be putting these Israel Foreign Aid, Israel, Ukraine and
- 1:13:24Taiwan Foreign Aid bills on the floor. They are expected the final vote to
- 1:13:30happen on Saturday evening, but then they will also have an open amendment process,
- 1:13:33so they'll be trying to put in a fourth bilder that will have the
- 1:13:38REPO Act TikTok band bill sanctions and other measures to confront Russia, China,
- 1:13:43and Iran. That's the exact quote. And they will also be trying to
- 1:13:47put some border security text in there as well as a separate amendment slash rules.
- 1:13:53So that's kind of what the I guess the train of thought is in
- 1:13:58the course of action that Johnson has it out for us. Just now,
- 1:14:00Well, that is that's Ryan, that's big news. That might screw up
- 1:14:03your Saturday night as well. So so so Johnson wants to move ahead,
- 1:14:09as you said, on funding for Ukraine for you, do you say Israel
- 1:14:13and Taiwan? Did you say okay? And and maybe pree separate bills too,
- 1:14:17and and and those would would would those be bills that would likely pass
- 1:14:21with Democrats with some Republicans or a lot of Republicans and Democrats support or would
- 1:14:27or would would it be strictly party lines? And then the then the conservative
- 1:14:30wing, the right wing of the Republicans would would spoil it. I mean,
- 1:14:34what what would happen with all this? Well, well, I'm you
- 1:14:39know, if he puts exactly what President Biden is asking for in these bills,
- 1:14:43it looks like they would have a course of passing. I think it
- 1:14:46really depends on what this open amendment process is going to look like and what
- 1:14:50gets into the bill. But there's been some Democrats, like you have Jared
- 1:14:55Moskwitz from Florida who has said, well, if he put he's putting in
- 1:14:58there what President Biden is asking for? You know, why wouldn't Democrats support
- 1:15:02this? I think it really depends on what Democrat leadership is going to do.
- 1:15:06I think, you know, if Democrats jump on board, we'd see
- 1:15:10a pretty vast amount of bipartisan support for these bills. But I think it
- 1:15:15really just depends on if Hakeem Jeffries and Catherine Clark and the other Democrat leaders
- 1:15:19tell their party, no, we're not going to support this. The only
- 1:15:23thing we're going to take is the President Biden slash Senate Foreign Aid bill that
- 1:15:28passed I believe a month ago. That's the only thing we're going to take
- 1:15:31here. If that happens, then this is going to be doomed. And
- 1:15:34I'm not quite sure what happens next. Well, how does Mike Johnson get
- 1:15:38along with all those knives in his back? I mean, it must it
- 1:15:41must be hard. It's hard to know. And one thing that's interesting is
- 1:15:45that Moscowitz, the Democrat from Florida we were just talked about, he has
- 1:15:47said that if in fact, Speaker Johnson puts the Ukraine Aid bill in Israel,
- 1:15:53built in the Ukraine bill on the floor, you know, he doesn't
- 1:15:56see why why Democrats would want to hand a political victory over to Marjorie Taylor
- 1:16:01Green. That's one of the argents he made yesterday. And there was this
- 1:16:04other Democrat by the name of Tom Swazi, the one who just took George
- 1:16:08Santos a seat, also a Democrat. He said he's not voting for the
- 1:16:12motion to vacate and there's no concessions needed. He's just not going to support
- 1:16:15that idea. Well, well, interesting times, Ryan, you have plenty
- 1:16:19to talk about. I didn't even get to the Boeing whistleblower today, but
- 1:16:23that's going on to man. Yeah, no, it is a pretty busy
- 1:16:29day on Capitol Hill. We also got the Columbia President, Universe Columbia University
- 1:16:34president testifying before the House Education Committee right now. So this is a who
- 1:16:40Yeah, I better let you get back to work. Thanks, Ryan,
- 1:16:42I appreciate it. Thanks to being all right man, you too, well
- 1:16:45busy day on Capitol Hill, West Virginia. High speed fiber internet is coming
- 1:16:49and city Net is helping lead the way to connection. City It is West
- 1:16:53Virginia's local technology company. Their home office's phone number starts with three h four.
- 1:16:58Long after the West Virginia fiber project is completed, city Net will still
- 1:17:00be your local Internet connection. When it comes to technology, city Net connects,
- 1:17:05protects, and perfects. Okay. I was efforting to get the other
- 1:17:13side on this court decision, this federal court decision. And don't think that
- 1:17:20came together. I was multitasking here. Don't think that came together. So
- 1:17:25we're gonna have it. Looks like open phones and open text for the last
- 1:17:30half hour. At one eight hundred seven sixty five eight two five five one
- 1:17:34eight hundred seven sixty five Ta LK or text me three oh four talk three
- 1:17:40oh four. This is talk line on Metro News, the Voice of West
- 1:17:42Virginia. It's eleven thirty. Let's get a news update, checking with the
- 1:17:46Metro News radio network and find out what's happening statewide this hour, all across
- 1:17:50the great state of West Virginia. West Virginia Metro News. I'm Chris Lawrence.
- 1:17:57A fight early this morning in Kenawi County has left a man dead and
- 1:17:59a woman hospitalized. Deputies were called at the home near Shillion about two in
- 1:18:02the morning. Kaddai County Chief Deputy Joe Crawford said there was a domestic incident
- 1:18:05in which the woman was stabbed. The mail unseen was the suspect and retreated
- 1:18:11into the home refusing to come out. Crawford said it then became a standoff.
- 1:18:15Our units on scene tried to talk the individual out. During that time,
- 1:18:23he brandished a weapon from the window inside the house. Unfortunately, our
- 1:18:30deputies had to use Deadly four. He's dead, the woman is hospitalized,
- 1:18:34and the names of those individuals have not been released. The investigation is ongoing.
- 1:18:39Morgantown City Council is being pressured by some to change city homeless policies that
- 1:18:43might make it easier for those down on their luck to transition into housing.
- 1:18:46Sarah Hudson says dismantling homeless encampments causes a loss of vital paperwork for those individuals
- 1:18:53that they need to seek assistance, and she urged the city council to consider
- 1:18:56lockable bends that to provide the homeless with secure story of their belongings. First
- 1:19:00certificate, source security card, one sweep and that's all gone. You have
- 1:19:04nothing. So having a place where folks can keep stuff is vital and helping
- 1:19:10them move forward. Hudson says the cost of fifty such bends would be about
- 1:19:14fifteen hundred dollars. You're listening to Metro News, the voice of West Virginia.
- 1:19:21I'm a Laney Knight, a project manager with Civil and Environmental Consultants.
- 1:19:26Progress is active in West Virginia. CEC is proud to play a part in
- 1:19:30assisting with multiple projects that are fueling that progress. Where a small firm with
- 1:19:34big firm capabilities who also call West Virginia home. Our number one priority is
- 1:19:39to stand side by side with our clients to ensure their vision becomes a reality.
- 1:19:43At CEC, we engineer progress in the great state of West Virginia.
- 1:19:46Find out what CEC can do for you at we ARECEEC dot com. Help
- 1:19:53DEEA keep our community safe and healthy by participating in National Prescription Drug take Back
- 1:19:58Day Saturday, April twenty seven. Take action right in your own home by
- 1:20:01cleaning out your medicine cabinet of unneeded medications keep them safe, clean them out,
- 1:20:06take them back. Find a collection site near you at deatakeback dot com.
- 1:20:13Do your part to lower overdose deaths and prevent prescription drug misuse before it
- 1:20:16starts. That's deatakeback dot com. A Randolph County Elementary student is recovering from
- 1:20:23injuries suffered when a car hit him in the parking lot at school. Happened
- 1:20:27at Colton Elementary. The student was treated for minor injuries at Davis Memorial Hospital
- 1:20:31and investigation is underway, but the driver so far has not been cited.
- 1:20:34Secretary of State Macwarner announcing sample ballots for the West Virginia primary election May fourteenth
- 1:20:40are now available at the Secretary of State's website. They give voters an opportunity
- 1:20:44to see what names and issues they'll have to choose from when primary election day
- 1:20:47arrives. From the Metro News ANCHORDESK I'm Chris Lawrence. Talk line from me
- 1:21:13and COVID Sure in studios in the Miller Building one one hundred and seven sixty
- 1:21:16five eight two five five text me three oh four talk three oh four.
- 1:21:19We're going to go open phones here wants something changes for the next half hour
- 1:21:24and open texts at three oh four Talk three oh four, three oh four
- 1:21:29Talk three oh four. Happy with the ACLU defend Lance Armstrong's rights to use
- 1:21:33performance enhancing drugs to gain competitive advantages over his cycling opponents. With the ACOU,
- 1:21:39defend the rights of the Dominican Republic Little League team to use overage kids
- 1:21:42against their opponents in the Little League World Series to gain an advantage. I
- 1:21:46don't know. You'd have to ask them, Hoppy, how many cases of
- 1:21:49transgender males females who transition to male have you seen who want to compete in
- 1:21:56male sports. I haven't seen a single case or have I happy we should
- 1:22:02have four sports categories male female, trans male, trans female. This would
- 1:22:08also get closer to the goal of everyone getting a trophy. So I think
- 1:22:12that's tongue in cheek, appy. I hate that trans children have become the
- 1:22:16focal point of this gubatoil election. If we were focusing on kids in this
- 1:22:20election, I wish it was the eight thousand kids in West Virginia's foster care
- 1:22:25system that are not getting a help they need. But since we are where
- 1:22:29we are, I sincerely appreciate that you're trying to really see this from both
- 1:22:31sides. Thank you for helping this conversation instead of using it as political fodder
- 1:22:36and clickbait. Good job, hey, Speaking of which, I'm glad you
- 1:22:40mentioned this, but I'm not glad to have to relay this. But this
- 1:22:44just caught my eye this morning in show prep, and I'm going to give
- 1:22:46you just brief details of two stories. This is a WSAZTV story. Two
- 1:22:53women have been charged after a toddler died in October of last year from fentanyl
- 1:22:58exposure. One of the women was the mother of the child. One of
- 1:23:04the women is charged with child neglect resulting in death of her three year old
- 1:23:08daughter. Another woman is charged Let's see another woman has been charged with child
- 1:23:13neglect resulting in death. On October sixteenth, twenty twenty three, the child
- 1:23:18became unresponsive at her grandfather's home. Child taking the hospital and died. Second
- 1:23:26story, it's out of Parkersburg. Investigation into gunshots fired Monday afternoon led Parkersburg
- 1:23:33police to arrest two people on charges of child neglect. According to police,
- 1:23:39these two individual arrested men and a woman, and they were charged with three
- 1:23:42counts of child neglect creating risk of injury. Officers responded, shots fired,
- 1:23:48etc. Etc. While searching the apartment where they live, they found three
- 1:23:54children, ages ten, six and seven months. Officers observed deplorable living conditions
- 1:24:00that would not be safe and secure place for children to reside. They reported
- 1:24:05bags of trash piled up inside the residents on the back porch, trash strung
- 1:24:10out through the residents, residents of roaches and mice. Job Protective Services are
- 1:24:15looking into it. And the reason I say that is you could find a
- 1:24:23story or two like that every day in West Virginia. Every day with some
- 1:24:28media outlet, there will be a story or stories like that in West Virginia.
- 1:24:31And I don't think I'm exaggerating saying every day are almost every day and
- 1:24:34those are the ones we hear. About what percentage of that of cases like
- 1:24:41that to actually exist, I don't know, It's probably fractional. But the
- 1:24:45point is that so much of this is linked to the drug crisis in West
- 1:24:48Virginia. And I know that some folks with hard hearts, and sometimes I
- 1:24:53feel this way myself is Okay, you're gonna do drugs, You're gonna do
- 1:24:57serious drugs. You have an addiction issue, you don't want to get help
- 1:25:00whatever. And sometimes I get a cold heart and say, well, that's
- 1:25:05what do you what do you want? What are we supposed to do for
- 1:25:08you? But in so many of these instances, and I don't believe that
- 1:25:12ultimately, but sometimes that's my reaction. But in so many of these instances,
- 1:25:15there are innocent children. Why do we have eight thousand children in foster
- 1:25:19care because of this? Because of the drug problem. I mean, that
- 1:25:23is the biggest driver of this, is the drug problem. And so these
- 1:25:29innocent children end up in foster care, and that goodness for foster care,
- 1:25:32but ideally they be with you know, with a healthy mom and dad.
- 1:25:39But this is this is this And I promised going into the new year,
- 1:25:44I was not going to use the word existential, very oftener at all.
- 1:25:45But I think this is part of our existential problem in West Virginia. And
- 1:25:50that is one of the really, really terrible tentacles of the drug crisis.
- 1:25:58You know, it's not just the individual who suffers from addiction, but it's
- 1:26:04all the tentacles from that, and many times, so many times they are
- 1:26:09children involved. Three oh four talk three four, let's see hoppy. There
- 1:26:21was a presentation from the State lab at intrams where they were talking about DNA.
- 1:26:27Turns out biologically there are only two genders. Facts matter. Well,
- 1:26:31I don't remember that, and I'm not disputing that, But I'll say again
- 1:26:36that the medical community recognizes gender dysphoria as a Again, I think it's a
- 1:26:43psychological condition where one's gender identity does not match their biology. That is also
- 1:26:53a fact. Now, how you deal with that, how families deal with
- 1:26:58that, how individuals deal with that, that's a whole nother discussion. But
- 1:27:00gender dysphoria is a real thing, Hoppy. If a transgender boy to girl,
- 1:27:09if a transgender girl wants to play sports, then allowing transgender to occur,
- 1:27:13but play sport with the biological gender that is the boys. I'm not
- 1:27:19sure I follow that. Three oh four talk three oh four, i'ppy.
- 1:27:27Once again, West Virginia's judicial system has made news, and not in a
- 1:27:30good way. Over what what did I miss? Judicial system? What did
- 1:27:35I miss? I'm thinking about the news of the day. If you're talking
- 1:27:39about the transgender story, that was a federal court decision. If you're talking
- 1:27:45about the police chief in Charleston, that was a administrative decision, I'm not
- 1:27:48sure. Is there something I missed about West Virginia's judicial system today. If
- 1:27:54it was, tell me I don't recall Hoppy. You people have lost your
- 1:27:59mind. You have let psychological issues cross over into physical issues. The so
- 1:28:03called girl who you keep calling she and her has male sex organs. He
- 1:28:09does not have a womb or uterus, et cetera that can reproduce. He's
- 1:28:13not a female, no matter what he calls himself. Gender just for he
- 1:28:15is a mental condition, not a physical one, says the texture. The
- 1:28:24child in question, who I think now is fourteen years old maybe has identified
- 1:28:29as a girl for about five years, I think, and actually has a
- 1:28:33new birth certificate identifying as a girl. I believe. I believe I read
- 1:28:39that Hoppy interesting. The event won by the individual was a shot put,
- 1:28:45a strength and weight category that and look, I this is in the public
- 1:28:49domain, so I'm not trying to pick on anybody, but I do think
- 1:28:54it is a nugget of relevance in this discussion. So this transgender girl who
- 1:29:03plays who participates in the Bridgeport Middle School track team, there was a meet
- 1:29:10because I just was looking this morning doing some brief research. And I'm not
- 1:29:15saying this as an AHA moment, but I do think it's potentially relevant as
- 1:29:21part of the discussion. Potentially relevant as part of the discussion. Not an
- 1:29:27AHA moment. But on March thirteenth, the Bridgeport, according to what I
- 1:29:30saw on their website, the Bridgeport Middle School track team did participate in a
- 1:29:34meet where this transgender girl won the shot put and won to buy two feet.
- 1:29:45What does that mean? I don't know what it means. I don't
- 1:29:47know what it means except as a in summary, gender just for you is
- 1:29:57a real, is real? Believe that as a as a human being,
- 1:30:04and you know, as a parent, I would want to be supportive of
- 1:30:09a child or children that have gender dysph you, but I do believe there
- 1:30:13is an inherent unfairness, an inherent unfairness for a transgender girl to participate in
- 1:30:20girls' sports, even if that child is taking puberty blockers because there are physiological
- 1:30:28differences. Humpy, what was the deal with playing that ad? That a
- 1:30:38negative ad on Morrisey? Yeah, I apologize for that. That was really
- 1:30:41bad juxtaposition. It was an accident. I had Morrissey on as the Attorney
- 1:30:45General to speak to this issue and then went to a break and the first
- 1:30:50commercial in the break was a negative ad by a pack against Morrissey. And
- 1:30:55then look, I played the commercials. They're right in front of me,
- 1:30:58but I don't look down to see what's next. Typically, so I just
- 1:31:01fired the break and I apologized for that, and I texted an associated with
- 1:31:08Morsey and apologized and said, please please tell him I apologize for that.
- 1:31:13It was unfortunate. It was not on purpose, but it was unfortunate.
- 1:31:15Should have happened. Happy Trump supporters are saying transgender is part of the fall
- 1:31:23of society, while Trump is on trial for paying a porn star for sex
- 1:31:27while his wife was pregnant with child says the texture hoppy standing outside of your
- 1:31:38window on the rails to trails with my brother, Okay, hoppy having a
- 1:31:44daughter that plays sports, I don't want a person born male taking her spot
- 1:31:47on a team or victory. However, I have great sympathy for the children
- 1:31:51going through these tough times and wish politicians would not try to gain votes by
- 1:31:56making them and their parents out to be monsters. Compassion is lost in the
- 1:32:00debate. Yeah, I again, the issue does get pretty complicated. I
- 1:32:06know that we want to boil this down to something simple, but it does
- 1:32:11get complicated. I think that a big Title nine issue here to me is
- 1:32:15that Title nine was created to create equity for girl sports, and it's done
- 1:32:21that. It is created and equally generally or aspired to an equal playing field
- 1:32:26for women, and the result has been dramatic for women's sports in this country.
- 1:32:32So if you have an instance where a transgender girl competes in girl sports
- 1:32:45or young women's sports or women's sports and is superior to for physiological reasons,
- 1:32:55other girls or women in that sport, then it would seem you are by
- 1:33:00definition discriminating against the women, the biological women, and therefore would be in
- 1:33:08violation of title of Title nine. That's what it feels like to me.
- 1:33:14Take a break of me. Back talking continues after this takes at the trough.
- 1:33:18They can't stop eating, kind of like Patrick Morrissey when it comes to
- 1:33:24making money from the woke sex change industry. Morrissey lobbied to spend Medicare dollars
- 1:33:30on a New York hospital that performs gender reassignment surgery, and his wife's firm
- 1:33:34lobbied for planned parenthood. They're not just an abortion provider, they're also a
- 1:33:41group that gives puberty blockers to kids, and they have a clinic right here
- 1:33:45in West Virginia. Her firm's lobbyists have given thousands of dollars to Morrissey's campaigns,
- 1:33:50So let's review. Shall we kids transitioned? Morrissey guzzled millions in trans
- 1:33:57cash. Patrick Morrissey says he's a true conservative. He's just a liberal lobbyist
- 1:34:02that's pigging out on the woke sex change industry. Morrissey is wrong for West
- 1:34:08Virginia. Paid for by West Virginia Forward, not authorized by any candidate or
- 1:34:12Candidates committee. We get almost team Pontoon Voting is a great way to spend
- 1:34:21time with your family and friends. Lou Wendell Marine has just received a new
- 1:34:26shipment of boats, so now is a great time to buy. Open Tuesday
- 1:34:30through Saturday eight thirty to five Sunday one to five, four eighteen, First
- 1:34:33Avenue in Saint Albans. Come in and picking up your new pontoin. Vote
- 1:34:38today. We get almost Lou Wendel Marine Sales. We furnish Family Fund.
- 1:34:45Larry Pack is a proven conservative Republican running for State Treasurer who fights for our
- 1:34:50families. Larry Pack is one hundred percent pro life and supports the Second Amendment.
- 1:34:56Larry Pack has real West Virginia values. Larry Pack is a proven job
- 1:35:00creator and knows what it takes to grow our economy. Larry Pack helped Governor
- 1:35:04Justice deliver the largest tax cut in state history. Our families now keep more
- 1:35:09of their hard earned money. Let's all vote for Republican Larry Pack for State
- 1:35:13Treasurer. Paid for by Larry Pack for West Virginia Larry Pack Treasurer. This
- 1:35:17is talk Line on Metro News, The Voice of West Virginia. West Virginia
- 1:35:24Outdoors is the Mountain State's only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more
- 1:35:29than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence
- 1:35:32has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years.
- 1:35:36I shot him. He ran over to the edge of the field. He
- 1:35:40made it about five ten yards out of the edge of the field and fall
- 1:35:44over there. Whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the
- 1:35:48enjoyment of the great outdoors. He stuck his head through the blind into where
- 1:35:54you were. Yeah, yeah, Well he had jumped he leaked, okay
- 1:35:58blind, Oh gosh, yeah, he had. His whole body was in
- 1:36:01the air for a couple of seconds and is the only man that landed in
- 1:36:05the blonde was, of course in its front leg. West Virginia Outdoors covers
- 1:36:10it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for your daily fix,
- 1:36:14Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes of news and notes from the
- 1:36:17woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News of Voice of West Virginia.
- 1:36:23Hey everybody, it's Tony Courritty, I'm Greg Hunter and I'm Brad Howe,
- 1:36:26and we invite you to join us Sunday through Fridays right here on the Metro
- 1:36:30News radio network. It's the city Net Statewide sports Line. We talk West
- 1:36:34Virginia University football, basketball, baseball, you name it. If it's got
- 1:36:39anything to do with the Golden Blue, we're on it. And don't forget
- 1:36:42the text line available every night. So we invite you to join us.
- 1:36:45The Senator coach Hunter and me Tony Coritti. It's the city Nets state wide
- 1:36:49sports line on Metro News News in the Mountain State. Happens quick and for
- 1:36:55decades you have depended on Metro News for accurate news delivered fast. Now here's
- 1:37:00your chance to help keep your fellow West Virginians informed. If you see news
- 1:37:03happening, become a Metro News hawk by texting news too three five sixty five
- 1:37:08to one. If you take a picture or video of what you see,
- 1:37:12submit that as well. Text the word news to three five sixty five one
- 1:37:15to submit your tip or story. Standard texting rates apply. Please don't text
- 1:37:20and drive. Metro News talk Line with Hoppy Kerchible is brought to you by
- 1:37:38Encoda Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most.
- 1:37:43Visit in Covia dot com to learn more. Talk line from the COVID Shurt
- 1:37:45studios. Back to the text at three or four Talk three or four Hoppy
- 1:37:48two things can be true at the same time. A biological male can have
- 1:37:51gender just for you, and it can still be unfair for that biological male
- 1:37:57transgender female to compete against females. That's a pretty good summary of what I
- 1:38:02think about this. I'll be class move with you apologizing. I'm not a
- 1:38:09Morrissey fan, but I'm a happy fan. Stuff happens. Don't beat yourself
- 1:38:12up. Well, I look the campaigns, and I get it that candidates
- 1:38:18are sensitive. I mean two things. They got to be very very evident
- 1:38:23to have thick skin. But also it's it's rough and tumble, and they
- 1:38:27get it gets more rough and tumble all the time. And Morrissey is being
- 1:38:30excoriated by some of these packs over the whole transgender issue, and so it
- 1:38:38was. It was an awkward juxtaposition, to say the least, and it
- 1:38:42was not fair. It was not fair to to Morrissey Hobby. I don't
- 1:38:48know why you're apologizing for these commercials. Your radio network pushes this agenda.
- 1:38:59I'll be there. Approximately one point five percent of the population born as true
- 1:39:01hermaphrodites. Those individuals should be allowed to choose prior to puberty, take the
- 1:39:06necessary meds surgery, that participate in the chosen gender. Biologically, males should
- 1:39:12not be given an option as it opens to many problems and no longer is
- 1:39:15no longer fair to the biological female, says the texture. I'll be when
- 1:39:23a transgender man or a woman, Okay, when a transgender woman gets in
- 1:39:30the octagon with John Jones, I'll believe this is about equality. Wonder why
- 1:39:36women don't want to fight men. I mean, a transgender man is really
- 1:39:41a man, right, I'll be to be fair. Maybe we need a
- 1:39:46newsport classification for trans athletes. Yeah, I don't know. I mean,
- 1:39:51I don't know about that. I've heard people suggest that, but I mean,
- 1:39:56how many trans athletes are there? I don't think through that many.
- 1:40:00The only one public we know publicly we know about West Virginia is the is
- 1:40:04the transgirl in Bridgeport. So I don't know how many they are really there?
- 1:40:08Really are I mean, the parents of this transcender athlete from Harris County,
- 1:40:15did they seek medical advice for puberty blockers and vaccinations to attend public schools?
- 1:40:20If our children are subject to the greater good for our community, it
- 1:40:24appears that Marcy is right. Well, I know that the I have to
- 1:40:30go back to the just the Court opinions like sixty four pages long. I
- 1:40:34don't know if I can find a particular section of that, but I know
- 1:40:40that the child in question has been taking puberty blockers. I'm looking for that
- 1:40:48section right now, and I think the key section might be this that before
- 1:40:57puberty, circulating testosterone levels do very significantly depending on whether a person has two
- 1:41:02x chromosomes one X and one y chromosomes, so biological male or female,
- 1:41:06or some other genetic makeup. Once puberty begins, however, sex based differences
- 1:41:12begin to emerge. Those differences, along with others that begin at the same
- 1:41:15time, lead to different physical processes during puberty. These differences manifest at what
- 1:41:19the medical professionals call the Tanner two stage. The court goes on to say
- 1:41:26the majority that the undisputed evidence shows that this BPJ Becky Pepper Jackson has never
- 1:41:33gone through the Tanner two stage. As part of her treatment for gender dysphoria,
- 1:41:41be Pepper Jackson began receiving puberty blocking treatment at the beginning of that stage.
- 1:41:45The medication prevented Becky Pepper Jackson from progressing through the Tanner two stage of
- 1:41:51puberty. As a result, Becky Pepper Jackson has never experienced has never experienced
- 1:41:58elevated levels of circulating testostero. That's what the majority found in they're ruling,
- 1:42:02all right, we'll be right back, stay with us. Winning the lottery
- 1:42:05means time to work on my skydiving skills. I'm a thrill seek I love
- 1:42:11the rush, armstretched wide, free falling win on the cheeks. I want
- 1:42:16to join the skydiving acrobat too. Man, your turn is up. You
- 1:42:21have to exit the car wash dryer. Oh sorry, just skydimee training.
- 1:42:26I'll see you tomorrow. It's a car wash. I better check my tickets.
- 1:42:30This could be my chance. West Virginia Lottery. What if it could
- 1:42:32happen to you? Please play responsibly? What's in a number? If you
- 1:42:40match just six of twenty five correctly playing Cash twenty five for the West Virginia
- 1:42:43Lottery, you'll take them a top prize of twenty five thousand dollars. Drawings
- 1:42:46are held Mondays, Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Fridays. It only costs a
- 1:42:49dollar to play, With four drawings each week. The odje are pretty good.
- 1:42:53You're gonna have fun playing cash twenty fives at the trough. They can't
- 1:42:59stop. Kind of like Patrick Morrissey when it comes to making money from the
- 1:43:03woke sex change industry. Morrissey lobbied to spend Medicare dollars on a New York
- 1:43:10hospital that performs gender reassignment surgery, and his wife's firm lobbied for planned parenthood.
- 1:43:15They're not just an abortion provider, They're also a group that gives puberty
- 1:43:20blockers to kids, and they have a clinic right here in West Virginia.
- 1:43:26Her firm's lobbyists have given thousands of dollars to Morrissey's campaigns, So let's review.
- 1:43:31Shall we kids transitioned? Morrissey guzzled millions in trans cash. Patrick Morrissey
- 1:43:38says he's a true conservative. He's just a liberal lobbyist that's pigging out on
- 1:43:43the woke sex change industry. Morrissey is wrong for West Virginia. Paid for
- 1:43:48by West Virginia Forward, not authorized by any candidate or candidate's committee. A
- 1:43:56West Virginia scholar program changes the lives of families. High school juniors can now
- 1:44:00apply for full scholarship at West Virginia Wesleyan College, one of our state's finest
- 1:44:06institutions of higher learning. If your child is a high school junior, now
- 1:44:10is the time to go to WV Metro news dot com, have them apply
- 1:44:14today, and they could win a full scholarship to West Virginia Wesleyan that includes
- 1:44:18room, board, tuition, and fees. To apply, simply log on
- 1:44:23to WV Metro news dot com and click on the West Virginia Scholarlink. You
- 1:44:27have until midnight April twenty eighth to apply. The twenty twenty four West Virginia
- 1:44:31Scholar Program is sponsored by Greer Industries, West Virginia Hospital Association, GML,
- 1:44:38Architects and Engineers, A, West Virginia Farm Bureau, and Friends of Coal.
- 1:44:42If you're a high school junior in West Virginia, here's your chance to
- 1:44:45possibly change your life forever. Go to WV metro news dot com, clickcom
- 1:44:49the West Virginia Scholarlink and apply Today. You're listening to talk Line on Metro
- 1:44:57News, the voice of West Virginia. WV metronews dot com the only website
- 1:45:03you need to stay informed in the Mountain State. Get the latest news and
- 1:45:08sports story, information on the great outdoors, and never miss an episode of
- 1:45:12your favorite Metro News programs and podcasts, including Talkline, Hotline, sports Line,
- 1:45:17and Three Guys Before the Game. Make a bookmark now and visit do
- 1:45:21WV metronews dot com first thing every morning to find out what's happening all across
- 1:45:27the state. WV metronews dot com. West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain states
- 1:45:31only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than quarter million hunters and
- 1:45:36anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down hunting
- 1:45:42and fishing stories for more than twenty five years. Stockfish for repatriation purposes to
- 1:45:46that's reintroduction, re establishment of brookshrout and two of those streams, the oldest
- 1:45:51that we have worked on, the earliest ones that we started putting fish into.
- 1:45:56We've noticed natural reproduction in both of those streams, whether it's hunting and
- 1:46:00fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great outdoors. It
- 1:46:04was a pretty good fride. It takes me about ten minutes to get it
- 1:46:08in. My dad actually had to run to the truck and grab ant because
- 1:46:12there's my way. I could list him up over top of the rail.
- 1:46:15West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for
- 1:46:19your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes of news
- 1:46:24and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News of Voice
- 1:46:29of West Virginia. It's two hours of sports conversation to wrap up your weekend.
- 1:46:32It's the City Net Sunday night sports line. Hey, this is Travis
- 1:46:35Jowes joining myself and Greg Hunter every Sunday night from six oh six until eight
- 1:46:40o'clock as we wrap up the sports weekend. We talked Mountaineers, high School,
- 1:46:44Mountain East Conference, and the latest in the national scene. The Sunday
- 1:46:46Sports Line is listener interactive. You could call or text the show at three
- 1:46:51oh four Talk three oh four. It's a perfect weekend sports wrap up on
- 1:46:56your favorite Metro news aphilia or watch the show at wv metronews dot com.
- 1:47:11Texter Texter says I have two granddaughters involved in cross country and track. The
- 1:47:15ruling is wrong on so many levels. Everyone knows that apparently we've come a
- 1:47:19long way. Baby doesn't mean much anymore. Women who've worked hard to have
- 1:47:24opportunities in sports should be in an uproar, says the Texter. See you
- 1:47:28tomorrow. This has been talk Line on Metro News. Metro News is the
- 1:47:30voice of West Virginia.