Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 538. Does T4 - Synthroid Cause Cancer?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Thyroid Fixer podcast, where we dive deep into the world of thyroid and hormones, especially for you ladies navigating perimenopause and menopause, and really for anyone struggling with hypothyroidism. I'm your host, Dr. Amy, thyroid and hormone specialist and CEO of a global telemedicine practice where we prescribe the right thyroid treatment and bioidentical hormones to all 50 states and most of Canada, helping you become that badass human that you're meant to be.
- 0:30So if you're battling weight gain and hair loss, you can't lose weight no matter what you do, your energy levels are plummeting and your libido left town, then you're in the right place and you have found your tribe. Remember, I want you to embrace every inch of that badass woman that you truly are. So if you're ready to dive in and fix things,
- 0:49Let's get started. Does Synthroid T4 cause cancer? This question was brought to me in response to an Instagram post that I did updating everyone on my cancer journey. If you haven't seen it, bounce over to my IG. But in one of the posts where I was updating you all that I'm finally turning a corner and feeling human again...
- 1:11After my hysterectomy, the cancer's gone, I'm free. Someone replied to my post saying, well, you might want to check out Dr. So-and-so because Synthroid and T3, all those synthetic thyroid hormones you're taking cause cancer. And of course, the fighter in me immediately wanted to lash out, but I stepped back and I said, okay, let me keep an open mind and look into this because this isn't the first time that I've heard this statement.
- 1:40Now, whenever we make a statement like that, we better back it in science. Now, I will admit my initial reply to this woman was, I take exception over doctors like Dr. So-and-so saying that and using scare tactics to basically push people into his program where he can't prescribe thyroid medication.
- 2:06And that's really what I see in this functional and integrative world. And I've said it before on other podcasts. The practitioners who cannot prescribe you those beautiful hormones that you need, practitioners who cannot give you the T3, the T4, the estrogen, the progesterone, the testosterone, those amazing, beautiful, natural, bioidentical hormones that you need, well, they have to find another way to make money. And the way they're going to do that,
- 2:32is by pushing quick fixes and detox protocols and fixing the cell protocols in order to get you to pay them. So one way to do that is fear. So I thought, you know, instead of completely destroying this doctor, let me back up and look at the research. Because whenever we make a statement, we need to stop, pause, take a breath, and look at all of the research. And I'm not talking just one study. I mean everything.
- 3:01Now, this is not the first time that I've heard this about the correlation of the causation, the correlation between levothyroxine or T4 or Synthroid and cancer risk. The last time I heard this and the last time I spent any time looking into it, the outcomes that I found were exactly in line with the outcomes that I found yesterday.
- 3:23So nothing really has changed from the last time that I heard some jibber jabber about T4 and cancer. And I thought, well, you know, since I've just walked this cancer path, let's do everything we possibly can to gain all the knowledge.
- 3:38so that I can pass this information on to you and help all of you avoid the big C in any way, shape, or form. So then the question became, is this something that we have to worry about? What we're going to do is actually break this all down together. So we are deep diving, but don't worry, we're going to keep it simple. We're going to talk about how too much...
- 4:00Synthroid might be quietly affecting your immune system and nudging cancer-promoting pathways. And this is not fear-mongering. It's about understanding the science so that you can take charge. Before we dive into that, we have to review what is reverse T3 because this plays a role. So when we're talking about T4, T4 has to convert
- 4:23and become T3. It has two paths it can go down. It can either go down the path of becoming the active thyroid hormone T3, or it can go down this other path and become something called reverse T3. It's the inactive thyroid hormone. It's your antithyroid hormone. And when your reverse T3 is elevated...
- 4:42It actually puts you into a survival mode state. Something called human dormancy syndrome occurs. And this is where your body basically thinks it's a bear in the winter and it goes into hibernation. And what that means is no more fat burning, no more energy production. Forget about your brain functioning or even pooping every day. You are in survival mode. So we never, ever want reverse T3 elevated.
- 5:07And we have downloads all over the place on what the optimal range of reverse T3 is. But for right now, I want you to know that if reverse T3 is high, if it's elevated, if it's above a 12, if it is above a 12 on your labs, your body is in lockdown. The only thing that converts to reverse T3 is...
- 5:25is T4. So we can easily extrapolate from that that high doses of T4, which are very, very common, can all push up reverse T3 levels. Now we can stack this, right? So we can stack that high dose of T4 that your doctor is giving you where they just keep raising your value. Doc, I'm not feeling any better. Well, we started you on 50 micrograms of Synthroid. Let's take that to 88. And let's take that to 112. And then let's take that to 125.
- 5:53And they keep going higher and higher and higher and you feel no better. And then they're probably not even testing a reverse T3, but that's on the side here. That's a side point. They keep adding in more and more and more T4. You stack that with stress. You stack that with inflammation, nutrient deficiencies, low iodine. And now you have...
- 6:13an elevated reverse T3. And when I say elevated, again, I'm not saying that it has to be red on your labs. It doesn't have to have a little H next to it. It's above a 12. It's elevated in functional medicine. You are outside of the optimal range of reverse T3.
- 6:28When reverse T3 is elevated and it puts your body in shut down mode and you are not burning fat, your brain's not functioning, your cells aren't functioning to produce ATP or any kind of energy whatsoever for you, your gastrointestinal tract slows down, digestion slows down, elimination and detox slow down, circulation slows down. Do you think that your immune system might also slow down? Okay. Okay.
- 6:57Let's just put that out there. Now we've said that, let's keep building on this and then we'll put it all together in the end. We talked about reverse T3. I think it's also important to mention that with that elevated reverse T3, as I've said many times on many different shows, it acts like a bouncer at the club. So it's going to sit outside of your cell door and block T3 from actually entering the cell. We need T3. So now let's break down T3. T3 actually feeds your immune system.
- 7:26T3 helps immune cells like dendritic cells wake up and fight, fight infection, fight critical illness, fight cancer. But if you have low T3 and high reverse T3, which we see in critical illness over and over again, that's going to leave your immune system sluggish and not working to the best of its ability. Think of T3 as T3.
- 7:50your morning coffee for your immune cells. It boosts their alertness. And reverse T3 is like decaf. Takes away the buzz and it blocks the real coffee from working. So your immune cells are in a dormant state as well. When we go back to T4,
- 8:07And combine that with reverse T3. T4 and reverse T3 hook on to a cell surface receptor called integrin alpha V beta 3. Long word. But this triggers a pathway that encourages cell growth and blood vessel formation. A pathway that cancer tumors love.
- 8:29Just take that alone. So we're blocking T3 that actually activates your immune cells. So going back to that woman's statement on my Instagram post, right there, she's 100% incorrect that T3 causes cancer because that's not true. T3 boosts your immune cells. If T3 is boosting immune cells and T3 is lowering reverse T3,
- 8:56And T3 will ultimately lower your free T4 because naturally, when you have more of the active thyroid hormone on board, your T4 need and your T4 level will be lower as will your reverse T3. As long as you're not pounding the T4 over and over again on top of the T3, you need to make the right adjustments. But if T3 is actually boosting your immune system and high levels of T4 and high levels of reverse T3 shut it down...
- 9:25then that's a 100% false statement that T3 will cause cancer. Okay, let's just put that on the table right off the bat and take any stress off of you that you might have been sitting there thinking, oh my God, does my lyothyronine cause cancer? No, it actually helps protect you. So looking at how thyroid hormones influence immune function and cancer biology at the cell level,
- 9:47T3 comes in and plays that vital role in regulating those dendritic cells, which serves as an essential antigen presenting cell, bridging your innate and your adaptive immunity. We heard a lot about this back in 2020, innate and adaptive immunity. So research shows that those dendritic cells,
- 10:08express thyroid hormone receptors and they respond to optimal physiological levels of T3 by upregulating key markers. And I'm not even gonna go into what all those key markers are, but key markers that basically fight cancer.
- 10:25You may have heard of CD8, CD86, CD40, MHC2. And then T3 also increases interleukin-12 production. You may have heard of that. And enhances the ability of those dendritic cells to promote native T cell proliferation and IFNY release. Oh my gosh, what does that mean? It means that it's signaling your immune cells to take action.
- 10:49It's helping your dendritic cells, which is your body's early warning system, to activate other immune cells, the T cells, so that they can multiply and get ready to fight viruses and cancer. And it actually helps boost the production of interferon gamma, which is a powerful molecule that helps your body target and destroy viruses, bacteria, and cancer. So what can we take from that? T3 and optimal levels of T3 are fantastic. And lyothyrene and cytomel.
- 11:18In their so-called synthetic form, of course, I call them biosynth because they are biologically identical to the T4 and the T3 that your body makes. And yes, I put Synthroid and Levo and Tyrosynth into that category. So even the biosynthetic T3 of Liothyronine and Cytomel is beneficial and actually helps protect you.
- 11:41from cancer by supporting your immune system. Now again, kind of bouncing back to T4 and reverse T3, thyroxin, T4, and reverse T3. Remember they bind to that membrane receptor and the activation of this receptor triggers these signaling cascades that drive cell proliferation and angiogenesis.
- 12:03a process that tumor cells exploit for growth. So we do not want that. That's something that's bad, something we want to avoid. So reverse T3 and T4 will bind to this growth receptor on your cell. And when this happens, it flips that switch inside your body. It's signaling the cells to grow and form new blood vessels.
- 12:25And this isn't necessarily helpful like healing a wound. Cancer cells also love to grow. They hijack this system to grow faster and to spread. So when your body has too much T4 or your reverse T3 is high and not enough T3 is in the body,
- 12:41It can unintentionally help those bad cancer cells thrive. These hormones can also hide cancer from your immune system. So here's the scary part. Those same signals that promote cell growth, they also send out messages that tell your immune system, stand down, back off.
- 12:59We don't need you. They increased this molecule called PD-L1, something that cancer cells use to hide from your body's natural defenses, almost like camouflage. And then at the same time, your important watchdog immune cells, the ones that actually tag the dangerous cells so the rest of your immune system can attack,
- 13:18They get weaker and they stop doing their job. So what does that mean? Now you have a system where cancer cells are hiding and they can't be killed. And the watchdog cells that normally go, hey, there's a cancer cell over there. We better go out and attack. They're in the barracks.
- 13:34They're taking a vacation. That is the perfect scenario for cancer to grow and spread. Now, I'm not saying this to scare you. Once again, I want to give you all of the facts. And in fact, this little deep dive...
- 13:49that I just went down in the last 24 hours, is interesting in that it's also giving all of us another leg to stand on with our doctors who want to push more and more and more T4, who want to refuse to test reverse T3, who tell you that T3 is bad for you, now you can call bullshit. Now you can actually send them this episode, which they probably won't listen to,
- 14:16where I am literally sitting here staring at the studies, staring at the science as I record this, where it explains exactly the different mechanisms and pathways that improper thyroid treatment and lack of testing can actually help produce cancer. All right, let's keep going. Let's dive into those studies where we can break down exactly what,
- 14:43The fear mongers out there are grabbing onto to make their big, broad, scary statement that T4 and T3 in their synthetic forms cause cancer. Again, we have to look at the details and not make broad swooping statements. There was a Swedish national cohort study done in 2020 with a 2025 update.
- 15:04There's a really large cohort of 8.6 million adults. And T4 use was used, and they found that it modestly increased overall cancer risk. And the cancers involved were breast, colon, skin, ancreas, and thyroid. Now, when you look at this study, the one thing that's missing...
- 15:25is testing for reverse T3. Now they are showing that levothyroxine treatment is linked to an elevated cancer risk, particularly in women, but they're not saying why. They're not really getting into the different doses of T4, assuming everyone was on T4 only. And again, tying it back to what we already said, if they are low in free T3,
- 15:50the participants are not currently on any kind of T3 therapy, which improves our immune system and helps protect the body. And they're only on T4, which activates all these different pathways, suppresses the immune system, keeps them hypothyroid, increases the reverse T3. Well, then that's the reason. So again, this study is showing a correlation between
- 16:13but they're not showing a causation because there isn't one. There's no direct cause as in what is in this particular medication causes your body to form cancer. You know, this isn't a glyphosate pill, right? This isn't a Roundup pill. We know if I gave you a Roundup pill every single day of your life, you probably would show some kind of cancer because there is a causation effect that
- 16:39that we know already with the multitude of lawsuits out there. But with the information that's out there regarding glyphosate, we know it's a carcinogen. It is tagged as a direct carcinogen or a cancer-causing molecule. Levothyroxine, synthroid, tyrosine, in and of itself, and used in monotherapy, okay, not my favorite. It's not going to get you optimized. It's not going to give you the best life ever. But it's not a causation of cancer. It does not directly cause cancer.
- 17:09There have been other studies like the Taiwan National Health Database study in 2021 that had 600,000 T4 users versus 2.4 million controls. And they showed that T4 use was linked to roughly a 50% increased cancer risk for brain, skin, pancreatic and breast. Yeah.
- 17:29Now again, when we break this down, when we look at it, were they testing for reverse T3? Were they actually looking at the person's free T3 levels? What were these people on? Were they optimized? And this is where a lot of these studies fall short. Now, there is an interesting study that compared T3 users alone or in combination versus T4 only users.
- 17:58And they found no increased cancer risk for the T3 users alone or in combination. So this is how it actually broke down. And this is going to simplify all of these studies for you. And then I'll give you the takeaways. T4 alone, mild to moderate increased risk, dose and duration dependent.
- 18:17Now, okay, it's not perfect. They're not talking about the reverse T3 levels, but they're at least taking into account the dose that someone is on, which increased dose of T4 will increase your reverse T3 and will decrease your free T3.
- 18:32duration if you've been on T4 only for decades, which many people out there are because it's standard of care, quote unquote. If you've been on T4 only for decades, then yes, you are at an increased risk of cancer. And my suggestion would be get your shit together and get optimized.
- 18:51Work with someone who knows what they're doing with the thyroid. And absolutely, this is a shameless plug for what we do because we do it right, because we know what we're doing. And I will stand on a mountain every single day and shout it out that myself and my team, we know what we're doing when it comes to the thyroid and to optimizing you. We do it every single day. And I get so tired of all of these practitioners out there promising you the world and leaving you in the dust.
- 19:20So not only are they leaving you fat, foggy, tired, constipated, in pain, bald, they're also leaving you with an increased risk of cancer. And that, that is something to stand your ground on, isn't it? That is something you get a little bit pissed off about, isn't it? That is something to fire your doctor over, isn't it? And shouldn't that alone light a fire?
- 19:46under you, that if you won't take the next steps to get optimized for your weight, for your hair, for your beauty, for your aesthetics, for getting through your day, for having any kind of energy or being able to remember your dog's name, will you do it?
- 20:01to prevent cancer. Will you do it so that you don't have to hear the C word? Okay, moving on. T4, high dose. It actually has the category. And even greater, remember T4 alone, and I didn't give the dose here. This is just a summary table. T4 alone, mild to moderate increased risk. Dose and duration dependent. T4, high dose, even a greater increased risk, especially in thyroid cancer survivors. Now let's pause here on this point.
- 20:30If you've had thyroid cancer, what do we try to do with your TSH? We try to suppress it so that thyroid tissue cannot just grow back. 99.9% of endocrinologists and surgeons who remove your thyroid will put you on T4 only. Now, I have a whole separate podcast for my thyroidectomy patients, for my partial thyroidectomy peeps out there, for my radioactive iodine peeps out there.
- 20:56where I specifically dive into why you desperately need T4 and T3. And the summary of that is they removed your thyroid gland that once produced T4 and T3. They removed the main conversion gland of T4 to T3. T4 is inactive, T3 is active, and they only give you the T4 inactive thyroid hormone. It makes no sense. Just when I say that, that paragraph alone, right, makes no sense.
- 21:19So in thyroid cancer survivors, we are suppressing your TSH or they, not we, we do it the right way. They are suppressing your TSH with high doses of T4. Well, that actually increases your risk of cancer. So as they're trying to prevent your thyroid cancer from coming back, they're increasing your risk of all cancers.
- 21:40And more specifically, because breast cancer kind of showed up on top here, significant increased risk for breast cancer, but there was also an increased risk for all cancers. Now we go down to the next therapy type, which is T3 alone, or T3 and T4 together showed no increased risk.
- 22:01And you want to know what's in the notes? Possibly protective with a lower mortality rate. I think we should say that again. T3 alone or T4 and T3 in combination showed no increased risk of cancer and actually showed to be protective, lowering all cause mortality. So what are our takeaways? High dose or long-term Synthroid.
- 22:23T4, Levo, Tyrosins, compounded T4, T4 only. Use may increase your cancer risk. Reverse T3 plays a role in this by blocking the T3 receptors and activating growth pathways.
- 22:38Now, lyothyronine, like this well-meaning individual was trying to warn me about on Instagram because she got it from Dr. So-and-so who's using the fear tactics to boost his business. Lyothyronine T3 appears totally safe with no increased cancer incidence or...
- 22:56mortality. So the clinical considerations from this study, number one, avoid that TSH over suppression in thyroid cancer survivors with T4 only. We can get TSH suppression with T3 as well, which remember the T3 and T4 therapy type showed no increased risk. So why don't we just do that? Because this poor person has already had cancer once, already heard that C word once. Why do we want them to hear it again? Right.
- 23:23monitor reverse T3 and free T3 to assess tissue level thyroid function. Wow, that's not something I've ever said, is it? Oh my God. Something I say every day and that should be done on every single thyroid test. And if your doctor is not testing reverse T3 and free T3, and I don't care if they're functional, conventional, integrative, alternative, naturopathic, you got to run. Because if they're not testing reverse T3 every single time, if they're not testing free T3 every single time, they don't know what they're doing with the thyroid test.
- 23:51Consider combination therapy if you're symptomatic on T4 alone. Wow, go figure. Again, something else I've been saying forever. T4 only when we're talking about those other symptoms that affect us daily, the weight gain, the hair loss, the fatigue, the brain fog. T4 only.
- 24:10only works in 2% of those with hypothyroidism. 98% need T4 and T3. 100% need T4 and T3 to reduce your cancer risk. Apparently there's 2% out there that they're not gaining weight and their brain is functioning and they're pooping every day on their T4 only. Good for them. We give them props. The only thing I would say to those people in that 2%,
- 24:36would be to watch your cancer risk. Because just because you feel good doesn't mean that your body's happy on the inside. And if you're walking around with an elevated reverse T3 and low free T3, while you may not have debilitating symptoms, you are at an increased risk of cancer. And then just get your labs done often. Get them all done, like I just said, and get them done often. And really take a step back and look and make sure that you are in the optimal range.
- 25:02Yes, optimally, in a perfect world that goes by, how do you feel? If I ask you those four most important words that every single practitioner should ask you, especially when they're looking at your labs, because you're more than a lab value, they should be asking you, how do you feel? When they ask you, how do you feel? If you feel amazing and you have zero symptoms, that's fantastic. We're not going to change a lot. But I do want you to come over here and peek at...
- 25:27your free T3 and your reverse T3. And let's make sure that those are as close to optimal as possible just for that extra layer of protection. So in summary, Liothyronine, Levothyroxine, Cytomel, Synthroid, Tyrosin, Levoxyl, Tyrosin Sol, do not directly cause T3.
- 25:48cancer. They are not carcinogenic. Anyone that makes that big, bold statement, I want you to unfollow them, unsubscribe, and block because they are spreading fear for whatever motive they have. And they haven't even taken the time like I just did to step back and look at all the different studies out there. What?
- 26:08do those studies say? How do they break it down? How are they coming to those conclusions? Is there something in Synthroid that directly triggers your body to produce cancer cells? No, no. It's that too much T4 is keeping you in that hypostate. It's keeping your immune system suppressed.
- 26:28keeping your T3 that is so beautiful and so protective to your immune system, that active thyroid hormone that gives power and wakes up your immune cells to help them spot the bad guys, the cancer cells, and attack them, keeps it healthy, keeps it active. That's the information that we need to know about you, but I don't want you in fear.
- 26:49fear as you pop your sin throat every morning, hopefully with a little bit of T3. I don't want you to live in fear based on someone's big, bold statement. I want you to be okay, live in peace. But the takeaway from this is that you need to look at how optimized your thyroid is. And possibly from this information, it might make you stand your ground a little bit more with your doctor. It might cause you to find a new doctor, book a call with us.
- 27:17take steps so that you can not only live a better life and reduce or eliminate all of those hypothyroid symptoms that are totally consuming your day, but so you can also put another layer, another layer of protection on your body against cancer. So I am happy to say to that person, to Dr. So-and-so, and to everyone out there that my T3 only used for the last...
- 27:4118 years did not cause my endometrial uterine cancer. It didn't. I'm pretty, I'm 100% positive on that. How about that? I am 100%. As I've stated in previous podcasts, no one really knows what directly happens.
- 27:57causes cancer. It's a variety of different mechanisms from a genetic predisposition to it, to environmental, to emotional trauma, thoughts, cortisol, all of it. So for someone out there to stand there and say a thyroid hormone causes cancer, they have their head up their ass. They need to really look at cancer. They don't even have to go into cancer research. How about
- 28:25that there are so many different pathways that trigger these cells to mutate and basically go crazy. But all that being said, my goal is to give you some peace and peace of mind with this podcast, but also to light a little bit of fire under your ass to get your thyroid optimized.