Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E050: Bitcoin’s Monetary Realities with Bitstein
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company on ramps. Multi institution custody is a
- 0:35segregated institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:39institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:43unique permissions have been met at on RAMP we understand that
- 0:47your Bitcoin journey is a multi generational pursuit catalyzed
- 0:50by the ideals of perseverance, aspiration and legacy.
- 0:54That's why we're proud to introduce on RAMP Heritage, a
- 0:57suite of private client services dedicated to ensuring your
- 1:00Bitcoin legacy is preserved and passed on, embodying the true
- 1:04essence of wealth that goes beyond mere numbers.
- 1:07If you would like to learn more, please schedule a consultation.
- 1:10What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 1:15going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extremism
- 1:19ever assembled in the history of Darkness. 1974, 198792972000.
- 1:28And whatever you want to call this, it's all just the same
- 1:30thing over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 1:34I say when we sell. I say when we.
- 1:43Sell. All right.
- 1:44Well, welcome to this week's edition of The Last Trade.
- 1:48A little bit different format today Marty is it was
- 1:52unavailable for this for this time in the end.
- 1:55So I'm going to pretend to be Marty as as the the pseudo host
- 2:01of the show today. And also this week we have
- 2:06Michael Tanguma, our Co host is is out for a family engagement.
- 2:14So Mitch is joining us, is in Michael's place and our guest
- 2:20today is Michael Goldstein otherwise known as Bitstein,
- 2:24who's a bit of a meme legend and and I guess curator of important
- 2:32Austrian economics and Bitcoin thinking and writing via the
- 2:37Satoshi Nakamoto Institute. So I'm super excited to have
- 2:41Bitstein here today. Haven't figured out if I'm going
- 2:43to call him Bitstein or Michael. It's going to be a tough one for
- 2:46me since I've only known him as Bitstein on Twitter.
- 2:49But before we get into that, Mitch, how are how are things
- 2:54for you? What's new with you lately?
- 2:57I think you have some news for our audience.
- 2:59Yes, I've been on the show a few times when I was working at
- 3:03Bitco, but I I've joined on ramp to be Chief Revenue Officer.
- 3:07It's been been incredible last few weeks you know working on
- 3:11this side of the business after helping build you know the the
- 3:15core infrastructure of on ramp at Bitco but mostly just wanted
- 3:19to be spending my time helping make a multi institution custody
- 3:22of the standard and focusing my energy to to make that a
- 3:25reality. So it's been a privilege, yeah.
- 3:28We're we're super excited to have Mitch on board and I think
- 3:32Mitch like like the rest of the team at on RAMP has gotten
- 3:37gotten hooked by the idea of what multi institution custody
- 3:40can can do, can do for Bitcoin can be for the world and and and
- 3:45what it can represent for this new era of Bitcoin finance and
- 3:51all the possibilities that come out of it.
- 3:52So you know Mitch has the bug like the rest of us at on RAMP
- 3:56do and super excited to have you Mitch appreciate that.
- 4:01All right. So today we have Michael
- 4:03Goldstein. And Michael, I'll let you, I'll
- 4:07let you introduce yourself. You'll do a better job than me
- 4:11of all the all the things that you are have done over the years
- 4:15for Bitcoin and what you're working on these days.
- 4:17If you want to dip into that too.
- 4:21Yeah. The the, the man, the myth, the
- 4:23legend, the the best memes, the best meme videos in all of
- 4:27Bitcoin. If you haven't seen them, you
- 4:29probably have seen them and you may not have realized that
- 4:32they're from Bitstein. But Michael, welcome to the
- 4:35show. Hi, Marty.
- 4:37Yeah. Thanks for having me on.
- 4:40No, Jesse, Yeah. No thank you for the the, the,
- 4:43the kind introduction. Yeah, my name is Michael
- 4:47Goldstein. I've, I've been known as
- 4:49Bitstein for about a decade now I guess.
- 4:52But yeah, in Bitcoin, what have I done?
- 4:57Mostly just sit around and post on Twitter.
- 5:03But yeah, I, I, I founded the Satoshi Nakamoto Institute in
- 5:082013 as a way to curate, as you said, the sort of best ideas in
- 5:16in Bitcoin and the different intellectual traditions that
- 5:20went into either making Bitcoin what it was or allowing us to
- 5:27sort of best understand what Bitcoin is.
- 5:30And so that's drawing from the the cypherpunks and the crypto
- 5:33anarchists that preceded Bitcoin.
- 5:36It comes from the Austrian economic tradition, which I
- 5:40think is the the sort of best economic school of thought for
- 5:45being able to make sense of Bitcoin thanks to its incredibly
- 5:50brilliant and robust monetary policy or not monetary policy,
- 5:55monetary theory. And so I I that's that's what
- 6:00I've done. That's actually been that that
- 6:04was in rather a bit of a dormant state for a number of years.
- 6:09But recently with the growth of Bitcoin and watching Bitcoin
- 6:14actually do what we always thought it would has inspired me
- 6:19to take it on much more seriously.
- 6:23So we've now formed A5O1C3 tax exempt nonprofit as a vehicle
- 6:32for expanding the Satoshi Nakamoto as it is is instituted
- 6:36as it is today into hopefully a premier world class educational.
- 6:43Platform Fantastic. Got it.
- 6:47And for for those who so I wasn't around in 2013, I came.
- 6:53I arrived in the scene in 20/16/2017 and the people that
- 6:58had been inspired by Bitcoin in the in the years before I
- 7:01arrived it sort of seemed to me that there were a few different
- 7:06channels where they like either got orange peeled or or found
- 7:10the rabbit hole however you want to describe it and and it seemed
- 7:14to me that those main categories were either Andreas videos maybe
- 7:21using Silk Road or perhaps they were they were originally a
- 7:25cypherpunk and so then stumbled into it through through that
- 7:29Channel. But then the last big category
- 7:32was the Satoshi Nakamoto Institute and the the Compendium
- 7:36of information that you and and Pierre Richard put together to
- 7:42present the case in a coherent framework for why this thing
- 7:49makes sense and what and what it what it is really.
- 7:52Because I think you can speak to this, Michael, of back then I I
- 7:56don't think most people engaging with Bitcoin understood that
- 8:01Bitcoin was digital gold in the spirit of Austrian economics and
- 8:05that that still had to be sort of surfaced and bubbled up to
- 8:09the top in terms of how people thought about Bitcoin and how it
- 8:13fit into the world. Is that a fair characterization?
- 8:16I think I think there's some truth to it.
- 8:18So we were certainly not the only and certainly not the first
- 8:23to talk about Bitcoin and Austrian economics.
- 8:27If you really go dive deep into the the the old history of you
- 8:32know Bitcoin talk forum and and such, you'll find plenty of
- 8:36people discussing various ideas in Austrian economics.
- 8:42What I think that I think we're we're we're among the first to
- 8:48do I think more systematic analysis of like actually trying
- 8:53to breakdown concepts in Austrian the Austrian theory of
- 8:59money and relate it to Bitcoin and show how how nicely Austrian
- 9:06economics can explain Bitcoin and also what that means for the
- 9:11future of Bitcoin. We were heavily inspired by
- 9:15pre-existing literature. So there is a a wonderful
- 9:23master's thesis by by a man named Peter Serta on the
- 9:28economics of Bitcoin and he did a great job laying out all all
- 9:34these sorts of concepts and in many ways a lot of our our stuff
- 9:38is kind of lifted from from what we learned from from him.
- 9:43So we we were not the the first but we were the ones.
- 9:46I think we we were probably the most vocal and shall I say like
- 9:52Hardline you know on on that topic.
- 9:56Yeah. And and so so we can I guess now
- 9:59dig into my favorite piece of yours and and probably the the
- 10:05piece you're best known for which is everyone's A scammer
- 10:10which is a fantastic title. First of all it really makes the
- 10:16sorry that's my dog. Anyway, I think that's a a
- 10:21fantastic title and an even better article and Michael, I'd
- 10:25love to hear your explanation of of where that came from.
- 10:31I guess the the the short synopsis of what of what that
- 10:35article makes the point about. And then in particular, I'm very
- 10:40curious to see if that has stood the test of time in your views
- 10:44has was it predictive of of the continuing trends in Bitcoin and
- 10:48crypto? Yes.
- 10:50So everyone's a scammer is actually one of the few articles
- 10:55I've written that people like it so much that they think I've
- 10:59written much more than I have. So I wrote that in September of
- 11:052014. So it was a little after I had
- 11:09gotten out of college, which, you know, college.
- 11:13College was a wonderful time, not because college education is
- 11:17worth it, but because quite the opposite.
- 11:19It gave me way too much free time which allowed me to deep
- 11:22dive into Bitcoin and and these topics.
- 11:27And it was in that time we had a group called the Mesi Circle,
- 11:31which is sort of the proceeding organization to the Satoshi
- 11:37Nakamoto Institute and that it was an Austrian economics
- 11:40reading group I had founded to just dive into all kinds of
- 11:45random topics. When we learned about Bitcoin
- 11:49it, it quickly became the Bitcoin circle and that's where
- 11:51a lot of this, this thought was, was fomenting.
- 11:55So over the course of 20/13/2014 was when the bulk of our sort of
- 12:02economic analysis was, you know, put together and like really
- 12:07just how how to think about Bitcoin and further why we think
- 12:12Bitcoin is going to go to the moon and why, you know, even
- 12:17even in early 2013, as soon as we as soon as we learned about
- 12:21Bitcoin, there was this feeling it's like, OK, well this is
- 12:22clearly the greatest money ever. So it's going to replace the,
- 12:25the Federal Reserve. Let's get on it with all of that
- 12:30in mind. You know by by end of 2014 there
- 12:35was this feeling it's like if if everything we're saying is true
- 12:40about Bitcoin and its potential, you know there are there are no
- 12:47back seas in Bitcoin because let me step back, Bitcoin is is
- 12:55destined to become the global reserve currency.
- 12:59What that means is like at the time the the price was I I guess
- 13:03that may have been around the the top bubble so we could even
- 13:06call it as much as $1000. That is well below what the
- 13:12final price would be expected, would be expected to be if
- 13:17Bitcoin became the global reserve currency.
- 13:20And it is that this this time period that we live in is a very
- 13:27unique one in that we don't experience very much in history
- 13:33the rapid monetization of a new good.
- 13:37And our place in that history needs to be taken seriously
- 13:41because it only happens this once.
- 13:44This is a sort of once in AI mean with Bitcoin you know it's
- 13:49arguable that this is a once in humanity event.
- 13:54You know that that's the extremely bullish case but you
- 13:58know that's that's very well possible.
- 13:59So it needs to be taken seriously.
- 14:01And so everyone's a scammer was a was was basically about taking
- 14:09that very seriously and taking your long term vision of Bitcoin
- 14:15very seriously at the time, just as there is today.
- 14:21There is this view, but I think it was even stronger back then
- 14:25because there wasn't as much there.
- 14:29There wasn't as much meaning around like there there was no
- 14:33stacking sats. Meme huddle was still a a new
- 14:38meme. Obviously people knew to hold.
- 14:41But, you know, a lot of these memes that we take for granted
- 14:44today that, you know, tell us to stay humble, sex hats and all
- 14:47that, that didn't exist at the time.
- 14:49And a lot of people were under the belief that in order to make
- 14:55Bitcoin become the global reserve currency, you need to
- 14:59start spending it. So you need to go, you know, you
- 15:01need to go find merchants and you need to be giving them your
- 15:04bitcoins in order to, you know, get the get the economy going
- 15:10and spur adoption and such. And we had written a number of
- 15:16articles that presented a a different way of thinking about
- 15:20this. So there's another one with a
- 15:22provocative title of I'm hoarding Bitcoin.
- 15:26And no, you can't have any or or something along those lines.
- 15:30And it was pushing it back against this idea saying that
- 15:34actually, what what drives Bitcoin in the big picture has
- 15:39more to do with the increasing reserve demand.
- 15:43You know, just like demand to hold Bitcoin rather than the
- 15:47trading itself. And in fact, when you're when
- 15:49you're selling Bitcoin, which is effectively what spending
- 15:52Bitcoin is, you are now stating to the market that I value
- 15:56Bitcoin less than what it whatever it is that you're
- 15:59buying. There can be incidental, you
- 16:04know, benefits to adoption when this happens.
- 16:07So maybe a merchant who accepts Bitcoin will be a more steadfast
- 16:13hobbler than you are. But if that's the case, then
- 16:17they're kind of scamming you in the sense that they've gotten
- 16:21you to believe that they or at least they've like enabled your
- 16:25belief that you should want, you know, a Lambo instead of
- 16:29Bitcoins for, you know, longer into the future.
- 16:34Because once again it's like well if bitcoins, I guess today
- 16:38it's you know, 66,000, if in the future it's going to be 10
- 16:42million, that represents a very large opportunity cost.
- 16:46So yeah, basically the the article was a way to kind of you
- 16:53know in a in a somewhat cheeky fashion look at all of these all
- 16:58of these ways in which people might find themselves putting
- 17:03their short term interests ahead of their long term interests.
- 17:07And the heuristic of everyone's a scammer was was meant as a way
- 17:13to kind of use your long term interest as the default and just
- 17:21assume if someone wants my sets, they're probably just like
- 17:25they're just scamming me out of my sets because I care more
- 17:27about my my long term interest. Now that doesn't mean that
- 17:31there's not, you know, a reason why you might want to actually
- 17:34spend your Bitcoin. But you have to keep that in
- 17:39mind very seriously because of that fact that there's no back
- 17:42seas once you've spent it is it is unclear that you will ever be
- 17:47able to get those that that amount of satoshi's back because
- 17:53you know, we don't, we don't know when the price is going to
- 17:57go up at a meteoric rate it it could happen tomorrow.
- 18:02And so you really have to think carefully, carefully about how
- 18:07you engage with the Bitcoin economy.
- 18:08And that's that's basically the the, the purpose of the article.
- 18:12Yeah, it does. It's so effective in in flipping
- 18:17people's natural thought process about, you know, trying to make
- 18:23more dollars, but, you know, by speculating on Bitcoin and
- 18:27instead flip it into no, this is the this is the gold rush, this
- 18:30is the land grab, this is the the, the thing you want to end
- 18:33up with. And I think that actually I
- 18:37think it was inspired me in part for when I wrote Bitcoin in the
- 18:43American West which I I you know did a did a deep dive into how
- 18:49the development of the Bitcoin frontier is sort of tracking the
- 18:53same sort of trajectory that the American West.
- 18:56The development of the American West over you know the 150 years
- 19:02post the Louisiana Purchase also also followed.
- 19:07And you know the core theme there is that that that's
- 19:12ultimately a land grab right where you're people who see the
- 19:16opportunity in the in the American West go and stake a
- 19:19claim and you know we we get we got memes out of that era too of
- 19:26go West young man is sort of the equivalent to stay humble and
- 19:30stacks ATS in my opinion because it's ultimately just good advice
- 19:34in an era in a in a time when the world is changed because of
- 19:38a new a new frontier a new asset landscape that people should
- 19:45should seize the opportunity of and it yeah weirdly I have to
- 19:49credit your your piece for sort of inspiring that like gold rush
- 19:55mindset of of here's the right way to engage with how to think
- 20:01about Bitcoin from a personal. Financial perspective and then
- 20:07importantly how that game theory plays out of like it's
- 20:11ultimately a competition you're you're we're in a global
- 20:14competition right now for staking a claim to Bitcoin and
- 20:18you know folks like entities like MicroStrategy are, are are
- 20:23the ones that understand that and most of the world is still
- 20:27sleeping on it. What I I really appreciate about
- 20:31sort of like pieces of the piece and it it's a couple years
- 20:35before, but it does strike some of the nerves that ended up I'd
- 20:40say impacting the block size war and the clash of store value
- 20:44versus medium of exchange and the use cases there and
- 20:48ultimately if the infrastructure would change on block side to
- 20:52facilitate medium of exchange better compared to store value.
- 20:57So I think, you know it was a couple years early and and
- 21:01noticing that. Yeah on on that theme Michael.
- 21:07So I think this is one of the like the harder things to to
- 21:11wrap your head around if you're coming from the like classical
- 21:13Keynesian understanding of money that a new monetary good has a
- 21:19path dependent trajectory from collectible to store value to
- 21:25medium of of exchange to unit of account.
- 21:28And and you, you have to go in that order in order for it to
- 21:32become to to to make it to that next stage.
- 21:37And I think that that's actually something explored well in in
- 21:39Shelling out, which I read on the Satoshi Nakamoto Institute.
- 21:43I wouldn't have found it otherwise.
- 21:45And that one sure sure hit me hard was that something was that
- 21:52idea of like a path dependency of a monetary good understood
- 21:57like in the Bitcoin space at all back then.
- 22:00It sort of feels like it's still not well understood that in, in
- 22:04my opinion, medium of exchange and like getting getting
- 22:11businesses to accept Bitcoin kind of doesn't matter at this
- 22:14point. And that's because I'm such an
- 22:17adherent to the idea that Bitcoin's big use cases store a
- 22:20value and being a savings technology that allows people to
- 22:25store store their purchasing power today and and have it grow
- 22:29over time in purchasing power because of increasing scarcity
- 22:32from the reduction of block the block subsidy.
- 22:36But in 2013, fourteen did the Bitcoin community have this idea
- 22:42of of from the Austrian world yet of the path dependence of
- 22:47the new monetary good? Well I'll I'll start off by
- 22:51saying it's like I don't, I don't fully agree with that way
- 22:57of conceptualizing it. I think that there's a lot of I
- 23:00think there's a lot of truths in it but I don't know that it's
- 23:02necessarily I I I don't know if that's actually the the totally
- 23:09correct way to to to frame everything but there there's a
- 23:12lot of language in there that I think has to be sort of sussed
- 23:16out and and parsed and and and such.
- 23:20But to really nail it down, with that being said, I I I do think
- 23:25that, you know, in the past there really was this very
- 23:29strong I feeling among bitcoiners that you got to be
- 23:35spending Bitcoin, we got to get merchants involved and so on and
- 23:38so forth. I I was basically the same like
- 23:41I remember in 2013, anywhere I'd go and say, hey, do you accept
- 23:43Bitcoin? Do you accept Bitcoin?
- 23:45And, you know, it never worked. And you know, there's no reason
- 23:48for them to be accepting Bitcoin for a variety of reasons,
- 23:52especially just not having any clue what it is 'cause if you
- 23:56have to think like today, everyone knows what Bitcoin is,
- 24:00or at least like they in the sense that they've heard the
- 24:02word and they know that it's some kind of digital money
- 24:04thing. In 2013, if you said, hey, do
- 24:09you accept Bitcoin, the most common response you would get is
- 24:13I What is that? Like?
- 24:14People have literally never heard of it.
- 24:16And so that that that is something to to to to know about
- 24:23the difference between then and now.
- 24:26But yeah, at the same time, yeah.
- 24:28So there was a lot of people who were, you know, gung ho on, you
- 24:32know, trying to get merchants to accept it because that's that's
- 24:35how you know something's and money is because people are
- 24:37spending it to to buy things. And you know, colloquially
- 24:41people call that medium of exchange.
- 24:43I I think that these words are somewhat misleading in the sense
- 24:49that a a medium of exchange is not based on specifically the
- 24:58thing that you're handing over during a trade per SE.
- 25:04Because like it just as an example, is you.
- 25:09When you go to a store and you swipe a Visa card, you are not
- 25:16handing over dollars, you are handing over like a Visa
- 25:21database transaction or something and dollars get
- 25:24settled later. So the medium of exchange in a
- 25:30in a praxeological sense. So in the the study of human
- 25:34action medium of exchange is more precisely defined as a good
- 25:40acquired for the purposes of indirect exchange.
- 25:44It is it is a good that you acquire not because you want to
- 25:47use it yourself or not because you want to consume it or or put
- 25:52it to work, you know as as some capital, but because
- 25:55specifically you believe it's a good that others are going to
- 25:59want that you can then use to trade them for what you need,
- 26:04you know. And of course there's all the
- 26:06you know double coincidence of want stuff that I'm sure your
- 26:09listeners are are aware of. And so when people talk about
- 26:14medium of exchange versus store value, I I tend to in my head
- 26:19the way I think about it is, is not medium of exchange versus
- 26:22store value, but more method of payment versus you know savings
- 26:29vehicle. And I view those like method of
- 26:32payment is just a specific technical way that you're
- 26:36transferring medium a a medium of exchange and store value.
- 26:41You don't literally store value. You can't, you can't like you
- 26:45know value is not this quantifiable metric or like a
- 26:50thing per SE. That's like I'm going to go put
- 26:52value in this box and it's going to stay there and when I come
- 26:55back it'll be the same value and stuff.
- 26:58Store of value is more of a, it is a a shorthand that is used to
- 27:03describe a lot of market dynamics that goes into, you
- 27:09know a good a medium of exchange.
- 27:12I tend to think about it more in terms of a medium of exchange
- 27:16over the long run. So the reason we have a medium
- 27:19of exchange is because we're uncertain about the future.
- 27:22We don't know. We don't know what's best right
- 27:26now. You know, I could, I could go
- 27:29invest in this. So I could go invest in that.
- 27:31I don't know. I'm going to hold on to money
- 27:34because that way when I see something that actually, you
- 27:38know suits what I need at this moment, I will have the good
- 27:42that is most likely to be accepted on the other side to to
- 27:49to be able to to to spend and acquire that good.
- 27:52So store value is asking the question of when I look at the
- 27:56different potential media of exchange that exists, everything
- 28:00from wampum to cows to shells to gold to dollars to Bitcoin.
- 28:07When I look at that, what are the media of exchange or the
- 28:12specific medium of exchange that I believe will have the most
- 28:19demand in the future when I want to use this thing.
- 28:22And so there's there's a sort of speculative aspect to all of
- 28:26that is there's a speculative aspect to to all of human
- 28:29action. But when you're acquiring a a
- 28:33good and you're acquiring it for the long run, you're effectively
- 28:37that is what we kind of call a store of value because it's like
- 28:40you're you're thinking about what will the value be of this
- 28:44well into the future in the marketplace such that this can
- 28:50presumably allow me to acquire whatever it is that I might need
- 28:55in the future that I don't know yet.
- 28:59So the I I don't really see that that path dependency only
- 29:05because at least in those terms because I I think that they're
- 29:10describing just the functions of money as you're always using
- 29:14money. I think that even today you know
- 29:17we have Bitcoin as a medium of exchange because I I acquire my
- 29:21Bitcoin for the purposes of indirect exchange.
- 29:24It's just not indirect exchange today.
- 29:26It's a quote store of value because of that very fact that
- 29:31I'm thinking about my indirect exchange into the future.
- 29:35So I'm choosing to hold the medium of exchange that I I
- 29:38think will best suit that need. Not just not just tomorrow, not
- 29:42just 1/4 from now, but ten years, 100 years down the line
- 29:47and then unit of account. We also have on the Nakamoto
- 29:50Institute a an article called Bitcoin is the best unit of
- 29:54account and it's about how and this was written in 2013.
- 29:58It already is the best unit of account and you don't have to go
- 30:01through this process. That process is more of the
- 30:04process of everyone realizing that it's the best unit of
- 30:09account because on an individual level, what is a unit of
- 30:12account? A unit of account is me doing my
- 30:16accounting books. You know taking stock of what
- 30:19are all the what are all the things I own, what are the all
- 30:23the liabilities I own, what is my cash flow and and so on and
- 30:27so forth. You know, basically running,
- 30:29running a business, whether it's as a personal finance matter or
- 30:33as an organizational business. And when you Add all those
- 30:38things up, there's a question there, which is how do I
- 30:41denominate this? And in the United States and in
- 30:45a lot of the world, people denominate in dollars.
- 30:49It would be very silly of me to start denominating in pesos.
- 30:53I I probably would not do very well in the United States if I
- 30:56was, if I was doing it that way. But I could.
- 31:01So people have to ask what do I want to denominate?
- 31:03Because profit and loss ultimately is a is a
- 31:07psychological thing. Anything can be profitable if
- 31:10you prefer it, given you know the subjective nature of value
- 31:14and such. So with with unit of account you
- 31:20are making the decision of how do I want to count up my profit
- 31:26and loss, how do I want to determine how I'm doing
- 31:29economically. So everyone today and all the
- 31:33way since since January 3rd, 2009 has had the choice of do I
- 31:38want to use dollars or Bitcoin as a unit of account.
- 31:42Now at the very beginning Bitcoin probably would not have
- 31:45been a good unit of account because there wasn't even a
- 31:47price attached to it in the marketplace, so you would have
- 31:51no way of of doing that accounting.
- 31:53But ever since, you know, 2010 or so, there has been a price
- 31:57and you can do accounting. And ever since that moment, if
- 32:01you chose to look at all of your economic activity and price it
- 32:06in Bitcoin and make the decision of today, I want to have more
- 32:11Bitcoin on the books than I had yesterday instead of the typical
- 32:16I want more dollars on the books than I had yesterday.
- 32:20Anyone who's done that and done it with a a long term view in
- 32:23mind you know four to five years into the future at least all of
- 32:28those people have have done tremendously well relative to
- 32:33had they chosen the dollar as a unit of account.
- 32:37So in that sense it's like unit of account is not the capstone
- 32:42except in terms of for the other person that you're trading with
- 32:47how how much can you expect them to also be using Bitcoin as a
- 32:51unit of account for for themselves.
- 32:55So there's a bit of that distinction there of looking at
- 32:58it from the individual perspective, which I think all
- 33:01of those sort of functions, so to speak are already present in
- 33:06Bitcoin. To looking at it from a network
- 33:09perspective of what is it that we can sort of expect the
- 33:14economy as a whole, just the general economy to be looking at
- 33:19regarding this. The other important thing there,
- 33:23it's sorry, I I see that you're like opening your mouth.
- 33:25It's. It's fantastic stuff.
- 33:27Yeah. OK.
- 33:28OK. So I'll I'll I'll continue the
- 33:32the other sort of important thing here and and what was
- 33:36motivating us back then is like OK guys I you know you're you're
- 33:40saying it's a land grab and it's definitely it's it is it is a
- 33:44kind of of land grab and it's like you have this one choice
- 33:49you know this one shot you know Eminem's getting you know all
- 33:53the Eminem quotes in there you you want to make sure you get it
- 33:57right. With that in mind, if you
- 34:00recognize Bitcoin as such, you've you've studied it, you
- 34:04see Bitcoin a certain way and you make the the entrepreneurial
- 34:08judgement based on your knowledge of how money works,
- 34:12based on on the the current situation of the the economy,
- 34:17etcetera, etcetera. If you've come to the
- 34:19entrepreneurial judgement that Bitcoin is so good of a money
- 34:23that you think everyone's going to want some to and they're
- 34:27going to use it as their medium of exchange in the future to the
- 34:32point where it's a global reserve asset and so on and so
- 34:35forth. If that's your view of Bitcoin,
- 34:38then obviously you are indeed going to want to grab a lot of
- 34:42land. And you're not.
- 34:43You're you're going to go out into the West and you're not
- 34:47just going to grab, you know, the, you know, 40 acres.
- 34:50You're going to try to grab, you know, a whole territory.
- 34:54And so a lot of the arguments around, you know, so-called
- 34:58Bitcoin maximalism, which we effectively, in a in a sense,
- 35:03championed. It wasn't.
- 35:04It wasn't named. It was.
- 35:05It was. It was named as a sort of
- 35:07pejorative. Point.
- 35:09Of view. But you know, what I've always
- 35:12argued over the years is that it's more descriptive than it is
- 35:16prescriptive. It's not, you know, saying like,
- 35:19oh, you must do this. It's more, I believe people are
- 35:24going to have these ideas about Bitcoin and that Bitcoin as an
- 35:29economic good is going to have a given performance such that
- 35:33people are simply going to want to hold it more than more than
- 35:38they're want going to want to give it up.
- 35:40And this is something if you, if you go into the literature, you
- 35:44know Ludwig von Mises talks about this, Karl Menger talks
- 35:48about this. When a good is being identified
- 35:52as a medium of exchange, like a a sort of new medium exchange on
- 35:57the market, entrepreneurs are going to want to hoard a larger
- 36:05amount than they otherwise would because of this sort of
- 36:09speculative entrepreneurial judgement of what the future
- 36:14holds. And so that is the process of
- 36:17what we've we've seen and also the one that you're probably
- 36:19going to want to make you know choices based on and and why
- 36:23everyone's a scammer if they're trying to get in your way of of
- 36:27getting there. So yeah, so I, I, I actually
- 36:31sort of disagree just to to sum that up, I, I kind of disagree
- 36:34with that particular way of at least the the labels around the
- 36:40past dependency. I don't think that they're as as
- 36:43clear as they should. And you know that also puts it
- 36:46on me to to try to come up with a a better way of of really
- 36:51nailing that down with the economic terminology and
- 36:55concepts. But at the same time the basic
- 36:59argument that you're making that the the market we would expect
- 37:05it to want to hold more than be you know spending.
- 37:10I I fully agree with that and I think these are the reasons.
- 37:12Why that's fantastic. Yeah I I loved all the nuance in
- 37:17there and I think I think ultimately we're we're on the
- 37:21same page there it and it is around the labels specifically
- 37:25like I agree that I think that objectively Bitcoin is the best
- 37:32store value the best medium of exchange and the best unit of
- 37:35account. And I think in many ways to be a
- 37:37Bitcoin maximalist is to recognize that sort of how you
- 37:43how you talked about it of to be a Bitcoin maximalist is to adopt
- 37:48Bitcoin as your unit of account fundamentally and.
- 37:51That's. A recognition of it is
- 37:54objectively the best unit of account that I could use.
- 37:57And that means that we are as Bitcoin maximalist, who knows
- 38:01how many of us there are in the world.
- 38:03Maybe there's 100,000 that might be generous or might be less.
- 38:07But I think we're the the the 1st, 100,000, the first point O
- 38:121% of the world population to recognize that this is
- 38:16objectively the best unit of account to reach that end state.
- 38:22But it is. It is simultaneously the best
- 38:24medium of exchange and the best store of value.
- 38:26And I think that the store of value function is the thing that
- 38:30imposes itself on the world as economic reality specifically
- 38:35because of the having's as you you may know bit seen I'm a I'm
- 38:39a fervent adherent to the importance of increasing
- 38:43scarcity as the the the prime mover of why Bitcoin gets more
- 38:49valuable over time and and induces adoption out of
- 38:54self-interest. And so I think that that
- 38:58objective reality is something that the world is slowly
- 39:01recognizing and they and that'll be that people will figure out
- 39:05that this is a good store value that helps me grow my purchasing
- 39:08power by saving in Bitcoin much sooner than they will realize
- 39:11that this is the union of accounts that I should organize
- 39:14my entire life around. And and I think that that how we
- 39:19the the labels are are the difference here of like it is a
- 39:24a gross generalization to describe the evolution of this
- 39:28monetary good into four discreet buckets like that when it is
- 39:32really a function of how the bell curve of technology
- 39:36adopters progress through each of those independent stages of
- 39:40how to view Bitcoin. You know, I think, I think a
- 39:43large portion of the world would view Bitcoin as a as a cute
- 39:46collectible that has some value, right.
- 39:48So like a huge portion of the adoption curve has reached that
- 39:51stage of understanding of Bitcoin, but very, very, very
- 39:55few have reached the unit of account and state.
- 39:58And I think that the the store of value function because of
- 40:02increasing scarcity is how Bitcoin forces the world to
- 40:08adopt it. And then in doing so creates the
- 40:12network effects that are the bridge between store of value
- 40:16and medium of exchange, because it's the intra subjective value
- 40:21of. I recognize that somebody else
- 40:23wants Bitcoin. That helps change how you
- 40:26transact from dollars into a a currency that both sides want
- 40:33right. The the the double sided thing
- 40:35that you alluded to earlier. And so you're right.
- 40:38It's ultimately about labels, but I think we're kind of
- 40:40talking about the same thing from different angles and and
- 40:45ultimately you know it's it's it's the most beautiful topic in
- 40:47the world because it's the whole story of bitcoin's monetization
- 40:51and and conquest of the financial landscape.
- 40:55I think that yeah, just to pull pull on one little thread here.
- 41:01The idea that you know that small group of the Bitcoin
- 41:04maximalists that are living on a Bitcoin standard that understand
- 41:08the they inherently, in every single purchase or economic
- 41:14decision they're making, they're making a sound economic decision
- 41:16of is this do I need this good more than I, you know where is
- 41:24that more valuable to me than the the idea of holding a
- 41:28Bitcoin for the future with the expected value of what I
- 41:32anticipate that Bitcoin to be. And I I think the, you know,
- 41:35when you talk about the land grab, there are so few people
- 41:39today that are viewing Bitcoin with that framework that are
- 41:43making that sound economic decision, you know, every time
- 41:46that they are transacting. Yes I I I invite people to go
- 41:51read a a rather long article that I had written called torta
- 41:56node world order they can find in my sub stack or or on the
- 42:01Bitcoin times where it was originally written for.
- 42:05And I kind of in many ways like make like a kind of high high
- 42:12view of of my my sort of entire Bitcoin world view in a sense.
- 42:18But one of the things that I always like to do and I I, I
- 42:20tried to focus on in the the the first bits of of that that
- 42:27article where it pertains to to Bitcoin in particular is I I I
- 42:33always like going back to the the fundamentals of of economic
- 42:38concepts and such because it can bring us more clarity as as we
- 42:43build up and and try to understand this.
- 42:44So I had mentioned the concept of uncertainty and I think in
- 42:49Austrian economics this is really one of one of the key
- 42:53things needed to really understand monetary theory.
- 42:58And it it kind of gets to this like core logical reason why we
- 43:05would want to use a medium of exchange at all.
- 43:07And so when you start to put things in terms of uncertainty
- 43:11and how different properties play into bitcoins, ability to
- 43:18be more certain and you know the the market goes towards the good
- 43:24that can provide the most certainty around that particular
- 43:30good. And so when you're talking about
- 43:31scarcity as a a prime mover, well, one of the biggest
- 43:36uncertainties, especially if like you're holding the dollar,
- 43:38is at what point are they just going to print a third of all
- 43:43money that exists? It's like, well, you just wake
- 43:47up and then in 2020-2021 they do exactly that.
- 43:52And you know, today we we are dealing with the fallout of such
- 43:56a thing, whereas the Bitcoin monetary policy has not budged
- 44:02even a single Satoshi. And all of this can be fully
- 44:05verified. And This is why the coin is so
- 44:08important. It's why it's so important that
- 44:10people learn about nodes and why they might want to run a full
- 44:14node for themselves is because it gives them more certainty
- 44:18about the thing that they are trading, which lets them
- 44:21overcome more, you know, economic problems that they face
- 44:29into the future. So do I need, I I I want to have
- 44:33goods that can handle, handle trades that I need to do today.
- 44:37I want trade. I want a good that I can also
- 44:39hold on to to trade in 100 years.
- 44:41I want a good that I can trade in very small amounts and I want
- 44:46a good that I can trade in very large amounts.
- 44:48Because sometimes I want to buy a house.
- 44:50Sometimes it's just, you know, you know, a a burger, sometimes
- 44:54it's a house. You know, I want it to to, you
- 44:58know, basically all of these different uncertainties on the
- 45:01scales, like on the dimensions of of space and of time and of
- 45:08scale play into what good has the properties most capable of
- 45:14handling that. And it's from that that I do
- 45:17fully agree with you that scarcity is such a a core part
- 45:22of of what makes Bitcoin tick. And it's why 21,000,000 is
- 45:27perhaps the very most important meme in all of Bitcoin.
- 45:32Not because the other things don't matter.
- 45:34In fact 21 million can only happen because of of certain
- 45:39other things but it's it's 21 million that is sort of the the
- 45:44the sort of secret ingredient and that that that makes it all
- 45:49function together. Thanks for tuning in.
- 45:54If you're interested in exploring any of these topics
- 45:57further, or want to learn more about how we can help you secure
- 46:00a new or existing Bitcoin allocation, get in touch with
- 46:03our team at on rampbitcoin.com. We look forward to supporting
- 46:07you on your Bitcoin journey. I love it.
- 46:11Yes, totally agree. It does make me wonder, what are
- 46:14your thoughts on the Infinity divided by 21 variant of that
- 46:18meme? So it's it's been a while since
- 46:22I've I've thought about this because it's it's not a meme
- 46:25that's ever really stuck with me.
- 46:28On the one hand, I appreciate the idea of like, well,
- 46:31literally everything in the universe will be priced in
- 46:35Bitcoin. That being said, I don't think
- 46:38that it's an accurate portrayal of what the price actually is.
- 46:42Because not like you can have more material wealth than the
- 46:51total value of the monetary economy in.
- 46:57In that the the total the total value of of wealth can be higher
- 47:03because not everyone is selling all the wealth at all the same
- 47:06time. So there can be a stock of it.
- 47:09Now if they started selling more stuff, the price of Bitcoin
- 47:13would go up. But at any given time it's like,
- 47:15you know I'm I'm, I'm on a computer right now having this
- 47:18conversation, it's like as much as I should sell all the chairs
- 47:23and everything, it's like well, I I actually do want a computer
- 47:25because I want to talk with my my friends online.
- 47:28And so there's still wealth that's just stored as wealth.
- 47:32And you can price it in Bitcoin, but it's not necessarily
- 47:35representative in represented in the Bitcoin price itself
- 47:40completely. Or like it kind of is like there
- 47:42is this grand order book of everything is like, is this
- 47:48making sense? Like it's like everything is is
- 47:50priced in Bitcoin, but not everything is actually the the
- 47:58the current price of Bitcoin. The actual market price of it
- 48:04does not necessarily reflect literally everything, because
- 48:08the current market price only reflects the people actually
- 48:12buying and selling things for Bitcoin.
- 48:14The. The small subset of available
- 48:16for sale supplies isn't doesn't accurately encompass the true
- 48:21the total value of of or you know, doesn't neatly encompass
- 48:27the total value of all the Bitcoin.
- 48:29Yes. So I would just caution people
- 48:30from from treating it as literally the price is Infinity
- 48:36or something like that because that's that's not the case but
- 48:40it is it is true that so we we could see a world in which
- 48:46pretty much everything humans are pricing in Bitcoin.
- 48:50Yeah, that's that's interesting. That's a that's a objection to
- 48:54it I haven't heard before. I I I agree with you.
- 48:56I actually don't. I don't like that meme overall
- 48:59because. But for me it's because once you
- 49:02introduce Infinity then the implication is that all other
- 49:07assets go to 0 value you know in the in the in the pie and
- 49:14Bitcoin becomes 100% and it's. And I reject that.
- 49:17Yeah, right. Anyway thanks for for everyone
- 49:25letting us get into the the semantics Bitstein and I dove
- 49:28into there. But at this point I think it'd
- 49:31be really interesting Michael to to get your perspective on so
- 49:37you you know you've been you've been in the game for 10 years.
- 49:41You've been in Bitcoin for 10 years and have seen the value of
- 49:44Bitcoin for 10 years and you know at the start of that
- 49:47journey that's inherently involves a recognition that this
- 49:51system is better than the current system.
- 49:54And the current system as of 2014 was in a pretty different
- 49:59place pre pre COVID stimulus printing in 1/3 of all the money
- 50:04that it's ever existed in M2 and all the other things that have
- 50:08happened. I guess would would love to hear
- 50:13your thoughts on how the your, your thesis in 2014 has tracked
- 50:21versus reality in terms of the the relative direction of the
- 50:28existing conventional system versus Bitcoin.
- 50:34And and I think it also would be valuable to get your thoughts on
- 50:39like what that or or I guess personal experience on what that
- 50:43has felt like for you to hold through the FUD and the
- 50:48uncertainties of 10 years of being a Bitcoiner.
- 50:51And you know with in particular with respect to like what
- 50:54lessons have you learned about what it takes to hold for 10
- 50:58years. And you know, has that made you
- 51:00more or less certain at the end of that 10 years?
- 51:06Yeah, I actually realized that was something that I didn't
- 51:08cover with everyone's a scammer like how how it held up and I
- 51:12will say on that one, I think it held up tremendously.
- 51:15The only the only caveat is Ethereum did launch after the
- 51:22the article came out. And so there there were a lot of
- 51:26people who did very well against Bitcoin and certain people who
- 51:31held early on and if they held they'd still I think be you know
- 51:36up against Bitcoin. But as as a general rule, I
- 51:41think the general rule holds and Even so I think based on
- 51:49everything we've discussed, obviously I I I don't think that
- 51:52Ethereum would be able to maintain that thing.
- 51:57So it's like, yes, if you got in at $0.05 you'll probably not not
- 52:02get as as harmed or like, but. You're a scammer scamming people
- 52:09out of their Bitcoin. Yeah, yeah, so.
- 52:12But, so that. That's the one little funny
- 52:14thing is, you know, Etherium did happen, but I still think that
- 52:21Bitcoin was the right thing. And I mean that that plays into
- 52:24this, this other question. So funny enough, I mean when, I
- 52:29mean, I was, I was young and and much more idealistic at the
- 52:32time. So when as soon as I got into
- 52:36Bitcoin, there was a feeling it's like, OK, well everyone
- 52:39else is going to learn this tomorrow and you know we'll have
- 52:42full, full global reserve asset status in in 5-10 years Max.
- 52:48That clearly didn't happen and I think I had to I I I had to
- 52:55learn through that process that actually the market is a very
- 53:01dynamic thing. That's that's what we can learn
- 53:03from the Austrian economists like that that the market is, is
- 53:07is very dynamic and people are always learning and and so on
- 53:10and so forth. But the actual process is not
- 53:14necessarily as fast as you always might want it to be
- 53:18because the economy is also very large.
- 53:21And so there's there's a lot of work that has to be done to
- 53:26actually see ideas percolate through the entire economy and
- 53:33that that's that has its own, you know, humbling aspect to it.
- 53:37That being said, at the same time, Bitcoin has done
- 53:41tremendously well because it's it's grown exponentially since
- 53:46since then. And I I think I just had in my
- 53:51mind a much steeper exponential curve than the reality.
- 53:56But in terms of thinking that, oh, this thing is going to
- 53:59exponentially grow very rapidly, it it really did it's it's it's
- 54:05it's absolutely crazy to think where Bitcoin is relative to
- 54:10then and not see it as being total vindication that hyper
- 54:14bitcoinization is completely real.
- 54:17Because there's there's there's no other way to describe just
- 54:20this incredible growth and you know seemingly extremely
- 54:26sustainable growth too. The fact that every time someone
- 54:30comes out and they're like oh, bitcoin's going to go all the
- 54:32way down to 20,000, it's like that you think that's bearish.
- 54:37But when you zoom out enough and you've been watching, you know,
- 54:41for as long as I have, that is incredibly bullish that you as
- 54:45the ultra Bitcoin bearer, that's like the, that's the worst
- 54:49you're coming up with except for like a, you know, obviously the
- 54:53person who just says it's going to go all the way down to 0,
- 54:56those people are going to just continue to exist.
- 54:59But the person who wants to be super bearish and all they can
- 55:01come up with is like you know 20,000 or whatever that's
- 55:05extremely bullish and thank you for vindicating me.
- 55:08So I I see, I see us as having lived through hyper
- 55:12bitcoinization for the past you know since since 2010 when
- 55:17Bitcoin got its first price and and we we just continue to see
- 55:22it and you know the the way that you know exponential and sort of
- 55:26hyperbolic functions work is as you go the the slope increases
- 55:34as as well And so we we've always been in hyper
- 55:40bitcoinization but you know we could always see more hyper the
- 55:44other side of it. Another another thing to
- 55:47consider too is that I've had to recognize is that, you know,
- 55:51when Bitcoin is, you know, a few 100 bucks or a few 1000 bucks,
- 55:56it is good for individuals. Like individuals can start
- 56:00thinking about it. But a large corporation, a micro
- 56:04strategy, I don't think could have even really happened until
- 56:08micro strategy happened. Because Bitcoin has to get to a
- 56:12certain amount of liquidity before an organization can look
- 56:16at and be like, oh, it's possible for me to get in on
- 56:19this without totally, you know, cornering the market because
- 56:23like you want to corner the market in the sense of getting a
- 56:25huge land grab. You don't want to corner the
- 56:28market in terms of like I just have this big thing, I
- 56:31completely move the market and you know with the money you sort
- 56:36of just you actually want to get in without affecting the price
- 56:40if you can help it. And from that perspective it's
- 56:45like it takes a certain amount of time and growth for it to get
- 56:49to that point. And so I also had to learn,
- 56:51learn that. And so it's, you know, there's a
- 56:53reason El Salvador took until it did.
- 56:57And it it it, it stands to reason why it was a country like
- 57:01El Salvador and not the United States.
- 57:05Because El Salvador could afford to take on a certain amount of
- 57:10risk at such a low liquidity. Whereas it would it would make
- 57:13no sense necessarily for for the US to to take that sort of
- 57:19action, even if I think they should, and even if I think that
- 57:24it would ultimately be good for everyone if they did.
- 57:28Yeah yeah I love that the the mental framing of like Bitcoin
- 57:33wins from the from the edges you know it's like it El Salvador is
- 57:39kind of if you if you were to a few years ago stack rank the
- 57:46economic power of of all countries in the world.
- 57:49El Salvador would would be lower on the list and that meant they
- 57:54had a greater opportunity to to sees advantage of the the
- 57:58Bitcoin opportunity. And you know similarly like we
- 58:02see politicians from the fringes have been the first ones to
- 58:06embrace Bitcoin. You know seeing Senator Lummus
- 58:10have success getting into office by embracing Bitcoin as part of
- 58:14her platform and then inspired you know RFK Junior and Ted
- 58:20Cruz. And you know even now Trump
- 58:23starting to tiptoe into crypto as as part of this platform
- 58:28which is is you know winning from the edges until eventually
- 58:32it becomes something that the mainstream has to adopt as well.
- 58:36Also the other thing I wanted to to dig into there was I love how
- 58:41you characterize I think accurately that that we are we
- 58:44have been living through hyper bitcoinization this whole time
- 58:48because I think in Bitcoin people trick themselves into
- 58:54looking forward to a God candle sort of thing right where you
- 58:57some overnight the price is going to go from where we are to
- 59:01$1,000,000 and and I think that the the history of Bitcoin shows
- 59:06that's this is never how it's going to be.
- 59:08It's a slow iterative process of of three steps forward 2 steps
- 59:14back and the the volatility being the human condition that
- 59:20the human psychology that we all bring to trying to understand
- 59:23this thing and price it and speculate on it and trade it and
- 59:26and we are the volatility, not Bitcoin.
- 59:28Bitcoin is certain as you and Pierre Rashard like to point out
- 59:34and and so yeah, like I think it's hugely helpful mental
- 59:40repositioning to recognize that we are in the midst of hyper
- 59:45bitcoinization. It has been playing out.
- 59:47It it stands to continue playing out.
- 59:50And then the other piece in there that that I that I want to
- 59:53ask you more about is you insinuated that you believe that
- 59:58that rate can will accelerate and you know with with the
- 1:00:04recent popularity of the power law stuff and you know kind of
- 1:00:10stock to flow model being a little bit.
- 1:00:16Passe I guess at this point in time in the Bitcoin landscape
- 1:00:20what are what are your thoughts on do we have diminishing
- 1:00:24returns do we have an S curve that you know we we're where
- 1:00:30we're going to accelerate faster or what do you see for the for
- 1:00:34the future of how hyper bit colonization plays out.
- 1:00:39I I I don't. Know it's also an impossible
- 1:00:42question. Yeah, I I I I really, I I really
- 1:00:45don't know. I I think, I think Bitcoin will
- 1:00:51continue to be exponential and the reason that I think it'll be
- 1:00:54it'll continue to be exponential is just simply that it is a
- 1:01:00network good and networks have a a sort of exponential factor to
- 1:01:06it in the sense that you're you're dealing with you know
- 1:01:10multiple you know peer peers connecting with one another.
- 1:01:14So it's like, you know the the, the number of lines that
- 1:01:17connect, you know when you have an increasing number of dots and
- 1:01:20you draw lines between all of the dots, that number grows
- 1:01:23exponentially. And you know an economy grows
- 1:01:27that way and also means that an economy shrinks that way as as
- 1:01:31people move away from another. So that's been our basic
- 1:01:34argument as to why you know Bitcoin will be exponential is
- 1:01:38that that network aspect of being a network good like a
- 1:01:43money And so yes I think it will be exponential but what specific
- 1:01:48exponential curve that will be, I don't know.
- 1:01:51My, my point is, is that exponentials just naturally do
- 1:01:54sort of speed up in, in the sense that, you know today, you
- 1:02:00know, if Bitcoin went up $2000, I mean just the other day it
- 1:02:04went up a a few $1000 and it's like, Oh yeah, that's a fun day,
- 1:02:08but that's also kind of like normal in Bitcoin.
- 1:02:11Whereas in the past going up a few 1000 bucks would have been
- 1:02:17nothing. Sorry, sorry, the opposite of
- 1:02:19not, it would have been like the most insane thing ever.
- 1:02:24And so in that sense these, these magnitudes are are going
- 1:02:28up. So yeah, I I don't, I don't know
- 1:02:31that I want to like get into prognosticating a particular
- 1:02:35curve. I just think that it's it's
- 1:02:36important to think about these these fundamentals.
- 1:02:39Gotcha. Thing to me about like magnitude
- 1:02:42going up is less. I mean I I totally agree you
- 1:02:45know $1000 swings you know were definitely harder to come by
- 1:02:50when when we were in priced at like 5K compared to TO65K as we
- 1:02:55we are right now. But the the magnitude is is to
- 1:03:00me like what we're seeing on the political spectrum right now.
- 1:03:06You had the the House of Representatives just vote to to
- 1:03:10repeal SEV 121. The fact that we we actually
- 1:03:14have bipartisan effort and people who actually care in
- 1:03:18government right now to to put regulation on you know digital
- 1:03:22assets in Bitcoin to help you know financial institutions step
- 1:03:28into the industry to mature the asset class Like that's that's
- 1:03:33the magnitude right now that's fascinating to me that you're
- 1:03:36seeing political chess moves you know take place at presidential
- 1:03:39elections. Obviously the the Senate's going
- 1:03:44to vote on today Schumer told Democratic senators to go vote
- 1:03:48their heart like there's a real chance that Biden has if if
- 1:03:52Biden who said he's going to veto any any repeal of SAB 121
- 1:03:58like that might actually have to happen you know over the next
- 1:04:02you know coming days or or or week or so.
- 1:04:06I I I can't believe the order of magnitude of how quickly I'd say
- 1:04:14you look at where we've come the last two years from the FTX
- 1:04:18fallout to now meaningfully impacting elections and dynamics
- 1:04:26in government. I I think it's incredible to see
- 1:04:29the progress we've made since since by that that that low
- 1:04:32moment. Yes, with with every step of the
- 1:04:35way, you have that much bigger of an amount of of people that
- 1:04:41can be invited to partake in Bitcoin in a way that they had
- 1:04:46it previously then, then in the past.
- 1:04:49You know, in the past it was just like, you know, at best
- 1:04:51you're going to like convince some libertarian nerds to to put
- 1:04:55in some money and just kind of see it as this cool thing.
- 1:04:58But as it grows, you know, different events happen that
- 1:05:01reveal something to the world, about the world, to people,
- 1:05:05shows them an underlying uncertainty within their the the
- 1:05:09way that they're doing things now, and gives them an
- 1:05:12opportunity to learn how Bitcoin can plug up that uncertainty.
- 1:05:16And that's whether it's like seeing the the fallout, the the
- 1:05:22monetary fallout of of the the COVID or the, you know, even
- 1:05:28things like, you know Canadian truckers and just continual
- 1:05:32rising prices and and so on and so forth.
- 1:05:35Each one of these things is a, isn't it an invitation for
- 1:05:38people to to reassess. And it's always like it's it's a
- 1:05:42larger and larger pool of people at that at that point.
- 1:05:46Because even if people know about Bitcoin, they don't really
- 1:05:49know Bitcoin yet. But this is an invitation and
- 1:05:52all of that work of them knowing about Bitcoin, it softens them
- 1:05:56up as well. So yeah, I I think it'll be
- 1:06:00exponential. I'm just not going to comment on
- 1:06:03what particular curve I think it's going to be because it's
- 1:06:07just that's that's beyond me I. Don't.
- 1:06:09Yeah, I gotcha. Yeah.
- 1:06:11The suffice to say on a log scale up and to the right and
- 1:06:15and we'll leave it at that, yeah.
- 1:06:17It's number go up technology and it's going to continue to
- 1:06:20function that I do know. Yeah I I agree with you there I
- 1:06:24I who knows who knows on that on that front and and yeah Mitch
- 1:06:28makes a great point that like it's a it's like a tent pole you
- 1:06:33know Bitcoin Bitcoin can be a tent pole for for politicians
- 1:06:37and and political parties to you know invite more people in to
- 1:06:43expand the tent And and I I think and I hope and we'll see
- 1:06:49that the game theory there plays out in a way where all political
- 1:06:56corners of the spectrum recognize that this is you know
- 1:07:00something that that they want to adopt as part of their platform
- 1:07:03such that it is not a partisan issue ultimately hopefully
- 1:07:08that's where we're heading and but the Democrats have a little
- 1:07:11little catching up to do if that's going to play out that
- 1:07:14way. Go for it.
- 1:07:17Oh, I was just going to say I think any, any and all
- 1:07:19politicians should be pandering to me, so.
- 1:07:22Yes. I'm.
- 1:07:24I'm fine with that. Yeah, I I think right now
- 1:07:28obviously I think the presidential level, you know,
- 1:07:31the dynamic is taking place that it is becoming a partisan issue.
- 1:07:34But we, we certainly do have friends on on both sides of the
- 1:07:37aisle. That being said, you know, the
- 1:07:40game theory takes place that, you know, there's a very real
- 1:07:44chance that Bitcoin and largely digital assets in general do end
- 1:07:48up impacting this presidential election.
- 1:07:51That's the case. If we do, if the data is there,
- 1:07:54you know that the votes are there, the incentive mechanisms
- 1:07:57in place so that you know, Democrats don't make that
- 1:08:01mistake again in the future. So I I think it it's you know as
- 1:08:06the you know the space matures and as that game theory plays
- 1:08:11out I I do think you know it's it's going to it's going to have
- 1:08:16to be table stakes to to be supportive of the industry
- 1:08:20compared to what we've we've experienced over the last couple
- 1:08:23of years. That's a very interesting, like,
- 1:08:25possible arc for this of like potentially the crypto vote
- 1:08:32tips, the scales in this upcoming presidential election.
- 1:08:35And then four years from now it's table stakes because you
- 1:08:39know, they recognize that they, you know, if they had just
- 1:08:42pandered to the crypto vote, then the Democrats might have
- 1:08:45had, you know might have not lost a contingent that ended up
- 1:08:48being crucial and and it could be table stakes 5 years from now
- 1:08:54in the next in the next go round.
- 1:08:56But in the meantime, probably be a lot of animosity towards the
- 1:09:02crypto voters that that swung it for Trump despite being young
- 1:09:06and typically young people voting for Democrats.
- 1:09:11Yeah I I personally try to disengage from from the
- 1:09:15political aspect in a in a sort of direct sense and and rather
- 1:09:22you know this is This is why I I want to do things like the
- 1:09:25Nakamoto Institute is as people are finding themselves drawn
- 1:09:31into Bitcoin from whatever angle it might be.
- 1:09:35Whether it's a a democratic politician who just wants to
- 1:09:39pander to someone or it's you know actual you know business
- 1:09:44owners and individuals trying to improve their their economic
- 1:09:49standing. Or if there's even heads of
- 1:09:51state out there who are interested in finally leading a
- 1:09:57country in a in a more with more of a long term vision than we we
- 1:10:02see in a lot of modern politics. Whatever case that might be, all
- 1:10:08of those people have to learn about Bitcoin and they have to
- 1:10:11actually learn how this thing functions, what is it?
- 1:10:14And so on and so forth. And so my my goal in all of this
- 1:10:19is not to not to find myself engaging in the direct politics,
- 1:10:24but for providing the, the educational resources needed for
- 1:10:30for any of those people to really get a sense of the the
- 1:10:35truth about Bitcoin and its potential.
- 1:10:40And why from whatever walk of life you might come from that,
- 1:10:46that Bitcoin can be a a beacon for a free and prosperous and
- 1:10:53peaceful future and kind of help people align with that.
- 1:10:59You know there's there's concern on a few things of of people
- 1:11:06forgetting like the the true importance of Bitcoin.
- 1:11:09So they might get into the the politics and such and it just
- 1:11:13like the the politics begins to overtake the underlying idea
- 1:11:18itself. And that that would be kind of
- 1:11:21that would be rather disappointing on that front for
- 1:11:25that for that to be the case because it's actually the
- 1:11:27underlying idea that makes the political idea or the the the
- 1:11:33political strategy even a even one to consider for those who
- 1:11:37are interested in that. So there's a need to to to sort
- 1:11:42of continue carrying that torch and being being a good steward
- 1:11:48for the the information that best helps people get up and
- 1:11:53running with Bitcoin as well as add to our stock of knowledge.
- 1:11:58We don't know everything about Bitcoin even after all these
- 1:12:02years like I'm I'm but a a humble pleb at the end of the
- 1:12:05day, as I think all of us ultimately are.
- 1:12:08And so we also have to we have to, we have to take care of the
- 1:12:12knowledge that we do have and grow it so that in whatever form
- 1:12:16that Bitcoin continues to to to grow.
- 1:12:20Those new bitcoiners have have a place to to learn about Bitcoin
- 1:12:26in the highest quality way possible.
- 1:12:29Yes, fantastic. Yeah, I you're preaching to
- 1:12:32acquire here for sure of the importance of Bitcoin education.
- 1:12:37It's paramount in my in my view. And in fact it's.
- 1:12:40I think you'd probably agree with this Michael.
- 1:12:42It's something of a calling once you understand Bitcoin and the
- 1:12:48mental model that I have of of what it takes for Bitcoin to
- 1:12:51win. It's just to ensure that we have
- 1:12:54a positive viral coefficient of of you know spreading the word I
- 1:13:01guess the gospel of the the facts really let's take the
- 1:13:05religion out of it but the the hard and fast economic facts of
- 1:13:11how Bitcoin can improve your life and that's Bitcoin
- 1:13:14education. And you you had a a talk about
- 1:13:20the I forget the the name of the talk but about the meme nature
- 1:13:24and the importance of memes in propagating Bitcoin education
- 1:13:30and and the and the message of Bitcoin.
- 1:13:33Do you want to talk briefly on that?
- 1:13:36Sure, yes. I gave a talk it was at Bitblock
- 1:13:40Boom in in 2019 called the art of Bitcoin rhetoric How to meme
- 1:13:45Bitcoin to the moon and the the the talk was was basically just
- 1:13:53looking into various aspect of rhetoric especially online
- 1:13:57rhetoric which we kind of we kind of just kind of lump all
- 1:14:01into to memes that that word itself is is kind of a a broad
- 1:14:07thing but it's effectively about rhetoric.
- 1:14:10And you know I I, I do start out saying that it's like Bitcoin is
- 1:14:13just going to moon as it is. Like the the hard economics are
- 1:14:17such that there is a a sort of natural organic growth to
- 1:14:25Bitcoin that's kind of bigger than any particular act of of
- 1:14:31trying to educate or persuade or you know you know whatever other
- 1:14:36kind of rhetoric you're engaged in.
- 1:14:39But I I tried to give a a talk. It was it was a very tongue in
- 1:14:43cheek, but hopefully very informative talk as well that
- 1:14:48helped people think about the the sort of battlefield of
- 1:14:53online rhetoric where you're you're dealing with many
- 1:14:58different groups of people who have different interests and
- 1:15:01motives. You're dealing with people who
- 1:15:04explicitly just hate Bitcoin and you're not going to convince
- 1:15:07them in the same mix as you're dealing with people who want to
- 1:15:11have very strong technical discussion of Bitcoin and also
- 1:15:15people who have no clue about Bitcoin but maybe want to learn
- 1:15:19about it and so on and so forth. And there's all sorts of
- 1:15:25rhetorical battles that sort of have to be thought fought in
- 1:15:29order to get particular signals out through the noise.
- 1:15:34And so I talk about, you know, different different tactics and
- 1:15:37and strategies, so to speak, to to how to think about these
- 1:15:41things. So for instance, people find
- 1:15:45themselves wanting to sort of cave to other people's
- 1:15:50narratives around Bitcoin that we have fundamentally no reason
- 1:15:55to have to like cave towards. An example is with the the
- 1:16:01energy debates. A lot of these, a lot of these
- 1:16:04debates are being done in bad faith where there's lots that we
- 1:16:09could discuss about you know, what are what are the most
- 1:16:11efficient, you know, ecologically friendly ways of of
- 1:16:16mining Bitcoin or something like that.
- 1:16:18There's there's many discussions to be had even among people who
- 1:16:22are completely in favor of everything being fossil fuels.
- 1:16:27I I personally happen to be a huge fan of fossil fuels.
- 1:16:30I also very much care about, you know ecological issues.
- 1:16:35But to even engage in the debate on those terms with certain
- 1:16:39individuals is to be seating A-frame where they're able to
- 1:16:44put you in a spot of weakness as because of the fact that they
- 1:16:48just hate Bitcoin. They they don't actually.
- 1:16:51The the energy debate is just something that they can try to
- 1:16:54just run a a gotcha on when really you know, it's not that
- 1:17:01they are worried that Bitcoin uses too much energy, they just
- 1:17:04don't like Bitcoin. So it doesn't matter, it doesn't
- 1:17:07matter how much energy Bitcoin is using at all.
- 1:17:10They will still think that it's way too much and it's
- 1:17:14environmentally damaging even if it was just one guy's laptop
- 1:17:18because you know, you could also, you know turn off that
- 1:17:20light after you leave the the room and you'll you'll do so
- 1:17:23much to help the the environment.
- 1:17:25So a lot of these discussions that people find themselves in
- 1:17:30they're very disingenuous. And so I invite bitcoiners to
- 1:17:35you know, I, I, I talk a lot about trolling but I, I, I also
- 1:17:39explained that it's like you you ultimately the the point is to
- 1:17:43spread the truth and so the the the goal of trolling is not
- 1:17:47literally to be toxic and just you know be be vile and mean to
- 1:17:51people that that's that's just being an awful person.
- 1:17:54I'm not. I'm not in support of that.
- 1:17:56However, understanding the rhetorical battlefield and
- 1:18:00knowing how to get get around these sort of gotchas that that
- 1:18:07come from bad faith and also you know not not, you know not being
- 1:18:15tricked into giving more respect than respect is due is is is
- 1:18:21very important to be able to to to to to transmit that truth.
- 1:18:25But I guess the other point that I was trying to make there is
- 1:18:28that to have the the actual signal that you're wanting to
- 1:18:33get out in the first place, you have to truly understand what
- 1:18:36you're talking about. Or at least you know, try to be
- 1:18:38truly understanding what you're talking about.
- 1:18:40And so underneath all of that, your goal should be to
- 1:18:44understand the truth and then be figuring out how do I get that
- 1:18:48truth out there? And when someone is coming at me
- 1:18:51with an argument, be able to identify is this person arguing
- 1:18:55in good faith or in bad faith? If they're arguing in good
- 1:18:58faith, you should be doing everything you can to help them
- 1:19:02through misconceptions. They might even have a critique
- 1:19:07or two that that resonate while it's like actually yes that is a
- 1:19:10trade off that Bitcoin has but This is why that that trade off
- 1:19:15is acceptable. Other things might be like the
- 1:19:17energy thing and then you know you you honestly should just
- 1:19:21like laugh at it because there's there's people are not trying to
- 1:19:24have a good faith argument. They're having a bad faith
- 1:19:26argument and so you have no obligation to take them
- 1:19:30seriously and and you know I, I, I see no problem in you know
- 1:19:36throwing around jabs online but that would also be a a call for
- 1:19:41you know if if that is not your personality to also do not
- 1:19:47tailor your message to those people because they are acting
- 1:19:51in bad faith. You might use it as a
- 1:19:53springboard to to have discussion with people who are
- 1:19:57of good faith but do not get trapped by people who are are
- 1:20:02arguing in in bad faith. So like I said, it's a it's a
- 1:20:06very tongue in cheek thing. But a lot of people have really
- 1:20:11enjoyed it and gotten a lot of value of it.
- 1:20:13So I'm I'm very I'm very you know happy that I was able to
- 1:20:17kind of help people see things in that in the different light.
- 1:20:21That's part of why it's it's fun to be in tongue in cheek is
- 1:20:24because it it helps people kind of snap out of their their you
- 1:20:29know what whatever their sort of current Overton windows so to
- 1:20:33speak or you know whatever other term you might you know their
- 1:20:36their their current way of thinking of it.
- 1:20:39If you're able to come at it from a totally different
- 1:20:41direction it can kind of snap people out of it and think
- 1:20:45outside of the box. And and I I always like being
- 1:20:47able to help people think a little bit outside of the box,
- 1:20:50because that's usually where a lot better answers are.
- 1:20:56Absolutely, yeah. And it seems to be necessary to
- 1:20:59to even begin to entertain the possibility that Bitcoin's right
- 1:21:03is that you have to 1st get outside of the box that you've
- 1:21:06been confined to your whole life without realizing it.
- 1:21:08Yeah, I mean I've had to deal with 10 / 10 years now of of you
- 1:21:13know every academic, journalist, politician you name it, telling
- 1:21:17me how how you know idiotic Bitcoin is going to 0 this and
- 1:21:21that and so on and so forth. It's always been the sort of
- 1:21:25losing proposition in the the mind of the general public and
- 1:21:29it requires having a strong resolve and developing a strong
- 1:21:34resolve based on hopefully a a a conviction built on on firm
- 1:21:42foundations. But once you're standing there,
- 1:21:45you know it's you can take on the world.
- 1:21:48Love it. It's fantastic and I think that
- 1:21:52that creates a nice little segue to for for us to wrap up here on
- 1:21:57on the what's going on currently for the Satoshi Nakamoto
- 1:22:00Institute, what your plans are and also what people can do if
- 1:22:08they want to get involved or support what you're doing with
- 1:22:11Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, any any things to say there?
- 1:22:16Yes, so you know as I said before the Satoshi Nakamoto
- 1:22:20Institute is now A5O1C3 tax exempt non profit which means
- 1:22:26that anyone who's AUS citizen can donate to us with a tax
- 1:22:34deduct tax deductible donation. So you know that's that's
- 1:22:41obviously much more enticing to to for certain people, for
- 1:22:45certain types of you know tax you know advantages and such.
- 1:22:53But then there's of course it's like why would why would you
- 1:22:55want to get involved with us in the 1st place.
- 1:22:58So you know, our, our mission is to advance and preserve Bitcoin
- 1:23:03knowledge, you know of of its history, of its economics, of
- 1:23:06its technology and so on and so forth and have a place that
- 1:23:11people can come to and learn all of these things about Bitcoin.
- 1:23:16And as I've kind of alluded before, alluded to before, we
- 1:23:23have to think not just in terms of now but also deep into the
- 1:23:26future. And so my goal is to be
- 1:23:31stewarding the the finest information on on Bitcoin such
- 1:23:38that new bitcoiners today and generations to come can still
- 1:23:42come and and learn what they need to know about Bitcoin to to
- 1:23:48to best thrive and yeah so. So ways that you can get
- 1:23:55involved first is it is it is an open source website.
- 1:24:01So you are always welcome to come help with the code help
- 1:24:06with content you know actually you know get your get your hands
- 1:24:11dirty helps helps more than probably anything else because
- 1:24:17it enables the other things. But we also have launched a
- 1:24:22translation community. We are trying to we we want our
- 1:24:26content to be as accessible globally as possible because
- 1:24:30Bitcoin is global and it shouldn't just be people who can
- 1:24:35read English that get to enjoy the the wisdom of Nick Zabo and
- 1:24:41Timothy May and many of the other great thinkers that we've
- 1:24:45we've showcased on the website. And so we have a translation
- 1:24:49community if if you would like to assist with translation
- 1:24:53efforts. And finally there's also you
- 1:24:57know donations. So being able to you know you
- 1:24:59can you can donate to U.S. tax deductibly and is if that's the
- 1:25:05correct term. But and you know with that, that
- 1:25:09allows us to you know pay for our hosting help, pay for me to
- 1:25:15to be able to work full time, be able to expand operations to be
- 1:25:20able to do more work. Currently it's it's mostly a one
- 1:25:24man show so only so much can get done at A at a given time.
- 1:25:28But you know, with your help, maybe that can change in the
- 1:25:31future. Currently one of our big
- 1:25:34projects, you know, we unveiled a a new logo for the Satoshi
- 1:25:38Nakamoto Institute and we have a broader fundraiser going on to
- 1:25:45help fund a redesign of the website.
- 1:25:49And the idea here is it's almost like a, it's almost like a phase
- 1:25:54change in a way. You know, prior we were targeted
- 1:26:00towards like a lot of nerdy libertarians online.
- 1:26:03There's only so many people who are going to be interested in
- 1:26:06Austrian economics or cryptography or you know what
- 1:26:09have you. But because Bitcoin has grown to
- 1:26:13the place that it is, these topics are now tapping into the
- 1:26:17mainstream and it is something that the whole world wants to
- 1:26:20know. And so with redesigned, we want
- 1:26:24a we we're we're trying to build an aesthetic that helps display
- 1:26:29to the world our seriousness and commitment to the long term
- 1:26:34education of bit corners now and in the future.
- 1:26:37And so you can find information about this on our newsletter and
- 1:26:44if you if you donate you can help us, you know get this
- 1:26:47redesign process going so that we can you know, have that have
- 1:26:53the the aesthetics that match our long term vision.
- 1:26:58Awesome. Yeah, it's it's fantastic work.
- 1:27:00It's a vital resource and everyone if you haven't checked
- 1:27:04it out go check it out and and you know see if you can support
- 1:27:08what what Michael's up to Michael want to thank you for
- 1:27:12coming on the show. It was a great conversation,
- 1:27:15really appreciate your time and I look forward to to maybe
- 1:27:18having you come come chat wonky semantic stuff about the
- 1:27:24trajectory of Bitcoin another time in the future.
- 1:27:28That would be fantastic. Thank you so much for having me.
- 1:27:32All right everybody and and and Mitch, thanks for joining this
- 1:27:35week too and everybody will will see you all next week back with
- 1:27:39the usual cast.