Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 208 - Paraguay’s Banking Scandal: What’s Really Going On? | Raphaël Lima
Transcript
- 0:00So the banquet broke at 4 a.m. Tuesday, and by 8 p.m., 9 p.m. Friday, the president was
- 0:08in jail and everyone in the bank was arrested. When they raided Santiago Pena's mansion,
- 0:14they found a bunker, a secret door behind a stone. There's some Israeli vault in there
- 0:23that they can't open. And meanwhile, in Brazil, where they had also a banking scandal, this week,
- 0:29the discussion is releasing the banker that did the scandal. So it's like...
- 0:34A third of the population is left-wing, a third of the population is right-wing,
- 0:38and a third of the population hates both. So there's no way, like, it's mathematically
- 0:44impossible for you to have a government that works.
- 0:59Paraguay. I suppose I've got a lot of questions about this, Raphael.
- 1:06When all the problems started, I got a lot of Bitcoin friends, obviously, and they all started going,
- 1:14hey, look, this is the beginning of the end. Look, it's happening in Paraguay.
- 1:19That was my first sort of like introduction to what was going on there.
- 1:23then sort of over the next few days it seemed to be that the government or at least the central bank
- 1:32or paraguay themselves seemed to be dealing with dealing with it quite well it seemed to be anyway
- 1:40but you live there you're part of it you were on the you're on the ground so um can you sort of
- 1:46just like start off by just describing what happened first i take it you were you were in
- 1:51the country when it first started. Yes, yes, yes. I live here since February. My Spanish is still not
- 1:57that good, but anyways. So what happened was that Monday to Tuesday last week, about 4am,
- 2:07something like that, the central bank put out a notice that they were intervening and closing
- 2:13down Waino Bank, saying that they failed to meet security and reserve requirements and didn't clarify
- 2:21quite very much what exactly happened, but the fact is, effectively, the bank was broke.
- 2:28And everyone woke up to that news, which was quite a wake-up that day.
- 2:35And instantly, there was a lot of revolt because it was a bank, it was a very popular bank,
- 2:41because banking in Paraguay is, well, I think I would rather fall off of a cliff than doing
- 2:50the standard procedure to open a bank account here and i've done it quite a few times it's awful
- 2:55and bueno was very much easier it was very a modern bank and since you could open accounts
- 3:00in your apps that's the type of simple stuff it started digital banks a lot of people had small
- 3:06accounts into it and that's where the news came that it was the biggest bank in paraguay in terms
- 3:12of accounts open yes in terms of deposits no we'll get there but everyone was naturally livid about it
- 3:19And quite immediately, responses came out from the government.
- 3:25The president of the central bank resigned quite quickly.
- 3:30And within probably 12 to 14, 15 hours, I'm going to try to be precise on that because quite quickly everything happened.
- 3:39Within like 15 hours at most, arrest orders for everyone in the board of directors, CEO, vice, CEO, something like that, and the owner were issued in two or three hours.
- 3:54Maybe they had all surrendered.
- 3:56I think all but one had surrendered the police.
- 3:58They were everyone arrested.
- 4:01The resignation of the president of the central bank came a bit later.
- 4:05probably, I think maybe in the early hours of Wednesday, possibly.
- 4:12And the government, the president, or now the former president,
- 4:16were quite quick to say, well, there is a guarantee fund.
- 4:22There's a private guarantee fund.
- 4:23All banks have to pitch in and it's managed by the government.
- 4:26It will cover the expenses.
- 4:28And by law, it has to cover expenses in 15 days.
- 4:32but we will pass legislation so that it covers all deposits immediately.
- 4:38So you don't have to wait for the 15 days to try to calm everyone down.
- 4:42Protests started on Tuesday, but mostly on Wednesday.
- 4:46They got bigger.
- 4:47But they were mostly by left-wing people,
- 4:50which are less than 5% of the population of Paraguay,
- 4:53and they're not taken seriously.
- 4:54Everyone's like, that's not us.
- 4:57That's like those crazies over there.
- 4:58So by Wednesday you have the announcement of that, of the legislation, everything gets approved,
- 5:07and sanctioned and published by Thursday evening, Thursday morning actually, and by Thursday evening
- 5:18the central bank starts to issue payments to the account holders, and at the same time the
- 5:25The scandal got up in politics all the way to the president because he was a business
- 5:31partner, he was an associate of the bank, he was a partner of the bank, a stockholder
- 5:38of the bank, should I say, up until 2025.
- 5:43He had very big connections to it.
- 5:46The former president of the central bank, his former job was at Ueno Bank.
- 5:51The person who nominated him to be the president of the central bank was the former president
- 5:55Santiago Pena.
- 5:57And he was friends with the bank and the people on the bank.
- 5:59He was quite close.
- 6:00Their images were quite close.
- 6:03And there was a very large amount of state money inside the bank.
- 6:08Namely the largest account is the Social Security of Paraguay.
- 6:149% of their money was at the bank, which was misconstrued by news as saying, oh, the money
- 6:22of the Social Security was at Bueno, so everyone thinks it's like 100%.
- 6:26It's not.
- 6:27It's roughly 9%.
- 6:28I may get it wrong, but it's like 9.7%, like something like that.
- 6:32And Social Security has their money in very many banks in Paraguay.
- 6:37They spread it out, so it wasn't a complete scandal in that.
- 6:42But the fact is that Weno was the largest share of all of them.
- 6:48Whereas if you think in deposits, Weno was about the fifth bank in Paraguay.
- 6:54They had 3 million accounts.
- 6:55But in terms of money actually in there, they were in fifth place by quite a wide margin.
- 7:00So everyone started asking, why did you have so much money there?
- 7:04Why was it the largest account holder?
- 7:07And you had also very many other government banks depositing money there.
- 7:12You had the finance ministry.
- 7:13You had the Itaipu Dam, which is the hydro dam of Paraguay.
- 7:19It's huge.
- 7:20They had a lot of money there.
- 7:21And then came out the news that an employee on the central bank did warn the government about these reserve requirement problems quite some time ago.
- 7:36and Santiago Pena ordered him to be switched out to some other job.
- 7:43So that was, everyone's like, okay, now we're done.
- 7:47And there was very strong pressure from the opposition to impeach him.
- 7:54And at that point, he became undefensible.
- 7:57He was already in a very delicate situation because of all those connections.
- 8:01And then his own party got together, sat down and said,
- 8:05well, we're not standing up for him, you get out.
- 8:08And there was a big meeting in Thursday morning, Thursday afternoon,
- 8:15like early in the afternoon, probably like 1 p.m., 2 p.m. loco.
- 8:19It was widely reported.
- 8:22And it was also widely reported that they had the votes to impeach him in the Senate.
- 8:27And the result of that meeting was likely something to the effect of
- 8:32they notified him that he would not be defended, he would be impeached.
- 8:38He then promptly resigned, because in Paraguay, if the president resigns,
- 8:42he becomes a lifetime senator with immunity.
- 8:47But there's a catch.
- 8:49The House of Representatives has to accept his resignation.
- 8:53They did not, unanimously.
- 8:56Did not accept his renunciation.
- 8:58He presented the impeachment articles.
- 9:01And Friday morning, they accepted that in the lower chamber.
- 9:06And Friday evening, he went to trial.
- 9:10He requested that to be delayed a little bit, but they didn't.
- 9:14And by the start of the night, I think 7 or maybe 8 p.m., he was impeached legally, unanimously.
- 9:22and his arrest order was issued maybe 20 minutes later.
- 9:29And so now he ended the week in jail, basically.
- 9:34So the bank went broke at 4 a.m. Tuesday
- 9:37and by 8 p.m., 9 p.m. Friday, the president was in jail
- 9:42and everyone in the bank was arrested.
- 9:45And also the payments had already started.
- 9:47By Thursday, the payments to account holders had already started.
- 9:50so they had roughly 3.2 million account holders of which 1.3 had absolutely no money whatsoever in
- 9:59there i was one of them a lot of people opened accounts during the the world cup because oh they
- 10:04had like this cool the school card with like the the team colors it's like oh it's cool to have a
- 10:09card are you gonna put money there so uh like because you could you could get a lot of perks
- 10:15like you get a priority to buy tickets and shows you can get cashbacks so 1.3 million had no money
- 10:23whatsoever in there and i think roughly 1.6 something like that 1.5 million something like that
- 10:32had less than um that would be like a thousand reais which would be uh 150 180 pounds
- 10:42or like $200, less than $200 in the account.
- 10:47So it was like just change money.
- 10:51And so by today, so Tuesday, we're recording this,
- 10:55the new president has already announced
- 10:58that they have paid back 95% of account holders.
- 11:01And by the end of the day, it should go up to 98%,
- 11:07which is everyone that was insured by deposit insurance.
- 11:13Only roughly 2,000 to 4,000 accounts are not fully insured.
- 11:21So they would go to the bankruptcy procedures and everything and go fight it out.
- 11:26So it was quite quick.
- 11:28It was quite a lightning strike in there.
- 11:32And so that's roughly the timetable of everything that's happening.
- 11:36and it was um it was quite beautiful to see but well i yapped a lot so it's i mean it does sound
- 11:44pretty good i mean the the cynic in me says that they have sorted out all the small level depositors
- 11:52to keep people happy basically um but correct me if i'm wrong rafael because this might just be the
- 12:00the circles that I revolve in but but recently um um Paraguay's made a real concerted effort to
- 12:09sort of attract like foreign investment right in in on the global scale I've I've been hearing about
- 12:14Paraguay for for for a you know a year and a bit or so and and and then suddenly it becomes a meme
- 12:21and everyone's like yeah Paraguay Paraguay Paraguay Paraguay um is that true first and and secondly if
- 12:27it is true, how does that all fit in with this? And are people genuinely rocked by this? Or are
- 12:36outsiders like myself? I mean, I took a bit of a look, a deep dive into it. And yes, it does look
- 12:42like, from a PR perspective, at least, people are saying, yeah, this is great. That's what's coming
- 12:48from the sort of Central America, the sort of Latin American people, if you see what I mean.
- 12:53But what do you think for real Firstly is that true that there this concerted effort to get people to come to Paraguay now by the government And two is this a serious thing or not
- 13:06OK, so if it is a government effort, now, I don't have that level of government connections.
- 13:11But I do own a company that helps people to move to countries where you will pay less taxes and leave freely, which is called SETI.
- 13:21we have i think i think we crossed 4 000 clients over this last week probably because lula got
- 13:30elected in brazil and most of our public is brazilian so we had like thousands of people just
- 13:35kind of like we had four months worth of demand in like five days wasn't it so but to say we've
- 13:41like moved thousands of people well at this point and we've moved a lot to paraguay live here i'm
- 13:48I'm in our office, there's a big house here in Viomoto.
- 13:51And so we've done that.
- 13:53We've helped to raise attention about that, especially in Brazil.
- 13:58Like I'm probably the most connected person to like the image of Paraguay in Brazil.
- 14:02It's us, it's our company.
- 14:04And it's very real because it's a very good option for many types of people in certain conditions.
- 14:11So it's not the perfect Disneyland.
- 14:15It's not.
- 14:16But for many people, it is a very good option.
- 14:19And the government has been quite friendly and quite quick in those efforts to bring money.
- 14:26Because quite a few years ago, Paraguay's economy was very connected to Brazil's economy.
- 14:31Which is, I mean, you're connected to other economies.
- 14:34But I mean, when you're like dependent on one that's not really good.
- 14:37So they're trying to diversify that.
- 14:39Santiago Pena and his government, in previous efforts, but especially Santiago,
- 14:43they did efforts to get friends in the world and get more money in to grow
- 14:48because they know they're very competitive country and there have been
- 14:53efforts they're really good and it's really worth it it's not for everyone of
- 14:56course it's a country in development I mean you have problems if it rains quite
- 15:02strongly you're gonna have plenty in certain areas the streets are not really
- 15:06good and you don't want to be stopped by the traffic police that would be a very
- 15:11bad day for you. I mean, there are
- 15:13issues, but
- 15:14in terms of
- 15:16the potential to grow and
- 15:19you have, and having a
- 15:2195% plus
- 15:23right-wing conservative
- 15:25Catholic society,
- 15:27yeah, that's very attractive to certain
- 15:29types of people, right?
- 15:31If you like the heat, I mean,
- 15:33today's a very cool day, it's like
- 15:3529 Celsius outside
- 15:37and people were like praying in the streets that
- 15:39thank you that this is not a
- 15:40hellishly hot day of November.
- 15:45But I just, of course, but it is a very good country.
- 15:50And there was a very, and there is still a very large effort to bring in investment.
- 15:54Just so you have an idea, the GDP of the country is roughly $50 billion.
- 15:59And about a month or so ago, they announced they're going to have a $12 billion data center here.
- 16:06So, yeah, like 25% of the GDP in one data center, and you're getting a lot of investment coming in.
- 16:16We're doing that.
- 16:17We're bringing in, after Lula's re-election in Brazil, a few hundred companies to do business here and produce here, industrialize here, and export, and that type of stuff.
- 16:27So, yes, that is a good effort.
- 16:29Has that been impacted?
- 16:32Eh.
- 16:34Eh.
- 16:34I mean, a lot of our clients were like, wait, what's going on?
- 16:40And then we explained the whole thing, like the first phase of what we talked about here.
- 16:43And everyone was like, oh, it's quite quick.
- 16:46I expected about nothing of that.
- 16:49I would expect absolutely nothing to happen and three random people going to jail because they signed the paper and that's it.
- 16:58And Wayno was not a systematically important bank.
- 17:02It was not an export-import bank.
- 17:04Some businesses, some commerce had their part of their funds there.
- 17:09So that's going to be a hassle.
- 17:11But I mean, the trust, the deposit guarantee goes up to roughly $38,000.
- 17:17And the minimum wage here is $500, just so you get like a comparison.
- 17:22So I mean, unless your company had 100% of your funds in one bank, which is probably
- 17:28a mistake by your management to do so.
- 17:34That's kind of okay.
- 17:36Some investors were thinking,
- 17:38well, okay, so the president changed.
- 17:40So what does he believe?
- 17:41Oh, the same thing as the other one.
- 17:43Oh, all right.
- 17:44So everyone just checked their things
- 17:46for like a few days and decided,
- 17:48we're moving on.
- 17:50The dollar did rise on these last few days.
- 17:53A lot of people dollarized.
- 17:54A lot of people tried to protect themselves a little bit.
- 17:57But I mean, we were going out because like our team,
- 18:03most of our team is here for these weeks
- 18:05because we do a November thing with our company.
- 18:07We try to get everyone together because we're a digital company.
- 18:10So we were like going out almost every day.
- 18:13Bars were full, restaurants were full.
- 18:15It was a normal weekend.
- 18:17It was a normal day.
- 18:19Of course, like if your money is there, it's not a good day for you.
- 18:23But it's not like when the financial crisis hit or like when Greece, when the banks shut down, that wasn't that.
- 18:32And you see like photos of people lining up on the banks.
- 18:35Yes, of course, because what the government did was they said, well, we're going to pay you in other banks.
- 18:41So if you have an account in another bank, we're going to pay you there.
- 18:45And if not, then we'll just let you know.
- 18:48So, hey, now you've got an account in this bank.
- 18:51Go get your money.
- 18:52So yeah, it was annoying to get out and go into lines, get your money.
- 18:56But I mean, coming to the second question of what was the perception?
- 19:01Well, I mean, it's a Latin American country with a high perception of corruption.
- 19:05And it's a very developing country still.
- 19:08So naturally, everyone would expect absolutely nothing to happen.
- 19:13And we had a lot of the foreigners who were here, like the Europeans especially,
- 19:18they were like, when Credit Suisse went haywire in bloody Switzerland, that didn't happen.
- 19:28Like, no bankers got jailed in Switzerland.
- 19:31Nobody got jailed in Britain when the FGC happened.
- 19:37And you got the president behind literal bars in four days.
- 19:44they were like oh all right i mean obviously that shouldn't have happened in the first place but now
- 19:51that it did that was quite fine like everyone was like positively surprised so it's it's black
- 19:58clouds and silver lines why why is that then i mean you're absolutely right that there's been a
- 20:04number of banking crises in various countries one of the few i can think of where actually someone
- 20:11went to jail was Iceland. Do you remember that one? I'm pretty sure someone went to jail then.
- 20:17But other than that, you're absolutely right. Nobody ever pays the price for these kind of
- 20:23things. So why is it that Paraguay of all places, is it because it's a genuinely kind of, I don't
- 20:30know, honest group of people or is it something else? What's going on? Oh, there is that. They're
- 20:36very honest people i mean and you can see that in the smallest of things like i had to like those
- 20:41chairs these chairs are new like one would have a defect we had to go to the store and change it
- 20:45like a few hours ago and uh we exchanged it for another chair because like the prices and they had
- 20:51to give me back like six dollars something like that because the price differences between the
- 20:59chairs and so my wife was me with me she was like oh i want this decoration and then they had to
- 21:05to give me back like 80 cents of a dollar, something like that.
- 21:12And I was like, no, you don't need to, just forget that.
- 21:15And said, no, no, what costs 80 cents?
- 21:18So they got like this notepad and said, you take that.
- 21:22They wouldn't take my like 80 cents.
- 21:26We're going to give you something.
- 21:28That was super cool.
- 21:29And that's not like an isolated thing.
- 21:31I'm just telling this story because this happens all the time.
- 21:32some guy parked a convertible in front of my building for a whole day
- 21:36open, like hatch fully open
- 21:40you can't do that in London today
- 21:42can you like get a convertible, like a Mercedes convertible
- 21:47badass, like bomb car
- 21:49pull the hatch down, park it somewhere in some neighborhood, nothing happens
- 21:53is that London now?
- 21:56can you do that?
- 21:56no, I think the whole car would be taken
- 21:59that in front of my house, nothing happened.
- 22:02Nothing happened.
- 22:03So they're very honest people.
- 22:07It's very safe
- 22:07here too. But there is also
- 22:09something that they
- 22:11very profoundly
- 22:13and very deeply hate politicians.
- 22:17Like they do.
- 22:17They do.
- 22:19And even the people who like the Colorado
- 22:21party and who are members,
- 22:24they still hate the shit
- 22:25out of them.
- 22:26And it's like, they're less worse than the others, and I like this and that other guy.
- 22:31Oh, and if they step one way outside the line, I will set his house on fire.
- 22:37Like, that is their mentality.
- 22:39And they're very civil about it, because if you see the protests,
- 22:43like, if you see the videos of the protests, they're not breaking anything.
- 22:47They're not setting fire to stuff.
- 22:48They're just pissed off.
- 22:49And there was a politician here who's quite famous.
- 22:51He tried to, like, show up in the protests, like, I'm the alternative.
- 22:54And people just like drag him away.
- 22:57It's like, sod off.
- 22:58No, you're not.
- 23:01Like, we hate him, but we also hate you in very many different ways.
- 23:05But fuck off.
- 23:08So what was understood by the politicians was either we fix this or stuff's going to happen.
- 23:18And people were very civil about it.
- 23:21Nothing was looted.
- 23:22Nothing was broken.
- 23:23broken. The streets were clean
- 23:26after the protests.
- 23:28It was amazing.
- 23:29But everyone was absolutely livid.
- 23:32And if they had
- 23:33done something else
- 23:35lighter than what they did,
- 23:39I mean,
- 23:41if you saw the World Cup
- 23:44and you saw how Paraguay
- 23:46stood up to France
- 23:48and Germany and fought it out
- 23:50up until the last second, I will tell you
- 23:51That is the Paraguayan spirit.
- 23:55They're not going to let you go.
- 23:58So, yeah, that's that.
- 24:00They pay less, they pay half the taxes than a Brazilian pays,
- 24:04and they hate it like four times as much.
- 24:06I'm an NCAP.
- 24:07And when I explain libertarianism to them, they're like,
- 24:11yeah, that's just common sense.
- 24:13Government screws up for everything, and we shouldn't have them at all.
- 24:17They're like, I don't know, is that a philosophy?
- 24:20Oh, all right.
- 24:21was was penna the santiago the the president was he considered corrupt prior to this well did they
- 24:32did or is it just a general sentence yeah yeah what about in paraguay i mean i mean you know
- 24:38arguably there are some good ones out there somewhere but in paraguay was he known for
- 24:43being a bit of a crook or or presumably we're we're all in agreement now he is a crook is that
- 24:48right it's not just circumstantial what's happened he he's he's he's he's had his finger in a few pies
- 24:54he's he's been fight siphoning money out of the out of the bank by the looks of it as well in the
- 25:00form of loans to himself that he can't pay back various things i heard yeah there was things like
- 25:05they they did a raid in his house in san bernardino which is like the the nice light lake city close
- 25:11to here and his house was fully paid by loans from uh wino bank which there is absolutely no way that
- 25:17could pay them back like honestly with like his declared earners earnings it's like there's no way
- 25:21um and there were criticisms because like you said you asked me the first question was when
- 25:27did this begin and i was tempted to say three years ago and then just like don't do the whole
- 25:32timeline but when it was always a very politically connected bank it was very which is always
- 25:38suspicious it's like why do you have all these politicians close to you it's like you're a banker
- 25:42But in Latin America, that's normal because that's Latin America.
- 25:48You just go like, ah, everyone's dirty.
- 25:51But yeah, that was questionable.
- 25:53Like everyone knew that there was something iffy about it.
- 25:56But if you in Latin America 50 of everything is kind of iffy in some ways And sometimes like no they just friends because it a small country and everyone knows each other And sometimes like yeah but that kind of I don know
- 26:11That's a normal thing.
- 26:14And except for his hardcore fan base, nobody would say that he's like squeaky clean.
- 26:19But nobody would say that about anyone in PowerWide.
- 26:22And if you come up and say, oh, no, this guy is absolutely squeaky clean.
- 26:2690% of the population would just point at you a laugh and be like, that's not how stuff works.
- 26:34But that being said, nobody today thinks that he's clean.
- 26:40Only some diehard, hardcore fans are saying, yeah, but under his presidency, we grew a lot,
- 26:48and crime fell, and wages went up.
- 26:51And everyone's like, yeah, and he should be 100% in jail.
- 26:54it's like it doesn't don't try that right um so yeah there were criticisms of him there is
- 27:01criticisms of his party but that's just politics south of the mexico border in the u.s
- 27:07you're gonna get how come so many people so many um members of the public had accounts there
- 27:15is it true that that that this was the most subscribed to bank for sort of like
- 27:20the man on the street.
- 27:23How come? Because it's a new
- 27:25bank as well, right? It wasn't a
- 27:27world. 40%
- 27:29of Paraguayans don't have any
- 27:30bank accounts whatsoever.
- 27:3440%.
- 27:34It's still very much an unbanked country.
- 27:37And Weno was a
- 27:38digital bank that was easy to use because
- 27:40the other banks here, they're just crap.
- 27:43It's just so annoying to deal
- 27:45with them. Every time I have to
- 27:47handle them, I'm thinking, I might
- 27:49get deported today like this might be the day you know they're just shit to deal with so they were
- 27:55easy they were easy to to get a bank account they had only like one base one office but they had
- 28:04like small places where you could like get a card and and they did like good marketing like that's
- 28:10something that people are sad because they're like but that was such a good bank to use like
- 28:14what the hell i mean they're crook they're screwed them okay but like yo can someone
- 28:20like copy that and do that but clean like please someone because you could get a card easily
- 28:27you could pay your bills easily you could uh you could save money easily you could like operate it
- 28:33easily um they did good marketing they had like they sponsored the uh the national team they had
- 28:39the cool team cards with the colors.
- 28:43And by the way, Paraguayan nationalism,
- 28:47it's amazing.
- 28:51People just randomly put the flag up everywhere.
- 28:55Imagine Texas where people have the flag everywhere.
- 28:58It's like that.
- 28:59So it's super beautiful.
- 29:00Everyone wants the credit card with the Almiroja colors
- 29:04of the national team,
- 29:06especially after after they classified for the um for knockout phase everyone's like
- 29:11static and they were just very good at that that being said they had 3.2 million accounts um
- 29:1940 of those they had no money in because people were like oh so they're more handy to have because
- 29:24i can get the app and open the account and then like transfer some money and i can buy the tickets
- 29:30for the corn show that happened in May
- 29:33that I'm super on the way that I couldn't go.
- 29:36I'm still mad about that.
- 29:37And I can get priority in the line,
- 29:40so I can get the account for that
- 29:41and just pay it easily.
- 29:42The other places didn't.
- 29:44So a lot of people had accounts because of that.
- 29:46But 92% of account holders
- 29:50of those 3.2 million in the 6.57 million people country,
- 29:55they had less than $200 there.
- 29:57So it's just like your cheap change,
- 29:59like being small things
- 30:02your like restaurant bank
- 30:04people didn't bank like
- 30:06seriously there
- 30:07because like businesses
- 30:10here they're more old fashioned
- 30:12so they would look at this and be like
- 30:13that's
- 30:15I don't know about that I'm gonna go with
- 30:18the old bank where you have like
- 30:19like
- 30:22personally and like I prefer
- 30:24you that so
- 30:25it was the largest bank in accounts
- 30:28but in terms of financial impact, eh.
- 30:33Am I right in thinking that the reason it collapsed
- 30:38is because they were lending out more than they had in reserves
- 30:41or there's a level at which they can't, right, okay.
- 30:44Yeah.
- 30:44Which is pretty much the modus operandi of every bank now anyway.
- 30:49I thought you didn't need to hold any reserves anymore.
- 30:52That must be a, what's happened to it now?
- 30:55They do, but sorry to cut you off on that,
- 30:57But what happened was the owner apparently was taking out a lot of loans to his own companies,
- 31:05companies, other companies of his same group.
- 31:07And he exceeded the security margin of that by a lot.
- 31:13So essentially, it was a bank to bank his own stuff.
- 31:18And when they went to check if the reserves actually added up and the contracts, they didn't.
- 31:26and they had spent a lot of money on cashbacks
- 31:30because you could get like huge cashbacks here.
- 31:33They spent a lot of money in that,
- 31:35spent a lot of money in advertising and everything.
- 31:37And people were not putting money back in the bank,
- 31:40not investing with it
- 31:42because it's starting to be a cultural thing here
- 31:47to save money in banks and like fix deposits
- 31:50or like bonds.
- 31:52They're still like such a new industry.
- 31:54Companies didn't use to...
- 31:57You only have regularly issued bonds by companies.
- 32:02Every week you have a new one for the last two, three years, possibly.
- 32:07So it's still very much a new thing.
- 32:09So they were spending a lot of money, but they were getting a lot of business back into it.
- 32:14Meanwhile, he was bankrolling every one of his other companies and stuff just didn't add up.
- 32:20So apparently, the last number I saw, that I might be off by a little bit here,
- 32:24But apparently they only have like roughly 30%.
- 32:27But that doesn't count the guarantee fund.
- 32:29So the guarantee fund like insured like 98%.
- 32:32And the rest of them is the funds of the bank.
- 32:36But also they're going to execute all the properties of the owner, the directors, everything.
- 32:43It's not going to add up.
- 32:44Like they're still going to get a haircut to something.
- 32:47Probably I had to guess right now it would be something like 50%.
- 32:51Something like that.
- 32:53but that's mostly state stuff.
- 32:57And what's happened to the actual bank itself,
- 33:00as in the app?
- 33:02And are they going to bring it back or is that it?
- 33:04No, they won't.
- 33:06No.
- 33:07It's dead.
- 33:09Completely.
- 33:10It's dead completely.
- 33:11And in fact, their office,
- 33:13they had like a cool bent,
- 33:16kind of like parametric roof,
- 33:18you know, like wavy.
- 33:19People are like riding skates on it.
- 33:20like people are riding bikes and skates on it it's like it's it's a new like skate pit thing
- 33:30but you reckon that that's put a hole in the market now for for an easy to use digital app
- 33:38appy type bank then yeah if if someone wants to do it there is a market probably someone already
- 33:45started thinking about it but then you're gonna have to explain we're a digital fun new bank is
- 33:50to use and we're not going to calm down it's like we're not those guys like probably probably you're
- 33:57gonna have to wait you know it's gonna it's like when like a very bad event happens in every comic
- 34:03out there things so i guess in like 18 months we can joke about it but like not next week
- 34:09like you're just gonna have to hold off a little bit you know and were there any is there much um
- 34:16integration with things like Bitcoin in Paraguay at all?
- 34:20Oh, no, no, there isn't.
- 34:23Nothing at all?
- 34:24No, I'm not going to say like nothing at all,
- 34:27but it's hard to use.
- 34:29And 40% of the people are not even banked.
- 34:32And banks here, they're very concerned
- 34:36because there are very many ways
- 34:40in which a bank or a bank manager,
- 34:42your personal account manager,
- 34:44can be legally and criminally responsible
- 34:47if your bank account is used for some sort of crime.
- 34:52So they're very careful.
- 34:56If I had a bank account here, which I don't,
- 34:59because they're like, oh, so you work for this foreign company
- 35:02bringing people in and you do all the sorts of...
- 35:05The company is in the US, but you're Brazilian.
- 35:09Yeah, we don't want you as a client.
- 35:11Try the next one.
- 35:12They're like, that sounds too no.
- 35:15They're like that.
- 35:16So if you say, oh, I do Bitcoin, you're probably going to get your account closed on the spot.
- 35:26Probably on the spot.
- 35:28Some banks, if they know you, if you have other money, if you have history with them,
- 35:35they're going to ask for a lot of proof of funds.
- 35:39Where did that come from and how?
- 35:42where are your tax returns
- 35:43and if I had a bank account
- 35:46and I just like wired
- 35:4710, 15 thousand dollars
- 35:50to it, it would lock and my manager
- 35:52would call me and be like yo
- 35:53are you insane?
- 35:56You're just like
- 35:57randomly putting 50k in the bank
- 36:00with no proof, no warning
- 36:02what the hell dude
- 36:04they're like super sketchy
- 36:06Paraguay is a very very
- 36:08bad country
- 36:10to bank in
- 36:12it's just hellish and uh usually they have a i do everything on a on a crypto app and i just like
- 36:18swipe my card and there's a crypto app so like the only three things that i can pay with crypto apps
- 36:24here is uh my my lights my electric bill my water bill and my uh medical insurance bill
- 36:32which a friend of mine pays me and i pay him so that's it so but and there are some people
- 36:38There are a lot of people here that like crypto.
- 36:40There are some crypto made-ups.
- 36:43But it's hard to interact.
- 36:46And there is a new crypto legislation here.
- 36:50After Paraguay got in the shooting of America, it was like three days later,
- 36:53they issued something to the effect of if you handle over $5,000 in crypto per year,
- 37:01you have to report to the government, blah, blah, blah.
- 37:03And everyone was correctly concerned of, I mean, Paraguay is not the hugest thing in information security and etc.
- 37:15The odds of that leaking and me getting kidnapped are relevant.
- 37:19I don't want that.
- 37:20So some people left because of that.
- 37:23And we developed a solution where you can legally have your crypto in a company that is not fiscally resident in Paraguay because you only have to report if it's your person or your company that is fiscally held in Paraguay.
- 37:41so we started to open a lot of companies to people in other countries where they can
- 37:47crypto friendly countries where they can incorporate and have their crypto legally
- 37:51there and that the company has an exchange account and everything and then they spend it here
- 37:57so it doesn't legally qualify as something that you have to report so it's kind of annoying
- 38:02but I mean once you have that set up it's easy. And is it still the big news at the moment?
- 38:10is it still the biggest news story happening right now?
- 38:13Oh, by far, yes.
- 38:15Yeah, by far, yes.
- 38:16You have a lot of many side stories
- 38:19because there are probably going to be Weno files,
- 38:21like you had the Panama files.
- 38:23You're going to have the Weno files,
- 38:25like when everyone opens that up
- 38:26and sees who was partners, who had money,
- 38:29who made the decision.
- 38:30Because everyone's livid,
- 38:31so that's going to be investigated at some level.
- 38:33I'm not saying that everyone's going to get investigated,
- 38:38but many people will.
- 38:39So we're going to have the files of that.
- 38:42There will be the Pena trial because he's in jail,
- 38:44but there is still like, they have to try him
- 38:47and they convict him.
- 38:49There will be the trial probably
- 38:51of the former central bank president,
- 38:55which that's the thing I'm saying.
- 38:57I mean it sad that this happened but the fact that we talking about the legal and criminal trial of the former president of the central bank when would I use that phrase in Europe
- 39:12When would I use that phrase in the US? I mean, it's shit that we're here, but it's also kind
- 39:19of cool. So you're going to have those legal proceedings. The most interesting,
- 39:26most content generating curiosity generating storyline now is that when they raided uh
- 39:35Santiago Pena's mansion they found like a bunker like a secret like door behind like a stone
- 39:42there's like some Israeli vault in there that they can't open and they're like what is there
- 39:48surely it's empty by now I just watched a video of that on Twitter like
- 39:54They're like a solid stone bunker, isn't it?
- 39:58Like in his house with a sliding wall.
- 40:01How are we going to get into it?
- 40:03Are you going to call it the Israeli company and have them open?
- 40:07Can we dig it out?
- 40:09So that's like, oh, I want to know.
- 40:11Now, it's surely it's an empty room, but there was something there
- 40:15and it probably moved it already.
- 40:17And there are people betting on what's going to be like,
- 40:21People are like, oh, so maybe it's a vault, maybe it's a winery, maybe it's like a sex dungeon.
- 40:27People are babbing on their wildest things.
- 40:30But yeah, there are like bajillion storylines on top of that.
- 40:34And it's the story of the country.
- 40:35We're going to have fun with that for weeks on end.
- 40:39What's the local sentiment, though, about the general idea that this was a massive collapse of the bank
- 40:46and this is symbolic of a wider problem in banking at the moment?
- 40:51which, you know, if you're evolving the circles that I revolve in, the talk of financial collapse is,
- 40:59I mean, it's always been a pretty hot topic, but it's very much more a hot topic now,
- 41:03especially with the advent of some pretty amazing LLMs, which know how to penetrate banks better than anyone used to be able to.
- 41:14So has that narrative made its way into Paraguay or is this just a kind of something that people don't really necessarily think about?
- 41:23Well, to be perfectly fair, over the last weeks, I've been working 12 to 14 hours a day on our company because Brazil reelected a socialist president.
- 41:34We had thousands upon thousands of clients.
- 41:37So I haven't been on the streets talking to everyone.
- 41:40I'm following the situation, of course, but I wasn't in the protests and talking to the average Paraguayan on the street, so I might be off a little bit.
- 41:49But what I have talked with a lot of people, considerably a lot of people, is that they're annoyed that it happened, but they're like, oh, yeah, the president was corrupt.
- 41:59Wow, what a twist of event.
- 42:02Yeah, but now he's in jail, so we're all happy.
- 42:05And I was like, well, what do you think of the new guy?
- 42:08I hope he does everything right
- 42:11and he's scared
- 42:13shitless of everyone
- 42:15because it's like
- 42:16we need to not screw up
- 42:19so he's like he's
- 42:20very quite clearly scared
- 42:23for his life and he should be
- 42:25there is some political
- 42:28chairdance going on
- 42:29think of
- 42:31when
- 42:32recently in the UK
- 42:36like the curious armor went out and the and the burning guy came in and then you have to like
- 42:41switch everyone switch the offices like yeah yeah there are still socialists but yeah you had bad
- 42:47going on so the factions are kind of at each other so that's going on but the average party was like
- 42:53oh okay it was we always thought that when it was kind of uh so yeah it was uh we're happy he's in
- 42:59jail they're still pissed uh because that happened they're still pissed because the the social
- 43:05security money and a lot of state money will be lost so which eventually is on the taxpayer
- 43:13uh but they're i want to say placated but placated is too is too good they're they are
- 43:25less inclined to setting things on fire due to solutions moving on they're like okay so if
- 43:34If solutions keep moving on that way, politicians will not be set on fire.
- 43:41So they're like, OK, if you want to call that placated,
- 43:45I think that would be too much of a stretch.
- 43:48But they're really proud that they as a people,
- 43:53because they don't see that as like, oh, so the politicians did the right thing
- 43:58and they stood up.
- 43:59But that's not.
- 44:00Their understanding is we scared them into doing that.
- 44:04And that's good.
- 44:05They still fear us.
- 44:06That's good.
- 44:07Let's keep it that way.
- 44:09So, and it's interesting to see the narrative back in Brazil.
- 44:13I don't know the other countries, but back in Brazil, the left wing is like,
- 44:17oh, so you see the right wing country failed and they're now bankrupt and eating trash off the streets.
- 44:23And the right wing is replying by, no, first, that's Cuba.
- 44:26And secondly, they jailed the president and the bankers and they're investigating stuff.
- 44:34So, and meanwhile, in Brazil, where they had also a banking scandal, this week, the discussion is releasing the banker that did the scandal.
- 44:42So it's like, the right wing is like, it's very bad that this happened.
- 44:47but i mean you did behave like we would expect japan to do or something like that
- 44:56that's the bit i don't get is what it must be cultural it must be a cultural thing in paraguay
- 45:05because it's so common for people who commit financial fraud and to get away with it right
- 45:13to literally get away with it um as you've just alluded to in brazil the same is it called so it's
- 45:20a cultural thing in in panama in um in paraguay is it they're very culturally proud of themselves
- 45:26they're very much fighting people like you you're not going to you're not going to bully paraguay
- 45:34around and i see that in politics i see that in business i see that i mean they're not rough
- 45:42they're very sweet people they're very welcoming they're very cordial they're very welcoming they're
- 45:47very they really want you to feel at home and included and etc but do not try to push them
- 45:55around you will fail and i see that even in chess like i play chess competitively and i play two
- 46:02tournaments here in brazil when you get a position where it's like bro like if we played this
- 46:09position a hundred times he would lose 98 times out of our 100 resign and the other guy's just
- 46:15he resigns and sometimes you get like very boring positions where it's almost surely a draw and
- 46:20really i had to draw this and do something else probably was they will not quit it's like i'm
- 46:24losing yeah come at it come get me this they will not resign and they will fight it out it's amazing
- 46:32and if you see the i i wanted to do like the statistics on it their tournaments have very
- 46:38less, have very
- 46:41low draw rate.
- 46:44Like, someone's gonna lose.
- 46:45They're not gonna be, oh, no.
- 46:46No. Like, play.
- 46:49And I think
- 46:51that's just a cultural reflex, but everything
- 46:53is like that. They're very proud people.
- 46:55What you saw in the
- 46:57World Cup, where I think
- 46:59that was marked in, I think,
- 47:01one of the
- 47:02cultural showdowns of Paraguay.
- 47:05It was not Paraguay-Germany, it was Paraguay-Turkey.
- 47:07where they got a goal in like six minutes.
- 47:10They had just been like crushed by the US.
- 47:14Everyone was like,
- 47:15it was like a funeral in the country.
- 47:17It was so sad.
- 47:18So they came in against Turkey
- 47:19to get like one goal in like six minutes
- 47:21and one of their players gets expelled.
- 47:24And they spend like 90 minutes
- 47:27with minus one player getting like blasted
- 47:34and just defending,
- 47:36They just like, they stall it out, defend, do something.
- 47:39And I was watching it in a bar,
- 47:42but they go, a whole bunch of bar lines.
- 47:44I'm Brazilian.
- 47:45I know what it's like to love soccer.
- 47:48I know what it's like.
- 47:51I saw Brazil getting its fifth championship.
- 47:55They were happier when they beat Germany.
- 47:57The way that the team stood it out against Turkey
- 48:03and then came up against Germany and were like,
- 48:06We're going to beat you, dudes.
- 48:07And then beat them.
- 48:09That's the Paraguayan spirit.
- 48:10That was not just an off game.
- 48:12You saw how they are.
- 48:14And when they saw all of this, they were like, all right.
- 48:18All right.
- 48:19Now we're going to...
- 48:21Let's talk.
- 48:23And that was a very proud moment, I think, in their history.
- 48:28This episode is brought to you by Amity Age.
- 48:31Now, Amity Age are old friends of this podcast.
- 48:34Dushan, their co-founder, was one of my first guests nearly four years ago.
- 48:39Back then, we talked about their Bitcoin education center in the free city of Prospera.
- 48:43Today, well, their Bitcoin mining operation has grown into one of the largest in Central Europe,
- 48:48with experience running farms in Slovakia, Paraguay and Ethiopia.
- 48:52Next stop for them is Alberta, Canada.
- 48:55Limited pipeline capacity there leaves natural gas stranded, flared or sold at a steep discount.
- 49:01That means cheap energy, and energy is the main cost of Bitcoin mining.
- 49:05For Amity Age, this is their opportunity.
- 49:08They are acquiring wells, infrastructure and land to produce their own gas,
- 49:12generate their own electricity and mine their own Bitcoin.
- 49:16And this is your opportunity.
- 49:18They already have 70 megawatts of client demand lined up and ready to go.
- 49:22Participation starts at $500,000 to fund the energy infrastructure,
- 49:26and they want to hear from accredited investors who share their long-term vision.
- 49:30Capital is, of course, at risk, so do your own research and then get in touch at amityage.com forward slash free cities.
- 49:37That's A-M-I-T-Y-A-G-E dot com forward slash free cities.
- 49:42Take self-sovereignty to the next level and own the energy behind the money.
- 49:48On the subject of the wider potential of financial collapse, has this affected your viewpoint on that at all?
- 49:59and what is that viewpoint?
- 50:01No, and also coming back to something you asked
- 50:03that I completely forgot.
- 50:06It was educational for them.
- 50:07They learned a lot about banking this week.
- 50:11Oh, so that can happen.
- 50:13Because the last bank bankruptcy here
- 50:15was like 25 years ago, something like that.
- 50:19So this generation had not experienced it
- 50:22and they learned about that a lot.
- 50:26A lot of people got educated into that the bad way,
- 50:28But there is only two ways of learning, repetition or pain.
- 50:32So yeah, a lot of people learned.
- 50:34A lot of people got interested in crypto too.
- 50:36They were like, oh, now I get it.
- 50:40So the money is mine, not the bank.
- 50:41Oh, like if you sell crypto here, like if you're a crypto advocate in Prairie, you're
- 50:47having a field day.
- 50:49Because it's just like, oh, it's money that is yours, not some friend of some politician.
- 50:55so they're probably going to have a field day for months on end right now and like personally for me
- 51:03I mean I think the I think the I've been one of one in one of those people things like there's a
- 51:11Phoenician collapse like when you start getting into libertarians and Western school and that
- 51:15sort of thing you kind of turn into that like quite quickly and then you realize we're a lot
- 51:22more resilient than that. And countries and governments are very much more resilient in how
- 51:30they can kick the can down the road than you think. And Japan has been proving that since the 80s,
- 51:37pretty much. You can kick a can pretty far. Eventually, that's going to be a problem. Yeah.
- 51:42Is it going to be a problem tomorrow? I mean, it's going to be a problem sometime.
- 51:46But I don't think that's likely tomorrow or something.
- 51:54Of course, you should be educated into that.
- 51:59You should understand what's going on.
- 52:00You should at least, even if you don't own crypto, you should understand.
- 52:04it,
- 52:07it's kind of, I do an
- 52:09analogy with preppers. You don't have to be a
- 52:10prepper. But
- 52:12if you know nothing
- 52:15about
- 52:15how to stand up for yourself,
- 52:19that could be a problem. I mean, you could
- 52:20just learn a little bit.
- 52:23Have some
- 52:24education.
- 52:26But I don't...
- 52:27Coming back to it, I think that
- 52:30when that
- 52:32happens, and that's going to be at some point
- 52:34Yeah, there will be a reckoning.
- 52:36We're not going to have QE infinity.
- 52:39At some point, she's going to hit the fan.
- 52:42But I think that what this event taught us is that in the end, it's going to be, are the people going to accept this or not?
- 52:49And this is something, and I'm sorry to cut you off, but it's something that I have been talking far more with my public in Brazil after the elections in Brazil where the socialists got reelected.
- 53:01and I've been saying that to libertarians in general.
- 53:05It's not the politicians.
- 53:07It's not like, oh, the politicians in the European Union
- 53:11or the globalists, it's the people.
- 53:13The politicians, they didn't just drop out of,
- 53:16I would say drop out of the sky,
- 53:18but it's actually,
- 53:18it didn't emerge out of the pits of hell.
- 53:21That didn't happen.
- 53:23That tends to happen very strongly
- 53:25because the average Joe in the streets
- 53:28either thinks that's good
- 53:31or he tolerates that or he's submissive and just allows it because he's unaware.
- 53:38So, and that's how you get this far in the situation where you get the debt and the deficit
- 53:43in the US or you get the crazy situation with migration, legal problems in Texas and that
- 53:49in Europe and the left-wing wave that was in Latin America that is now clean, except
- 53:56for Brazil.
- 53:57That's how you get those situations.
- 53:59They're not. Politicians don't conjure things up in their evil dens.
- 54:04I mean, they sometimes do, but they need the public to be there, or they need the public supporting it,
- 54:11or they need everyone to be calmly in their houses.
- 54:15If everyone just, which is what happened in Paraguay,
- 54:19if everyone calmly and in a very civilized manner flips the fuck out
- 54:24and instructs politicians on the fact that there is a line and you have crossed it,
- 54:31move backwards or we will make you so,
- 54:36things tend to find solutions quite quickly.
- 54:40So I think that's the lesson that we should get from this one.
- 54:44With regards to the socialist wave that we're now apparently seeing in the West,
- 54:51um first of all um do you think that do you think that's real i mean we're certainly going a little
- 54:59bit left um and secondly does it happen that quickly would it would it happen that quickly
- 55:06in back in latin america we've had it we've seen it we've seen a swing away from from that kind of
- 55:12politics um you could argue that in the states all it took was trump to be in in in for a couple of
- 55:20terms for everyone then to go, oh my God, this is ridiculous. Let's go back the other way.
- 55:24So, you know, I don't know. You might not think that's what's happening, but how would it work
- 55:31in Latin America? Could it swing back to its former situation quite rapidly, do you think?
- 55:38It absolutely could. There is a very cultural difference between Latin Americans and Europeans
- 55:44and that we're very emotional and we're hot-tempered.
- 55:49I think the Spaniards and the Italians can get that a little bit better,
- 55:53which is where we got it from, of course.
- 55:56I mean, it didn't come out of nowhere.
- 55:58But the Germans, the Dutch, they're more objective about it,
- 56:02so they don't really quite understand that.
- 56:06So it could happen in the sense that Latin America is very emotional.
- 56:11So if there's a trauma or if you can really appeal to people's anger or their hearts, you can get a lot of political results.
- 56:18And, of course, the basic reply to that is, well, that happens everywhere.
- 56:23Yes, that happens everywhere.
- 56:25But in Latin America, that's a plus.
- 56:28There is an extra effect into that.
- 56:31But the right-wing wave that is happening right now in Latin America has to do with the fact that the left has not delivered.
- 56:38The left got a lot of governments, and what they delivered was no economic growth.
- 56:45They did not deliver safety, much to the contrary.
- 56:50Usually, crime goes up quite significantly.
- 56:54There are exceptions to Argentina and Uruguay, but in pretty much every other country in Latin America,
- 57:01crime went up very strongly during this left-wing wave, and they're very corrupt.
- 57:06So then people come back and vote to the right wing, partly because also Latin America is very Christian, which does help.
- 57:18Of course, Christianity, especially Catholics, are infiltrated by the left wing globally, but especially in Latin America.
- 57:26But in general, Christianity helps as a protection.
- 57:32but also they go to the right wing
- 57:35because some that won't fail, let's go to this one
- 57:37at least they're fighting crime
- 57:38so Bukele
- 57:40was a huge influence
- 57:43in creating the meme
- 57:45of you can just do things
- 57:46you could just jail the
- 57:48criminals, which he's now
- 57:50replicating in Haiti
- 57:52he's widely loved in Haiti
- 57:55so there is that
- 57:56but then what happens is that
- 57:58usually what happens
- 58:01and I'm sorry, but this is the truth.
- 58:04Usually the right wing comes in
- 58:06and fails to deliver
- 58:08and people swing back,
- 58:11which is what happened with Trump.
- 58:14There used to be a common sense point
- 58:20in the right wing in the 70s and 80s
- 58:24which was best explained and prophesied
- 58:30or organized.
- 58:32I'm going to say organized because he himself
- 58:34said that he wasn't creating anything.
- 58:36He was just making explicit,
- 58:38which was Mayer's theory of fusionism,
- 58:41which was the idea
- 58:42in the 80s held by
- 58:44Ronald Reagan, which
- 58:46was a Mayer fan.
- 58:49He talked about him too much, a lot.
- 58:51Margaret Thatcher,
- 58:52she actually read Hayek.
- 58:55She didn't just pose with the books.
- 58:57She actually studied him.
- 58:58and Pope John Paul II, which was the triumvirate against the Soviet Union.
- 59:06It was the fusionist idea of conservative Christian morals and free market economics.
- 59:15And that was the consensus-based position of the right wing in the 80s and 70s,
- 59:23but especially in the 80s, Reagan, Thatcher.
- 59:26It wasn't even like a theory.
- 59:29It was just, duh.
- 59:30It's what we are.
- 59:32And I think that maybe because the Soviet Union fell and the right was like, oh, so the enemy is done.
- 59:40So now we can infight and then just started fighting each other.
- 59:44Maybe it was that.
- 59:45Maybe I don't know exactly.
- 59:46but the right wing started to drift away from free market economics and thinking maybe I can
- 59:56make state work and and you had guys I think Bush was a part of that I think other governments were
- 1:00:03a part of that Trump is the worst manifestation of that in that he very clearly thinks that the
- 1:00:10problem of government is not that government doesn't work, it's that it's not his. Because
- 1:00:17if he was the CEO of America and he could just fire people, he would fix it and make government
- 1:00:22work. He really thinks that, which is wrong. But that started to become a mainstream idea on the
- 1:00:30right. Like I was saying before, it's not the politicians do that. Voters, the public thinkers
- 1:00:36do that and then politics just follows it. It's downstream, right? So in, I don't know what
- 1:00:42happened. There was the libertarian wave with Ron Paul. And sadly, it seems that it lost because
- 1:00:49the statist wave was stronger. And so what happened was that throughout the world, you have right
- 1:00:56wings whose position is, we hate the left and we hate crime. And then they get in and it's like,
- 1:01:03oh, right, so now improve the economy,
- 1:01:05cut spending, privatize, deregulate.
- 1:01:08And they're like, no, no, no, no,
- 1:01:08wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait,
- 1:01:09hold on, hold on, hold on.
- 1:01:11It's us now.
- 1:01:13And we can totally make this work.
- 1:01:15So we don't need to do that anymore.
- 1:01:19And it fails to deliver results, obviously,
- 1:01:22is what Trump did with the tariffs and everything
- 1:01:24and running deficits
- 1:01:26and basically not listening to Thomas Massey.
- 1:01:29And well, now you have the result, right?
- 1:01:32And I think that's the tendency of what happened.
- 1:01:34I think that's why the left wing is coming back.
- 1:01:37And if you look at the right wing in Europe,
- 1:01:39the way I describe Le Pen is that she's a right-wing socialist.
- 1:01:45I mean, she has very many right-wing positions,
- 1:01:47but then you look at her economics, and it's like,
- 1:01:52what?
- 1:01:55What?
- 1:01:56You know, you see the right wing in Europe,
- 1:01:59they're very concerned about migration,
- 1:02:00which they should But I mean look at Britain What did the right wing do during their whole reign to rein in government and make business easier They did nothing They had the perfect opportunity with Brexit to reform everything
- 1:02:23and then they intentionally botched it so that Brexit would come out poorly, and they could come
- 1:02:31back and say, oh, see, that's why we should have been in the European Union the whole time,
- 1:02:34because they didn't want to do it, right?
- 1:02:36So I think that if that continues,
- 1:02:38and probably that's going to happen,
- 1:02:40yes, there will be a swing back from the left.
- 1:02:43And to summarize,
- 1:02:45the right wing needs to come back
- 1:02:47to read the Mises and Ron Paul.
- 1:02:50And we need a Ron Paul back.
- 1:02:51To summarize, listen to Thomas Massey.
- 1:02:54Like, how hard is it?
- 1:02:57I think the problem with the right wing
- 1:03:00and the left wing currently
- 1:03:02is that there's no incentive to solve the problem of big government and the deficit that we see in
- 1:03:10all countries. I mean, the crippling thing that's happening in my country, which seems to be quite
- 1:03:15common, is the fact that the government is bankrupt and the only way it can get more money
- 1:03:21is to either take it from citizens in tax or to borrow it from various sources. And both of those
- 1:03:29are detrimental to the life of a citizen, basically. So, so, and the incentive to sort
- 1:03:36of fix that doesn't really exist in a democratic system, because the way to fix it is to, is to
- 1:03:44basically piss a lot of people off. It's just to say, well, unless you're making the government
- 1:03:48smaller, of course, in which case, I'm not necessarily pissed off. But, but really, you need
- 1:03:53to stop spending so much money. You certainly need to stop giving away money to people to sort
- 1:04:00of do nothing. And those don't garner good results in the polls, as far as I know. So I don't know,
- 1:04:08I don't think anyone's going to fix it. I think whoever, certainly in my country, when I look at
- 1:04:14who the people that are vying for power, even the ones that I think, oh, maybe this guy,
- 1:04:21is he's saying all the right things almost certainly when he gets into power there's not a
- 1:04:28lot he can do because the incentive model then will restrict him plus you know and this isn't
- 1:04:34talked about a huge amount um in in political spheres but when when um when the government
- 1:04:40changes in the uk i think it's only a couple of hundred people that actually change there's
- 1:04:46thousands of people in the civil service who stay exactly the same their politics whatever they are
- 1:04:54stay exactly the same and and i think there's a there's a a stat which is quite funny but it's true
- 1:05:00that you're more likely to die in a position than you are to lose your job in the civil service in
- 1:05:08the UK. So you've got all these career people whose job is to basically spend your money.
- 1:05:16And if they start spending less of it, it's bad for them because they basically got to justify
- 1:05:21spending money. So the whole system is just terrible, ain't going to fix itself. I'm almost
- 1:05:29of the thought process now that really, you know, I'm a bit of a, I'm a bit of a sort of financial
- 1:05:35doomer now I think in in the end and and I agree the can can be kicked well the can's been being
- 1:05:43kicked for a long time and I'm pretty sure since I was a kid people have said they're kicking the
- 1:05:48can you know and they're still kicking it um so I don't I don't I'm not sure that how much longer
- 1:05:54we've got of that but it could be a hundred years more of kicking the can I've got no idea you know
- 1:06:00But I think the only way this resolves itself is through a very serious collapse.
- 1:06:10But then again, look, this has just happened in Paraguay.
- 1:06:12And what do they do?
- 1:06:13I mean, I presume, where did they get the money from to give people back their funds?
- 1:06:18Did the central bank just conjure up a bunch of money?
- 1:06:21No, no, it was the deposit insurance, which is all banks are required.
- 1:06:27And that's a private fund, by the way.
- 1:06:30all banks are required to deposit a certain amount to create a fund to ensure all deposits.
- 1:06:36If a bank goes like that, that fund replaces people.
- 1:06:40So even if Wenoa only had roughly 30% of their money, that's not the only money to pay back those people.
- 1:06:48You still have that fund, which is huge, and is paying back everyone successfully.
- 1:06:55And so you have an extra caution on that.
- 1:06:57So that's what that was what was paying right now.
- 1:07:01So it's not a government money, but it's just the insurance money on the deposits.
- 1:07:07But coming back to something you were saying, I think that there needs to be pain because something that I said before in the podcast, there are only two ways really that you can learn something, repetition and pain.
- 1:07:20There is no other way.
- 1:07:22And there is something that I got from Lou Rockwell.
- 1:07:27And because Lou Rockwell, if I'm not mistaken, if I am, do please correct me.
- 1:07:31But he turned libertarian because he lost his brother in the Korean War to friendly fire.
- 1:07:40And he talks about that.
- 1:07:41I think it was that.
- 1:07:42Like maybe there's something to deal with.
- 1:07:43But his point was that it was at that moment that he thought, why was my brother duking it out with some Soviet in Korea and got shot by us?
- 1:08:00And that was what made him think about war and anti-war.
- 1:08:06And he was first anti-war and then libertarian.
- 1:08:08And you're not going to be in your pool on a Wednesday evening,
- 1:08:16evening, drinking a beer with your house paid off,
- 1:08:20like two Porsches in your garage, thinking, you know what?
- 1:08:25You know what?
- 1:08:26I think, Anthony, I think there's something really
- 1:08:28wrong with the world right now.
- 1:08:29No, you're not going to do that.
- 1:08:32Something needs to happen to you for you to really
- 1:08:35review your morals.
- 1:08:37And I think that's the story of Javier Milley in Argentina.
- 1:08:41Because what he did was that he educated people.
- 1:08:45The state is going to continue huge.
- 1:08:48Europe is going to continue on this stupid path
- 1:08:50as long as people live under the illusion that this is working.
- 1:08:56And what Milley did was that he was able to educate
- 1:09:01part of the Argentinian electorate, not everyone,
- 1:09:05but enough to win, that politicians don't produce, that they take, that taxation is bad,
- 1:09:13that government needs to be shrunk, that the entrepreneur is the hero and the politician is
- 1:09:17the problem. He was able to get that in. But he was able to get that in, first of all, because he's
- 1:09:23a through and through libertarian, like no bullshit about it. He's not like, eh, like full on.
- 1:09:31Second of all, he's a very good communicator.
- 1:09:34You might not like his style, but it works.
- 1:09:38And he was in the situation of a crisis in Argentina
- 1:09:41because you could not be in Argentina with inflation over 200% per year,
- 1:09:47with the economy stagnated, like unemployment everywhere,
- 1:09:51and people knew people in their family and their friends
- 1:09:54that were defrauding the government or being a parasite somehow.
- 1:09:57like you could not be in that situation and fool yourself into thinking that everything's fine
- 1:10:03so you had that alignment of things and he was able to get the win now if he's going to be able
- 1:10:10to now do the reforms and get the win again now that's a question right but I mean just do bear
- 1:10:15in mind that none of us thought that that was going to happen in the first place so I mean we
- 1:10:21can be hopeful, right?
- 1:10:24But that being said,
- 1:10:26I think that one of those things,
- 1:10:28one of the things that differentiated Paraguay
- 1:10:30here is that
- 1:10:31Paraguay still has its problems. I mean, it's a good country.
- 1:10:34I love it. I love the people. I love the culture.
- 1:10:36But they still have a lot of problems.
- 1:10:37They have problems with sanitation. They have problems with the streets.
- 1:10:39They have problems with corruption. You cannot
- 1:10:42fool yourself into thinking that, oh, everything's
- 1:10:44fine. It's like, no, things are improving.
- 1:10:46But you're not in heaven.
- 1:10:48Whereas,
- 1:10:49Because if you're in Europe, you can say, oh, all right, we're having this and that problem.
- 1:10:55But I mean, it's still London.
- 1:11:00I mean, it used to be better, et cetera, et cetera.
- 1:11:03But you're not going to have a gander in Manchester and think, you know, I just think that society is coming down and this has clearly failed in every single way possible.
- 1:11:14I mean, it has problems, but people would still live...
- 1:11:20If you gave the option to everyone on planet Earth of where they could live in,
- 1:11:26many of them would pick Great Britain today.
- 1:11:30He would criticize that choice, but if he lives in fucking Uganda, he would choose it.
- 1:11:37And the whole of Europe is that way still, because even though they have their problems,
- 1:11:42stagnation, crime, immigration,
- 1:11:43those problems. Belgium is still
- 1:11:46Belgium. The Netherlands
- 1:11:48are still fine.
- 1:11:51You still
- 1:11:52have one of the most successful societies in the history
- 1:11:54of mankind, even though they're
- 1:11:56fucking it up quite strongly right now.
- 1:11:58So, you can
- 1:12:00operate, you can still
- 1:12:02operate under the delusion
- 1:12:03that actually everything is
- 1:12:05quite fine, because to understand
- 1:12:07it, you need to go into theory
- 1:12:09and all the numbers and everything
- 1:12:11And most people don have the time for that They not like that Human beings are not like that You are like that
- 1:12:23with very few things because you can think, oh, those ignorant people,
- 1:12:27they don't understand economics and budget and everything, and how central banking and a fractional
- 1:12:32reserve. What do you understand about notebooks, laptops, technology, the internet, and cell phones,
- 1:12:38and television.
- 1:12:40Again, there's nothing in that.
- 1:12:42Absolutely nothing.
- 1:12:43If 500 people on Earth died,
- 1:12:49we as a species would not understand
- 1:12:52how to do that again.
- 1:12:54We would have to do that everything from scratch.
- 1:12:58If the right airplane falls,
- 1:12:59we don't know cell phones anymore.
- 1:13:02We just trust that.
- 1:13:03We're just like,
- 1:13:04oh, seems to be working fine.
- 1:13:06I'm just going to use it.
- 1:13:07And that's how people are with politics and economics.
- 1:13:1095% of people are like, dude, I got my children, I got my problems, I got my bills to pay, I got stuff to do, I got beers to drink.
- 1:13:17I don't have time to learn about this big-ass book about central banking for some reason because some nerd in the internet is screaming about Bitcoin.
- 1:13:26I don't know.
- 1:13:27So, unless they have something personally impacting their lives, they're just going to go on under things thinking that,
- 1:13:38ah, maybe this guy's going to fix it, maybe not, but what am I going to do, you know?
- 1:13:43Whereas, and the Europeans, they tend to be very much more passive.
- 1:13:48They tend to see a protest, except the French, they tend to see a protest and be like, oh, that's such,
- 1:13:53Why didn't they write a very strongly worded letter to their prime minister?
- 1:13:58What is the necessity of such ruckus?
- 1:14:01But we Latin Americans, we do that more strongly.
- 1:14:05And I think that's one of the reasons we get a right-wing wave here in Latin America,
- 1:14:10which is drawing a lot of conservative and libertarian Europeans to move here.
- 1:14:14Whereas Europe's probably not going to do that.
- 1:14:17They're just going to keep on writing strongly worded letters to their representatives
- 1:14:22and thinking that's probably going to do something.
- 1:14:26Talking of strongly worded letters,
- 1:14:31what's your view, like your macro view on Bukele?
- 1:14:36Because he seems too good to be true almost.
- 1:14:40Like you mentioned a little while ago
- 1:14:43that he's been in Haiti recently.
- 1:14:46And as far as I understood it, correct me if I'm wrong,
- 1:14:49but some Salvadorians were in Haiti
- 1:14:51and got abducted so he just said right we're gonna come and get you guys you know he's like
- 1:14:57he's like the dream leader he really does seem to care for people right but but also I that that
- 1:15:04also makes me deeply uncomfortable because no politicians are that good are that honest are that
- 1:15:12genuine are that you know like maybe they are maybe maybe maybe I'm getting that wrong what do
- 1:15:17you think about Bukele? I got something. This is copped up from Chabarni from Argentina. I'm
- 1:15:23hoping I didn't just butcher his name from Chabarni. He says, well, all politicians are
- 1:15:29kind of wrong in the head because you have to be in order to put your entire life and name and
- 1:15:36reputation at stake to convince the average voter who's a mental retard and to crave and enjoy
- 1:15:44like people clapping at you like that like that's there is something like screwy that like you have
- 1:15:53to be that uh so they're not normal and as i i i have run for office i gladly i lost i didn't want
- 1:16:01to win but i've worked with politicians for like 10 years at this point in all levels yeah that's
- 1:16:07correct. Like most people who are in politics, they do have very much fun at it. And I was in it,
- 1:16:13like personally, I've been in the backstage for most of the time. I was in the front stage for like
- 1:16:18a few months and I just hated everything about it. Like every single thing about it.
- 1:16:23But so you have to be kind of wonked in the head. And still like, if you're a politician in Latin
- 1:16:28America, I mean, eh, you're probably not squeaky clean. So we're not going into that. That being
- 1:16:34said, he has basically refuted most academics of liberal democracy in saying that we need to do
- 1:16:51this, this, things this perfect way. And he's basically saying, well, I mean, Darth Vader was
- 1:16:58a Jedi and, you know,
- 1:17:01he could have
- 1:17:02fixed it.
- 1:17:04If the Jedi Council
- 1:17:06didn't bitch too much about Anakin
- 1:17:08and just let him do his stuff,
- 1:17:11you know,
- 1:17:12a lot of things could have been
- 1:17:14avoided if we just, you know,
- 1:17:17like, softened the
- 1:17:18rules on him a little bit and just
- 1:17:20let him go mayhem on things.
- 1:17:22Maybe that was an idea.
- 1:17:24Maybe we should have
- 1:17:25listened to
- 1:17:28to a few guys and not just had that many meetings.
- 1:17:34But Bukele, he's the meme of you can just do stuff.
- 1:17:39And he is.
- 1:17:42And it's effective because he's providing what civilization needs,
- 1:17:48which is security, economic prosperity,
- 1:17:51and the idea of predictability at some level,
- 1:17:57which is very much the Hans-Hermann Hoppe criticism of monarchy would suck less than democracy
- 1:18:06because you can have someone that is prepared.
- 1:18:09And if he's good, he just stays.
- 1:18:11You don't have to rotate in and put some retard in the middle of it.
- 1:18:15And if he sucks, then someone just coos him out and something happens.
- 1:18:21And he does make the argument, the fringe argument.
- 1:18:26He's kind of there for what would be a private society.
- 1:18:33Because in sort of a way, it's what is happening.
- 1:18:38You have a small enough country where your government can be...
- 1:18:41Because if you have a huge country like fucking India,
- 1:18:44the whole bureaucracy of that country is the population of a country.
- 1:18:49But the government structure of El Salvador can be like 200 dudes.
- 1:18:53like it's not you don't have a necessity of more than that like you can have you can have everyone
- 1:19:00in a whatsapp group you know so um and what he's doing is what a private city would do
- 1:19:09in saying oh so there are people doing crime oh we could just lock them up oh and but but they're
- 1:19:17not going to just accept it. Oh, okay, we could just shoot them. They seem to have a lot of guns
- 1:19:24illegally. I mean, I'm just saying. We could just deport them or something, which is what a private
- 1:19:31society would do. They wouldn't have a meeting about this. And so he's getting results into that.
- 1:19:36And a lot of people went into that. A lot of people embarked into that because he realized,
- 1:19:42well this works people tend to gravitate to results which is what I was saying about like
- 1:19:48technology like we don't care how this works like some of some nerds here out care like we care like
- 1:19:54marginally but we're not gonna get into like you're not gonna study the engineering of your
- 1:19:58house you just like vaguely know it works and you pay a million pounds into it you're not gonna
- 1:20:04wonder like is was that column like properly done it's like it seems it is I mean the the roof not
- 1:20:11being the floor does seem to be good evidence of it. I'm not going to question that any further,
- 1:20:16right? So, but let's see the results. I mean, this is still young in terms of political history.
- 1:20:25It can seem that it has gone for a few years, and it does. But when you judge political events,
- 1:20:32you tend to glaze over a few decades. I mean, when I was talking a while ago about Mayer and
- 1:20:39the consensus of the 80s and 70s.
- 1:20:41I just glazed over 20 years.
- 1:20:44So even though
- 1:20:44these events are
- 1:20:46like,
- 1:20:49there have been a few years,
- 1:20:51I mean, in 20, 30 years, people are just going to
- 1:20:53glaze over that and be like, oh, he did this, this
- 1:20:55and that, and then this.
- 1:20:56So let's see the final chapters.
- 1:20:59He's still young, there's still a lot of
- 1:21:01stuff to happen, but
- 1:21:02he's very much demonstrating the idea
- 1:21:05that you can
- 1:21:06have
- 1:21:08a guy that just has a lot of power, which breaks some senses in the classical idea of liberal
- 1:21:17democracy and just goes, but I'm just going to do the right things. I'm not going to be like a
- 1:21:21dictator. I'm just going to actually do stuff and people tend to prefer that.
- 1:21:27Is there any truth in the idea that often in Latin America,
- 1:21:35what leaders that have turned out to be quite despotic
- 1:21:40were very well liked in the beginning.
- 1:21:42Is there truth in that?
- 1:21:45And could that be the case with Bukele?
- 1:21:47Well, I think that's the history of mankind.
- 1:21:51Genghis Khan was very much loved.
- 1:21:53I can't talk about a few guys in the 20s, 30s and 40s
- 1:22:01that were very much liked in Europe at first.
- 1:22:03That's a very human thing.
- 1:22:05I don't think that's a Latin American thing.
- 1:22:07I think that in Europe that has gone away, whereas in America, in Africa, that still
- 1:22:19decays In many places in South Asia that still very much the case I can point to a few countries in Africa where this is the case
- 1:22:32So I think that this is just the conundrum probably between
- 1:22:41I really like this guy versus should he have power or not
- 1:22:47and the issues with that.
- 1:22:49And I think that is working out with Bukele precisely because it's a very small and homogenous country.
- 1:22:57Because if you think about the examples, there's also a very important thing about Paraguay that we didn't talk about, which is it's an ethno state.
- 1:23:05It is. It is a state of mostly one idea, one religion, and one people.
- 1:23:11And I'm not saying that all countries should be like that or all societies should be like that.
- 1:23:15I'm just saying that it is, and it does make it a lot easier for you to have a government,
- 1:23:21because there is much less, there are very, very few things that you would disagree on.
- 1:23:27If you see elections here in Paraguay, it's candidates agreeing on everything.
- 1:23:32Like the municipal dispute here, the municipal elections, candidates agreed on like literally
- 1:23:38everything except what to do with the traffic police.
- 1:23:41and one guy was reformed
- 1:23:44the other guy was tried to
- 1:23:46weed out
- 1:23:47and the woman
- 1:23:49the girl that won
- 1:23:51her idea was
- 1:23:53I'm just gonna fire everyone
- 1:23:55that was the disagreement
- 1:23:58that was the entire disagreement
- 1:24:01so when you have an ethno state
- 1:24:04like that
- 1:24:04which is El Salvador
- 1:24:06and there is no left wing
- 1:24:09there is just one idea
- 1:24:11You can get one guy and he does that direction,
- 1:24:14and 93% of the people are going to be like,
- 1:24:17yeah, I'm cool with that.
- 1:24:18Whereas if you have, think of the United States.
- 1:24:24It's not like these people.
- 1:24:26Forget all that.
- 1:24:29A third of the population is left-wing,
- 1:24:31a third of the population is right-wing,
- 1:24:33and a third of the population hates both.
- 1:24:36So there's no way, it's mathematically impossible
- 1:24:39for you to have a government that works.
- 1:24:44Like, two-thirds of the population will hate whatever happens.
- 1:24:50Why do we look at that and think, you know what,
- 1:24:53if we just have another election,
- 1:24:55like, if we just, like, primary better,
- 1:24:58like, think the UK, like, forget migration and religions,
- 1:25:02everything, forget that.
- 1:25:04you have a country where
- 1:25:07a quarter of the population
- 1:25:10wants to deport everyone.
- 1:25:14A quarter of the population is a raging liberate.
- 1:25:18A quarter of the population is just,
- 1:25:21could we just calm down?
- 1:25:24Could we just calm down?
- 1:25:27And another quarter of the population is whatever the hell.
- 1:25:30I don't know.
- 1:25:30you're not going to get them to work.
- 1:25:35Whereas if you look at the countries today
- 1:25:37where you think, you know, that society is doing,
- 1:25:40they're doing pretty swish, actually.
- 1:25:42That's kind of working out.
- 1:25:45You're mostly going to find small countries,
- 1:25:48small populations, one ethnicity or one major one,
- 1:25:52one religion.
- 1:25:54So you're going to get Hungary, Czech Republic,
- 1:26:00like Poland, South Korea, Japan, which is not a small population, but I mean, it's the people,
- 1:26:06the culture with the most internal preference of all cultures, right? So you're going to get those,
- 1:26:11Paraguay, El Salvador, Panama, maybe, you know, you're going to get those ones where it's like,
- 1:26:19like, yeah, people tend to agree with that. So, or even like countries where we kind of disagree
- 1:26:27with them politically, like Denmark. We disagree, like Norway. We can disagree, like they're social
- 1:26:33democrats, etc. But they're not a society at strife. They're agreeing that we should go over
- 1:26:40there. So I think that shows that it's beautiful to have different people and different ideas and
- 1:26:50everything. But when one gets the power to vote in the other, it's not going to work. It's not
- 1:26:56going to be you could just like do your thing over there because like you can like or you can dislike
- 1:27:02bukele but the fact is that the majority of population are happy with that and that's okay
- 1:27:08and if we had a situation in any country let's say like kind of like alberta tried to do in canada
- 1:27:16where it's like oh you you're this and you really don't like that just go your own way you just
- 1:27:20Just do your thing.
- 1:27:23You could do that.
- 1:27:24Oh, California wants to be a raging socialist.
- 1:27:27All right, so become your own country.
- 1:27:28Do your stuff.
- 1:27:29Stop parasiting everyone.
- 1:27:31And then we're going to figure out quite quickly what happens when you do that,
- 1:27:34which is what happened to Cuba, basically, or Venezuela.
- 1:27:38It's going to be quite quickly.
- 1:27:40And then people can choose the results.
- 1:27:42Why don't we just do that?
- 1:27:44And I think that's one of the reasons why Paraguay works.
- 1:27:47It's because the majority of the population is very right-wing.
- 1:27:51They consider being socialist, being a left-wing, some sort of a mental illness, which they're
- 1:27:57correct.
- 1:27:58They're very much Christian.
- 1:27:59They're mostly Catholic, but if you're a Protestant like me, they're like, oh, Jesus, yeah, okay,
- 1:28:06right.
- 1:28:07There is no strife right there.
- 1:28:08So that works.
- 1:28:09And if you don't like that, don't come in.
- 1:28:12And if you like that, then come in.
- 1:28:14And then everyone sorts themselves out.
- 1:28:16And that's the idea of free private cities.
- 1:28:18Like, just have your own thing and go to your own thing.
- 1:28:21And we can just be at peace and not have to convince someone that absolutely hates you to let you do your stuff.
- 1:28:30Final question.
- 1:28:33In light of everything.
- 1:28:35If a Brazilian is asking you today whether to move to Paraguay, are you saying anything different?
- 1:28:40But if a Brazilian asked if he come to Paraguay, if he should move, what would I say to him?
- 1:28:48As in now?
- 1:28:50As in now?
- 1:28:51After the last week of events?
- 1:28:54It depends on what he does. The answer doesn't change over the last years.
- 1:29:03It's still the same country, same people, same ideas, same problems, same opportunities.
- 1:29:07So can you be an entrepreneur for yourself? Can you stand up for yourself? Can you open a business? Are you an on-demand specialized profession? Yeah, totally.
- 1:29:20are you willing to endure some hardship to grow over one two maybe three years to kind of like
- 1:29:28work it out and then grow and you want to grow and yeah all right do you want uh more of um
- 1:29:35of a frontier situation where things are not done but you're part of that construction is that
- 1:29:40something that appeals to you yes but if you're like no no i i want a country that is like
- 1:29:45completely done everything is fine and nice and i i don't want to like have problems then that's
- 1:29:51not for you i i just want to have like a normal job and just get my normal wage and live a normal
- 1:29:57stable life that's not for you uh i want to like i'm a i work for the state no it's it's that type
- 1:30:07of thing you know if you're um if you're if you're looking to grow and if you're looking to and if
- 1:30:14you're willing to face the hardship that you need to face to grow and if you're an adaptative creative
- 1:30:22entrepreneurial person yes if you just want to be the guy that works his nine works his nine to five
- 1:30:28and chills out on the weekend yeah maybe that's not for you and nothing's changed in the last week
- 1:30:36nothing changed if you would ask me should i move to the u.s in the 1910s that would be my reply
- 1:30:43like what sort of person would do that same question
- 1:30:48well anyway thanks for bringing that to us and um um any where where do we direct people to these
- 1:30:59days for your channels just last time i spoke last time i spoke to you you were you were saying
- 1:31:04that you're you're english english you're trying to sort of ramp up the the english speaking part
- 1:31:10yeah i still haven't done that that was supposed to be my november in december and then brazil
- 1:31:14re-elected a socialist president and now that's pushed back like a few months because we're having
- 1:31:20like insane demand right now it's it's like i have no time for my current social media like that
- 1:31:27so yeah but uh you could you could just look for settee in any social media s-c-t-t-e-e
- 1:31:34the name of the sale and if you're if you're portuguese speaking it's ideas
- 1:31:41radical is that how you say yeah radical which is by the way uh a quote by hans herman hoppy
- 1:31:51that we need radical ideas to change yes well cool thanks thanks mate nice to speak to you again and
- 1:32:00And thanks for the update and look forward to another one.
- 1:32:04Hopefully not about a banking collapse in Paraguay,
- 1:32:07but some more positive news, hopefully.
- 1:32:10I'll see you in Paraguay when you come down here.
- 1:32:30Thank you.