Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / High Free Cash Flow Yield as a Bear Market Shield
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine a company right declaring billions of dollars in
- 0:03record profits, making headlines everywhere, but they literally
- 0:06don't have enough actual cash in the bank to like, fix a broken
- 0:10copy machine. It sounds completely absurd.
- 0:13It does, but it happens every single day in the stock market.
- 0:16Welcome to today's Deep Dive. Just a quick heads up before we
- 0:19get started to access more advanced researches,
- 0:23applications and our latest published personal intelligent
- 0:26Multi Agent Deep Value Intelligence.
- 0:28Welcome to explore and join the Deep Values dot AI community.
- 0:33And if you want to track total market temperature, welcome to
- 0:35search and download the iOS app Buffett Indicator from the Apple
- 0:39App Store. OK, so let's untack this.
- 0:41There's this old saying in business, revenue is vanity,
- 0:43profit is sanity, but cash is reality.
- 0:46A classic. Right.
- 0:47And we nod our heads at that in our daily lives, but then we
- 0:49look at our investment portfolio and suddenly we're perfectly
- 0:53happy buying into promises, projections and just absolute
- 0:56accounting magic. It is a fascinating cognitive
- 0:59dissonance, honestly. I mean, we demand hard cash when
- 1:02we sell a car, take a salary right now.
- 1:04But in the equity markets, we are constantly seduced by the
- 1:07narrative of what a company might do 10 or maybe 20 years
- 1:11down the line. And that brings us to the core
- 1:14mission of today's deep Dive. We are looking at a stack of
- 1:18detailed research on why a high free cash flow yield acts as a
- 1:22bear market shield. It's essentially the ultimate
- 1:24defense. Exactly.
- 1:25We're going to build you a structural ground game today.
- 1:28We are living in a super volatile, deeply narrative
- 1:32driven market right now, so we're going to explore why
- 1:35hunting for actual, undeniable cash generation is the ultimate
- 1:39strategy for protecting your portfolio.
- 1:41Because when the tide goes out and those macroeconomic shocks
- 1:44hit, all those future narratives just vanish.
- 1:47The only thing that dictates a company's survival and its
- 1:50outperformance really is the cash it actually has in the bank
- 1:53today. So let's set the stage with what
- 1:55the market is throwing at you right now.
- 1:57You can't really appreciate a shield until you see the arrows
- 1:59flying at you, right? We're looking at the
- 2:02macroeconomic data from the first quarter of 2026.
- 2:06The S&P 500 was sitting at this really elevated valuation of
- 2:09about 21 times forward earnings. And historically this 21 X
- 2:13threshold is a real danger zone. Yeah.
- 2:16The air gets very thin at that altitude.
- 2:18It really does. That's where valuation driven
- 2:21volatility gets catalyzed. Right.
- 2:22Any slight miss in earnings expectations at that level
- 2:26triggers a massive sell off and then you.
- 2:28Layer on severe geopolitical frictions, we've got disruptions
- 2:31from the Middle East, the ongoing situation in Ukraine and
- 2:34on top of that, central banks holding a higher for longer
- 2:37interest rate regime. Which puts immense pressure on
- 2:39everything. Exactly.
- 2:41Suddenly, passive index, which relies heavily on these lofty
- 2:44multiple driven growth strategies, starts looking
- 2:47incredibly vulnerable. But at that exact same time,
- 2:50there was a completely different story playing out right beneath
- 2:53the surface. The cash flow story.
- 2:55Yep, the Victory US Large Cap Free Cash Flow Index.
- 2:58The ticker for that ETF is VFLO, by the way, was trading at a
- 3:01modest 12.6 times forward earnings.
- 3:04That is a massive margin of safety compared to the broader
- 3:07market. It's basically half the price.
- 3:09Right. And if we connect this to the
- 3:10bigger picture, what we really talking about here is the
- 3:13mathematical concept of duration inequities.
- 3:17Duration like with bonds. Exactly.
- 3:20Most people only think about duration when they buy bonds.
- 3:23If you buy a 30 year bond, your money is tied up for a long
- 3:27time. You know, you don't see the big
- 3:29payout for three decades. Which makes you highly sensitive
- 3:33to interest rate changes today. Right, but equities actually
- 3:36have duration too. Wait, really?
- 3:38But a stock doesn't have a maturity date.
- 3:40You can hold it forever. True, but its value is derived
- 3:43by discounting projected future cash flows back to the present
- 3:47day. Think about a a hyper growth
- 3:50tech company that isn't making any real cash right now.
- 3:52OK, so it's all just projection. Exactly.
- 3:55It's stock prices based almost entirely on the expectation of
- 3:58massive cash flows decades into the future.
- 4:00Mathematically, that makes it a long duration asset.
- 4:03These growth stocks function almost exactly like 30 years 0
- 4:07coupon bonds. Oh 'cause you get 0 yield today,
- 4:10Just the promise of a huge payout at the end.
- 4:12Precisely. Let me try an analogy here.
- 4:14Buying a long duration growth stock is like paying a fortune
- 4:18today because a world renowned chef promises to cook you a
- 4:22fancy dinner 10 years from now. I like where this is going
- 4:25right? But if inflation spikes and the
- 4:27world gets chaotic, the value of that future dinner drops and you
- 4:31might starve in the meantime. But a high free cash flow yield
- 4:35stock? That's a solid, nutritious
- 4:37sandwich placed in your hands today.
- 4:39That's a great way to look at it.
- 4:41In a high inflation, high interest rate regime, a sandwich
- 4:45today is objectively more valuable than the promise of a
- 4:47banquet in a decade. Because you actually get to eat.
- 4:50Exactly. When central banks rapidly hike
- 4:53interest rates, like the really aggressive 2022 cycle, the
- 4:57discount rate applied to those future cash flows skyrockets.
- 5:00The present value of money you won't see for 20 years just
- 5:03collapses. And that's why those growth
- 5:05multiples get utterly crushed under monetary shocks.
- 5:08Yes, high free cash flow companies are short duration
- 5:10assets. A stock with a 10% free cash
- 5:13flow yield has a theoretical payback period of just 10 years.
- 5:17You were getting your money back significantly faster.
- 5:20OK, I hear what you're saying about growth stocks being
- 5:22dangerous, but look at the technology sector.
- 5:25The Magnificent 7 dominate the domestic indices.
- 5:29If tech crashes, the whole market goes down anyway, doesn't
- 5:32it? A lot of people assume that.
- 5:33I mean, isn't this just a repeat of the 1999.com bubble?
- 5:37That is the reflex fear for many defensive investors, for sure.
- 5:40But if you look at the actual data from those two eras, the
- 5:43numbers are night and day. The structural evolution of the
- 5:46tech sector has completely flipped the script.
- 5:49How so? Well, at the peakofthe.com
- 5:51bubble in 1999, the NASDAQ Q 100 traded at an absurd 73 times
- 5:56earnings and it's free cash flow yield was a microscopic .76%.
- 6:01Yikes, so they were just burning cash?
- 6:02Exactly, those are early stage unprofitable companies burning
- 6:06cash just to survive. They were just issuing debt and
- 6:09new shares to keep the lights on.
- 6:10Right. But look at late 2023.
- 6:13The modern technology regime, the NATA Q100, traded at about
- 6:1631 times earnings, but it was backed by a 2.68% free cash flow
- 6:21yield. Oh wow, that's a huge
- 6:22difference. It is.
- 6:24Today's tech giants aren't speculative startups.
- 6:27They are mature, highly profitable global cash
- 6:30generators. They don't need to issue debt to
- 6:33survive. They are actually funding the
- 6:35global economy. So targeting high free cash flow
- 6:38doesn't mean you automatically exclude tech.
- 6:40Not at all. Many high cash flow strategies
- 6:43hold significant allocations in large cap technology because
- 6:46that's where a massive amount of actual cash is being minted.
- 6:49OK. So if cash flow is the literal
- 6:52difference between surviving a rate hike and getting wiped out,
- 6:56we have to talk about how we actually measure it because
- 6:59companies are, you know, incredibly good at making their
- 7:01accounting look. Pretty Oh, they are masters at
- 7:03it. We have to start with the
- 7:04standard definition. Operating cash flow is the
- 7:07physical money generated by business activities collections
- 7:10from customers minus payments to suppliers.
- 7:13So that strips away all the non cash accounting fiction.
- 7:16Exactly. From that operating cash, you
- 7:18subtract capital expenditures. That's the money spent buying,
- 7:21maintaining or upgrading physical assets.
- 7:24Like buying a new factory or fixing a server, right?
- 7:27What remains is your free cash flow.
- 7:30It's what the company can use to pay dividends, buy back stock or
- 7:35pay down debt without harming the underlying business.
- 7:38And to see if a company's reported profits are real, we
- 7:41use something called the free cash flow conversion ratio.
- 7:45You divide the free cash flow by the net income.
- 7:48If it's around 100% it means the profits they are claiming on
- 7:51their income statement are actually turning into cold hard
- 7:54cash in the bank. It is a beautiful indicator of
- 7:57earnings quality. If a company claims a billion
- 7:59dollars in profit but their conversion ratio is 20%, you
- 8:03have to ask where the money is. Right, it's just numbers on a
- 8:05page at that point. Exactly.
- 8:06It's likely trapped in unsold inventory, Tory delayed
- 8:09receivables, or it's just a pure accounting mirage.
- 8:12There was a crazy data point in the research regarding Apple on
- 8:15this. In their fiscal year 2024, they
- 8:18reported a net income of $93.7 billion, but their free cash
- 8:23flow was 108.8 billion. Incredible numbers.
- 8:26They literally generated $15 billion more in actual cash than
- 8:30their official accounting profit.
- 8:32That happens when depreciation charges, which you know lower
- 8:36reported net income on paper, significantly outpace the actual
- 8:40cash needed for maintenance capital expenditures.
- 8:43So it's a hallmark of an incredibly dominant cash
- 8:46generative business model. Absolutely.
- 8:48But I feel like whenever I turn on financial news, analysts are
- 8:51just obsessing over the PE ratio or EV to EBITDA.
- 8:56It sounds so professional. Why do we need to do all this
- 8:59conversion ratio math when those metrics are everywhere?
- 9:02What's fascinating here is how fundamentally flawed those
- 9:05traditional metrics are when you understand accrual accounting.
- 9:09Let's take the classic PE ratio. OK.
- 9:11A price to earnings, right? Earnings, or net income, are
- 9:15deeply distorted by noncash charges.
- 9:18Management has enormous leeway to legally massage their net
- 9:21income. Just legally fudge the numbers.
- 9:23Basically, let's say a company buys a fleet of delivery trucks
- 9:26for $1,000,000. They don't record $1,000,000
- 9:29expense today. They spread it out over the
- 9:31useful life of the trucks, say five years.
- 9:33OK. That makes sense.
- 9:34So that's $200,000 a year in depreciation expense, which
- 9:37lowers their net income. Exactly.
- 9:40But what if the CEO wants to boost earnings to hit a bonus
- 9:44target? They could just tell their
- 9:46accountants that they think these trucks will actually last
- 9:4910 years instead of five. Wait, really?
- 9:51They can just do that? Yep.
- 9:52Suddenly, that depreciation expense drops to $100,000 a
- 9:56year. Net income just artificially
- 9:59jumped by $100,000. Wow, the PE ratio looks better.
- 10:02Earnings per share go up. The stock might even pop.
- 10:05But did the business actually generate a single extra dollar
- 10:09of real cash? Not a dime.
- 10:11It's a pure accounting mirage. OK, that is terrifying.
- 10:14You can just change an assumption and create profit out
- 10:17of thin air. What about EV to EBITDA?
- 10:19Doesn't that filter out a lot of the noise?
- 10:21It is extremely popular because it is capital structure neutral,
- 10:24meaning it factors in the company's debt.
- 10:26But we have to look at what EBITDA stands for earnings
- 10:30before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization.
- 10:33So it completely ignores depreciation until, which goes
- 10:36back to our delivery truck example.
- 10:38Or, like if you're a railroad company, the physical wear and
- 10:42tear on your train tracks isn't some imaginary accounting
- 10:45concept that steel is rusting. Exactly.
- 10:49Eventually you have to spend real cash to replace those
- 10:52tracks or the trains derail. For any asset heavy business,
- 10:55telecoms, manufacturing, energy, ignoring depreciation is
- 10:59financial suicide. And free cash flow directly
- 11:02subtracts those capital expenditures.
- 11:03Yes, it gives you the actual economic reality of what it
- 11:06costs to keep the business running.
- 11:09But we shouldn't just look at price to free cash flow though.
- 11:12The superior metric, the one quantitative strategies actually
- 11:15use, is enterprise value based free cash flow yield.
- 11:19EV based FCF yield. We use enterprise value instead
- 11:22of market cap because market cap the stock price multiplied by
- 11:25the shares only tells you what the equity is worth, right?
- 11:27It ignores debt. That's right.
- 11:29If you buy a whole company, you're assuming it's debt too.
- 11:32Enterprise Value calculates the total value of the company
- 11:35equity plus debt minus cash. So by dividing free cash flow by
- 11:39enterprise value, you are measuring the real cash
- 11:42generated relative to the entire capital structure of the
- 11:44business. Exactly.
- 11:46It completely exposes companies that look incredibly cheap on a
- 11:49PE basis but are actually buried under massive, unmanageable debt
- 11:53loads. OK, theory is fantastic, the
- 11:56math makes sense. But the real question for you
- 11:58listening is, does this actually save your retirement when the
- 12:01market collapses? The data says yes, let's.
- 12:04Look at the historical data because this is where the rubber
- 12:06meets the road. Yeah, take the 12 year European
- 12:09nightmare scenario from June 1999 to June 2011.
- 12:13Nightmare is the correct word. This period included the total
- 12:17collapseofthe.com bubble, 2 severe recessions, and the
- 12:20devastating 2008 global financial crisis.
- 12:23Just brutal. And over that entire 12 year
- 12:25period, the broader European market returned an annualized
- 12:28sideways result of just 30.5% total.
- 12:31That barely outpaces inflation. But if you looked at the top 20%
- 12:35of companies ranked by trailing 12 month free cash flow yield,
- 12:38they returned an incredible 248.7%.
- 12:42And that includes the companies in that bracket that went
- 12:45bankrupt. So there's no survivor bias
- 12:48massaging the numbers. Wow, so that spread is just
- 12:51structural alpha. The real world retirement case
- 12:54study in the sources illustrates this even better.
- 12:56We have two hypothetical retirement portfolios from 2015
- 13:00through September 2024. Both start with $100,000.
- 13:04Both take $4000 inflation adjusted withdrawals every year
- 13:07to live on. The classic 4% rule stress test.
- 13:11Yep. So the first portfolio, the
- 13:13Collins portfolio is invested in a passive capitalization
- 13:16weighted index tracking the broad market.
- 13:18Because it's cap weighted, it inherently loads up on expensive
- 13:21long duration growth stocks. Right and when the severe market
- 13:24drawdowns of 2018 and 2022 hit, their principal gets hammered
- 13:29because they're being forced to sell shares to fund that $4000
- 13:32withdrawal while the market is crashing.
- 13:34They trigger something called sequence of returns risk.
- 13:36It's a death spiral for a portfolio.
- 13:38It really is. By September 2024, the Collins
- 13:42portfolio has shrunk to just 84,783 three dollars.
- 13:46Their effective withdrawal rate is now dangerously escalating
- 13:49because their pool of money is so much smaller.
- 13:51But then you have the Mueller portfolio.
- 13:52Right. They invested in a rules based
- 13:55strategy targeting the top 100 companies based on free cash
- 13:58flow yield, specifically tracking the COWZ index.
- 14:02They lived through the exact same macroeconomic crises.
- 14:06But instead of shrinking, the Mueller portfolio absorbed the
- 14:09blows and compounded at a massive 14.63% annualized
- 14:14return. Even with the annual
- 14:16withdrawals, their balance grew to roughly $340,000.
- 14:20They generated massive alpha over the passive index.
- 14:23The underlying cash generation capacity of those businesses
- 14:25literally cushioned every downturn.
- 14:28Here's where it gets really interesting and why this works
- 14:30mechanically. Think about a high free cash
- 14:32flow company during a market crash like a hybrid car using
- 14:35regenerative braking. Oh, that's an interesting way to
- 14:37put it. When the market tanks, panic
- 14:39sets in, right Stock prices plummet, but this high FCF
- 14:44company is still generating a mountain of actual cash every
- 14:47single day from its operations. Because the business itself
- 14:50hasn't changed. Exactly because its stock price
- 14:53is now artificially cheap, the company uses that cash to
- 14:57aggressively buy back its own shares at a massive discount.
- 15:01Mechanically, that structurally increases the ownership
- 15:04percentage and future earnings per share for every remaining
- 15:07investor who holds the stock. It's regenerative.
- 15:09They capture the chaotic energy of the crash and turn it into
- 15:12permanent shareholder value, while the passive index
- 15:15investors are just watching their savings evaporate.
- 15:17Which raises an important question.
- 15:19If buying high free cash flow yield is such a magic bullet,
- 15:22why doesn't every single fund manager just sort of spreadsheet
- 15:25by FCF yield and by the top 50 names?
- 15:28Yeah, why not? Because raw numbers can lie.
- 15:31If you just buy blindly based on the highest trailing cash flow,
- 15:34you will walk straight into two massive blind spots, capital
- 15:37starvation traps and stock based compensation dilution.
- 15:41OK, so a capital starvation trap.
- 15:44I'm guessing this is when a cyclical company, like maybe an
- 15:48energy company running oil rigs just stops doing routine
- 15:51maintenance to hoard cash. They want to look good on paper
- 15:54for a few quarters. That is a perfect description of
- 15:57the mechanism. Picture an oil cycle hitting its
- 15:59peak. Commodity prices are sky high.
- 16:02Cash is pouring in to make their metrics look truly elite.
- 16:06Management defers all the heavy, expensive maintenance on their
- 16:09equipment. So the capital expenditures drop
- 16:12to 0 exactly, which artificially inflates their free cash flow
- 16:16yield. It explodes upward.
- 16:18Right, It might look 150 or 200 basis points higher than its
- 16:21historical average. An algorithm or a novice
- 16:24investor screens for the highest yield, sees this company, and
- 16:27buys it thinking it's a massive bargain.
- 16:29But the bill always comes due. Always.
- 16:31You're buying a value trap right before the earnings Cliff.
- 16:34When prices normalize and they're finally forced to spend
- 16:36hundreds of millions to fix their decaying equipment, the
- 16:39free cash flow evaporates overnight.
- 16:42That's brutal. And then you have the second
- 16:44trap. Stock based compensation or SBC?
- 16:47This one drives me crazy. It's a huge issue in tech.
- 16:50A company points to their massive free cash flow and they
- 16:53say, look, we're using it to buy back shares and reward
- 16:56investors, but at the exact same time they are issuing an equal
- 17:01or greater number of new shares to pay their executives.
- 17:04It's a financial treadmill. You are sweating, the company is
- 17:07spending cash, but your ownership stake isn't moving
- 17:11forward. In fact, if the SBC outpaces the
- 17:13buybacks, you are actively being diluted.
- 17:16Exactly. You have to filter out cosmetic
- 17:18buybacks and demand diluted share count reduction.
- 17:21So how do you actually dodge these traps without making it a
- 17:23full time job? I mean, analyzing the
- 17:25maintenance schedules and stock based compensation of 500
- 17:28different companies sounds completely exhausting.
- 17:31You rely on professional rules based institutional index
- 17:34methodologies. The VFLO index approach handles
- 17:37this elegantly to avoid that cyclical capital starvation
- 17:41trap. Their methodology doesn't just
- 17:42look backward at what a company did last year, they calculate an
- 17:46expected free cash flow yield. By blending the trailing 12
- 17:50months of actual data with the forward 12 months of projected
- 17:53estimates. Precisely, if an oil company is
- 17:56standing on the edge of that earnings Cliff we talked about,
- 18:00the forward estimates pull their blended yield way down and the
- 18:03algorithm automatically kicks them out of the screen.
- 18:06Plus VFLO as a growth filter to 0 in on the 50 companies
- 18:10exhibiting the highest sustainable cash flow growth
- 18:13over time. And the other one we talked
- 18:14about was the COWZ index. That was the methodology used in
- 18:18the Mueller retirement case study.
- 18:20Right, the COWZ methodology takes a different, equally
- 18:23effective approach. It systematically excludes all
- 18:26financial and insurance companies from its universe.
- 18:28Because for a bank, cash isn't a surplus.
- 18:31Cash is literally their inventory.
- 18:33Exactly. Including them completely warps
- 18:36the metric. Then it removes companies with
- 18:38negative projected earnings, ranks the remaining by trailing
- 18:41FCF yield, and selects the top 100.
- 18:44The true genius of these rules based indices is their dynamic
- 18:48adaptability through quarterly rebalancing.
- 18:50There was a great data point on this from late 2023, the COWZ
- 18:54index went through a rebalance and had a 24% turnover.
- 18:58It dynamically slashed its exposure to the energy sector.
- 19:02In mid 2023, energy made-up over 35% of the index because oil
- 19:07companies were generating exceptional cash and
- 19:10prioritizing debt reduction and buybacks.
- 19:12Right. But as commodity prices
- 19:13normalize, their cash flows moderated.
- 19:15And the rules based system didn't get sentimental.
- 19:17It systematically sold off energy and rotated that capital
- 19:21heavily into information technology and healthcare, where
- 19:24valuations had suddenly become highly attractive.
- 19:27It's an automated rotation into whatever sector is actually
- 19:30generating cheap, abundant cash at that specific moment in the
- 19:33economic cycle. It takes the human bias right
- 19:36out of. It which is invaluable.
- 19:38So what does this all mean for you listening, We've covered a
- 19:40lot of ground today in this deep dive.
- 19:43We've looked at the fragility of multiple driven growth
- 19:45strategies in a world of high rates and geopolitical friction.
- 19:49We've broken down how accrual accounting can create profit out
- 19:52of thin air and why enterprise value based free cash flow yield
- 19:56cuts through the fog to show you the real economic cost of
- 19:59running a business. We've seen the historical proof,
- 20:02like saving a retirement portfolio from devastating
- 20:05sequence of returns risk, and we've unpacked how systematic
- 20:09rules can help you dodge those nasty value traps.
- 20:12Right at its core, anchoring your portfolio to the
- 20:15fundamental reality of actual cash generation isn't just a
- 20:18defensive move, it's a structural advantage.
- 20:21It really is the difference between investing in a narrative
- 20:24and investing in an economic reality.
- 20:26When market sentiment rotates rapidly and indiscriminately.
- 20:29A high FCF yield ensures you own businesses that can self fund,
- 20:33reinvest and capture market share while their competitors
- 20:36are starving for capital. I want to leave you with a final
- 20:39provocative thought to Mull over.
- 20:41Remember that 12 year European bear market back test we
- 20:44discussed earlier? The one that returned nearly
- 20:46250%. Yeah, that one researchers noted
- 20:49that when they added a simple 12 month price momentum filter,
- 20:53meaning they only bought the cheap cash flow companies that
- 20:55were also showing strong price appreciation over the previous
- 20:58year, the cumulative returns skyrocketed to an astonishing
- 21:02755%. It begs an exciting question for
- 21:06you to explore on your own. What if the ultimate investing
- 21:10sweet spot isn't just finding a company with a mountain of cheap
- 21:12cash, but catching it at the exact moment the rest of the
- 21:15market finally wakes up to it? Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 21:20on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 21:23or differing interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 21:26is for information and research purposes only and does not
- 21:29constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 21:33before making investment decisions.
- 21:34If you like to access wider topics, including life investing
- 21:37philosophy, please subscribe to our sister channel Deep Values.
- 21:40Don't forget to like this video. Much appreciated.