Latest / On the Path / Church Violence and Security: Thoughts for Churches in 2026
Transcript
- Steven: Greetings and salutations. Welcome to On the Path, the official podcast of Concilium. I'm your host, Steven, and we are so glad to have you with us today. Joining me is one of our teammates, JD. JD, how are you doing? J.D.: I'm doing well this morning, Stephen. It's good to be here. Steven: Excellent. Well it's awesome to have you with us. Our podcast today is on a subject that I think is you're you're pretty pretty right on. It's the topic of church security and violence at churches. And there's there's a lot of thoughts and opinions floating around on that whole subject and topic. And I think it can even be a bit controversial. so JD, would you mind walking with us today, with our listeners, through maybe some some questions regarding this topic. J.D.: Sure, I'd be glad to. Steven: Excellent. Well I've I've picked out a few that I hope will be have some good information and and allow for some good conversation to happen for our listeners. So we'll see how it goes. first one then to get us rolling is what kinds of violence are churches encountering in ministry just in general? J.D.: Alright, well the first thing to understand is that violence is not the most probable threat facing a church anyway. but specifically within the within the study of violence at churches, active shooter attacks, active assailant attacks, or mass attacks as they're commonly known, represent just a handful of the violent incidents that we studied through twenty nineteen, from twenty nineteen through twenty twenty four. it's still even in the in the two years since then, I can think of a couple of intended active shooter attacks, or actual mass attacks in terms of casualties, but the overwhelming majority of violence at churches are are not an individual walking into a church seeking to kill as many people as possible, or succeeding in killing more than three or four, which is the the definition of a mass attack. the largest segment of incidents are driven by disputes. sometimes they're spontaneous, sometimes they're pre-planned, but they're often very personal and they can have significant overlap with mental instability, though it's hard to tell how many actually do based on media reporting alone. but yes, what what we have found is that the majority of violence at churches does not fit what you might think of as the classic definitions of active shooter or mass attack. So in other words They're not the types of incidents that have captured our imagination and and sparked our fears over the years. Steven: So that might even be just those mass attacks and active shooting get picked up by the news and potentially just maybe seems more frequent than maybe it is. Is that J.D.: Yeah, maybe seeming more frequent than they actually are, but they they certainly show what is possible at a church that's not prepared to protect Steven: Yeah. J.D.: itself, that doesn't have security measures in place, that's not investing in prevention or response. So certainly those headlining mass attacks, mass casualty incidents that we have seen over the years are very important and and they have drawn attention to the need to secure our churches, but there are far more routine reasons to be securing your church with a safety team, with access controls, with off duty law enforcement. Steven: Gotcha. Okay. That's helpful insight 'cause you know, I think that's people I think don't necessarily always think about more of that dispute driven, spontaneous, it's kind of personal between somebody, being the the context with which some things might arise versus the other. Okay. J.D.: Mm-hmm. Right. Steven: All right, well good. Well question number two then, as we continue down these these thoughts here, it seems that church security tends to be very Sunday morning focused. can that create a blind spot? And what are some of the activities churches probably maybe they don't think of as security events, but maybe actually deserve more attention? J.D.: Yeah, so they can absolutely create a blind spot. the the notorious mass attacks are ones that have happened on Sunday mornings. They tend to happen on Sunday mornings, that is. but Sunday mornings, they they're the most common specific time of the week for violence at churches, and yet they do not represent the majority of incidents. the second most common of course by by adding up the hours of the day, there's obviously more church office hours throughout the week, Monday through Friday, than there are hours on a Sunday morning during services. but weekday office hours are the second most common time for violence to occur. And if you were to add weekday school hours to that, to churches for churches that have schools on site, then then weekdays are nearly equal. they nearly break even with Sunday mornings in terms of frequency of incidents. And then that's still not counting weeknight activities. funerals, and and even weekend activities. so there's there's just any activity that your church is holding, whether it's on your property or somewhere else like a public park, can be the scene of violence. Again, usually violence that is related to a a personal dispute or grievance or domestic incident, some form of retaliation, and and even gang violence too. Steven: Gotcha. So the data shows that there's also outside of Sunday morning, all those other hours of operations, to use that term, I guess, very broadly, J.D.: Yes. Steven: there's certainly data that shows incidents happening during those times as well. So J.D.: Right. Yes. Steven: okay. I can see how that might be a blind spot 'cause maybe it's that thought of everybody's together on Sunday morning, you don't necessarily think of these other times as being a an area of concern as well. So J.D.: Right. And again that that goes to the popular understanding of an active shooter incident or a mass attack as as being the primary threat to churches Steven: Mm-hmm. J.D.: and and those are those types of attackers are going to gravitate towards large gatherings. but but again, much of your violence is Carried out by individuals who may be unstable or emotionally disturbed, or seeking to rob the church, a burglary incident that turns into a violent incident. I'm not saying that just because they're not active shooter or are not mass attacks, that there's not an element of targeting to them. But the the intention is not to kill a large number of people and And and so yes, violence occurs for many different reasons at churches just as it does in the community, Steven: Mm-hmm. J.D.: in in society around a church. And that's the important thing to recognize. Steven: All right, so the more ministry we do, increases the kinds of situations a church might need to be prepared for. So obviously J.D.: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Steven: the answer isn't to stop doing ministry. So so J.D.: Right, right. Steven: how do how do churches continue being, you know, kind of being welcoming and ministering to people while also being wise about, you know, these risks that accompany the ministry we're doing? J.D.: Well, first, safety teams or security teams, volunteers approved by the church who've been trained and oriented to practicing security within the church setting specifically, they need to be spiritually, mentally, and emotionally in a ministry mindset. And that's a term that a number of colleagues outside of Concilium use, as well as myself, just have this ministry mindset that their first mission is the church's mission. however a particular church might word their mission statement if they have a mission statement. the the first mission of a church safety team is the church's mission. It's not security and safety. The security mission is subordinate to the church's mission. It it flows out from that. And and just an easy way that I that I remember that is the phrase that every Marine is a rifleman, yeah based on the elo the the most basic foundational training of a marine is is an infantryman. every Christian is a witness. so you have to approach security in a church as something that aids the ministry. And good ministry is something that desires a stable environment for teaching, equipping, and for fellowship. but you have to have soft hearts and s sharp minds simultaneously. Being hard-shelled and standoffish as a security volunteer or safety team member undermines the universality of the Christian's call to witness and to be ready at any time to witness. so safety teams and security teams need to be ready to engage with people as people and not just as potential threats or or known threats. so you you have to inherently view it as a ministry, not as a necessary non-ministry. I have my fingers up in air quotes. church security is not the so-called non-ministry that solely exists to keep people safe so that everybody else can do ministry. Church security needs to be viewed as a ministry of its own. And that raises one of the problems with relying on contracted security guards or off duty law enforcement, because then you're outsourcing what can be a very key part of your ministry to well you can be outsourcing that outside the church and sometimes to non believers. so the best setup is to have a ministry minded, trained team of capable volunteers working alongside off duty law enforcement who are taking their cues from the safety team until the need arises for them to take charge of a law enforcement action. So I know I covered a lot of ground right there in those in that answer. but Steven: No, that's helpful though. Yeah, that's good good content. J.D.: my own church's team works very closely with off duty law enforcement. we have a great working relationship. but you know we we have a very clear understanding between us. They're they are integrated in our team. but the church is taking responsibility for security and those law enforcement officers are there to support us and and again when the situation calls for it to step forward and take the lead as law enforcement rather than as just security. but but again outsourcing is is a missed opportunity for a church to minister and and it can also be can create contradictions in your your church's image and the way it pursues its mission by by having security being led by people who are not from your church. in meanwhile, your volunteer team just needs to be very competent and and very aware that their their main job is to support the church and be part of the church as they're doing security. Steven: Very interesting. That's very helpful. I like the ministry mindset. I think that's a good thing to approach it from as the kind of the first part of the sort of the the the the generative part when you're the church is coming at planning for this part of ministry. Interesting. J.D.: Yeah, and and that's not to say, of course, that you do not need to apply professional security standards. Steven: Hmm. J.D.: you you can't just take a ministry mindset and and then soft pedal the actual skills that you need to resolve security situations or respond Steven: That's good. J.D.: to attacks. You need to apply professional security standards. it's it's inadequate to be an unorganized group of armed citizens who are just waiting for an attack to occur. for for many years that was the general the most basic approach to church security was for just people with concealed carry permits to very loosely organize themselves and say hey if somebody walks in here with a gun we're gonna do something about it. that that's that's not adequate. You need to prioritize prevention. the the framework that we promote with concilium is detect, deny, and defend. So you need to be able to see threats before they come at you. You need to be able to deny access to your buildings to those threats and then you need to defend against the against those threats. And so you use layers of human and technical monitoring and access controls in your parking lots, at your building entrances, and inside your buildings at different at different places. So so tying that in with the ministry mindset, you're very unlikely to encounter a person who arrives at your church with a predetermined intent intent to kill as many people as you can. Steven: Yeah. J.D.: you need to prepare for that, but you don't want to fixate on that. You don't want it to that threat to define your approach to the role. you are much more likely to encounter a person who has significant spiritual and mental needs who must be respectfully contained. Apart from the conversation with verbal de escalation skills and physical access controls until law enforcement can arrive and and either detain or trespass the subject or initiate some sort of mental health intervention. And of course you may Steven: Yeah. J.D.: have professionals on your church staff who are capable of mental health interventions as well. and and Steven: So probably having some training in like de escalation techniques and things like that, right? To try to ps yeah. J.D.: Yes. The people skills are very important for church security. And and there's an irony here that you may actually have to use those people skills to keep members of your own church who really don't have any business in in whatever the incident is, you may have to use those people skills to keep them away from the subject. I'm I'm thinking in terms of a person who's being disruptive. Steven: Yeah. J.D.: it's not a good idea to just go straight hands-on with that person who's being disruptive. There's too much risk of a physical confrontation breaking out when there doesn't need to be one. And that has that has safety concerns, that has liability concerns. so somebody who's disruptive, a heckler, an unstable person who's not making any sense, you may actually be better served by by keeping away the members of your church who may be too eager. To resolve the situation or be taking the wrong approach to it. And Steven: Yeah. J.D.: and again, just you know, you're one of your main goals is to calm a situation when you're when you're dealing with a an aggressive or a loud, unruly, disruptive person. But you're not necessarily trying to end it as fast as you can end it. if you get impatient and you get in a hurry, you you can get hurt, you can hurt the other person, you can hurt your church's reputation. And you can create liability concerns. Steven: I guess related to that whole thing then, you know, I'm thinking of an event happening in front of a whole lot of people, you know, maybe in the lobby or in the sanctuary itself or worship center. what are what are some other places that the church might want to consider spending more time focusing on? Like, you know, I saw in you know a previous concilium report that I think it sixty sixty one percent of violent incidents actually happened outdoors. Forty four of those were in the parking lots. I mean, I I guess if you are thinking beyond just that that nexus right there, is is there are there other places where some attention could even help reduce the likelihood of event happening, reduce the likelihood of other church members even getting involved, you know, is are there other places that J.D.: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Steven: it would be worthwhile for churches to to focus on as well? J.D.: Yes, definitely. So the report you mentioned was something we published in twenty twenty five called Violence during US Church Activities from twenty nineteen to twenty twenty four. and that that was the result of a cumulative study. There are previous iterations of that document each year prior to twenty twenty four. but yes, that's where that statistic came from. and that the majority of incidents happen outdoors. Your parking lot is one of your most prominent outdoor locations on a on a church's property. and even even the attackers who who don't start their attack, who don't commit violence until they get inside a building, they still had to come inside from outside. so it's that layered security that I mentioned. Your first layer of security needs to be in the parking lots, needs to be outdoors, need to be away from the building. Your next layer needs to be at the building entrances. And and you need to be backed up at those entrances by physical access controls, locks specifically, doors and locks and and windows that are secured. and then inside the building is is where you are monitoring the flow of people with inside the building and access to sensitive areas or for instance the platform in the sanctuary where the the the pastor is is preaching from. yes, you definitely need those layers so that you can have as many opportunities as possible to observe a person's demeanor, their clothing, their hand placement, their confidence level as they walk in the building. Is is a person appearing are they appearing overly confident in their surroundings? Is it is it because they are They they know that they are there to hurt people and they are confident in their mission, or are conversely, are they do they appear frightened and nervous and anxious in a way that nobody else seems to be? you are observing the people coming into your building, moving around within your building, sitting in the service, standing during worship music. You're observing them for anomalies, behaviors that don't that are not in step with what everybody else is there doing, where they're going, why they're there. you're you're basically looking for people who who don't who aren't really acting like they're there to go to church. Yep. The ones that just don't look right. J D L R. Steven: Just doesn't look right situation. Mm-hmm. J.D.: And again, it's not them that just don't look right. It's w what are they doing? Steven: within the context of where you're w with what everybody else is doing. That makes sense. J.D.: Exactly. And and demeanor is a big one. Demeanor, what are they doing with their hands to body language, eye contact, or lack thereof? and and and so even even people who show up with an intent to cause a disruption, and I'm not necessarily talking about mentally unstable people, I'm talking about you know, somebody who might be a protester or a heckler who's seeking to infiltrate the service and then make a scene during the service, they they're still going to be arriving knowing full well that they are they are about to do something that can get them arrested and and put in jail. So you're you're still looking for those signs of discomfort and unease that are a little different than the signs of discomfort and unease that you might find among just a casual visitor of your church who d just doesn't know their way around. which which of course that whole concept of of greeting visitors and and making an introduction, learning their names, learning, you know, w why they're there, who invited them, just the small talk stuff. I'm not talking about formally screening your visitors. I've seen recommendations for that before. It's no don't formally screen your visitors at the door. but but the small talk to to discern their intentions or maybe who else they know in the church. that is that's also a a method of security that is based on people skills. It's not a hard skill in security, it's a very soft skill. Steven: Well, it's also being just good ministry mindset back to your first one. You know, you're getting to know people and relationships J.D.: Yeah. R ex exactly. There's Steven: are very important, right? And that's how they start, right? By getting to know people. J.D.: Good ministry lends itself well to good security. and and properly contextualized security lends itself very well to good ministry. Steven: Well, that might pivot us to a maybe the most controversial question of our of our podcast here together. it's the issue of firearm usage. and is is that, pardon the word you you know, silver bullet, but is it the silver J.D.: Yeah. Steven: bullet to church safety plan or what else should churches be doing? Got into some of that, but you know, what should our mindset when it comes to this whole firearm component maybe be for churches? J.D.: Well well, for all the reasons I've already explained, is it it's not a silver d bullet and it shouldn't be the foundation. firearms are a tool in your kit. they're they should not be the focal point of your safety team's identity or policies and procedures. they're a tool and I wouldn't want to be without them doing church security because th there are just certain situations, and we've already mentioned them that are low probability, high impact, but there are certain situations that you cannot solve unless you are prepared to use deadly force to defend yourself and others. So they're a very important tool, but they are just a tool in a kit. they should not be the foundation for the security plan or the program or the mindset. They do require a high level of competency in practice, in discernment, in situational awareness, understanding of use of force laws, and the liability and insurance implications. So they are time intensive. And the trap is to invest so much time on maintaining your firearms skills and capabilities individually and as a team that y you forget that y you're you're putting all of this preparation into the low probability scenarios. Because they are high impact. So so you can't lose sight of your high probability scenarios. You can't you can't lose sight of your high probability Steven: Right. J.D.: interactions with people who need to be de-escalated or redirected or trespassed from your property, but who do not have violent intent. firearms policy needs to be clearly fleshed out within the church's overall policies and within the security policies. but the foundation of your team is really observational and situational skills along with those people skills that we were talking about a moment ago, including verbal Steven: Yeah. J.D.: de-escalation and then physical access controls. Steven: That's a that's a good word. I know that's a pretty that whole question is a big, big subject and discussed a lot. So I think you had some wise counsel put in there. how much time and resources do you find churches spend on violence response versus violence prevention? J.D.: I don't have any metrics on it, but just and and I've I've noticed the trend change over the last several years. So I'm definitely not gonna say that that concilium is alone on this curve. but there there is more focus on prevention. but historically the focus has been on response. Historically the focus has been on on What are we going to do if a man with a gun walks onto the platform and shoots the pastor? whereas the the where the trend is sort of heading where it needs to be heading is how do we spot that person before he ever comes in the building? Are there ways for we could spot that we could spot that person before he ever shows up on the property? Are are there is are there communications that he has made? Has he communicated threats? Has he the term we use leaked, has he leaked violent intent to people in his network, that that can report that to police? So, you know, is your church networked in the community with other institutions who may be targeted by violence? Are you networked with your local law enforcement agency? do you do you have a congregation that's aware of the need to report suspicious activity if if they have a family member who's familiar with the church or even part of the church. Some some attacks can come from actual insiders at the church. It it depends on the makeup of your church sometimes. But there have have been violent incidents of churches carried out by regular attenders. and and one of the attacks that was mostly foiled in Michigan last year was the son of a church member who'd been in a in a long running erratic discussion with a pastor about some very bizarre spiritual viewpoints, but that person who is very familiar with the church ended up being the attacker. so so just you know what what are you watching for and how are you watching for it? You know, are you looking at social media? Are you talking to people? Are relationships in place? Are are are is trust established between the safety team and the congregation or between the the pastors and elders in the congregation or the deacons in the congregation. Do do you have a culture in your church where if people see indications of violent intent that's oriented towards a person in the church or toward the toward the church generally, is that a culture where that information is going to be shared with the you know, with the the need for a certain level of confidentiality, but but are people willing to share? Steven: Excellent. This is some really good thoughts. So if church leadership then were to be listening to this conversation, there's a lot of good, you know, things that you got into across those questions there. If they were listening to this and they realize they haven't done anything maybe in this area, or perhaps they've done some stuff, but they feel, you know, actually listen to that, I think we might have some gaps that we might want to think about or talk about. You know, where where would you recommend they start? J.D.: I mean, you there are many security experts in your community, in your law enforcement agencies, in organizations like Concilium, the security experts are all over the place. Any of them who truly understand the mission and the environment of the church should be able to give the church point the church in the right direction in terms of how to get started with security. But you you do want to make sure that somebody has a very clear understanding of the mission and environment of the church. I I've heard it said that the mission of the church is is to be an open and welcoming place. That's the environment that the church needs to operate in in order to fulfill its mission of advancing the gospel. Right? It's like the mission of the church is not to be Steven: Yeah. Mm-hmm. J.D.: open. Openness is a characteristic of the church. so yeah, it's it's it's really important that you that you find somebody who really understands who you are as a church. and can apply security to that. Now, for the establishment of a team, there generally needs to be a lot more organized strategy and training. And that's where the the companies and non profits like Concilium that provide training, that's w that's where we come into play. I is like yeah. Steven: Yeah, well speaking of us then considering what what can we do specifically to to assist with churches? J.D.: All right, so we have a monthly publication called Insight Digest that contains topical essays on church security strategy or crime trends, what have you. But the ma the focal point of those publications is is a rundown of of incident reports from churches from the previous month. and we do focus on the ones that involve violence because those are the the most complex ones. Property crimes are a huge problem at church, but they usually do not include interactions between church members or staff and the offenders. so so property crimes are a big deal for churches, but that's that's very much a a a prevention task where your volunteer safety team is not going to be involved as much as everybody in your church is going to be involved in making sure the doors are locked, the that windows are secure, that the lighting is good, that the landscaping is trimmed back crime prevention through environmental design factors. that's that's a much more holistic effort. In fact, this whole thing of security at church is a holistic effort. But when it comes to calibrating your safety team to the threats that they're going to face on watch at your church, then then yes, we do tend to to cover the violent incidents and the disturbances and the threatening behaviors more fully. But we we publish that every month. And then Concilium has church security training available. That's gospel focused. It's great commission driven. Concilium The majority of what Concilium does is globally focused, supporting missionaries and even the persecuted church overseas. So Steven: Right. J.D.: when you when you're when you engage us on church security in the United States, you are engaging an organization that has the the full geographic spectrum of the Great Commission in mind, it has your church's mission in mind. Is looking at security as a means to enable your church's mission. not just to keep people safe. You want to keep people safe, but you don't want to get in the way of the church's mission in that process. And and so concilium is rooted in gospel advance and great commission around the globe. And we also consult on policy development, not just team training. Steven: Gotcha. And a lot of best practices and things of that nature. Well good. Well, JD, I think we're probably up against the clock here and I know you got a lot of stuff to get to, so we'll let you go. Thank you J.D.: All right. Steven: for your time. Thank you for sharing your insights and and and wisdom into this this pretty you know, there's a lot of thoughts on it that are out there kind of in the in the world and I think you gave some some really good tips and considerations. for our listeners, you know, particularly if you are in charge of church security or anything like that, please reach out to us, you know, if you have any questions. You can hit us on email at infocconcilium.us. Again, that's infocconcilium.us. Put in that subject line, church security question or search security church security training, something like that. We'll be glad to get you connected to our team members who are, you know, help out with all of that. you can also find us on Facebook and LinkedIn and you can even subscribe to this podcast. So with that, I think JD will let you go unless you have anything else to say. A any last minute add ons? Any hunt off the presses? J.D.: No, that that covers everything. Thanks, Steven. I'm glad to be on Steven: Awesome, man. J.D.: the podcast again. Steven: Excellent. Well, I'm sure we'll see you further down the path. And for our listeners, we hope to see you all further down the path as well. And until then, may your ministries be faithful, resilient, and effective.