Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Fringey Mini: It all started with a wolf
Transcript
- 0:00You're not gonna expect this. Okay, I'm doing
- 0:02the mini, so I hope I'm not surprised by the
- 0:04mini. Anyhow, these ducks, they would really
- 0:07like this episode. They would be really impressed
- 0:09with what I'm about to tell you. Well, that makes
- 0:12me more excited. Yeah, I don't know, those ducks
- 0:15seem pretty impressed very easily. Anyhow, sorry
- 0:18guys, you're not involved with the eider ducks,
- 0:20so don't worry about them. Chelsea, not a source
- 0:23I use very often, sciencealert .com. Oh, that
- 0:27sounds official. Yeah, it's written by Enrique
- 0:30Gastinaga on June 5th, 2025, article title. Big
- 0:35Bang may not be the beginning of everything,
- 0:38new theory suggests. Oh, what is it? The Big
- 0:41Bang is often described as an explosive birth
- 0:43of the universe, a singular moment when space,
- 0:46time and matter spring into existence. But what
- 0:49if this was not the beginning at all? What if
- 0:52our universe emerged from something else? something
- 0:54more similar and radical at the same time. In
- 0:57a new paper published in Physical Review, D,
- 1:01my colleagues and I propose a striking alternative.
- 1:05Our calculations suggest the Big Bang was not
- 1:08the start of everything, but rather the outcome
- 1:10of a gravitational crunch or collapse that formed
- 1:13a very massive black hole, followed by a bounce
- 1:16inside. The idea, which we call the Black Hole
- 1:19Universe, offers a radically different view of
- 1:22cosmic origins. yet it is grounded entirely in
- 1:26known physics and observations. Today's standard
- 1:29cosmological model, based on the Big Bang and
- 1:33cosmic inflation, has been remarkably successful
- 1:35in explaining the structure and evolution of
- 1:38the universe, but it comes at a price it leaves
- 1:40some of the most fundamental questions unanswered.
- 1:42For one, the Big Bang model begins with the singularity,
- 1:45a point of infinite density where the laws of
- 1:48physics break down. This is not a technical glitch,
- 1:50it's a deep theoretical problem that suggests
- 1:52we don't really understand the beginning at all.
- 1:55To explain the universe's large -scale structure,
- 1:58physicists introduced a brief phase of rapid
- 2:00expansion into the early universe called cosmic
- 2:03inflation, powered by an unknown field with strange
- 2:06properties. Later, to explain the acceleration
- 2:09observed today, they added another quote mysterious
- 2:12unquote component, dark energy. In short, the
- 2:15standard model of cosmology works well, but only
- 2:18by introducing new ingredients we have never
- 2:20observed directly. Meanwhile, the most basic
- 2:22questions remain open. Where did everything come
- 2:24from? Why did it begin this way? And why is the
- 2:27universe so flat, smooth, and large? Our new
- 2:30model tackles these questions from a different
- 2:33angle by looking inward instead of outward. Instead
- 2:37of starting with an expanded universe and trying
- 2:40to trace back how it began, we consider what
- 2:42happens when an overly dense collection of matter
- 2:45collapses under gravity. This is a familiar process.
- 2:49Stars collapse into black holes, which are among
- 2:51the most well understood objects in physics.
- 2:54But what happens inside a black hole, beyond
- 2:57the vent horizon from which nothing can escape
- 2:59remains a mystery. In 1965, the physicist Roger
- 3:02Penrose proved that under very general conditions,
- 3:06gravitational collapse must lead to a singularity.
- 3:09This result, extended by the late British physicist
- 3:12Stephen Hawking and others, underpins the idea
- 3:15that singularities like one and the Big Bang
- 3:17are unavoidable. The idea helped win Penrose
- 3:20a share of the 2020 Nobel Prize in Physics and
- 3:23inspired Stephen Hawking's global bestseller
- 3:25Brief History of Time from Big Bang to Black
- 3:27Holes. But there's a caveat. Their, quote, singularity
- 3:30theorems, end quote, rely on, quote, classical
- 3:33physics, end quote, which describes ordinary
- 3:35macroscopic objects. If we include the effects
- 3:39of quantum mechanics, which rules the tiny microcosmos
- 3:43of atoms and particles, as we must at extreme
- 3:46densities, the story may change. In our new paper,
- 3:49we show the gravitational collapse does not have
- 3:52to end in a singularity. We find an exact analytical
- 3:56solution, a mathematical no approximations. Our
- 3:59maths show that as we approach the potential
- 4:01singularity, the size of the universe changes
- 4:03as a hyperbolic function of cosmic time. The
- 4:06simple mathematical solution describes how collapsing
- 4:09clouded matter can reach a high density state
- 4:11and then bounce, rebounding outward into a new
- 4:14expanding phase. But how come Penrose's theorem
- 4:17forbid such outcomes? It all comes down to a
- 4:21rule called the quantum exclusion principle,
- 4:23which states that no two identical particles
- 4:25known as fermions can occupy the same quantum
- 4:28state, such as angular momentum or spin. And
- 4:31we show that this rule prevents the particles
- 4:33in the collapsing matter from being squeezed
- 4:36indefinitely. As a result, the collapse halts
- 4:38and reverses. The bounce is not only possible,
- 4:41it's inevitable under the right conditions. Crucially,
- 4:44this bounce occurs entirely within the framework
- 4:46of general relativity, which applies to large
- 4:49scales such as stars and galaxies, combined with
- 4:52the basic principles of quantum mechanics. No
- 4:54exotic fields, extra dimensions, or speculative
- 4:57physics required. What emerges on the other side
- 5:01of the bounce is a person really like our own.
- 5:04Even more surprisingly, the rebound naturally
- 5:06produces the two separate phases of accelerated
- 5:09expansion, the inflation and dark energy, driven
- 5:11not by a hypothetical field, but by the physics
- 5:14on the bounce itself. That's probably as far
- 5:17as I need to go. There's a bit more, but it's
- 5:21it's a little too sciency so we can end it there.
- 5:23It was pretty sciency. Yeah. Anyhow, I just This
- 5:28is somehow weirdly what I've always kind of understood
- 5:31the Big Bang to be is basically our universe
- 5:34came from the creation of a black hole in a bigger
- 5:37universe and that's where the Big Bang comes
- 5:39from. So it's another kind of what would you
- 5:42call that like a mirror? What a universe with
- 5:45an indie universe created by a black hole creating
- 5:47yeah. Yeah it's it's hard to picture something
- 5:50coming from nothing to be honest but With that,
- 5:54I will counter you with, whales come from wolves.
- 5:58They do, but black holes do not. I understand
- 6:01now. They actually might come from wolves. I
- 6:04don't think they do. Am I not understanding the
- 6:06whole concept? I just don't think Evolution of
- 6:07the Lion comes to that. Correctly. It might be
- 6:09wolves the whole way down, I don't know for sure.
- 6:12I feel like it's wolves the whole way down. I
- 6:15heard it was turtles, but it may be wolves the
- 6:17whole way down. I feel like it's wolves. But
- 6:19does that not make it infinitely easier to envision
- 6:22the Big Bang as like, oh yeah, it's just the
- 6:25creation of a black hole. I feel like whatever
- 6:28it is is not gonna make sense to our... mind,
- 6:31whatever it is. Well, you have to remember too,
- 6:35it would be the creation of a black hole in a
- 6:38universe above us, which would have different
- 6:40physics rules, because our rules of physics will
- 6:43only apply within our event horizon. What is
- 6:46the theory of the nine different universes? What
- 6:50is that again, where we're like bubbles within?
- 6:54That's not string theory. Is that string theory?
- 6:56I thought there was like 15 different levels.
- 6:59Maybe it's 15. I think it is string theory, but
- 7:02maybe it exists within that, but it's just so
- 7:06hard. I'm not a physicist. I can barely wrap
- 7:10my head around how big space is, and I don't
- 7:14know. Nobody can. You just don't know how to
- 7:17ignore that. I welcome other theories other than
- 7:20the Big Bang Theory. But this isn't really a
- 7:23different one. It's just saying that the Big
- 7:24Bang was a black hole created. Yeah. Which doesn't
- 7:28mean we can forget about that point in time.
- 7:31It just means that that point in time was a black
- 7:33hole created. Yeah. Anyhow, that's probably enough
- 7:36math and or physics and or space talk. I don't
- 7:39know if I'm going to be able to do the episode
- 7:42this week. Give me 48 hours. Yeah, you guys got
- 7:4448 hours to get better. I need 48 hours. Chelsea
- 7:46does not. Oh, she does, but too bad. She's got
- 7:49to do it. Anyhow, bye. Bye.