Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Master the Art of Strategic Apology at Work
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this moment in 2018 that I still think about when I'm coaching people on workplace mistakes. Starbucks CEO Kevin Johnson flew to Philadelphia to apologize in person to two Black men who had been arrested in one of his stores while waiting for a business meeting. They hadn't bought anything, the manager called the police, and the video went viral. Luna: That apology is actually taught in business schools now. But what makes it different from the typical corporate non-apology? Lucas: Johnson did three things most people skip. First, he took full ownership — no 'mistakes were made' passive voice, he said 'I am sorry.' Second, he named the specific harm: racial bias, not just a 'customer service issue.' Third, he announced concrete action — closing 8,000 stores for unconscious bias training. That's a strategic apology. It didn't just manage the crisis, it actually rebuilt some trust. Luna: I buy that for a CEO. But what about the rest of us? Like, I've seen people apologize for a typo in an email and somehow damage their reputation more than if they'd just fixed it silently. Lucas: Right, that's the trap. Apologizing for small things can signal you lack confidence or that you think small errors are a big deal. The key is to calibrate the apology to the magnitude of the mistake. A typo? Email a corrected version with 'here's the updated doc' — no apology needed. Missing a deadline that affected your team? That's a face to face apology with a plan to prevent recurrence. Luna: So the size of the apology should match the size of the harm. But I think there's another layer — power dynamics. When a junior person apologizes to a senior person, it can feel like groveling. When a senior person apologizes to a junior, it can feel like a power move. Lucas: That's a great point. And it ties into why Johnson's apology worked — he had positional power, and he used it to signal that he took responsibility even though he could have deflected. But for someone without that power, the calculus is different. If you're an entry-level employee and you apologize too profusely, you might actually reinforce the perception that you're incompetent. You have to apologize once, clearly, and then move on to solutions. Luna: That's the part most people mess up. They apologize, but then they keep apologizing. 'I'm so sorry, I really messed up, I can't believe I did that...' — it becomes about their guilt, not about fixing the problem. Lucas: Exactly. A strategic apology has three beats: acknowledgment of the specific impact, ownership without excuses, and a forward-looking commitment. Then you shut up. The listener needs to feel heard, not be subjected to your self-flagellation. I actually have a rule of thumb — if your apology takes longer than the conversation that led to the mistake, you've said too much. Luna: I like that. So let's talk about when an apology can backfire. I've read research showing that women apologize more than men, partly because they have a lower threshold for what counts as offensive behavior. That means if a woman apologizes for something small, it can reinforce stereotypes of being oversensitive or less competent. Lucas: Yeah, the data is pretty clear. One study found that men apologize about half as often as women for the same infractions. So for women, there's an extra layer of judgment. The advice I'd give — and I'm not a woman, so I'd love your take on this — is to reserve apologies for things that actually harmed someone's work or feelings, not for minor inconveniences. And when you do apologize, keep it brief and solution-focused. Luna: I think that's right. And I'd add one thing: when you're on the receiving end of an apology, how you respond matters too. If someone apologizes and you say 'it's fine' when it's not, you're just storing resentment. But if you say 'thanks, I appreciate that, and here's what I need going forward,' you turn the apology into a relationship-building moment. Lucas: That's a really underused skill. Most people either minimize the harm to avoid awkwardness or they use the apology as a chance to vent. Neither helps. The best response acknowledges the apology and sets a clear expectation for the future. Luna: I want to go back to something you said earlier about never apologizing for small things. There's a nuance there. If you're new on a team and you make a small mistake, sometimes an apology can actually build rapport — it shows you're human and accountable. But you have to do it right. Lucas: That's the 'apology as social glue' function. The classic example is bumping into someone in the hallway. You say 'sorry' even though it's no one's fault. It signals that you're aware of shared space and norms. In a work context, if you miss a minor deadline that doesn't affect anyone, a quick 'my apologies for the delay, it's on your desk now' is fine. It's the over-apologizing that becomes a problem. Luna: Right. And this is where I think a lot of people get tripped up — they confuse accountability with apology. You can take accountability without saying 'I'm sorry.' 'I dropped the ball on this, here's what I've done to fix it' is often more powerful than 'I'm so sorry, I feel terrible.' Lucas: That's a perfect distinction. Accountability is about ownership and action. Apology is about remorse and repair. Sometimes you need both, but often accountability alone is enough. If you missed a deadline but have already resubmitted the work, the apology can be implicit in the fix. Luna: Let me ask you this — what about apologizing for something that wasn't entirely your fault? Say you're part of a team that missed a client deadline because the client changed the scope. But you were the point person. Do you apologize for the delay? Lucas: This is where the strategic piece really matters. You can apologize for the experience the client had — 'I'm sorry that the timeline slipped, that's frustrating' — without taking blame for the cause. You're acknowledging their frustration, not admitting fault. That's a different move. It's empathy, not liability. Luna: That's clever. You validate their feelings without throwing yourself under the bus. And it leaves room to explain the context later if needed. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the core of strategic apology — it's not about being right or wrong, it's about preserving the relationship and your standing. If you can do both, you've mastered a real career skill. Luna: I think we should also talk about the 'non-apology apology.' You know, 'I'm sorry you feel that way' or 'I'm sorry if anyone was offended.' Those almost always make things worse because they shift the blame onto the other person. Lucas: Oh, those are textbook ways to erode trust. They signal that you don't actually believe you did anything wrong, but you're saying the words to make the problem go away. The research on conflict resolution is pretty clear — victims of incivility or harm want acknowledgment of the harm, not a dismissal of their feelings. If you say 'I'm sorry you were offended,' you're essentially saying 'your reaction is the problem.' Luna: So what should you say instead? Genuinely curious. Lucas: Try 'I'm sorry that my comment landed that way. That wasn't my intent, and I want to understand how it affected you.' That's a real apology because it owns the impact, not just the intent. It also opens a dialogue rather than closing it. Luna: That's a good framework. And I think it works because it separates intent from impact. Most people don't intend to cause harm, but the impact is real. A strategic apology addresses the impact without getting defensive about intent. Lucas: Right. And the follow-through is critical. If you apologize and then nothing changes, the apology was performative. The Starbucks example again — Johnson didn't just apologize, he closed stores for training. That showed he understood the depth of the problem. In your own work, if you apologize for being late to meetings, you better show up early for the next three. Luna: That reminds me of something I read about trust repair. It takes repeated actions over time to rebuild trust after a serious breach. One apology, no matter how good, doesn't undo the damage. It's the start of a process. Lucas: A hundred percent. And this is where most people fail — they apologize and think the work is done. But trust is rebuilt in small increments. Every on-time delivery, every kept commitment after the apology is a deposit in the trust account. If you don't follow through, the apology becomes a hollow gesture. Luna: I want to bring this back to the listener's daily reality. Suppose you're in a meeting and you realize you've contradicted a colleague in front of the boss. You feel the tension. What do you do? Lucas: The worst move is to double down or ignore it. The better move is to say something like, 'I think we're actually on the same page, and I didn't phrase that well. Let me reframe.' That's a soft apology — you're taking responsibility for the miscommunication without saying 'I was wrong.' You preserve the colleague's face and your own. Luna: That's a great tactic. And it works because it's not really about who was right — it's about keeping the collaboration functional. I think that's the underlying theme here: a strategic apology is never about admitting defeat. It's about managing the relationship so you can keep working together effectively. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why I think of it as a power skill, not a weakness. The people who can apologize well — genuinely, specifically, and with follow-through — are the ones who build the strongest networks and the most resilient careers. Luna: Alright, so let's land this. If our listener takes one thing away from today, what should it be? Lucas: I'd say: before you apologize, ask yourself three questions. One, what specific harm did I cause? Two, can I fix it or prevent it from happening again? Three, will my apology actually serve the relationship or just relieve my own guilt? If the answer to three is 'my guilt,' pause and reconsider. If it's 'the relationship,' go ahead — but keep it brief, specific, and action-oriented. Luna: That's a solid framework. And one more thing — if you're on the receiving end, don't just say 'it's fine.' Say 'I appreciate that, and here's what I need.' That turns the moment into a collaboration. Lucas: Perfect. So next time you mess up — and you will, we all do — don't hide from it. Apologize strategically. It might be the best career move you make this week.