Latest / SQPN: All Shows / Rings of Power S3E1: Marnûkh
Transcript
- 0:00Network stinger: The Secrets of Middle
- 0:01Network stinger: Earth is brought to you by the StarQuest
- 0:03Network stinger: Production Network and is made possible by our many generous patrons.
- 0:06Network stinger: If you'd like to support the podcast, please visit givestarquest.
- 0:10Network stinger: com
- 0:15Jeff Haecker: You're listening to The Secrets of Middle-earth, where we discuss the hidden themes and deeper layers
- 0:20Jeff Haecker: in the works of J.
- 0:21Jeff Haecker: R.
- 0:21Jeff Haecker: R.
- 0:21Jeff Haecker: Tolkien, whether in his writings or in any of the media derived from them.
- 0:25Jeff Haecker: I'm Jeff Haecker.
- 0:26Jeff Haecker: And joining me today on the panel are Rob Leonardi.
- 0:29Jeff Haecker: Hey Rob.
- 0:29Rob Leonardi: Well
- 0:30Rob Leonardi: met
- 0:30Jeff Haecker: and Fr. Bryan Shackett.
- 0:32Jeff Haecker: Hey Father Brian.
- 0:33Jeff Haecker: Hey Jeff, glad to be here.
- 0:35Jeff Haecker: And Patrick Mason.
- 0:36Jeff Haecker: Hey Pat.
- 0:36Patrick Mason: Howdy, Jeff.
- 0:38Jeff Haecker: Alright, so today we are discussing the long
- 0:40Jeff Haecker: wait.
- 0:41Jeff Haecker: uh
- 0:41Jeff Haecker: season three of rings of power.
- 0:44Jeff Haecker: But before that, we will we had just a little bit of news that um
- 0:48Jeff Haecker: as we've kind of discussed, they're doing they have their odd drop schedule in episodes
- 0:53Jeff Haecker: At the time of this recording, episodes one
- 0:55Jeff Haecker: through four were
- 0:56Jeff Haecker: dropped a week ago, um, or last week, and they'll be dropping uh
- 1:01Jeff Haecker: five and six this week, and then um
- 1:03Jeff Haecker: seven and eight
- 1:05Jeff Haecker: uh
- 1:05Jeff Haecker: next week.
- 1:07Jeff Haecker: But the news is that they are showing the episode seven in theaters on Monday, November 23rd.
- 1:12Jeff Haecker: So
- 1:13Jeff Haecker: we wanted to put that out there in case anyone uh
- 1:15Jeff Haecker: wants to try to go see it.
- 1:16Jeff Haecker: I think you'd have to look up how to
- 1:18Jeff Haecker: Get tickets, I believe it's
- 1:20Jeff Haecker: could be through Fandango or other
- 1:21Jeff Haecker: means.
- 1:22Jeff Haecker: Um
- 1:23Jeff Haecker: and you know it'll depend on your local listings, but
- 1:26Jeff Haecker: They are showing that episode in the theaters and I won't spoil what specifically they're doing, but
- 1:31Jeff Haecker: in it, uh
- 1:32Jeff Haecker: which was advertised, but you could probably take a
- 1:35Jeff Haecker: Take a guess at a big event that
- 1:36Jeff Haecker: a big you know
- 1:37Jeff Haecker: canon event that um
- 1:39Jeff Haecker: may be coming up in this season.
- 1:41Jeff Haecker: So
- 1:41Jeff Haecker: just
- 1:42Jeff Haecker: wanted to throw that out there.
- 1:43Jeff Haecker: Um
- 1:44Jeff Haecker: but
- 1:44Jeff Haecker: for this episode we are discussing the premiere of Rings of Power season three
- 1:48Jeff Haecker: only.
- 1:49Jeff Haecker: Marnûkh.
- 1:50Jeff Haecker: But before we do, we thought we would give you a lightning recap of season two
- 1:54Jeff Haecker: that creates Mithril.
- 1:56Jeff Haecker: And if you need a season one recap, the Council of Robs did that a couple episodes ago as well.
- 2:01Jeff Haecker: So
- 2:01Jeff Haecker: I'm gonna throw it to Rob
- 2:02Jeff Haecker: for our season two
- 2:03Jeff Haecker: recap.
- 2:04Rob Leonardi: The Elves
- 2:05Rob Leonardi: begin to use the rings forged by Celebrimbor.
- 2:07Rob Leonardi: Halbrand leaves Mordor and ends to
- 2:09Rob Leonardi: Heads to Eregion
- 2:11Rob Leonardi: where he becomes Anatar.
- 2:12Rob Leonardi: He helps Celebrimbor
- 2:14Rob Leonardi: forge rings.
- 2:15Rob Leonardi: Elrond
- 2:16Rob Leonardi: leads an expedition from Lindon to Eregion
- 2:18Rob Leonardi: and Adar captures Galadriel, and Elrond returns to Lindon
- 2:22Rob Leonardi: to partake in a campaign to stop Elon.
- 2:24Rob Leonardi: Adar's forces who seek to find and kill Sauron.
- 2:27Rob Leonardi: Meanwhile, King Durin is twisted by the ring and the Balrog
- 2:31Rob Leonardi: awakens when they delve deeply, but he saves his son and Durin takes his father's place.
- 2:37Rob Leonardi: He sends a forest of Du
- 2:39Rob Leonardi: To Eregion under siege
- 2:41Rob Leonardi: that helped drive the orcs away.
- 2:43Rob Leonardi: Sauron is revealed to Celebrimbor, and Sauron tortures the elves, seeking his secrets.
- 2:48Rob Leonardi: Eregion has fallen, and the elves flee to a new dell
- 2:52Rob Leonardi: of ribbons.
- 2:53Rob Leonardi: The
- 2:53Rob Leonardi: realm of dwarves is now in peril
- 2:55Rob Leonardi: as the new King Durin must secure his home.
- 2:58Rob Leonardi: Meanwhile,
- 2:59Rob Leonardi: Mordor
- 2:59Rob Leonardi: is now under control of the orcs
- 3:02Rob Leonardi: and some of the evil Southlanders.
- 3:04Rob Leonardi: The Numenoreans head back to Numenor, but a sealed door is separated from them.
- 3:08Rob Leonardi: them
- 3:08Rob Leonardi: and he makes his way to the settlement of
- 3:11Rob Leonardi: Pelargir, where the Southlanders have settled.
- 3:13Rob Leonardi: On Numenor, Pharazôn takes over and loyalists begin to be punished.
- 3:18Rob Leonardi: The Queen charges Elendil to take care of the faithful and
- 3:22Rob Leonardi: he heads to the west of Numenor, and Isildur takes a ship back to Numenor unaware of the troubles back home.
- 3:29Jeff Haecker: All right.
- 3:30Jeff Haecker: And
- 3:30Jeff Haecker: Great job, Rob.
- 3:32Jeff Haecker: And uh I don't think any mithril was created without lightning strike, so we're good to go there.
- 3:37Jeff Haecker: Um
- 3:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: And
- 3:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: and only three breaths, you're doing okay.
- 3:42Jeff Haecker: Three breaths for three reasons.
- 3:48Jeff Haecker: Alright.
- 3:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: Remember
- 3:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: next episode 9 Breath for Nine Rays.
- 3:54Jeff Haecker: Alright.
- 3:54Jeff Haecker: And just to note, um, as we mentioned, four episodes have been released, but we're only covering episode one.
- 4:00Jeff Haecker: Um
- 4:00Jeff Haecker: we're doing uh weekly coverage, pa
- 4:02Jeff Haecker: uh episode by episode, so there will be no fear of spoilers.
- 4:06Jeff Haecker: And if we have seen a what
- 4:07Jeff Haecker: seen ahead, we have sworn some fateful oaths of doom to not reveal what is to come.
- 4:13Jeff Haecker: So
- 4:14Jeff Haecker: And if we do, there may be some cookies c
- 4:16Jeff Haecker: in our future, so
- 4:18Jeff Haecker: Alright, so here's our episode one
- 4:20Jeff Haecker: of season three recap
- 4:22Jeff Haecker: Five years into
- 4:23Jeff Haecker: the war with Sauron, the Elven Rings help preserve their realms, while he tries to forge a new ring to concentrate his power, but he
- 4:30Jeff Haecker: has not been able to complete a ring that will work.
- 4:32Jeff Haecker: He orders an orc, Marnûkh, to go find any Elven Smiths who studied under Celebrimbor.
- 4:38Jeff Haecker: In a flashback thousands of years ago, Celeborn sees Galadriel training in the woods, and they spar and fall in love
- 4:45Jeff Haecker: In the present, she leads a party of elves in a skirmish against orcs and men from Mordor.
- 4:49Jeff Haecker: She faces a Nazgnogal, and we're gonna spend the whole season not saying that right, so just bear with us.
- 4:55Jeff Haecker: Nazgnagogul and the elves
- 4:57Jeff Haecker: retreat.
- 4:58Jeff Haecker: And Mordor, a party of men from Rhûn arrive to make an alliance between Sauron and Saruman, I mean the dark blue wizard.
- 5:04Jeff Haecker: He tells them that they can serve him instead and shows them a ring.
- 5:08Jeff Haecker: But there is only one job opening today, in his best Joker impression.
- 5:12Jeff Haecker: In Rivendell, Elrond tells Galadriel that Gil-galad has forbidden to request aid from Numenor, while Galadriel feels Sauron's eye upon her
- 5:21Jeff Haecker: Arondir
- 5:22Jeff Haecker: fears for Theo, seeing his face in a young servant of Mordor that he kills.
- 5:26Jeff Haecker: The witch
- 5:27Jeff Haecker: Kemen continues to oversee the deforestation of Pelargir while dealing with envoys from Mordor promising rings.
- 5:34Jeff Haecker: O
- 5:34Jeff Haecker: Theobreaker picks up the letter that Kemen dropped.
- 5:38Jeff Haecker: The surviving Easterling
- 5:40Jeff Haecker: is given the ring by Sauron and gives his name as Khamûl.
- 5:43Jeff Haecker: Elrond visits Durin discussing the dwarves staying out of the war, but Durin is secretly supplying swords to them.
- 5:50Jeff Haecker: Durin's brother Thrain is on the move to contest Durin's claim.
- 5:53Jeff Haecker: Durin and Disa are dealing with their teenage children as they prepare for the envoys from the other dwarven realms
- 5:58Jeff Haecker: to arrive.
- 5:59Jeff Haecker: Thrain has skipped the welcome ceremony and gone to the pub with his old friends instead.
- 6:04Jeff Haecker: Durin has Ail
- 6:05Jeff Haecker: brought to the Great Hall, and Thrain bends the knee to Durin.
- 6:08Jeff Haecker: The other dwarven lords want their promised rings, but Durin says they were made by Sauron and they have hidden them.
- 6:14Jeff Haecker: And he also says that the former king died in a mining accident.
- 6:17Jeff Haecker: In front of the other lords, Thrain backs King Durin, and they talk about their father, with Durin telling him the truth.
- 6:24Jeff Haecker: Thrain also flirts with Disa, hinting at a romantic past.
- 6:29Jeff Haecker: And then later, Thrain confronts Durin about supplying swords to the elves, and an orc, Marnûkh, sees them, telling him he has knowledge to save Middle-earth
- 6:38Jeff Haecker: Using the rings that Gilgaladin
- 6:40Jeff Haecker: uh
- 6:40Jeff Haecker: using the rings, Gil-galad and Círdan see a vision of this and discuss the war, and that Sauron is absorbing kingdoms, leaving Numenor
- 6:47Jeff Haecker: and Rhûn
- 6:48Jeff Haecker: as the last kingdoms of men not under his control.
- 6:51Jeff Haecker: In Rhûn, Gandalf observes the Rhûnites and the Dark Blue Wizard, and Sauron says he will see to Gandalf himself.
- 6:58Jeff Haecker: And then
- 6:59Jeff Haecker: in the end, some of the Southlanders, including Theo, come before Sauron to lead a rebellion against Numenor
- 7:04Jeff Haecker: And he offers a ring to them, but only one.
- 7:08Jeff Haecker: Theo lunges for the dagger as the Southlanders begin to fight.
- 7:12Jeff Haecker: Alright, so
- 7:14Jeff Haecker: Quite a bit going on in this episode, so I'll start with our impressions.
- 7:17Jeff Haecker: So
- 7:17Jeff Haecker: what did you think of this episode, Father Brian?
- 7:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: I actually
- 7:20Fr. Bryan Shackett: for the most part
- 7:21Fr. Bryan Shackett: there's a few things I didn't I didn't care for, but overall I thought it was a decent episode.
- 7:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought it interesting seeing into the
- 7:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: inner workings of of Mordor
- 7:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: more than we have in the past, right?
- 7:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought that was interesting.
- 7:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: I tend
- 7:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: I was not expecting the dead body of
- 7:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 7:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: Caliburn
- 7:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: Boar on the wall
- 7:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: in the
- 7:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: episode.
- 7:42Rob Leonardi: Yeah.
- 7:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: You haven't seen it, I guess, while you're here, I guess.
- 7:45Fr. Bryan Shackett: But anyway, spoilers, but I I was not expecting that.
- 7:47Fr. Bryan Shackett: And it did kind of throw me
- 7:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: cali
- 7:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: like Celebrimbor.
- 7:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: Oh
- 7:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: my
- 7:52Rob Leonardi: god.
- 7:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 7:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: all in all, I
- 7:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought it was decent.
- 8:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I I enjoyed
- 8:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: I enjoyed a fair portion of it.
- 8:03Fr. Bryan Shackett: Um, there's a few things that we'll go into that I didn't really care for
- 8:06Fr. Bryan Shackett: and some of the timing I had an issue with.
- 8:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: Not loving the Mar
- 8:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: Nuke stuff.
- 8:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: We'll see how that goes.
- 8:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm I'm not in love with that.
- 8:16Fr. Bryan Shackett: Or what did um m r
- 8:17Fr. Bryan Shackett: Mr.
- 8:17Fr. Bryan Shackett: Horror Story say that
- 8:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: will
- 8:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: say the character's name was from
- 8:21Jeff Haecker: D.
- 8:22Rob Leonardi: Goblin the Goblin
- 8:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: Thank you, Rob.
- 8:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: Mr.
- 8:25Fr. Bryan Shackett: Nerdby.
- 8:25Fr. Bryan Shackett: Our good old Boblin.
- 8:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah, I I
- 8:27Fr. Bryan Shackett: wasn't loving that honesty.
- 8:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: Really wasn't.
- 8:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: But
- 8:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 8:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: Interesting.
- 8:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm inter
- 8:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: interesting to see the full formations of the uh
- 8:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: of some of the Witch Kings.
- 8:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: Which the you know, the Witch King, the Nazgul.
- 8:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 8:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: I guess we're gonna do that, but
- 8:41Fr. Bryan Shackett: That was interesting.
- 8:42Fr. Bryan Shackett: I have some thoughts on that.
- 8:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: Oh
- 8:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: no, I enjoyed it.
- 8:46Fr. Bryan Shackett: Could have been worse, could have been better.
- 8:48Jeff Haecker: Okay.
- 8:49Jeff Haecker: What about you, Rob?
- 8:51Rob Leonardi: Yeah, so I actually really like this episode.
- 8:54Rob Leonardi: Um
- 8:54Rob Leonardi: it's
- 8:56Rob Leonardi: It was really
- 8:57Rob Leonardi: much
- 8:59Rob Leonardi: sorry.
- 9:00Rob Leonardi: Let's try that again.
- 9:01Rob Leonardi: I really enjoyed this episode.
- 9:05Rob Leonardi: It really blew a hole in a lot of our theories
- 9:08Rob Leonardi: in terms of
- 9:10Rob Leonardi: um
- 9:11Rob Leonardi: Theo
- 9:12Rob Leonardi: being the oathbreaker, because now he's definitely going to be either dead.
- 9:16Rob Leonardi: after this episode
- 9:17Rob Leonardi: or he's going to be turned into a a Nazgunul giggle thing majig
- 9:22Rob Leonardi: and
- 9:23Rob Leonardi: it's going to be interesting
- 9:25Rob Leonardi: and I don't
- 9:26Rob Leonardi: I I think that that changes a lot of things because I wonder if he's gonna now become
- 9:31Rob Leonardi: Witch King
- 9:32Rob Leonardi: sort of thing.
- 9:32Rob Leonardi: I don't know.
- 9:33Rob Leonardi: Because the no the Witch King had to be a king before, right?
- 9:36Rob Leonardi: Anyway, um
- 9:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: Wh which
- 9:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: gang was from Numenor, wasn't it?
- 9:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: Or do we not know who was from Numenor?
- 9:41Jeff Haecker: Yeah, no, he wa
- 9:42Jeff Haecker: we don't know that he was from Numenor.
- 9:44Jeff Haecker: We only know that there were th
- 9:45Jeff Haecker: I think three Numenorians
- 9:47Jeff Haecker: were
- 9:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: We don't know which one.
- 9:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: Okay, yeah.
- 9:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah, and
- 9:49Jeff Haecker: we knew Khamûl
- 9:50Jeff Haecker: as the only one who's named.
- 9:52Jeff Haecker: So
- 9:52Rob Leonardi: yeah.
- 9:53Rob Leonardi: Um
- 9:54Rob Leonardi: so
- 9:56Rob Leonardi: Yeah, it blew a hole in a lot of our
- 9:58Rob Leonardi: fan theories here.
- 9:59Rob Leonardi: But
- 9:59Rob Leonardi: and and
- 10:00Rob Leonardi: I
- 10:01Rob Leonardi: I
- 10:02Rob Leonardi: I am definitely abhorring the
- 10:05Rob Leonardi: um
- 10:05Rob Leonardi: boblin
- 10:06Rob Leonardi: the goblin
- 10:07Rob Leonardi: plot line here.
- 10:08Rob Leonardi: Um
- 10:10Rob Leonardi: And
- 10:11Rob Leonardi: apart from that, I really actually enjoyed the rest of this episode.
- 10:15Jeff Haecker: Okay.
- 10:16Jeff Haecker: All right, Pat.
- 10:16Jeff Haecker: So you have a pretty full beard right now.
- 10:18Jeff Haecker: How are the flames?
- 10:20Jeff Haecker: Uh
- 10:20Jeff Haecker: hitting your face, treating that beard.
- 10:22Rob Leonardi: I think they're singing at
- 10:23Rob Leonardi: basically.
- 10:32Patrick Mason: And
- 10:33Patrick Mason: uh
- 10:34Patrick Mason: the asterisk
- 10:36Patrick Mason: is that I have already accepted
- 10:38Patrick Mason: that Galadriel
- 10:40Patrick Mason: Warrior
- 10:41Patrick Mason: Princess
- 10:42Patrick Mason: is going to cause flames across my face.
- 10:45Patrick Mason: Every time I see
- 10:46Patrick Mason: because she's not Galadriel.
- 10:47Patrick Mason: She's
- 10:48Patrick Mason: warrior princess
- 10:50Patrick Mason: elf
- 10:50Patrick Mason: maiden, you know, uh
- 10:53Patrick Mason: bee.
- 10:54Patrick Mason: And
- 10:55Patrick Mason: and but
- 10:55Patrick Mason: so
- 10:56Patrick Mason: because of that, like
- 10:57Patrick Mason: I I
- 10:59Patrick Mason: I've come to terms with her not
- 11:01Patrick Mason: just she's not she
- 11:02Patrick Mason: she's just not glacier, whatever.
- 11:05Patrick Mason: And
- 11:05Patrick Mason: and with that, everything in this
- 11:08Patrick Mason: in this uh episode was fine.
- 11:09Patrick Mason: Like I was okay with it
- 11:11Patrick Mason: Um
- 11:13Patrick Mason: so I you know
- 11:14Patrick Mason: I really enjoyed the the start of the Dwarven
- 11:17Patrick Mason: Game of Thrones.
- 11:18Patrick Mason: I enjoyed uh the stuff with Elrond.
- 11:21Patrick Mason: Um, I enjoyed uh, you know, I really like seeing Sauron
- 11:25Patrick Mason: uh
- 11:26Patrick Mason: with
- 11:26Patrick Mason: having his own little
- 11:28Patrick Mason: devil on the shoulder,
- 11:30Patrick Mason: Angel.
- 11:30Patrick Mason: I don't know what Keller
- 11:31Patrick Mason: Rimbor
- 11:32Patrick Mason: is yet.
- 11:33Patrick Mason: Um
- 11:37Rob Leonardi: devil to a devil, I think, is an angel, right?
- 11:40Patrick Mason: Yeah, it's a double negative.
- 11:41Patrick Mason: Jimmy I can
- 11:42Rob Leonardi: just end an episode.
- 11:43Rob Leonardi: Did Jimmy Akin just
- 11:44Rob Leonardi: in an episode on what angels are and
- 11:46Rob Leonardi: or
- 11:46Rob Leonardi: sorry
- 11:46Rob Leonardi: what
- 11:47Rob Leonardi: demons are not.
- 11:48Rob Leonardi: So
- 11:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: And uh
- 11:50Fr. Bryan Shackett: maybe you should go back and listen to that again, Rob.
- 11:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: I don't think that's how that
- 11:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: how
- 11:55Rob Leonardi: that's working.
- 11:58Rob Leonardi: Depends.
- 11:58Rob Leonardi: It depends.
- 12:02Patrick Mason: Yeah, so I mean
- 12:03Patrick Mason: overall, I you know, I thought pretty good.
- 12:05Jeff Haecker: Go ahead, Pat.
- 12:05Patrick Mason: Yeah, pretty good.
- 12:07Patrick Mason: Asteris.
- 12:08Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 12:08Jeff Haecker: So you so did you did you armor up your beard a little bit like the dwarves from uh season two
- 12:13Jeff Haecker: did?
- 12:13Patrick Mason: Full face mask.
- 12:14Jeff Haecker: Little armor
- 12:15Jeff Haecker: full face mask.
- 12:16Jeff Haecker: Full face mask.
- 12:17Patrick Mason: There you go.
- 12:19Jeff Haecker: Yeah,
- 12:19Jeff Haecker: and I'll agree.
- 12:20Jeff Haecker: I I like the premiere quite a bit as well.
- 12:23Jeff Haecker: Um
- 12:23Jeff Haecker: you know
- 12:24Jeff Haecker: I was surprised that they
- 12:26Jeff Haecker: uh
- 12:26Jeff Haecker: like
- 12:26Jeff Haecker: we knew Celeborn was gonna be in this, but I'm surprised
- 12:29Jeff Haecker: even in the flashback that we saw him this early.
- 12:32Jeff Haecker: Um
- 12:33Jeff Haecker: So
- 12:34Jeff Haecker: I I I thought they would save that for a little bit later, that they would like
- 12:37Jeff Haecker: that it would be a much more dramatic reveal.
- 12:40Jeff Haecker: Um
- 12:41Jeff Haecker: but
- 12:42Jeff Haecker: So it and I, you know, I don't mind I I've never really minded the Galadriel stuff.
- 12:46Jeff Haecker: I think
- 12:47Jeff Haecker: I've kind of said before that you want to start her
- 12:50Jeff Haecker: If you want her to be like it's it's hard to do
- 12:53Jeff Haecker: immortal beings and make them interesting
- 12:55Jeff Haecker: if you're gonna do like a long-running series, like
- 12:58Jeff Haecker: in the
- 12:59Jeff Haecker: in the books it works because it's just like you can tell thousands of years of history and and pages
- 13:03Jeff Haecker: and
- 13:03Jeff Haecker: in a couple pages.
- 13:04Jeff Haecker: But in y if you're doing a show where you're like
- 13:07Jeff Haecker: moment to moment with the characters, you need a little bit
- 13:10Jeff Haecker: I think you need to kind of start them in a
- 13:12Jeff Haecker: place that's not
- 13:13Jeff Haecker: Where that's not where they end up just because you want to have that development over time.
- 13:17Jeff Haecker: So
- 13:17Rob Leonardi: Right.
- 13:18Rob Leonardi: That's the same thing with Elrond
- 13:19Rob Leonardi: 's hair.
- 13:20Jeff Haecker: Yeah, exactly.
- 13:21Jeff Haecker: So
- 13:22Jeff Haecker: it didn't really
- 13:23Jeff Haecker: So it didn't really bother me.
- 13:25Jeff Haecker: It's it's never really bothered me as much as others.
- 13:27Jeff Haecker: I mean it's
- 13:28Jeff Haecker: and I think she's improved over the series.
- 13:30Jeff Haecker: Um
- 13:32Jeff Haecker: And uh
- 13:33Jeff Haecker: in you know, and I'll agree the dwarf stuff, like the dwarf stuff uh
- 13:37Jeff Haecker: continues to be, I think, the one of the better plot lines in the show.
- 13:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah, uh I'd agree with that.
- 13:41Jeff Haecker: And uh
- 13:42Jeff Haecker: and I really like what they're doing, and like Durin and Disa
- 13:44Jeff Haecker: continue to to crush it, I think.
- 13:46Jeff Haecker: Um
- 13:47Jeff Haecker: I'm
- 13:48Jeff Haecker: I know there's a lot going on, so they didn't have time for really for Numenor here other than
- 13:53Jeff Haecker: Other than you know, Witch Kemen's uh very brief uh
- 13:56Jeff Haecker: very
- 13:57Jeff Haecker: very brief intro.
- 13:58Jeff Haecker: Um
- 13:59Jeff Haecker: and of course the next episode when we reveal the title is uh you'll you know I think it's pretty obvious where
- 14:03Jeff Haecker: what that will be about.
- 14:05Jeff Haecker: Um
- 14:06Jeff Haecker: but uh
- 14:07Jeff Haecker: and I even thought the elf
- 14:09Jeff Haecker: the the war
- 14:10Jeff Haecker: of of
- 14:10Jeff Haecker: of the elves
- 14:11Jeff Haecker: against Mordor was was pretty good
- 14:13Jeff Haecker: for the most part.
- 14:14Jeff Haecker: We only really saw a little bit of it and we and we got to see a little bit of Círdan and Gil-galad
- 14:19Jeff Haecker: kind of
- 14:19Jeff Haecker: Talking about the war
- 14:21Jeff Haecker: and kind of planning, so
- 14:23Jeff Haecker: kind of setting up for bigger things to come there, I think.
- 14:25Jeff Haecker: Um
- 14:26Jeff Haecker: and then
- 14:27Jeff Haecker: and then Sauron
- 14:28Jeff Haecker: just as a character, like getting it
- 14:30Jeff Haecker: just
- 14:31Jeff Haecker: Charlie Vickers is just
- 14:33Jeff Haecker: continuing to kill it as Sauron.
- 14:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah.
- 14:35Jeff Haecker: He's just chewing
- 14:36Jeff Haecker: every scene that he's in, he's chewing it up
- 14:39Jeff Haecker: and just making the making the biggest meal out of it.
- 14:42Jeff Haecker: And um
- 14:44Jeff Haecker: You know, and and it's interesting seeing him in kind of like this
- 14:47Jeff Haecker: because we
- 14:48Jeff Haecker: we've never seen I mean we've we've seen we've known he's Sauron
- 14:51Jeff Haecker: since
- 14:52Jeff Haecker: the end of season one.
- 14:53Jeff Haecker: Some of us
- 14:53Jeff Haecker: for longer than that, but um
- 14:55Jeff Haecker: some of us denied it for a while.
- 14:58Jeff Haecker: Um
- 14:58Jeff Haecker: beginning to kind of fully see him.
- 15:00Jeff Haecker: And then in season two
- 15:01Jeff Haecker: for the most part he was he was Anatar.
- 15:04Jeff Haecker: Or sour
- 15:05Jeff Haecker: anditar
- 15:05Jeff Haecker: as we called him.
- 15:06Jeff Haecker: So it's
- 15:08Jeff Haecker: interesting to fully see him
- 15:09Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 15:10Jeff Haecker: It's interesting to see fully see him as
- 15:12Jeff Haecker: has sour
- 15:13Jeff Haecker: on like and fully
- 15:14Jeff Haecker: embracing his
- 15:16Jeff Haecker: his dark lord uh
- 15:17Jeff Haecker: ness.
- 15:18Jeff Haecker: So
- 15:19Jeff Haecker: um
- 15:19Jeff Haecker: just
- 15:20Jeff Haecker: congrats to him.
- 15:21Jeff Haecker: I think Charlie Vickers is is doing awesome in the show
- 15:24Jeff Haecker: and
- 15:25Jeff Haecker: um
- 15:26Jeff Haecker: And yeah, we
- 15:27Jeff Haecker: we
- 15:27Jeff Haecker: maybe, you know, we we
- 15:28Jeff Haecker: seemingly lost
- 15:29Jeff Haecker: the the O
- 15:30Jeff Haecker: Theo Breaker theory has kind of
- 15:32Jeff Haecker: maybe seemingly lost some weight.
- 15:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think it's
- 15:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: gone.
- 15:37Jeff Haecker: We'll see.
- 15:38Jeff Haecker: We shall see.
- 15:43Jeff Haecker: But yeah, overall I thought the episode was and yeah, the m the Marnûkh
- 15:46Jeff Haecker: of it all, which is interesting that they named the whole episode after a character that gets two scenes
- 15:51Jeff Haecker: in this episode.
- 15:52Jeff Haecker: So I was kind of
- 15:54Jeff Haecker: maybe
- 15:54Jeff Haecker: maybe they just want you to think this is a bigger
- 15:57Jeff Haecker: piece of it then yeah.
- 15:58Rob Leonardi: So so
- 15:58Rob Leonardi: so for those who don't know, Boblin the Goblin is a is a character in D
- 16:02Rob Leonardi: D
- 16:02Rob Leonardi: where
- 16:03Rob Leonardi: effectively he's
- 16:04Rob Leonardi: he's the innocent
- 16:06Rob Leonardi: um
- 16:07Rob Leonardi: the innocent bystander of a lot of the party's
- 16:10Rob Leonardi: um, let's say
- 16:12Rob Leonardi: fun
- 16:13Rob Leonardi: deeds.
- 16:15Rob Leonardi: And
- 16:16Rob Leonardi: Is completely innocent for the most part until he p
- 16:19Rob Leonardi: turns out to be the BBEG, which obviously we know is Sauron
- 16:22Rob Leonardi: at the end of the gate at the end of the day here, but it
- 16:25Rob Leonardi: it's like, oh yeah, I'm gonna help you along the way
- 16:27Rob Leonardi: until
- 16:28Rob Leonardi: I
- 16:29Rob Leonardi: present you to
- 16:30Rob Leonardi: Sauron
- 16:31Rob Leonardi: is my kind of the setup I'm thinking.
- 16:33Rob Leonardi: It's going here.
- 16:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah, I mean
- 16:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think that's simplication, right?
- 16:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: The they're trying to play it off, right, is like is he gonna turn in s
- 16:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: like turn over Sauron or is he gonna turn over the
- 16:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: so is he gonna like turn in Sauron to
- 16:45Fr. Bryan Shackett: like betray Sauron
- 16:46Fr. Bryan Shackett: to the good guys
- 16:47Fr. Bryan Shackett: or is he gonna try to bring
- 16:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: the ring Sauron, right?
- 16:50Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean we'll see what he's what which
- 16:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: way they go with.
- 16:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm not liking either way realistically, but
- 16:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: the uh
- 16:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: again
- 16:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: I
- 16:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: I know we're I know Tolkien never really landed on on the evilness of the orcs.
- 17:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: I know it's a whole conversation we've had before, so go back and check out those podcasts if you're curious about that.
- 17:06Fr. Bryan Shackett: But I'm just not loving the whole Marnûkh thing.
- 17:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: I really wasn't.
- 17:09Fr. Bryan Shackett: The
- 17:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: Um, I have to save
- 17:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: record though, I just now in Filming's podcast
- 17:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: realized what you guys met by Saranitar.
- 17:16Fr. Bryan Shackett: I was very confused
- 17:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: the entire time talking about that.
- 17:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: I was like
- 17:20Fr. Bryan Shackett: Who is Serenitar?
- 17:21Fr. Bryan Shackett: Why are we talking about this?
- 17:22Fr. Bryan Shackett: And
- 17:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: I am
- 17:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: just now
- 17:25Fr. Bryan Shackett: realizing
- 17:25Fr. Bryan Shackett: what you meant by that.
- 17:27Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 17:27Fr. Bryan Shackett: it's like
- 17:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: Mate, the past like three episodes make so much more sense than that.
- 17:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: I was so confused.
- 17:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: I was like, alright, whatever, I was gonna go with it, but I was
- 17:40Jeff Haecker: Yeah
- 17:41Jeff Haecker: I can't remember who coined who coined that in
- 17:43Jeff Haecker: when we did our season two
- 17:45Jeff Haecker: coverage.
- 17:49Jeff Haecker: Yeah, probably.
- 17:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm just I was
- 17:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: uh I was
- 17:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: I was a
- 17:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: so con
- 17:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: we filmed the episode, that was so confused.
- 17:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: I was scared
- 17:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: Anyway.
- 17:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: Back to Rings
- 18:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: of Power.
- 18:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: Back to Rings
- 18:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: of Power.
- 18:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: I just thought I needed to share that.
- 18:03Fr. Bryan Shackett: I was
- 18:03Fr. Bryan Shackett: very
- 18:03Fr. Bryan Shackett: confused.
- 18:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: Anyway,
- 18:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: D
- 18:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 18:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 18:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: very confused.
- 18:12Fr. Bryan Shackett: But anyway, I
- 18:12Fr. Bryan Shackett: sorry to derail
- 18:13Fr. Bryan Shackett: that I just had to get that out of the way.
- 18:14Rob Leonardi: The importance of going back and listening to all the episodes.
- 18:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: I came in after that, less than
- 18:20Fr. Bryan Shackett: record shows.
- 18:22Fr. Bryan Shackett: I came in after that
- 18:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: Kevin.
- 18:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: If you want to know
- 18:24Patrick Mason: all the inside jokes, you need to go back about three years.
- 18:28Patrick Mason: You really do.
- 18:28Patrick Mason: Like it.
- 18:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: That's true.
- 18:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: That's true.
- 18:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: But
- 18:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: I
- 18:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: I will say
- 18:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: the uh um
- 18:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: I know I didn't say it
- 18:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: in my recap.
- 18:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: I did like the
- 18:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: I love
- 18:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think the time the time jump was really good.
- 18:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought that was a very good plot device.
- 18:42Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought that worked out well.
- 18:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: We could get a lot of like
- 18:46Fr. Bryan Shackett: like
- 18:46Fr. Bryan Shackett: ground in those five years to
- 18:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: get where we wanted to be, I think, right?
- 18:50Fr. Bryan Shackett: So I was
- 18:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought that served everything well.
- 18:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: I loved how they started off
- 18:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: kind of showing like
- 18:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: the
- 18:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: handing of the rings.
- 18:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: And again as it looks like the no
- 18:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: the no
- 19:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: the Nazgan
- 19:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: Nas
- 19:02Patrick Mason: Nas
- 19:02Jeff Haecker: Nazgan
- 19:05Fr. Bryan Shackett: leggle.
- 19:06Fr. Bryan Shackett: They're just
- 19:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: the nozz
- 19:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: they're just the nozzle
- 19:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: before they fade
- 19:09Fr. Bryan Shackett: looks like right
- 19:11Jeff Haecker: so we we
- 19:11Jeff Haecker: I think we talked about it in the trailer episode but
- 19:14Jeff Haecker: that word
- 19:15Jeff Haecker: it it it it translates to
- 19:17Jeff Haecker: uh
- 19:18Jeff Haecker: To ring servant, whereas Nazgûl translates to Ring Wraith.
- 19:21Jeff Haecker: So they're not Wraiths yet.
- 19:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah, so like the Ra' the ones before they become Wraiths, basically, it looks like.
- 19:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: Which
- 19:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: interesting.
- 19:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean it's going a little fast
- 19:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: with things.
- 19:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: Some of them aren't really kings, but like
- 19:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: we'll see how that goes.
- 19:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I enjoyed
- 19:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: I can't say I enjoy, it's kinda evil stuff, but I thought that was a well done part of the episode.
- 19:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: Doing all that.
- 19:41Fr. Bryan Shackett: Um
- 19:42Fr. Bryan Shackett: I definitely liked
- 19:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: you
- 19:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: you they did a good job at showing how like
- 19:45Fr. Bryan Shackett: how the elves are like not winning this.
- 19:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 19:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: they did a good job of showing that I thought.
- 19:51Jeff Haecker: Yeah, and one
- 19:52Jeff Haecker: so one note
- 19:52Jeff Haecker: that I was a little bit confused by is in in Galadriel's recap, because she recaps the last five years, um
- 19:59Jeff Haecker: she says that there's uh
- 20:01Jeff Haecker: that
- 20:01Jeff Haecker: that there's the elven realms are under siege
- 20:04Jeff Haecker: and that the three rings
- 20:05Jeff Haecker: are
- 20:06Jeff Haecker: protecting them and they show three separate areas on the map with a ring.
- 20:09Jeff Haecker: And at first I was like, wait, what other
- 20:11Jeff Haecker: realm are they talking about
- 20:13Jeff Haecker: And if
- 20:14Jeff Haecker: that
- 20:14Jeff Haecker: shout
- 20:14Jeff Haecker: out to um
- 20:15Jeff Haecker: uh
- 20:15Jeff Haecker: I think her name's Elisa
- 20:17Jeff Haecker: on the Discord
- 20:18Jeff Haecker: pointed out that it's because Lindon is separated into two
- 20:22Jeff Haecker: Uh there's a bay in between, but it's for
- 20:24Jeff Haecker: Lindon
- 20:25Jeff Haecker: and Har
- 20:25Jeff Haecker: Lindon, but they
- 20:26Jeff Haecker: they make up one realm of Lindon.
- 20:28Jeff Haecker: And then Rivendell is the other.
- 20:29Jeff Haecker: So that's
- 20:30Jeff Haecker: if you were confused by that, I was
- 20:32Jeff Haecker: too.
- 20:32Jeff Haecker: Um, but there's the two these are the two elven
- 20:35Jeff Haecker: realms
- 20:35Jeff Haecker: right now because
- 20:35Jeff Haecker: Eregion
- 20:36Jeff Haecker: is destroyed, uh
- 20:38Jeff Haecker: Rivendell is newly founded, uh or you know, been founded in the last five years, and then Lindon
- 20:43Jeff Haecker: Uh
- 20:44Jeff Haecker: where the Great Havens are, um, you know, that's still around from before.
- 20:47Jeff Haecker: So
- 20:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: that's the realms of the high elves, we should clarify, right?
- 20:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: Because the uh
- 20:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: because
- 20:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: the I think they've mentioned the wood
- 20:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: elves
- 20:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: are mentioned in the episode as well, I
- 20:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: remember correctly, right?
- 20:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: Were they the uh
- 20:57Rob Leonardi: the
- 20:58Rob Leonardi: they did mention that the green yeah the the L
- 21:00Rob Leonardi: 's from the green wood um
- 21:02Rob Leonardi: because it's not
- 21:03Rob Leonardi: merch wood yet.
- 21:06Fr. Bryan Shackett: Sorry, Rob, I'll just go ahead.
- 21:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm gonna cut you off.
- 21:08Rob Leonardi: No, no, I'll say
- 21:09Rob Leonardi: Go ahead.
- 21:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: Elrond was talking to Durin and mentioned it, right?
- 21:14Jeff Haecker: Yeah, okay.
- 21:15Jeff Haecker: Yeah, yeah.
- 21:15Jeff Haecker: Okay.
- 21:16Jeff Haecker: So
- 21:17Fr. Bryan Shackett: the uh
- 21:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: But yeah, I mean I was a bit like uh
- 21:20Fr. Bryan Shackett: it
- 21:21Fr. Bryan Shackett: explains how um
- 21:22Fr. Bryan Shackett: the two
- 21:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: how
- 21:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: in
- 21:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: uh
- 21:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: how
- 21:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: Gil-galad
- 21:25Fr. Bryan Shackett: and Círdan can't actually be talking to each other since the
- 21:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 21:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: and
- 21:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: with
- 21:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: together because
- 21:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: those two realms.
- 21:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: are
- 21:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: kinda near each other, right?
- 21:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: 'Cause the end of the episode they're kind of talking to each other.
- 21:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 21:36Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 21:37Rob Leonardi: The
- 21:37Rob Leonardi: other thing that I I liked at the beginning of the episode
- 21:40Rob Leonardi: with the Sauron
- 21:41Rob Leonardi: stuff specifically
- 21:42Rob Leonardi: was that you see Sauron
- 21:44Rob Leonardi: like
- 21:45Rob Leonardi: having problems.
- 21:46Rob Leonardi: You see him failing.
- 21:48Rob Leonardi: Right?
- 21:48Rob Leonardi: He's trying to do his best to create the ring.
- 21:51Rob Leonardi: And he creates what looks like the ring.
- 21:53Rob Leonardi: And then we have the hilarious interaction of the got
- 21:56Rob Leonardi: the the goblin, the the orc
- 21:58Rob Leonardi: um
- 21:58Rob Leonardi: 's
- 21:59Rob Leonardi: hands magically getting caught on fire, and then he gets magically caught on fire and everything like that.
- 22:05Patrick Mason: particularly
- 22:05Patrick Mason: good.
- 22:06Rob Leonardi: Yeah.
- 22:09Rob Leonardi: Um
- 22:10Rob Leonardi: but then if
- 22:11Rob Leonardi: he sends out the orcs to go collect as many rings as they can find, right?
- 22:16Rob Leonardi: Which directly connects to the war of the Rohirrim.
- 22:19Rob Leonardi: in the cartoon when we get the um
- 22:22Rob Leonardi: the voices of Merry and Pippin back as it orcs
- 22:26Rob Leonardi: saying that they're collecting rings for
- 22:29Patrick Mason: what does
- 22:30Patrick Mason: it
- 22:31Patrick Mason: rings
- 22:32Jeff Haecker: Yeah, well, I think they specifically say he wants the elven rings
- 22:36Jeff Haecker: because he wants to know
- 22:38Jeff Haecker: he
- 22:38Jeff Haecker: 'cause he's not able
- 22:39Jeff Haecker: he's he's missing something that Celebrimbor
- 22:42Jeff Haecker: knew.
- 22:42Jeff Haecker: So he wants the three elven rings
- 22:44Jeff Haecker: or
- 22:45Jeff Haecker: and
- 22:45Jeff Haecker: or
- 22:46Jeff Haecker: the
- 22:47Jeff Haecker: a record of what Celebrimbor did
- 22:49Jeff Haecker: or any surviving Elven smiths.
- 22:51Jeff Haecker: So that's kind of his plan is he needs
- 22:53Jeff Haecker: because I don't think there's like at this point
- 22:55Jeff Haecker: he I mean he's forged the Dwarven Rings that he was involved with.
- 22:58Jeff Haecker: He's forged the nine that he was involved with.
- 23:01Jeff Haecker: Um
- 23:02Jeff Haecker: that I
- 23:02Jeff Haecker: I think we saw him put his like use his goo
- 23:05Jeff Haecker: uh
- 23:06Jeff Haecker: as part of it
- 23:07Jeff Haecker: um
- 23:08Jeff Haecker: when he was kind of pocketing the mithril.
- 23:10Jeff Haecker: Uh
- 23:10Jeff Haecker: in season two.
- 23:11Rob Leonardi: Yes, but it we
- 23:12Rob Leonardi: we also talked
- 23:13Rob Leonardi: about how
- 23:14Rob Leonardi: there's more than those rings that were made still.
- 23:17Rob Leonardi: Like they they were testing out other rings and other
- 23:20Rob Leonardi: there were other rings of power just not
- 23:23Rob Leonardi: to the levels of what
- 23:25Rob Leonardi: the nine
- 23:26Rob Leonardi: the th
- 23:27Rob Leonardi: the
- 23:27Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 23:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: Seven and the
- 23:29Rob Leonardi: seven and the three are.
- 23:30Jeff Haecker: Okay.
- 23:31Jeff Haecker: Yeah, I guess I
- 23:31Jeff Haecker: I
- 23:32Jeff Haecker: I guess the way I interpreted it was he wanted the elv
- 23:34Jeff Haecker: he wanted the three elven rings
- 23:36Jeff Haecker: that
- 23:36Rob Leonardi: He does, absolutely.
- 23:38Jeff Haecker: And then and then he wants the Smiths
- 23:40Jeff Haecker: or
- 23:40Jeff Haecker: records and then
- 23:42Jeff Haecker: shout out to that one
- 23:43Jeff Haecker: orc that said, you know, had to tell him, like, hey boss,
- 23:46Jeff Haecker: you told us to burn all that stuff.
- 23:48Patrick Mason: Not saying this is your fault, but
- 23:52Rob Leonardi: that's
- 23:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: your fault.
- 23:55Patrick Mason: That was Marnûkh
- 23:55Rob Leonardi: though, right?
- 23:56Jeff Haecker: Was it Marnûkh?
- 23:56Jeff Haecker: Okay, yeah.
- 23:57Jeff Haecker: Yeah, that
- 23:58Jeff Haecker: 's the per
- 23:59Jeff Haecker: my
- 23:59Jeff Haecker: last
- 23:59Jeff Haecker: email that you never want to send to your
- 24:01Jeff Haecker: to your boss.
- 24:03Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 24:04Fr. Bryan Shackett: FOIA, you told me to do something different last time.
- 24:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: Not blaming you.
- 24:11Patrick Mason: This is your fault, but also it's totally your fault.
- 24:14Patrick Mason: Yeah.
- 24:14Patrick Mason: I well I like
- 24:15Patrick Mason: it.
- 24:17Jeff Haecker: Oh sorry.
- 24:18Jeff Haecker: Oh
- 24:19Jeff Haecker: yeah, I'll just is
- 24:20Jeff Haecker: one
- 24:20Jeff Haecker: weird just to go back to Marnûkh for a second.
- 24:22Jeff Haecker: One thing I I
- 24:23Jeff Haecker: so what makes me think that he's potentially sincere
- 24:27Jeff Haecker: is because
- 24:28Jeff Haecker: we saw and we saw this with uh
- 24:30Jeff Haecker: Glug, I think, in season two.
- 24:32Jeff Haecker: Like
- 24:33Jeff Haecker: Adar was so fanatical about killing Sauron.
- 24:36Jeff Haecker: that it led to the orcs betraying him because they wanted they thought it was
- 24:40Jeff Haecker: you know
- 24:41Jeff Haecker: wasting their lives unnecessarily.
- 24:44Jeff Haecker: Um
- 24:44Jeff Haecker: and then
- 24:45Jeff Haecker: now
- 24:45Jeff Haecker: Sauron
- 24:46Jeff Haecker: is doing the same thing.
- 24:48Jeff Haecker: by like
- 24:48Jeff Haecker: experimenting
- 24:49Jeff Haecker: like he's
- 24:50Jeff Haecker: he's making his his orcs try these rings that he's making that catches them on fire and
- 24:55Jeff Haecker: you know they'll
- 24:56Jeff Haecker: It's not a huge spoiler to say that that's not gonna be the last orc that gets murked by the actions of Sauron
- 25:01Jeff Haecker: this season, I don't think.
- 25:03Jeff Haecker: So
- 25:03Jeff Haecker: I
- 25:04Jeff Haecker: I think
- 25:05Jeff Haecker: so yeah, I think it's
- 25:07Rob Leonardi: not watched ahead.
- 25:08Jeff Haecker: Yeah, but I think it's uh
- 25:10Jeff Haecker: so I think it's that Marnûkh
- 25:11Jeff Haecker: could be I don't know, um at the as of this episode.
- 25:14Jeff Haecker: I'd
- 25:14Jeff Haecker: I think he could be sincere in wanting to stop Sauron
- 25:17Jeff Haecker: because he wants
- 25:18Jeff Haecker: he doesn't want, you know
- 25:20Rob Leonardi: He has a baby back home?
- 25:21Jeff Haecker: Could be.
- 25:22Jeff Haecker: I mean, yeah.
- 25:22Patrick Mason: Well
- 25:23Jeff Haecker: I mean
- 25:23Jeff Haecker: we
- 25:24Jeff Haecker: 're not
- 25:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: let's not go there.
- 25:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: Let's not go there.
- 25:29Jeff Haecker: I'm just saying I
- 25:30Jeff Haecker: s
- 25:30Jeff Haecker: Marnûkh could be legitimate and his wanting to stop Sauron.
- 25:34Jeff Haecker: We just don't know at this point.
- 25:39Patrick Mason: Um, this
- 25:41Patrick Mason: so
- 25:41Patrick Mason: I
- 25:42Patrick Mason: uh
- 25:42Patrick Mason: cla
- 25:42Patrick Mason: like
- 25:43Patrick Mason: as dumb quote unquote as the orcs are in goblins, evil
- 25:47Patrick Mason: is very clever.
- 25:48Patrick Mason: um
- 25:49Patrick Mason: in its idiocy
- 25:51Patrick Mason: and
- 25:51Patrick Mason: and
- 25:52Patrick Mason: can
- 25:52Patrick Mason: make good use
- 25:54Patrick Mason: of, you know, the trustingness
- 25:56Patrick Mason: of good
- 25:57Patrick Mason: And
- 25:58Patrick Mason: so
- 25:58Patrick Mason: I
- 25:59Patrick Mason: I
- 25:59Patrick Mason: I can see this both
- 26:01Patrick Mason: and I love the introduction
- 26:02Patrick Mason: because it does set
- 26:03Patrick Mason: that
- 26:04Patrick Mason: that's
- 26:04Patrick Mason: that seed of doubt into your mind, right?
- 26:07Patrick Mason: Is this guy actually sincere about the fact that he doesn't think Sauron's
- 26:11Patrick Mason: got the stuff?
- 26:12Patrick Mason: Or that, you know, uh and even Sauron's got that playing in his head, right?
- 26:17Patrick Mason: I think the orcs are even starting to pity you.
- 26:19Patrick Mason: So
- 26:21Patrick Mason: Is he
- 26:22Patrick Mason: there
- 26:23Patrick Mason: uh and where he's going off
- 26:24Patrick Mason: and he thinks
- 26:25Patrick Mason: uh
- 26:25Patrick Mason: Sauron, you know, needs to fall or go away.
- 26:29Patrick Mason: The question mark then becomes
- 26:30Patrick Mason: what's his ulterior motive or what's the ultimate goal he's got?
- 26:34Patrick Mason: Is it to replace Sauron? Is it just to get rid of him and own mortar?
- 26:37Patrick Mason: Like
- 26:38Patrick Mason: Because it's it's
- 26:39Patrick Mason: pr
- 26:39Patrick Mason: he's an orc, so it's probably not gonna be something good, like
- 26:43Patrick Mason: fundamentally, but it might be better
- 26:45Patrick Mason: than
- 26:46Patrick Mason: Sauron
- 26:47Patrick Mason: or what Sauron wants.
- 26:48Patrick Mason: And then the other hand, you know, he this could be a long game, right?
- 26:53Patrick Mason: He could be
- 26:54Patrick Mason: hardcore playing the elves
- 26:55Patrick Mason: or or dwarves or whoever he finds
- 26:58Patrick Mason: to try and get that
- 26:59Patrick Mason: ring so that he can be the, you know, the ender of all wars, right?
- 27:03Patrick Mason: Um
- 27:03Patrick Mason: the
- 27:04Patrick Mason: and and we see this, you know, even Tolkien's uh
- 27:07Patrick Mason: writing with the Orcs
- 27:09Patrick Mason: where they talk about not wanting to be with the big bosses and have the big bosses over them anymore and wanting to just take a couple
- 27:15Patrick Mason: lads and settle
- 27:16Patrick Mason: somewhere in the mountains away from it all, right?
- 27:19Patrick Mason: If they could do that, they would.
- 27:21Patrick Mason: And so
- 27:22Patrick Mason: there is a real question about this character's motives.
- 27:24Patrick Mason: I
- 27:25Patrick Mason: I'll be interested to see how they play it out
- 27:27Patrick Mason: Um, but I'm not
- 27:29Patrick Mason: I'm not immediately
- 27:30Patrick Mason: problem
- 27:30Patrick Mason: like it's it's not a problem for me.
- 27:33Patrick Mason: Unlike
- 27:33Patrick Mason: Galadriel.
- 27:34Rob Leonardi: So I
- 27:39Rob Leonardi: I am
- 27:40Rob Leonardi: more of
- 27:40Rob Leonardi: of
- 27:41Rob Leonardi: concern
- 27:41Rob Leonardi: that they're going to try to do some sort of like
- 27:44Rob Leonardi: redemption arc with this orc, right?
- 27:46Rob Leonardi: Which
- 27:47Fr. Bryan Shackett: probably
- 27:47Rob Leonardi: I mean
- 27:48Rob Leonardi: Tolkien
- 27:49Rob Leonardi: explicitly, as we talked previously, Tolkien explicitly um
- 27:52Rob Leonardi: did not
- 27:53Rob Leonardi: come
- 27:54Rob Leonardi: to a conclusion with that himself.
- 27:56Rob Leonardi: So
- 27:56Rob Leonardi: are they trying to write that in as a
- 28:00Rob Leonardi: post
- 28:00Rob Leonardi: hoc conclusion?
- 28:01Rob Leonardi: Are they trying to just kind of shoehorn
- 28:04Rob Leonardi: it in?
- 28:04Rob Leonardi: Because like
- 28:05Rob Leonardi: theoretically we could do the you know
- 28:07Rob Leonardi: do some thinking here and yeah it orcs.
- 28:11Rob Leonardi: Okay, they came from elves, they're twisted.
- 28:13Rob Leonardi: They probably should still go to the Hall of Mandos
- 28:16Rob Leonardi: and spend a lot of time there, right?
- 28:19Rob Leonardi: Um
- 28:20Rob Leonardi: and
- 28:22Rob Leonardi: I I just don't know with with this particular orc in this particular setting if it's if it's right.
- 28:27Rob Leonardi: I mean if it if it does come out that you know he has a
- 28:30Rob Leonardi: he has
- 28:31Rob Leonardi: some
- 28:31Rob Leonardi: sort of motive of just his feller
- 28:34Rob Leonardi: brethren, or maybe he ha you know, because
- 28:36Rob Leonardi: we saw last season that they apparently these orcs
- 28:39Rob Leonardi: have families.
- 28:41Rob Leonardi: Um, you know, it's it's a good thing that
- 28:44Rob Leonardi: There's not any equivalent of a twisted dwarf or else we'd have a really twisted Orc and Dwarf romance.
- 28:50Rob Leonardi: Oh
- 28:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: you had to you had to go
- 28:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: You had to go there, Rob
- 28:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: Had to go there
- 28:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: Well nine and a half for three
- 28:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: episode, yeah.
- 28:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: You had to go
- 28:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: one
- 29:01Patrick Mason: Good grief.
- 29:03Fr. Bryan Shackett: I didn't know I think
- 29:04Fr. Bryan Shackett: I didn't know you're gonna do I didn't know how you're gonna bring that in, but
- 29:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: You got there.
- 29:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: You got there.
- 29:09Patrick Mason: It hurts.
- 29:10Patrick Mason: It burns.
- 29:13Jeff Haecker: Yeah, so
- 29:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: the
- 29:15Jeff Haecker: Oh go ahead, father.
- 29:16Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I wouldn't I
- 29:17Fr. Bryan Shackett: so yeah, I mean
- 29:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: again I
- 29:20Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm as
- 29:20Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm not in
- 29:21Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think I kinda take a midline
- 29:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: between Pat and Rob
- 29:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: here.
- 29:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: Like I
- 29:25Fr. Bryan Shackett: I don't
- 29:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm not like
- 29:27Fr. Bryan Shackett: All in favor of the Smart
- 29:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: Nuke thing.
- 29:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: I guess part of see how they played out.
- 29:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: I guess we'll have to wait and see what they do with it.
- 29:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: Um
- 29:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm still a little like they did kind of
- 29:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: orc
- 29:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: redemption stuff last season too, push with some of some of that a little bit, right?
- 29:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: Not
- 29:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: If not directly, but some of that, so I can see they're going in that direction.
- 29:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: Again, since
- 29:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm not sure.
- 29:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: But that was
- 29:45Rob Leonardi: that was with Adar
- 29:46Rob Leonardi: though.
- 29:46Rob Leonardi: And like
- 29:47Rob Leonardi: that's a little different.
- 29:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: It it was, admittedly, yeah, but it's like maybe beginnings
- 29:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: of kinda going that direction.
- 29:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: So we'll see.
- 29:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean it's if they don't if they're more
- 29:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: if they don't land in anything because
- 29:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: the professor didn't land in anything, I'll be more okay.
- 29:59Patrick Mason: Well, and I
- 29:59Patrick Mason: 'll see
- 30:00Patrick Mason: I think that's as a pot
- 30:01Patrick Mason: you know, me, Jeff, and uh Thomas is where we landed was El
- 30:04Patrick Mason: uh
- 30:04Patrick Mason: Ador
- 30:05Patrick Mason: was in a redemptive
- 30:06Patrick Mason: space.
- 30:07Patrick Mason: Like he
- 30:07Patrick Mason: he very clearly potentially redeemed.
- 30:10Patrick Mason: Whether or not, you know, that's up to Mandos.
- 30:13Patrick Mason: Um
- 30:14Patrick Mason: so
- 30:15Patrick Mason: I'll be interested to see if they go that route with the orc
- 30:18Patrick Mason: I don't
- 30:20Patrick Mason: I just don't see it playing out that way.
- 30:22Patrick Mason: But
- 30:22Patrick Mason: I have been wrong
- 30:24Patrick Mason: many times before.
- 30:26Patrick Mason: It's not Gandalf.
- 30:27Patrick Mason: Or it couldn't it's still not Gandalf, but I don't care.
- 30:32Rob Leonardi: Okay, well, if
- 30:34Rob Leonardi: pinning
- 30:35Rob Leonardi: that
- 30:35Rob Leonardi: I I
- 30:36Rob Leonardi: the other thing is
- 30:37Rob Leonardi: what if they're doing like a golem thing where they're gonna have him travel along as the golem did with Sam and Frodo and then betray them at the end.
- 30:46Patrick Mason: Yeah.
- 30:47Rob Leonardi: It
- 30:47Patrick Mason: is
- 30:48Patrick Mason: my precious.
- 30:51Rob Leonardi: Whatever that looks like.
- 30:52Rob Leonardi: Um
- 30:53Rob Leonardi: going
- 30:53Rob Leonardi: back to that pin
- 30:54Rob Leonardi: though, I think that they're specifically
- 30:57Rob Leonardi: trying to make this
- 30:59Rob Leonardi: Um, we're you know, our our theory of this being Sauron, that it's not Sauron.
- 31:04Rob Leonardi: I
- 31:04Rob Leonardi: I I'm going to put my foot in it and say it's not Sauron
- 31:08Rob Leonardi: now.
- 31:08Patrick Mason: Yes.
- 31:09Rob Leonardi: That's what I meant.
- 31:10Rob Leonardi: Sorry.
- 31:14Jeff Haecker: Are you studying here?
- 31:17Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm pretty confident, Sarah.
- 31:23Rob Leonardi: Please ask him.
- 31:25Fr. Bryan Shackett: Those are pretty importantly different people.
- 31:28Jeff Haecker: Yeah, to be fair, they did call him Aruman in the uh animated film
- 31:32Jeff Haecker: because they thought people would be confused.
- 31:34Rob Leonardi: Yes, I I I apologize.
- 31:36Rob Leonardi: I knew I was gonna screw up n
- 31:37Rob Leonardi: I told you guys before
- 31:38Rob Leonardi: before doing this I was gonna screw up names.
- 31:41Patrick Mason: No, I
- 31:41Patrick Mason: but I think you're right.
- 31:43Patrick Mason: But
- 31:44Rob Leonardi: They they even even now they they keep referencing him as the dark uh
- 31:49Rob Leonardi: wizard, right?
- 31:50Rob Leonardi: I
- 31:50Rob Leonardi: it
- 31:50Rob Leonardi: dark blue wizard makes a lot more sense
- 31:53Rob Leonardi: and
- 31:53Rob Leonardi: just having him look
- 31:55Rob Leonardi: like
- 31:56Rob Leonardi: Saruman
- 31:58Rob Leonardi: Yes.
- 32:00Rob Leonardi: Um
- 32:01Rob Leonardi: I I think that's just coincidence, but I think what
- 32:04Rob Leonardi: what
- 32:04Rob Leonardi: the thing that I
- 32:06Rob Leonardi: I
- 32:06Rob Leonardi: with
- 32:07Rob Leonardi: the
- 32:07Rob Leonardi: connecting it with the W
- 32:09Rob Leonardi: War of the Rohirrim
- 32:10Rob Leonardi: that
- 32:11Rob Leonardi: Saruman
- 32:13Rob Leonardi: is actually going to be in Rohan
- 32:15Rob Leonardi: now
- 32:16Rob Leonardi: because that's at the end of um
- 32:19Rob Leonardi: At the end of War of the
- 32:21Rob Leonardi: Ro
- 32:21Rob Leonardi: War of the Rohirrim, we
- 32:23Rob Leonardi: that's where he is.
- 32:25Rob Leonardi: But
- 32:26Rob Leonardi: that all being said
- 32:28Rob Leonardi: It could very well be the dark blue wizard has the come
- 32:30Rob Leonardi: to Jesus moment and becomes the white wizard.
- 32:34Jeff Haecker: Well, and one thing to remember is
- 32:36Jeff Haecker: is
- 32:36Jeff Haecker: The War of the Rohirrim is like three thousand years from
- 32:39Jeff Haecker: from where this this is taking place.
- 32:45Jeff Haecker: We've talked about that the wizard
- 32:46Jeff Haecker: shouldn't be here yet
- 32:47Jeff Haecker: because
- 32:48Jeff Haecker: They they come over in the third
- 32:50Jeff Haecker: right, they come over in the third age, I believe.
- 32:52Jeff Haecker: Um
- 32:54Jeff Haecker: they're sent over.
- 32:55Jeff Haecker: So
- 32:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: There's some questions about
- 32:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: there's some questions about their potentiality, like of the blue wizard being sent earlier, so there is some questions about the blue w
- 33:02Fr. Bryan Shackett: they could be here, realistically.
- 33:03Fr. Bryan Shackett: Gandalf does make sense to be here, but but the
- 33:06Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 33:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: One thing I will say is like
- 33:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: I was told
- 33:09Fr. Bryan Shackett: crafting
- 33:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: wrong here, is
- 33:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: did the showrunners
- 33:12Fr. Bryan Shackett: come out and say that it's not Saruman?
- 33:13Fr. Bryan Shackett: Didn't that
- 33:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: did it get set as a motion?
- 33:16Rob Leonardi: They came out and specifically said
- 33:18Rob Leonardi: we are
- 33:18Rob Leonardi: specifically not saying it's Saruman.
- 33:21Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 33:22Jeff Haecker: There
- 33:22Jeff Haecker: 's
- 33:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: a means
- 33:23Jeff Haecker: because it wasn't dandoff and it wasn't, you know, until
- 33:26Jeff Haecker: until it was.
- 33:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: I don't think
- 33:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: Sarmine does
- 33:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: every
- 33:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: every time it goes on, Saruman being the d the the the dark
- 33:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: was
- 33:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: doesn't make any sense, right?
- 33:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: The one thing that struck me,
- 33:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: maybe I I think this
- 33:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: maybe it's
- 33:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I I don't remember if it was last part of season two or th or this or this episode.
- 33:41Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think it was last part of season two.
- 33:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: Were they was there a reference that
- 33:45Fr. Bryan Shackett: Maybe I
- 33:45Fr. Bryan Shackett: maybe I misunderstood the the dark one
- 33:47Fr. Bryan Shackett: the dark wizards when he how we talked, but how
- 33:50Fr. Bryan Shackett: implying that the other wizards are also there.
- 33:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: Maybe that was a throwaway line from the end of that.
- 33:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: Last season?
- 33:55Jeff Haecker: I don't remember that, but he says he knew
- 33:57Jeff Haecker: he he he imply
- 33:58Jeff Haecker: he says he knew he knows Gandalf.
- 34:00Jeff Haecker: Um
- 34:01Jeff Haecker: like he says something about like you told me
- 34:04Jeff Haecker: Some
- 34:04Jeff Haecker: I can't remember the exact comments.
- 34:05Fr. Bryan Shackett: You can miss me to come.
- 34:07Jeff Haecker: Yeah, something like that.
- 34:07Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 34:08Rob Leonardi: Well and not only that, but now also we do know that
- 34:12Rob Leonardi: Sauron
- 34:13Fr. Bryan Shackett: got
- 34:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: it
- 34:15Rob Leonardi: No
- 34:16Rob Leonardi: we're good, we're good, keep going.
- 34:19Rob Leonardi: He knows Gandalf by name now.
- 34:21Jeff Haecker: Sauron.
- 34:22Jeff Haecker: You just mixed it up.
- 34:24Jeff Haecker: Dang
- 34:25Jeff Haecker: it.
- 34:26Jeff Haecker: Oh
- 34:26Jeff Haecker: yes, that was
- 34:28Rob Leonardi: You guys made me so confident.
- 34:31Jeff Haecker: Well you're jumping back and forth between two things,
- 34:33Jeff Haecker: I know
- 34:34Rob Leonardi: I know, I
- 34:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: know.
- 34:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: May not even be in the episode.
- 34:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: That's the fun thing.
- 34:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: In the show
- 34:41Fr. Bryan Shackett: even, right?
- 34:42Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 34:42Fr. Bryan Shackett: Sauron does know Gandalf by name.
- 34:45Jeff Haecker: Yeah, that was
- 34:46Jeff Haecker: yeah.
- 34:46Jeff Haecker: That that
- 34:47Jeff Haecker: took a little bit of like
- 34:48Jeff Haecker: really
- 34:49Jeff Haecker: we're
- 34:49Jeff Haecker: Cause it
- 34:50Jeff Haecker: 'cause they should know e
- 34:51Jeff Haecker: they would know each other by their
- 34:52Jeff Haecker: um
- 34:53Jeff Haecker: or or Gandalf would
- 34:54Jeff Haecker: or Sauron would know Gandalf by his Maiar name, uh
- 34:57Jeff Haecker: Olórin.
- 34:58Jeff Haecker: But
- 35:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: he might know him because uh they do have the thing saying it's been five years and uh Gandalf's been fighting them at every turn.
- 35:05Fr. Bryan Shackett: They had that line in the episode this
- 35:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: right, how
- 35:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: he's been fighting them at every turn.
- 35:09Fr. Bryan Shackett: So maybe that's how
- 35:09Fr. Bryan Shackett: it's
- 35:10Jeff Haecker: the Easter
- 35:10Jeff Haecker: or the Rhûnites
- 35:11Jeff Haecker: though, I think.
- 35:13Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah, no, yeah, definitely.
- 35:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: But there's a chance that
- 35:15Jeff Haecker: I mean he probably has spies, but then
- 35:17Jeff Haecker: how would anyone know?
- 35:19Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 35:19Jeff Haecker: Unless that's what happened to the Harfoots
- 35:21Jeff Haecker: that again that Sauron captured them and
- 35:25Jeff Haecker: You know, gotten that information out of them.
- 35:27Fr. Bryan Shackett: He does that kind of thing, right?
- 35:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: Which
- 35:29Jeff Haecker: quick quick minute one like one minute sidebar.
- 35:31Jeff Haecker: I did not miss the Harfoots at all in this episode.
- 35:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: Not at all.
- 35:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: Not at all.
- 35:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: Not at all
- 35:36Jeff Haecker: And they have said that they're supposedly going to be in it in a smaller, limited capacity, but yeah, did not miss them at all.
- 35:43Jeff Haecker: Um
- 35:44Jeff Haecker: I
- 35:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: I was okay with that not being there.
- 35:45Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought I
- 35:46Fr. Bryan Shackett: in all seriousness, I
- 35:47Fr. Bryan Shackett: no
- 35:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: no
- 35:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: Nothing bad to the actors there.
- 35:50Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought the it flowed better without them there, honestly.
- 35:53Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 35:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought the
- 35:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: whole thing flow better.
- 35:55Jeff Haecker: Yeah, but since
- 35:56Jeff Haecker: let's see, since since we're in mortar,
- 35:58Jeff Haecker: let's maybe wrap up that discussion.
- 36:01Jeff Haecker: Um
- 36:02Jeff Haecker: Yeah, so we we had two scenes of the of the Rhûnites coming in.
- 36:07Jeff Haecker: Um
- 36:08Jeff Haecker: or we had
- 36:09Jeff Haecker: or we had rather two
- 36:10Jeff Haecker: two scenes of of Sauron giving out rings.
- 36:12Jeff Haecker: So the first was of course the Rhûnites
- 36:14Jeff Haecker: coming in their
- 36:15Jeff Haecker: master
- 36:16Jeff Haecker: uh
- 36:17Jeff Haecker: Saruman dark blue wizard whichever one you prefer
- 36:19Patrick Mason: dark blue wizard
- 36:20Jeff Haecker: is
- 36:21Rob Leonardi: but definitely not
- 36:22Rob Leonardi: sar
- 36:23Rob Leonardi: Saruman
- 36:24Rob Leonardi: has
- 36:24Rob Leonardi: sarum
- 36:25Jeff Haecker: has sent them to make
- 36:26Jeff Haecker: make an alliance
- 36:27Jeff Haecker: um
- 36:28Jeff Haecker: Because the elves earlier in the episode, they taught or I think in Galadriel, and maybe in Galadriel's recap, she talks about how there's only two
- 36:35Jeff Haecker: like that Sauron has basically
- 36:37Jeff Haecker: swallowed up all these kingdoms.
- 36:39Jeff Haecker: and realms of
- 36:40Jeff Haecker: of men between and it's really just the elves
- 36:43Jeff Haecker: remaining
- 36:43Jeff Haecker: and the dwarves are kind of staying, you know, they're staying out of the war at the moment.
- 36:48Jeff Haecker: Um
- 36:49Jeff Haecker: And then you have uh
- 36:51Jeff Haecker: you have
- 36:51Jeff Haecker: Rhûn in the east and then Numenor
- 36:53Jeff Haecker: and and Numenor
- 36:54Jeff Haecker: is is staying out
- 36:55Jeff Haecker: as they've
- 36:56Jeff Haecker: um
- 36:56Jeff Haecker: or
- 36:57Jeff Haecker: Elr
- 36:57Jeff Haecker: because I
- 36:58Jeff Haecker: El
- 36:58Jeff Haecker: Ron wants to bring Numenor in.
- 37:00Jeff Haecker: Or
- 37:00Jeff Haecker: Galadriel wants to bring Numenor in and um
- 37:03Jeff Haecker: Elrond says Gil-galad won't hear of it.
- 37:06Jeff Haecker: So it's the Rhûnites are kind of the only one that they think might be in play, um, but they are coming to
- 37:12Jeff Haecker: treat with Mordor.
- 37:14Jeff Haecker: Um
- 37:14Jeff Haecker: and of course, you know, Sauron just immediately s has
- 37:18Jeff Haecker: has them start getting killed and uh, you know, because they're he wants them to pledge allegiance to him so that he can kind of control
- 37:25Jeff Haecker: everything.
- 37:26Jeff Haecker: So what did y'all think of the scene where he offers them
- 37:30Jeff Haecker: offers them a ring, but that Mordor can only spare one
- 37:33Jeff Haecker: this day?
- 37:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: Well apparently
- 37:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: just
- 37:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: that's both times that happens, apparently he has the same spiel
- 37:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: every time we've learned.
- 37:42Rob Leonardi: I think that was more than one day.
- 37:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah.
- 37:45Fr. Bryan Shackett: No, no, yeah.
- 37:46Fr. Bryan Shackett: He's like every time
- 37:46Fr. Bryan Shackett: he clearly
- 37:47Fr. Bryan Shackett: said the same thing both times and it's like
- 37:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: and in the last season when he ha
- 37:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: when, you know
- 37:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: ,
- 37:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: Are you Sauron?
- 37:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: I've gone by
- 37:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: he's the same thing.
- 37:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: I've
- 37:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: I've gone by main
- 37:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: names.
- 37:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: So apparently Sauron only had doesn't think
- 37:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: doesn't have the main
- 37:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: lines he has.
- 37:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: But anyway
- 38:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: All
- 38:02Fr. Bryan Shackett: all respect to Freddy Victor
- 38:03Fr. Bryan Shackett: 's is doing a phenomenal job in the character.
- 38:06Fr. Bryan Shackett: Anyway, I thought it was I mean
- 38:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: Sauron would do that kind of thing.
- 38:09Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought that was in character for what Sauron would do, right?
- 38:12Fr. Bryan Shackett: like
- 38:12Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 38:12Fr. Bryan Shackett: breed hate and resentment amongst
- 38:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: amongst them
- 38:15Fr. Bryan Shackett: ultimately right
- 38:16Fr. Bryan Shackett: by
- 38:16Fr. Bryan Shackett: offering power.
- 38:17Fr. Bryan Shackett: I found it interesting.
- 38:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: He obviously is not being honest with them about what the rings are doing.
- 38:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought that was interesting, right?
- 38:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: He said, Oh, you you
- 38:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: what
- 38:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: you
- 38:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: it allows you to
- 38:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: exist in both this world and then in the in the
- 38:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: in the next world.
- 38:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: Obviously,
- 38:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: sharing
- 38:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: the longer he uses it, he becomes more
- 38:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: less and less himself, right?
- 38:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: So obviously he doesn't
- 38:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: he doesn't share everything, which is
- 38:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: on par for how the Sauron
- 38:41Fr. Bryan Shackett: works.
- 38:41Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 38:41Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought that was interesting.
- 38:42Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought that made sense or how he'd act, right?
- 38:45Fr. Bryan Shackett: And uh
- 38:46Fr. Bryan Shackett: yeah.
- 38:47Fr. Bryan Shackett: It shows that he has
- 38:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: not a plan, I would say, but he ha
- 38:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: his
- 38:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: plan is basically to it
- 38:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: to
- 38:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: let the rings breed the hate in these people.
- 38:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: And then bring it back to these groups to these areas to kind of continue it, right?
- 39:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I
- 39:00Patrick Mason: I rather like
- 39:01Patrick Mason: so
- 39:02Patrick Mason: yes, uh this does hear back to the Dark Knight, but it's also a kind of Hunger Games.
- 39:07Patrick Mason: Um
- 39:08Patrick Mason: that I'd like to
- 39:09Patrick Mason: I'd like to throw out there as well.
- 39:11Patrick Mason: So uh but I did immediately get the Dark Knight reference.
- 39:14Patrick Mason: The you know
- 39:15Patrick Mason: breaks the pool pool cue and throws it at the guys.
- 39:18Patrick Mason: Um
- 39:20Patrick Mason: it's really smart.
- 39:22Patrick Mason: And the reason it's really smart is because
- 39:25Patrick Mason: guaranteed if you give one of those five and let all five walk out
- 39:30Patrick Mason: Then they're immediately gonna start fighting each other for it.
- 39:33Patrick Mason: And you're gonna have this happen on the road home somewhere
- 39:37Patrick Mason: and possibly lose the ring, possibly they all kill each other, right?
- 39:41Patrick Mason: Or
- 39:41Patrick Mason: one of them gets the ring on their finger, becomes, you know, ultra powerful and kills the other
- 39:46Patrick Mason: the other four, but maybe it wasn't the guy you wanted.
- 39:50Patrick Mason: or
- 39:51Patrick Mason: the
- 39:51Patrick Mason: most ruthless guy, right?
- 39:54Patrick Mason: And this is really what this is a test of.
- 39:56Patrick Mason: Who is the most ruthless guy who will be utterly d
- 40:00Patrick Mason: you know
- 40:01Patrick Mason: obedient to me because he killed his fellows to get to get to it?
- 40:05Patrick Mason: And
- 40:05Patrick Mason: I'm gonna give him the ring, so he's the most powerful amongst his brethren, and and there's no chance of them fighting over this on the way home, of this becoming a a point of contention.
- 40:16Patrick Mason: You know, five men enter, one
- 40:17Patrick Mason: man leaves
- 40:18Patrick Mason: Done deal, he's my guy, right?
- 40:20Patrick Mason: This is how you become a champion of Mordor.
- 40:23Patrick Mason: Um, like
- 40:24Patrick Mason: I said, evil
- 40:25Patrick Mason: 's not necessarily dumb.
- 40:28Patrick Mason: It's
- 40:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: No, it's
- 40:30Patrick Mason: stupid.
- 40:31Patrick Mason: But it
- 40:32Patrick Mason: it's gonna be very clever, and this is a very clever play by Sauron.
- 40:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: It's very
- 40:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: very calculating.
- 40:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: And I think I like
- 40:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: I do like that they're showing that part of Sauron, 'cause like, you know, season two was pretty good about that about
- 40:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: showing Sauron's calculating each for
- 40:45Fr. Bryan Shackett: for the most part.
- 40:46Fr. Bryan Shackett: I like this start off showing how he's calculating and trying to breed this in these different groups, these
- 40:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: different areas, right?
- 40:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: And
- 40:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think
- 40:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: because the he's already con
- 40:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: always had all these realms of men, and clearly they're h they're implying that these nozzles
- 40:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: are coming from these various realms, right?
- 41:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: And
- 41:02Fr. Bryan Shackett: I would guess, my prediction, my
- 41:05Fr. Bryan Shackett: prediction, that they're pushing forward to him be
- 41:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: naming himself the king of men.
- 41:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: 'Cause isn't that what eventually causes
- 41:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: Pharazôn to come in because he named himself the king of all men.
- 41:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 41:15Fr. Bryan Shackett: we could be I c I can see that happening, right?
- 41:17Fr. Bryan Shackett: That how they're living up to pushing that.
- 41:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: So we'll see.
- 41:20Fr. Bryan Shackett: I just
- 41:20Fr. Bryan Shackett: I do like that.
- 41:22Rob Leonardi: When we first see the
- 41:23Rob Leonardi: the initial
- 41:25Rob Leonardi: um
- 41:27Rob Leonardi: the initial
- 41:28Rob Leonardi: fighting it out, w
- 41:29Rob Leonardi: there was already three rings missing, right?
- 41:32Rob Leonardi: And one of them w
- 41:33Rob Leonardi: uh
- 41:34Rob Leonardi: we know was from the north.
- 41:37Rob Leonardi: With
- 41:37Rob Leonardi: Los
- 41:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: Loss, yeah.
- 41:39Rob Leonardi: Yeah,
- 41:39Rob Leonardi: because that
- 41:40Rob Leonardi: that's what Gal
- 41:41Rob Leonardi: that's who Galadriel faced.
- 41:44Rob Leonardi: Did they
- 41:44Rob Leonardi: say that
- 41:46Rob Leonardi: Um
- 41:47Rob Leonardi: they were saying that Rhûn and Numenor are the only ones left, right?
- 41:51Rob Leonardi: Instead of
- 41:52Rob Leonardi: the Southlanders
- 41:54Rob Leonardi: fell already.
- 41:56Rob Leonardi: Who was who is the last one to get the ring?
- 41:58Jeff Haecker: Well the Southlanders, I think, already
- 41:59Jeff Haecker: like he could have given one of them a ring too, one of like
- 42:03Jeff Haecker: the s
- 42:03Jeff Haecker: the
- 42:03Jeff Haecker: the faithful
- 42:05Jeff Haecker: uh
- 42:05Jeff Haecker: servants of Mordor or whatever.
- 42:07Jeff Haecker: I don't but the ones that allied with him already were
- 42:10Jeff Haecker: were allied with
- 42:11Jeff Haecker: or they were allied with the Dar, I guess.
- 42:13Jeff Haecker: And then I'm presumably Sauron
- 42:16Jeff Haecker: Took them over.
- 42:16Jeff Haecker: So yeah, you're you're right.
- 42:17Jeff Haecker: I think I think it would make sense that one of them is one of these Southlanders that
- 42:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: makes sense.
- 42:23Jeff Haecker: He probably did a similar thing of like
- 42:25Jeff Haecker: When he comes back and Adar
- 42:27Jeff Haecker: 's gone, you know, he pulled in the five, you know, a group of the leaders and said, you know, one of you, you know, we can give one of you a ring, but not all of you.
- 42:36Jeff Haecker: Um
- 42:38Patrick Mason: Well, and
- 42:39Patrick Mason: It's a very
- 42:40Patrick Mason: um
- 42:41Patrick Mason: so it's a divide and conquer tactic, right?
- 42:43Patrick Mason: And this is the kind of thing, so Julius Caesar coming into
- 42:46Patrick Mason: Gaul, right?
- 42:47Patrick Mason: How do I conquer this this
- 42:49Patrick Mason: huge nation that's, you know
- 42:51Patrick Mason: of all these different tribes, how do I get some of them on my side?
- 42:55Patrick Mason: How do I get others to fight others
- 42:57Patrick Mason: so that I can I can eventually conquer them all?
- 42:59Patrick Mason: And
- 43:00Patrick Mason: you know,
- 43:00Patrick Mason: you see this with the British in India.
- 43:02Patrick Mason: They
- 43:03Patrick Mason: really
- 43:03Patrick Mason: anytime
- 43:04Patrick Mason: a
- 43:05Patrick Mason: semi-smaller but ultimately super powerful
- 43:08Patrick Mason: c
- 43:08Patrick Mason: group wants to go conquer another group.
- 43:11Patrick Mason: And this is the tactic, right?
- 43:13Patrick Mason: And the way he's doing it is
- 43:15Patrick Mason: is
- 43:16Patrick Mason: offering the gifts
- 43:17Patrick Mason: and then bringing them under his sway.
- 43:19Patrick Mason: And
- 43:20Patrick Mason: and slowly, you know, you defeat them enough, then you bring them into the hall, you give them
- 43:25Patrick Mason: something to get them on your side and then
- 43:28Patrick Mason: that promise
- 43:29Patrick Mason: and
- 43:30Patrick Mason: and the immediacy of the power of the ring, right?
- 43:33Patrick Mason: We see when
- 43:34Patrick Mason: um
- 43:35Patrick Mason: Oh
- 43:35Patrick Mason: shoot, I forgot his name.
- 43:37Patrick Mason: But the
- 43:37Patrick Mason: the Rhûn
- 43:38Patrick Mason: ,
- 43:39Patrick Mason: yeah, when he puts the rules
- 43:42Rob Leonardi: or
- 43:44Patrick Mason: it's an immediate thing, right?
- 43:46Patrick Mason: He he is
- 43:47Patrick Mason: taken and immediately given power.
- 43:49Patrick Mason: And the other Nazgûl we're introduced to
- 43:51Patrick Mason: is a relatively new one, right?
- 43:53Patrick Mason: They say, who is this new this new Nazgûl?
- 43:56Patrick Mason: And it's um
- 43:57Patrick Mason: you know the k
- 43:58Patrick Mason: this king who had previously been
- 44:00Patrick Mason: uh
- 44:00Patrick Mason: loyal to us.
- 44:02Patrick Mason: And so
- 44:03Patrick Mason: uh
- 44:03Patrick Mason: it's uh again, it's extremely strategic and tactical on the part of Sauron
- 44:08Patrick Mason: as he's moving through a Region
- 44:10Patrick Mason: and and kind of the world of men to take over
- 44:13Patrick Mason: um
- 44:14Patrick Mason: to try and conquer everything.
- 44:17Jeff Haecker: Yeah, and he's doing the same thing with
- 44:19Jeff Haecker: uh
- 44:20Jeff Haecker: oh
- 44:22Jeff Haecker: Yeah, he's doing the same thing with uh
- 44:24Jeff Haecker: with Numenor trying to reach um
- 44:27Jeff Haecker: uh
- 44:27Jeff Haecker: trying to get the
- 44:28Jeff Haecker: them
- 44:29Jeff Haecker: to come to him and he sends letters and uh envoys to Pelargir.
- 44:33Jeff Haecker: And
- 44:34Jeff Haecker: um
- 44:35Jeff Haecker: they, you know, ki
- 44:36Jeff Haecker: which
- 44:37Jeff Haecker: Kemen obviously rebuffs him.
- 44:39Jeff Haecker: Um
- 44:44Jeff Haecker: not
- 44:45Jeff Haecker: yet
- 44:46Jeff Haecker: um
- 44:46Jeff Haecker: re
- 44:47Jeff Haecker: rebuffs him
- 44:48Jeff Haecker: and
- 44:49Jeff Haecker: um you know
- 44:50Jeff Haecker: and he's and he says he's going home like he's been called home it uh
- 44:53Jeff Haecker: like we don't know if he's been here this whole five years
- 44:56Jeff Haecker: or if he's kind of gone back and forth to Numenor, but
- 44:59Jeff Haecker: um
- 45:00Jeff Haecker: You know, he's he says
- 45:02Jeff Haecker: like
- 45:02Jeff Haecker: uh like kind of like Pharazôn like you were s I think like you were hinting and saying that
- 45:07Jeff Haecker: they think they're better than than Sauron, so they're not gonna deal with him.
- 45:10Jeff Haecker: But you have um
- 45:11Jeff Haecker: poor Theo there
- 45:13Jeff Haecker: gets
- 45:13Jeff Haecker: picks up the letter
- 45:15Jeff Haecker: um
- 45:16Jeff Haecker: and you know
- 45:17Jeff Haecker: see me and they've been treated pretty poorly by the new
- 45:20Jeff Haecker: by the Numenorians this whole this last five years because
- 45:22Jeff Haecker: initially at the end of season two
- 45:24Jeff Haecker: the Numenorians say like
- 45:25Jeff Haecker: Well y'all can stay in Pelargir, you just have to provide a tribute of
- 45:29Jeff Haecker: of X amount of timber so that we can build our, you know, giant invasion fleet.
- 45:34Jeff Haecker: Um
- 45:35Jeff Haecker: And, you know, it sounds okay in theory, but then by the time by this time, like the Numenorians have, you know, it's it's seeming like they're effectively a
- 45:44Jeff Haecker: You know, it's it's like a work camp or prison colony almost.
- 45:47Jeff Haecker: Like you can stay here, but you're gonna be under our, you know, under our strict rule.
- 45:52Jeff Haecker: And you know, Theo gets gets whipped by Numenor.
- 45:56Jeff Haecker: So
- 45:57Jeff Haecker: Um, you know, I
- 45:58Jeff Haecker: I was really
- 45:59Jeff Haecker: you know, I I I really felt bad for Theo
- 46:02Jeff Haecker: like
- 46:02Jeff Haecker: a lot of this season, like he's kind of been or a lot of the series, he's
- 46:06Jeff Haecker: Like I thought he had hoped to kind of be redeemed
- 46:09Jeff Haecker: um
- 46:09Jeff Haecker: eventually as the
- 46:10Jeff Haecker: like he he was kind of the leader of Pelargir and then Numenor came in.
- 46:14Jeff Haecker: And you know, I
- 46:15Jeff Haecker: I'm s I'm not saying it's, you know,
- 46:17Jeff Haecker: O
- 46:18Jeff Haecker: Theo Breaker's off the table completely
- 46:20Jeff Haecker: at this point, but
- 46:22Jeff Haecker: it's seemingly like he's not gonna got
- 46:24Jeff Haecker: not gonna have that redemption.
- 46:26Jeff Haecker: you know, in in a couple thousand years um
- 46:28Jeff Haecker: when he's called to
- 46:30Jeff Haecker: to fight.
- 46:31Jeff Haecker: So
- 46:32Jeff Haecker: um
- 46:33Jeff Haecker: that'll be
- 46:34Jeff Haecker: Yeah, go ahead, Father.
- 46:35Jeff Haecker: I was
- 46:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: gonna say I think it's very unlikely that he's gonna be the
- 46:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: Oathbreaker at this point.
- 46:43Rob Leonardi: Yeah, I think they're gonna have to introduce a new character that will end up being the Oathbreaker
- 46:47Fr. Bryan Shackett: It may
- 46:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: uh
- 46:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: make
- 46:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: sense.
- 46:49Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 46:50Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah, I mean I think that
- 46:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: yeah.
- 46:51Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 46:52Jeff Haecker: Most
- 46:53Jeff Haecker: most
- 46:53Jeff Haecker: likely
- 46:54Jeff Haecker: because
- 46:54Jeff Haecker: um
- 46:55Jeff Haecker: yeah,
- 46:56Jeff Haecker: I just I I just thought that's where they were going.
- 46:58Jeff Haecker: Um
- 46:59Jeff Haecker: quite a bit.
- 46:59Jeff Haecker: So I'm I'm
- 47:00Jeff Haecker: kinda surprised that they're they're going another direction here.
- 47:04Jeff Haecker: But
- 47:04Jeff Haecker: um, you know, seemingly, again, you know, I'm not saying it's completely off the table, but
- 47:09Jeff Haecker: Um, but yeah, it
- 47:11Jeff Haecker: so
- 47:11Jeff Haecker: Theo, you know, just to kind of go back to what happens, Theo
- 47:15Jeff Haecker: takes the letter and the Southlanders do go to Mordor
- 47:19Jeff Haecker: to
- 47:19Jeff Haecker: to answer, and
- 47:21Jeff Haecker: You know, Sauron gives his
- 47:23Jeff Haecker: gives his pitch again of
- 47:25Jeff Haecker: uh
- 47:25Jeff Haecker: we can only spare one ring this day
- 47:28Jeff Haecker: and
- 47:28Jeff Haecker: throws a dagger to them and they start to fight when it cuts to block.
- 47:32Jeff Haecker: So
- 47:32Jeff Haecker: I think we'll circle we'll circle back to the dwarves in a minute, so we're not we're not gonna leave them out.
- 47:36Jeff Haecker: But
- 47:37Jeff Haecker: just
- 47:37Jeff Haecker: if
- 47:38Jeff Haecker: if you have not seen ahead, I don't know who has, but if you have not seen ahead, um
- 47:44Jeff Haecker: Is Theo
- 47:45Jeff Haecker: making it out of there?
- 47:46Jeff Haecker: Is Theo making it out of the out of that room?
- 47:49Rob Leonardi: I think he has to, but he's gonna have to make
- 47:52Rob Leonardi: I mean, why
- 47:53Rob Leonardi: else would you put him
- 47:54Rob Leonardi: in character in a room like that?
- 47:55Rob Leonardi: He th
- 47:56Rob Leonardi: he either is gonna have to make it out somehow, like
- 47:58Rob Leonardi: Through magic, because
- 48:00Rob Leonardi: you know, it's magic, but you know,
- 48:02Rob Leonardi: wrong
- 48:03Rob Leonardi: podcasts.
- 48:03Rob Leonardi: Um
- 48:06Rob Leonardi: or
- 48:07Rob Leonardi: he's gonna have to end up becoming one of the Nasnagigles.
- 48:12Fr. Bryan Shackett: The Nasnick giggles, I like that.
- 48:15Fr. Bryan Shackett: The NASNAGles.
- 48:16Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I would agree.
- 48:17Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 48:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: I have not seen ahead, I've only seen this episode.
- 48:21Fr. Bryan Shackett: film
- 48:21Fr. Bryan Shackett: only by watching this one.
- 48:22Fr. Bryan Shackett: But I would be I'd be very surprised if he can't if he didn't come out because like it's a major character you're gonna
- 48:27Fr. Bryan Shackett: just
- 48:27Fr. Bryan Shackett: off of the first episode.
- 48:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: That'd be surprising.
- 48:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: If it happens, wow, that's a direction I was not
- 48:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: I would not be expecting.
- 48:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: But the uh
- 48:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: I
- 48:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I would imagine he had to come out, right?
- 48:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: You say the truly tragic thing about Theo, I think, is
- 48:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: when he's whipped, you can tell it doesn't
- 48:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: He he he when he he flinches when he's when he's whipped, but he's emotionless, meaning it's happened before.
- 48:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: That's what the implication is, right?
- 48:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: This is not new.
- 48:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: This is not something that's it's random.
- 48:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: It's just happened before.
- 48:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: And
- 48:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think they do a good job at at building up how
- 49:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: the Numenor
- 49:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: the how the King's men are becoming evil.
- 49:04Fr. Bryan Shackett: They've did a decent job
- 49:05Fr. Bryan Shackett: the last season about that, but you can clearly see that's that's coming
- 49:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: clear now too, building that up eventually if
- 49:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: what's gonna come in the future, right?
- 49:12Fr. Bryan Shackett: And um
- 49:13Fr. Bryan Shackett: let alone the horror that Theo is clearly
- 49:16Fr. Bryan Shackett: coming.
- 49:17Fr. Bryan Shackett: And assuming he does become one of the one of the
- 49:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: one of the Nazgûl.
- 49:21Fr. Bryan Shackett: Right.
- 49:22Fr. Bryan Shackett: It's interesting
- 49:22Fr. Bryan Shackett: because the others are kind of seeking power to a certain extent, right?
- 49:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: If h
- 49:27Fr. Bryan Shackett: his
- 49:27Fr. Bryan Shackett: fall is more from
- 49:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: more
- 49:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: from
- 49:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: all this pain that he he's not dealing with and everything, right?
- 49:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: So it'd be a different kind of fall.
- 49:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 49:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: that's the interesting direction to go in, I think.
- 49:37Jeff Haecker: So the qu
- 49:38Jeff Haecker: so
- 49:38Jeff Haecker: question I have is
- 49:39Jeff Haecker: if he
- 49:41Jeff Haecker: You know, if he if he does become a Naz
- 49:43Jeff Haecker: a Nazgangul, is he going to become a Naz
- 49:46Jeff Haecker: ghoul?
- 49:46Jeff Haecker: Like will he can he be redeemed if he puts the ring on and and you know
- 49:49Jeff Haecker: merges into the
- 49:51Jeff Haecker: you know, seen an unseen
- 49:53Jeff Haecker: world kind of like Khamûl
- 49:54Jeff Haecker: did, is there a path r
- 49:57Jeff Haecker: backward for him to give that power up?
- 50:01Rob Leonardi: So
- 50:02Rob Leonardi: it
- 50:02Rob Leonardi: I mean, I think obviously th there's the hope for redemption for everybody
- 50:06Rob Leonardi: if they turn around and and
- 50:08Rob Leonardi: are
- 50:09Rob Leonardi: sincerely contrite, right?
- 50:11Rob Leonardi: But at the end of the day, if he is going to do that, is he what?
- 50:14Rob Leonardi: Is he gonna be like, okay, here's your ring back
- 50:18Rob Leonardi: Like
- 50:19Rob Leonardi: I
- 50:21Fr. Bryan Shackett: would even say there's something deeper there, like the
- 50:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: at least in Tolkien's mentality, like if he
- 50:25Fr. Bryan Shackett: to get this, he kind of has to sell his soul.
- 50:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: Right?
- 50:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: To a certain extent
- 50:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: and and bind his soul to
- 50:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: this unnatural force.
- 50:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: So I like
- 50:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: while there's always hope for redemption until we die,
- 50:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: It would seem that
- 50:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: if he binds his will and soul to the ring and thus to Sauron, it'd be
- 50:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: very challenging without the intervention of the Valar
- 50:47Fr. Bryan Shackett: or
- 50:47Fr. Bryan Shackett: you know, Gandalf or somebody to
- 50:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: heal that, right?
- 50:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: That be
- 50:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean
- 50:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: some
- 50:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: there'd have to be some kind of divine intervention to heal that heal that that selling that he's done.
- 50:57Patrick Mason: Yeah.
- 50:57Patrick Mason: So
- 50:57Patrick Mason: I I haven't I haven't
- 50:59Patrick Mason: washed ahead either.
- 51:00Patrick Mason: I
- 51:00Patrick Mason: I think it's possible he dies.
- 51:03Patrick Mason: Um
- 51:03Patrick Mason: it would be
- 51:05Patrick Mason: I I almost kind of would rather he died
- 51:08Patrick Mason: than see him turn into a Nazgul.
- 51:11Patrick Mason: Um
- 51:12Patrick Mason: because
- 51:13Patrick Mason: so
- 51:13Patrick Mason: and
- 51:13Patrick Mason: I'll put it this way.
- 51:16Rob Leonardi: He can go meet his mom.
- 51:21Patrick Mason: Him becoming a Naz
- 51:22Patrick Mason: or a Naznagul
- 51:24Patrick Mason: and then
- 51:25Patrick Mason: somehow finding his way back to redemption.
- 51:28Patrick Mason: Now that's an interesting plot.
- 51:30Patrick Mason: Uh and so if if if he does end up with the ring, I do hope there's a way
- 51:34Patrick Mason: and
- 51:35Patrick Mason: I think there is a way back.
- 51:36Patrick Mason: I think it involves like
- 51:38Patrick Mason: probably
- 51:38Patrick Mason: having the ring cut or a bit off your finger, uh, and taken by somebody else, and then you having to be kind of like
- 51:46Patrick Mason: brought back by, you know, the healing efforts of another
- 51:50Patrick Mason: And the way I you know how that would work, I'm I'm not exactly certain.
- 51:54Patrick Mason: I figured, you know, Gandalf or Bombadil or somebody would be involved 'cause
- 51:58Patrick Mason: magic.
- 51:59Patrick Mason: Um
- 52:00Patrick Mason: but it it very much uh
- 52:02Patrick Mason: you know
- 52:03Patrick Mason: all these rings
- 52:05Patrick Mason: from
- 52:06Patrick Mason: you know the lore, at least, other than the elven ones, have that draw.
- 52:12Patrick Mason: Like
- 52:12Patrick Mason: Like, not just that I own it, but it owns me, right?
- 52:16Patrick Mason: And
- 52:16Patrick Mason: and we saw like
- 52:17Patrick Mason: the strength of will it took to build for Bilbo to get rid of the ring, and Bilbo never thought he was using
- 52:22Patrick Mason: you know, the Dark Lord's
- 52:24Patrick Mason: power.
- 52:24Patrick Mason: He was just hiding from the Sackville Bagginses on occasion.
- 52:28Patrick Mason: You know, it was
- 52:29Patrick Mason: it wasn't
- 52:30Patrick Mason: I'm gonna use
- 52:31Patrick Mason: N
- 52:32Patrick Mason: If Theo becomes a Nazgul, he's gonna then go right
- 52:35Patrick Mason: off and kill
- 52:36Patrick Mason: Numenori.
- 52:37Patrick Mason: He's gonna do terrible things in the name of Sauron, like guaranteed.
- 52:40Patrick Mason: So
- 52:41Patrick Mason: Uh uh
- 52:42Patrick Mason: I you know the the path to redemption becomes extremely difficult, right?
- 52:45Patrick Mason: It's the
- 52:46Patrick Mason: well you fall you fell into this really, really, really deep pit.
- 52:50Patrick Mason: So
- 52:50Patrick Mason: I mean there's a way out, and it but it's gonna take a lot of climbing
- 52:54Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 52:55Jeff Haecker: And
- 52:55Jeff Haecker: one
- 52:56Jeff Haecker: so one thing that m
- 52:57Jeff Haecker: makes me think uh
- 52:58Jeff Haecker: that this brings up is
- 53:00Jeff Haecker: we saw a kind of a
- 53:02Jeff Haecker: a
- 53:02Jeff Haecker: and it's a different it's different because he's a dwarf, but King Durin
- 53:06Jeff Haecker: He
- 53:07Jeff Haecker: he c
- 53:08Jeff Haecker: overcame the ring madness
- 53:09Jeff Haecker: for the most part at the end.
- 53:11Jeff Haecker: And he
- 53:12Jeff Haecker: and it was I think it was through the love of his son
- 53:16Jeff Haecker: And the love of his
- 53:17Jeff Haecker: his people and
- 53:18Jeff Haecker: his mountain that he was able to turn away from it.
- 53:21Jeff Haecker: So
- 53:22Jeff Haecker: uh
- 53:23Rob Leonardi: I think that they were
- 53:24Rob Leonardi: the
- 53:25Rob Leonardi: The
- 53:25Rob Leonardi: rings themselves are a different type of power pr
- 53:29Rob Leonardi: depending on the
- 53:30Rob Leonardi: like
- 53:31Rob Leonardi: the nine rings are
- 53:32Rob Leonardi: are
- 53:32Rob Leonardi: different than the elven
- 53:33Rob Leonardi: rings, right?
- 53:34Rob Leonardi: They're different than the elven rings.
- 53:37Jeff Haecker: We've seen a path
- 53:39Jeff Haecker: uh for redemption from someone who's worn a ring.
- 53:42Jeff Haecker: And again, granted the rings of men were meant to enslave them.
- 53:47Jeff Haecker: A lot
- 53:48Jeff Haecker: and men are eat
- 53:49Jeff Haecker: you know, we know men are more tempted and whereas
- 53:51Jeff Haecker: dwarves the rings kind of seem to magnify just
- 53:54Jeff Haecker: magnify just their greed.
- 53:55Jeff Haecker: Um
- 53:56Jeff Haecker: so
- 53:57Jeff Haecker: It's not one
- 53:58Jeff Haecker: to one, but it's you know
- 54:00Jeff Haecker: it's it's potential there.
- 54:01Jeff Haecker: So but yeah, I think you're right.
- 54:03Jeff Haecker: If if Theo does take the ring and becoming
- 54:05Jeff Haecker: now as Nigal
- 54:06Jeff Haecker: I think it would be
- 54:08Jeff Haecker: I think you're right, Pat.
- 54:09Jeff Haecker: It would be much more interesting if he struggles with it.
- 54:12Jeff Haecker: And if he if he does find a a path to redemption
- 54:17Jeff Haecker: um
- 54:18Jeff Haecker: later.
- 54:19Jeff Haecker: And I mean
- 54:20Jeff Haecker: just
- 54:21Rob Leonardi: he's specifically doing it to to get rid of Numenor.
- 54:24Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 54:24Rob Leonardi: Right.
- 54:25Jeff Haecker: Well and this
- 54:26Jeff Haecker: and this makes me think
- 54:27Jeff Haecker: too
- 54:28Jeff Haecker: If he somehow turns the ring down, like eventually either, you know, it's taken from him or whatever, he he does turn away from
- 54:35Jeff Haecker: if he does get the ring and turns away
- 54:37Jeff Haecker: He's part of that unseen
- 54:39Jeff Haecker: he's kind of been partially brought to that unseen
- 54:41Jeff Haecker: world.
- 54:42Jeff Haecker: Is that a way
- 54:44Jeff Haecker: that he might become a king of the dead?
- 54:47Jeff Haecker: Like
- 54:48Jeff Haecker: So I
- 54:49Jeff Haecker: and I'm not joking.
- 54:49Jeff Haecker: I'm not
- 54:50Jeff Haecker: I'm not just making a joke.
- 54:51Jeff Haecker: I'm serious.
- 54:57Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 54:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: I don't think it is.
- 54:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: I love the idea, but I don't think it is.
- 54:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm sorry.
- 55:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm gonna
- 55:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: gong
- 55:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: up.
- 55:02Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean but I
- 55:03Fr. Bryan Shackett: 'm
- 55:04Rob Leonardi: okay.
- 55:04Rob Leonardi: I I can see if he becomes a Nazna
- 55:06Rob Leonardi: giggle that he can easily get a
- 55:09Rob Leonardi: a
- 55:09Rob Leonardi: horde of people behind him and they can s
- 55:12Rob Leonardi: they can effectively surround him as a king, right?
- 55:16Rob Leonardi: Especially because I think last
- 55:18Rob Leonardi: last season was really trying to push him to being like the
- 55:22Jeff Haecker: He was the Lord of
- 55:23Jeff Haecker: Flare.
- 55:24Rob Leonardi: Yeah, the
- 55:25Rob Leonardi: Lord of Pelargir, but at the same time, he's a
- 55:27Rob Leonardi: he's a Sutherling, so like there's no
- 55:29Rob Leonardi: direct like
- 55:30Rob Leonardi: he's going to actually be able to do it.
- 55:33Rob Leonardi: Yeah.
- 55:33Rob Leonardi: Unless the Southern Lings
- 55:35Rob Leonardi: actually like name him as king
- 55:37Rob Leonardi: and
- 55:38Rob Leonardi: which
- 55:38Rob Leonardi: which they
- 55:39Rob Leonardi: could do, but after killing four of the people he went with, I don't know.
- 55:43Rob Leonardi: Um
- 55:44Rob Leonardi: Well,
- 55:46Fr. Bryan Shackett: you can just do that.
- 55:53Patrick Mason: You know, oppressing him, oppressing his people, and
- 55:56Patrick Mason: you know, all around being not not great people.
- 55:59Patrick Mason: And
- 56:00Patrick Mason: but
- 56:01Patrick Mason: At some point
- 56:02Patrick Mason: he does
- 56:03Patrick Mason: let's say he's able to pull that off, right, for Sauron.
- 56:06Patrick Mason: Then Sauron's gonna make him go kill people he doesn't care about.
- 56:10Patrick Mason: Like, I
- 56:11Patrick Mason: why am I killing these elves?
- 56:12Patrick Mason: Like they remind me of Arondir.
- 56:13Patrick Mason: Like he'll have the same
- 56:15Patrick Mason: um
- 56:16Patrick Mason: conscious problem that Arondir
- 56:18Patrick Mason: has uh
- 56:19Patrick Mason: killing you know
- 56:20Patrick Mason: the men.
- 56:21Patrick Mason: And so I I can see that playing out on uh Theo's conscious if he is an
- 56:26Patrick Mason: acul
- 56:28Patrick Mason: And then that
- 56:29Patrick Mason: leading to him kind of rejecting Sauron.
- 56:31Patrick Mason: But then at the end of the day, like uh
- 56:33Patrick Mason: uh
- 56:34Patrick Mason: if he's in charge of a bunch of people who have to go fight
- 56:37Patrick Mason: uh
- 56:38Patrick Mason: with
- 56:38Patrick Mason: Gondor
- 56:39Patrick Mason: against Sauron, Gondor is just Numenor
- 56:43Patrick Mason: writ
- 56:43Patrick Mason: later
- 56:44Patrick Mason: and heck with those guys.
- 56:46Patrick Mason: I don't like them either.
- 56:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah.
- 56:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean I
- 56:50Fr. Bryan Shackett: m
- 56:50Fr. Bryan Shackett: I just
- 56:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: I just keep thinking like uh
- 56:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I don't know.
- 56:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean what
- 56:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: he's sold
- 56:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: he's basic
- 56:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: he's basically
- 56:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: selling his soul, right?
- 56:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: So it's like
- 56:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: There's a binding that he's done and willingly.
- 57:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: And if he takes it like
- 57:02Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm not saying it's impossible, but it's one of those things where you'd have to have some kind of
- 57:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: like
- 57:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: Valar
- 57:09Fr. Bryan Shackett: or, you know, Gandalf or some kind of like
- 57:11Patrick Mason: Tom Bombadil.
- 57:15Rob Leonardi: They would need a priest.
- 57:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: But like some
- 57:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: some like divine intervention here, someone with authority
- 57:22Fr. Bryan Shackett: to act uh
- 57:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: in it to undo that, right?
- 57:25Fr. Bryan Shackett: And I
- 57:25Fr. Bryan Shackett: and
- 57:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean
- 57:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: the Valor actively are not intervening, so I guess Gandalf could do it, but the
- 57:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 57:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: the
- 57:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: uh
- 57:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: or Grand
- 57:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: Elf, forgive me
- 57:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: Could do it.
- 57:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: But the um
- 57:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: oh
- 57:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: no, I mean
- 57:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: I w
- 57:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think his fall is more tragic, so if you go for a tragic fall
- 57:41Fr. Bryan Shackett: you could
- 57:41Fr. Bryan Shackett: you could clarify his fall in the Lamarcy
- 57:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: being a tragic fall compared to the others, right?
- 57:45Fr. Bryan Shackett: More sympathetic.
- 57:46Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think I can see like go back and forth
- 57:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: will
- 57:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: will
- 57:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: he or won't he go all the way?
- 57:50Fr. Bryan Shackett: And then have like a tragic call at the end if he goes all the way and becomes that, you know.
- 57:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: I can see that.
- 57:54Rob Leonardi: Although uh
- 57:55Rob Leonardi: to your point
- 57:56Rob Leonardi: or to
- 57:56Rob Leonardi: what you said, but a different point, is that it does set up a really good foreshadowing to what he is going to be doing if he is the Oathbreaker King.
- 58:04Rob Leonardi: that
- 58:05Rob Leonardi: hey, he's doing this to sell his soul.
- 58:07Rob Leonardi: He's going to, you know, and
- 58:09Rob Leonardi: effectively
- 58:10Rob Leonardi: br
- 58:10Rob Leonardi: break the bonds that he creates
- 58:12Rob Leonardi: of
- 58:13Rob Leonardi: uh, you know, the
- 58:14Rob Leonardi: not the selling of the soul, but but the
- 58:16Rob Leonardi: um
- 58:17Rob Leonardi: kind of like the exact opposite
- 58:19Rob Leonardi: with a
- 58:20Rob Leonardi: Isildur, and then he's left as
- 58:24Rob Leonardi: The King of the Dead.
- 58:26Rob Leonardi: Alright, Jeff, you have
- 58:27Rob Leonardi: you have convinced me.
- 58:29Rob Leonardi: He's back on the table.
- 58:30Jeff Haecker: I've
- 58:30Jeff Haecker: swayed
- 58:31Jeff Haecker: you
- 58:32Jeff Haecker: I've swayed you to my to my side using rings.
- 58:34Jeff Haecker: Um
- 58:39Jeff Haecker: So yeah, let's uh so yeah, we'll we'll definitely see what happens there.
- 58:42Jeff Haecker: So yeah, let's uh move on to I think the
- 58:45Jeff Haecker: you know the other main plot line of this
- 58:47Jeff Haecker: of this episode was of the Dwarven
- 58:50Jeff Haecker: Game of Thrones.
- 58:51Jeff Haecker: So
- 58:52Jeff Haecker: We uh you know, as
- 58:53Jeff Haecker: hinted at the end of season two, that
- 58:56Jeff Haecker: there was there's a
- 58:57Jeff Haecker: you know
- 58:58Jeff Haecker: a contestment uh
- 59:00Jeff Haecker: and contesting of the throne with Thrain
- 59:02Jeff Haecker: being out there, and we actually get to see him
- 59:05Jeff Haecker: this episode.
- 59:05Jeff Haecker: So what do y'all think of uh
- 59:08Jeff Haecker: of Thrain's appear, you know, first appearance here
- 59:11Jeff Haecker: and
- 59:11Jeff Haecker: um
- 59:12Jeff Haecker: and what what that might imply for the rest of uh of this season.
- 59:17Fr. Bryan Shackett: I wanna take the justice
- 59:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: step
- 59:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: back
- 59:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: just before we see thrain.
- 59:21Fr. Bryan Shackett: We do for
- 59:22Fr. Bryan Shackett: the first time
- 59:22Fr. Bryan Shackett: have a bearded a bearded dwarf woman.
- 59:25Fr. Bryan Shackett: That
- 59:25Fr. Bryan Shackett: should
- 59:25Fr. Bryan Shackett: be.
- 59:26Jeff Haecker: But she had it done.
- 59:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: True.
- 59:30Rob Leonardi: And a dwarf
- 59:30Rob Leonardi: without a beard.
- 59:31Patrick Mason: The beardless.
- 59:32Jeff Haecker: Balber
- 59:33Jeff Haecker: the beardless.
- 59:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: The beardless.
- 59:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: So it's like, okay.
- 59:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean
- 59:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: Tolkien did say the door
- 59:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: that Dwarven Woman had beards, so you know that's a that's
- 59:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: he did
- 59:41Rob Leonardi: say that.
- 59:41Fr. Bryan Shackett: But
- 59:42Fr. Bryan Shackett: any
- 59:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: the um
- 59:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: I don't know.
- 59:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean so I I
- 59:45Fr. Bryan Shackett: I again I thought the Dwarven Line was very
- 59:47Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought that storyline's very interesting.
- 59:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: It seems like they're they're pulling up the uh
- 59:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 59:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: Like playing at
- 59:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: the I
- 59:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: say
- 59:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: this is rolling
- 59:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: them
- 59:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: to
- 59:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: the [inaudible]
- 59:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: words
- 59:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: ,
- 59:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: I say
- 59:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: this is playing
- 59:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: allies.
- 1:00:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: So it's definitely
- 1:00:02Fr. Bryan Shackett: what the
- 1:00:04Fr. Bryan Shackett: elves, right?
- 1:00:05Fr. Bryan Shackett: They're supplying weapons to the elves
- 1:00:06Fr. Bryan Shackett: before they enter the war.
- 1:00:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 1:00:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: playing up that historical thing.
- 1:00:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought that was uh interesting.
- 1:00:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: Um
- 1:00:12Fr. Bryan Shackett: I
- 1:00:13Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I thought I
- 1:00:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: thought they're gonna play up a whole thing about Thrain coming to, you know, like try to take power.
- 1:00:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: I was
- 1:00:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: surprised
- 1:00:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: when he supported the king and like
- 1:00:20Fr. Bryan Shackett: told everybody to go that direction.
- 1:00:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought uh
- 1:00:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought that was an interesting scientist
- 1:00:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: is
- 1:00:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: is
- 1:00:27Fr. Bryan Shackett: obviously the
- 1:00:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: hasn't already
- 1:00:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: moved
- 1:00:38Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 1:00:39Jeff Haecker: What about you, Pat?
- 1:00:40Jeff Haecker: What do you think of the dwarves as our as our resident
- 1:00:42Jeff Haecker: uh bearded uh
- 1:00:44Patrick Mason: bearded man here?
- 1:00:46Patrick Mason: No, sorry.
- 1:00:47Patrick Mason: Um
- 1:00:48Patrick Mason: uh
- 1:00:49Patrick Mason: the dancing on the table
- 1:00:52Patrick Mason: Uh
- 1:00:52Patrick Mason: I thought Thrain's introduction was pretty good.
- 1:00:54Patrick Mason: I, you know, he is
- 1:00:56Patrick Mason: who he is, which is, I think, you know, kind of the way
- 1:01:00Patrick Mason: Rurd older
- 1:01:01Patrick Mason: son.
- 1:01:01Patrick Mason: uh who's
- 1:01:02Patrick Mason: who's returned home.
- 1:01:03Patrick Mason: I think it's very interesting that they're playing a game of, you know, a version of Regicide.
- 1:01:08Patrick Mason: Um
- 1:01:09Patrick Mason: obviously we all call that chess, but you know the ultimate goal is to kill the king.
- 1:01:13Patrick Mason: Um
- 1:01:14Patrick Mason: and
- 1:01:15Patrick Mason: so, you know, across all of the different fandoms, I just refer to that
- 1:01:19Patrick Mason: those kind of games as as regicides.
- 1:01:21Patrick Mason: Uh
- 1:01:22Patrick Mason: and
- 1:01:23Patrick Mason: th
- 1:01:23Patrick Mason: that's effectively the game they're sort of playing each other
- 1:01:27Patrick Mason: um
- 1:01:27Patrick Mason: being writ
- 1:01:28Patrick Mason: small
- 1:01:29Patrick Mason: uh on the screen when they're talking about their father's death.
- 1:01:32Patrick Mason: Uh I
- 1:01:33Patrick Mason: so I thought that was
- 1:01:34Patrick Mason: very clever.
- 1:01:35Patrick Mason: I thought it was a very interesting thread
- 1:01:38Patrick Mason: that apparently Disa
- 1:01:39Patrick Mason: and him were
- 1:01:41Patrick Mason: something, although Disa
- 1:01:42Patrick Mason: seems to be playing it down as hard as she possibly could while Thrain was playing it up as hard as uh
- 1:01:49Patrick Mason: as
- 1:01:50Patrick Mason: he could.
- 1:01:51Patrick Mason: So I don't know, you know, the truth is probably somewhere in the middle
- 1:01:54Patrick Mason: I don't know if there was a
- 1:01:56Patrick Mason: uh
- 1:01:57Patrick Mason: you know if they were flames.
- 1:02:00Patrick Mason: I assume prior
- 1:02:02Rob Leonardi: It was an arrangement.
- 1:02:03Patrick Mason: Yeah, well, and that's another thing.
- 1:02:04Patrick Mason: Like I
- 1:02:06Patrick Mason: I don't know how
- 1:02:07Patrick Mason: it's so I
- 1:02:08Patrick Mason: I'm interested to see how that plays in.
- 1:02:10Patrick Mason: Uh
- 1:02:11Patrick Mason: I
- 1:02:12Patrick Mason: I did like the introduction of
- 1:02:14Patrick Mason: um
- 1:02:15Patrick Mason: the children
- 1:02:16Patrick Mason: or the teenagers
- 1:02:18Patrick Mason: now
- 1:02:18Jeff Haecker: The Waynes.
- 1:02:19Jeff Haecker: I think
- 1:02:20Jeff Haecker: the Wains, I think.
- 1:02:21Patrick Mason: And
- 1:02:22Patrick Mason: although they didn't get much screen time, uh they were on there, so uh it does look like they're going to do something over the course of the season
- 1:02:29Patrick Mason: I thought they were set.
- 1:02:31Patrick Mason: that they were gonna do something.
- 1:02:32Patrick Mason: Uh
- 1:02:32Patrick Mason: I also like
- 1:02:33Patrick Mason: I really like the discussion already playing out about the rings, right?
- 1:02:38Patrick Mason: That y
- 1:02:38Patrick Mason: you know, it is
- 1:02:40Patrick Mason: It's very much
- 1:02:42Patrick Mason: reminiscent of any
- 1:02:44Patrick Mason: time
- 1:02:44Patrick Mason: uh you have a new sort of weapon or something else on the playing field.
- 1:02:48Patrick Mason: Like, do we
- 1:02:49Patrick Mason: Do we go this route to make sure that we're keeping up with everybody else?
- 1:02:53Patrick Mason: Uh, or do we not touch it because this thing is, you know, evil?
- 1:02:58Patrick Mason: And
- 1:02:59Patrick Mason: uh, you know, there's the two
- 1:03:02Patrick Mason: The blue dwar
- 1:03:02Patrick Mason: are the iron hills and the blue hills
- 1:03:05Patrick Mason: uh
- 1:03:05Patrick Mason: dwarf are or blue mountains dwarf, they're both of the opinion that they paid for the rings, they
- 1:03:10Patrick Mason: want their rings.
- 1:03:11Patrick Mason: And you know, we can't
- 1:03:13Patrick Mason: be falling behind the humans and the elves.
- 1:03:15Patrick Mason: And uh
- 1:03:16Patrick Mason: Durin
- 1:03:17Patrick Mason: is like, no, you don't know what this thing does.
- 1:03:19Patrick Mason: Like it's it's gonna drive you nuts.
- 1:03:21Patrick Mason: And it's interesting to see that play out.
- 1:03:24Patrick Mason: I
- 1:03:24Patrick Mason: obviously we're not to the end of the road yet.
- 1:03:26Patrick Mason: I am very curious, you know, because they have a little like
- 1:03:30Patrick Mason: you know, this season on
- 1:03:32Patrick Mason: uh
- 1:03:32Patrick Mason: Rings of Power, all the stuff they show, so they show, you know, some
- 1:03:37Rob Leonardi: I purposely
- 1:03:38Rob Leonardi: did not watch
- 1:03:38Rob Leonardi: that.
- 1:03:39Patrick Mason: I don't think I realized we were at the end of the episode until I was like how
- 1:03:43Patrick Mason: I was like, wait a minute, this is moving really fast.
- 1:03:45Patrick Mason: Um
- 1:03:46Patrick Mason: but
- 1:03:47Patrick Mason: uh I think they showcased some stuff
- 1:03:50Patrick Mason: Definitely a lot of playing going on.
- 1:03:52Patrick Mason: I don't know if it's gonna be
- 1:03:54Patrick Mason: like
- 1:03:54Patrick Mason: direct
- 1:03:55Patrick Mason: um
- 1:03:56Patrick Mason: kind of between
- 1:03:58Patrick Mason: I I d
- 1:03:59Patrick Mason: I don't know how it's gonna play out.
- 1:04:00Patrick Mason: I'm just very, very
- 1:04:02Patrick Mason: interested, and that means they did a good job.
- 1:04:05Patrick Mason: Um
- 1:04:07Jeff Haecker: Yeah, and they also
- 1:04:08Jeff Haecker: they also note
- 1:04:09Jeff Haecker: that um
- 1:04:10Jeff Haecker: they don't say what happened to King Durin.
- 1:04:12Jeff Haecker: They say
- 1:04:13Jeff Haecker: that it was a Balrog, they say it was a mining accident.
- 1:04:16Jeff Haecker: Um
- 1:04:17Jeff Haecker: But
- 1:04:18Jeff Haecker: Durin does tell Thrain the truth, so
- 1:04:22Jeff Haecker: you know, that's something to kind of
- 1:04:24Jeff Haecker: consider
- 1:04:25Jeff Haecker: that
- 1:04:26Jeff Haecker: Thrain maybe has some intel now that
- 1:04:28Jeff Haecker: uh
- 1:04:29Jeff Haecker: because
- 1:04:30Jeff Haecker: he does uh he does kind of give
- 1:04:32Jeff Haecker: Ben
- 1:04:32Jeff Haecker: the need
- 1:04:33Jeff Haecker: to durin
- 1:04:34Jeff Haecker: in front of the other lords, but then kind of behind the scenes he's kind of
- 1:04:38Jeff Haecker: maybe
- 1:04:39Jeff Haecker: starting to like
- 1:04:40Jeff Haecker: you know
- 1:04:41Jeff Haecker: do his own thing
- 1:04:43Jeff Haecker: against Durin.
- 1:04:44Jeff Haecker: So
- 1:04:45Jeff Haecker: that's just something
- 1:04:46Jeff Haecker: to kind of keep an eye on
- 1:04:47Jeff Haecker: is he
- 1:04:48Jeff Haecker: Is
- 1:04:49Jeff Haecker: Durin did tell Thrain the truth?
- 1:04:50Jeff Haecker: Because Durin, I
- 1:04:51Jeff Haecker: I think Durin like one th
- 1:04:53Jeff Haecker: the thing I like about Durin and Dwarves
- 1:04:55Jeff Haecker: generally is that they're
- 1:04:56Jeff Haecker: They're very forthcoming and they tell the truth.
- 1:04:58Jeff Haecker: They don't
- 1:04:59Jeff Haecker: they're not playing, you know, they're not they're not keeping secrets and playing games
- 1:05:03Jeff Haecker: really.
- 1:05:04Jeff Haecker: Um
- 1:05:04Jeff Haecker: and it makes sense to kind of
- 1:05:06Jeff Haecker: that you don't want to panic your entire kingdom by saying there's a Balrog next door.
- 1:05:11Jeff Haecker: Right.
- 1:05:12Jeff Haecker: And they
- 1:05:12Jeff Haecker: and they probably don't know what exactly would happen to it.
- 1:05:14Jeff Haecker: Like if it disap
- 1:05:15Jeff Haecker: if it, you know, ran deep
- 1:05:17Jeff Haecker: deep in the roots of the mountain or something.
- 1:05:19Jeff Haecker: Like you're not gonna go chase it
- 1:05:21Jeff Haecker: because
- 1:05:21Jeff Haecker: why would you do that?
- 1:05:23Jeff Haecker: And you're not in you know,
- 1:05:24Jeff Haecker: group of dwarves isn't gonna kill a Balrog.
- 1:05:26Jeff Haecker: So
- 1:05:27Jeff Haecker: you know, I think it makes sense that they don't tell that, but I think
- 1:05:31Jeff Haecker: I think it, you know,
- 1:05:32Jeff Haecker: uh
- 1:05:33Jeff Haecker: Thrain seems to be kind of playing both
- 1:05:35Jeff Haecker: playing both
- 1:05:36Jeff Haecker: playing his own game, uh, to, you know, maybe maneuver himself into position.
- 1:05:41Jeff Haecker: Um
- 1:05:42Jeff Haecker: So
- 1:05:43Jeff Haecker: I think that'll be something interesting to like will that intel that will that
- 1:05:47Jeff Haecker: intel that he knows about the king
- 1:05:49Jeff Haecker: play into
- 1:05:51Jeff Haecker: You know,
- 1:05:52Jeff Haecker: play into
- 1:05:52Jeff Haecker: something.
- 1:05:52Jeff Haecker: Cause he because when Thrain comes in, he doesn't come with the other lords into the hall
- 1:05:57Jeff Haecker: to you know
- 1:05:58Jeff Haecker: bend the knee and whatnot.
- 1:05:59Jeff Haecker: He goes to the pub.
- 1:06:01Jeff Haecker: So like he's obviously disres
- 1:06:02Jeff Haecker: he's disrespecting
- 1:06:04Jeff Haecker: his
- 1:06:04Jeff Haecker: brother
- 1:06:05Jeff Haecker: right from the outset.
- 1:06:06Jeff Haecker: And he kind of plays it off
- 1:06:08Jeff Haecker: um
- 1:06:09Jeff Haecker: and
- 1:06:10Jeff Haecker: you know, poor Narvi has to run back and forth.
- 1:06:14Jeff Haecker: This dwarfs
- 1:06:14Rob Leonardi: is so bad for him.
- 1:06:16Jeff Haecker: Dwarves are natural sprinters.
- 1:06:17Jeff Haecker: They're not
- 1:06:18Jeff Haecker: they don't have the st
- 1:06:18Jeff Haecker: the stamina
- 1:06:19Jeff Haecker: for long distances.
- 1:06:22Jeff Haecker: Yeah, so you
- 1:06:23Jeff Haecker: had to say
- 1:06:23Jeff Haecker: he had to run back and forth sadly.
- 1:06:25Jeff Haecker: Um
- 1:06:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: I
- 1:06:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: really loved that part of it.
- 1:06:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I was thinking, you know
- 1:06:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: I
- 1:06:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: I f
- 1:06:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: I f
- 1:06:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: I feel for the guy.
- 1:06:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: It's like we're back and forth.
- 1:06:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: Back and forth.
- 1:06:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: Back and forth.
- 1:06:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: I was like, you know, I've been there and it's like
- 1:06:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I I
- 1:06:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: love at the end how
- 1:06:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: he said
- 1:06:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: Can you send someone else to
- 1:06:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: go tell them?
- 1:06:45Fr. Bryan Shackett: I do agree that they're clearly building up more for the thrain
- 1:06:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: and I I thought this
- 1:06:49Fr. Bryan Shackett: I th that's why I
- 1:06:50Fr. Bryan Shackett: like
- 1:06:50Fr. Bryan Shackett: They're building up this character, building up where he's gonna do, maybe stuff he can do with the um
- 1:06:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: try to claim the throne, things like that.
- 1:06:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 1:06:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 1:06:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: It's if they're doing it well, there could be a or
- 1:07:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: could be a fun version of the Dwarven Game of Thrones
- 1:07:03Fr. Bryan Shackett: going on here.
- 1:07:04Fr. Bryan Shackett: That could be interesting, right?
- 1:07:05Fr. Bryan Shackett: And obviously the rings get sent out.
- 1:07:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: Obviously, we know they go to the other dwarves.
- 1:07:09Fr. Bryan Shackett: Obviously, we know that's gonna happen.
- 1:07:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: M
- 1:07:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: at least in the lore
- 1:07:12Fr. Bryan Shackett: it does.
- 1:07:13Fr. Bryan Shackett: So I'm curious
- 1:07:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: how's
- 1:07:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: is he gonna play into that?
- 1:07:15Fr. Bryan Shackett: So you're gonna play into getting these rings and spraying the rings out more, you know, maybe
- 1:07:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: Possibly.
- 1:07:19Rob Leonardi: Well it is it
- 1:07:20Rob Leonardi: is it
- 1:07:21Rob Leonardi: was it established that Thrain already is in the Lonely Mountain?
- 1:07:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: It didn't say w
- 1:07:27Fr. Bryan Shackett: he's from the blue but he's from the Blue Mountains?
- 1:07:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: No.
- 1:07:29Jeff Haecker: It just said that he had been gone from
- 1:07:32Jeff Haecker: I don't think it said one way or the other
- 1:07:33Jeff Haecker: where he was
- 1:07:34Jeff Haecker: it just said he had been gone from Cause of Doom for a long time
- 1:07:37Jeff Haecker: and he hadn't spoken to his father in
- 1:07:40Jeff Haecker: in
- 1:07:41Jeff Haecker: many years, so
- 1:07:44Jeff Haecker: They may have said where he was, I don't remember, but um
- 1:07:47Jeff Haecker: yeah,
- 1:07:48Jeff Haecker: definitely something and
- 1:07:49Jeff Haecker: and it you know it comes up at the end too when they're
- 1:07:51Jeff Haecker: cause d
- 1:07:52Jeff Haecker: cause Thrain
- 1:07:53Jeff Haecker: is
- 1:07:53Jeff Haecker: Thrain
- 1:07:54Jeff Haecker: spies on Durin that he was trading, you know, giving
- 1:07:58Jeff Haecker: Giving
- 1:07:58Jeff Haecker: reference
- 1:07:59Jeff Haecker: to
- 1:07:59Jeff Haecker: yeah, sword
- 1:08:00Jeff Haecker: running to uh
- 1:08:01Jeff Haecker: to the elves
- 1:08:02Jeff Haecker: um
- 1:08:03Jeff Haecker: when they're trying to kind of stay because if
- 1:08:05Jeff Haecker: because
- 1:08:05Jeff Haecker: they're they're staying, you know, they're they're staying out of the war, but if Mordor
- 1:08:09Jeff Haecker: found out they were supplying the elves
- 1:08:12Jeff Haecker: you know, that could be
- 1:08:14Jeff Haecker: bad news for the dwarves.
- 1:08:15Jeff Haecker: And
- 1:08:17Jeff Haecker: and we know you know, we know at some point, you know, at least it's
- 1:08:20Jeff Haecker: it
- 1:08:21Jeff Haecker: it's we know at least from some of the stuff they've said in the
- 1:08:23Jeff Haecker: that the Balrog
- 1:08:25Jeff Haecker: will come back
- 1:08:25Jeff Haecker: and will
- 1:08:26Jeff Haecker: be an ally of sorts to Sauron.
- 1:08:28Jeff Haecker: So
- 1:08:28Rob Leonardi: Well yeah, he kills Gandalf.
- 1:08:30Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 1:08:31Jeff Haecker: Well I mean in the Will
- 1:08:32Jeff Haecker: not
- 1:08:33Patrick Mason: fellowship.
- 1:08:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: Here
- 1:08:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: 's the question, Jeff.
- 1:08:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: Like, did
- 1:08:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: you think
- 1:08:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: do would the uh
- 1:08:42Fr. Bryan Shackett: would the dwarves
- 1:08:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: know
- 1:08:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: what the Balrog is?
- 1:08:47Jeff Haecker: I don't know.
- 1:08:48Rob Leonardi: They know
- 1:08:48Rob Leonardi: what Mithril
- 1:08:49Rob Leonardi: came from, so.
- 1:08:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: Okay, well.
- 1:08:53Jeff Haecker: I thought that was an Elven
- 1:08:54Jeff Haecker: that was a tale from the Elves of what Mithril
- 1:08:56Jeff Haecker: was.
- 1:08:57Jeff Haecker: I could be wrong.
- 1:08:58Jeff Haecker: It's been a while since I watched season one.
- 1:09:01Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 1:09:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: The aren't the all the vows from the
- 1:09:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: first air
- 1:09:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: first
- 1:09:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: age, the the ball
- 1:09:12Fr. Bryan Shackett: wags of course, right?
- 1:09:13Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm just curious like would these 'cause none of these there were there, so I'm curious if these know what it is.
- 1:09:17Fr. Bryan Shackett: Because they never actually say what it is.
- 1:09:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: We know what it is.
- 1:09:20Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm curious if they don't really know.
- 1:09:22Patrick Mason: It's possible
- 1:09:23Patrick Mason: Durin does
- 1:09:24Patrick Mason: because
- 1:09:25Patrick Mason: it
- 1:09:25Patrick Mason: if you went and consulted like
- 1:09:27Patrick Mason: 'cause you've always got those folks, right, with
- 1:09:29Patrick Mason: w whatever kingdom who keep the lore books
- 1:09:32Patrick Mason: and and know about the old histories, whether or not they believe it, right?
- 1:09:36Patrick Mason: And it takes
- 1:09:37Patrick Mason: You know, it takes Gandalf years of digging through the Gondorian scrolls to finally figure out, oh, this is what Durin's Bane
- 1:09:43Patrick Mason: was
- 1:09:44Patrick Mason: and
- 1:09:45Patrick Mason: and
- 1:09:45Patrick Mason: put the two pieces together.
- 1:09:47Patrick Mason: So
- 1:09:48Patrick Mason: Whether Durin ever figured it out is is kind of an open question in my mind.
- 1:09:53Patrick Mason: But none of the other dwarfs
- 1:09:54Patrick Mason: saw it, and he's not telling them about it.
- 1:09:56Patrick Mason: And so there's no like
- 1:09:58Patrick Mason: There'd be no like
- 1:09:59Patrick Mason: wisened old library
- 1:10:00Patrick Mason: master sitting over in the corner and and Durin describes it and he's like,
- 1:10:04Patrick Mason: I know what that is, um, because he's he hasn't told anybody.
- 1:10:07Patrick Mason: Um
- 1:10:08Jeff Haecker: Yeah, or he's
- 1:10:09Jeff Haecker: or he talks to Elrond about it and
- 1:10:12Jeff Haecker: because
- 1:10:12Jeff Haecker: Elrond would
- 1:10:13Jeff Haecker: I think Elrond as as a lore keeper
- 1:10:15Jeff Haecker: would know
- 1:10:17Jeff Haecker: what a Balrog
- 1:10:18Jeff Haecker: is
- 1:10:18Jeff Haecker: uh from the Tales of the First Age.
- 1:10:20Jeff Haecker: So he might have talked to Elrond about it
- 1:10:22Rob Leonardi: too.
- 1:10:23Rob Leonardi: If
- 1:10:24Rob Leonardi: if the dwarves
- 1:10:25Rob Leonardi: would have known that Khazad-dûm had a Balrog underneath, would
- 1:10:30Rob Leonardi: they have gone to resettle
- 1:10:32Rob Leonardi: um
- 1:10:33Rob Leonardi: cause
- 1:10:34Rob Leonardi: doom after the hobbit
- 1:10:36Rob Leonardi: dwarfs
- 1:10:36Rob Leonardi: went.
- 1:10:40Patrick Mason: I'm just
- 1:10:41Jeff Haecker: yeah, and that's
- 1:10:42Rob Leonardi: fair.
- 1:10:43Jeff Haecker: And that's like, you know, close to three thousand years after
- 1:10:46Jeff Haecker: or more after this, so they would, you know
- 1:10:50Jeff Haecker: like
- 1:10:51Patrick Mason: Yeah it
- 1:10:52Jeff Haecker: like you said, if it's an old tale that they may not believe and they're like, oh that's just an old, you know
- 1:10:56Jeff Haecker: old
- 1:10:57Jeff Haecker: ghost story and we don't believe it.
- 1:10:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah, I mean it may it's called Durin's Bang 'cause it slays
- 1:11:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: Durin, right?
- 1:11:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 1:11:02Fr. Bryan Shackett: they
- 1:11:02Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean that
- 1:11:03Fr. Bryan Shackett: that's how it's known, so
- 1:11:04Patrick Mason: and
- 1:11:05Fr. Bryan Shackett: No, in the law
- 1:11:06Rob Leonardi: it slays Duran and then it slays Durin and then it slays Duran.
- 1:11:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: Well I was thinking, I mean it's called Durin's Bane, so in the show, and uh
- 1:11:13Fr. Bryan Shackett: obviously in the
- 1:11:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: lore
- 1:11:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: you're not supposed to have two Durins in the same time, it's a whole thing.
- 1:11:17Fr. Bryan Shackett: But
- 1:11:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 1:11:19Rob Leonardi: Which
- 1:11:19Rob Leonardi: which
- 1:11:19Rob Leonardi: I think they they try to recon
- 1:11:21Rob Leonardi: it if you uh with the um
- 1:11:23Rob Leonardi: durin saying that he heard his father speak to him
- 1:11:26Rob Leonardi: I think they tried that's that's how they tried to retcon it a bit.
- 1:11:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: Really?
- 1:11:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: How can you retcon it?
- 1:11:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: They were live at the same time.
- 1:11:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: It's like this is
- 1:11:32Rob Leonardi: but like
- 1:11:32Rob Leonardi: the
- 1:11:33Rob Leonardi: I guess like the the the
- 1:11:35Rob Leonardi: I don't know.
- 1:11:36Rob Leonardi: I'm trying to
- 1:11:37Rob Leonardi: I'm trying to like it, okay?
- 1:11:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: This is not Saruman, okay?
- 1:11:41Fr. Bryan Shackett: This is not Saruman, just in case we're wondering here, right?
- 1:11:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: It's
- 1:11:44Rob Leonardi: the spirit of Elijah, okay?
- 1:11:48Rob Leonardi: Elisha got double portion of the spirit of Elijah.
- 1:11:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: Okay, alright, alright, okay, okay.
- 1:11:54Patrick Mason: So yeah
- 1:11:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: the um
- 1:11:56Patrick Mason: Yeah.
- 1:11:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah.
- 1:11:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: Okay.
- 1:11:58Patrick Mason: Well and and you gotta remember, by the time of the Hobbit, even Sauron
- 1:12:01Patrick Mason: is a distant myth of the past, right?
- 1:12:05Patrick Mason: Like like he
- 1:12:05Fr. Bryan Shackett: That's true.
- 1:12:06Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah, they don't
- 1:12:06Fr. Bryan Shackett: only if you know
- 1:12:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: who
- 1:12:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: the
- 1:12:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: only thing
- 1:12:09Patrick Mason: a Balrog is like
- 1:12:10Patrick Mason: that's just a word that doesn't
- 1:12:12Patrick Mason: what is that nonsense word that you said?
- 1:12:13Patrick Mason: What does that even mean, right?
- 1:12:15Patrick Mason: Like
- 1:12:15Patrick Mason: cause that's first
- 1:12:16Patrick Mason: age stuff.
- 1:12:19Jeff Haecker: But
- 1:12:20Jeff Haecker: yeah, so
- 1:12:21Jeff Haecker: it'll be interesting to see what happens with uh with the dwarves there and and yeah, as
- 1:12:25Jeff Haecker: as we hinted uh or as we said
- 1:12:27Jeff Haecker: um
- 1:12:28Jeff Haecker: You know, Thrain
- 1:12:29Jeff Haecker: and Thrain, you know, has that moment with
- 1:12:32Jeff Haecker: Disa
- 1:12:32Jeff Haecker: where they that hints at a past
- 1:12:34Jeff Haecker: and uh
- 1:12:35Jeff Haecker: their son sees it um
- 1:12:37Jeff Haecker: and she kind of plays it off.
- 1:12:38Jeff Haecker: So, you know, there's something there too, I think.
- 1:12:41Jeff Haecker: To kind of watch out for.
- 1:12:42Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think they're I think that's gonna
- 1:12:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I think that's adding to the point of showing that Thrain does have ulterior motives here.
- 1:12:48Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think he's gonna try something.
- 1:12:50Fr. Bryan Shackett: And I'm thinking it's gonna be
- 1:12:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: I know we're all thinking
- 1:12:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: maybe
- 1:12:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: taking the throne.
- 1:12:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think he's not gonna get the throne, but I think he's gonna get the rings.
- 1:12:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think he's gonna be the reason the rings are gonna are gonna gigget
- 1:12:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: spread out, I think.
- 1:13:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: That's my prediction.
- 1:13:02Jeff Haecker: Yeah, very well could be.
- 1:13:06Patrick Mason: I think something is going to happen to Durin.
- 1:13:09Patrick Mason: Not necessarily that his brother causes
- 1:13:11Patrick Mason: to happen, but something's gonna happen to Durin that incapacitates him
- 1:13:15Patrick Mason: Or
- 1:13:16Patrick Mason: he he has to go somewhere or something and Thrain
- 1:13:19Patrick Mason: steps in
- 1:13:20Patrick Mason: uh
- 1:13:20Patrick Mason: at that point
- 1:13:21Patrick Mason: and then yeah the rings go out.
- 1:13:23Patrick Mason: I don't necessarily
- 1:13:24Rob Leonardi: Or Bob
- 1:13:25Rob Leonardi: and the
- 1:13:25Rob Leonardi: goblin
- 1:13:26Rob Leonardi: decides to share the rings out.
- 1:13:28Rob Leonardi: Because
- 1:13:30Patrick Mason: it's always going to be
- 1:13:31Patrick Mason: I don't like that.
- 1:13:36Patrick Mason: I don't like that idea.
- 1:13:39Patrick Mason: That's a no for you.
- 1:13:41Patrick Mason: No
- 1:13:41Patrick Mason: Yeah.
- 1:13:42Patrick Mason: 'Cause it
- 1:13:42Patrick Mason: the real question is,
- 1:13:44Patrick Mason: you know, if Durin's the only one who knows where they are, then assuming
- 1:13:48Patrick Mason: he tells his brother
- 1:13:50Patrick Mason: Or
- 1:13:51Patrick Mason: his
- 1:13:51Patrick Mason: brother's gotta find out somehow in order to spread them.
- 1:13:53Patrick Mason: But I think that
- 1:13:54Patrick Mason: I think you're right, uh, Father Brian.
- 1:13:56Patrick Mason: I think they're gonna go out through
- 1:13:58Patrick Mason: uh
- 1:13:58Patrick Mason: Thrain.
- 1:14:00Patrick Mason: The question is, it what's
- 1:14:01Patrick Mason: what is
- 1:14:02Patrick Mason: how does that look?
- 1:14:02Patrick Mason: And I think it's gonna
- 1:14:04Patrick Mason: look like an official act while Durin is somehow incapacitated.
- 1:14:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'd agree with
- 1:14:09Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think that makes a lot of sense, honestly.
- 1:14:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: I really do.
- 1:14:12Jeff Haecker: Awesome.
- 1:14:13Jeff Haecker: And
- 1:14:13Jeff Haecker: yeah, I think
- 1:14:14Jeff Haecker: um
- 1:14:15Jeff Haecker: you know
- 1:14:16Jeff Haecker: just
- 1:14:16Jeff Haecker: I figure when we spend a couple minutes kind of discussing
- 1:14:19Jeff Haecker: uh
- 1:14:20Jeff Haecker: some
- 1:14:20Jeff Haecker: speculation.
- 1:14:22Jeff Haecker: One note I had is in the
- 1:14:24Jeff Haecker: in the
- 1:14:24Jeff Haecker: the uh
- 1:14:25Jeff Haecker: we didn't
- 1:14:26Jeff Haecker: we talked a little bit about the L's and
- 1:14:28Jeff Haecker: and such and we we have to kind of wrap up here shortly.
- 1:14:31Jeff Haecker: Um, but we in the flashback to Celeborn and Galadriel's first meeting, um
- 1:14:35Jeff Haecker: we did, you know, when they were having their kind of their fight, we did see
- 1:14:40Jeff Haecker: him
- 1:14:40Jeff Haecker: cut hair from her head, which is kind of a big deal if you think back to the Silmarillion
- 1:14:45Jeff Haecker: where she wouldn't give uh
- 1:14:46Jeff Haecker: lock uh uh a strand of her hair to Fëanor
- 1:14:49Jeff Haecker: Um
- 1:14:51Jeff Haecker: and
- 1:14:51Rob Leonardi: then a foreshadowing that she did give a
- 1:14:53Rob Leonardi: couple
- 1:14:54Rob Leonardi: strands to Gimli.
- 1:14:56Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 1:14:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I
- 1:14:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: liked I liked Celeborn.
- 1:15:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: I liked seeing him.
- 1:15:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: I
- 1:15:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: I
- 1:15:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean the actor did a great job, I thought.
- 1:15:03Fr. Bryan Shackett: And we not
- 1:15:03Fr. Bryan Shackett: it wasn't much, of course, but I I like seeing it.
- 1:15:05Fr. Bryan Shackett: And I think they're trying to build up that Galadriel
- 1:15:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: does actually love
- 1:15:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: love him.
- 1:15:09Fr. Bryan Shackett: Right, because it
- 1:15:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: by giving
- 1:15:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: giving him
- 1:15:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think that's what they're going for.
- 1:15:13Fr. Bryan Shackett: Again, I was in love.
- 1:15:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: Go back to what you said earlier, Pat.
- 1:15:16Fr. Bryan Shackett: I wasn't in love with the whole like uh
- 1:15:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: Like how was
- 1:15:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: I
- 1:15:19Fr. Bryan Shackett: dancing, I was fighting.
- 1:15:20Fr. Bryan Shackett: It's like
- 1:15:21Fr. Bryan Shackett: alright, fine, whatever.
- 1:15:22Fr. Bryan Shackett: But the uh
- 1:15:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 1:15:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: I wasn't in love with that whole thing.
- 1:15:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: I would have been more in favor of
- 1:15:26Fr. Bryan Shackett: she was this way, losing him
- 1:15:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: caused her to become like I would have been more along those lines, but the uh
- 1:15:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 1:15:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean I love the fact that
- 1:15:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: they'll they both love each other.
- 1:15:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: The love story between Celeborn and Galadriel
- 1:15:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: is a very famous one, a very, very big one, so hopefully they do that justice.
- 1:15:41Patrick Mason: I I absolutely love the uh
- 1:15:43Patrick Mason: crouching tiger, hidden dragon
- 1:15:46Patrick Mason: uh
- 1:15:46Patrick Mason: sequence that we got.
- 1:15:47Rob Leonardi: I really did.
- 1:15:48Rob Leonardi: And I was gonna go
- 1:15:49Rob Leonardi: shun
- 1:15:50Rob Leonardi: it.
- 1:15:51Jeff Haecker: Yeah, I did
- 1:15:52Jeff Haecker: it's it was very woo
- 1:15:53Jeff Haecker: like whooshia martial art
- 1:15:54Jeff Haecker: uh like
- 1:15:54Jeff Haecker: kung
- 1:15:55Jeff Haecker: fu
- 1:15:55Jeff Haecker: felt
- 1:15:56Jeff Haecker: like
- 1:15:56Jeff Haecker: fantasy.
- 1:15:57Patrick Mason: Um but I absolutely loved it
- 1:15:58Patrick Mason: because it it showcased
- 1:16:00Patrick Mason: It that and the dancing scene and the fact that the one
- 1:16:03Patrick Mason: the both were intermingled.
- 1:16:05Patrick Mason: Um
- 1:16:05Patrick Mason: and and Celeborn
- 1:16:06Patrick Mason: played up
- 1:16:07Patrick Mason: the sort of
- 1:16:09Patrick Mason: elvin
- 1:16:10Patrick Mason: otherworldliness very well.
- 1:16:11Patrick Mason: That actor did an extremely good job of doing that.
- 1:16:14Patrick Mason: And
- 1:16:15Patrick Mason: this
- 1:16:16Patrick Mason: that scene was possibly the most Galadriel scene we've gotten out of this series.
- 1:16:21Fr. Bryan Shackett: Oh yeah, totally.
- 1:16:22Patrick Mason: By far.
- 1:16:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: Very totally.
- 1:16:24Patrick Mason: Um
- 1:16:24Patrick Mason: again, like problems with her being
- 1:16:27Patrick Mason: and yes, her
- 1:16:27Patrick Mason: is she
- 1:16:28Patrick Mason: set up
- 1:16:28Patrick Mason: because her brother died that she becomes the way she is, supposedly, and
- 1:16:33Patrick Mason: none of that makes any sense.
- 1:16:34Patrick Mason: But uh
- 1:16:35Patrick Mason: okay.
- 1:16:35Patrick Mason: But this part was really good.
- 1:16:37Patrick Mason: Uh
- 1:16:38Patrick Mason: I
- 1:16:38Patrick Mason: really enjoyed it.
- 1:16:39Patrick Mason: Um
- 1:16:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: It was.
- 1:16:40Patrick Mason: Yeah, uh
- 1:16:41Patrick Mason: that's all I can say.
- 1:16:42Patrick Mason: It it was very it was very well done across the board.
- 1:16:45Patrick Mason: as a scene, uh
- 1:16:46Patrick Mason: cinematography was great.
- 1:16:48Patrick Mason: And
- 1:16:48Patrick Mason: again, the, you know, kung fu
- 1:16:51Patrick Mason: was
- 1:16:52Patrick Mason: was
- 1:16:52Patrick Mason: was fun
- 1:16:54Fr. Bryan Shackett: It was fun.
- 1:16:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: I I do like the seeming, and this is I think
- 1:16:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: I do think this is good.
- 1:16:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: I mean
- 1:16:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: the calming presence that Celeborn clearly seems to have upon Galadriel even at that even in that brief moment there, right?
- 1:17:05Fr. Bryan Shackett: And
- 1:17:06Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought that was a cool addition
- 1:17:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: and
- 1:17:08Fr. Bryan Shackett: obviously
- 1:17:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: when he comes back, 'cause obviously we're gonna see him more, obviously he's gonna come back.
- 1:17:13Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think it's a
- 1:17:15Fr. Bryan Shackett: it's clearly gonna have an impact.
- 1:17:16Fr. Bryan Shackett: So we'll see how that plays out.
- 1:17:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm
- 1:17:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: very interested to see how that plays out.
- 1:17:20Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 1:17:21Jeff Haecker: I'm
- 1:17:22Jeff Haecker: Yeah, uh
- 1:17:23Jeff Haecker: it
- 1:17:23Jeff Haecker: one
- 1:17:24Jeff Haecker: it's one of the annoying things about the c
- 1:17:25Jeff Haecker: time compression in the show
- 1:17:27Jeff Haecker: is
- 1:17:28Jeff Haecker: like
- 1:17:28Jeff Haecker: there should be
- 1:17:30Jeff Haecker: Like they should have had a child by now because Elrond
- 1:17:33Jeff Haecker: has to marry that child.
- 1:17:34Jeff Haecker: So
- 1:17:34Jeff Haecker: I I had initially thought a while back that they were going to have like
- 1:17:38Jeff Haecker: Celeborn had gone away with their child to keep
- 1:17:42Jeff Haecker: the child safe during this
- 1:17:44Jeff Haecker: war that Galadriel was fighting.
- 1:17:46Jeff Haecker: Um
- 1:17:47Jeff Haecker: but they've obviously have
- 1:17:50Rob Leonardi: it's only been five years since El
- 1:17:51Rob Leonardi: Ron kissed her, so they're gonna have to take a little more time than that.
- 1:17:55Jeff Haecker: Yeah, but
- 1:17:56Jeff Haecker: I think
- 1:17:57Jeff Haecker: um
- 1:17:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: just
- 1:18:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: no.
- 1:18:02Jeff Haecker: So I don't know.
- 1:18:03Jeff Haecker: I thought that's what
- 1:18:03Jeff Haecker: they might do something along those lines
- 1:18:05Jeff Haecker: and
- 1:18:05Jeff Haecker: that we would
- 1:18:06Jeff Haecker: like that we would have seen
- 1:18:08Jeff Haecker: um
- 1:18:09Jeff Haecker: You know, th
- 1:18:10Jeff Haecker: th there would be a hint of of Celebrían being born at this point, but
- 1:18:13Jeff Haecker: um
- 1:18:14Jeff Haecker: you know, they only have about
- 1:18:15Jeff Haecker: they have about three hundred or so years, 'cause I think Arwen's born in like
- 1:18:19Jeff Haecker: 200, third age 200 or something like that.
- 1:18:22Fr. Bryan Shackett: That's still pretty young for
- 1:18:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: L.
- 1:18:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: Yeah.
- 1:18:28Jeff Haecker: I know, I'm just saying.
- 1:18:29Jeff Haecker: I think that
- 1:18:30Jeff Haecker: that's just an interesting aspect of the Celeborn
- 1:18:32Jeff Haecker: and
- 1:18:33Jeff Haecker: uh
- 1:18:33Jeff Haecker: Galadriel thing uh in this series.
- 1:18:36Jeff Haecker: And then
- 1:18:36Jeff Haecker: yeah, just uh you know
- 1:18:38Jeff Haecker: we'll we can do a quick like lightning round speculation of just what
- 1:18:41Jeff Haecker: something you want to speculate on.
- 1:18:43Jeff Haecker: I I'm gonna still maintain that
- 1:18:45Jeff Haecker: This season will end with like they're gonna do the five season thing that we've been that I've been saying for years
- 1:18:50Jeff Haecker: that this season will be
- 1:18:52Jeff Haecker: end with Sauron's capture by Numenor, season four Akallabêth, and season five
- 1:18:56Jeff Haecker: Last Alliance.
- 1:18:57Jeff Haecker: And
- 1:18:57Jeff Haecker: At this point, they haven't
- 1:18:59Jeff Haecker: said whether season four or five are ordered and are coming
- 1:19:02Jeff Haecker: are for sure.
- 1:19:03Jeff Haecker: Um, but I think with it being kind of a one of the
- 1:19:06Jeff Haecker: Jeff Bezos
- 1:19:07Jeff Haecker: ' pet projects, it will
- 1:19:08Jeff Haecker: so.
- 1:19:09Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'd be very surprised giving us money they're spending at this th
- 1:19:11Fr. Bryan Shackett: yeah.
- 1:19:11Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 1:19:12Jeff Haecker: And if it's like actually turning
- 1:19:13Jeff Haecker: like if it's if it's it's been getting better every season, so
- 1:19:16Fr. Bryan Shackett: That's true.
- 1:19:17Jeff Haecker: I think that's huge.
- 1:19:18Jeff Haecker: It's
- 1:19:18Jeff Haecker: like it's it's showing great it's like
- 1:19:20Jeff Haecker: it it's sh
- 1:19:21Jeff Haecker: i and I've liked it the whole way, but
- 1:19:23Jeff Haecker: I feel like this is a much better season overall so far.
- 1:19:26Jeff Haecker: And I I have seen the first four, so I think it's
- 1:19:29Jeff Haecker: it's by far
- 1:19:30Jeff Haecker: just a more even season than the past.
- 1:19:32Jeff Haecker: So
- 1:19:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: you can tell that honestly even in the first episode, I think, right?
- 1:19:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: You can I think you can tell it's more even the
- 1:19:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: The pacing is a little better than the
- 1:19:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: than the other
- 1:19:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: zip, honestly.
- 1:19:41Fr. Bryan Shackett: Um
- 1:19:42Fr. Bryan Shackett: yeah, because
- 1:19:42Fr. Bryan Shackett: those
- 1:19:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: were
- 1:19:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: pacing was was a mess.
- 1:19:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: And I I thought the pacing was better this episode.
- 1:19:46Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought the overall setup of the plots made sense in the sense like they set
- 1:19:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: a thing up, they
- 1:19:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: they introduced you
- 1:19:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: ideas.
- 1:19:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: I thought they did a good job at that.
- 1:19:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: Um the cinetography was decent, I thought.
- 1:19:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: So I do think
- 1:19:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: and I think I
- 1:19:58Fr. Bryan Shackett: know you said this
- 1:19:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: earlier, Charlie Vickers
- 1:20:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 1:20:00Fr. Bryan Shackett: Sauron
- 1:20:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: playing an amazing role.
- 1:20:02Fr. Bryan Shackett: He's doing a great job at that, I would say.
- 1:20:04Fr. Bryan Shackett: He's
- 1:20:05Fr. Bryan Shackett: One of the standouts I think for the whole series
- 1:20:07Fr. Bryan Shackett: is his playing of Sauron, I would argue.
- 1:20:09Fr. Bryan Shackett: Um honestly.
- 1:20:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: So
- 1:20:10Fr. Bryan Shackett: yeah.
- 1:20:12Fr. Bryan Shackett: But if we're if we're if we're diving do we dive in
- 1:20:14Fr. Bryan Shackett: I have a prediction.
- 1:20:15Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm gonna throw up.
- 1:20:16Fr. Bryan Shackett: Go for it.
- 1:20:17Jeff Haecker: Call your shot, father.
- 1:20:18Fr. Bryan Shackett: I don't know if this makes any sense, but here's my prediction.
- 1:20:22Fr. Bryan Shackett: How
- 1:20:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: um
- 1:20:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: Okay, Theo, if he's, you know, he gets the ring, he doesn't get the ring, whatever.
- 1:20:29Fr. Bryan Shackett: He gets the ring.
- 1:20:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: That's my first prediction.
- 1:20:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: Maybe I'm wrong.
- 1:20:32Fr. Bryan Shackett: I have not seen anything else, but
- 1:20:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: you wrong.
- 1:20:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: Then
- 1:20:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: some of the health fails, and
- 1:20:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: The rink gets caught off his finger, something happens, and the Kemen
- 1:20:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: dude takes Theo's ring.
- 1:20:41Fr. Bryan Shackett: And then becomes a
- 1:20:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: uh
- 1:20:44Fr. Bryan Shackett: A Nazgul.
- 1:20:45Jeff Haecker: The Witch Kemen.
- 1:20:46Jeff Haecker: The Witch Kemen.
- 1:20:47Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm not sure.
- 1:20:51Fr. Bryan Shackett: He's gonna be a Nazgul, right?
- 1:20:52Fr. Bryan Shackett: Alright?
- 1:20:53Fr. Bryan Shackett: How can he not be at this point?
- 1:20:55Fr. Bryan Shackett: The uh um
- 1:20:56Fr. Bryan Shackett: that's my prediction.
- 1:20:57Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think that's good.
- 1:20:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: Safe prediction, best of my prediction.
- 1:21:01Fr. Bryan Shackett: Any
- 1:21:01Jeff Haecker: anything powder, Rob, that you wanna you wanna
- 1:21:03Jeff Haecker: a shot you wanna call right now?
- 1:21:04Patrick Mason: Uh I so
- 1:21:05Patrick Mason: I don't want to call it a shot because I think I've already caught I've already laid out most of my predictions, but I do want to mention it
- 1:21:11Jeff Haecker: That
- 1:21:11Jeff Haecker: star
- 1:21:12Jeff Haecker: I'm on is the dark blue wizard.
- 1:21:15Patrick Mason: There's no Gandalf.
- 1:21:17Patrick Mason: It's not the
- 1:21:17Patrick Mason: you know, it's not
- 1:21:18Patrick Mason: yeah.
- 1:21:19Patrick Mason: Um
- 1:21:20Patrick Mason: yeah, I think
- 1:21:21Patrick Mason: it
- 1:21:22Patrick Mason: it was really
- 1:21:23Patrick Mason: it was really amazing to see Beleriand.
- 1:21:26Patrick Mason: In
- 1:21:27Patrick Mason: and
- 1:21:28Patrick Mason: because
- 1:21:28Patrick Mason: Beleriand to me is on a map.
- 1:21:30Patrick Mason: And I've never thought about it as like a
- 1:21:33Patrick Mason: I don't know, it's weird.
- 1:21:34Patrick Mason: It's I've never really visualized it.
- 1:21:37Patrick Mason: in that way and it was it was kind of wonderful to see
- 1:21:40Patrick Mason: Galadriel and Celeborn just sort of sitting there looking out upon it, describing how beautiful it is, and describing what they would do, you know, what
- 1:21:48Patrick Mason: they will eventually do with Lothlórien
- 1:21:51Patrick Mason: uh
- 1:21:51Patrick Mason: and
- 1:21:52Patrick Mason: and just how beautiful it is
- 1:21:54Patrick Mason: and
- 1:21:55Patrick Mason: we get an immediate well not immediate but in the same episode
- 1:21:58Patrick Mason: juxtaposition with Kemen
- 1:22:01Patrick Mason: Calling it just a dreadful place.
- 1:22:03Patrick Mason: Like this
- 1:22:04Patrick Mason: what a dreadful or what a
- 1:22:06Patrick Mason: I think
- 1:22:07Patrick Mason: something like that.
- 1:22:07Patrick Mason: What a terrible place.
- 1:22:08Patrick Mason: Like
- 1:22:08Patrick Mason: I had to talk to a stupid tree about cutting down his forest and then
- 1:22:13Patrick Mason: you could hear him howling from like miles away.
- 1:22:16Patrick Mason: And
- 1:22:16Patrick Mason: and just the dis
- 1:22:17Patrick Mason: the utter disdain that
- 1:22:19Patrick Mason: the you know the kingsmen, the Numenorians have for Middle Earth.
- 1:22:23Patrick Mason: Whereas the elves
- 1:22:25Patrick Mason: very much love
- 1:22:27Patrick Mason: it.
- 1:22:27Patrick Mason: And it's it's a very different view.
- 1:22:30Patrick Mason: And you have, you know, and the third party Sauron
- 1:22:33Patrick Mason: who
- 1:22:33Patrick Mason: neither
- 1:22:34Patrick Mason: he doesn't
- 1:22:35Patrick Mason: And
- 1:22:36Patrick Mason: and
- 1:22:36Patrick Mason: uh
- 1:22:37Patrick Mason: he gets this laid out by his
- 1:22:39Patrick Mason: uh
- 1:22:40Patrick Mason: uh
- 1:22:41Patrick Mason: Kellebor, you know, Celebrimbor
- 1:22:43Patrick Mason: on the shoulder.
- 1:22:44Patrick Mason: you know, he he
- 1:22:45Patrick Mason: he doesn't love.
- 1:22:46Patrick Mason: He's got something broken with his internal machinery of his soul.
- 1:22:51Patrick Mason: And I love that image
- 1:22:52Patrick Mason: because Sauron
- 1:22:53Patrick Mason: is a
- 1:22:53Patrick Mason: is one of Oromë's
- 1:22:55Patrick Mason: or not Oromë's um
- 1:22:56Patrick Mason: Aulë's
- 1:22:57Patrick Mason: of Fallen
- 1:22:58Patrick Mason: Meyer.
- 1:22:58Patrick Mason: So he's so, you know, this idea that he can't make the connections
- 1:23:03Patrick Mason: he would really need to love
- 1:23:05Patrick Mason: others
- 1:23:06Patrick Mason: and so he just seeks control.
- 1:23:08Patrick Mason: So his
- 1:23:09Patrick Mason: he neither loves nor hates Middle Earth.
- 1:23:11Patrick Mason: He just wants to control it
- 1:23:13Patrick Mason: And it's sort of this three-piece
- 1:23:15Patrick Mason: model, right?
- 1:23:16Patrick Mason: With the elves who love Middle-earth
- 1:23:19Patrick Mason: too much, the
- 1:23:21Patrick Mason: uh
- 1:23:21Patrick Mason: you know, the Numenorians who hate it
- 1:23:24Patrick Mason: really.
- 1:23:25Patrick Mason: as something, you know, belie beneath them or below them and Sauron
- 1:23:28Patrick Mason: who just wants it.
- 1:23:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: And you
- 1:23:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: almost see
- 1:23:31Fr. Bryan Shackett: building up to the eventual
- 1:23:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: int
- 1:23:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: introduction of the faithful Numenorians being like a midprime between some of these groups, right?
- 1:23:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: Like the faith
- 1:23:39Fr. Bryan Shackett: the the faithful, like uh
- 1:23:40Fr. Bryan Shackett: the ones showing the proper way of
- 1:23:42Fr. Bryan Shackett: navigating all that.
- 1:23:43Fr. Bryan Shackett: I think
- 1:23:44Patrick Mason: the faithful stewards of the garden, right?
- 1:23:46Patrick Mason: The people who are who go in and sew good and then build it up.
- 1:23:50Patrick Mason: Are
- 1:23:50Jeff Haecker: any prediction Rob that you want to call that?
- 1:23:52Rob Leonardi: No, I'm not gonna shoot my shot.
- 1:23:53Rob Leonardi: I'm just gonna sit here and enjoy my popcorn eat
- 1:23:56Rob Leonardi: watching this show
- 1:23:57Rob Leonardi: because I know at the end
- 1:23:58Rob Leonardi: what has to happen, I just don't know how they're going to try to get from point A to point Z
- 1:24:03Rob Leonardi: And I'm I'm here for the ride.
- 1:24:05Rob Leonardi: I'm enjoying this.
- 1:24:06Rob Leonardi: So right now, uh
- 1:24:07Rob Leonardi: whether um
- 1:24:09Rob Leonardi: whoever turns out to be a Nasna
- 1:24:11Rob Leonardi: Gigol or whoever turns out to be the the king of the dead
- 1:24:15Rob Leonardi: Um, I'm just enjoying it.
- 1:24:16Rob Leonardi: As long as Boblin
- 1:24:17Rob Leonardi: the Goblin
- 1:24:18Rob Leonardi: doesn't make too much interference, I'll be happy.
- 1:24:20Fr. Bryan Shackett: Let it be known though that Sauron
- 1:24:23Fr. Bryan Shackett: and Saruman
- 1:24:24Fr. Bryan Shackett: are not the same, Rob.
- 1:24:26Rob Leonardi: Yes, yes.
- 1:24:27Fr. Bryan Shackett: Is that your prediction
- 1:24:28Fr. Bryan Shackett: is your prediction that Saruman is Saruman?
- 1:24:30Fr. Bryan Shackett: Is that your prediction?
- 1:24:31Rob Leonardi: Actually it's Tom
- 1:24:32Rob Leonardi: Bombadil.
- 1:24:33Fr. Bryan Shackett: Oh really
- 1:24:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: ,
- 1:24:34Fr. Bryan Shackett: in disguise.
- 1:24:35Fr. Bryan Shackett: Okay.
- 1:24:36Fr. Bryan Shackett: I'm actually Tom Bombadil
- 1:24:37Fr. Bryan Shackett: pulls mask off
- 1:24:38Fr. Bryan Shackett: a cell.
- 1:24:39Jeff Haecker: And Tom Bombadil is actually Melkor
- 1:24:41Patrick Mason: Tom Bombadil.
- 1:24:43Patrick Mason: Gandalf's gotta fight an elephant.
- 1:24:50Jeff Haecker: All right.
- 1:24:50Patrick Mason: Um, Goldberry.
- 1:24:56Patrick Mason: Oh no, don't do that to
- 1:24:57Patrick Mason: Goldberry.
- 1:24:59Patrick Mason: No, don't do that to Goldberry.
- 1:25:01Jeff Haecker: I want to say that was some that was a pr
- 1:25:02Jeff Haecker: some
- 1:25:03Jeff Haecker: some speculation or
- 1:25:04Jeff Haecker: leak or s that someone made like before season two.
- 1:25:07Jeff Haecker: Well no, we
- 1:25:08Jeff Haecker: I continue to joke about
- 1:25:11Patrick Mason: like, oh he's really Melkor and and
- 1:25:13Patrick Mason: no.
- 1:25:13Jeff Haecker: Yeah.
- 1:25:16Fr. Bryan Shackett: That's a definite.
- 1:25:17Jeff Haecker: All right.
- 1:25:17Jeff Haecker: Um
- 1:25:18Jeff Haecker: well
- 1:25:19Jeff Haecker: I think we've got a little bit of time.
- 1:25:21Jeff Haecker: We had some feedback come in that I think Rob's gonna read for us here.
- 1:25:24Rob Leonardi: Yeah, so the first feedback is from way back
- 1:25:27Rob Leonardi: in Turin Turambar
- 1:25:29Rob Leonardi: Part two, which
- 1:25:31Rob Leonardi: is
- 1:25:32Rob Leonardi: Really awesome that we just got feedback from that because
- 1:25:35Rob Leonardi: if you guys are gonna send feedback, please do we'll
- 1:25:37Rob Leonardi: just try to share it as much as possible.
- 1:25:38Rob Leonardi: This is actually
- 1:25:39Rob Leonardi: Uh this is from Ed.
- 1:25:41Rob Leonardi: He says, hi, I'm a fan of the podcast.
- 1:25:43Rob Leonardi: I just made a comic strip based on the Turin Turambar cookies.
- 1:25:46Rob Leonardi: Here it is.
- 1:25:47Rob Leonardi: And it's a um it's a little comic strip, which is actually like the the introduction that you guys did
- 1:25:53Rob Leonardi: uh
- 1:25:53Rob Leonardi: forward
- 1:25:54Rob Leonardi: turn
- 1:25:54Rob Leonardi: tour of our part
- 1:25:55Rob Leonardi: two
- 1:25:55Rob Leonardi: and um
- 1:25:56Rob Leonardi: I we will post this on the discord
- 1:25:58Rob Leonardi: when
- 1:25:59Rob Leonardi: this episode drops so everyone can uh enjoy these this cookies these
- 1:26:03Rob Leonardi: these cookies being made
- 1:26:05Rob Leonardi: Um but effectively it yeah it's it's really cool and the person
- 1:26:09Rob Leonardi: it kinda looks like me a bit, even though I wasn't part of that episode.
- 1:26:12Rob Leonardi: So
- 1:26:13Rob Leonardi: Um
- 1:26:14Rob Leonardi: enjoying that very much.
- 1:26:16Rob Leonardi: And if anyone needs their new
- 1:26:18Rob Leonardi: the recipe for the cookies I did post then on the Discord, go search for them and try them out.
- 1:26:23Rob Leonardi: I want to know if they're good because I have not tried them myself.
- 1:26:27Rob Leonardi: Um, the next bit of feedback is from Concerning Hobbits
- 1:26:31Rob Leonardi: Part One.
- 1:26:32Rob Leonardi: Tammy
- 1:26:33Rob Leonardi: says, great show.
- 1:26:34Rob Leonardi: I think I'm going to say
- 1:26:35Rob Leonardi: Bilbo is my favorite hobbit.
- 1:26:37Rob Leonardi: He had to be pushed out the door to have an adventure, but once he got out there, he had a grand old time.
- 1:26:43Rob Leonardi: Uh
- 1:26:43Rob Leonardi: concerning hobbits part
- 1:26:45Rob Leonardi: two, we also got feedback on from Frau
- 1:26:47Rob Leonardi: Hack.
- 1:26:48Rob Leonardi: Really enjoyed this week's episode.
- 1:26:50Rob Leonardi: Humility is the hobbit virtue you're looking for.
- 1:26:53Rob Leonardi: The one where you're happy with what you have and the part you play or
- 1:26:58Rob Leonardi: the calling you've been given, like Saint Michael as opposed to Satan.
- 1:27:02Rob Leonardi: Um
- 1:27:03Rob Leonardi: I think
- 1:27:03Rob Leonardi: because
- 1:27:04Rob Leonardi: we were
- 1:27:04Rob Leonardi: we were trying to say that the hobbits were
- 1:27:06Rob Leonardi: um
- 1:27:07Patrick Mason: They didn't have like a
- 1:27:10Patrick Mason: great things, and I was like, I I
- 1:27:12Patrick Mason: I know there's a word for this.
- 1:27:15Patrick Mason: So thank you.
- 1:27:16Patrick Mason: Thank you.
- 1:27:18Patrick Mason: Uh
- 1:27:18Rob Leonardi: and Tammy says, I'm way behind on my podcast listening and just finished Concerning Hobbits Part 2.
- 1:27:24Rob Leonardi: I think I'm off my game because instead of chiming in with
- 1:27:31Rob Leonardi: With the others when Rob, slash Tobias, not me
- 1:27:34Rob Leonardi: Rob, the other Rob
- 1:27:35Rob Leonardi: Um
- 1:27:36Rob Leonardi: said
- 1:27:36Rob Leonardi: Bilbo
- 1:27:37Rob Leonardi: phased down
- 1:27:38Rob Leonardi: faced down a dragon by himself
- 1:27:40Rob Leonardi: the last time that happened in
- 1:27:41Rob Leonardi: legendarium
- 1:27:42Rob Leonardi: was a guy named Turin and we know what happened there.
- 1:27:45Rob Leonardi: I smiled idiotically and yelled
- 1:27:47Rob Leonardi: cookies
- 1:27:50Rob Leonardi: Okay, on the way to
- 1:27:51Rob Leonardi: the monsters episode.
- 1:27:53Rob Leonardi: I'm expecting much
- 1:27:54Rob Leonardi: doom
- 1:27:56Rob Leonardi: and maybe cookies
- 1:27:57Rob Leonardi: too.
- 1:27:59Jeff Haecker: Awesome.
- 1:28:00Jeff Haecker: Yeah, we'll share.
- 1:28:01Jeff Haecker: Yeah, so another reference
- 1:28:02Jeff Haecker: turn.
- 1:28:02Jeff Haecker: We've got that comic that we'll share.
- 1:28:04Jeff Haecker: So
- 1:28:05Jeff Haecker: but I think that'll do it for this episode of The Secrets of Middle-earth.
- 1:28:08Jeff Haecker: We'd like to take a moment to thank all of our patrons who make this show possible, including Suzanne L, Michael S, Eric R.
- 1:28:15Jeff Haecker: Patricia S, and Dixie
- 1:28:17Jeff Haecker: P.
- 1:28:17Jeff Haecker: Their generous donations help us to continue to create the secrets of Middle-earth and all the shows at StarQuest.
- 1:28:23Jeff Haecker: And you can join them at givestarquest.
- 1:28:25Jeff Haecker: com.
- 1:28:25Jeff Haecker: Be sure to follow the Secrets of Middle Earth in Apple Podcasts, YouTube
- 1:28:29Jeff Haecker: Music, Spotify, or any podcast directory or app.
- 1:28:32Jeff Haecker: You can find us on social media at facebook com slash StarQuest Media
- 1:28:36Jeff Haecker: or
- 1:28:36Jeff Haecker: on X
- 1:28:37Jeff Haecker: where we are at SQPN or on Instagram where we are at StarQuest Network.
- 1:28:41Jeff Haecker: And don't forget that you can get your own official Secrets of Middle Earth merch, including our awesome t-shirt.
- 1:28:46Jeff Haecker: at sqpn.
- 1:28:47Jeff Haecker: com slash merch.
- 1:28:48Jeff Haecker: It's a great way for you to support the show and show your love for Tolkien and his wonderful world of Middle-earth.
- 1:28:53Jeff Haecker: And as the holidays are coming up
- 1:28:55Jeff Haecker: makes a great gift.
- 1:28:57Jeff Haecker: Now we'd love to hear from you, our listeners.
- 1:28:59Jeff Haecker: What did you think of the premiere of Rings of Power season three?
- 1:29:02Jeff Haecker: Are there any predictions
- 1:29:04Jeff Haecker: or where do you land on the
- 1:29:06Jeff Haecker: Oh
- 1:29:06Jeff Haecker: Theo Breaker or Witch Kemen debate?
- 1:29:09Jeff Haecker: You can let us know on our Facebook page or on Twitter
- 1:29:12Jeff Haecker: by sending an email to middleearth at sqpn.
- 1:29:14Jeff Haecker: com, by leaving us a comment on YouTube or on Spotify.
- 1:29:18Jeff Haecker: Or by visit by visiting our channel on the StarQuest
- 1:29:20Jeff Haecker: Discord community at sqpn.
- 1:29:22Jeff Haecker: clout.
- 1:29:23Jeff Haecker: com slash Discord.
- 1:29:25Jeff Haecker: And uh
- 1:29:26Jeff Haecker: we also have specific threads in our C
- 1:29:28Jeff Haecker: in our spoiler channel, so in two episode blocks so you can chat there even if you've not seen ahead.
- 1:29:32Jeff Haecker: And I will say
- 1:29:33Jeff Haecker: say those threads have been popping off uh since the episodes premiered.
- 1:29:37Jeff Haecker: So
- 1:29:38Jeff Haecker: um
- 1:29:38Jeff Haecker: so join us next time for the next episode of the Rings of Power, the Gift of Men.
- 1:29:44Jeff Haecker: So
- 1:29:44Jeff Haecker: until then, thank you, Patrick Mason, for joining me and sharing the secret
- 1:29:49Patrick Mason: Ah, you're very welcome.
- 1:29:51Patrick Mason: Just remember to heat your gloron to 4,000 degrees.
- 1:29:56Jeff Haecker: And Father Brian, thank you as well.
- 1:29:59Fr. Bryan Shackett: Glad to be here and may the stars continue to shine in the hours of our meeting.
- 1:30:03Jeff Haecker: And Rob
- 1:30:03Jeff Haecker: Leonardi, thank you
- 1:30:05Jeff Haecker: too.
- 1:30:06Rob Leonardi: Can someone else go fetch him?
- 1:30:11Jeff Haecker: Cardio is hard.
- 1:30:12Jeff Haecker: And I'm Jeff Haecker.
- 1:30:13Jeff Haecker: Thank you for listening to The Secrets of Middle Earth on StarQuest, and remember
- 1:30:16Jeff Haecker: Bring up six.
- 1:30:18Jeff Haecker: No
- 1:30:18Jeff Haecker: eight barrels of ale.
- 1:30:25Network stinger: Here's another show on the StarQuest Network you're sure to enjoy
- 1:30:29Network stinger: The Secrets of Sacred Art.
- 1:30:30Network stinger: Find it wherever fine podcasts are found or at StarQuest.
- 1:30:34Network stinger: fm slash
- 1:30:35Network stinger: art