Latest / Market Pulse / Consumer Wealth Trends: What Financial Marketers Need to Know
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Market Pulse podcast from Equifax. I'm your host,
- 0:04Tom O'Neill, senior advisor with Equifax,
- 0:07where we look out onto the macroeconomic and credit environments to see how they
- 0:11impact financial institutions and American households.
- 0:15We focus on helping clients navigate economic uncertainty while identifying
- 0:20opportunities for growth in the consumer credit space.
- 0:23I'm thrilled to be joined today by Ian Wright, chief Strategy Officer for IXI.
- 0:28As leader of the IXI network,
- 0:30Ian leverages data on more than $30 trillion worth of consumer deposits and
- 0:35investments to help financial services to help financial service
- 0:40marketers with their most challenging needs.
- 0:43Today we're gonna be discussing trends in wealth post COVID and how those
- 0:47differing trends impact consumers and what financial institutions need to know
- 0:52about it. But before we get started,
- 0:54let's get a quick economic update from our friends at Moody's. Analytics.
- 0:58Trade deals are all the rage right now as the Trump administration's August 1st
- 1:02tariff deadline looms.
- 1:04Several agreements have been struck in the lead up to the deadline,
- 1:07including with Japan and the European Union,
- 1:10which will each face a 15% import tax and pay no tariff on US
- 1:15exports heightened uncertainty from US.
- 1:17Trade policy has weighed on hiring and production,
- 1:21but cemented trade agreements will clear the fog going forward within the US.
- 1:25Price pressures from higher tariffs have been muted so far,
- 1:29but are starting to emerge.
- 1:31The consumer price index rose 0.3% in June,
- 1:34bringing the year ago rate to 2.7%,
- 1:37which is up from 2.4% in the previous month, core CPI,
- 1:41which excludes food and energy rose 0.2%,
- 1:44and the annual rate increase from 2.8% in May to 2.9% in
- 1:49June. Now,
- 1:50some of the increase in the annual inflation numbers in June were due to
- 1:54unfavorable base effects, as inflation was soft at this point last year.
- 1:59But certain tariff sensitive goods, like household appliances, for instance,
- 2:03showed a meaningful increase in prices as results of firms
- 2:08passing down higher costs from import taxes to consumers.
- 2:14Now, tariffs are altering consumer behavior.
- 2:16Many consumers front loaded purchases earlier in the year to get ahead of
- 2:20expected tariff increases as sales then plummeted in May as tariffs rose and
- 2:25forward buying ended before partially rebounding in June. But nonetheless,
- 2:30retail sales are only a touch above December levels in the aggregate.
- 2:34As consumers feel the force, the tariff induced price increases,
- 2:39they will pull back on spending even more.
- 2:42There is pressure on the Fed to start easing monetary policy,
- 2:45but with inflation proving stubborn,
- 2:47there appears to be little appetite to cut rates.
- 2:50The Fed has to strike a balance between stable prices and maximum employment,
- 2:54both of which can be simultaneously undermined by tariffs. However,
- 2:59since tariffs generally represent a one-time price shock,
- 3:03it seems likely that the Fed will prioritize the labor market as growth slows.
- 3:07Therefore,
- 3:08we anticipate 2 25 basis point cuts this year in September and
- 3:13December.
- 3:14Thank you, Moody's. So, Ian, welcome. Thank you for joining us today.
- 3:19Thank you. Great to be here. Tom, always great to have a conversation with you.
- 3:22Yeah, I always enjoy our conversations and, but this one's being recorded,
- 3:26so we have to watch what we say . I wanted to start off by,
- 3:31by bringing up the, the wealth trends reports that,
- 3:36that Equifax is just releasing based upon the IXI data that
- 3:41I mentioned in the, the intro.
- 3:43And that report highlights pretty significant wealth growth since the
- 3:482008 recession. It's the,
- 3:50the growth has actually reached 66 trillion, you know, by, you know,
- 3:54by the middle of last year, I think it was. What really are the,
- 3:58the primary drivers of that growth?
- 4:00Yeah, it's been a, a fantastic decade and a half for consumers,
- 4:04but as we'll see,
- 4:05maybe that's been a little uneven depending upon who you are and where your
- 4:09economic and financial capabilities exist.
- 4:12But it's really been the stock market that has been fueling wealth especially
- 4:16post COVID. Just between 2001 and two thou, sorry,
- 4:212021 and 2026 total
- 4:25consumer assets went up by $6 trillion. So six of that six,
- 4:30$6 trillion million occurred just in the last five years.
- 4:33So about 9% growth even just recently.
- 4:38Wow. That's, and, and obviously since it's, since so much of that has,
- 4:43has happened within the, the stock market,
- 4:47I would imagine that it hasn't quite benefited all households, you know,
- 4:52equally across that can you give a, I know we,
- 4:55we can certainly go really deep into this conversation and,
- 4:58and probably will but what, what,
- 5:02what are the different segments that have been influenced differently by this,
- 5:07this growth and wealth?
- 5:09The growth has been interesting, as you said.
- 5:11So I looked at where were consumers in 2021 and and where were they
- 5:16In 2024,
- 5:18I saw what I call the typical consumer household looking at the median household
- 5:23using medians instead of means or averages.
- 5:26So we don't have those very wealthy people kind of pulling up and skewing the
- 5:31picture a bit.
- 5:32But even though wealth increased by five or $6 trillion during that period,
- 5:37the median value,
- 5:38the median household value for wealth actually decreased to $66,000.
- 5:43Investments went down by 12%. Deposits stayed about even.
- 5:48So then you kind of have this conundrum, right, well,
- 5:50how did wealth increase overall mm-hmm .
- 5:53But then how did the typical consumer
- 5:56actually be worse off during that experience? And it's, as you said,
- 6:01the growth hasn't been even we look at consumer wealth in
- 6:06three different tiers. If you look at the middle tier,
- 6:09which is the mass affluent,
- 6:11they have a hundred thousand dollars to a million dollars in total deposits and
- 6:15investments.
- 6:17That segment consists of about 44 million households,
- 6:20and it reduced by about 4%,
- 6:24both in the number of households that are in the segment and also by the
- 6:28number of assets that it controls. Now, where did those households go?
- 6:33Most of them went down to what we call the mass market,
- 6:35which have less than a hundred thousand dollars. Wow. That segment,
- 6:39which is about 75 million households,
- 6:42actually increased by 7% in household counts,
- 6:46but only 1% actually in assets.
- 6:49So we see that middle tier actually going down,
- 6:52but not contributing to the wealth when it did go down in wealth.
- 6:56On the other end of the spectrum is we do have a good story,
- 6:59and this is where the growth does occur,
- 7:02and that's with the affluent households.
- 7:05If you're someone who has a million dollars,
- 7:07your wealth probably grew over that five year, or I'm sorry,
- 7:10that four year period. In fact,
- 7:12the 14 million households that they're in that segment they grew their assets by
- 7:1817%. So when we're talking about growth,
- 7:20we're really looking at that sliver of households in the us right.
- 7:25And they hold nearly three quarters of all the wealth.
- 7:29It's, it's interest, what you're describing people,
- 7:32a a large movement moving out of the, the middle tier,
- 7:37essentially a lot moving down. I would imagine some moving up into the,
- 7:41and that middle tier, the, the mass affluent,
- 7:44you essentially shrieking shrinking over that time period.
- 7:47It's fascinating because that's exactly what we've seen in the credit side
- 7:52of, of the, the world as well, obviously here at Equifax. You know, we,
- 7:56we have a ton of, of credit data that we're constantly sifting through and,
- 8:00and looking for, for meaning within.
- 8:03And we've seen a lot of that same type of,
- 8:07of circumstance. You know, we've, we've been referencing the K shaped
- 8:12for probably the, the same four or five years that, that you're talking about.
- 8:17And we, we reference it both in terms of economic terms as well as credit terms.
- 8:21And essentially what that is, it's,
- 8:25it's as simple as it sounds, you know, envision a k you know, you've got,
- 8:29you know, a k with a, you know, perpendicular line,
- 8:34and then you've got one, you know,
- 8:35line shooting upwards and one line shooting downwards. It's as,
- 8:40as simple a visualization as that. And it, it represents that,
- 8:44that that trend of a lot of households,
- 8:48a lot of consumers thriving, doing just fine. Thank you very much.
- 8:53And then others that are, that are truly struggling,
- 8:57and certainly that's, that's always the case, you know, from the dawn of time,
- 9:01that's always been the case where you have your haves, your have nots.
- 9:04What's particularly interesting over the last few years is how much that gap
- 9:08between those populations has grown.
- 9:11You, you mentioned.
- 9:12You, you mentioned the, the, the differences in terms of wealth growth.
- 9:16We see it in terms of things as simple as credit scores. Mm-Hmm .
- 9:20You know, we have a lot of people that were in those mid-tier credit scores.
- 9:24Some of them certainly have moved up over the last years, a few years.
- 9:28A lot of them have moved down and, and fewer left in the middle.
- 9:32It's a very interesting phenomenon that we're, we're seeing.
- 9:35Yeah. I, I term now, since we're a couple years past COVID,
- 9:39I'm starting to use the barbell effect, right?
- 9:41And that's another term a lot of virtual services folks use, but it's true.
- 9:44You're seeing the middle kind of disappear and you're either unfortunately
- 9:48moving down or you're being able to benefit and move up either in wealth or it
- 9:52sounds also like in your credit behavior as well.
- 9:55So, Ian, you, you spoke of, of investments, you know,
- 9:59clearly being a fueling factor of, of this, this growth that we've seen in,
- 10:03in wealth over the last few years.
- 10:05How has that also compared to to deposits
- 10:10to CDs and other forms of, of wealth that,
- 10:13that our financial institution lenders you know, are, are looking at these days?
- 10:18Yeah, if we, if we stick to just liquid investments, so those are, I'm sorry,
- 10:22liquid assets. So those are assets that I can turn into money very easily.
- 10:26So it would be a deposit account or an investment account, right?
- 10:30It's also what a financial services marketer could try to target and bring into
- 10:34their own institution.
- 10:37We've actually seen deposits remain somewhat flat over that same time period,
- 10:41that three to four year time period and actually went down by a trillion
- 10:45dollars. So it was that 15 trillion,
- 10:47we estimated down to 14 trillion as of the summer of last year.
- 10:52So really all the growth came from the investments.
- 10:56And that's true across the board,
- 10:59but particularly in the stock market and that's owning stock directly.
- 11:03And again, when you think about who owns stock,
- 11:06even though it's been democratized really across different households in
- 11:11the US where everyone has more stock ownership,
- 11:14we still see the majority of stock ownership at those higher levels of wealth.
- 11:19It's also true through ETFs and mutual funds too. So in my portfolio,
- 11:24if I'm mainly investing in stocks, I'm gonna experience some of that growth,
- 11:29but it's maybe gonna be a little bit diluted if instead if I was just directly
- 11:33investing in stocks. Also,
- 11:36interesting that in the last several years we've seen bonds come back as well.
- 11:40Bonds have increased in value and they've contributed probably about probably
- 11:44about a third of,
- 11:45of what we've seen in the growth outside of that majority of the stock market.
- 11:50So it's definitely been investments, but not only stocks, mainly stocks,
- 11:55but we did also see those bond levels increase as well.
- 11:59Ian, we, we spoke about how this growth in wealth has certainly not
- 12:04been even, you know,
- 12:06distributed evenly across all populations.
- 12:10How have you seen this impact across, say, different age tiers, you know,
- 12:14retirees versus Gen Zs and, and, and younger consumers? Has,
- 12:19have there been any developing, you know,
- 12:21trends that are noticeable within those demographics?
- 12:24Definitely, definitely.
- 12:25And you could probably imagine that folks who are maybe more advanced in age
- 12:29have had the time to build up in wealth, and that's always been the case,
- 12:33but it's even more so the case now. Not only the, the most recent 10,
- 12:3815 years,
- 12:39really the last 2030 years consumers who were able to invest in the stock
- 12:44market, even at different levels,
- 12:45were able to really derive up their overall wealth and move into those
- 12:50affluent segments that we talked about earlier.
- 12:53We have a segment we call the retirees.
- 12:55You could probably guess they're at least 65 years old.
- 12:59Why they comprise about a third of the us,
- 13:0134% of households they own or command 44% of all the assets.
- 13:06So they are an incredibly important segment for financial services marketers to
- 13:11capture not only today,
- 13:14but one of the biggest questions in financial services is this impending
- 13:18transfer of wealth that's over the horizon. When the retirees move on,
- 13:23they're gonna leave their wealth to their families.
- 13:26They're gonna leave it at different inheritance options.
- 13:29So financial services marketers are then trying to look at, well,
- 13:32who's gonna maybe move into wealth who aren't in wealth today?
- 13:37And we see a lot of the Gen X families spread across those wealth segments I
- 13:42talked about, but they're in that age span that in the not too distant future,
- 13:46and then also maybe in a little bit longer they're gonna inherit their wealth.
- 13:51So they might not have the largest amount of wealth today,
- 13:54about 27% of assets, but once they inherit wealth,
- 13:59they're gonna really move to the forefront of being the wealthiest segment.
- 14:04You also mentioned the Gen Z segment.
- 14:06They really haven't had enough time to develop their wealth.
- 14:10The investing they can do hasn't been benefited by compounding
- 14:15which is one of the most powerful laws, right? There are some households though,
- 14:20that have been able to communicate that wealth. It's a very small number.
- 14:23There are less than 400,000 households that are in the Gen Z segment
- 14:27that have at least a million dollars. So they're very hard to find.
- 14:32If you can find them, they're fantastic customers, right?
- 14:35Because the overall opportunity to have a customer lifetime value that's
- 14:39high is incredible with that household. 'cause You'll have them for 40, 50,
- 14:4460 years. Right.
- 14:46Right. It's interesting noticing, again,
- 14:50the similarities between what we're seeing within wealth trends and what we've
- 14:54also been seeing within, within credit trends and how
- 14:59just the factor of age, you know, is, is such a, a, a noticeable trait,
- 15:03you know, when, when sort of predicting how different, you know,
- 15:07populations or households might
- 15:11might have benefited or not benefited over the last few years
- 15:16using those, those age demographics as,
- 15:21as an example within the credit trends, you know, field for example,
- 15:24we've seen how
- 15:28within s the same income tiers as well as
- 15:33the same risk tiers,
- 15:36age is such a huge distinction between how well different populations,
- 15:41different households and consumers have weathered the financial storms over the
- 15:45last few years. Because of what you mentioned earlier. You know, the,
- 15:49the younger generations simply haven't had the time to build up those assets to
- 15:54let you know investments compound over time and, and,
- 15:58and have a financial rock to fall back on when,
- 16:03when times get tough.
- 16:06So it's been been interesting to see that within those
- 16:11same tiers everything else being, being similar,
- 16:15just knowing that,
- 16:16that someone hasn't had as much time within their financial lives to build up
- 16:20those assets can be a, a predictor. So like you say,
- 16:24if you can find those, hang onto 'em. Yeah. Grab 'em and, and,
- 16:28and hold on.
- 16:29Yeah. Give them your promotional rates,
- 16:31give them your top tier customer service,
- 16:33make sure their needs are met and anticipate their needs as well.
- 16:37Absolutely. Now, how, how about you know, age is certainly an interesting one.
- 16:41How about geography? Anything that's,
- 16:43that we see on a geographic basis on a state level or, or, you know,
- 16:48a broader territory level that's that you, you can pull out?
- 16:52Yeah, definitely. If, if you do talk to financial service marketers and you say,
- 16:56well, what are your biggest markets?
- 16:57Everyone's probably gonna say the big five states California, Florida, Illinois,
- 17:02New York, and Texas. And those are still the biggest markets overall.
- 17:07If you're introducing branches somewhere,
- 17:09or if you're doing some new advertising for market acquisitions,
- 17:12those are still gonna be your largest markets. But if you're looking for, well,
- 17:17where are concentrations maybe of the most affluent households or,
- 17:22or households where the median assets is higher?
- 17:24It's interesting that New England starts to actually appear more often than not.
- 17:30We find that Connecticut,
- 17:31Massachusetts New Hampshire and then New Jersey and New Jersey would include
- 17:38we're seeing from some wealth going out of New York into the suburbs of New
- 17:41Jersey. And then Hawaii have the, the highest assets.
- 17:45So each one of those states on their own might not be the biggest market in
- 17:49terms of volume of the number of households,
- 17:52but if you're looking to increase your average account balances,
- 17:56those are some areas you definitely wanna make sure that you have a presence in.
- 18:01Right. And then if you wanna take it down to another level,
- 18:03say let's look at some cities and as I mentioned earlier,
- 18:06we'll look at cities from the census definition.
- 18:09So what's known as the core based statistical area or CBSA
- 18:14where you're seeing the largest affluent growth is New York,
- 18:17Chicago la and then also Dallas.
- 18:21We do have then maybe about four cities.
- 18:23There are about the same beyond that in terms of growth,
- 18:26but growth is happening. And it might be in some areas that you suspect,
- 18:30you hear taxes getting bigger. You hear that, you know,
- 18:34the New York suburbs is where maybe some of that Manhattan money is going to.
- 18:39But I was interested to see that LA is still in that list when at least
- 18:43anecdotally people say wealth is fleeing from California. Right?
- 18:47You're not necessarily seeing that the case in at a level that would make
- 18:52a dent in California being an attractive market.
- 18:55It's just so large that it still makes sense for any financial services marketer
- 19:00to try to target consumers in that state.
- 19:04Interesting. Okay. So, so then let me put you on the spot then. You know, ah,
- 19:08if we are going to then go ahead and say, all right,
- 19:11we want to target Los Angeles, we want to target, you know, the young affluent,
- 19:16we want to, you know, we want to target something,
- 19:20how does one go about doing that?
- 19:23Where should marketers be focusing their efforts on capturing, you know,
- 19:27whatever targets, you know, make sense for them to, to define?
- 19:31Hmm, great question. I like to look at it from a three-step process. First,
- 19:35what is the geographic market that presents me with the most opportunity?
- 19:40And this would be true if I have brick and mortar locations,
- 19:43or even if I'm a digital bank,
- 19:44because I'm still gonna wanna inform my advertising with a different designated
- 19:49marketed area or DMA that I wanna focus that marketing on as well
- 19:54as my digital and online advertising to see which zip codes
- 20:00I'm looking for when I wanna bid on an ad.
- 20:03So I would start with that looking geographically where I want to focus.
- 20:07And as I mentioned, California's a great state still to focus on.
- 20:11And then further, if I wanna look at a metropolitan area, as I said,
- 20:14Los Angeles is a great area. San Francisco still has significant wealth,
- 20:19and if you include down in the Silicon Valley area,
- 20:22you've got great opportunity there.
- 20:24But then what I would wanna do is understand which households in those
- 20:28geographies are really the drivers that are pushing those numbers up and making
- 20:32it a attractive market that I wanna make sure that I can win.
- 20:36And that's where we can help understand what is a total a household's total
- 20:41wealth,
- 20:41and also what their deposits versus their investment breakdown looks like.
- 20:46So you can understand if this is a household that if I've got a high yield
- 20:50savings account or a CD that I wanna offer promotional rate on,
- 20:54they can not only open an account, not only fund it,
- 20:57but they can fund it with a significant amount of money.
- 21:00So I get a return on my advertising right away.
- 21:03And then the third step though, would, would,
- 21:05would be to understand what sort of messages are going to resonate with these
- 21:09households. And that's where tried and true segmentation can help,
- 21:14or what I talked about before might be a little bit more of the quantitative,
- 21:16the hard numbers of where is the opportunity Segmentation helps with the
- 21:20qualitative. Okay,
- 21:22once I know I wanna advertise to these people what's the sort of
- 21:26messaging that I should focus on? What should resonate with them?
- 21:30Maybe where are they in their life stage?
- 21:32So maybe their needs are gonna be different in this part of Los Angeles versus
- 21:36another part of Los Angeles. You put those three steps together and you,
- 21:41you pretty much have the best way that you can attack any market.
- 21:45Interesting. So you're not just getting to the identification, the, the what,
- 21:50you know. Yeah. But then drilling down very importantly into the how, like,
- 21:55okay, everyone's gonna be trying to, to hit these populations.
- 22:00How do I distinguish myself?
- 22:01How do I tailor my message to what they are most receptive to?
- 22:05Correct, correct. And,
- 22:07and even sometimes I don't need to know that it's the O'Neill household that I
- 22:10want to target. I just know that there are households in the,
- 22:13where the O'Neill household resides that I want to target.
- 22:17So there's a big sort of back and forth and understanding someone's identity
- 22:22and resolving a message to someone's actual identity, which is fantastic,
- 22:26but it shouldn't hinder any of your efforts.
- 22:29Awesome. This has been very interesting,
- 22:33and I appreciate your time.
- 22:35Before I wrap up here I do want to sort of do the,
- 22:40do the proverbial 30,000 foot question, open it up and say,
- 22:45as you look out, you know, we're, we're halfway through 20, 25. Now,
- 22:49as you look out, you know, for the rest of the year, and,
- 22:52and I'll even let you go into 2026 if you desire,
- 22:56what do you see in store? You know, are are we gonna see continued growth?
- 23:00Are we,
- 23:01are we expecting what we've been seeing over the last few years to,
- 23:06to continue? What do you think?
- 23:08I think so with some caveats with the new administration and that
- 23:13are willing to take,
- 23:14I guess you could say more bold or more significant efforts it's difficult
- 23:19to maybe chart or plot a progress that's gonna be an even line.
- 23:25We might see more dips in valleys and mountains occurring on the deposit
- 23:30side. So if you're in banking or your credit union,
- 23:33I think we're gonna see deposits stay somewhat flat, unfortunately,
- 23:38and we're still gonna have that hunt for deposits,
- 23:40which everyone has been trying to attract more deposits over the last three
- 23:45years. There is some fatigue that's set in. Fortunately,
- 23:48I think that's gonna continue for the next year or so where you're gonna have to
- 23:53offer some very attractive rates for people to decide to change their existing
- 23:57relationships and bring more deposits over. On the investment side, though,
- 24:01that has been the engine, right? The stock market,
- 24:04we did have a dip in the stock market earlier this year,
- 24:08but it's come back and we're up year to date.
- 24:11And if this sort of progress and expectation occurs and continues to occur,
- 24:16I think we'll still see growth. Maybe not at the same level that we had before,
- 24:20but we'll still see growth in the future. However,
- 24:23all bets are off if there are significant policy changes by the existing
- 24:28administration. Right.
- 24:29Yeah, I'll be interested to see, I think not just myself,
- 24:32everyone is going to be interested to see that as well as, right,
- 24:35not just the answer to will there be more growth, but where, you know, yeah.
- 24:40Are we going to see a continued spread of the, of the k,
- 24:45you know, gap or, you know, will things be a little bit more evenly distributed?
- 24:50Ian, as always, it's a pleasure talking with you and, and,
- 24:54and having you share your insights.
- 24:56If our listeners would like to reach out to you, how can they find you, Ian?
- 25:00Yeah, so best way to reach out to me is through email.
- 25:04My email address is ian dot wright IAN dot
- 25:11W-R-I-G-H t@equifax.com. And I'd love to hear from folks.
- 25:14Awesome. Thank you again, Ian. And to our listeners,
- 25:18I hope you enjoyed today's topic. If you have any questions,
- 25:21you can certainly reach out to us,
- 25:22especially if you have ideas for a future podcast. Reach out to us at Risk
- 25:30advisors@equifax.com. We look forward to hearing from you. Thank you.