Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #60🎙️ |Public Inquiry - Review of Week Beginning 12th May 2026|
Transcript
- 0:10And the seasons they go round and round and the painted ponies
- 0:15go up and down were captive on the carousel of time we can't
- 0:23return, we can only look behind from where we came, and go round
- 0:30and round and round in the circle game. Thanks to Joni
- 0:36Mitchell for her song, The Circle Game. I won't torch you
- 0:39all by singing the rest of it, but you probably get the general
- 0:43idea. Well, it's Friday, thank God. Poets, they call it. Piss
- 0:48off early tomorrow's Saturday. We all just did that, except not
- 0:52on Friday, Thursday evening, actually, as I recounted in
- 0:57podcast number 59 that after it became blindingly obvious that
- 1:02the timetabling of the landscape days on the 26th and 29th of May
- 1:05wasn't going to work, and the bright sparkling spanking new
- 1:10suggestion from the PAC of reconvening for a week in
- 1:14August, topics to be decided was discovered also to be
- 1:18unworkable, the day finished with the not unreasonable
- 1:22outcome that FODC and the applicant would challenge the
- 1:26timetabling decisions of 26th to 29th of May in court. As you
- 1:32might imagine, there was not much more to be said after that,
- 1:36and we were all dismissed and told to come back on Monday. I'm
- 1:40guessing the PAC will back down around the timetable and where
- 1:44will that leave us and the seasons they go round and round
- 1:48and the painted ponies go up and down and we're all captives on
- 1:52the carousel of time. To get back to the review of the week I
- 2:00think most people are carrying a kind of mental tiredness that is
- 2:03hard to explain, unless you're sitting in that room all day
- 2:07listening carefully, trying to absorb huge amounts of technical
- 2:11information, while also hearing deeply personal testimony from
- 2:15people whose lives are tied to this landscape. The week began
- 2:20with discussions around the proposed closure bond and
- 2:23section 76 agreement the figure being discussed was just over 20
- 2:29million and there was a lot of concern from objectors about
- 2:34whether that amount reflects the actual scale of risk attached to
- 2:38this proposal questions were raised repeatedly about
- 2:41long-term liability, pollution incidents, enforcement, and who
- 2:47ultimately carries responsibility if something goes
- 2:50wrong years down the line, after the company has extracted every
- 2:54last gramme of mineral wealth it could possibly could, and has
- 2:58long since fled the scene, leaving a trail of toxic
- 3:02environmental devastation behind them. One thing that became very
- 3:06clear in the early discussions was that Del Radian do not
- 3:10accept the likelihood of catastrophic failure. That
- 3:14position sat uneasily with many people in the room, because
- 3:17objectors referenced multiple examples from around the world
- 3:21involving failures of mining waste facilities using similar
- 3:26technologies, there were references to acid mine drainage
- 3:31already known to exist at Courant-Alt, concerns around
- 3:35perpetual monitoring, and concerns that mine waste
- 3:38facilities require maintenance indefinitely. A lot of the
- 3:44discussion came back to future generations. Who monitors these
- 3:48sites 15 years from now, 100 years from now? Who pays? Who
- 3:54enforces it? What happens if ownership changes or a company
- 3:57no longer exists? The questions being asked by local people in
- 4:02the spurns were from their own lived experience. Yet many of
- 4:06the responses remain tied to legal mechanisms and planning
- 4:10language that offers little or no comfort. Contributions from
- 4:16the farming community were incredibly powerful. The farmers
- 4:20spoke about their land, cattle, families, and fear. What this
- 4:24development could mean for agriculture in the area, and the
- 4:27knock-on effect on families. There was real frustration that
- 4:31no proper baseline agricultural study appears to have been
- 4:34carried out. People raised concerns about blasting, dust,
- 4:39ammonia, nitrates, water contamination, and the wider
- 4:42impact on farming beyond the footprint of the site itself.
- 4:47One farmer spoke about living beside the proposed mine for
- 4:50over 70 years and worrying now about the future for his sons
- 4:54and grandchildren. There were also testimonies shared from p.
- 5:00People who live beside mining operations elsewhere in the
- 5:02world, these contributions change the atmosphere in the
- 5:06room. Stories from Peru, Guatemala, Honduras, and
- 5:10Limerick describe cattle dying, health deteriorating,
- 5:14contamination fears, and communities gradually changing
- 5:18over time. Pat and Noola Gagnon's testimony from County
- 5:22Limerick stayed with a lot of people, their account of
- 5:25illness, miscarriages, sick animals, and eventually leaving
- 5:29their home and farm because of the impact industrial waste had
- 5:33on their lives was difficult to listen to. Tourism became
- 5:37another major issue during the week. Dalradion maintained
- 5:43throughout that they do not believe there will be
- 5:45significant tourism impact arising from the proposal. This
- 5:50position was strongly challenged by local tourism providers,
- 5:53anglers, residents, community representatives, who spoke about
- 5:58the Spurns as a place people come to because of its peace,
- 6:01beauty, rivers, dark skies, and rolling landscape, a number of
- 6:07people spoke emotionally about the fear of industrialization in
- 6:10an area of outstanding natural beauty. The proposed hall roads,
- 6:15power lines, waste facility, lighting, noise, and dust all
- 6:20featured heavily in those discussions. There was also
- 6:24frustration around the lack of meaningful engagement with
- 6:27tourism operators by the applicant, and the absence of
- 6:30any detailed research into how people might perceive the area
- 6:34if a large gold mine goes ahead. One local person described the
- 6:39idea of a hall road cutting through an area where walking,
- 6:42cycling, and tourism are actively being promoted. Another
- 6:46speaker talked about raising children in spurns and wanting
- 6:50them to inherit somewhere safe and healthy, where they and
- 6:53their generations coming behind them will thrive long into the
- 6:57future. The angling contributions were also
- 7:00significant. The FOIA system and the Onkaloo River were described
- 7:05as hugely important environmentally, culturally, and
- 7:08economically. There were warnings about salmon decline
- 7:11already happening, and concerns about introducing further
- 7:15environmental pressures into a vulnerable river system, and as
- 7:21the week moved into planning policy discussions, the
- 7:25atmosphere seemed increasingly tense. A lot of attention
- 7:28focused on whether existing planning policy is being
- 7:32interpreted consistently. FODC repeatedly argued that the local
- 7:37development plan is the key planning document and should
- 7:41carry significant weight. There was concern from objectors that
- 7:45some policies appear to be treated flexibly when they
- 7:48create difficulty for the applicant. For example, the
- 7:52discussions around waste policy were particularly striking. DFI
- 7:58stated that they do not believe the waste management policy
- 8:01applies, FODC challenged that strongly, and during the
- 8:06discussions, Dalryddian acknowledged that the proposal
- 8:09does involve a waste facility for extractive waste, while
- 8:13continuing to argue that the waste management policy should
- 8:17not apply to it. At times, the exchanges became a little
- 8:21surreal. Comparisons were made to car parks and coffee grounds,
- 8:27while people in the room were thinking about millions of
- 8:29tonnes of potentially toxic mine waste. There was visible
- 8:33frustration from many of the local community during this part
- 8:36of the proceedings. The issue of neutrality for the department
- 8:41DFI also surfaced repeatedly during the week. There's a
- 8:46growing concern amongst local people about the role of the
- 8:49department and the reluctance to give direct answers on difficult
- 8:53issues. A phrase during the week was that the department's
- 8:57neutrality was becoming tiresome. I think what many
- 9:02people are struggling with is the sense that ordinary members
- 9:05of the public have spent years researching technical documents,
- 9:09mining failures, environmental risks, planning policy, while
- 9:13the departments themselves often appear cautious about taking
- 9:17firm positions. In my mind, it is a form of weaponized
- 9:21incompetence that feeling deepened considerably during the
- 9:27waste policy discussions. There was a real sense of disbelief in
- 9:31the room that the department could continue to present itself
- 9:35as an honest broker while also being the ultimate decision
- 9:38maker in the process, and as I said earlier, the timetable
- 9:44issued also continued right through the week, date shifted
- 9:48again and again, topics moved around, additional hearings
- 9:52appeared likely later in the year, and possibly beyond, that
- 9:56uncertainty has become a major issue for people trying to
- 9:58participate. Many local people are using annual leave to
- 10:03attend. Some have childcare responsibilities, some are
- 10:06self-employed, some are travelling long distance
- 10:09repeatedly. There were strong concerns raised about procedural
- 10:13fairness and meaningful public participation. And finally, the
- 10:19process itself has taken a toll. You can hear it in the voices of
- 10:22people who have been carrying this for years now. People are
- 10:25tired in a way that goes far beyond long days and late
- 10:28nights. There is awareness that comes from trying to hold
- 10:32together ordinary life while constantly preparing to defend
- 10:35the place we call home. And so, another week turns on the
- 10:41strange carousel of time. The people keep showing up, the
- 10:44stories keep being told, and round and round the process
- 10:47goes, while a community tries not to lose itself in it.
- 10:52Anyways, that is the week that was at the public inquiry. Thank
- 10:56you to everyone who contributed, spoke, supported each other,
- 11:00brought food, helped with lifts and continues to show up every
- 11:04day, despite how exhausting this process has become. And a small
- 11:09request, this podcast has grown entirely through word of mouth,
- 11:13people sharing episodes, and listeners coming back day after
- 11:16day to follow the public inquiry. If you found value in
- 11:20it, following the podcast and Spotify, or leaving a review on
- 11:23Apple Podcasts, genuinely, genuinely makes a huge
- 11:27difference. It helps push these conversations out beyond our own
- 11:32circles and into places they may, they might not otherwise
- 11:37reach. For something that started with just a microphone,
- 11:41a notebook, and lots of late nights trying to make sense of
- 11:44the day. The support has been extraordinary. Thank you. And
- 11:48we'll see you all again on Monday,
- 11:56you.