Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Problem Solving: Gestalt Psychology & Well-Defined vs. Ill-Defined Problems
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. Hey everyone.
- 0:03So, um, I want you to picture someone for a second.
- 0:05Let's just call him nut. Okay. Nut. Right. So
- 0:08nut is sitting at his desk and he is just staring
- 0:11intensely at a completely blank word document.
- 0:15Oh no. Yeah. The cursor is just like blinking
- 0:18at him, mocking him and he's nervously clicking
- 0:21his pen. We have all been there. Seriously. He
- 0:25has this massive cognitive psychology essay due
- 0:28in what, maybe a few hours, and he hasn't typed
- 0:30a single word. Finally, he just slams his fist
- 0:33on the table and yells, I need a plan. Oh, man,
- 0:37I feel that in my bones. And honestly, we are
- 0:39acting as your virtual study buddies today reviewing
- 0:42Chapter 9 on problem solving. And well, we've
- 0:44all been Nutt. Totally. It is like the universal,
- 0:46incredibly stressful student experience. It really
- 0:49is. But from a purely cognitive psychology perspective,
- 0:52what Nutt is experiencing is a literal breakdown
- 0:55in goal -directed behavior. Right. He has this
- 0:57desired state, a finished essay, and his current
- 1:00state is a blank page. And the gulf between those
- 1:03two realities is basically what we define as
- 1:05a problem. Which, I mean, that definition always
- 1:08strikes me as almost too broad. How so? Well
- 1:10because if you look at it through an evolutionary
- 1:12lens, a bat trying to hunt down a moth in the
- 1:15dark is technically solving a problem. Oh yeah.
- 1:18Or like finding food in a really harsh winter
- 1:20is a problem. Yeah. Chapter 9 isn't about bats
- 1:23or, you know, basic biological survival. Right.
- 1:26It's about abstract cognition. Exactly. It's
- 1:29about the kind of abstract high -level thinking
- 1:32that makes human beings unique. Which is such
- 1:34an important distinction to make because not
- 1:38everything that requires action is a problem.
- 1:40Like, if you reach over to grab your coffee mug
- 1:42right now, your brain is doing a monumental amount
- 1:45of spatial geometry. Oh, yeah. Calculating distance.
- 1:49Adjusting for the weight of the liquid inside.
- 1:51Exactly. Applying the exact right grip pressure.
- 1:54If we tried to program a robot to do that, it
- 1:56would require like thousands of lines of code.
- 1:59But for you, it takes zero conscious effort.
- 2:02None at all. It's totally automated. So for a
- 2:05situation to be a true cognitive problem, it
- 2:08has to demand conscious, deliberate mental work,
- 2:11where the solution just is not immediately obvious.
- 2:14What's staring at a blank screen? Or, I don't
- 2:17know, figuring out how to navigate a super tricky
- 2:19conversation with a friend. Or sitting across
- 2:21from an opponent in chess, yeah. Right. So our
- 2:24mission for this deep dive today is to break
- 2:26down the actual mechanical psychology of how
- 2:29we achieve these abstract goals. when the path
- 2:32forward is totally obscured. And we're going
- 2:34to use some mnemonics to help you study. Yeah,
- 2:36and maybe look at this through a broader philosophical
- 2:39lens, too, so you can actually remember this
- 2:41stuff for the exam. Sounds like a plan. Yeah.
- 2:43So before we can figure out how to get Nut to
- 2:45write his essay, we have to classify the nature
- 2:48of the obstacle in his way. Right, map the territory.
- 2:51Exactly. Cognitive psychology argues that you
- 2:54can't apply a solution until you map the territory.
- 2:57We divide these abstract problems into two main
- 2:59camps, basically. Well -defined problems and
- 3:02ill -defined problems. Okay, let's tackle well
- 3:05-defined problems first. For your notes, think
- 3:07of these as situations that could be formalized
- 3:09algorithmically. Like a math equation. Yeah,
- 3:12exactly. And I like to use the acronym SOG to
- 3:16remember the three required criteria. S -O -G.
- 3:19Okay, break that down. So first, there is a clear
- 3:22initial state. That's the S. Think of setting
- 3:25up a chess board. You know exactly where every
- 3:27single piece is. Right. There's no ambiguity.
- 3:30None. Then there is a finite set of operators.
- 3:34The O. These are the strict rules you are allowed
- 3:37to apply. Like knowing a bishop can only move
- 3:39diagonally. Okay, and the G. Finally, there is
- 3:42a clear goal state. The G. Which in chess would
- 3:46be checkmate. SOG. That is super helpful. And
- 3:49you know, that SOG framework is exactly why computers
- 3:51are undeniably brilliant at well -defined problems.
- 3:54Well, yeah, because they don't have to guess.
- 3:56Right. A computer doesn't need intuition to play
- 3:58chess. It just calculates every single possible
- 4:00permutation of operators from the initial state
- 4:02to the goal state, and it just picks the most
- 4:05efficient path. It's just pure brute force computation.
- 4:08Exactly. But the reality of human existence is
- 4:11rarely a chess board. OK, let's unpack this.
- 4:13Because if we look at ill -defined problems,
- 4:16The ones which lack clear initial states, obvious
- 4:19rules, or even a singular goal state, are we
- 4:23just basically describing life? Yeah, pretty
- 4:25much. Like a professor telling you to paint a
- 4:27beautiful picture is ill -defined because there
- 4:30is no algorithmic definition for beauty. Nope,
- 4:33none at all. But taking it even further, Aren't
- 4:35the biggest questions in religion and morality
- 4:38essentially the ultimate ill -defined problem?
- 4:40Oh, that's an interesting way to look at it.
- 4:42Like how to live a good life or what is the right
- 4:44thing to do. There is no SOG algorithm for empathy
- 4:48or moral judgment. What's fascinating here is
- 4:51that even within those massive, deeply subjective
- 4:54gray areas, the cognitive mechanisms we use still
- 4:57rely on well -defined structures. Wait, really?
- 5:00How does that work? Well, the line between well
- 5:02-defined and ill -defined isn't really a solid
- 5:05brick wall. The human brain manages overwhelming
- 5:07ill -defined ambiguity by actively searching
- 5:10for well -defined sub -problems to latch onto.
- 5:13Wait, how does that actually work in practice?
- 5:15Like, how do you chop up something as vague as
- 5:17a moral dilemma or a creative essay into sub
- 5:19-problems? Think about Nut for a second. OK,
- 5:22poor Nut. Right. His overarching goal writing,
- 5:25a compelling essay, is completely ill -defined.
- 5:28There are infinite ways to write it. Yeah, which
- 5:31is why he's paralyzed. Exactly. His brain can't
- 5:34process infinity. So to make progress, he has
- 5:37to establish a highly well -defined subproblem.
- 5:40Like what? Like first he has to just open the
- 5:42textbook, then he has to read the chapter. Reading
- 5:44is a highly well -defined subproblem. Oh, I see.
- 5:47Because the letters are the state, the rules
- 5:49of English are the operators. Bingo. He looks
- 5:52at the letters, applies the operators of the
- 5:54English language, and achieves the goal of literally
- 5:57comprehending the sentences. We basically navigate
- 6:01the unknown by stringing together these small,
- 6:04manageable islands of certainty. That makes so
- 6:06much sense. So the real challenge with these
- 6:08tricky, ill -defined problems is how we mentally
- 6:10frame them. Which brings us to the Gestalt psychologists
- 6:15from the 1920s. Ah, yes, the Gestalt guys. Yeah,
- 6:18they push back against the idea that problem
- 6:20-solving is just like grinding through a checklist.
- 6:24They introduce this concept called restructuring.
- 6:26Yeah, and to grasp restructuring, we really need
- 6:29to look at how the brain holds information. When
- 6:32you face an obstacle, you basically create an
- 6:35internal representation of it. Like a mental
- 6:37map. Exactly. You build a mental model based
- 6:41on the external reality, the physical objects
- 6:43or the social dynamics right in front of you.
- 6:45Right. But sometimes the way your brain automatically
- 6:49maps that representation is the exact thing that
- 6:51is preventing you from solving the problem. A
- 6:54perfect example of this from the textbook is
- 6:56the story of the two kids playing badminton.
- 6:58Oh, I love this story. It's so good. So the older
- 7:01boy is physically bigger and more coordinated,
- 7:04so he wins every single round. The younger boy
- 7:07is getting crushed. gets completely demoralized,
- 7:10and just throws down his racket saying he wants
- 7:11to quit. Which means suddenly, the older boy
- 7:14has a problem. Right. He's about to lose his
- 7:16playing partner. And if the older boy relies
- 7:19on his initial mental representation of the game,
- 7:22he is totally stuck. Because his internal model
- 7:25says, this is a competition. I win, he loses.
- 7:28Exactly. And from that framework, His only operators
- 7:32are either bribing the younger kid to keep playing,
- 7:34shaming him for quitting, or intentionally playing
- 7:37terribly to let him win. And none of those are
- 7:40real solutions. They just kind of delay the inevitable.
- 7:43Right. But he doesn't do any of those things.
- 7:45He restructures the problem. He literally changes
- 7:47the internal representation of the goal. He tells
- 7:50the younger boy, instead of playing against each
- 7:52other, let's see how long we can keep the birdie
- 7:54in the air together. The cognitive flexibility
- 7:56required to do that is immense, honestly. I mean,
- 8:00he didn't change the external reality. They are
- 8:02still just two kids with rackets and a birdie.
- 8:05Yeah, the physical state is exactly the same.
- 8:07But he changed the mental mapping. And it's a
- 8:09profound moral shift, too, if you think about
- 8:12it. He took a zero -sum framework of dominance
- 8:14where one person's joy relies entirely on the
- 8:17other's defeat. And he restructured it into a
- 8:21framework of cooperation and mutual benefit.
- 8:23That's a great point. The problem of the younger
- 8:25boy quitting simply vanishes because the game
- 8:29is no longer designed to produce a loser. Gestalt
- 8:32psychologists call that productive thinking.
- 8:34You aren't just applying an old algorithm to
- 8:36a new situation, which, by the way, is called
- 8:39reproductive thinking. Right. Reproductive is
- 8:41just doing what you've always done. Exactly.
- 8:44Productive thinking demands that you step outside
- 8:46your existing schema and create an entirely novel
- 8:49framework. And when that sudden restructuring
- 8:52clicks into place, it produces what we call insight.
- 8:55The famous aha. Yes. It is that rush of dopamine
- 8:59when you're staring at a wall, completely stuck,
- 9:03and suddenly the wall just becomes a door. And
- 9:06to show you what that cognitive friction actually
- 9:08feels like, we have a little interactive puzzle
- 9:09for you. Yes, we want you to actively think about
- 9:12this as you listen. It is called the chain problem.
- 9:15Okay, so picture Nut again. Nut is given four
- 9:18separate pieces of a metal chain. Each piece
- 9:20consists of three links. So four pieces, three
- 9:23links each. Right. His goal is to connect all
- 9:26of these pieces into one single continuous closed
- 9:29loop. OK. Seems simple enough. But here is the
- 9:32constraint. It costs two cents to cut a link
- 9:34open. and it costs three cents to weld a link
- 9:38closed. And that has a total budget of exactly
- 9:4015 cents. Right. And if you do the math on your
- 9:43first instinct, which is usually opening the
- 9:46end link of piece A and attaching it to piece
- 9:48B, you'll realize it costs five cents per connection.
- 9:52Because it's two cents to open, three to close.
- 9:54Exactly. So three connections to make a long
- 9:57line plus a fourth connection to close the loop
- 9:59equals 20 cents. You are over budget. So how
- 10:02does he do it for exactly 15 cents? Keep that
- 10:05in the back of your mind. We'll break down the
- 10:07solution before the end of this study session,
- 10:08but just notice the frustration you might be
- 10:10feeling right now. That feeling is the absolute
- 10:13hallmark of an insight problem. The reason the
- 10:16solution isn't obvious is due to a cognitive
- 10:18blind spot called fixation. Which really makes
- 10:21you wonder, if insight and restructuring are
- 10:23so powerful, why do we get blocked at all? Like,
- 10:26why isn't our brain just constantly shifting
- 10:28perspectives until the answer appears? Because
- 10:31shifting perspectives takes a massive amount
- 10:33of metabolic energy. Oh, right. The brain is
- 10:37lazy. Well, efficient. The human brain is designed
- 10:39to be efficient, not necessarily creative. We
- 10:42develop these mental blocks, specifically functional
- 10:45fixedness, because our past experiences wire
- 10:48us to see objects only in terms of their most
- 10:51common use. The classic demonstration of this
- 10:53is the candle problem. Oh, a psychology staple.
- 10:57Right. So you are placed in a room. On a table,
- 11:00there is a box of matches, a few candles, and
- 11:03some thumbtacks. There's a cork board on the
- 11:05wall. Your task is to attach the candle to the
- 11:08wall so that when you light it, absolutely no
- 11:11wax drips onto the floor. And a novice approaches
- 11:14this with functional fixedness. They try to tack
- 11:17the wax candle directly to the wall, which just
- 11:19splits the wax. Yeah, or they try melting the
- 11:22side of the candle to stick it to the board,
- 11:23which eventually just falls off. Right. They
- 11:25fail because they look at the box holding the
- 11:27matches, and they categorize it strictly as a
- 11:29container. The insight comes when you dump the
- 11:31matches out. You tack the empty match box to
- 11:34the cork board, and you sit the candle inside
- 11:36the box. The box basically becomes a shelf. But
- 11:38overcoming that functional fixedness is incredibly
- 11:41hard because you have to mentally suppress the
- 11:44concept of container to unlock the concept of
- 11:47support structure. It's the exact same mechanism
- 11:50at play in the two -string problem. Oh yeah,
- 11:51where two strings are hanging from a ceiling
- 11:53too far apart to grab at the same time. Right,
- 11:56and the only object in the room is a heavy pair
- 11:58of metal pliers. To solve it, you have to tie
- 12:01the pliers to one string, swing it like a pendulum,
- 12:04walk over to grab the second string, and catch
- 12:06the first one as it swings back. Here's where
- 12:09it gets really interesting because there is this
- 12:11brutal irony to all of this. In evolutionary
- 12:15terms, learning that a box holds things or that
- 12:18pliers grip wire is highly adaptive. Yeah, it
- 12:22means we don't have to relearn the physics of
- 12:23our environment every single morning. Exactly.
- 12:25We build these efficient neurological shortcuts.
- 12:28But when it comes to abstract problem solving,
- 12:31that exact evolutionary advantage becomes a trap.
- 12:34The more experienced we are with an object, the
- 12:36blinder we are to its alternative uses. It is
- 12:39a massive cognitive trap, and it doesn't just
- 12:42apply to physical objects either. We get functionally
- 12:44fixed on concepts and procedures too, which we
- 12:47call a mental set. A mental set. Right. When
- 12:50you use a specific approach to solve a problem
- 12:53successfully, your brain crystallizes that approach.
- 12:57Psychologists love to study this using wrong
- 12:59answer verbal insight problems. These are brilliant
- 13:02because people don't just feel stuck. They confidently
- 13:05blurt out the entirely wrong answer. Oh, I know
- 13:08exactly what you're talking about. Like this
- 13:09one. Imagine a lake. There is a patch of water
- 13:12lilies on this lake that doubles in size every
- 13:1524 hours. It takes exactly 60 days for the lilies
- 13:19to cover the entire lake. How many days does
- 13:21it take to cover half the lake? And the immediate
- 13:23reflexive answer most people shout is 30 days.
- 13:27Which is reproductive thinking. Exactly. Their
- 13:29brain hears the numbers, 60 and a half, triggers
- 13:32a simple division algorithm, and spits out 30.
- 13:35They completely bypass the actual logic of the
- 13:37scenario. Because if the patch doubles every
- 13:40day, the lake is half covered on day 59. One
- 13:43day later, it doubles to cover the whole lake
- 13:45on day 60. You might argue that people are...
- 13:47just, you know, rushing and not reading carefully.
- 13:50But Dalip and Dominovski ran a study in 1992
- 13:53where they actually gave people error feedback.
- 13:56Oh, right. Someone would say 30 days and the
- 13:59researchers would literally say, no, that is
- 14:01incorrect. Take your time and try again. And
- 14:03the feedback barely helped. Only about one third
- 14:06of the participants realized their math error.
- 14:09the vast majority remained entirely fixated on
- 14:12their flawed mental representation. They just
- 14:15couldn't tear down the division algorithm. Because,
- 14:18computationally, dismantling a mental model and
- 14:21building a new one from scratch feels exhausting
- 14:23to the brain. The most dramatic proof of this
- 14:25has to be the water jug problem. Picture that
- 14:27again. Okay, that's back. He has three empty
- 14:29jugs and a faucet. Jug A holds 127 cups, Jug
- 14:33B holds 21 cups, and Jug C holds three cups.
- 14:37He needs to measure out exactly 100 cups. Which
- 14:39requires a fairly complex schema to figure out.
- 14:41You fill the massive 127 cup jug. You pour out
- 14:45enough to fill the 21 cup jug once, leaving you
- 14:47with 106. Then you fill the tiny 3 cup jug twice,
- 14:51dumping it down the drain each time. 106 minus
- 14:543 minus 3 equals exactly 100 cups. Right. It
- 14:57is a multi -step arithmetic dance. Now, immediately
- 15:00after Nut does that, you give him a new task.
- 15:03Jug A holds 39 cups. Jug B holds 15 cups. Jug
- 15:07C holds 3 cups. He needs exactly 18 cups. And
- 15:11people who just solved the first puzzle will
- 15:13apply that exact same complex dance. Yes. They
- 15:16will fill the 39, subtract the 15, subtract the
- 15:193 twice, going through this massive algorithmic
- 15:22headache. just to get to 18. But if you bring
- 15:24someone in fresh off the street who didn't do
- 15:26the first puzzle, they look at it and say, ah,
- 15:28just fill the 15 cup jug and the 3 cup jug. 15
- 15:31plus 3 is 18. It's so obvious. Right. The first
- 15:33group was completely blinded to the incredibly
- 15:35simple solution because their mental set literally
- 15:38forced them down the complex bath they had just
- 15:40used. So the million dollar question for our
- 15:42exam prep is, if our own prior experiences build
- 15:45these rigid mental sets, how do we break out
- 15:48of them? Cognitive psychology says the best way
- 15:50to escape a mental set in one do - is to borrow
- 15:52a structural framework from an entirely different
- 15:54domain. We use analogies. Exactly, analogies.
- 15:58Let's look at Carl Dunker's radiation problem
- 16:00from 1945, which is notorious for stumping people.
- 16:04Okay, lay it on me. You are a surgeon. Your patient
- 16:06has an inoperable tumor deep in their stomach.
- 16:09You have a radiation laser. If you use a low
- 16:12-intensity ray, it passes harmlessly through
- 16:15healthy tissue, but it's too weak to destroy
- 16:17the tumor. Right. If you use a high -intensity
- 16:19ray, it will destroy the tumor, but it will also
- 16:21destroy all the healthy tissue it burns through
- 16:23on the way there. How do you save the patient?
- 16:26And almost nobody gets this right off the bat.
- 16:28The brain just loops between too weak and too
- 16:30deadly. So true. So later researchers like Gick
- 16:34and Holyoke tried something. Before giving participants
- 16:37the radiation problem, they had them read a story
- 16:39about a dictator and a general. Right. In the
- 16:42story, a general wants to capture a dictator's
- 16:45fortress. He has a massive army that could easily
- 16:48crush the fortress. However, he discovers that
- 16:51all the roads leading to the fortress are rigged
- 16:53with land mines. Yeah, and small groups of men
- 16:56can walk over the mines safely, but the heavy
- 16:59weight of the full army will detonate them, destroying
- 17:02the roads and the troops. The general solves
- 17:05this by dividing his massive army into dozens
- 17:07of small squads. He sends each squad down a different
- 17:11road and synchronizes their watches so they all
- 17:14converge on the fortress at the exact same moment.
- 17:17Which means they pass the mine safely, unite
- 17:19their strength at the center, and overthrow the
- 17:21dictator. Now map that onto the medical problem.
- 17:25When people just got the radiation puzzle alone,
- 17:27about 10 % solved it. When they read the general
- 17:30story first, success jumped to 30%. But when
- 17:33the researchers explicitly said, use the military
- 17:36story as a hint for the medical problem, a massive
- 17:3975 % solved it. The solution is to set up multiple
- 17:43low -intensity radiation lasers all around the
- 17:46patient's body, aiming them all at the tumor.
- 17:48Right. They pass harmlessly through the healthy
- 17:50tissue from different angles. Yeah. But where
- 17:52all the beams intersect at the tumor, their combined
- 17:55intensity destroys it. which reveals a critical
- 17:58mechanical truth about analogies. Possessing
- 18:01the knowledge isn't enough. You must actively
- 18:03map the cognitive structures. And there is a
- 18:06handy acronym for the exam, RMA. RMA. First,
- 18:11you recognize the connection between the base
- 18:13story and the target problem. Okay, recognize.
- 18:15Second, you map the corresponding parts. Your
- 18:18brain has to literally link the concepts. The
- 18:21fortress is the tumor, the heavy army is the
- 18:23high -intensity ray, the small squads are the
- 18:25low -intensity rays. Right, mapping. Finally,
- 18:28apply that mapping to generate the new solution.
- 18:31Recognize. Map. Apply. The reason that first
- 18:34-step recognition is so difficult is that human
- 18:36beings are easily distracted by surface features.
- 18:39We look at lasers and tumors and we look at armies
- 18:41and landmines and our brains say these have nothing
- 18:43to do with each other. Totally different domains.
- 18:45Exactly. To recognize an analogy you have to
- 18:48peel away the surface details to find the underlying
- 18:50abstract blueprint. We call that blueprint a
- 18:53problem schema. And Gick and Holyoke discovered
- 18:56a way to actually train the brain to see that
- 18:59blueprint without needing an explicit hint. It's
- 19:02a process called schema induction. Right. If
- 19:04you have someone read two different stories that
- 19:06share the same underlying solution, say the military
- 19:10story, and another story about firefighters using
- 19:12multiple small hoses to put out a blazing fire,
- 19:16The brain does something incredible. It acts
- 19:18like a mathematical lowest common denominator.
- 19:20By comparing the two stories, the brain strips
- 19:23away all the irrelevant surface details. The
- 19:26soldiers, the water, the fire, the dictator.
- 19:29It filters out the noise. Yeah, and it extracts
- 19:31the pure structural truth. Multiple weak forces
- 19:34converging from different directions equal one
- 19:37strong force. Once you induce that schema, you
- 19:39can apply it to tumors or business logistics
- 19:42or whatever else. Mastering schema induction
- 19:44is honestly the literal dividing line between
- 19:47a novice and an expert. An expert isn't someone
- 19:50who is naturally a genius. An expert is simply
- 19:52someone who has spent thousands of hours in a
- 19:54specific domain extracting and storing a massive
- 19:57library of these deep structure schemas. And
- 20:01Chase and Simon proved this in their 1973 chess
- 20:03study. They showed chess boards to grandmasters
- 20:06and total beginners for just a few seconds, then
- 20:09asked them to recreate the board from memory.
- 20:12And when the pieces were arranged in logical
- 20:14game formations, the grandmasters reproduced
- 20:17them flawlessly. But the twist is what matters
- 20:19here. When the researchers placed the pieces
- 20:22randomly in ways that break the rules of chess
- 20:24and would never appear in a real game, the grandmasters
- 20:27did no better than the beginners. They couldn't
- 20:30remember where anything was. Because the grandmasters
- 20:32aren't using photographic memory, they're using
- 20:34pattern recognition. A chess expert has an estimated
- 20:3850 ,000 schemas stored in their brain. 50 ,000?
- 20:42Yeah. They don't see a knight, a bishop, and
- 20:44a pawn. They see a classic defensive wall. They
- 20:47chunk the information. But take away the logical
- 20:49structure, and their expertise basically evaporates.
- 20:52Expertise is violently domain -specific. So what
- 20:55does this all mean? It all comes down to how
- 20:57knowledge is organized. McLean Chi did a study
- 21:00comparing physics professors to first semester
- 21:02physics undergrads. Oh, this is a great one.
- 21:04She handed them a stack of physics problems and
- 21:07asked them to group them by similarity. The undergrads
- 21:10grouped them by surface structure. They put all
- 21:12the problems with springs in one pile and all
- 21:15the problems with ramps in another pile. While
- 21:17the professors ignored the springs and ramps
- 21:19entirely, they grouped the problems by deep structure.
- 21:22They organized them based on the invisible physical
- 21:25principles required to solve them, like the conservation
- 21:28of energy or Newton's second law. I think about
- 21:32this like developing a moral compass. What do
- 21:34you mean? Well, a novice navigating a relationship
- 21:37conflict gets obsessed with the surface structure.
- 21:40They argue for hours over who left the dishes
- 21:42in the sink or whose turn it was to walk the
- 21:44dog. Oh, right. But a wise person, an expert
- 21:47in human behavior, looks at the deep structure.
- 21:50They recognize that the fight isn't actually
- 21:52about the dishes. The underlying schema is a
- 21:55fundamental human need for respect or a feeling
- 21:58of being undervalued. That's a beautiful way
- 22:00to put it. And if we connect this to the bigger
- 22:02picture, seeing the deep structure explains one
- 22:05of the most counterintuitive findings in cognitive
- 22:08psychology. Experts actually spend significantly
- 22:11more time analyzing a problem before they act
- 22:13than novices do. Which sounds completely backward.
- 22:17You'd assume an expert would just glance at it
- 22:19and instantly know what to do. Right. But they
- 22:21eventually execute the solution much faster.
- 22:24But they frontload the cognitive labor. A novice
- 22:27panics. grabs the first surface -level detail
- 22:30they see, rushes in, and hits a dead end. They
- 22:33just start trying operators. Yeah. But an expert
- 22:36stops. They intentionally delay acting so they
- 22:38can analyze the deep structure and guarantee
- 22:40they're retrieving the exact right schema from
- 22:43their memory bank. Speaking of taking a moment
- 22:45to analyze, I almost forgot. The chain problem.
- 22:48We cannot leave you hanging on that puzzle. Oh,
- 22:50right. Remember Nut, with his four pieces of
- 22:53chain, three links each, 15 cents total budget.
- 22:55Right. And if you try to just open the end of
- 22:58one piece and attach it to the next, you hit
- 23:0020 cents. The insight requires you to overcome
- 23:02functional fixedness regarding the pieces themselves.
- 23:05You don't disconnect them. No. You have to completely
- 23:08destroy one of the pieces. Exactly. You take
- 23:10one of the three link pieces and you cut every
- 23:12single link open. Opening three links costs six
- 23:15cents. Okay, six cents. Now you have three separate
- 23:18open links. You use those three open links to
- 23:20connect the remaining three solid pieces together.
- 23:23Welding them closed costs nine cents. Six plus
- 23:26nine equals exactly 15 cents. Mind blown. It
- 23:30requires you to restructure your mental representation
- 23:32entirely. You had to stop seeing four equal pieces
- 23:36and start seeing three foundational pieces and
- 23:38one sacrifice piece. A perfect example of productive
- 23:41thinking. All right. Let's summarize your study
- 23:43guide before we go. Remember, SOG for well -defined
- 23:46problems. State operators. Goal. And ill -defined
- 23:50problems are murky, but we conquer them by breaking
- 23:52them into well -defined sub -problems. Be aware
- 23:55of your own mental representations. Sometimes
- 23:58you need to restructure a problem like changing
- 24:01the goal of badminton to find an insight. And
- 24:04watch out for functional fixedness in mental
- 24:07sets, which trap you in rigid algorithms. When
- 24:10you are totally stuck, use an analogy. RMA. Recognize
- 24:14the connection. Map the parts. Apply the solution.
- 24:17And if you want to be an expert in your field,
- 24:20stop focusing on the surface details. Put in
- 24:23the time to induce the deep structure schemas,
- 24:25and always analyze the problem fully before you
- 24:27make a move. Which leaves us with a final philosophical
- 24:31thought for your notes. We know that experts
- 24:33are only experts because of domain -specific
- 24:35schemas. Right. If you scramble the rules, a
- 24:38chess grandmaster is no better than a novice.
- 24:40But life itself is a wildly ill -defined problem.
- 24:43The rules change every day, the operators are
- 24:45unpredictable, and the goal state is highly subjective.
- 24:49So true. So is it ever truly possible to become
- 24:51an expert at life? Or are we all just perpetual
- 24:54undergrads constantly scrambling to induce new
- 24:57schemas from the messy stories we care with each
- 24:59other? Wow. What a question to leave hanging.
- 25:02Thank you so much for hitting the books with
- 25:03us today. Good luck on the chapter 9 exam and
- 25:06we'll see you next time on the Psychology Undergrad.