Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / SXSW EDU Special: Breaking Down Barriers: Inclusive Technology in the Classroom
Transcript
- 0:00I'm here today with Tara Courchaine, Michelle Soriano, and Kelli Suding of CAST.
- 0:05Thank you all for being here. Appreciate your time. And I wonder,
- 0:09just to start, could you introduce yourselves and your roles at CAST?
- 0:13Sure. I'm Tara Courchaine. I'm the Chief Research and Development Officer at CAST.
- 0:18I've been at CAST for a little over two years, and I oversee all of our federally
- 0:22funded K-12 research work.
- 0:24Hi, and I'm Michelle Soriano, and I am one of our Technical Assistance Specialist at CAST.
- 0:30I support both the National Center on Accessible Educational Materials and the CITES Center.
- 0:36Hi, and I'm Kelli Suding. I'm also one of the Technical Assistant Specialists
- 0:40at CAST, supporting the National Center on Accessible Educational Materials, or AIM, and CITES.
- 0:46Wonderful. So, you know, at ELA, the Educating All Learners Alliance,
- 0:50we focus a lot on accessibility within education, inclusive education,
- 0:55and I know that you do too.
- 0:57Could you tell us a little bit about how inclusive technology kind of breaks
- 1:02down the barriers for students who have learning disabilities?
- 1:06Absolutely. Well, inclusive technology really ties into our belief at CAST around
- 1:10universal design for learning. And we really feel that when...
- 1:15Instruction and technology is inclusive, kids can be successful in the general
- 1:19education classroom together.
- 1:21So kids that do have differing abilities or needs, when they have technology
- 1:26that is accessible for them, such as text-to-speech or speech-to-text,
- 1:30it really works so that they don't need something different.
- 1:33They don't need to wait longer to get what they need. They're not using a different device.
- 1:38They're all working together in a community so that they can have a sense of
- 1:43not just inclusion, but belonging.
- 1:46Belonging. Yeah, that's interesting. So when we think about inclusive technology
- 1:49as well, it's really about choice built in to the technology.
- 1:53So when we were talking about universal design for learning,
- 1:55it's choice built into the environment.
- 1:57But when we think about inclusive technology, it's an option that all of our
- 2:00students can have when they're in the classroom.
- 2:02So it's like Tara alluded to, so then our students don't look like they feel different.
- 2:07So then we have students who need what is assistive technology,
- 2:10which means they actually need that type of like text-to-speech or speech-to-text
- 2:15to be successful in the classroom.
- 2:16So just thinking about the choice is already built into the environment.
- 2:20And then it's really not an afterthought. We're not retrofitting the technology
- 2:23like, oh my gosh, I have to get a third-party app or a third-party software
- 2:27for my students to be able to access, decode, and engage in the content.
- 2:31So it's really important to always think about inclusion always in the forefront. Sure.
- 2:35Yeah. It's interesting Interesting you mentioned that idea of belonging.
- 2:39And there really is a difference between someone being welcome and someone belonging there.
- 2:48And I think it might be what you said, the idea of that choice being built in already for them.
- 2:54There's no thought and accommodation that needs to be made on the fly, anything like that.
- 2:59Yeah, and even to push that even further, belonging. And it's also,
- 3:03there's a difference between being entertained by the technology and being engaged in the technology.
- 3:07So that's really what inclusive technology can support.
- 3:10A lot of fun, you know, like we learn through play and that's really important,
- 3:14but when it comes to actually engaging in the content.
- 3:17That's, yeah, that's kind of pushing more toward that. I wonder if you could
- 3:21say a little bit more about that idea of learning through play.
- 3:24Oh yeah. Learning through play. I think even at, at cast,
- 3:28even during our own meetings, we're doing things where there's activities where
- 3:31it's like really fun and we're seeming like in playing and sometimes it's also not only entertaining,
- 3:36but we're engaged as how we learn things without even really knowing,
- 3:40because some of our students will be resistant when it feels like another thing
- 3:43they have to do. unless like we could talk about worksheets, right?
- 3:46You hand a student a worksheet with learning disability, they cannot engage
- 3:51and interact with that content because the barrier is decoding.
- 3:55So they only have access to that worksheet.
- 3:57And so when we think about play, instead of having those worksheets,
- 4:01having activities where we're standing up, we're thinking about multisensory
- 4:04opportunities through that play.
- 4:07And that's how we learn. You think of early childhood, preschool.
- 4:10Babies, they're learning through that play, like touching and feeling.
- 4:14And so I think just because our students get older, even as adults, we don't lose that.
- 4:19That's why when we present together at CAS, come to our sessions because we're
- 4:23like, hey, dance parties, all those things to really engage the brain.
- 4:27So we can be successful and we can also learn. And we have to take those moments
- 4:32of play to be able to really reset our brains to be able to engage into the lesson.
- 4:37That makes me think of just one other thing I want to mention is a lot of the
- 4:41research shows that we learn the best when we're curious.
- 4:45And through play and through exploring is where our curiosity is sparked.
- 4:51So that's really a critical piece too.
- 4:54Yeah, yeah. I mean, I imagine that just thinking about it from what you described
- 4:59that, you know, play is really...
- 5:03Has to be sort of an intuitive thing. So to have all these barriers between
- 5:08you and what you're learning is it's going to, I guess, decrease the enjoyment
- 5:14of it, but just the intuitive nature of it and the play of it.
- 5:17Well, and I think something that really increases those barriers is when we're
- 5:24not proactive in thinking about that design.
- 5:26And so when we're really designing ways, whether it's play, whether it's engagement
- 5:31through multiple means, we really have to be proactive in thinking about all
- 5:35of our kiddos' needs, really thinking about the technology that we're bringing
- 5:38in. Is it truly inclusive?
- 5:40Are we trying to retrofit it? Or are we really considering that from the beginning?
- 5:45Because that's what's going to help decrease those barriers in everything that our students do.
- 5:51Yes. And we're just going to keep on adding here. It reminds me of an experience. Yeah.
- 5:55It reminds me of an experience one time co-teaching with a sixth grade teacher.
- 5:59And so I was in special education. This was a Gen Ed teacher.
- 6:01And so we brought in some technology. The school didn't really,
- 6:05it wasn't one-to-one technology. So they brought in technology.
- 6:08And then the Gen Ed teacher had this activity. And I can't remember,
- 6:12it was like a quiz activity on the iPads. And so it was really great.
- 6:16But the thing is that was missing was the kids were really excited.
- 6:19So they're all in this big group looking at this technology, doing these quizzes.
- 6:23And they were just like having a blast, okay? Like having a blast.
- 6:26You had to answer questions a certain amount of time.
- 6:29I remember the superintendent came in and said, oh my gosh, look at all these
- 6:32students are engaged. And I said, I hear what you're saying.
- 6:35Some of our students are not because we're not considering the processing time
- 6:38of having those time quizzes.
- 6:40So they're just back sort of like cheering on their peers when in fact the processing
- 6:45time was not considered.
- 6:47So for those students, you know, they're not going to say, I'm sorry,
- 6:50I can't answer it quick enough. They just sit back.
- 6:52And so they're more of, they're, they're They're more passive in their own education.
- 6:55So inclusive technology is thinking about all the activities so all of our students
- 6:59can be engaged and not just participating passively.
- 7:04We want all of our students to take charge of their own learning.
- 7:07And those opportunities are thinking about the design with universal design
- 7:10for learning and those inclusive technologies.
- 7:12Yeah. I mean, you mentioned earlier this idea of making sure that students are
- 7:16engaged through technology, not just, you know, entertained by it.
- 7:20So what are some changes that you would like to see more that edtech vendors
- 7:25can make to make their technology and their products more accessible and inclusive?
- 7:30Yeah, I think a big part is having people who use assistive technology in the whole process.
- 7:36Within the design process? Within the design process and not thinking after
- 7:39it's been designed. So we think, oh my gosh, this is a really cool tool.
- 7:42And then you think we have a user who uses, let's just say, a screen reader.
- 7:48And all of a sudden the screen reader can get to the question but then they
- 7:51can't get to the options or the game itself or it's you know it's provided by.
- 7:56The screen reader can't access the images and maybe it's a game that
- 7:59is really reliant on visuals and so we
- 8:01have to think is there alt text in there how's the screen reader actually
- 8:04going to be able to start you know from this from the
- 8:07start to the finish and we always say at cast accessibility should be the start
- 8:11to the finish and it's not extra steps it's just steps that you've missed and
- 8:15so what i really hope is that edtech vendors keep that in mind and always have
- 8:20those users with disabilities on the boards and in the conversations,
- 8:26especially when it comes to, because a big part is procurement.
- 8:28When we have states and districts who are wanting to use these softwares and
- 8:33discover that they're not accessible, I mean, those things aren't going to be purchased.
- 8:39So just keeping that in mind, like accessibility from the start to the finish
- 8:43and have those users involved in the conversations as well. Sure.
- 8:46And I also think that it's really important.
- 8:48And one thing that I really wish we can move beyond, and it's something I had
- 8:52to learn as an educator as well, is that sometimes those things that you think
- 8:56that's cute and it's fun and it's, oh,
- 8:58they will love this or, oh, this is going to really look awesome in my classroom. It's not accessible.
- 9:04And if it's not accessible, then our students aren't going to benefit from it
- 9:07and they're not going to get the and reap the outcomes that we're hoping for.
- 9:11And so when we're thinking about it, especially from a vendor standpoint,
- 9:14when they're designing things to accommodate the curriculum or the books that
- 9:18people are purchasing, making sure that it's not a drag and drop if it's not
- 9:22accessible, right? Because screen readers cannot use that.
- 9:25Things that are activities that are built in, embedding choice,
- 9:29but choice that everybody has the option to engage in any single activity that's on there.
- 9:34Because our schools are purchasing and they're spending a lot of funds to purchase
- 9:40these things and they're getting them.
- 9:42And you You know, you don't know what you don't know until you know it.
- 9:45And when you get it and it's not accessible, boom, we've just spent a whole
- 9:49lot of money for things that our students cannot engage with.
- 9:54Wow. Yeah. Building upon that, oftentimes when, you know, schools purchase those
- 9:58technologies and then they, you know, ed tech, the developers may like,
- 10:02haven't been really thinking about accessibility.
- 10:04So then what happens is we try to retrofit. We're getting accessible overlays
- 10:08over the actual software or the technology, which ends It ends up becoming the barrier.
- 10:13So really thinking about the skill sets. I loved how you said drag and drop.
- 10:16We think about that on the iPad. There's a lot of drag and drop,
- 10:19but students don't have those skill sets sometimes even do that.
- 10:22You know, maybe it's mobility.
- 10:23So just keeping all of that in mind. Yeah.
- 10:26You it's interesting. We've kind of been talking about it from the ed tech vendor side.
- 10:31And you mentioned the perspective of the educator themselves.
- 10:35And I wonder if you were to give a quick tip to teachers listening who are looking
- 10:41at inclusive technology for inclusive technology.
- 10:45What would you tell them if they're if this is something they're just getting into? to?
- 10:49Well, first I would say, hey, CAS has got some resources for you that can help you learn.
- 10:54Yeah. Because we all start learning somewhere and we don't know what we don't know until we know it.
- 10:59And so what I would say is ask the questions. Really think about the diverse
- 11:03needs of the possible students that might come into your classroom tomorrow
- 11:08because high mobility rate is everywhere.
- 11:10And then go and explore how to vet for accessibility.
- 11:14So if you're thinking about using something specific with your curriculum, go through these steps.
- 11:20We have steps that are the poor, right? Is it perceivable? Can every student
- 11:24perceive it? Is it operable? Is it understandable?
- 11:28Is it written in layman terms? If it's written at a language that you're presenting
- 11:33to a third grade student and it's like at a seventh grade level,
- 11:36guess what? They're not going to know what you're talking about.
- 11:38And then is it robust? Can it
- 11:40be used across technology devices across software that's being utilized.
- 11:45And then I would also encourage them to take it one step further.
- 11:49Hey, come spend some time learning about how to slide into accessibility.
- 11:54And so when you slide into accessibility, you're learning how to create accessible
- 11:59documents that students can use embedded within their technology as well.
- 12:04So you're learning about.
- 12:05Styles? How are we going to create the headings of a structure?
- 12:09Because y'all, that helps with the outline so that I can navigate anywhere in
- 12:13that document without taking a million hours to get there or pretending like
- 12:18I'm there and like, yep, not there. Don't call on me.
- 12:21Then you have the L in slide is links, learning how to really personalize the
- 12:26links, making sure that they're descriptive, making sure that it's not this
- 12:30HTTPS colon hash backslash backslash.
- 12:33Because when you you think about an individual who's using a screen reader, guess what?
- 12:37They're going to read out every single letter and they're not going to know
- 12:41where it's going to take them to. Then you think about the images.
- 12:45Hey, if you're putting a cute little picture or something that's referenced
- 12:48to what you're talking about on your documents, make sure you include alt text.
- 12:52Make sure you have a description of what that picture is.
- 12:55And then of course, the D is really just making sure that the design,
- 12:59making sure that the description and everything that you have in there,
- 13:02especially those links have those descriptive factors and then E, evaluate.
- 13:08And the best thing that I can tell you is whether you're using,
- 13:11you know, Google Docs, whether you're using PowerPoint, whether you're using
- 13:15something, use the accessibility checker.
- 13:18It is my BFF.
- 13:20It is my best friend. We go through it, even as casties, we go through it and
- 13:24we check things that we're going to present to make sure that it meets that
- 13:28accessibility check, to make sure that we didn't overlook something.
- 13:32And y'all, as educators, been there, done that. It's not one more thing.
- 13:37It is the steps that you miss, but it is the value add to everything that you
- 13:43are already doing. And guess what?
- 13:46It helps increase that student outcome.
- 13:49Because if my students can take it in and they can make sense of it and it's
- 13:52relevant, then they're going to have better outcomes.
- 13:56And I just want to add two more things on a very light note.
- 13:59One is teachers need to give themselves permission.
- 14:02They need permission to try new things, to work with new ideas.
- 14:08They need permission to fail, and they need permission to succeed,
- 14:12and they need to give themselves that.
- 14:14And then the second piece that goes along with it is give yourself grace.
- 14:19You need a lot of grace to be a successful teacher, and then you just keep at it and keep trying.
- 14:24Sure, yeah. I think something else that's really great to remember,
- 14:28and Kelli reminds us of this often, remember your why.
- 14:31Remember why you're doing this. Remember why you got into the field,
- 14:35because there's so much going on.
- 14:37There's a lot of chaotic pieces, but when we can always remember our why and
- 14:41we know how we're trying to make that impact for our students and our learners,
- 14:45it just brings it back and it gives you that sense of, ah,
- 14:49all right, y'all, we've got this. Yeah, that's wonderful.
- 14:54At ILA, we're developing an accessibility course for edtech vendors.
- 14:58And what would you say to an edtech vendor who's considering the possibilities
- 15:05of accessibility, whether that is stuff that's already in place or exciting
- 15:12things on the forefront?
- 15:13What would you say to a vendor considering these possibilities but not knowing where to start?
- 15:19You know what I would tell the vendors is...
- 15:22That even though it may seem like more work and more time and more money at
- 15:26the beginning to update your workflow or think about how to design for accessibility,
- 15:31at the end, it's going to produce or have more profit than it would have otherwise
- 15:37because it's usable by more people.
- 15:39It's usable by a broader audience. And sometimes people have situational disabilities
- 15:44where they may benefit from something that's embedded in that software that
- 15:48wouldn't have been there if it hadn't been designed excessively. Sure.
- 15:52I love that. And I always think back to something that I learned when I was
- 15:56first learning about universal design for learning is that what is required
- 16:00for some is beneficial for all.
- 16:02And so if we're really thinking through that lens and that mindset of,
- 16:06you know, I want to design something that can meet the widest range of variability,
- 16:12because we know that learners take in information in different ways,
- 16:15then I know that more individuals are going to benefit from that. And so I agree with Tara.
- 16:22I think just considering the needs and don't think of it like,
- 16:25oh man, I have to redo it, but really think about like, wow,
- 16:29I'm going to redo this and I'm going to make sure that we're impacting the widest
- 16:34range of learners that we possibly can because word of mouth is very strong, right?
- 16:40So when we have a school who's purchasing something and it is truly accessible,
- 16:44because accessibility is on the forefront of everybody's mind, right?
- 16:49And so when we're purchasing something and it's proven to be accessible,
- 16:52other states are going to want to purchase it as well because educators, we like to talk.
- 16:58And so sharing that good news, we want to be able to share that,
- 17:01hey, this vendor has really created something strong and powerful and accessible. Yes, and?
- 17:08I think sometimes we think disabilities and then individuals accessing the content,
- 17:13maybe on a website, we think of more individuals who maybe have blindness, low vision.
- 17:17So we're considering that. That's like the first thing is considered.
- 17:20Then we think about someone with a physical disability. How can they engage
- 17:24and interact with the content online?
- 17:27But sometimes I feel like it's
- 17:29overlooked for individuals with learning disabilities, such as dyslexia.
- 17:33I mean, 20% of the world's population has dyslexia or symptoms of dyslexia. that's a large number.
- 17:38And so when it comes to that, if your, if your, your software or what you're,
- 17:44whatever you're creating doesn't have those elements of text to speech,
- 17:48the ability for, you know, speech to text, being able to enlarge,
- 17:52like highlighting and all of that, that's going to be a huge barrier.
- 17:55And those are the, those are the times when we can't see the disability.
- 17:58I feel like sometimes it's seen, it's not as crucial.
- 18:02And that's not it. We think about for For every learner, not just one learner,
- 18:06not just for some, but every learner.
- 18:08So when we say users, the broadest range of users, that really means including
- 18:12every single learner in the way that they learn and can engage and decode and
- 18:19interact with whatever's being created.
- 18:21I love that. Every, every learner.
- 18:24Well, Kelli, Michelle, Tara, I really appreciate your time. This has been a
- 18:28great conversation. Thank you for joining us today. Thanks so much for having us. Thank you.