Latest / Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective / SWM 150 – Control, sex and marriage
Transcript
- 0:43Hello and welcome to the Sex Within Marriage podcast. I'm JD, marriage educator, coach, writer, and podcaster. At UncoveringIntimacy.com, we offer a wide range of resources to help couples strengthen intimacy in all areas of their marriage.
- 0:56I watched a video by author Gary Thomas on his Substack account last month in which he and his wife, Lisa, discussed how having a controlling spirit can be devastating to a marriage. It's an excellent video and I highly recommend checking it out.
- 1:09The discussion of how to move away from being a controlling spirit in your marriage was great and, frankly, the two of them are just adorable together. There's a link to the video in the show notes if you're interested in watching it.
- 1:22But an interesting thing in the video was that the language used to describe control can get really confusing. He gave some examples of couples where control was something that damaged their relationship as well as some stereotypical dynamics in which this occurs.
- 1:36Along the way, he couched one of his examples a bit by saying that these are bad examples of control compared to the good example of control that God is, when God gives us a choice, and the choice is basically to give up control and follow God, or keep control and do our own thing.
- 1:52And it's not that he did a bad job of describing the difference between the two. It's that it's hard to separate the two ideas of control easily, and that's something we haven't done a good job of in Christianity.
- 2:02In a later comment, Gary said that he didn't consider those loving examples of, quote-unquote, control, but rather of, quote, legitimate function, end quote, which was a bit ambiguous.
- 2:14It doesn't discuss the governance or restrictive aspect of it, only that it's a proper and necessary thing, but it doesn't do a great job of explaining why it is that God demands we give up control to him, which is seen as the most moral thing a person can do, but a husband or wife demanding control of their spouse is incredibly damaging.
- 2:35Is it simply because God is perfect? If so, that makes this a very difficult question when doing evangelism, because the person you're trying to teach about God likely doesn't know or trust that God is perfect, yet you are suggesting that they give up control of their lives to him.
- 2:51For those who teach the concept of eternal suffering in hell, this gets even more complicated, because this demand of control can come with a heavy dose of coercion as well, the obey me or be tortured for an eternity.
- 3:05If a spouse said, do as I say or else I'm going to torture you, we would consider that abusive.
- 3:10Now, Gary mentioned in passing that even if God forced you to follow him to be perfect just as he is, you would still improve and you'd be a better person.
- 3:19But in marriage, that doesn't qualify as being a good reason.
- 3:22If I went to my wife and said, look, I'm in control now, you will eat what I say you can eat, when I say you can eat it, and if you don't like it, I'm out the door, then everyone would consider that out of bounds.
- 3:34It wouldn't matter if she was trying to lose weight, it wouldn't matter if it worked, and she was happy with the results.
- 3:41The setup would still be considered abusive.
- 3:44The ends don't justify the means.
- 3:46We all inherently recoil against this idea.
- 3:49Why?
- 3:50Because it's a violation of free will.
- 3:52The choice was removed, or at least leveraged in such a way that it makes it difficult to make a real decision.
- 3:59You are being driven down a single path.
- 4:01Whether that path is good or bad doesn't matter.
- 4:04It's the violation of will that we naturally detest.
- 4:08After all, if she went to a nutritionist and paid them a bunch of money and said, all right, well, I'm going to tell you what to eat and when, and if you don't do it, then you'll have lost all your money and gotten nothing in return.
- 4:19That would be considered fair game.
- 4:22No one would blink an eye at it.
- 4:23That's a standard relationship with a nutritionist, someone who doesn't love her, and it's merely transactional.
- 4:28But if it's a husband doing the same thing, even if he had the same training as a nutritionist, that would be a violation.
- 4:37And so, of course, the reason for a recoil gives us the answer to what the difference is.
- 4:42It is the removal of choice along the entire situation.
- 4:45And it's a bit embarrassing that the BDSM community has been talking about this idea of consent and how important it is for so long, yet we as Christians tend to struggle with the same concepts when we believe it's a core tenant of our faith.
- 5:04It's one of the reasons I don't believe in eternal suffering in hell, nor the idea of predestination, as both were taught to me as a child with a reform-slash-Calvinist Christian background.
- 5:15They both violate the idea of consent, and as Gary Thomas pointed out in this video, love is not controlling.
- 5:22He said, God proclaims his truth, calls his people to respond, but he doesn't control us.
- 5:27And I 100% agree with his statement, with the caveat that Gary's definition of control implies without consent.
- 5:36So, is it just consent that makes things okay?
- 5:39Our society these days would have you believe it is, so long as it's between two consenting adults, is a phrase often touted as a justification for all sorts of behavior.
- 5:50And yet, a wife who stays with an abusive husband, we would not think of as healthy.
- 5:55Why not?
- 5:56It's consenting, she has chosen to stay.
- 5:59Sure, some are coercive and actively block attempts to leave, but some simply choose to stay.
- 6:06So, then consent isn't enough.
- 6:09Rather, I think it's a mix of consent and love.
- 6:12It has requirements on each side.
- 6:14One side must be willing to give up control, and the other must be willing to act in a way that is loving.
- 6:20Or at the very least, with the other person's best interest in mind.
- 6:23While we may not say the nutritionist in the above example is necessarily acting in a loving manner, they have to at least want the best for their clients.
- 6:33If they were attempting to poison them or starve them, this would not be okay, even with consent.
- 6:39So, then if consent and love are the requirements, how far does this extend?
- 6:44And I'll give two examples from our marriage, which I'm sure will open me up to a lot of scrutiny and perhaps criticism, but it's where we're at, and these are concepts that I've been thinking about.
- 6:55Alright, the first is finances.
- 6:57My wife hates to deal with money.
- 6:59It stresses her out, she doesn't like math much, and she hates feeling anxious about bills, investments, and everything else related to it.
- 7:07So, in our marriage, I deal with the finances.
- 7:09I track the accounts, I build the budget and watch it, I choose our investments, and I analyze our portfolio and make our retirement plans.
- 7:16She is rarely involved, except when I adjust the budget and it affects her.
- 7:22I tell her what I'm doing with her finances, but she's not terribly interested in giving a lot of input.
- 7:27If there's a charge or income and I can't figure out what it's for or how to categorize it, then I ask her, but by and large, she does not want to be involved in the finances.
- 7:36She just wants to know that if she goes to the grocery store, the gas station, or wherever else, she can tap her phone and they'll let her take the stuff she wants home.
- 7:45Now, that's not to say she isn't conscientious about our money or how we spent it.
- 7:50She is, but she never has to stress about the larger picture or most of the details.
- 7:56So much so that about a month ago, we had someone help us with a financial review.
- 8:00They wanted us both to be present, but for every question they asked, Christina would just invariably look over at me, including questions about investments under her name.
- 8:09At one point, they even asked about her retirement investments, and she said she had none.
- 8:14I corrected that and told them what her retirement accounts were and what the balance of them were.
- 8:21She had completely forgot about them and forgot the fact that, yes, before we had kids, she did work and does have a retirement account.
- 8:30Now, on the other side of the spectrum, I have a brother and sister-in-law who don't even share accounts.
- 8:35They've been married for nearly two decades now, and they still keep their finances separate.
- 8:39They each pay their part of the bills, and they have their own money.
- 8:42And I'm sure they think what I'm doing is domineering, controlling, overbearing, or some other word, but it works for us.
- 8:50It's our deal entered in with both consent and love.
- 8:54The other example is sex.
- 8:56Many years ago, Christina decided she would no longer say no to sex.
- 9:00Now, that was the ideal she set for herself.
- 9:03It wasn't my idea.
- 9:04She chose to give up that control.
- 9:06Now, the reality is, it took us a long time for both of us to accept that shift.
- 9:11It's actually a lot harder for me to accept it than her.
- 9:14But now, nearly a decade later, we've slowly evolved this into me completely controlling our sex life, only taking the final steps of that in the last little while.
- 9:24And really, it's still evolving.
- 9:26When, what, how, how long, and more, they're all up to me.
- 9:30That means sometimes we have sex multiple times per day.
- 9:33Sometimes it's for a few hours in a day.
- 9:36Truth be told, some of this, on top of everything else we have going on, is contributing to why I've written less lately.
- 9:42It's a fairly new development, and we're having a lot of fun with it.
- 9:46And I'm sure somebody is going to listen to this and go, yeah, sure, you're having a lot of fun, but your poor wife.
- 9:53But I mean it.
- 9:54We are having a lot of fun with it.
- 9:56She has been happier, smiley, affectionate, and more joyful all around than she ever has been before.
- 10:03Surrendering control of our sex life seems to have lifted a large burden off of her, and she just gets to enjoy it.
- 10:10And I think it does help that I quite enjoy giving her pleasure, and lots of it.
- 10:16And I tend to focus on hers more than mine.
- 10:18These days, I'm trying to grow into the role of accepting that control as fast as she's willing to give it up.
- 10:24And a lot of our small conflicts now are her asking why I didn't ask for more when she could tell I wanted it.
- 10:30But I was trying to be considerate.
- 10:33And honestly, I'm still sometimes scared to ask for more.
- 10:36She actually now wants me to be more selfish, which I frankly struggle to do.
- 10:42And I think a big part of it is that we men are trained all of our lives to defer to our wives, well before the time that we have one.
- 10:50All of our stories, TV shows, movies, jokes, and more tell us that the wife will be in charge.
- 10:55And any husband who thinks otherwise is fooling himself, especially regarding sex.
- 11:00As I said, it's been harder for me to deprogram that than it has been for her.
- 11:05Or perhaps she started sooner than I in the process, and it wasn't until we hit a certain point that I started having to grow to keep up.
- 11:12Now, it isn't all one-sided.
- 11:15Christina is far more interested and knowledgeable about chickens than I am.
- 11:19She has full control over the chickens.
- 11:21Which to breed, which to sell, which to color butcher, which eggs to eat, which to hatch, and which to feed to the dogs.
- 11:27And it seems that there's a pattern emerging in our marriage, that whoever has the interest gets the control.
- 11:34We don't fight over it.
- 11:35If anything, we fight more with ourselves to accept the dynamic of giving and taking control, rather than fighting with each other to try to wrestle control.
- 11:44And I don't know if that comes with age, wisdom, length of marriage, trust, or experience.
- 11:49It's most likely all those work together to build a foundation that allows for this, because why isn't this the default?
- 11:57Why aren't we taught this?
- 11:59Now that we've reached this stage in our marriage, it seems obvious to us.
- 12:03Why would you not let the person who has the most interest in something lead it, assuming they can do so in a loving and competent way?
- 12:10And in some areas of life, these are considered acceptable.
- 12:14The one who has the more interest in cooking should probably cook more.
- 12:17Doesn't mean that they have to cook all the time, but take the lead.
- 12:21The one who is more interested in a clean house should take the lead there.
- 12:25Again, that doesn't mean they're responsible for all the cleaning, but in our marriage, that's not me.
- 12:30I clean until Christina's happy.
- 12:32Not until I'm happy.
- 12:33Because I'm happy so long as I can move freely around the house.
- 12:36I will not even notice piles of laundry in the living room waiting to be sorted.
- 12:41And I'm sure someone will claim that this is malicious incompetence, but that only tells me that you have no idea who I am or just how little I notice the things around me.
- 12:51I am a terrible multitasker, and that extends to being able to walk towards whatever task I'm doing and not noticing things around me.
- 12:59Those are two separate things, and I can't do both.
- 13:02But the thing I'm focused on, that I do very well.
- 13:06Thank you.
- 13:08It's why, though I like cooking and cook far more than Christina, I make only one-dish meals.
- 13:13Because I can't track two things on the stove.
- 13:15I have literally burnt a boiled egg before because I was trying to watch TV at the same time.
- 13:20That was literally decades ago, and I learned my lesson.
- 13:24And I use the example of finances.
- 13:26Why would you hand over finances to a spouse who is financially illiterate?
- 13:30It makes no sense.
- 13:31Give it to the one who likes learning about stocks, mutual funds, ETFs, knows what an MER is, what's the difference between tax-sheltered and tax-deferred investments are, between capital gains and dividends and tax implications of each.
- 13:44If that's neither of you, then get a financial advisor.
- 13:48The one interested in fitness and health should be planning outdoor activities.
- 13:52The one interested in homeschooling, the kids should lead in that, doing the research of choosing curriculum and planning what it's going to look like.
- 13:58And again, this doesn't mean that person has to be 100% responsible for it, only that they should lead.
- 14:05In our house, Christina does the homeschooling.
- 14:07She picks a curriculum.
- 14:08She schools the kids.
- 14:10There are times that I step in.
- 14:12When there's a question about math or science, those questions tend to come to me.
- 14:17Why?
- 14:17Because I'm both interested and good at math.
- 14:20So why don't we do this with sex?
- 14:23Why do we default to the one with the least interest in leading in that area of marriage?
- 14:28Why not give control to the one that's going to nurture and build that part of the relationship?
- 14:33Of course, this still has to follow the tool rules above.
- 14:36That control has to be given freely and accepted with love.
- 14:40Now, does this work for every marriage?
- 14:42I don't know.
- 14:43What I do know is that the couples where I see the lower drive spouse giving up more and more control of their sex life to the higher drive spouse, both end up happier.
- 14:51They have more frequent sex and better sex, and it shows in the rest of their lives.
- 14:57They're more loving towards each other.
- 14:59They communicate better.
- 15:00They manage conflict better.
- 15:02Every aspect of their life improves when they move towards this model.
- 15:07I see it in my coaching practice and in the wives in our becoming more sexually engaged course.
- 15:12Here's the catch, though.
- 15:13The lower drive spouse has to want to do it themselves of their own accord.
- 15:17It can't be coerced out of fear, guilt, or any other sort of manipulation.
- 15:23If you try, then you've now disqualified yourself as a candidate for being in love and control.
- 15:28It doesn't mean it will never happen, but you've damaged your chances and possibly pushed it back.
- 15:33And I see this, too, in both coaching and in our course, particularly with the wives.
- 15:39If a wife signs up for a course and I find her husband told her to take it, I immediately offer her money back and warn her that if she feels pressure to take it, it will not work.
- 15:48In fact, it will make things worse.
- 15:49I have actually seen wives who didn't disclose that this was the reason they took the course, because I ask at the beginning, but I can't force them to be truthful.
- 15:58And then I find out at the end, and sure enough, all the metrics that we use to gauge the benefits from the course actually invert.
- 16:04They lose contentment.
- 16:05They lose confidence.
- 16:06They drop in marital and sexual satisfaction.
- 16:09In the same cohort where others are growing and seeing a revival in their marriage, these wives who are pushed to join experience the opposite, a hardening of their hearts and a solidifying of the hurtful dynamic in their relationship.
- 16:22So if you're a higher drive spouse listening to this podcast episode and think, I need my spouse to read or listen to this, be very careful.
- 16:30I'm not saying don't send it to them, because some relationships can handle that sort of exchange without it leading to conflict.
- 16:36But for many, it's going to lead to pressure, guilt, hurt, and resentment.
- 16:41If there's a good chance of that happening in your marriage, then there are other things to work on first, like trust and communication.
- 16:48If, on the other hand, you're interested in trying it out, give it a try.
- 16:52If you need help, check out the course I mentioned.
- 16:55There's a link in the show notes or coaching.
- 16:57I'm more than willing to talk through it with you and share our experiences.
- 17:00And if you've experienced this in your own life, please share your experiences in the comments on the blog post.
- 17:07And before I go, I want to let you know about something special.
- 17:10We just launched the Sexy Photo Challenge for Christian Wives.
- 17:13If you've ever wanted to feel more confident in your own skin, deepen your connection with your husband, or just try something new and fun, this is for you.
- 17:21You'll get guided photo prompts, tips for proposing, and a private forum for encouragement and support from other wives, all delivered in a way that's faith-based and creative.
- 17:33It's not about perfection.
- 17:35It's about embracing your beauty and blessing your marriage.
- 17:38If you want to learn more, there's a link in the show notes.
- 17:42And just check it out, and you can join the challenge today.
- 17:45You don't need to feel confident to start.
- 17:47You'll grow confident along the way.
- 17:49And that's all I have to talk about today.
- 17:51If you have any thoughts, questions, et cetera, about this topic, feel free to comment on the blog post or send me an email.
- 17:58I love having these kind of discussions.
- 18:00We'll talk to you next time.