Latest / My Playful Wife — A Tender Literary Love Story / My Playful Wife — Season 1, Episode 74: What He Brought

Transcript

My Playful Wife — Season 1, Episode 74: What He Brought · My Playful Wife — A Tender Literary Love Story

0:00
My playful wife. You shouldn't have to keep her
0:05
in the dark. And then she told him a thing I
0:07
had heard only in pieces before, about her own
0:11
mother, dead these many years, whom she has never
0:14
stopped caring. How she still talks to her sometimes.
0:20
The adoption, once we had begun it, required
0:24
us to go back through his history. because the
0:26
law cannot make a child yours forever without
0:29
first establishing, in detail, whose he had been
0:32
before, and so there was a process of gathering,
0:35
of the file thickening, of dates and placements,
0:39
and the bloodless paragraphs of a small life
0:42
being assembled into a case. And somewhere in
0:45
that gathering I was made to confront a thing
0:48
I had managed, in the warmth of the present,
0:50
to half forget. that kabir had not arrived in
0:54
our lives from nowhere that he had come trailing
0:57
a whole existence that predated us and excluded
1:00
us that the boy i was preparing to claim forever
1:03
was a person with a past i had no part in and
1:06
could not enter and that to keep him truly meant
1:09
keeping that too i had known this in the abstract
1:12
of course the way you know facts about a country
1:16
you have not visited But the adoption made it
1:18
concrete, made me sit with the documents of his
1:21
prior life, and there is a difference between
1:23
knowing a child has a history and being handed
1:26
the actual paginated weight of it, the placements
1:29
listed in order, the moves, the names of strangers
1:32
who had each, for a while, been the adults in
1:35
his world, and then had not been. I had been
1:38
thinking of his life as beginning, in some emotional
1:41
sense, when he came to us. It had not. It had
1:45
begun seven years before, in a story I would
1:49
never fully know, among people I would never
1:52
meet, and the boy I loved was the product of
1:55
all of it. Every chapter, including the ones
1:58
that hurt him and the ones, whatever they were,
2:01
he still hid in a photograph in the dark. It
2:07
began with the bag. He had come to us, all those
2:11
months ago. With a single small bag, and in the
2:15
rush and terror of the arrival, I had never properly
2:18
looked at what was in it. It had been unpacked,
2:21
the clothes absorbed into drawers, the bag itself
2:25
stowed somewhere and forgotten. But the adoption
2:28
made us locate everything, account for everything,
2:32
and so the bag came back out, and I looked, for
2:35
the first time, at the actual inventory of what
2:38
a seven -year -old had carried into his fifth
2:40
or sixth home as the entire portable sum of his
2:44
life. It was almost nothing. A few clothes he
2:48
had already outgrown. A broken toy. A school
2:51
certificate from somewhere, for something. And
2:54
it undid me. That meagerness, more than any dramatic
2:58
revelation could have, because there is a particular
3:01
devastation in the smallness of what a moved
3:04
child owns, the way a whole childhood, all its
3:08
love and loss and history, can be made to fit
3:11
with room to spare. In one small bag a child
3:14
can carry himself. That was what he had brought.
3:18
That was everything the world had let him keep.
3:22
I sat on the floor with those few poor things
3:24
spread around me for a long time, and I will
3:27
admit I wept, quietly, which I had not done over
3:30
any of the dramatic moments, but did over this,
3:33
the broken toy and the outgrown clothes. Because
3:37
the meagerness was the whole story told in objects.
3:41
Other children his age had rooms that overflowed,
3:44
drawers that would not shut, the careless abundance
3:48
of the kept and the secure. He had a bag. And
3:52
the bag was not small because he wanted little
3:54
or felt little. It was small because no one had
3:58
ever stayed in his life long enough to accumulate
4:00
things with him, because every move had been
4:03
a shedding, because you travel light when you
4:06
have learned that nothing you own is safe from
4:08
the next upheaval. The bag was the physical proof
4:11
of his whole displaced childhood, and it fit
4:14
with room to spare in my two hands. But it was
4:21
not, I discovered, quite everything, because
4:24
there was one more thing, and he had not kept
4:27
it in the bag. He had kept it hidden, separately,
4:31
in a place of his own choosing, and I came upon
4:34
it by accident, and the instant I saw it I understood
4:37
it was the most important object he owned, a
4:40
single photograph, creased soft from handling,
4:43
of a woman. I did not know who she was. He had
4:47
never mentioned her. She was in none of the official
4:50
paragraphs in any way I could match to a face.
4:53
She was simply a woman, youngish, in a photograph
4:57
a boy had carried through every move of his life
5:00
and kept hidden in every house, taken out, I
5:04
could only imagine in private, in the dark, when
5:07
no one was watching. The secrecy of it was the
5:10
part that broke my heart most precisely, because
5:13
it meant that for years, in every house, this
5:17
child had performed a small daily betrayal of
5:20
his own heart for the sake of safety, had hidden
5:23
the person he loved most, had loved her only
5:26
in the dark, had learned that his deepest attachment
5:29
was a thing to be concealed from the very adults
5:32
who were supposed to be caring for him. No child
5:35
should have to love in secret. That he had concluded,
5:39
somewhere, that the safest thing was to keep
5:42
his most precious bond hidden from every adult
5:45
in his life is its own quiet indictment of everything
5:48
that had happened to him, and it told me, more
5:51
than any file could, exactly how alone he had
5:55
been with the one love he had managed to keep.
5:57
And when he realized I had found it, his whole
6:00
body changed, went rigid and defensive in the
6:03
old way, and he snatched it back and braced,
6:05
braced for me to take it. to disapprove of it,
6:08
to be the adult who finally made him give her
6:11
up. I have thought a great deal since about how
6:14
many adults before me that brace was built for.
6:18
A child does not flinch like that from nothing.
6:21
The rigidity, the snatching back, the bracing
6:24
for confiscation is a learned response, and it
6:27
is learned only by having had things taken. by
6:30
having had, at some point, an adult decide that
6:33
the attachment to the past was inconvenient or
6:36
unhealthy or a threat to the new arrangement,
6:39
and remove it. Somewhere in his history, someone
6:43
had made him give something up or had tried to.
6:46
The brace was a scar, and scars are records of
6:49
specific injuries. He was not bracing against
6:53
an imagined cruelty. He was bracing against a
6:56
remembered one, and the only way to answer a
6:59
remembered cruelty is to be, reliably and repeatedly,
7:04
the opposite of it. And I felt, in that moment,
7:11
something I am not proud of and will record anyway,
7:14
because the notebooks do not flatter, a flicker,
7:18
small and real, of competition. Some ungenerous
7:24
part of me, the part that had waited so long
7:27
to be a father and wanted to be the whole of
7:29
his family, felt a flash of something like jealousy
7:32
of the woman in the photograph, a small mean
7:35
wish to be enough for him, to be all of it, to
7:39
not have to share the boy I was about to make
7:41
my son with a past I could not enter and a face
7:44
I did not know. It lasted only a second. But
7:48
it was there, and I saw it. And I understood
7:51
that it was the exact feeling that makes lesser
7:53
families do the cruel thing, that makes adoptive
7:56
parents subtly compete with a child's origins,
7:59
badmouth the birth family, encourage the quiet
8:02
erasure of the past so that they can be the only
8:05
love, the real family, the ones who count. The
8:09
jealousy is natural. It is also poison. And I
8:13
had to take that small flare of it in myself
8:15
and look at it squarely and refuse it, there
8:19
in the doorway, with the boy braced over his
8:21
hidden photograph, waiting to find out what kind
8:24
of family he had landed in. So much hung on the
8:28
next 30 seconds, and I knew it. A child holds
8:31
out his most precious and most secret thing,
8:34
braced for it to be disapproved of, and how you
8:37
respond in that instant tells him everything
8:39
about the kind of people he has been given to.
8:42
Get it wrong, flinch, frown, reach to take it,
8:45
say anything that reads as competition or disapproval,
8:49
and you confirm his deepest fear, that love here
8:53
too is conditional, that the price of being kept
8:56
is the surrender of who he was before. Get it
8:59
right, and you tell him the opposite, the thing
9:01
he has never once been told, that he can be wholly
9:05
himself, past and all, and still be wholly wanted.
9:09
There are moments in the raising of a wounded
9:11
child that are hinges, on which a great deal
9:14
of the future silently turns, and they almost
9:17
never look like the dramatic ones. This was one.
9:20
A boy, a photograph, and 30 seconds. Saloni came,
9:28
because Saloni always comes at the right moment,
9:31
and she did the thing I was still struggling
9:33
toward, and she did it out of a knowledge I do
9:36
not have. She sat down near him, not too close,
9:41
and she did not ask to see the photograph, and
9:44
she did not reassure him in the false bright
9:46
way. She just said quietly, Is that someone you
9:50
love? And when he gave the smallest possible
9:53
nod, still braced, she said, Good. You should
9:58
bring her out where you can see her. You shouldn't
10:00
have to keep her in the dark. And then she told
10:03
him a thing I had heard only in pieces before,
10:06
about her own mother, dead these many years,
10:09
whom she has never stopped caring, how she still
10:13
talks to her sometimes, how the dead do not leave,
10:16
how loving the people who are here has never
10:19
once required her to stop loving the one who
10:21
is gone. I have a mother I lost, she said to
10:24
him, plainly one bereft person to another. You
10:28
have someone too. That's not something you have
10:31
to choose about. You don't have to love us instead
10:34
of her. There isn't an instead. You get to love
10:38
all of them, the ones who are here and the ones
10:41
who aren't, all at once your whole life. Nobody
10:45
who actually loves you will ever ask you to put
10:47
her away. And the boy looked at my wife, who
10:51
had just told him she carried her own ghost and
10:54
some terrible vigilance in him, the one that
10:57
had hidden the photograph in the dark for years,
11:00
eased. It could only have come from her, that
11:03
particular grace, because it came out of a wound
11:06
and not out of a theory. I could have reasoned
11:09
my way to the right response, given time, given
11:12
the notebook, but Celonie did not have to reason,
11:15
because she was speaking as one bereaved person
11:18
to another, offering not advice but company,
11:21
the recognition that passes between two people
11:24
who each carry someone gone. That is a thing
11:27
I cannot quite give Kabir, not having lost the
11:31
way they have lost. My own childhood wound was
11:34
absence, not bereavement, the unwatched and not
11:38
the loved and taken. But Saloni knew his exact
11:41
grief from the inside, the love that survives
11:44
the person, and she met him in it, plainly, without
11:48
performance, and gave him the one permission
11:50
no one had thought to give him, to go on loving
11:54
the woman in the photograph out loud. forever,
11:57
without it costing him us. We made a place for
12:02
her after that, which was the only right thing
12:06
to do. We found a small frame, and Saloni helped
12:10
him put the creased photograph in it, smoothing
12:13
it as flat as the years of handling would allow,
12:16
and we set it on the shelf by his bed, out in
12:19
the open, where he could see it, where she could
12:22
be part of the room rather than a secret carried
12:25
in the dark. He did not explain her, and we did
12:28
not ask. Whoever she was, whatever had happened,
12:31
the right to the story was his and not ours,
12:34
and he would tell it, or not, in his own time.
12:37
But she was out now. The woman he had carried
12:41
hidden through every move of his unchosen life
12:44
was, for the first time, allowed to sit openly
12:47
in a room that was permanently his, watched over
12:50
rather than hidden, and I understood that we
12:53
had done. In the small act of framing a photograph,
12:57
something merely as large as the adoption itself,
13:00
we had told him, in a way deeper than words,
13:04
that becoming ours did not mean ceasing to be
13:06
hers, that the family we were giving him was
13:09
one that made room for his ghosts rather than
13:12
evicting them. The shelf became, after that,
13:16
a small quiet shrine, though we never called
13:19
it anything so grand and never made a production
13:22
of it. It was simply that the photograph was
13:24
there now, in the open, part of the geography
13:27
of his room, as ordinary and as permanent as
13:31
the bed and the metro map taped to the wall.
13:34
And I noticed, over the following weeks, that
13:37
he stopped needing to take her out in secret,
13:39
because she was no longer a secret. The frantic
13:43
private guarding eased into something calmer,
13:45
the way any treasure does once you no longer
13:48
fear it will be confiscated. We had not made
13:52
him love her less by allowing it. We had made
13:54
the loving safe, and a love made safe stops being
13:58
a clenched and hidden thing and becomes, simply,
14:02
part of the furniture of a life, carried lightly
14:05
because it no longer has to be carried in fear.
14:11
I wrote it that night in the sixth notebook,
14:14
a framed photograph of a stranger now watching
14:17
over a sleeping boy down the hall. That to truly
14:21
take a person, you must take all of them, including
14:24
the parts that predate you and exclude you and
14:27
will never be yours. That a child is not a blank
14:31
slate gratefully receiving your love, but a whole
14:34
prior person with a heart that already has tenants,
14:37
loves, and losses installed long before you arrived.
14:41
And that the test of whether you actually love
14:43
him, as against loving the idea of being his
14:46
rescuer. is whether you can make room for those
14:48
prior tenants instead of trying to evict. The
14:51
jealousy I had felt was the wish to be his whole
14:55
world. But you do not love a child by being his
14:58
whole world. You love him by helping him hold
15:02
the whole of his world, which is larger than
15:04
you and older than you, and includes faces you
15:08
will never know. Saloni understood this in her
15:10
body because she carries her own lost mother
15:13
and knows there is no instead. No choosing, only
15:18
the heart's astonishing capacity to hold the
15:20
present and the absent at once. We were not replacing
15:25
what Kabir had lost. We were becoming the people
15:28
who would help him keep it. That, and not erasure,
15:31
is what it means to give a wounded child a family.
15:35
Not a new world to replace the old, but a safe
15:38
place at last to grieve and to treasure the old
15:41
one. And I think this is the great misunderstanding
15:44
about what a damaged person needs, whether a
15:48
child or anyone, that they need to be given a
15:51
wonderful new thing to replace the terrible old
15:53
one, a fresh start, a clean slate, a chance to
15:57
forget. They do not need to forget. They cannot
16:00
forget. And the pressure to forget only adds
16:04
the burden of pretending to the burden of grieving.
16:07
What they need is the opposite of a clean slate.
16:10
They need a place safe enough that they no longer
16:13
have to keep the old slate hidden, where the
16:16
whole of their history, the loved and the lost
16:19
and the unbearable, can finally be set down in
16:22
the open and looked at without fear. We were
16:25
not Kabir's fresh start. We were, if we did it
16:29
right, his first safe place to stop running from
16:31
where he had been. Then the working line, the
16:37
sixth notebook open. a once -hidden photograph
16:40
standing openly in the lamplight of a boy's permanent
16:43
room. To take a person fully, take all of them,
16:48
including the loves that came before you and
16:51
have nothing to do with you, a claimed child,
16:54
a new spouse, anyone who comes to you with a
16:58
history, arrives with a heart already tenanted,
17:01
with prior loves and prior losses lodged in them
17:05
long before your name was known. The mean and
17:08
frightened response is to compete, to want to
17:11
be their whole world, to encourage the quiet
17:14
erasure of whoever came first so that you can
17:17
be the only one who counts. Refuse that. It is
17:21
poison, however natural. You do not love someone
17:24
by being the entirety of their world. You love
17:27
them by helping them carry the whole of it, the
17:30
part that includes you and the larger part that
17:33
never will. Make a place. out in the open for
17:37
their ghosts. Frame the photograph. There is
17:40
no instead. The heart was always meant to hold
17:44
the present and the absent at once, and the surest
17:47
sign that you truly love a person is that you
17:50
help them keep the loves that are none of your
17:52
doing. I capped the pen and went to looking on
17:56
him, as I do, and the photograph stood on the
17:59
shelf in the faint light, the young woman watching
18:02
over the boy who had carried her hidden through
18:05
every house of his life, and could now, at last,
18:08
sleep in the same room with her face uncovered.
18:11
I did not know her name. I might never know it.
18:15
But I had stopped that day, wishing her away,
18:19
and had started instead to feel something like
18:21
gratitude toward her, whoever she was, for having
18:25
loved him first, for having given him whatever
18:28
she gave him before the world took him from her,
18:30
for being a face worth carrying through six homes
18:33
in the dark. She had had him before us. She would
18:37
always have had him. And the family we were making,
18:41
the permanent one, the Terminus, was going to
18:43
be the kind that had room on its shelves for
18:45
everyone a child had ever loved. Because a home
18:48
that makes you hide your ghosts is not a home.
18:50
And we had promised him, in every language we
18:53
had, that this one was. To be continued in Episode
19:11
episode 74 of My Playful Wife. If this story
19:15
is staying with you, the next episode is already
19:18
waiting. Subscribe so you don't miss it. The
19:22
complete book is on Amazon, and early episodes
19:25
plus bonus chapters are on my Patreon. Links
19:28
are in the description. Thank you for listening.