Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E065: Navigating Custodial Risk with Rich Kerr
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when. We sell.
- 0:26Hey, OK side Mahaki, I say when we sell.
- 0:33Right, everyone, welcome back to the last trade.
- 0:35Today we're joined by Rich Kerr, President of On Ramp Manage
- 0:39Wealth and of course joined by my Co hosts Jesse Myers and
- 0:43Michael Tanguma. How's everyone doing today?
- 0:46Doing good president, manage wealth and host of the famous
- 0:51Wake Up Call show. Oh yeah, right.
- 0:54Yeah. Thanks for the every Monday
- 0:55morning. Thank you for the plug.
- 0:58Yeah, I mean, get to get to chop it up with Mark Connors.
- 1:02I mean, you can't ask for a better format than that.
- 1:05That guy keeps me laughing and I learn all the way through.
- 1:08So it's it's quite an enjoyable show.
- 1:11How has that been going? I know it's not the direct topic
- 1:13we're here for, but just curious any, any learnings for the past?
- 1:17Like I want to say it's been a month to two months total.
- 1:19Yeah, big findings. Yeah, it's actually been two
- 1:23months. And I think one of the one of
- 1:25the fun parts about speaking directly to financial
- 1:29professionals, in particular, Michael, is you can bring in
- 1:34people that have all sorts of different, you know, adjacencies
- 1:39or are actually in the RIA space themselves and, and hear their
- 1:43points of view. And what are their challenges?
- 1:46What are they struggling with? What are the opportunities that
- 1:50they see? And how do they wish to exploit
- 1:52them? And, you know, either support
- 1:54the RIAA community if they're in adjacency or if they're in the
- 1:59business itself trying to think through, you know, how do I grow
- 2:02with it? And what are the risk factors
- 2:05that I need to be thinking about?
- 2:06And how did I work with my compliance, you know, partners
- 2:10and, and actually develop a, an investment thesis that we could
- 2:14bring in Bitcoin and hold it and secure it properly for clients.
- 2:18And so it's, it's been a lot of fun just kind of talking with
- 2:22professionals around the myriad of things that they have to go
- 2:26through in order to actually implement a well thought out
- 2:30strategy with Bitcoin and why it's important.
- 2:34Why, why does it speak to them to bring it forward?
- 2:37And what, and more importantly, what does it bring to their end
- 2:41clients? And, and so, you know, there's a
- 2:44whole host of different topics that we'd get to get to play
- 2:47with and, and different professionals in the industry,
- 2:50whether they be investment consultants or Rias, you know,
- 2:54compliance people or, you know, RIA consultants.
- 2:59I mean, we've had a chance to speak to a little bit of
- 3:01everybody and give a different lens to how does Bitcoin
- 3:05ultimately adopt mainstream and, and, you know, accelerate and
- 3:11scale inside of all of these businesses.
- 3:14And so I think we'll probably play with some of that today
- 3:17because I think, you know, Jesse wrote such a great piece around
- 3:23Bitcoin and custody and what and the evolution of custody.
- 3:29And then also a little bit about some of the threats that live in
- 3:32the space today that were have been around for since the
- 3:36existence of Bitcoin. And so there's a couple of
- 3:38different ways that we're going to talk about that.
- 3:40And those are really important conversations to the financial
- 3:43professionals that we're speaking with every day.
- 3:47So excited about being here to join and maybe share a different
- 3:52perspective. Awesome.
- 3:55Yeah, I appreciate that Rich. As someone who's been following
- 3:59your show, the wake up call, it's been really interesting
- 4:02just from how you've curated the the guests and and the way that
- 4:06the dynamic between you and Mark.
- 4:08I think it's very unique because there are so many different
- 4:12shows in the Bitcoin space, but I really haven't found anything
- 4:15quite similar to what you're doing with Mark by focusing
- 4:18specifically on the managed wealth, family office,
- 4:22traditional finance, you know, just kind of the broker dealer,
- 4:24I guess the entire wealth management community.
- 4:27And I really would encourage anyone who has an interest,
- 4:29whether they work in that industry directly,
- 4:31professionally, or they're just curious to hear about some
- 4:34themes there. Definitely check it out.
- 4:36It's every Monday and we'll certainly be talking about some
- 4:39of those themes today. But Rich, I appreciate you
- 4:42bringing up the piece that Jesse wrote recently titled Everyone's
- 4:46a Scammer. It is a timely piece because I
- 4:51don't know about you guys, but I, I get calls non-stop and
- 4:56it's, it's always been like that, but it is really ramped
- 4:59up. And even just yesterday or the
- 5:01day before, I forget at this point, I wanted to answer a call
- 5:04just to confirm my bias to see if it was people trying to
- 5:07indeed steal my Bitcoin and to, not to my surprise, it was
- 5:13someone. So I called them out early on in
- 5:15that conversation and the, the person admitted, yes, I want to
- 5:18steal your Bitcoin. And then we, we left the
- 5:20conversation there. So Jesse, it's a, it's a well
- 5:23timed piece really. I, I had the chance to read
- 5:26through it this morning and, and really enjoyed it.
- 5:27So maybe we could just hand it over to you to talk through some
- 5:30of the main points there. At Onramp, we believe that
- 5:33Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 5:37The hard part is securing it right.
- 5:40There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 5:42exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 5:45arrangement. On Ramp solves for these
- 5:47concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 5:50solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 5:54ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 5:56possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 6:00your family is protected as well.
- 6:02On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 6:05whether for your whole stack or for part of it as a compliment
- 6:08to your existing self custody setup.
- 6:11For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 6:15Yeah, yeah. And first of all, the so
- 6:18Bitstein wrote Everyone's a scammer many years ago and, and
- 6:23so. Ten years ago to the date, I
- 6:25found out Brian told me to take Zach today.
- 6:27Oh wow, I didn't realize that that's no.
- 6:29Coins and dances. So, so that's what why we went
- 6:33with everyone's a scammer part duh, Part 2.
- 6:38And yeah, this this piece has been something I've been meaning
- 6:42to write for some time and have struggled to write with, with
- 6:46the baby sort of breaking up my my usual writing process
- 6:50entirely. But everyone sort of felt this
- 6:55recently that there's this uptick of scams going on in the
- 7:00Bitcoin space, in the crypto space in general.
- 7:04And you know, if you pay attention to Bitcoin Twitter,
- 7:08you've been seeing these little anecdotes pop up here and there
- 7:11and these examples and, and the latest data breach here and, and
- 7:17just a general increase in this kind of activity.
- 7:20And so I felt it was a good time to raise awareness to all the,
- 7:27the various ways in which people are at risk when they're holding
- 7:30Bitcoin. And, and I think that people in
- 7:34general, Bitcoiners in general are, are endangering their
- 7:40future a little bit more than they realize out of complacency.
- 7:46And and so bringing together these various anecdotes and
- 7:51perspectives to try to paint a picture of, you know, the, the
- 7:56way things are going right now. People need to take the security
- 8:00of their Bitcoin a little bit more seriously.
- 8:02Then then then people tend to, and I wanted to, I kind of want
- 8:06to shake Bitcoiners a little bit and say, like, you know, you're
- 8:08dealing with potential generational wealth here.
- 8:12Act like it, you know, take the steps that that are necessary to
- 8:15to treat that asset accordingly. So the piece goes through it.
- 8:21It starts with an anecdote of of someone who left 202 hundred
- 8:26Bitcoin on a paper wallet in their safe taped to the roof of
- 8:30their safe. And and burglars actually got
- 8:33into their house and opened the safe and didn't notice the paper
- 8:37wallet taped to the the roof of the of their safe.
- 8:40So that 200 Bitcoin was saved by by a piece of of tape
- 8:45ultimately. But that's a terrible position
- 8:48to to be in and, and could have just as easily gone the other
- 8:52way, right? If, if those burglars had
- 8:56noticed a piece of, of paper taped to the roof of a safe,
- 9:00that that Bitcoiner would have lost generational wealth right
- 9:04there. And you know, recently there's
- 9:07been a couple of of interviews that John Seth early Bitcoiner
- 9:12has, has recorded with these scammers who have been cold
- 9:17calling him. Unfortunately, people's
- 9:20information if they're, if they're a Bitcoiner at this
- 9:24point in time or if they're into crypto at this point in time,
- 9:27several different companies, information about their clients
- 9:34and customers has, has been compromised, has been breached
- 9:37and stolen and is now available on the dark web.
- 9:41As a result of that, you know, if you are a Ledger customer or
- 9:46there's a, a number of other companies that, that I'm not
- 9:50actually not sure which ones, I, so I don't want to incorrectly
- 9:55say include a name that that isn't actually in that group,
- 10:00But I, you know, I know of a, a half dozen that are, that are in
- 10:04there and a, and a few more that I think are in there.
- 10:09The their customer information has been leaked.
- 10:11And now if you're a customer, you might be getting phone calls
- 10:15to that, to your information that's now available on the dark
- 10:19web. But who's calling you is people
- 10:21who are pretending to be tech support and they're young
- 10:24American high schoolers really who are pretending to work for
- 10:31Ledger or these other companies. And and they are calling you
- 10:37today because there's an urgent crisis that you need to fix.
- 10:40Otherwise your bitcoins at in jeopardy.
- 10:42But if you just follow these steps that that this very cool,
- 10:46calm, collected customer service representative will walk you
- 10:50through, then you will take care of the of the problem and your
- 10:54Bitcoin will be perfectly safe. Again.
- 10:57The problem is that if you follow these directions, this is
- 11:02actually not someone who works for tech support for that
- 11:05company. This is a scammer trying to get
- 11:08you to make a, a hasty decision and focus on an imaginary crisis
- 11:16and try to solve it and hand over your login information in
- 11:19in the process in a, in a way that it doesn't feel like you're
- 11:22doing that, but that's what you're doing.
- 11:25And so there's a cottage industry now of these scammers
- 11:28calling all sorts everyone on these lists of known customers
- 11:34and they're succeeding. And so you know, that's causing
- 11:38an influx of them. You know, more scammers are are
- 11:43piling in to try to do the same thing to the to the extent that
- 11:49you know, Jackson's getting calls 'cause he's on some list.
- 11:53And in this, these interviews, John Seth manages him.
- 11:58Rich is showing all of his his scam calls that he hasn't picked
- 12:03up recently. So John Seth manages to get in
- 12:08two separate interviews, these kids to talk about what what
- 12:11they're doing and why and what they have been doing and how
- 12:14successful they've been. And they brag about how they've
- 12:17been making 10 to $100,000 a day by and, and if you're stupid
- 12:22enough to hand over your private keys, you don't deserve your
- 12:26Bitcoin. And these kind of
- 12:28rationalizations of unscrupulous young men who are trying to make
- 12:34a quick buck and are telling themselves that they're not in
- 12:38the wrong. You know, you deserve to be
- 12:40stolen from. And so, so that's what's going
- 12:44on on the, the social engineering cold calling side of
- 12:47things. There's also, of course, tons of
- 12:50of phishing emails in the piece I included recently, Swan has
- 12:54had a problem where their e-mail list has gotten out and, and two
- 13:00recent phishing emails were sent out that look like they are
- 13:03coming from Swan and the same sort of format of there's a
- 13:08crisis. You have to solve it.
- 13:10Click here to to to secure your Bitcoin.
- 13:13But if you go down that path, you will actually be giving over
- 13:16the login information to for a scammer to take your Bitcoin
- 13:19from you. So, you know, cold call, phone
- 13:24calls, phishing emails and of course, $5 wrench attacks is
- 13:28sort of is looming threat of if you have Bitcoin in and it's in
- 13:35your possession, whether on a single hardware wallet or
- 13:39multiple, and then you have it at home with you, you're you're
- 13:43becoming a target. And we're starting to see,
- 13:48frankly, criminals to date haven't known about Bitcoin
- 13:52enough to understand that Bitcoiners are vulnerable
- 13:58because they might be holding it at home.
- 14:01And I think that that is starting to shift.
- 14:03And it will inevitably become common knowledge that that
- 14:07people with crypto, if they're holding it on in self custody,
- 14:12they probably have the ability to give it over, you know, if
- 14:17you if you hold a gun to their head, unfortunately.
- 14:22And so this climate is is problematic to say the least,
- 14:28that there's an increasing activity of scammers trying to
- 14:31to get Bitcoin from people. And it's kind of been hard to
- 14:35know how big of a problem this is.
- 14:37But recently the FBI put out numbers saying that in 2020,
- 14:41three $5.6 billion in crypto related loss was incurred by
- 14:49Americans, which is up 44% from the year before.
- 14:53So you got the FBI sort of putting a big number to this.
- 14:57And you know, obviously people aren't sharing their losses so
- 15:01readily because it's it's kind of kind of shameful to have
- 15:04fallen for a, a phishing scam. And, and so people may not talk
- 15:09about it as much as, as, as it is actually happening to, to
- 15:13folks in the Bitcoin space. So you know that that's the
- 15:18context of, of a growing problem that is, is going on in, in the
- 15:23Bitcoin and, and crypto space in general.
- 15:26And it's, there's an easy solution to it.
- 15:29And, and that is to more seriously take a look at your
- 15:33custody solution. And so the second-half of the
- 15:38piece is sort of an exploration of, well, first, why it's
- 15:43important to, to upgrade your custody.
- 15:46And it, that's very simple. I mean, recently we had Michael
- 15:50Saylor put out numbers saying that he expects Bitcoin to go to
- 15:54$13 million base case, $13 million per coin in 20 years,
- 15:59which is, is based on, on some of my analysis and methodology,
- 16:04which I'm we're very proud of. But that numbers is crazy,
- 16:09right? That's a huge number that
- 16:11amounts to to A200X over the next 20 years.
- 16:16And people who hold crypto today, hold Bitcoin aren't
- 16:21they're not thinking about it as a 2A potential 200X.
- 16:25They're thinking about, oh, it's OK.
- 16:27If I, I leave $100,000 of Bitcoin on, on Coinbase, that's
- 16:31OK. That's a small portion of My
- 16:33Portfolio. Maybe maybe it's, you know, you
- 16:37can imagine that it's $100,000. I make $100,000 a year.
- 16:41It's not, you know, I don't need to move heaven and earth to, to
- 16:46do anything different. Coinbase is good enough.
- 16:48You can easily rationalize that. But if it's 200 XS in the next
- 16:5420 years, that's $20 million. That's, that's retirement.
- 16:59That's, that's potentially generational wealth.
- 17:05And if you had $20 million on, on Coinbase today, you would,
- 17:11you would get it off. You would set up a better
- 17:15custody solution and move your coins into that custody
- 17:19solution. And that's the right way to
- 17:21think about the stakes here, because if you screw up, this is
- 17:28a a once in a species opportunity that you're going to
- 17:31miss out on and and that that's a tragedy.
- 17:35So any anybody who's gotten to a place where they understand what
- 17:38Bitcoin is and they put meaningful capital into Bitcoin
- 17:41and then they're still running this risk of leaving it on an
- 17:45exchange and potentially getting scammed by social engineering
- 17:50hackers trying to get their log information and, and drain their
- 17:52funds from Coinbase or any other exchange.
- 17:56That, that that becomes a tragedy like what could have
- 17:59been for that individual, for their family that will never be
- 18:04realized because those funds were were stolen early in the
- 18:08process. It, it's just terrible.
- 18:12So because of, you know, when you think about in those terms,
- 18:16if you, if you think about, you know, the $100,000 of Bitcoin
- 18:20that I have sitting on an exchange, what should I do with
- 18:24it instead? You should set up a better
- 18:26custody solution and, and withdraw it from an exchange.
- 18:29There are obviously a a number of different custody formats and
- 18:34and I. Before jumping into the custody
- 18:37side, can we maybe add a little meat like contextualize a little
- 18:40points, then we'll go to custody.
- 18:41That works just on the the notion of kind of like the to go
- 18:47back to the everything you said. It was a perfect recap.
- 18:50Amazing article. We've been talking about, we've
- 18:52been feeling personally, I think my background is known.
- 18:56We've talked about a lot helping build out Unchained and dealt
- 19:00deal with the plastic devices. I feel like we're in a very good
- 19:02spot to talk with thousands of onboarding, billions of dollars
- 19:07and I had hesitated a little bit and talking about a lot of
- 19:10things Jesse referenced because it seemed like FUD like this is
- 19:13this notion of what Jesse is explaining comes from like
- 19:16multiple different factors. 1 is just knowledge right.
- 19:19So Jesse referenced bitcoins toll addressable market or or
- 19:23the Tam of growth. That's a component.
- 19:25If somebody thinks about it in that lens, then you're already
- 19:27thinking like this. Bradley Chambers is very notable
- 19:30for this. He came on the pod recently.
- 19:32Another potential of this is just knowledge.
- 19:34So when you're working in the sector, you see all day long
- 19:36that anecdote that Jesse shared was not made-up.
- 19:39That's something we heard directly and he softened it in
- 19:41this initial. I think it's a little bit more
- 19:43in the piece, but these are like professional rings that come
- 19:46into cities and literally spend 3 months there just to do this
- 19:49exact task that's increasing. So that's the knowledge there.
- 19:54And then the last part is just living in the future.
- 19:55So if you're overly exposed, IE or IE, what does Sailor say?
- 20:03Irresponsibly long. You feel this way already, and
- 20:06you naturally have to find the right solution.
- 20:08So you're already feeling there. But for the vast majority of the
- 20:11market, they haven't got there. And that's the point of a lot of
- 20:14these writings, this conversation, the education of a
- 20:17firm like ours. Now, a couple of things Jesse
- 20:21referenced was it's pretty crazy the past like 3 weeks to pass 5
- 20:24when it comes to the FBI rings, DOJ pulling where they're stings
- 20:29of these people that are naturally they're actually going
- 20:31into homes to torture people to get their capital.
- 20:33This happened in the UK. There's the North Korean thing
- 20:36that recently came about, I think was like 4 billion.
- 20:40So this is increasing. And to our friend Chris Kiper
- 20:43about always invert, it's like I let's flip it.
- 20:46It's like when do you answer the phone?
- 20:47When is it not a scammer is the real question because it's like
- 20:50I don't answer my phone ever. It's like that's how bad it is.
- 20:53So like all that to say, you take all that and then let's
- 20:58operate under 4 absolute assumptions that may be
- 21:01controversial, but I'm pretty confident we'll all be where
- 21:04everybody ends up is 1 is everybody is a scammer.
- 21:06Like in Bitcoin, if you really think about its prescient
- 21:09because they're either trying to take your Bitcoin by way of like
- 21:11hair sell it so you can invest in mind you cryptocurrency or
- 21:16any investment to outperform Bitcoin, or it's here, give me
- 21:20your Bitcoin. I can rehypothecate it or here,
- 21:23let me social engineer. So that just exists.
- 21:26Jesse referenced the CRM stuff. You should always operate like
- 21:30all your info is always going to be out there because it's data
- 21:33and it's very hard to secure. So they're going to know how
- 21:36much Bitcoin you have and it's not talked about enough.
- 21:38But like AI tools, all the metadata from everything is
- 21:43effectively out there already, where you can discern a
- 21:46directional amount of how much Bitcoin somebody owns.
- 21:50So if. If that's true, then operate
- 21:52like Bitcoin is 6 figures. And if you have those two to be
- 21:55true, well then now the scamming, the sophistication of
- 21:57a digital bare asset is the there's unknown unknowns on how
- 22:02great it'll be and what it'll look like in a digital world, in
- 22:05fishing, but then in a physical world.
- 22:07And what does that look like? And how does it manifest itself
- 22:09in a real way where people where the last part is operate like
- 22:13your house is not a place to store this stuff because it
- 22:16shouldn't be. But that is for 90% of
- 22:18individuals because the first two haven't been realized yet,
- 22:21which is operate like all your infos out there and be operate
- 22:24like it's 6 figures. Because when those two happen
- 22:26and the Ledger or treasures in your house and your families
- 22:30around, that is not a game you want to play.
- 22:32And that's just not the common knowledge.
- 22:34And it's kind of sad because all the people that are in Bitcoin,
- 22:37everybody is talking about self custody.
- 22:39They fail to lack the fact that A, it's valuable, it's still
- 22:43needed. There's a place for it.
- 22:44But like when this thing happens, there's going to be a
- 22:47lot of pain. And I like to think about, when
- 22:48we think about our clients is like, we want to put them in a
- 22:50position for this, not to be realistic.
- 22:52That's why we don't onboard them to devices and have to put them
- 22:55in these positions. So I think just to anchor back
- 22:58to a little bit of like the gravity and where we sit and
- 23:00this all becomes apparent when it hits these price points.
- 23:04We're just living in the future by the nature of working in the
- 23:06space, seeing and having these discussions.
- 23:08And everybody else has the luxury of like living in the
- 23:12regular world and dealing with all the normal stuff.
- 23:14They don't have to think about this all day long.
- 23:16And so This is why we bring it to light and talk through it.
- 23:18And then the custody is like the second part of this.
- 23:20And what are the frameworks to think about?
- 23:22How do you plan around it? Yeah.
- 23:25Want to react, Jesse, to to your piece that you just described in
- 23:29them to Michael's points as well, because I still think that
- 23:33we're in the early innings of these scams and threats.
- 23:37Jesse, one of the things that you referenced is the individual
- 23:40who fortunately did not have their Bitcoin stolen from them
- 23:44because they had it taped on the top of their safe that the paper
- 23:47wallet. And that's only because the
- 23:51criminals did not find find that because that's not yet common
- 23:55knowledge, or at least it's not widespread information that this
- 23:58is the prominent way that people secure their Bitcoin.
- 24:01Of course, on the flip side, there are some more
- 24:04sophisticated groups that do realize this.
- 24:06And Michael alluded to that earlier, that there are criminal
- 24:09rings that I think we're traveling a lot in the
- 24:13Southeast. I think it was a group that was
- 24:14based out of West Palm, if I remember correctly, but then
- 24:17traveled in different states in the Southeast and maybe maybe
- 24:20even up north to New York. So there are more sophisticated
- 24:23people that know that there are millions of dollars, if not more
- 24:28of Bitcoin secured in people's homes.
- 24:30But we're still really early on for this.
- 24:33Like if you go out into the streets and you talk to people,
- 24:36you still realize that most people don't even know what
- 24:38Bitcoin is. They don't even inherently know
- 24:40that it has any sort of value. And they don't have any idea
- 24:43about Jesse's work on full potential valuation or Michael
- 24:47Saylor's Bitcoin price target, right?
- 24:49So we're still early for people even understanding what This is,
- 24:53why it's valuable. But as people come into this
- 24:56space and they start to realize this and they have malicious
- 25:00motives and we're still on a standard of people securing
- 25:04significant wealth in their house, that's really going to be
- 25:07an ugly world to live in. I Jesse, I think you might have
- 25:09referenced it on a previous podcast we did, but it's kind of
- 25:11like almost reverting back to a barbaric state, right?
- 25:15Where like we had now have to defend our, our money and
- 25:19property within our home and we constantly have to live under
- 25:21fear of threats of, of people doing that.
- 25:23And I don't want to live in that world.
- 25:26I don't think that Bitcoin will actually be adopted or
- 25:28proliferated in that type of world either, which is why
- 25:31we're, we're here having this conversation.
- 25:33And then the second piece outside of the physical threats
- 25:35is the, the swan emails. I have a first hand account on
- 25:38that too. One of my buddies got that
- 25:41e-mail that went out a little bit over a week ago now.
- 25:44And he texted me a screenshot and he was like, what do I do
- 25:47with this? Because he thought it was
- 25:49legitimate and I had to and a, he shouldn't have his Bitcoin on
- 25:52an exchange to begin with. And I've told him this, but he
- 25:54also doesn't want to do self custody because he doesn't, he's
- 25:58not sophisticated enough to do it, quite frankly, and he
- 26:00doesn't want to do it. So he texts me this, he says,
- 26:04what do I do with it? Like I got this e-mail, it's
- 26:06concerning. And I also told him a couple
- 26:08weeks ago, hey, you should really consider not having your
- 26:11Bitcoin on an exchange anymore. So he was already kind of like
- 26:14frightened about having it there.
- 26:15And then he got that e-mail and he was like, well, like, I
- 26:18really should do this now. And I was like, hang on a SEC,
- 26:20like let me, let me take a look at this.
- 26:21And I was like, this is not a legitimate thing.
- 26:23You had like, ignore it, don't do anything.
- 26:25Fortunately, he didn't act on it yet, but it just goes to show
- 26:28that these people are getting very sophisticated.
- 26:31I even saw the emails, like I said, and it looks very
- 26:34professionally done. Obviously, if you like take a
- 26:36look at the domain that it's being sent from and you and you
- 26:40understand actually, you know, what's going on there with how
- 26:43it's worded and what they're asking of you.
- 26:46You obviously know it's a scam. But for someone who might be
- 26:48newer to the space, not as sophisticated, doesn't
- 26:51understand what seed phrases are, yadda, yadda, it looks, it
- 26:54looks very legitimate. So I just wanted to react to to
- 26:58both of your points that this is, we're in the early innings
- 27:01of this. It's still a trillion dollar
- 27:02asset class. There's $900 trillion of wealth
- 27:04out there. And this is only going to get
- 27:06worse, you know, as we kind of progress from here into the next
- 27:09cycle. Yeah, it's yeah.
- 27:11That Go ahead, Rich. I was just going to share a
- 27:14story, you know, just kind of draw a parallel, I guess.
- 27:19You know, when I first graduated from school, I went out and I
- 27:22became a financial advisor. I was running financial plans
- 27:26and, and you know, working with individual investors.
- 27:31And one day I had an inherited client, right?
- 27:33And what that means is essentially somebody who left
- 27:36the company, client doesn't have a relationship, go ahead and
- 27:41call on that individual, right? So I called on her and she was
- 27:45like, yeah, come out and see me. And I drove out to East Mesa,
- 27:49clear out, you know, towards Red Mountain.
- 27:51It was a heck of a drive, but it was a retirement community out
- 27:54there. And I walked in and it was a
- 27:57older lady, and she was roughly 80 years old.
- 28:01Wonderful person. We sat there and we talked, and
- 28:03she made me tea and we had a nice conversation.
- 28:06We talked about her life, her children, what her children are
- 28:11doing, the whole 9 yards. It was a fascinating
- 28:14conversation, great person. And she said to me, before you
- 28:19leave, Rich, will I get a chance to see you again?
- 28:21And I said, absolutely, I'm assigned to your account and I'd
- 28:24be happy to meet with you and address any financial planning
- 28:27needs that you have, investment needs, anything that you have,
- 28:31you know, any kind of questions around.
- 28:33And so yes, you'll absolutely meet me again.
- 28:35And she goes, oh, good. She said, before you leave, can
- 28:38you take a look at this? And she goes come with me.
- 28:41And she walks down the hall and she had a little auxiliary
- 28:45closet in the hallway. And she opens it up and she
- 28:48pulls out this box and pulls a file.
- 28:52And inside that file was a stack of stock certificates and bonds
- 28:59with coupons that she would clip and send out.
- 29:04And and I share this story, right?
- 29:05Because immediately I was like, Oh my gosh, you know, she's 80
- 29:11years old. She's a prime target.
- 29:13I don't have a clue how much all of this is worth.
- 29:15I haven't really studied what the certificates were and
- 29:18everything. But I said, I'm a little bit
- 29:20concerned about, you know, how you are protecting these assets,
- 29:24right? Because they're in bearer
- 29:25condition and this makes her a threat or puts her in a threat
- 29:31situation. And so we sat back down and had
- 29:35a discussion around, you know, potentially considering a
- 29:39different custodial solution, right, bringing those in house,
- 29:43being able to have those on a, on a qualified custodians
- 29:46platform and, and not being exposed to the bearer nature,
- 29:51especially with the bonds. So I came back, stock powers
- 29:55everything and we basically, you know, brought in a multiple
- 29:59people because you can't just take all of this stuff right
- 30:02without a proper level of security and, and controls and,
- 30:06and witnesses. And we brought it all back and
- 30:08we sent it into the Home Office in her account funds and it was
- 30:12about $5.7 million. This, this, this is 1991.
- 30:22Now, if you think about if you're a financial professional
- 30:28or you're an individual investor who was around during those
- 30:31times of bearer assets and thinking about the risk that you
- 30:35incurred, you'd say to yourself, well, that was lunacy at the
- 30:37time, right? Looking back at it, you go, Oh
- 30:39my God, I can't believe I had five and a half million dollars
- 30:42sitting in in a closet and the risks that it presents, right
- 30:47risk of loss, fire, you know, and there were ways that they
- 30:50can, you know, re recoup securities in the event of, you
- 30:55know, total, you know, disaster. But that being said, it was a
- 30:58real, real risk, especially with the bearer bonds.
- 31:02And so I look back and I think about Bitcoin in the same lens,
- 31:06right, It's a bearer asset if you are holding it, you know, in
- 31:10self custody, and that's not a bad thing.
- 31:12Some people have the ability to hold that asset in, in bearer
- 31:18form. It might not align to your
- 31:21estate planning needs. It certainly presents risks and
- 31:25Jesse does a great job and I think his article about lining
- 31:29the strengths of that approach and also the weaknesses.
- 31:32And you have to know yourself. You really have to know
- 31:35yourself. Do you have the time?
- 31:37Do you have the inclination? Do you have the competency?
- 31:40And if you have all three of them, great, you know, now make
- 31:45sure that your controls are in place and your and your backup
- 31:49plans are in place. And those who can you have
- 31:52trusted people in your life that know how to how to handle things
- 31:56and should something happened to you.
- 31:57But that being said, time, inclination and control, if one
- 32:02of those is missing, you've got a problem.
- 32:06You might have two, but you got, you got to have all three.
- 32:09Otherwise you've got a problem. So that's just a a a story to
- 32:13share. What one just to respond to that
- 32:16Rich. I always anchor back to him when
- 32:18we met and you you referenced your experience and professional
- 32:25professional experience and personal at Schwab and the
- 32:30altruism like the the the notable, the the nature that
- 32:33Schwab was known for, for being innovative, but also
- 32:36democratizing the ability to individual sale preserve their
- 32:40wealth and that maybe it had slowed down or you found Bitcoin
- 32:43or like, well, maybe they'll lie.
- 32:45I'm not as aligned. And maybe this is, you know,
- 32:48some other things that maybe it's time that kind of hang it
- 32:50up here. And I think about Bitcoin is
- 32:53like this ultimate. I think everyone would agree it
- 32:55democratizes the ability for people to preserve their wealth.
- 32:59The problem with it is that the asset does, but the custodial
- 33:04solutions have historically not done that, IE you can't really
- 33:08put material amounts of wealth on an exchange because people
- 33:11know where they get rugged. And so they don't, they start
- 33:13that process and then they don't get to extend into the future to
- 33:17put majority or like a larger percentage because they never
- 33:19get to see that unless they've picked one of the, you know,
- 33:21exchanges that are still around. There's only a few.
- 33:23The alternative to that is everyone claims self custody is
- 33:27not hard. It isn't if you focus a lot of
- 33:29time or have the time and effort, majority of people for
- 33:32better or worse, you can't expect them to go through and
- 33:35take that to put your point bearer, take custody of it and
- 33:39then start to position more and more wealth and into the asset.
- 33:44So it you historically just have either somebody looks at it and
- 33:47doesn't put any money in or it's very little because anything
- 33:50they put in is just looked at as well.
- 33:51It's a flyer. It's not a preserver of wealth.
- 33:55And so this notion of what we were talking about here with
- 33:59what we do is like, to my mind, the first time we've seen that
- 34:03where you can open it up, you're not have a centralized risk at
- 34:07the same time as you learn you don't have the risk of oh, well,
- 34:10I get rugged, IE blocked by IE Celsius.
- 34:12Every every cycle has its own, you know, cohorts that are just
- 34:15minefields in the space that keep people out from getting
- 34:18material exposure. And then overtime, if you get as
- 34:21you get educated, you have the room to breathe, to take self
- 34:24custody and do anything you want with the asset if you so choose
- 34:27to. But it's not the first thing you
- 34:29have to do, which I think ultimately keeps a lot of people
- 34:32out or I know it keeps a lot of people out because it's just
- 34:35daunting and it takes time to really get good of self custody.
- 34:38It's like throwing somebody a gun.
- 34:40You can't just go to war with it.
- 34:41Like you've got to practice it. Nobody, anybody saying any
- 34:43otherwise just is their line. It's not true.
- 34:47Yeah, you know, it's interesting.
- 34:49I guess I'll share another story because I think, I think we
- 34:52learn from experiences and, you know, whether it's our owner or
- 34:56others, but, you know, I became a huge bitcoiner really around
- 35:052020. And it was born out of, you
- 35:08know, I guess some false arrogance that I had.
- 35:11And, and, and frankly, some, some bad, not well thought out,
- 35:16not well researched advice that I had given a couple of people
- 35:19that I really care about and told them steer clear of it,
- 35:23right? And because I, I didn't know
- 35:25anything about it and I just said steer clear of it.
- 35:27And, you know, few months go by and, and I'm sitting in front of
- 35:33a number of people and I'm giving a, you know, a speech to
- 35:35people about the importance of, of, of being well researched and
- 35:41knowing, right. The difference between knowing
- 35:44and thinking, you know, and giving that to a client and that
- 35:49you need to really be well researched.
- 35:51And, you know, before you ever, you know, just, you know,
- 35:55patently give advice relative to an individual security and how
- 36:00it might fit a client's portfolio.
- 36:03And you know, that moment hit me and I was reminded immediately
- 36:06of, of, you know, how I had, you know, basically, you know, did
- 36:11the same thing with two people that I care about.
- 36:14And, and I realized, oh gosh, I just, I said something about
- 36:18Bitcoin without having any point of view and doing any level of
- 36:23personal research. Well, I did that right.
- 36:26I went through it, I went back and I said, OK, I got to make
- 36:28amends. I got to learn, I got to double
- 36:30down. I'm going to do some, some work
- 36:32on Bitcoin. I had both eventually became a
- 36:34Bitcoiner and started stacking, right?
- 36:39And I started at Coinbase and then I said, OK, well, there's
- 36:43all these other exchanges. Maybe I need to diversify the
- 36:46exchange risk because I was aware of exchange failures.
- 36:50So I went to River and I went to Swan and I went to strike and I
- 36:54had all of my coins kind of scattered around Michael.
- 36:57And and then all of a sudden I realized, OK, exchanges are
- 37:02probably not the place. They have a they serve a
- 37:04purpose. They allow you to enter into
- 37:09the, the Bitcoin, but they're not, you know, necessarily where
- 37:13I want to store my Bitcoin because they have a history of
- 37:16failure in a nascent industry. So I'm going to become is
- 37:19somebody that that steps into cold storage, right?
- 37:23And I went and did my research and I, you know, got a, got a
- 37:27treasure, you know, it started moving the assets from all the
- 37:33various exchanges on to it. And then sure enough, we had the
- 37:36big draw down of of 22 and I just started, you know,
- 37:42stacking, right? I just was like, OK, this is
- 37:44great. I'm, I'm all in.
- 37:46And I'm just going to continue to, you know, cost average and
- 37:49put, you know, chunks of money into, into Bitcoin.
- 37:53Next thing I know, I'm feeling pretty proud of where I'm at and
- 37:57my wife who is a very seasoned executive in the financial
- 38:01services space. And she, she said to me, she
- 38:04goes now look, how much do we have on this little device and
- 38:12how does it fit into our estate plan?
- 38:14And what happens if you get hit by a bus?
- 38:19And how do I do this? And, and I just was like, OK,
- 38:24yeah, I get it. I've got a problem.
- 38:26I've I've walked us into a problem.
- 38:29And now I need to have a conversation about what she
- 38:32says. She says, look, I, I'm a
- 38:36believer in Bitcoin, but I also have concerns, right?
- 38:42How does, how in the world does this thing hit an adoption curve
- 38:47if everybody's running around with their wealth on a little,
- 38:54little UBS drive, right? And what does that, what does
- 38:57that mean? She's like, it doesn't make
- 39:00sense of mass adoption. This isn't the way to mass
- 39:04adoption. So how she goes, imagine a 70
- 39:07year old client going, OK, yeah, what am I going to do here?
- 39:10I'm going to in walking through it.
- 39:12And she's like, remember how hard it was to get people to
- 39:15move to online capabilities just to check their accounts?
- 39:20They got there, but it took 15 years to get people comfortable
- 39:26looking and reviewing at their accounts.
- 39:28And she was like, these devices aren't going to do it.
- 39:31That's not going to be the way that Bitcoin scales.
- 39:35Advisors won't adopt that technology.
- 39:38It won't be the, it won't be good for them because they're
- 39:41going to be tinkering and doing key checks and things that are
- 39:44low value activities when the relational aspects of their work
- 39:48is so much more meaningful. And I was like, OK, I get it.
- 39:51So I went out and I started doing some more research and I
- 39:55found collaborative custody it multi city and I was like OK,
- 39:59this improves our situation. And I can integrate my, my
- 40:03inheritance and their estate planning and I can title
- 40:07accounts correctly. And we have a partner, right?
- 40:12And that feels good. And my wife was like, OK, this
- 40:15feels good, but it's still not a scalable solution like this.
- 40:19She's thinking about how does this thing evolve?
- 40:23And you know, that research kind of led me down the path to start
- 40:27integrating into the Bitcoin community a little bit more.
- 40:30And I found, you know, on ramp and and I was like, Oh my God,
- 40:35once the light bulb clicked, I was like, OK, so multi sig,
- 40:39which is native to Bitcoin. I liked that.
- 40:43And all of a sudden I started looking at the trust minimize
- 40:47minimized approach, right, by saying, OK, you've got three
- 40:50different, you know, institutions that have a very
- 40:54specific and defined role. And I thought, OK, they can't
- 41:01unilaterally do anything without my authorization.
- 41:05This is a control factor. This is really cool.
- 41:08So I said to my wife, I go take a look at this.
- 41:10What do you think about what on ramp is done here?
- 41:14And, and she's like, this is how Bitcoin scales.
- 41:19This is how adoption curves move.
- 41:22This is exactly what is familiar to the 90% who are not early
- 41:28adopters of Bitcoin, right? Those people that have the time,
- 41:31the inclination, and the competency, right?
- 41:35All the others that may be missing one, maybe they're
- 41:38missing 2, Maybe they're missing all three.
- 41:40Maybe they don't have the time inclination or the competency
- 41:44and they just want the Bitcoin exposure because they recognize
- 41:47the value proposition of sound money in very, very dangerous
- 41:51times where debts are exploding and deficits are running wild
- 41:56and, and you know, nothing seems to make sense.
- 42:00People are getting attracted to Bitcoin, right?
- 42:03So how did they come to it? How did they secure it?
- 42:07And how does it feel familiar to them in a way that they don't
- 42:11have a bunch of hidden key fobs in a treasure map?
- 42:15And she was like, this is potentially the way that this
- 42:19makes sense and can scale. And I just thought, oh, wow,
- 42:23wow. I got to be a part of it.
- 42:25And, you know, and I was fortunate.
- 42:26I, I was very fortunate to, to find you guys because it aligned
- 42:31with my calling. So.
- 42:32It's good. We're fortunate to find you too.
- 42:33Your your wife has given us the best compliment, at least I've
- 42:36heard that we may ever hear. That's a that's a big feat,
- 42:39especially coming from you guys being involved in it's so
- 42:43involved in the financial industry.
- 42:45It's kind of a funny thing because I think we forget the
- 42:48tropes, right? Like of, you know, first
- 42:51principle thinking gets thrown around a lot, but it's like you
- 42:54hear things and you just do them.
- 42:56And self custody has ultimately been baked into bitcoins ethos
- 43:00for so long that I think we kind of forget.
- 43:03Well, like if this is how it all goes well, what does the world
- 43:06look like is the first question. And then the second one is,
- 43:09well, we understood why we couldn't trust a custodian, but
- 43:12it's not just like a small improvement to put two
- 43:15custodians. It's more than even a step
- 43:17function because you could trust some custodians, but you don't
- 43:20know which ones. That's why you don't do it.
- 43:23But then when you need to trust two of three, it changes the
- 43:25dynamic and it scales proportionate with the amount of
- 43:27capital. So it's just a fundamentally
- 43:29different. It goes back to that analogy of
- 43:31like the wheel being used the wrong way.
- 43:33Like my opinion, multi sig has just been used the wrong way.
- 43:35And once you flip it, you kind of like, oh, that was a thing.
- 43:37It's the first time you've had governance built into a protocol
- 43:40because gold didn't have this. And this is effectively the
- 43:43difference between gold. And then you're like, oh, now I
- 43:45understand how to build financial products around it.
- 43:47And so we get to talk about every day and everybody's like,
- 43:49I don't really get what's going on here.
- 43:51And it's just like, OK, well, we'll show you because at 100K
- 43:54everybody be like, oh, I get it. Like I don't really like these
- 43:56plastic things in my house. And I really don't like Coinbase
- 43:58holding all of it. It may be later in the call
- 44:01we'll pull up that chart that everybody's been talking about
- 44:04with the, you know, Coinbase that looks like a spider web
- 44:07with all of that, you know, capital sitting there, which is
- 44:09just kind of, if people are talking about it at 58,000,
- 44:11imagine at 108,000 like it's just going to be a existential
- 44:16like crisis for for the asset class in general.
- 44:19Yeah, Michael, to your point, I think what makes it more than
- 44:26the step function improvement is, is with, with, with and to
- 44:34date you've got third party custody and self custody.
- 44:38And obviously you, you don't have control of your coins in
- 44:423rd party custody. You do have control of your
- 44:44coins in, in self custody. But then you have all the risks
- 44:48of, of this sort of barbarism that that Jackson mentioned of
- 44:54you're, you're keeping it buried out back or you're hiding it
- 44:59under a floorboard in your house or in a safe.
- 45:02And, and then, then you're living in a world where like
- 45:05everyone's wealth is stored with them and that invites a
- 45:12regression of civilization where you're kind of, you know, you go
- 45:16back to a world where everyone's a target at all times because
- 45:20they've got their wealth on them or near them.
- 45:23And that's, I think part of the, the story of bitcoins evolution
- 45:28and, and, and understanding the psychology of adoption to to
- 45:34date and looking forward, where people are not the mainstream is
- 45:38not going to adopt this as the the centerpiece of their
- 45:41financial lives if it involves, you know, keeping their wealth
- 45:46on or near them at all times and being responsible for the
- 45:49technical and security burden of that.
- 45:54And the thing about multi institution custody is it is
- 46:00this form of custody where you get the benefit of third party
- 46:05custodians expertise, but you retain control.
- 46:09And so you know this, this mantra to over the 15 years of
- 46:13Bitcoin's life of not your keys, not your coins has been really
- 46:17helpful historically because it has pointed people away from
- 46:20trusting their coins with Mount Cox and towards taking self
- 46:24custody. And that's been the better the
- 46:27the better of the two options because the failures of
- 46:30centralized exchanges have been way greater than the failures of
- 46:34of individuals screwing up their self custody.
- 46:37So not your keys, not your coins has been good.
- 46:40But what it really at the at the core of that, what what what the
- 46:43sage advice there is is not your control, not your coins, because
- 46:49it's ultimately it's about control.
- 46:51You want to make sure that you're not giving over control
- 46:53of your coins to a third party custodian that could that could
- 46:57then become susceptible to a hack or could re hypothecate
- 47:02your coins or could somehow, you know, abscond with your coins.
- 47:06I like maybe the Quadrica founder did.
- 47:10And so so you know, you don't want to give up control of your
- 47:14coins and so that self custody has been the only game in town.
- 47:19But with multi institution custody you get to this
- 47:23combination of the expertise of third party custodians
- 47:28participating while you are not giving up control of your coins
- 47:33because each participant only has 1/3 of the quorum of the key
- 47:39material. And so in that sense, you, you
- 47:43retain control because you're the only legal, legally
- 47:47authorized person to, to, to direct the, the key holders to
- 47:55sign on your behalf. And that's the, the ultimate,
- 47:58you know, wisdom of not your keys, not your coins.
- 48:02So, you know, I think looking forward, what's possible with
- 48:06multi institution custody is, is that we move out of this 15 year
- 48:10period of, of either trust, trust someone with your coins or
- 48:16bury it Outback. And you move from that into a
- 48:20future state where individuals no longer have to take on the
- 48:24technical burden and the security burden of setting up
- 48:30and maintaining their own custody solution, but they get
- 48:33to have control of their coins. And so that's the that's the
- 48:37best of, of both worlds. And I think it's how this asset
- 48:41matures. You know, we're we're building a
- 48:43new financial system here from scratch and that involves going
- 48:48through the bar barbaric era and then civilization develops
- 48:53further from there. And that and that in Bitcoin
- 48:56land looks like pulling in the the benefits of institutional
- 49:00trust, but also making sure that the end user retains control and
- 49:06stripping away the requirement of understanding how to set up
- 49:09and maintain a a cryptographic key, because the mainstream is
- 49:14not going to be capable of that and shouldn't have to do that.
- 49:17And so I think, you know, that's, that's the the
- 49:20significance of what multi institution custody creates
- 49:24looking forward. And, and it's also why it's the
- 49:27best solution for the mainstream that is yet to come to Bitcoin.
- 49:30And these people, you know, in the mainstream people are,
- 49:35should not be expected to have to put in 100 hours to learn how
- 49:41cryptographic signatures work and then understand multi sig
- 49:44and then understand hardware wallets and the vulnerabilities
- 49:46and think about all the threat vectors that they have and, and
- 49:51do it all yourself. They, it's just not tenable.
- 49:53It's not what the mainstream's going to be capable of, frankly,
- 49:58But they're going to be capable of having an an account with,
- 50:01with an institution that is coordinating among several
- 50:04institutions and, and provides all the benefits and risk
- 50:09mitigates as much as possible, you know, all in one package.
- 50:14Yeah. And the the point you made
- 50:16working backwards on that, it's like I'm intimately familiar
- 50:20with the process of collaborative custody, whether
- 50:23it's Swan nunchuck or anything. And the reality is if somebody
- 50:26really sits in a it by themselves and is honest with
- 50:29themselves, they are probably very, very uncomfortable.
- 50:32If you realize the different functions you have to be
- 50:36prepared to do. If you're going to use something
- 50:38like that, you ultimately need to be prepared for your hardware
- 50:41device to malfunction and then you to be able to restore it
- 50:44backwards and forwards. And then if the partner goes
- 50:48down, which you have to be prepared for because that's why
- 50:50you're using it, then how do you reconstitute the wallet?
- 50:52And then where do you put the wallet?
- 50:54Is it online? Offline, You need it both.
- 50:55But then that's a piece of information.
- 50:58And then you have your seeds. Will they need to be away from
- 50:59your hardware devices? And then you actually need to
- 51:01make sure they're tamper proof. Because somebody takes a
- 51:03picture, they can start to pull together all the different
- 51:06pieces and maybe it doesn't matter AT20K or 40K, but maybe
- 51:09it matters AT60K or 100K. And when you really look at all
- 51:12that, nobody's incentivized to tell anybody that.
- 51:15When you look at, it's like, oh wait, this actually doesn't.
- 51:17But going back really quick, Jesse, you you hit on something
- 51:21about like it's probably an anomaly.
- 51:23The amount of self like the majority of assets sit in self
- 51:25custody today, right? I think it's whatever, like 70%,
- 51:28sixty to 70%. And you mentioned like the
- 51:31barbaric or the the phase of adoption.
- 51:34You joke back and thinking about like gold and gold didn't come
- 51:38out as a coin, right? It like came out as this or and
- 51:41you know, if you like go back to it, it's not going to be direct,
- 51:43but it's like you people were trading different forms of
- 51:46metallic units and then some people were scamming people for
- 51:50others until they realize like this is the one that scares.
- 51:53This is the one that's portable and all the things that makes
- 51:55gold gold. And that's what's happening
- 51:58right today with crypto currencies and all this stuff.
- 52:00It's just like one's monetizing everything else.
- 52:02It's kind of demonetizing against it.
- 52:04But then they probably put it underneath their cave or
- 52:07wherever they sat. And then people came and robbed
- 52:09them and they were like, well, maybe there's a better version
- 52:12of this. And then you have, you know,
- 52:13financial and market structure and you, you evolve as a
- 52:16society. And so we're if the parallel,
- 52:19I'm sure I don't have to explicitly say like that's the
- 52:21parallel what's happening today. And it's what kept the assets
- 52:24off, kept the assets offline. But it's been a sweet spot.
- 52:28It's going to be the anomaly. I'm just working through this as
- 52:30Jesse was saying, like, well, it was nice to have them offline
- 52:34because the price was $1000 or 10 bucks.
- 52:36Nobody's running around looking for your, you know, thousand BTC
- 52:41and 10 bucks. But it changes.
- 52:44And something that Bradley had shared privately that it's
- 52:46always stuck in my head is we don't test our food every time
- 52:49we go eat. Like, but we expect to live in a
- 52:51world where we're not going to trust anybody.
- 52:53Like, what does that look like? And so you extrapolate that
- 52:56further into custody of an asset that's worth a lot of money.
- 53:01I know a lot of, not a lot, but I mean, I know people will have
- 53:03over 10,000 BTC and they, they custody it themselves because
- 53:06how else do you do it? Or, or at least have this form
- 53:09of collaborative custody and they don't really spend their
- 53:11Bitcoin, right? Like what do you do with it?
- 53:13But at a certain point in the future, you do.
- 53:15And your exit liquidity is, is something in the financial
- 53:19world, whether it's real estate, whether it's, you know, some
- 53:22kind of financial asset. Well, there's a trail there that
- 53:25metadata, that thing opens you up to a bunch of risk that
- 53:28wouldn't have been there at, at this current moment because
- 53:30nobody's really watching and nobody knows you have 10,000
- 53:32BTC. Well, that looks different.
- 53:34And so to expect somebody that has, you know, call it 100
- 53:36million today to have 3 billion on their person or 4 billion or
- 53:39five. Like it's just it's not a there
- 53:42hasn't been a full picture of how do we get to where we want
- 53:45to go. And so I think like parallels
- 53:47like we were talking about in this notion of this is where it
- 53:50was, This is why it's important, This is why it's a good check.
- 53:54And I guess the last part is if people were around in 17, multi
- 53:57sig was just coming around from a consumer perspective, it's
- 53:59been used since 2013 or 14, but from an institutional
- 54:03perspective, but in 17 was really when like 1617 the cost
- 54:07is unchanged, the world came about.
- 54:09And then it really took till 21 to really pick up.
- 54:12And that's really be a function of price because as the price
- 54:14goes up, then the need goes similar with like what we're
- 54:17doing here. And if you take that to its
- 54:21extension, it's like multi sig was good air cover for single
- 54:23sig because now from a security perspective, you're able to say,
- 54:27look, I don't have a full control.
- 54:28You know, it's kind of like a pass phrase, like I have
- 54:30multiple keys or geographically separated all this.
- 54:33So in a world where people still want to use multi sig and collab
- 54:36custody of their own roll, their own multi institution still
- 54:38provides the air cover because you're like, look, I can't move
- 54:40the assets. I got to go like to institutions
- 54:42in a future state. I got to go to an on ramp branch
- 54:44and I got to go talk to them. Like it's just an evolution of
- 54:47where we go as an asset class that we'd all you can't.
- 54:49The only option is that we just hold it on our person or I can
- 54:53like hold somebody against the phone to Coinbase until they
- 54:55move the Bitcoin. Does your Bitcoin custody setup
- 54:58keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 55:01sitting on an exchange worried about hackers.
- 55:04Or maybe you've set up your own self custody but don't feel safe
- 55:06with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 55:08device in your desk drawer. Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp
- 55:13and our multi institution custody solution.
- 55:16Here's how it works. On Ramp creates a dedicated
- 55:19multi sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 55:22a key on ramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 55:27unilaterally. Instead, only you have control
- 55:30over your coins with on ramps multi institution custody.
- 55:35You'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is stored
- 55:37with best in class security on chain with fault tolerant multi
- 55:41sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 55:43going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 55:47exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks
- 55:50in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 55:54you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 55:57custody set up on ramps. Multi institution custody
- 56:00eliminates single points of failure, reduces your personal
- 56:04attack surface and technical burden, and provides access to
- 56:07financial services. That allow you to confidently
- 56:09secure your Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance
- 56:13backed warranties for all balances and transactions, low
- 56:16cost trading and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 56:20asset. Secure it right.
- 56:22Learn more at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 56:24Yeah, no, it's, I mean, everyone's made such great
- 56:27points, so many different topics here.
- 56:31One thing I was thinking of what while you both were speaking is
- 56:35the idea that people will acknowledge that we're early for
- 56:39Bitcoin, but at the same time they believe that we've
- 56:43effectively figured everything out as it relates to custody and
- 56:46Bitcoin infrastructure. And I, I tweeted something, I
- 56:50tweeted something earlier today just about Treasure devices.
- 56:54The first, the, the Model 1 was introduced in July of 2014 and
- 56:58the price of Bitcoin was about $600.00.
- 57:03Now we're a decade, a decade later in 2024, Bitcoin is about
- 57:0956,000, right? So the price is 100 X what it
- 57:14was a decade ago, yet people are using the same technology to
- 57:18secure the asset. I think that there's kind of a
- 57:21cognitive dissonance in the sense that if you believe that
- 57:25Bitcoin is early, you can't also believe that we've figured
- 57:28everything out. It's just those two do not mesh.
- 57:31So part of, you know, our mission here is to help people
- 57:36understand that their needs are evolving as Bitcoin evolves in
- 57:41its adoption and growth trajectory.
- 57:43And it does. Again, it doesn't mean that self
- 57:46custody is a bad way to secure the asset.
- 57:48I think everyone on this call uses self custody to some
- 57:51degree. But the, the difference is we
- 57:55don't necessarily believe that we're going to live in a world
- 57:57where you can't trust anyone, where you have to go into your
- 58:00cave and dig up your stamps, your seat phrase, stamp and seal
- 58:05and sign a transaction, right? It's just like it's worked.
- 58:09It's kept people safe. But the market is evolving.
- 58:13And to Michael's point, like actually I'm on the phone a lot
- 58:16of the day with people who have done self custody and they're
- 58:20telling me that they have these concerns and that they have
- 58:24these issues and I'm not prompting it out of them.
- 58:27I'm, they reach out to us or I have a conversation with them
- 58:30through social media some way, somehow.
- 58:33And they tell me, you know, this is how I've done it
- 58:36historically, but I've been doing it this way since Bitcoin
- 58:39was $5000 or since it was $10,000.
- 58:41And you know what? Now I have children or I got
- 58:44married, whatever it is, right? Or I moved and I realized when I
- 58:47had to travel that this was, this was challenging and for me
- 58:51to think about and it was causing, you know, it was
- 58:54hurting my Peace of Mind. So I'm hearing first hand that
- 58:57people are recognizing this and they're coming around to the
- 59:00idea that if we are early, then we also can't have everything
- 59:04figured out. And I think more people just
- 59:07need to think about that in the industry.
- 59:09There's a funny aspect of Jesse where you came from from, you
- 59:12know, Bain or or Stanford and Rich on the the Schwab side.
- 59:16I was 10 years ago, I was at Google and I went and visit.
- 59:19I was in Nashville last week and when there was an office we
- 59:21built out there and I went and stopped by to just catch up.
- 59:24Sure what I was doing and I was telling about a previous firm
- 59:26and what we did and I pulled out.
- 59:27I had one of these and like it clinks because it has this nice
- 59:30little just like like it moves that the I'm holding up a
- 59:33treasure. And, and I told him like what we
- 59:35did. And they just, they just like
- 59:37they, it just laughed. It's just a funny thing.
- 59:39If you really think about like, imagine going in a Schwab
- 59:41meeting. You're like, look, we're going
- 59:43to like get you this alternative asset, but we're going to ship
- 59:45these to you and like, you're going to put it in the office.
- 59:48They would just be like, Rich, can you please leave?
- 59:49I'm glad you left. We'll, we'll see you at the, you
- 59:52know, when you're in the nursing home or whatever, Like it's just
- 59:54ridiculous. No, I can't even imagine.
- 1:00:00I can't even imagine. But you know, it, it it's so
- 1:00:04funny, right? You know, Jesse was just kind of
- 1:00:06walking us through the whole, you know, trust dialogue and and
- 1:00:12I think that's a really, really important conversation, you
- 1:00:16know, because I think in many respects, you look at you look
- 1:00:21at the whole, the whole world today, right?
- 1:00:25You know, institutions have somewhat betrayed the trust of
- 1:00:29those that they were meant to, meant to or established to
- 1:00:34serve. And and you know, and that's a
- 1:00:36it's not a good feeling for anybody.
- 1:00:38I think we all on this call can feel it in some degree.
- 1:00:41And certainly everybody that I speak with, you know, have has
- 1:00:44felt a degree of woe. I need to really rethink what
- 1:00:47does trust mean? And, and that's a healthy thing.
- 1:00:52But when you're talking about financial services, it's an
- 1:00:54industry that's built on trust, right?
- 1:00:56It's an industry that really, really relies on trust.
- 1:01:01And you know, I think about, you know, the, the beauty of MIC in
- 1:01:09many respects is that it's familiar because it says, yes,
- 1:01:15I'm going to extend trust, but with boundaries it, it's, it's
- 1:01:21trust minimized, right? It has the ability for each
- 1:01:26institution to play a singular role within their competency and
- 1:01:33their skill set and their controls, but it minimizes that
- 1:01:39the total control of any single institution, right, because it's
- 1:01:43dispersed key risk in inside the quorum.
- 1:01:46And and so it, it says, hey, look, I can still have a
- 1:01:49trusting relationship with you, but the level of that trust has
- 1:01:54boundaries. And I'm asking you to play, you
- 1:01:59know, qualified custodian, a specific and singular role
- 1:02:02inside of a quorum. And I'm dispersing that risk
- 1:02:05across others. And I like that, right?
- 1:02:08Because by I'm a trust extension guy, right?
- 1:02:11Like my whole life, I always said, you know, I'm going to
- 1:02:14lead with trust and, and extend trust to people.
- 1:02:19Others kind of come from a Hey, you got to prove, prove to me
- 1:02:22who you are. And, and, and neither is right,
- 1:02:26neither is wrong. We just have different ways that
- 1:02:28we are wired. But the beautiful thing about it
- 1:02:32is when you feel like, OK, well, geez, I think the government has
- 1:02:36betrayed the trust of the of the people in in some some way,
- 1:02:40shape or form. And I think universally,
- 1:02:42regardless of where you are on the on the party spectrum, I
- 1:02:45mean, that doesn't make a difference.
- 1:02:47You probably are saying the heck what went wrong here?
- 1:02:50They betrayed their trust. They didn't manage the the the
- 1:02:54responsibility effectively for for the citizens.
- 1:02:57You know that stand up, that government, you know, one can
- 1:03:01all come point at, you know, the food industry or the healthcare
- 1:03:05industry or whatever industry, it doesn't make a difference.
- 1:03:07They're all showing some degradation of the trust that
- 1:03:10has been extended to them. So maybe we as people just need
- 1:03:14to sit back and say, okay, look, regardless of trust does matter,
- 1:03:19it does need to be earned, but we also need to be able to
- 1:03:22extend it with limitations and boundaries.
- 1:03:24And so there's a really interesting inner dialogue that
- 1:03:27I think we're all probably going through and evaluating how we
- 1:03:30think about trust. The same can be said on the
- 1:03:34advisor side. If you don't mind me kind of
- 1:03:36just pivoting a little bit when, you know, I worked inside Schwab
- 1:03:41for 31 years and it was such a wonderful ride.
- 1:03:44And I had the opportunity to help build out our wealth
- 1:03:48management capabilities at Schwab starting in, you know,
- 1:03:51early, you know, in the 2000s and, and, you know, and, and
- 1:03:56that's really grown into something pretty cool.
- 1:03:59But at the same point in time, I also had the chance to crossover
- 1:04:03and work on the institutional side and work directly with
- 1:04:06advisors and helping them, you know, establish their business
- 1:04:10and run successful businesses and, and continue to grow and,
- 1:04:15and, and, and succeed with their clients.
- 1:04:17And I, it's never lost on me. I think about, you know, a a
- 1:04:23number of firms that that I have very close relationships with
- 1:04:27and how they made this decision from going from a wirehouse into
- 1:04:34the independent channel and the deep, deep level of due
- 1:04:40diligence that they did on their custodial channels that they
- 1:04:44could have explored whether that be Schwab or Fidelity or or
- 1:04:49Raymond James or LPL right there with a lot of choices that were
- 1:04:53available to them. And they spent an enormous
- 1:04:56amount of time registered investment advisors doing very
- 1:05:01deep due diligence on the capabilities of that firm before
- 1:05:05they ever made the choice of who was going to be their custodial
- 1:05:08partner, right, of the litany of things that they had to think
- 1:05:11about it, starting a business, that one took a lot of mind
- 1:05:14share and a lot of, you know, looking under the rug in and
- 1:05:20trying to find where where there were problems.
- 1:05:23And, and there's a reason for that, right?
- 1:05:25Because the number one obligation that they have to
- 1:05:28their clients is to protect their assets, to protect their
- 1:05:32assets, not just to acquire and consolidate an asset, allocate
- 1:05:37and run a great financial plan, But it is to say that these
- 1:05:41assets are important to you. This is the store of your lifes
- 1:05:45work. And I will make certain that the
- 1:05:48custodial choice is one that is sound and you will, you will do
- 1:05:54that. You will have a great custodian,
- 1:05:56not just not just me as a small business owner and A and a
- 1:06:00partner in, in your financial affairs.
- 1:06:04That being said, I look at, you know, all of the advisors who
- 1:06:10are either very seasoned in the space today or maybe even just
- 1:06:15trying to raise their own level of awareness to the asset class
- 1:06:20now that we have a 15 year track record, right?
- 1:06:23It's catching their eye and they're like, OK, wait a second,
- 1:06:25I need to take a look at this. And the ETFs play a role into
- 1:06:29making them take a look at it a little bit more seriously.
- 1:06:33But you know, regularly, I mean, actually every conversation,
- 1:06:38pretty much every conversation in some way, shape or form.
- 1:06:42The, the thing I hear from advisors is, well, why not just
- 1:06:47ETF, right? Why not just ETF Rich?
- 1:06:51It seems, it seems easy. And I try to remind them of, you
- 1:06:59know, those early days of when they launched their own firm and
- 1:07:02how important that custodial partner was in that selection
- 1:07:06process and that due diligence. And by the way, that due
- 1:07:09diligence is ongoing on every strategic partner of those
- 1:07:12firms. They are rigorous about it,
- 1:07:14right? And it's part of their
- 1:07:15compliance, you know, approach is to do that due diligence on a
- 1:07:19regular basis and assess the quality of their custodian and,
- 1:07:22and, and the marketplace. And so why, why just lean in to
- 1:07:27easy when you're entering into an asset class that is so
- 1:07:34profound, like Bitcoin, right? To Jesse's point, it's a once in
- 1:07:38a species asset. It has unique properties and it
- 1:07:42needs to be considered a very unique asset and you need to do
- 1:07:46the due diligence on what you're really getting invested in.
- 1:07:50And so it doesn't matter on where people are on the
- 1:07:53spectrum, right? Very seasoned or, or just coming
- 1:08:00to the place. There is a degree of nonchalance
- 1:08:03that sometimes happens in the due diligence.
- 1:08:07They kick the tires a little bit, but they're not really
- 1:08:09seeking and learning and understanding the implications.
- 1:08:13And so, you know, my, my whole goal in going back to the wake
- 1:08:16up call is to try to raise that level of understanding that this
- 1:08:19is a unique asset. It does have unique properties.
- 1:08:24And you do need to think about the way that it is custodied and
- 1:08:28whether or not your client ultimately has control.
- 1:08:32And so there's some really fascinating conversations that
- 1:08:35we're having. And I love the fact that
- 1:08:37they're, you know, ever growing conversations.
- 1:08:42You know, it just my calendar continues to fill up with more
- 1:08:46and more firms that are finding, you know, on ramp and, and
- 1:08:50trying to explore why we're a little bit different.
- 1:08:53And, and whether they choose us or not doesn't matter to me at
- 1:08:58this point in time. What matters to me is that
- 1:09:00they're actually thinking properly about the asset and
- 1:09:04they're thinking properly about the custody and the care of that
- 1:09:08asset over the long term for their clients and the
- 1:09:11implications and not entering it incorrectly simply because it's
- 1:09:14easy. And that's what the ETFs do,
- 1:09:17right? You just hit a rebalance button
- 1:09:19and boom, you know, it's allocated across your clients
- 1:09:23and rebalanced and you know, it's cheap and it's price
- 1:09:26exposure. But what happens when your
- 1:09:29client two years down the line says, wait a second, what is
- 1:09:33this? Because it's behaving very
- 1:09:35differently in my inside of My Portfolio.
- 1:09:38And they do some work and they say, well, jeez, I want to do
- 1:09:41it. You know, I want actual Bitcoin.
- 1:09:43I don't want a price proxy. Well, now you're going to have a
- 1:09:46potential taxable gain and you entered the asset incorrectly.
- 1:09:51You've done well for your client, but you you've entered
- 1:09:54the asset incorrectly and you have downstream complications.
- 1:09:58But I am seeing more and more of the season firms, right?
- 1:10:01The ones who really came to it early and felt a degree of
- 1:10:05conviction and they did their due diligence and they secured
- 1:10:09the Bitcoin. They're rethinking their
- 1:10:11business models too, You know, Do I want it sitting on single
- 1:10:15exchange? Is that something that I'm
- 1:10:17comfortable with at this stage of the game or am I comfortable
- 1:10:23holding keys or setting up and being exposed to people seed
- 1:10:28phrases and doing key checks with clients, you know, am I
- 1:10:33comfortable doing that? Is that a risk that makes sense
- 1:10:37and is it a, a good approach long term for my value
- 1:10:45proposition and what I bring to the client relationship?
- 1:10:48Am I, am I doing low value activities right in order to,
- 1:10:53you know, help a client and they don't really, they couldn't do
- 1:10:59it on their own without me, right?
- 1:11:00Did I set them up in the right arrangement?
- 1:11:02And so there's some really interesting conversations that
- 1:11:05are emerging at all levels of the advisor space.
- 1:11:09Yeah, I'm kind of jealous of Rich.
- 1:11:11I got lucky to get on a couple of those calls.
- 1:11:13I don't know how it happened. It was via like LinkedIn and,
- 1:11:15and, and I I was able to get a taste of some of these
- 1:11:19conversations that are happening on the RA front.
- 1:11:21And one of the angles on like the barbell, like thinking about
- 1:11:25it like a barbell, there's the natural independent advisor that
- 1:11:27wants to differentiate which you want to look different than the
- 1:11:30ETF, right, because they all look the same.
- 1:11:32But then there's the other side of it, which is ultra
- 1:11:34sophisticated, ultra high net worth individuals want
- 1:11:36specialist, which is pretty standard in asset management.
- 1:11:42But the, The funny thing is that, you know, you kind of know
- 1:11:47empirically like you, you get what you pay for.
- 1:11:50So they, you know, like, OK, well, if an ETF is low cost,
- 1:11:54maybe I should look more or maybe a specialist can help me
- 1:11:57think about counterparty risk. But then I think that there's
- 1:12:00this notion of if you want a specialist for an asset where
- 1:12:05the the stakes aren't so high, you still that's standard,
- 1:12:08right? You go somewhere, but imagine
- 1:12:10the stakes being as high where we've seen the past 15 years.
- 1:12:12If you pick the wrong custodian in the wrong place, the assets
- 1:12:14don't end up at the best spot or IEA loss of 0.
- 1:12:18So what does that look like for the next couple of years or in
- 1:12:20the future? Are the big incumbents actually,
- 1:12:24is there a way for them to adopt, integrate or is it, is
- 1:12:29it, do they not, or are they not able to catch up?
- 1:12:31Because by the time they catch up to custody, then there's all
- 1:12:33these other financial products that end up looking like there's
- 1:12:35just an interesting dynamic. Only how does that play out?
- 1:12:38That is going to be, you know, TVD because like the most
- 1:12:41innovative thing we think about right now is an ETF, which is a
- 1:12:45fun rapper that sits at Coinbase.
- 1:12:47And that's the most innovative because they're still people
- 1:12:49that haven't stepped in. And by the time they step in and
- 1:12:54do anything, let's just call it MIMIC multi institution custody.
- 1:12:57That's years from now, if at best.
- 1:13:00But then there's a whole slew of financial products that have
- 1:13:02already existed, while a lot of bad things have probably
- 1:13:05happened at centralized custodians because of the asset,
- 1:13:08its volatility, its risk profile of custody.
- 1:13:10So it's just an interesting dynamic of these independent
- 1:13:13advisers in their best interest to find alternatives because it
- 1:13:16lets them be specialized. But then the market starts to
- 1:13:18catch up to it because it's technology and the flight, the
- 1:13:22capital moves very quickly. And is BlackRock and these other
- 1:13:26firms able to catch up and do that?
- 1:13:27If this asset takes as much capital flow from what we
- 1:13:30believe it the different buckets, It's just an
- 1:13:33interesting landscape where I think most people, including us,
- 1:13:35we believe, OK, Blackrock's a new BlackRock.
- 1:13:36Fidelity is going to be Fidelity Schwab, it's going to step in
- 1:13:39and they'll probably adopt it and pull.
- 1:13:40It's like I'm starting to believe that less and less
- 1:13:42because of how radically different this asset is that I
- 1:13:45don't know, at the end state they will be big players.
- 1:13:51Said Richard. I have a question.
- 1:13:55I have a question for you. Just in terms of the
- 1:13:59conversations that you've been having recently.
- 1:14:02I've been a part of some of them.
- 1:14:04And to Michael's point, it's been really exciting and
- 1:14:08informative for me to be a part of those conversations and just
- 1:14:10get to hear first hand how your experience from Schwab for over
- 1:14:1530 years really ties into your approach with working with
- 1:14:18advisors. But I know I'm not on every call
- 1:14:21that you have and even those meetings that you have in
- 1:14:24person, which seem to be, as you said, filling up your calendar
- 1:14:27more and more. So there's a lot of interest.
- 1:14:29I'm curious if there's like any themes that you notice in terms
- 1:14:34of the advisors that you're speaking with, whether it's firm
- 1:14:37size, is there any theme geographically?
- 1:14:41Is there any theme around where they're at in terms of having
- 1:14:44Bitcoin product within the firm? Just curious to hear from your
- 1:14:49perspective where you're seeing the most interest these days and
- 1:14:52maybe how you'd expect that to change in the next 6 to 12
- 1:14:56months? Yeah, that's an interesting
- 1:14:59question. I, I, I think I'm seeing a
- 1:15:01little bit of everything in terms of firm size.
- 1:15:05You know where we, we, well Jackson, I mean you, you and
- 1:15:10I've been on calls with Rias that are well north of $100
- 1:15:14billion AUM. So they're, they're, they're,
- 1:15:19they're paying attention now they don't have as much to lose,
- 1:15:29You know, in other words, it's easy for them to lean into the
- 1:15:32ETFs. It's scalable.
- 1:15:35These firms have been have hit a certain scale advantage and and
- 1:15:41you know, the ETF's play really, really well there for firms that
- 1:15:45are thinking about their scale and but they are also
- 1:15:48recognizing that they that that's not a sufficient enough
- 1:15:52solution all by itself. And they do need to have one off
- 1:15:55scenarios to meet the more complex client needs or more
- 1:15:59sophisticated client. And when I say that, I mean the
- 1:16:03client who is actually has an awareness of what Bitcoin is and
- 1:16:07actually places value on it, they're not going to be inclined
- 1:16:10to see an ETF in their portfolio.
- 1:16:12They want, you know, they want those ownership assurances.
- 1:16:16And so they're, they're starting to look at what is the array of,
- 1:16:20of ways to access this product that meet unique client
- 1:16:24circumstances. Where I find the most interest
- 1:16:29is actually in a very unique space.
- 1:16:33It's usually that advisor that's sitting at 100 million to 750
- 1:16:39million and there's a lot of advisors that are sitting in
- 1:16:45that 100 to 750 million. And the reason why those are the
- 1:16:50really interesting conversations.
- 1:16:52I mean it really interesting they got teeth is because the
- 1:16:57the principal probably hasn't had a succession event.
- 1:17:00They are still in it. They are entrepreneurial.
- 1:17:03They are very close to their to their to their client and their
- 1:17:07client needs. They build specialized
- 1:17:10capabilities. It's very boutique in many
- 1:17:13respects and and they want to constantly differentiate and add
- 1:17:20value to their clients. 1, to retain those clients because
- 1:17:24those clients are highly sought after and they know that the
- 1:17:27competitive landscape is difficult.
- 1:17:30And two, because you know, they recognize that that they can
- 1:17:35continue to grow and they can differentiate with the right
- 1:17:39level of expertise. And so the trend I would tell
- 1:17:41you here is really about education advisors are looking
- 1:17:48for partners in this space that allow them to upgrade their
- 1:17:55knowledge in how to access or, you know, not just to access,
- 1:17:59but how to secure and how to collaborate in in the Bitcoin
- 1:18:05space and integrated into their wealth management offer.
- 1:18:08So there's a lot more, they're more nimble, they're hungrier,
- 1:18:11they wish to differentiate and they recognize that they, there
- 1:18:15are threat vectors on them, right, for their clients that
- 1:18:19they want to close off. And, and you know, it doesn't
- 1:18:23matter what size firm you're with at the end of the day,
- 1:18:26advisors are smart people. Smart people are drawn to
- 1:18:29financial services, right? And because it tests them
- 1:18:32intellectually, it tests them relationally and, and there's
- 1:18:38good money here and to be made if you, if you are very good and
- 1:18:42you can differentiate. And so the question is, is how
- 1:18:45do you continue to grow as an advisor and how do you grow your
- 1:18:48knowledge and, and be able to answer and address the big
- 1:18:51questions that clients are asking today?
- 1:18:54And whenever I'm on a call with a, with an advisor, I always, I
- 1:18:58always ask them what, what's top of mind for clients when they
- 1:19:01come through your door? What universally are you
- 1:19:03hearing? And almost universally, the
- 1:19:08question is around inflation and the impacts of inflation on
- 1:19:13their discretionary in income, right?
- 1:19:16And it doesn't matter how wealthy you are or how little of
- 1:19:20assets you've accumulated, you are feeling the pain of
- 1:19:26compounding impacts of inflation.
- 1:19:29And, you know, it does affect people.
- 1:19:32And so the question becomes for these advisors is, how are we
- 1:19:36really addressing it? And does our 6040 model really
- 1:19:40address it on real terms based off of what you know, we're
- 1:19:45experiencing when people go to the pump or when they go to the
- 1:19:48grocery store or if they're paying their rent and their
- 1:19:52mortgage or whatever it might be, right?
- 1:19:54People are feeling compressed and limited in what they can do.
- 1:19:58And so advisors recognize that and they understand the return
- 1:20:03characteristics of what Bitcoin has presented over a 15 year
- 1:20:07track record. And they sit back and go
- 1:20:10probably need to probably need to have a solution and what's
- 1:20:15the right solution? And so.
- 1:20:16Universally, I'm hearing education matters to them.
- 1:20:20And so, you know, I think, you know, all four of us well know
- 1:20:24on this call, we spend a ton of time trying to be educators, to
- 1:20:30be teachers, to be good partners, you know, to our
- 1:20:34clients and prospective clients and pushing out content that has
- 1:20:39meaning and that helps people on their Bitcoin journey.
- 1:20:42And we're customizing and building pieces that that speak
- 1:20:46to the advisory firm, right? How do we, how do you speak to a
- 1:20:49financial professional who's looking to integrate this and
- 1:20:52become an expert and retain their trusted advisor status
- 1:20:56with their clients and put them in a position of trust and
- 1:20:59retain in that? In that position, We're, we're
- 1:21:02trying to, you know, solve that and we're working really hard to
- 1:21:06collaborate with those advisors to give them what they need to
- 1:21:10be able to be successful with their clients.
- 1:21:13Yeah, Yeah. Well said.
- 1:21:14I mean, I've, I've certainly noticed that too rich on some of
- 1:21:17the calls I've been on with you where typically our story and
- 1:21:22the Bitcoin story is resonating with folks who want to grow
- 1:21:26their business and have clients that are more concerned about
- 1:21:30their purchasing power and the inability of traditional
- 1:21:33financial assets to grow their purchasing power.
- 1:21:36At this point. We live in a world now where if
- 1:21:39you invest in equities or real estate, you're merely keeping
- 1:21:42pace with the rate of inflation, which wasn't the case a decade
- 1:21:45ago. If you were invested in,
- 1:21:47frankly, any investable asset, you are getting still a pretty
- 1:21:51nice real return. But then the inflation made its
- 1:21:53way into the real economy in the past almost half a decade at
- 1:21:56this point. And now people are really
- 1:21:59challenged to even preserve their wealth, let alone grow it.
- 1:22:02And I think there's an interesting story, Rich, I know
- 1:22:04that you've been thinking and writing about this as well, but
- 1:22:08there's an interesting story. To the extent that Bitcoin does
- 1:22:11align incentives with advisors and their clients, because Rias
- 1:22:16will win when their clients win, they're not making money pushing
- 1:22:20product on them. They're winning when their
- 1:22:23clients grow, in a lot of cases grow their assets under
- 1:22:26management if they're fee based advisor, right?
- 1:22:28So any advisor who looks at the performance of Bitcoin over the
- 1:22:32past 510 or 15 years and becomes compelled by that and wants to
- 1:22:37incorporate that into a portfolio will end up benefiting
- 1:22:42themselves kind of in a roundabout way because their
- 1:22:44clients will have a higher expected return, assuming the
- 1:22:50things that have played out over the past 15 years continue to do
- 1:22:53so. And we continue to see adoption
- 1:22:55of all sorts of institutions, individuals which we are seeing.
- 1:22:59So it does really align incentives in a unique way that
- 1:23:03I haven't really seen before in the finance industry.
- 1:23:06Yeah, I mean it. There's so many ways that
- 1:23:08advisors can grow by integrating Bitcoin, you know, one, it opens
- 1:23:13up new channels to go after assets of existing clients that
- 1:23:17have Bitcoin on exchanges and improving their setup right to
- 1:23:22new, you know, bitcoiners that exist out there, you know that.
- 1:23:27Let's look at what Michael just said. 70% hold it in self
- 1:23:31custody and they are and and there's what 1 1/4 trillion
- 1:23:37dollar asset class as of today roughly.
- 1:23:39I mean that's a huge pool of assets that are nobody is going
- 1:23:44after. And then the other piece about
- 1:23:47that is, you know, the advisors who are captured in wire houses,
- 1:23:53they're going to go independent and they are calling us all the
- 1:23:56regular and, and we're like, OK, we can't really do much for you
- 1:24:00and your current situation. But you know, if your
- 1:24:03circumstances ever change, we, we, we, we're happy to be a
- 1:24:06thought partner and help you. And those folks are going to
- 1:24:09come out. And the question is, where are
- 1:24:11they going to land? Are they going to launch their
- 1:24:13own firm or are they going to join a firm that actually has an
- 1:24:16infrastructure set up that supports Bitcoin adoption?
- 1:24:20And that's a really interesting opportunity.
- 1:24:22And then I, I would say the final piece, which you're
- 1:24:24touching on, which is the kegger story, right?
- 1:24:27I just saw this morning, right, the 10 year kegger for Bitcoin
- 1:24:31is 63%. And I think Brian Kubelis, who's
- 1:24:36our head of strategy and marketing, he, you know, said in
- 1:24:39any four year period, if, and correct me if I'm wrong here,
- 1:24:43Jesse, you probably know this better than I, but in any four
- 1:24:47year period, and even taking a look at the very worst four year
- 1:24:51period, the kegger for Bitcoin was 25%.
- 1:24:55And so when you think about the compounding effects within the
- 1:25:00incentive alignment for an advisor, if and I'm an advisor,
- 1:25:04I want Bitcoin in my clients portfolios because not only is
- 1:25:09my client going to win, which makes them a stickier client
- 1:25:13because they're saying, OK, you did great for me.
- 1:25:15Thank you, right. You really protected our, our,
- 1:25:18our wealth, but you also did great as a firm because your
- 1:25:24assets expand, right? So if I'm a billion dollar firm
- 1:25:28and I put just for simple math, I put what a 5% allocation into
- 1:25:34Bitcoin, you know what, that's 50 million, OK.
- 1:25:38And then, you know, start dropping a, you know, 63% kegger
- 1:25:43on that. And then, and then extrapolate
- 1:25:46that growth over a 10 year track record and knowing that you pull
- 1:25:50a 1% management fee out of that, then look at what your revenue
- 1:25:55has done as a business owner. And I would encourage everybody
- 1:25:58to do that, you know, and, and just be able to sit back and go,
- 1:26:01wait a second. Not only did I serve my clients
- 1:26:04well and they grew, I grew along with them.
- 1:26:09We all benefited by bringing this solution forward just with
- 1:26:12a simple allocation. And that's the beautiful thing
- 1:26:14about it. It's.
- 1:26:15Scary. It's scary how the incentives
- 1:26:18map to every little place it touches, but also the asymmetry
- 1:26:21because asymmetry to what you described in the upside, but
- 1:26:24also the downside if they don't adopt this because the capital
- 1:26:27flight and loss of clients because it's a one way store.
- 1:26:31Like if they don't find it there, they're going to go
- 1:26:32somewhere else. So they can get the growth of 63
- 1:26:35percent or they can get the growth of whatever the
- 1:26:37percentage that's going to be leave or the negative growth of
- 1:26:39whatever is leaving on an annualized basis, which is a
- 1:26:43very scary thing. I I think that's how you
- 1:26:46reference kind of when you talk about like, what would the, the
- 1:26:49thing I always remember is said, you know, talking to advisor,
- 1:26:52what, what price does your client deserve Bitcoin?
- 1:26:55Yeah, Mr. Advisor. It kind of just like stops
- 1:26:57people dead in their tracks thinking about this.
- 1:27:00Yeah, I mean, it's, I say that all the time is like, you know,
- 1:27:05in Bitcoin we always say what everybody gets Bitcoin at the
- 1:27:08prices they deserve. What price do your clients
- 1:27:11deserve? I mean, answer that.
- 1:27:13I mean, it's, it's not rhetorical.
- 1:27:15I, I want you to tell me, want you to tell me that you got, you
- 1:27:19know, get off 0 get off 0 and you know, that's, that's the
- 1:27:27beautiful thing. But then you know, to the point
- 1:27:29of why we're all here. Once you do make sure that you
- 1:27:33don't that your diligence doesn't stop there, there.
- 1:27:36You've got to secure it because the biggest risk to Bitcoin once
- 1:27:40you're in it is the loss of it. Yeah, well said.
- 1:27:46Well, I know we're up on time, but Rich, really appreciate you
- 1:27:51coming on. I feel like the last 10 minutes
- 1:27:53or so of this conversation is just a preview of what you and
- 1:27:56Mark are covering on the wake up call.
- 1:27:58So for folks that are interested in this angle as it relates to
- 1:28:01Bitcoin adoption in the wealth management industry, be sure to
- 1:28:04check that one out. And then, of course, you can
- 1:28:07reach out to any four of us on this call directly on e-mail or
- 1:28:11through our website or over LinkedIn or social.
- 1:28:13Happy to get in touch, have a conversation.
- 1:28:16And then I want to give one final plug as well.
- 1:28:18We have a webinar on Tuesday, September 17th, so less than a
- 1:28:24week away. The details for that will be in
- 1:28:27the show notes. Today we'll be discussing the
- 1:28:30report that we recently published the evolution of
- 1:28:32Bitcoin custody touched on some of the themes here today, but
- 1:28:36I'd imagine we'll go even deeper.
- 1:28:37And then one of the benefits of joining that as well as we'll
- 1:28:40have a lot of time allotted to AQ and A at the end of the
- 1:28:43session. So for those of you who are
- 1:28:45listening to the podcast or following us along and have
- 1:28:49questions or concerns and, and want to air those out and, and
- 1:28:52get the team's feedback, be sure to join that one.
- 1:28:54It'll be a good session. So Rich, Jesse, Michael, good to
- 1:28:59see you all. Thanks for the time today and
- 1:29:02thanks everyone for joining and listening along today.
- 1:29:05Thanks, Rich. Thanks guys.
- 1:29:07Great to be with you. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:29:09week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:29:11valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:29:14rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:29:16All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:29:18notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:29:21reminder that On Rat Media is for informational and
- 1:29:23entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:29:26investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:29:29your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:29:32Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:29:36one of our private client advisors.