Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / How Marketplaces Keep Liquidity When Supply Shocks Hit
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, imagine you run a marketplace and overnight, fifteen percent of your supply vanishes. Not because of churn, not because of seasonality—something structural, like a regulatory ban in a key city or a supplier going bankrupt. Luna: That's the nightmare scenario. Every marketplace lives or dies by liquidity, and a supply shock is the fastest way to kill it. Lucas: Right. And there's a playbook for this. We saw it in 2020 with Airbnb—overnight, international travel died. But they didn't just sit there. They pivoted the entire product to local stays, and within weeks, listings within driving distance were all that mattered. Luna: And that kept both sides alive. Hosts still had some demand, and guests still had a reason to open the app. Lucas: Exactly. But that was a massive company with engineering resources. What about a smaller marketplace? Say you're running a platform for local tour guides, and a new city ordinance requires licenses that half your guides don't have. Luna: Okay, that's a real supply shock. What do you do? Lucas: First thing you do is you get on the demand side. You don't just sit and hope. You tell your demand side, 'Hey, we have fewer options right now, but here's what we do have.' And you might even use a waitlist—like Zillow does with rentals when a market gets tight. Luna: A waitlist? That's interesting. Because it signals scarcity, which can actually increase demand. Lucas: It's a classic tactic. And it buys you time to fix the supply side. But here's the thing—if you're transparent about why supply is thin, users often stick around. That's the trust factor. Luna: So communication is the first line of defense? Lucas: It's the cheapest one, at least. But there's a more aggressive lever: you can raise your take rate temporarily. Look, if demand stays high and supply drops, the remaining suppliers have more pricing power. So you can take a bigger cut without them leaving, because they're making more per transaction anyway. Luna: That feels like a risky move. You're literally charging more when your service is worse. Lucas: It is risky. But it's a real strategy. I've seen marketplaces do this in verticals like freight and trucking during capacity crunches. The key is to frame it as a temporary measure and be transparent about it. If you're opaque, you burn trust. Luna: And if that backfires, you've now got both a supply and a demand problem. Lucas: Which is why the best play is to avoid the shock altogether. That means diversifying your supply base. Don't rely on one city, one category, one big supplier. Airbnb learned that the hard way—when a city like Barcelona tightened rules, they leaned into other regions. Luna: But isn't there a tension there? Marketplaces often win by focusing on a narrow vertical first. Lucas: Sure, and that's the chicken and egg problem we've talked about before. But even within a narrow vertical, you can diversify geographically. A marketplace for freelance designers can have clients in different industries, not just one tech hub. Luna: So it's about building a resilient supply base from day one. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a lesson that applies beyond marketplaces. Whether you're building a platform or just managing a supply chain, you want to avoid single points of failure. Luna: You know, this kind of resilience is what keeps me listening to shows like this. It's practical, and it makes you think about your own business, even if you're not in a marketplace. Lucas: Glad you said that. And it's actually something we hear from listeners a lot—that these conversations help them think about their own operations. If that's you, and you're in a position to support the show, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a simple way to keep the show ad-free and independent. Luna: Yeah, every little bit helps. And we genuinely appreciate it. Lucas: So back to the playbook. Another tactic is to subsidize the supply side temporarily. You can offer incentives to new suppliers to join during the crunch, maybe a reduced commission for the first three months. Luna: That's like a sign-up bonus, but for the supply side. Lucas: Right. Uber did that when they entered new cities—they guaranteed drivers a minimum hourly rate. It's a way to jumpstart supply when you know demand is there. Luna: But that costs money. Where does that come from? Lucas: Often from venture capital, especially if you're in growth mode. But even profitable marketplaces can use a slice of their take rate to fund these incentives. It's a short-term hit for long-term liquidity. Luna: And if you don't have that cash? What's the move? Lucas: You get creative. You might partner with a complementary business to cross-promote. Or you might relaunch a feature that you'd shelved. The point is, you have to be proactive, not reactive. Luna: So it's about having a plan before the shock hits. Lucas: That's the real lesson. Most marketplaces don't have a crisis playbook for liquidity. They think it'll never happen to them. But it will. And the ones that survive are the ones that have thought through 'What if we lose half our supply in a month?' Luna: Have you seen any smaller marketplaces that did this really well? Lucas: There's a niche marketplace for vintage camera gear—they had a supplier who was a major source of rare lenses, and he passed away. They lost maybe thirty percent of their inventory overnight. They sent a heartfelt email to their buyers, explaining the situation and saying they were working to bring on new dealers. They also curated a waitlist for the most sought-after lenses. The community actually rallied around them. Luna: That's the trust angle again. They were honest, and their customers stuck with them. Lucas: And they used that time to onboard five new dealers who were previously on the fence. Within six months, their inventory was back above pre-shock levels. Luna: So it's not just about surviving the shock—it's about coming out stronger. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the difference between a marketplace that treats liquidity as a numbers game and one that treats it as a relationship game. The latter builds a moat. Luna: That's a great way to put it. So, if you're running a marketplace, what's the one thing you should do today to prepare for a shock? Lucas: Start tracking your supplier concentration. If any single supplier—or any single geographic region—accounts for more than, say, twenty percent of your supply, that's a red flag. Diversify before you need to. Luna: Sound advice. And I'd add: make sure you have a crisis communication template ready. You don't want to be writing that email in a panic. Lucas: Exactly. Preparation is everything. And on that note, that's a wrap for today. We'll be back tomorrow with another deep dive into the business of two-sided networks.