Latest / 7 Minute Books: Free Book Summaries / Girl on Girl by Sophie Gilbert - Book Summary

Transcript

Girl on Girl by Sophie Gilbert - Book Summary · 7 Minute Books: Free Book Summaries

• 0:01
  Sam: Hey, welcome to 7 Minute Books. I'm Sam, and today we're talking about Girl on Girl by Sophie Gilbert, a book that takes the idea of the female gaze and complicates it in the best way. Sophie, I have to ask, did this book make you look at your own Instagram feed differently?
• 0:19
  Sophie: Hey there Sam, thanks for having me. Absolutely, it did. Gilbert's whole point is that the female gaze isn't some pure, innocent alternative to the male gaze. It's a conflicted gaze, full of identification and objectification at the same time. She digs into art, film, fashion, and social media to show how women looking at women is never a simple act of solidarity. It's shaped by all the same pressures and anxieties we're trying to escape.
• 0:50
  Sam: So she's pushing back on the idea that if a woman takes the photo, it's automatically feminist?
• 0:56
  Sophie: Exactly. She starts with Laura Mulvey's theory of the male gaze from the 1970s, but then says the female gaze isn't just a mirror image. It's a battlefield. When a woman photographs or paints another woman, she's wrestling with her own internalized patriarchy, her own desires, her own anxieties about aging and beauty and power.
• 1:20
  Sam: That's a lot. I mean, it makes sense, but it's uncomfortable. So even a woman behind the camera can be objectifying?
• 1:28
  Sophie: Yes, and she doesn't let anyone off the hook. The book is structured as a series of case studies, from 19th-century painters to Instagram aesthetics. She's not interested in heroes or villains. She wants to show how complicated it all is.
• 1:43
  Sam: Okay, let's talk about the selfie. Because that's the one that hits closest to home. Is the selfie a feminist act or not?
• 1:51
  Sophie: Gilbert says it's both. On one hand, it's a tool for self-definition and community building. But on the other, it's often a performance of desirability for an imagined audience whose standards are still dictated by patriarchy and capitalism. The endless cycle of posting and comparing becomes a new form of labor, a way of policing yourself against the very standards you might reject.
• 2:16
  Sam: So it's like you're trying to be free, but you're also keeping score.
• 2:20
  Sophie: Exactly. The female gaze turned inward can become self-surveillance. You're constantly checking yourself, curating yourself, and it's exhausting.
• 2:30
  Sam: And then she goes into fine art, right? She talks about Nan Goldin. I remember her photos of friends in really raw moments. Did Gilbert think that was a purer gaze?
• 2:41
  Sophie: She praises Goldin's honesty and vulnerability, but she also asks whether Goldin is exploiting her subjects' pain for artistic capital. There's this tension between bearing witness and voyeurism. Even when a woman is trying to show reality, there's a power dynamic. The photographer is still the one holding the camera.
• 3:01
  Sam: That's a tough one. Because you want to celebrate that kind of honesty, but then you wonder about the ethics.
• 3:07
  Sophie: Right, and Gilbert doesn't give an easy answer. She just holds that tension up for us to see.
• 3:14
  Sam: What about the section on queer desire? I feel like that's where she finds some hope.
• 3:19
  Sophie: Yes, she critiques how lesbian or bisexual desire is often commodified for a male audience, reduced to a spectacle. But then she looks at queer female artists who are creating a visual language for authentic desire, one that's about mutual recognition rather than possession. That's where she sees real potential.
• 3:40
  Sam: And then there's film. She talks about Sofia Coppola, Kathryn Bigelow, and Céline Sciamma's Portrait of a Lady on Fire. I've seen that movie, and it's so much about the act of looking.
• 3:52
  Sophie: Gilbert calls it a masterclass in the radical potential of the female gaze. In that film, looking is reciprocal and equal. It's about understanding and connecting, not taking. But she's careful not to romanticize it. She also points out that even female directors can have a cruel gaze, like in mean girl movies where the camera lingers on flaws in a punishing way.
• 4:17
  Sam: So the female gaze can be just as judgmental as the male gaze?
• 4:23
  Sophie: Absolutely. It's not inherently kinder or more righteous. It's shaped by the same social pressures and insecurities. Women aren't a monolith.
• 4:33
  Sam: That's a really important point. I think we often want to believe that women would do it better, but that's not necessarily true.
• 4:41
  Sophie: And that's what makes the book so sharp. It refuses to offer a utopian alternative.
• 4:47
  Sam: She also goes after the beauty industry, right? The way it co-opts empowerment language to sell products.
• 4:54
  Sophie: Yes, she argues that the beauty industry has become a master manipulator of the female gaze. The before and after photos, the tutorials, the skincare routines, they're framed as self-love, but they're actually a new form of discipline. They train women to constantly scrutinize and improve themselves. The goal is to make you feel perpetually inadequate so you keep consuming.
• 5:19
  Sam: So the female gaze becomes an internal critic that never shuts up.
• 5:24
  Sophie: Exactly. And it's dressed up as empowerment. That's the insidious part.
• 5:29
  Sam: What about fashion? She talks about supermodels and body positivity.
• 5:34
  Sophie: She traces how models like Linda Evangelista and Naomi Campbell projected attitude and power, but were still trapped in a visual language of male desire. And more recently, the push for body positivity and diversity is welcome, but it can also become another form of commodification. Brands signal virtue while still profiting from insecurity. The gaze directed at the imperfect body can be just as judgmental, only now it's disguised as progress.
• 6:04
  Sam: So even the celebration of real bodies can be a trap?
• 6:08
  Sophie: It can be, if it's just another way to sell something. Gilbert is not saying it's all bad, but she wants us to be critical.
• 6:16
  Sam: That's a lot to take in. So what's the takeaway? Is there any hope?
• 6:20
  Sophie: Gilbert ends with a cautious hope. She says the first step is acknowledging that we're all complicit. We've all internalized the male gaze. The task is to become conscious of it, to question our own visual instincts, and to look for alternatives. And she warns about AI and deepfakes, saying we need critical visual literacy more than ever.
• 6:43
  Sam: So it's not about finding a perfect gaze, but about being aware of the mess.
• 6:48
  Sophie: Exactly. The female gaze is a struggle, a constant negotiation. It's not comfortable, but it's necessary.
• 6:57
  Sam: I think the one thing I'm taking away is that the enemy isn't just the male director or photographer. It's the invisible patterns of seeing that we all carry inside us. That's a tough pill to swallow, but it's liberating too, because it means we can change.
• 7:14
  Sophie: And if you want to go deeper, the whole library is over at 7minutebooks.com/app, with over 6,000 fiction and nonfiction titles you can read or listen to in any language. It starts at $2.99 a month, $9.99 a year, or $19.99 once for lifetime access.
• 7:36
  Sophie: Girl on Girl is ultimately a mirror held up to the female viewer, asking us to examine not just what we see, but how we see and why. We'll see you in the next one.