Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️115 | | Climate Change, Political Power and the Price of Security|
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: I've been reading a report this week that has left me with an uncomfortable thought. We may be approaching a time when the most important thing a politician can offer us isn't prosperity or growth or another ambitious programme for economic development? It may be protection, protection from
- 0:29things we spent most of our lives taking for granted, like being able to ensure our homes, afford our food, rely on a water supply, or assume that the roads and the bridges we use every day will still be there after a spell of particularly bad weather. And before anyone imagines I've been reading some
- 0:52gloomy prediction about the end of civilization, the report is actually about politics. It's called Climate Popularism, published in October 2026 by Climate Majority Project, and it examines how climate disruption could transform what people expect from their governments. And you can download it in the
- 1:14link in the show notes. I've started reading it, and I found myself becoming increasingly interested because the authors aren't particularly concerned with persuading people to become environmentalists; they're interested in something much more immediate. What happens to politics when people begin to
- 1:33feel that the basic conditions of their lives are becoming less secure? And what happens when governments fail to recognise that insecurity until it's already causing serious damage, one of the central arguments in the report is that people are now experiencing the global disruption of climate change in
- 1:55their everyday lives, at the supermarket, at the petrol pump, through household bills, and the cost of keeping a roof over their heads. Climate change is becoming increasingly entangled with all of those things. Take food, for instance. We live in a country where most of us can walk into a supermarket and
- 2:17expect the shelves to be full. There might be the occasional shortage, or a price increase that makes us wince, but the basic system generally works. Yet our food supplies depend on a vast network of farms, transport systems, energy supplies, and international trade. A failed harvest in one
- 2:39part of the world can affect prices somewhere else. Severe droughts, flooding, and extreme heat can disrupt production across several regions, and those pressures work their way through the supply chains until they arrive on our kitchen tables. Climate change is one of the forces increasing those
- 3:02risks, and it's worth remembering that we don't have to experience a climate disaster in Northern Ireland to feel its economic consequences. The same applies to energy. We saw during the energy crisis how quickly events elsewhere could transform the cost of heating a home here. Now add the growing demands that
- 3:25extreme weather places on electricity networks, buildings, and infrastructure, alongside the enormous investment needed to make energy systems more dependable and less carbon intensive. For someone with a comfortable income, higher bills may just be an irritation. For someone already choosing between
- 3:46heating and other essentials, they can be devastating. And then there's insurance. I think insurance is one of those subjects that rarely attracts much attention until somebody discovers they can't get it. As flood risks increase, insurers may raise premiums, impose exclusions, or become unwilling
- 4:08to cover certain properties. The consequences go well beyond an expensive annual renewal. A home that becomes difficult to insure can become difficult to mortgage, difficult to sell, and for the family living in it, a source of constant anxiety. You could have worked all your life, paid off your mortgage, and done
- 4:31everything you were supposed to do, only to find that changing environmental conditions have undermined the security you thought you'd achieved. There's a particular cruel unfairness in that, and it's one of the reasons I find this report so thought-provoking, because climate change is often
- 4:51discussed as though we're all going to experience the same problem. We're not. The report warns about a future in which the protection from. Of disruption becomes increasingly unequal. Those with money will generally have more options. They may be able to improve their homes, instal alternative
- 5:12energy systems, pay for expensive insurance, or move away from places becoming more vulnerable. Large businesses may be able to invest in backup supplies, diversify their operations, or absorb additional costs.
- 5:30But think about a family renting a poorly insulated house, an older person living alone on a fixed income, a small farmer trying to cope with increasingly unpredictable weather and waterlogged land, or a rural community where public services are already stretched, transport limited, and essential
- 5:53infrastructure has seen better days. These people can't necessarily buy their way out of trouble, and that brings us to a disturbing possibility: we could find ourselves living in a society where security becomes another privilege that money can purchase, where some communities are well protected against
- 6:14flooding and others are repeatedly left to recover from it, where some households can afford reliable energy and others remain exposed to every price shock. Where those who have contributed least to the climate problem are amongst those least able to protect themselves from its
- 6:32consequences. There is something deeply unjust about that prospect, and the report goes on to explore another danger that deserves particular attention: when people begin to feel that their lives are becoming less secure, when their concerns are repeatedly dismissed, when they struggle to make ends meet and
- 6:55lose confidence that their elective representatives have either the willingness or the ability to improve things, a political vacuum begins to develop, and political vacuums have a habit of attracting some fairly unpleasant characters. The report examines how right-wing populist movements
- 7:15have been able to exploit precisely these conditions. They recognise that people are angry, frightened, and increasingly disillusioned with conventional politics, and they're very good at turning those feelings into political support. They offer certainty where governments have offered confusion. They promise
- 7:36protection where people have experienced neglect. They give frustrated communities someone to blame, and before long, the conversation has shifted away from the failures that created the insecurity in the first place. The problems become immigrants, minorities, outsiders, environmental
- 7:56campaigners, or whichever group happens to make the most convenient target. People who might otherwise have common interests find themselves suspicious of one another, while the underlying problems remain largely untouched. We've seen enough the politics of division in Northern Ireland to recognise
- 8:16how damaging that can be, and I think it would be a serious mistake to imagine that we're somehow immune to newer forms of it. The report argues that dismissing people who are drawn towards populist movements is no answer either. People who feel abandoned by politics don't suddenly become less angry
- 8:37because somebody tells them they voted for the wrong people. Their concerns about housing, employment, rising costs, and the future of their communities may be entirely legitimate. The danger comes when those genuine concerns are exploited by people offering easy answers and encouraging resentment towards
- 8:58others, and as climate disruption places increasing pressure on food supplies, household finances, public services, and infrastructure, there may be a great deal more security for political opportunists to explore. The authors argue that the answer lies in giving people something
- 9:19to believe in, governments that respond to needs, communities that have meaningful influence over their future, and practical measures that make everyday life more secure. The authors argue that the answer lies in giving people something real to believe in. Governments that respond to their needs, communities that
- 9:40have meaningful influence over their future, and practical measures that make everyday life more secure. Because when people can see that their concerns are being taken seriously, and that working together can actually improve their circumstances, the appeal of those who thrive on fear. Division will begin to
- 10:01weaken, and that's a lesson our own political representatives would do well to consider. For as long as I can remember, politicians have been promising us economic growth, more investment, more employment, more development, more opportunities. Every election brings a fresh collection of
- 10:21promises about the prosperity waiting just around the corner. I often wonder how many corners Northern Ireland has left, but the underlying assumption has remained remarkably consistent: if the economy grows, life will improve. And of course, economic activity matters. People need jobs, businesses need to thrive,
- 10:45and public services need to be funded. But the report made me think about something we don't discuss nearly enough: the difference between being prosperous and being secure. A country can generate substantial economic activity while leaving large numbers of people vulnerable to rising costs,
- 11:04environmental damage, and failing infrastructure, a community can attract investment without necessarily becoming a better or a safer place to live in.
- 11:15And some of the things that contribute most to our security barely register in the conventional calculations of economic success. Necessary things such as a reliable water supply, healthy soil, a functioning river system, a landscape that absorbs and slows rainfall, a community where
- 11:38people know one another well enough to offer help when something goes wrong. We tend to notice these things only when they stop working. Then suddenly they become very expensive indeed. The report gives examples of communities investing in practical climate resilience, including restoring
- 12:00damaged peatlands to improve the condition of upland ecosystems and help manage water. There's something wonderfully revealing about that. For years, peatlands were often treated as unproductive land, something to drain, improve, or put to another use. Now we're spending money repairing them because
- 12:20we've begun to appreciate what they were doing for us, nature has been providing services for centuries without sending anybody an invoice. It's probably only a matter of time before somebody decides to calculate what those services were worth. And once you start looking at the world in those
- 12:39terms, some of our assumptions about economic progress begin to look decidedly shaky. A river that supplies clean water has economic value. A healthy catchment that helps reduce flood risk has economic value. Peatlands that retain carbon and support functioning ecosystems have economic value, but these
- 13:02things also have a value that reaches beyond money, and we should be wary of pretending that every loss can be neatly converted into pounds and pence. The point is that our existing natural systems are becoming increasingly important to our future security, and decisions affecting them need to be made
- 13:25with that future in mind. Now you may be wondering where all this leaves the proposed gold mine in The Sperrins. Well, I've been thinking about that too, as you might imagine, because after months of listening to evidence at the Coronel public inquiry, I've become very familiar with the way major industrial
- 13:43developments are presented. The proposed economic benefits are set out, and the potential environmental consequences are examined through a formidable collection of reports. The applicant argues that the development can proceed with appropriate safeguards. Those challenging the proposal have
- 14:07spent months testing the evidence behind the confidence. But reading climate popularism has made me think about the economic assumptions that sit around the entire discussion. We're entering a period now when water security, healthy ecosystems, and the capacity of communities to withstand climate
- 14:28disruption are becoming increasingly valuable. And yet, we still tend to approach industrial investment using a framework that gives immediate economic activity a very prominent place in the conversation. The long-term value of what may be affected is much more difficult to express.
- 14:49That doesn't automatically settle the argument about the mine, but it changes the context in which the argument takes place. And there's another dimension: when the public inquiry resumes. The final sessions will examine climate change and greenhouse gas emissions associated with the
- 15:05proposed development. Delray's revised assessment forecasts approximately 305,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent over the assessed life of the project. Most of those emissions fall within what's called Scope Three, meaning they arise through activities associated with the wider supply chain,
- 15:26including activities beyond the mine site and outside of Northern Ireland. The applicant has proposed measures to reduce emissions and a carbon neutrality approach, and those proposals will be examined as part of the climate evidence. But the important thing for this discussion is that emissions
- 15:43contribute to a global problem, regardless of where they occur. Carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere doesn't become someone else's responsibility because it was emitted beyond our borders. And while the contribution of one mine is small compared with worldwide emissions, the global total is
- 16:02the accumulation of countless individual activities and decisions. The report is very clear that preparing for the consequences of climate change cannot become an excuse for abandoning efforts to prevent further warming. We have to reduce the causes of the problem while preparing for the
- 16:21consequences already coming our way, I think that's a useful principle to carry into the final climate hearings, because the economic benefit of a proposed development need to be considered in a world where greenhouse gas emissions carry consequences, and where protecting the natural systems
- 16:40that help communities adapt is becoming increasingly important. The world in which these decisions are being made is changing.
- 16:48Our understanding of what constitutes responsible development needs to change along with it. And there is another idea in the report that I found unexpectedly encouraging. It concerns the importance of belonging. The authors argue that people need more than promises from
- 17:07politicians; they need to feel that they have some influence over the conditions of their lives and that they belong to communities capable of acting together. They suggest that practical local action can help rebuild the trust and sense of purpose that have been weakened in many places, and that brought
- 17:26a smile to my face, because whatever else that might be said about the campaign to protect The Sperrins, it has certainly brought together an extraordinary assortment of people, people who would never otherwise have met, people with very different backgrounds, occupations, experiences, and
- 17:45political views. Some arriving with detailed knowledge of the environment, others came because they were worried about what might happen near their homes, and most of us had no idea what we were getting ourselves into. Like me, they didn't expect to spend years becoming acquainted with mined waste facilities,
- 18:03groundwater modelling, and the finer points of environmental legislation. Believe me, there are a lot easier hobbies to while away your time with. But something happens when people begin working together to protect the place we care about. We learn from one another. We discover skills we didn't know
- 18:21we possessed. We become more confident by challenging information and asking difficult questions, and we begin to recognise that we have a collective voice. That doesn't mean everybody agrees about everything. Anyone who has ever been involved in community will know that agreement is not
- 18:38always its most abundant resource. But people can find common purpose despite their differences, and that alone is a cause for celebration. Interestingly, one of the dangers identified in the report is that insecurity can drive people apart, making them suspicious of one another and
- 18:58more vulnerable to divisive political messages. The alternative is to build communities that are capable of cooperation, mutual support, and practical action. We've seen evidence of that already in The Sperrins. I suspect we'll need a great deal more of it in the years ahead. I want to return to
- 19:18the political implications of the report. The authors argue that protecting people from climate disruption will increasingly become a measure of political competence. That's quite a statement. For generations, governments have been judged largely by their ability to deliver economic
- 19:36growth, employment, public services, and Financial stability; those responsibilities will remain, but climate change is adding another dimension. Governments will have to demonstrate that they can protect the basic systems on which everyday life depends: food, water, energy,
- 19:59housing. Transport and health, and the natural environment that supports them all. And in Northern Ireland, where government departments have developed something of a talent for operating within their own little silos, this presents a particular challenge. Climate change has no respect for
- 20:19departmental boundaries. It already affects agriculture, health, infrastructure, planning, and the economy, and does not care whether departments responsible for those areas are talking to one another or not. We can produce all the individual strategies we like, but unless somebody is
- 20:39prepared to join the dots and make sure those policies actually influence decisions across government. We'll end up with a fine collection of documents and precious little joined-up thinking. We already have a climate legislation and environmental commitments. What we need to discover is how
- 20:57seriously those commitments influence decisions across government. There is a world of difference between acknowledging a problem and organising a public policy around dealing with it. Returning once more to the report, it also makes an uncomfortable observation about political leaders who fail to
- 21:15respond to changing circumstances. They risk becoming irrelevant. I wouldn't go quite that far in predicting the fate of our own politicians. Northern Ireland has demonstrated an impressive ability to preserve familiar political arrangements through circumstances that might have
- 21:33finished them off elsewhere. But I know the expectation of voters will change, particularly younger folk who are very well aware of how climate change is impacting their immediate future, and who feel utterly disempowered due to traditional style politics.
- 21:48A politician who can deliver a new development or announce an investment may find that people are increasingly interested in the security of their homes, the reliability of essential services, and the ability of their communities to cope with disruption, and those are issues that cannot be addressed through
- 22:05announcements alone. They require preparation, investment, and the willingness to make decisions whose benefits may not become obvious until years later, which is an awkward proposition for a political system accustomed to measuring success in election cycles. I would encourage our elected
- 22:23representatives to read climate populism. They may disagree with some of its political analysis, particularly the discussion of the Westminster politics. But the central warning deserves attention: the conditions on which people's lives are changing, and political leadership will increasingly be
- 22:43judged by how well governments respond. The ability to anticipate danger and protect communities may become every bit as important as the ability to attract investment, and perhaps that should influence how we think about development today. There's a final thought I want to leave you with. The report
- 23:04describes two broad ways society might respond to the climate disruption ahead. We can wait until events force us into action, spending enormous sums repairing damage, building emergency defences, and trying to keep essential systems functioning. or we can begin preparing now, strengthening
- 23:26communities, reducing emissions, and investing in the things that make us less vulnerable. The difficulty with the second approach is that its success can be almost invisible: a flood that didn't happen, a household that remained warm during an energy crisis, a water supply that continues functioning
- 23:46through difficult circumstances, a community that manages to recover quickly because people have the resources and the relationships they need. There may be no dramatic photographs, no emergency press conference, and no minister standing in front of a newly constructed defence announcing how much
- 24:04money has been spent, just ordinary life continuing, and perhaps that's one of the reasons prevention has never been particularly glamorous politically. It's much easier to take credit for repairing a disaster than for making sure it didn't happen in the first place. But the financial and
- 24:22human costs of waiting could be enormous, and that brings us back to the question of what we value. All of our lives, we have been encouraged to judge progress through the language of investment, development, and economic growth. Yet, as I've already said, next generation may have a rather different set
- 24:41of priorities. They may be interested in whether their homes are still affordable to ensure, whether they can rely on clean water, whether their communities have been protected against increasingly severe weather, whether food and energy remain within reach of ordinary household budgets, and whether
- 24:59the natural. Systems we inherited are still functioning when they need them. They may also look back at the decisions being made now and wonder how much warning we required before we began taking the consequences seriously. I spent much of this year listening to evidence about proposed gold mine in The
- 25:17Sperrins, and I will be back following the final climate sessions, when the public inquiry resumes once more, but reading this report has reminded me that the debate taking place in that hearing room belongs to a much larger conversation about the future of Northern Ireland, and indeed Ireland, a
- 25:37conversation about what makes a community secure, how we measure prosperity and the responsibilities of those who make decisions on our behalf. It's a conversation that is going to become increasingly difficult for politicians to avoid, because when the consequences of climate
- 25:55disruption begin affecting people's homes, their livelihoods, and their families, the public will have little patience for assurances that ever everything has been kept under review. They'll want to know what was done while there was still time to prepare, and I suspect that in the years ahead,
- 26:12political success may come to be measured less by what governments managed to build and more by what they had the foresight to protect. It's a rather different way of looking at progress, and I hope somebody in Stormont is paying attention. Thank you for listening, and we'll see you all again soon.
- 26:31You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Front Line. Thank you for joining us today.
- 26:39All the links you'll need from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about
- 26:56protecting our land and communities, and don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people
- 27:16who protect them.