Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / How The Big Ten Is Punishing Jim Harbaugh For The Michigan Sign-Stealing Scandal
Transcript
- 0:01Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:06here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going, Tony the Great
- 0:16Pumpkins going to get here anytime now, any minute now. It's just about
- 0:23to happen. I can feel it almost. I thought for sure, leaving
- 0:28my house and being completely out of touch with the world for thirty minutes was
- 0:31going to be what triggered the Big Ten to finally make what we have been
- 0:36promised was a early afternoon announcement. And here we are in mid to late
- 0:43afternoon, still a waiting an announcement. So but other than that, a
- 0:51completely productive day on both of our accounts, I assume. Just yeah,
- 0:57I did see, and welcome to everybody who is joining us and will join
- 1:00us. Heather Dinich tweeted at three twelve pm that the Big Ten decision is
- 1:07still expected today, but it's taking longer than expected because of the legality involved
- 1:14in the process and documents. So I don't know. I don't know what
- 1:19today means, if that's end of business, If that's the end of today,
- 1:23like eleven fifty eight, and of course being a Big Ten being in
- 1:30Chicago, they have a false time zone situation there as well, so you
- 1:34know, to add another hour onto that. Who knows when this is going
- 1:38to happen. At this point, Tom, I would just prefer let's just
- 1:42hold off until Monday. Let's just take the weekend and do football and then
- 1:47get back into the office on Monday and hash this thing out. Yeah,
- 1:51and you know, there was a lot of griping about sorry, I'm looking
- 1:57at my phone, which I spent literally the entire day doing, just reflexively
- 2:00refreshing, like, hey, anything new? No, all right, yeah,
- 2:05I mean, as you said, the tweet from Heather Dentage, the
- 2:08big ten decision expected today. I mean, there's been a lot of griping
- 2:15about, you know, how dare you make Jim Harball get on an airplane
- 2:19without knowing what the I mean when exactly, you know, after this season
- 2:27is not an acceptable answer to this question, when exactly would you like these
- 2:30punishment released? Because if it had been released on Thursday, it would have
- 2:34been Well, we sent you twenty pages of documents, much of which we
- 2:38wrote on our own, and then you know you didn't take enough time to
- 2:40review it. So obviously you didn't take this seriously enough so that too soon,
- 2:45and then if it's Friday, it's like, well, he's about to
- 2:47get on an airplane. You can't do this on Friday. And if they
- 2:50wait till Monday, it's going to be how they had one of the biggest
- 2:53games of the year. How could you make them wait in limbo over the
- 2:57weekend. This is totally I mean, there is no time where there will
- 3:00not be a complaint about when this got released. So when this gets released
- 3:04in terms of you know, it's it's not fair, like it's going to
- 3:08get released at some point, like you should have timed your scandal better.
- 3:12I don't know what to tell you, Like that's that is just the reality
- 3:15of the situation. You want the Big ten to be meticulous on this.
- 3:19You want the Big ten to be thorough on this. If the Big you
- 3:22know, if Michigan slapped their response on the table, having taken basically the
- 3:25full forty eight hours, it's worth noting if we're worried about how late in
- 3:29the week this got. When Michigan slapped their thing on the table, the
- 3:31Big Ten came back five minutes later and said, here's the punishment. I
- 3:35don't think that would have gone over well, you want the Big Ten to
- 3:38consider the legal arguments that are being made and then make a thoughtful response and
- 3:44a levying of whatever punishment there is or isn't that that seems like, you
- 3:50know, for such big fans of due process, it feels like odd to
- 3:53be like, well, hurry up. Like I know why we're saying hurry
- 3:55up, but I you know, it doesn't really seem like that's consistent with
- 4:00the newfound love of due process. Yeah, what is the proper time frame?
- 4:06And if it's next week, then all you know, you're just letting
- 4:11this drag out and you're letting everybody just float in the wind. We need
- 4:13something now, but so soon. But then you're also seeing the you can't
- 4:18punish the players, you can't punish the coaches, you can't punish I don't
- 4:24know who is supposed to be punished in this thing that the Big ten believes
- 4:28Michigan did wrong. Like, how do you punish somebody and punish nobody and
- 4:32make everybody feel good about it and it's not going to happen. I saw
- 4:36Desmond Howard this morning talking about how the SEC would never do this to Nick
- 4:41Saban, and I was wondering, when did when did Jim Harball become in
- 4:48the same con get into the same conversation as Nick Saban and and what an
- 4:53entity would or wouldn't do to protect him, Because last time I looked,
- 4:58there's Nick Saban, there's everybody else, There's a bunch more people, and
- 5:01then there's Jim Harbaugh and jimbo Fisher has a national championship. Jim Harbaugh is
- 5:06waiting for his first. So like, there are levels to these coaches.
- 5:12And I don't even know time at this point how many car dealerships Jim Harbaugh
- 5:15has. If it's none, then he I don't even know what he's doing
- 5:18in this discussion. Yeah, if you missed it, Nick Saban and his
- 5:25I don't know business group bought to I think Mercedes Benz dealerships for like three
- 5:30hundred million dollars earlier in the week. So Nick Saban's doing just fine.
- 5:34It does the idea that Michigan is going to go to the SEC, which
- 5:41is somewhat related to the SEC. We never do this to Nick Saban.
- 5:46You have seen that floated from people who are not like thirteen follower egg Avatar,
- 5:53Twitter, people like actual people who are you know, have some kind
- 5:57of a following and talk to occasionally people who are affiliated with the university.
- 6:04The idea that Michigan is going to get so big mad over whatever happens here
- 6:10that they're going to go to the SEC is quite literally the dumbest thing I
- 6:14have ever heard in my entire life. That is a decision that gets made
- 6:17at the university president level. And I know Santa Onno wrote a big mad
- 6:21letter on last Thursday or Friday or whatever that then came out three days later,
- 6:27and everyone misinterpreted the timing of they are not leaving for the SEC.
- 6:32No university in the entire nation, outside of maybe the IVY League has spent
- 6:38more of the last thirty years hot boxing its own farts and sniffing them gloriously
- 6:43than the University of Michigan. They cannot wait to tell you how they are
- 6:46the Harvard of the West. And you know, as James Earl Jones in
- 6:50tones in the pregame video that they play, this is the greatest university in
- 6:54the world. You think they want to be in a conference with Mississippi State?
- 6:58Are you kidding me? Are you nuts? Like if you are a
- 7:01parent and your children have reached the age of three, you recognize this behavior.
- 7:08They are throwing themselves on the ground and throwing a big old tampera chare
- 7:11because they are so mad and they're gonna show you, and they're gonna kick,
- 7:14and they're gonna punch, and they're gonna be so mad. When I
- 7:17was a kid, my younger brother would get mad and threaten to run away
- 7:21from home, and then he would go hide under the dining room table,
- 7:25and then you know, we would all pretend, oh where is he?
- 7:29Who? Where could he be? Man? He really did at this time.
- 7:31That's this Michigan's gonna run away from home. They're gonna go hide under
- 7:34the Big ten's dining room table. Because this is a university that fancies itself
- 7:40to be the you know, one of the elite elite, and is a
- 7:44very highly regarded university nationally, one of the top public universities in the country.
- 7:48Take twelve seconds to scroll through the US News and World Report list of
- 7:53top public universities and tell me which neighborhood Michigan wants to be living in.
- 7:57Let alone the fact that, hey, the South is pretty far away,
- 8:01but also what neighborhood do you want to be in? The one with that's
- 8:05adding UCLA and you know USC and you know already has a bunch of the
- 8:13top public universities, or do you want to be in the league with Mississippi
- 8:16State and LSU, And I mean, like, come on, that's setting
- 8:22aside, of course, Tony, the fact that the TV deal doesn't expire
- 8:26till twenty thirty, and I think the temper chan I don't know how long
- 8:30this temper tantrum is going to last, but I have never seen one last
- 8:33six and a half years. So if you're going to leave before twenty thirty,
- 8:37you're going to lose all your TV money, which I'm sure they would
- 8:41love to do, leave that all behind. And you know, in addition
- 8:45to all the other reasons I previously listed, like literally literally the stupidest idea
- 8:50I have ever heard in my life. Yeah, and you have a for
- 8:54many, many years and decades, we've heard about how Michigan is more than
- 8:58just football, and then this would be an entire football decision. You're just
- 9:01going to pick up and leave and find new research partners and all kinds of
- 9:07things like that. So no, that is not going to happen to anybody
- 9:09who says that any in ms in terms of suggesting that is being being childish
- 9:18childlike, more childish than childlike, because not all children are childish. Question
- 9:22from Jordan Kapler. If you were Tony Patiti Big ten commissioner, what penalties
- 9:26are sanctions would you bring down on the true culprit of all this Kevin Noon,
- 9:31Well, I think you have to. Obviously there's a suspension going on.
- 9:39You vacate all of his wins from the past as well, anytime Kevin
- 9:43is won, vacate that, take that strike from the record. Do you
- 9:50you need a show cause Kevin needs to show cost for any time he wants
- 9:52to come back onto the show, I think, and I'm not sure that
- 9:58he's got enough. No, I've got there to prove his worth in terms
- 10:03of having the showing the cause if you will. Yeah, a literal show
- 10:07cause that he must have cause to appear on the show. Yes, I
- 10:11like that. Texas or Busted Boyd. Everyone has been wearing out their F
- 10:13five keys today, that is it has It has been a day of just
- 10:18people looking at their screens and just hitting the refresh button over and over and
- 10:24over and over again, waiting. You know, I have not seen this.
- 10:26Have you seen Jason said that Greg Doyle has a CBS from CBS as
- 10:31a story at that the NCUBA investigation has been expedited and due to be finished
- 10:35this fall. I'm going to guess, without having seen that, I am
- 10:39going to guess that that would be the investigation. It must be the investigation
- 10:43into the previous stuff, the stuff that he sat three games for at the
- 10:46beginning of the season. Because under the NCAA's bylaws they knew investigation into the
- 10:54the whole Connor Stallion's situation, they have to issue a notice avoue gations to
- 11:00Michigan, which I don't believe they have done the NCAA, and then Michigan
- 11:03gets ninety days. So there's no way that that one could be expedited and
- 11:09be done this fall. That's not realistic. It's possible that the other one
- 11:15could be the previous one, but that's you know, it's not possible for
- 11:20them to. I mean, we know what fans of due process and procedure
- 11:22Michigan lawyers are, so I don't think they're going to be able to do
- 11:26that. Super chat from Mike Smith, which I need to find here.
- 11:30This is Kevin absolutely killing me by not being here super chat for Mike Smith.
- 11:33Can someone answer me a question I can't get an answer to. If
- 11:35Michigan has this dossier with twenty years of dirt on Ohio State and the rest
- 11:39of the Big Ten, why hold onto it now? Why not turn it
- 11:41in when they were average? Tom, That's an interesting question. I've already
- 11:48asked. Why didn't they turn it in when they were getting as part of
- 11:52their defense for all of this? Why hold back? If you're holding stuff
- 11:58back on people rather than turning them in in real time, it's you're holding
- 12:03it back in case somebody ever gets something on you, I guess. And
- 12:07then now we can fight fire with fire, which then implies that you're doing
- 12:11things you shouldn't be doing. And hey, if we get caught for this,
- 12:15then we've got some ammo to go after others for and with. So
- 12:20I don't understand holding that back, and if you if you really want to,
- 12:24just because because Jim Harbaugh has hold on people, he has like complaining
- 12:31to the conference before and confronted people before and did it in the PAC twelve.
- 12:35Rick new Heizel talked about it when they were back and then when Jim
- 12:39Harbor was at Stanford Rick new Heizel was either UCLA or Washington, probably UCLA,
- 12:46and they had one of their coach's calls and Jim Harbaugh confronted him like
- 12:50over the call about something or other, and then he had another complaint about
- 12:56the number of refs that were going to USC get us he practices, and
- 13:00it was more than that they were going to Stanford's practices and that was giving
- 13:03USC an unfair advantage, to which Pete Carroll had to break in and say,
- 13:07Jim, we're the most penalized program into PAC twelve. There are PAC
- 13:11ten at that point, there is no advantage in having them over. So
- 13:16you know, we obviously know the story, the backstory of the complaining about
- 13:20Ohio State having a illegal coaching back in twenty twenty. So he's he's they've
- 13:26thrown out accusations before, but holding onto stuff like this it is interesting for
- 13:33a rainy day, fun type of thing. But I'm saying, if you
- 13:37are fighting for your life, and it sure seems like that's a little bit
- 13:41of what Michigan has been doing, you're not going to hold this stuff until
- 13:45after the fact. You're like, okay, if you if you give us
- 13:48hand us something down that we don't like. Then we are really going to
- 13:52give you some information that you would like about everybody else. It's like,
- 13:56well, give it to us now, the old give it to us now,
- 13:58We'll take it. We'll do what we can with it. We would
- 14:01appreciate your help. We thank you. If you see something, say something
- 14:05that sort of thing, please give us all of your Manila folders and we
- 14:09will look into it. NBA fans, the weight is over. Basketball is
- 14:13back. In DraftKings sports Book, an official sports betting partner of the NBA,
- 14:16is celebrating with an unbeatable offer. New customers can score two hundred dollars
- 14:20instantly in bonus bets. We're throwing down five dollars on the NBA. Win
- 14:22or lose, it doesn't matter. You'll start the season with an instant dub.
- 14:24And with DraftKings parlays, everyone's got a shot at even bigger basketball wins.
- 14:28String together multiple bets from the same game, or build your parlay across
- 14:31multiple games for a shot at making your payday even sweeter. Basketball is more
- 14:33fun when you're in on the action. Download the DraftKings Sportsbook app now and
- 14:35use code huddle up. New customers can get two hundred dollars and bonus bets
- 14:39instantly for betting just five dollars only on Draft Kings sports Book with codehuddle up
- 14:41the Crown is yours. Gambling problem called one hundred gambler or visit www dot
- 14:46twenty hundred gambler dot net, New York Call eight seven seven eight hope and
- 14:48why, or text hope and why. In Connecticut, help is available for
- 14:52problem gambling. Call eight A eight seven eight ninety seven seven seven seven or
- 14:54visit CCPG dot org. Please play responsibly on behalf of boot Heel Casino and
- 14:58Resort, Kansas license partner Golden Nuggetlake, Charles, Louisiana twenty one. Over
- 15:01Age varies by juristiction in Ontario Honest That's expire one hundred and sixty eight hours
- 15:05after issuance. See sportsbook dot draft Kings dot com, slash basketball terms for
- 15:09eligibility and deposit restrictions, terms and responsible gaming resources. Speaking of things that
- 15:16we're going to be looking into. Tony tweet from Pete Thamil thank you to
- 15:18the folks in the in the in the chat for bringing this to our attention.
- 15:22Tony. We have some actual honesty goodness, breaking news. I'm gonna
- 15:26have to change the podcast alert a level to red because this feels significant.
- 15:31From Pete Thamil sources, the Big Ten is expected to discipline Michigan for the
- 15:37in for the in the in person scouting Pete needs an editor and ongoing sign
- 15:41stealing investigation, and will prohibit Jim Harball from being on the sideline until the
- 15:46clusion conclusion of the regular season. He will be allowed to coach during the
- 15:50week. So that from Pete Thamil of ESPN that you know, the idea
- 15:56of just a fine got floated on when Wednesday night. The idea of a
- 16:03three game suspension, which would align with this, got floated earlier in the
- 16:07day. I mean, I guess I have always thought that the just during
- 16:15the game suspension is not really that much of a suspension for a head coach.
- 16:19That's I mean. And this is not me saying like insufficient penalty.
- 16:22This is just me saying like in general, that does not that never strikes
- 16:26me as particularly like egregious penalty to get dumped on you because most of your
- 16:33coaching gets done during the week. During the game, I mean, you
- 16:36have you're managing the clock, and that kind of stuff. You have offensive
- 16:37coordinators, you get defensive coordinators. You're making some head you know, high
- 16:41level decisions. But they just spent three games doing this, So I don't
- 16:45you know, this is not this is going to get you know, pounded
- 16:49as like this is the most draconian thing ever that the Big Ten has ever
- 16:52done, you know, I mean whatever, I have reached the point where
- 16:57people are yelling and screaming about a you know, fine only on Thursday night.
- 17:00It was like, yeah, I mean whatever, if that's what they
- 17:03feel the evidence means, then that's what the evidence means. This this feels
- 17:07like, okay, you know, this is this is not like wildly out
- 17:11of line with what I was thinking they might get. It is beyond the
- 17:15two games. It would be beyond the two games that we've talked about that
- 17:18Tony Petiti can hand down, which once we saw Michigan getting their elbows out
- 17:26and getting ready to fight back with all of the letters and the media throng
- 17:33from the Michigan side in terms of getting out what they wanted, we kind
- 17:37of figured it it felt like more than two games at that point, I'm
- 17:42you know, yeah, whether or not this is harsh enough or not.
- 17:47We know that Michigan has gone three and oh this season already when Jim Harper
- 17:51wasn't on the sidelines. Now that was non conference, very easy opponents to
- 17:56face. Obviously Penn State, Maryland in Ohio State would be much different.
- 18:03But I'm with you, and we talked to Ryan Day and they talk about
- 18:07how all of the work it's done during the week. That's when all of
- 18:11the play calling is essentially done during the week. Things like that, the
- 18:15game planning, and so a head coach is making fourth down decisions, you
- 18:21know, now, let's go for it, No, let's punt, let's
- 18:22you know, things like that, the coordinators are making the call. I
- 18:26feel like a and I've been saying I think most of the day and maybe
- 18:30before that like a more a more powerful or perhaps a more strict punishment would
- 18:38have been. I think the coordinators being suspended for three games, because then
- 18:45you have to scramble a little bit and figure out how you're going to handle
- 18:48this. They've already they've already been without Jim Harbaugh. They know how to
- 18:52handle that. So this to me is it's you know, it's not earth
- 19:00shattering, and that the interesting parts to me is that it goes beyond the
- 19:07two games, and so this is going to create a fight. What is
- 19:11what is Michigan's response the injunction that whole thing, they're a legal response,
- 19:17What does that entail? And how quickly does that get filed? How quickly
- 19:19does this all get processed? And and is he on the sideline tomorrow while
- 19:25they wait for a judge of some sort and then all that legal stuff.
- 19:30How quickly can that be done? Well, I would assume that they have
- 19:34basically I would assume that the attorneys for Michigan and or Jim Harbaugh and or
- 19:40both have basically been in the same three point stance that you and I have
- 19:44been in all day long, waiting for the shooted you know, wait for
- 19:48the gun to go off and then boom, you're out of the blocks and
- 19:51you're going If someone was like sitting in the uh, you know, cafeteria
- 19:56of the whatever courthouse, they're going to file this in all day long,
- 20:00that would not surprise me at all. It is just you know, I
- 20:03mean, I am expecting to see news of a news of some kind of
- 20:07an injunction filed within the next fifteen to thirty minutes and then you know,
- 20:11after that, it's a little bit up in the air because Pete Hamill did
- 20:15reporting earlier in the day where he talked to a retired chief justice from the
- 20:21courthouse where you know, he thought this might get filed, and that was
- 20:26in the something Washingtonawk County Court Circuit Court in ann Arbor, so and he
- 20:34talked to a retired chief justice from there and sort of walked through, you
- 20:38know, what this would all be, what list might all look like,
- 20:41and you know, the arguments that Michigan might lay out, and the arguments
- 20:45that the Big Ten might lay out, and you know where this might all
- 20:48kind of end up. And I posted that I thought that was very interesting.
- 20:53And then Ross Fulton, who is our ex's and o's guru on bucke
- 20:56huddle dot com but who was also a lawyer by profession, said he thought,
- 21:00this is you know, that was kind of all maybe irrelevant because this
- 21:03is all going to end up in federal court anyway, and I don't know
- 21:06if that's end up in federal court immediately, like it would have to go
- 21:10in federal court or it would start in you know, some kind of a
- 21:12local circuit court and then get bumped to you know, the Big ten would
- 21:15take it to a federal court. Ultimately, I can't imagine. I mean,
- 21:21this is the courthouse is I think closed today because of the Veterans Day
- 21:26holiday. I believe I saw that. So then the question is you know
- 21:29that you can you can always find a judge, right, this is you
- 21:32can get anyone who's watched any law and order Tony, uh knows you can
- 21:36find a judge in the middle of the night, you know, on the
- 21:37weekend whatever. They hate to be interrupted on the golf course, Tony,
- 21:41but you can always find a judge. So you know, they go find
- 21:45a judge, you presumably present this your emergency injunction to them, and then
- 21:51the question is, you know, does it get granted. If it gets
- 21:52granted, I assume then that probably means I can't. I doubt they're going
- 21:56to have an emergency hearing on a Friday. I mean it's three forty one
- 22:00pm Eastern right now. I doubt you could get people together for that kind
- 22:06of a hearing on a Friday. So I would assume an emergency injunction means
- 22:11he's probably coaching against Penn State. Assuming the emergency injunction is granted, but
- 22:17this is this is me stacking many many assumptions very tall, and I'm not
- 22:22sure how much that stack is teetering. Back to the Greg Doyle thing that
- 22:27was may have been a confusion there. Dennis Dodd wrote something twenty eight minutes
- 22:33ago saying that the source tells CBS Sports that they're putting the sign stealing investigation
- 22:40on a very fast timeline by the NCAAA. So there is five six more
- 22:47weeks in the fall. So I don't know how that's all going to work.
- 22:51Because you get the notice of allegations, then Michigan has like ninety days
- 22:53to respond, and then the NCAA has like sixty days to deal with that
- 22:57response. So I don't I don't know how you smash all of that together.
- 23:03But maybe maybe the investigation is what is being sped up. And I
- 23:08don't know how much you can speed up the response time that you have put
- 23:14in the rule books, right, You can't. You're not going to if
- 23:18it is like laid out there that this is ninety days. I can't imagine
- 23:22the NCAA is going to try and expedite that and leave themselves open to more
- 23:29litigation potentially. I mean, you're going to probably see a lot of the
- 23:32same arguments that Michigan that the Michigan folks made against the Big ten case if
- 23:37you try and do that. And you know this, the reason that the
- 23:41Big ten is acting right now is because the NCAA can't act by rule.
- 23:45So I just, you know, I'm sure that the case from the NCAA
- 23:51will get fast tracked. It certainly means that, but you know, and
- 23:56as Mike Freno says, presumably they just mean the time to the notice of
- 24:00allegations that that, you know, you could you could get fast tracked to
- 24:03the point where you have a notice of allegations this fall. Sure, I
- 24:07could potentially buy that, but then you got to wait the ninety days.
- 24:11So that's you know, so there just isn't a way to you know,
- 24:17have the NCAA, you know, right right in and solve the problem for
- 24:19everyone this fall. That's that's just not a realistic timeline based on the bylaws
- 24:25that the nc double A has. So that's why the Big ten is stepping
- 24:29in and doing this sort of you know, intermediate thing. And I think
- 24:33there is maybe some confusion that I think I saw someone earlier saying that's it,
- 24:37and this is not necessarily uh, not necessarily it because there's a whole
- 24:45separate thing. Uh, there's a whole separate Uh hang on, all right.
- 24:52Uh, Kevin, wave at me when you're ready to jump jump on.
- 24:55Oh, Kevin's ready to jump on. All right. Sorry, Hi,
- 24:57there's Kevin. Hi, Kevin, Kevin. We were just talking about
- 25:00the fact that I think there's some people confused about the fact that, you
- 25:03know, this from the Big Ten which is not official yet, but Pete
- 25:07Themmier reporting that it's going to be a remainder of the regular season next three
- 25:11games kind of situation where Jim Harbor would be suspended just for the games,
- 25:15not for the week. I think there's some confusion that that's separate from whatever
- 25:22is going to happen with the you know, the COVID visitation issues that had
- 25:26that they had that Michigan's self imposed to three games suspension fourth the beginning of
- 25:30the season. It's also separate from the nc DOUBLEA investigation into this, into
- 25:36the Connor stallions, sigence stealing, whatever else it ends up being. Those
- 25:41are separate issues. Those are separate things. So, you know, the
- 25:45Big Ten putting three games on Jim Harball right now with this that does end
- 25:48up being a correct report. That does not That is not the end of
- 25:52the issue. That does not mean that other coaches the program might not get
- 25:59pro might not have wins, vacated, might not have show causes, whatever
- 26:03it is. That's a whole separate thing that's still to come. This is
- 26:07just a short term, temporary, immediate sort of situation. Yeah, but
- 26:12this shows that they went to the jag because it's over two games, and
- 26:17this is what they came up with. This is what they came up with.
- 26:19And I understand, and I read a report right before getting on air
- 26:23with you guys that the NC TWOA is looking to fast track it's investigation.
- 26:29What is an NC two A fast track twelve months? Eighteen months? I
- 26:33mean, yeah, maybe they maybe they could turn something pretty quick. I'm
- 26:36sorry, I'm at a hotel lobby and tiny little tables here. I think
- 26:42that it was a case of trying to make everybody happy and making nobody happy.
- 26:45Does does Michigan sit there and think it got away with something and not
- 26:48bother to go for a temporary restraining order, an injunction or anything along those
- 26:53lines, Because I don't know if I want to open up discovery, and
- 26:57this is a case of okay, well you can't coach the games, but
- 27:02you can do everything else, which is akin to what happened with you know,
- 27:07his self imposed deal over the Hamburgers when urban Meyer had his suspension.
- 27:12Wasn't he out for you know, for the entirety he couldn't be at the
- 27:15facility. I just I don't know. I mean, you know, we
- 27:19don't have anything official at this point, but it sure, it sure feels
- 27:23pretty light to me. We've got a couple of super chats I want to
- 27:29punch up real quick here diego as chances of roping Ross into one of these
- 27:33to talk about the legal side. I'd love to hear from an attorney about
- 27:36issues like personal jurisdiction. I can ask Ross's not on our time zone and
- 27:41maybe doing his actual job right now, so we can I can check into
- 27:47that. He has been sharing some insights on the huddle board presented by Jeff
- 27:51Ruby Steakhouse at Buckey huddle dot com. He has been in that thread quite
- 27:53a bit answering questions. So that is a great place to get insight from
- 27:57Ross because I'm guessing we will not be able to get him on this show,
- 28:02especially right now super chat from Stephen oglesby Jim is screaming no, no,
- 28:07no, I can't hear you, so it's holding up the process.
- 28:08Now he is on an airplane right now. The fun question is, so
- 28:12is their WiFi on the airplane, because you know, sometimes the WiFi doesn't
- 28:15work. So is this going to be like the what was it? Has
- 28:19Justine landed yet? Hold kerfluffle about ten years ago where a lady sent a
- 28:25tweet that people decided was extremely offensive and then by the time she landed in
- 28:30some other continent it had blown up and she was like the top training topic
- 28:33in the world. I'm guessing Jim Harball probably has a better sense that he's,
- 28:37you know, a topic of conversation today. Epper right there is not
- 28:42real that's a separate that's a separate plane conversation. I'm going to guess.
- 28:48I'm going to guess that there is a Wi Fi on the plane. And
- 28:51it is also not a very long flight from ann Arbor to State College.
- 28:55It's probably like a forty five minute hour long flight something like that. So
- 29:00if anyone wants to throw the if anyone wants to throw the tail number in
- 29:03the chat. We can track the plane. We can do a good old
- 29:06fashioned college football airplane tracking. I was gonna say. The other question is
- 29:10is their Wi Fi in Happy Valley in State College. Sometimes in the chat
- 29:18that maybe the Big Ten just tweeted something, but I don't know. There
- 29:22are a lot of fake things. I'm looking right now. Okay, well,
- 29:25while you look for that, I'm going to read the super chat from
- 29:27Mike Freno. I really struggle to understand why this was blown up so big
- 29:30by Michigan. Three game game only suspension hardly seems enough to harm relationships with
- 29:33everyone. Now, I guess the question is did Michigan's rebuttal change what the
- 29:41Big Ten was going to do? Here? Was the Big Ten going to
- 29:44levy a level, a more serious punishment, and then this is sort of
- 29:48dialed back in respect of Hey, here's what they said, and here's what
- 29:52the you know they Hey, you kind of had a point on this one,
- 29:55but not on this one, and we don't know because there's been This
- 29:59is the The rumored punishment has been all over the place, from justifying to
- 30:03suspended indefinitely to suspended for two games, suspended for you know, the rest
- 30:10of the regular season just you know, fine, five million dollars whatever.
- 30:14It has been all over the map, and this feels like kind of right
- 30:18in the middle of what they had talked about. So I'm not like,
- 30:22I look at this and I think exactly what Tony said, which is,
- 30:26you obviously had to go to the Jakeak, the Joint Group Executive Committee or
- 30:30whatever it is to get this run, to get this approved. So obviously
- 30:36this was not just Tony Pettiti doing you know, wight wagging his finger and
- 30:41doing this on his own. This was a bunch of Big Ten leadership had
- 30:44to approve this as well. Because it's a more than two game suspension.
- 30:47So from that perspective, it feels substantive. From the perspective of actual on
- 30:53field impact, I don't think it's huge, but it also means he has
- 30:57now, assuming this goes through and there no you know, there's no injunction
- 31:02or anything like that, he will have missed literally half of the regular season
- 31:07for in game suspensions for two separate violations, which I mean, you know,
- 31:12we always have the legacy conversation with players and stuff. If you have
- 31:17two separate suspensions and you've missed half of a season for two separate suspensions.
- 31:22Potentially, if this is where this all, you know, if this is
- 31:26what ends up being the case, that feels like that becomes a little bit
- 31:30of a legacy thing. It's a lot of a legacy thing. I don't
- 31:33know how many coaches would be able to withstand getting two suspensions in a season
- 31:37and not lose their job, let alone have a coach WHI you're trying to
- 31:41extend, who is also trying to head to the NFL every single year.
- 31:44This is very this is a very damaged relationship. That is beyond But the
- 31:49first paragraph from the Big Ten, they did release a statement, the Big
- 31:53Ten Conference announces violation of Sportsmanship policy by University of Michigan football program. The
- 32:00first paragraph from the release is the Big Ten Conference announced today that the University
- 32:02of Michigan has been found in violation of the Big Ten Sportsmanship policy for conducting
- 32:08an impermissible in person scouting a operation over multiple years, resulting in an unfair
- 32:15competitive advantage that compromised the integrity of competition. That's very strong. That's so
- 32:24strong that when you see those words followed by that coach can't be on the
- 32:29sidelines for the next three games. You're like, this doesn't seem to follow.
- 32:35But you've said you're saying it's an unfair competitive advantage for years. I
- 32:39don't know, is it one game per year that that he's being punished here
- 32:44for Well, again, it's not. This is not the final punishment.
- 32:49Yeah, this is, I mean, and I feel like we need to
- 32:51reiterate that because I have had a couple I thought that was pretty clear,
- 32:53but apparently there were there were a couple of people that asked me about that
- 32:57who recently, like in the LAS day, so maybe that's hasn't been clear.
- 33:01This is not the final punishment on this. This is just here's what
- 33:06the Big ten feels is needed to do now, and then the NC double
- 33:09A will take its time and do more when the NC DOUAA gets a chance
- 33:15to do that. And it sounds like that's being fast tracked, but that's
- 33:19you know, fast tracked for the NC double A is not immediate. That's
- 33:22that's going to take a little time. So I you know, this this
- 33:28to me as an interim thing, I don't really have an issue with this.
- 33:32I really kind of had figured out that this was going to go wherever
- 33:36it was going to go, and I was going to probably be okay by
- 33:39and large with whatever it was, because there's just there's only so much they
- 33:45can do in the middle of the season, and so you know, you're
- 33:53not you are there was there were, you know, people floating the idea
- 33:58and sorry for me acting like I can't talk. Here's the Here's had to
- 34:02throw together a quick slide with the Big Ten statements so you can all read
- 34:07it. It is the Big Ten Conference, as Tony said, announced today,
- 34:10the University Michigan has been found in violation of the Big Ten Sportsmanship Policy
- 34:14for conducting it impermissible in person scouting operation over multiple years, resulting in an
- 34:19unfair competitive advantage that compromised compromise the integrity of competition. I need to stop
- 34:28doing two things at once, is my big takeaway here. Big Ten Conference
- 34:32Agreement ten at point zero point one states in part that the Big Ten Conference
- 34:35express all contests involving a member institution to be conducted without compromise to any fundamental
- 34:39element of sportsmanship. Such fundamental elements include integrity of the competition, civility towards
- 34:45all and respect particularly toward opponents, and officials, and as penalty imposed on
- 34:51the institution, the university football team must compete without the head football coach for
- 34:53the games remaining in the twenty twenty three regular season, effective immediately. The
- 34:57disciplinary action shall not preclude the unit versity or with a football team from having
- 35:00its head football coach at ten practices or other football team activities other than the
- 35:05game activities to which it applies. For clarity, the head football coach shall
- 35:07not be present at the game venue on the dates of the games to which
- 35:12this disciplinary action applies. The Big Ten Conference will have no additional comment at
- 35:15this time. So there it is. That is the entirety of the Big
- 35:19Ten statement on this. I don't know. I look at the I look
- 35:25at the options that they had available. This this feels okay to me.
- 35:30This feels reasonable to me, don't. I don't think it's going to have
- 35:34an enormous impact, But I think there was sort of an expectation built up
- 35:37that either you know, the Michigan people had the expectation built up that nothing
- 35:40was going to happen. This was all nonsense. This was all just lies
- 35:44from you know, the lies from the haters. And they were people on
- 35:49the other side, who were sure that the Michigan was going to like not
- 35:52be allowed to finish playing in this season. And I don't think either of
- 35:55those were realistic. This this is probably a little bit of they split the
- 36:00baby kind of thing. I mean, no, do you disagree, I'll
- 36:05ken go real quick. I'm going to say this is a punishment without much
- 36:07of an impact, and I think that's just splitting the baby thing. Yeah.
- 36:12I mean again, as I said when I first sat down, if
- 36:15you're going to the Jax to go over and above and this is what you
- 36:19come up with, I just this is this is completely toothless. I mean,
- 36:24you may as well have just done nothing at this point and just kick
- 36:27the can down the road to to the n C two A. I mean,
- 36:31of anything, this is just probably going to galvanize Michigan about with their
- 36:35Michigan against versus everybody, or Michigan versus the rules, or whatever whatever it
- 36:40is that you want to want to say at that point, if you wanted
- 36:45this suspension to have a little bit to it, then you have to suspend
- 36:49them out for the for the entire three weeks. You know, no no
- 36:53game preps, none of that. There was a lot of talk of what
- 36:58about what about the what about the coordinators? They certainly seem to be involved
- 37:02in talking to Connor Stallions. And if this is about Connor Stallions, and
- 37:06this isn't necessarily about the rumors of footage on servers and other things out there
- 37:12that I mean, people were talking about in the chat that they were talking
- 37:14about it in ninety seven to one, So it's not necessarily a well well
- 37:17guarded secret that there are certainly allegations out there about some items of that nature.
- 37:23It just it seems like a lot. It seems like a lot of
- 37:28farting around for no real results. I want to read a tweet from Jordanstrak,
- 37:32who is a Toledo based media person, was on TV there and then
- 37:37also does mud hen stuff and hockey stuff, and he's a Michigan fan and
- 37:40we get along and I'm not ripping him. I'm just reading this to give
- 37:45you a perspective of a Michigan fan. This was he's quote tweeting the Pete
- 37:47Theamill tweet from like ten minutes ago. This is a punishment that makes everyone
- 37:52happy right there. I don't think that's true. Jim Rabble gets to game
- 37:59plan all week coordinator do their thing during the games. Michigan has a chip
- 38:01on their shoulder. Honestly feels like a win win, Let's move on.
- 38:07And I think this is it's definitely galvanizing. I'm not sure punishments are supposed
- 38:12to be galvanizing, but this one is. But like I said, it's
- 38:17a punishment with I think this is Tony Petiti trying to You don't want to
- 38:22cost one of your teams a playoff shot, but you want to show like,
- 38:28hey, what you've done is wrong, and so what we're doing right
- 38:30now suspending Jim Harball. But the thing is there are still investigations coming.
- 38:36This is not the end of it. This is not Michigan imposing the penalty
- 38:39like they did previously to try to show like, hey, we're sorry about
- 38:45this, even though Jim Harball didn't seem to be sorry about it. So
- 38:50you're trying to get some good thoughts going from the NCAA on the previous thing,
- 38:57and this one is completely different at this point. Now, until we
- 39:00see the notice of allegations and things like that, Michigan's response to it,
- 39:04because right now Michigan's response hasn't really been we didn't do it. It's just
- 39:07hey, we we want the NCAA, the dear NCAAA to get involved.
- 39:14And so I don't know that the nca will look at this and be like,
- 39:16okay, time served. In terms of what else needs to happen.
- 39:21This isn't just going to be a head coach punishment. Once this is all
- 39:23said and done, this is going to be well beyond that. I mean
- 39:28the fact that the Big ten. I don't even know that we need to
- 39:30say alleged anymore because some different things have been alleged and have not been proven.
- 39:35But when a big ten comes out and says you've had a competitive advantage
- 39:37for multiple years, that's a fact. And now we wait for the the
- 39:44the real punishment. This is just a now thing. This is like go
- 39:47to the corner. Now we're going to talk about this. This is this
- 39:52is throwing your dog like a biscuit before dinner, Like, okay, go
- 39:55eat this. Take take five minutes, go eat this, and then when
- 39:59I'm done with my work, then well then we'll feed you your dinner.
- 40:00That it's this isn't a mouse boosh of a penalty. Uh, and you
- 40:06know we'll see it. Well, we'll see where. We'll see where it
- 40:09goes from there. Uh. The the ms Wilson one two three, thank
- 40:13you for the super chat flaming Elmo gift from the SEC. Thank you for
- 40:16your coverage. The flight number is d A L eight nine seven, which
- 40:20I just pulled that up on flight tracker. That plane landed five minutes ago
- 40:23in State College, Pennsylvania, coming from Detroit. So yes, that probably
- 40:29is very likely the UH correct airplane going from the correct airport to the correct
- 40:34airport. So I would say very very likely. Yes, that was the
- 40:37correct tail number. UH and Michigan should be on the ground now in State
- 40:40College. We'll see what kind of coverage comes out of State College. Kind
- 40:44of wish we were there because we've done We've done a bunch of team arrival
- 40:46videos. Boy, this would be a consequential one. Be the bet the
- 40:51interview with Jim Harball from the ground is h has some some interest where is
- 40:58watch the game Chili's or Apple? Because he can't be at Beaver Stadium.
- 41:01State College is kind of limited in its options. I would have said,
- 41:05hasses, but I don't think there's a TV there, so I mean maybe
- 41:08he gets a three for me from is that Chili's or Applebee's. I don't
- 41:13know. It's it will be interesting to see the whoever the acting head coach
- 41:17is talk about this and no, I can't say anything. But also I
- 41:22don't know how often the assistants do talking for for Michigan, but they're gonna
- 41:27have to say something, and it's it'll be you know. I can't comment,
- 41:30but I'm just interested to see who that is is. Well, they
- 41:34go with the most experienced, first time second time interim weekly head coach.
- 41:40Jan Moore would be the guy, even though he's certainly in the crosshairs of
- 41:45the Stallion scandal. But I would I would assume that it would be more.
- 41:49That would be my guess as well, because I think the three games
- 41:52he served earlier in the year, it was Mintor for one more, Jesse
- 41:55Mintor the defensive coordinator for one correct, Yeah, Sharon Moore the offensive coordinator
- 42:00after he served his own suspension, then he got to serve as the interim
- 42:02head coach for a game, and then Mike Hart and Jay Harbaugh each got
- 42:07half of a game that was I think UNLV for the third game. So
- 42:12they have had guys serve as head coaches obviously, you know Sharon Moore or
- 42:16the second game was what Bowling Green maybe, so you know this will be
- 42:21a little bit higher profile game, higher stakes game. But you know,
- 42:25they have had guys serve as head coaches before. Super Chat from Austin Frank
- 42:31seems like they just want Michigan to lose a game so they don't have to
- 42:34intervene too heavy handedly. If they lose, the problem takes care of itself.
- 42:37I mean, I am sure that that is a sentiment that has been
- 42:42felt around. You know, would the College Football Playoff be absolutely devastated if
- 42:46Michigan dumped this game in Happy Valley tomorrow and then they could kind of go,
- 42:52well, I mean, you didn't play a very good out of conference
- 42:53schedule and you lost a game, and you know, with the tiebreaker,
- 42:57probably not going to go your way even if you beat Ohio State. Yeah,
- 43:00I mean, too bad, so sad, but we'd love to invite
- 43:02you to our playoff, but sorry, we're out of spots. Yeah,
- 43:08and I think there's also is there a super chat about that very thing about
- 43:12the College Football Playoff, so we can just tie into that. From Mike
- 43:16Farino, does the CFP take this into account now that there's an official stance
- 43:20that cheating took place, or with Michigan still eligible, do they not care?
- 43:24The interesting they will not care at this point because they are eligible.
- 43:28However, it is interesting that the Big Ten has said now that Michigan has
- 43:32been operating at a competitive advantage and that stopped roughly two games ago at this
- 43:38point, so I do wonder if there will be some of that at least
- 43:45now will they talk because they're not even talking about this in the committee.
- 43:47They don't even talk about the Michigan allegations. Now that these are no longer
- 43:52allegations and there's a punishment handed down, I think they will talk about it,
- 43:55but I don't think it's going to change Michigan's eligible ability. I do
- 44:00wonder if maybe it would change their thoughts on Michigan because of the advantage.
- 44:05However, the advantage that they've had is against teams they already had an advantage
- 44:09over, So I don't think it's materially going to change. But I am
- 44:15interested to see what they actually have to say about it, because that's just
- 44:17one of the things we had to find out each week. Hey are you
- 44:21thinking about this yet? And I think everybody Big Ten, the committee that
- 44:25this CFP would would not be broken hearted by a Michigan loss. The CFP
- 44:32or Michigan or the Big Ten. Rather sorry, if Michigan were to lose
- 44:37their are they essentially out of it now? As long as Penn State wins
- 44:44out then for the Big Ten championship. But as we know, you don't
- 44:47need to win to Big Ten to make the playoffs. However, what you
- 44:50do need is a strong non conference win, and Michigan wouldn't have that.
- 44:55Well, Michigan would probably threaten the soup in state for beating them or something
- 45:00like that, because we've heard all this saber rattling and Tom mars is talking
- 45:06on one side. And then the university has its own representation, and Harbaugh's
- 45:12representation is either posting stuff on blogs or lifting stuff off of blogs. But
- 45:16as for the College Football Playoff Committee, their task, their charter is to
- 45:21pick the four best teams to fill the four slots in the four team playoff.
- 45:27Here last year of the four team playoff, they certainly could say that
- 45:31with the Big Ten ruling against Michigan that that certainly handicaps their ability to be
- 45:39one of the four best teams. But I don't think that that. I
- 45:44don't think we're at that point right now. I think that that's one of
- 45:46those things that if Michigan is still on the table, if Michigan beats Penn
- 45:52State and gets to x y Z point, then they're going to have to
- 45:54make a determination. But we never really see the CFP get out ahead of
- 45:58things. The cf HE always reacts much later, and you know, and
- 46:04that's been to Ohio State's benefit in fourteen when Ohio State jumped Baylor and TCU
- 46:08because of what happened in that game and everything else. But I don't think
- 46:14that we're necessarily going to see any sort of adjustment in the rankings that are
- 46:19not predicated by actual on field actions. All Right, super chat from THH
- 46:28just says, this means this really means nothing, and I mean it's more
- 46:30than nothing, but it's not you know, this is not the absolute bombshell.
- 46:36I mean, we had people talking about Michigan, you know, dropping
- 46:37the hammer, the Big Ten dropping the hammer on Michigan, and it's going
- 46:40to happen on Monday, and it's like, I don't think either of those
- 46:43is really accurate. This is this is a punishment. This is not and
- 46:47I don't think it's an unreasonable punishment. I don't think it's like an unreasonably
- 46:52light punishment. It's a punishment, but it's not that. This is certainly
- 46:55not Michigan getting nuked into the Stone Age. But again there's there is potentially
- 47:00you know, significantly more coming later with the NCAA super TEP from David Greenshield,
- 47:06first COVID, same Jim Harbaugh and now the Big Ten commissioner. Hm.
- 47:13Well, this hundredive is the Big Ten didn't have to make any sort
- 47:15of move and could have punted at the point. Again, to Tom's point,
- 47:20this is not the final verdict. This is not the final This isn't
- 47:24the final boss, This is not any of that. This is just this
- 47:28is like the easiest of many bosses. Like if your character has no skills
- 47:32or whatever, you might lose. But other than that, you sit there
- 47:36and you look back as I got that guy was easy to push over.
- 47:38I mean, this is very early in the process. I think that we're
- 47:42going to see a couple more graduated steps. But as I've said, if
- 47:45you're going to take if you're going to make the efforts to act and act.
- 47:50Don't just don't come in with this lukewarm milk toast nothing burger. So
- 47:55this is little Mac versus Glass Joe? Is that what that is? Yeah?
- 48:00Super chef from Jordan Kapler. So if hardball can't be on the sidelines,
- 48:05can he go to other games? Can Jim be the new Connor Stallions?
- 48:07I mean that would be diabolical and what a what a snub right in
- 48:13the big ten's face to go and do that Rutgers. I listen, listen,
- 48:22hey, listen. The Fifth Amendment still applies. We can't you can't
- 48:25you know, you can't do unreasonable, you know, excessive? I mean,
- 48:30yeah, could he could get banned from baseball? That's if. What
- 48:34if he shows up to Ohio State this weekend and has isn't a baseball glove,
- 48:37has a baseball glove on him? What if he shows up to court
- 48:42like Judge Judy, sitting in the front row like you did the last time
- 48:45with Judge Judy. Uh? Super chef from Bill Evans five dollars. Thank
- 48:49you, Bill, appreciate it. If you had a question, I missed
- 48:52it. Sometimes people will put the superchd in and then have a separate question.
- 48:55So if you guys happen to see the question from Bill, let me
- 48:59know, che for Mike Smith. If this is your punishment, you know
- 49:01UML is going to try and get an adjunction asap. Why not just do
- 49:04the two games that isn't eligible for appeal after this weekend. That would last
- 49:07to the end of the regular season anyway. And I don't think there's a
- 49:13difference there. Again, I am not an attorney, but you know that
- 49:15the verbiage in terms of may not be appealed is the same at the end
- 49:22of the basic punishments that the Commissioner can levy and the punishments that the j
- 49:28get ca and levy that are more serious. I think that is cannot be
- 49:31appealed to the conference is how that is, how that is sort of read.
- 49:38So there's not a line there that's like, you know, you can't
- 49:42appeal these, but you could appeal these. The verbiage is the same.
- 49:46So the case against it would be the same regardless. And you know,
- 49:51if you suspended him for two games and it was you know, Maryland and
- 49:53Ohio State but not Penn State, boy, I don't think Penn State would
- 49:57be big fans of that. So you know it's I'm gonna be so interested
- 50:04to see what the response is because I have not seen anything yet in terms
- 50:07of an injunction filed correct. Have I missed anything? I'm not, but
- 50:13I'm on Hotel wi FI. If I look off the screen, it made
- 50:17drop on me. So I did see a tweet from Kyle Roland, our
- 50:22buddy with the Toledo Blade, saying can we get a welfare check on David
- 50:25Schuster? I'm legitimately worried about this guy's mental health. David Schuster was that
- 50:32weird guy that like Bretons, like Walt, Disney World, and a bunch
- 50:37of other stuff. Deer at goofy Uh, yeah it was. He was
- 50:43the guy who was like tweeting at all the corporations that sponsored College Game Day,
- 50:47I think, or ESPN telling them he was not going to do he
- 50:52was gonna take his kids to six Flags instead of Disney World. If if
- 50:57ESPN did not find people. Yeah, yes, So there are some other
- 51:02statements I think from the Big Ten. I just saw Nicole Arbek. I'm
- 51:07not sure where this is coming from. It tweeted this. It's from a
- 51:10letter from the university here from the Big Ten, the Conference is unmoved by
- 51:14the university's attempt to downplay its impermissible conduct by asserting that other conference members may
- 51:19have engaged in sign to coding. As the university readily admits in its response,
- 51:23it does not know the exact methods that it alleges other teams used to
- 51:27decode its own signs. The Conference has not received any information that any other
- 51:31member schools engaged in impermissible advanced in person scouting, let alone a scheme of
- 51:36the size and scale like the one at issue here. The Conference is unaware
- 51:39of any active NCAA investigations into impermissible advanced scouting involving other members of the conference.
- 51:45Should the Conference become aware of such impermissible conduct, it will take appropriate
- 51:50action. However, the Conference vehemently rejects any defense by the university or any
- 51:54other conference member that cheating is acceptable because other teams do it too. I
- 52:00thought we were going to have a Rico case here. That's all right,
- 52:05that's another heavy that's got more than this lame suspension, and the Big Ten
- 52:14has just in the last twenty minutes or so released some of the correspondents back
- 52:20and forth with Michigan. The you know the correspondents received by conference from Institution
- 52:25data November eighth, twenty twenty three. You have seen that all leak through
- 52:28Dan Wetzel already UH the correspondence from conference to Institution data November fourth. So
- 52:32this is last Saturday, and so I think this is probably essentially a summation
- 52:38of what a summation of what the conference talked to Michigan about last Friday.
- 52:46This email constitutes a formal notice of the conferences belief that a violation of the
- 52:50Big Ten Sportsmanship policy has occurred. Specifically, both the Big Ten Conference in
- 52:52the University of Michigan were informed by NCA staff and no number. Second,
- 52:57that evidence characterized by the nc double A is uncontrovert veritable. Evidence exists to
- 53:00demonstrate that a non coaching football staff member, Connor Stallion's coordinated scheme by which
- 53:06individuals were directed to attend games of future opponents, were scouting purposes and violation
- 53:08of NCUBLEA by Law eleven point six point one, which it prohabits in person
- 53:13scouting of future opponents. In addition, the individuals engaged in scouting were instructed
- 53:16to make video recordings of signals used by opposing teams which violates NCAA Football Playing
- 53:22Rules FR one Dash four Dash eleven Dash H prohibition on recording signals given by
- 53:27an opposing player, coach, or other team personnel, and the conference's Football
- 53:30Game Management Manual. These were not isolated or haphazard incidents. The violations were
- 53:36pervasive, systemic, and occurred over multiple years, specifically dating back to at
- 53:38least with the twenty twenty one season and continuing through the current season. The
- 53:43staff member purchased strategically located tickets for games involving future opponents. It goes on
- 53:46and on, but they they In addition to information shared with the conference and
- 53:54institution by the nc DOUBLEA during the aforementioned call on November second, other evidence
- 53:59possessed or viewed by the conference includes a spreadsheet shown to the conference by the
- 54:01NCAA, for which one worksheet included the twenty twenty three schedules of scheduled opponents
- 54:07and potential opponents. Included extensive informulation related to scouting assignments for games, including
- 54:13the names of individuals who would be attending games, the presence of dollar amounts
- 54:16associated with some games, the notes intent indicating the need to find individuals and
- 54:20certain locales to attend games. Another worksheet within the same spreadsheet file included written
- 54:24descriptions of the opponent's signals. The worksheet he's either in possession of or has
- 54:29been shared with the institution's outside council for this matter. Data showing ticket purchases
- 54:32by the staff member for games involving future opponents, including at least four games
- 54:37in twenty twenty one, thirteen games in twenty twenty two, and five games
- 54:38during the first seven weeks of the twenty twenty three season. This photos and
- 54:45videos for the public domain that show the staff member adjacent to and communicating with
- 54:49coaches during games occurring within the timeframe at issue. One photo was taken from
- 54:53mister stuy and since deleted Instagram account, showing him during the October second,
- 54:57twenty twenty one game at Wisconson standing shoulders shoulder with defensive coordinator Mike McDonald,
- 55:01with mister McDonald focused on the field and mister Stallion's looking intently in the direction
- 55:06of the opposing sideline. Mister Stallions caption for the photo read quote just two
- 55:09football guys debating what the best halftime snack on the plotter is close quote.
- 55:15There is also a video of mister Stallions watching the opposing sideline during the November
- 55:17twenty six, twenty twenty two game at Ohio State and then just during to
- 55:21the Michigan defense in reaction to the signals being provided to the opposing offense.
- 55:23That would be the video from Adam King from Channel ten in Columbus. There's
- 55:28also video of mister Stallions during the December twenty thirty first twenty twenty two game
- 55:31against CCUS standing shouldered to shoulder with defensive coordinator Jesse Mitch and talking to him
- 55:36while intently watching what was happening on the field and or the TCAU sideline.
- 55:39So this is you know, it goes on and on, but this is
- 55:44please provide any response by five o'clock pm on Tuesday, November seventh, twenty
- 55:47twenty three, is what they asked ask them to do. So that is
- 55:52so apparently they got notified on Saturday and were given until Tuesday to formulate a
- 55:58response. So that's that's a reasonable amount of time. There were people who
- 56:02were taking the timeline of you know, how can you have the punishment on
- 56:07Friday and saying, well, why didn't they just notify them last week.
- 56:10Well, they notified them on Saturday, so they did not notify them on
- 56:14Monday. That just it came out on Monday that they had notified them on
- 56:17There's so much in here, we should just all pause for fifteen minutes and
- 56:21go read all of this. One of the things here, you guys are
- 56:23going to talk for a minute, and I'm going to start making some screenshots
- 56:25and some graphics because you know how I love to read this stuff. You
- 56:29got me five more minutes and then it's time to jump in an Ober and
- 56:30good drinks and beer. All right, So you hear that everyone shows about
- 56:34to get better, So hang in there, give us a thumbs up now,
- 56:36but shows about to get better. Just one little piece in this.
- 56:40This is from the university or from their conference to Michigan. On November eighth,
- 56:45the university and its head football coach delivered their responses to the conference's notice.
- 56:51The university's response did not deny that the impermissible scheme occurred, but argued
- 56:57that the conference did not have the authority to enforce its own rules. For
- 57:00instance, the university argued that a rule authorizing the conference to impose additional penalties
- 57:05after an NCAA investigation based on the final results of that investigation, actually prohibited
- 57:09the conference room enforcing an entirely different rule, a sportsmanship policy. This is
- 57:17one week started hearing about how the Big Ten was not happy with Michigan.
- 57:21I think a lot of this is just because of all of the lawyer hair
- 57:23that had been pulled out and put on the floor of the Big ten meeting
- 57:29rooms, because of the arguing back that Michigan was doing on some of these
- 57:32things in the way they're arguing it, and the Big ten lawyers is shaking
- 57:37their heads. But there's so much stuff here. There is one thing,
- 57:44Chris Vanini was also pulling some of this, and I am here's one part
- 57:49of it. I don't exactly know where this is in that letter, but
- 57:52this is from the Big Ten. The university's November eight response does not deny
- 57:55that the impiscible scheme occurred. Instead, it offers only procedural and tech arguments
- 58:00designed to delay accountability. And that's just more a very this. This is
- 58:07not a happy content. This is not a happy Big Ten, and they're
- 58:09letting everybody know about it. And I'm kind of with Kevin. What they're
- 58:13saying is stronger than the punishment, like pay attention to what the Big ten
- 58:19is saying about Michigan here, and the the the use of the word cheating,
- 58:22Like if I go through this and control f cheating and see how many
- 58:27times cheat is mentioned, you know, things like that, and the the
- 58:31impermissible, all of that. It's pretty damning. Kevin' you got anything you
- 58:37want to say before you get out of here, Well, let's talk.
- 58:40I'm not going to read any statements because I can't. I can't open a
- 58:44second window at risk of dropping off of here. But again, I'm going
- 58:47to need I'm going to need to read some of this documentation. I will
- 58:52do that from the bar and get accused by my wife of not paying attention
- 58:54to her and why did she bother taking me up to Cleveland for my birthday?
- 58:58And we're living in strange times, my friends. This is all interesting.
- 59:02I'm going to be curious to see what type of timeline the n C
- 59:06two A can move on. It's certainly not going to be days or weeks.
- 59:10I mean, unless you know, we're talking about like thirty weeks.
- 59:14But we'll see. At this point, I think it's a pretty thin punishment
- 59:17at this point, as I said, and Tony said that, I said,
- 59:21and I will say again, the words are much stronger than what the
- 59:23actions are at this point. I was kind of waiting to see if,
- 59:27when the Big ten released more information, if there was going to be some
- 59:30lower level things that would be included in there. Apparently not at this point.
- 59:36But once again, just to kind of pull the pin and walk out
- 59:38of the room. We're only talking about one issue right now. We're only
- 59:42talking about the Stallion stuff. There's a lot of other accusations out there that
- 59:45are not being discussed at this point. Whether or not that falls more under
- 59:50the NC two A purview or the FBI investigation or whatever, I don't know.
- 59:55I mean, we're we're still in the opening stanzas of this song.
- 1:00:00We're not We're not really that deep into it yet. I'm still going to
- 1:00:05maintain that this is a relatively truthless punishment at this point. But if you're
- 1:00:09Ohio State, you got to get out there and just take care of business.
- 1:00:12Every Michigan fan in the world who's in the chat is just talking about
- 1:00:15the impending beat down that is coming to Columbus and ann Arbor, and all
- 1:00:20I say there is I'll be interested to see if both teams are undefeated and
- 1:00:23what that game looks like. All right, so let's we are way behind
- 1:00:29on super chats. Kevin, Thank you for hopping on. Always good to
- 1:00:30have you. Enjoy your enjoy the rest of your evening, try not to
- 1:00:34why don't you, Why don't you hand your wife your phone and just enjoy,
- 1:00:37enjoy a lovely evening away from this whole mess. And we'll we'll be
- 1:00:40here. We'll be here to uh you know, we don't worry. Well,
- 1:00:44we'll text you tomorrow with uh'll see We'll see you tomorrow. Yeah,
- 1:00:46we'll see you tomorrow. We'll be hanging out pictures of recruits, big recruiting
- 1:00:52weekend for Ohio State. Does anybody even know who they're playing? Oh?
- 1:00:54Yeah, Michigan State. So we'll be ready for that come tomorrow. Yes,
- 1:00:59it turns out there as an high a state football game that we will
- 1:01:00be covering tomorrow. So we'll see Kevin there. You will see Kevin there
- 1:01:04as well. Thank you, Kevin. All right, so let's get caught
- 1:01:07up. We are way behind on super chats. My apologies. We're gonna
- 1:01:09blast through a bunch of these to get caught up on all of that super
- 1:01:14chat from wv Buckeye. Good to see everyone. See you in Columbus tomorrow.
- 1:01:16We will see you there. Is This has been a season where it
- 1:01:22feels like we have spent so many weeks like we got into a nice routine
- 1:01:24at the beginning of the week, the beginning of season, like, Okay,
- 1:01:28on Monday, we do this show, and Tuesday we do this show.
- 1:01:30Wednesday we do this show. And then the last like three or four
- 1:01:34weeks has just been like, well, I don't know, We'll just see
- 1:01:36what something happens in the Michigan thing, and then that's what we'll end up
- 1:01:37talking about, because that's all anyone wants to talk about anyway. So yeah,
- 1:01:40High State plays Michigan State tomorrow. We'll get there. At some point,
- 1:01:45we'll have a pregame show. We'll probably talk about it some on the
- 1:01:47pregame show. Find us at YouTube dot com slash bucke huddle to watch that.
- 1:01:52And while you're on here. Talked about how we could make Kevin's wife
- 1:01:57happy by having him not on his phone. You can make Tony's wife by
- 1:02:00putting me pushing the thumbs up button. That would be much appreciated. Next
- 1:02:06up from Mike Farino by doing game of Dave game suspensions only, was that
- 1:02:09potentially a move to pretent an injunction. Michigan has are on three games with
- 1:02:13Gym surviving in a similar suspension underminds the reparable team aspect a heart tee irreparable
- 1:02:19harm aspect. That's a great point, well, and that's one of the
- 1:02:22points that the beat Dami Well talking to that Chief Justice, that was what
- 1:02:25he said. What would be the conferences or the judges argument or whatever that
- 1:02:31what is irreparable when you've already won three games for being suspended. You were
- 1:02:36three to zero when you were suspended, So I don't know that this would
- 1:02:38be irreparable. So I think that is accurate, although we don't know that
- 1:02:44an injunction isn't going to happen, or that isn't trying to happen. I
- 1:02:47do think this is is Michigan upset, sure that they didn't want anything to
- 1:02:53happen, But can they really be upset with this punishment when at this point,
- 1:03:01again this is just the preliminary punishment. You haven't lost any games,
- 1:03:06nothing has really been lost, so you still have everything. Nothing has been
- 1:03:09taken from you other than you know, four hours on Saturday, you're not
- 1:03:15going to have your head coach. So I wonder if this is something that
- 1:03:20they will fight, because if you do fight it, that does that three
- 1:03:24game suspension, If say you get an injunction for a day, does that
- 1:03:28three game suspension just carry over? Now you might be missing him for the
- 1:03:32Big Ten championship game or a bowl game something like that. Or is this
- 1:03:37just something what whatever the fight is, he seemingly is not going to be
- 1:03:40on the sideline for Ohio State. So at this point, what's what's to
- 1:03:45fight? Well? And that's kind of the question is do they fight it
- 1:03:51or do they look at this as you know, kind of finding something of
- 1:03:53a middle ground, which, you know, the old line that a good
- 1:03:57compromise leads everyone upset. I'm guessing that Ohio is people are looking at this
- 1:04:00and going that's not enough. I'm upset, and Michigan people are looking at
- 1:04:03this and going that's too much. I'm also upset. I would be,
- 1:04:10you know this based on Michigan's response and how you know, there were seventeen
- 1:04:17ways in which you can't do this to me. Only I can do this
- 1:04:20to me, and you know, and he didn't even know anything, and
- 1:04:24you can't prove anything, and even if you could prove anything, you don't
- 1:04:27have grounds to do this. And you know, I still sort of expect
- 1:04:30them to go and pursue this. But I do wonder if the you know,
- 1:04:34the to Mike's point, the the fact that they have won three games
- 1:04:40already without him on the sidelines, and won them somewhat comfortably even though they
- 1:04:44were against terrible competition, if that does maybe undermine the irreparable harm aspect of
- 1:04:48Michigan's argument that pet Dammel made had had the judge explained to him. In
- 1:04:54writing in his article earlier on Friday, Can I just put out sorry?
- 1:05:00Section five of the letter from the Universe from the conference to the university says
- 1:05:04that Jak and I have determined that this disciplinary action against university is appropriate.
- 1:05:10So just to answer that question, that Jay K was involved, hence the
- 1:05:15larger than two games, yes, so you know, so again that also
- 1:05:18probably helps undermine the argument against you know, this is just one crazy guy
- 1:05:25who thinks he needs to you know, this is the Jak is university president,
- 1:05:30University executives or leaders from around the country. So you know, you
- 1:05:33built some consensus across the conference where you got everyone else on one side of
- 1:05:39the table in Michigan on the other. So that probably helps, you,
- 1:05:42would think in terms of making this case potentially stick. We will see if
- 1:05:47Michigan files an injunction. If there was one file, there was a report
- 1:05:51that they would have to be addressed within fourteen days, which fourteen days from
- 1:05:55now we will already be up in the Great Lakes state of Michigan and getting
- 1:06:00ready for the Ohio State Michigan game following day. So, oh boy,
- 1:06:04what a fascinating week that could be. How would you like to have Michigan's
- 1:06:08response. I would, more than anything in the world, love Michigan's response.
- 1:06:12So they have released a statement and it reads is this, Like all
- 1:06:15members of the Big Ten Conference, we are entitled to a fair, deliberate,
- 1:06:17and thoughtful process to determine the full set of facts before a judgment is
- 1:06:21rendered. Today's action by Commissioner Tony Pettiti disregards the conference's own handbook, violates
- 1:06:27basic tenets of due process, and sets an untenable precedent of assessing penalties before
- 1:06:31an investigation has been completed. We are dismayed at the Commissioner's rush to judgment
- 1:06:36when there's an ongoing NCAA investigation, one in which we are fully cooperating.
- 1:06:42Commissioner Petiti's hasty action today suggests that this is more about reacting to pressure from
- 1:06:45other conference members than a desire to apply the rules fairly and Impartially, by
- 1:06:50taking this action at this hour, the Commissioner is personally inserting himself onto the
- 1:06:55sidelines and altering the level playing field that he is claiming to preserve, and
- 1:07:00doing so on Veterans Day, a court holiday. To try to thwart the
- 1:07:03university from seeking immediate judicial relief as hardly a profile and impartiality. To ensure
- 1:07:11fairness in the process, we intend to seek a court order together with Coach
- 1:07:15Arbaugh, preventing this disciplinary action from taking effects. All right, well there
- 1:07:19you go, So a good compromise, Tony leaves everyone upset. So yeah,
- 1:07:26I mean you can. I would assume they're going to be able to
- 1:07:30find a judge. Like, even though it is Veterans Day, you started
- 1:07:33talking about Veterans Day, and I'm like, are they going to talk about
- 1:07:36the troops? You can't. I was so sure that was where that was
- 1:07:40headed. Yeah, I assume they're going to be judge shopping, knocking on
- 1:07:45doors. I would assume they probably already know who they're going to take this
- 1:07:48to, and that they have probably notified the person, like, hey,
- 1:07:51you might hear from us sometime, might be weird, might be on Friday
- 1:07:56afternoon, kind of late. But you know, the idea that this is
- 1:08:00just patently unfair. The timing of this, like, whatever, when did
- 1:08:02you want this to happen? Because after the season is not an acceptable answer.
- 1:08:06So if it happened yesterday, then the conference didn't give enough time to
- 1:08:12take your well ridden legal YadA YadA into account. If it happens today,
- 1:08:17it's the holiday and the troops and you know, the courts are closed and
- 1:08:23so it's going to be three percent harder to get this done. And if
- 1:08:26it's next Monday, then you waited too long and you let it linger over
- 1:08:29our heads for the Penn State game. So you know, the timing of
- 1:08:31this whatever, man like, there was no timing that was going to make
- 1:08:34Michigan happy on this. So you know, we'll see next steps at this
- 1:08:41point in terms of a legal you know, an emergency in junction and you
- 1:08:46want to put odds, go ahead and put odds on whether Jim Harbaugh standing
- 1:08:49on the sideline in Beaver Stadium on Saturday, because I don't want to be
- 1:08:55the one who puts odds on this. I really I could see anything from
- 1:08:59five for to you know, eighty percent. Yeah, I'm and now you
- 1:09:03know how they do the sideline interviews at the half or coming back from the
- 1:09:08half. If he's there, What are you asking about your team's performance?
- 1:09:15Jim? Are you happy with your team's performance given the cloud over your program
- 1:09:20right now? And do you have anything you would like to say? And
- 1:09:24of course you know that nothing will be said, but I do. Michigan
- 1:09:29arguing fairness in their reply is a little like, come on, this this
- 1:09:34whole thing was because of you're somebody in your program doing something to create unfairness,
- 1:09:42and so then for you to be like this isn't fair, I mean,
- 1:09:45I guess that's an eye for an eye at that point. Yeah,
- 1:09:48and boy, it's going to be so interesting to see where this where this
- 1:09:54all goes. We're even further behind in super chat. Sorry, stim Jeff
- 1:10:00Hines. He says, the punishment is you're guilty, and there that is
- 1:10:02certainly the reputational damage to Jim Harbaugh on the Michigan program that has come over
- 1:10:09the last few weeks is not insubstantial. And you know, I say that
- 1:10:15and people are probably hearing that in terms of like Michigan attorneys saying like this
- 1:10:18is incredible damage to their reputation, like probably earned you probably earned what she
- 1:10:26got here. And you know, the there has not been a lot of
- 1:10:30pushback on anything other than Jim Harbaugh had direct knowledge of this and you know,
- 1:10:38hey, it's too soon that has Those have been really the two big
- 1:10:41lines of pushback right now, which is, Okay, who else knew?
- 1:10:45Did literally no one else in the building knew? Or you know, I
- 1:10:50don't. I don't know that anything that they have pushed back on yet has
- 1:10:54been you know, has told me that they're gonna like skate with a light
- 1:11:00punishment next year. I don't think that's probably going to be the case.
- 1:11:03But you know, we'll see. The NCAA has missed eighteen inch putts before,
- 1:11:08so we'll we'll see where that all goes. Super chat from Mike Smith.
- 1:11:14Wait a second, so the trust me Bro source was wrong about what
- 1:11:15Michigan had against other schools who could have guessed that real shocker. Now,
- 1:11:19that was the idea that Michigan has this incredible vault of you know, like
- 1:11:29reams and reams of documents of documenting every wrongdoing that every other Big Ten team
- 1:11:33has done over the last decade or whatever. That I mean, the whole
- 1:11:40process is not over. Maybe that comes out later, but that never made
- 1:11:44a whole heck of a lot of sense to me, because if you've got
- 1:11:46all this stuff showing, you know, hey, other teams are doing exactly
- 1:11:49what we did, which was something that has been claimed at least some places
- 1:11:54online, that feels like something you would have rolled out of that rolled out
- 1:11:59of that vault on about Tuesday morning this week and said that's part of the
- 1:12:04No, you can't punish us now because everyone does it. Because instead it
- 1:12:06was well, someone called someone about a different game and it wasn't legal,
- 1:12:13illegal, but it was kind of the same thing, like, if you
- 1:12:15have the goods, it feels like you deliver the goods before the punishment has
- 1:12:20already been levy. The time to drop that in the conference's lap is three
- 1:12:26days ago, and it seemingly didn't happen, So that sort of makes me,
- 1:12:30wonder what exactly is in the vault. Let's get Herldo Rivera and find
- 1:12:33out. No, no, you don't want to get him. You want
- 1:12:35to get somebody who has well, you can find something in a vault.
- 1:12:40The this that's just next one, next one. Time We've got to get
- 1:12:45through these super chat from CW Wonder if Ward Manual in Michigan ad will now
- 1:12:50pull his seat with the Playoff committee with this move by the Big Ten president.
- 1:12:55An interesting question. He took this past week off. I don't know
- 1:12:59that he will, but it is interesting. The first week that they had
- 1:13:04the meeting, there was a question from I think maybe Ralph Russo of the
- 1:13:12AP asking, uh, the book organ the chair of the committee, Hey,
- 1:13:18are you guys worried about having Ward Manual on the on your committee,
- 1:13:21tainting the committee and tainting you basically having that a guy with that kind of
- 1:13:26reputation and or at least with with what's going on and kind of getting this
- 1:13:30reputation now that he's associated obviously with Michigan and I wouldn't expect them to push
- 1:13:38him out or it's just a matter of what does does he have time for?
- 1:13:42I think he does because this is now either a judge is going to
- 1:13:45handle us for the time being or not, in which case, like,
- 1:13:49what is what has changed about Ward Manual's situation? He's not going to be
- 1:13:55watching to make sure that Jim Harbaugh isn't on the sidelines. There's obviously the
- 1:13:59get back coach for that, or Tom to stay away coach. That's that's
- 1:14:04a tremendous, tremendous idea give really a fun twist on an old classic in
- 1:14:10college football. They stay away coach? I did. We have had people
- 1:14:14in various places asking about, so what happens if Jim Harball just shows up,
- 1:14:17Like, I don't think this is like, this is not pro wrestling.
- 1:14:20Jim Harball is not going to like, you know, glass glass breaks
- 1:14:24and Jim Harbaugh comes striding swaggering down the down the tunnel at Penn State.
- 1:14:29I mean probably not right? Yes, Who who did Jim Harbaugh have on
- 1:14:33campus this past week? He had Rick Flair on campus? Right? Was
- 1:14:39that Rick Flair? Rick Flair the dirtiest? Will he say WU? Tony?
- 1:14:45Will he say WU? Is my question? Probably probably I am in
- 1:14:50the process of I think we have are we caught up on super chats?
- 1:14:54Hang on, I think we may have had one more. Sorry, I'm
- 1:14:55trying to do four things at once here. This is what happens when Kevin
- 1:14:58is goofing off. Super Chat from Bill McMillan. Thank you very much for
- 1:15:02your super chat. Five hundred and ninety seven items in the live chat.
- 1:15:08I haven't looked for a while. I'm sure everyone's getting along great. Oh
- 1:15:10yeah, yeah, super chat from Mike Smith. Honestly, I do hope
- 1:15:13this stops all the questions to Ohio State coaches and players so we can focus
- 1:15:15on Ohio State and instead of focusing on something else. Day said, the
- 1:15:18locker room feels different. Let's get it back well. I think the current
- 1:15:24stretch of games might have people looking elsewhere in terms of the excitement around college
- 1:15:30football. But a night game in Ohio Stadium against anybody, I think is
- 1:15:33going to get people back into the swing of things. And I'm with you.
- 1:15:39I'm ready to talk about Ohio State stuff like we have. This is
- 1:15:43this is all tangentially Ohio State. We talked about Michigan year round, years
- 1:15:46round, so this is not just something we're doing just because this is something
- 1:15:50we do year round. We talk about Michigan because you can't talk about one
- 1:15:56without the other. You can't talk about Higher State without acknowledging Michigan. You
- 1:15:59can't talk about me without acknowledging Ohio State. It's just right now, Michigan
- 1:16:03is doing the whole look what I can do type of thing and trying to
- 1:16:08command everybody's attention. And it's working now. Mark asked the most recent comment,
- 1:16:14I missed this. What did Michigan do well? Buddy? How much
- 1:16:18time you got? So? Just check the internet? All right? Yes,
- 1:16:24always check certain places on the internet. Be careful about where you're checking
- 1:16:28on the Internet. I also tried to pull up a popular Michigan site a
- 1:16:31minute ago to check a source on something, and unsurprisingly it did not load.
- 1:16:36Maybe having a servers under stress might be the read here. I did
- 1:16:42want to pull up this. It is the it is the let's say,
- 1:16:45we can pull this up all the way. There we go. This is
- 1:16:49from the Big Ten's letter that went out to officially notify Michigan. And this
- 1:16:54is this is part of the things that Tony was talking about earlier, the
- 1:16:59extraordinary nature of the offending conduct and information obtained by the conference. And this
- 1:17:03is the Big Ten essentially making a case for Hey, yeah, it's weird
- 1:17:10for us to be doing this right now, but here's why we're doing it,
- 1:17:13and you know the talk to the President of the NCAA, Charlie Baker,
- 1:17:18back on October eighteenth. During that call, the NCAA disclosed to both
- 1:17:23the conference and the university that had received highly credible evidence of a wide ranging,
- 1:17:28multi year, in person, off campus scouting scheme orchestrated by a non
- 1:17:30coaching staff member of the university football program. There were several extraordinary aspects of
- 1:17:35this call. It is rare and outside the NCAA's typical protocols for the NCAA
- 1:17:39to disclose information about an active investigation to institutions other than the institution under investigation.
- 1:17:45However, the NCAA stated and believed that the disclosure was necessary due to
- 1:17:47the unprecedented scope of the then alleged scheme then alleged is you will note past
- 1:17:54tense, and because of the significant impact on the impermissionable scheme could have on
- 1:17:58competition during the current football season. It was also extraordinary that the NCAA president
- 1:18:02arranged for and participated in the call, underscoring not only the severity of the
- 1:18:05allegations, but the immediate impacts all of these circumstances were a clear statement from
- 1:18:11the NCUBLEA that the nature and reliability of the evidence that they had received indicated
- 1:18:16that the improper scheme related to the university's football team was ongoing and created a
- 1:18:20substantial risk of compromising the integrity of football competitions this season. That is italicized.
- 1:18:27The two words this season are italicized so that you put emphasis on it
- 1:18:31when you read. At that point, the university's football team had played seven
- 1:18:34games this season and had five more regular season games remaining. So you know
- 1:18:42what that is telling you right there is you know, this is not you
- 1:18:45know, this is not just a few Big ten presidents who are big mad
- 1:18:48or the Big ten coaches who were on the conference call and they were the
- 1:18:53only ones who thought this was a big deal and are pressuring the Big ten
- 1:18:57into that decision. That is the NCUBA, including President Charlie Baker, looking
- 1:19:01at this and going like, hey, this is way bigger than the normal
- 1:19:05kind of crap that we deal with, because they deal with all that kind
- 1:19:09of stuff all the time, and it's you know, generally dealt with poorly.
- 1:19:12And but then they you know, it is dealt with poorly but slowly.
- 1:19:16This for this to get fast tracked in this way and fast tracked to
- 1:19:20the Big Ten, that tells you there are a lot of people at the
- 1:19:25highest levels of the sport taking this very very very seriously, which you know,
- 1:19:30then when you see the you know, there was what was the phrase
- 1:19:33that that Tony Petiti used, It was, you know, the one of
- 1:19:39the most serious or one of the worst scandals in league history. And like
- 1:19:43self evidently he was talking about on field scandals and like you know, scandals
- 1:19:46that directly impact the on field product. The fact that the situation was ongoing
- 1:19:51that helps make it a bigger deal. All all of that stuff makes it
- 1:19:58a you know, makes it a bigger deal, helps maybe underscore why you've
- 1:20:01got such immediate action on this. Yeah, just the as you said,
- 1:20:08the immediacy of it. The serious super chat from Jeff Fines is kind of
- 1:20:13what we've been talking about with the biggest punishment here is that the important headline
- 1:20:16is that the Big Ten confirms Michigan cheated. And that's something that you can't
- 1:20:24wash your hands of. That's something that is not just this year, but
- 1:20:29and really until you until the Big Ten puts an actual timeline on it other
- 1:20:32than calling it multiple years. People are going to attach this to the success
- 1:20:36in twenty twenty one, the success in twenty twenty two, and then you
- 1:20:42know, they did not need to do this advanced scouting and cheating this year
- 1:20:46with the schedule that they have. So I don't know, I don't even
- 1:20:49know if they went out from this point on, will people give them the
- 1:20:53credit for it, because there is still the taine of it, And never
- 1:20:59mind the fact that the may come in and wipe all of it out anyway,
- 1:21:01and so whatever you win will be taken away and will be vacated,
- 1:21:05and you'll still have the t shirts and you'll still have the not the trophies,
- 1:21:12You'll still have the zubaz pants and the the fanny packs and things like
- 1:21:17that. But this is far from over. And now Michigan can move on,
- 1:21:26I think is that's the other thing. Now we can all move on.
- 1:21:28But it doesn't sound like Michigan wants to move on just yet. They
- 1:21:30want to continue to fight this, and this is a conference that is not
- 1:21:35happy with Michigan. I think they're more unhappy with Michigan than Michigan is with
- 1:21:40them because some of those words that they're throwing at Michigan. This is not
- 1:21:43a situation where like, you know what, we need to remain friends,
- 1:21:45I'm going to use use some kind words like they are throwing it out there.
- 1:21:49And I could see now why Michigan fans would not like Tony Pettiti because
- 1:21:54it sure seems like he is anti Michigan. But what he is is he's
- 1:21:57just telling you. He's laying it out there like he has given them noble.
- 1:22:00This is something that Jim Delaney would be writing to them and it'd be
- 1:22:05in that same language. And that's like, I am the commissioner of the
- 1:22:08Big Ten. I am this with the JAK has done this, the presidents,
- 1:22:12we have all like that. This is not a unilateral This is not
- 1:22:14just Tony Pettiti on his own. This is everybody from the Big Ten involved
- 1:22:19in this. This is not one guy against an entire university. This is
- 1:22:23a conference saying hey, we caught you guys cheating. Yeah, and the
- 1:22:29fact that it went beyond the two games and you had to get the jack
- 1:22:30involved again. The JAK is you know, leaders from around the conference,
- 1:22:34from other universities, This is not just you know, hey, this school
- 1:22:38did this to us, or this one guy did this to us. That
- 1:22:41is leadership from across the conference. You had the phone call with the league's
- 1:22:45athletic directors. She had the phone call with the leagues football coaches. Neither
- 1:22:49of those sounded like they were full of happy, shiny people who were thrilled
- 1:22:54about what had happened or viewed it as not a big deal. So,
- 1:22:57you know, I think I think there's been a little bit of trying to
- 1:22:59Rea frame this is like, well, if you really look at it,
- 1:23:01only these you know, only this one guy is doing this. It's like,
- 1:23:04well it's not really true. West Best says, go go blow bye
- 1:23:09bye, Jimmy. I mean, this is even if the emergency injunction is
- 1:23:14not granted he's not done coaching Michigan forever, it would be a three game
- 1:23:19suspension. I still think there's a half way decent possibility he's on the sidelines
- 1:23:27on Saturday that they get some kind of an emergency injunction, because at this
- 1:23:30point, it's four forty three on the East Coast, So you're going in
- 1:23:33and you're talking to whoever, and if you get if you get someone to
- 1:23:36grant you the injunction, and I wouldn't even want to begin, you know,
- 1:23:41handicapping the likelihood that that happens. But if you do get that injunction
- 1:23:45granted, how long is it going to take the Big ten to file a
- 1:23:48you know whatever the counter or have a hearing, I mean the hearing.
- 1:23:51It happens according to the reporting from Pete Thamil early on earlier on Friday,
- 1:23:57in the you know, Washingtonaw County courthouse setting, which then there were questions
- 1:24:02about where that whether it would actually stay there or whether it get bumped up
- 1:24:05to a federal court because it's or a district court or you know, federal
- 1:24:09district court or something like that because it's in you know, dealing with entities
- 1:24:13in two different states. And we got to get all that sorted out.
- 1:24:15But you know, if there was you know, if there was a hearing
- 1:24:19based on an emergency and junction that was granted, that had to happen within
- 1:24:23fourteen days, So that's not necessarily going to be a five minutes later they're
- 1:24:28all talking and arguing that's a you probably get to coach the Penn State game,
- 1:24:31and then you might even get to coach the Maryland game before that actually
- 1:24:35happens, I go ahead the counter to the injunction, just so you know
- 1:24:43it's an out junction. Tony Gerdaman esquire. So here's the next thing from
- 1:24:51that, from the conference's statement, the conference's actions to protect the integrity of
- 1:24:56upcoming competitions. Later, on October eighteenth, to these same day that the
- 1:25:00call with Charlie Baker, the NCAA president, happened, two senior conference staff
- 1:25:05members and I participated in the call with the university's president at Santa Ono,
- 1:25:09Athletic Director Ward Manual, and general counsel. During that call, I expressed
- 1:25:13my belief that disclosure of the informercial will scheme to the university's remaining twenty twenty
- 1:25:16three football opponents was necessary to preserve player safety and protect the integrity of those
- 1:25:20competitions. After significant discussion and at my insistence, the Conference and the university
- 1:25:27agreed that the disclosures were necessary inappropriate. Also on October eighteenth, the university
- 1:25:31obtained consent from the NCAA to inform its football coaching staff of the NCAA's investigation,
- 1:25:35a deviation from normal practice that was required in light of the extraordinary nature
- 1:25:40of the NCAA's description of the conduct and the n season disclosures being provided to
- 1:25:44other conference members. That same evening, the conference informed the university's next football
- 1:25:47opponent, Michigan State University, of the information disclosed by the NCAA regarding the
- 1:25:53permissible scheme. On October nineteenth, the Conference similarly informed the universities remaining twenty
- 1:25:59twenty three foot all opponents. The conference also consulted with US Integrity, which
- 1:26:03confirmed the conference's view that immediate transparency about the information the conference had learned was
- 1:26:08important. Later that day, the conference issued a press release stating that the
- 1:26:11conference in the university had been notified by the NCAA that it was investigating allegations
- 1:26:15of improper sign stealing by the university's football program, and that press release the
- 1:26:18conference stress that it quote considers the integrity of the competition to be of the
- 1:26:23utmost importance that it would continue to monitor the NCAA's investigation. So this is
- 1:26:28a little bit of the In journalism, it's called a TikTok. It's sort
- 1:26:30of like the so here's the behind the scenes. Here's what we couldn't show
- 1:26:33you before. So here's you know how this sort of happened behind the scenes
- 1:26:39as the whole investigation sort of came together. I think the one of the
- 1:26:43key things in there the words were improper sign stealing, and throughout much of
- 1:26:47those sign stealing is legal. That's why there's the improper sign stealing listed in
- 1:26:54there. Just just one little other little needle point to Michigan on that one.
- 1:27:00All right, I'm kind of scrolling through this this document. If you
- 1:27:03want to email me the link to the Michigan statement, I will pull that
- 1:27:06up because I do want to read that again because that was that was pretty
- 1:27:10significant. I'm going to punch up the punch up the live chat just to
- 1:27:15see where everything's going. Hey, it's gone great. Turns out everyone agrees,
- 1:27:18so so it's fine. Yeah, it is it is you know,
- 1:27:25I mean, this is this is a and here's this is an interesting point
- 1:27:30that Brad Smith is making. I don't think it is former MISSOO quarterback Brad
- 1:27:33Smith, but it could be. The twenty twelve O high state team was
- 1:27:36undefeated and couldn't play for the national championship. What about quote if the kids
- 1:27:40talk then, because that is the you know, it's unfair that Michigan could
- 1:27:44have their season impacted, and look, they're having such a great season,
- 1:27:46so you know it would be really unfair to have them have their season impacted
- 1:27:50by this. And you know that's the twenty twelve team really did not benefit
- 1:27:57in any way from the stuff that happened that led to the you know,
- 1:28:01led to that, you know, the the firing of Jim or well,
- 1:28:05I guess technically the resignation of Jim Dressel, but you know, all that
- 1:28:10whole thing, and then Urban Meyer coming in and you know, the twenty
- 1:28:15eleven team going to a bowl game, and then the twenty twelve team,
- 1:28:16which had largely nothing to do with it. I think there was actually no
- 1:28:20overlap between the people the TAT five and the twenty twelve team, if I
- 1:28:25remember correctly. I don't think so. But either way, you know,
- 1:28:30it's all recruits. So that's that's what I thought. Yeah, So,
- 1:28:35you know, I mean a lot has changed on the views since then,
- 1:28:39but I certainly understand why, not only from a twenty twelve perspective, but
- 1:28:45also from my twenty twenty one in twenty twenty two Ohio state perspective, I
- 1:28:48understand why that argument. Certainly does not find it particularly sympathetic audience in Columbus.
- 1:28:55Butch Jones speaking of great college football names. Butch Jones, do you
- 1:28:59guys foresee two s and vacated wins on the horizon? I would be very
- 1:29:01happy with that, I mean, and that would be that would be part
- 1:29:04of the NC double A case. That's not something the Big ten can do,
- 1:29:08So that would be part of the NC double A case coming based on
- 1:29:13the you know, the the language that we're seeing here from the Big Ten
- 1:29:16that you know that that we're talking about, you know significant, there's a
- 1:29:26lot of words here. You know that essentially that the a lot of stuff
- 1:29:31that created a here we go, U created a substantial risk of compromising the
- 1:29:36integrity of football competitions. They're talking about the fact they had to act this
- 1:29:41season because it created a substantial risk of compromise the integrity of football competitions.
- 1:29:45So if you're gonna talk that way about twenty twenty three, then obviously you
- 1:29:50feel that it compromised football competitions in previous seasons, which then would certainly lead
- 1:29:58you to believe you're talking about vacating wins, vacating Big Ten championships, all
- 1:30:02that kind of stuff for twenty twenty one, twenty twenty two. I mean,
- 1:30:08if that's the way the Big ten's talking about it now, you know,
- 1:30:12and that was like the immediate reaction. It doesn't seem like the Big
- 1:30:14Ten is like, yeah, it turns out this wasn't a big deal,
- 1:30:16because we're having this conversation right now. So I would be pretty surprised if
- 1:30:21you didn't see twenty twenty one in twenty twenty two, and you know,
- 1:30:26maybe even twenty twenty three vacated. Yeah, that's my expectation. And again
- 1:30:30that's why we need to see how far back this goes. I know the
- 1:30:34initial reports for Pete Thamill have it going back to twenty twenty one. The
- 1:30:39Stallions has been on the staff since in some former fashion, since twenty fifteen,
- 1:30:44But when did this really begin? And so I'm thinking if it starts
- 1:30:48wherever they just determined that the science stealing, the illegal and proper science stealing
- 1:30:54begin, that's when the vacating will begin. So I'm expecting twenty twenty one,
- 1:30:59two twenty two, and the first what seven games of the twenty twenty
- 1:31:02three season to be wiped and maybe you'll see the first five and seven,
- 1:31:12you know, just it would just be I'm trying to think of what Michigan's
- 1:31:14record would be if they go ahead and went out this year, would just
- 1:31:18be five and oh in regular season? Is that how that would work?
- 1:31:24If it's just vacated, there's there are no losses there, so yeah,
- 1:31:28I mean, if it's if it's just from yeah, when when do you
- 1:31:31do it? Is it from the moment that the the moment that the stuff
- 1:31:38got got the Stallions left the team? Is it from some moment after that?
- 1:31:43I mean, because you will certainly have people arguing that the impact probably
- 1:31:47reached beyond you know that you know, yeah, Michigan State found out on
- 1:31:50the Thursday, and sure they could have adjusted their their signs or their play
- 1:31:58calling or whatever to deal with the fact that they knew that this was coming.
- 1:32:02But you still, I mean, realistically, that's not something you can
- 1:32:06change overnight and with because that came out on what Thursday that week? Wednesday,
- 1:32:11Thursday that week, That's just that's not a lot of time to make
- 1:32:15wholesale changes there. Now, would that have changed the outcome of that game?
- 1:32:18Was? You know, did that make a forty nine point difference?
- 1:32:21I would say probably not. But that's also you know, it doesn't have
- 1:32:28to make that big live a difference. If it had an impact, then
- 1:32:30it seems like that would certainly be something you could argue should be vacated as
- 1:32:35well. Well yeah, well, and we've seen for decades if you use
- 1:32:40an ineligible player, that game is vacated. And it doesn't matter whether that
- 1:32:44player scored three touchdowns or fumbled twice. You know that if you use an
- 1:32:48eligible player, then that game is basically going to be vacated. I am
- 1:32:54putting together a graphic with the Michigan response right now, which is taken directly
- 1:33:01from a couple squares of from Nicole auerbus Twitter account. So this is going
- 1:33:09to be formatted differently than all the other things. My apologies, my sincere
- 1:33:15apologies for the formatting and everything else about this show. But here we are.
- 1:33:18You punch that up in just a second. This is why Kevin needs
- 1:33:23to be here. This is what Kevin does. We've all been wondering for
- 1:33:27so long, what does Kevin do around here? It turns out he does
- 1:33:29this kind of stuff. But we'll punch that up in a second, because
- 1:33:32this is this is a notable response this is not a nothing response from Michigan.
- 1:33:38There's there is, you know, promises of further action from Michigan here.
- 1:33:44Like all members of the Big Ten Conference, we are entitled to a
- 1:33:45fair, deliberate, and thoughtful process to determine that the full set of facts
- 1:33:48before a judgment is rendered today. Today's action by Commissioner Tony Petiti disregards the
- 1:33:53conference's own handbook, violates basic tenets of due process, and sets an untenable
- 1:33:58precedent of assessing penalties before an investigation has been completed. We are dismased at
- 1:34:01the Commissioner's rush to judgment when there is an ongoing NCAA investigation, one in
- 1:34:05which we are fully cooperating. Commissioner Petiti's hasty action today suggested that there's more
- 1:34:10that this is more about reacting to pressure from other conference members than the desire
- 1:34:14to apply that rules fairly Impartially, by taking this action at this hour,
- 1:34:18the Commissioner is personally inserting himself onto the sidelines and altering the level playing field
- 1:34:24he's claiming to preserve, and doing so on Veterans Day, a court holiday,
- 1:34:28to try to thwart the university from seeking immediate judicial relief is hardly a
- 1:34:30profile and impartiality. To ensure fairness in the process, we intend to seek
- 1:34:34a court order, together with Coach Haarbaugh, preventing this disciplinary action from taking
- 1:34:39effect. So there you go. That is the statement from Michigan, as
- 1:34:43reported by Nicole Auerbach. So that's I mean, that's pretty strong. I
- 1:34:49don't you know, it's it's a whole due process argument, and I don't
- 1:34:58you know, I don't know it's it's there's no question whether there was wrongdoing
- 1:35:04and there's no question that under NCAA rules, Jim Harbaugh is responsible for it.
- 1:35:09Now, Michigan, in their legal response to the thing, said,
- 1:35:12well, that's nc DOUBLEA rules, that's not Big ten rules. It does
- 1:35:14specifically say that in Big ten rules. But you know, I think depending
- 1:35:17on who you're getting, who you're who is signing your checks, you will
- 1:35:19find that either a persuasive argument or not a persuasive argument. Uh, if
- 1:35:24you were an attorney. But you know, I don't there's not a question
- 1:35:30whether this happened or not. There's a you know, it's so you know,
- 1:35:35I don't know how much relief they're going to get from a judge.
- 1:35:41I mean, and this is one of these great unknowable things until we actually
- 1:35:45find out. Okay, who did they talk to and what did they say?
- 1:35:48Well, and hear from certified clapaholic, there is question of wrongdoing.
- 1:35:57I don't think the conference has any question that Michigan did some wrong doing,
- 1:36:00that there is wrongdoing in the program. Now they have not tied any of
- 1:36:02that to Jim Harbaugh, but the NCAA will come in and say it doesn't
- 1:36:06matter. He should have known and now some of that will be Here's the
- 1:36:11other thing, Tom, The rule that the head coach should know is recent.
- 1:36:15So at what point does that get applied and can they can they grandfather
- 1:36:20that into stuff that was going on two years ago as opposed to stuff that
- 1:36:24was only going on this year, So that may actually save the previous two
- 1:36:29years. But I'm again we'll see super check. Drew Smith Harball officially has
- 1:36:35more suspensions than bowl wins. I will say he won a bowl game at
- 1:36:41Stanford, though I'm wondering if he was already gone for that. Did he
- 1:36:46already leave for San Francisco at that point? That was twenty ten, it
- 1:36:49was his last team won the Orange Bowl, ranked fourth in the nation,
- 1:36:54got to win there. Of course, the first the only bowl win for
- 1:36:59Harball at Michigan was in twenty fifteen, the Citrus Bowl against Florida or South
- 1:37:05Carolina something like that. I don't know that it really matters. He is
- 1:37:11listed as the he is listed as the head coach. I'm citing Wikipedia here
- 1:37:15because this is the extremely important thing. Yeah, extremely important thing. I
- 1:37:18can like. David Shaw is not listed as an interim coach on there,
- 1:37:24so I'm going to guess, especially because he went to the forty nine ers.
- 1:37:26Generally those hires are made after the n the NFL season ends, which
- 1:37:30happens after the college football season ends. You have Black Monday, where everyone
- 1:37:35gets fired at the end of college at the end of the NFL season,
- 1:37:40So I would guess he'd probably coached that. So, yes, he has
- 1:37:42more suspensions than wins bowlwins at Michigan at least is an accurate statement there.
- 1:37:47Do we need to start wrapping up? Yeah? I do, Okay,
- 1:37:53Yeah, it's unfortunate. Yeah, I think we've I think we've kind of
- 1:37:56hit the big developments and if there are more developments, and boy howdy,
- 1:38:00are we expecting more developments on this at some point? We will. We'll
- 1:38:04probably hop back on at some point. There is high school football going on
- 1:38:09tonight that is also on the editorial calendar, so we have people headed into
- 1:38:15various spots. So this is not great timing, and really, Tony Petiti,
- 1:38:20Tony should have taken that into account as well. I would agree with
- 1:38:25that. This I do agree with. I don't know if it's haste and
- 1:38:28not waiting until Monday or lack of face and not doing it yesterday. Yesterday
- 1:38:31would have been much better. We all had more free schedules. But I
- 1:38:35guess that will do it. I want to thank you all. If you
- 1:38:38haven't yet, go ahead at the like on this video before you leave.
- 1:38:41I know you're trying to leave right now. Also find us at Buckeye huddle
- 1:38:43dot com. Join us, become a member there, say hello to us
- 1:38:46there on the message board, which I'm sure is hopping right now, just
- 1:38:49as this chat is not just like this chat but hopping. So that will
- 1:38:55do it. From here, thank you all for tuning in, and we'll
- 1:38:58talk to you guys later