Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 352:1-353:3

Transcript

Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 352:1-353:3 · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

0:02
Okay, good morning. I'm about to start soon bet.
0:07
Just a quick clarification. Thanks to Mordecai nests from
0:11
the Jersey. In case, we weren't clear if it
0:14
if it sinks leading the way I explained back and shin mem tet
0:19
when we say someone has doll it almost.
0:22
All right, so just to clarify, now we mentioned already but I'm
0:26
not trying to bring up right now.
0:28
As we previously mentioned for almost is either for armors or
0:34
5.6. Generally some Shock Norris far
0:36
them go by For Ramos and ashkenazim, sorry Sergeant, get
0:41
5.6 and ashkenazim. Amida, Robin and only get four.
0:47
But that's not what I wanted to bring up.
0:48
What is a little confusing we say yet?
0:51
For I must now, does that mean a straight for almost?
0:55
Does that mean you get a circumference?
0:57
You can go in every direction? Well, the circumference.
1:00
But then there's the diagonals to the a so forget or the
1:03
hypotenuse to forget about that. What I mean is you get four in
1:07
each. Direction, or do you get to in
1:09
each Direction? That various verses the younger
1:16
to be, right? But not discussing the, the
1:18
corners, exactly. So what is your forearms?
1:22
So when it comes to to Coleman, we're going to see later, that's
1:26
clear with the mission is disgusting.
1:29
And forth, particles are easy, and some, a cloak in the
1:33
mishnah. If you get four in each
1:36
Direction, which is really 8, or do you get to in these
1:39
directions? Normally helical we're going to
1:41
see we go by two in each Direction.
1:45
And but you could do for, you could choose, you could do for
1:48
in One Direction and 0 in the other.
1:51
Like, if you're stuck in a spot outside its home and you not a
1:54
lot of move, the situation if you can't move more than dollar
1:57
damos. So that's the general rule
1:59
there. We will see when it comes to
2:02
carrying, so this is a little bit.
2:07
Little bit confusing or difficult.
2:11
Exactly quantify a quarter. If everyone would agree or not
2:16
sure it's even points out someone who argues because the
2:19
fish. Obviously there's a couple
2:21
little discussions, but basically to keep it simple,
2:24
what seems to be according to the mishnah, Bora artificial
2:27
Khan, and pastas is you can only carry Four in total that would
2:33
mean for in One Direction and 0 in the other or two in each
2:38
Direction. That's for carrying by carrying
2:41
the gemara makes the distinction over there.
2:44
Duffman cut between the two but just to explain for carrying in
2:49
order to be an ester of caring hopes a dollar ammos you have to
2:52
do it, my Kira and a Hanukkah. Basically a linear distance from
2:58
one to the other Abdullah Thomas.
3:01
So if you're going back and few start off in the middle and then
3:05
you're going back and forth. Sideways sideways sideways.
3:07
That's a three in one direction, 3, in the other three and one,
3:11
and three on the other. So, in total, that's a distance
3:13
of 6. So that pass justif, you're
3:16
starting in the middle and you're going back and forth.
3:19
It beader. Abundant similar to the concept
3:22
of carrying. Paco's Tacos, mandala, Ramos.
3:26
Because it's hard to say that would be a gender Raisa because
3:29
you never really didn't like hironaka in the distance of 4
3:33
from each other. But again, there is what to be
3:36
without bail, but I just wanted to point that out that so in
3:40
that case when you have three people in the row, so they point
3:44
out that if you're in the middle and you want to take the same
3:48
movement from one side to the other, you could only max out on
3:51
two in each side, the guy in the middle can go for and one side
3:55
and 0 on. Other or two into that you can
3:58
take the same food and go back and forth and area that's
4:03
greater than 4. All right?
4:08
Shoulda known better. Once again, a quarry of a safe
4:10
word is goggle. Martius her wishes.
4:14
This is a person is up high. He's on a platform and a stage
4:18
on a roof. That's what we're discussing.
4:20
And when I say, it doesn't usually apply nowadays are
4:25
books. We don't usually read from
4:26
Scrolls, we're going to see. It could be see, Fred kodesh.
4:30
It could be non Seaford, kodesh. It could also be shards of our
4:35
him and then apply to someone playing with a yo-yo.
4:38
Having a paper towels and it runs loose, it can apply to
4:42
sheets and it's falls down. If you're hanging, it's a you
4:45
want to shake your tablecloth outside your window if you're on
4:50
a balcony or or you know, over over Russia serabian where
4:54
everything even a caramel has. So let's see.
4:58
Olive how Kariba safer Ali. Scoop a person is reading from a
5:02
safer and he's on a platform this platform.
5:05
We're assuming this case is a rusher say Kid.
5:08
It's four by four and ten high they need to gargle Russia
5:12
Academia Seaford miedo and see your hold Venetia Rosh Hashanah.
5:16
Be a do so half of it, one end of whatever you're holding,
5:21
there was playing with disgust whatever the situation is.
5:24
So anyways, here are talking about see, Fred Coalition,
5:27
actually, so half of it rolls down and the other half is still
5:32
in your hand, so it can't be a gender.
5:34
I said, there's no problem there.
5:35
I said, because you only have Malakal xhosa, if the entire
5:41
object is completely goes from one resource to another or
5:45
completely goes doll it on us. So, here you're still holding on
5:48
to it. So then you're still holding on
5:50
to it. Go to the wet.
5:51
Saw a feeling cargo hooks we are bombers.
5:53
It doesn't matter how far it goes.
5:55
You're still holding on to one end.
5:57
Roll it back up. No problem.
5:59
I mean, it's a little problem either a button, but the mice,
6:03
it happened there, so it's not a problem.
6:06
You let it take it back. Laughs you so it depends on a
6:12
few little vicious arriving by school for viciously of it even
6:16
if we're talking about a derisive this issue of Russia
6:20
sake to Russia serabian. So it's continuous emission busy
6:25
on kiss where kodesh Ichiro. So we allow this to happen, this
6:29
is the case of where it landed on.
6:31
You're standing on a platform where people are walking, how
6:36
gods are robbing Darcy all High school for people are walking on
6:39
this area. So it's the Brazilian you're
6:40
going to have, you're holding this, this scroll and part of it
6:45
or if you going to leave it there on the floor and people
6:47
walk over there. So it's a major problem.
6:50
So therefore we allow you to this, right?
6:53
The case is where we're being extra lenient but because they
6:56
on kise kodesh is if it landed on the floor we'll see if it's
7:00
still dangling in the air. We're much more.
7:02
Mako the dog God keeps me a kodesh.
7:05
The only time I made girl When we're talking about Russia siaka
7:09
to her, she has to Rob him and it's already on the floor.
7:12
So the only time we're so made girl, to lift it up.
7:14
Completely, as if when you're on a platform that people walk and
7:18
B, Zion kiss of a kodesh of all the shards.
7:21
Varia masseur. I feel enough LOL caramel is,
7:25
but by normal items, we mentioned, yo-yo paper, towels
7:28
sheets. If it's Falling onto the floor
7:33
and its resting on the floor. Then we're then remarkable just
7:38
to leave it there and not to pick it back up again.
7:43
These are all you need are abundant here because since
7:46
you're holding on to it, it's just there, there a button on,
7:48
we're afraid that. If it falls completely, then you
7:51
might come to lift it up and then lifting and you situations.
7:55
If it's your sister, Robin was an issue, the Raisa and for a
7:58
car - we're makhmur. Or because it's already in two
8:03
different ratios and we're don't care if I'm a car.
8:06
Most delicious. Yeah, he didn't to there still.
8:09
Is that gazzara? Okay.
8:13
So, I think we should continue now because it's a Carnales, the
8:18
are some who are make L even by not kiss via kodesh.
8:22
Because we just mentioned, it's a little bit like x 0, that's 0.
8:25
So it is a locket acronym if you have these other items and even
8:30
if they land on the floor in a car - wish number brings more
8:35
hawkish on. Okay, the microcast akane table
8:40
base, right base, higher kuriboh, Our God.
8:44
Now this case is your on the rooftop, we need Gago Rocha
8:49
Academia de and now falls out of your hand.
8:52
So similar case, but before it's a lower platform where people
8:55
are walking, it's a bigger design.
8:57
Here are talking about you on a rooftop and now the the scroll
9:01
is basically hanging along the wall.
9:03
So there's much less be zillion involved.
9:07
So actually, yeah, let's welcome dr.
9:09
Animo Krugman writes, as long as it doesn't reach the bottom
9:12
tent, fucking love the ground, then go low and slow.
9:18
Then you can definitely pick it up and you can even pick it up.
9:21
Even by shards of Aryan, any item that's hanging up in the
9:24
air, and you're holding on to it, even whatever.
9:28
The item is doesn't have to be Keisha Ecco this year.
9:30
A lot of, pick it up, if it's still in the air above above 10.
9:35
It's, I'm not complete or exactly.
9:38
So go a little bit so he gearless Arts.
9:40
Fuck him, fuck him. Attacked on him.
9:42
Now what happens in now you're thinking off the roof and it's
9:45
with intent fucking from the floor.
9:49
So Ima Kodama super be intentional of us.
9:52
Really go low and slow hookah Daysha.
9:55
Yeah baby design of collective. So if this scenario is very
10:01
uncommon, if it's tingling off the roof, Along a wall but the
10:07
wall is slanted and its resting. It has to be a very big slant,
10:12
it has to be slanted enough. That the item is resting on the
10:16
slanted roof. Again with gravity a might roll
10:19
off but it's resting on it. And it also has to be sloped
10:24
enough or flat enough that people use it to rest items on
10:29
its otherwise it wouldn't have a den of Russia, sir.
10:31
Robin would have a de novo wall or Or Karma list or a
10:36
caramelized. So therefore okay, it's not very
10:40
common, but as long as it's less, if it's above 10, no
10:44
problem. Below 10 is where it's a
10:46
problem. If it's going to rest a little
10:47
bit on the wall, will had a shallow yamada's are not called
10:50
active and therefore, it's in his big.
10:52
So therefore if it's less than 10 and that situation, it's a
10:55
problem. So we let you just leave it
10:58
there but it's not a bizarre. No one's going to step on it.
11:00
It's not going to really, it's not so bad, it's turn it.
11:04
So that the Letters are facing down, obviously, assuming it's
11:07
not going to get ruined if you turn it over facing down.
11:10
So then that's okay. Ve main 0ms shoo-bop.
11:14
But normally The Situation off a roof is the wall is fairly
11:18
straight vertical. So then Cole's Munch illegal
11:21
Arts go to its low as long as it doesn't touch the ground.
11:24
All the way touching the ground. It's 100% litter to pick it back
11:29
up. Vice our environments in the
11:38
Hocus and certainly by caramelized some Wacha.
11:41
But anyway, so the the mission abroad is points out the garage.
11:45
I believe he's a Dusty allocate among the coronium.
11:47
He says, once it's within 312 him out of the ground, then
11:52
there is there's an ester to pull it back up.
11:55
But my said believe, most as long as it's a module above the
12:02
ground, there's no problem to pull it up.
12:05
Okay, shoulda known gimel DNA's, easy lubricious Robin.
12:11
So these are protrusions little, could be a windowsill could be a
12:16
full balcony, porch. Something coming off the side of
12:20
a building, okay? Could be large, it could be big
12:24
Olive, she met Barton, bascinet seed a reshoot, the robbing the
12:28
him shell. Adam, hud-vash name the are go.
12:32
So the case is you have let's say 2 You have two houses next
12:37
to each other. Along the Russia Sarabi.
12:43
I'm sorry opposite sides. Exactly, two houses that are two
12:49
opposite sides of the opposite. Each other.
12:51
There are shows. Her Robin and either belongs to
12:55
one person or it's two people and they made an air of a team's
12:59
name shaving with Elizabeth Musial as there.
13:02
So now, if they want to throw it across the resistor, Robin in
13:05
the air, from one to another okay.
13:09
Eve, So if you're on the same plane, the same height, you're a
13:16
lot of throw from one to another because we assume it's not too
13:20
difficult if you are on the same plane and you're going to make
13:23
it, we're going to be able to throw it straight and it's going
13:25
to land and the other person's side the American government
13:29
have Heroes. Always rug misery in can him.
13:32
Clay Terrace the coyote by him. She me blue, you shop, bro?
13:37
So then there's a gender abandon that if Is higher than the
13:41
other, it makes it harder to throw and to land inside the
13:45
other person's balcony. So then it's uh sir to throw
13:50
from one to another unless we're talking about things that if
13:53
they fall to the ground they're going to break Paris glass
13:56
things like that because if it's things that are breakable so we
14:00
say you're going to be more careful.
14:02
So to make sure you aim otherwise you wouldn't throw it
14:05
and therefore there's no gazzara because there's only if things
14:08
are going to fall, this is if you're hanging over, it was just
14:11
a robin, the beneath you. But made of our in memoriam.
14:16
What are we talking about Brewster?
14:17
Sir Oliver has been a hem that's in between you.
14:21
It would land into a register of him about 80 might Carmelita of.
14:24
There'd been a motorbike Havana but if it's a caramel eat.
14:29
So then it's 100% motor. It's almost like a car wreck
14:32
their Alexandra and we're not going to worry about it because
14:34
even if it falls you're not going to the question is that
14:38
you re going to end, you might come to carrying it if it falls
14:41
again, I go back downstairs and pick it up and whatever.
14:44
So they You can have those issues but if it's in a
14:45
Carmelita it's a little bit like 0, then 0 it was, your intention
14:49
is for it, not to fall, so it only be in a studio album.
14:58
Right. So the mission of our points out
15:00
from the mugging of Rome that it's darker, if it's above 10,
15:04
if you threw it from one port to another, which is team at every
15:08
possible case, if it's above 10, but it's going through a mock
15:12
complete or if you're throwing it below 10, it's probably an
15:17
issue they're abundant. He says that's it.
15:21
Which is very unusual. Okay?
15:23
But yeah or like rolling it across but that okay.
15:29
Okay. But these now here, another
15:34
platform, the high nude of Hubble.
15:36
Let me know, code teller show, surabhi you have on the side of
15:40
your say, you have an apartment building on the side of your
15:43
building. Will normally see this case, if
15:47
you have, if you call it a balcony or a window sill, right
15:51
out sorek a little window platform, right outside a
15:55
window. So then so that's the case.
15:58
Zzzz Dino Hoffa, blood mean a kotler.
16:00
Sure sir Robin will see it could have walls or not have walls
16:05
depending on what scenario you come up with but the simple case
16:09
over here is there's no walls. Okay and but it's a La Mala Mia
16:14
Sara it's above 10 talking from the floor, the yeast Barbra
16:20
Barbra and it has an area of four by fours fucking.
16:25
So if there was would be Russia, say yeah, he'd either a balcony
16:30
that we have porch. But if it has no walls, it could
16:33
only be a ratio serabian with there's walls.
16:36
So hello and how B Petula, if there's a window had Is earlier,
16:42
if you have a window from the inside of the house, that leads
16:45
straight, or within three, talking at least to this
16:49
platform. It has it in of a whore, a
16:52
vicious jacket. It has an extension of a hole or
16:57
cavity, an extension of the inside of the home, which is the
17:01
richest socket. So now the window, extends onto
17:04
the porch or a whole doorway, it would it would make it even if
17:08
it didn't have four walls. You should um, Shin because the
17:12
house is 4 Walls, even though the porch wouldn't, I'm saying
17:14
if there would be a platform or a porch without for loss.
17:17
So then we stomp chimel of you're allowed to take anything
17:20
you want from inside the house to your porch, balcony, or this
17:24
platform or outside your window. NYU.
17:28
Sneezes him selim Artemis. Eventually an option.
17:32
Now, what happens if you have two platforms one above the
17:35
other, right? A second floor.
17:36
And the third floor, one tenant, on top of another one owner and
17:39
top of an owner. And It's so if it's two
17:46
different people, alpha position in La Mala Mia Sara even though
17:49
they're both above ten, twelve him so image because he's a, um,
17:54
shall we finish alone? Roja Barbara, Barr has released
17:57
a Michelle David Nation, who was shooting at smoke zishe,
18:00
attacked ever shoot. A herd of austrians are all set.
18:03
So if you have one on top of another Even if you have a
18:08
window, it's a stir because they're one on top of another
18:13
and they will need to make an air of an order to to allow it
18:17
because they're one on top of another and they're owned by two
18:21
different owners. So then you need to make an air
18:24
of an order for it. Not to be oh sir one to another.
18:28
I just had to be then they are available at Ciro's, the email
18:32
below your own arba. So I believe it's each one going
18:41
to their own house. They can't even go from their
18:44
own house to their own balcony. If they don't make an error, if
18:47
it's one on top of another Yep. I said what about the other?
18:53
They also know that they are there.
18:57
You know, let's go. Yeah, so if Need to double check
19:04
if there's windows that connect them to their own homes, or a
19:07
door that connects them to their own home.
19:11
Need to double-check the question.
19:14
Yes, however, but talked on our baahubali on in BO arba.
19:21
Now if the bottom one is 4 by 4, and the top one is not for by
19:26
480, missed Amish belly on Ella, can I get hello?
19:30
No David. So then because You have one.
19:34
I skipped one. Oh sorry, mr.
19:37
Mishkin a, I did again the, amen.
19:39
The earlier narva the gum invite act on our behalf.
19:42
It's neither of them are four by four.
19:46
So neither of them has its own shows, it's not a proper
19:50
Malcolm, neither one of them is going to oh sir, one onto the
19:53
other so mr. Hamish name so then you can use
19:56
both of them over hold a kotel, add a Sriracha parking attack
20:01
Tony and you can anywhere along the wall.
20:03
It's not a problem. As long as you don't hit within
20:06
ten twelve him of the ground. Which where is your restaurant?
20:09
When were talking about? Yeah, but talk to Ann Arbor
20:12
billion in Barba. Now what if you have the One is
20:16
four by four and the top balcony or platform is not 4x4.
20:21
It's just a little piece of wood or a little extension, and, you
20:25
know, Misha Misha belly on delicate nugget Alone.
20:28
David about bashar's issue which needs to be a colonist or least
20:33
a mesh with me. She said, she talked of
20:35
Shakalaka shoot, lots more. So, the one underneath it has,
20:39
it's a full proper reshoots, a 4x4, and the one on the top is
20:43
not. So the one on the top, One way
20:46
to explain it, is it gets basically.
20:50
It doesn't have its own Den avaricious.
20:52
Oh yeah. He'd, but whatever is opposite
20:56
the cologne itself. Not what's on the side of the
20:58
cologne, whatever is opposite, the cologne itself that still
21:02
gets the din of a hurry Richard socket so that person could
21:05
carry from his into there, but he can't care.
21:08
But he cannot carry from his finger inside his house through
21:11
his window to the side. Unless it would have been a full
21:16
Four by four. Okay, let's see.
21:23
Let me finish bed. Yeah, Mission Road points out.
21:26
One important thing that that if you we're talking about a sore
21:31
least Amish was going on your Olive, that uppercase, When you
21:39
have one on top of another, right?
21:43
What was that? Doesn't matter, doesn't matter.
21:50
Okay, I'll just try it. It's from Steve cutting, our
21:54
dark of the caelian shaft pitaka B.
21:57
So it's only a problem to carry if it's if one of the homes is
22:02
also on to another home, it's a problem to carry from inside of
22:06
your house to outside to your balcony, if the two balconies
22:11
become mustard to each other, but whatever was left on the
22:14
balcony. I've been asked mushers so
22:17
that's you're allowed to carry it in the balcony and if the the
22:23
case I think was yeah. Okay.
22:27
So we'll leave it like that. This lion Correct, right, right.
22:44
Right. Right.
22:45
Right? Okay.
22:46
Good point. So, an are cases that will
22:48
double check, but with our cases of the house, what are the
22:51
apartments, when you have a proper balcony, with proper
22:55
walls? Probably there's no problem to
22:57
have one on top of another without making an error of
23:00
you're saying. Okay.
23:01
Well we'll double-check but that sounds like a good distinction
23:05
here. We're talking about these
23:06
protrusions and that are like like a porch or is there a Shelf
23:12
with has no railing all the way around.
23:14
Okay. Guillermo Cole's.
23:18
He's hired say, ollivier is just a robin.
23:22
Okay, so now any of these protrusions right?
23:27
That are hanging over a show serabian Scimitar least on my
23:30
shillelagh. When we say you're allowed to
23:32
use them from inside to outside because Shroomish damage for a
23:36
national event, not only manual Equus ferus is who he took
23:39
science Abraham. So here we're talking about
23:41
there's no walls it's just a protrusion and things can fall
23:44
off, right? So he says, you're only allowed
23:47
to put things there. That are things that are
23:50
valuable things that are not going to break.
23:52
That's it is things that not love that the valuable things
23:55
that are that you're afraid. You don't want them to break
23:58
because they are breakable, okay.
24:00
It said to him, she in, you flourishes are robbing me shavoo
24:03
there. If they fall down are going to
24:04
break about shark alien. I saw him but other kalium are
24:08
us to things that are non-breakable shama, you blue
24:11
Larissa, Robin William. So then if it's April protrusion
24:17
a shelf, that's over a Russia serabian, which is the Raisa.
24:21
So then you can put anything there that might fall off.
24:24
If it's, if it's a not break. Double the doubt because these
24:28
Ohio table, but that's only by just a little shelf or even who
24:32
rocks at dvaraka God. But if it's a shelf, that's huge
24:36
or big shelf that you can stand on, it doesn't have to be so big
24:39
but enough to be able to stand on their sheemish Tommy Rush, Oh
24:43
made shamim a clear that you could stand there with Ackley
24:47
then we Charley stomach bakala killing.
24:49
Then it's not a problem because we're not afraid, it's going to
24:51
fall off, it's not so narrow. It's not so small.
24:54
The IAM he has he's Elka David. You'll say I love your caramel
24:57
is and if it's a if it's over, if you have onesies and it's
25:05
overhanging a Karma lists which is usually the situation, but
25:08
again it depends where you are. So if it's a onesie so you don't
25:12
have to worry about a ravine as one owner onesies you.
25:16
Don't worry about everything and it's a caramel East Coast should
25:19
have Australia. Hola much.
25:20
I was long as it's above 10, it's always going to be motor to
25:23
carry from your window inside and outside it to the jury.
25:26
Malcolm a tour or whoever is just yeah.
25:28
Feed, they know have been kids, are bigger small but feel.
25:32
Okay, Liam, shaming stubborn. Even if it's things that don't
25:35
break, we don't have to worry about it.
25:36
She look as real the caramel, it was over a caramel eat.
25:39
They didn't make any of these type of zeros my competitor for
25:44
sure is matter if it's over a mile competitor but it's very
25:48
hard to have a the ground am a competitor because it's less
25:52
than four by four but yeah. Okay I think we'll just stop