Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Understanding NCUA's National Supervision Policy Manual (NSPM) and Examiner's Guide
Transcript
- 0:01Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:04Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:07your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:10The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:13Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:15If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:18team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:23and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:25com to find out more.
- 0:27Hey everyone.
- 0:28This is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:32I'm excited today that we're going to be talking about the
- 0:34national supervision policy manual and the NCUA examiner's guide.
- 0:39I've got two Of my team members here that if you're a longtime listener,
- 0:43you're very familiar with them.
- 0:45Todd Miller and Steve Farr, guys, how you doing today?
- 0:48Doing well.
- 0:49Yeah.
- 0:49Up, up by Glacier park today.
- 0:51So it's gotta be a good day.
- 0:53Living the dream, living the dream.
- 0:56Hey let's for, we may have We got a lot of long time listeners, but we
- 1:00might have someone who stumbled across us here the first time, either based
- 1:03on the topic and a Google search or who knows just a new listener.
- 1:07So Todd, if you could give a little bit of your background at NCUA for those
- 1:11that are listening what you did at NCUA before you, you switched teams with
- 1:16Steve Steve and I to help credit unions.
- 1:19Sure.
- 1:19I spent about 34 years with N.
- 1:21C.
- 1:22U.
- 1:22A.
- 1:22I can break my career down into about three different parts.
- 1:26I spent a decade or so as an examiner and a problem case officer.
- 1:30Then I spent a decade or so as a capital market specialist.
- 1:34I had a lost year at West Corps, basically after NCOA conserved it,
- 1:38where I spent time there under you.
- 1:40Then I spent about the last 11 years of my career as a Director of
- 1:44Special Actions in the Western Region supervising troubled credit unions,
- 1:48problem case officers, capital market specialists, got to sit on a lot of
- 1:52internal committees at NCOA during that time, was a member of their supervisory
- 1:57review committee for handling appeals, so an enjoyable 34 years all together.
- 2:04Very good.
- 2:05Yeah.
- 2:05Interesting times.
- 2:06And on that last year, I was the acting director of the
- 2:09corporate program at the time.
- 2:11We had some retire, retirements at NCUA and of course the corporate crisis.
- 2:16And I was thinking the other day, relative to that funny
- 2:19story, at least it's funny to me.
- 2:21I used to read books on the way out to California when we were doing
- 2:24the West core conservatorship.
- 2:27And I was watching a TV show a couple of years back and I thought, you know what?
- 2:31I think these are the books I read.
- 2:32And it was Bosch on Amazon prime.
- 2:34So I was, I think I read every Bosch book known to mankind on the flights to
- 2:39West core and then on the red eyes back, I would listen to Dave Matthews band
- 2:45live with Tim Reynolds in Las Vegas.
- 2:48Cause it was acoustic and it was easy to listen to.
- 2:51And after about six months of doing the red eyes, my wife finally told
- 2:55me, I don't know why you do that.
- 2:57Cause when you come back you're angry.
- 2:58So you might as well stay another day.
- 3:01Yeah.
- 3:01All right, Steve let's hear let's hear your NCUA synopsis
- 3:06of the time you spent at NCUA.
- 3:08Yeah, I'm gonna Gary my comments specific kind of the topic of the day and that
- 3:13helpful and that my career is really to two parts versus Todd's three.
- 3:17And then I spent the 15 years as in the examiner ranks out in the credit unions.
- 3:24And as a problem case officer, I was involved in a lot of
- 3:27administrative actions and few conservatorships and a lot of items
- 3:32that are covered in today's subject.
- 3:34And I was a big user, of course, of the examiner guide, and then I spent the
- 3:41last half of my career in an additional 15 plus years in the central office.
- 3:46Where we would be working on, the development of guidance and super,
- 3:50the NCUA supervisory letters and those types of things that were
- 3:54produced to try and help examiners and credit unions understand the
- 3:59regulations and what NCUA is doing.
- 4:02I think those parts of my career will come in handy today.
- 4:04Yeah, I'm looking forward to this chat.
- 4:07And I remember, I started on Columbus day, 1986.
- 4:11They gave me, my first day was a annual holiday and they told me that
- 4:16the paperwork was too hard to start me on a Tuesday and I asked my trainer
- 4:20what I should do and he said, pull out the examiner guide and read it.
- 4:23Pull out the federal credit union act and read it.
- 4:25And I remember that beautiful blue binder with those really
- 4:29slick connectors on the side.
- 4:31It was the coolest binder I've ever seen in my life.
- 4:33Bye.
- 4:34I think I might have finally gotten rid of that.
- 4:36But yeah, it was Todd, I think you might still have it or he's
- 4:39looking to see if he has it.
- 4:41Hey, this is a podcast.
- 4:42You couldn't see Todd move, but he looked like he was checking to
- 4:45see if it was there on the shelf.
- 4:46So anyway.
- 4:48If it is, it's down on the library in the basement.
- 4:52I might have gotten rid of it, but yes, I carried that blue
- 4:55binder around for many years.
- 4:57It was quote unquote our NCOA Bible there for a while.
- 5:00All the answers were between those two blue blue binders.
- 5:05Very good.
- 5:05All right.
- 5:06So, who wants to go first?
- 5:07We've got the NSPM, which came later.
- 5:09We've got the examiner guide, but maybe a little bit of history of
- 5:13how we got here to kick this off.
- 5:16I can start on that and Steve can fill in the blanks if he would like,
- 5:20or we'll let Steve talk and I'll fill in the blanks if he likes.
- 5:24Yeah, we, the, one of the things that I wanted to up is we'll talk
- 5:27about the history of, the exam guides been around, before we, we were
- 5:31even around in some shape or form.
- 5:33But the one that caught my attention was.
- 5:36Let's talk about the newer document, the National Supervision Policy Manual,
- 5:41and why did that even, get developed?
- 5:44I was at a conference when the first discussion came through, and
- 5:47that the NSUI board is going to require that we put together this,
- 5:51basically, a procedure manual.
- 5:54And so I wonder if you guys have the thoughts as to remembering why that
- 5:58came about, and see if they match what my recollection on that is.
- 6:02So I have Todd, you go ahead.
- 6:05I have some definite thoughts on it, but let Todd go ahead.
- 6:08I think the two are really tied together in a lot of, respects, because as
- 6:13the NSPM, the National Supervision Policy Manual came into being,
- 6:18NCUA de emphasizes the exam guide.
- 6:20But back when Mark, Steve, and I started, that exam guide was our primary
- 6:25document that told us how to do our job.
- 6:28It was in hard copy, the internet really, none of that was online back then.
- 6:33And they even mailed up updates, we got little packets.
- 6:36Take out this page, put in this page.
- 6:38But over time, the regions all had developed their own different ways of
- 6:43actually doing their work, their project plans for the year, how they administered
- 6:49exams, how they put in place, enforcement actions, how they wrote doors, findings
- 6:56became like six little different agencies.
- 6:58There were some similarities there.
- 7:00You had an exam guide that tied them together, but each regional
- 7:04director and directors of supervision had a huge influence on how each
- 7:08of the regions were operated.
- 7:10And as examiners would sometimes work on teams that crossed regions that
- 7:15created challenges because they would do their work a little different way.
- 7:18So you'd have some.
- 7:19These internal issues when examiners worked across regional lines.
- 7:23And we did that sometimes when there were staff shortages.
- 7:26And the other thing is credit unions, it's a small world.
- 7:29They all talk to each other.
- 7:31And so they knew about all the differences too.
- 7:33And complaints would find their way back to NCUA board members.
- 7:37And I believe it was Ms.
- 7:39Matz was the chairman when the first and SPM came out, I might be
- 7:43wrong about that, but I think it was mismatch when they first came out.
- 7:47It's Matt said, Hey, this is not acceptable.
- 7:50The regions need to all be on the same page.
- 7:52And that led to that first national supervision policy manual as a way to
- 7:58get the regions on the same page and doing their work and administrating
- 8:01their programs in the same manner.
- 8:03And as that NSPM came out, there was a D emphasis on the exam guide.
- 8:09Over time.
- 8:11There's more and more has been put into the NSPM.
- 8:13It's up to 427 pages now, but it gives you a pretty good idea how
- 8:19NCUA supervises and administers their exam and enforcement programs.
- 8:27Steve, anything you want to care to add to Todd's synopsis there?
- 8:32All I can remember is because I was at a conference with, it was basically all
- 8:36of E and I was at it and this word came down on that and we had that normal
- 8:41reaction on resistance to change, the same as credit unions deal with
- 8:46when something comes along and that.
- 8:48We were like, Oh, man, why in the world do we need this?
- 8:50This is going to be, nothing but trouble.
- 8:52And, and plus, I think we were thinking that it's going to be
- 8:55a lot of work to put together.
- 8:56I remember that initial resistance to change it.
- 8:59My recollection is same as Todd in that there was probably just a particular
- 9:03couple issues that made it all the way up for board actions or something that were
- 9:07done quite differently between regions and the credit unions involved were being.
- 9:12Pretty animate, probably correctly.
- 9:14So about why are we being treated differently depending
- 9:17on what region we're in?
- 9:19Yep.
- 9:19You, both of your memories are similar to mine and Todd, you were all right.
- 9:24It was a board member, Debbie Matz that, that pushed for this.
- 9:28And I can remember.
- 9:29So I transitioned from regional director.
- 9:33To executive director on January 1, 2013, and I can specifically remember
- 9:40being at a meeting where we also had a regional director meeting.
- 9:47There was also it was either the kickoff meeting to the N.
- 9:50S.
- 9:50P.
- 9:50M.
- 9:50or the 2nd or 3rd meeting of the N.
- 9:53S.
- 9:53P.
- 9:53M.
- 9:53And I can remember.
- 9:55My representative in region one at the time, Albany was Rebecca Palowiczynski,
- 10:00Sherry Freed at the time, who by the way is about to retire from
- 10:04NCUA was a representative, I think from the Western region at the time.
- 10:11And that introduced the topic of layering.
- 10:14The concept was the age, the board would come out with a regulation,
- 10:18NCUA would come out with some guidance, and then Todd, as you
- 10:22said, the regions would layer.
- 10:24Their own thoughts on top of that and layering became banned and the only
- 10:29way that something could be changed would be via this new vehicle, the N.
- 10:34S.
- 10:34P.
- 10:34M.
- 10:34And that would be through this committee.
- 10:36So if a regional director in the old ways said, you know what?
- 10:40A code three.
- 10:41I don't want to do 90 day contacts.
- 10:43I want to do 73 day contacts.
- 10:45They could do something like that.
- 10:46Now, if they wanted to float that idea, it had to come to this committee.
- 10:51And as there are no in the whole planet, there are no statues for
- 10:56committees because committees tend to slow things down.
- 10:58Sometimes they make things better, but it made NCUA more consistent, but
- 11:02it made them a little bit less nimble and a little bit more bureaucratic.
- 11:06And we might tip into some of that bureaucracy, say that
- 11:10bureaucracy a little bit later.
- 11:12But yeah, that's the interesting times, those transitions.
- 11:17I have a story kind of related to that.
- 11:18So I was the director of special actions.
- 11:20The first one came out for staff comment, and a lot of the policies and
- 11:25procedures in that very first one that came out for staff comment exempted
- 11:30the division of special actions.
- 11:32Then the actual first version came out, all those exemptions were gone.
- 11:36So I didn't put a lot of comment in it because, Hey, I'm exempt from all of this.
- 11:40I'm exempt from all of this.
- 11:42And then when actually version one comes out, I'm no longer exempt from it.
- 11:46Even the direct vision of special actions, which does
- 11:49quite often have to move quickly.
- 11:52Now they had to follow every single thing in the guide to where in
- 11:56the first draft version divisions of special actions were exempt.
- 11:59So I wasn't very happy with the first version when I found I had
- 12:02to follow all of it when I read the comment version, which said I didn't.
- 12:07Might have been, that might been, they change it pretty frequently.
- 12:09You mentioned 2013.
- 12:10They're on version 22.
- 12:1222 Now, they do tend to change it every year, but as the board changes
- 12:17policies and procedures, they do make midyear changes to it on occasion.
- 12:21'cause in 10 years we're up to version 22, 22 versions.
- 12:27Go ahead, Steve.
- 12:28So the owner of the NSPM that is, am I correct?
- 12:32It is the Office of Examination and Insurance or is it the
- 12:36committee itself, Todd?
- 12:38It's, it is the E& I director.
- 12:41Correct.
- 12:41Correct.
- 12:42And 22 versions and every version they seem to redact a little bit more
- 12:47which is a podcast all for its own.
- 12:50But Todd you had talked about how, everything was in
- 12:53hard copy when we started.
- 12:54And then there was, then initially there was an examiner guide that
- 12:58went on the webpage that was very consistent, it might've been outdated,
- 13:02but it didn't change very often.
- 13:04And then that started to be updated more frequently.
- 13:07But then for whatever reason, NCUA.
- 13:11Either redacts or provides dead links on a lot of things that used to be in
- 13:17earlier versions available, which is frustrating as we try to help clients.
- 13:21It's frustrating for Credit unions, when they're trying to figure out
- 13:26what it is, NCWA's expectations are.
- 13:29And it's frustrating for me when I compare it to what FDIC does.
- 13:33And that, again, that's a topic for a whole other podcast.
- 13:36It's a topic for a FOIA request that I just never seemed to get
- 13:39around to doing but any thoughts on what you've seen there?
- 13:42Any, I think maybe a little bit more history is relevant and maybe we should
- 13:47talk about it a little bit, because at one time the exam guide was the
- 13:50primary document examiners used to do their job, then the NSPM came out now
- 13:57the exam guide is turned into kind of a mismatch of different things and it's.
- 14:03A good reference general reference document, but it's not very current.
- 14:08It's a mixture of a web based access and some of it is still the old
- 14:13PDF chapters that we use before but it hasn't been kept very current.
- 14:18I know they started a project to make it all web based.
- 14:21He's probably eight or nine years ago, and it's still not finished.
- 14:24If you go to that exam guide, there's a lot of areas.
- 14:28Where if you click on it, it will say content still under development.
- 14:32There's not an easy way to print it out a chapter.
- 14:35What I would say about the exam guide is each section has a workplace or a
- 14:41reference section and work paper section.
- 14:44Those are useful, all the references there.
- 14:48That's probably the only useful piece of the exam guide that's left.
- 14:52Is all that reference because then it gives you citations to regulations
- 14:56to some of the OCC documents to some of the FDIC documents.
- 15:01Page one of the exam guide there is a disclaimer.
- 15:06This is not a strict requirement unless it's noted by law or regulation.
- 15:10So they disclaim a lot of it.
- 15:12You can tell there's different authors because the new chapters are somewhat
- 15:15inconsistent, but I do think we should maybe just talk a little bit about.
- 15:20Agency transparency, because the exam guide used to be transparent
- 15:24about what examiners do.
- 15:26Now they've moved to the NSPM, where it's transparent about processes and
- 15:31supervision, but their exam processes themselves are no longer transparent.
- 15:36Under ARIES, you had questionnaires, so examiners could, or credit
- 15:40unions could do a self assessment of how they're doing according to
- 15:43what their examiners would look at.
- 15:46As NCUA is moved to MERIT, They've done away with most of the questionnaires
- 15:51and they have what are called job aids.
- 15:54None of those are public anymore.
- 15:56That's how the examiners do their exams.
- 15:59Part Aims have no access to any of those unless maybe an
- 16:03examiner gives them to them.
- 16:06So they're all hidden away.
- 16:08Within the NSPM quite often there are links to some of these checklists.
- 16:13There's references to some of this stuff.
- 16:16Most of that is links to MCUA SharePoint.
- 16:19So the public can't see it.
- 16:21There are some areas that I have notes of what's redacted.
- 16:23So we might as well just run through it really quick.
- 16:26That would be great.
- 16:26I would love to hear the notes of what's redacted.
- 16:30Oh, there's a lot of broken links, but there are specific
- 16:33sections that are redacted.
- 16:35There's parts of the administrative actions chapter that are
- 16:40redacted and blacked out.
- 16:41I suspect some of that is their kind of decision tree is when they move
- 16:45from one to the other, but I don't know that because it's redacted.
- 16:48There's pieces to changes in officials that are redacted.
- 16:53And I think a lot of that is just how NCUA researches those officials backgrounds.
- 16:58So it's some privacy type information.
- 17:00Under district management, this is the one redaction that I don't understand at all.
- 17:06They redact almost half of what is related to concentration risk reviews.
- 17:13So concentration risk has caused NCUA the greatest number of losses.
- 17:18But within the redacted area, they have triggers as to what they
- 17:22consider excessive concentrations and what they expect examiners to do.
- 17:27Those triggers are redacted.
- 17:28So NCA is very open about where their triggers are for interest rate risk.
- 17:33You have a pretty good idea where their triggers are for liquidity risk, but the
- 17:37area that causes them the most losses, concentration risk, they're not going
- 17:42to tell you where their thresholds are.
- 17:44I have a form that says this is what we look through when you have
- 17:48concentrations above a certain limit.
- 17:51And that form basically is these are the steps they look to mitigate risk.
- 17:55Something that examiners would, or accreditings would like to know.
- 17:59What are processes that we have to manage our concentration risk?
- 18:02Totally redacted.
- 18:04NCUA has a job aid on concentration risk.
- 18:07Tells examiners how to review concentration risk.
- 18:10It would be helpful for accrediting to build out their risk management processes.
- 18:14Totally redacted.
- 18:17They do have a letter out on concentration risk.
- 18:19It's not as specific as that job aid or what's in that
- 18:24actual concentration risk form.
- 18:27So I find it somewhat interesting that their area of greatest risk is
- 18:30where the agency is least transparent about what their comfort levels are.
- 18:34When you put it, when you put it that way, that's a pretty powerful statement.
- 18:38And this is redacted, not dead link, right?
- 18:41This is blacked out, right?
- 18:44And, to redact something there, there has to be a legal reason not to provide it.
- 18:50And I was going to say.
- 18:53The word guarantee you is on my mind here.
- 18:57I want to say I'll guarantee you that all those redactions have not been reviewed by
- 19:02the Office of General Counsel, especially by the volume of them coming up.
- 19:06And if the redactions have been reviewed.
- 19:08I absolutely guarantee you that with the number of dead links that they've
- 19:13got, that has not been reviewed.
- 19:15And I remember a time where I was in the audience and a board member
- 19:19had to testify to Congress and they had to testify on a certain topic.
- 19:25But the topic that came up was the redaction.
- 19:29Of a state, a document that the state that was very interested in related to the
- 19:36overhead transfer calculations, and they had redacted all sorts of things because
- 19:41it would have made the discussion with NASCS easier and became a challenging.
- 19:48Discussion with Congress for the chairman of N.
- 19:52C.
- 19:52U.
- 19:52A.
- 19:52They went around and they turned around and were ordered to go
- 19:55back and look at it and re redact.
- 19:57Make sure that they have legal reason to not redact some of that.
- 20:02And it turned out that it was staff didn't want to release it.
- 20:05It wasn't stuff that should have been.
- 20:07Redacted.
- 20:08But in this instance, Todd, you nail you really nailed the issue of redaction
- 20:13with a very fine point here that the agency loses money when they put too
- 20:19many, when credit unions put too many eggs in one basket and here they are.
- 20:23Having these rules in a black box, not explaining it to the industry.
- 20:28And we've had conversations with some credit unions where that has
- 20:31turned out to be very frustrating.
- 20:33And I just, I don't think.
- 20:36I'm sure they could make a legal argument if they want to, but it would
- 20:40be good for credit unions to know where those guardrails are, right?
- 20:44I think it would, and like I said, it would help them round out their own
- 20:48governance and risk management processes because those expectations are laid out in
- 20:53those questionnaires and in that examiner guidance or job aid is what they call it.
- 20:59They choose to not share that with us.
- 21:01Especially when we're seeing an increase of NCUA saying you need to really justify
- 21:05what your concentration risks are.
- 21:07Again, it would be good to have those guardrails.
- 21:09Steve, any thoughts on this?
- 21:11General topic.
- 21:12Yeah, and doing kind of research for this and some other items
- 21:15we've been working on lately.
- 21:17I, I looked up this interagency statement on clarifying the
- 21:20role of supervisory guidance.
- 21:22It was came out in 2018 and it's by the federal reserve, FDIC, NCOA office.
- 21:29So control their currency, and one of the bullet points on there is the agencies
- 21:33intend to limit the use of numerical thresholds or other bright lines in
- 21:37describing expectations and supervisory guidance that creates a problem.
- 21:42Because we say, everybody would like to know what the examiners are looking
- 21:47at in terms of the bright lines, for lack of a better term in what
- 21:52is considered a concentration risk.
- 21:55They didn't eliminate the bright lines.
- 21:58They just hit them.
- 21:59Yeah, and yeah, so I don't know how that sits in terms of this and
- 22:03it's we have numerical thresholds.
- 22:07Is it because of this that we don't disclose it?
- 22:09But if the examiners have it, then they have the same effect because
- 22:12they're managing to those items.
- 22:14It's certainly in the best interest for credit unions to
- 22:16be able to know where those are.
- 22:19And then with, proper other Guidance and issues and how those will be looked at.
- 22:24But that information is so useful.
- 22:27If the examiner is using numerical thresholds, yeah, the
- 22:31cranes seem to know about it.
- 22:32Cause there's, they do pretty good documentation on where we're at with some
- 22:36of those interest rate risk measures.
- 22:38And that those are out there and they've, they work pretty hard on saying, the
- 22:43Canadians can have their own, but it has created a lot of friction.
- 22:47And I'm sure Todd, you'll have that's additional thoughts on this.
- 22:50Like the interest rate response, and this is the same way with
- 22:52their internal concentration.
- 22:55Targets their scope determinants determines that whole exam scope
- 23:00and it lays out expectations for governance, with the interest rate
- 23:04risk and their supervisory test they say, okay, you hit these targets.
- 23:08We're going to look at your processes a lot more closely.
- 23:11And they specifically say these are not limits on the institution.
- 23:15It's when our risk thresholds are triggered and we're going to spend
- 23:19more time and effort on looking at how you manage interest rate risk.
- 23:22This is the same thing with the concentration risk.
- 23:26I know cause I was on the committee that helped develop them and the job
- 23:29aides and the whole forum that they use.
- 23:32And it becomes a scope determinant.
- 23:34And it would be helpful for the industry to know what those are.
- 23:39It would be helpful for them to even see the job age because here's
- 23:43what we're going to look through concentration risk governance.
- 23:46And I would say this with all the job aids and merit.
- 23:49With areas you had the questionnaires, credit unions could do a self assessment
- 23:53of their risk management process and all those different areas and how many
- 23:57questionnaires were in that workbook.
- 23:58But they covered pretty much every area of operation.
- 24:02They have these job aids and merit now, and none of those
- 24:05are transparent and available.
- 24:07So credit unions They have to use basically external types of information
- 24:12to do their own self assessment.
- 24:14The FDIC, the comptroller, the currency, they're very transparent in their
- 24:18exam processes of their documents.
- 24:21MCUA used to be under merit, not so much anymore.
- 24:25But just a couple other things that are redacted in the NSPM.
- 24:29There's the development of critical case in this case list.
- 24:32It's an internal thing.
- 24:34Really no benefit for credit needs to know how the regions do that.
- 24:38It doesn't impact them in any way.
- 24:41There's some documentation requirements for contact shorter than eight hours.
- 24:46Industry probably doesn't need to know that.
- 24:48There's a whole section on the fiscal program and enforcement
- 24:51actions that are blacked out.
- 24:53It's not blacked out for the federals, but it's blacked out for FISCUs.
- 24:57And I'm not sure exactly what that is.
- 24:59It's probably things dealing with the state regulators is probably why they have
- 25:03it blacked out, although I don't know.
- 25:05And then the entire quality assurance program is blacked out.
- 25:11And, would that help Cardenas or not?
- 25:14Maybe not.
- 25:15It would explain why some of them are taking months and months and
- 25:18months to get their exams up.
- 25:21Months and months.
- 25:22And we haven't had one that took a year yet.
- 25:24Got one that came close.
- 25:26But that's an interesting list.
- 25:28And again, I've got it on my baby someday I'll send some letters or some
- 25:35FOIA requests to NCUA to get a little bit of this information to improve.
- 25:41The transparency for our clients and perhaps to discuss here on the podcast.
- 25:46Okay.
- 25:47And Todd, when you were talking about, the examiner's guides outdated,
- 25:50the NSPM is really taken its place.
- 25:52And then of course, there's letters to credit unions,
- 25:54which are official guidance.
- 25:56And then there's the the reference section, which you said is
- 25:59the key of the examiner guide.
- 26:01I'm trying to remember.
- 26:02I.
- 26:03I don't recall seeing or having discussions with any clients
- 26:07where we saw NCUA refer back.
- 26:11To the examiner guide or refer back to the N.
- 26:14S.
- 26:14P.
- 26:14M.
- 26:15They'll refer back to guidance, but not the N.
- 26:18S.
- 26:18P.
- 26:18M.
- 26:18Or examiner's guide.
- 26:19You guys agree with that?
- 26:21That was part of mismatch.
- 26:22This thing to change doors and findings to specific regulatory citations.
- 26:30Either the act regulation letters to credit unions.
- 26:35So there, I don't remember that we ever referenced the exam guide, most sections,
- 26:41like I said, in that reference section, they will list out all the regulations
- 26:45that are applicable to that chapter.
- 26:46They'll have links to, some of the other regulatory agencies.
- 26:51Sometimes they'll cite the other regulatory agency,
- 26:53but it's not an actual link.
- 26:55You would have to go to the other regulatory agency and search it.
- 26:58Quite often in the web based exam guide, there's links to the NSPM,
- 27:02but it takes you to page one because they change the NSPM frequently.
- 27:07So they don't give you links to the appropriate chapter in the NSPM.
- 27:11It just makes you go search the NSPM.
- 27:14I can understand why they do that.
- 27:16Cause the exam guide is very slow to change.
- 27:19It goes through a committee process, and it seems to be at the bottom of
- 27:22E& I's list of things to update, and like I said, it's fallen out of use as
- 27:27they've buried all these job aids within the merit exam program, so examiners
- 27:32don't reference it very often, so I can understand why it's low on NCUA's priority
- 27:37list and why sometimes They don't have links to actual places because those
- 27:43links get outdated and frustrations.
- 27:46But by giving titles of things to look up, it's helpful.
- 27:50And like I said, in the exam guide, those reference sections at the end of each
- 27:53chapter can be very helpful if credit unions are searching on a specific topic.
- 27:58I don't know that cardings use it very much anymore because
- 28:00like I said, it's very difficult.
- 28:02You can't download a chapter to a pdf.
- 28:05You can download the nspm and search it.
- 28:07You can't do that with the exam guide anymore.
- 28:10So it's a difficult to use reference source.
- 28:14And I'll put a link to the in the show notes to the link to the redacted version
- 28:19of the NSPM that we're referring to now.
- 28:22I mentioned exam reports and, what you can cite to.
- 28:25And we've got a couple great podcasts coming up that weave into the NSPM
- 28:30guide, the examiner's guide, et cetera.
- 28:32But on camel code threes, what do you do now that your camel code 3?
- 28:36What do you do now that your camel code 4?
- 28:38What do you do when NCUA asks to meet with your board of
- 28:42directors without the CEO present?
- 28:44And we also have one that either has come out just before or just after this one
- 28:50that will be on document resolutions and project management as it relates to that.
- 28:55So a lot of good content coming to your regular listeners as you gear
- 28:59up, as you get out of summer and you gear up for your next exam.
- 29:03So what?
- 29:04Anything else?
- 29:05Go ahead.
- 29:05Go ahead, Todd.
- 29:06One little side light on the N.
- 29:08S.
- 29:08P.
- 29:08M.
- 29:08And the exam guide.
- 29:10I said they don't keep the exam guide links currents.
- 29:12They usually due to the N.
- 29:13S.
- 29:13P.
- 29:14M.
- 29:14But the N.
- 29:15S.
- 29:15P.
- 29:15M.
- 29:15References the exam guide into several specific areas with enforcement actions.
- 29:20It references specifically chapters 29 and 30 of the exam guide in multiple places.
- 29:26But those chapters of the exam guide are not available to the public.
- 29:31I don't know that it was intentional, but they're not there.
- 29:35I firmly believe that There's some intent and there's some
- 29:38just, oops that's going on.
- 29:39Just be again, because it's hard to keep all the links, alive and running,
- 29:42which is a good segue to the fact that Steve, in, in your former life at NCUA,
- 29:47you wrote NCUA's enforcement manual, there is a redacted version out there
- 29:51that I have a redacted version of that.
- 29:54If anybody's interested in getting it, but any thoughts on the
- 29:57enforcement chapters being gone or enforcement in general, Steve.
- 30:01The enforcement manual was actually issued as an incident.
- 30:04A instruction has had to do with the politics of the
- 30:08ensue board at that moment.
- 30:10So that's a whole nother story.
- 30:121 thing that we've found in the Nspn with our clients, we worked with is the.
- 30:18Process that deals with the processing of administrative actions.
- 30:23So it's been really helpful for the Koreans to know that they have to
- 30:27respond within 30 days or whatever.
- 30:29And we're able to point them as to those time frames that they become
- 30:33subject to with some notices and in response to those particularly.
- 30:39Administrative actions, I think was, has been a part of it that
- 30:43we've shared with our clients more regular than any other parts.
- 30:48Yeah, that's a great point that and and of course, the 30 days to
- 30:51appeal, we have a separate podcast on appeals, a couple of separate
- 30:54podcasts on appeals that are out there.
- 30:57Generally speaking, appeals you have to, they make sense.
- 31:00If depending on how you define victory of an appeal, because it's
- 31:05hard to get something overturned, but sometimes you can get.
- 31:08Your point made or a few things changed, but not when the like a camel
- 31:12code overgrade override, for example.
- 31:14But now I'm going down a rabbit hole.
- 31:17If you're interested in appeals, check that out on another podcast.
- 31:21Very good guys.
- 31:22Any last thoughts here as we wrap up any questions I should have asked you as
- 31:25it relates to the examiner guide or N.
- 31:27S.
- 31:27P.
- 31:27M.
- 31:28or any thoughts you want to make sure we hit.
- 31:30I would just say for credit unions, if they want to dig into the NSPM, the
- 31:36chapters to look at for the most part that impact them are those chapters on
- 31:41district management, it explains how your examiners behave and schedule things.
- 31:46Then there's separate chapters for federal programs and FSCU programs.
- 31:51Those chapters will lay out how the whole exam process and timeline works in.
- 31:58If you just look at nothing else just look at those and it'll give you a
- 32:01general idea of how your examiners are operating and how your exams get
- 32:06scheduled and things of that nature.
- 32:09If you want to look at a regulatory waiver, for any reason, whether
- 32:13it's for derivatives, for non member deposits, for bank purchases, mergers,
- 32:18there is a chapter in the NSPM on regulatory waivers that covers all
- 32:22of that, which credit unions might find helpful if they're seeking one
- 32:29of those specific regulatory waivers.
- 32:31I will say that unless it's changed, the bank purchase had
- 32:37some deadlinks and that's what actually got me onto the topic.
- 32:41In my mind of a potential FOIA because they issued a proposed rule saying they
- 32:45were going to clarify What it takes to get a bank purchase and that it would be
- 32:50in the nspm Then they never issued the final rule, but the nspm is redacted.
- 32:55So that was I actually went to nsu and talked to him a little bit about
- 32:58that which led me to the point where I had to do a FOIA and just haven't
- 33:02got around to it Very good guys.
- 33:04This is this has been a lot of fun bringing back some old.
- 33:07You Old memories.
- 33:08I never expected to bring up Bosch and Dave Matthews in the
- 33:12same podcast, I did here today.
- 33:14So that's kind of cool.
- 33:16Thanks guys.
- 33:17Have a great day.
- 33:19And this is Mark Treichel.
- 33:20I want to thank you, the listener for listening.
- 33:22I hope you'll listen to it again soon.
- 33:23Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.
- 33:31Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 33:36your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 33:39of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 33:44If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 33:47out our services at marktreichel.
- 33:49com.