Latest / The Long for Truth Show / When Charismatics Get Christ and the Trinity Wrong: With Chris Rosebrough
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to the Long for Truth podcast. I'm Robin Long. Join my husband
- 0:06Dan and I as we explore the roots of the early Pentecostal and Charismatic movements,
- 0:11and we shine a light on false doctrines and false teachers in the modern
- 0:15church. Let's get started. You know the way you have to memorize theology
- 0:25and doctrines. Of course, it don't work. We believe that there's one
- 0:31God, but we believe that there are three expressions of God. God the
- 0:39Father has a body, he sits on the throne, he has arms,
- 0:43he has legs, doors of his ad Jesus does too, So this Holy
- 0:47Spirit is just invisible. It was interesting to note that one of the fullest
- 0:51classes that we had on Wednesday night has been on the Holy Spirit itself.
- 0:57He is the personality of God reveal through human bodies. God is not limited
- 1:04by physical dimensions, and I know you know that, but he never really
- 1:10leaves. Okay, however, he does change forms. In coming to the
- 1:19earth. The word became flash, so that the flash, as I said,
- 1:23can become the word. Jesus laid aside his deity, and he said
- 1:29he considered being equal with God is nothing. He laid that aside. This
- 1:34is so that he could say legally, you are going to do the same
- 1:41things that I'm doing, and even greater things. He could not say that
- 1:47if he did them as a son of God. My theology is spot on.
- 1:51Hello everyone, welcome along for truth. My name is Daniel Long.
- 1:55Today we are going to be discussing trinitarian and Christilogical heresies within the modern charismatic
- 2:02movement. Now this is super important because even though the clips of the pastors
- 2:09and teachers that we're going to show you may not outright deny the Trinity,
- 2:14or deny the personal union of Christ, or deny the deity of Christ,
- 2:21whenever they try to explain it, they get it wrong. So I have
- 2:25got some help today talking about this. Joining me is my good friend,
- 2:30Pastor Chris Rosebrow. Pastor Chris rosebro is the pastor of Kongsvinger Lutheran Church in
- 2:36Oslo, Minnesota. He is also the host of the Fighting for the Faith
- 2:40YouTube channel and podcast. And I think he's been on issues etc. As
- 2:46a guest about a thousand times. Now, is that about right? I've
- 2:51lost track. It's been a lot many times, all right, all right,
- 2:54So we are going to be discussing this really important doctrine today. So,
- 3:00Chris, how you doing? Thanks for joining me. I'm doing the
- 3:02good lens and tide. It's a little busy right now, but it's things
- 3:07are going fantastic, so awesome. All right, So Chris, I'm going
- 3:12to start with a basic question, but it's really important and I think it
- 3:17kind of sets the tone of where we're going to be going. How important
- 3:23is it for a pastor to understand basic theology, basic doctrine. I know
- 3:34that's a I know that's a simple question, but it really is an important
- 3:38one because, like I said, it's going to set the tone of where
- 3:39we're heading. Right, So let me let me ask answer your question with
- 3:45a question, how do you think it is if your doctor hasn't passed and
- 3:50doesn't really understand basic human anatomy? Oh yeah, that's a good analogy.
- 3:54That that's a very good that's a really good analogy. So yeah, a
- 4:00doctor can do is kill you, all right, But when a pastor screws
- 4:05up, he can send you to hell. So I would note that it's
- 4:10far more important that your pastor rightly understands God's word and has mastered legitimately mastered
- 4:18all of the basics of the Christian faith and has a very commanding understanding of
- 4:23the scriptures. Part Without this, you are being led by somebody who could
- 4:29legitimately mislead you. And when it comes to things that are eternal, those
- 4:32are far more important than things that are temporal. That's it. That's it,
- 4:36so all right. If I think of pastors and teachers within the charismatic
- 4:43movement that have a good grasp some on basic theology, I think of guys
- 4:48like Wayne Grudem. I think of guys like Sam Storms, Michael Brown,
- 4:54maybe John Piper. But you've been doing this for a long time, a
- 4:59lot longer than I have. How how often when you are going through the
- 5:06research do you find a pastor or a teacher that in the charismatic or even
- 5:12seeker sensitive movement that has a really good grasp on theology. If they're popular,
- 5:20most likely they're not. Is the best way I can Charismatics have as
- 5:27a cultural problem that they kind of chase after the latest and greatest and shiniest
- 5:31little pennies, and oftentimes the people that are able to garner a large audience
- 5:38are usually the ones within the charismatic movement. Who are the most unskilled when
- 5:43it comes to rightly handling God's word. They're very skilled in holding your attention
- 5:46telling a story of what do they tell stories? But the theological precision and
- 5:51doctrinal rigor and a good commanding understanding of the scriptures oftentimes is very elusive for
- 5:59the most popular folks within the charismatic movement. That doesn't mean that charismatics as
- 6:02a whole don't value sound doctrine or don't understand theology properly. We got to
- 6:09make sure that we're not saying that, because I know plenty of charismatics who've
- 6:13emailed me over the decades it's said, I can't stand these people that you're
- 6:16reviewing. But you've got to understand that not all charismatics are like that.
- 6:20So I you, we have to admit that very clear. But if they're
- 6:26appearing on TBN or they're uber popular and have over a millions of two,
- 6:30chances are there miserable when it comes to rightly handling God's word. Yeah,
- 6:35I've been listening to the program for a long time, you know, since
- 6:39you've been doing your podcast, and so I think I started listening to you
- 6:43in sometime late twenty ten, early twenty eleven, something like that. So,
- 6:48and I have listened to so many sermon reviews, and so it's I
- 6:55asked that question and specifically talking about those pastors and teachers within those those movements,
- 7:02seeker sensitive, charismatic movement, it's there, it's it. They seem
- 7:08few and far between, and and what I've researched, it's been the same
- 7:11thing. Yeah. Yeah, they legitimately have a problem, and and that
- 7:16is that they they legitimately think that just because somebody is popular and has a
- 7:21growing audience and how that's a sign of God's blessing or the Holy Spirit among
- 7:28Yeah. So are you ready to dive into some clips with with some uh,
- 7:36some of these guys talking about the Trinity. You're gonna get yourself together
- 7:41here and and I'm as ready as I'm gonna be, so all right,
- 7:46So this first clip is Benny hen And this is Benny Henn talking to a
- 7:51group of people. It's it's quite interesting because he says that God the Father
- 7:58has a spirit body. Yeah. Watch, God the Father has a body.
- 8:03It's a spirit body. In fact, he told Moses in Exodus thirty
- 8:07three four when he said, let me show me your glory. So God
- 8:11returns in Exodus thirty four and says, no man can see my face and
- 8:16live there, for he has a face. I'll hide you behind my hand.
- 8:18He has a hand. I'll let you see my back. He has
- 8:22a back. He says, I wrote the law with my fingers, so
- 8:26he has fingers. So whenever I hear spirit body somebody saying that, you
- 8:33know, talked like that, I automatically think gnarscissism. It just it just
- 8:37automatically clicks, you know, in my head, gnosissism, spirit body.
- 8:41But what so he gave some passages there and he talked about, you know,
- 8:48the appearance of God in scripture. But we know that God doesn't have
- 8:52a spirit body. God is a spirit God, the Father does not have
- 8:56a human body or a spirit body. I should say, yeah, Christ
- 9:01says that God is spirit of those who worship him must worship him in spirit
- 9:03and in truth. And so here's the issue is that he's taking a text
- 9:09like from Exodus right there, and there are what we call anthropomorsive anthropomorphisms within
- 9:16the Old Testament. And when we're not talking about a appearance of the Angel
- 9:22of the Angel of the Lord you know, we have we have God describing
- 9:28himself in anthropomorphic terms. But to push hard on it and somehow say that
- 9:33that means God the Father has a spirit body. You don't have a text
- 9:37that says that. And I would note if, in fact, let me
- 9:39let me share my let's let's share my bible. Here in First Corinthians,
- 9:43chapter fifteen, talking about the resurrection, it says that that so it is
- 9:50with the resurrection of the dead, what is sown perishable to raised imperishable is
- 9:54son and dishonor is raised in glory. It is son in weakness, it
- 9:58is raised in power. His sown a natural body. It has raised a
- 10:01spiritual body human beings. According to the scripture, in the resurrection, we're
- 10:07resurrected with spiritual bodies. And so I would note that you can't use this
- 10:13language and apply it to God the Father, because I don't have a text
- 10:16that says it. In fact, the very language he used is describing human
- 10:20beings and what they will be raised from the dead with Christ himself was raised
- 10:24in the spiritual body, and our bodies will be like his when he returns
- 10:30in glory and he raises us from the dead. So you know, you
- 10:33get the idea. This is just a sloppy This is absolutely sloppy and originnately,
- 10:39he's not bound by the text of scripture. He's just kind of freewheeling
- 10:43it and off wroting here and coming up with his own language that he doesn't
- 10:48really have the authority to do. So I would call this necessarily a heresy,
- 10:54but it sure is going beyond the scripture and doing stuff with the biblical
- 11:01text that he doesn't have warrant to do. So I would go with a
- 11:05more sound theologian who understands how the Old Testament anthemromorphisms work and not contradict Jesus
- 11:11that says that God is Spirit and those who were perhp the Spirit in truth.
- 11:16So all right, all right, well so let me uh let me
- 11:20move on then, So we are going to look at a older clip,
- 11:24Chris, I I know you have. I'm pretty sure you've seen this because
- 11:28I think you've covered this, uh Michael Todd incident. Do you remember when
- 11:33Michael Todd was teaching modalism. So yeah, I'm showing this clip for a
- 11:39couple of reasons. Uh. Number one, because it is so important that
- 11:45you get this stuff right and Michael Todd is huge and to get it wrong
- 11:48with all of the people that follow him. But I set the clip up
- 11:54so you could see that this is still on his channel. This clip is
- 12:00still on his channel, and I want you to notice the amount of subscribers
- 12:05he has, amount of views this video has. It has over a million
- 12:09views already. You've just been taught wrong. It's one God. Everybody say
- 12:15one God. Say it like you mean it. One God. Three expressions.
- 12:20Okay, let me let me okay, what is this? It's water,
- 12:26That's that's what we say. But if you want to be very scientific,
- 12:28this is H two oh. Okay, this is H two oh.
- 12:33I'm thirsty, I got a straw. That's good. Let me ask you
- 12:41a different question. Hold on, real quick. We established this is what
- 12:46it's H two oh. What is this? You say? Ice? If
- 12:54we go down to its basic form, this is H two oh. Now
- 13:03it it's in a different form than the liquid version, but this still is
- 13:09uhh. This is a different expression. So when your drink is too warm,
- 13:18you don't put more water in it. It's H two oh. But
- 13:24you put a different expression of H two oh into your drink, and we
- 13:30call it ice. What is this. This is H two O two.
- 13:39It's dry ice and it's a different expression. So if that was God,
- 13:45the Father, God the Son, this is God the Holy Spirit steal a
- 13:50zoo, but it takes on a completely different form. Oh, and this
- 13:56is what God is about to do in your life. You're about to see
- 14:01evidence of the power of the Holy Spirit. Still God, Still God,
- 14:07Still God, Still God, Still God, Still God, God the Father,
- 14:15God the Southern and God help me the Holy Chris. So that video
- 14:26had last time, and I clipped that earlier this week and it has over
- 14:31a million views, thirty thousand likes. I mean, there's a lot of
- 14:37people that are hearing modalism, and that is what he is teaching there.
- 14:41And I know Michael Todd would not deny the Trinity or say that he's he
- 14:46is an anti Trinitarian, but he is teaching modalism. Yeah, I can't
- 14:54help it here. That's modalism, Patrick. The Trinity is like water,
- 15:01and how you can find water in three different forms, liquid and ice and
- 15:05vapor. That's mortalism, Patrick. And not only that, you did you
- 15:13catch the sham Wow infomercial vibes. I didn't think of it like that,
- 15:22but that's a good analogy, absolutely, absolutely, Oh you tie the payments
- 15:28of you know, it's it's nuts. So here's the issue is that he
- 15:35got the one God right. And the thing is that describing how the trinity
- 15:41works is not easy, so we always want to find analogies to try to
- 15:46figure out how to understand the Godhead. Because the scriptures are clear there is
- 15:50only one God. It says it very emphatically like Isaiah forty three to ten.
- 15:54You are my witnesses, declares the Lord and declares Yahweh, the servant
- 15:58whom I have chosen, so that you may know and believe me. Before
- 16:00me, know God was formed, nor will there be any after me.
- 16:03That's what it says. So there are no other gods except for Yahweh.
- 16:07And yet in scripture there are three persons that are called God, God,
- 16:12the Father. Nobody challenges that. Where the real fights at is regarding God
- 16:18the Son, and Jesus is called God and worshiped as God, and then
- 16:22the Holy Spirit is also called God. And sow does that equal three gods?
- 16:27Know, that doesn't make any sense because that would be a contradiction.
- 16:30There's only one God. So then how do you work this out. And
- 16:36the issue is is that when you go to analogy, you're going to fail.
- 16:38And so use ice in its different modes becomes modalism. And modalism is
- 16:45the heresy that teaches that although there is one God, God manifests in three
- 16:49different forms, and God will manifest as the Father at times, and then
- 16:53go and change wardrobe and then appear as the Son, and then you know,
- 16:57and then quit, put on his dub feathers, and then the descend
- 17:00and he'll be He's the Holy Spirit. That that's modalism. Whereas the biblical
- 17:07doctrine teaches that the three persons of the one God, they actually can talk
- 17:12with each other. There they are distinct persons, yet they are the one
- 17:15deity. So a great example quote co equal and coeternal, you know,
- 17:22each person existing for all eternity and equal with one another. Exactly. So
- 17:29let me let me show you something from the scriptures on this one. Yes,
- 17:33in the Gospel of Matthew, chapter three, we have the baptism of
- 17:37Jesus. It says that then Jesus came from Galilee to Jordan to John to
- 17:41be baptized by him, and John would have prevented him, saying, I
- 17:45need to be baptized by you, and do you come to me? But
- 17:47Jesus answered, let it be so now, for thus it is fitting for
- 17:49us to fulfill all righteousness. So then he consented, and when Jesus was
- 17:53baptized, immediately he went up from the water, and behold, the heavens
- 17:57were open to him. And he saw the Spirit of God descending like a
- 18:00dove and coming to rest on him. And behold a voice from heaven said,
- 18:06this is my beloved son, with whom I am well pleased. The
- 18:10issue with modalism is that now we've got to we've got to explain this.
- 18:14How do we explain that we have all three persons appearing on the same stage,
- 18:18if you would, Jesus, the Son of God, is in the
- 18:22water, the Holy Spirit descends on him in the form of a dove,
- 18:26and the voice of God, the Father is heard from heaven. And then
- 18:29you also have to add into the mix, is that, when like Jesus
- 18:32is praying in the garden of Gsemine in Matthew chapter twenty six, he says,
- 18:37he's praying, my Father, if it be possible, let this cup
- 18:41pass from me. Now, the left not as I will, but as
- 18:44you will. Well, here's the issue is that if modalism were true,
- 18:49how do we explain Jesus submitting to the Father's will if he's the Father.
- 18:56It doesn't make any sense. So the issue is that ultimately modalism is going
- 19:03to fail on multiple fronts because now every time Jesus prays, it's just it's
- 19:07theater. It's it's theatrics. It's a form of deception. At the Baptism
- 19:11of Christ, the different appearances of the appearance of the Holy Spirit and the
- 19:15Father speaking from heaven, that's all theatrics. It's just special effects. It's
- 19:22not some kind of reality. Then you have God engaging in deception, and
- 19:26modalism fails on so many fronts, but that being the primary place in which
- 19:30it fails. Instead, the only thing that can explain this is good,
- 19:33good old fashioned Trinitarian theology that recognizes that they are different persons but they are
- 19:40the same God. Yeah, And when you're when you're talking about the scripture
- 19:45texts that show Jesus speaking to the Father, you can also go to John
- 19:48seventeen right, the High priestly Prayer, where Jesus is praying to the Father
- 19:52and how do you I don't know if you want to look at that really
- 19:56quickly, but I mean, how do you get past that? Yeah,
- 20:00it's it's it's the same with his prayer in the garden of get somebody.
- 20:03You can't get past because at this point Jesus is just praying to himself.
- 20:07Yeah, you know, which is doesn't make a lick of sense. It's
- 20:11just a form of deception at this point. And then you have to ask
- 20:14the question, is Jesus legitimately uh trustworthy is he? Or is he a
- 20:22deceptive Okay? So so the high priestly prayer, when Jesus spoke had spoken
- 20:26these words, he lifted up his eyes to Heaven and he said, Father,
- 20:30the hour has come, glorify your son, that the son may glorify
- 20:33you. If they're just different modes here, we've got a problem because the
- 20:40primary mode that God is operating and is the son and him looking up to
- 20:45Heaven to speak to the Father. Again, it's deceptive theatrics. It's it
- 20:51turns Jesus into somebody that we can't even trust. Yeah. So our next
- 20:56clip, Chris, as we look at this and try to work this stuff
- 21:00out, is a guy by the name of Stephen Chandler, and he is
- 21:04kind of up and coming. I'm gonna just show the profile here of him
- 21:08and his church. He is the pastor over at Unity Church in Maryland,
- 21:15and so this is him and his wife and they're both co pastors. They
- 21:18also have another set of pastors that are their Apostolic pastors. And so I
- 21:26guess if you want to be an apostle, you can just you know,
- 21:30you can just call yourself one if you'd like to. But he the videos
- 21:36that I've watched of Stephen Chandler, he's really trying to mimic in a lot
- 21:40of his styles and things Michael Todd somewhat. So this is him trying to
- 21:45teach on the Trinity. Now again, these guys wouldn't, you know,
- 21:48deny the Trinity, but it's just the way they're teaching it. So check
- 21:52this clip out. You may have heard me preach. It's one of my
- 21:55favorite kind of revelations from Scripture. But the Bible says that we humans were
- 22:00made in the image of God, and Genesis chapter one, verse twenty seven,
- 22:03twenty six it says, let us make mankind in the image of God.
- 22:07In the image of God, they made him. Now God is one
- 22:11God. Somebody say, one God. I told you you go feel like
- 22:15you're in Destiny College today we're going to get hot. And there's one God,
- 22:18but he manifests himself in three forms, God the Father, God the
- 22:22Son, and God the Holy Spirit. There's one God, but he manifests
- 22:27himself in three forms. Now, you were made in the image of God.
- 22:32And if you were made in the image of God, it means that
- 22:33you look just like God. If God is one God in three forms.
- 22:37It's so funny. People say, I don't understand the trinity. You don't
- 22:41have to understand the trinity, just understand you. So he goes on from
- 22:45there and he says that, you know, we look like God because God
- 22:52is triune, He's a trinity, and we are the same because we have
- 22:56a body, a soul, and a spirit. And so he kin it's
- 23:00that to Father, Son and Holy Spirit. But that's kind of where he
- 23:03goes from there. So what what are your thoughts? Yeah, So,
- 23:07the the issue of basically taking humanity and making a tripartite rather than a bipartite
- 23:14is that that the scriptures really don't teach that that, you know, we're
- 23:19you know, in fact, the ancient Church really understood humanity is possessing a
- 23:23body and a soul and uh, and that being the case that that's those
- 23:27those are the two component parts of the of the human And so I know
- 23:33the text that they're taking out of context to try to make it sound like
- 23:36that there's a third part, but that's a primary that that triparthide distinction is
- 23:41is a necessary component of the Word of faith heresy, because you have to
- 23:47make a distinction between soul and spirit so that you can explain then why you
- 23:52still sin and why bad things happen to you and where thinking where this kind
- 23:56of stuff comes from. So it's it's a fatal fault in anthropology. And
- 24:00the demon slayers, guys like Isaiah is out of r Vlad Savchuk would say
- 24:04the same thing. They would say that because we have a body, soul
- 24:08in a spirit that you know, the demon can't possess our body or our
- 24:12soul or I mean, the demon can't possess our spirit, but it can
- 24:17possess our body. So yeah, I see where you're coming from there.
- 24:22It's just it's sloppy non biblical anthropology. But to then draw the analogy and
- 24:27make it so that we don't have to understand the Trinity just look to ourselves.
- 24:32That doesn't help either, because I'm not three persons unless I have multiple
- 24:37personality disorder. And so yeah, yeah, but you know, and notice
- 24:44too, the same kind of thing. God appears in three Did he say
- 24:48three forms? I think he said three forms. Yeah, so he was
- 24:52he slipped into modalism along the way as well, So he doesn't have a
- 24:56commanding understanding of the doctrine of the Trinity. And you know, what these
- 25:00folks really need is to sit down and read and study the Athenationian Creed.
- 25:06You know, yeah, you know that that is a wonderful way to learn
- 25:11what the doctrine of the Trinity is and what it is, and learn how
- 25:14to speak correctly about the one God and three persons. My doctrinal statement is
- 25:18no different from yours, except for the MANIFESTI manifest instead of persons, which
- 25:26you described as modalists and I described as pauline. This next clip, vlad
- 25:29Savchuk is talking about prayer and God. I'm believing God. I believe it's
- 25:36God. The Son is going to give him a message about the Holy Spirit.
- 25:41So check this out, you know, when I was younger. I
- 25:45got about this in the Holy Spirit at a very young age, you know,
- 25:48fifteen or sixteen years of aation, and that's all that I knew there
- 25:52was to the Holy Spirit. And until recently, about four years ago,
- 25:55that the reality that the Holy Spirit is the person penetrated my life and it
- 25:59started to things slowly but surely. But one of the things that I struggled
- 26:03is the fact that when I see the Father, I think of the Father
- 26:07because I have an amazing dad. It's easy for me to connect God the
- 26:11Father to my father because he was amazing. He's still amazing, great Dad.
- 26:15When I think of Jesus, I saw Jesus movies, Jim coviasel Great
- 26:19Jesus. I see Hollywood made movies, and so I imagine a guy with
- 26:25the beard. I imagine a Jewish man, a long rope, nice guy,
- 26:27nails, you know, there's holes in his wrists. And so when
- 26:30I see Jesus, when I say Jesus, I don't think of a lamb.
- 26:36I think of a being. And my problem was this is when I
- 26:40say the Spirit, my mind would always go cloud, wind, fire,
- 26:47and it was just like which image do I choose today, okay, the
- 26:52fire today because I want it hot. The wind blow, blow deep rivers,
- 26:56deep rivers, and then always. And I said, when I was
- 27:00when I was researching, when I was searching for this, and I said,
- 27:02Lord, why did you not give the Holy Spirit a body? It
- 27:07would have been so much easier for us to fellowship with him? And I
- 27:11heard this prompting in my heart. The Lord replied back and said, the
- 27:15Holy Spirit has a body. It's just he chose yours. Jesus chose the
- 27:22Jewish body. I chose the Father's the Holy Spirit. When he came choosing
- 27:27the body, he says, you know what, let's not create any new
- 27:30ones. Let me just take his hers and theirs. The Holy Spirit is
- 27:34no less a person than Jesus just because he doesn't have a Jewish body.
- 27:40Look in the mirror, that is his body. Okay, Chris. So
- 27:45I know what he's trying to say that you know, we're we're the temple
- 27:49of the Holy Spirit. But the way that comes across is just not biblical
- 27:56at all. No, it's in fact, it's blast from this because he's
- 28:00claiming that source of this is Jesus. And so you know that prompting within
- 28:06his heart that told him this, And so I understand, I agree with
- 28:11you. What he's trying to get at is is that collectively the body of
- 28:14Christ. You'll note that we're called the body of Christ, not the body
- 28:18of the exactly exactly, you know. So we've got a problem here is
- 28:25that Jesus wouldn't contradict the word. And so the church is described as the
- 28:30body of Christ and in relation to the Holy Spirit. Let me show you
- 28:33a text here, get you up here, and so we'll do a little
- 28:38Greek on this one too. One Corinthians three sixteen. Do you not know
- 28:42that y'all that's a plural, that's a plural, That y'all are God's temple,
- 28:48and that God's Spirit dwells in y'all. Okay, So we're described in
- 28:56scripture as the body of Christ, and we are, and we, as
- 29:00the body of Christ, are the temple of the Holy Spirit. Stick to
- 29:04the language, and don't you know, and don't sit there by direct revelation.
- 29:08Jesus told me the Spirit does have a body, and it's you no
- 29:11wrong. The Spirit has a temple, okay, And this is how the
- 29:15scriptures describe this. And then and then and then even that works down on
- 29:18the individual level, where in one Corinthians six, Paul says, flee from
- 29:23sexual immorality. Every other sin a person commitss outside the body sexual, but
- 29:27the sexually immoral person sins against his own body. Or do you not know
- 29:32that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit? We have twice,
- 29:37uh, we being described as the temple of the Holy Spirit, first collectively
- 29:41as the as the church, y'all, and then also as individuals. So
- 29:48that being the case, why don't we just stick with the bounds of scripture
- 29:52and stay within the limits of how scripture describes these things rather than coming up
- 29:56thing, I've got a direct revelation from Jesus and then say something that contradicts
- 30:02the word, which proves you didn't really hear from Jesus. And uh,
- 30:07and then create a problem when it comes to numatology and as well as the
- 30:12proper understanding of the deity. Yeah, and you know, Benny hen says
- 30:17the same thing. The Holy Spirit has a body and the body as you.
- 30:19So they're just they're just copying one another. David Diga Hernandez said the
- 30:25same thing. He says that the Holy Spirit's body is you that you know,
- 30:30the Holy Spirit has a body and you are that body. And yeah,
- 30:34no, I mean we are like you said, we are the body
- 30:37of Christ. I think of Acts chapter nine where uh, where Paul falls
- 30:41off the horse and Jesus says, uh, Saul, Saul, why are
- 30:45you persecuting me? You know what I mean? So we are the body
- 30:49of Christ. We're not the you know, body of the Holy Spirit,
- 30:52Temple of the Holy Spirit. Spirit. Yeah right, So stick with the
- 30:56language the scriptures chose, because God, the Holy Spirit knew full well how
- 31:00to make these distinctions and what's true and what's not true, and we need
- 31:07to stick with that and not invent stuff. And it's blasphemous to put these
- 31:11words into Jesus's mouth because now you have Jesus not even understanding how the how
- 31:15the scriptures work, which is not is not a good thing to do.
- 31:21Here ex me all right, So you've seen this next clip. This is
- 31:25Louis Giglio. God is about community. I was trying to talk to high
- 31:30school and middle school kids the other night about the Trinity. Imagine how fun
- 31:33that was for everybody. And I was explaining that God is so into community
- 31:41and so not about I'm just gonna kind of live out my faith, or
- 31:45I'm going to live out my Christianity, or I'm going to have my spirituality
- 31:48on my own. He is so not into that and so into community that
- 31:52he actually himself is a community. Yes, one God, but that God
- 32:01has three distinct persons, the Father who we relate to in one way,
- 32:06the Son who we relate to in another way, and the Spirit who we
- 32:09relate to in another way. But they are all interrelated and interconnected, and
- 32:14they are all in complete unity together as one God in three persons. So
- 32:20our God is actually a community of gods, all unified in one God.
- 32:24What is he trying to say to you and me? We are all about
- 32:29community, So basically a unity of gods. Yes, that's what I wanted
- 32:37to point out, folks. I mean, and these are again I'll say
- 32:43this again, but these are guys who wouldn't deny the Trinity. But man,
- 32:46a pastor should know how to at least talk about the Trinity to his
- 32:52congregation or you know, whatever congregation he's speaking to. Yeah. So,
- 33:00so here's your problem with Giglio. There's a few things. Number One,
- 33:01A lot of people don't remember this, but I actually did an entire lecture
- 33:06on the subject called Resistance is Fuel. You'll be assimilated by the community.
- 33:10All the first gen guys who bought into the purpose driven church methodology, who
- 33:16were part of the Saddleback community of churches and Willow Creek, they were all
- 33:22influenced by a fellow by the name of Peter Drucker. And Peter Drucker legitimately
- 33:28tried to make it his life work to try to rescue fascism from you know,
- 33:34from the iteration that it had become in Nazis, and he actually had
- 33:37to flee Nazi Germany. And so he believed that the core of fundamental philosophical
- 33:44concept behind fascism the denial of the existence of the individual, and that the
- 33:49only thing that exists is the community. He thought that that was a valid
- 33:52that was valid here on earth. But before God, we were only before
- 33:58God were we individuals. And so because Drucker played such a central role in
- 34:02the in the creation of purpose driven churches and in these large megachurches about into
- 34:08that methodology, they inherited and learned from him a form of communitarianism, which
- 34:15is a light version of fascism, and and so there their constant emphasis on
- 34:21community comes from that ideology. Now it's not exactly the same as fascism,
- 34:25but it basically has the same roots and some of the same core concepts and
- 34:30uh and and so one of the reasons that a lot of people don't know
- 34:34this the reason why megachurches exist and why they're so big, and why it's
- 34:39they were designed on purpose to make it so that when an individual went to
- 34:44worship, they would lose that complete sense of it being an individual and they
- 34:47would only be able to see the community. And so what he's doing is
- 34:52he's taking this, he's taken this this light form of fascism that he doesn't
- 34:57even recognize where it's from and what it is. And he's now then projecting
- 35:02this concept onto God and in order to try to make make a distinction.
- 35:09But the issue is this is number one. Nowhere does it describe the Trinity
- 35:15as a community community right God? Yeah, community of gods. That's not
- 35:21right, Okay, you know, we worship one God in unity and trinity.
- 35:27Right. So the idea here is that he's I know, what he's
- 35:32trying to do, he's trying to basically take a swipe at the sinfulness of
- 35:37like bonafide stark naked individualism. And the issue is is that the opposite error
- 35:44isn't the truth error either. So has God made us individuals? Yes?
- 35:50Are we also part of different communities? Yes, it's both. It's not
- 35:54one or the other, it's both. And and where you end up making
- 35:58an error is when you go with like rugged individualism and with the idea that
- 36:02I have no I have no responsibilities within a community like the United States or
- 36:07my city or my state. That's false, okay. Uh. And then
- 36:10on the other end, fascism is wrong because it teaches that you don't exist
- 36:15as an individual and you don't have individual rights, you only have responsibilities to
- 36:20the community. That's also false and not taught in scripture. I'm gonna put
- 36:22that link to that in the uh in the YouTube description so people can take
- 36:27a listen to that. That was a really good lecture. So all right,
- 36:30so now we're gonna move on to Christology. We talked about, you
- 36:36know, trinitarian stuff, So now we're gonna move on to Christology. I
- 36:39have two clips and two clips only. Uh. One is by Robert Morris
- 36:45and the other is by well did I actually no I take that back.
- 36:52Guess what, I only have one You only have to deal with one clip.
- 36:55I have Robert Moore and that is it. So we'll take a look
- 37:01at this Robert Morse clip. But this, to me, what Robert moorese
- 37:09says here is just so heretical. I mean, that's all I can I
- 37:15can say. So check this clip out. Here's what I want to share
- 37:19something with you that may absolutely shock you. This may shock you. How
- 37:23did Jesus know the word? Now? Wait, don't don't answer because most
- 37:28of us would give this answer, well because he wrote it, or because
- 37:31he is the word. Well, hang on a minute. You have to
- 37:35remember that he completely laid down his divinity and picked up his humanity. He
- 37:40became a human, did you know? And I didn't understand this for a
- 37:45long time until I understand this doctrine. Until I understood this doctrine, Jesus,
- 37:51the Bible says Hebrews five eight says that he learned obedience through the things
- 37:54which he suffered. He learned obedience. So I don't want to ask you
- 37:58him. How can I, not omniscient God, learn anything If Jesus saw
- 38:04the need when he was a human to listen to Bible teachers and ask questions
- 38:09and learn the Bible. Why wouldn't you do the same thing? And maybe
- 38:15if we did, then when we were tempted, we could say it is
- 38:20written. It is written. One more, Luke two point fifty two says,
- 38:24and Jesus increased in wisdom and stature and in favor of God and men.
- 38:30I just want you to notice the first part, Jesus increased in wisdom.
- 38:35How would an all knowing God increase in wisdom except that he laid his
- 38:40divinity down and he became a human. So that's outright heresy, and that
- 38:47just destroys the two natures in Christ. I mean that just it's that's horrible.
- 38:53It's and this guy is so popular. You know, he's got so
- 39:01many followers, and he's got so many connections, so many people that I've
- 39:07you know, talked about on this show. They're all connected. You know.
- 39:09He's he's at Michael Todd's church, and he's at this person's church teaching
- 39:15his tithing stuff. But now he's teaching you know, this kind of heresy,
- 39:21uh, you know about Christ. Yeah, So this is called the
- 39:25canotic heresy, and it is a complete botching of Philippians too, that you
- 39:32know that do nothing out of selfish ambition or inglorious conceit, but you know,
- 39:37consider others as more important than yourself. And looking to Christ, who,
- 39:40though he was by nature God, did not count equality with God a
- 39:44think we grasp. But he emptied himself by taking on the form of a
- 39:46servant and being found in human likeness. He was obedient to the point of
- 39:51death, even death on the cross. And so the text the text says
- 39:54that he emptied himself and was found in the form of a slave. They
- 40:00that that the word empty is canotic, and that's where we get kenosis from
- 40:04uh and and so they basically say that Jesus laid aside his divinity. No,
- 40:09he did not and uh and so I would note that this is usually
- 40:15a doctrine that is taught in conjunction with like New Apostolic Reformation type of churches,
- 40:22because what they overemphasize is they say, you need to do the same
- 40:27works that Jesus did. You know, they'll say, the scripture says that
- 40:30Jesus said, you'll do the same works that I do, and bet and
- 40:32even more even greater right, and so they think that works equals miraculous signs.
- 40:39And so what they'll say then is the how Jesus was able to do
- 40:43is miraculous signs. Is that he laid aside his divinity. And he was
- 40:47a perfectly submitted, an obedient human being who operated by the power of the
- 40:53Holy Spirit. And so that example for us that we are supposed to follow
- 40:59the problem him as this it doesn't wash in scripture. And Jesus never laid
- 41:04aside his divinity. Ever, he may have muted it, like hit the
- 41:09mute button, like you know, you think about Christ on the amount of
- 41:13transfiguration, right, you know, they he takes Peter, James and John.
- 41:16And I'm convinced that there's a word that's missing from the text where it
- 41:21should have said blamo, you know, because you know immediately, you know,
- 41:27Jesus he's shining like as white as as white gets, and and you
- 41:31know, and his his glory comes shining through. I would note, how
- 41:36is that possible if he's not still God or he laid aside his divinity.
- 41:39But there's even a even a greater text. Let me show you this in
- 41:44uh in the Okay, in the Gospel of John chapter two, we have
- 41:51Jesus' first miracle, and don't let the teetotalers know this. But Jesus turned
- 41:57water into wine, and it wasn't grape juice. Okay, So here's the
- 42:00account. On the third day, there was a wedding at cana and Galilee,
- 42:05and the mother of Jesus was there. Jesus also was invited to the
- 42:07wedding with his disciples. When the wine ran out, the mother of Jesus
- 42:10said to him, they have no wine. And Jesus said to her woman,
- 42:15what does this have to do with me? My hour has not yet
- 42:16come. His mother said to the servants, do whatever he tells you.
- 42:21So now there were six stone water jars for the Jewish rights of purification,
- 42:23each holding twenty or thirty gallons. And Jesus said to the servants who filled
- 42:29the jars with water, and they filled them to the brim, and then
- 42:30he said to them, now draw some out and take it to the master
- 42:34of the feast. So they took it, and when the Master of the
- 42:37feast tasted the water now become wine, and did not know where it came
- 42:39from, though the servants who had drawn the water new. The master of
- 42:44the feast called the bridegroom and said to him, everyone serves the good wine
- 42:47first, and when the people have drunk freely, then the poor wine.
- 42:52But you've kept the good wine until now. And then watch verse eleven.
- 42:55This the first of his signs that Jesus did at cana and Galilee and manifested
- 43:01his glory, and his disciples believed in him. No attribution given to the
- 43:07Holy Spirit. All of it goes to Christ, which means he did not
- 43:10lay aside his divinity. In fact, he couldn't if you were to take
- 43:15a look at what's called the doctrine of the genus ineomaticum. This talks about
- 43:21how the two natures in Christ work. Let me give you an analogy here
- 43:25and then you'll kind of see how this works. So Dan, let me
- 43:30ask you, do you have a body? I do? And do you
- 43:32have a soul? I do? How many of how many Dan Longs are
- 43:37there one? There's only one? So the body and soul come together in
- 43:43what's called the hypostasis, right uh, And to make the one that is
- 43:49that is Daniel Long. Similar thing happens with Christ. And you can see
- 43:53this very clearly kind of play out in like Romans one and like the opening
- 43:58portions of it, where Christ is you know as to his you know,
- 44:01human nature is descendative, David, as to you know, he's declared to
- 44:06be the son of God by his rising from the dead. So Jesus has
- 44:10a human nature, and that means Jesus has a human body as well as
- 44:14a human soul. But also Christ has a divine nature. And in what's
- 44:19called the hypostatic union, in the incarnation, uh, the human nature and
- 44:22the divine nature come together to create the Jesus Christ, otherwise known as the
- 44:28Word. And so there's not two jesus Is. And just like so when
- 44:32you go to work, do you do you only do your work with your
- 44:36body or do you do your work body and soul? You have to do
- 44:38both? Do both? Yeah right, because if you if you were to
- 44:43try to do something without your soul, and you know, you'd be born.
- 44:46Yeah right, because when you tear body and soul apart, well there's
- 44:52a corpse, okay. Uh. And and and the idea then we just
- 44:57like we do everything body and soul. Everything Christ does he does with both
- 45:00his natures, both his human nature and his divine nature. And it's it's
- 45:04really sloppy to say, well, he did that by virtue of his divine
- 45:07nature. He did this by virtue of his human nature. No, everything
- 45:12that Jesus does he does with both natures. And that's really that sound biblical
- 45:17theology. Even the Athenationian Creed spends some time explaining how all this works,
- 45:22and the biblical text behind it are readily available. But the idea then is
- 45:27that Jesus never laid down his divinity. Ever. He did everything he did
- 45:32with a divine nature. But just because he didn't tap into it doesn't mean
- 45:37that he laid it aside. So you'll note then that Jesus Christ, who
- 45:42is both has a human nature and a divine nature, during his time of
- 45:45his humiliation, while he was here serving us, he did not make full
- 45:52use of his divinity. As a result of it, Jesus could grow in
- 45:55wisdom, he can learn his alos, baths, gimbals and dalits, and
- 46:00he even you know, you know, he even had to have his voice
- 46:01change, went through the acne phase of teenage and stuff like this. All
- 46:06of that because he is he has both a human nature and a divine nature.
- 46:09When we talk about Christ, we have to keep the hypostatic union in
- 46:14in full view and understand that both natures have come together to create the One
- 46:17Christ. Yeah, and so let me let me ask you this. So
- 46:23they say that Jesus did everything by the power of the Holy Spirit, all
- 46:28his miracles, everything, what did they and Robert Morse saying that Jesus laid
- 46:34aside his divinity, what did they say about his death on the cross?
- 46:38Because if Jesus, you know, had shut off his divinity, there,
- 46:45I mean we could never I mean, he couldn't have paid for the sins
- 46:49of the world. Yeah. That's the other bit is is that if you
- 46:52have Jesus laying aside his divinity, then Christ's atoning work on the cross is
- 46:57woefully efficient, you know, because you'll note that he only suffers for six
- 47:02hours. Uh. But you know, but we're when we're taught when by
- 47:07virtue of the incarnation, you can say things about God that you couldn't say
- 47:12before the incarnation. So uh, you know, so when when Mary,
- 47:17the mother of Jesus, she's pregnant with Christ and I mean just a few
- 47:22days pregnant, Jesus is my microscopic at this point, uh, inside of
- 47:25her, and she goes to see her cousin Elizabeth. And when she walks
- 47:30in Elizabeth, who's six months pregnant, you know, John the Baptist leaps
- 47:32in her womb and uh and and she said, and she says, who
- 47:37am I that that the Mother of my Lord would come? You know?
- 47:40And so weird language Mother of my Lord. So so we can say about
- 47:46God virtue of the incarnation that God has a mommy, but not God the
- 47:52Father, and not God the Holy Spirit, but only God the Son through
- 47:55through the agency of the incarnation. So we can say then of God also
- 48:00in Christ, the Son of God, that God died. Okay, But
- 48:07but this is all language that you couldn't normally use about God because God is
- 48:13spirit. So the incarnation adds a whole new layer of things that we can
- 48:17say about God. And you'll note that Christ is tempted in every way that
- 48:22we are, and yet is without sin. Yet you can't tempt God,
- 48:25but you can tempt the God and Jesus Christ. So you get the idea
- 48:30here. When the Canontic error is not merely an error, it's a flat
- 48:35out christological heresy because it turns it it creates a false Jesus that doesn't really
- 48:42exist, a false Jesus that has laid aside his divinity when he didn't,
- 48:46and it teaches you false things about yourself. And you'll note that when you
- 48:49lay aside Jesus's divinity in your theology, which you're secretly doing, is amping
- 48:54up your own personal divinity. You have to you have to grade Christ in
- 49:00order to exalt yourself. Yeah. I was thinking about a passage as you
- 49:05were talking about that, about the crucifixion where Peter tells the Jews and Acts.
- 49:12I think chapter three you crucified the Lord of Glory. I mean that
- 49:17right there, right right there, has you know, you have the human
- 49:22and the divine right there, yep. And then let me show you another
- 49:25one. This is kind of fun because we're talking about, you know,
- 49:29how you can say things about God you couldn't normally say because of the incarnation.
- 49:34And in the Book of Acts, chapter twenty, you have Paul's farewell
- 49:37address to the pastors in the Church of Ephesus or these are the churches actually
- 49:43different churches in Ephesus, and how this is really interesting language that the apostle
- 49:49Paul says. So in one of his parting admonitions to these pastors. He
- 49:53says to them in verse twenty eight, pay careful attention to yourselves and to
- 49:58all the flock in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseeers, to care
- 50:01for the Church of God. So note to THAYU, here is kind of
- 50:06our our, our immediate thing, the Church of God, which he God
- 50:10obtained with his own blood. And you read that when did God bleed?
- 50:17Yeah? Yeah, you know, yeah, so you know, and the
- 50:22ads in Christ by virtue of the incarnation in the hypostatic union. Yeah,
- 50:28and you've got first John one seven, the blood of Jesus Christ, his
- 50:30son cleanses us from all sin, you know. So you've got all of
- 50:36those passages that they talk about that and if you know, so this whole
- 50:42idea that we can do everything that Jesus did because you know, Jesus did
- 50:47everything by the Holy Spirit. Now let me ask you this. They they
- 50:52they they say because of his baptism. They're at the baptism, you know,
- 50:57and we looked at that text already you have Jesus, you have the
- 51:00Father, and you have the Holy Spirit descending on Jesus. I believe that
- 51:05is where they say that from that point forward, Jesus does everything that he
- 51:08does by the power of this Holy Spirit, because he's anointed with the Holy
- 51:12Spirit. There So, so how do you differentiate like the miracles, So
- 51:17there's no way that he walked on the water by the well. I guess
- 51:22they would say he did walk on the water by the power of the Holy
- 51:23Spirit. Yeah, I guess they would say he did break the the you
- 51:29know, the bread and the fish by the power of the Holy Spirit.
- 51:30But I've never seen any of them walk on water or turn water in a
- 51:35wine, or break you know, feed five thousand people with a few loaves
- 51:38and few fishes. Right, So again that what they're trying to do is
- 51:44turn Jesus's miracles into examples that we can follow and then do greater Here's Jesus
- 51:49says to his disciples that they would do greater works air God, okay,
- 51:53not that they would do greater semon signs. Okay. And so the idea
- 51:59then is is if just think this out with me. In the Book of
- 52:01Acts, did the apostles do greater miraculous signs than Jesus did? Answer?
- 52:07No, they did not, Okay, I would note nobody has because Jesus
- 52:13raised himself from the grave on the third day after his Bible. So,
- 52:16and then you look at the gospels, the sheer quantity of people that Christ
- 52:22healed and delivered from demons and all the things that he did. None of
- 52:27his apostles even approached that number. Okay, and nobody Sinse has either.
- 52:32So clearly he's not talking about them doing greater miracles than he did. But
- 52:37I would note this Peter far exceeded Christ in works. And let me explain.
- 52:43Yeah, because Peter lived for decades after Christ's ascension, and he was
- 52:47crucified what in the the mid to late sixties a d and so he and
- 52:53you know, when Jesus died on the cross, there was maybe what one
- 52:57hundred, one hundred and twenty is Christians. When Peter dies after he's crucified,
- 53:04there are hundreds of thousands of Christians, Okay. And so Peter did
- 53:08far more works than Jesus ever did. For sure, did he do greater
- 53:14signs than Jesus, not even close. And so this idea that the point
- 53:19to is his baptism, and it's true, his baptism is his anointing.
- 53:23That we have no problem saying that the issue is is that they then read
- 53:29into it and say, from this point forward he never did any miracles using
- 53:31his own divine nature. Well John two just contradicted that, so you know,
- 53:36and that was the first miracle he performed. So already your whole thesis
- 53:38falls flat on its face. Yeah. Yeah, And you know you're talking
- 53:43about the disciples not doing the greater signs than Jesus. And you know,
- 53:47you have people like kat Kerr and Gloria Copelan and others who have said that
- 53:52we have the power over the weather. Well, Paul was shipwrecked. You
- 53:57know how many times? Why didn't Paul just calm the storms and make things,
- 54:04you know, make the waves cease and you know, save everybody on
- 54:08the ship instead of you know, they're all being shipwrecked to the island of
- 54:12Malta. You know, it's like it's even funnier than that, because in
- 54:16that section of the Book of Acts, okay, that that storm, that
- 54:20nor'easter lasts for two weeks. Okay, And that's right when when the when
- 54:27Jesus appears to him and lets him know that that nobody's going to die.
- 54:31Uh. You know, what Paul basically says is that you should have listened
- 54:36to me, and we shouldn't have ever left. You know, he never
- 54:40got up on the bow of the ship and said, I agreed, Commander
- 54:45Northeaster to be Jesus. You know, none of that, he says,
- 54:51he said he should have listened to me. Oh, shut up, Paul,
- 54:53you know when they talking like that. So, oh well, well,
- 55:00Chris, any any closing thoughts at all before we uh, before we
- 55:04sign off here? I think we've covered a lot of ground. Yes,
- 55:07So so here's the idea. We're not being nitpicky because this when you air
- 55:12christologically or you err regarding the nature of God, you end up in idolatry
- 55:17and that sends you to hell because uh, this falls under the anathemas of
- 55:22scripture. When somebody preaches a different Jesus, a different spirit, or a
- 55:24different gospel, they're not a Christian. And so you know, again coming
- 55:30back to what I said, you would never go to a doctor that that
- 55:34failed basic human anatomy. I mean, not only that, it would be
- 55:37impossible for him to pass as his board certifications anyway. The same idea,
- 55:42then you don't want to be under a pastor, and it doesn't matter if
- 55:45he's the hottest commodity on them at the moment. If he's not capable of
- 55:50rightly handling God's word and correctly expressing what the scripture teaches regarding the nature of
- 55:54God, uh the One, the One, God, three persons, as
- 55:59well as a proper understanding of Christ and his two natures, you need to
- 56:04run because these are errors that land people in hell because they're heresies. They're
- 56:07not just mere upsie oopsies. Yeah wow, very good. Well, Chris,
- 56:14thank you. You are so busy during this time of year, and
- 56:16I really appreciate you taking the time to come on the show and talk about
- 56:22this about proper theology, proper tyrant trinitariot, and Christological doctrine. So thank
- 56:30you for doing that with me. My pleasure. All Right, folks,
- 56:35we will see you next week. Thanks for joining us.