Latest / Politics with Paul / What Should Be in Our Civics Curriculum? w/ Douglas Addison (CFFAD) | Politics with Paul #101
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09It's been a little while since we've had a guest on.
- 0:11So as a reminder for previous listeners and a disclaimer for new listeners, I do not take a
- 0:16stance for or against against political views or people they support, but this isn't going to
- 0:21be a partisan discussion anyway.
- 0:23Civics education in America greatly needs improvement in this country.
- 0:27Teaching civics and government and so on is a core aspect of this podcast and several
- 0:33episodes have focused specifically on civics education and how to make it better.
- 0:38But while a lot of people would agree that it needs to be upgraded, there isn't necessarily
- 0:43agreement on what that looks like.
- 0:45So what are some ideas to explore?
- 0:48What should be in our civics curriculum?
- 0:50Well, that's what today's guest, Doug Addison, is here to talk about.
- 0:55Douglas is the founder and president of the Center for Free, Fair and Accountable
- 0:59Democracy, CFFAD.
- 1:02The goals of CFFAD are to one, help Americans understand why representative democracy is
- 1:08precious, and two, help them understand, protect, and improve the foundations of trust
- 1:15in our republic.
- 1:16And to do that, CFFAD has been offering several short courses on its website, each reviewed by
- 1:23experts on the right and the left.
- 1:25But I understand the organization will be making some changes soon, which I hope we can
- 1:29discuss in the interview.
- 1:31And previously, Douglas was an economist with the World Bank for thirty years.
- 1:35Now let's help drive the larger conversation forward on what our civics education should
- 1:41entail.
- 1:42Please welcome Douglas Addison to the show.
- 1:44Doug, thanks for being here.
- 1:45How are you?
- 1:47Good.
- 1:47Good.
- 1:48We're in the middle of a heat wave, but it's nice to be inside with air conditioning.
- 1:53So
- 1:54I live in Florida, so it always feels like that that's going on.
- 1:57But, yeah, it's it's it's been brutal for a lot of the East Coast.
- 2:02But let's talk about things that are a bit nicer.
- 2:05So I like going back to where it all started with guests about what we're talking about.
- 2:10So generally speaking, why did you get into civic education and teaching people about our
- 2:16system of government?
- 2:18Yeah.
- 2:19Okay.
- 2:19Well, first of all, thanks for having me on your show.
- 2:22Really appreciate that.
- 2:23And it's nice to share your passion for civics and how to make it better.
- 2:27And that's something to think about on this two hundred and fiftieth anniversary of our
- 2:31declaration of independence.
- 2:33I mean, it's amazing we're doing this podcast on the day before.
- 2:37So I feel like it's very special.
- 2:40Yeah.
- 2:41I think there's there's probably three parts.
- 2:43I had fun thinking about it, actually.
- 2:45So I appreciate your question.
- 2:46First, going way back, I suppose I've always had an interest in politics.
- 2:50I remember I tried once to get my high school to adopt a constitution for its student
- 2:56council.
- 2:56I failed, but the the passion remained with me.
- 3:00I I checked in with them actually last year.
- 3:03They have one now.
- 3:05So maybe I had a small impact indirectly.
- 3:07I don't know.
- 3:08Second, I did have a long career doing economics.
- 3:11I I was marching all over the world assessing how governments in developing countries use
- 3:17their budgets to improve the lives of their citizens or not.
- 3:22It was all economics, but I could see out of the corner of my eye that the governments that
- 3:29were more authoritarian tended to use their money less wisely, more corruptly, and that
- 3:35they were generally worse off, and their people were worse off than the governments that were
- 3:40more democratic.
- 3:41So as I was getting towards retirement age, I was also noticing, and this is my maybe the
- 3:48third component.
- 3:49I was noticing that a lot of Americans didn't seem to be realizing how lucky they are to live
- 3:54in a democracy.
- 3:55A lot of things to complain about.
- 3:57But when you look at how the rest of the world is, I feel like we really are very lucky to
- 4:04live in a democracy.
- 4:05So by the time retirement came, I knew what I wanted to do next.
- 4:09And I started by upgrading my knowledge.
- 4:12I did a a master's thesis after retirement looking at democracy from the perspective of
- 4:18conflict and conflict resolution, which was very illuminating.
- 4:22And I learned it actually more than a few political scientists look at it in that light.
- 4:28And I spent a lot of time also just catching up on the constitution and important documents
- 4:33like the federalist papers and anti federalist papers and so on.
- 4:37So that's kind of my my three part answer, how I got started.
- 4:42Nice.
- 4:42It that is an important part you bring up.
- 4:45There is a lot to criticize that goes on in this country, and I I think a lot of times,
- 4:50people unfortunately, or at least the loud voices tend to go to one extreme or the other.
- 4:55You either gotta be completely down on America and think like, oh, how can we be proud of
- 5:01anything?
- 5:01Look at all the things that America has done.
- 5:03And then on the other side, it's like, you can't criticize America at all because it's
- 5:07unpatriotic, and I don't think either one of those kinds of responses are helpful.
- 5:12You you need to take the good with the bad.
- 5:14You have to recognize all the many things that have gone wrong, but at the same time, it could
- 5:22be so much worse just like you said.
- 5:24I haven't really gotten to look a whole lot at other countries' constitutions, but, yeah, it's
- 5:31amazing just the stark differences you can find in all those those countries.
- 5:35Although they technically have a basis of law, some of them aren't really even worth the paper
- 5:40that they're written on just because the the authoritarian leaders just basically just do
- 5:46whatever they want.
- 5:47But let's talk about the work now of the CFFAD.
- 5:52Mhmm.
- 5:52So why did you start this organization?
- 5:54And although I talked about it somewhat in the intro, what are some of the things that CFFAD
- 5:59does and that can be found on the website?
- 6:02Yeah.
- 6:03Yeah.
- 6:03Well, so again, the main reason why we got started is because I and several colleagues
- 6:09that I I made acquaintances with felt that most Americans didn't realize how lucky they are,
- 6:15and we wanted to remedy that.
- 6:16And when we started back in 2018, we we started with two observations.
- 6:21First was that civics was oriented mainly around the kindergarten to twelfth grade
- 6:26audience, and that audience was supersaturated really, either by in school programs or
- 6:32nonprofits.
- 6:33You could think of iCivics or you could think of the We the People program, from the Center
- 6:39for Civic Education, and there are many, many more.
- 6:42So that's the first observation.
- 6:45But second, despite that supersaturation, every year you would see reported annual surveys that
- 6:52show that most Americans didn't really understand how our system of government is set
- 6:59up.
- 7:00Never mind why.
- 7:01We definitely wanted to try to tackle that.
- 7:05Our approach so far is we're still fairly young organization.
- 7:10There's much more for us to do.
- 7:11But so far, we've been offering short courses on government, what governments can do for us.
- 7:17You'd you'd be surprised that a lot of people aren't even clear on that.
- 7:22What governments can do for us, an introduction to congress, to the presidency, to the
- 7:26judiciary, to federalism, covering all those bases, some discussion of elections.
- 7:32And as you mentioned correctly, all of those courses have been reviewed by experts on the
- 7:37right and the left.
- 7:39We are overtly nonpartisan.
- 7:42But maybe what is important to note so far is that what distinguishes us from the traditional
- 7:49civics curricula, besides the fact that we're catering to adults, is that we're highlighting
- 7:54maybe a little more than most civics curricula would.
- 7:58How today's issues of trust and distrust between various political parties and factions,
- 8:04they actually have strong parallels to those in the framers' time.
- 8:08And we show how the framers used the constitution to manage that distrust, and in
- 8:15particular, the distrust of government.
- 8:18The government in their day was well known for its capacity to do harm to ordinary people.
- 8:26And, we show how how the again, how the the framers used the constitution to limit that
- 8:31harm.
- 8:32Also, how the system changed over time because it has a lot, and how those changes might
- 8:38affect our trust today.
- 8:39And we also get into the weeds maybe a little bit more than the K through 12 curricula would
- 8:46on how citizens can interact with their government.
- 8:50If you're a businessman fighting or hoping for certain regulations, where do you go?
- 8:56Who do you contact?
- 8:57It's it's more than just your congressman.
- 8:59There are a lot of important offices now in the executive branch that a lot of people don't
- 9:04know about.
- 9:05So we we try to make those types of things a little bit more apparent for the adult readers.
- 9:12Hope that's a good answer.
- 9:13No.
- 9:14It is.
- 9:14And it makes me think of when you were talking about the distrust in the framers' time and in
- 9:22the founding fathers' time, and that was something I discussed in an episode I made for
- 9:27the podcast a couple weeks ago, basically about what would the founding fathers and the framers
- 9:32of the constitution think about America today because you often hear so much about and a lot
- 9:37of times it's couched in which political party is ruling at the time.
- 9:42But this whole, oh, the founding fathers would be so disgusted with with what's going on right
- 9:47now.
- 9:48And a lot of times, Republicans say that when it's a Democrat when there's Democrats running
- 9:51the show, and then Democrats will say that when Republicans are running the show.
- 9:55And it's just a kind of some it's a misunderstanding, I suppose, of of history.
- 10:06You had so much of that distrust back then.
- 10:08Even federalists and democratic republicans were constantly at each other's throats and
- 10:13thought the others were trying to destroy the country.
- 10:16So it's it's I believe this is one of the worst eras of polarization that we've had, but it's
- 10:24not the worst.
- 10:26I mean, there's been plenty of comparable ones.
- 10:28And then you, of course, have the civil war where we were quite literally, as much as I
- 10:32hate using that word, quite literally, two different countries because of how much we
- 10:36distrusted each other.
- 10:38So that part in particular resonates with me.
- 10:40And I definitely wanna get a little bit more into some of those more specifically about some
- 10:45of those courses.
- 10:46But like we said at the beginning, one of your organization's goals is to help Americans
- 10:52understand why representative democracy is precious.
- 10:56Do you think that that is something that is missing from civics education where, like, it's
- 11:00just basically treated as a given maybe?
- 11:03And how does this recent public opinion polling on the negativity about democracy and support
- 11:09for authoritarianism affect that goal?
- 11:13Mhmm.
- 11:14Mhmm.
- 11:14Yeah.
- 11:15So is it missing that democracy is precious in most civics curricula?
- 11:23In a sense, on the one hand, there are civics curricula that sort of focus on American
- 11:29exceptionalism, and maybe there's a presumption there that democracy American democracy is
- 11:37valuable, is precious.
- 11:39But I don't know that even the exceptionalist school spells it out quite the way that I I
- 11:47would hope for in my board members.
- 11:50I think in in general, it's it's missing.
- 11:53In general, I think most civics content is created on the assumption that The US system of
- 11:59government is permanent and ever improving.
- 12:02People talk about American democracy as an idea, as an aspiration, so that it's something
- 12:08that's always improving.
- 12:09And if that's true, there's little need to explore why democracy is better than anarchy or
- 12:16authoritarian alternatives.
- 12:18I think about the defeat of Nazism in World War II and the collapse of communism, and I think,
- 12:25to some extent, they've been misinterpreted to mean that there's no serious competition to
- 12:30democracy.
- 12:31And in fact, the end of World War two saw the consolidation of the Soviet dictatorship, and
- 12:37even the collapse of that system in 1991 did not mean the end of authoritarianism and
- 12:43autocratic regimes.
- 12:44You know, the most obvious examples are the People's Republic Of China and North Korea, but
- 12:50there are little autocracies scattered all over the world.
- 12:53So perhaps there's more to it than an exceptional system of government that's
- 13:00permanent and ever improving.
- 13:02Maybe it's important to explore why democracy is better, and that could be added to the other
- 13:08jobs of civics to explain the history of our government and how it works and our liberties,
- 13:13rights, and obligations.
- 13:15So let's link that into your other question.
- 13:17You mentioned recent polling on attitudes about democracy and authoritarianism.
- 13:23For us and our organization, the situation is quite concerning.
- 13:27Published survey data show that the support for representative democracy has been declining for
- 13:32decades.
- 13:34This is not a new problem.
- 13:36It's been going on for at least thirty years.
- 13:39And at the same time, a lot of people are increasingly tempted by authoritarian
- 13:43alternatives.
- 13:44Can I throw just a few numbers at you?
- 13:47Sure.
- 13:47Go ahead.
- 13:48Yeah.
- 13:49So, these are from the World Values Survey and a survey by Activote.
- 13:56So in 1995, 24% of Americans who were polled supported a strong unrestrained leader,
- 14:05somebody who is unrestrained by congress or the courts.
- 14:09And by 2017, that had increased to 37%.
- 14:13That's a lot.
- 14:14And this smaller active vote survey maybe give it a little margin of error, but in 2025, that
- 14:23percentage increased to 40%.
- 14:25Even if it stayed at 37%, that's too much.
- 14:30Mhmm.
- 14:31For us, that that we think that reality ought to be setting off three alarm fire in the civic
- 14:37education community.
- 14:39I mean, what if our system of government is not permanent after all?
- 14:43And how are citizens to fully understand how much they risk giving up by supporting
- 14:49authoritarian and autocratic tactics when no one's teaching them the pros and cons of
- 14:55authoritarian government versus democracy and when no one's teaching them what authoritarian
- 15:00tactics look like.
- 15:04Good news is our research shows that a lot of the people tempted by authoritarian options are
- 15:10actually ambivalent between democracy and autocracy.
- 15:14And we find that this ambivalence is present in both major parties.
- 15:20It's not that you can point the finger at one or the other.
- 15:22In fact, typically, happens is people's support for democracy increases when their opposition
- 15:30is in the White House.
- 15:31Yeah.
- 15:32And their support for autocratic options increases when their party is in control.
- 15:39Why can't we just get things done?
- 15:41Let's get rid of these rules that get in our way.
- 15:44It's almost natural.
- 15:45Right?
- 15:46So one of the changes that we'd like to make in our work and that we'll be focusing on over the
- 15:51next couple of years is trying to address that ambivalent audience more directly and and
- 15:57trying to help them conclude in favor of American democracy.
- 16:01So there you go.
- 16:02Yeah.
- 16:04That's that's that's the that's the funny thing about authoritarianism and and democracy or
- 16:09when you're talking about certain rules for the quote unquote, the other side versus your side,
- 16:15you're a lot more wanting restrictions on how government works when it's people who don't do
- 16:22what you wanna do.
- 16:23And then when it is people that do what you wanna do, then all of a sudden, you're like,
- 16:28just let them do whatever they want.
- 16:29It's always funny how that works.
- 16:31Right?
- 16:31And I I think this might be reading into things too much, but I think part of that is that
- 16:38there's it does feel like there's less empathy and ability for people to put themselves in
- 16:44other people's shoes, at least when it comes to politics and try to see why people feel the way
- 16:50they do.
- 16:51Mhmm.
- 16:51And a while ago, I had a an episode that talked about efficient versus deliberative democracy.
- 16:57It was kind of a workshopping idea, and it's it's not a it's not a new concept.
- 17:02I don't know if it's necessarily been worded the same way that I thought of it, but, you
- 17:07know, it's that whole tug and pull between, do you want a government that is quick to get
- 17:11things done, but maybe doesn't think all things all the way through?
- 17:14Or do you want a government that is more pensive, but there's a pressing issue that
- 17:20needs to be taken care of and you might not necessarily have the time?
- 17:23And I talked about it in all sorts of different context of government's powers and so on.
- 17:30And it's it's it's one of the things one of those things that's not easy to answer, but I
- 17:36do wish that more people realize the ambivalence like you said.
- 17:40I would even go so far as to call it hypocrisy for some people as to say, well, if our
- 17:47person's in the White House and and they and they run the government, we like
- 17:51authoritarianism more.
- 17:52It's one of those one of the prime examples I think of is support for the filibuster.
- 17:58I'm not gonna name names, but I can definitely think of both Democrats and Republicans that
- 18:02have flipped the switch on what whether they support the filibuster in the US senate, and it
- 18:09just so happens to be conveniently based on whether their party controls the US senate at
- 18:14that point.
- 18:15When your party doesn't control The US Senate, the filibuster is the greatest thing ever.
- 18:19When you do control the US senate, suddenly the filibuster is a scourge that needs to be
- 18:23eliminated.
- 18:24And it's just a shame that some people are just so blinded by their partisanship and ideology
- 18:31that they'll sometimes be completely willing to be so hypocritical about it.
- 18:37But one of the other things I mentioned about CFFAD is that that you guys work to help
- 18:44Americans understand, protect, and improve the foundations of trust in our republic.
- 18:50So how do you guys do that, and why do you think there is such a lack of trust in American
- 18:55political institutions and how do we go about fixing that?
- 18:58Right.
- 18:59Those are pretty big questions.
- 19:01Yeah.
- 19:03Definitely.
- 19:04On your first question, I think we we'd like to do better.
- 19:08We we know that there's more that we could be doing, but thus far, we've been using our
- 19:13rather small advertising budget to reach out to any and all interested Americans, adults.
- 19:19And we've been focusing mainly on helping them understand our system is valuable and how it's
- 19:25set up and how that value is created.
- 19:27And we're doing that on the assumption that that understanding can lead to better trust.
- 19:33And we then offer pointers on how citizens can interact with various government offices.
- 19:39And our hope is that that will set the stage for people so inclined to do their own research
- 19:44into how they might act in support of American democracy.
- 19:49And we had some survey data showing that, typically, who have that better knowledge are
- 19:55are more participatory and more time will tell which way causality is flowing though.
- 20:02I mean, that's I I think we we need to be alert and keep track of the actual impact that we're
- 20:08having.
- 20:08I could talk your head off about about that about that.
- 20:12But moving on to the the the second question, why trust in democracy has been falling?
- 20:18Well, there's a lot of theories, and I'm not sure there's consensus.
- 20:23But I think probably most people would agree with the following.
- 20:27First, yes, there is a lack of knowledge, and that's definitely part of it.
- 20:32Alongside of that, there has been organized persistent efforts at disinformation, long
- 20:39standing in some cases, you know, coming from the former Soviet Union and now coming from
- 20:46existing Russian government, the Chinese government, the Persian government, and others
- 20:51who would like to see American democracy divided and weakened.
- 20:56Poor performance on the part of the government is a very big part of distrust for many people.
- 21:01But in that context, polarization both leads to poor performance through gridlock, and it
- 21:09worsens the frustration each side feels.
- 21:12They feel cheated by the other side.
- 21:14They're getting more than us.
- 21:15Well, that frustration provides easy excuses for all sorts of attacks on elections, attacks
- 21:22on checks and balances, our liberties and rights.
- 21:25It's not a healthy thing.
- 21:27And if you don't like democracy, disinformation and polarization are great tactics.
- 21:32And frankly, I think Americans should understand they're being manipulated.
- 21:36This is real stuff.
- 21:37It's really happening.
- 21:39So I I wanna mention a few other bits and pieces of Alongside the frustration, there's a
- 21:46certain mindset some people have for better or for worse.
- 21:49They they're just expedient.
- 21:51They want they want solutions, and they don't care how they get them.
- 21:55If a democratic government can deliver, that's great.
- 21:58If it takes an autocrat to make it happen, that's great.
- 22:02So their expediency leads them open to giving up their voice and their rights if they believe
- 22:09it's gonna lead to better results.
- 22:12And that expedient mindset's definitely evident within the ambivalent audience that we're
- 22:18interested in serving.
- 22:19So all of these topics, knowledge of what's essential to democracy, disinformation,
- 22:25polarization, expediency, we'll hope to address more and more as we go forward shifting towards
- 22:32our ambivalent audience.
- 22:33Paul, I don't wanna put too much emphasis on trust.
- 22:38Some distrust can be a healthy thing.
- 22:40You might remember Thomas Jefferson was alleged to have said, eternal vigilance is the price of
- 22:46liberty.
- 22:46Well, there's surely something to that.
- 22:49And, frankly, that distrust, as I mentioned earlier, has a lot to do with why the framers
- 22:55included checks and balances in our constitution as well as civil liberties, civil
- 23:01rights, rule of law.
- 23:02They knew their leaders might use government to do harm, and they wanted to make that as hard
- 23:09as possible in our new system of government.
- 23:12So I've probably gone on too long, but there's some thoughts for your in response to your two
- 23:18questions.
- 23:18No.
- 23:19No.
- 23:19That's okay.
- 23:20I agree with just about everything there.
- 23:24I I would say I think there's a fine line that you you can draw between skepticism and
- 23:33suspicion and distress.
- 23:34And I think a lot of times we unfortunately spill way too much over onto the suspicion
- 23:39side, but you definitely also can't just assume that government is always there to help you out
- 23:45or that everybody's got altruistic motives because that's just not true.
- 23:49That's not that's not realistic to think.
- 23:52So it's it's it's that's definitely an important point to be saying, well, we can't
- 23:56just outright trust everything either because that's that's not gonna help anybody either.
- 24:01Ignorance in that scenario is not bliss.
- 24:05But one thing that you did say that I also want to expound on, you're talking about that you
- 24:10want people to realize how much they're being manipulated.
- 24:13I think you do.
- 24:15I think people it's not the the issue is not that people don't realize they're being
- 24:20manipulated.
- 24:20I think a lot of people do.
- 24:22I think they just don't understand how it is happening and how their biases are coming into
- 24:31play.
- 24:31They can A lot of times, conveniently, the manipulation's only coming from people that
- 24:35don't think like them.
- 24:36Mhmm.
- 24:37You know?
- 24:38And I think, and and funny enough, that actually makes you easier to manipulate because
- 24:43now people that are more similar to you in thinking who are also who can be nefarious
- 24:49actors, now they know that you're basically going to just believe anything they say so you
- 24:55can sow distrust about elections that don't go the way you want them to or that basically
- 25:01everything that they're trying to do is going to destroy this country.
- 25:05And I I think you that's how there's just this people realize there's manipulation, but they
- 25:12don't realize just how extensive it is, and they don't really understand how to better
- 25:17protect themselves against it.
- 25:19There's
- 25:20Mhmm.
- 25:21And I think goes back to that whole spilling too much over into suspicion and distrust and
- 25:27hate versus being healthily skeptical.
- 25:31But, I mean, yeah, that's that's something that you can just we could go on for hours and that
- 25:36could be its own episode.
- 25:38I I do wanna dive more into trust in our political institutions at some point, but I do
- 25:44also wanna get to this next question here.
- 25:48So states vary in all sorts of ways in what they teach about civics, how they assess
- 25:53learning, whether it's required in middle and or high school and so on.
- 25:57And you you brought up I iCivics earlier in the conversation, and it it wasn't the I think it's
- 26:02a organization that is now under their their umbrella, and I'm I'm forgetting what they're
- 26:08called.
- 26:08But they had a map of that showed, like, all sorts of differences in how states handle
- 26:14civics and how they teach it.
- 26:15Do you think that there should be more standardization of civics across all the states
- 26:21and The US territories?
- 26:23And if you do, how much would you say they should be standardized?
- 26:26Yeah.
- 26:27That's a very fraught question in some ways.
- 26:29I'd like to start out just observing that the constitution leaves educational policy to the
- 26:36states, and I think we need to honor that.
- 26:38But even if it didn't, I I think that we all would benefit from a competition of ideas.
- 26:43So if there were any form of standardization, I'd hope it would be voluntary, and I would
- 26:51propose two things.
- 26:52And your listeners won't be surprised now because I've said them over and over that
- 26:58students first be exposed to the pros and cons of democracy compared to anarchy and
- 27:04authoritarian government.
- 27:06And second, that they should be made aware of the many ways that government institutions can
- 27:12be bent to serve one person or one family or one faction at the expense of others so they
- 27:18know what to look for.
- 27:19And and then they can put that together with Thomas Jefferson's adage to be vigilant.
- 27:24So I think that's where I'd leave it.
- 27:27Yeah.
- 27:28It's it's it's a good microcosm, I suppose, of the whole debate about what should be in the
- 27:36purview of federal and state governments.
- 27:39Yes.
- 27:39There should be a lot of I'm very reluctant to employ a one size fits all kind of policy when
- 27:47it comes to education, but there are you at the same time, there are some concepts that you
- 27:52really wish that everybody knew, but how do you go about implementing that?
- 27:57And then should you basically force people to, for lack of a better term, force people to
- 28:03abide by that?
- 28:04It's a it's a like you you indicated, it's a very fraught or delicate balance to strike
- 28:13there, and it's it's definitely not any easy answers to that.
- 28:17Some of the courses you've had on there, I I like some of the approaches you've had, and
- 28:24you're not just the the courses on the CFFAD website are not just about, oh, well, these are
- 28:29the three branches of government, and this is what this agency does.
- 28:33Now some of them are more like, well, what is corruption?
- 28:37And more not necessarily in the weeds things, but some more unusual concepts that are not
- 28:42necessarily in civics, and it would be nice if those things were implemented more in civics
- 28:47education around the country.
- 28:49But once again, you have to be careful with, you know, dictating what the state should and
- 28:54should not teach.
- 28:56But I think that that really is a good segue into the next question because, obviously,
- 29:01there is a lot of hyperpartisanship and harsh ideological rhetoric going on in today's
- 29:07politics and discussions in general.
- 29:11But do you think that civics education in America specifically also has problems with
- 29:16being used to promote partisan or ideological views rather than the fundamentals of our
- 29:21democracy.
- 29:23Yeah.
- 29:24Maybe I just wanna make one one more remark about your last question.
- 29:28With 50 states, each one different from the other, it's happy for me when they want to sort
- 29:34of extol some of the things that make their states special.
- 29:37So I just wanted to make a note that that that's another good reason for for not imposing
- 29:43too strict standards.
- 29:44It it's an amazing country that we live in, and I think people need to know that.
- 29:49But coming to the the the the partisanship and whether civics is used maybe as a weapon in
- 29:55partisan battles.
- 29:56Well, yeah.
- 29:57I mean, from the outside, it does look like that.
- 30:02That's happening.
- 30:04And I think because I'm I'm old enough now, I can look backwards.
- 30:09I think it's sort of long been true, and maybe it's only natural in a country like ours.
- 30:15We have so many people from so many different kinds of backgrounds with so many different
- 30:20kinds of perspectives and needs.
- 30:22So perhaps to some extent, we should expect that there will be always a contest about what
- 30:30should be taught in civics and and in many other topics, frankly.
- 30:34But I think you're right to put your thumb on the important point that it's not a good idea
- 30:42to let partisan fights obscure the fundamentals.
- 30:46And I say that because power shifts from time to time.
- 30:50Power alternates, and it is in the interest of every partisan, no matter which side you're on,
- 30:57to maintain some of the fundamental institutions of American democracy.
- 31:03People and parties on the losing end of the stick in any given moment need to know that
- 31:09they can compete again and again in the future in fair contests.
- 31:15And that kind of assurance only comes when you have accountable representation, checks and
- 31:22balances, civil liberties, civil rights, rule of law, federalism, and all of that backed by a
- 31:28written constitution.
- 31:29These things protect everyone no matter which side you're on.
- 31:34So, yeah, have your partisan fights.
- 31:37Sometimes those fights can be very productive even.
- 31:39Sometimes they're fights worth having, but don't throw out the things that protect you.
- 31:48Absolute oh, sorry.
- 31:49Go ahead.
- 31:50No.
- 31:50I was just gonna say one one one thing that we we sometimes say around here is don't give your
- 31:55leaders more power than you'd tolerate in your opposition.
- 31:59So yeah.
- 32:00Over to you.
- 32:01Yeah.
- 32:02Yeah.
- 32:02Especially when you think of going back to the whole, it's okay if my side is authoritarian.
- 32:07It's goes, at some point in time, you give your side too much power.
- 32:12Now your side is going to try to dictate the future of your side, and now you're gonna start
- 32:18splitting off.
- 32:19And now you used to be on the winning side, and now you may be under the thumb of people who
- 32:25now get to dictate government policy or how civics should be taught.
- 32:31And now suddenly, maybe you regret those actions or or maybe you don't see your own part
- 32:37in how that happened.
- 32:38And, I mean, obviously, a lot of people think that it's not their side being partisan.
- 32:42It's it's the other side being partisan.
- 32:44Conveniently or funny enough, that is also partisan itself.
- 32:48But, yeah, I think there's there's a not just obviously, I I mean, I do think that there's
- 32:58partisanship and ideology that seeps into civics education too much, but maybe civics
- 33:04education also needs to include ways to be able to spot that.
- 33:08But I think you do also bring up a good point that there has that that's not necessarily a
- 33:12new thing either in civics.
- 33:14So that's been a thing that's that's happened before and it's been a thing that we've had to
- 33:19discuss and deal with before.
- 33:21And a while back, I had a guest on here.
- 33:24His name is Alex Vaster, and he was talking about the preservation of political information
- 33:30because he has this database about California political history.
- 33:35And it's it's really fascinating thing he's he's built over there.
- 33:39And we got on to civics, and he said something that really has stuck with me to to this day.
- 33:45And, basically, he said that civics is about our relationship with our governments and
- 33:51teaching government is more about the simple facts of how it all works.
- 33:55And over time, the education has been trending more towards government rather than civics.
- 34:01And basically felt like that might be a reason why fewer people seem to care about civics
- 34:08these days.
- 34:09So do you see that as well?
- 34:12Do you think that civics education is missing that relationship between citizen and
- 34:18governments, or do you see it differently?
- 34:21I might see it a little differently.
- 34:27Know, I think most civics textbooks have pretty strong sections on how students can and should
- 34:34participate in our government and what their some of their obligations are in that regard.
- 34:40And I don't think that that's changed much over the last many decades.
- 34:44So if if that's relationship, if that's what he's talking about, I think that that's that's
- 34:49been there and is still there.
- 34:51But what I'm seeing and our our organization is seeing is that, well, those of you who are
- 34:58listening who are in the civics profession will be shocked by this at all.
- 35:02But the share of students who get access to a good civic education had been falling since the
- 35:08nineteen seventies, really.
- 35:11A lot of people lost faith in government either because of or during the civil rights battles
- 35:20and then Vietnam and Watergate.
- 35:23And then there was a push to move education towards science and technology and away from
- 35:31the arts, and civics lost out in that fight as well.
- 35:35And it's only recently that access to civics has started to improve again.
- 35:40So there's been a real several lost decades there.
- 35:43And even where it's improving in terms of access, a lot of it's still quite superficial.
- 35:49A few states even only require that their students pass the 100 questions in the the
- 35:57citizenship test.
- 35:59And if you ever look at that citizenship test, those 100 questions, not a single one directly
- 36:05addresses the value of American democracy and how that that value is created.
- 36:12So superficial and generally lacking in any discussion of the pros and cons of democracy
- 36:18versus authoritarianism and authoritarian tactics.
- 36:21So yeah.
- 36:22So I I think I'd I'd I'd put the I'd put the emphasis on things other than the participatory
- 36:31role of because that's there.
- 36:35Gotcha.
- 36:36I I guess I I kinda see it for I if a little bit from both perspectives, I feel like but at
- 36:45the same time, that's also a good point to bring up as a lot of it is just the pure access
- 36:50to civics just hasn't been there.
- 36:53And and maybe they just really it's not so much that they haven't been taught the relationship
- 36:58to governments for for some people, but more just that they haven't even had the opportunity
- 37:05to have that be taught to them.
- 37:07But that that was it still was something that I thought was a very intriguing point of view.
- 37:12And it it since it's been a while since I had the the the that interview with with Alex, I I
- 37:17might have forgotten some of the nuances of of his answer too.
- 37:22But it it does feel like sometimes when people talk about civics, it's it's more just rote
- 37:27facts about government rather than the the essence of why all this stuff matters.
- 37:33May and and maybe that's more of kind of what I'm trying to get at.
- 37:38It kind of goes back to what we were talking about earlier as we kind of assume that it's
- 37:41self explanatory why this stuff matters, but if you just assume that it's self explanatory why
- 37:48democracy is the route to go, why the American system of government despite all its flaws
- 37:53still works, then eventually people are going to start questioning it and and say, well, you
- 37:58know what?
- 37:59This actually isn't working instead of having all the information that we just took for
- 38:04granted be taught to them before.
- 38:06And so a couple more questions before we wrap up.
- 38:11Mhmm.
- 38:12An intriguing article on the CFFAD websites that I came across was this proposal of six
- 38:20points that tend to be well, actually, it's looks like it's actually more like a, like,
- 38:26seven, but six or seven points that tends to be missed but should be added to civic education
- 38:31for all ages.
- 38:32Now, obviously, all of those are important.
- 38:33That's why you have them on this article.
- 38:36But I wanted to see if there are any that you would especially stress and could you expound
- 38:43upon them.
- 38:44Mhmm.
- 38:44Okay.
- 38:45When I think about that, I find it hard to stick to just two or three.
- 38:53Doesn't have to be your favorites.
- 38:54Just two or three that right now you you wanna expound on.
- 38:57Yeah.
- 38:57Well, so the first, I suppose, would be that people have to accept that there are always
- 39:06gonna be people who disagree in any society.
- 39:10They're gonna disagree on what the problems are.
- 39:12They're gonna disagree on how to solve the problems.
- 39:14So they're gonna disagree on what's fair and what's just.
- 39:17Any place, any time.
- 39:19Take Iceland.
- 39:20It's one of the most ethnically pure countries in the world, but they disagree on all kinds of
- 39:26things.
- 39:27Taxes, whether it include whether it's to stop whaling or not, who should profit from their
- 39:34cheap geothermal energy, how much tourism to tolerate, all kinds of things to argue about.
- 39:41Second, governments are created.
- 39:47They are created, and they're created by people to make decisions for their society.
- 39:57Sometimes the people making governments are elites.
- 40:00Sometimes they're the people with the most guns.
- 40:03Sometimes they're just ordinary people.
- 40:05Sometimes those governments are created to solve problems and disagreements in ways that
- 40:11most citizens can support, and sometimes they're created just to impose solutions
- 40:17regardless of what people think.
- 40:22But because governments are created by people, no form of government is permanent.
- 40:29Opportunistic people are always gonna be trying to bend the rules to their advantage.
- 40:34And I remember at the the beginning of our discussion together, you you mentioned the
- 40:40federalists and the Democratic Republican Party.
- 40:43I just wanna use that as an example.
- 40:45So not long after the American government was established under the new constitution, the
- 40:52government was run by the Federalists.
- 40:55John Adams was the president, and he did not have much tolerance for dissent.
- 41:01And he felt that because we were, at the time, engaged in a low level conflict with France
- 41:08over trade, that dissent was dangerous in his opinion.
- 41:12He and his supporters in Congress passed an antisedition law.
- 41:17And they did this despite the fact that the constitution included the Bill of Rights and
- 41:25free speech.
- 41:26Well, they're bending the rules to their advantage.
- 41:29They don't wanna hear dissent from the Democratic Republican Party.
- 41:33People were jailed.
- 41:35There's a congressman from Vermont who accused president Adams of having a thirst for a
- 41:40ridiculous pump, and a newspaper editor who defended that congressman in print was jailed.
- 41:49A journalist who called president Adams a hermaphrodite was jailed.
- 41:55An ordinary citizen who was caught saying that he hoped president Adams would get hit in the
- 42:00rear by a cannonball who was jailed.
- 42:02You know, these things sound ridiculous, but they really happen because somebody in power
- 42:09and their supporters didn't wanna tolerate dissent.
- 42:14So those are three.
- 42:15I gotta toss in the fourth, which is if governments are created by people and no form
- 42:22of government is permanent, then what form of government is best?
- 42:25We hope to convince you that the legislative debate and compromise in the American system of
- 42:32government, at least as it's supposed to be, is far better than absolute monarchs, dictators,
- 42:40military juntas, theocracies.
- 42:42I just want to toss out some reasons why democracies tend to be less corrupt, and I know
- 42:47a lot of people are very upset by government corruption.
- 42:51They are more inclusive of all peoples in their territory.
- 42:56They are better at problem solving and for a variety of reasons.
- 43:01But the stability and the openness of of democracies are are just naturally facilitative
- 43:08of a lot of innovation that you you won't find in in lesser countries.
- 43:15They are democracies tend to be more stable, less violent.
- 43:19They offer more amenities, and they're just generally richer and and happier.
- 43:24All all things worth worth having.
- 43:26So those aren't the four.
- 43:28I know you wanted only two or three, but
- 43:30That's that's that's alright.
- 43:31I I will say one that I mean, obviously, they all speak to me, but something that's I think
- 43:39is really not I I think most of these people theoretically would would agree with.
- 43:46Now whether they actually do, because some people like we just talked about, like with
- 43:50John Adams and and people in general, they say, oh, yeah.
- 43:53We should be able to disagree, but they get really upset if people disagree.
- 43:57But something I think a lot of people really don't truly accept is the is the fact that
- 44:06there's inevitable trade offs.
- 44:09Even within democracy, there are always trade offs.
- 44:11When you debate policies, there is any policy you come up with.
- 44:16It's made by human beings.
- 44:17It involves human beings.
- 44:18It applies to human beings.
- 44:20There's something that's gonna be wrong with it.
- 44:22There's always, always something that's going to be a fault, and you just won't be able to
- 44:28fix everything.
- 44:29And so you have to debate between multiple things.
- 44:32And I think you see that a lot with it's one of the things that I really get frustrated with
- 44:38ideologues about is just because ideology likes to package things up very neatly and say, well,
- 44:45you know, everything can be can be fixed and explained by capitalism, socialism, communism,
- 44:53conservatism, liberalism, anarchism, fascism, whatever the case may be.
- 44:58But there's always going to be something wrong with it.
- 45:01And some of them are a lot more wrong than others, like fascism, for example.
- 45:07But democracy, for all its flaws, and it has many flaws, it can be very slow, it can be
- 45:14inefficient.
- 45:15It can sometimes still lead to a bad policy, but it's far better than what you're gonna get
- 45:22with or with any other system of government like you said.
- 45:25And is it people wanna focus so much on the flaws of of something they don't like and then
- 45:32minimize flaws of a policy that they do like, and it's it's something that I find very
- 45:37frustrating.
- 45:38And I I'm I'm not gonna pretend like I haven't done that myself because I I definitely have.
- 45:42We all have our biases, but I think it's just something that is just so the fact that there
- 45:48are trade offs with basically everything you do or opportunity costs since you're an economist.
- 45:53You think of it in the in the sense of opportunity costs.
- 45:58It's it's what you're you're always going to have something like that involved.
- 46:03And I think that's something that does need to be emphasized more, not just in civics, but
- 46:07just in general.
- 46:08Mhmm.
- 46:09But we are coming up near the very end.
- 46:11I do have one more question after this, but let's go ahead and get to this.
- 46:19Are there any final thoughts you'd like to leave us about civic education or making a fair
- 46:23and accountable democracy, and how can viewers and listeners help out the CF?
- 46:29Yeah.
- 46:29Okay.
- 46:30Well, I was wondering if I could try to end on a a little bit of an optimistic note.
- 46:36For sure.
- 46:37So in just the same way that governments are made by people, I wanna observe that
- 46:42polarization is also made by people.
- 46:45It's something manufactured by people who see little use for collaboration or compromise.
- 46:52But when you accept that these things are driven by people who have some purpose in mind,
- 46:58it should be a little bit easier to imagine that we ordinary people also have the power to
- 47:05unmake polarization and to improve American democracy.
- 47:11In that spirit, I I wanna give you the other half of the John Adams and the anti sedition
- 47:16story.
- 47:17Your followers might be interested to learn that, Thomas Jefferson and and John Adams who
- 47:22were at each other's throats, not only over the antisedition and the trade wars, but many other
- 47:28things.
- 47:29And they both died on the fiftieth anniversary of the declaration of independence in 1826,
- 47:36having become friends again for the last fifteen years of their life.
- 47:40And that came about through the efforts of their mutual friend, doctor Benjamin Rush.
- 47:47He didn't say, well, they just hate each other, and it's so sad.
- 47:51He did something about it and, led to wonderful things, true friendship to their dying day on
- 47:56the fiftieth declaration of independence.
- 47:59So that's something to think about on Independence Day.
- 48:02I know it's also all about family and fireworks, and those are very important.
- 48:08But let's also think how we wanna conduct ourselves in our independence.
- 48:12So that's how I might leave it.
- 48:14As to how people can help us, well, we we welcome volunteers.
- 48:18We welcome partners.
- 48:20And especially, we'd love to know if anybody else is out there already addressing the
- 48:25ambivalent audience, already helping them conclude in favor of democracy successfully or
- 48:31unsuccessfully.
- 48:32We can learn from each other.
- 48:34So, volunteers, partners, all in, and we're grateful, Paul, for for this opportunity.
- 48:40Sure.
- 48:41And I'm thankful for you for coming on here.
- 48:44Yeah, that's something I look back to and sometimes cite as John Adams and Thomas
- 48:49Jefferson being such great friends.
- 48:52They were founding fathers, and then they were torn apart by politics, and then they
- 48:58eventually came back together.
- 48:59And you you look at just how many people are being torn apart, friendships are being
- 49:04severed, familial relationships are being disintegrated.
- 49:11Stories like that in a time where communication was much tougher than it is now.
- 49:16It's something that you can look back to to say that these separate relationships don't have to
- 49:23be that way for the rest of their of people's lives.
- 49:28And so I appreciate you bringing that that part up.
- 49:31So to wrap things up here now is and to be on another lighthearted note.
- 49:38So for anybody who's new to the podcast and and for previous listeners, whenever I have a guest
- 49:44on, I like to have a random, fun, non political question just to get a different side of our
- 49:50guests.
- 49:51And also, they're just weird questions that I just think about sometimes.
- 49:55So, Doug Addison, today's random question for you is which US president had the best hair?
- 50:05And that can be facial and or top of the head.
- 50:10I have never ever thought about that before.
- 50:14No?
- 50:16Never.
- 50:16You know, I'm just thinking the founding fathers often wore wigs.
- 50:22It's also true.
- 50:23So we may not have the best idea of there may there may have been baldness or something going
- 50:28on underneath there.
- 50:30So I think Grant had a nice photo.
- 50:34Grant Grant did have a very sick beard.
- 50:36I I I gotta hand it to him for that.
- 50:38That's a good choice.
- 50:39I believe James Garfield was also one who had a similar beard.
- 50:42I wanna didn't he?
- 50:44I had to look at look at him again, but I think he has some had some photos of that too.
- 50:48Now for my money, though, just for out of pure uniqueness is I gotta hand it to mister Martin
- 50:55Van Buren.
- 50:56I know he his his presidency is not necessarily remembered the most fondly because of the the
- 51:01panic of is it 1837, I think?
- 51:04But, boy, those mutton chops, those are very hard to beat.
- 51:08I don't know if any I don't know many people that can pull that off these days, but those
- 51:12those sideburns, those mutton chops, yeah, those those are pretty incredible.
- 51:18So I I gotta hand it to him there.
- 51:20I would never I would never try that out myself.
- 51:22But
- 51:23There were some some etchings of Teddy Roosevelt in his youth had some pretty good
- 51:28munchies.
- 51:30Yep.
- 51:30And and Teddy Roosevelt just I mean, he's got gotta have specifically the best mustache that
- 51:36any president has ever had.
- 51:38So, yeah, gotta give that to him for there.
- 51:40But
- 51:41Well, I thank you for that questions.
- 51:44No.
- 51:44Absolutely.
- 51:45More in the future.
- 51:47Yeah.
- 51:47Exact exactly.
- 51:49Yeah.
- 51:49No.
- 51:49Some it's just those are just things I think about sometimes.
- 51:52But sometimes politics gets a little too serious.
- 51:56Sometimes you just need something that's a little different.
- 51:59But Yeah.
- 52:00But I I appreciate you humor humoring me with that question.
- 52:05So I will in the show notes, will obviously put the CFFAD website.
- 52:10I'll also put the link to those, to that question about what we should add to civics.
- 52:15I'll also add that.
- 52:16Are there any other links that you would like me to put in the show notes?
- 52:23Yeah.
- 52:23Well, there's a second post related to what what should we add to civics a week or two ago.
- 52:29So you could put the two of those together if you like.
- 52:31And then, yeah, the link to our courses, and and we also have a glossary of terms.
- 52:37You they could eat just catch that through the the general website or or you could give the
- 52:42links directly as you wish.
- 52:44Okay.
- 52:44Okay.
- 52:45I'll I'll add those then.
- 52:47As for my links, my several works that I have, my five day educational email course about how
- 52:52we can all better mitigate polarization and toxicity in this country.
- 52:57My first book well, it's planned to be the the currently, only book I have, but hopefully soon
- 53:05to be the first book that I've had.
- 53:08My book on independence and why they struggle so much in elections and how they could
- 53:14possibly become more competitive, that is on Amazon and several other retailers.
- 53:18I'll have the links for that as well.
- 53:20And my writings on medium..com.
- 53:22And then for my other links, my LinkedIn, my Facebook, my website, Paul Raider dot org, and
- 53:27my email, PaulRaiderwrites@Gmail.com.
- 53:32And that's going to wrap things up for us on this end.
- 53:35Thank you so much again for coming on, Doug, and for you at home for listening and watching,
- 53:41and we'll see you next time.