Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Understanding California Bicycle Laws and Injury Claims with Kiran Bisla
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Understanding California Bicycle Laws
- 0:06and Injury Claims. I'm Allapoli Castro, CLE advisor
- 0:09for the Beverly Hills Bar Association, and today
- 0:12I'm delighted to introduce our speaker, Kiran
- 0:15Bisla. Kiran is a partner and co -founder of
- 0:18Sky Law Group. After graduating law school, Karen
- 0:21began her legal career by representing large
- 0:24corporations and complex litigation. However,
- 0:27Karen's passion and aptitude for masterfully
- 0:29dealing with cases involving a high level of
- 0:32emotion, need for trust, and relationship building
- 0:34steered Karen to representing individual plaintiffs
- 0:37in tort -based and family law matters. Karen's
- 0:40tort -based cases span everything from bicycle
- 0:42and pedestrian accidents, premises liability,
- 0:45to municipal claims, and even domestic violence
- 0:47-based cases. At the end of each day, Karen is
- 0:50pleased to be able to do good work for good people
- 0:52and is truly humbled by the gratitude of her
- 0:55clients for the legal services she provides.
- 0:58We can't wait to hear what she has to share with
- 1:00us here today. Karen? Thank you, Ala. I appreciate
- 1:04your introduction. So thank you for being here
- 1:06today this afternoon. Today we're going to take
- 1:10a comprehensive look at California's bicycle
- 1:13and e -bike laws and how they're impacting personal
- 1:17injury litigation in real time. Before we get
- 1:21started, I wanted to let everyone know that I'm
- 1:23going to have a very detailed PowerPoint presentation
- 1:26today. I will make that available to everyone
- 1:29after, so please don't rush to write notes. You
- 1:32can have my PowerPoint. So bicycle laws and e
- 1:36-bike laws is a rapidly evolving space. Whether
- 1:39you're representing cyclists or defending municipalities,
- 1:43understanding both the legal framework and the
- 1:45cultural shifts surrounding alternative transportation
- 1:49is essential. My goal today is to equip you with
- 1:52current statutory knowledge. practical case strategy
- 1:56tips, and tools to better analyze fault, immunity,
- 2:00and insurance coverage in many of these cases.
- 2:03Hopefully today you'll walk away with a better
- 2:05grasp of new laws, trends, and practical strategies
- 2:09to better represent your clients. Okay, can we
- 2:13go to the next slide? So here's my agenda for
- 2:19today's presentation. I'm going to give you a
- 2:22roadmap for the next hour. We'll start with a
- 2:24quick overview of crash trends and why this topic
- 2:28is increasingly important for litigators. We'll
- 2:31then break down key California vehicle code provisions,
- 2:34especially those that govern cyclist behavior
- 2:37and street positioning. From there, we'll look
- 2:39at sidewalk writing rules, which is very, very
- 2:42annoying, which are highly dependent on local
- 2:45municipal codes that vary with streets at some
- 2:48times. E -bike laws are changing quickly, so
- 2:51we'll cover recent updates, including the Omni
- 2:54Bike Bill and the 2025 regulatory changes. I'll
- 2:59also share recent case law, notably the California
- 3:02Supreme Court's decision in Tanzavadi and its
- 3:06implications for governmental immunity. Finally,
- 3:09we'll wrap with insurance considerations, litigation
- 3:11tips, and some injury hotspots in Southern California.
- 3:16And this is going to be our roadmap. We'll begin
- 3:20with crash data, dig into California vehicle
- 3:22code and laws governing both traditional and
- 3:25electric bicycles. And please move on. So let's
- 3:31talk about why this matters. So California, due
- 3:34to its amazing climate and weather, leads the
- 3:37United States in 2022 with 149 cycling deaths.
- 3:42California has always been a leader in green
- 3:45transportation, but that comes with unintended
- 3:48consequences, especially when infrastructure
- 3:50and policy lag behind public behavior. Many of
- 3:55these deaths in California involved motor vehicles
- 3:58and could have been mitigated with clearer road
- 4:01rules and better driver awareness. And here are
- 4:03some stats. Los Angeles County averaged 36 bicycle
- 4:07fatalities per year in 2016, with the highest
- 4:11number of 42 fatalities reported in 2019. Changes
- 4:15in laws and protectors for bike riders caused
- 4:18the fatality number to drop to 38 in 2022. Orange
- 4:23County has had about 3 ,953 bicycle incidents
- 4:28and 73 fatalities between 2017 and 2021. In 2022,
- 4:35Orange County had 19 bicycle fatalities. Now
- 4:39at the same time, we're seeing a huge spike in
- 4:41e -bike usage, particularly among minors, which
- 4:45brings a different risk profile. These riders
- 4:48are faster, younger, and often less experienced
- 4:51than traditional cyclists. As lawyers, we must
- 4:55be able to interpret these trends and translate
- 4:58them into arguments about duty, foreseeability,
- 5:02and liability, whether we're making a claim or
- 5:05defending one. Cycling fatalities are climbing
- 5:08and California leads the nation in cyclist deaths.
- 5:11Despite infrastructure improvement, the collision
- 5:14risks are rising, especially with e -bikes. Next
- 5:18slide, please. And in regard to nationwide data
- 5:24changes, e -bikes are now one of the larger types
- 5:30of bikes that are causing injuries and crashes.
- 5:36They were previously counted under motor vehicles
- 5:39in regard to an e -bike crash versus a bike crash.
- 5:44And this small change explains some of the recent
- 5:48statistical spikes and can impact how insurers
- 5:52or municipalities interpret causation and responsibility.
- 5:56Next slide, please. So crash trends by age and
- 6:03location. What's most concerning is minors make
- 6:06up over half of e -bike injury victims. In 2020
- 6:11-13, the injuries rose to 70%. And where were
- 6:15these areas? Mainly coastal and affluent suburban
- 6:18areas. And knowing these patterns helps us understand
- 6:22foreseeability and even comparative fault arguments.
- 6:26Next slide, please. In the United States, purchases
- 6:31of e -bikes increased from 437 ,000 in 2020 to
- 6:371 .1 million in 2022. And I believe even today,
- 6:40the amount of e -bikes on the road definitely
- 6:42exceeds 1 .1 million nationwide. And this increase
- 6:47in youth access to e -bikes has come with real
- 6:49risks. Head trauma has exploded 49 -fold from
- 6:532017 to 2022, while, unfortunately, helmet usage
- 6:58among minors has decreased by 6%, and that's
- 7:01according to JAMA. The statistical evidence points
- 7:05to an alarming 70 % increase in e -bike injuries
- 7:08from 2023, with more than half of all e -bike
- 7:12accidents involving children under 18. This is
- 7:15consistent with broader national trends showing
- 7:18e -bike injuries doubling annually from 2017
- 7:21to 2022. In California, the highest number of
- 7:25e -bike injuries in 2024 was in beach areas before
- 7:30spreading inland. According to a medical director
- 7:34at the Children's Hospital of Orange County,
- 7:37the director reported injuries with the once
- 7:39coastal in nature have become problematic in
- 7:43areas that are now inland, such as Huntington
- 7:48Beach, Irvine, Santa Ana, Orange, and Newport
- 7:51Beach. By early 2025, the top five cities for
- 7:56e -bike injuries in Orange County were the ones
- 7:58I just mentioned. Next slide, please. And for
- 8:06e -bike injury hotspots in Los Angeles, you're
- 8:09gonna really look to areas with high density
- 8:13in terms of people, such as downtown, as well
- 8:16as the beach cities, Venice, Santa Monica, and
- 8:18other beach cities. The highest risk neighborhoods
- 8:21in Los Angeles are, what I previously stated,
- 8:25and you'll notice that most of these areas are
- 8:28tourist heavy or high density traffic zones.
- 8:31Understanding these patterns can help you develop
- 8:34foreseeability arguments or inform comparative
- 8:37fault analysis, especially when representing
- 8:40injured children or pedestrians. The risk in
- 8:43youth ridership and an increasing speed of e
- 8:46-bikes has led to a significant concentration
- 8:49of accidents in high density urban neighborhoods
- 8:53and coastal cities. Attorneys should be aware
- 8:56that foreseeability arguments can often be bolstered
- 9:00by showing how certain locations pose a higher
- 9:03danger due to vehicle congestion, road design,
- 9:08or local bike enforcement practices. Next slide,
- 9:13please. Okay, now e -bikes are new to a lot of
- 9:19us in regard to liability and classifying them,
- 9:22but Being able to classify them is important
- 9:25when you start your analysis about an injury.
- 9:28So let's define our e -bike classes. California
- 9:32splits them into three classes, each with different
- 9:34legal treatment. Class one is an e -bike or a
- 9:38low speed pedal assisted electric bicycle that
- 9:42is equipped with a motor that provides assistance
- 9:45only when the rider is pedaling and that assistance
- 9:48stops when the bicycle reaches 20 miles per hour.
- 9:51These e -bikes are legal on any paved service
- 9:55that a regular bike is allowed to operate. Class
- 9:58II e -bikes, or low speed throttle assisted electric
- 10:02bicycles, are equipped with motors that can exclusively
- 10:06propel the bicycle, but that cannot provide assistance
- 10:10when the bicycle reaches 20 miles an hour. These
- 10:14e -bikes are legal on any paid surface that a
- 10:17regular bike is allowed to operate. And now Class
- 10:213 is an e -bike or speed pedal assisted electric
- 10:26bicycle that is equipped with a motor that provides
- 10:29assistance only when the rider is pedaling and
- 10:33stops providing assistance when the bicycle reaches
- 10:3628 miles per hour. Class 3s, for example, are
- 10:40often subject to stricter restrictions and safety
- 10:44gear mandates. Operators of Class 3 e -bikes
- 10:48must be 16 years or older and wear a helmet.
- 10:52Class e -bikes are prohibited from Class 1 multi
- 10:56-use bike paths unless specifically authorized
- 10:59by a local ordinance. Knowing the class of e
- 11:03-bike involved is crucial in evaluating both
- 11:06statutory compliance and liability. Next slide,
- 11:11please. In 2025, California refined what qualifies
- 11:20as an e -bike. These rules are designed to prevent
- 11:23overlap with mopeds and motorcycles, which fall
- 11:27under stricter laws. If a bike exceeds these
- 11:30specifications, it could open the door to claims
- 11:33of illegal operation or improper classification.
- 11:38So according to this, the max motor only speed
- 11:41is 20 miles per hour. The max motor is 750 watts
- 11:46and all e -bikes must have pedals. Next slide,
- 11:50please. Key California vehicle code provisions.
- 11:57Now these are going to be some of the most important
- 12:00statutes that you're going to utilize in your
- 12:02analysis of liability and fault. These are the
- 12:06backbone laws. Section 21 -200 sets the tone.
- 12:12Cyclists, even e -bike cyclists, are treated
- 12:15like any other vehicle. Sections 21 .202 and
- 12:1921 .208 guide how cyclists should position themselves.
- 12:24However, the 21 .202 has changed, which I'll
- 12:27get to. The new version of section 21 .760 from
- 12:33the Omni Bike Bill is critical. It now requires
- 12:36lane changes when passing bikes. Previously,
- 12:40vehicle code section 21 -202 just stated that
- 12:44a rider has to stay to the right, and passing
- 12:47can be if there is three feet between the car
- 12:50and the rider. And the Omni Bike Bill changed
- 12:52that, so now a vehicle has to actually change
- 12:56lanes to get around a cyclist. Next slide, please.
- 13:04Okay. These are a lot of codes, but let's cover
- 13:07some of the basic safety and operational requirements.
- 13:11I've also listed the vehicle codes next to it
- 13:13so you can refer to it in the future. So like
- 13:17I said, cyclists must ride in the direction of
- 13:19traffic. That's always important. Stay as far
- 13:22right as practical unless exceptions apply, which
- 13:25has now been changed, which I'll get to in a
- 13:28sec. Use bike lanes if slower than traffic, unless
- 13:32turning or avoiding a hazard. A helmet is required
- 13:36under 18 for riders and passengers of bicycles
- 13:39and e -bikes. Bicycles have to always yield to
- 13:43pedestrians in crosswalks. A bike rider can't
- 13:47ride under the influence of alcohol or drugs.
- 13:51A bicycle cannot be an obstruction on a sidewalk.
- 13:55A bicycle rider must have at least one hand on
- 13:59handlebars at all time. A bicycle or e -bike
- 14:03rider cannot have headphones in both ears. I
- 14:07found this one interesting. A bicycle cannot
- 14:10hitch a ride or attach itself to a vehicle. And
- 14:14in regards to carrying items, a bicycle rider
- 14:17cannot prevent, excuse me, can't have information
- 14:22or packages in their hands that prevent them
- 14:24from having one hand on the handlebar at all
- 14:28times. Now here are some other interesting ones
- 14:33that I found. Okay. Well, we're going to move
- 14:36on here. Okay. So this is an important change
- 14:46in the restriction and or requirement for how
- 14:52vehicles interact with bicycles. So California
- 14:56vehicle code section 2160 is also known as a
- 14:59three feet for safety act, which was enacted
- 15:01in 2013 and required drivers to maintain a minimum
- 15:06distance of three feet when passing a bicycle,
- 15:09traveling in the same direction on a highway.
- 15:11This was problematic for lots of reasons because
- 15:14it was very difficult for pedestrians and cyclists
- 15:17as well as vehicles to judge exactly how much
- 15:21space was between them and the cyclists. So that
- 15:25law was changed by the Omnibill Bike Act called
- 15:28AB 1909, which was signed into law on September
- 15:3216, 2022, and went into effect January 1, 2024,
- 15:38which expands on this regulation and makes drivers
- 15:43required to change lanes entirely when passing
- 15:46a bicycle if another lane is available and the
- 15:49maneuver can be done safely. So this is intended
- 15:52to provide a greater safety margin than the previous
- 15:55three foot rule, which could be challenging to
- 15:58accurately estimate and enforce. OK, next slide.
- 16:07So more about the Omni bike bill because it does
- 16:10make some changes to other aspects of bike riding
- 16:13besides the three foot rule so Class e bike riders
- 16:21are allowed on are allowed on bike paths unless
- 16:25there are prohibitions and They are not allowed
- 16:31however on equestrian trails recreational or
- 16:35multi -use trails or hiking trails. Cyclists
- 16:39are now permitted to cross intersections and
- 16:42response pedestrian walk cycles. This allows
- 16:45a cyclist a head start so they can begin crossing
- 16:48before a vehicle traffic moves, which will help
- 16:51enhance their visibility and reduce potential
- 16:54collisions. So before a cyclist had to wait until
- 16:57the crosswalk changed, to walk, whereas now they're
- 17:01allowed a head start so that they are more visible
- 17:03to vehicles in the lane of travel. Next slide.
- 17:11Okay, this is a very frustrating aspect of bicycle
- 17:15riding. When you often have a case where a bicycle
- 17:20rider was injured, you have to analyze where
- 17:23they were in the city and sometimes even what
- 17:26street they were on because Sidewalk riding is
- 17:30not governed by the vehicle code and it varies
- 17:33by city to city and sometimes even block to block.
- 17:38Unfortunately, vehicle code 21 -200 remains conspicuously
- 17:43silent on the specific matter of riding on a
- 17:45sidewalk. This was a deliberate legislative choice
- 17:49that reflects California's recognition of a diverse
- 17:53urban and suburban environment across the state.
- 17:56acknowledging that a single standard approach
- 17:59might not adequately address the varying needs
- 18:01of different communities. So certain jurisdictions
- 18:08and cities have very different ways to treat
- 18:11sidewalk riding. This is important to know that
- 18:15liability and legality can change from block
- 18:18to block. Next slide. Okay, so I tried to provide
- 18:26a comprehensive list of some of the areas where
- 18:30bike riding is more frequent and prominent to
- 18:33give you a way to know what the ordinance would
- 18:37be. So Los Angeles bike riding is allowed unless
- 18:41it is reckless. So you can ride on a bike and
- 18:46this is the standard. so long as, quote, willful
- 18:49or wanton disregard for the safety of a person
- 18:52or property does not happen. The standard establishes
- 18:55a negligence based framework that permits responsible
- 18:58sidewalk riding while prohibiting reckless behavior.
- 19:02In Santa Monica, sidewalk riding is prohibited.
- 19:05Same with Manhattan Beach and Inglewood. Marina
- 19:09Del Rey, it's prohibited in unincorporated sections
- 19:12of Los Angeles. In West Hollywood, it's only
- 19:16allowed if there are no bike lanes. In Pasadena,
- 19:20we are permitted if you can yield to pedestrians
- 19:23and you must yield to pedestrians anyway. In
- 19:26Long Beach, sidewalk riding is sign -based. In
- 19:29Glendale, it's prohibited in business districts.
- 19:34Next slide, please. Okay, these are the restrictions
- 19:41for sidewalk riding in Orange County. In Irvine,
- 19:45it is permitted unless a sign is posted indicating
- 19:48otherwise. In Newport Beach, it's prohibited
- 19:51completely. Huntington Beach is a little different.
- 19:54It's prohibited near business districts, schools,
- 19:57parks, and even churches. So definitely look
- 19:59at that section if you have a bicycle case in
- 20:02Huntington Beach. In Tustin, it's permitted,
- 20:04but one must yield to pedestrians. In Fullerton,
- 20:08there are no specific ordinances. So it's permitted
- 20:11by default. and Westminster prohibited near business
- 20:16districts. Next slide, please. San Diego is very
- 20:25different in their take on when you can ride
- 20:29a bicycle or a bike on a sidewalk. So San Diego,
- 20:33Oceanside, Encinitas, National City, Chula Vista,
- 20:38Imperial Beach, Lemon Grove, Santee, and the
- 20:42unincorporated San Diego area is all allowed
- 20:45except in business districts. In Carlsbad it's
- 20:49prohibited, El Cajon prohibited, Vista prohibited,
- 20:55Escondido regulated but not prohibited, San Marcos
- 20:59regulated but not prohibited, Solano Beach not
- 21:03regulated, and La Mesa not regulated. So you
- 21:07can see based on all these different counties
- 21:09ordinances and regulations how difficult it can
- 21:12be to evaluate a bicycle or e -bike case depending
- 21:16on where the potential client is. Next slide.
- 21:25Okay, so oftentimes since we have e -bikes now
- 21:30with people riding them all over the cities,
- 21:32as well as bicycles, I thought it might be interesting
- 21:35to see how they compare in regards to the law,
- 21:38because they're generally considered the same,
- 21:40but there are a couple of differences. So all
- 21:43of them are covered under vehicle code 21200,
- 21:47and bicycles are not classified. They're treated
- 21:50as one category, whereas e -bikes, as we previously
- 21:53discussed, have three categories under vehicle
- 21:56code section 312 .5. Bicycles can use most bike
- 22:02paths unless there's a local restriction, and
- 22:05as we spoke earlier, Class 3 e -bikes are prohibited
- 22:09from Class 1 bike paths. For bicycles, helmets
- 22:13are required only for passengers and riders under
- 22:1618, whereas for an e -bike, a helmet is required
- 22:19for all Class 3 riders. Sidewalk riding is governed
- 22:24by local ordinance that we already discussed,
- 22:26and Class three bikes are often banned from sidewalks.
- 22:32Bicycles no longer need to be registered or one
- 22:35doesn't have to have a license to ride them.
- 22:38And for e -bikes, there's no registration or
- 22:40license requirement, but you must meet power
- 22:43and speed limits. Now this is important too for
- 22:47insurance. For bicycles, insurance is not required
- 22:50but may be covered under homeowners or renters
- 22:53policies if you get into an accident or have
- 22:56a client who injured someone while riding a bicycle.
- 23:00However, with e -bikes, insurance is not required.
- 23:03However, it's often excluded from traditional
- 23:05policies. So you might want to check your homeowner's
- 23:08policy to see if motor vehicles are allowed.
- 23:11And generally, e -bikes are not allowed under
- 23:13motor vehicle policies either. Next slide, please.
- 23:23When you're evaluating a bicycle case, remember
- 23:26that local codes are the key to evaluating both
- 23:30plaintiff and defendant's conduct. Was the rider
- 23:33violating a municipal rule? Were there warning
- 23:36signs? Even if it's not negligence per se, these
- 23:40facts may tip comparative fault or duty analysis.
- 23:45Next slide, please. Okay. Let's talk a little
- 23:51litigation strategy. Many plaintiffs' attorneys
- 23:55often overlook statutory exceptions. However,
- 23:58these are gold when your client is accused of
- 24:00not riding, let's say, as far right as practical
- 24:03or on the sidewalk or not on the sidewalk. Local
- 24:06ordinances also give you a way to frame your
- 24:09client's conduct as reasonable. And don't forget
- 24:12technical compliance. Was the e -bike modified?
- 24:16Was it even legal to ride it on the road? Next
- 24:20slide. Okay. So we're going to be speaking about
- 24:26one of the newer cases called Tanzabadi versus
- 24:30Rancho Palos Verdes. The site for this case is
- 24:3514 Cal App 5th, 639 in the year 2023. Now this
- 24:42was a precedent setting case involving a cyclist
- 24:45who died in a collision with a tractor trailer.
- 24:48And while the evidence in the case suggested
- 24:51that the cyclist might have been at fault by
- 24:54proceeding straight through an intersection from
- 24:56a right turn lane, the court focused on the city's
- 25:00potential liability for the road design. Specifically,
- 25:03the court ruled that while the city maintained
- 25:06immunity for the design itself, it could be held
- 25:10liable for failure to warn of the dangerous condition
- 25:13created by discontinuing a bike lane for a half
- 25:17-mile stretch to accommodate parking for a park.
- 25:22So this is a unique case. And this case, the
- 25:26Supreme Court of California drew a crucial distinction.
- 25:30The city had design immunity for eliminating
- 25:32a bike lane, but they could still be liable for
- 25:36failing to warn cyclists of the hazard that the
- 25:39design created. This opens up new arguments in
- 25:43cases involving municipal roadways. So even if
- 25:47a design immunity applies, failure to warn may
- 25:51still create liability. And that's the appropriate
- 25:54section, which is government code 835, an exception
- 25:58for a dangerous condition. Excuse me. Next slide,
- 26:02please. So when liability is contested, lean
- 26:09on the exceptions built into the law. Ride right
- 26:12and bike lane rules have flexible carve outs,
- 26:15which we have discussed. In public entity cases,
- 26:18argue failure to warn if design immunity shuts
- 26:21the door. And when seeking damages, don't shy
- 26:25away from statistical context, especially with
- 26:28injured minors. Next slide, please. One area
- 26:36of the law that's evolving as we don't really
- 26:40have a whole lot of legislation or case law on
- 26:44this is for insurance. What covers what when
- 26:48you're riding an e -bike? California right now
- 26:52does not require e -bike riders to carry insurance.
- 26:56However, if a child is riding an e -bike and
- 26:59someone who has homeowners or renters insurance,
- 27:03That might cover liability if that child injures
- 27:07someone while riding an e -bike, but it depends
- 27:10on the policy language. Many policies for motor
- 27:15vehicles and homeowners exclude motorized vehicles,
- 27:18especially if they exceed certain speeds or wattage
- 27:22thresholds. Auto insurance almost always excludes
- 27:26e -bikes. That's because e -bikes aren't classified
- 27:30as motor vehicles under most policies. To address
- 27:34this, the insurance industry now offers dedicated
- 27:37e -bike policies. These can cover theft, injury,
- 27:41liability, and property damage. When representing
- 27:44a rider or someone injured by one, it's crucial
- 27:47to examine all applicable coverage, personal,
- 27:50household, or specialized. And if you were in
- 27:53doubt, if there is insurance under your homeowners,
- 27:56always check the policy language. The policy,
- 27:59as we know, is going to govern what controls
- 28:02and what doesn't control for coverage. Okay,
- 28:09next slide please. E -bike insurance and practice.
- 28:15So practically speaking, liability coverage for
- 28:18an e -bike related injury often turns on small
- 28:21details and policy definitions. If the bike exceeds
- 28:2620 miles an hour, under a motor power alone,
- 28:30or has more than 750 watts of power, it may fall
- 28:34into a gray area or be excluded. But even when
- 28:37coverage applies, insurers may dispute it based
- 28:41on how the e -bike was used, for instance, racing,
- 28:45business use, or restricted terrain. These nuances
- 28:50are especially important when your client is
- 28:52either the injured party or a minor who caused
- 28:55harm. Each policy is critical in every case.
- 29:00And if you have clients or family members who,
- 29:04like my children, want e -bikes, definitely obtain
- 29:07an e -bike insurance policy. It's going to protect
- 29:10you, it's going to protect your children, and
- 29:12it might even prevent your assets from being
- 29:16looked at if there is, in fact, a lawsuit. Okay,
- 29:21next slide, please. Okay. So here we're summarizing
- 29:29some of the important statutes that will govern
- 29:33what is going to define liability in your case.
- 29:38And knowing these statutes and their built -in
- 29:40exceptions will help you frame the conduct of
- 29:43cyclists accurately and persuasively. Next slide,
- 29:49please. Okay. Litigation wise, if you have a
- 29:58situation where there might be some city liability,
- 30:00always claim failure to warn under government
- 30:03code 835. And also emphasize foreseeability,
- 30:08especially for minors in areas that are urban
- 30:10or near the beach or have a high density of cars
- 30:13and pedestrians like we often see in downtown.
- 30:20Next slide. As we have discussed, there are many
- 30:27evolving laws in this area of bike riding and
- 30:31e -bike riding. And just remember, ordinances
- 30:33may vary block to block. So it's crucial to look
- 30:37at what part of the city, even what part of the
- 30:42street your potential client had obtained an
- 30:45injury while riding a bike or an e -bike. And
- 30:48really advocate for your clients in regard to
- 30:51their statutory rights and their rights as bicycle
- 30:55riders. Next slide. Unfortunately, I don't have
- 31:02anything further and I would definitely entertain
- 31:06any type of questions that you can provide to
- 31:10me on the Q &A. I know some of you might not
- 31:13be live, but I did get one question about sidewalks,
- 31:19sidewalk riding in Culver City. I do not have
- 31:23that particular area, but I can look it up and
- 31:25get it to you. So I will definitely find the
- 31:28local ordinance if they have one and get it to
- 31:30you. Another question is no headphones in both
- 31:34ears. Does that include earbuds? So what I would
- 31:37consider is if you're using Bluetooth, I would
- 31:41have one ear that has one earbud in and one ear
- 31:46that doesn't. I have another question here. I'm
- 31:51in pre -lit now. My client was riding a Teleria
- 31:54X3. Adjusters claiming my client is 213 because
- 31:58of the type of the bike. Have you come across
- 32:00this? The tires were not off -road tires, but
- 32:03my client sold the bike without telling me. I
- 32:07would attack this in a few ways. I'm not really
- 32:11sure what class bike the X3 is, although it seems
- 32:15like it's a class three bike. And then I would
- 32:19also see if the bike has been modified in regard
- 32:23to changing tires, like you said, or if it's
- 32:25for racing. I would also see if the client has
- 32:32homeowners or renters or any type of policy that
- 32:35could cover this because that might be difficult
- 32:39to say that you have insurance when it might
- 32:42be a type of bike that falls outside of any of
- 32:46the rules we have or any of the requirements
- 32:49we have for insurance. It sounds like it's a
- 32:51class three bike. Another question is, what about
- 32:57stop signs? Do bikes need to abide all stop signs?
- 33:02Yes, absolutely. All bike riders have to abide
- 33:05by stop signs. They're considered. They have
- 33:08to, like vehicles, they have to follow the rules
- 33:10of the road. there are no exceptions to bike
- 33:14riders when it comes to stop signs. And I have
- 33:17also seen many bike riders just go through a
- 33:20stop sign, and that is actually not going to
- 33:23help them if they are in a accident because they
- 33:26need to stop. This question is, I want to be
- 33:31sure I understand that no one 18 or over is required
- 33:34to wear a helmet. So for an e -bike, The rule
- 33:39is, I believe that you have to wear a helmet
- 33:42if it's a class three, but only if you're under
- 33:4518. So the 18 or, or younger requirement is basically
- 33:52for minors. And for bicycle riders, you have
- 33:56to wear a helmet. If you're under 18, if you're
- 33:58a bike rider or a passenger for an e -bike, I
- 34:01believe you have to have a helmet if you're under
- 34:0418 for an e -bike as well. Thoughts on Los Angeles
- 34:11municipal county cyclist anti -harassment ordinance?
- 34:16I'm not too familiar what that is, unfortunately.
- 34:20So if you could follow up and give me some information
- 34:24as to that, I would love to answer that question.
- 34:28Another question is, are e -scooters lawful on
- 34:31sidewalks in the city of LA? I don't know that
- 34:38because I wasn't really focusing on e -scooters
- 34:40because they fall under a different category
- 34:42of mopeds. So I'm not sure, but I would love
- 34:48to do a seminar on other motor vehicles besides
- 34:51bicycles. So I would have to get back to you
- 34:55on that, but I'm not 100 % sure about scooters.
- 35:02Okay. So another question. How do juries view
- 35:05cyclists generally? How do juries view cyclists
- 35:09generally view bicyclists compare hostility toward
- 35:12many motorized motorcyclists? How about minor
- 35:14cyclists? I believe, unfortunately, that in certain
- 35:20areas and jurisdictions there is a An idea that
- 35:27a lot of bike riders do not follow the rules
- 35:29of the road and they run through stop signs and
- 35:32they don't do what they're told. So they might
- 35:35have some discriminatory treatment just like
- 35:40motorcyclists. I don't think it's as bad as motorcyclists.
- 35:43but I think there is some there and that's something
- 35:46you would have to overcome. I know a lot of people
- 35:49are getting very upset by seeing children zooming
- 35:52around their neighborhoods on e -bikes. So that
- 35:56could be another way of harassment and or discrimination
- 36:01because these are really dangerous and a lot
- 36:03of children don't wear helmets and they're going
- 36:06pretty fast at 20, 28 miles an hour. Okay, this
- 36:12question is, can I ride on the left sidewalk
- 36:15even though it's opposite of traffic? In order
- 36:22to determine whether you can ride on the sidewalk,
- 36:24it depends on what part of the city or what actual
- 36:26city you're in. So I would look at that first,
- 36:30and no, I don't believe you can ride at any time
- 36:33opposite of traffic. You must travel with the
- 36:37flow of traffic. Is it legal for e -bike riders
- 36:41to do wheelies on public streets? I don't believe
- 36:45it is legal. Cars aren't allowed to do wheelies
- 36:49and they're considered vehicles, so no, they
- 36:53cannot. The vehicle code does prohibit bikes
- 36:59on sidewalks. It's one of the double digit statutes.
- 37:03So yes. How common is it to pursue negligent
- 37:07and trust claims against a minor's parent who
- 37:10may have gifted an e -bike to their kid? I would
- 37:15definitely. consider that cause of action if
- 37:18in fact you have a minor who injured a person
- 37:22or another cyclist using an e -bike and the parent
- 37:27either was not supervising, was not instructing,
- 37:31didn't provide a helmet, and maybe didn't even
- 37:34obtain insurance. So I would definitely pursue
- 37:37that. as a cause of action? And I think we're
- 37:40going to see that more until California comes
- 37:43up with legislation requiring insurance for e
- 37:45-bikes. So I would definitely pursue that cause
- 37:48of action for that fact pattern. Can e -bikes
- 37:52drive on Santa Monica Beach bike path continuing
- 37:55north onto Los Angeles near Entrada and West
- 38:00Channel Road going north to Will Rogers State
- 38:03Beach, which is Los Angeles? Los Angeles and
- 38:09Santa Monica, what I have learned about e -bike
- 38:13riding on bike beach paths, I believe they're
- 38:18allowed to drive on the beach bike path unless
- 38:21there is some notification saying that they can't.
- 38:26You're going to have to check the local ordinance
- 38:29for that just to be safe because I don't want
- 38:31to potentially give you wrong information because
- 38:33I don't know every single um exception to the
- 38:39rule and there are very unique exceptions down
- 38:43near the beach on certain areas within Los Angeles
- 38:47including the beach cities. So please check that
- 38:50if you can't find it I reach out to me and I
- 38:53will look into it and hopefully get you an answer.
- 38:56Also, if the bike rider is in a bike lane and
- 39:00gets hit and is an adult and not wearing a helmet,
- 39:04the driver would not be able to claim liability
- 39:07on the part of the bicyclist for not wearing
- 39:10a helmet if there was no head trauma. I would
- 39:15assume you would always claim comparative fault
- 39:18that a bicyclist is safer wearing a helmet than
- 39:23not, but You know, as plaintiffs' attorneys and
- 39:29defense attorneys, we're going to plead whatever
- 39:31we think is viable. And I think that is a valid
- 39:36reason to say that a person not wearing a helmet
- 39:40is not inviting a traumatic brain injury, but
- 39:44they're not protecting themselves from that kind
- 39:46of injury, if in fact it happens, because it
- 39:50is foreseeable that they might get hit by a car
- 39:52for whatever reason. So you could definitely
- 39:55argue comparative fault there. Is it legal for
- 40:01e -bike riders to do wheelies on public streets?
- 40:03If it is illegal, what is the penalty? I believe
- 40:08it is illegal as cars cannot do that nor can
- 40:12bikes. I don't know the exact code that would
- 40:17punish someone for doing that, but I can look
- 40:20it up and find it for you. I believe it has to
- 40:23be part of the vehicle code that is going to
- 40:26dictate and determine what is appropriate bike
- 40:29and e -bike usage. So I do not think that a e
- 40:34-bike can do a wheelie on a public street. You
- 40:39can probably be cited by a police officer and
- 40:44maybe get a ticket for that. And I think that's
- 40:49what police officers do if there are any problems
- 40:52or if a bike rider, e -bike rider is not comporting
- 40:56with the rules of the road and regulations. How
- 41:01do you overcome the hostility so many people,
- 41:03including insurance adjusters have towards cyclists?
- 41:07Well, that's a good loaded question. So I'm not
- 41:11sure if you're talking pre -litigation or litigation,
- 41:15but in litigation and at a jury trial, Obviously,
- 41:19there's going to be questions you want to ask
- 41:22potential jurors about their biases towards bicycle
- 41:26riders. But I would think in California, since
- 41:29we are a greener state and we're trying to promote
- 41:32cleaner air and less pollution, less traffic,
- 41:37that that might be an avenue you could argue.
- 41:41And in a jury, obviously, you're going to try
- 41:43and get rid of as well as you can for cause all
- 41:47of the people who are very against bike riding.
- 41:51And you really need to lean into the rules of
- 41:55the road for cyclists and to show that your cyclist
- 41:58was doing things correctly and according to the
- 42:01law. And it was the negligence of the car or
- 42:07the vehicle that caused the injuries and focus
- 42:11on the good jurors you might have and focus on
- 42:15the good aspects of your case to overcome hopefully
- 42:18some of the bad facts. Okay. What are duties
- 42:25of state parks and Santa Monica Conservancy to
- 42:28maintain mountain trails or does this writer
- 42:31assume risk of ruts or rock slides? That's another
- 42:37question that probably falls outside of the specifics
- 42:42of this talk, but I know there are some trail
- 42:46immunity claims that one can make so that the
- 42:50government would make or the city would make.
- 42:53So I'm not really sure about ruts and rock slides
- 42:58on mountain trails because of trail immunity.
- 43:02So I think you would have to look into the specific
- 43:05jurisdiction and area. where the rider is riding
- 43:09and then obviously look at how bad the trail
- 43:12is and some of the areas that are causing problems.
- 43:19What are the exceptions for riding on the right
- 43:22under vehicle code 21202? I believe one is supposed
- 43:30to ride to the right as close as possible so
- 43:34long that it is safe. So safety is going to be
- 43:38the most important consideration. If it's not
- 43:43safe to ride that far on the right because of,
- 43:45let's say, construction or parked cars, then
- 43:49you're going to move over a little. But I think
- 43:50those are the exceptions. You just want to make
- 43:53sure safety is the overall consideration. I have
- 43:57a client who is pulling out onto a street and
- 43:59a cyclist was on the sidewalk from the direction
- 44:02facing traffic. struck the cyclist because he
- 44:08was turning right. Does the cyclist have any
- 44:10liability for riding against instead of with
- 44:13traffic? So yes, the cyclist should be riding
- 44:17with traffic at all times. And you have to also
- 44:21be careful about whether or not the cyclist is
- 44:24even allowed to ride on the sidewalk given the
- 44:28particular city. area or street where this took
- 44:32place. However, you can also argue foreseeability,
- 44:37comparative fault. If this is a jurisdiction
- 44:39where bike riders are frequently on the sidewalk
- 44:42or frequently around the area because it's close
- 44:45to the beach or it's downtown, you might be able
- 44:48to make a comparative argument. And that's what
- 44:51I would do. And excuse me, you can also say that
- 44:54the car should have seen the bike rider. So I
- 44:58would attack it that way. But you do have some
- 45:01issues that are against you, which is riding
- 45:03against traffic and possibly the sidewalk. So
- 45:06I would look into that area more carefully. Is
- 45:11there UMUIM insurance coverage at play? Not for
- 45:17e -bikes or bicycles, unless you have a particular
- 45:21e -bike policy. So you would have to obtain a
- 45:26policy specifically for an e -bike. generally
- 45:30any accidents are not going to be covered under
- 45:33an auto policy that would have UM or UIM coverage.
- 45:38Maybe for a bike there might be homeowners coverage
- 45:41that's available, but I don't think, excuse me,
- 45:45I know e -bikes are not covered under homeowners
- 45:48policy. So maybe there are UM UIM coverage for
- 45:52an e -bike policy, but I would look into that
- 45:55and see if it is available to you. Does anyone
- 45:59have any other questions? Hopefully I answered
- 46:01them appropriately. Hey, so it looks like we
- 46:06have a few questions that came over through our
- 46:08help desk. That's all right. Oh, sure. So the
- 46:10first one is, let's see. Given the 49 -fold increase
- 46:14in e -bike related head trauma among youth, how
- 46:17might this data influence your litigation strategy
- 46:20when representing a minor involved in an e -bike
- 46:22collision? We know that it's foreseeable that
- 46:28this is going to happen. And if I'm representing
- 46:33an injured child who didn't wear a helmet, I
- 46:38would really focus on the other party's negligence
- 46:43into what caused it, foreseeability. I would
- 46:48try and make my client look to be The innocent
- 46:55party, even though they might have some liability
- 46:58and fault because they might have been riding
- 47:01without a helmet. I wasn't really sure which
- 47:04side I would be arguing in a situation like this.
- 47:07So if I was defense, I would really nail them
- 47:09with, well, the parents should have bought a
- 47:11policy. The parents should have. made the child
- 47:15wear a helmet and this child should have been
- 47:17supervised. This child should not have been riding
- 47:19in the area without an adult. So it really depends
- 47:22how I would attack it in regard to what side
- 47:25I'm on. But as a plaintiff's attorney, I would
- 47:28definitely say that we know that there is a lot
- 47:32of children on the road riding these e -bikes
- 47:35without helmets and that vehicles now have to
- 47:39be aware because even if it's someone's fault.
- 47:42You don't want to see a child dead because they
- 47:45just forgot to wear a helmet that day. So I would
- 47:49really lean into the foreseeability aspect of
- 47:52expecting more children, more e -bike riders
- 47:55on the road. And hopefully California's laws
- 47:58are going to catch up with what's happening with
- 48:01the rise in e -bikes, not only in California,
- 48:04but around the country. Great. And then I have
- 48:10another. How would you present evidence of municipal
- 48:13code variability in a case involving sidewalk
- 48:16writing where a writer might cross from one legal
- 48:20zone to a prohibited one mid -block? So I would
- 48:25talk about whether or not, obviously you can't
- 48:29talk design immunity, but whether or not they
- 48:32fail to warn about certain risks and you would
- 48:37really have to lay into the facts of that particular
- 48:40situation as to where the problems arose with
- 48:44the bike rider depending on where they were.
- 48:47Is there a failure to warn because the bike lane
- 48:49ended? Is there failure to warn because the roads
- 48:53narrowed and there was no adequate notice, I
- 48:56would really look into see how notice requirements
- 49:00are affecting how bikes bike riders perceive
- 49:04what's happening and obviously maybe look into
- 49:07an expert. A bike riding expert would give you
- 49:11an idea or even a municipal municipality city
- 49:14expert will give you an idea as to whether or
- 49:17not the city has some liability for not. warning
- 49:20of hazards or failing to warn. Okay and then
- 49:28with e -bikes often excluded from homeowners
- 49:31and auto policies, what steps should attorneys
- 49:33take early in case to determine if a client or
- 49:37adverse party has any applicable coverage? So
- 49:40I would definitely ask if they have a specific
- 49:42e -bike policy. and then ask just to see, and
- 49:48it's possible maybe their homeowners covers it,
- 49:51even though we know that most of them won't.
- 49:53I would look to see what possible coverage they
- 49:56have under any potential insurance policy, renters,
- 50:00homeowners. We know auto doesn't cover it. We
- 50:02know homeowners doesn't cover it, but maybe the
- 50:05policy wasn't written with specific exclusions.
- 50:08So I would look to that, but if they don't have
- 50:11an e -bike policy, it might be very difficult.
- 50:19Great. And then let's see. When asserting a government
- 50:23code 835 claim, what types of evidence are most
- 50:28persuasive to show that a city knew or should
- 50:31have known about the danger, especially with
- 50:32regard to e -bike accidents? So I would look
- 50:37and see, and you're going to have to do a lot
- 50:39of investigation as to where factually, where
- 50:43this took place and You might almost have to
- 50:47have an expert go out there or a bike rider themselves
- 50:50and tell you how soon it would take to notice
- 50:53this defect. Pictures. You might want to do discovery
- 50:59on any changes the city has made in that particular
- 51:03area in the past and whether or not they did
- 51:07notify people or if there are signs, if the signs
- 51:11have been modified, moved, removed, destroyed.
- 51:14So it's very fact intensive, but you also really
- 51:18want to get a good understanding of the location
- 51:21where the incident happened and utilize the facts,
- 51:27pictures and expert and maybe the knowledge of
- 51:31your client if he or she rides in that area regularly
- 51:35and notice some changes. We got a question here.
- 51:43How do you handle investing in a case you ride
- 51:45an e -bike to simulate the incident? I think
- 51:48that's a really good idea. I don't know if I
- 51:51would go, I don't have one. I don't know if I
- 51:52would go purchase an e -bike, but maybe I would
- 51:55have someone stimulate, stimulate, simulate,
- 51:59excuse me, simulate the exact speed conditions,
- 52:04et cetera. uh, to know what they were seeing
- 52:07and perceiving and whether or not their perceptions
- 52:10were reasonable according to the situation, the
- 52:13weather, the lighting, the road conditions, et
- 52:17cetera. So, um, you could probably find an expert
- 52:20to do that, or you could do some testing, but,
- 52:23um, I think that's important. One thing I always
- 52:26do when I have cases like this or other cases
- 52:29as well, I go to the scene of the crash and I
- 52:32try and look and see what was happening around
- 52:36that specific time. If I can replicate, if I
- 52:38can be there when the weather conditions are
- 52:40similar, just so I get an understanding, because
- 52:43if I, as the attorney, have an understanding
- 52:45of what's going on, I think I can then relate
- 52:47it better to an expert who might help me and
- 52:50also get a better understanding of what the client
- 52:52went through. So I would definitely go to the
- 52:55scene and maybe rent an e -bike to see what the
- 52:59client was experiencing, maybe videotape it too,
- 53:01just for my own reference. and also to show an
- 53:05expert later. So I think that's a very good thing
- 53:08to do in prepping for a case. Alrighty, with
- 53:19considering all of the questions that we've had
- 53:23today, do you have any final thoughts or key
- 53:26takeaways for our attendees today? Yeah, I want
- 53:30to thank you all for your time and for all the
- 53:32questions and I understand I I rushed through
- 53:35a lot of information but If you are practicing
- 53:39in this area of law or you have clients who are
- 53:42coming to you, I would always check to make sure
- 53:45that there aren't any new cases regarding cyclists
- 53:49and e -bikes and government immunity and failure
- 53:52to warn because this is a very new area of law.
- 53:56There are a lot of e -bikes as we know that are
- 54:00on the road. laws have not caught up to the fact
- 54:03that these vehicles are on the road. And one
- 54:07has to become very well versed in the vehicle
- 54:10codes, the exceptions, the sidewalk rules. And
- 54:14even if you think that your client may not have
- 54:17a case, you could be surprised due to the conditions,
- 54:21the factual conditions, what was happening with,
- 54:24let's say, a driver that hit your client, or
- 54:27even a minor. Because at the end of the day,
- 54:31we are human. And when you have to try your case
- 54:33in front of a jury, you're going to have to take
- 54:35the good facts with the bad. So considering there
- 54:38is a stigma against bike riders, these are going
- 54:41to be difficult cases, but there are a lot of
- 54:44things and or. facts, case law, and vehicle codes
- 54:48that can help you, even if one of your clients
- 54:51might have been what you think is the wrong or
- 54:54party who caused the crash. I would definitely
- 54:57consider working those cases up and seeing what
- 55:00you can do to try and advocate for them because
- 55:03we all need a cleaner environment and e -bike
- 55:07riders and bicycle riders are helping that. definitely
- 55:11check the statutes, definitely check the local
- 55:14ordinances, and definitely check for case law
- 55:16because certain things are going to be coming
- 55:19down as more people get into these crashes and
- 55:22collisions. And thank you for your time. Thank
- 55:27you, Karen. This concludes today's presentation.
- 55:29We would like to once again thank our speaker,
- 55:32Karen Bisla, for such an excellent program. And
- 55:35of course, a big thank you to our audience and
- 55:37members for learning with us today. Have a great
- 55:39day, everybody.