Latest / Revitalizing the Declining Church with Dr. Desmond Barrett / 165. Church Branding
Transcript
- 0:04Welcome to Revitalizing the Declining Church with Doctor
- 0:07Desmond Barrett, brought to you by the Brizzy Institute for
- 0:10Church Revitalization, Missional Engagement and Leadership
- 0:14Development, an institute that envisions to partner with
- 0:17churches and her leaders to strategize, strengthen, and
- 0:21discern God's will for the local church.
- 0:28Welcome to episode 165 of Revitalized and Declining
- 0:31Church. I'm your host, Doctor Desmond
- 0:33Barrett. On today's episode, I want to
- 0:35talk to you about church branding matters.
- 0:38It's a leadership lesson from Cracker Barrel, a corporate
- 0:41store in the United States. When the church world hears the
- 0:45word church branding, it often carries a negative connotation
- 0:49for those who listen to it. Why is that?
- 0:53Could it sound just too corporate, even too worldly for
- 0:57a Bible believing church that you lead or that you're a part
- 1:00of? Whatever the cause, the word
- 1:02church branding has been seen as negative and not a positive
- 1:07attribute that could help your local church connect with your
- 1:11community. While the church branding may
- 1:13not matter to you or those that sit in the Pew, it matters to
- 1:18those who are seeking a new home.
- 1:21What's your church says on the outside speaks volumes to the
- 1:24perception of connection, or lack thereof, in the community
- 1:28on the outside. Recently, Cracker Barrel, an
- 1:32American restaurant chain known for its southern charm.
- 1:35It grew from one location in Lebanon, TN to over 660
- 1:40locations in 45 out of the 50 states.
- 1:44However, it faced a significant backlash over its store
- 1:47rebranding. If you have never been to this
- 1:50casual dining stop, let me describe it for you.
- 1:53The outside of Cracker Barrel looks like an old country store
- 1:57with rocking chairs for guests to sit a spell and watch the
- 2:01world go by while they can play checkers on a large board placed
- 2:06on top of old barrels. Inside the main entrance, guests
- 2:10walk into an old fashioned country store before being
- 2:14seated in a massive dining hall with a stone fireplace placed
- 2:19right in the middle. The walls are decorated with
- 2:22vintage collectibles, antique crafts and signs, yet your mind
- 2:28is transported to another time and place as you eat homestyle
- 2:32cooking you might have found at your grandparents home.
- 2:36Cracker Barrel is a no frills dining experience where
- 2:40customers seem to know what to expect.
- 2:43In 2023, the Cracker Barrel Board of Directors chose to hire
- 2:48a new CEO with experience in innovation and growth across
- 2:52several global brands. The new hire did not understand
- 2:56the culture or the customers and in turn created a major mess
- 3:01figuratively and financially for the company.
- 3:05After conducting several studies with several brand management
- 3:08companies, Cracker Barrel used the recommendations to move
- 3:12forward with the complete remodel of its restaurant
- 3:14interiors and food assortment as well as update to their classic
- 3:20logo. The company invested over $700
- 3:23million in the remodel, which would see customers leave the
- 3:27chain due to poor food quality, logo disenchantment, and drastic
- 3:32atmosphere. Change the lessons, and that's
- 3:35what I want to talk about today. The lessons from this rebranding
- 3:39gone wrong are valuable for the Big C Church, but they're also
- 3:45especially valuable to you in the context of church
- 3:50revitalization culture. Corporate America should not be
- 3:54a bad word, but seen as a valuable opportunity zone where
- 3:58churches like yourself can learn from the best of another
- 4:02industry and adopt or adapt best practices to expand and build
- 4:08God's Kingdom right where you are.
- 4:12When you evaluate any dissatisfaction from customers
- 4:15or in your case and in my case church members, it typically is
- 4:20because they feel that change was too radical.
- 4:23Radical change dressed up in helping the church only harms
- 4:28the intended outcomes. Church revitalization is about
- 4:32systematic change that inspires hope for the future, that leads
- 4:37to steps to preserve the past, present in the current situation
- 4:43that they find themselves and preparing for the future.
- 4:48Change for change's sake is not as significant as change that
- 4:53prepares the church for a stronger community, Christ
- 4:57centered teaching and spiritual connections that last longer
- 5:01than a few hours on a Sunday morning.
- 5:05And so on today's episode 165 Church Branding Matters.
- 5:09I want to give you 4 leadership lessons that I took from this
- 5:13story of Cracker Barrel and adapted it to my own church and
- 5:18I believe you can adapt to your your particular church also.
- 5:22The first lesson a church leader can glean from the Cracker
- 5:26Barrel fiasco is this. The company looked to the future
- 5:30but sabotaged their today. The company executives were
- 5:35forward thinking in their outlook but missed the results
- 5:39of their actions in today's marketplace.
- 5:42They wanted to prepare for the future by adapting the
- 5:44restaurant, its menu items and atmosphere to expand beyond
- 5:49their core customer base and position them to reach a new
- 5:53generation of customers. You see, on paper that is a
- 5:57sound strategy, but in reality, they did not prepare the public
- 6:03or their shareholders for what the transformation would mean,
- 6:07therefore sabotaging the stock price and causing customer
- 6:11dissatisfaction. And as a church right where you
- 6:15find yourself undergoing church revitalization, the lessons you
- 6:20can learn from this situation are twofold.
- 6:23And the big idea is this communication is central to
- 6:28leading, otherwise there is a risk of losing members and the
- 6:33change narrative. Leadership is not just about
- 6:38developing a plan, it's about executing the plan.
- 6:42I cannot over stress that communication is the central
- 6:46component for success beyond prayer in turning around to
- 6:49local church. The problem that far too many
- 6:53church leaders find themselves in is that they under
- 6:57communicate thinking that they have already over communicate so
- 7:01they stop. When you communicate I want you
- 7:05to think about how you are expressing the ideas and the
- 7:08changes to come. There are several ways to
- 7:11communicate the plans that God has laid on your heart for your
- 7:15local church. The first one is this focus on
- 7:20the worship folder. Share weekly updates on the
- 7:24proposed changes or changes that have yet to be made.
- 7:28The Weekly Worship folder, or some may call a bulletin, is a
- 7:33great space to highlight the positive aspects of
- 7:37revitalization efforts and prepare members for what is to
- 7:41come in the future. The second is quarterly updates.
- 7:45Use each quarter as an opportunity to highlight what
- 7:49God has done and what is still yet to be accomplished by
- 7:53printing and sharing verbally which projects have been
- 7:57completed, which changes still need to come.
- 8:00Use these quarterly updates as opportunities to celebrate what
- 8:04God has done through this change season.
- 8:07It is also a good time to do an In the Know meeting.
- 8:12This meeting is like a church meeting, a family meeting where
- 8:15members can ask questions, hear updates on the progress of the
- 8:18change and allow the opportunity for the pastor, the church board
- 8:22to share their ideas and thoughts on how things are going
- 8:26with the congregation and answer their comments and answer their
- 8:30thoughts and listen. The third portion of
- 8:34communicating is social media. Use it as an opportunity to
- 8:38highlight in a positive way what God is doing throughout the
- 8:42church. Social media is a tool, a tool
- 8:45to express the positive aspects of the change season in the
- 8:49church and how God is using others to accomplish his goals.
- 8:54The post should include celebration stories, pictures
- 8:58highlighting events, and a positive story about what God is
- 9:01doing through the revitalization effort.
- 9:05The narrative if not set by you or the church leadership team,
- 9:09it will be set by uninformed individuals who will share
- 9:14disinformation because they lack a complete understanding of what
- 9:18is taking place. The 4th part of communication is
- 9:23essential to leading is intentional conversations.
- 9:28one-on-one. Small groups or large
- 9:31opportunities during a Sunday service or during the week must
- 9:35be made. As a pastor, you have a chance
- 9:38to help shape the narrative of what God is doing through the
- 9:41work of everybody in the church. Use not only servants to
- 9:45highlight the good things, but also be intentional in how you
- 9:50share and express celebrations or even concerns.
- 9:55Where churches get in trouble and maybe you found yourself
- 9:58there yourself as a leader is when they think that the people
- 10:02don't need to know or even want to know what's happening.
- 10:08Still, inevitably, the lack of communication can convey a
- 10:12message that might be unintended, which could be
- 10:17negative. Cracker Barrel failed at the
- 10:20basics of information sharing. While the company executive sold
- 10:24the revitalization to the board of directors and early on to the
- 10:28company investors and industry analysts, they failed to
- 10:33communicate effectively with their customer base, which in
- 10:37turn revolted when the redesign occurred.
- 10:42That is a key lesson for you that I want you to hear.
- 10:45It's a key lesson for church revitalization leaders to
- 10:48understand. Ineffective communication is as
- 10:53deadly as no communication. Let me say that again.
- 10:57Ineffective communication is as deadly as no communication.
- 11:04When developing a plan or even changing a small item in the
- 11:07church, I want you to make sure you have buy in before radically
- 11:11transforming the norm or you may lose credibility in the process.
- 11:17The second lesson a church leader can glean from the
- 11:20Cracker Barrel fiasco is the company did not provide
- 11:24opportunities to engage customers as part of the ongoing
- 11:29process of transformation. The brand management consultants
- 11:34that Cracker Barrel worked with focused early on on customers
- 11:39customer engagement and customer satisfaction, but they failed to
- 11:43continue to provide ways for customers to share their
- 11:47concerns or answer their questions or even hear their
- 11:51thoughts. When this change occurred, the
- 11:55company initially lost 7% of its stock price on a single day.
- 12:00That was over $100 million in investors assets when customer
- 12:06satisfaction dissatisfaction was realized over the two months of
- 12:11customer pushback, the company would lose 10% of its stock
- 12:16price, prompting continued revolt not only from customers,
- 12:22but also from investors and industry analysts.
- 12:25When members of the local church do not like what is happening
- 12:29and are unable to share privately or publicly their
- 12:31concerns, like the investors in Cracker Barrel, they're going to
- 12:36do a couple of things. They're going to stop tithing
- 12:38altogether. They're going to restrict their
- 12:41ties to a program or a ministry so it is not used in
- 12:45revitalization. They're going to decrease their
- 12:48attendance and participation in church services.
- 12:52They might even sit out for several weeks or leave the
- 12:55church altogether. As a leader, you have to be
- 12:59willing to hear ideas. You have to be willing to hear
- 13:02comments and thoughts that may challenge your own leadership,
- 13:06as members are the ones who will either invest in the change or
- 13:10resist it. Suspicion can be a church
- 13:13leader's worst enemy. If you and others are not
- 13:17sharing a transparent narrative with the church or the members,
- 13:22the members will assume the leadership is hiding something.
- 13:26Disillusionment is seen throughout today's society with
- 13:29no sector immune to suspicion and even conspiracy theories
- 13:35that have become part of modern life.
- 13:38With society changing as a whole, the church has to become
- 13:42a haven from change, and it has for a lot of the aging members.
- 13:47So their nose, their initial nose is not necessarily against
- 13:53that idea of church revitalization, but against the
- 13:56idea of change by over communicating, sharing, and by
- 14:03making a plan transparent. You set up the Nos to become
- 14:08yeses over time. Here, my heart.
- 14:13Don't be afraid of conversations.
- 14:16I want you to embrace them. Cracker Barrel took months to
- 14:20listen to its customers wiping out market value because it
- 14:26wanted to be right, or at least so loyal to its plan that it
- 14:31would dismiss the customers it currently had.
- 14:35Sound like you, leader. Are you dismissing people
- 14:39because you want to be right? Is your church leadership team
- 14:43dismissing those that are perceived negative because your
- 14:47plan is the best plan? If being right and losing 10% or
- 14:53more of your congregation is a win that I would not want to see
- 14:59what you would consider a loss. I want you to be open.
- 15:03Be open to the tough questions. It will only help you reflect on
- 15:07the principles behind the change, help hear the the
- 15:10concerns that could be turned into celebrations, and really
- 15:14create a a feedback loop that is outside your own control, but in
- 15:18turn enhances your understanding of where the majority of the
- 15:21congregation is or might be heading in the future.
- 15:26These ideas are not meant just once to to be spoken about just
- 15:33once. They are but continually as an
- 15:37ongoing opportunity to engage stakeholders and learn from what
- 15:42you are hearing. The third lesson a church leader
- 15:46can glean from the Cracker Barrel fiasco is the company
- 15:49failed to stop the sabotaging. The self sabotaging that took
- 15:54place from inside while the customers revolted on the
- 15:57outside. Due to the lack of trust and buy
- 16:00in for the new revamp plan, Cracker Barrel insiders began
- 16:04leaking damaging information to news medias, feeding the
- 16:09narrative that the store remodel modeling program was a disaster.
- 16:14The company had to first stop the leaking of information by
- 16:17linking the plan's promise with the future potential of new
- 16:20customers, improved sales and a higher stock price in the
- 16:24future. Yet initially they dug in and
- 16:27refused to listen to the customers or even change their
- 16:30strategy. And there is a tendency, if
- 16:32you're honest right where you are in the early stages of
- 16:35revitalization, for efforts for for leaders like yourself to
- 16:39take similar steps in sinking any hope of fundamental
- 16:44transformational change. Leaders must be open to hearing
- 16:49from disgruntled members, even if the they do not walk away.
- 16:55Agree. At least pastor, that member
- 17:00feels heard, which is the first step towards understanding the
- 17:04other side in a disagreement. The pastor and the church board
- 17:08have to decide whether this is an isolated concern by listening
- 17:12to that member. Or could this concern
- 17:15potentially be a larger problem? Larger problems warrant greater
- 17:20engagement with not only that one person talking to you, but
- 17:23with more people. But you have to also see if it's
- 17:28just one person. Is it an isolated issue that can
- 17:32be ignored but not forgotten? Has these things can grow and
- 17:37fester? Not everyone is going to agree
- 17:40all the time. But by limiting disagreements,
- 17:43pastor you give the revitalization plan a stronger
- 17:46chance of taking hold and transforming the church for the
- 17:49future. If a member of the leadership
- 17:52here's a negative comment. This is anybody that is in
- 17:56leadership. Here's a negative comment or
- 17:58receives questions. I want to challenge you do not
- 18:01take it as a personal attack or an attack even against the plan.
- 18:05I want you to embrace the opportunity to share with God
- 18:08has directed the team to lay forth in the plan.
- 18:11Use use the conversations to take the temperature of your
- 18:15congregation. Leaders can get so focused on
- 18:19the plan that they miss the people who have to support and
- 18:23move the plan forward. Do not allow negative mindsets
- 18:28or or narrow mindedness to get in the way of hearing a
- 18:32narrative that's not your own. Allow disaffected or
- 18:37disenfranchised members to share their concerns and engage in
- 18:41communication that helps the community of faith by embracing
- 18:45each other. If not for the plan, at least
- 18:48for your Christianity. Well, the associates of Cracker
- 18:53Barrel were themselves dissatisfied with the roll out
- 18:56of the change and they began leaking this internal
- 18:59information to the public. And instead of receiving the
- 19:02information and addressing the concerns, what did the corporate
- 19:05office do? They set about circling the
- 19:07wagons and hunkering down, believing that the negative
- 19:10stories would die down and they could get back to the changes
- 19:14that they wanted to make. That's a great leadership lesson
- 19:18for you, pastor or even a church board member.
- 19:21Do not hide from negative voices.
- 19:24Want you to go to them, listen to them, listen to their
- 19:27concerns. Lean into what they are saying
- 19:31and not how you are feeling while they are saying it.
- 19:35Remember, it's not about you, it's about God.
- 19:39Focus on the future by connecting back with them
- 19:42through your faith and allow the Spirit to guide the process it
- 19:46is in and through the process that the promise of God will be
- 19:50fulfilled through your ministry and through the local church.
- 19:55All right, let's begin to land this plane.
- 19:58The 4th lesson a church leader can glean from the Cracker
- 20:01Barrel fiasco is this. The company lost loyal customers
- 20:06because they changed too quickly.
- 20:09Within two months of the rollout plan, same store sales dropped
- 20:13dramatically. The store's modernization plan,
- 20:15which had high hopes of expanding the customer base,
- 20:19alienated current customers and LED future customers to
- 20:23reconsider visiting the store due to the negative publicity.
- 20:26This 1-2 punch sank the plan leaving companies.
- 20:31The companies hope for a a store refresh in church
- 20:36revitalization. The same effects can happen to
- 20:39you when leaders ignore the comments or the commitment and
- 20:43the community that they shepherd.
- 20:45Ultimately, the customers voted with their feet and stayed away
- 20:49from their local store. And in the church, it remains
- 20:52true just the same. When members are unhappy with
- 20:55what is happening in the local church, they attend less, they
- 20:59volunteer little, and eventually, due to
- 21:01dissatisfaction, they leave. Each of these steps is a small
- 21:06warning sign that something larger is taking place.
- 21:09As a leader, you must be sensitive to the undercurrents
- 21:13in the local church. They take place in small
- 21:17gatherings in the foyer on Sunday nights or Wednesday or,
- 21:21or even Sunday mornings. People pay attention to the
- 21:25people who used to not like each other, but all of a sudden are
- 21:29talking and they're, they seem like they're teaming up because
- 21:31they have something in common. And that's to defeat the plan.
- 21:36Also pay attention to voices, voices that are hushed when you
- 21:41walk by. Huh.
- 21:44These little signs are big warning signs that problems are
- 21:48festering and if left unaddressed will grow and
- 21:52overtake the positive God agenda that you might have for the
- 21:55local church, Cracker Barrel corporate executives if they had
- 22:00not hidden behind spokespeople or a public relations firm.
- 22:05And address the systematic problem upfront with the honesty
- 22:08and clarity they would have had to they would not have had to
- 22:13reverse their decision or lose $700 million in investor income
- 22:18or even 10% market cap thereafter.
- 22:22As a leader, be bold in addressing issues.
- 22:25Not as a bully, but as a Christ follower with grace and
- 22:29understanding. Provide space and time for
- 22:33honest conversations and heartfelt forums where all ideas
- 22:37can can be shared in what God has said to to them, the one
- 22:42who's negative and the one who's positive.
- 22:46Then lead all sides in prayer and in praying together to
- 22:52remind each of them all sides, that together we're on the same
- 22:58side. And that is in the city wanting
- 23:02the same outcome winning souls for Jesus.
- 23:07In the end, change is not easy. It upsets some who focus on self
- 23:14over the wants of the Savior. But instead of writing off
- 23:19negative voices, I want you to be open.
- 23:21Be open to sharing heart to heart what God is saying to each
- 23:24other. I imagine if you do, you might
- 23:28even realize that you agree 90% of the time.
- 23:32So give that other 10%, the 10% where you don't agree, just give
- 23:37it over to God. Let him figure it out.
- 23:41In the end, Cracker Barrel did change.
- 23:44Cracker Barrel did adapt to the societal pressures placed on it
- 23:48by the stakeholders. Only time will tell whether this
- 23:53was a wise decision for either party beginning or the beginning
- 23:58of the end of a classic brand. So here's my closing words as a
- 24:05revitalization pastor myself. Maybe I'm speaking to you pastor
- 24:11or even that member of a church going going through a change
- 24:15season. If you do not change, the church
- 24:19will die. If you change the church too
- 24:23fast, the church will die. It's only when both sides, the
- 24:30change nots and the would be changers adapt to each other
- 24:35that God does something special and the church realizes the
- 24:41revitalization that God had for it all along.
- 24:45So here's my closing words. Stay focused, focus on God,
- 24:51focus on each other. Trust the process.
- 24:54Trust, promise, and fulfill God's plan for your local
- 24:59church. Thanks for listening to
- 25:06Revitalize the Declining Church with Doctor Desmond Barrett.
- 25:08If you liked what you heard today, would you be willing to
- 25:10share it with your colleagues or your local leaders inside your
- 25:13church? Why don't you subscribe so you
- 25:16don't miss the next episode that comes out?
- 25:18As always, my friends, I believe in you.
- 25:20I'm praying for you. Have a great week.