Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [2012] Berkshire Hathaway Letter to Shareholders
Transcript
- 0:00Berkshire Hathaway, Inc to the shareholders of Berkshire
- 0:03Hathaway Incorporated. In 2012, Berkshire achieved a
- 0:07total gain for its shareholders of $24.1 billion.
- 0:11We used $1.3 billion of that to repurchase our stock, which left
- 0:16us with an increase in net worth of $22.8 billion.
- 0:20For the year, the per share book value of both our Class A and
- 0:24Class B stock increased by 14.4%.
- 0:28Over the last 48 years, that is, since present management took
- 0:32over, book value has grown from $19.00 to $114,214.00, a rate of
- 0:3919.7% compounded annually. A number of good things happened
- 0:43at Berkshire last year, but let's first get the bad news out
- 0:46of the way. When the partnership Iran took
- 0:48control of Berkshire in 1965, I could never have dreamed that a
- 0:52year in which we had again of $24.1 billion would be subpar in
- 0:58terms of the comparison we present on the facing page.
- 1:01But subpar it was. For the ninth time in 48 years,
- 1:05Berkshire's percentage increase in book value was less than the
- 1:09S and PS percentage gain, a calculation that includes
- 1:12dividends as well as price appreciation.
- 1:15In eight of those nine years, it should be noted, the S&P had a
- 1:19gain of 15% or more. We do better when the wind is in
- 1:24our face. To date, we've never had a five
- 1:26year period of underperformance having managed 43 times to
- 1:30surpass the S&P over such a stretch.
- 1:33The record is on page 103, but the S&P has now had gains in
- 1:38each of the last for years outpacing us over that period.
- 1:42If the market continues to advance in 2013, our streak of
- 1:46five year wins will end. One thing of which you can be
- 1:49certain, whatever Berkshire's results, my partner Charlie M
- 1:53Unger, the company's Vice Chairman, and I will not change
- 1:56yardsticks. It's our job to increase
- 1:59intrinsic business value, for which we use book value as a
- 2:02significantly understated proxy at a faster rate than the market
- 2:07gains of the S&P. If we do so, Berkshire's share
- 2:10price, though unpredictable from year to year, will itself
- 2:14outpace the S&P overtime. If we fail, however, our
- 2:19management will bring no value to our investors who themselves
- 2:23can earns and P returns by buying a low cost index fund.
- 2:27Charlie and I believe the gain in Berkshire's intrinsic value
- 2:30will overtime likely surpass the S&P returns by a small margin.
- 2:35We're confident of that because we have some outstanding
- 2:38businesses, a cadre of terrific operating managers and a
- 2:42shareholder oriented culture. Our relative performance,
- 2:46however, is almost certain to be better when the market is down
- 2:50or flat. In years when the market is
- 2:52particularly strong, expect us to fall short.
- 2:56The second disappointment in 2012 was my inability to make a
- 3:00major acquisition. I pursued a couple of elephants
- 3:03but came up empty handed. All per share figures used in
- 3:07this report apply to Berkshire's A shares.
- 3:10Figures for the B shares are 11,500 TH.
- 3:14Of those shown for A three. Our luck, however, changed early
- 3:18this year. In February, we agreed to buy
- 3:2150% of a holding company that will own all of HJ Heinz.
- 3:26The other half will be owned by a small group of investors led
- 3:29by Jorge Paolo Le Man, a renowned Brazilian businessman
- 3:33and philanthropist. We couldn't be in better
- 3:36company. Jorge Paolo is a long time
- 3:38friend of mine and an extraordinary manager.
- 3:41His group and Berkshire will each contribute about $4 billion
- 3:45for common equity in the holding company.
- 3:48Berkshire will also invest $8 billion in preferred shares that
- 3:52pay a 9% dividend. The preferred has two other
- 3:56features that materially increase its value.
- 3:59At some point it will be redeemed at a significant
- 4:02premium price and the preferred also comes with warrants
- 4:05permitting us to buy 5% of the holding companies common stock
- 4:08for a nominal sum. Our total investment of about
- 4:11$12 billion soaks up much of what Berkshire earned last year,
- 4:16but we still have plenty of cash and are generating more at a
- 4:19good clip. So it's back to work.
- 4:21Charlie and I have again donned our safari outfits and resumed
- 4:25our search for elephants. Now to some good news from 2012.
- 4:29Last year at Old U that beat NSF is car Lubrizo L Marmont Group
- 4:35and Mid American Energy are 5 most profitable.
- 4:38Non insurance companies were likely to earn more than $10
- 4:40billion pre tax in 2012. They delivered despite tepid US
- 4:47growth and weakening economies throughout much of the world.
- 4:51Our Powerhouse 5 had aggregate earnings of $10.1 billion, about
- 4:56$600 million more than in 2011. Of this group, only Mid
- 5:01American, then earning $393 million pre tax, was owned by
- 5:06Berkshire eight years ago. Subsequently, we purchased
- 5:10another three of the five on an all cash basis.
- 5:13In acquiring the 5th BNSF, we paid about 70% of the cost in
- 5:18cash and for the remainder issued shares that increased the
- 5:22amount outstanding by 6.1%. Consequently, the $9.7 billion
- 5:27gain in annual earnings delivered Berkshire by the five
- 5:31companies has been accompanied by only minor dilution that
- 5:35satisfies our goal of not simply growing but rather increasing
- 5:39per share results. Unless EU S dot economy tanks,
- 5:42which we don't expect, our powerhouse 5 should again
- 5:45deliver higher earnings in 2013. The five outstanding CEOs who
- 5:50run them will see to that. Though I failed to land a major
- 5:54acquisition in 2012, the managers of our subsidiaries did
- 5:58far better. We had a record year for bolt on
- 6:01purchases spending about $2.3 billion for 26 companies that
- 6:06were melded into our existing businesses.
- 6:09These transactions were completed without Berkshire
- 6:11issuing any shares. Charlie and I love these
- 6:14acquisitions. Usually they are low risk,
- 6:17burden headquarters not at all, and expand the scope of our
- 6:21proven managers. Our insurance operations shot
- 6:24the lights out last year while giving Berkshire $73 billion of
- 6:28free money to invest. They also delivered a $1.6
- 6:32billion underwriting gain, the 10th consecutive year of
- 6:36profitable underwriting. This is truly having your cake
- 6:40and eating it too. GEICO led the way, continuing to
- 6:43gobble up market share without sacrificing underwriting
- 6:46discipline. Since 1995, when we obtained
- 6:49control, Geico's share of the personal auto market market has
- 6:52grown from 2.5% to 9.7%. Premium volume, meanwhile,
- 6:58increased from $2.8 billion to $16.7 billion.
- 7:03Much more growth lies ahead. The credit for Geico's
- 7:07extraordinary performance goes to Tony Nicely and his 27,000
- 7:11associates. And to that cast we should add
- 7:14our gecko. Neither rain or storm nor gloom
- 7:17of night can stop him. The little lizard just soldiers
- 7:21on telling American show they can save big money by going to
- 7:24geico.com. When I count my blessings, I
- 7:27count GEICO twice. 4 Todd Combs and Ted we S Siehler, our new
- 7:33investment managers, have proved to be smart models of integrity,
- 7:37helpful to Berkshire in many ways beyond portfolio management
- 7:41and a perfect cultural fit. We hit the jackpot with these
- 7:45two in 2012. Each outperformed the S&P 500 by
- 7:50double digit margins. They left Maine the dust is
- 7:53well. Consequently, we have increased
- 7:55the funds managed by each to almost $5 billion, some of
- 7:59disseminating from the pension funds of our subsidiaries.
- 8:03Todd and Ted are young and will be around to manage Berkshire's
- 8:06massive portfolio long after Charlie and I have left the
- 8:10scene. You can rest easy when they take
- 8:12over. Berkshire's year end employment
- 8:15totaled a record 288462. See page 106 for details, Up
- 8:2117,604 from last year. Our headquarters crew, however,
- 8:27remained unchanged at 24. No sense going crazy.
- 8:31Berkshire's BIG4 Investments, American Express, Coca-Cola, IBM
- 8:35and Wells Fargo all had good years.
- 8:38Our ownership interest in each of these companies increased
- 8:41during the year we purchased additional shares of Wells
- 8:45Fargo. Our ownership now is 8.7% versus
- 8:487.6% at year in 2011 and IBM 6.0% versus 5.5%.
- 8:56Meanwhile, stock repurchases at Coca-Cola and American Express
- 9:00raised our percentage ownership. Our equity in Coca-Cola grew
- 9:04from 8.8% to 8.9% and our interest at American Express
- 9:09from 13% to 13.7%. Berkshire's ownership interest
- 9:14in all four companies is likely to increase in the future.
- 9:18Mae W had it right. Too much of a good thing can be
- 9:21wonderful. The four companies possess
- 9:24marvelous businesses and are run by managers who are both
- 9:27talented and shareholder oriented.
- 9:30At Berkshire, we much prefer owning and non controlling but
- 9:33substantial portion of a wonderful business to owning
- 9:36100% of a SOSO business. Our flexibility and capital
- 9:41allocation gives us a significant advantage over
- 9:44companies that limit themselves only to acquisitions they can
- 9:47operate. Going by our year and share
- 9:50count, our portion of the Big Four's 2012 earnings amounted to
- 9:54$3.9 billion. In the earnings report to you,
- 9:58however, we include only the dividends we receive about $1.1
- 10:02billion. But make no mistake, the $2.8
- 10:06billion of earnings we do not report is every bit as valuable
- 10:10to us as what we record. The earnings that the four
- 10:13companies retain are often used for repurchase S, which enhance
- 10:17our share of future earnings and also for funding business
- 10:21opportunities that are usually advantageous.
- 10:23Over time, we expect substantially greater earnings
- 10:27from these for Invest ES. If we are correct, dividends to
- 10:31Berkshire will increase and even more important, so will our
- 10:35unrealized capital gains, which for the four totaled $26.7
- 10:40billion at year end. There was a lot of hand wringing
- 10:43last year among CEOs who cried uncertainty when faced with
- 10:47capital allocation decisions. Despite many of their businesses
- 10:51having enjoyed record levels of both earnings and cash.
- 10:55At Berkshire, we didn't share their fears, instead spending a
- 10:58record $9.8 billion on planted equipment in 2012, about 88% of
- 11:05it in the United States. That's 19% more than we spent in
- 11:092011, our previous high. Charlie and I love investing
- 11:13large sums in worthwhile projects.
- 11:16Whatever the pundits are saying, we instead heed the words from
- 11:19Gary Allen's new country song, Every Storm Runs Out of Rain.
- 11:24We will keep our foot to the floor, and we'll almost
- 11:26certainly set still another record for capital expenditures
- 11:30in 2013. Opportunities abound in America.
- 11:34A thought for my fellow CE OS. Of course, the immediate future
- 11:38is uncertain. America has faced the unknown
- 11:41since 1776. It's just that sometimes people
- 11:45focus on the myriad of uncertainties that always exist,
- 11:49while at other times they ignore them, usually because the recent
- 11:52past has been uneventful. 5 American business will do fine
- 11:56over time, and stocks will dowel just as certainly since their
- 12:00fate is tied to business performance.
- 12:03Periodic setbacks will occur, yes, but investors and managers
- 12:07are in a game that is heavily stacked in their favor.
- 12:11The Dow Jones Industrials advanced from 66 to 11,497 in
- 12:17the 20 TH century, a staggering 17,320% increase that
- 12:23materialized despite for costly wars, a Great Depression, and
- 12:27many recessions. And don't forget that
- 12:29shareholders received substantial dividends throughout
- 12:32the century as well. Since the basic game is so
- 12:36favorable, Charlie and I believe it's a terrible mistake to try
- 12:39to dance in and out of it based upon the turn of tarot cards,
- 12:44the predictions of experts, or the ebb and flow of business
- 12:48activity. The risks of being out of the
- 12:50game are huge compared to the risks of being in it.
- 12:53My own history provides A dramatic example.
- 12:55I made my first stock purchase in the spring of 1942, when the
- 12:59US was suffering major losses throughout the Pacific war zone.
- 13:04Each day's headlines told of more setbacks.
- 13:07Even so, there was no talk about uncertainty.
- 13:10Every American I knew believed we would prevail.
- 13:13The country's success since that perilous time boggles the mind.
- 13:17On an inflation adjusted basis, GDP per capita more than
- 13:21quadrupled between 1941 and 2012.
- 13:25Throughout that period, every tomorrow has been uncertain.
- 13:29America's destiny, however, has always been clear.
- 13:33Ever increasing abundance. If you are ACEO who has some
- 13:36large profitable project you are shelving because of short term
- 13:40worries, call Berkshire, Let us unburden you.
- 13:43In summary, Charlie and I hope to build per share intrinsic
- 13:47value by 1 improving the earning power of our many subsidiaries,
- 13:512, further increasing their earnings through bolt on
- 13:54acquisitions, 3 participating in the growth of our invest EES for
- 13:59repurchasing Berkshire shares when they are available at a
- 14:02meaningful discount from intrinsic value and five, making
- 14:06an occasional large acquisition. We will also try to maximize
- 14:09results for you by rarely, if ever issuing Berkshire shares.
- 14:14Those building blocks rest on a rock solid foundation.
- 14:17A century hence, BNSF and Mid American Energy will continue to
- 14:22play major roles in the American economy.
- 14:24Insurance, moreover, will always be essential for both businesses
- 14:29and individuals, and no company brings greater resources to that
- 14:33arena than Berkshire. As we view these and other
- 14:36strengths, Charlie and I like your company's prospects.
- 14:39Intrinsic business value As much as Charlie and I talk about
- 14:43intrinsic business value, we cannot tell you precisely what
- 14:46that number is for Berkshire shares or, for that matter, any
- 14:50other stock. In our 2010 annual report,
- 14:53however, we laid out the three elements, one of which was
- 14:57qualitative, that we believe are the keys to a sensible estimate
- 15:01of Berkshire's intrinsic value. That discussion is reproduced in
- 15:05full on pages 104 to 105. Here is an update of the two
- 15:10quantitative factors. In 2012, our per share
- 15:13investments increased 15.7% to $113,786 and our per share pre
- 15:21tax earnings from businesses other than insurance and
- 15:24investments also increased 15.7% to $8085.
- 15:30Since 1970, our per share investments have increased at a
- 15:34rate of 19.4% compounded annually and our per share
- 15:38earnings figure has grown at a 20.8% clip.
- 15:42It is no coincidence that the price of Berkshire stock over
- 15:45the 42 year period has increased at a rate very similar to that
- 15:49of our two measures of value. Charlie and I like to see gains
- 15:53in both areas, but our strong emphasis will always be on
- 15:57building operating earnings. Now let's examine the four major
- 16:01sectors of our operations. Each has vastly different
- 16:04balance sheet and income characteristics from the others.
- 16:08Lumping them together therefore impedes analysis.
- 16:11So we'll present them as four separate businesses, which is
- 16:14how Charlie and I view them. Insurance.
- 16:16Let's look first at insurance Berkshire SCORE operation and
- 16:20the engine that has propelled our expansion over the years.
- 16:24Property casualty PC insurers receive premiums upfront and pay
- 16:28claims later. In extreme cases, such as those
- 16:31arising from certain workers compensation accidents, payments
- 16:35can stretch over decades. This collect now, pay later
- 16:39model leaves us holding large sums money we call float that
- 16:42will eventually go to others. Meanwhile, we get to invest this
- 16:46float for Berkshire's benefit. Though individual policies and
- 16:49claims come and go, the amount of float we hold remains quite
- 16:53stable in relation to premium volume.
- 16:55Consequently, as our business grows, so does our float and how
- 17:00we have grown as the following table shows.
- 17:03Year flaunt in dollars millions 1970 dollars Thirty nine
- 17:081980230719 91,632 Two thousand 27,871 2010 65,832 2012 73,125
- 17:25Last year at old you that our float was likely to level up for
- 17:29even decline a bid in the future.
- 17:31Our insurance CEO set out to prove me wrong and did
- 17:35increasing float last year by $2.5 billion.
- 17:39I now expect a further increase in 2013, but further gains will
- 17:44be tough to achieve. On the plus side, Geico's float
- 17:47will almost certainly grow in National Indemnity's reinsurance
- 17:51division. However, we have a number of
- 17:54runoff contracts whose float drifts downward.
- 17:57If we do experience a decline in float at some future time, it
- 18:01will be very gradual. At the outside now more than 2%
- 18:04in any year, if our premiums exceed the total of our expenses
- 18:09and eventual losses, we register an underwriting profit that adds
- 18:13to the investment income our flow produces.
- 18:16When such a profit is earned, we enjoy the use of free money and
- 18:20better yet get paid for holding it.
- 18:23That's like you're taking out a loan and having the bank pay you
- 18:25interest. Unfortunately, the wish of all
- 18:28insurers to achieve this happy result creates intense
- 18:31competition so vigorous in most years that it causes the PC
- 18:36industry as a whole to operate at a significant underwriting
- 18:39loss. This loss, in effect, is what
- 18:42the industry pays to hold its float.
- 18:44For example, State Farm, by far the country's largest insurer in
- 18:49a well managed company, besides incurred an underwriting loss in
- 18:53eight of the 11 years ending in 2011.
- 18:56There financial S for 2012 are not yet available.
- 19:00Their area a lot of ways to lose money and insurance and the
- 19:04industry never ceases searching for new ones.
- 19:07As noted in the first section of this report, we have now
- 19:10operated at an underwriting profit for 10 consecutive years,
- 19:14our pre tax gain for the period having totaled $18.6 billion.
- 19:19Looking ahead, I believe we will continue to underwrite
- 19:22profitably in most years. If we do, our float will be
- 19:26better than free money. So how does our attractive float
- 19:29affect the calculations of intrinsic value?
- 19:31When Berkshire's book value is calculated, the full amount of
- 19:35our float is deducted as a liability, just as if we had to
- 19:39pay it out tomorrow and were unable to replenish it.
- 19:42But that's an incorrect way to look at float, which should
- 19:45instead be viewed as a revolving fund.
- 19:48If float is both cost less and long enduring, which I believe
- 19:52Berkshires will be, the true value of this liability is
- 19:55dramatically less than the accounting liability.
- 19:58A partial offset to this overstated liability is $15.5
- 20:02billion off goodwill that is attributable to our insurance
- 20:06companies and included in book value is Sonos set.
- 20:10In effect, this goodwill represents the price we paid for
- 20:13the float generating capabilities of our insurance
- 20:16operations. The cost of the goodwill,
- 20:19however? Has no bearing on it's true
- 20:22value. For example, if an insurance
- 20:24business sustains large and prolonged underwriting losses,
- 20:27any goodwill asset carried on the books should be deemed
- 20:31valueless, whatever its original cost. 7 Fortunately, that's not
- 20:36the case at Berkshire. Charlie and I believe the true
- 20:39economic value of our insurance goodwill, what we would happily
- 20:42pay to purchase an insurance operation producing float of
- 20:46similar quality to be far in excess of its historic carrying
- 20:50value. The value of our float is one
- 20:53reason, a huge reason why we believe Berkshire's intrinsic
- 20:56business value substantially exceeds its book value.
- 21:00Let me emphasize once again that cost free float is not an
- 21:03outcome to be expected for the PC industry as a whole.
- 21:07There is very little Berkshire quality float existing in the
- 21:10insurance world. In 37 of the 45 years ending in
- 21:152011, the industry's premiums have been inadequate to cover
- 21:19claims plus expenses. Consequently, the industries
- 21:23overall return on tangible equity has for many decades
- 21:26fallen far short of the average return realized by American
- 21:30industry. A sorry performance almost
- 21:32certain to continue a further unpleasant reality adds to the
- 21:36industry's dim prospects. Insurance earnings are now
- 21:39benefiting from legacy bond portfolios that deliver much
- 21:43higher yields than will be available when funds are
- 21:46reinvested during the next few years, and perhaps for many
- 21:49years beyond that. Today's bond portfolios are, in
- 21:52effect, wasting assets. Earnings of insurers will be
- 21:56hurt in a significant way as bonds mature and are rolled
- 22:00over. Berkshire's outstanding
- 22:02economics exist only because we have some terrific managers
- 22:05running some extraordinary insurance operations.
- 22:08Let me tell you about the major units.
- 22:11First by float size is the Berkshire Hathaway Reinsurance
- 22:14Group, run by AJ Jane. AJ.
- 22:17It ensures risks that no one else has the desire or the
- 22:20capital to take on. His operation combines capacity,
- 22:24speed, decisiveness and most important, brains in a manner
- 22:28unique in the insurance business.
- 22:30Yet he never exposes Berkshire to risks that are inappropriate
- 22:34in relation to our resources. Indeed, we are far more
- 22:38conservative in avoiding risk than most large insurers.
- 22:42For example, if the insurance industry should experience a
- 22:45$250 billion loss from some mega catastrophe, a loss about triple
- 22:50anything it has ever experienced, Berkshire as a
- 22:53whole would likely record a significant profit for the year
- 22:57because it has so many streams of earnings.
- 22:59All other major insurers and reinsurers would meanwhile be
- 23:03far in the red, with some facing insolvency.
- 23:06From a standing start in 1985. AJ it has created an insurance
- 23:10business with float of $35 billion in a significant
- 23:14cumulative underwriting profit, a feat that no other insurance
- 23:18CEO has come close to matching. He has thus added a great many
- 23:22billions of dollars to the value of Berkshire.
- 23:25If you meet AJ at the annual meeting, bow deeply.
- 23:29We have another reinsurance powerhouse in General Rhee
- 23:32managed by T Admat Ross. At bottom, a sound insurance
- 23:36operation needs to adhere to 4 disciplines.
- 23:39It must, one, understand all exposures that might cause a
- 23:42policy to incur losses, Two, conservatively assess the
- 23:46likelihood of any exposure actually causing a loss and the
- 23:50probable cost if it does. 3 set a premium that on average will
- 23:54deliver a profit after both prospective loss costs and
- 23:58operating expenses are covered, and four, be willing to walk
- 24:01away if the appropriate premium can't be obtained.
- 24:04Many insurers pass the first three tests and flunk the 4th.
- 24:08They simply can't turn their back on business that is being
- 24:12eagerly written by their competitors.
- 24:14That old line, the other guy is doing it, so we must as well.
- 24:18Spells trouble in any business, but none more so than insurance.
- 24:228. TAT has observed all four of the
- 24:24insurance commandments and it shows in his results.
- 24:28General residential huge float has been better than cost free
- 24:32under his leadership and we expect that on average it will
- 24:35continue to be. We are particularly enthusiastic
- 24:39about general residential international life reinsurance
- 24:42business, which has achieved consistent and profitable growth
- 24:46since we acquired the company in 1998.
- 24:49Finally, there is GEICO, the insurer on which I cut my teeth
- 24:5362 years ago. GEICO was run by Tony Nicely,
- 24:57who joined the company at 18 and completed 51 years of service in
- 25:012012. I rub my eyes when I look at
- 25:03what Tony has accomplished last year.
- 25:06It should be noted his record was considerably better than is
- 25:09indicated by Geico's gap underwriting profit of $680
- 25:13million. Because of a change in
- 25:16accounting rules at the beginning of the year, we
- 25:18recorded a charge to Geico's underwriting earnings of $410
- 25:23million. This item had nothing to do with
- 25:262012's operating results, changing neither cash, revenues,
- 25:30expenses nor taxes. In effect, the write down simply
- 25:35widened the already huge difference between Geico's
- 25:37intrinsic value and the value at which we carry it on our books.
- 25:41GEICO earned its underwriting profit, moreover, despite the
- 25:45company suffering its largest single loss in history.
- 25:49The cause was Hurricane Sandy, which cost GEICO more than three
- 25:52times the loss it sustained from Katrina, the previous record
- 25:56holder. We insured 46,906 vehicles that
- 26:00were destroyed or damaged in the storm, a staggering number
- 26:04reflecting Geico's leading market share in the New York
- 26:07metropolitan area. Last year, GEICO enjoyed a
- 26:10meaningful increase in both the renewal rate for existing
- 26:14policyholders, persistent PSI, and in the percentage of rate
- 26:18quotations that resulted in sales closures.
- 26:20Big dollars ride on those two factors.
- 26:24A sustained gain in persistent PSI of a bear one percentage
- 26:27point increases intrinsic value by more than $1 billion.
- 26:31Geico's gains in 2012 offer dramatic proof that when people
- 26:35check the company's prices, they usually find they can save
- 26:39important sums. Give USA try it 1-800-847-7536
- 26:46or geico.com. Be sure to mention that you area
- 26:49shareholder. That fact will usually result in
- 26:52a discount. In addition to our three major
- 26:55insurance operations, we own a group of smaller companies, most
- 26:59of them buying their trade in odd corners of the insurance
- 27:02world. In aggregate, these companies
- 27:04have consistently delivered an underwriting profit.
- 27:07Moreover, as the table below shows, they also provide us with
- 27:11substantial float. Charlie and I treasure these
- 27:14companies and their managers. Late in 2012, we enlarged this
- 27:19group by acquiring Guard Insurance, a Wilkes Barre
- 27:22company that writes workers compensation insurance primarily
- 27:26for smaller businesses. Regards.
- 27:27Annual premiums total about $300 million.
- 27:31The company has excellent prospects for growth in both its
- 27:34traditional business and new lines.
- 27:36It has begun to offer regulated, capital intensive businesses.
- 27:41We have two major operations, BNSF and Mid American Energy,
- 27:45that have important common characteristics distinguishing
- 27:49them from our other businesses. Consequently, we assign them
- 27:52their own section in this letter and split out their combined
- 27:56financial statistics in our GAAP balance sheet and income
- 27:59statement. A key characteristic of both
- 28:01companies is their huge investment in very long lived
- 28:05regulated assets, with these partially funded by large
- 28:09amounts of long term debt that is not guaranteed by Berkshire.
- 28:12Our credit is in fact not needed because each business has
- 28:16earning power that, even under terrible conditions, amply
- 28:19covers its interest requirements.
- 28:22In last year's tepid economy, for example, the NSF's interest
- 28:26coverage was 9.6 X. Our definition of coverage is
- 28:30pre tax earnings interest, not EBITD interest, a commonly used
- 28:35measure we view as deeply flawed.
- 28:37At Mid American meanwhile, 2 key factors ensure its ability to
- 28:41service debt under all circumstances.
- 28:44Companies recession resistant earnings which result from our
- 28:48exclusively offering an essential service and it's great
- 28:51diversity of earnings streams which shield it from being
- 28:55seriously harmed by any single regulatory body.
- 28:58Everyday our two subsidiaries power the American economy in
- 29:02major ways. BNSF carries about 15%, measured
- 29:06by ton miles of all intercity freight, whether it is
- 29:09transported by truck, rail, water, air or pipeline.
- 29:14Indeed, we move more ton miles of goods than anyone else, a
- 29:18fact making BNSF the most important artery in our
- 29:22economy's circulatory system. BNSF also moves its cargo in an
- 29:27extraordinarily fuel efficient and environmentally friendly
- 29:30way, carrying a ton of freight about 500 miles on a single
- 29:34gallon of diesel fuel. Trucks taking on the same job
- 29:38guzzle about for times as much fuel.
- 29:40Mid Americans electric utilities serve regulated retail customers
- 29:44in 10 states. Only one utility holding company
- 29:47serves more states. In addition, we are the leader
- 29:51in renewables. First, from a standing start
- 29:54nine years ago, we now account for 6% of the country's wind
- 29:58generation capacity. Second, when we complete three
- 30:02projects now under construction, we will own about 14% of you dot
- 30:07solar generation capacity. Projects like these require huge
- 30:11capital investments upon completion.
- 30:13Indeed, our renewables portfolio will have cost $13 billion.
- 30:19We relish making such commitments if they promise
- 30:21reasonable returns, and on that front we put a large amount of
- 30:25trust in future regulation. Our confidence is justified both
- 30:30by our past experience and by the knowledge that society will
- 30:33forever need massive investment in both transportation and
- 30:37energy. It is in the self-interest of
- 30:40governments to treat capital providers in a manner that will
- 30:43ensure the continued flow of funds to essential projects.
- 30:47And it is in our self-interest to conduct our operations in a
- 30:50manner that earns the approval of our regulators and the people
- 30:54they represent. Our managers must think today of
- 30:57what the country will need far down the road.
- 30:59Energy and transportation projects can take many years to
- 31:03come to fruition. A growing country simply can't
- 31:06afford to get behind the curve. We have been doing our part to
- 31:09make sure that doesn't happen. Whatever you may have heard
- 31:12about are countries Crumbling? Infrastructure in no way applies
- 31:16to be NSF or railroads generally.
- 31:18America's rail system has never been in better shape, a
- 31:22consequence of huge investments by the industry.
- 31:25We are not, however, resting on our laurels.
- 31:29BNSF will spend about $4 billion on the railroad in 2013, roughly
- 31:34double its depreciation charge and more than any railroad has
- 31:38spent in a single year. 10 in Matt Rows at the NSF and Greg
- 31:43Abel at Mid American, we have two outstanding CE OS.
- 31:47They are extraordinary managers who have developed businesses
- 31:51that serve both their customers and owners well.
- 31:54Each has my gratitude and each deserves yours.
- 31:58Here are the key figures for their businesses.
- 32:00Mid American 89.8% Owned earnings and millions Net
- 32:05earnings 3372 dollars $2972. Sharp eyed readers will notice
- 32:13an incongruity in the Mid American earnings tabulation.
- 32:17What in the world is Home Services, a real estate
- 32:20brokerage operation doing in a section entitled regulated
- 32:24Capital Intensive Businesses? Well, it's ownership came with
- 32:28Mid American when we bought control of that company in 2000.
- 32:32At that time I focused on Mid Americans utility operations and
- 32:36barely noticed Home Services, which then owned only a few real
- 32:40estate brokerage companies. Since then, however, the company
- 32:44has regularly added Residential Brokers 3 in 2012 and now has
- 32:49about 16,000 agents in a string of major U.S. cities.
- 32:54Our real estate brokerage companies are listed on page
- 32:57107. In 2012, our agents participated
- 33:01in $42 billion of home sales, up 33% from 2011.
- 33:07Additionally, Home Services last year purchased 67% of the
- 33:11Prudential and Real Living franchise operations, which
- 33:15together license 544 brokerage companies throughout the country
- 33:20and receive a small royalty on their sales.
- 33:23We have an arrangement to purchase the balance of those
- 33:26operations within five years. In the coming years, we will
- 33:30gradually rebrand both our franchisees and the franchise
- 33:33firms we own as Berkshire Hathaway Home Services.
- 33:37Ron Peltier has done an outstanding job in managing Home
- 33:40Services during a depressed period.
- 33:42Now as the housing market continues to strengthen, we
- 33:46expect earnings to rise significantly. 11 manufacturing,
- 33:50service and retailing operations.
- 33:53Our activities in this part of Berkshire cover the waterfront.
- 33:56Let's look though at a summary balance sheet, an earnings
- 34:00statement for the entire group. Our income and expense data
- 34:03conforming to generally accepted accounting principles gap is on
- 34:08page 29. In contrast, the operating
- 34:11expense figures above are non GAAP.
- 34:13In particular they exclude some purchase accounting items,
- 34:17primarily the amortization of certain intangible assets.
- 34:21We present the data in this manner because Charlie and I
- 34:24believe the adjusted numbers more accurately reflect the real
- 34:28expenses and profits of the business is aggregated in the
- 34:31table. I want to explain all of the
- 34:33adjustments. Some are small and arcane, but
- 34:36serious investors should understand the disparate nature
- 34:39of intangible assets. Some truly deplete over time,
- 34:43while others never lose value with software.
- 34:46For example, amortization charges are very real expenses.
- 34:50Charges against other intangibles such as the
- 34:52amortization of customer relationships, however, arise
- 34:56through purchase accounting rules and are clearly not real
- 34:59expenses. Gap accounting draws no
- 35:02distinction between the two types of charges, both that is a
- 35:06recorded as expenses when calculating earnings. 7th law.
- 35:10From an investor's viewpoint they could not be more
- 35:12different. In the GAP compliant figures we
- 35:15show on page 29, amortization charges of $600 million for the
- 35:20companies included in this section are deducted as
- 35:23expenses. We would call about 20% of the
- 35:26Zerialand indeed that is the portion we have included in the
- 35:29table above and the rest not. This difference has become
- 35:32significant because of the many acquisitions we have made.
- 35:36Non real amortization expense also looms large at some of our
- 35:40major invest EES. IBM has made many small
- 35:44acquisitions in recent years and now regularly reports adjusted
- 35:47operating earnings and on GAAP figure that excludes certain
- 35:51purchase accounting adjustments. Analysts focus on this number as
- 35:55they should. A non real amortization charge
- 35:58at Wells Fargo however is not highlighted by the company and
- 36:02never too my knowledge has been noted in analyst reports.
- 36:06The earnings that Wells Fargo reports are heavily burdened by
- 36:09an amortization of core deposits charge.
- 36:12The implication being that these deposits are disappearing at a
- 36:16fairly rapid clip, yet core deposits regularly increase.
- 36:20The charge last year was about $1.5 billion.
- 36:24In no sense except GAAP accounting is this whopping
- 36:27charge and expense. And that ends today's accounting
- 36:30lecture. Why is noon shouting More and
- 36:32more? The crowd of companies in this
- 36:34section sell products ranging from lollipops to jet airplanes.
- 36:38Some of IT businesses enjoy terrific economics measured by
- 36:42earnings on unleveraged net tangible assets that run from
- 36:4525% after tax to more than 100%. Others produce good returns in
- 36:51the area of 12 to 20%. A few, however, have very poor
- 36:56returns, a result of some serious mistakes I made in my
- 37:00job of capital allocation. More than 50 years ago, Charlie
- 37:03told me that it was far better to buy a wonderful business at a
- 37:07fair price than to buy a fair business at a wonderful price.
- 37:11Despite the compelling logic of his position, I have sometimes
- 37:15reverted to my old habit of bargain hunting, with results
- 37:18ranging from tolerable to terrible.
- 37:21Fortunately, my mistakes have usually occurred when I made
- 37:24smaller purchases. Our large acquisitions have
- 37:27generally worked out well and in a few cases more than well
- 37:31viewed as a single entity. Therefore, the companies in this
- 37:34group are an excellent business. They employ $22.6 billion of net
- 37:40tangible assets and on that base earn 16.3% after tax.
- 37:45Of course, a business with terrific economics can be a bad
- 37:49investment if the price paid is excessive.
- 37:52We have paid substantial premiums to net tangible assets
- 37:55for most of our businesses, a cost that is reflected in the
- 37:59large figure we show for intangible assets.
- 38:02Overall, however, we are getting a decent return on the capital
- 38:06we have deployed in this sector. Furthermore, the intrinsic value
- 38:10of the businesses in aggregate exceeds their carrying value by
- 38:15a good margin. Even so, the difference between
- 38:17intrinsic value and carrying value in the insurance and
- 38:21regulated industry segments is far greater.
- 38:24It is there that the huge winners reside.
- 38:26Marmon provides an example of a clear and substantial gap
- 38:30existing between book value and intrinsic value.
- 38:34Let me explain the odd origin of this differential.
- 38:37Last year at Old You that we had purchased additional shares in
- 38:40Marmon, raising our ownership to 80%, up from the 64% we acquired
- 38:46in 2008. I also told you that Gap
- 38:48accounting required us to immediately record the 2011
- 38:52purchase on our books at far less than what we paid.
- 38:55I've now had a year to think about this weird accounting
- 38:58rule, but I've yet to find an explanation that makes any
- 39:01sense, nor can Charlie or Mark Hamburg, our CFO, come up with
- 39:06one. My confusion increases when I am
- 39:08told that if we hadn't already owned 64%, the 16% we purchased
- 39:14in 2011 would have been entered on our books a tour cost in 2012
- 39:19and an early 2013 retroactive to year and 2012.
- 39:23We acquired an additional 10% of Marmont and the same bizarre
- 39:27accounting treatment was required.
- 39:29The $700 million write off we immediately incurred had no
- 39:33effect on earnings, but did reduce book value and therefore
- 39:382012 S gain in net worth. The cost of our recent 10%
- 39:42purchase implies a $12.6 billion value for the 90% of Marm on.
- 39:47We now own our balance sheet Carrying value for the 90%
- 39:51however is $8 billion. Charlie and I believe our
- 39:55current purchase represents excellent value.
- 39:58If we are correct, our MARM on holding is worth at least $4.6
- 40:03billion more than its. Carrying value Marmon is a
- 40:06diverse enterprise comprised of about 150 companies operating in
- 40:11a wide variety of industries. Its largest business involves
- 40:15the ownership of tank cars that are released to a variety of
- 40:18shippers, such as soil and chemical companies.
- 40:22Marmon conducts this business through two subsidiaries.
- 40:25Union Tank Car in the USDOT NT Proc or in Canada 13.
- 40:30Union Tank Car has been around a long time, having been owned by
- 40:34the Standard Oil Trust until that empire was broken up in
- 40:371911. Look for its UTLX logo on tank
- 40:40cars when you watch trains roll by.
- 40:42As a Berkshire shareholder, you own the cars with that Insignia.
- 40:47When you spot a UTLX car, puff out your chest a bit and enjoy
- 40:51the same satisfaction that John D Rockefeller undoubtedly
- 40:55experienced as he viewed his fleet a century ago.
- 40:58Tank cars are owned by either shippers or lessors, not by
- 41:02railroads. At year end, Union Tank Car and
- 41:05Proc or together own 97,000 cars having a net book value of $4
- 41:10billion. A new car, it should be noted
- 41:13costs upwards of $100,000. Union Tank Car is also a major
- 41:18manufacturer of tank cars, some of them to be sold, but most to
- 41:22be owned by it and leased out. Today it's order book extends
- 41:26well into 2014. At both B NSF and Marmont, we
- 41:31are benefiting from the resurgence of U.S. oil
- 41:34production. In fact, our railroad is now
- 41:37transporting about 500,000 barrels of oil daily, roughly
- 41:4210% of the total produced in the Lower 48, IE not counting Alaska
- 41:46and offshore. All indications are that the
- 41:49NSF's oil shipments will grow substantially in coming years.
- 41:53Space precludes us from going into detail about the many other
- 41:57businesses in this segment. Company specific information
- 42:00about the 2012 operations of some of the larger units appears
- 42:04on pages 76 to 79, Finance and Financial Products.
- 42:09This sector, our smallest, includes 2 rental companies,
- 42:14XDRA Trailers and Court Furniture, as well as Clayton
- 42:17Homes, the country's leading producer and finance are of
- 42:21manufactured homes. Aside from these 100% own
- 42:25subsidiaries. We also include in this category
- 42:28a collection of financial assets and our 50% interest in Burkadia
- 42:32Commercial Mortgage. We include Clayton in this
- 42:35sector because it owns and services 332,000 mortgages
- 42:40totaling $13.7 billion. In large part, these loans have
- 42:44been made to lower and middle income families.
- 42:47Nevertheless, the loans have performed well throughout the
- 42:50housing collapse, thereby validating our conviction that a
- 42:54reasonable down payment and a sensible payments to income
- 42:57ratio will ward off outsized foreclosure losses even during
- 43:01stressful times. Clayton also produced 25,872
- 43:06manufactured homes last year, up 13.5% from 2011.
- 43:11That output accounted for about 4.8% of all single family
- 43:16residences built in the country, a share that makes Clayton
- 43:19America's number one home builder.
- 43:21Court and XDRA are leaders in their industries as well.
- 43:25Our expenditures for new rental equipment at XDRA totaled $256
- 43:30million in 2012, more than double its depreciation expense.
- 43:35While competitors fret about today's uncertainties, XDRA is
- 43:40preparing for tomorrow. Burka Dia continues to do well.
- 43:43Our partners at Lucia Dia do most of the work in this venture
- 43:47and arrangement that Charlie and I happily embrace.
- 43:51Investments Below we show our common stock investments that at
- 43:54year end had a market value of more than 1 billion dollars.
- 43:58123,112 percentage of shares. Company Company cost.
- 44:04Market owned. One point about the composition
- 44:07of this list deserves mention in Berkshire's past annual reports.
- 44:11Every stock itemized in this space has been bought by me in
- 44:15the sense that I made the decision to buy it for
- 44:17Berkshire. But starting with this list, any
- 44:20investment made by Todd Combs or Ted we SC Hiller or a combined
- 44:24purchase by them that meets the dollar threshold for the list,
- 44:28$1 billion this year, will be included.
- 44:30Above is the first such stock, DIRECTV, which both Todd and Ted
- 44:35hold in their portfolios and whose combined holdings at the
- 44:38end of 2012 were valued at the $1.15 billion shown.
- 44:43Todd and Ted also managed the pension funds of certain
- 44:46Berkshire subsidiaries, while others, for regulatory reasons,
- 44:50are managed by outside advisors. We do not include holdings of
- 44:54the pension funds in our annual report tabulation S, though
- 44:58their portfolios often overlap Berkshires.
- 45:01We continue to wind down the part of our derivatives
- 45:04portfolio that involve the assumption by Berkshire of
- 45:07insurance like risks. Our electric and gas utility
- 45:10businesses however will continue to use derivatives for
- 45:15operational purposes. New commitments would require us
- 45:18to post collateral and with minor exceptions we are
- 45:22unwilling to do that. Markets can behave in
- 45:25extraordinary ways and we have no interest in exposing
- 45:28Berkshire to some out of the blue event.
- 45:30In the financial world that might require our posting
- 45:33mountains of cash on a moments notice.
- 45:36Charlie and I believe in operating with many redundant
- 45:39layers of liquidity and we avoid any sort of obligation that
- 45:43could drain our cash in a material way that reduces our
- 45:47returns in 99 years out of 100. But we will survive in the 100
- 45:51TH while many others fail and we will sleep well in all 115.
- 45:57The derivatives we have sold that provide credit protection
- 46:00for corporate bonds will all expire in the next year.
- 46:04It's now almost certain that our profit from these contracts will
- 46:07approximate $1 billion pre tax. We also received very
- 46:11substantial sums up front on these derivatives and the float
- 46:14attributable to them has averaged about $2 billion over
- 46:18their five year lives. All told, these derivatives have
- 46:22provided a more than satisfactory result, especially
- 46:25considering the fact that we were guaranteeing corporate
- 46:27credits, mostly of the high yield variety throughout the
- 46:31financial panic and subsequent recession.
- 46:33In our other major derivatives commitment, we sold long term
- 46:37puts on 4 leading stock indices in the USUK, Europe and Japan.
- 46:44These contracts were initiated between 2004 and 2008 and even
- 46:49under the worst of circumstances have only minor collateral
- 46:52requirements. In 2010, we unwound about 10% of
- 46:56our exposure at a profit of $222 million.
- 47:01The remaining contracts expire between 2018 and 2026.
- 47:05Only the index value at expiration date counts.
- 47:09Our counterparties have no right to early termination.
- 47:12Berkshire received premiums of $4.2 billion when we wrote the
- 47:16contracts that remain outstanding.
- 47:19If all of these contracts had come due at year in 2011, we
- 47:23would have had to pay $6.2 billion.
- 47:26The corresponding figure at year in 2012 was $3.9 billion.
- 47:32With this large drop in immediate settlement liability,
- 47:35we reduced our gap liability at year in 2012 to $7.5 billion
- 47:41from $8.5 billion at the end of 2011.
- 47:45Though it's no sure thing, Charlie and I believe it likely
- 47:48that the final liability will be considerably less than the
- 47:51amount we currently carry on our books in.
- 47:55In the meantime, we can invest the $4.2 billion of float
- 47:58derived from these contracts as we see fit.
- 48:01We buy some newspapers. Newspapers.
- 48:04During the past 15 months, we acquired 28 daily newspapers at
- 48:08a cost of $344 million. This may puzzle you for two
- 48:13reasons. First, I have long told you in
- 48:16these letters and at our annual meetings that they, circulation,
- 48:20advertising and profits of the newspaper industry overall are
- 48:23certain to decline. That prediction still holds.
- 48:27Second, the properties we purchased fell far short of
- 48:30meeting RFT stated size requirements for acquisitions.
- 48:34We can address the second point easily.
- 48:36Charlie and I love newspapers, and if their economics makes
- 48:39sense, we'll buy them even when they fall far short of the size
- 48:43threshold we would require for the purchase of, say, a widget
- 48:47company. Addressing the first point
- 48:49requires me to provide a more elaborate explanation, including
- 48:53some history. News, to put it simply, is what
- 48:56people don't know that they want to know, and people will seek
- 48:59their news. What's important to them, from
- 49:01whatever sources provide the best combination of immediacy,
- 49:05ease of access, reliability, comprehensiveness, and low cost.
- 49:09The relative importance of these factors varies with the nature
- 49:12of the news and the person wanting it.
- 49:15Before television and the Internet, newspapers were the
- 49:18primary source for an incredible variety of news, a fact that
- 49:22made them indispensable to a very high percentage of the
- 49:25population. Whether your interests were
- 49:28international, national, local, sports, or financial quotations,
- 49:33your newspaper usually was first to tell you the latest
- 49:36information. Indeed, your paper contains so
- 49:39much you wanted to learn that you received your money's worth,
- 49:42even if only a small number of its pages spoke to your specific
- 49:46interests. Better yet, advertisers
- 49:49typically paid almost all of the products cost, and readers rode
- 49:53their coattails. Additionally, the ads themselves
- 49:56delivered information of vital interest to hordes of readers,
- 50:00in effect providing even more news.
- 50:03Editors would cringe at the thought, but for many readers,
- 50:06learning what jobs or apartments were available, what
- 50:09supermarkets were carrying, which weekend specials or what
- 50:12movies were showing where and when was far more important than
- 50:16the views expressed on the editorial page. 16 In turn, the
- 50:21local paper was indispensable to advertisers.
- 50:24If Sears or Safeway built stores in Omaha, they required a
- 50:27megaphone to tell the city's residents why their stores
- 50:30should be visited today. Indeed, big department stores
- 50:34and grocers vied to out shout their competition with multi
- 50:37page spreads, knowing that the goods they advertised would fly
- 50:41off the shelves with no other megaphone remotely comparable to
- 50:45that of the newspaper ads sold themselves.
- 50:48As long as a newspaper was the only one in its community, its
- 50:52profits were certain to be extraordinary.
- 50:54Whether it was managed well or poorly made little difference,
- 50:58as one Southern publisher famously confessed.
- 51:01Oh my exalted position in life to two Great American
- 51:04institutions, nepotism and monopoly.
- 51:07Over the years, almost all cities became one newspaper
- 51:10towns or harbored 2 competing papers that joined forces to
- 51:14operate as a single economic unit.
- 51:16This contraction was inevitable because most people wished to
- 51:20read and pay for only one paper. When competition existed, the
- 51:24paper that gained a significant lead in circulation almost
- 51:28automatically received the most ads.
- 51:30That left ads drawing readers and readers drawing ads.
- 51:34This symbiotic process spelled doom for the weaker paper and
- 51:38became known as survival of the fattest.
- 51:41Now the world has changed. Stock market quotes and the
- 51:44details of national sports events are old news.
- 51:47Long before the presses begin to roll.
- 51:49The Internet offers extensive information about both available
- 51:53jobs and homes. Television bombards viewers with
- 51:56political, national and international news in one area
- 52:00of interest after another. Newspapers have therefore lost
- 52:04their primacy and as their audiences have fallen so as
- 52:08advertising revenues from help wanted.
- 52:10Classified ads, long a huge source of income for newspapers,
- 52:14have plunged more than 90% in the past 12 years.
- 52:18Newspapers continue to reign supreme, however, in the
- 52:21delivery of local news. If you want to know what's going
- 52:25on in your town, whether the news is about the mayor or taxes
- 52:28or high school football, there is no substitute for a local
- 52:32newspaper that is doing its job. A reader's eyes may glaze over
- 52:35after they take in a couple of paragraphs about Canadian
- 52:38tariffs or political developments in Pakistan.
- 52:41A story about the reader himself or his neighbor's will be read
- 52:45to the end. Wherever there is a pervasive
- 52:48sense of community, a paper that serves the special informational
- 52:52needs of that community will remain indispensable to a
- 52:55significant portion of its residents.
- 52:57Even a valuable product, however, can self destruct from
- 53:01a faulty business strategy, and that process has been under way
- 53:05during the past decade at almost all papers of size.
- 53:09Publishers, including Berkshire and Buffalo, have offered their
- 53:12paper free on the Internet while charging meaningful sums for the
- 53:15physical specimen. How could this lead to anything
- 53:19other than a sharp and steady drop in sales of the printed
- 53:22product? Falling circulation, moreover,
- 53:25makes a paper less essential to advertisers.
- 53:28Under these conditions, the virtuous circle of the past
- 53:31reverses. The Wall Street Journal went to
- 53:34a pay model early, but the main exemplar for local newspapers is
- 53:37the Arkansas Democrat Gazette, published by Walter Hussman
- 53:42Junior. Walter also adopted a pay format
- 53:44early, and over the past decade his paper has retained its
- 53:48circulation far better than any other large paper in the
- 53:52country. Despite Walter's powerful
- 53:54example, it's only been in the last year or so that other
- 53:57papers, including Berkshires, have explored pay arrangements.
- 54:02Whatever works best, and the answer is not yet clear, will be
- 54:05copied widely. Charlie and I believe that
- 54:08papers delivering comprehensive and reliable information to
- 54:11tightly bound communities and having a sensible Internet
- 54:15strategy will remain viable for a long time.
- 54:18We do not believe that success will come from cutting either
- 54:21the news content or frequency of publication.
- 54:24Indeed, skimpy news coverage will almost certainly lead to
- 54:28skimpy readership, and the less than daily publication that is
- 54:31now being tried in some large towns or cities, while it may
- 54:35improve profits in the short term, seem certain to diminish
- 54:39the papers relevance over time. Our goal is to keep our papers
- 54:43loaded with content of interest to our readers and to be paid
- 54:47appropriately by those who find us useful, whether the product
- 54:50they view is in their hands or on the Internet. 17 Our
- 54:54confidence is buttressed by the availability of Terry Kroger's
- 54:58outstanding management group at the Omaha World Herald, a team
- 55:02that has the ability to oversee a large group of papers.
- 55:06The individual papers, however, will be independent in their
- 55:10news coverage and editorial opinions.
- 55:12I voted for Obama. Of our 12 dailies that endorsed
- 55:16the presidential candidate, Tin opted for Romney.
- 55:19Our newspapers are certainly not insulated from the forces that
- 55:22have been driving revenues downward.
- 55:24Still, the six small dailies we owned throughout 2012 had
- 55:28unchanged revenues for the year, a result far superior to that
- 55:32experienced by big city dailies. Moreover, the two large papers
- 55:37we operated throughout the year, the Buffalo News in the Omaha
- 55:40World Herald, held their revenue loss to 3%, which was also an
- 55:44above average outcome among newspapers in America's 50
- 55:48largest metropolitan areas. Our Buffalo and Omaha papers
- 55:52ranked near the top end circulation penetration of their
- 55:55home territories. This popularity is no accident.
- 55:59Credit the editors of those papers, Margaret Sullivan at the
- 56:02News and Mic Riley at the World Herald, for delivering
- 56:05information that has made their publications indispensable to
- 56:09community interested readers. Margaret, I regret to say,
- 56:13recently left us to join the New York Times, whose job offers are
- 56:17tough to turn down. That paper made a great hire and
- 56:20we wish her the best. Berkshire's cash earnings from
- 56:23its papers will almost certainly trend downward over time.
- 56:27Even a sensible Internet strategy will not be able to
- 56:30prevent modest erosion a tour cost.
- 56:33However I believe these papers will meet or exceed our economic
- 56:37test for acquisitions. Results to date support that
- 56:40belief. Charlie and I, however, still
- 56:43operate under Economic Principle 11 detailed on page 99 and will
- 56:47not continue the operation of any business doomed to unending
- 56:51losses. One daily paper that we acquired
- 56:54in a bulk purchase from Media General was significantly
- 56:58unprofitable under that company's ownership.
- 57:00After analyzing the papers results, we saw no remedy for
- 57:04the losses and reluctantly shut it down.
- 57:07All of our remaining dailies however, that should be
- 57:10profitable for a long time to come.
- 57:12They are listed on page 108 at appropriate prices, and that
- 57:16means that a very low multiple of current earnings suite will
- 57:19purchase more papers of the type we like.
- 57:22A milestone in Berkshire's newspaper operations occurred at
- 57:25year end when Stan Lip Say retired as publisher of the
- 57:28Buffalo News. It's no exaggeration for me to
- 57:31say that the News might now be extinct were it not for Stan.
- 57:35Charlie and I acquired the News in April 1977.
- 57:39It was an evening paper, dominant on weekdays but lacking
- 57:42a Sunday edition. Throughout the country, the
- 57:45circulation trend was toward morning papers.
- 57:48Moreover, Sunday was becoming ever more critical to the
- 57:51profitability of metropolitan dailies.
- 57:54Without a Sunday paper, the news was destined to lose out to its
- 57:58morning competitor, which had a fat and entrenched Sunday
- 58:01product. We therefore began to print a
- 58:03Sunday edition late in 1977. And then all hell broke loose.
- 58:08Our competitor sued us, and District Judge Charles Brieant
- 58:12Junior authored A harsh ruling that crippled the introduction
- 58:15of our paper. His ruling was later reversed
- 58:18after 17 long months in a three to 0 sharp rebuke by the 2nd
- 58:22Circuit Court of Appeals. While the appeal was pending, we
- 58:26lost circulation, hemorrhaged money, and stood in constant
- 58:29danger of going out of business. Interstan Lipsay, a friend of
- 58:34mine from the 1960s who with his wife had sold Berkshire, a small
- 58:39Omaha weekly. I found Stan to be an
- 58:41extraordinary newspaper man, knowledgeable about every aspect
- 58:45of circulation, production, sales and editorial.
- 58:49He was a key person in gaining that small weekly of Pulitzer
- 58:52Prize in 1973. So when I was in big trouble at
- 58:56the news, I asked Stan to leave his comfortable way of life in
- 58:59Omaha to take over in Buffalo. He never hesitated.
- 59:03Along with Murray Light, our editor, Stan persevered through
- 59:07four years of very dark days until the News won the
- 59:10competitive struggle in 1982. Ever since, despite a difficult
- 59:15Buffalo economy, the performance of the News has been
- 59:18exceptional. As both a friend and as a
- 59:20manager, Stan is simply the best. 18 dividends A number of
- 59:25Berkshire shareholders, including some of my good
- 59:28friends, would like Berkshire to pay a cash dividend.
- 59:31It puzzles them that we relish the dividends we receive from
- 59:34most of the stocks that Berkshire owns, but pay out
- 59:37nothing ourselves. So let's examine when dividends
- 59:40do and don't make sense for shareholders.
- 59:42A profitable company can allocate its earnings in various
- 59:45ways which are not mutually exclusive companies.
- 59:49Management should first examine reinvestment possibilities
- 59:52offered by its current business projects to become more
- 59:56efficient, expand territorially, extend and improve product
- 59:59lines, or to otherwise widen the economic Moat separating the
- 1:00:03company from its competitors. I asked the managers of our
- 1:00:06subsidiaries to unending LY focus on Moat widening
- 1:00:10opportunities and they find many that make economic sense.
- 1:00:14But sometimes our managers misfire.
- 1:00:16The usual cause of failure is that they start with the answer
- 1:00:20they want and then work backwards to find a supporting
- 1:00:22rationale. Of course, the process is
- 1:00:25subconscious. That's what makes it so
- 1:00:27dangerous. Your chairman has not been free
- 1:00:30of this SN. In Berkshire's 1986 annual
- 1:00:33report, I described how 20 years of management effort and capital
- 1:00:37improvements in our original textile business were an
- 1:00:40exercise in futility. I wanted the business to succeed
- 1:00:45and wish my way into a series of bad decisions.
- 1:00:48I even bought another New England textile company.
- 1:00:51But wishing makes dreams come true only in Disney movies.
- 1:00:55It's poison in business. Despite such past miskews, our
- 1:00:59first priority with available funds will always be to examine
- 1:01:02whether they can be intelligently deployed in our
- 1:01:05various businesses. Our record $12.1 billion of
- 1:01:09fixed asset investments and bolt on acquisitions in 2012
- 1:01:14demonstrate that this is a fertile field for capital
- 1:01:17allocation at Berkshire and here we have an advantage.
- 1:01:20Because we operate in so many areas of the economy, we enjoy a
- 1:01:24range of choices far wider than that open to most corporations.
- 1:01:29In deciding what to do, we can water the flowers and skip over
- 1:01:32the weeds. Even after we deploy hefty
- 1:01:35amounts of capital in our current operations, Berkshire
- 1:01:38will regularly generate a lot of additional cash.
- 1:01:41Our next step therefore is to search for acquisitions
- 1:01:45unrelated to our current businesses.
- 1:01:47Here our test is simple. Do Charlie and I think we can
- 1:01:50effect a transaction that is likely to leave our shareholders
- 1:01:54wealthier on a per share basis than they were prior to the
- 1:01:57acquisition. I have made plenty of mistakes
- 1:01:59in acquisitions and we'll make more.
- 1:02:02Overall, however, our record is satisfactory, which means that
- 1:02:06our shareholders are far wealthier today than they would
- 1:02:09be if the funds we used for acquisitions had instead been
- 1:02:13devoted to share repurchase S or dividends.
- 1:02:16But to use the standard disclaimer, past performance is
- 1:02:20no guarantee of future results. That's particularly true at
- 1:02:24Berkshire because of our present size.
- 1:02:26Making acquisitions that are both meaningful and sensible is
- 1:02:29now more difficult than it has been during most of our years.
- 1:02:33Nevertheless, a large deal still offers us possibilities to add
- 1:02:37materially to per share intrinsic value.
- 1:02:40BNSF is a case in point. It is now worth considerably
- 1:02:44more than our carrying value. Had we instead allocated the
- 1:02:47funds required for this purchase to dividends or repurchase S,
- 1:02:52you and I would have been worse off.
- 1:02:54The large transactions of the BNSF kind will be rare.
- 1:02:58There are still some whales in the ocean.
- 1:03:01The third use of funds, repurchase S, is sensible for a
- 1:03:04company when its shares sell at a meaningful discount to
- 1:03:08conservatively calculated intrinsic value.
- 1:03:10Indeed, disciplined repurchase S are the surest way to use funds
- 1:03:15intelligently. It's hard to go wrong when
- 1:03:18you're buying dollar bills for 80 or less.
- 1:03:21We explained our criteria for repurchase S in last year's
- 1:03:24report, and if the opportunity presents itself, we will buy
- 1:03:28large quantities of our stock. We originally said we would not
- 1:03:32pay more than 110% of book value, but that proved
- 1:03:36unrealistic. Therefore, we increase the limit
- 1:03:39to 120% in December when a large block became available at about
- 1:03:44116% of book value. 19 But never forget, in repurchase decisions,
- 1:03:51price is all important. Value is destroyed when
- 1:03:54purchases are made above intrinsic value.
- 1:03:57The directors and I believe that continuing shareholders are
- 1:04:00benefited in a meaningful way by purchases up to our 120% limit.
- 1:04:05And that brings us to dividends. Here we have to make a few
- 1:04:08assumptions and use some math. The numbers will require careful
- 1:04:12reading, but they are essential to understanding the case for
- 1:04:15and against dividends. So bear with me.
- 1:04:18We'll start by assuming that you and I are the equal owners of a
- 1:04:22business with $2,000,000 of net worth.
- 1:04:25The business earns 12% on tangible net worth, $240,000,
- 1:04:30and can reasonably expect to earn the same 12% on reinvested
- 1:04:34earnings. Furthermore, there are outsiders
- 1:04:37who always wish to buy into our business at 125% of net worth.
- 1:04:43Therefore, the value of what we each own is now $1.25 million.
- 1:04:48You would like to have the two of us shareholders receive 1/3
- 1:04:51of our company's annual earnings and have 2/3 be reinvested.
- 1:04:55That plan you feel, will nicely balance your needs for both
- 1:04:59current income and capital growth.
- 1:05:02So you suggest that we pay out $80,000 of current earnings and
- 1:05:06retain $160,000 to increase the future earnings of the business.
- 1:05:11In the first year your dividend would be $40,000 and as earnings
- 1:05:15grew in the 1/3 payout was maintained, so two would your
- 1:05:19dividend. In total dividends and stock
- 1:05:22value would increase 8% each year. 12% earned on net
- 1:05:26worthless. 4% of net worth paid out.
- 1:05:29After 10 years our company would have a net worth of dollars
- 1:05:32431-7850. The original $2,000,000
- 1:05:37compounded at 8% in your dividend in the upcoming year
- 1:05:40would be $86,357. Each of us would have shares
- 1:05:45worth $2,698,656, 125% of our half of the company's net worth,
- 1:05:54and we would live happily ever after, with dividends and the
- 1:05:58value of our stock continuing to grow at 8% annually.
- 1:06:02There is an alternative approach, however, that would
- 1:06:05leave us even happier. Under this scenario, we would
- 1:06:08leave all earnings in the company and each sell 3.2% of
- 1:06:12our shares annually. Since the shares would be sold
- 1:06:15at 125% of book value, this approach would produce the same
- 1:06:19$40,000 of cash initially, a sum that would grow annually.
- 1:06:24Call this option the Sell Off approach.
- 1:06:26Under this sell off scenario, the net worth of our company
- 1:06:30increases to $6,211,696 after 10 years $2,000,000, compounded at
- 1:06:3812%. Because we would be selling
- 1:06:40shares each year, our percentage ownership would have declined
- 1:06:45and after 10 years we would each own 36.12% of the business.
- 1:06:50Even so, your share of the net worth of the company at that
- 1:06:53time would be $2,243,540. And remember, every dollar of
- 1:07:01net worth attributable to each of us can be sold for 1.25
- 1:07:05dollars. Therefore, the market value of
- 1:07:07your remaining shares would be $2,804,425, about 4% greater
- 1:07:15than the value of your shares if we had followed the dividend
- 1:07:18approach. Moreover, your annual cash
- 1:07:20receipts from the sell off policy would now be running 4%
- 1:07:24more than you would have received under the dividend
- 1:07:26scenario. Voila, you would have both more
- 1:07:29cash to spend annually and more capital value.
- 1:07:32This calculation, of course, assumes that our hypothetical
- 1:07:36company can earn an average of 12% annually on net worth, and
- 1:07:40that its shareholders can sell their shares for an average of
- 1:07:43125% of book value. To that point, the S&P 500 earns
- 1:07:49considerably more than 12% on net worth and sells at a price
- 1:07:53far above 125% of that net worth.
- 1:07:56Both assumptions also seem reasonable for Berkshire, though
- 1:07:59certainly not assured. Moreover, on the plus side,
- 1:08:03there also is a possibility that the assumptions will be
- 1:08:05exceeded. If they are, the argument for
- 1:08:08the sell off policy becomes 7 stronger over Berkshire's
- 1:08:11history, admittedly one that won't come close to being
- 1:08:15repeated. The sell off policy would have
- 1:08:17produced results for shareholders dramatically
- 1:08:19superior to the dividend policy. Aside from the favorable math,
- 1:08:24there are two further and important arguments for a sell
- 1:08:27off policy. First, dividends impose a
- 1:08:29specific cash out policy upon all shareholders.
- 1:08:33If say 40% of earnings is the policy, those who wish 30% or
- 1:08:3850% will be forwarded. Our 600000 shareholders cover
- 1:08:44the waterfront in their desires for cash.
- 1:08:47It is safe to say however that a great many of them, perhaps even
- 1:08:51most of them, are in a net savings mode and logically
- 1:08:54should prefer no payment at all. 20 The sell off alternative, on
- 1:08:59the other hand, let's each shareholder make his own choice
- 1:09:02between cash receipts and capital build up. 1 Shareholder
- 1:09:06can elect to cash out, say, 60% of annual earnings, while other
- 1:09:10shareholders elect 20% or nothing at all.
- 1:09:14Of course, a shareholder in our dividend paying scenario could
- 1:09:17turn around and use his dividends to purchase more
- 1:09:20shares, but he would take a beating in doing so.
- 1:09:24He would both incur taxes and also pay a 25% premium to get
- 1:09:28his dividend reinvested. Keep remembering open market
- 1:09:32purchases of the stock take place at 125% of book value.
- 1:09:37The second disadvantage of the dividend approach is of equal
- 1:09:40importance. The tax consequences for all tax
- 1:09:43paying shareholders are inferior, usually far inferior,
- 1:09:46to those under the sell off program.
- 1:09:48Under the dividend program, all of the cash received by
- 1:09:52shareholders each year is taxed, whereas the sell off program
- 1:09:56results in tax on only the gain portion of the cash receipts.
- 1:10:00Let me end this math exercise and I can hear you cheering as I
- 1:10:03put away the dentist drill by using my own case to illustrate
- 1:10:07how a shareholders regular disposals of shares can be
- 1:10:10accompanied by an increased investment in his or her
- 1:10:13business. For the last seven years, I have
- 1:10:16annually given away about 41 four percent of my Berkshire
- 1:10:20shares. Through this process my original
- 1:10:23position of 712497000 be equivalent shares split adjusted
- 1:10:29has decreased to 528525623 shares.
- 1:10:34Clearly, my ownership percentage of the company has significantly
- 1:10:37decreased, yet my investment in the business has actually
- 1:10:41increased. The book value of my current
- 1:10:43interest in Berkshire considerably exceeds the book
- 1:10:46value attributable to my holdings of seven years ago.
- 1:10:50The actual figures are $28.2 billion for 2005 and $40.2
- 1:10:55billion for 2012. In other words, I now have far
- 1:10:59more money working for me at Berkshire.
- 1:11:02Even though my ownership of the company has materially
- 1:11:04decreased. It's also true that my share of
- 1:11:07both Berkshire's intrinsic business value and the company's
- 1:11:11normal earning power is far greater than it was in 2005.
- 1:11:15Over time, I expect this accretion of value to continue,
- 1:11:18albeit in a decidedly irregular fashion, even as I now annually
- 1:11:23give away more than 41 two percent of my shares, the
- 1:11:25increase having occurred because I've recently doubled my
- 1:11:29lifetime pledges to certain foundations.
- 1:11:31Above all, dividend policy should always be clear,
- 1:11:35consistent and rational. A capricious policy will confuse
- 1:11:39owners and drive away would be investors.
- 1:11:42Phil Fisher put it wonderfully 54 years ago in Chapter 7 of his
- 1:11:46Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits, a book that ranks
- 1:11:50behind only the Intelligent Investor in the 1940 edition of
- 1:11:54Security Analysis. In the all time best list for
- 1:11:57the Serious Investor, Phil explained that you can
- 1:12:00successfully run a restaurant that serves hamburgers or
- 1:12:03alternatively one that features Chinese food, but you can't
- 1:12:07switch capriciously between the two and retain the fans of
- 1:12:11either. Most companies pay consistent
- 1:12:13dividends, generally trying to increase them annually and
- 1:12:16cutting them very reluctantly. Our BIG4 portfolio companies
- 1:12:21follow this sensible and understandable approach and
- 1:12:24insert cases also repurchase shares quite aggressively.
- 1:12:28We applaud their actions and hope they continue on their
- 1:12:31present paths. We like increased dividends and
- 1:12:34we love repurchase S at appropriate prices.
- 1:12:37At Berkshire, however, we have consistently followed a
- 1:12:41different approach that we know has been sensible and that we
- 1:12:44hope has been made understandable by the paragraphs
- 1:12:46you have just read. We will stick with this policy
- 1:12:49as long as we believe our assumptions about the book value
- 1:12:52buildup and the market price premium seem reasonable.
- 1:12:55If the prospects for either factor change materially for the
- 1:12:58worse, we will re examine our actions.
- 1:13:01The Annual Meeting The annual meeting will be held on
- 1:13:04Saturday, May 4th TH at the CenturyLink Center.
- 1:13:07Carrie SOV will be in charge. Though that's a new name, it's
- 1:13:12the same wonderful Carrie as last year.
- 1:13:14She got married in June to a very lucky guy.
- 1:13:17All of our headquarters group pitches in to help her.
- 1:13:20The whole affair is a homemade production and I couldn't be
- 1:13:23more proud of those who put it together. 21 The doors will open
- 1:13:27at 7:00 AM and at 7:30 we will have our second international
- 1:13:32newspaper tossing challenge. The target will be the porch of
- 1:13:35a Clayton home precisely 35 feet from the throwing line.
- 1:13:39Last year I successfully fought off all challengers, but now
- 1:13:43Berkshire has acquired a large number of newspapers and with
- 1:13:47them came much tossing talenter. So the throwers claim.
- 1:13:50Come see whether their talent matches their talk.
- 1:13:53Better yet, join in. The papers will be 36 to 42
- 1:13:57pages and you must fold them yourself.
- 1:13:59No rubber bands. At 8:30 a new Berkshire movie
- 1:14:03will be shown. An hour later we will start the
- 1:14:05question and answer period, which, with a break for lunch at
- 1:14:08the Centurylinks stands, will last until 3:30.
- 1:14:12After a short recess, Charlie and I will convene the annual
- 1:14:15meeting at 3:45. If you decide to leave during
- 1:14:19the day's question periods, please do so while Charlie is
- 1:14:22talking. The best reason to exit, of
- 1:14:25course, is to shop. We will help you do so by
- 1:14:28filling the 194,300 square foot hall that adjoins the meeting
- 1:14:33area with products from dozens of Berkshire subsidiaries.
- 1:14:36Last year you did your part and most locations racked up record
- 1:14:40sales. In a nine hour period, we sold
- 1:14:431090 pairs of Justin Boots. That's a pair every 30 seconds,
- 1:14:4810,000 and 10 lbs of See's candy, 12,879 Cocut knives, 24
- 1:14:54knives per minute and 5784 pairs of Wells Lamont gloves.
- 1:15:00Always a hot item, but you can do better.
- 1:15:03Remember, anyone who says money can't buy happiness simply
- 1:15:07hasn't shopped. A tour meeting last year,
- 1:15:09Brooks, our running shoe company, exhibited for the first
- 1:15:12time and ran up sales of $150,000.
- 1:15:16Brooks is on fire. Its volume in 2012 grew 34%, and
- 1:15:22that was on top of a similar 34% gain in 2011.
- 1:15:26The company's management expects another jump of 23% in 2013.
- 1:15:32We will again have a special commemorative shoe to offer at
- 1:15:35the meeting on Sunday at 8:00 AM.
- 1:15:38We will initiate the Berkshire 5 KA race starting at the
- 1:15:41CenturyLink. Full details for participating
- 1:15:45will be included in the Visitor's guide that you will
- 1:15:47receive with your credentials for the meeting.
- 1:15:50We will have plenty of categories for competition,
- 1:15:53including one for the media. It will be fun to report on
- 1:15:56there performance. Regretfully, I will forego
- 1:15:59running. Someone has to man the starting
- 1:16:01gun. I should warn you that we have a
- 1:16:03lot of home grown talent. Ted we SC Hiller has run the
- 1:16:06marathon in three O 1. Jim Weber, Brooks dynamic CEO,
- 1:16:11is another speedster with a 331 best.
- 1:16:14Todd Combs specializes in the triathlon but has been clocked
- 1:16:18at 22 minutes in the 5K. That, however, is just the
- 1:16:22beginning. Our directors are also fleet of
- 1:16:24foot. That is, some of our directors
- 1:16:26are. Steve Burke has run an amazing
- 1:16:29239 Boston Marathon. It's a family thing.
- 1:16:32His wife Gretchen finished the New York Marathon in 325.
- 1:16:37Charlotte Guy Man's best is 337, and Sue Decker crossed the tape
- 1:16:42in New York in 336C did not return his questionnaire.
- 1:16:46GEICO will have a booth in the shopping area staffed by a
- 1:16:49number of its top counselors from around the country.
- 1:16:53Stop by for a quote. In most cases, GEICO will be
- 1:16:56able to give you a shareholder discount, usually 8%.
- 1:16:59This special offer is permitted by 44 of the 51 jurisdictions in
- 1:17:04which we operate. 1 Supplemental Point.
- 1:17:06The discount is not additive if you qualify for another such as
- 1:17:10that given certain groups. Bring the details of your
- 1:17:13existing insurance and check out whether we can save you money
- 1:17:16for at least half of you. I believe we can be sure to
- 1:17:19visit the Bookworm. It will carry about 35 books and
- 1:17:23DVD's, including a couple of new ones.
- 1:17:25Carol Loomis, who has been in valuable tome in editing this
- 1:17:29letter since 1977, has recently authored Tap Dancing to work
- 1:17:34Warren Buffett on practically everything.
- 1:17:36She and I have cosigned 500 copies available exclusively at
- 1:17:40the meeting. The Outsiders by William
- 1:17:43Thorndike Junior is an outstanding book about CEOs who
- 1:17:47excelled at capital allocation. It has an insightful chapter on
- 1:17:51our director, Tom Murphy, overall the best business
- 1:17:55manager I've ever met. I also recommend The Clash of
- 1:17:58the Cultures by Jack B Ogle and Laura Ritt. 10 houses investing
- 1:18:03between the lines. Should you need to ship your
- 1:18:05book purchases, a shipping service will be available
- 1:18:08nearby. The Omaha World Herald will
- 1:18:10again have a booth offering a few books it has recently
- 1:18:13published. Read blooded Husker fancies
- 1:18:16there. Any Nebraska and who isn't Tone
- 1:18:19will surely want to purchase Unbeatable.
- 1:18:21It tells thee story of Nebraska football during 1993 to 97 a
- 1:18:27goldener in which Tom Osborne esteems went 60 to 322.
- 1:18:32If you airy a big spender or aspire to become one, visit
- 1:18:35Signature Aviation on the east side of the Omaha Airport
- 1:18:38between noon and 5:00 PM on Saturday.
- 1:18:41Then we will have a fleet of net jets aircraft that will get your
- 1:18:44pulse racing come by bus, leave by private jet live a little.
- 1:18:49An attachment to the proxy material that is enclosed with
- 1:18:52this report explains how you can obtain the credential you will
- 1:18:55need for admission to the meeting and other events.
- 1:18:58Airlines have sometimes jacked up prices for the Berkshire
- 1:19:01weekend. If you are coming from far away,
- 1:19:04compare the cost of flying to Kansas City versus Omaha.
- 1:19:07The drive between the two cities is about 21 two hours and it may
- 1:19:12be that you can save significant money, particularly if you had
- 1:19:15planned to rent a car in Omaha. Spend the savings with us at
- 1:19:19Nebraska Furniture Mart, located on a 77 acre site on 72 in D
- 1:19:24Street between Dodge and Pacific.
- 1:19:26We will again be having. Berkshire Weekend Discount
- 1:19:29Pricing. Last year the store did $35.9
- 1:19:32million of business during its annual meeting sale, an all time
- 1:19:37record that makes other retailers turn green.
- 1:19:39To obtain the Berkshire Discount, you must make your
- 1:19:42purchases between Tuesday, April 30th TH and Monday May 6th TH
- 1:19:47inclusive, and also present your meeting credential.
- 1:19:50The period special pricing will even apply to the products of
- 1:19:54several prestigious manufacturers that normally have
- 1:19:57ironclad rules against discounting, but which in the
- 1:20:01Spirito for Shareholder weekend have made an exception for you.
- 1:20:05We appreciate their cooperation. NFM is open from 10:00 AM to
- 1:20:099:00 PM, Monday through Saturday, Antenna dot m.to 6:00
- 1:20:14PM on Sunday. On Saturday this year from 5:30
- 1:20:18PM to 8:00 PM, N FM is having a picnic to which you are all
- 1:20:22invited at Borschi IMS. We will again have two shareholder only
- 1:20:27events. The first will be a cocktail
- 1:20:29reception from 6P dot m.to 9:00 PM on Friday May 3rd Rd.
- 1:20:34The second, the main gala will be held on Sunday, May 5th TH
- 1:20:39from 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM. On Saturday we will be open
- 1:20:43until 6:00 PM. In recent years, our three day
- 1:20:46volume has far exceeded sales in all of December, normally a
- 1:20:50jeweler's best month. Around 1:00 PM on Sunday, I will
- 1:20:54begin clerking at Borschi IMS. Last year my sales totaled $1.5
- 1:20:59million. This year I won't quit until I
- 1:21:01hit $2,000,000 because I need to leave well before sundown.
- 1:21:05I will be desperate to do business.
- 1:21:08Come take advantage of me. Ask for my crazy Warren price.
- 1:21:11We will have huge crowds at Borschi IMS throughout the
- 1:21:14weekend for your convenience. Therefore shareholder prices
- 1:21:18will be available from Monday April 29th TH through Saturday
- 1:21:22May 11th TH. During that period, please
- 1:21:26identify yourself as a shareholder by presenting your
- 1:21:29meeting credentials or a brokerage statement that shows
- 1:21:32you area. Berkshire holder on Sunday in
- 1:21:35them all outside of Borschi, IMSA blindfolded Patrick Wolf
- 1:21:39twice You dot chess champion will take on all comers who will
- 1:21:43have their eyes wide open in groups of 6.
- 1:21:46Nearby, Norman Beck, a remarkable magician from Dallas,
- 1:21:51will be Wilder onlookers. Additionally, we will have Bob
- 1:21:54Ham and and Sharon OS Berg, 2 of the world's top bridge experts,
- 1:21:59available to play bridge with our shareholders on Sunday
- 1:22:02afternoon. Don't play them for money.
- 1:22:05Gore Otts and Piccolo's will again be open exclusively for
- 1:22:08Berkshire shareholders on Sunday, May 5th TH.
- 1:22:11Both will be serving until 10:00 PM, with Gore Otts opening at
- 1:22:161:00 PM and Piccolo's opening at 4:00 PM.
- 1:22:19These restaurants are my favorites and I will eat at both
- 1:22:22of them on Sunday evening. Remember to make a reservation
- 1:22:25at Gorats. Call 402-551-3733 on April 1st
- 1:22:32but not before in at Piccolo's. Call 402-342-9038 at Piccolo's.
- 1:22:39Order a giant root beer float for dessert.
- 1:22:42Only sissies get the small one. I once saw Bill Gates Polish off
- 1:22:462 of the giant variety after a full course dinner.
- 1:22:50That's when I knew he would make a great director.
- 1:22:52We will again have the same three financial journalists lead
- 1:22:55the question and answer period at the meeting, asking Charlie
- 1:22:58and me questions that shareholders have submitted to
- 1:23:01them by e-mail. The journalists and their e-mail
- 1:23:04addresses are Carol Loomis of Fortune, who may be emailed ATC
- 1:23:09Loomis fortunemail.com, becky.quickofcnbc@berkshirequestioncnbc.com
- 1:23:16and and Andrew Ross Sorkin of the New York Times,
- 1:23:19atersorkanytimes.com. From the questions submitted,
- 1:23:22each journalist will choose the six he or she decides are the
- 1:23:26most interesting and important. The journalists have told me
- 1:23:29your question has the best chance of being selected if you
- 1:23:32keep it concise, avoid sending it in at the last moment, make
- 1:23:36it Berkshire related and include no more than two questions in
- 1:23:40any e-mail you send them. In your e-mail, let the
- 1:23:43journalist know if you would like your name mentioned if
- 1:23:45you're question is selected. Last year we had a second panel
- 1:23:49of three analysts who follow Berkshire.
- 1:23:51All were insurance specialists and shareholders subsequently
- 1:23:55indicated they wanted a little more variety.
- 1:23:57Therefore, this year we will have one insurance analyst,
- 1:24:01Cliff Gallant of Nomura Securities, Jonathan Brandt of
- 1:24:04Rua Northeast. See you in an IFF and gold.
- 1:24:07Farbie will join the analyst panel to ask questions that deal
- 1:24:11with our non insurance operations.
- 1:24:13Finaleido spice things up. We would like to add to the
- 1:24:16panel A credential Ed bear on Berkshire, preferably one who is
- 1:24:20short the stock not yet having a bear identified.
- 1:24:23We would like to hear from applicants.
- 1:24:25The only requirement is that you be an investment professional
- 1:24:29and negative on Berkshire. The three analysts, we'll bring
- 1:24:32their own Berkshire specific questions and alternate with the
- 1:24:35journalists in the audience and asking them.
- 1:24:38Charlie and I believe that all shareholders should have access
- 1:24:41to new Berkshire information simultaneously and should also
- 1:24:45have adequate time to analyze it, which is why we try to issue
- 1:24:48financial information after the market close on a Friday and why
- 1:24:52our annual meeting is held on Saturdays.
- 1:24:55We do not talk one-on-one to large institutional investors or
- 1:24:59analysts. Our hope is that the journalists
- 1:25:02and analysts will ask questions that will further educate
- 1:25:05shareholders about their investment.
- 1:25:07Neither Charlie nor I will get so much as a clue about the
- 1:25:10questions to be asked. We know the journalists and
- 1:25:13analysts will come up with some tough ones and that's the way we
- 1:25:16like it. All told, we expect at least 54
- 1:25:20questions, which will allow for six from each analyst and
- 1:25:23journalist and eighteen from the audience.
- 1:25:26If there is some extra time, we will take more from the
- 1:25:29audience. Audience questioners will be
- 1:25:31determined by drawings that will take place at 8 Colon 15-A dot
- 1:25:36m.at each of the 11 microphones located in the arena and main
- 1:25:40overflow room. For good reason, I regularly
- 1:25:43extol the accomplishments of our operating managers.
- 1:25:46They are truly All Stars who run their businesses as if they were
- 1:25:50the only asset owned by their families.
- 1:25:53I believe their minds set to be as shareholder oriented as can
- 1:25:57be found in the universe of large publicly owned companies.
- 1:26:00Most have no financial need to work.
- 1:26:03The joy of hitting business home runs means as much to them as
- 1:26:06their paycheck. Equally important, however, are
- 1:26:09the 23 men and women who work with meet our corporate office
- 1:26:13all on one floor, which is the way we intend to keep it.
- 1:26:17This group efficiently deals with a multitude of SEC and
- 1:26:20other regulatory requirements. Files a 21,500 page federal
- 1:26:26income tax return as well as state and foreign returns.
- 1:26:29Responds to countless shareholder and media inquiries.
- 1:26:32Gets out the annual report. Prepares for the country's
- 1:26:36largest annual meeting, coordinates the board's
- 1:26:38activities in the list goes on and on.
- 1:26:41They handle all of these business tasks cheerfully and
- 1:26:44with unbelievable efficiency, making my life easy and
- 1:26:48pleasant. Their efforts go beyond
- 1:26:50activities strictly related to Berkshire.
- 1:26:53Last year, they dealt with 48 universities selected from 200
- 1:26:57applicants who sent students to Omaha for AQ and a day with me.
- 1:27:01They also handle all kinds of requests that I receive, arrange
- 1:27:05my travel, and even get me hamburgers for lunch.
- 1:27:08No CEO has it better. I truly do feel like tap dancing
- 1:27:12to work every day. This Home Office crew, along
- 1:27:15with our operating managers has my deepest thanks and deserves
- 1:27:19yours as well. Come to Omaha, the cradle of
- 1:27:22capitalism, in May 4th TH and Chime in March 12013.
- 1:27:27Warren E Buffett, Chairman of the Board.