Latest / The Lives They're Living / Jonathan Coleman on Nan and Gay Talese
Transcript
- 0:00A guest today is Jonathan Coleman.
- 0:02Jonathan's books include at Mother's Request, a True Story of Money, murder
- 0:08and Betrayal, which won an Edgar Allen Poe Award and was made into a CBS miniseries
- 0:14Exit The Rainmaker Long Way to Go Black and white in America, and a collaboration
- 0:21with Basketball Icon and NBA logo.
- 0:25Jerry West in the book, west by West, my Charm, tormented Life.
- 0:30And Jonathan wrote a wonderful essay about West recently, and
- 0:35it has actually a connection.
- 0:36Today's episode, and I'll put a link to that in the show notes.
- 0:40, Just a little bit more biography, which I had a trim because we don't have the
- 0:45entire episode, but there's so much.
- 0:47I want to get to some more on your biography, , starting with the beginning
- 0:51of your career in London on Ian Hamilton's legendary Journal of the New review.
- 0:56He then became a book editor, KOP and Simon and Trier also
- 1:00related to today's episode.
- 1:02Then worked as a journalist for CBS News.
- 1:05He's written for many publications, including the New York Times, the
- 1:08New Yorker, New York magazine, and ones that don't start with New York,
- 1:12such as Time and Sports Illustrated.
- 1:15He's a contributing editor of the Sunday Long Read, and he's also an
- 1:20award-winning voiceover talent and recently narrated the audio book of Ken.
- 1:24All that is Hollywood ending.
- 1:26Harvey Weinstein and the Culture of Silence.
- 1:29And for many years he taught narrative nonfiction writing
- 1:33at the University of Virginia.
- 1:35Jonathan Coleman, welcome to the lives they're living.
- 1:38I've been looking forward to this, Ben.
- 1:40Me, me too.
- 1:41The part of your career kind of leads us into the subject of this episode
- 1:46and it's, it's the first, I think, dual subject that I've had on the lives
- 1:51of living, and that is the couple, the married couple, Nan and Gay Tise.
- 1:57And I think I'm correct in saying you met Nan Tise early on in
- 2:03your career at Simon and Trier.
- 2:04So tell us, , who she was when you met her, and tell us a little bit about her.
- 2:12I met Nan in the summer of 1977 when I came to c, came to
- 2:17Simon and Schuster from Knauf.
- 2:20Nan had been an editor at Random House for a number of years and had
- 2:25come to Simon and Schuster in 1974.
- 2:29I knew her by reputation.
- 2:32I also knew soon after I got there that Nan had acquired the work of Ian McEwen.
- 2:39Mm-hmm.
- 2:40Our offices fortuitously for me, not necessarily for her, but fortuitously
- 2:45for me, were right next to each other.
- 2:48And the story, and I was fascinated by this.
- 2:52The story of how she acquired McEwen was very indicative of the person I would come
- 2:59to know and come to know so well that I thought of her as the sister I never had.
- 3:08Mm-hmm.
- 3:09Um,
- 3:12she was interested in Mecu and she'd read a book of short stories
- 3:15that Random House had published.
- 3:17Shortly after she left, but not by her, but a book of stories.
- 3:22First Love Last Rights, which she liked well enough that
- 3:26she wanted to pursue McEwen.
- 3:29She had published the Director of the Iowa Writers Workshop, a guy named John Legett,
- 3:35so she approached McEwen through Legett.
- 3:40McEwen was spending.
- 3:42Some time at, at the Iowa Writers Workshop.
- 3:45I had actually met McEwen in London when I worked for the new review
- 3:49when he was just starting out.
- 3:51He and Martin NamUs, that whole generation of British writers who were young and
- 3:56wanted to curry favor with Hamilton and appear in Hamilton's the new review.
- 4:01So I met a young McEwen and Nan said.
- 4:07Yeah, I'm trying to publish Ian McKeen, but he doesn't wanna let me see his novel.
- 4:14The next thing I knew,
- 4:16she'd made an arrangement with him.
- 4:18A very peculiar arrangement.
- 4:21She could read the book, but not in his presence.
- 4:24It would be like, the book will be left out for you, but
- 4:29you'll just happen upon it.
- 4:32. McEwen went off to Florida on some trip.
- 4:36Legett had the manuscript and they all went through this sort of charade.
- 4:43But she flew out there
- 4:45, Ewen is not there.
- 4:46She reads the novel and purchases it.
- 4:51Gives it a title, the Cement Garden.
- 4:55And it was a, a very bizarre book.
- 5:00Not only dealt with the dark side of things, but death and, and
- 5:05it was started to occur to me.
- 5:08Nan has an interest in these sorts of things, but her
- 5:11interest was in great writing.
- 5:13I think it's important for people to know that she was considered at 1.1
- 5:21of the most beautiful women in all of New York.
- 5:24. I can say from the moment I laid eyes on her even till now Hmm.
- 5:32And I may get a little emotional, , because she's still with us and
- 5:36they're both still with us mm-hmm.
- 5:37In their nineties.
- 5:40Trust me when I tell you she commanded a room when she
- 5:44walked into it and still would.
- 5:48She's a very forceful person beneath this upper middle class
- 5:53upbringing in Rye, New York.
- 5:56She was taught by nuns at Convent of the Sacred Heart.
- 6:01She was presented at the Westchester Cotillion.
- 6:04I, I actually just, that's printed that out from her bio
- 6:09'cause it's another world.
- 6:11She was a debutante and I, I don't wanna even want to go into what a debutante
- 6:15is for those not familiar presented at the 1951 Westchester Cotillion.
- 6:21Yes.
- 6:22That's a different world.
- 6:24But I'm here to tell you that that's not really who she was.
- 6:29Mm-hmm.
- 6:29And is she
- 6:34one of the strongest.
- 6:36Most self-confident women I have ever met in my life.
- 6:40And if she were listening now, she would be embarrassed and, and she would demure
- 6:46and she would fight me about that.
- 6:48Right.
- 6:49She would insist that you listeners would have no idea.
- 6:53How scared she was.
- 6:54It's like, how did I even get into this room with these people?
- 6:59But trust me, when I did my research on her and I started to
- 7:03study her, not just because she let me mooch cigarettes from her.
- 7:08You could still smoke in the office then, and she had a pack,
- 7:11and I would mooch from her.
- 7:14I was fascinated by, first of all, I'd never met a debutante before.
- 7:18She could not be dislodged from her position on things.
- 7:23If she felt strongly about something, she felt strongly about something.
- 7:28And I, I wanna bring Gay into this, in this regard.
- 7:33As I got to know the two of them as a couple, I only got to know
- 7:37him because he was married to her.
- 7:39Mm-hmm.
- 7:39So she brought me into his life and into their lives.
- 7:45And as I got to know them better, I visited them on a few occasions at a
- 7:49home they had in Ocean City, New Jersey and mornings were very important.
- 7:56They lived separate lives within the same house.
- 8:00Like in this house in the summer in Ocean City, New Jersey, his hometown.
- 8:06His hometown and a place that he was devoted to long
- 8:12after she went there for him.
- 8:14She was not enamored of Ocean City, New Jersey.
- 8:17She was enamored of swimming.
- 8:21Yeah.
- 8:21Would swim in the ocean every day with a very distinctive
- 8:25bathing cap on, of course.
- 8:27Incredibly beautiful woman, but what her beauty was about was her intelligence.
- 8:34Hmm.
- 8:34And, and her eyes that radiated Don't tread on me.
- 8:40Yeah.
- 8:40, And people didn't pick that up about her at first.
- 8:43, They thought of her wrongly as gay Elisa's helpmate.
- 8:50Hmm.
- 8:51But I'm here to tell you, and Gay would not disagree with
- 8:55this, far stronger than gay.
- 8:58Mm-hmm.
- 8:59Is far more dependent on her.
- 9:03Just looking at some of those dates, graduated from
- 9:06Manhattanville College in 1955.
- 9:10Went to work at Random House as a proofreader.
- 9:12So this is the deep, in the middle of the fifties.
- 9:15To be a woman in any business, including publishing, they
- 9:20were relegated to lowly task.
- 9:25Proofreader probably one of the more prestigious and to.
- 9:31Work her way up rather quickly to a major editing position.
- 9:36That speaks of some of the qualities you're talking about.
- 9:39Yeah.
- 9:39There's no question.
- 9:40, And all credit to Albert Erskine at Random House for
- 9:46realizing what he had in his midst
- 9:50, But the funny thing about her, , she pursued gay, which was very atypical.
- 9:59You had all these men.
- 10:01As I understood then, I've done my research on this, she was
- 10:05being phoned and besieged with invitations all the time, right?
- 10:11But when she met Gay, there was something about him that
- 10:17intrigued her as long as I.
- 10:21Have known her.
- 10:22She always referred to her mother as Mummy.
- 10:25As mummy, like the royal family.
- 10:27My gosh.
- 10:29She knew that this was not somebody.
- 10:32Her parents would want her right to marry.
- 10:35Well, you mentioned Ocean City and that's a, , unprepossessing town
- 10:41down the shore from Philadelphia.
- 10:43, Solidly middle class and gay Gaetano born Gaetano grew up there.
- 10:49His father was a tailor which.
- 10:52Give some insight into his sartorial, , inclinations.
- 10:57. And the mother owned a dress shop.
- 10:59So not from the cotillion, debutante, , convent of the
- 11:02sacred heart world by any means.
- 11:05Not at all.
- 11:05Not at all.
- 11:06, And also to the aherns nan's maiden name to the Aherns.
- 11:12He was a journalist.
- 11:13Yeah.
- 11:14With, with, with, with an unsteady income.
- 11:16He wasn't a banker.
- 11:17He was all wrong for their daughter.
- 11:20Right, right.
- 11:21Except he was, in her opinion, he was everything she wanted because
- 11:27she's the one who actually was proactive about their eloping in Rome.
- 11:33Let me just say, , again, from her biography, some of, her
- 11:38professional accomplishments, and then I want to start talking a
- 11:41little bit more about gay's work.
- 11:43She had a over 60 year career in publishing.
- 11:46Now retired.
- 11:47She had her own imprint among her authors in addition to Ian McKeen, , were
- 11:52Pat Conroy, Margaret Atwood, Jennifer Egan, and Tony of Fraser and Thomas
- 11:58Kaeli and of course many others.
- 12:00So was a major figure in New York publishing for many years.
- 12:05, But the groundwork for that.
- 12:08Going back to Random House where she was showing her skill
- 12:11in her P Pros and her spine.
- 12:14In an encounter with, with Ae Hotchner and the book he was writing about Hemingway.
- 12:20He was assigned to her.
- 12:23Mm-hmm.
- 12:23And he was assaulted because he said, oh, I've been given this woman editor,
- 12:29the most junior editor on the staff.
- 12:30Hach, as he was known quickly, found out to have a lot of respect
- 12:36for her because she had questions.
- 12:38About what he was writing in, including the title.
- 12:42He wanted to call the book My Papa, and she said, who's Papa?
- 12:45What?
- 12:46Papa.
- 12:46Papa Hemingway.
- 12:47It became, right, right.
- 12:49And that was, I remember that one.
- 12:50And she said, your book should be called Papa Hemingway and he quickly realized.
- 12:55I better take her seriously.
- 12:56And Thomas Keneally, who wrote Schindler's List for her, which she
- 13:01had to fight for fight Dick Snyder about , at Simon and Schuster.
- 13:06Keneally was again, disillusioned, at first he thought what he was
- 13:13getting is not what he wound up with.
- 13:15What he thought he was getting was a compliant.
- 13:18Attractive waspy editor who he could push around.
- 13:23And then he found out very quickly in, in Cane's words, I wound up with Sister Nan.
- 13:30I, I suddenly was in the convent and, I was about to be spanked.
- 13:35She was a very strong minded editor and if she thought that you were, , about to
- 13:42go awry or stray, she pulled you back in.
- 13:45There's not an author that she had.
- 13:50That didn't know that, including Atwood and, , and Oriana
- 13:53fci, who was a powerhouse.
- 13:57She met a powerhouse in Nan.
- 13:59And what's interesting about their marriage, if you have an a marriage
- 14:03in with one member is an editor and the other is a well-known author.
- 14:09And phone calls are coming into the aforementioned editor from other authors
- 14:15and also manuscripts of those authors are making their way into the bedroom
- 14:20at night, you've got a problem and there was a problem, and gay career had dips.
- 14:27They had dips after the controversial thy neighbor's wife, and so he
- 14:32quickly became very jealous.
- 14:34Of these authors and in, in a way psychologically, I'm not her therapist.
- 14:40I don't know that she ever had a therapist, but it was in a strange way,
- 14:45her way of combating , and going on with a marriage, these are my authors in a way.
- 14:52Her authors were her lovers.
- 14:54He may have had affairs outside of the marriage, but her way of combating
- 14:59that and still holding through to her promise we're not, there's no divorce.
- 15:04We're here for the long haul.
- 15:05Mm-hmm.
- 15:05Buddy.
- 15:05Mm-hmm.
- 15:06And, and it was like astounding even to her children, to their daughters.
- 15:10They were astounded.
- 15:12, You mentioned the neighbor's wife, which probably was the most notorious book he
- 15:17wrote, but before that, in the fifties when he met her, he was with the New
- 15:21York Times and worked his way up from,
- 15:25. Copy boy , to reporter, , then became a freelancer writing some of the classic
- 15:30pieces that you probably taught.
- 15:32I did in my Yes.
- 15:33Literary journalism days.
- 15:34His profiles of, , Joe Diaggio and Floyd Patterson and Frank Sinatra
- 15:39has a cold, one of the most famous pieces of journalism of all time.
- 15:44Then started writing, , books.
- 15:47, Some of the first had these.
- 15:49, Trademark Biblical titles, the Kingdom and the Power Honor.
- 15:53Thy Father, A Kingdom of Power is about the New York Times, and that
- 15:57was a controversial book in its time.
- 15:59Honor Thy Father about the Mafia, thy Neighbor's wife, , which
- 16:04I want to ask you about.
- 16:06And then unto the Sons, which came out in 1992, which was where I crossed
- 16:10paths , with him because it was about some of the Italians including,
- 16:15, ancestors of his who had come to Ambler, Pennsylvania to work in the quarries.
- 16:19And I was able to profile him for Philadelphia Magazine, spend some time
- 16:24with him, , including at , their house in New York and seeing some of his.
- 16:28Working methods, , which, which were unusual to say the least.
- 16:33He was one of the classic new journalists, , the term coined by Tom Wolf.
- 16:39And it's interesting, he often said that two of his main models were not fellow
- 16:45journalists at all, but fiction writers.
- 16:47Prominently Irwin Shaw and John O'Hara.
- 16:50Yes.
- 16:51And bit of that old fashioned storytelling and meticulous at the same time.
- 16:57, But when he met her and, and then married her in 1959, all
- 17:00that acclaim was in the future.
- 17:02And he was a working journalist.
- 17:05He was a working journalist and she , saw herself as his wife.
- 17:12, With a job.
- 17:13, She never thought she had a career.
- 17:14. It became a career because it just evolved that way.
- 17:20She knew she wanted to have children.
- 17:22She also knew that she didn't wanna stay home with him, gay could not have had
- 17:29the life and career he had without her.
- 17:32Mm-hmm.
- 17:33Anybody who has paid even the slightest bit of attention to
- 17:38their individual stories or their collective story knows that.
- 17:42, And the breakfast at Ocean City,
- 17:46Nan herself as she was getting some coffee ready.
- 17:50She said, you know, when my husband gay and he was right there, the
- 17:55three of us in the kitchen says no to whatever is asked of him.
- 18:00It never means no, it always means maybe.
- 18:04Mm-hmm.
- 18:05Because gay's a very suggestible person and he's always open to
- 18:11something that might be better.
- 18:13Whereas I, on the other hand, and then he interjected when
- 18:19she says no, she means no.
- 18:24And I've never seen any deviation from that in the working of their marriage..
- 18:30I imagine , their daughters picked up on that , and knew which one to approach.
- 18:36, When there was , a question to be asked, when when the older daughter
- 18:40was getting ready, to go to Smith.
- 18:43Gay was down in Ocean City that weekend.
- 18:46Nan had not gone down.
- 18:48He was still in some ways licking his wounds from the critical
- 18:51reception to thy neighbor's wife.
- 18:55And he was just spending more time out of New York than in, , but she needed
- 19:01to go to school and Nan was gonna take her, drive her up to North Hampton, mass.
- 19:08But she had to get from Ocean City, New Jersey, back to New
- 19:11York . She wanted one last weekend with her father in Ocean City.
- 19:17Three buses came and went without her on them because he wasn't ready.
- 19:24To me, it's one of the most touching stories of the thing that any parent.
- 19:29Has ever encountered the sendoff.
- 19:32He couldn't do it, couldn't do it.
- 19:34And she finally is going, you've got to put her on that bus.
- 19:38And he finally did,
- 19:40well, I do want to talk about, , Alisa's book, thy Neighbor's Wife, because
- 19:46that book was probably the most controversial of his career and in a
- 19:54specific way that involved his wife, Nan.
- 19:58The book was about Sex in America and in the aftermath of the sexual revolution.
- 20:05, Yes, but I'd like to also make an argument, not for the first
- 20:09time, that various people made, including John Leonard.
- 20:15In my opinion, to his credit, the New York Times book reviewer.
- 20:19Yeah.
- 20:20Who I considered and considered one of the great book critics of ever of all time.
- 20:26Mm-hmm.
- 20:28That it was also a book about the first amendment.
- 20:31Hmm.
- 20:31So much of the focus on how Tise went about doing the book is exactly
- 20:40that, that it was also a very serious book about the First Amendment.
- 20:45Mm-hmm.
- 20:46And Al Goldstein , and what you could publish.
- 20:49And I do think that that was lost.
- 20:51And Nan wasn't the only one to say this, but I remember the day she
- 20:54flew outta New York to go to Chicago to appear on Phil Donahue when
- 20:58Phil Donahue show was in Chicago.
- 21:01And essentially,
- 21:04at least in the way I viewed it, was take on middle America.
- 21:07Mm-hmm.
- 21:08And explain the complexities of marriage.
- 21:12Yeah.
- 21:12Yeah.
- 21:14One of the things she said was , the majority of people who reviewed the book
- 21:20revealed much, much more about themselves mm-hmm.
- 21:24Than the book that they were reviewing.
- 21:25And I remember thinking, yeah, that makes sense to me.
- 21:29It was also a brave thing for her to say.
- 21:32She was not somebody to bite her tongue.
- 21:34No, no.
- 21:35Which again, ran counter to the image people would've had of a debutante
- 21:41, from Westchester County, New York.
- 21:43No, she was very strong but having said that, the book was
- 21:49very, very hard on all of them.
- 21:52Yeah.
- 21:53It took a tremendous toll on all, including the two girls.
- 21:58Pamela and Catherine whom Nan essentially marched up to their respective schools.
- 22:07Took them out.
- 22:09Took them outta the schools.
- 22:10She was not gonna be putting up with her kids being bullied in the way that we
- 22:14know how mean kids can beat to other kids.
- 22:17Yeah.
- 22:17There was a, a very famous New York magazine piece written by Aaron Latham,
- 22:22during the process of writing the book.
- 22:25Gay was open to Latham tagging along some of his research.
- 22:32And Jonathan, we should just say, I think a lot of listeners weren't around
- 22:37when the book came out, haven't read it, might not be familiar with it, that
- 22:40in the course of this long book, , as gay's books were at that time, quite
- 22:44long, , part of his exploration into sex and sexuality in America was.
- 22:49, Going to sex clubs, talking about, I think his own affairs.
- 22:53Correct me if, if I'm wrong.
- 22:55And journalists being journalists and, and you and I have been
- 22:59journalists, we've taught journalism.
- 23:01They, Aaron Latham and others latched on to some of those sensational
- 23:07aspects that could make headlines and those were the headlines.
- 23:12Nan told me the story of basically they were coming home one night from dinner
- 23:18and gay, he'd been thinking about the subject anyway, in the wake of, you
- 23:24know, the summer of Love in 67, . And basically you see that neon sign.
- 23:31Girls, girls, girls.
- 23:33And this is somebody, regardless of what the subject was, this is somebody who
- 23:42possessed as insatiable a curiosity.
- 23:48As I have ever encountered in anyone, I would say that Robert Caro's curiosity
- 23:55about things is right up there, but not, but is not as wide ranging as Ali's.
- 24:02You either have that innate.
- 24:05Deep, almost obsessive curiosity about things or you don't, and
- 24:11you can't manufacture that.
- 24:12And you have the ability to have patience and listening, which he learned from
- 24:17his mother, which he learned from spending hours in her dress shop.
- 24:24Hmm.
- 24:25Talking to the women of Ocean City, the church going women of Ocean City.
- 24:29But he was always listening to what they were talking about.
- 24:34. Part of the new journalism was being a participant.
- 24:37Yeah.
- 24:37And, and he was a participant.
- 24:39And people didn't like it.
- 24:41And they wonder, well, what, what about your children?
- 24:45What about your wife?
- 24:47And Nan basically.
- 24:50Had a pact with him long before.
- 24:53Thy neighbor's wife.
- 24:55She wanted him to be able to be who he was and she wanted
- 24:59to be able to be who she was.
- 25:01She liked being alone.
- 25:05I need to emphasize this.
- 25:06Do not think of her as the poor wife at home.
- 25:12She was at home.
- 25:14With a tuna fish or egg salad sandwich, which I many evenings shared with her and
- 25:20she would invite me to come up oftentimes when it's something that I had on my mind.
- 25:25That I wanted to talk with her about.
- 25:27And she said, come up, Gay's out tonight.
- 25:29'Cause gay would go out every night.
- 25:31She did not wanna go out every night.
- 25:33That is not what she wanted.
- 25:35He was home all day.
- 25:37He was cooped up.
- 25:38He would put on a three piece suit, looked better than anybody else in
- 25:42New York, maybe other than Tom Wolf.
- 25:44And he was out every night.
- 25:46She did not want that.
- 25:48She went out occasionally.
- 25:50She was home.
- 25:50She liked being alone with the dogs and with her manuscript and making her
- 25:57comments, some of which were gonna be hard for her authors to hear, even though she
- 26:02knew it was what they needed to be hear.
- 26:05And yet it took a toll on them.
- 26:08Yeah, and And what he wasn't prepared for, and I'm not sure she was either.
- 26:15Was, it was a pretty tough backlash against the book, which Nan really
- 26:22only reinforced what people have said for a long time about Americans we're
- 26:28a puritanical people, to me when she flew out to Chicago, I thought.
- 26:36They have no idea what's coming for them.
- 26:38And, and she was brilliant.
- 26:40I mean, brilliant, composed, and, and I just said that was the day that Nan a
- 26:46Tise, nana, her, and Tise took on America.
- 26:50To me, that was her shining moment.
- 26:53Well, you talked about a complicated marriage.
- 26:56The fact of it being, I'm trying to do the math now.
- 27:001959 to 2026 is 67 years.
- 27:05Am I, is that possible?
- 27:08Is, uh, a testament to, these two Very, very smart.
- 27:15. And in their own way, ambitious people being together.
- 27:20That's, that's no mean feat for that long.
- 27:24And it's a testament to them.
- 27:27It's no mean feat.
- 27:28And I know that I myself wondered at times over the years,
- 27:35I can't imagine that Nan wants to stay because there were no shortage.
- 27:41Of men over the years who had great interest in her.
- 27:45And I want to interject something, and this will be news for you.
- 27:49If, if, and I'm not saying you're seeking news, but it's very poignant.
- 27:54Two things.
- 27:55One, in a Vanity Fair piece in 2017, uh, there was an illusion
- 28:02to something, which is true, but I don't know the specifics of.
- 28:06Nobody does that.
- 28:09There was a period during the writing of thy neighbor's wife where Nan did leave
- 28:15for a few days, she didn't disappear.
- 28:18I mean, she said she was leaving.
- 28:21I'm gonna be gone for a little bit, but she never discussed any
- 28:25specifics and I never asked her.
- 28:28I never would've asked her.
- 28:30But I know that there was somebody that she went and spent some time with, and I
- 28:36don't even think she was gone that long.
- 28:39But the poignant moment is the late Robert Stone, a terrific writer
- 28:45who I'm, I'm worried that a lot of people may have forgotten, and I
- 28:51hope they have in dog soldiers and.
- 28:54Many other books.
- 28:55Hall of Mes is, is one of my favorites.
- 28:58His first book
- 28:59Nan told me this and I don't feel at all reluctant to share this
- 29:03'cause I think it's poignant.
- 29:04Robert Stone wanted to take her ice skating at Rockefeller Center.
- 29:10He wanted to do this very badly.
- 29:12And she was very gracious.
- 29:15She said no more than once.
- 29:20She was touched by the invitation.
- 29:23, I guess 'cause I'm a romantic man.
- 29:24I loved the, just the element of it.
- 29:27He tried a couple of times.
- 29:29He, he didn't necessarily want anything beyond that.
- 29:32In his mind's eye, he wanted to go ice skating with her,
- 29:37whether the tree was up or not.
- 29:39Yeah.
- 29:39With her.
- 29:40And I can see that because Nan.
- 29:43I've never actually seen anybody wear a beret
- 29:48better than her.
- 29:51I've never seen her ice skate either.
- 29:53But when you brought up Shaw earlier and John O'Hara, another writer that they both
- 29:59loved and had in common and is one of my favorite writers, and again, I, I fear
- 30:04that a lot of people don't know the work.
- 30:06A will have forgotten the name, John Cheever.
- 30:09Stone wanted to ice skate with her.
- 30:11Yeah.
- 30:11Yeah.
- 30:13That's it.
- 30:13And she never left.
- 30:15I approached gay in 2015, very gently raising the possibility.
- 30:24A biography and I said, I'm sure people have asked you about this before.
- 30:29And I was still living in Charlottesville.
- 30:32I live in New York now, but I was living in Charlottesville at the time.
- 30:34He said, well, maybe next time you're in town you can come over.
- 30:38We can talk about it.
- 30:40Well, we actually never wound up talking about it.
- 30:44He wound up graciously, elegantly.
- 30:49Putting it off.
- 30:51There was an academic, he had done work with on a, a book about his
- 30:55craft, a, a woman named Barbara Bury.
- 30:57Mm-hmm.
- 30:57And he said, well, she knows a lot of talk to Lounsbury and lows.
- 31:01Barry's advice to me was, do not give up.
- 31:04He will do everything he can to throw you off, but do not give up.
- 31:09And he never said no.
- 31:12Yeah.
- 31:13Again, 'cause he didn't say no.
- 31:15It was always, he would say, maybe, maybe he never said no.
- 31:19The furthest we got was this, why don't you begin and meet me on the back nine?
- 31:28And, and that's, that's an arrangement that subjects often
- 31:31make with potential biographers.
- 31:33Right, right.
- 31:34Don't start with me, come back to me.
- 31:37Right.
- 31:38But Nan called me.
- 31:40And said, I know how tenacious you can be.
- 31:43She knew me well and she grew up with tenacious.
- 31:48Gay was tenacious, but so was she.
- 31:51Right.
- 31:51So was she.
- 31:52They understood tenacity.
- 31:54She said, just step back, it's not a good time for him.
- 31:58And she said, I think that you would be perfect for this.
- 32:02And I, she said, I think Gay does too.
- 32:05'cause he knows the last thing you would write is any sort of Hague geography.
- 32:09I said not at all.
- 32:10I mean, I would if I'm gonna do this, you know, but I did back
- 32:13off because, because she asked me.
- 32:16You just said it's just not a good time.
- 32:18I did back off that, but, but this is the conclusion I came to, and
- 32:23this, I guess is as poignant to me as Stones asking Nan to go ice skating.
- 32:28To begin to sit down with me as opposed to sitting down with anybody
- 32:34he respected for a magazine profile.
- 32:38That was fine.
- 32:39He could do that.
- 32:40But to begin to sit down for a biography, and I could be completely
- 32:46wrong about this, but my sense would be that would be saying, I'm done.
- 32:52Yeah.
- 32:53Yeah.
- 32:53And he wasn't done right.
- 32:55And he still isn't done.
- 32:57And he, and he evoked the marriage book, which he's been working on this
- 33:01nonfiction marriage project under contract to Koff for many years.
- 33:06. And one thing that Nan said has also stuck with me.
- 33:12She said, you know, I don't know why he's doing this book.
- 33:15She's made this comment to others.
- 33:17I don't know why he's doing this book.
- 33:19She said he wrote, th neighbor's wife, but that wasn't about our marriage.
- 33:22She said he doesn't know anything about marriage.
- 33:26I said, you've been married.
- 33:28She said, yes.
- 33:28It doesn't matter.
- 33:29We've been married a very long time.
- 33:31But he knows nothing about what makes a marriage work.
- 33:36He knows nothing about marriage.
- 33:39Hmm.
- 33:40Interesting.
- 33:41But I said, I'm not a dope.
- 33:42I mean, you weren't happy all these years.
- 33:45She said nobody's happy all these years in a marriage.
- 33:49She said, in fact, there were long stretches of time.
- 33:52I was quite unhappy.
- 33:53I said, okay.
- 33:55And she said, and whenever I was unhappy, I wrote about it.
- 34:00Where did you write about it?
- 34:02She said that I'm not prepared to say for myself.
- 34:06I said frequently.
- 34:08Yes, because I was frequently unhappy.
- 34:12But we're married.
- 34:13We will always.
- 34:15Married, and I want you to take a step back about pressing him about a biography.
- 34:22These were very important things to me because
- 34:26I do feel that I had a kind of, and I hate to speak in the past tense, they are
- 34:31in their nineties, they're still alive.
- 34:33I don't hear a lot.
- 34:35I mean there, there was a period where Gay was saying, please take Dan to lunch.
- 34:41And I said I try to, and I, I wanted to bring over food many times.
- 34:47'cause I know what she likes.
- 34:48I said, whatever your heart desires, I will bring over.
- 34:51And she will say, I'm in Connecticut.
- 34:54She wasn't in Connecticut, she was in New York.
- 34:56She was like in her own way, being evasive.
- 34:59I just know that.
- 35:02In the largest sense, it's probably the most profound marriage that I'm aware of.
- 35:07Her heart was not one in the way that everybody would've imagined.
- 35:11Her heart was one.
- 35:13She had a lot to do with securing.
- 35:16She wanted an interesting life for herself.
- 35:18Yeah.
- 35:19Yeah.
- 35:20She never wanted to be married to a Wall Street banker who was coming
- 35:24home to Rye at the end of the day.
- 35:29The thing I wanted to mention, and I'd be interested in your reaction is I
- 35:32encountered him when I wrote that profile in, in 92, and he invited me to his house
- 35:39and, subsequently was just very generous.
- 35:42In, in a way that not all writers are, , reached out to me on several occasions.
- 35:50, Some few years after that, my colleague, Kevin Kran and I edited anthology of
- 35:56literary journalism called The Artifact.
- 35:59I Have, it's Right Behind Me.
- 36:01Okay.
- 36:02And we had an event, a publicity event at the Union Square, Barnes and Noble.
- 36:09We said, let's, it is not just us.
- 36:11Let's get some writers here.
- 36:12Who would be number one in our wishlist?
- 36:15Well, it was probably Gay Ulis, so we asked him and he said yes.
- 36:20And he came and showed up and sat on a panel with Michael Wine Rip
- 36:24and the late Richard Ben Kramer, and it was a wonderful evening.
- 36:27And after that, he's also been generous in a number of ways to me.
- 36:31Who's.
- 36:32Just, you know, not part of his world, not a friend, but just a fellow writer.
- 36:37And I have the sense that he views the world of writers as a fraternity.
- 36:43Is that your impression as well?
- 36:46Extremely generous and I'm glad that you brought this up because, I would've
- 36:52felt badly if I had been remiss to discuss this incredibly generous.
- 36:58Incredibly prompt in responding.
- 37:02He came to email late.
- 37:03. I have a packet of his famous typewritten postcards.
- 37:09The only thing in writing on the postcard is his name.
- 37:14Everything else is typewritten.
- 37:16They would come unexpectedly, something he would see, something he would recommend.
- 37:23He always was alert, he was always polite.
- 37:28If he thought he hadn't responded quickly enough, he would apologize about that.
- 37:34, This is not the image of him that a lot of people know, but it is very much part of
- 37:42who he is because he could seem snappish.
- 37:48He could seem abrupt.
- 37:50, But he could also bring a glass of freshly squeezed orange juice to
- 37:57a young woman whom he heard crying outside of of the brownstone who
- 38:04didn't even know she was in front of.
- 38:06His brownstone of her name is Dina Pins.
- 38:10Who later became a friend who came to the Christmas Eve party every year.
- 38:15The story of which was told to me by Ms.
- 38:18Penos, not by him, that's how they met.
- 38:22He, he heard somebody crying
- 38:24. Maybe his work was done, maybe not.
- 38:26He could hear things.
- 38:27He was always alert to things.
- 38:29Went out, saw her crying.
- 38:31She'd had a heartbreak.
- 38:32He said, I think you need some orange juice.
- 38:34It, it wasn't just regular orange juice, it was freshly squeezed orange juice.
- 38:39. Nan not so much a softie in that regard.
- 38:43Right.
- 38:43And yet.
- 38:45When I knew that my wife and I were separating, she was the first person
- 38:50I went to see, partly because I thought she would tell me I was making
- 38:54a huge mistake, which she didn't.
- 38:56He did later, but she listened, yeah.
- 39:00To everything and talked about the complexities.
- 39:05Of marriage.
- 39:06Right.
- 39:07, I I love the fresh squeezed orange juice, the detail out of an Irwin
- 39:11Shaw story , or John Cheever, that that should have been written.
- 39:16Well, Jonathan Coleman, thank you so much for talking about Nan and gay
- 39:20tise on the lives that are living.
- 39:23I have so many, I have so many other things written down
- 39:26that I didn't even get to.
- 39:27Did we have a successful podcast?
- 39:29Uh, in my opinion, yes, but we, we'll let the public be the judge and who knows,
- 39:34maybe, maybe one day we'll do part two because there, there's a lot out there.
- 39:41And now here's your moment of Gay and Nan Tillis.
- 39:47. So my, my father impressed upon me a pride in craft and, and so in a cry, a pride
- 39:53in crafting a sentence is what I am now connecting to my father's pride in craft.
- 39:58In his way, he sewed, the way he shaped the garment, the way he, he
- 40:02made something that lasted, clothes made by him or the other people that
- 40:07I mentioned who are related, who are tailors for four or five generations.
- 40:11Beginning in Italy are people who.
- 40:14Identify with their work.
- 40:16Mm-hmm.
- 40:16And, and take pride in the fact that their work sometimes lives beyond them.
- 40:19And I feel that way as a writer.
- 40:22It may sound arrogant of me, but I'm not really arrogant about it, but I'm
- 40:26very prideful and caring about what I do, and I get this from my father.
- 40:37I had just graduated from college and I was at Vogue Magazine and I
- 40:42think I had just been married to gay to Lisa, the writer or, um, we were
- 40:49intending to get married , gay was at that time at the New York Times.
- 40:54, An editor from Random House, , approached him about reading a book and asked if he
- 40:59would come, into the office and he said, you know, let me , have Nan take my place
- 41:06because she reads all the time much.
- 41:09It's much better.
- 41:16. Take the meeting, which I did, and I met Albert Erskine, the editor in
- 41:20chief, and he handed me a piece of paper and said, find the errors in it.
- 41:26And so, and, and at one point he turned to me and said, you
- 41:30know, you can use the dictionary.
- 41:33So I corrected it and gave it back to him, and I was hired on, on the spot.
- 41:40Hmm.
- 41:41You must have been well trained by the nuns.
- 41:43Yeah, no, it wasn't.
- 41:45It was just reading all the time.
- 41:47I always read and happily, most of the writers I read, , were very good.
- 41:53So I picked up good habits from them.
- 41:56So then they hired you as what?
- 41:59They hired me as a copy editor.
- 42:01And I remember I worked on all of Joe Fox's, , books.
- 42:07He was of.
- 42:09Very admired editor At that time, Philip Roth and Truman Capote were his authors,
- 42:16and there were some others as well.
- 42:18But, , in copy editing sometimes I would actually edit them and talk
- 42:24to Joe about it and say, I think we should the, the, uh, this follows
- 42:29chapter seven and et cetera, et cetera.
- 42:32So then, so they eventually made me an editor.